Retail Report of Warehouse Student Number: 7142501 Kate Lewis Fashion Promotion: MATS 10172 Contents Page: Page 3: Introduction Page 3: History of Warehouse Page 4: Company facts and figures Page 6: The marketing mix Page 9: S.W.O.T. analysis Page 12: UK retailing positioning map Page 14: Recommendations and analysis Page 16: Conclusion Page 17: References 2 Introduction Warehouse’s culture and style is one of tailored elegance, which inspires its customers with constantly changing clothing themes and ideas. The Warehouse chain was established in 1975 by Jeff Banks and Maurice & Michael Bennett (Mintel 2007). Since then it has been established with Sears, Arcadia, Rubicon and now Mosaic. After being with many groups Warehouse has finally established its brand image and is concentrating on growing within the market as being known for its “Styley, Confident, Sexy, Glamorous, Edgy, Clean, Individual” (www.warehouse.co.uk A) clothing and accessory range. There are currently 323 Warehouse stores, of which 36 are located outside the UK (Mintel). Warehouse has three main stores in London, and seven stand-alone stalls within department stores (www.multimap.com A). There are also two Warehouse stores within Manchester and the same amount of concession stalls as London (www.multimap.com B and Mintel 2007). This now covers 17% of Mosaic-owned stores. Warehouse has started competing outside the High Street, via the internet. Clothes and accessories can be bought through their web site, and recently a new Warehouse Outlet web site has been launched - where pre-seasons stock can be bought at cheaper prices. This report aims to analyse all aspects of the Warehouse brand, from the clothes it offers to its financial report. Building up knowledge on the store can then allow useful and relevant recommendations to be made. History of Warehouse 1976 - Jeff Banks and Maurice & Michael Bennett create the Warehouse brand. 1999 - Arcadia acquires Warehouse from Sears. 2001 - Arcadia sells Warehouse to Rubicon. 2005 - Rubicon is acquired by the Shoe Studio Group and changes its name to Rubicon Retail. 2006 - Mosaic acquires Rubicon and thus obtains Warehouse. 2006/2007 - Warehouse enters the Middle East, Indonesia, Philippines and Turkey. (Mintel 2007) 3 Company facts and figures The pro-forma figures in Figure 1 only show a 4.7% growth in sales across the UK Mosaic group, this is 0.7% lower than the overall growth in the UK sector. As this table shows the sales as if Warehouse had been apart of Mosaic for the whole of 2006 it could suggest a lower than average growth for Warehouse. Figure 1: Mintel 2007 When the data from Figure 1 is combined with that in Figure 2, a clearer picture of Warehouse’s performance is visible. Principles and Warehouse share a sales figure of around (£ 000, excl. sales tax) 567.2 over 2006 and 2007. This level of performance has continued into 2007/08 after ending 2006/2007 with a strong final quarter. (Mintel 2007) The sales figures for Warehouse come at a 17% rise compared with the preview years’ figures - meaning it has performed best out of all the stores within the Mosaic group. (www.drapersonline.com) This increase in sales could be because of the growing number of Warehouse stores. With 78 new stores opening between 2006 and 2007 (Mintel 2007) the store seems to have targeted a previously unreached market who are eager to buy their goods. The large number of international stores are also enabling a larger scope of consumers can be targeted by Warehouse. Ways of making these new stores well known could now be put in place to ensure every target consumer is made aware of Warehouse’s growth. And according to Warehouse its customers is “passionate about fashion, knowledgeable about trends, appreciates design and quality, body confident, independent, primarily 18-30” 4 (www.warehouse.co.uk B). This knowledge of its customer can then be used to develop useful forms of advertising. Figure 2: Mintel 2007 Although it is difficult to analyse Warehouse’s performance with these, quite vague, figures – it is easy to see that it’s a well performing brand. Although its only recently been introduced to the Mosaic group, it is already one of its most successful brands. Although some of the other Mosaic-owned stores aren’t in direct competition with Warehouse, staying at this high level of performance should try to be attained. The steady growth of Warehouse should be carefully monitored by the brand so that stores are only opened where they should make a profit. Expansion for the sake of becoming more global can be a risk as it can make the brand forget to target, and take pride, in different customer bases and thus causing a lack of consumer interest. 5 The Marketing Mix The use of the marketing mix allows Warehouse to break down all the different aspects of its company and analyse them separately. The different sections Warehouse will be scaled down into are price, product, place and promotion. Price The high standard of fabric quality and good tailoring means prices are quite high compared to other retail stores. The average price for tops sits at about £30; this is a pretty average price for high street clothes. Jeans and trousers from Warehouse are roughly £40, compared to stores such as Zara this is a more expensive price boundary - but is roughly similar to other brands such as Topshop. The high prices give the brand more of an exclusive persona. A new website called www.warehouseoutlet.co.uk contains pre-season clothes at discounted prices - offering cheaper alternatives which could reach a younger market. However in store - student discount is not available, suggesting that Warehouse is aiming for an older market. Jewellery and accessories are quite cheap, and are definitely affordable for an older and younger customer. Price Analysis There seems to be wavering image choices based on price which Warehouse seem to have not yet established. It comes across as an exclusive, expensive store in one respect - but a cheap and out of fashion store in another. Warehouse should try and decide on one of those approaches to price and just focus on that - instead of trying to appeal to a wide range of budgets. If Warehouse decides to continue its more reasonably priced image it should consider offering student discount as this could be a psychologically better way of promoting cheaper prices. As even though 10% (the usual rate of student discount) isn’t much, it draws in that market of consumers without giving a brand a cheap, low quality image. As Warehouse prices are similar to more fashionable brands such as Topshop, they to could consider creating more trends and fashions to better its competition. Or Warehouse could consider moving away from the same market as Topshop etc. and aim to be more exclusive to the older generation which many high street brands miss. Product Warehouse is well known for its high quality tailoring of formal wear such as suits - evening dresses are also recognised as popular buys. They offer clothes from size 6-16. 6 The turnover of the different ranges of products in-store is becoming increasingly more frequent (once a week) - offering the customer a wider variety of clothes. Warehouse clothes are distinctively high street, i.e. very mainstream. Similar clothes found in Warehouse can be seen in other stores. The clothes Warehouse offers are not classed as “disposable fashion” as they are too expensive. Many items are quite plain and simple to give them a classic and longer-lasting stance within fashion. Women’s-only fashion. Sub-brands within Warehouse include its Spotlight collection and WareDenim. Product Analysis The almost timeless pieces sold in Warehouse do give justification for its high prices, and increasingly more trends are being seen within the stores. The same sort of approach could be taken if Warehouse considers opening a men’s section, as men’s fashion is considerably more basic than women’s. The idea of branching out within its market segment could also be put in place with its range of sizes. Offering sizes 6-16 on today’s high street is seen as quite a small range - some stores offer sizes from 4-26. Warehouse could try and create a larger size range to become more competitive while appealing to a wider range of consumers. Currently in the Manchester Arndale store there are three main trend themes which rotate regularly to give a variety of looks. Origami (black, yell, grey), festival boutique and safari looks are currently in store - this is helping Warehouse loose its previous image of being quite serious and formal with little offering to the casual-wear market. Place Warehouse stores, within any city or town, are usually found on the main high street, in the main shopping precinct and/or in the large department stores. Its stand alone stalls feature in a wide variety of stores – such as Selfridges, House of Frasier and Debenhams. Within the Trafford Centre alone there are four different places where Warehouse items can be bought - making them extremely accessible. (www.mulitmap.com C) Warehouse also has a place within the electronic-retail environment. In 2006 the Warehouse website was re-launched with Fresca Commerce, which now provides a quick, safe and enjoyable Warehouse online transaction. (www.mulitmap.com D) 7 Place Analysis Having Warehouse situated on popular sections of retail high streets means maximum coverage from consumers can occur. However this also means that it is in constant competition with similar women’s clothing stores. This means Warehouse must make its stores look more distinct to draw consumers away from competition and into their store. Over the last five years, apparel buying online for womenswear has increased by 19% and is steadily increasing year by year (www.wgsn-edu.com). Warehouse should therefore strive to further distinguish its place within the online market to boost sales and size. Promotion Mannequins are used within the store to display items together to advertise specific trend looks. Few magazine adverts, only featured a few times in last months Vogue. Their plastic bags are plain white with the Warehouse name written in black along the bottom; these are similar to Topshop’s plastic bags and do little to advertise the brand. Little promotional activity has taken place to show off its online store. 8 Promotion Analysis I believe that for Warehouse’s recent image change into a more fashion-forward and individual brand to be successful, much more effort should be spent advertising these personas. Also, the services Warehouse offers online may hugely increase in popularity and demand if more promotional material was released about it. The new direction of fashion Warehouse is heading towards also has to marketed correctly, because “where competition or other impediments to positive consumer action exist…a promotional programme is developed and used to communicate with the targeted group” (Fill, Chris 1999) Other simple changes such as their plastic bag design could be changed to adhere to the current eco-friendly trend. Providing paper bags are not only physically more appealing than plastic bags, they are more noticeable to other shoppers while being carried. S.W.O.T. Analysis SWOT analysis’ are very effective at breaking down different areas of a brand so that possibly unrecognised factors can be made visible and taken on-board. Considering the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats of Warehouse can aid overall analysis of the brand and create practical methods of improvement. Strengths Shops are in good location for market penetration. Previous baby boom has increased today’s 20-30 year olds - which are Warehouse’s market, so large amount of possible consumers. There is an increase in professional women, which suits the smart and formal Warehouse image. They are creating more trends to comply with catwalk shows. Store layouts make finding trends easy and simple. They have maintained their high standard of quality and fit. The Warehouse online store is very easy to navigate. Weaknesses Weak promotion campaigns. Confusing brand recognition. Website claims positive aspects of store which could be disputed may be over confident? The store has been with four groups over the last 18 years, this lack of stability hasn’t allowed Warehouse to fully settle. Clothes are made from numerous different countries - loosing out on economies of scale. 9 The brand is well known and very established within retail. Opportunities Promotion of services and new clothing ranges could boost brand interest. Sub-brands could vary within the store; such as maternity, petite, tall and plus size ranges. High quality products could be reflected in high quality services, to differentiate themselves from competitors. Warehouse could use celebrity endorsement to give consumers a clear personality behind the brand. Warehouse are currently about to open stores in India and Russia, which will improve its international status and reach global markets. Threats Brands such as Topshop are more fashionable than Warehouse, and other competitors such as Zara are more affordable. Economic threats - the age range Warehouse is targeting may have little disposable income as will be buying first homes, cars and maybe starting families. Brands that can produce fast-fashion make Warehouse look like it’s not up-to-date. They do not offer a distinct service that makes them stand out from competition. Internal competition within the Mosaic group may mean too much pressure is added to compete with other Mosaic brands. Analysis of S.W.O.T. components Warehouse is a very promising brand - it is well known by consumers and with its usual prime locations on the high street; it can easily be accessed by their target market. The store layout is simple and trends are made visible according to the area of the shop they’re in, this further allows a customer to quickly come in and browse around - making it convenient for Warehouse’s working customer. However, the fact that it does have new stock coming in weekly and are of varying trends aren’t made well-known to the female market - not 10 knowing these facts could restrict the amount of times a consumer goes into the store in a month for example. The main way to get this message across would be though better and more distinct fashion promotion campaigns or in-store staff knowledge to boost the consumer’s knowledge on Warehouse. Warehouse is seen as quite an expensive high street store in comparison to competing brands such as Zara, this may have something to do with the mix of countries Warehouse manufacture from. Loosing out on economies of scale in such a large business can greatly reduce Warehouse’s chances of successfully competing for new customers. If Warehouse focused on only sourcing from one or two countries then it would be a start on being able to produce cheaper garments and possibly in a faster lead time. Or this money could be saved and used for spending on marketing and promotion. Further opportunities through new sub-brands could be a successful way of improving Warehouse’s portfolio without changing the new look it’s trying to achieve too drastically. A maternity range would be ideal at drawing in more consumers from the 20-30 year old market, as there is a gap in the market for fashionable and affordable maternity clothes. Consumers may also see this as a positive brand image - one who caters for all types of older women, from those jetting off on holiday, to having a baby or starting a new job. This representation could be identifiable to the consumer through celebrity endorsement, through someone or some women who encompass what Warehouse envisions its customers aspiring to be like. However the concern that celebrity endorsement is just a trend could mean that a lot of money is spent on advertisements which may soon seem out of date. Warehouse must still find a way of making itself stand out on the high street, as stated previously - major competition from retail brands means that unless Warehouse offers something different, it will fall behind other retailers. 11 UK Retailing Positioning Map 12 Key HM - H&M J - Joy KM - Karen Millen MS - Miss Selfridges NL - New Look P - Primark RI - River Island T - Topshop UO - Urban Outfitters W - Warehouse Z - Zara Positioning Map Analysis Positioning maps give a clear picture of the main Warehouse competitors in terms of price, quality and fashionability. It seems that Warehouse is on par with River Island and Topshop in terms of price. Although different markets are targeted between all three stores. Warehouse aims for the older market - so being in this high price range would still make it affordable for it’s customer, and possibly make it seem more exclusive. Warehouse performs better when it comes to high quality, rather than high fashion. This could be used to Warehouse’ advantage when deciding how to market its new ranges and trends. Warehouse would seem to sell better quality garments than River Island and Topshop, showing that there are potential opportunities to provide a retail factor that other shops are missing. Warehouse are also starting to see new competition arise in the form of new retailer ‘Joy’ – it competes on a similar price and fashion level and is becoming increasingly popular in Manchester alone. Warehouse could use its well-known brand image against Joy’s new persona to beat this new rival – through advertising campaigns or shop front layout for example. These tables are also helpful at analysing where consumers see Warehouse on the above scales; this can be compared to where Warehouse thinks they stand. If the two findings are different then Warehouse can construct ways of either improving to meet low consumer standards of the store, or to strive to reach high market impressions. Overall the tables should be filled in once a season, to also see where changes have occurred within Warehouse’s competition and general women’s fashion market. Keeping aware of competition movement will lower the chances of 13 Warehouse being suddenly faced with existing and potential customers moving away from their stores and towards others. However, the basis of all women’s clothing brands is fashion, a factor which Warehouse is struggling with. Topshop ranks far higher in fashionability, however River Island remains slightly below Warehouse. This is because shops such as River Island, H&M and Zara seem to design clothes that represent the store; rather than what trend is currently in. They stick to a theme of clothing throughout many seasons and become known for a particular style of design. Whereas Topshop just focus on being fashion-forward and do not concentrate too much on making the garments look like a specific Topshop style. Warehouse has the opportunity to fashion its clothes around either of those types, in the past it had more of its own look and with little fashion trends being used. Over the past year though Warehouse has started to identify more with current trends, meaning its place in the second table could rise over the next few years. Recommendations/Analysis I would first recommend that Warehouse creates a strong advertising campaign; either using celebrities who represent the new Warehouse look, or lots of smaller adverts to catch peoples eye on the fact that it’s a changed brand. Warehouse’s new persona may not be very well known by today’s consumers, so using celebrities will create media attention as well as indicating what the new vision and culture for Warehouse is. Expanding the product portfolio could also benefit Warehouse by offering more choice. Sub-brands which appeal to different sizes can lead to satisfied and loyal customers who can’t find clothes to fit in other stores. These are customers who will continue to return to the shop and may tell their friends about the store. This basic form of advertising is very effective at drawing in large groups of the brand’s market segment. Warehouse should also try and analyse what type of price group it wants to aim at. Locating in stores such as Debenhams and Selfridges give’s the brand a vast array of customers to please. Opening stores in locations known for expensive stores and then starting a discount warehouse web site also offer two very different sides of Warehouse. This means Warehouse would find it difficult to please both markets - focusing on the more exclusive price range would probably suit Warehouse best. Its already high prices and professional store 14 layout give a good base for creating a Warehouse brand which sells sophisticated and expensive pieces. Changing groups so often would leave any brand struggling to identify and settle itself within an organisation. Internally, Warehouse could try and build up strong relations with Mosaic so to lower the chances of another move. If Warehouse does this it will not have to worry about moving groups again for a good while and allow it to focus on more important aspects of the business such as pleasing the customer. Warehouse could also take up the opportunity of being part of a successful group by benefiting from economies of scale. Lowering internal costs could allow more money being put back into the business in key areas – such as towards promotion or improving quality levels. Carrying out more research into its existing customers could also benefit Warehouse. There it can be seen what markets, if any, Warehouse are missing but could target to – and also if there are any improvements Warehouse could make to its overall service. These could be put into place to make the company look more caring and inviting, while also correctly positioning itself for maximum profit and sales. Having an already well designed online store puts Warehouse directly ahead of competition such as Zara. If, through research, it is seen that Warehouse’s target market are regular internet users then it could be beneficial for Warehouse to promote its online store. This could put Warehouse one step ahead of some of its competition, increase sales and create a brand image which sees Warehouse as technology aware, up to date and easily accessible. Overall Warehouse should not try and ‘copy’ its competition, although they might be successful – consumers would probably prefer something different – whether this be through a personal customer experience or through the reassurance of excellent quality levels. Warehouse could take up either of those options and run it along side its new image of being more fashion and trend-aware to almost overwhelm customers and leave a positive, lasting impression in their mind. 15 Conclusion The Warehouse brand has been going through a drastic change recently to make itself more fashionable in the consumer’s eyes. When entering the store the changes are visible; with well dressed mannequins, attractive wall displays and definite trend section – however this change is useless unless it is recognised. Warehouse have definitely succeeded in providing an appealing shopping experience, this now needs to draw new customers to the store who still picture the old, less fashionable Warehouse stores. Afterall, “in today’s economy the consumer, not the company, is at the center of the business universe” (Woodruff and McDonald, 1982) Although there are important improvements Warehouse should make to its brand to create a larger customer group and sales margins – it is showing signs of recognising these factors. How these changes are carried out will be seen over the next few seasons, Warehouse does look promising though to turn itself around into a well defined fashion brand with new and exciting prospects. 16 References Websites www.mulipmap.com A – http://www.multimap.com/clients/browse.cgi?client=fresca_warehouse_01&GridE=-0.12618& GridN=51.50002&lon=-0.12618&lat=51.50002&db=GB&reclimit=10&place=London%2C%20Englan d%2C%20SW1P%203&submit=Search&submit.x=34&pc=&addr2=&client=fresca_warehouse_01&su bmit.y=12&addr3=london&scale=50000 – Accessed 10th Febuary 2008 www.multimap.com B – http://www.multimap.com/clients/browse.cgi?client=fresca_warehouse_01&GridE=-2.23437& GridN=53.48077&lon=-2.23437&lat=53.48077&db=GB&reclimit=10&place=Manchester%2C%20Lan cashire%2C%20England%2C%20M1%202&submit=Search&submit.x=0&pc=&addr2=&client=fresca_ warehouse_01&submit.y=0&addr3=manchester&scale=50000 - Accessed 10th Febuary 2008 www.multimap.com C – http://www.multimap.com/clients/places.cgi?client=fresca_warehouse_01 - Accessed 10th Febuary 2008 www.multimap.com D – http://www.multimap.com/press/press_releases/pr182_warehouse/ Febuary 2008 - Accessed 10th www.warehouse.co.ukA – http://www.warehouse.co.uk /fcp/content/Brand/content - Accessed 9th Febuary 2008 www.warehouse.com B – http://www.warehouse.co.uk/pws/content.ice?page=OurCustomer&pgForward=content Accessed 9th – Febuary 2008 www.drapersonline.com – http://www.drapersonline.com/news/2007/10/mosaic_earnings_rocket_despite_mixed_perfor mance_across_chains.html - Accessed 13th Febuary 2008 www.wgsn-edu.com – http://www.wgsn-edu.com/members/cotton-inc/reports/ci2008jan29_000307?from=search – Accessed 10th Febuary 2008 Reports Mintel Report (2007) Clothing Retailing, October, Mintel Publications, London. 17 Books Fill, C., (1999) Marketing Communications, Second Edition, Financial Times Prentice Hall. Essex, UK. Woodruff, J. L., (1982) Handbook of Textile Marketing, Fairchild Publications. New York, USA. Word Count: 3,967 words 18