Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework EVERY PARENT A PROPOSAL FOR A POLICY FRAMEWORK AND IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGIES FOR DELIVERY OF PARENTING PROGRAMS BY CHILD AND YOUTH HEALTH Prepared by Pam Linke for Child and Youth Health July 2001 1 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework CONTENTS Introduction Preamble Purpose of the parenting policy framework project The importance of parenting Child and Youth Health role Current context for parenting Parenting Policy Vision Policy Objective Principles Policy Interpretation Framework Key Result Areas Overview of Recommendations Strategies and Initiatives Conclusion Appendices Appendix 1. Stakeholders Consultation Appendix 2. CYH Managers' Consultation Appendix 3. WA Parent Consultation. Appendix 4. National and International Investment in Parenting. Appendix 5. Parenting Programs in South Australia. 2 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework INTRODUCTION This document presents a proposed framework for Child and Youth Health to use for delivery of parenting programs congruent with government's obligation to support all parents. The goal of the framework is to make a significant contribution, in partnership with parents and other relevant agencies, to the development of safer, more competent and more supportive communities, the promotion of child and youth health and resilience and the prevention of crime and antisocial behaviour. It is expected that the strategies recommended will impact on other agencies both voluntary and within DHS with immediate benefits in offering a source of referral for parenting programs, and working in partnership, and downstream effects in less need for service provision. The document is intended to be read in conjunction with the accompanying report "What Works" and does not repeat in any detail the findings in that report. The recommendations in the document are based on the evidence of efficacy and cost effectiveness of programs for parents which have been rigorously evaluated and have produced positive outcomes for children, families and communities in the short and longer term. It is also based on the contribution of stakeholders about where there are gaps in services for South Australian parents, and what the role of Child and Youth Health should be in the delivery of services to parents. There is a plethora of well-evaluated research about programs for parents and outcomes for children, and the importance of supporting parents is accepted by most major western nations, by other states in Australia and by South Australia (see evidence in What Works). Stakeholders’ consultations also support this. What is needed is the implementation of the programs that can make a real difference. Child and Youth Health is in a unique position to extend its major contribution to the health of South Australian children and families through support to parents by virtue of: its long history of working with parents (since 1909) its wide community acceptance as a parenting resource its wealth of experience and knowledge about parenting its Statewide reach and mandate to serve parents across South Australia. It is noted that the efficacy of many of the programs offered by Child and Youth Health in the present or in the past is supported by the research in “What Works”. The research and consultation give a sound basis for extending, further developing, building onto and evaluating these programs. I would like to acknowledge the valuable contributions of the Child and Youth Health policy planning group, the project reference group, the Child and Youth Health manager’s forum and the stakeholders consulted. I would particularly like to thank Julia Cranney and Tina Karanastasis from DHS Policy and Planning, Karen Lamont from the Department of Education Training and Employment, Chris Caudle and Ros Islip from Child and Youth Health, Planning and Development for their support and important contributions to this paper. Pam Linke 2001 3 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework 4 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework PREAMBLE The purpose of the Parenting Policy Framework Project This project has been undertaken to review Child and Youth Health services to parenting in the current context and to recommend future directions. The importance of parenting Parenting provides for the development, care and protection of children and young people in ways that aim to maximise their opportunity to grow up in a safe and stable environment and reach their full potential. Parenting involves the relationship and interactions between parents, children and young people, all of whom are continually developing. It is a demanding and at times difficult task, which requires not only inner resources of empathy, resilience, confidence and appropriate skills and knowledge, but also the support of a caring community. Every parent is different, each with their unique qualities and each facing different challenges in their parenting. Parenting is not entirely learned, it is about loving and caring and an expression of people’s individual relationships with each other. Some of the basic components of effective parenting are acceptance of the child as a unique, loved and lovable human being, with opportunities for the development of secure attachment relationships a physically and emotionally safe and protective environment developmental opportunities provided by adequate food, education, health care a stimulating environment and encouragement of opportunities for play guidance in the development of behaviours and skills for positive and respectful interactions with others. The Child and Youth Health role The Mission of Child and Youth Health is to work in partnership with individuals, families, communities and relevant organisations: to enhance the health status of children and young people in South Australia, focusing on the promotion of health, and the prevention of ill-health, and to support those parents and families who are the primary carers of children and young people. While support for families in their essential role of parenting children and young people has always been an important part of the mission of Child and Youth Health, new research is showing clearly the increasing needs of parents and the value of supporting them in their role. Child and Youth Health supports the achievement of DHS Strategic Directions in relation to parenting and will make a significant further contribution to the promotion of effective parenting through leadership, policy development and service delivery across South Australia. In addition, Child and Youth Health will assist in the 5 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework development of caring communities that provide support to parents, and contribute to the enhancement of parenting through the development of supportive social policy. 6 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Current context for parenting Child and Youth Health is an organisation which implements the responsibilities and commitments of Government to provide services to parents. As a State wide service, Child and Youth Health makes a major contribution to the health and well being of children, young people and the community through its services to parents. It does this both through the services it provides to parents across the State and through its role in provision of information and leadership related to parenting. The evidence for re-orienting Child and Youth Health parenting services comes from many sources including the following. Demographic changes such as family mobility and different family structures impact on traditional support and knowledge bases for parents. Current research highlights importance of parenting and what helps to ensure positive outcomes for children. (See "What Works") National and international policy developments focus on the importance of providing supportive environments for children. Community expressed concerns about the need for safe and supportive environments for their children. Consultation with major stakeholders reinforces the importance of support for parents in South Australia. Consultation with parents indicates that parents want safer, more supportive communities and services which value family relationships. Overseas studies have shown the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of providing services to parents. 7 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework CHILD AND YOUTH HEALTH PARENTING POLICY 8 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework CHILD AND YOUTH HEALTH PARENTING POLICY VISION South Australian parents will have services in preparing for parenting to the point where young people make the transition to interdependence and independence and that support them to optimise the life opportunities for each child and provide for a safer and more supportive community. OBJECTIVE The objective of this Policy Framework is to provide clarity about the role, expectations and values of Child and Youth Health in providing services for parents, and others who are involved in parenting, in relation to their parenting role. The Policy Framework demonstrates the organisation’s commitment to promote, improve and support parents’ role and to strengthen families and provides the basis for all Child and Youth Health strategies and activities . PRINCIPLES Child and Youth Health services to parents and those who care for children and young people are based on the following principles. The best interests of the child and young person are paramount. Effective parenting is fundamental to the healthy emotional, physical, cognitive, social and spiritual development of children and young people. Parents have the primary responsibility for bringing up their children and others in the community make a valuable contribution. Children have the need for care and nurture from both parents where this is possible and in the best interest of the child. A positive, ongoing, reciprocal relationship with at least one caring adult is basic to healthy development. The ability to parent is based on each individual’s level of knowledge, confidence, self worth and own experiences of being parented. Diverse family patterns are to be respected within the framework of Children’s Rights and Australia’s legal obligations, with recognition that there is no one right way of parenting and rearing children. Parenting is enhanced with adequate social and community support. Collaborative work between governments, community organisations and the corporate sector is an effective way to provide services to parents. Parents should have access to the best evidence based information available to support their parenting role. In order to respond sensitively and appropriately to parents’ needs, those who work with parents need to understand their own attitudes, feelings and values in relation to parenting. Effective services to families and children are based in responsive relationships. 9 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework POLICY INTERPRETATION FRAMEWORK The Child and Youth Parenting Policy should be interpreted within the following framework. The primary emphasis of parenting programs and activities will be on promotion and support of effective parenting as a foundation for optimal child health and development. Information, skill development and support for parents will be designed to contribute to the achievement of Child and Youth Health Strategic Directions for parenting, namely: - providing the opportunity to build skills, support and network through individual parent contacts, parenting groups and the provision of parenting information - providing additional support and opportunities to learn parenting skills, to parents with special needs - identifying additional ways of working, including with other service providers with parents, to increase their parenting skills and confidence - working in partnership with the Department of Human Services, including the Aboriginal Services Division, to further develop services to parents across the state. Planning for future parenting services will be guided by an evidence based planning model which incorporates the following - identification of health and wellbeing issues including the physical, behavioural, emotional, political and environmental aspects - demographic analysis - prevalence and severity of identified health issues - community consultation - assessment of the efficacy of interventions. Concentration of effort will be in areas of highest impact such as the early years and periods of developmental transition, and families with indicated needs based on principles of equity of access. Targeted parenting programs will be offered within the context of a universally available parenting service. Staff who are to be involved in these programs will be given appropriate training and mentoring. Statewide parenting programs and services will be determined corporately by Executive or a Child and Youth Health parenting working group related to the National Health Goals (one of the working groups to be formed around the five for children and young people). There will be some regional parenting initiatives based on evidence for a particular local need and within the overall principles and organisational focus. Research in practice programs will be conducted in conjunction with the research capacity of the Planning and Development Directorate. It is recognised that all Child and Youth Health contacts with parents have the potential to impact positively on parenting skills and relationships and outcomes for children, so all staff will be appropriately skilled in providing relationshipbased service to parents. 10 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework KEY RESULT AREAS All services will have continuous quality improvement through staff training and mentoring. Specialist services for parents will have specially trained and selected staff and leadership with expertise in parenting and child development. All services will be based on the best available evidence at the time. 1. Raise awareness across the whole community about the importance of parenting and the requirements of children for optimal development through information, community education and media promotion. 2. Provide information and education for all parents through written, face to face and on-line means. 3. Provide a universal home visiting and assessment service. 4. Provide a targeted home visiting service consistent with models that have proven effectiveness for infants who are at risk of compromised developmental, educational and/or social outcomes. 5. Provide group support, education and skill building sessions for new parents. 6. Provide, in partnership with other appropriate agencies, neighbourhood parenting centres to offer a raft of services to all parents related to need and opportunities for social capital building. 7. Support a volunteer group "Friends of CYH" in building parenting support in local communities. OVERVIEW OF RECOMMENDATIONS The following section introduces in more detail the strategies and initiatives that Child and Youth Health could use to implement the recommendations from the research. Clearly if the evidence shows areas where what we are doing could have more benefit for parents by a shift from current activity to a more effective one, making that shift will be one of the strategies recommended. For other recommendations there are not sufficient resources to implement them effectively within the current budget and these have been identified with suggested resource implications. There are four broad categories of recommendations: Maintenance of existing activities. Further development of existing activities. Reduction or termination of existing activities. New initiatives. 11 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework OVERVIEW OF CO-ORDINATED PARENTING SERVICES WITH UNIVERSAL AND RESPONSIVE SERVICE PROVISION BUILT ON A BASIS OF WIDE COMMUNITY KNOWLEDGE ABOUT PARENTING. (Adapted from National Mental Health Strategy, 2000, model). This model is based on developing links across DHS services and partnerships with communities and agencies which serve them. n io ve nt pr e Parent Helpline n ntio r ve parent educat ion groups i nte od urho hbo ne ig nting par e r es c ent ted ge ar et g siv itin o n is sp v r e ome h uni versal home vi sit ing for all new parents new parents groups nt ar e p ted ling e l g tar unse co referal for intervent ion Increased knowle dge for al l parents www.cyh.com - parenting information for local groups Parenting SA - PEGS/media 12 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework STRATEGIES AND INITIATIVES The following strategies and initiatives are based on the best evidence available and together will provide a coordinated and comprehensive service to families across South Australia with maximum potential to positively influence outcomes for children. (Where there are no recommendations the implication is that the service should continue as is). The Strategies and Initiatives are predicated upon the development of a parenting leadership team with appropriate expertise and support, to undertake further development and implementation of the projects. A team of parent educators from regional staff with an interest in this aspect of parenting would be involved in delivery of parent education programs (not necessarily full time) and a team of infant specialists would deliver specialist infant programs, including home visiting. Key Result Area 1. Raise awareness across the whole community about the importance of parenting and the requirements of children for optimal development through information, community education and media promotion. What we do now Media information - Marketing Section. Social marketing of parenting information - done by Parenting SA and Marketing section Information provision through parenting website, Good Advice magazine , books, videos and pamphlets. - KIS Directorate, Publications Section and Parenting SA Some groups according to local needs and staff interests and expertise. Parenting SA offers a valued service in grants for small local groups according to need. Hosting and support of NIFTeY - NIFTeY has had and continues to have a major role in publicising the importance of early environments - P & D and KIS. Recommendations 1. Aim: To raise community awareness and knowledge about important parenting/child development issues. To provide a link to services for parents needing more support. 1.1 Strategy: Train and make available staff to do regular single session groups/clinics on parenting issues eg sleep, toilet training. Develop a series of presentations and session formats which could be used by presenters (could possibly be marketed interstate). Delivered by: Infant specialists and Parenting Leadership Team Cost/time implications These sessions could provide time saving by taking the place of some individual consultations. 1.2 Strategy: Train and make available staff in a coordinated parent education program related to evidence of what works protecting children from particular 13 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework "risk" issues and transition points. In particular, groups for parents of toddlers, parents undergoing family break-up, parents of children with developmental delay, parents of young adolescents and young parents. These staff would also be available for presentations on parenting requested by local community groups eg preschools, schools, child care centres. Develop a series of presentations which could be used by presenters (could possibly be marketed interstate). Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team and Parent Educators. Cost/time implications: Staff time (could be partly offset against current groupwork costs plus FTE social work time), A travel budget for service delivery to country staff would be needed. A central location for the staff team would be needed. Developing presentation kits - 6 initially - 2 FTEs x 3 days from the Parenting Leadership team and building on current presentation resources. (An alternative staffing spread more widely among staff would have the benefit of upskilling more staff but would be much more expensive and complex to deliver. Where possible sessions could be delivered with local regional staff involvement). Staffing – This program could be most efficiently staffed across the State by 5 FTE multidisciplinary staff located with the Parenting Leadership Team or seconded part time from local regions. Train selected staff – 2 days full time plus one half day per term group meeting and ongoing support from the parenting leadership team. Service Delivery – Each staff member would be expected to deliver 12 parent education courses per year covering the major issues identified by research, 3 issues clinics per week, and approximately 2 one off presentations. Outcome: This program could deliver across SA, up to 400 one off presentations at the request of local community groups, including training of students and professionals, 60 parent education courses including transition points and key issues where intervention has been shown to be effective and 600 issues clinics (groups) which would reduce staff time dealing with the same issues individually. It would make a very significant contribution to supporting parents across SA. 1.3 Strategy: To cooperate with ABC TV to develop a new series of parenting programs similar to PGR which were very popular and still are popular but dated. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team, Parenting SA, Marketing Cost/time implications: Cost and staff consultant time to be negotiated. 1.4 Strategy: To provide community group leaders with training and support. To develop a parent group leaders training program for community groups wanting to offer parenting programs, including recipients of Parenting SA grants if required. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team. Cost/time implications: Cost would be in developing a course, and delivering programs. There is an opportunity for some cost recovery. 14 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Key Result Area 2. Provide information and education for all parents through written, face to face and online means. What we do now Information provision through WWW, Good Advice, books, videos - KIS, Marketing. Parent Help-Line - 24 hour advice and information - KIS Recommendations 2. Aim: To improve parents’ access to information, education and skill building through the www and parent helpline. 2.1 Strategy: To use Parent Helpline to provide specialist parenting interventions where needed by providing an additional specialist parenting staff resource for Parent Helpline for service delivery and staff support. Delivered by: KIS Cost/time implications: 0.5 FTE PS02 (could possibly come from Parenting SA grant). 2.2 Strategy: To provide on-line email responses to parenting queries on the Website. To provide an additional specialist parenting staff resource for Parent Helpline to reply to web based questions and develop proforma replies where possible. Delivered by: KIS Cost/time implications: Could be done by the parenting staff resource in (2.1). Technical cost $3000. Marketing cost $2000. Key Result Area 3. Provide a universal home visiting/assessment service to all new parents. What we do now Initial enrolment at clinics, some home visits, targeted or indicated by presenting issues or risk factors Recommendations 3. Aim: To provide an initial contact with Child and Youth Health for all new parents. To link parents with services according to assessment of parent and infant needs. 3.1 Strategy: To have a specialist home visiting team home visit all new parents within 2 weeks after the birth of the baby. Where parents are assessed as not having special needs to offer them clinic visits if they need to and Getting to Know Your Baby groups. Where they are assessed as having further needs to offer ongoing relationship based home visits for support from the same staff member, as needed up to 2 years (See 4.). Delivered by: Regional infant specialists. Cost/time implications: Training: Mentoring: 15 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Service Delivery: (Cost for a pilot program in one region – to be provided by the Director Nursing, and P & D) 3.2 Strategy: To provide an initial contact with Child and Youth Health for prospective parents. To begin relationship building before the birth of the child according evidence of the effectiveness of this. To work in partnership with maternity hospitals to have a specialist home visiting team visit prospective parents within 2 months prior to the birth of the baby. The same staff member to follow up with the post birth home visit (as in 3.1) Delivered by: Infant specialists. Cost/time implications: [Child and Youth Health is not funded for antenatal work – Costing to be provided by the Director Nursing, and P & D] Training: Mentoring: Service Delivery: Key Result Area 4 . Provide a targeted home visiting service consistent with models that have proven effectiveness for infants who are at risk of compromised developmental, educational and/or social outcomes. What we do now Ad hoc targeted home visits related to need and clinical judgement. Recommendations 4. Aim: To provide a coordinated responsive home visiting service, starting antenatally, which conforms with models of proven effectiveness for infants who are at risk of compromised developmental, educational and/or social outcomes 4.1 Strategy: To work in partnership with maternity hospitals to have an infant specialist home visiting team visit prospective parents within 2 months prior to the birth of the baby. The same staff member to follow up with the post birth home visit and to provide ongoing home visits for up to 2 years where needed. Delivered by: Infant specialists. Cost/time implications: Costing to be provided by the Director Nursing, and P & D with considerations as to the possibility of starting antenatally, a social work support provision and requirements for training in an evaluated model. Key Result Area 5. Provide group support, education and skill building sessions for new parents. What we do now Provide new parents’ groups based on various models and based on a group leaders' guide that is now outdated. A new Leader’s Guide has been developed and is currently being trialed. A book for parents to read to children has been drafted and will be sponsored by Parenting SA in the first instance. It will used be used in conjunction with the groups. 16 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Recommendations 5. Aim: To provide new parents with the understanding of important developmental and relationship needs of babies, and parenting skills as well as the opportunity to build supportive networks. 5.1 Strategy: To initiate and evaluate relationship based groups for all new parents modelled on current research into parenting babies. To support parents in relating to their babies, to each other, and to Child and Youth Health staff. To introduce parents to the Friends of CYH network. Delivered by: Infant specialists as above. Cost/time implications: This is current service of CYH. With an aim to make it available to all new parents who wish to use it. Initially the project could continue the present number of courses using the new service delivery model and leader’s guide. Further costs would be in increasing the number of courses available, producing the new leader's guide, training staff in using it and developing evaluation. [To be costed by Director of Nursing and P & D] Key Result Area 6. Provide, in partnership with other appropriate agencies, neighbourhood parenting centres to offer a raft of services to all parents related to need and opportunities for social capital building. What we do now Friends of Child and Youth Health provide local support groups for parents of young children. Regional teams provide support for local parent groups. Parenting SA provides grants for local parent groups. Recommendations 6.1 Strategy: To provide, in partnership with other organisations, neighbourhood parenting centres in 15 locations across South Australia to provide a non stigmatised local focus for all parenting issues and services eg CYH services, play group and child care, parent education, early literacy etc. These would provide centres of excellence, opportunities to develop new programs and work in partnership with universities and the Department of Education, Training and Employment to provide the best possible outcomes for parents and children. To develop proposals in conjunction with DETE for Commonwealth Government funding for these centres. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team and regional staff. Cost/time implications: Local CYH services could be delivered from the centres. A leadership position, and multidisciplinary teams for service delivery would need to be established. Some of this could be achieved by re-location of current staff. 17 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Key Result Area 7 Provide leadership in service provision to South Australian parents. What we do now Ad hoc consultancy and presentations for community groups by various sections of CYH. Feedback on Government policy documents. Membership of national committees. Bring national and international experts to South Australia and make their expertise available to the community generally. Support for NIFTeY. Recommendations 7. Aim: To develop a focus of parenting leadership skills in CYH.. 7.1 Strategy: To develop a specialist, multidisciplinary, cross-sectorial parenting leadership team to: keep abreast of new developments initiate programs provide training and support and consultation for Child and Youth Health staff and community parenting organisations provide material for publications both on-line and paper based promote Child and Youth Health parenting services provide a parenting focus for Child and Youth Health. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team Cost/time implications: Need to employ some people with expertise, provide training and support eg ability to attend and present at conferences, keep up with research etc. Initially one full-time position, and two half time positions from within the current establishment of nurses and social workers (if possible) is suggested. 7.2 Strategy : To assist with coordination for community organisations and groups who provide parent education by convening a regular parenting forum relating to the Child Health Council to provide opportunities for sharing, cooperative work, new information and needs assessment. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team. Cost/time implications: To be decided 7.3 Strategy: To assist with skill development for community organisations who provide parent education by offering professional training in parent education to community agencies and groups. To explore (with TAFE and ITABs) the possibilities of offering accreditation, either formal or from Child and Youth Health, for parenting courses and leadership. Delivered by: Parenting Leadership Team. Cost/time implications: Some cost recovery could apply. 7.4 Strategy To promote the need for cross government funding for early parenting initiatives in order to provide for a safer, better educated and healthier community with cross government cost savings by taking up the requirements to support parents with the Government Management Team. Delivered by: CEO and Board. Cost/time implications: to be decided. 18 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework CONCLUSION The above recommendations, based on rigorously evaluated programs, can provide a statewide universal and responsive parenting program which has the potential to address the needs of all parents and make a real difference to outcomes for children, their parents and the community. Specific project teams/officers would be required to develop, fully cost and institute the above recommendations. It is recommended that the program be led by a Parenting Leadership Team consisting of about two and a half positions with expertise in parenting, group work, child development and counselling and at least one position with expertise in infant mental health. 19 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework APPENDICES 20 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Appendix1 CYH PARENTING FRAMEWORK - STAKEHOLDERS CONSULTATION. Stakeholders Phil Robinson, Service Director, Division of Mental Health Sharon Williams, Director, Aboriginal Family Support Services. Tina Karanastassis, DHS, Senior Policy Officer for Children and Young People. Nancy MacWaters, Manager Planning and Development, Northern Metro. Clive Skene, Clinical Director, Southern CAMHS Jan Shaw, Assistant State Manager, SA State Office, Commonwealth Dept of Family and Community Services. Dale West, Chief Executive, Centrecare Heather Grimmett, Commonwealth Dept of Family and Community Services Ian Proctor, General Manager, FAYS Eugenia Tsoulis, Executive Director, Migrant Resource Centre of SA. All stakeholders were asked the same questions and the following report draws together their responses to each question. 1. What do you think is the importance of parenting? Parenting is a fundamental building block for children. It starts before birth with preparation for the first child. Developing the tools and nurturing skills that enable people. It is about emotional as well as physical - need to look at tangibles and intangibles, loving and caring are just as important. Parenting weaves the social fabric of our community. The Stolen Generation means that for many Aboriginal families nurturing skills haven't been passed down. Parents need basic communication skills, and to be an active part of the family unit. From a multicultural and generic perspective it is laying down a good foundation for children that will advance health and wellbeing - it encompasses everything, optimises opportunities in life. With multicultural families filling the blanks might be different focus on interdependence, continuity of framework, respect for culture. Parenting is incredibly important. For intergenerational at risk parents input to parenting can be a way of breaking cycles for individual families and the community and the effects of disadvantaged children on others in the community. Parenting is the building block of society. We predicate most services on the fact that quality of parenting is the vital ingredient in the wellbeing of our clients. Parenting skills are not innate, they need to be learned. Too much else happens for people to be able to negotiate child rearing without the skills. There is a strong relationship between parenting and outcomes for children. Parenting involves very complicated roles, many parents are confused leading to disintegration into different types of relationships. Effective parenting could keep children out of child protection services. 21 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Parenting is a key issue for the Commonwealth with the Stronger Families and Communities Strategy. Politically it is a major initiative. Commonwealth provides opportunities for funding, targeted at community interest, community driven. Commonwealth is heavily involved in parenting through funding agencies, rather than direct service. The parenting style you grow up in is superimposed on what sort of person you are going to be and how you will parent your children - one of the most important influences of life. 2. Are resources currently devoted to parenting adequate related to your own experience and to what is happening in other countries? What are the gaps? Not adequate. (All respondents) Not sure what resources there are – no mapped out understanding of all the resources allocated to parenting and who is doing what. Not enough is done at the early intervention/prevention end. Should deal with families most at risk as there will never be enough for all. The system does not deal well with helping families from very different cultures to negotiate the system. Aboriginal Family Services are now looking at developing a program looking at involving Aboriginal concepts in parenting. There are not sufficient resources to work with intensively with all parents who require it. Should be done simultaneously across the State. Australia lacks the resources of wealthier countries. More resources are needed to mainstream parenting services now, then in the future could be diverted to other areas. There has been improvement and greater recognition in the last decade that parenting is a skill, that people require assistance - everyone who has a child needs assistance. If you look hard enough there are resources - not sure there are enough. The main resource not there is a modelling resource where parents can see effective parenting in action. There is nowhere parents can go and watch people parent effectively. There are not enough resources for parents of adolescents, or culturally and linguistically diverse families, most are in English. CYH should collaborate with the multicultural sector in language groups and more different language information. It seems there are not systematic programs available to refer people to like there were in the past when Child and Youth Health ran parenting groups and early childhood counselling. Programs must fit individuals and locations - with a flexible approach to differing needs eg Parenting Centres for the "hard to serve" parents. There is a need to reach parents that FAYS don't get to. Qualities of programs should be - flexible, pitched at an understandable level, holistic (not just behaviour management - include nutrition and physical needs), proactive, free to the customer, and include a community development approach eg street centres. Parent Helpline and the PEGS are helpful for most parents who are looking for short term guidance and this aspect is pretty well covered, for CAMHS clients with more problems there are long waiting lists and services fall way below optimum (no increase in staff numbers since 1983). 22 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework It is not cohesive - parenting is in many different State government departments and the community. There is a need for coordination of services. Australia puts in significant money but not to the extent of some overseas countries. There is a lot of ad hoc funding. There is no national agenda around parenting. People from refugee camps have no models, the family structure has been destroyed. Not adequate because resources still go at the "fix" end - it is more visible and political. Prevention is not acknowledged in funding. Funding is more likely to go to homeless kids than strengthening families. 3. Do you think resources currently devoted to parenting are fragmented? Yes there are lots of areas where we dabble but no follow through or continuity. There needs to be a more cohesive and coordinated approach - a continuum of modules of service of which parents can take parts or the whole. Currently clients have to do different bits all over the place, there is no tie-in. Yes, there need to be overarching policies and operational policies. Currently it is piecemeal and knee-jerk, needs coordination. Resources are mostly in two buckets CYH and WCH. (Not aware where all the pockets of money are). Yes, there is insufficient coordination, we don’t work as closely as we could. Finally it is getting better in some areas and there are some good demonstration programs eg North West Family Integration Program - parents can move between programs and there are less gaps. Yes – don’t know what is available for new groups eg Arabic, Bosnian, Persia. Parenting SA small grants are excellent in helping these groups. There is no one to train group leaders – could be done in English in partnership with the group. Yes, but this is not necessarily a bad thing. We need to be aware of what resources are around. A broad range of services is desirable, not every program suits every parent. Programs run in the community allow for networking within that community. Would like to refer to parenting groups. Everyone does their own thing - this gives choice, different families need different approaches, but needs better assessment process and keeping track. Need to look at things more holistically, we may find we have more than we think. What is important is partnership. There needs to be consistency across the State in terms of philosophy. There needs to be a series of principles that all adhere to, an underpinning value base. Funding should be brought under one or two umbrellas or be sure that all adhere to a set of guidelines and principles with local responsiveness. It must be confusing to families with no idea what is available. Community services are generally fragmented within and between services due partly to rigid guidelines for the use of funding. There are buckets of money that go to different organisations. If there is someone to pull them together for parents that is OK, if parents have to do it for themselves it is very difficult. Not sure how parents can access parenting services if they don't know where they are or use CYH. 23 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework 4. What is most important to be done for parents? Access to assistance when needed. Need to build community literacy about parenting. Services should be holistic - food shelter, non-judgmental support - so people don't feel they have done things wrong. The context is relationships - how you do it. Relationships take time, there is a tension between this and outcomes in the short term. Train key people from different ethnic groups to visit the households of women in trouble. The general community needs to understand first, then spread information and support to women in need. There needs to be evaluation of outcomes. Preparation for parenthood, we neglect this at our children's peril. Needs to be practical, hands-on, this is what to expect. Men know practically nothing about child development and women don't know much. The dilemma is about giving high quality service to a small number when many others are in need. Government needs to understand that services to parents cannot be cheap or short. Empower them to make decisions. Some parents don't nurture because they are afraid it will be wrong. Increase overall community knowledge in other ways to discipline. Multifaceted, build confidence and support networks. Demystify the motherhood myth - everyone needs help and should feel OK to seek help. To take equal responsibility, not do things for parents. Listen to what parents say they need and develop services according to what they need and what is possible. Eg Parents say they want one stop shops. Improve community literacy and awareness about parenting, then skill building according to need. Look at equity and equality of outcomes. Appropriate responses to where they are at eg different info and support for different age groups and different needs. Needs a continuum of service which is not there because the preventive end is not there. People don't always know what they need. There is a need to raise community understanding about parenting. Listen to parents' concerns, respect different parenting styles, don't impose any one model as the only way, offer choices but let people (especially refugees) know there are legal responsibilities in Australia, everyone does not know what they are. Respect different cultural behaviour in relation to parenting. Start where the parent is at. We would hope to achieve an increase in awareness of the importance of parenting to the future of children but it relates to life circumstances as well and people need sufficient stability to make it a reality. 5. What expertise do you think is needed? Generic or specialist? Both - all respondents. Universal and targeted - reflect the diversity of the community dealing with parents - staff ethnically as well. Workforce should reflect community diversity. 24 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Everyone needs some training but we also need special skills for up to date best practice. Things change so a broad background person can't make the decision about where to lead from new developments, a little knowledge can be dangerous. Mentoring is important. Need both mainstream and ethnospecific targeted services through organisations most in touch because many people won’t come to generic services. Sensitivity of the professional is really important. People have different skills and those working with parents should be skilled and empathic. Use staff who are really keen to work with parents. Aboriginal families need a blend generic information and skills and specialised skills unique to Aboriginal cultures (same for NESB). Expertise that allows parents to move on but maintain cultural identity and cultural practices including the nuances of different clan groups. It needs to be multidisciplinary - a range of disciplines have a contribution eg nursing, social work, psychology and medical for a holistic service. All need competency - train the trainer may not work. Needs quality assurance process and underlying values. Make sure objectives are met. A fundamental principle is the selection of the right staff for different groups and related to where people are at. Need highly trained staff and mentoring with ancillary support. Select sensitive staff and train for sensitivity. Room for specialist focus - different skills as a parent are needed at different ages. Family size also important - more relationships to negotiate. Specialist skills should go with interest and enthusiasm for working with families. Basic community knowledge about parenting through to highly specialised programs. The first stop shop is non threatening, add special programs where needed. Some generic information eg PEGS, and 1000 things that need extra specialist attention. 6. Are there any particular groups, age groups, transition points that you think could benefit from better/more adequate/better coordinated parenting services? Transition points such as birth have particular risk. Intervention should be targeted to high risk groups eg single mothers, low SES, family break-up. (With limited resources can we provide a service to the whole community as well?) Ante natal is essential, birth, kindy, school, high school, family break-up, indigenous (service development type initiatives). Prenatal, postnatal is critical, plus transition to school, 0-3 years prevention, transition for women to parenting. Baby toddler home to kindy kindy to school primary to high school young people. Right through the continuum from birth to old age. 25 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Early years, seeding years where you plant the seeds of development, but all the way through a child's journey you impart different things - without this you deprive the child and community. Parents who haven't the benefit of knowing their own parents have more needs. When children grow up without the tools of parenting they don't know what they haven't got and can't pass on what they don't know eg how to develop pride in your home if you have never had a home. Victims become perpetrators, it happens in many areas. Adolescents, 9-13, need intensive work when family conflict begins. Not much for middle years and teens. Adolescence, transition from toddler to school, middle years, transition from adolescent to young adult. Address access and equity barriers. Assist with life challenges. The difficult transition to independence in adolescence. Parental understanding is most important. 7. How do you think a balance can be achieved to attain complementary rather than duplication of services? It's about a matrix of services, acknowledging what is provided in other places and areas, and documenting and sharing. Providers don't always know what else is being done or what is available. Disseminate information so people can access it. Services need to be accessible therefore information about where they are is important. If all agencies could work together and not have to compete. Don't worry too much about duplication, there is enough demand for all. The gaps are more important. No-one is overserviced. Sustainability is important. We can't afford the luxury of duplication nor the fact that parents can only find one kind of service. We don't all need to do everything eg CYH might do new baby work and other agencies eg DETE pick up later age groups. Need a map of who does what to see where funding comes from and how to work together in some way. Need money under CYH umbrella. Need State DHS levels for quality assurance. May be accreditation, register of accredited courses, data base of accredited parenting interventions on the web. Only support accredited, evidence based services. There must be a rationale. There is a policy coordination issue, clear sense of who is providing what and where is needed. A process to identify what is there, look at duplication and look at more planned approach to allocate resources. Needs overall State policy. Need strong community awareness of what is available, offer to complement what is happening, network and support community agencies. Coordination could be centralised within one agency but preferable a strong interagency group to work towards a common goal. Services talking together and networking. Govt agencies need to network as well as community. 26 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework 8. Would it be helpful for an agency or agencies to provide leadership and/or coordination? Yes - all respondents with different ideas about how this could work. There definitely needs to be an organisation that is a signpost - not necessarily provide all services but provide directions. It's about a hub that can direct people to where they can get the best service, and often an introduction as well. Maybe make the 1st call, help open the door. (Aboriginal people would use PHL it there were Aboriginal staff). This is a critical component. The question is which agency. As well as leadership there needs to be partnership - equal partnerships. Maybe a coalition of agencies with each agency having its own area of expertise (difficult question). Yes, CAMHS provides leadership, seen as mental health specialists. Parenting is not seen as mental health in the early years. Part of the dilemma is not to just accept the parenting issue presented but look at parenting practices as a way to safely intervene. Agencies must work together, and need an appropriate forum - Commonwealth has a linking role. Yes, but competition for funding has taken away cooperation that needs to be there - joint project management does not work. Openness is not there any more. Yes, if networking is to work, someone must take the leadership. 9. Do you see Child and Youth Health as a suitable agency to take a leadership role, in what way? Services such as CYH and WCH would appear to be appropriate agencies to be leading as it is part of their core business. Yes, CYH have the volume to be able to deal with a number of fronts and a range of issues across the broad spectrum. Children’s Interests Bureau could formulate the DHS driver and designate CYH to lead a forum or committee, linking back to the Children’s Interests Bureau. Draw together agencies for coordination. A very important role is developing policy and working with other agencies for implementation and accountability – not service delivery – a co-ordination and training approach. Potentially, there is a lot of work to do. Focus on partnership - with a diversified workforce universal approaches do not work, it need and internal cultural shift. Need people as part of CYH to guide and support the process with special multicultural and Aboriginal parenting units within CYH. Yes CYH should take a leadership role, could take more instead of being locked into day to day. There is an opportunity to do things differently. Provide knowledge, broader approach, more coordination in cooperation with other agencies. Yes CYH should have a leadership role around parenting. Should do more for early intervention. Could work in partnership with CAMHS for programs for parents of adolescents. 27 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Yes, target group is young children and CYH is very well places for the early years. There are clear gaps - organisations have expertise and non-expertise. Level of support varies significantly from one region to another. CYH and DETE could do a lot more together. In a broad sense CYH has a name that gives expectation that there is expertise that may not be found elsewhere and an opportunity to push for expertise in particular areas. CYH can be expected not to push a particular barrow except what is best for children. NIFTeY being associated with CYH is an example of leadership. Yes, but does not cover all ways of gaining information. People don't go to CYH when children are older. Perhaps CYH could have a bigger parenting focus than just weigh and measure babies. MBHA weighing is still in people's minds. 10. How do you see your agency linking to Child and Youth Health in services to parents? CYH and CAMHS are complementary. If CYH had early childhood programs like they used to many cases could be referred. There are opportunities for CAMHS and CYH to collaborate in training and support. The nexus for CAMHS is in the kind of problem ie diagnosis, not age of child. CYH and CAMHS have mutual partnerships, especially with Second Story. Need to cultivate the connection between agencies and opportunities for staff development also sharing of educational opportunities. For Aboriginal clients real bridges are important to assist clients to use each other's services. It is about how we best holistically provide a service eg Pt Augusta Aboriginal parenting program. DHS has an overarching policy which defines the DHS position but looks at how units can work in a more integrated fashion. CYH should contribute to the policy and be part of it. CYH should translate the DHS overarching position into clear policies. Partnerships about developing family policy incorporating parenting. FACS has a stronger focus on families and communities and can fund parenting requests. It would be useful next year to do a mapping exercise with CYH and Migrant services to look at services and gaps and where links could best be made. 11. Any other points? The Aboriginal community is in crisis on a number of fronts with major difficulties. Service delivery should look at community needs, take the focus from provider to client, and let clients have real input into the services they receive. In an attempt to deal with quantity we have lost quality. We have lost the art of listening. Lyell McEwen hospital will have the first group of postnatal home visits from Feb next year. New ways of thinking could start with this. 28 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework How we get to the table with other State Government departments is a crucial challenge. Importance of multicultural needs - there are huge gaps and the majority of people don't understand different cultural needs. Diversity Directions provide information but more for services than parents. Programs must have the right person with the right information for the right family. An informal presence in preschools eg one day a month would make it easy for parents to ask for help when they need it. 29 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Appendix 2. CONSULTATION WITH CHILD AND YOUTH HEALTH MANAGERS This consultation was a response to the information in the Report “What Works” and the implications of the recommendations in the report for Child and Youth Health . The following is a summary of feedback from the consultation. Major implications Need for CYH staff with the skills and the commitment to continue long term any program that is commenced. CYH needs to be more flexible and responsive in our approach as to how we deliver services. Consistency of information / service is important. CYH need sto develop high standards across the organisation Evaluation should be tied in to the basket of 4 or 5 programs. Long term planning is needed for good evaluation. Programs should be standardised but must allow for documented variation and professional judgement. Some staff may be concerned that responding to the evidence may be too prescriptive. There is a need to become client service focussed and not service focussed. There may be a perception / image re change from “public health” to “welfare” mentality (ie risk of being seen as defacto FAYS workers) Suggested implementation strategies Community consultation and then be willing to meet the identified needs. Interagency collaboration. Validated and rigorous assessment tools need to be used in CYH to lead to appropriate paths. Generalist vs Specialist. Take in a specialist approach – staff who want to do it. Appropriate staff and specialist training Towards a definition of parenting Parenting is providing a safe environment being supportive and challenging a unique experience parenting requires support Importance of parenting in early years on a child’s future: - physical - social - emotional - educational - moral - spiritual There are many contributors to ‘parenting’ especially the link between parents and caregivers. 30 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework 1. Parenting is complex and incorporates many themes: values trust boundaries unconditional love and support and uses and teaches these underlying principles to young people 2. Parenting provides opportunities for shaping future generations and communities. Gaps in services to parents Parenting sessions for Fathers Need framework to work with adolescent parents Developmental needs (0-25) through life cycles Parenting for children with disabilities Face to Face groups for parents of 6-12 year olds Grandparents who parent Ability to provide services 0 – onwards 31 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Appendix 3. WHAT PARENTS REQUIRE The following information was taken from a comprehensive consultation with parents in Western Australia (both country and city areas), Ibrahim, Jenni Developing a plan for families: listening to the community, WA: Family & Children’s Office, 2000 “It doesn’t matter how you define a family, what matters is good relationships”. Northam Forum The following are responses from the consultation that have relevance to Child and Youth Health. [As WA has a similar demography to SA it can be assumed that these responses would be relevant to SA]. Ways to strengthen individual families Value family relationships Prevent family breakdown Value the importance of fathers Preparation for fatherhood Promote male help-seeking and meet these service needs Stimulate early childhood learning in the home Make the most of technology in children’s learning Ways to strengthen families’ links with community Create lively supportive communities Respond to young people’s needs Safer home environments Improve community facilities Make it easier to balance work and family. Ways to make services more family friendly. Family friendly approach Provide more information about services Improve access to services Adopt a cross government approach Better planning Improved communication Provide services locally. Major issues faced by WA families and children Work Safety Health Finance Alcohol & drug abuse Education Relationship breakdown 32 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Summary Although the questions in the survey were not particularly about parenting and the responses did not particularly target parenting all of the above issues are relevant to parenting and to early intervention in support, skill building and confidence building for parents. 33 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Appendix 4 PARENTING POLICY FRAMEWORKS A REVIEW OF COMMONWEALTH, STATE GOVERNMENT AND OVERSEAS INITIATIVES Prepared by Chris Caudle For the Child and Youth Health Parenting Framework Project May 2001 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 34 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework PARENTING POLICY FRAMEWORKS A REVIEW OF COMMONWEALTH AND STATE GOVERNMENT INITIATIVES May 2001 Please note The parenting programs described below are usually linked to a universal platform of service provision such as Children’s Services and Maternal and Child Health Services as well as other secondary and tertiary services such as Disability Services and Child Protection. State New South Wales Victoria Policy framework Families First – a Support Network for Families Raising Children Aim is to increase effectiveness of early intervention and prevention services in helping families to raise healthy, well adjusted children. Parenting Skills Development Initiative Aim is to provide ensure that parenting practices are informed by quality research and that this knowledge is disseminated statewide by systematic training and education. This program has recently been reviewed as part of the Strengthening Families Evaluation. A final report was expected in March 2001 but was not available at the time of writing. Infrastructure Implementation is the combined responsibility of participating agencies in each area (Area Health Services, Department of Community Services, Department of Ageing and Disability, Department of Education and Training, Department of Housing, NSW Dept Health, NGO’s funded by government to support families. Regional Officers Groups (CEOs, Area Managers, Department Heads of government agencies in each area) are supported by the Office of Children and Young People in process of implementing Families First. Implementation is through the Victorian Parenting Centre which is linked to nine Regional Parenting Resource Services across Victoria. The Victorian Parenting Centre is supported by the Community Support Fund through the Department of Human Services, Office of the Family. Each Regional Parenting Resource Services is auspiced by a community health service provider eg Anglicare Content focus Focus is on supporting parents, building sustainable community support networks and improving family access to support through a better coordinated service network. Features include universal and targeted services home visiting volunteers supporting families Focus is on promotion of positive parenting practices through the Positive Parenting Program. The program’s multilevel framework aims to tailor information, advice and professional support to the needs of individual families. Level 1 information dissemination about child development. Level 2 brief time-limited professional consultation with strategic use of information for parents experiencing specific difficulties related to their child’s development or behaviour. Level 3 active skills training Level 4 broad focussed skills training designed for parents requiring extensive support. 35 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework State Policy framework Infrastructure Content focus Western Australia Creating Connections 2000-2005. A five year WA State Government plan with more than 80 initiatives to benefit families and build stronger communities. Focus is on improving the health and stability of families and children strengthening the links between families, neighbourhoods and communities increasing access to family friendly government, business and community services (FamilyOne Business Strategy) The five year plan affirms the state government’s commitment to a whole-ofgovernment approach to supporting families and children and strengthening family life. The Family and Children’s Policy Office will play a pivotal role in implementing the plan. It will act as a facilitator across government. The Family and Children’s Policy Office works with the Family and Children’s Advisory Council to promote the importance of families and children with government, business and community organisations. Many parenting initiatives are joint projects of Family and Children’s Services, the Health Department and the Education Department. A range of initiatives are offered to support parents in their parenting role (see content focus) Initiatives developed to support parents in their parenting role in Western Australia include Parenting Line Parenting Information Centres ( in metropolitan and country centres) Parenting education campaign Parenting information for Aboriginal families Parent Link volunteer home visiting service (for parents needing ongoing support and specific skills development) Under tens preventive family support service (for families with children displaying anti social behaviour) Home school support (encourages and supports children to remain in the school system) Building Blocks (a joint initiative of Family and Children’s Services and the Health Department which builds on and extends previously developed services aimed at supporting families and skilling parents eg initial home visit, ongoing home visits for parents with a low level of need, the Best Beginnings service with a focus on families with children aged 0-2 and Aboriginal Family Support service with a focus on families with children aged 0-2. Best Start project (a joint project involving Family and Children’s Services, Health Department, Education Department and local Aboriginal communities to improve wellbeing of children from birth to five years). Strong Families program for families experiencing difficulties who have contact with two or more government agencies 36 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework State Queensland Federal Commonwealth Department of Family and Community Services Policy framework Putting Families First Aims to achieve three outcomes for all families giving children the best start valuing and supporting the nurturing role of families creating safe, supportive communities for families. Infrastructure Implementation is a shared responsibility of state and local governments, the non-government and business sectors and local communities. Identified outcomes and indicators are shared across portfolios – this creates a common framework for the implementation process. Departments use the framework and resources to enable the implementation of effective strategies at local level. Regional Manager Forums have responsibility for developing local initiatives in partnership with families, the community, non-government and business sectors. Content focus Existing services will be further developed to make them more coordinated and widely available. The intention is to enable and extend local leadership There is a government commitment to develop a child and family support network in every local community (will vary according to local needs). A range of possible future investment priorities has been identified for achievement of the three desired outcomes of Putting Families First. Policy framework Stronger Families and Communities Strategy. The Strategy focuses on the following three areas: early childhood and the needs of families with young children; strengthening marriage and relationships; and balancing work and families Infrastructure The Government will invest an additional $240 million for nine new initiatives, over the next four years. Funding is available to states on a per capita basis and is distributed by local FACS offices through a project funding scheme. Content focus The nine initiatives are Creating a Stronger Families Fund Early Intervention Parenting and Family Relationship Support Providing more Flexibility and Choice in Child Care Commissioning a landmark national Study of Australian Children Nurturing Potential Leaders in Local Communities National Volunteers Skills Development Initiative Supporting Local Solutions to Local Problems Setting up a Can Do Community Initiative Running a Communication Strategy Further details on each initiative are attached. 37 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Stronger Families and Communities Strategy Nine new initiatives Initiative Creating a Stronger Families Fund Early Intervention Parenting and Family Relationship Support Providing more Flexibility and Choice in Child Care Commissioning a landmark national Study of Australian Children Nurturing Potential Leaders in Local Communities Helping volunteers with a National Volunteers Skills Development Initiative and funding for the International Year of the Volunteer Supporting Local Solutions to Local Problems Content focus To encourage communities to find new ways to strengthen families, with a focus on early childhood and effective parenting - $40 million. To strengthen families. This will also provide services and activities such as parenting, support and play groups; marriage and relationship education. It will also provide family counselling with a focus on regional Australia and support for legal, medical and other professionals in their support for families - $47.3 million. To improve the flexibility of child care, to better meet the needs of families and provide more choices ($65.4 million). To focus on early childhood and effective early intervention and prevention strategies in areas of health, education, child care and family support ($6.1million). To offer skills and support for potential community leaders who live in socially disadvantaged areas and come from outside industry and government structures ($37.1 million). To help people involved in volunteer work build skills and to support International Year of the Volunteer celebrations in 2001 ($15.8 million). To support communities to build their own capacity in small and cost-effective ways ($15.4 million). Setting up a Can Do Community Initiative To showcase Australian best practice with real life examples of how to revitalise communities$5.2 million. Running a Communication Strategy To reinforce the significance of good parenting and strong family relationships to our children’s lives, our communities and Australia’s future ($8 million). 38 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework PARENTING POLICY FRAMEWORKS: GOVERNMENT THINKING AND POLICY REGARDING YOUNG CHILDREN THE UNITED STATES, CANADA AND THE UNITED KINGDOM May 2001 Country United Kingdom Policy framework Sure Start A new cross-Government program to provide support to parents and local communities, addressing their needs and making available the support they require to give their children the best possible start in life. Objectives include improving social and emotional development improving health improving the ability to learn strengthening families and communities increasing productivity of operations A summary of processes and targets for each of the objectives is attached. Infrastructure Sure Start pulls together health, education and welfare services for 0-3 year olds in a coordinated way. By 2002, there will be at least 250 Sure Start local programs. They will be concentrated in neighbourhoods where a high proportion of children are living in poverty and where Sure Start can help them to succeed by pioneering new ways of working to improve services. Content focus The design and content of local Sure Start programs vary according to local needs, but it is expected that all programs will include the following core services outreach and home visiting support for families and parents support for good quality play, learning and childcare experiences for children primary and community health care, including advice about family health and child health and development support for children and parents with special needs, including help getting access to specialised services 39 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework United Kingdom – Sure Start objectives and targets Objectives Improving social and emotional development Improving health Improving the ability to learn Strengthening families and communities Increasing productivity of operations Process by supporting early bonding between parents and their children, helping families to function and by enabling the early identification and support of children with emotional and behavioural difficulties by supporting parents in caring for their children to promote healthy development before and after birth by encouraging stimulating and enjoyable play, improving language skills and through early identification and support of children with learning difficulties by enhancing families' opportunities for involvement in the community and improving the sensitivity of existing services to local needs Targets Parenting support and information for all parents. A 10 per cent reduction in children re-registered on a child protection register. All local Sure Start programs to have agreed and implemented, in a culturally sensitive way, ways of identifying, caring for and supporting mothers with post-natal depression. A 5 per cent reduction in proportion of low birth-weight babies. A 10 per cent reduction in children admitted to hospital as an emergency during their first year of life with gastro-enteritis, a respiratory infection, or a severe injury At least 90 per cent of children with normal speech and language development at 18 months and 3 years. 100 per cent of children in Sure Start areas to have access to good quality play and early learning opportunities, helping progress towards early learning goals when they get to school 75 per cent of families report personal evidence of an improvement in the quality of services providing family support. All local Sure Start programs to have parent representation on local program boards At least 250 local programs in England. 100 per cent of families in contact with the local Sure Start program within the first two months after birth. Evaluation strategy in place by 2000-01 Post Spending Review 2000 objectives and targets (the new Public Service Agreement) In return for the extra resources allocated to Sure Start in the Spending Review settlement, Ministers' have agreed new objectives and targets. Objective Improving social and emotional development Improving Health Improving children's ability to learn Strengthening families and communities Targets reduce the proportion of children aged 0-3 in the 500 Sure Start areas who are re-registered within the space of twelve months on the child protection register by 20 per cent by 2004 achieve by 2004 in the 500 Sure Start areas, a 10 per cent reduction in mothers who smoke in pregnancy achieve by 2004 for children aged 0-3 in the 500 Sure Start areas, a reduction of five percentage points in the number of children with speech and language problems requiring specialist intervention by the age of 4 reduce the number of 0-3 year old children in Sure Start areas living in households where no-one is working by 2004 40 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Country Europe Policy framework European Early Promotion Project. The European Early Promotion Project is currently being evaluated in a research context in five European countries. Infrastructure The project involves training health visitors or other primary health care personnel to conduct promotional interviews with all prospective parents in their area, approximately four weeks before and after birth. At the same time, the health visitors screen for risk factors associated with child mental health difficulties. Parents identified as at risk are immediately offered a series of home visits by the health visitors, who use the Parent Adviser model to engage and help families prevent subsequent difficulties. Content focus The Parent Adviser model is a system for enabling non-mental health professionals to support families effectively. It includes an explicit theoretical framework, an elaborated training course, a service delivery system, and evaluative research studies. The model has been used to train health visitors, school nurses, early years staff, community doctors, teachers, and others to work with parents of children with a variety of difficulties, including chronic illness and disability and emotional/behavioural problems. Canada (Ontario) The Early Years Study. The Ontario Government’s response to-date includes a number of steps to advance early child development, including: plans to create Demonstration Projects to test and evaluate different approaches to helping young children learn a commitment to guarantee funding to all school boards for Junior and Senior Kindergarten, as recommended in the Study announcement that all existing preschool early learning programs will be combined and expanded – with increased funding. Minister Marland will appoint an Early Years Task Group who will advise the Government on elements and standards for an Early Years Program for Ontario children and parents. An Early Years Challenge Fund will help communities promote local early child development and parenting programs by investing $30 million annually by 2001-02 to match private- and voluntary-sector contributions to local programs. In response to the Early Years Study, the Honourable Margaret Marland, Minister Responsible for Children, announced details of five Demonstration Projects that will test and evaluate approaches to good early child development and parenting in our province. Practical examples to both community and government, these projects will show what works for parents and children across Ontario. They will also demonstrate how to bring business, voluntary and charitable organisations together to support early child development. The Demonstration Projects selected are in different parts of the province and represent a range of community-based leadership models. They are located in South East Grey, London, North Bay, Ottawa-Carleton and York Region. 41 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Country United States Policy framework The US National Research Council and the Institute of Medicine established a Committee on Integrating the Science of Early Childhood Development. The committee’s conclusions and recommendations are grounded in four overarching themes. all children are born wired for feelings and Infrastructure A summary of recommendations for each theme is attached. Content focus ready to learn early environments matter and nurturing relationships are essential society is changing and the needs of young children are not being addressed interactions among early childhood science, policy and practice are problematic and demand dramatic rethinking. 42 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework United States The US National Research Council and the Institute of Medicine: Committee on Integrating the Science of Early Childhood Development Committee conclusions and recommendations are grounded in four overarching themes summarised in the table below. Theme All children are born wired for feelings and ready to learn Early environments matter and nurturing relationships are essential Society is changing and the needs of young children are not being addressed Interactions among early childhood science, policy and practice are problematic and demand dramatic rethinking. Recommendations 1. Resources on a par with those focussed on literacy and numeracy should be devoted to translating the knowledge base on young children’s development into effective strategies for fostering the development of curiosity, self-direction and persistence in learning situations the ability to cooperate, demonstrate caring and resolve conflict with peers the capacity to experience the enhanced motivation associated with feeling competent and loved 2. School readiness initiatives should be judged not only on the basis of their effectiveness in improving the performance of the children they reach, but also on the extent to which they make progress in reducing the significant disparities that are observed at school entry in the skills of children with differing backgrounds. 3. Substantial new investments should be made to address the nation’s seriously inadequate capacity for addressing young children’s mental health needs. 4. Decision makers at all levels of government, as well as leaders from the business community, should ensure that better public an d private policies provide parents with viable choices about how to allocate responsibility for child care during the early years of their children’s lives. During infancy, there is a pressing need to strike a better balance between options that support parents to care for their infants at home and those that provide affordable, quality child care that enables them to work or go to school. 5. Environmental protection, reproductive health services, and early intervention efforts should be substantially expanded to reduce documented risks that arise from harmful prenatal and early postnatal neurotoxic exposures, as well as from seriously disrupted early relationships due to chronic mental health problems, substance abuse, and violence in families. The magnitude of these initiatives should be comparable to the attention and resources that have been dedicated to crime prevention, smoking cessation, and the reduction of teen pregnancy. They will require the participation of multiple societal sectors and the development of multiple strategies. 6. The major funding sources for child care and early childhood education should set aside a dedicated portion of funds to support initiatives that jointly improve the qualifications an increase the compensation and benefits routinely provided to children’s nonparental care givers. 7. The President should establish a joint federal-state-local task force charged with reviewing the entire portfolio of public investments in child care and early education. Its goal should be to develop a blue print for locally responsive systems of early care and education for the coming decade that will ensure the following priorities that young children’s needs are met through sustained relationships with qualified caregivers that the special needs of children with developmental disabilities and chronic health conditions are addressed that the settings in which children spend their time are safe, stimulating, and compatible with the values and priorities of their families 8. The President’s Council of Economic Advisers and Congress should assess the nation’s tax, wage and income support policies with regard to their adequacy in ensuring that no child who is supported by a full-time working adult lives in poverty and that no family suffers from deep and persistent poverty, regardless of employment status. The product of this effort should be a set of policy alternatives that would set the nation toward achieving these fundamental goals. 43 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Appendix 5 DHS Parenting Programs in South Australia Taken from: Population Strategies Unit, Strategic Planning and Policy Division, Audit of DHS programs and services for children and young people: prepared for the Children’s Interests Bureau, June 20th, 2001. Organisation Aboriginal Services Title Grandmother program “ Health Ways DHS/IDSC Collaborative with agencies in Northern Metro region CAMHS Kids Plus Infant Mental Health Prevention Early years Southern CAMHS Counselling Service 2-18 Helen Mayo House Women’s and Babies Health Service 0-5 CAMHS Northern Adolescent Services Enfield 12-18 CAMHS Northern, DETE and FAYS Behavioural intervention service – statewide Dept of psychological medicine Family partnerships 5-18 CAMHS – N and WCH CAMHS – N Target Age 0-18 Pregnant women, young girls, infant students Children 0-18 0-18 “ – Elizabeth FAYS DHS WCH Tier 3 Diversionary 0-18 Early years strategy Parenting Network 0-6 0-3 DHS Check your child’s drawing 0-5 “ “ “ “ AHSHS Mt Barker CAMHS Mt Gambier Finger fun Hands on fun Ready set write Parenting and pregnancy support Parenting and family support “ Pre school Preschool? 0-16 44 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework CYH DHS Metro Division DHS Metro Division Family and Community Development Program CYH DHS Metro Division Shine SA Parenting Forum Whyalla/Challenging children’s support group North West Children and Families Integration Project Supported Accommodation Assistance Program Neighbourhood Development Program – various locations Young mothers program Specific FC & DP services targeting children Parent ed, parents and service providers Targeted risk groups Women in domestic violence and their children Parents with young children Teenage parents (and their babies) Target children at risk in city and country areas – Parents Talking Relationships and Sexual Health Universal Parenting Parents of young people Play groups association Child and Youth Health Play groups New Parent Groups 0-5 New parents and their babies Child and Youth Health Child and Youth Health Health consultations Child and Youth Health Parent Education All parents with children 0-12 Parents of 0-12 year olds, NNESB, Aboriginal, young parents, low socioeconomic Parents of children 0-12 months Child and Youth Health Parent Helpline Child and Youth Health Child and Youth Health Parenting SA Friends of CYH All parents of children and young people All parents Internet Client Services All parents Parent Easy Guides Parenting SA Small grants Parenting SA/ACCHS Talking Realities All parents + some for specific groups eg new arrivals Specific parent groups Young parents Child and Youth Health Adelaide Central Community Health Service Targeted Services Parenting support and information All parents Parents of 0-25 yr olds, general and targeted Intensive evidence based parenting support interventions Training in specific topics related to children and parental bonding Local parenting skills and development information programs Living skills /support Counselling, Staines Baby Development program (Goodwood), Parent/Adolescent Counselling (Pt Pirie, Pt Lincoln) Communication, confidence building Free and low cost parenting information, including online Parent child play groups Relationship building groups, information, skills dev. Health information/ respond to needs Various services Specialist intervention and/or information in group setting Telephone advice and information service Mutual support and information groups On line parenting and health information Parenting information sheets/hard copy and online Funding for parenting education Skills and confidence building Parenting skills, Teen parent program, Raising confident children, young 45 Child and Youth Health Parenting Policy Framework Adelaide Central Community Health Service Family support and well being Parents general Adelaide Central Community Health Service Adelaide Central Community Health Service Speech and language Parents of children with language disorder Various target groups Adelaide Central Community Health Service Adelaide Central Community Health Service Inner Southern Community Health Service Cambodian Playgroup Vietnamese Child Parent Program Aboriginal and Islander Playgroup Enuresis program Services for young people Children and adolescents with enuresis Young parents Parenting support and information Mothers Fathers Inner Southern Community Health Service Inner Southern Community Health Service Speech and language 0-4 Early child development 4-5? Noarlunga Health Services – Community Health Parenting support and information 0-25 Inner Southern Community Health Service Northern Metro Community Health Service Enuresis training 0-12 Parenting support and information General and targeted parents support program (antenatal), Vietnamese child-parent program Weekly drop in for parents and children at local primary school – support. Social support for single parents. Fathers group Parent support, skill development Reduce isolation, confidence building, skills development Dry bed skills training. Young parents’ support, Teen parenting peer education project Positive parenting program Fathers club – skills and relationship building, effective parenting strategies Language and confidence building groups School readiness for children with developmental delay – parent support. Positive parenting, fathers support, language and preliteracy group, developmental play group Enuresis clinic Breaking up – information and support Young mothers – confidence building Positive parenting groups Family support to Vietnamese families Language building playgroup Parenting group for parents of children with developmental delay 46