Teacher Notes & Web-Resources Guide for The Many Faces of Tuberculosis: A Web-based Exploration Elliott Gimble, Life Science/HHMI Outreach Program Summer 2008 “Though conventional tuberculosis is highly treatable and curable (with a 90 percent rate of success), TB kills more people worldwide in a typical year, according to the Global TB Report Card, than ‘all wars, earthquakes, floods, tsunamis, airline accidents, terrorist attacks, and murder’ combined. Nearly two million people succumb to the disease annually, mostly in the developing world, where 98 percent of new infections arise.” (From: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/rxforsurvival/series/diseases/tuberculosis.html) Introduction: This web-based activity for students explores the microbiology, pathology, and socio-political aspects of tuberculosis (TB), a vital and growing global health threat. The ultimate goal is for students to integrate their understanding of the immune system, microbial taxonomy, and disease with critical thinking about global health policy. Students should come to this activity after having studied the human immune system and some microbial taxonomy; that is, an understanding of the differences between bacteria, archaea, viruses, and protists. Some other additional ideas, web sites, and resources (some specific to TB) are listed below for teachers looking to expand beyond tuberculosis or hoping to adapt this activity further for their classrooms. Goals: This web-based student activity has two goals: 1. (Student Goal): Examine and relate the microbiology and pathology of tuberculosis and appreciate the socio-political impacts of this global disease. 2. (Teacher Goal): Provide curriculum ideas and source suggestions for teachers developing additional web activities that explore other microbial diseases. Guiding Questions Pick some or all of these questions or suggested topics as focal points for the assignment, depending on the depth and emphasis you seek. What are the symptoms of the disease? What is the pathology of the disease? • What is wrong inside the body/organism? Which parts are affected and how? • How does the immune system respond to the disease? How is the disease transmitted? • Is there a microbial or an animal vector? Describe its life cycle. • How is it contagious or passed on to others? Summer 2008 Workshop in Biology and Multimedia for High School Teachers Harvard University Life Sciences – HHMI Outreach Program How prevalent is the disease? • Who and how many people or organisms are affected? • Are there demographic or geographic patterns in the spread of the disease? • What are the social, political, economic, or genetic factors that influence prevalence? What is the prognosis for a person with the disease? • How long do infected people/organisms live? Is it curable or only treatable? • In which ways and how seriously are their lives affected? What treatments are available? • Are they costly? Are they available to the general public? If not, why not? • What paths are researchers taking to try to prevent, control, treat or cure the disease? What does the latest research suggest? Case Study: A Case or Outbreak • Research and describe one specific case or an outbreak of the disease (and perhaps pertinent factors that led to it) as an illustration of the disease’s potential impact. Activity Ideas Using disease to integrate several topics in the curriculum can take many forms. Here are a few suggestions, from a single class period activity to a longer, independent project or paper. Webquest – Use the TB worksheet to have students explore tuberculosis on-line (in class or as homework) and complete the worksheet. Jigsaw – Have different groups of students focus their individual research on different diseases (or distinct aspects of a single disease) and in class, share what they have learned in small groups with others who have studied other diseases or aspects. Poster – Using the required topics as a guide, incorporate information on a creative and visually appealing poster to be used in a gallery walk or presented to the class. (A student information grid for up to 6 diseases is part of this Teacher Guide.) PowerPoint or other presentation – Students assigned a specific disease present to the class individually or in teams of two. Or use the TB worksheet to develop your own PowerPoint lecture using the information, video clips, and resources described. Brochure – Assigning some or all of the guiding question topics, student teams develop an informative and creative brochure describing a specific disease. Term Paper – Using the guiding questions (or others), assign a 5-7 page term paper on a specific disease, chosen by the student from a list. Consider having each student in a class section research a different disease. Summer 2008 Workshop in Biology and Multimedia for High School Teachers Harvard University Life Sciences – HHMI Outreach Program Resources CDC http://www.cdc.gov/DiseasesConditions/ The Center for Disease Control has many fact sheets and other information. This site provides a good starting place with an excellent list of diseases and links to specific sources. Other Disease Information Sites http://www.merck.com/mmhe/sec17/ch193/ch193a.html#sec17-ch193-ch193a-438 http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/tuberculosis/DS00372/DSECTION=causes http://www3.niaid.nih.gov/topics/tuberculosis/default.htm http://www.textbookofbacteriology.net/tuberculosis.html Includes more details of M. tuberculosis as an organism and disease pathology. World Health Organization http://www.who.int/en/ http://www.stoptb.org/ http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2008/pr05/en/index.html Includes maps, reports, statistics and information on MDR-TB. The Stop TB site includes information and videos specific to this disease and information on WHO’s partners in addressing TB. Microbeworld http://www.microbeworld.org/microbes/types.aspx Information on microbial life and taxonomy. Harvard Life Sciences/HHMI Outreach http://outreach.mcb.harvard.edu Excellent Lessons and Animations may be found here (the Immune System and Evolution are especially relevant to this unit). Nobel Prize http://nobelprize.org/ Source of information on the scientists and science behind many discoveries. Also some very useful animations and games specific to diseases or topics. Additional Activities and Websites 1. NIH Curriculum – Emerging and Re-Emerging Infectious Diseases http://science-education.nih.gov/supplements/nih1/diseases/default.htm NIH’s high school curriculum (free and on-line) with excellent activities and videos including the story of Debi French, a high school student who found herself fighting a case of active TB. 2. Medline TB tutorial http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/tutorials/tuberculosis/htm/index.htm (select to play it either with questions or as self-playing without questions). This excellent tutorial/slide show from the National Library of Medicine describes the disease, its prevalence, causes and treatment. May be a good review for those who learn best this way or who have extra time and inclination. Summer 2008 Workshop in Biology and Multimedia for High School Teachers Harvard University Life Sciences – HHMI Outreach Program 3.The Most Dangerous Woman in America: Questions about Quarantine http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/typhoid/ Video and activities to go with it about Typhoid Mary. Presents the public health challenges and issues surrounding carriers and quarantine. Could lead to discussion/debate in class, especially in conjunction with the Michael Speaker case; see the article below: http://travel.nytimes.com/2007/06/02/health/02tick.html 4. National Center for Case Study Teaching in Science http://www.sciencecases.org/mdr_tb/mdr_tb.asp This case study is one of several relating to microbes (and other topics in biology) at this SUNY- Buffalo website, dedicated “to promote the development and dissemination of innovative materials and sound educational practices for case teaching in the sciences.” 5. Rx for Survival http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/rxforsurvival/index.html This multi-part PBS series on infectious disease and the scientists and patients involved with them includes an excellent web site with education resources, video clips, links, etc. See also, for example, the July 18, 2008 edition of Science for information about the fight against antibiotic resistant TB. 6. Vitamin D and TB http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/review/rvw_spring06/rvwspr06_tb.html Recent research suggests Vitamin D may reduce TB infection. Answer Key to Part 2 of the Many Faces of TB exercise Part 2 – TB: The pathogen and the disease 1. How many people are thought to be infected with TB worldwide? (2 billion - 1/3 world population) 2. What is the name of the bacteria that causes TB? Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb). 3. How many people worldwide have active TB? (8 million) How many a year die of it? (2 million) 4. Although many people have TB in their body (are infected) only ___ in 10 will ever see the disease become active during their lifetime. (1) (Note: Patients with TB in the body but no symptoms has a case of “latent TB”; those with symptoms have “active TB.”) 5. In the US, the Centers for Disease Control estimate ________ people in the United States have active TB and another ___ to ____ million have latent TB. (13,799, 10-15) 6. Tuberculosis typically affects what part of the body? (lungs) 7. How is TB passed on from person-to-person? (in airborne droplets during breathing, etc.) Summer 2008 Workshop in Biology and Multimedia for High School Teachers Harvard University Life Sciences – HHMI Outreach Program 8. Why are people with weak immune systems more susceptible to developing active TB? They can’t fight it off. 9. What does the TB bacteria do in someone with active TB? (multiply, attack lungs, etc. move about via circulation). 10. Symptoms include: (cough, loss of weight/appetite, fever, chills, night sweats) 11. How are Multidrug-Resistant (MDR-TB) and Extensively Drug-Resistant (XDR TB) Tuberculosis different than regular TB? (forms in which TB can’t be killed by at least the 2 best antibiotics and sometimes others too). 12. When was Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) discovered and who did so? (1882, Robert Koch). 13. Name the organism(s) where Mtb is found: (only in humans). 14. TB can be treated successfully by using __________________ but these must be taken for months or even years. Multidrug resistant TB requires even more drug therapy over longer periods. (a variety of antibiotics) 15. Approximately _______________ people suffer from HIV and TB, according to the WHO; which disease is the primary cause of death for these patients? (11.4 mill; TB) Summer 2008 Workshop in Biology and Multimedia for High School Teachers Harvard University Life Sciences – HHMI Outreach Program