Interaction between
Public Interest Disclosures Act and
Government Information (Public Access) Act
This fact sheet outlines the interaction between the Public Interest Disclosures Act 1994
(PID Act) and the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (GIPA) in relation to
the release of information concerning a public interest disclosure.
Section 22 of the PID Act
Considering a GIPA request
Section 22 of the PID Act prohibits a ‘disclosure’ of information
that ‘might identify or tend to identify the identity of a person
who has made’ a public interest disclosure, subject to certain
exceptions. When a request is made under the GIPA Act for
information concerning a public interest disclosure, the authority
will need to consider whether this section applies, and if so the
nature and scope of the prohibition.
Operational decisions about the disclosure of information that
might disclose the identity of a reporter under the PID Act can
be made by the head of the authority or a delegated officer
(such as the PID Coordinator) exercising powers under section
22 of that Act. However, a Right to Information Officer exercising
the powers under the GIPA Act has a much more limited
discretion. When considering a GIPA Act request for information
relating to a PID, the options available would appear to be:
Section 14 of the GIPA Act
1. where the identity of the reporter is either generally known
or known to the GIPA applicant, it would appear that section
22 of the PID Act may well not apply (although some other
public interest consideration against disclosure in the GIPA
Act might apply)
Section 14(1) GIPA Act provides that it is to be ‘conclusively
presumed’ that there is an overriding public interest against
disclosure of any of the government information described in
Schedule 1 to that Act. Item 1 of that Schedule lists that there
is an overriding public interest against disclosure of information
which is prohibited by, amongst other laws, section 22 of the
PID Act. This restriction applies whether or not the prohibition is
subject to specific qualifications or exceptions and whether or
not a breach of the prohibition constitutes an offence.
Application of section 22
In relation to the question whether section 22 applies, in
considering the meaning of ‘disclosure’ the NSW Court of
Appeal and the ADT have taken the view that once information is
known it cannot be disclosed (unless it became known by some
unlawful means). For example, ‘[t]he essence of disclosure of
information is making known information to a person that the
person did not previously know’1. This indicates that section
14(1) and Schedule 1 of the GIPA Act would not apply in relation
to the PID Act if the identity of the reporter has already been
revealed or disclosed or become known by some lawful means.
If the identity of the reporter has not otherwise been lawfully
disclosed, section 22 only applies to information that ‘might
identify or tend to identify the identity of the person who has
made’ a public interest disclosure.
1 Nasr v State of NSW (2007) 107 A Crim R 78 at 106 [127] – See also:
Richards v Commissioner, Department of Community Services (2011)
NSW ADT 98 [40]; R v Ritson: R v Stacey (2010) NSW DC 160 at [51] – [58];
Forster v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1951) 83 CLR 606 at 614-615.
08/2013
2. where section 22 of the PID Act applies, it prohibits
disclosure of information that might identify or tend to
identify the reporter:
›› in some cases, the section 14(1) GIPA Act and section 22
PID Act prohibitions might be able to be addressed by
redacting documents to remove information that might
identify the reporter,
›› in other circumstances where even confirming the existence
of a public interest disclosure might tend to identify the
reporter, authorities might well be justified in relying on
section 58(1)(f) of the GIPA Act to refuse to confirm or deny
that such information is held by the authority.
A GIPA application may ask for more than just the name
of the PID reporter. If there is no conclusive presumption
against disclosure, the public interest test and considerations
in sections 12-15 of the GIPA Act must be applied. If the
information includes someone’s personal information, agencies
are obliged to take reasonably practical steps to consult with
that person to ascertain whether they have any objection to
disclosure of some or all of the information and the reasons for
any such objection (see section 54 of the GIPA Act). Depending
on the information sought by the application, persons who need
to be consulted might include the reporter, any subjects of the
disclosure and/or any witnesses.
The Information and Privacy Commission (IPC) provides
information, advice, assistance and training to agencies and
the public on matters relevant to the GIPA Act. The IPC can be
contacted at ipcinfo@ipc.nsw.gov.au or 1800 472 679.
Public interest disclosures
Fact Sheet
8
Interaction between Public Interest Disclosures Act
and Government Information (Public Access) Act
Decision making flowchart for agencies:
Is information about a PID
within the scope of the GIPA
application?
Yes
No
Could the information to be
disclosed reveal the identity
of the reporter?
Section 22 of PID Act
does not apply
Yes
No
Is the reporter’s identity known
to the GIPA applicant?
Section 22 of PID Act
does not apply
Yes
No
Section 22 of PID Act unlikely
to apply - other public interest
factors of GIPA Act may apply
Section 22 of PID Act applies
Can the identity of the reporter
be redacted?
Yes
No
Provide redacted information
Deny GIPA application
Contact us for more information
Our business hours are: Monday to Friday, 9am–5pm (Inquiries section closes at 4pm)
If you wish to visit us, we prefer you make an appointment. Please call us first to ensure your complaint is within our jurisdiction and our staff are available to see you.
Level 24, 580 George Street
Sydney NSW 2000
General inquiries 02 9286 1000
Facsimile 02 9283 2911
Email pid@ombo.nsw.gov.au
Web www.ombo.nsw.gov.au
Toll free (outside Sydney metro) 1800 451 524
Tel. typewriter (TTY) 02 9264 8050
© Crown Copyright, NSW Ombudsman, August 2013
Telephone Interpreter Service (TIS): 131 450
We can arrange an interpreter through
TIS or you can contact TIS yourself before
speaking to us.
ISBN: 978-1-925061-04-8 08/2013
This work is copyright, however material from this publication may be copied and published by State or Federal Government Agencies without permission of the Ombudsman on the condition that
the meaning of the material is not altered and the NSW Ombudsman is acknowledged as the source of the material. Any other persons or bodies wishing to use material must seek permission.
This fact sheet is one of a series produced by the NSW Ombudsman. Feedback is welcome.