711-M. Glander The Spark: Aesthetics’ balancing influence on western thought Long ago aesthetics was valued and part of commerce, it is returning to that role again reformulated and reborn. Its Gemini twin is the Sciences. The pendulum swings and does not judge, but societies are benefitted or challenged according to which quadrant the pendulum is in. For the purpose of this paper, we will look at Aesthetics as including art, music, literature that are media for stories, folklore, and fairytales. Derived from the soul of an individual, the Aesthetic drives him/her to perform or act in contribution to society as a whole. Science, on the other hand, encompasses data, theory, and proofs in observable, measurable areas derived from the intellect, and society pulls the scientist along in the direction of its interest. Both are seeking ‘truth’; however, they define it through sensory experience. Society or at least one other person has to be in agreement that the output is in fact what it says it is as art or science, so ‘the Spark’ is recognizable to all. Finally, both question culture in an attempt to prevent negative impact on culture as the practitioner sees it. More often those of both communities are at the whim of society for their paycheck. There are in fact more similarities between the two fields than dissimilaries, yet history has put them at polar opposites in competition with each other. This may be changing. Looking at the model Tolstoy presented in his essay “What is Art?” in 1899, and the UN report on Creative Economies, it is true that ‘Past is postscript’. Today the UN releases a report looking at how creativity merging with economics. The Creative Economy report claims in its Foreword that “This Report provides empirical evidence that the creative industries are among the most dynamic emerging sectors in world trade.” So how is it that we balance spirit and intellect today? Though the west focuses on intellect where “the development of modern culture is characterized by the preponderance of what 1 711-M. Glander one may call the ‘objective spirit’ over the ‘subjective spirit’” (Simmel, 1903), much of the developing world is still greatly influenced by and value ‘spirit’ or ‘the spark’. Those in the North-West can learn from the South-East to achieve better balance. And the South-East is struggling to retain the valued Spark as technology encroaches and changes their way of life. So in analyzing the question of the role of Aesthetics in balancing Science, can the balance be maintained by both paradigms? Definition: Down through history many have seen inspiration coming from the divine. In the Middle Ages, the influential mystics were St. Bernard and Bonaventure (anyone who gets a kick out of Song of Solomon is probably worth listening to). German mystics of the 13th century fitted their experience of a mystical union with God as transcending the conscious acts of intelligence and will. They described the experience as the ‘spark’ or ground of the soul [Eckhart, sermon 37]. Eckhart, Tauler, and Suso were all Dominicans, therefore, essentially Christocentric in their presentation of this view. They saw their lives as a balance of this ‘spark’ that is supra-rational —the Divine essence itself – with the intellect. Eckhart presents his view in this way: love and knowledge, which are activities of the soul and not the essence of the soul: it takes place in the innermost recess of the soul, the ‘spark’ or scintilla animae, where God unites the soul to Himself in a hidden and ineffable manner (Copleston & Eckhart, 1936, p 24-45). It is higher than knowledge, higher than love, higher than grace. For in all these there is still ‘distinction’. In this power God doth blossom and flourish with all His Godhead, and the Spirit flourisheth in God (Eckhard in Pfeiffer, 1857, 46, 3). The active intellect cannot give what it has not got. It cannot see two ideas together, but only one after another. But if God works in the place of the active intellect, He begets (in the mind) many ideas in one point (Inge, 1899, ftnote 250). Thus the ‘Spark’ is separate from usual life experience and brings creativity to it. 2 711-M. Glander The idea of inspiration coming from something greater than the intellect is also found in Judaism. Rabbi Maimonides hints at the vision of the light body that is the Merkabah, or vehicle of inner light formed from the hidden radiance of the soul, called Shekinah. You shouldn't think that these secrets are fully understood by any of us. They aren't. Frequently, truth flashes into us so we see like it is daytime, then concern and habit conceal it in form, and we are in the dark again, almost as before. We are like people in the dark of night, with lightning flashing repeatedly. For some here the lightning flashes continually, so they are always in light. They see the night as day (Maimonides, 1190/2004, p. 6). Sufi Muslims tell a story of a true lover who finds the Light only if, like the candle, he is his own fuel, consuming himself. The word used is ‘Ruh’ or soul-spark, and the soul is described as the divine spark within. Rumi distinguishes the spark from thought when he says, “Thinking gives off smoke to prove the existence of fire. A mystic sits inside the burning. There are wonderful shapes in rising smoke that imagination loves to watch. But it's a mistake to leave the fire for that filmy sight. Stay here at the flame's core” (Jalāl al-Dīn Rūmī, Coleman Barks (Trans). (1987). We are three: new Rumi poems. Maypop Books, p. 18). Artists and intellects alike acknowledged that their inspiration came from something higher than themselves for hundreds of years. The Schism: Artists, musicians, and writers were valued for tapping the spark and sharing the end product down through the Renaissance until the Enlightenment hit. “The artist must create a spark before he can make a fire and before art is born, the artist must be ready to be consumed by the fire of his own creation” (attributed to Auguste Rodin). From Spinoza and Leibniz onward, the rational and outward intellect took over the spark and inward gained insight successful separating the two. After that time, it 3 711-M. Glander has been much more difficult for artisans of all sorts to make a comfortable living as the intellect and science were valued over the aesthetic. The discussion of the interaction of inspiration in art and science continued as thinkers struggled with their life experience and the societal values, and they countered Enlightenment thinking from a philosophical standpoint. Schiller (1794) describes the controversy: Intuitive and speculative understanding took up a hostile attitude in opposite fields, whose borders were guarded with jealousy and distrust; and by limiting its operation to a narrow sphere, men have made unto themselves a master who is wont not unfrequently to end by subduing and oppressing all the other faculties. Whilst on the one hand a luxuriant imagination creates ravages in the plantations that have cost the intelligence so much labor; on the other hand, a spirit of abstraction suffocates the fire that might have warmed the heart and inflamed the imagination (Schiller, 1794, Letters upon the Æsthetic Education of Man, Kessinger Publishing 2004, p. 13). In the 1800s, men like Tolstoy explained and proposed alternative perspectives to aesthetics and science. A balance: Tolstoy Tolstoy commits a section of “What is Art?” focusing on the interaction of art and science. “Art is an organ of human life, transmitting man’s reasonable perception into feeling” (p.183). In his proposition, art’s future goal is “uniting the most different people in one common feeling, by destroying separation, will educate people to union, will show them, not by reason, but by life itself, the joy of universal union reaching beyond the bounds set by life” (p.184). Art’s role of lifting humanity, places it on a higher plane than science, but not as a substitute for it, but as partners in directing society. The symbiotic relationship is described in this way: True science investigates and brings to human perception such truths and such knowledge as the people of a given time and society consider most important. Art transmits these truths from 4 711-M. Glander the region of perception to the region of emotion. Therefore, if the path chosen by science be false, so also will be the path taken by art. Science and art are like a certain kind of barge with kedge-anchors which use to ply on our rivers. Science, like the boats which took the anchors upstream and made them secure, gives direction to the forward movement; while art, like the windlass worked on the barge to draw it toward the anchor, causes the actual progression. And thus a false activity of science inevitably causes a corresponding false activity of art (1899, p. 174, italics mine). Science is “the new human spiritual activity” (p. 174) in Tolstoy’s time. And he cautions that it is “the study of that which interests us – is science …the only real science—is harmful in that it diverts attention from the really important subjects to insignificant subjects” (p. 176). He continues by pointing out what should be the goal of science: We need only look around us to perceive that the activity proper to real science is not the study of whatever happens to interest us, but the study of how man’s life should be established, -- the study of those questions of religion, morality, and social life, without the solution of which all our knowledge of nature will be harmful or insignificant (p. 177). And he concludes that “only then will art, which is always dependent on science, be what it might and should be, an organ coequally important with science for the life and progress of mankind” (p. 182). The Shift: It is possible that such great thinkers as Albert Einstein have finally led us back to valuing Inspiration, Creativity, and Innovation. Without a doubt the greatest intellect of the twentieth century, Einstein credited his results as being generated by creativity and imagination, and he valued fairy tales as an aid to intellectual development. - “The true sign of intelligence is not knowledge but imagination” (Einstein, 1931, p. 97). - “I am enough of an artist to draw freely upon my imagination. Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world” (Viereck, G.S., 1929, p. 117). 5 711-M. Glander - “The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and all science. He to whom this emotion is a stranger, who can no longer pause to wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead: his eyes are closed” (Einstein, 1931, p. 44). Perhaps the horror of what science has led civilization toward in the war machines and the atom bomb have made humanity reconsider its ‘spirituality’, refocus on the Spark, and recognize that some things are greater than ourselves. Simmel in 1903 saw that the person resists to being leveled down and worn out by a social-technological mechanism. An inquiry into the inner meaning of specifically modern life and its products, into the soul of the cultural body, so to speak… Such an inquiry must answer the question of how the personality accommodates itself in the adjustments to external forces (1950). This is very difficult for a person raised in the North-West with the high value of independence. To consider a need for inspiration from outside one’s self is to admit that there is a lack within. Yet if the perspective is changed just slightly, a reasonable view shows that we are a part of all that is around us and that we are richer for being a part of and gaining insight from the world and each other. “At times our own light goes out and is rekindled by a spark from another person. Each of us has cause to think with deep gratitude of those who have lighted the flame within us” (Albert Schweitzer, 1965, p. 108). External influences and people are vital to our internal individual development and thinking. What took the place of pure science and reason was development or progress. In this new century the failures of progress are being seen (Easterly, Collins, Sachs), just as the failures of science were being seen in the early parts of the last century. The focus and pendulum swing is again on Creativity and Innovation, “Just as energy is the basis of life itself, and ideas the source of innovation, so is innovation the vital spark of all human change, improvement and progress” (attributed to Ted Levitt, HBR editor). Business Week introduced the “Creativity Economy” in 2005, 6 711-M. Glander The Knowledge Economy as we know it is being eclipsed by something new -- call it the Creativity Economy. Even as policymakers and pundits wring their hands over the outsourcing of engineering, software writing, accounting, and myriad other high-tech, high-end service jobs - not to mention the move of manufacturing to Asia -- U.S. companies are evolving to the next level of economic activity.” Business books fill the stands with titles such as Managing Creativity and Innovation (Harvard Business Essentials), Breakthrough Zone: Harnessing Consumer Creativity for Business Innovation by Roy Langmaid and Mac Andrews, Edison on Innovation: 102 Lessons in Creativity for Business and Beyond by Alan Axelrod, and The Secrets of Successful Team Management: How to Lead a Team to Innovation, Creativity and Success by Michael West. A new perspective is required and reconceptualizing old ways of doing business is vital. As we talk about the foreshadowing of a whole economy based upon creativity and innovation, the dawn of the ‘Creative Age,’ as the Nomura Research Institute put it, we are more acutely aware of the importance of reinventing our business strategies, our corporations, our communities, our schools, our housing and land-use policies, and more. Nothing can remain the same if we are to survive, let alone succeed, in this new global economy (Eger, 2007). Coming full circle, aesthetics and economics once more merge. So the UNCTAD proposes in its Creative Economy Report 2008 (CER) that developing nations, the South-East, can join the developed world, perhaps even leap-frog it, by forming innovative Creative Economies. The accompanying International Conference on Creative Economy for Development objective is “to promote the effective use of creativity as a source of wealth, a means of generating employment, and a significant factor in poverty reduction.” During this Conference in 2008, two NGOs from Africa, Maison des Jeunes de Kimisagara from Rwanda and the Lake Victoria and Nyansa Creative Arts Association from Kenya, were invited to participate in a partnership with a Brazilian NGO, Ação Comunitária do Brasil do Rio de Janeiro (ACB/RJ), to develop a pilot experience based on the creative- 7 711-M. Glander economy principle of sharing experiences in order to put into practice what had been discussed (p. 36). This is a beginning. Many South-Eastern epistemologies originally attributed ‘science’ to the mystical, and art brought the mystical into every day existence. Necessity for most in the developing world is the mother of invention, and this is seen in what they are able to do and create with very few resources. The focus on a heritage of traditional stories helps carry values into the present day. Even China is finding it needs a moral center to avert the destructive side of capitalism; it has chosen to revive Confucian principles (Tang, Yijie, 2007). Unity and inclusiveness of all parts of life is also found in Buddhist thought. All these aspects contribute to Creative Economies and can serve developing countries in joining the global community. In the merging and emergence of a new economy, the developing world can once contribute on an equal level. The convergence of human capital, cultural, and social capital with institutional capital forms creative outputs that are economically viable (CER, p. 34). Creative Economies, however, require a certain type of person, the Entrepreneur, who transforms ideas into successful businesses. And it is work done in community. This is the way that Africans understand and operate, and the new tool is the computer. The emergence of low-cost PCs gave rise to a powerful network that has transformed opportunities for learning and communicating. The magical thing about this network is not just that it collapses distance and makes everyone your neighbour. It also dramatically increases the number of brilliant minds we can have working together – and this scales up the rate of innovation to a staggering degree. As more and more of the world's information, commerce, and communications moves to digital form, it will open the door to a new world of connected experiences that link our interests and our communities into a seamless whole that extends across home, work, school and play. 8 711-M. Glander Already, a new generation of technology is transforming expectations for how we will conduct business, communicate, access entertainment and much more. Increasingly, people envision a world of anywhere access – a world in which the information, the communities and the content that they value are available instantly and easily no matter where they are (CER, p. 17). Entrepreneurship seems natural to the African milieu and perhaps the same powers that motivated the entrepreneurs at the turn of the 20th century in America are at work in the global South today. To reflect the growing number of African entrepreneurs in business today, and to showcase to the world Africa's limitless intellectual and economic capital, The African Network (http://www.theafricannetwork.org/) TANCON theme in 2009 is “Fostering African Entrepreneurship”. Certainly with a few skills and tools, young Africans entrepreneurs can contribute significantly to their nations’ growth. The Creative Economies encompass workers at all the stages of development from: (a) creation/ conception – where the development of an idea or concept takes place; (b) production/ reproduction – the stage at which an idea or concept is developed further then packaged; (c) marketing and distribution; and (d) consumption. This could mean many jobs, but requires numerous skills as well. The areas addressed by the Creative Economy Report embrace many different fields of creativity with various ways of categorizing them: Design Creative design is expressed in several ways: through the creation of decorative luxury items such as jewelry, by the uniqueness of a functional service such as the architectural design of a building, or as utilitarian mass-produced goods such as an interior object. Creative services Publishing & printed media Heritage goods and services Visual arts Audiovisual Performing arts New media 9 711-M. Glander CER, p. 37 One example given in the Report included: The city of Popayan, Colombia, was appointed as the first UNESCO City of Gastronomy and it provides quite a different model for development. It has made extraordinary strides in formalizing its informal gastronomy industry. By facilitating space and other facilities, imposing mandatory hygiene regulations, and publishing widely circulated restaurant and food surveys that include even the smallest food stands, Popayan has invigorated its economy and provided jobs and income to many people through the conscious support of this subsector of the creative industries. This newly discovered transparency and openness to the world are giving individuals, families and communities in Popayan the opportunity to come together and celebrate their distinctive recipes, rituals and ingredients within an international forum (p. 20). The focus on Africa in the section called, “Africa Remix: Contemporary Art of a Continent” is easy to imagine since “economically distressed countries such as Mali, Mozambique, Rwanda or Zambia have significant production and consumption of cultural products such as music, dance, crafts and visual 10 711-M. Glander arts” (p. 44). Ghana, Mali, Nigeria, and Senegal integrated culture into their Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs) as “major axes”. The PRSP for Mali links culture with religion, social harmony and security as a major axis in the country’s poverty reduction strategies. This is in recognition of the potential of Malian culture in promoting traditional and religious values with a view to creating a climate of social harmony and security (p. 45). As mentioned before Africa has entrepreneurs, art that values traditions, the drive to gain benefits from developing countries, and a community focus. Can she compete in the contest and not just succeed, but teach the North-West how it can be done? The Challenges: The biggest question is whether or not the Creative Economy will grow significantly enough to make a difference for Africa. Currently it is only 3.5% of total world exports (CER, p. 115). Is this approach for developing countries truly competitive or just novel? Significant hurdles for African countries to succeed in the Creative Economy include proper use of resources, training and recruiting talent, and advocating and implementing policies. The CER points out how this can happen in the ‘omnipresent’ dimensions of education, work, leisure, and entertainment. It goes on to show the need for a ‘society-inclusive’ dimension that integrates public and private sectors as well as all social classes – Africa still needs to address these areas. The ‘Intertemporal’ dimension includes the past, present, and future time in consideration and inclusion for economy development. This would allow cultural and historical values to not be lost, but reinforce the need for policy in the areas of economics, technology, culture, and society. This multi-dimensional approach is also multidisciplinary to include culture, labor, trade, technology, education, and tourism as seen in the figure below. The attempt is to balance the creative with the technological and economic. 11 711-M. Glander CER, p. 35/59 Examples of the hurdles in the value chain of the music industry include: African artists who have successfully penetrated World Music and who have been recorded locally need intermediaries in order for their work to be distributed internationally, so the commercial value of their success is not necessarily retained within their countries. This lack of understanding extends not only to role-players within the industry but to the industry and government, where commercial goals and objectives of cultural policy collide over the purpose of the support and where role-players see themselves in competition with one another (p. 64). Infrastructure needs also include local studios for recording and factories to produce CDs and publish music. The other area that is yet largely undeveloped is Internet distribution (p. 103). These are just some examples in the area of music. In the area of art, convincing the North-West to buy the creativity of the South-East is yet another challenge. For many it does not fit their aesthetic appreciation. Some have argued, for instance, that African art does not exist because the traditional objects that we might consider to be art do not meet the Kantian requirement that the objects only serve an aesthetic imperative. In other words, something is only art if it has a kind of purity to it, and is considered in itself, rather than in its 12 711-M. Glander cultural or social context. Clarification of cultural understandings such as this may need to occur for an exchange to be beneficial on both sides. Tourism is the third largest money maker in the country of Mali, but the influx of tourists is eroding the local cultures and arts and contributing to only a few pockets. Is the cost worth the benefits? The Dogon are a people group (450,000 worldwide) of the country of Mali that live on cliffs that run 200-300 miles north-south. They live as they have for a millennium since they first migrated to the area. Their art and traditional practices are an integral part of their daily life, have influenced artists such as Picasso, and are displayed in the major museums of the world (see metmuseum.org – Works of Art). According to the World Tourism Organization (2006), the number of international tourists has increased from 40.000 to 200.000 between 1990 and 2005. Tourism has encouraged the preservation of local way of life of the blacksmiths and cloth making with modifications (Hoffman, 1997, p. 168) and revealed to the world a rich cosmology of a ‘primitive’ people (Griaule, 1954). The Dogon leadership structure is one of elders that meet to determine village issues and enforce the cultural value system through storytelling and ritual. However, with tourism, there is little supervision of the guides or artisans due to the lack of ‘manpower’ and the relatively large amounts of money there is to be made. Obviously it’s going to affect the leadership structure and value system of this tribe. Since the money is now in the hands of the young, 20-something guides, this system is being overturned with the young men having the power to decide where the money goes and how it is spent and which stories are perpetuated and proliferated (often incorrectly) to a world audience. “It is no longer the family or the community that is proprietor and caretaker of resources, but the individual who is responsible for his own survival or demise” (Hoffman, 1997, p. 153). The elders in their phlegmatic, fatalistic way shrug 13 711-M. Glander their shoulders and say, “It is just the way it is.” Can the Dogon access the resources to enforce measures required to keep the tour guides accountable, to resolve conflicts over the sale of cultural artifacts not facsimiles (van Beek, 2003, p. 21) and how traditions are modified (Hoffman, 1997), and to keep tourism from destroying the very reason tourists come to the area? A forum of elders may go some distance to meeting this need. Developing new industries, partnerships, and knowledge can help. How do the Dogon put limitations on access for outsiders and yet allow or create access for all people to see the beauty that is Dogon? Conclusion: While the North-West thinks about how to do Creative Economics, the South-East practices it and are driving to succeed. Are Creative Economies closer to Tolstoy’s direction of how “man’s life should be established”? Are aesthetics finally rebalancing western thought and therefore allowing world-wide inclusion? Only time will tell as the pendulum swings. The wise person seeks the balance between Aesthetics and Science, the soul and the intellect, and preserves and values the Spark. ---- 14 711-M. Glander References Copleston & Eckhart. (1936). History of philosophy / Die deutchen Werke: erster Band, Meister Eckhart's Predigten, p. 24-45. Stuttgart-Berlin. Eger, J. M. (2007). The master of fine arts degree is now the new M.B.A. San Diego Business Journal, May 14. (also http://www.govtech.com/gt/articles/100427). Einstein, A. (1931). Mein Weltbild In Patrick, G. & Chapman, F. (1935). Introduction to Philosophy. Einstein, A. (1931). Cosmic religion: with other opinions and aphorisms. New York: Covici-Freide. Griaule, M. and Germaine Dieterlen. G. (1954). The Dogon. In African worlds: studies in the cosmological ideas and social values of African peoples. Daryll Forde (Ed). London: Oxford University Press, pp. 83-110. Hoffman, R. (1997). Tourism and the Dogon sculptor. PhD dissertation. UCLA. UMI No. 9811458. Inge, W. R. (1899). Christian Mysticism. Lectures at Oxford, 1899. Ftnote 250. http://www.archive.org/stream/christianmystici14596gut/14596.txt) Pfeiffer, F. (1857). Die deutsche Mystik. 2 vols. Leipzig, p. 543. Maimonides. (1190/2004). The Guide of the perplexed. Barnes and Noble. Rūmī, J.D. & Barks, C. (Trans). (1987). We are three: new Rumi poems. Maypop Books. Schiller, F. (1794). Letters upon the æsthetic education of man, Kessinger Publishing (2004). Schweitzer, A. &Kiernan, T.J. (1965). A treasury of Albert Schweitzer. Citadel Press by arrangement with Philosophical Library. Simmel, G. (1903). The Metropolis and mental life. Adapted by D. Weinstein from Kurt Wolff (Trans.) The Sociology of Georg Simmel. New York: Free Press, 1950, pp.409-424. Retrieved from http://www.altruists.org/static/files/The%20Metropolis%20and%20Mental%20Life%20(Georg% 20Simmel).htm and also see Google Books. Tang, Yijie. (2007). The contemporary significance of Confucianism. Frontiers of Philosophy in China. Volume 3 (4), December, 2008, pp. 477-501. Translated by Yan Xin from Jianghan Luntan (Jianghan Tribune), 2007, (1): 5–14. Tolstoi, Lyof N. (1899). The complete works of Lyof N. Tolstoi. Aline Delano (Trans.) NY: Thomas Crowell & Company. 15 711-M. Glander UNCTAD. (2008). Creative Economies Report. Retrieved from http://www.unctad.org/en/docs/ditc20082cer_en.pdf van Beek, W. E. A. (2003). African tourist encounters: effects of tourism on two African societies. Africa; 73, 2; International Module, 251-289. Viereck, G.S. (1929). What fife means to Einstein. The Saturday Evening Post Vol. 202, 26 October, p. 117. 16 711-M. Glander Appendix: CER p. 208 Alphadi: The fashion caravan Seidnaly Sidhamed, alias Alphadi, was born on 1 June 1957 to trader parents in Timbuktu, Mali. One of nine children, in Niger he grew up in the company of his siblings and liked to put makeup on his sisters and mother. He also studied the makeup of actresses in Hindu films. At a young age, this designer-to-be was already intrigued by everything that could enhance and better showcase feminine beauty. In Niger, however, fashion was taboo for boys. While his father had envisaged that Alphadi would pursue a medical career or work in the family business, following graduation from high school, Alphadi went to Paris to study tourism. In this centre of fashion, he was able to attend fashion shows and he also took night courses at the Chardon Savard atelier. Once he had completed his studies, he accepted a director’s position at the Ministry of Tourism in Niger, but he still had a passion for fashion. While working at the Ministry, he continued to perfect his fashion skills by receiving in Niger professors from Chardon Savard. In 1985, two years after having decided to devote his life to fashion, he presented the haute couture fashion line that he had created at his first fashion show, which was held in the City of Light during the International Tourism Tradeshow. From that time on, Alphadi has had many successes, including the Best African Designer award from the Fédération française de la couture et du prêt-à-porter in 1987. His fashion shows are familiar worldwide – in Abidjan, Brussels, New York, Niamey, Paris, Quebec, Tokyo, Washington. In 1999, he expanded his label by creating a line of sportswear called Alphadi Bis. With Wrangler, he also created Alphadi Jeans, and 2000 saw the launch of l’Air d’Alphadi, the first perfume by an African couturier. After twenty years of a career in fashion, with fashion shows organized all over the world, boutiques in Africa, Europe and the United States and, most importantly, an internationally respected brand, Alphadi is one of the most well-known African designers from the continent. Warm, very affable and experienced, this artist is ever ready to talk about his field. Inspired by the rich traditions and colours of Africa, Alphadi “firmly believes that fashion and culture are the industries that can lift Africa to the ranks of prosperous nations”. 17 711-M. Glander 18 711-M. Glander 19 711-M. Glander General public at: http://www.unctad.org/statistics, or www.unctadxi.org/creative . After cotton and gold, culture and tourism are our main resources. Other thoughts that don’t ‘fit’: 20 711-M. Glander Definition of knowledge – dynamic, capitalism and profit making, quality -> no room for mistakes and learning. Collaborative knowledge creation – impediments, having to learn how to do it. Whether or not to love someone enough to lead them through (love past insecurities, build on strengths), no way can do the work without team member (Alison, Dr. Tony). Rules of engagement with those of differing cultural backgrounds. Understanding worlds to create a unified perspective. Multiple modality. Knowledge – and billable hours. Recognition if not compensated. 21