Cardinia Shire Council Youth forum survey 2013 Report of findings Prepared by: Cardinia Shire Council Community Services Unit Published 2013 © Cardinia Shire Council 2013 (ABN: 32 210 906 807) Henty Way, Pakenham PO Box 7, Pakenham Vic 3810 Phone: 1300 787 624 Fax: (03) 5941 3784 Email: mail@cardinia.vic.gov.au Web: www.cardinia.vic.gov.au Table of contents REPORT OF FINDINGS ........................................................................................................... 1 1 CARDINIA SHIRE SNAPSHOT ................................................................................... 6 2 THE YOUTH FORUM SURVEY .................................................................................. 6 3 SURVEY DISTRIBUTION ............................................................................................ 7 4 METHODOLOGY.......................................................................................................... 7 5 PROFILE OF RESPONDENTS .................................................................................... 8 5.1 Age breakdown ....................................................................................................................................... 9 5.2 Gender breakdown ................................................................................................................................. 9 5.3 Disability .................................................................................................................................................. 9 5.4 Country of birth ...................................................................................................................................... 9 5.5 Location of respondents ...................................................................................................................... 10 6 TOP ISSUES OF CONCERN THAT YOUNG PEOPLE HAVE EXPERIENCED IN THE PAST YEAR .................................................................................................... 11 6.1 Issues of concern relating to gender .................................................................................................. 12 6.2 Issues of Concern for young people with a disability ..................................................................... 12 6.3 Issues of concern – a time series ........................................................................................................ 13 6.4 Stress ....................................................................................................................................................... 14 6.5 School and work-related stress ........................................................................................................... 15 6.6 Bullying................................................................................................................................................... 16 6.7 No issue ................................................................................................................................................. 16 7 AT WHAT AGE SHOULD YOUNG PEOPLE BE OFFERED SUPPORT IF THEY ARE EXPERIENCING PROBLEMS? ......................................................................... 17 8 WHO OR WHAT DO YOUNG PEOPLE TURN TO FOR INFORMATION, ADVICE OR HELP? ...................................................................................................... 17 9 THE TOP THINGS THAT ARE MOST IMPORTANT TO YOUNG PEOPLE...... 18 10 ACTIVITIES YOUNG PEOPLE DO IN THEIR SPARE TIME ............................... 19 11 SERVICES, ACTIVITIES, PROGRAMS, EVENTS OR OPPORTUNITIES IN YOUR LOCAL AREA ....................................................................................................20 12 HOW YOUNG PEOPLE GET AROUND ................................................................... 21 13 HOW DO YOUNG PEOPLE FIND OUT ABOUT STUFF?......................................22 14 CHANGING ONE THING TO HELP THE YOUNG PEOPLE ..............................23 15 HOW PREVIOUS SURVEY FINDINGS HAVE BENEFITTED YOUNG PEOPLE25 15.1 Recreational activities ........................................................................................................................... 26 15.1.1 Mobile Youth Bus (MYBus) ............................................................................................................... 26 15.1.2 Events..................................................................................................................................................... 26 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 3 15.1.3 Skate, BMX, Scooter competitions and workshops ........................................................................ 26 15.1.4 Afterschool/interest-based programs................................................................................................ 26 15.1.5 Holiday Program................................................................................................................................... 27 15.2 Information/advice/referral and support ......................................................................................... 27 15.2.1 My Place – Pakenham Youth Facility ................................................................................................ 27 15.2.2 Information and referral ...................................................................................................................... 27 15.2.3 Cardinia Youth Services Facebook page ........................................................................................... 27 15.2.4 Text message ......................................................................................................................................... 27 15.3 Personal development/health and wellbeing ................................................................................... 27 15.3.1 Personal development programs and workshops ............................................................................ 27 15.3.2 Resilience awareness workshops (RAW) .......................................................................................... 27 15.3.3 Drum Beat ............................................................................................................................................. 28 15.3.4 Shout Out Program .............................................................................................................................. 28 15.3.5 Open Doors Program .......................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.6 Sexual health workshops ..................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.7 Mural projects ....................................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.8 Sustain Program .................................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.9 Rise Up Theatre Project ...................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.10 Ignite Program ...................................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.11 Stress down workshops ....................................................................................................................... 28 15.3.12 Drug and alcohol/party safe workshops........................................................................................... 28 15.3.13 L2P Program ......................................................................................................................................... 29 15.4 Social support groups........................................................................................................................... 29 15.4.1 Young Mums Group ............................................................................................................................ 29 15.4.2 GLBTI (gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, intersex) ..................................................................... 29 15.5 Civic engagement .................................................................................................................................. 29 15.5.1 FReeZA committee’s ........................................................................................................................... 29 15.5.2 National Youth Week committee ...................................................................................................... 29 15.5.3 Young Leaders Program ...................................................................................................................... 29 16 COUNCIL’S ACTIONS TO ADDRESS THESE ISSUES ...........................................29 16.1 Information dissemination .................................................................................................................. 29 16.2 Planning ................................................................................................................................................. 29 16.3 Advocacy and commitment ................................................................................................................ 30 APPENDIX ................................................................................................................................ 31 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 4 APPENDIX 1 YOUTH FORUM SURVEY ........................................................................... 31 APPENDIX 2 SERVICES, ACTIVITIES, PROGRAMS ......................................................36 APPENDIX 3 EVALUATING THE SURVEY PROCESS ...................................................38 17 REFERENCES ..............................................................................................................40 Figures Figure 1: Survey distribution points in 2013 ..................................................................................... 7 Figure 2: Location of respondents across the Shire and neighbouring municipalities ............. 10 Figure 3: Who or what do young people turn to for information, advice or help .................... 18 Figure 4: Top things that are most important to young people ................................................... 18 Figure 5: Young people’s preferred method of receiving information ....................................... 23 Figure 6: Changing one thing to help young people in Cardinia Shire in 2013 ......................... 25 Tables Table 1: Age profile of respondents 9 Table 2: Country of birth of respondents 9 Table 3: Issues of concern that young people have experienced in the past year Table 4: Issues of concern that young people have experienced in the past year by gender 12 Table 5: Issues of concern for young people with a disability 13 Table 6: Overall rankings since 2007 14 Table 7: No issue of concern that young people have experienced in the past year 16 Table 8: The age that young people should be offered support 17 Table 9: Activities young people do in their spare time 19 11 Table 10: Services, activities, programs, events or other opportunities young people would like to see in their home town/area 21 Table 11: Modes of transport for getting around Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 22 5 1 CARDINIA SHIRE SNAPSHOT Cardinia Shire is located south-east of Melbourne and is one of nine ‘interface councils’ around the perimeter of metropolitan Melbourne, providing a transition between urban and rural areas. The primary urban centre is Pakenham, which is 55 kilometres from Melbourne’s central business district (CBD). The Princes Highway and Gippsland railway corridor runs east-west through the centre of the Cardinia Shire, providing a key road and rail link between Melbourne and West Gippsland. The western end of this corridor comprises the Cardinia Shire growth area (about 10% of the Shire’s land area). With an annual growth rate of 5.9 per cent, Cardinia Shire is Victoria’s second fastest growing municipality and the fourth fastest growing municipality in Australia for 2010–11. The population within the Shire’s growth area is expected to grow from 50,404 in 2013 to 80,685 people by 2021 and an estimated 104,566 residents in 2031. By 2031, about 67 per cent of Cardinia Shire’s population is forecast to reside in the designated growth area and the remaining 33 per cent to reside in the rest of the Shire. Cardinia Shire has a large rural population; 27 rural townships exist outside the urban growth area, resulting in unique service provision issues. The northern part of the Shire is set in the foothills of the Dandenong Ranges, and includes Bunyip State Park and Cardinia Reservoir. Koo Wee Rup swamp and Westernport Bay are significant features of the southern part of Cardinia Shire. There is a higher than average youth population in Cardinia Shire, with nearly 20 per cent of the population aged between 5–17 years compared to 16 per cent in the Greater Melbourne area. In 2012 there were 16,853 young people aged 10–24 years living in Cardinia Shire. This is expected to increase to 32,778 young people in 2031. Approximately 70 per cent (0 dp) of these young people will reside within the growth area subregion in the townships of Beaconsfield, Officer and Pakenham (Informed Decisions 2013). To service the municipality’s young people, Council provides a generalist youth service. The service is predominantly funded by Council, while State government provides a small proportion of funding for targeted events and programs. Its activities incorporate health and wellbeing, support and leadership programs, youth events and school holiday programs. 2 THE YOUTH FORUM SURVEY Council acknowledges that youth is a crucial period for establishing positive health and social behaviours and it is during this period young people acquire a range of skills and behaviours, face a range of life events, and make decisions that can influence their physical and psychological health, their social development, and their educational and employment opportunities (WHO 2010). To enhance the wellbeing of young people and their families Council has conducted a number of information gathering exercises over the past several years to assess the views, needs and aspirations of young people – who live, work, study, or participate in recreational activities within Cardinia Shire. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 6 The youth forum survey aims to: capture local issues identify trends provide geographic and age comparisons better target and improve service provision inform the development of Councils Annual Business Planning and Youth Strategy Council welcomes the voices, opinions and ideas of young people that are heard through the youth forum survey. This information assists in shaping policy, planning service delivery and creating strategies for improving the health and wellbeing of Cardinia Shire’s young people and their families. Survey results will also assist Council’s youth services to advocate for the needs of local young people and allow for young people’s voices to be heard by regional networks, State and Federal governments, service providers and the general community. 3 SURVEY DISTRIBUTION The 2013 youth forum survey was distributed in a variety of ways to reach a broad cross-section of young people aged between 10 and 25 years who currently reside, work, study or participate in recreational activities in the Shire (see Figure 1: Survey distribution points in 2013). The data was collected over a 13-week period from 15 April to 12 July 2013. Figure 1: Survey distribution points in 2013 4 METHODOLOGY This year a number of changes were made to the youth forum survey. These changes include the addition of six new questions and an amendment to the existing question relating to issues of concern. Some of the new questions will allow for comparisons to be made across other stateCardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 7 wide and national surveys while other questions have been included to capture information specifically for future service planning in the Shire. The new questions added to this survey include physical or mental disability, country of birth, current study and/or employment status, preferred age to receive support, who do young people seek support from and the top three things that are most important to young people. In previous youth forum surveys young people have been asked about issues of concern. This year both the question and the question format have been updated. The previous youth forum surveys have asked young people to list the top three issues facing young people in the Shire and put forward their idea for a solution to each issue. This year the issue of concern question has been reformatted and has asked young people to rank the top three issues of concern that they have experienced in the last year. Participants were also provided with 24 response options, and also an option to state ‘I don’t know’ or ‘no issues’. The addition of ‘I don’t know’ and ‘no issues’ as response options ensures that participants are not selecting issues by default as a result of the survey design, resulting in more accurate data. Where issues being experienced by youth did not appear in the option list provided, participants were also able to select ‘other’ and provide a written description of the issue they are facing. Direct comparisons to previous youth forum survey data for this question will now need to be carefully considered because of the significant changes to wording and structure of this question. This change allows us to be sure that the concerns are those that are being experienced by our young people and not highlighted as concerns because of what is for example in the media or topics of discussion in the class room. Two questions were excluded from this year’s youth forum survey. The question asking young people what they plan to do in the future and also what place they have difficulty travelling to were taken out. The question relating to future plans created confusion for many young people and there were minimal responses to the travelling question. 5 PROFILE OF RESPONDENTS A total of 1,687 young people responded to the youth forum survey in 2013. Young people from the ages of 10–25 were represented. The majority of respondents were students, of the remainder 26 respondents were in full-time employment or undertaking an apprenticeship/traineeship and 18 respondents were unemployed/not studying. The largest group of respondents were aged 13–17 and the smallest group were the young adults aged 18–25. As highlighted in Table 1 the responses from the 13–17 year old age group totalled 72.6 per cent of all respondents, which is a similar response rate to the 2011 youth forum survey from this age group. In 2011, 73.7 per cent of respondents from this age group were received. This result is significant and will invariably influence the findings in this report in terms of overall ratings for each question. The second highest response rate was received from the 10–12 year age group at 22.4 per cent and the 18–25 year age group response rate was 5 per cent. In 2011, the response rate for 10–12 year olds was the same as this year at 22.4 per cent and the 18–25 year old group has increased by 2.6 per cent from the 2011 youth forum survey which was 2.4 per cent. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 8 5.1 Age breakdown Age in years Number of respondents Percentage of respondents % 10–12 years 378 22.4 13–17 years 1224 72.6 18–25 years 85 5.0 Total 1,687 100 Table 1: Age profile of respondents 5.2 Gender breakdown The number of female respondents was again higher than that of the male respondents. A total of 899 or 53.3 per cent of females completed the youth forum survey compared to 788 or 46.7 per cent of males. 5.3 Disability A total of 73 or 4.3 per cent of respondents indicated that they had a disability. A further 217 or 12.9 per cent of respondents stated ‘not sure’. This indicates some uncertainty about what may or may not be considered a disability. For instance, feedback from youth workers assisting young people to complete the survey noted that some asked if learning disabilities should reported. To minimise confusion in the future and obtain more information, this question will be broadened in 2015 to include what type of disability the respondent may have. 5.4 Country of birth The 2011 Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) reported that 21 per cent of residents were born overseas. Cultural diversity is not as pronounced in Cardinia Shire as in other municipalities, as only 8 per cent of people in the Shire come from a non-English speaking background. In the 2013 youth forum survey, young people were asked to state their country of origin to capture the migration pattern of new families and those from new and emerging communities that have chosen to settle in Cardinia Shire. The number of respondents who stated Australia as their country of birth was 1,491 or 92.8 per cent. The next highest country of birth was the United Kingdom with 30 or 1.8 per cent of respondents followed by New Zealand with 20 or 1.2 per cent of respondents. The fourth highest ranking of nine or 0.5 per cent of respondents was from Africa followed by eight or 0.5 per cent of respondents from Sudan (see Table 2: Country of birth of respondents). Ranking Country of birth Number of respondents Percentage of respondents 1 Australia 1491 92.8 2 United Kingdom 30 1.8 3 New Zealand 20 1.2 4 Africa 9 0.5 5 Sudan 8 0.5 Table 2: Country of birth of respondents A total of 48 or 2.9 per cent of respondents did not state their country of birth. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 9 5.5 Location of respondents Almost all townships and towns in the municipality were represented by responses, in addition to a number of townships outside the Shire. These responses were received from students attending schools in the municipality. Pakenham recorded 640 responses, which was 21 per cent of the total number of responses received. Figure 2: Location of respondents across the Shire and neighbouring municipalities indicates the percentage of respondents received from each of the Shire’s three regions and neighbouring municipalities. The Shire’s growth region for the purpose of the survey results includes the townships of Beaconsfield, Officer and Pakenham. The Shire’s southern region for the purpose of the survey results has been defined as those townships south of the Princes Highway. They include Nar Nar Goon, Garfield, Tynong, Bunyip, Longwarry, Rythdale, Cardinia, Tooradin, Koo Wee Rup, Caldermeade, Lang Lang Catani, Cora Lynn and Vervale. The Shire’s hills region for the purpose of the survey results has been defined as those townships north of the Princes Highway. They include Pakenham Upper, Dewhurst, Guys Hill, Beaconsfield Upper, Maryknoll, Mt Burnett, Gembrook, Cockatoo, Emerald, Avonsleigh and Menzies Creek. City of Casey Council includes survey respondents from Berwick, Narre Warren, Blind Bight, Cranbourne, Hampton Park, Harkaway and Endeavour Hills. Other respondents include young people from Upwey, Yellingbo, Kallista, Rowville and Scoresby. Figure 2: Location of respondents across the Shire and neighbouring municipalities Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 10 6 TOP ISSUES OF CONCERN THAT YOUNG PEOPLE HAVE EXPERIENCED IN THE PAST YEAR Young people were asked to rank three issues of concern that they have experienced in the past year. They were provided with 24 options or the opportunity to state an issue of concern if it did not appear in the options list provided. The top three issues of concern for young people participating in the youth forum survey in 2013 were stress, school or work related stress and bullying. Being unhappy was ranked as the fourth highest issue followed closely by body image as an issue of concern that young people have experienced over the past year. Stress: the issue of stress rated as the top issue for all age groups. Stress was ranked as the top issue by 36.48 per cent of female respondents and 26.27 per cent of male respondents. School or work-related stress: was a strong focus for the 13–17 and 18–25 years old age groups. Bullying: was cited as the major concern for young people in the 10–12 years age group, who ranked bullying second as their issue of concern. Young people aged 13–17 years ranked bullying as their third highest issue. Being unhappy: raised as an issue of concern for respondents across all of age groups. Young people aged 10–12 ranked being unhappy as their fourth highest issue of concern (14.55%), as did youth aged 13–17 (19.44). For young adults aged 18–25 years, being unhappy ranked as their firth highest issue of concern (17.6%) after mental health and wellbeing (18.82%) which is closely related. Body image: was more significant for the 18–25 year age group. 27.06 per cent of this age group identified body image as an issue, ranking this the third highest issue of concern for this age group. Table 2: Country of birth of respondents highlights that there were some differences in issue responses when they were broken down by age groups, however compared to previous years the responses are generally consistent across all of the age groups. The top three issues raised by 10–12 year olds were stress, bullying and school or work related stress. The same three issues of concern were reported by those aged 13–17 years, however they were ranked differently with stress being the main issue of concern, followed by school or work related stress and bullying. The top issues for the young adult group were stress, school or work related stress and body image. Body image also featured across all age groups as an issue of concern that young people had experienced in the past 12 months. Overall ranking Ages 10–12 % Ages 13–17 % Ages 18–25 % 1 Stress Stress 20.11 Stress 33.91 Stress 51.76 2 School or workrelated stress Bullying 19.84 School or workrelated stress 29.66 School or workrelated stress 31.76 3 Bullying School or workrelated stress 18.78 Bullying 20.18 Body image 27.06 4 Being unhappy Being unhappy 14.55 Being unhappy 19.44 Mental health and wellbeing 18.82 5 Body image Life-changing events 10.05 Body image 19.36 Being unhappy 17.65 Table 3: Issues of concern that young people have experienced in the past year Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 11 6.1 Issues of concern relating to gender Table 3 highlights the different responses that were received in terms of gender. Stress and school or work-related stress, were the top two issues of concern for both males and females. However, the proportion of females that reported stress and school or work-related stress as an issue of concern over the past 12 months was higher than males on both accounts. A total of 36.48 per cent of females reported stress as an issue of concern compared with 26.27 per cent of males. More females also reported school or work related stress as an issue of concern than males, that is, 30.03 per cent of females compared to 24.24 per cent of males. The response rates on the issue of bullying were similar with 21.36 per cent of females reporting bullying as an issue of concern compared to 17.39 per cent of males. However, a concern about body image was much higher for females than males. A total of 27.03 per cent of females reported body image as an issue of concern compared to 6.60 per cent of males. There was only one issue of concern in which males responded higher than females. Males listed transport as an issue of concern over the past year with 5.96 per cent of males reporting transport concerns as opposed to 3.78 per cent of females. Overall transport was ranked tenth by young people in this year’s youth forum survey as an issue of concern in the past year. Overall ranking 2013 Females % Males % 1 Stress 36.48 26.27 2 School or work-related stress 30.03 24.24 3 Bullying 21.36 17.39 4 Being unhappy 21.80 14.21 5 Body image 27.03 6.60 Table 4: Issues of concern that young people have experienced in the past year by gender The Australian Psychological Society (APS) commissions an annual survey of the stress and wellbeing of Australians to provide insight into the psychological health of the Australian population. The Society’s latest report titled Stress and wellbeing in Australia in 2012: A state of the nation survey found that females reported significantly higher levels of perceived stress than males. However, females did not score differently to males on measures of wellbeing, anxiety and depression. Previous APS research has also found that females report more stressful life events than males. However, the research findings concluded that high levels of perceived stress may not necessarily have a higher impact on females’ mental health and general wellbeing (APS 2012). Body image also registered as an issue of concern for considerably more females than males. Mission Australia’s survey report 2010 highlights that the issue of body image is more a worry related to the unrealistic portrayal of ‘the perfect body’ in the media. The report suggests that the education programs, campaigns and messages about healthy eating and self-esteem are not reaching young women. It would appear that the “media’s unrealistic and unachievable images of physical perfection and peer pressure to fit in still seem to be causing concern for female respondents” (Mission Australia 2010). 6.2 Issues of Concern for young people with a disability In the 2013 Youth Forum Survey, we asked young people if they experience a disability. This enabled us to determine if there are any differences in the types of issues being experienced by youth with a disability in comparison to those without a disability. As shown in Table 5: Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 12 Issues of concern for young people with a disability below, there are some key differences in responses from youth with a disability. Rank 2013 Overall ranking Youth with a disability 1 Stress Stress and Bullying 2 School or work related stress School or work related stress 3 Bullying Mental health issues 4 Being unhappy Body image 5 Body image Being unhappy 6 Life changing events Being overweight 7 Being overweight Isolation 8 Peer Pressure Sexual health issue 9 Mental health issues Sexuality, transport and cyber bullying 10 Transport Table 5: Issues of concern for young people with a disability Stress and bullying were equally important issues experienced over the past year by youth who have a disability. The Australian research report Bullying, Mental Health and Disability shows that children with disabilities are often more likely to be victims of bullying. More than half (62%) of students with Autism Spectrum Disorder, for example, report being bullied once a week or more. This is significantly higher than the one-in-five to one-in-seven Australian students who report being bullied once a week or more (Bottroff & Slee, 2007). Anecdotal information from parents of children and young people with a disability in the Shire also suggests that children with a disability are often bullied. Parents have reported that this often takes the form of name calling and exclusion from groups and activities, including social functions such as birthday celebrations and out of school hour’s activities. Mental health concerns were ranked as third highest issue of concern that young people with a disability have experienced over the past year. This was a key difference in comparison to the overall results, where mental health issues were ranked as the ninth most important issue facing youth. The research report bullying, mental health and disability, demonstrated a significant relationship between bullying and unhappiness at school, feelings of unsafety at school, lower self-esteem and poorer coping skills. This is also likely to impact feelings of isolation being experienced by youth with a disability. Isolation was ranked seventh for youth who have a disability, but was not ranked at all in the top-ten for overall results. 6.3 Issues of concern – a time series This year, the question relating to issues of concern was presented in a different format to previous years, so caution should be exercised when comparing the results of previous youth forum surveys (see Methodology). While there are some issues which have presented consistently across the time series data, many new issues have emerged in 2013. This does not imply that issues identified previously are not important, nor reflect a complete shift in the issues youth face in Cardinia Shire. As response options become more extensive, young people have more to consider before responding based on their experiences. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 13 This introduces more variability in responses. It is likely that stress and school or work related stress have been common issues facing youth for some time, but having this option available enables youth to easily communicate this. Despite changes in the way we ask and issues emerging, there is one striking theme that emerges across the time series data. Bullying has been identified as a top five issue of concern for young people across all age groups for the past six years. Further, transport has featured in the top ten since the survey inception in 2007. Rank 2013 2011 2009 2007 1 Stress Bullying Bullying Drugs 2 School or work related stress Alcohol Drugs Transport 3 Bullying Drugs Activities Activities 4 Being unhappy Violence Transport Alcohol 5 Body image Smoking Boredom Bullying 6 Life changing event Transport Vandalism Boredom 7 Being overweight Boredom Alcohol Smoking 8 Peer pressure Vandalism Smoking Vandalism 9 Mental health and wellbeing Activities Safety Sports/facilities 10 Transport Shopping Skate parks Violence Table 6: Overall rankings since 2007 6.4 Stress Approximately one-in-five young people who participated in the Youth Forum Survey this year nominated stress as the top issue of concern to them personally, over the past year. It was rated as the top issue of concern by the 13–17 year age group and the 18–25 year age group. The 10– 12 year age group rated stress second only to bullying as the top issue of concern in the last year. The highest response rate of 51.8 per cent to this issue was reported by the 18–25 year age group. This was followed by the 13–17 year age group with 33.9 per cent of respondents rating stress as their top issue of concern, in comparison to 20.1 per cent of 10–12 year olds. Stress and wellbeing in Australia in 2012: A state of the nation survey and previous APS research confirms that young adults continue to report experiencing significantly higher levels of stress and significantly lower levels of wellbeing than the general population. In particular, those in the 18–25 year age group reported significantly higher levels of anxiety and depressive symptoms when compared to the older age groups in the broader community. Again, these results are comparable to those of other countries where older adults report lower levels of stress and higher mental health and wellbeing than young people. The APS Stress and Wellbeing survey found that contributing to young people’s levels of stress are concerns about friendships, relationship issues, environmental issues and matters related to work and study (APS 2012). Family income levels also appears to play a role in reported wellbeing, with higher education and income associated with higher levels of wellbeing; and those with lower levels of education reporting significantly more perceived stress when compared to the general population. This finding is in line with Mission Australia National Youth Survey 2012 which found that Australian teenagers are stressed and anxious about their family's finances and the high cost of living and how that has spiralled out of control - even in households where there are two income earners. Mission Australia reported that the global financial crisis and job losses were going to impact but the extent of it [means] young people really think they have got to do something to help the Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 14 family household. Many young people also reported being concerned about having their own money for the future and having a secure job and a house to live in (Mission Australia 2012). 6.5 School and work-related stress School and work-related stress was the second highest issue of concern for young people in the past year. This was ranked highly by the 18–25 year age group and also by the 13–17 year age group. A total of 31.7 per cent of the 18–25 year age group registered school and work-related stress as an issue of concern in the past year followed closely by the 13–17 year age group at 29.7 per cent. These results are also reflected in the findings of the Stress and wellbeing in Australia in 2012: A state of the nation survey report in which full-time students scored significantly higher on the measures of anxiety and depression when compared to the general population. This report also noted another source of stress for the younger adult group may be in the workplace with those in the 18–25 year age range reporting significantly lower levels of job satisfaction, job interest and work life balance than the general population (APS 2012). For the past two years the Mission Australia National Youth Survey has also found that students reported higher levels of stress and concern relating to school and work. The 2011 and 2012 Mission Australia surveys found that these problems articulated by respondents reflected teenagers' uncertainty about the economy and concerns about how they would cope financially in the long-run if they did not achieve good results at school. This was attributed to more gloomy economic forecasts and a rise in youth unemployment which in turn leads to escalating pressures to perform in school (Mission Australia 2011–12). The trend in the casualisation of Australia’s workforce has also contributed to young people’s work related stress. According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics and the journal Social Indicators Research, since 1984 casual employment in Australia has grown from 15 per cent to 25 per cent in the workforce. Young people are disproportionately bearing the brunt of the change in employment practices (ABS 2010). The Foundation for Young Australians 2011 inquiry confirmed this finding, reporting that more than twice as many young adults have taken part-time jobs. “Many are seeking full-time work,” the foundation says, “but have to make do with part-time or casual” (Foundation for Young Australians 2011). The 2013 youth forum survey responses to the top-two issues of concern relating to stress has also been reflected in national data in recent times. Young Australians, Their health and wellbeing 2011 reported that an estimated 1.2 million mental health related general practice encounters for young people in Australia, accounting for 32 encounters per 100 young people – an increase of around 21 per cent since 1989–99, according to the 2008–09 Bettering the Evaluation and Care of Health (BEACH) survey of general practice activity and Medicare Benefits Schedule claims data (AIHW 2011). In line with the Council’s 2013 youth forum survey results, the Young Australia’s report found that young females were almost twice as likely as young males to have mental health-related general practice encounters (41 encounters per 100 young females compared with 23 for young males). This is consistent with the observation that young females attend general practice more often than young males. The most common mental health problems managed for young people were depression (13.5 encounters per 100 young people), anxiety (5.7 encounters per 100), drug abuse (two encounters per 100), and sleep disturbance (1.8 encounters per 100). Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 15 6.6 Bullying The theme of bullying has again been identified as a top issue of concern for young people over the past year as it was in 2007, 2009 and again in 2011 youth forum survey results. This year bullying was ranked as the second highest issue of concern for the 10–12 year age group at 19.8 per cent. In 2011 this age group ranked bullying as their highest issue of concern at 40 per cent. Bullying was the third highest issue of personal concern for the 13–17 year age group, registering 20.1 per cent of responses. This issue did not rank in the top five issues of personal concern for the 18–25 year age group. Cyber bullying was also offered as an option in the survey but this option only received 1.5 per cent of responses as opposed to bullying which received 18.8 per cent of responses. This would suggest that the bullying that young people are experiencing is more prevalent in the playground, on the way to and from school or at social and sporting events. These findings are also consistent with the Community Adolescent Profiles, Cardinia Shire Council 2010 which found that 46.5 per cent of the Shire, students who were surveyed reported being bullied recently. This figure was higher than the proportion reported across the Southern Metropolitan Region (42.4 %) and the state wide figure of 44.6 per cent (DEECD 2010). It is estimated that one-in-four children will either be the victim of playground bullying or be a witness to playground bullying. It is also widely recognised that bullying most often occurs in the last years of primary and the first two to three years at secondary school (Kids Help Line 2009). The reported level of anxiety and prevalence of bullying reported by the respondents over the past six years in the youth forum survey is of concern. Bullying is characterised by an imbalance of physical or psychological strength between the bully and his or her victim. It is known to negatively impact on young people’s mental health status (DEECD) and has been shown to cause high amounts of distress for young people, with significant risks of psychological problems including the risk if depression, poor self-esteem and disengagement (YACVIC 2010). 6.7 No issue As noted in Section 4, young people were provided with 24 options to choose from to rank their top three issues of concern over the past year. One of the options was no issue. In the overall rankings, 30.2 per cent of the 10–12 year age group ranked no issue as their first choice. This would suggest that one-in-three of respondents from the primary schools in Cardinia Shire that participated in this survey were generally travelling well and had not experienced any issue of concern in the past year. A total of 13.7 per cent of 13–17 year olds and 8.2 per cent of 18–25 year olds chose no issue as an option. In terms of gender, 22.34 per cent of males chose no issue as opposed to 11.90 per cent of females. For young people with a disability 18 reported have no issue, which was also the second highest response rate after stress and bullying, which each received 24 responses. Options Overall % Males % Females % Young people with a disability No. of respondents Stress 31.71 26.27 36.48 34.29 No issue 17.13 22.34 11.90 7.14 Table 7: No issue of concern that young people have experienced in the past year Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 16 This result is also reflective of the Australian Psychological Society report which as stated previously highlighted that females report more stressful life events than do males. The results of this study confirm this finding but may also indicate that high levels of perceived stress may not necessarily have a higher impact on females’ mental health and general wellbeing (APS 2012). 7 AT WHAT AGE SHOULD YOUNG PEOPLE BE OFFERED SUPPORT IF THEY ARE EXPERIENCING PROBLEMS? This question has been included in the youth forum survey for the first time. Young people were asked to nominate the age that either they or a friend could have been offered support for a problem they were experiencing. The top three ages reported by young people were: 6–10 years of age 13 years of age 14 years of age The responses as shown in Table 7 indicate that both females and males had a preference for support during or before reaching adolescents, that is, at the age of 6 to 10 years of age. This age group ranked the highest for males with 13.6 per cent and the third highest for females at 11.6 per cent. The second highest response was for 13 years of age. This age was ranked the highest by females at 13.8 per cent and the second highest preferred age by males at 10.7 per cent. The third highest ranking was for young people to be offered support at 14 years of age. This was the second highest ranking for females at 11.9 per cent and the third highest ranking for males at 8.5 per cent. Age that young people should be offered support Females % Males % Overall 6 to 10 years of age 11.6 13.6 25.2 13 years of age 13.8 10.7 24.5 14 years of age 11.9 8.5 20.4 No problem 7.8 13.7 21.5 Don’t know 17.4 21.8 39.2 Table 8: The age that young people should be offered support The highest overall response to this question was don’t know at 39.2 per cent, while overall 21.5 per cent or one-in-five respondents reported no problem. This data suggests the need to intervene in the early years. 8 WHO OR WHAT DO YOUNG PEOPLE TURN TO FOR INFORMATION, ADVICE OR HELP? This question has been included in the youth forum survey for the first time. Young people were asked if they needed some information, advice or help with a problem who are the people or places that they turn to. They were given 16 options ranging from their family to social media chat rooms. Across all three age groups young people chose their immediate family (for example mum, dad, brother or sister) as the people they would turn to for information, advice or help most often. As illustrated in Figure 3 immediate family received 52.6 per cent of responses followed by friends with 31.5 per cent of responses and school teachers and extended family (for example aunty, uncle grandma) both receiving 11.1 per cent of Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 17 responses. Figure 3: Who or what do young people turn to for information, advice or help The male and female responses were similar to the overall findings for this question with 51.0 per cent of females nominating their immediate family as the people they would turn to for information, advice or help, while 54.6 per cent of males chose their immediate family. Friends were again the next choice for both males and females at 28.3 per cent and 34.3 per cent respectively. Extended family and school teachers were rated closely by females as the third choice for information, advice or help. School teachers received 13.2 per cent of female respondents and the extended family received 12.5 per cent of responses. Male responses for extended family and school teachers were also similar with extended family receiving 9.5 per cent of responses and school teachers receiving 8.8 per cent of male responses. This result would indicate the need to increase support and education to families and school teachers (not just youth workers and student welfare staff), in order for them to provide young people with information, advice or help on a range of youth related issues. 9 THE TOP THINGS THAT ARE MOST IMPORTANT TO YOUNG PEOPLE This question has been included in the youth forum survey for the first time. Young people were asked to nominate the top three things that are most important to them. Respondents were given 20 options to choose from ranging from friends to the environment. Again family was chosen as the most important thing across all three age groups. As illustrated in Figure 4 family received 50.2 per cent of responses followed by friends with 37.3 per cent responses and education received 10.7 per cent of the overall responses. Figure 4: Top things that are most important to young people Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 18 There is increasing evidence to show that families have a significant influence on reducing risk behaviours and creating positive health and wellbeing outcomes for children and young people. A report on young Australians’ wellbeing by the Australian Research Alliance for Children and Youth states that “childhood is the most critical stage in human development. Research from fields including neuroscience and economics provides evidence of how childhood and youth can influence a range of outcomes later in life” (ARACY 2008). The transition period of adolescence is critical time for effective parenting and during this time parents and caregivers can greatly influence the outcomes of young people. Australian Institute of Family Studies research concludes that “…having close, loving and encouraging childhood relationships with parents lays a strong foundation for thriving in young adulthood and may also buffer young people from mental health problems”(AIFS 2010). It should also be noted that education was ranked as the third most important thing to young people who participated in the youth forum survey this year which is reflected in school and work-related stress ranking second overall as an issue of concern. 10 ACTIVITIES YOUNG PEOPLE DO IN THEIR SPARE TIME Young people were asked to nominate what activities they do in their spare time. They were given 25 options with no limit on the number of choices. Overall the most popular activities for respondents in 2013 were: internet: 963 responses Facebook: 926 responses outdoor sports activities: 742 responses gaming: 706 responses shopping: 690 responses In 2011, the internet was the most popular activity for young people and has again proved to be a popular pastime. Facebook has overtaken shopping as a favoured pastime since 2011 and outdoor sports activities has climbed from fourth position in 2011 to be the third most popular past time for survey respondents. The inclusion of gaming for the first time in the youth forum survey signifies the rise of more passive pursuits with three of the top five activities being sedentary activities. Overall ranking 2013 Ages 10–12 No. of responses Ages 13–17 No. of responses Ages 18–25 No. of responses 1 Internet Internet 213 Facebook 770 Facebook 65 2 Facebook Outdoor sport 192 Internet 702 Internet 52 3 Outdoor sport Gaming 174 Mobile phone 525 Shopping 50 4 Gaming Shopping 129 Outdoor sport 524 Mobile phone 48 5 Shopping Instagram 119 Gaming 504 Work 46 Table 9: Activities young people do in their spare time Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 19 Australian health guidelines recommend that children and young people engage in at least 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity per day, and do not exceed two hours of screen time daily utilising electronic media such as the internet, television or gaming. From those that responded to the Youth Survey, young people in Cardinia Shire appear to use their spare time doing activities that are largely sedentary and this raises some health concerns. It has been shown that although some time limited use of the internet can be educational, children and young people who exceed the recommendations are more likely to be overweight, less physically active, have fewer social interactions, and consume more ‘unhealthy foods’ including snacks high in sugar, fat and salt, and sugary drinks. Further, as the amount of time children and young people spend using electronic media increases, their mental health and wellbeing is adversely impacted particularly in those aged between 10–12 years engaging in four hours or more of screen time daily. Unfortunately, research shows that only 40 per cent of Australian children aged between 9 and 13 meet physical activity guidelines, and as little as 7 per cent of these children use electronic media for less than two hours per day. Consequently, a large proportion of Australian children have less opportunity for active play, outdoor and creative play, and fewer of the associated benefits. In relation to gaming, however, there is growing popularity and availability of physically active games such as Nintendo Wii, Sony PlayStation Move and XBOX Kinect, which infers that gaming, can also be an active pursuit comparable to physical activity. The youth survey responses indicate that a number of youth in Cardinia Shire rank internet use first and foremost as a way to spend their spare time and that it is likely therefore that their screen time is composed largely by passive or sedentary behaviours. 11 SERVICES, ACTIVITIES, PROGRAMS, EVENTS OR OPPORTUNITIES IN YOUR LOCAL AREA Young people were asked what services, activities, programs, events or other opportunities they would like to see in their home town/area. Respondents were given 17 options with no limit on the number of options they chose. They were also given to opportunity to list their preferred service, activity, program or event if it did not appear in the options list. The overall responses for the most requested: social activities across all age groups were: cinema: 1015 (60.2%) places to hang out: 722 (42.8%) shopping: 714 (42.3%) services were: youth centre: 236 (14.0%) university: 224 (13.3%) TAFE: 195 (11.6%) programs/events were: music festival: 699 (41.4%) sport: 616 (36.1%) art program: 342 (20.3%) Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 20 Overall ranking 2013 Ages 10–12 No. of requests Ages 13–17 No. of requests Ages 18–25 No. of request 1 Cinema Cinema 229 Cinema 740 Cinema 46 2 Places to hang out Sport 188 Music festival 537 Music festival 38 3 Shopping Places to hang out 174 Shopping 531 Shopping 38 4 Music festival Shopping 145 Places to hang out 518 Places to hang out 30 5 Sport Playground 133 Sport 495 Youth centre 25 Table 10: Services, activities, programs, events or other opportunities young people would like to see in their home town/area See Appendix 2 for services, activities, programs, events or other opportunities requested by locality. 12 HOW YOUNG PEOPLE GET AROUND Young people were asked what the top-three ways of getting around to their daily activities were. Respondents were given 12 options and asked to number the top three modes of transport. They were also given the opportunity to list their daily transport modes if it did not appear in the options list. The overall responses for the most common daily transport modes across all age groups were: parent drives me: 1482 walk: 942 bus: 847 As highlighted in Table 6 the most common mode of travel for young people is by car, either being driven by parents or driving oneself as a young adult. Walking as a mode of transport is ranked second overall behind parents drive me. This may be the result of a large proportion of respondents living in the larger townships in the Shire or in the neighbouring municipality of Casey and are within walking distance to friend’s homes, venues and social activities. Bus was ranked third overall. Given the majority of respondents were primary and secondary school students, this response may relate to daily school buses and weekend travel to larger service centres. Transport mode Aged 10–12 Aged 13–17 Aged 18–25 Overall Ranking (out of total) Ranking (out of total) Ranking (out of total) Ranking (out of total) Parent drives 1 1 1 1 Friend drives 6 4 6 4 I drive myself 10 10 2 9 Bus 4 2 4 3 Train 5 5 5 6 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 21 Transport mode Aged 10–12 Aged 13–17 Aged 18–25 Overall Walk 2 3 3 2 Skate/scooter 7 8 8 8 Bicycle 3 6 10 5 Hitchhike 9 9 7 10 Other 8 7 9 7 Table 11: Modes of transport for getting around As a result of the Shire’s limited public transport options young people are reliant on their family for transport to and from their daily activities. The poor public transport network and the vastness of the municipality, that is 1,280 square kilometres, make it one of the highest residential car ownership areas in metropolitan Melbourne. The 2011 ABS census data reports that Cardinia Shire residents have one of the highest car ownership rates in Melbourne and the lowest public transport use. Approximately 65 per cent of households in Cardinia Shire had access to two or more vehicles compared to 51 per cent in Greater Melbourne and 5.1 per cent of residents travel to work on public transport compared to 11.5 per cent of commuters in Greater Melbourne (Informed Decisions 2013). The ability of the population to access services and employment is strongly influenced by access to transport, which has been acknowledged by the recent Victorian Auditor General’s Report titled report Developing Transport Infrastructure and Services for Population Growth Areas. The report calls for “urgent action to address this serious problem. Inadequate public transport and growing gaps in the road network in these communities are creating barriers to mobility, including access to critical services, education and employment opportunities. In turn, these deficiencies are increasing car dependence, pollution and exacerbating traffic congestion at significant community cost. These both limit state productivity and the time that people can spend with their families” (Victorian State Government). Mind the Gaps – an assessment of transport needs and issues for young people in Melbourne’s urban fringes found that “young people rely more heavily on public transport than other people”. A study by Griffith University’s Urban Program found that on average, young people also suffer greater transport disadvantage than the overall population. This compounds other disadvantage experienced by young people, making it even more difficult for them to get jobs or training, as well as to be engaged in social of community activities”(VCOSS 2010). 13 HOW DO YOUNG PEOPLE FIND OUT ABOUT STUFF? Young people were asked to nominate the top three ways that they would like to receive or find out about youth services, programs or events. Respondents were given 12 options of their preferred communication methods. They were also given the opportunity to list their own choices if it did not appear in the options list. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 22 The overall responses for preferred method to find out about events, programs and services were: Facebook:723 email: 583 posters at school: 456 The responses to this question highlight that Facebook is largely the preferred mode of communication for youth forum survey respondents, followed by email and posters at school, text message and interestingly mail. Figure 5: Young people’s preferred method of receiving information 14 CHANGING ONE THING TO HELP THE YOUNG PEOPLE Young people were asked if they could change one thing to help young people in Cardinia Shire, what that would be. This was an open ended question to provide young people with the opportunity to articulate their needs and aspirations. The responses cover a broad range of issues and provide context and meaning to the quantitative data collected in the previous questions. The data collected was grouped into 30 themes ranging from increasing services and facilities to homelessness and stronger tobacco controls. The area that received the most requests to help young people in the Shire was increased availability, accessibility of advice support and programs. Comments requesting increased and accessible services included: “Cardinia shire youth workers should be more involved with the schools, they should come and do talk about the issues we are facing as young people and what help is available. This could make us feel less alone” “create more help programs for those who are on a tight budget or a family with financial stress” “counselling services” “…more information about how to get help for mental health services”. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 23 Adolescence is a critical phase of emotional, social and physical growth and development. The right support at the right time can help young people lead healthy lives and stay connected, engaged and participating in their communities. The findings from this year’s youth forum survey indicate that parents, carers, friends and relatives are the main sources of advice and support for young people. Other important support can come from elsewhere — teachers, mentors, employers, coaches, broader community networks, religious organisations and formal social support services such as youth services and mental health services (VCOSS/YACVic 2013). However not all young people have support networks in place: 20 per cent of those surveyed by Mission Australia said they had nowhere to go for advice and support (Mission Australia 2011). It is important that supports are available and accessible for all young people. Everyone needs a safety net and someone to turn to for support at some point in their life. Recent research highlights the importance of taking a ‘life course’ approach – that is, considering adolescence in the context of what precedes it and what follows. This is particularly important as changes in our society create changes in the experience of ‘youth’ as a period in the life course. As evidenced in the youth forum survey responses. At the lower end, pre-teens are exhibiting behaviour and having experiences previously associated with teenage years. At the upper end, social and economic drivers, longer periods spent in education, the volatile job market and changing patterns of family formation mean that many young adults are reporting school and work related stress and mental health issues. Building the Scaffolding: strengthening support for young people in Victoria highlights the importance of creating a more seamless system of support from childhood through to adulthood, which does not suddenly stop at a particular age but takes developmental needs into account. This does not mean that every service has to provide support to every age group, but a more coordinated system would help to ensure that children and young people do not fall through the current gaps between child, adolescent and adult services (VCOSS/YACVic 2013). The second highest request was for more activities and social events. Comments requesting more social and recreational opportunities included: “have more community things to get people together for young people so that they can make new friends” “community services like free dance days, art classes and more. fun activities” “hold more festivals to promote kids helpline and other teen values like sexting, no smoking, no drinking” The third highest request was for more and increased sporting facilities. Comments requesting more sporting opportunities included: “get a wider variety of sporting clubs” “more skate parks” “I would change the amount of sporting facilities in Pakenham area. We are lacking…” The top ten requests for 2013 are listed in order of preference in Figure 6 below. Survey respondents have strongly indicated the need for locally based accessible support services and programs. They have also articulated the need for support to be made available to young people at an earlier age as problems for some young people emerge while they are still at primary school. There are relatively few services available to support young people at any earlier age and the Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 24 problems that arise for young people in their teens often have their roots in experiences that occurred in their earlier years (VCOSS/YACVic 2013). Figure 6: Changing one thing to help young people in Cardinia Shire in 2013 In 2011, improving public transport received the highest response rate. Just over one in five respondents believed that improving train and bus services was important. In line with this year’s results activities and sporting facilities were ranked after transport in 2011. 15 HOW PREVIOUS SURVEY FINDINGS HAVE BENEFITTED YOUNG PEOPLE Council’s Youth Services have undertaken the Youth Forum Survey since 2007. Since this time the input received has been instrumental in influencing program and service development/delivery both internally and by external youth agencies. Council has a key local leadership role in developing an integrated approach to planning and service provision for young people and their families. In addition other health, welfare and recreation services will be required to support the needs of young people. The provision of generalist youth services is critical to support the health and wellbeing and development of young people. Health and wellbeing refers to ‘a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing.’ Council’s Youth Services works to improve the capacity and resilience of young people through the provision of services, programs and activities. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Services deliver a range of health; well-being and developmental programs; services; activities; and events to young people who live within the Shire - enabling them to build resilience around issues they may face, fulfil their potential and develop themselves as young adults and community members. A number of programs, events, projects, and activities have taken place over the past two years as a direct result from what young people told us in 2011. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 25 15.1 Recreational activities 15.1.1 Mobile Youth Bus (MYBus) Council’s mobile youth bus (MYBus) was launched in June 2009. This was part of a response to young people in past forums, surveys and consultations who said they felt there was a lack of accessible and affordable activities available to young people. The MYBus has a range of interactive games and resources for young people as well as up-todate information about local services, events and programs. Young people can also gain information on a range of youth-related health and wellbeing topics. In 2012-2013 the Mobile Youth Bus attended 10 secondary schools, 15 primary schools and 16 rural townships in the Shire after school. 15.1.2 Events Young people had commented that they would like to have more events in their community. As a result, youth services has delivered numerous music and cultural events that have targeted different age groups and interests to provide a good cross section of social outlets for young people to participate in. FReeZA The FReeZA committee of young people provide the community with low cost evens that focus on music and culture. These events are spread across the Shire to ensure all young people can access an event. National Youth Week National Youth Week includes a range of recreational activities and an annual festival. The activities and festival are organised in partnership with young people who form the National Youth Week Committee. National Youth Week aims to raise the profile of young people’s contributions and achievements in the community. 15.1.3 Skate, BMX, Scooter competitions and workshops Due to their popularity and from feedback received from young people as part of the 2011 Youth Forum Survey Council, Youth Services continue to host skate/BMX and scooter competitions for young people each year. These are held in January and April. In 2011 and again in 2012 Council partnered with the YMCA and hosted a South Eastern League Skate and BMX competition. A Skate/BMX workshop was held at Gembrook Skate Park. The workshops were highly successful with over 30 young people participating. 15.1.4 Afterschool/interest-based programs Youth Services has delivered a range of interest based programs/workshops. Programs are developed based on feedback received from young people. Programs change on a term-by-term basis so that they reflect current needs and interests. Programs have included; dance, art, drama, cooking, music and general recreational activities. The youth services team ensures that there is one after-school program in a rural township each term. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 26 15.1.5 Holiday Program Based on young people’s feedback youth services delivers, a wide range of low to no-cost activities at part of the holiday program. There are excursions, incursions at My Place and activities on the MYBus every school holidays. Transport is provided to rural townships for some activities and the MYBus is located in rural townships for young people to easily access. In addition youth services provide an annual camp in September/October for young people aged 11-16. The camps include a range of indoor and outdoor adventure, recreational and arts based activities. 15.2 Information/advice/referral and support 15.2.1 My Place – Pakenham Youth Facility My Place opened in August, 2012 and houses nine different specialist youth agencies. The facility also provides space for youth agencies to provide an outreach service to young people aged 1025 years on a casual basis. These services and agencies include: Youth justice, Centrelink, headspace psychologist and GP. The facility provides a range of programs and activities for young people as well as an informational, advice, support and a referral service for young people and the community. 15.2.2 Information and referral The Council’s Youth Support Program will commence late 2013, providing young people aged 10-25 with short to medium-term support. The program assists young people to engage with other services and programs in the community. 15.2.3 Cardinia Youth Services Facebook page The 2011 Youth Forum report highlighted that young people use Facebook and the Internet as their preferred method of finding out about stuff. In 2012 Council’s Youth Services team developed its Facebook page. Facebook is used to inform young people, parents and the wider community about programs, events and services that are offered to young people by Council’s Youth Services team. In addition to Facebook, the Council website provides young people and families with up to date information about programs and services offered by the youth services team. 15.2.4 Text message The use of mobile phones continues to increase amongst young people, with many wishing to receive information via SMS. In response youth services developed a mobile phone number distribution list in order to send text messages to parents and young people about programs and events. 15.3 Personal development/health and wellbeing 15.3.1 Personal development programs and workshops Youth Services have developed and delivered the following programs and workshops based on issues that were listed for young people in Cardinia Shire. 15.3.2 Resilience awareness workshops (RAW) RAW is a one-hour workshop delivered to grade 6 students. The workshop tackles bullying and uses a strength-based approach to build young people’s resilience and support network. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 27 15.3.3 Drum Beat Drum Beat is delivered once-a-week over a term and uses the djembe as an engagement tool to explore feelings, communication, relationships, teamwork and self-control. 15.3.4 Shout Out Program Shout Out is a six week program delivered to groups of year nine girls and boys. The program engages young people to discuss issues such as body image, self-esteem, sexual health, drugs and alcohol, party-safe, communication and teamwork. 15.3.5 Open Doors Program The Open Doors Program is a partnership between TaskForce, Oakwood School, Youth Services and YMCA. The program provides young people who are not attending mainstream school and have complex issues/barriers to community engagement with an opportunity to participate in recreational activities/sport at no cost. 15.3.6 Sexual health workshops Youth Services provides primary and secondary schools and alternative education groups, with workshops on sexual health, puberty and respectful relationships when requested. 15.3.7 Mural projects Youth Services has partnered with young people, community and schools to develop murals. The mural projects provide young people with an opportunity to develop their creative/artistic skills as part of a community project. The murals have the added benefit of reducing graffiti in the Shire as they are strategically placed in areas that are identified as ‘hot spots’. 15.3.8 Sustain Program The Sustain program is delivered to young people who are in an alternative education setting (Community VCAL, Community Centre Gippsland, and Oakwood School). Young people develop a range of practical life skills as part of the program. 15.3.9 Rise Up Theatre Project Rise Up Theatre Project engaged year 10 students from five local secondary schools to participate in a piece of theatre that explored youth issues and created community dialogue about solutions to these issues. 15.3.10 Ignite Program 15.3.11 Stress down workshops 15.3.12 Drug and alcohol/party safe workshops The Ignite program was designed to engage young people who were at risk of disengaging from school. The program used music and film (the interests of program participants) to explore youth issues. Youth Services delivered a number of workshops to year 12 students. Students were provided with strategies of how to reduce stress during VCE, and informed about what support is available for them to access in their local community. As alcohol, drugs and smoking were in the top five issues that young people experienced in Cardinia Shire, a number of workshops have been developed to secondary schools and alternative education groups to provide education about hosting safe parties and the risks associated with drugs and alcohol. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 28 15.3.13 L2P Program Funded by VicRoads the L2P program supports young people to gain their mandatory 120 hours of driving experience with a community volunteer. Kooweerup Regional Health Service is contracted by Council to deliver the program. 15.4 Social support groups 15.4.1 Young Mums Group Youth Services in partnership with the Maternal Child and Health Service deliver a weekly program to pregnant or parenting young mums. The group provides participants with practical parenting skills as well as individual and peer support. Participants are involved in planning recreational activities on a term-by-term basis. 15.4.2 GLBTI (gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, intersex) The GLBTI group was established in early 2013 in response to young people wanting a positive outlet and social support from other young people who identified as being GLBTI. The group is delivered in partnership with TaskForce Community Agency. 15.5 Civic engagement 15.5.1 FReeZA committee’s Youth Services has now established two FReeZA committees due to the demand of young people wanting to participate in FReeZA. One committee is focused on music and the other focuses on culture, community and raising awareness about youth issues. 15.5.2 National Youth Week committee The National Youth Week committee is made up of young people across the Shire aged 13–18 years. These young people undertake event management training to assist them with planning and delivering the annual national youth week festival. 15.5.3 Young Leaders Program The young leaders program is delivered annually. It is targeted at young people who are year 10 or equivalent who display leadership skills. The program assists young people to build upon these skills and attributes. Young people increase their knowledge of how they can use their motivation, passion and leadership qualities in their school and wider community. The program has evolved to reflect young people’s needs and as a result a component of volunteering and developing a community project was implemented in the last two programs. 16 COUNCIL’S ACTIONS TO ADDRESS THESE ISSUES 16.1 Information dissemination The Youth Forum Survey Report is distributed internally as well as externally on Council’s website. Council’s Youth Services distributes the results to local agencies and organisations through Cardinia Shire Council youth network so that it can inform future program planning and encourage new partnerships to be developed. Results are also shared with members of the Cardinia Shire Council Youth Network, Interface Council Committee, Regional Youth Action Network (RYAN), local Secondary Schools and the Cardinia Shire Council Youth Strategy Reference Group. The reports are made available to the wider community via Council’s website. 16.2 Planning The data from the survey feeds into Council’s business planning, Youth services annual program and informs the delivery of the 2012–16 Youth Strategy. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 29 16.3 Advocacy and commitment Due to different organisations and levels of government having designated responsibilities and portfolios, Cardinia Shire Council may not have direct responsibility for addressing all concerns and gaps raised by survey respondents. However, Council is committed to listening to young people, their families and community partners to continually improve and develop local services for young people. Council uses the results of the survey when advocating for increased services and programs as well as developing local infrastructure which will meet the needs of local young people. Through Council’s commitment to working in partnership with government and local partners, it will share information to support the development of a more effective and joined up service system. Council’s Youth Services has used, and will continue to use, the results of the survey when advocating for an increase in specialist services (such as counselling and mental health services) within the municipality, as well as advocating for increased funding, grants and sponsorship. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 30 APPENDIX APPENDIX 1 YOUTH FORUM SURVEY Cardinia Shire Council wants to hear what you have to say. Learning about what is important to you as a young person in Cardinia helps us to consider the kinds of services and support young people would like and possibly need. We would like to know things such as; what you like to do, what issues you think are important for us to know about and suggestions you may have for things to be different. We keep your identity confidential and the information collected will be pulled together so we can understand what is important to all young people across the Shire. Your voice counts!! Age: ______________ female Gender (please tick) Do you have a physical or mental disability? male Yes No Not sure What country were you born in? ___________________ or Would rather not say What town do you normally live in/stay? _______________________________________________________ Please tick what is relevant to you Secondary school University Unemployed/not studying Primary school Full-time employment Apprenticeship/traineeship TAFE Part-time/casual employment VCAL, CGEA, Oakwood School Other _________________ Question 1 If you have experienced any of the following problems in the last year, please select what the top three issues of concern were to you, 1 being the most important rated issue, 2 as the second most important and 3 the third most important. Stress Bullying Cyber bullying Smoking School or work-related stress Alcohol Mental health issue Peer pressure Violence in public spaces Body image Drugs Being unhappy Family violence Transport Isolation No issues Victim of violence I don’t know Sexual health issue Graffiti Sexuality Life changing events (e.g. moving school, parent split up) Discrimination Being overweight Other _________________ Other _________________ Other ______________ Issue 1______________________________________ Issue 2 ______________________________________ Issue 3 ______________________________________ Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 31 Question 2 If you, or a friend, have experienced some problems as a young person and someone could have offered support – at what age do you think that would have been? Age: _____________ Question 3 If you need some information, advice or help with a problem who are the people or places you turn to? Please number in terms of priority with 1 being the most used, 2 being the second most used and 3 being your third most used. Immediate family (mum, dad, brother, sister) Extended family (aunty, uncle, grandma) Youth workers at My Place (youth facility) Telephone (kids help line) Friends Adult outside the family Phone apps Council website information Doctor Social media (chat rooms e.g. eheadspace) Other website information School teachers I don’t know School counsellor Youth workers Other _________________ Other _________________ Other _____________ Problem 1 ______________________________ Problem 2 ______________________________ Problem 3 ______________________________ Question 4 What are the top three things that are most important to you? Please number them in terms of priority with 1 being your most important, 2 your second most important and 3 your third most important. Friends Work Environment Place to hang out Recreational activities Sport Family Education Recreational activities Money Feeling happy Body image Access to support services Being successful Being healthy Equality Music/art Relationships Being accepted Other_________________ Other _________________ Other _______________ Priority 1_______________________________ Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 32 Priority 2 _______________________________ Priority 3 _______________________________ Question 5 Please tick what activities you do in your spare time. Work (part-/full-time) Outdoor sport activities Clubbing/pubs BMX/Bike trails Shopping Other Skateboarding/Skate park Facebook Instagram Music (band/lessons/playing) Gaming Internet Arts (dance/theatre/drawing) Parties Mobile phone (sms-ing) Volunteering Study Indoor sports activities Religion Tumblr Twitter I don’t know Gambling Other ____________ I don’t participate in any activities Question 6 Please tick what services, activities, programs, events or other opportunities you would like to see in your home town/area? Shopping centres Music festivals/gigs/concerts Improving the environment Cinemas Volunteering Sport Youth Centres Art programs Places to hang out Skate Parks Counselling services University TAFE Play grounds I don’t know Internet café Forums/committees for you to have a voice Other _________________ Other _________________ Other ___________ Question 7 In getting to your daily activities what are the top three ways you get around? Bus Parent drives me Skate/scooter Bike Train Friend drives me Nightrider bus Hitchhike Walk Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 33 I drive myself Taxi Other ___________ Activity 1 _____________________________________ Activity 2 _____________________________________ Activity 3 _____________________________________ Question 8 What are the top three ways that you would like to receive or find out information from Council about youth programs, services and events? Facebook Mail Posters at school Phone apps Posters in the community Telephone Website I don’t know Email QR codes Newspaper Text message Other _________________ Option 1: ____________________________ Option 2: ____________________________ Option 3: ____________________________ Question 9 If you could change one thing to help the young people from the Cardinia Shire, what would you choose to do? Question 10 Do you have any other comments to add? For entry into the draw to win an iPod or 1 of 5 $30 Westfield vouchers, ensure your details below: Name: _____________________________________________________________________ Mobile: _________________________ Email address: _______________________________ Address: ___________________________________________________________________ Optional: If you would like to be added to our youth services mailing list to find out about youth services events and programs, please tick how you wish to be notified below. Mail Text message Email All Thanks for your time in completing this survey. Please send hardcopy surveys to: Emma Carter – Youth Services Coordinator, Cardinia Shire Council, PO Box 7, Pakenham 3810 or fax 5945 4401 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 34 If you have anything you would like to discuss with Cardinia Shire Council’s Youth Services team or if you would like to talk to a youth worker, call 1800 4YOUTH or visit www.cardinia.vic.gov.au Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 35 APPENDIX 2 SERVICES, ACTIVITIES, PROGRAMS Below is a list of the services, activities, programs, events or opportunities that young people have nominated via locality. Shoppi ng centres Music festival s/ gigs/ concer ts Improvi ng the environ ment Cinem as Volunte ering Spo rt Yout h Centr es Art Progra ms Places to hang out Skate Park Counsell ing services Univer sity TAF E Forums /commit tees for you to have a voice Play ground s Inter net café I don't know Othe r Bayles/Cat ani/Cora Lynn 10 9 3 17 4 11 3 8 8 10 1 1 1 1 9 5 2 4 Beaconsfie ld 48 35 24 49 9 47 13 21 46 30 6 7 3 5 37 24 7 9 Beaconsfie ld upper/Guy s Hill/Pake nham upper/De whurst/M ount Burnett 13 15 11 21 8 15 10 10 17 3 3 6 5 3 12 6 1 2 Bunyip/G arfield/Lo ngwarry/ Modella/ Tonimbuk 7 41 24 47 13 41 19 20 38 22 7 12 8 5 30 20 4 7 Cardinia/ 5 5 5 12 2 6 0 6 11 5 0 5 3 1 6 6 2 2 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 36 Dalmore Cockatoo/ Avonsleigh 70 60 38 101 17 71 14 46 61 39 10 18 10 9 46 31 6 25 Emerald/ Menzies Creek/Cle matis 79 77 48 156 26 83 24 54 106 60 20 31 19 14 52 63 17 20 Gembrook 37 37 18 47 10 31 15 17 43 19 9 13 10 6 19 21 6 6 Koo Wee Rup/Mon omeith 40 29 11 56 3 29 5 7 33 13 5 10 5 2 16 16 7 14 Lang Lang/ Caldermea de 31 13 14 29 7 10 9 7 27 12 2 11 11 3 8 9 2 12 Nar Nar Goon/Tyn ong/ Maryknoll 16 18 5 15 4 13 4 7 8 3 4 3 0 3 5 5 6 2 Pakenham 187 220 92 264 63 138 72 75 177 66 45 72 83 29 68 74 54 32 Officer 16 11 8 18 4 13 0 5 11 8 1 3 5 3 5 5 4 2 Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 37 APPENDIX 3 EVALUATING THE SURVEY PROCESS The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data quality framework tool has been applied to the youth survey methodology and data collection to measure its “fitness for purpose”. Fitness for purpose is an assessment of the survey outcomes with specific reference to it intended objectives. The quality statement below covers a number of dimensions including the data collectors, the relevance of the data, timeliness, accuracy, coherence, interpretability and accessibility. Quality Statement Data source: Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Institutional Environment: Data Collector(s): Cardinia Shire Council's Youth Team is a local government organisation Collection authority: Cardinia Shire Council is bound under the privacy act and ensures confidentiality of the data provided. Data Compiler(s): Council complies the data Complete discretion and confidentiality is maintained in relation to the collection and reporting of the data. Relevance: Data topic: The data represents young people living, studying, working or recreating in Cardinia Shire aged 10 to 25 years of age. Level of geography: The greater proportion of the data is provided at a local government level including Cardinia Shire and the neighbouring municipality of Casey. Key Data Items: The key data items collected from this survey were the top three issues of personal concern that young people had experienced over the past year, the modes of communication and transport they use, activities they participate in and one thing they would change. Numerator/Denominator Source: Rates and percentages have been calculated for a number of responses using the total sample size. The data was collected to assess the views, needs and aspirations of young people who live, work, study or recreate in the Shire. It will be used to better target and improve service provision and inform the development of the Youth Strategy. The data collected provides a snapshot of personal issues of concern,, what they are doing in their leisure time, and improvements they would like to see in their communities. . Standard classifications have not been used other than age groupings Timeliness: Data collected: The youth survey data has been collected since 2007 on a biannual basis. Data available: The data is available four months after collection. Referenced Period: The data reference period is now 18 months. There are no updates or revisions to the data after its release, however it is compared to other data collection sources. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 38 Accuracy: Method of Collection: The data was collected in the form of hard copy and on line surveys from secondary and primary schools and one prep to year 12 school in the Shire. It was also available online from My Place, the Mobile Youth Bus and Council's website. Data Adjustments: The data was not adjusted in any way to account for nonresponse of the questions. Sample size: The total number of surveys received totalled 1,6873,004. Standard errors: A standard error count has not been included Under Counts: The number of young people aged 18 to 25 years of age was considerable less than the younger age groups. This was seen to be appropriate given that the main target group for Youth Services are the 13 to 17 years age group Over Counts: There were no issues with over counts The questions were open ended to minimise bias in answering. However in the younger age group, it was evident that groups of respondents provided the same answer. A code/numbering system was adopted this year to provide for more accurate interpretation of responses All age groups were represented in the survey and young people across the municipality well represented. Coherence: Consistency over time: This year a number of changes were made to the youth forum survey. These changes include the addition of six new questions and an amendment to the existing question relating to issues of concern. The new questions added to this survey include physical or mental disability, country of birth, current study and/or employment status, preferred age to receive support, who do young people seek support from and the top three things that are most important to young people. Consistency of jurisdictions: The data collected by Cardinia Shire is generally consistent with the youth data collected at the state and national level. Numerator/denominator: The data collected over the five year period for the majority of question s is comparable because of the relative consistency in survey questions and collection. There is a consistent time series for this data. Interpretability: Context: Cardinia Shire is one of the fastest growing municipalities in Victoria. Three new families move into the Shire every day, as a consequent many of the young people who participated in the survey would be part of the new and merging communities in the Shire. Other Supporting Information: A detailed explanation of the methodology and the respondents has been included in the report. There are no technical terms or service specific terms used in the report. Accessibility: Contact details: Cardinia Shire Council 1300 887 624 The Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of findings is available on Cardinia Shire Council's website. There are no privacy or confidentiality issues that prevent the findings being released. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 39 17 REFERENCES Australian Bureau of Statistics 2010, retrieved 15 August 2013 <http://www.smh.com.au/business/a-precarious-life-20120327-1vwhy.html>. Australian Institute of Family Studies 2010, Family Matters No.85, retrieved 25 August 2013 <http://www.aifs.gov.au/institute/pubs/fm2010/fm85/fm85.pdf> Australian Institute of Health and Wellbeing 2011, Young Australians Their Health and Wellbeing 2011, retrieved 17 August 2013 <http://www.aihw.gov.au/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=10737419259>. Australian Psychological Society 2012, Stress and wellbeing in Australia in 2012: A state of the nation survey, retrieved 22 August 2013, <http://www.psychology.org.au/NPW/survey>. Australian Research Alliance for Children and Youth 2008, The Wellbeing of young Australians: technical report. Woden ACT, retrieved 22 August 2013 <www.aracy.org.au>. Bottroff & Slee 2007, Bullying , Disability and Mental Health, retrieved 22 August 2013 <http://www.qld.gov.au/disability/children-young-people/bullying-disability-mentalhealth>. Centre for Community Child Health 2009 Caring for Young Children: What children need. Policy Brief No 15. Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne, retrieved 22 August 2013, <www.rch.org.au> (Demattia L, Lemont L, Meurer L, 2007, ‘Do interventions to limit sedentary behaviour change behaviour and reduce obesity? A critical review of literature’, Obesity Reviews, Vol 8, pp.69-81). Foundation for Young Australians 2011, How young people are faring 2011: the national report on the learning and work situation of young Australians, retrieved 17 August 2013 <http://www.fya.org.au/wpcontent/uploads/2011/FYA_HYPAF_Full_Report_PDF.p df> Hume, C, Salmon, J, Veitch, J, O’Connell, E, Crawford, D, Ball, K, nd, Children who met recommendations for physical activity and screen-time despite socio-economic disadvantage, Centre for Physical Activit and Nutrition Research, Deakin University Informed Decisions 2013, Cardinia Shire Population Forecast, retrieved 8 August 2013, <www.id.com.au/cardinia/forecastid/default.asp?id=213&gid=240&pg=8>. Informed Decisions 2013, How many cars do we own? – Shire of Cardinia Community Profile, retrieved 25 August 2013, < http://profile.id.com.au/cardinia/car-ownership>. Kids Help Line 2009, Bullying No Way, retrieved 21 May 2010, <http://www.kidshelp.com.au/upload/22846.pdf>. Mission Australia 2010, Youth Survey 2010, Sydney 2010. Mission Australia 2011, Youth Survey 2011, Sydney 2011. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 40 Mission Australia 2012, Youth Survey 2012, retrieved 22 August 2013, < http://www.missionaustralia.com.au/downloads/social-policy-reports>. Sweetser, Penelope; Johnson, Daniel; Ozdowska, Anne and Wyeth, Peta. Active versus passive screen time for young children. [online]. Australasian Journal of Early Childhood; v.37 n.4 Online Annex p.94-98; December 2012. Availability: <http://search.informit.com.au.ezproxy.lib.monash.edu.au/fullText;dn=195789;res=AE IPT> ISSN: 1836-9391. [cited 13 Sep 13]. Schochet I, Homel R & Montgomery D 2006, How do school connectedness and attachment to parents interrelate in predicting adolescent depressive symptoms? Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology. 1537 – 4424 Vol. 30 Issue 2 pp 70 – 79. Victorian Council of Social Services & Youth Affairs Council of Victoria 2013, Building the Scaffolding: Strengthening support for young people in Victoria pp 13 – 24. Victorian Council of Social Services 2010, Mind the Gaps, retrieved 21 May 2011, < http://www.vcoss.org.au/documents/VCOSS%20docs/Transport/VCOSS_mindthega p_report_web.pdf> Victorian Government 2013, Developing Transport Infrastructure and Services for Population Growth Areas, retrieved 25 August 2013 <http://www.audit.vic.gov.au/publications/20130821-Transportinfrastructure/20130821-Transport-infrastructure.html> World Health Organisation 2006a. Constitution of the World Health Organisation. Basic Documents, Forty-fifth edition, Supplement, October 2006. Geneva: WHO. WHO 2006b. Yang, F, Helgason, A R, Sigfusdottir, I D & Kristjansson, A L 2012, ‘Electronic screen use and mental wellbeing of 10-12-year-old children’, European Journal of Public Health, vol. 23, No.3, pp.492-498 Youth Affairs Council Victoria 2010, Sticks and Stones and Mobile Phones: Bullying Forum Report, retrieved 10 June 2010, <http://www.yacvic.org.au/policy/detailold.chtml?filename_num=309476>. Cardinia Shire Council Youth Forum Survey 2013 Report of Findings 41