Running Head: POWER PLAY 1 Power Play: A Feminist Reading of the Twilight Saga and The Wolves of Mercy Falls Trilogy Yvonne Clark Prof. Seifert Westminster College POWER PLAY 2 Introduction In this paper I would like to discuss how gender norms are constructed and maintained within two separate series’ of young adult novels, The Twilight Saga and the Wolves of Mercy Falls Trilogy (Myers, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). I will first go over gender typical behavior and stereotypes, move on to discuss an overview of the novels and then analyze the importance of the character’s names, legitimizing myths for males and females, the supernatural element in the novels, the subtle differences in power and end with a discussion on why these gender role expectations are in place, and how they could be affecting the audience. The characters in the popular young adult series’ of The Wolves of Mercy Falls by Maggie Stiefvater and the Twilight Saga by Stephanie Myer are constructed in such a way that they reproduce a systematic power disparity. This power disparity is that between men and women; women are represented in a stereotypical fashion that leaves them weak in deference to men. To highlight this relationship through feminist analysis, the example of the main protagonist Bella Swan and her male counterpart Edward Cullen in the Twilight Saga, and Grace Brisbane and her male counterpart Sam Roth, are found to show women as physically inferior, emotionally insecure and out of control, and behaviorally untrustworthy. The behaviors of the protagonists Bella and Grace are legitimizing myths that reinforce the particular sexist stereotypes of women being weak, less intelligent, emotionally high strung, out of control beings. This representation is then sold to a mass market audience of readers, many of whom are young and actively searching for male or female role models, and the implications of internalizing sexist beliefs can be very harmful, even leading to depression in some cases when females realize how inferior to males society wants them to be (Girgus, & Nolen-Hoeksema, 2006). POWER PLAY 3 Gender Typical Behavior Gender typical behaviors are behavioral traits that are stereotyped as being overwhelmingly masculine or feminine traits. These traits are then the norm for behaving as a male or female should behave, or is expected to behave in society (Crawford, enter date). Bem and Lewis conducted a survey within a large sample in 1975 and took the most popular descriptors for gender traits and complied them together. Masculine traits are generally seen as self-reliant, aggressive, loyal and strong, while feminine traits are seen as being yielding, moody, jealous, unreliable, gentle and tender (Bem & Lewis, 1975). These traits may have positive and negative aspects in and of themselves, but once they are tied together they display an overwhelming trend, with positive and powerful traits being more masculine and negative or weaker traits being seen as feminine. A Narrow View of Feminist Theory Legitimizing myths are one of the prevailing ways that the dominant power structures and discourses are continued in a society; feminist psychologist Mary Crawford defines legitimizing myths as: attitudes, values and beliefs that serve to justify the hierarchical norms (2006). Common legitimizing myths are that women are fundamentally different from men, they are weaker than men, women are less intelligent, incompetent, helpless, overemotional, fragile, and in need of control, or to take a benevolent sexist point of view, to be put on a pedestal (Crawford, 2006). A stereotypical woman is soft spoken, small, pretty, skinny, white, middle class and heterosexual; she is gendered, and as such, is from birth put into a system that dictates access to power and resources, a system that controls the way relationships between other women and men are shaped (Crawford, 2006). Crawford reports some shocking statistics taken by the United POWER PLAY 4 Nations as of 2009, that are real world examples of the stereotypes that both the Twilight Saga and the Wolves of Mercy Falls trilogy exemplify in relation to the power inequality between men and women: Women have less power in society and make up only 18% of the world’s political power. Men have more wealth and leisure time than women. Men on average, have a higher level of education than women do. Marilyn Frye sees these power disparities, these interactions in women’s day to day lives, as wires in the bird cage of oppression (Frye, 1983). One wire alone, like the education gap from the statistics above, can be overcome in an individual’s life, or helped to equalize with policies like affirmative action; a bird can easily fly or step around one wire. However, Frye points out that this is not how the world operates; a woman’s gender, race, sexual orientation, ability, and age all intersect and connect with one another to mold and immobilize women (1983). The gender norms and legitimizing myths presented in the young adult series’ of the Twilight Saga and the Wolves of Mercy Falls represent a wire in this bird cage and both series’ feed into legitimizing myths and reinforce sexist attitudes towards women. Summary of the Novels I would like to give you a quick overview of the 7 novels in these two series that I have looked at. The Twilight Saga is an extremely well known and popular paranormal romance told from the female protagonists’ perspective and the books focus largely on the heterosexual relationship between two characters, Bella and Edward (Meyer, 2005). The Wolves of Mercy Falls trilogy is a little less known, and switches between first person accounts told from both the main female and male protagonists; like Twilight, the Wolves of Mercy Falls focuses largely on POWER PLAY 5 the heterosexual relationship between the characters Grace and Sam (Stiefvater, 2009). I maintain that both novels reinforce stereotypical gender roles in the characters, which support a power disparity between males and females. Vampires and Werewolves through the Feminist Lens Beginning with the names of the characters, we see gender stereotypes immediately. Both of the females have names that fall in line with typical feminine traits. Bella in Italian means “beautiful” or “nice” (Dictionary.com, 2012). The character’s last name also plays into feminine traits as a swan is a bird who is often associated with women; a beautiful bird that is white to represent purity. Interestingly enough, a secondary character in the Wolves of Mercy Falls series is also named Isabella (Stiefvater, 2009). The Wolves of Mercy Falls’ protagonist also as has a gender stereotype as a name; Grace. Grace means “elegance or beauty of form, manner, motion, or action” (Dictionary.com, 2012). This definition is very similar to the descriptors of “tender, gentle and yielding” on the Bem Sex Role Inventory List (Bem & Lewis, 1975). However, the male characters have names without those associations. Edward and Samuel are not immediately associated with masculine characteristics like “aggression” and “independence”. The males in these series are not immediately stereotyped into their gender norms from their names, while the females are. Physically, Isabella Swan fits the description for a stereotypical Western woman, as she is described in the novels as the perfect intersection of the small, short, pretty, pale and clumsy girl (Myer, 2005). Bella is smaller in stature than all of the male characters of the novel, reproducing on a physical level a power structure indicating that males are bigger and stronger than females. Grace is also short, small, pretty, and pale and these two characters together begin to form the stereotype for a woman; someone who is always weaker than a man based on POWER PLAY 6 physical size alone. In fact, there is no mention of a male who is weaker than Grace in the entire series (Stiefvater, 2009; Stiefvater, 2010; Stiefvater, 2011). Comparing Bella to her counterpart Edward makes her even less formidable. Edward is a preternatural being, and as a vampire he is almost invulnerable to death. Tying back to Crawford’s legitimizing myths that support sexist views, both young adult series represent men and women as fundamentally different, just as humans and vampires or werewolves are different from one another (2006). “You’re indestructible,” Bella mumbles, breathing hard as Edward carries her across a field. Edward, as a male character, inhabits one of the most powerful bodies possible within the setting of the novel, while Bella remains, not only human, but a clumsy female, mentioned numerous times as she is tormented by the prospect of being physically active:“Remembering how many injuries I had sustained-and inflicted-playing volleyball, I felt faintly nauseated”(Myer, 2005). There are even instances where Bella cannot control her own body, and is in need of Edward’s rescue, for example, when she faints at the sight of blood in biology class (Myer, 2005). Bella’s performance as a fainting and weak woman is right in line with gendered female typical behavior, and Crawford’s legitimizing myths of needing to be protected due to weakness and fragility (Crawford, 2006). Grace also represents these legitimizing myths; "I remember lying in the snow, a small red spot of warm going cold, surrounded...They were licking me, biting me, worrying at my body, pressing in. I could have screamed, but I didn't. I could have fought, but I didn't. I just lay there and let it happen..." (Stiefvater, 2009). This last quote from Shiver, the first novel in the Wolves of Mercy Falls Trilogy, is particularly powerful as it is extremely reminiscent of rape, an ultimate example of superior male power over an inferior female; this is the first paragraph of the novel and immediately puts Grace into an extremely low power position. Sam, on the other hand, POWER PLAY 7 has the ability to rescue Grace from the “rape” scene. “Her eyes on my eyes. Her blood on my face. No longer one of them, I thought she was the most beautiful girl I'd ever seen, a tiny, bloody angel in the snow, and they were going to destroy her. I saw it. I saw her...And I stopped it.” (Stiefvater, 2009). This is a huge contrast to Grace’s earlier statement, where she does not fight, does not make any noise, she just “let[s] it happen”, but Sam can step in and stop the attack, he embodies enough power to become Grace’s savior (Stiefvater, 2009). In Twilight, not only is Bella shorter than Edward, she is younger by hundreds of years, putting Bella’s intelligence level below Edward’s from experience alone. However, age is not a factor that any of the characters consider when the fact that Edward is smarter than Bella is made clear to the reader. Edward’s intelligence is brought up in their first conversation, when Edward doubts Bella’s ability to complete a biology lab (Myer, 2005). This is reinforced by another male character in an authority position, when the teacher asks, “So, Edward, didn’t you think Isabella should get a chance with the microscope?” The teacher, Mr. Banner, automatically discounts the possibility that Bella could have answered the questions of the lab on her own, doubting her intelligence and her competence, when all the teacher knows of Bella is her gender, considering she is a new student at the school (Myer, 2005). Mr. Banner could be seen as calling Edward out for controlling this academic situation, however, is next assumption is not one of understanding, but one that walks the thin line of cheating, “Have you done this lab before?”, when Edward, not Bella, points out that she answered the majority of the questions (Myers, 2005). Intelligence disparities are also apparent in the Wolves of Mercy Falls Trilogy. While Grace is not necessarily stereotyped as dumb, there is a huge difference in the way intelligence plays out among the characters. Grace is seen as someone who is good with concrete ideas, POWER PLAY 8 topics that do not take much abstract or higher thought; because of this she is portrayed as the most intelligent female in the novel (Stiefvater, 2009). However, the males are the ones who are intelligent with the abilities of higher and complex thinking, for example, Sam knows multiple languages and contemplates philosophy, while Grace struggles with an English assignment, “I was giving myself a break from reading this stupid short story for English.” (Stiefvater, 2009). In fact, when all of the main and secondary characters in the novels become obsessed with curing the disease of the werewolf, it is Cole, the male counterpart to the female Isabella in this series, who has the “genius” to begin experimental studies and ultimately finds the cure; “I lay my notebook with my experiments on the step so Sam would know.” (Stiefvater, 2011). Women are stereotypically viewed as extremely emotional and highly concerned over the judgments others are making of them (Crawford, 2006). Bella fits this stereotype very well as she is portrayed as extremely emotional, and is constantly worried about gaining approval from the male in her life: “My mind was spinning with confusion. Had I made up the whole thing? He was perfectly polite now. I had to speak; he was waiting.” (Myer, 2005). Bella should speak when Edward expects her to, and say what she thinks he wants her to; by actively seeking approval from Edward, Bella removes herself from the decision making position in her life; moving from a powerful active position, into a passive role. While it would seem normal for any adolescent to be worried about what others think, as psychologist L.M. Brown points out that, adolescent girls particularly rely heavily on cues from their peer group for support during high school (2003). However, neither Bella nor Grace are overly concerned about what their peers, or even parents, are thinking; the protagonists are directly obsessing over whether or not she is pleasing her male partner. In Bella’s case, her feelings (excessive though they are) are not hers alone to POWER PLAY 9 debate either as Edward directs Bella towards emotions that are appropriate to feel, emotions she may or may not have, as he does in every novel when she reacts to her birthday presents, “Fine, I’ll behave.” Bella says, as Edward drives her to her birthday party (Myers, 2006). While Sam constantly counsels Grace to hold her emotions in check, even locking her in a bathroom when her emotional state becomes so extreme he “didn’t know what else to do” (Stiefvater, 2011). Edward’s control is so powerful he can control Bella without even needing to be present, and the second novel illustrates this, showing that the protagonist will hallucinate Edward telling her what to do in his absence (Myer, 2005; Myer, 2006). This process is overwhelmingly ruled by the female character’s emotions and worries. Grace also provides another example of this when she receives a call from Sam after a time of separation: “I had no bones left in my body. I slid off the bench, trying to hold the phone to my ear still, trying to hold my head up because my muscles felt completely unequal to the task. My heart was clubbing so painfully in my ears it took me a moment to realize that if he'd said something else, I wouldn't have heard it.” (Stiefvater, 2011). Losing complete control of your body due to emotion is only exemplified in the female characters, as males are portrayed as stoic and able to control their emotional reactions. Another common stereotype for women is that they are meant to be with men in a heterosexual relationship (Crawford, 2006; Brown, 2003). While neither female confront sexual orientation identity issues within the novels, both display typical adolescent curiosity towards sexual exploration. For example in Twilight Bella asks Edward how sex applies to his vampire body and he replies “The human desires are there…I may not be a human, but I am a man.”, assuring Bella that he can and does feel sexual attraction and “lust” (Myer, 2005). POWER PLAY 10 The relationship between Grace and Sam seems to be more egalitarian than that of Bella and Edward, but whenever consequences for a sexual relationship are brought up, Sam has the more adult and “reasonable” responses, like thinking about the consequences of sleeping together, as told from Sam’s point of view in the following passage: “Oh, God, Grace,” I gasped. “I’m not looking for self-control.” My hands were inside her shirt, palms pressed on her back, fingers spread on her sides; I didn’t even remember how they got there. “I—I don’t want to do anything you’ll regret.” Grace’s back curved against my fingers as if my touch brought her to life. “Then don’t stop.” (Stiefvater, 2009). The relationship between Edward and Bella is under Edward’s complete control. He is the one in the first novel to decide when they are friends and when they are in a relationship (Myer, 2005). He is the one who can decide when a kiss can start and how long it can last (Myer, 2005; Myer 2006). He decides that they will remain abstinent “ ‘Now please try to behave yourself,’ he continued, and he bent to softly brush his lips against mine” (Myer, 2005). Edward even goes so far as to black mail Bella into marrying him in exchange for immortality (Myer, 2006). From Bella’s perspective, Edward is justified to have disturbing moods and be emotionally distant because she is weak, slow, and has no control over her emotional or bodily reactions, the epitome of the legitimizing myths: “I whispered, remembering the black moods that pulled him away from me, that I’d always interpreted as well-justified frustration- POWER PLAY 11 frustration at my weakness, my slowness, my unruly human reactions….” (Myer, 2006) Throughout the whole series, there are 191 instances of sexual content as defined by the Teen Micro Media Content Analysis Sheet, originally developed by Pardun, L'Engle, and Brown and modified for the purposes of this project (2005). Within those 191 instances, less than eight of them are instances of sexual intercourse, even though Bella has been pushing Edward for a sexual relationship since the first novel, his excuse being, she is not strong enough to have sex with him because she is too fragile (Myer, 2005). Of the 191 instances of sexual content, fewer than 10 of them were not controlled, either initiated or ended, by Edward. Bella has no control over any aspect of her relationship with Edward, emotionally or physically. Mirroring a male dominant power structure in society since, from the counts of instances alone, the male is shown as the one who can make the decisions and who should be controlling these actions (Crawford, 2006). Grace, like Bella, is portrayed as the one who is out of control when it comes to sexual activity as well. It is Grace who pleads with Sam in the first novel to sleep in her bed, instead of on the floor; situations like this increase throughout the trilogy, with Sam being to one who has to maintain control over the lust of both of the characters (Stiefvater, 2009; Stiefvater, 2010; Stiefvater, 2011). However, once the decision is made for them to have sexual intercourse, Grace is the one responsible and she is viewed as the one who encouraged the loss of control (Stiefvater, 2009). These characters play out the hypocrisy in the stereotypes for gender roles and sex, as males should be in control, but when they are not, it is the fault of the female involved in the sexual situation, not the male (Crawford, 2006). POWER PLAY 12 Females are not the only ones who undergo stereotyping, males also have gender stereotypes that played out in the novels. The need or desire to be strong, or be a provider is exemplified in both series, and these are stereotypes directly opposite those of weakness and the need to be cared for in women (Crawford, 2006). Sam struggles with stopping Grace’s attack at the opening of the novel Shiver, and constantly worries about how best to “lead [his] pack” of fellow werewolves (Stiefvater, 2009). Edward also struggles with male stereotyping and expresses his frustration: “It's not right! I don't want you to have to make sacrifices for me. I want to give you things, not take things away from you. I don't want to steal your future.” (Myer, 2008). This quote comes at a point in the series where Edward is so strong, that Bella needs to make the “sacrifice” to give up her humanity and gain the strength of the supernatural to avoid her accidental death at Edward’s hands. In both of these situations the females are in the less powerful position, whether the context is being raped or being human, and the males have the power to decide how the story plays out; stopping the rape or making Bella stronger, even though both are gender stereotypical norms. Both of these series are considered paranormal romance novels. I would like to take a moment to address how the element of the supernatural plays out among the characters. In Twilight Edward is a vampire, this gives him super human abilities, like mind reading, immortality, super strength and speed, enhanced smell, hearing and sight, as well as high intelligence (Myer, 2005; Myer, 2006; Myer, 2007; Myer, 2008). In the Wolves of Mercy Falls Series, Sam is a werewolf, and not just any werewolf, but an alpha, poised to take over the pack. He has super human abilities as well, like super strength, speed, enhanced smell, sight, hearing, the ability to transform into a wolf, as well as high intelligence (Stiefvater, 2009; Stiefvater, POWER PLAY 13 2010; Stiefvater, 2011). Both of these male characters have more power, physically and mentally, than their female counterparts Bella and Grace. Both characters have so much more power than their female partners they are frightened of accidentally killing them. The females can only hope to gain this power of the supernatural from their male counterparts, since both create a situation where power cannot be transferred with out the males’ consent. While both of the characters Bella and Grace ask for the supernatural powers at some point in the series, if the males did not capitulate and approve the power transfer, both females would have remained human. In fact, the only reason that the females want to change is to become closer to their male partners and maintain their heterosexual relationships (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). Males are forced into this position, as neither Sam nor Edward chose to become more than human and they even lament the loss of their humanity. It is obvious in the series’ that the males do not prefer this power disparity between themselves and Bella and Grace, but both of the males are still the power holders whether they want to be or not (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). The element of the supernatural exaggerates a power disparity that already exists between the genders into something even more difficult to overcome. Subtle Differences in Power There are a couple of very subtle ways that power differences play out within the novels as well, that are due to gender stereotypes. There are female characters within both series that are stronger than Bella and Grace, females that are less “feminine” when it comes to behavioral traits, and could, arguably, be better matches to the male characters Edward and Sam (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). In fact both male characters are originally ‘set up’ to be with these females, Rosalie, a vampire for Edward and Shelby, a werewolf for Sam (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). However, the couples were paired in such a way within the novels that they did conform POWER PLAY 14 to gender norms; the female protagonists are less in the novels, physically smaller, shorter, less strong, less intelligent and less experienced. Even though there were female characters who were closer in power to the male characters, the main characters involved in the love story still had a heterosexual relationship that conformed to power disparities and gender norms. Within the novels the concept of love becomes very sexualized. Our culture has very specific guidelines for what is sexy and sensual (Crawford, 2006). If you do not fit the stereotype for sexy, then you also do not fit in the category for love. Both Grace and Bella find it difficult to believe that they can be loved because of the way that they look, as they describe themselves as “normal”, as if the norms in our society are already not even good enough (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). However, all of the main characters fit societal norms for being sexually attractive in both series’; they are all white, middle class or higher, able bodied, intelligent, skinny, pretty or handsome, or in Bella’s words “perfect” (Myer, 2005; Stiefvater, 2009). These norms exclude many individuals: individuals over the age of 23 or 24, with a disability, who are overweight, underweight, an ethnic or racial minority, transgender, gay, lesbian, bisexual, too intelligent, not intelligent enough, poor, or with a mental or physical disease. The ability to feel comfortable being loved or sexual is powerful, and these novels describe the people in our culture who have that power and by exclusion those who do not. Discussion and Conclusion The four main characters in the young adult series’ the Twilight Saga by Stephanie Myer and the Wolves of Mercy Falls reproduce the systemic power disparity between men and women by playing into legitimizing myths and gender role stereotypes. By romanticizing the stereotypes around women and men, the underlying sexist messages are hidden, and the power structure that places men in power over women is then popularly mass marketed to teenagers. Bella Swan, POWER PLAY 15 Edward Cullen, Grace Brisbane and Sam Roth, under feminist analysis, are used to show women as physically inferior, over emotional, and out of control of their behaviors and bodies, when compared to men. These behaviors reinforce sexist stereotypes that reproduce harmful situations when played out in a real world context. Gender stereotypes are upheld in these series’, for multiple reasons such as culture, age and power disparities. These gender stereotypes are culturally specific, and with the gender scripts for our culture defined, it could be hard to publish a novel (or even find readers for a novel) who alters or deviates from these scripts too often. We live in a patriarchal society with sexual scripts that give power to the male gender over the female gender; it is not surprising that these norms appear in literature (Crawford, 2006). Gender and sexual scripts are also used in the search for identity. Adolescence is a time when people begin defining themselves, and when trying out new identities, as adolescent theorist Berzonsky suggests, the stereotypes can be helpful (2011). Adolescents need a standard definition to appropriate or alter for their own purposes. In novels appealing to a young adult audience, it would only make sense that the stereotypes would be present. While the appearance of gender stereotypes in the novels can be viewed in a more neutral cultural setting, or as a helpful device when searching for an identity, young adult literature that presents gendered stereotypes represent a wire in the bird cage of oppression. Marilyn Frye explains oppression by likening individual ‘isms’, like racism, classism, sexism, to wires in a bird cage that oppress and immobilize the occupants, women. The implications of internalizing these sexist stereotypes for males or females lie within this realm of oppression. Novels like the Twilight Saga and the Wolves of Mercy Falls series’ popularize and fantasize situations that can be harmful if played out in the real world; Edward’s attitude towards Bella because she is POWER PLAY 16 “human” in the novel can be read as a prejudicial and containing negative attitude towards females (Crawford, 2006). The relationship between Grace and Sam can be read as statutory rape masked by love (Crawford, 2006). The difference between the female protagonists and the male protagonists in intelligence and physical stature represents sex discrimination in the work place and higher education, displacing women from resources that higher paying jobs and higher levels of education can make available (Crawford, 2006). The control that both Sam and Edward exert over the sexual lives of their partners, represents the unrecognized sexual abuse that women are more commonly victim’s of than men. Sam even has power enough to halt Grace’s metaphorical rape, while the final novel of the Twilight Saga contains a sex scene reminiscent of rape, when Bella wakes up bruised and furniture is destroyed from her wedding night, but the power inequity between Edward and Bella is justified because Bella is desperate for his love (Myer, 2008; Stiefvater, 2009). When looking at one wire, it is hard to understand how harmful it can be (Frye, 1983). For example, there are sexist representations of women and bias representations of men in the novels I have presented in this paper; to avoid the influence of the stereotypes people can simple stop reading the books and the bird can fly or hop around one wire. However, we do not live in a society of one ‘ism’, we live in a society where hundreds of variables interact to keep current power disparities in place. The power disparities between men and women cannot equalize until all of the wires are dismantled, even one as seemingly benign as a young adult romance novel. POWER PLAY 17 References: Bem, S. L., & Lewis, S. A. (1975). Sex role adaptability: One consequence of psychological androgyny. Journal Of Personality And Social Psychology, 31(4), 634-643. doi:10.1037/h0077098. Berzonsky, M. D. (2011). A social-cognitive perspective on identity construction. In S. J. Schwartz, K. Luyckx, V. L. Vignoles, S. J. Schwartz, K. Luyckx, V. L. Vignoles (Eds.), Handbook of identity theory and research (Vols 1 and 2) (pp. 55-76). New York, NY US: Springer Science + Business Media. doi:10.1007/978-1-4419-7988-9_3 Brown, L. M. (2003). Girlfighting betrayal and rejection among girls.. New York, NY: New York University Press. Crawford, M. (2006). Transformations women, gender & psychology. (2 ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill. Dictionary.com. (2012, April 16). Retrieved from http://dictionary.reference.com/browse Frye, M. (1983). The Politics of Reality. Trumansburg, N.Y. The Crossing Press. Girgus, J. S., & Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2006). Cognition and Depression. In C. M. Keyes, S. H. Goodman, C. M. Keyes, S. H. Goodman (Eds.) , Women and depression: A handbook for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences (pp. 147-175). New York, NY US: Cambridge University Press. Myer, S. (2005). Twilight. New York, NY: Little, Brown and Company. Myer, S. (2006). New Moon. New York, NY: Little, Brown and Company. Myer, S. (2007). Eclipse. New York, NY: Little, Brown and Company. Myer, S. (2008). Breaking Dawn. New York, NY: Little, Brown and Company. POWER PLAY 18 Pardun, C., L'Engle, K., & Brown, J. (2005).Linking exposure to outcomes: Early adolescents’ consumption of sexual content in six media. Mass Communication & Society, 8(2), 7591. Stiefvater, M. (2009). Shiver. New York, NY: Scholastic Press. Stiefvater, M. (2010). Linger. New York, NY: Scholastic Press. Stiefvater, M. (2011). Forever. New York, NY: Scholastic Press.