- Global Islamic Financial Forum 2014

advertisement

Global Islamic Finance Forum 2014

Treasurers’ Roundtable: Liquidity Management

Baljeet Kaur Grewal

Managing Director & Vice Chairman

2 SEPTEMBER 2014

CONTENTS

Section One: Global Liquidity Flows: Emerging Trends

Section Two: Islamic Finance and International Linkages

Section Three: Liquidity Management Challenges

2

GLOBAL LIQUIDITY TREND

Global Liquidity Levels (2012-1H2014 and YTD)

US liquidity level,

USD tln

2.0

2.4

2.5

2012 2013 1H2014

YTD, +4.2%

Euro liquidity level,

USD bln

479

398 437

2012 2013 1H2014

YTD, +9.8%

Turkey liquidity level,

USD bln

85 89

74

2012 2013 1H2014

YTD, -16.9%

GCC liquidity level,

USD bln

165

184

144

2012 2013 1H2014

YTD, -21.7%

Asia liquidity level,

USD bln

312

296

280

2012 2013 1H2014

YTD, -5.4%

Global banking liquidity appears to be easing against tighter conditions in the past. Banking liquidity will also be more positively reinforced with new liquidity requirements from regulators.

The flows of global liquidity will still be supported by EM countries. Despite some slight moderation in growth, positive signs from the US should sustain growth drivers in EM, whilst the forecast for the EU into 2015 may see liquidity levels fluctuate.

Source: Central banks, Regulatory bodies, Basel Committee, KFHR

3

GLOBAL BANKING CONDITIONS

Bank Lending to Nonfinancial Companies: Growth and

Conditions

Conditions loosening,

Lending contracting

Conditions loosening,

Lending expanding

Conditions tightening,

Lending contracting

Conditions tightening,

Lending expanding

Lending growth (%)

250

200

150

100

50

0

Middle East - Total Banking Sector Assets,

(2014 and 2014 -2018)

20

15

10

5

0

Source: IMF, BMI, KFHR

Total assets, % of GDP

Total assets, 5-year CAGR (%) (RHS)

Global Financial System Size by Segments, % of GDP

200

150

100

50

0

EM2001 EM2007 EM Latest AE Latest

Middle East - Banking Sector Credit Growth, % y-o-y

(2014F – 2018F)

30

20

Egypt

Qatar

United Arab Emirates

Jordan

Saudi Arabia

10

0

2012 2013 2014F 2015F 2016F 2017F 2018F

4

GLOBAL CROSS BORDER CREDIT DYNAMICS

USD tln

3.5

3

2.5

2

1.5

1

0.5

0

10

5

-10

-15

0

-5

Global credit is among the key indicators of global liquidity, where cross-border element regularly provides the marginal source of financing in the run-up to crises.

%

25

20

15

Global Cross Border and Domestic Credit Growth

Quarterly average of :

• Cross Border Credit Growth

(2001-2013): 5.9%

• Domestic Credit Growth (2001-

2013): 7.3%

Two major diverging trends in international banking markets.

• cross-border claims on advanced economies declined, while those on borrowers in emerging market economies increased sharply contributed to double digit cross border credit in Asia Pacific

Credit to emerging market economies as a percentage of total international interbank claims reached its highest level on record

• On a consolidated basis, in 1Q2013, claims on borrowers resident in these economies reached 14% of total international interbank lending - twice the level recorded five years ago.

Global Cross-border credit (yoy) Global Domestic credit (yoy)

US Cross Border Credit

Asia Pacific Cross Border Credit

Average of Cross

Border Credit

Growth (2001-

2013): 6.2%

2

1.5

1

0.5

0

USD tln

4

3.5

3

2.5

Euro Area Cross Border Credit

Average of Cross

Border Credit

Growth (2001-

2013): 5.8%

USD tln

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0

Average of Cross

Border Credit Growth

(2002-2013): 12.8%

Source: BIS, KFHR

5

ESTIMATED IMPACT ON BANKING LIQUIDITY FROM BASEL III

Global effect of combined liquidity and capital changes under Basel III on business models

0 20 40 60 80 100

Evaluating portfolios

Shifting out of complex less liquid instruments

Exiting lines of business

Exiting geographies

None of the above

2012 2013

8

4

0

Estimated capital impact on GCC Islamic banks

20

2.7

16

3.0

1.2

12

15.9

14.3

Capital (Basel 2)

Tier-1 Tier-2

Capital (Basel 3)

Basel 3 impact on capital ratios

 More and more financial institutions will review their business models and banks will continue to exit business lines and geographies as they streamline operations and strengthen balance sheet

 Expect to see more regional banks taking the forefront as global banks reassess their position and direction.

 Going forward, expect more partnerships to emerge across markets as thoughts turn to future growth opportunities.

Estimated capital adequacy ratio under Basel III of

GCC Islamic banks

Source: EY, KFHR

6

CONTENTS

Section One: Global Liquidity Flows: Emerging Trends

Section Two: Islamic Finance and International Linkages

Section Three: Liquidity Management Challenges

7

INTERNATIONALISATION OF ISLAMIC FINANCE

Global Islamic Finance Assets

Others

(North America and Europe)

• Banking assets (71.1)

• Sukuk Outstanding (6.4)

• Islamic funds (12.9)

• Takaful assets (0.01)

Total assets (90.3)

MENA (ex-GCC)

• Banking assets (593.9)

• Sukuk Outstanding (0.3)

• Islamic funds (0.4)

• Takaful assets (7.7)

• Total assets (602.4

)

Sub-Saharan

Africa

• Banking assets (22.9)

• Sukuk Outstanding (0.3)

• Islamic funds (1.7)

• Takaful assets (0.2)

Total assets (25.1)

GCC

• Banking assets (530.8)

• Sukuk Outstanding (85.3)

• Islamic funds (32.7)

• Takaful assets (8.23

)

• Total assets (657.1)

Asia

• Banking assets (213.5)

• Sukuk Outstanding (177.2)

• Islamic funds (25.9)

• Takaful assets (3.78)

Total assets (420.3)

*Values in USD bln as of 1H14

 The global Islamic finance assets reached approximately USD1.79tln

in assets as at end-2013, representing a sustained compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 16.95% during 2009-2013.

 Over the last decade, Islamic finance has gained much acceptance in the global arena as rising awareness of Shari’a compliant propositions has prompted more countries and entities to join the global cohort of Islamic finance stakeholders.

o The industry’s assets are expected to surpass the USD2tln mark during the 3Q2014.

o Today there are at least 700 Islamic financial institutions operating across more than 70 countries .

o MENA, GCC and Malaysia remain as the key driving jurisdictions.

Source: Bloomberg, IFIS, Zawya, World Islamic Insurance Directory, KFH Research

8

STRONG GROWTH ACROSS VARIOUS SECTORS

1 Islamic Banking

The value of global Islamic banking assets reached an estimated

USD1.53tln as at 1H2014, at a CAGR of 17.4% between 2008-2013

1,800

1,600

1,400

1,200

1,000

800

600

400

200

0

Islamic Banking Assets Growth Trend by Region (2008-2014F)

2008

GCC

2009

MENA (ex. GCC)

2010

Asia

2011 2012

Africa (ex. North Africa)

2013

Others

2014F

3

Islamic Funds

The global Shari’a compliant asset management industry has reached a new high of USD75.1bln in AuM

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

47.0

Global Islamic Funds AuM (2008-17 June 2014)

71.6

75.1

66.9

73.8

60.6

61.7

56.1

1200

1000

800

600

400

200

0

AuM No. of funds

Source: KFH Research Database

2 Sukuk

Global sukuk outstanding reached USD286.41bln in 1H2014, a

6.3% expansion YTD since end-2013 and a 16.8% growth y-o-y.

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Global Sukuk Outstanding Trend (2003-1H2014)

USD286.4bln

0

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 1H14

4

Takaful

Gross takaful contributions are estimated to have amounted to

USD21.5bln as at 1H2014. Annual growth in contributions y-o-y is forecasted to be more than 15% as at end-2014.

Global Takaful Contributions Forecast

2013E 2014F

8542

7229

Saudi

Arabia

2720

Malaysia

2311

1296

658

GCC

251

Asia Pacific Africa South Asia Middle East

9

ISLAMIC BANKING MODEL: REGULATORY REFORMS HEIGTENED

EXPECTATIONS ON LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT

Regulatory transformation will demand the industry increase depth and breath of liquidity investment tools and to adapt to radically different growth strategies

 Islamic banks are operating within an integral global financial system and are also exposed to various risks. Based on past crises, Islamic banks were also adversely affected from the economic crisis resulting in credit constraints.

 Generally, Islamic banks tend to hold an excess of cash reserves to buffer their liabilities due to the limited availability of short-term instruments.

 Global regulatory reforms are also being undertaken to enhance resilience of the industry and these reforms must be supported by robust product and market developments.

 Islamic banks are operating within a set of challenges in managing their liquidity, despite the heightened expectations through various regulatory reforms.

KEY REFORMS

Basel III & IFSB -

Capital

Basel III & IFSB -

Liquidity

Unique Islamic banking framework

Shari’a rulings & enhanced

Governance expectations

Impact on Business

Model

Risk weighted assets & revenue levels

Capital and funding pressure

Cost of funds and operational cost

Sukuk as growth and

Capital/liquidity instrument

10

Source: IFSB Islamic Financial Services Industry Stability Report 2013`, KFHR

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT: PRACTICES AND CHALLENGES

Current practices in advanced Islamic finance jurisdictions:

Challenges Remain in Most Markets :

Shortage of active money markets

Sub-optimal secondary trading in Islamic debt markets

Tenure mismatch in instruments

Government and central bank certificates*

Wakalah placements

Cash reserves

Islamic

Liquidity

Management

Instruments

Repurchase agreements*

Absence of a unified Shari'a framework and lack of standardised regulations

Commodity murabahah

Sukuk and other debt securities*

 Islamic banks have restricted access to short-term funding options used by conventional banks.

Since all transactions must be linked to a tangible, underlying asset

– this rules out purely financial contracts like repos and Certificates of Deposit. As a result, there is a big, unpopulated gap between cash and long-term papers.

 Shortage or unavailability of Shariah compliant securities in many jurisdictions will affect the performance and competitiveness of Islamic banks vis-à-vis conventional financial institutions in the internationalisation of

Islamic finance

Non-existence of cross-border liquidity infrastructure

Amplification of liquidity risk in a dual banking system

Despite the limited liquidity instruments for IFIs, both Basel Committees and

IFSB do not preclude the need for IFIs to be sufficiently resilient to withstand liquidity and market shocks.

*In reference to Shari’a compliant alternatives of these instruments

Source: IFSB Islamic Financial Services Industry Stability Report 2013`, KFHR

11

SUKUK MARKET: GROWTH DYNAMICS

Global Sukuk Issuance Trend

(2006-1H2014)

Sukuk Outstanding in Selected Markets (1H2014)

140

120

131.18

119.71

Turkey:

USD7bln

100

UK:

USD624mln

Kuwait:

USD373mln

80

85.07

66.2

Pakistan:

USD4bln

60

40

46.02 45.15

20

25.52

0

20.63

28.02

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 1H2014

Saudi:

USD47.8bln

Bahrain:

USD4.3bln

UAE

USD25bln

Malaysia:

USD163bln

Indonesia:

USD14.5bln

Singapore:

USD87mln

1H14

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

0%

Sukuk Issuances by Maturity Trend (2008-1H14)

< 1 year 1 - 3 years 3 - 5 years 5 - 10 years > 10 years

20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Source: Central banks, Regulatory bodies, Islamic banks, Zawya, IFIS, Bloomberg, KFHR

• The volume in 2014 has been spurred by issuances in 2Q14 worth

USD35.1bln

, which is the second most performing quarter in terms of new sukuk issuances since 3Q12 .

• Obligors’ based in a total of 14 different jurisdictions have tapped the primary sukuk market in 1H2014.

• Consistent with the past trend, Malaysia accounted for the largest share of the sukuk market with a USD41.7bln volume or 63% of the total issuances (2013: 68.8%).

Saudi Arabia was the other major domicile in 1H2014.

12

CONTENTS

Section One: Global Liquidity Flows: Emerging Trends

Section Two: Islamic Finance and International Linkages

Section Three: Liquidity Management Challenges

13

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT - CRITICAL ECOSYTEM TO DRIVE

INTERNATIONALISATION OF THE INDUSTRY

Internationalisation of Islamic finance to drive greater innovation and wider range of liquidity instruments including cross border solutions

Cross

Border level

Central

Bank Level

Interbank

Level e. g. Commodity Murabahah, Wakalah,

Lender of Last Resort,

Islamic alternative to Repo e.g.interbank Mudarabah,

Wakalah

Institution

Level e.g. Commodity Murabahah

14

Source: IFSB, KFHR

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT – MARKET IMPORTANCE

Importance of liquidity management at respective levels

1

Asset-Liability

Management of

Islamic financial institutions

Outcome

• Enhances the ability of the Islamic financial institution to meet operational cash flow;

Better efficiency in managing funding will improve profitability; and

• Provides an even ground for Islamic financial institutions to manage liquidity.

Importance of liquidity management

Source: KFHR

2

3

Macro

Environment

Global

Surveillance

• Helps to mitigate the probability of default by an Islamic financial institution which could lead to adverse systemic implication;

• Facilitate transactions among Islamic financial institutions hence improving costs; and

• Increase the level of liquidity in the financial system.

• Facilitates the growth and development of domestic regulator’s global involvement in liquidity risk management; and

Help integrate the initiatives of other jurisdiction regulatory efforts to produce a standard framework to address liquidity risk.

15

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT – MANAGING LIQUIDITY IN NEW

MARKETS

Promoting cross border liquidity

Placing Islamic funds to other Islamic centres

Establishing benchmark rates

Wide distribution of

Sovereigns sukuk

Open markets financial enabling entry and exit of investors

Selling of Islamic instruments among jurisdiction

• Due to the size of the Islamic banking industry and capital market, it will be challenging to create a local deep liquidity market , which explains why efficient cross-border liquidity risk management tools have been explored.

• The establishment of the IILM in 2010 is an important development in facilitating effective cross-border liquidity management.

• However, with the aim of managing liquidity risk, it is important that other risks (e.g. currency risk for cross-border liquidity management products) are not introduced.

• This lack of market liquidity is often seen as the major constraint to the development of an integrated

Islamic financial system

Source: KFHR

16

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT – THE CHALLENGES TODAY….

Macro Challenges and Developmental Issues Surrounding Islamic Liquidity Management

Global Shari’a

Standards

Need for more transparency, disclosure

Different legal, regulatory & tax frameworks

Global acceptance

Efficient payment & settlement system

Uniformity in other frameworks

Robust cross border infrastructure

Liquidity

Management

Challenges

& Issues

Adequate availability of short term instruments

Robust standards

Inadequate cross border liquidity market

Need for well designed, suitable assets for trade across borders

Different standards used among jurisdictions

Source: KFHR

Macro

Challenges

Developmental

Issues

17

ISLAMIC LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT – CONCLUSION

Market Expectations

Fundamental

Banking

Prerequisite

Global Expansion:

Managing Liquidity

Challenges

Internationalisation of Islamic finance raise the bar for more timely, sophisticated liquidity management instruments

 Cross border collaboration on liquidity, mitigates systemic risk, brings efficiency to the financial institutions funding operations

 Global and regional expansion of Islamic banks requires greater advancement of cross border liquidity instruments to manage the necessary exposures.

 Various availability of Islamic liquidity management tools such as Wakalah and unrestricted Wakalah, short-term

Ijarah sukuk, Government shari’a compliant instruments are needed to manage liquidity effectively.

Inadequate cross border liquidity infrastructure, identifying the right assets which is acceptable across most markets, different

Shari’ interpretations, absence of a LOLR among jurisdictions are among the challenges

18

“Best Islamic Research Firm 2013”

Islamic Finance News Awards Poll

2013

“Best Islamic Finance Research House

2014”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance

Awards 2014

“Best Islamic Consulting Service 2014”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance

Awards 2014

“Best Islamic Consulting Service 2013”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

THANK YOU

“Best Islamic Finance Research House 2013”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

2013

“Best Islamic Consulting Service 2012”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

2012

“Outstanding Contribution to Islamic

Finance”

Failaka-Amanie Symposium, Dubai

April 2010

“Best Islamic Research Company”

Islamic Finance News Awards Poll 2008

January 2009

"Best Research in Islamic Finance”

Master of Islamic Funds Award

November 2007

“Best Islamic Research Firm”

Islamic Finance News Awards Poll 2011

2013

“Best Islamic Finance Research House

2012”

November 2011

“Contribution to Islamic Finance Research”

International Islamic Finance Forum, Dubai

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

2012

“Best Islamic Finance Research House 2011”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

“Best Islamic Finance Research House”

The Asset Triple A Islamic Finance Awards

2009

“New Provider for Islamic Finance

5 th

May 2010

Research”

KLIFF Islamic Finance Awards

November 2008

2011

“Best Islamic Research Company”

Islamic Finance News Awards Poll 2009

January 2010

“Contribution to Research in

Islamic Finance 2009”

International Islamic Finance Forum April

2009

19

Download