Mechamasher | 02 craft brewing | 07 Meura technologies | 07 Meur a 2001 Micro A successful project at Cerveceria Costa Rica Irish distillers Pernod-Ricard makes its new brewhouse with Meura! The Meura Journal special issue Drink tec 2013 Meura’s developments since last Drinktec Dear Readers, Here we are at Drinktec 2013 already! In the past 4 years we have already presented you the first results of our latest technology of the time, the MEURABREW, the ILOBOX and the Hybrid MEURA 2001 Filter. In our various Newsletters published since Drinktec 2009 we have shared our vision of the brewery of the future based on the integration of our different technologies with you. We have summarised those various communications for your perusal in this edition of The Meura Journal, especially published on the occasion of Drinktec 2013. The savings in extract and in the consumption of utilities, without compromising the quality of the product, have always been at the core of the concerns and objectives of the MEURA engineers. It is therefore my great pleasure to invite you to also discover our latest development in The Meura Journal: the MEURASTREAM. This technology will allow reducing the thermal energy consumption of your brewhouse by up to 52 % and the hot water produced in excess by up to 60%! I encourage you to discover this new MEURA product and our team will welcome you at our stand at Drinktec 2013 to explain it in detail. And of course, as always, you’ll be greeted with a delicious selection of our very best Belgian beers. Sincerely yours, Christian De Brackeleire Chief Executive Officer drinktec 2013 16-20 september Messe München / Tr aditio nally pio n eers sin ce 1845/ w w w. m eur a .be The Meurastream: Reducing the steam consumption by 52% ! The industrial introduction, about 5 years ago, of the Meurabrew (Meura’s continuous brewhouse) is certainly one of the major technological developments in the recent history of the brewing industry. To date, 4 large size continuous brewhouses have been sold or installed. The Meurabrew is a very attractive solution for large breweries with a limited number of different wort streams and certainly in case of greenfield projects where the utilities still have to be installed. Consequently, this also means that it is not the optimum solution for every project. Thus, both types of brewhouse will continue to exist in parallel. Batch as well as continuous brewhouses still have significant steam consumption and an overproduction of hot water. In the last 5-10 years especially, the over-production of hot water has become a problem for many brewers. Since the industry is trying to reduce the water consumption of the overall process, the extra hot water produced in the brewhouse cannot (or can only partly) be used. Often the hot water tank in the brewhouse overflows on a daily basis which represents a water and energy loss. With reduced steam utilization and hot water excess in mind, Meura has developed a new concept, called the “Meurastream”. The principle of the Meurastream can be implemented in a batch brewhouse as well as a Meurabrew. The following diagram shows the principle of the MeuraStream: The following table compares the Meurastream with a brewhouse without energy recovery and one with the conventional vapour condensation technology (often called the “pfaduko” system). The calculations are made under the same conditions and recalculated to 15°P cold wort. This Meurastream consist of 2 major technologies: Brew water recovery at high temperature with energy re-use The principle of the Meurastream is very straightforward to explain. Part of the energy from the wort cooling process will be used to pre-heat the wort. Instead of heating the brew water in the wort cooler to 80-85°C, the water will be heated to about 96°C. This means that the volume of this hot water will be smaller than at the usual lower temperature. The energy from the steam injected into the Ecostripper is partially recovered and heats this water further to 97°C. The hot water is than temporarily stored in a very hot water vessel. For The MEURABREW: Meura’s Continuous Brewhouse In the last two decades, major advances in performance have been achieved in batch brewhouses mainly by using fine milling technology. Despite these improvements, breweries keep asking for further productivity increases together with a reduction of utilities consumption and waste disposal. The likelihood of further improvements using the current method of batch brewing is limited. Only a conceptual change can respond to the current and future demands of the brewing industry. In 1998, Meura, Traditionally a Pioneer, thus started a research programme to develop a continuous brewhouse, called the “MEURABREW”. The first industrial plant was successfully started up in May 2007. A second plant was commissioned in Suzhou (China) in April 2008. To date, 4 Meurabrew have been sold worldwide. History of the meurabrew development CONTINUOUS versus BATCH In 1998, Meura started the development of the continuous brewing concept. A complete pilot plant was installed in 1999. Based on these successful pilot trials, Meura’s engineering department began designing an industrial plant in 2004. With information gained, it was possible to start looking for a “first mover”. In general, continuous processes are more energy efficient, easier to control and consequently lead to a lower production cost. As far as the brewhouse process is concerned, here are the main specific reasons to develop a continuous brewhouse: In 2005, the discussions started with Jan Martens in Belgium, leading to an order in June 2006. The first operation of the Meurabrew on an industrial scale of 200 hl/h wort (up to 20°P) took place on 12 May 2007. In January 2007 a similar order was obtained for a plant in Suzhou (China). formation vessel, the wort is kept at 100°C with almost no evaporation (less than 1%). In this step all processes that involve heat treatment are performed (formation of DMS, sterilization, enzyme deactivation, hop isomerisation etc.) After this formation step the trub is eliminated by a whirlpool or Clarisaver (wort settling tank). The final step, in-line with the wort cooling, is the ECOstripper, a wort stripping technology. Wort is pumped on top of the stripper and in counter-flow 0.5% steam is injected to eliminate the unwanted volatiles. The overall evaporation rate is thus only 1,5%! Reduced peak consumption of utilities The most important utilities consumed in the brewhouse are steam and cooling liquid. In a batch brewhouse, different batches are processed at the same time and consequently lead to a large steam peak. The wort cooling takes place normally within 50-60 minutes, which means peak consumption during that period. Editor-in-Chief : Bénédicte Everaert, Meura S.A., Rond-Point J.-B. Meura 1, B-7600 Péruwelz (Belgium), P: +32 69 88 69 88, sales@meura.com the next brew, this 97°C water is heated to 103°C with an in-line steam booster and is used to pre-heat the wort to 99°C, when pumped to the wort kettle (or formation vessel). The temperature of the brew water will be lowered from 97°C to 82°C, which is then used for mashing-in and sparging. Summarized a part of the energy from the wort cooling is used for the wort pre-heating. ECOstripper technology With the Ecostripper, the heat treatment of the wort and elimination of volatiles is separated into two steps (in a classic brewhouse the wort kettle performs these processes at the same time). In a first vessel, called the Reduced energy and extract losses All pipes and vessels stay continuously filled with mash or wort, which makes it possible to avoid the heat and extract losses experienced in batch processes. Reduced waste disposal During the production no drainage occurs, which considerably reduces the wastewater volume. L imited space requirements The most state-of-the-art batch brewhouses only brew about 14 batches a day. About every 100 minutes one batch is produced, which consequently requires vessels that can handle the necessary volumes. Brewhouse vessels of a large size also mean large piping diameters, large-sized valves and pumps at the high flows. A continuous flow significantly reduces the plant dimensions. E asy process control In practice, it is difficult to have the same process conditions between similar batches. The fouling of the mash tun(s) and wort kettle during production change the heating performance of these vessels and thus change the process conditions. Consequently a significant variation in for example colour or bitterness is noted between batches of the same brands. These fluctuations are avoided with a continuous process. Classic Brewhouse Pfaduko Brewhouse Meura Stream 26,0 MJ/hl 19,4 MJ/hl 12,6 MJ/hl 37,8 l/hl 37,8 l/hl 15,6 l/hl Thermal energy Excess in hot water The table shows that the Meurastream reduces by 52% the thermal energy of a brewhouse without energy recovery and 35% for a brewhouse with pfaduko! Excess hot water is reduced by 60% thanks to the Meurastream! These figures make the MeuraStream most probably as the most energy efficient brewhouse concept available on the market. The MeuraStream concept can be easily implemented More details on page 4. in an existing brewhouse. Table I Batch brewhouse Continuous brewhouse 12 brews/day of 400 hl cold wort at 20°P 200 hl/h of cold wort at 20°P Mash 1 500 hl/h – 15 KW 180 hl/h – 5.5 KW Wort 3 600 hl/h – 30 KW 225 hl/h – 4 KW Steam peak flow 14 T/h 3T/h Water peak flow 650 hl/h 220 hl/h Electricity installed 375 kW 250 kW Electricity peak 300 KW 200 KW Peak cooling power 4,650 kW 2,200 kW Capacity Pumps Utilities Meura’s Continuous Brewhouse Table I shows a comparison between a batch brewhouse at 12 brews/day and a continuous brewhouse for a brewery with 3 million hl final capacity. © exnihilo.be 02 | M EUR A n e ws SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 CERVECERIA COSTA RICA A Meura 2001 Junior Hybrid filter installed in Belgium A successful project at Cerveceria Costa Rica Belgium, the country of the beer, has more than 100 breweries on its territory – of all sizes. The Huyghe brewery, located in Melle near Ghent, is one of the oldest breweries in the North of Belgium. The first brewing activities in the Huyghe brewery date back to 1654! The Huyghe brewery is renowned worldwide for its Delirium Tremens beer, which was awarded the gold medal at the World Beer Championship in Chicago in 1998, and for its Guillotine, a high fermentation beer that won the gold medal at the prestigious Brewing Industry International Awards in 2011. In 2010, faced with continuously increasing demand, the brewery decided to modernise and to double its capacity to reach 300,000 hl! Costa Rica (which means “Rich Coast” in Spanish) did not get its name by coincidence. It is indeed a beautiful country with a unique, rich variety of fauna and flora. The country is aware of the importance of its wildlife and, in 2007, the government decided to become the first carbon neutral country in the world by 2021! Located on the outskirts of San Jose, Cerveceria Costa Rica is the main brewery in Costa Rica. The major brand is Imperial and it is the most representative beer on the national market. In 2006, the brewery’s installed capacity was about 1.7 million hl. With the quantity of beer increasing continuously, the brewhouse was becoming a bottleneck due, in particular, to the lauter tun. For this reason, the brewery started to think about a brewhouse modernisation. After having closely analysed all the technologies available, they finally entrusted this new challenge to Meura. The main equipment installed by Meura: Milling line with a CLM 4 (classic hammer mill) Grist case on load cells. Mechamasher 60t/h M eura 2001 double Mash filter with 80 chambers capable of being extended up to MEURA 2001 (previous version) Note: with the Meura 2001 a filter chamber was defined as having two filter beds formed on two cloths including 2 membranes. One chamber could have a load of 175kg of malt or malt equivalent. MEURA 2001 Hybrid Note: with the Meura 2001 Hybrid, one plate has one cloth and one membrane and thus contains one filter bed. One plate is designed for a nominal capacity of 90kg malt or malt equivalent. 100 chambers. Maximum load of 19.2 tons of malt equivalent. CIP Station Electricity and automation (Braumat supervision) Since 2008, the brewery has been working with their brand new equipment. Brewery’s new figures Today, with the new Meura equipment, the brewhouse capacity has been increased by 74% compared to the original output. An average increase of the extract yield of about 1.5% compared to the previous lauter tun brewhouse is observed. This increase will give Cerveceria Costa Rica a quick return on their investment. It is possible to increase the production up to 14 brews per day at 16 °P. With the membrane compression the Meura 2001 mash filter provides a very dry spent grains with a dry matter of 25-30%. Quality beer Some other parameters have also been taken into account like the organoleptic beer profile. Several tests have been carried out among their customers and brewmasters regarding the beer’s taste, and no difference was found from the beer brewed in the old equipment. Keeping the organoleptic beer profile was one of the main targets for the brewery in order to avoid any consumer comments and complaints. Meura completely fulfilled this requirement! Meura as a real partner Another success for the project was the delivery time. Between the order and the first brew, only 4 months had passed. The Meura 2001 mash filter is a standard item of equipment where only the length is variable from one project to another, which enables a short production process and thus a short delivery time. Always giving customer communication high priority, Meura has, among others, a Spanish speaking team with high-level skills able to take on projects in Spanish speaking countries. This was a great help for communication and cooperation, no t only with the managers but also for all site personnel. Full training was delivered in Spanish, avoiding any misunderstandings with operators and allowing a much more open and flexible communication. We thank Cerveceria Costa Rica for choosing Meura as a partner and we wish them every success for the future! Brewhouse suppliers are continuously challenged to develop technologies that improve the extract yields, the productivity, the wort quality and increase the HGB. The Meura 2001 is recognized worldwide as the leading technology in the field of mash filtration. A solution was found by keeping only the filter bed in the direction of the best sparging efficiency. The Meura 2001 Hybrid was born, which has filter plates of one single identical design. The plate is now called the “hybrid plate” and no longer a “filter plate” or a “membrane plate”. Each hybrid plate is equipped with one cloth AND one membrane (compared to the Meura 2001 which had plates equipped with two membranes OR 2 cloths). In 2006, with a wealth of experience in mash filtration (280 Meura 2001 mash filters installed all over the world), Meura decided to rethink the Meura 2001 technology and modify the design of the filter chambers. The main objective was to further reduce the sparging water ratio, and this could only be done by improving the flow pattern inside the filter chambers. In 2007, a first prototype hybrid plate was installed in our pilot filter at Meura Technologies. The initial results were very promising and test plates were subsequently installed in an industrial filter, which confirmed and even exceeded the pilot results. At the end of 2008, the hybrid plates were ready for industrialization and the first Meura 2001 Hybrid (for the hybrid design of the filter plates) was installed in Palm Breweries. This leads to a wide range of advantages: The major improvement with the Meura 2001 Hybrid lies in a conceptual change in its filter plate design. Previous internal research showed an irregularity in the sparging efficiency of the filter bed cakes. The reason was a different filling pattern from one cake to another (see drawing). Filtration chambers are filled with an improved regularity, thus with an optimal homogeneity of the cake. Shear forces during filling are reduced The wort quality is improved thanks to a reduced sparging ratio (below 2.2 l/kg while maintaining 100% of extraction yield) Thanks to the improved flow pattern the filters can now be equipped with up to 160 plates (15.5 tons) compared to the previous filter equipped with maximum 65 chambers (12 tons). Reduced sparging time and thus shorter occupation time All these advantages currently make the new Meura 2001 Hybrid the best and most efficient mash filter in the world! The wide variety of beers, combined with an improvement of the brewhouse yield and wort quality, logically lead the brewery to the fine milling technology and subsequently to the Meura 2001 technologies. The main equipment supplied by Meura consists of: A Meura 2001 Hybrid Junior filter for 3.2 tons of malt equivalent Classicmill CLM1 Junior with A a capacity of 1.8 tons of malt per hour A grist hopper A Mechamasher of 15 tons malt grist per hour To cope with the unique variation in raw materials, the Meura 2001 Junior filter has been supplied with an intercalary plate that enables it to modulate the filter capacity to the desired level. It is the first time a Meura 2001 Hybrid Junior filter has been sold and installed in Belgium. This filter was specially developed for smaller-sized breweries like the craft brewers in the USA, Belgium and elsewhere in the world. With this article we wish to thank the Huyghe brewery for its trust in our technologies and its cooperation throughout the implementation of the project! M EUR A n e ws | 03 SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 Frankfurter Brauhaus Knows the best mash filter supplier In the mid-1990s the brewery decided to modernize the brewhouse with the installation of a mash filter. Supplied by one of Meura’s competitors, this filter was originally equipped with a membrane technology. But the concept failed and the supplier had to retrofit the filter to a conventional mash filter. This mash filter was never able to meet the brewer’s requirements and showed low yield, high wort turbidity, CIP required every 15 brews, etc. In 2009 the brewery needed to increase its brewhouse capacity and, because of their bad experience with the mash filter, a new lauter tun was the first option. But their need to be the most cost efficient brewer finally made them decide in favour of the only filter combining the highest quality and the highest cost efficiency: the Meura 2001 mash filter. The order was signed on 13 September 2009, at our booth at the Drinktec fair in Munich. Challenge The Meura technology installed in Frankfurter Brauhaus consist of: a Classicmill (CLM4 of 13.2 tons malt per hour) a Mechamasher (60 tons malt grist per hour) a sparging water tank Feed-back Today the brewery is extremely satisfied with its new state-of-the-art equipment. The performance of the Meura 2001 are incomparable to the previously installed mash filter and even exceed by far the expectations of the brewery. The project was thus a complete success for both Frankfurter Brauhaus and Meura. Meura wishes great and continued success to the brewery and thanks them for their outstanding collaboration during the project. a double Meura 2001 mash filter, each equipped with 43 chambers extendable to 53 chambers and producing brews of 770 hl cold wort. Maintaining your filtration efficiency During the commissioning of a mash filter, MEURA carries out the fine tuning of process parameters in order to achieve the best possible performance level. Later on, changes in external factors such as the wort recipe, loading, types and characteristics of raw materials, modification of brewing conditions, etc. may lead to deviations from the optimum level. As with all other technologies, the user should adapt the process parameters to the new situation. The following chart shows typical changes in the yield over a three-year period. The blue line indicates a possible decrease in the yield under the assumption that none of the parameter settings is modified. This double mash filter is equipped with the new Ilobox technology, which enables it to perform continuously with an optimized parameter setting. For the mechanical and electrical installation, Meura collaborated with the Polish subsidiary of Boccard Enterprises, Meura’s parent company, called Boccard Polska. Commissioning 100 Yield Less than two months after the signing of the contract, the installation started on 2 November 2009. On 4 January 2010 (less than four months after the contract was signed), the first brew was performed. The time period was thus very short but nevertheless all performance guarantees were fulfilled. Performance Service Level Agreement Meura 2001 Mash Filter UNITED BREWERIES: the CHA MUNDI Brewery Another Success Story for the Meura-Praj partnership and United Breweries. India, with its population of 1.23 billion and its low annual per capita beer consumption, close to just 2 liters, is an attractive market for International Brewers. United Breweries (UB), the largest brewer in India with 55% market share, and the proud owner of India’s number one beer brand, ‘KINGFISHER’, has been the undisputed leader in the Indian brewing industry for years. In 2011, UB decided to build a state-of-the-art greenfield brewery in Mysore in the state of Karnataka, which is also the home state of UB head office. The new plant was named The Chamundi Brewery. Already familiar with and convinced by the Meura-Praj partnership’s successful demonstration of the technology in three of its owned and contract breweries, UB entrusted them with the responsibility of building this complete brewery process section. The prestigious brewery, set on 75 acres of lush green land and with a brewery foot print of 4 million hl, is India’s largest, ‘greenest’ and will also be its most efficient brewery. Praj is supplying the complete process section right from malt reception to bright beer tanks with 400hl high gravity brewhouse consisting of the following MEURA equipment: A Classicmill CLM 2 PCV with a capacity of 5 tonnes of Indian malt per hour A Meura 2001 Hybrid filter for 7 tonnes of malt equivalent With its three MEURA 2001 mash filters already installed in United Breweries, UB enjoys the lion’s share of beer produced by the Meura mash filters in India. Currently Praj and Meura are executing a brewery expansion project for UB at MBIL-A, Maharashtra with 400 hl brewhouse and a fourth MEURA 2001 Hybrid mash filter to produce UB beer brands such as Kingfisher, Kingfisher Ultra, Kingfisher Blue etc. During 2010-2011, India’s beer consumption surpassed 240 million cases (a case is 12 bottles of 650 ml), 23% of which was produced using Meura mash filters. Thanks to a strong focus on improving efficiencies and economics in brewing, today Meura-Praj has installed and successfully commissioned more than eight mash filters in India. Another two mash filters will be commissioned by the end of 2013. Today 14 Meura 2001 filters are operational or under commissioning in India. With its 80% market share for mash filter breweries in the Indian brewing industry, Meura-Praj is the preferred partner for mash filter brewhouses in India. The partnership continues to strive to achieve excellence and elevate the renewed pleasure of the high quality, high efficiency beer making experience in India and the sub-continent. “ O n behalf of the United Breweries team, I would like to convey my sincere appreciation to MeuraPraj for being our valued technology partner in the brewery business and for their invaluable support and cooperation. We highly appreciate the expertise and cooperation provided by Meura-Praj alliance in the Chamundi Project and our various brewery installations.” Mr Cedric Vaz, Executive Vice President – Manufacturing United Breweries 98 New malt harvest New malt harvest 99 New malt harvest 0 Today Yield 1 Year SLA Yield 2 3 Optimal yield Extract losses represent a major extra cost. This is one of the main reasons why our customers invest in the purchase of a Meura 2001 filter. As an example, for a brewery using 30,000 T of malt per year (about 2 million hl/year) with a malt price of 400 €/T, a loss of 1% extract represents 120,000 € on a yearly basis. In order to assure a constant high extract yield over the years, Meura has developed a Performance Service Level Agreement (Performance SLA). The red line in the figure above shows the objective to be reached with a Performance SLA. The Performance SLA consists in 3 parts : 1) The Ilobox technology The optimization software developed on the ILOBOX (Iterative Logic Box) recalculates and delivers new process parameters to the PLC after each brew in order to maintain the optimum efficiency while respecting the user’s temporary priorities. The ILOBOX is able to evaluate the performance by measuring the wort density during the last compression cycle. Indeed, thanks to the Meura 2001 filter equipped with membranes, the density during final compression of the filter cake is related to the washable extract of the cake and thus indicates the performance of the sparging cycle. Besides the optimization of mash filter process parameters, the ILOBOX also offers other functionalities, such as archiving of performance data over the last two years and remote connection for a remote audit by MEURA. The working principle of the ILOBOX is based on a batch-to-batch optimization. The process parameters of a brew are recorded and analysed, and for the next brew (of the same beer type) a new set of optimized parameters is generated by the ILOBOX. The only two parameters that have to be installed by the brewery are the requested total cycle time and the volume of sparging water. The ILOBOX will generate the parameters that produce the highest extract yield. Meura started with this technology in 2006 and the results to date are impressive. A very regular high level of performance is obtained which often exceeds what a commissioning engineer is able to do, since the ILOBOX manages 17 parameters at once, whereas during commissioning just a few parameters are optimized. The last running has a density of 1-1.2°P and the density during compressing is about 0.5°P, indicating excellent results. In addition these figures were obtained with a sparging rate of less than 1.6 l/kg! This is a unique figure, which was never obtained before with a Meura 2001 filter. 2) The Remote Services In the event that a customer has specific questions about the Meura 2001 or for example about a specific filtration profile, the Meura technologies department is able to connect remotely with the Ilobox and have a look at the observed process values stored in the system. In addition on a monthly basis the Meura specialist will make a report on the performance of the brews pass during the month, and will further analyse any brews that showed a specific filtration issue. 3) The On-Site Services The ILOBOX is very efficient in providing the optimal parameters set for the Meura 2001 filter, but is not able to change process parameters up-stream of the mash filter that influence the filtration performance. For example, in the event that the grist composition is not optimal, shearing forces in the brewhouse are not under control, mash oxidation occurs, or there is filter under or overloading, parameters other than those of the Meura 2001 filter have to be optimized. In order to make the Performance SLA complete, a yearly site visit by a Meura Mechanical Specialist and a Process Technologist is scheduled. The Meura Specialist will carry out a mechanical check of the mash filter, supporting the production team so they can perform the best possible maintenance while helping prevent any mechanical failure. A Technologist will mainly control the up-stream equipment towards the mash filter and conduct a training session for any new team members. Conclusion: Meura’s Performance SLA offers you the services you need to keep critical production factors (like savings in extract) and related costs under control. The pay-back period for such an Agreement is extremely short. Thanks to Meura’s Performance Service Level Agreement you will keep your Meura 2001 mash filter at its top performance, which is key for your success. 04 | M EUR A n e ws SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 2) B rewhouse with conventional vapour condensation As explained on the front page of this Meura Journal, the MeuraStream consists of two major technologies: a wort cooler, where the cold brew water is heated to about 96°C, and the Ecostripper. FIGURE 1 Stripping efficiency (%) 100 FREE-DIVIS (ppb) 200 90 180 160 148 144 140 120 The ECOstripper : the central technology of the MeuraStream The principle of the MeuraStream is very straightforward. The only technology used which might not been familiar for every brewer is the Ecostripper, a de-intensified hot wort treatment. The technology was developed as early as the 1990s, but with rather limited industrial applications. In 2007, Meura presented at the E.B.C. in Venice the latest findings based on a 600 hl/h industrial installation. This study confirmed at first the positive influence on the flavour stability of the beer, which increased the interest of many brewers. Conventional boiling with a wort kettle at the same time performs the heat treatment (required, for example, for the formation of DMS from SMM) as well as the evaporation (required to eliminate unwanted volatiles). With the Ecostripper both processes are separated into two steps. In a first vessel, called the formation vessel, the wort is kept at 100°C with almost no evaporation (less than 1%). In this step, all processes that involve heat treatment are performed (formation of DMS, sterilization, enzyme deactivation, hop isomerisation etc.). The Ecostripper has a much higher stripping efficiency than normal wort boiling. In a wort kettle, the efficiency of free DMS removal is in the 50-60% range, whereas the Ecostripper is >90%. The figure below shows figures from an industrial Ecostripper for 3 steam ratios (1.5%/1.0%/0.5%) for a wort at 17.5°P. Since the Ecostripper is installed just in front of the wort cooler, there is no de novo synthesis of unwanted volatiles as is the case with a whirlpool in a brewhouse with a conventional wort kettle. The Ecostripper also removes unwanted aldehydes affecting flavour stability of the final beer and 70 115 112 60 111 100 50 80 40 60 30 40 20 10 0 1,5 17 5 1,0 maltA free-DMS pre-strip maltA free-DMS post-strip 20 19 12 4 0,5 maltB free-DMS pre-strip maltB free-DMS post-strip 10 0 Steam Ratio (%) maltA strip.efficiency maltB strip.efficiency Source : E.B.C. 2007 (Venice) “ Wort boiling – the Meura’s concept with wortstripping” by B. Bonacchelli , C. De Brackeleire, F. Harmegnies FIGURE 2 100 Strecker aldehydes removal efficiency (%) – for malt B 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2-methyl-propanal 2-methyl-butanal Wort stripping 1% 3-methyl-propanal Wort stripping 0.5% Class boiling Source : E.B.C. 2007 (Venice) “ Wort boiling – the Meura’s concept with wortstripping” by B. Bonacchelli , C. De Brackeleire, F. Harmegnies which are very difficult to remove with conventional wort boiling. The figure below shows the removal of the 3 main Strecker aldehydes. The figure above shows the positive effect of the Ecostripper on wort quality. Bench marking of the MeuraStream For the comparison we are considering a brewhouse equipped with a Meura 2001 filter and a wort kettle with vapour condensation with a total evaporation of 4%. Although the evaporation energy is partly recovered, the vapour condensation system has some known disadvantages: a) The need to evaporate at least 4% To have sufficient energy to heat up the wort, at least 4% evaporation (theoretically 3.6 to 3.8%, in reality 4%) is needed. With 100% malt brews, and thus quite a high concentration of DMS formed during boiling, this evaporation of 4% is certainly required. But this is not always necessary in the case of brewing with unmalted adjuncts. Thus, in many cases, a 4% evaporation is necessary not for wort quality reasons, but for the operation of the heat recovery system! 90 Wort stripping 1.5% After this formation step, the trub is eliminated by the whirlpool or Clarisaver. The final step, in-line with the wort cooling, is the ECOStripper. Wort is pumped on top of the stripper and in counter-flow 0.5% steam is injected to eliminate the unwanted volatiles. The overall evaporation rate is thus only 1.5%! 80 137 The most common applied technology to reduce the steam consumption is vapour condensation in the wort kettle chimney (also called “pfaduko”). With conventional vapour condensation, the vapours from the wort boiling are condensed to prepare water up to 96°C. This water is stored in a so-called stratification tank since at a certain stage water at 96°C will float to the upper part in the vessel while colder water at 76-80°C will be at the bottom. The wort of the next brew will be heated with this energy to about 92°C (and potentially further heated to 99°C with a steam booster). Compared with a brewhouse without any energy recovery, where the wort is at 78°C in the wort kettle, it represents an energy saving to recover this additional 14°C from the wort boiling. 1) B rewhouse without any energy recovery For the comparison, we are considering a conventional brewhouse equipped with a Meura 2001 filter and a wort kettle allowing a total evaporation rate of just 4%. b) No solution for excess hot water In a modern brewery, with wort cooling generating water at 80-85°C, the brewhouse is making more water than it needs for its own operation. Today more and more breweries do not have further consumers for this excess hot water. Vapour condensation does not influence this issue. also the water booster and a condensate cooler). In addition there are a few valves in the circuit, as well as a fan to evacuate the non-condensed vapours. To summarize: the system has a certain complexity and will require substantial investment costs (Capex), but also maintenance costs (Opex). d) Space requirement The heat exchanger to condense the vapour from the wort kettle is very large, certainly when a tubular exchanger is used. Also, large-diameter piping is needed to connect the chimney to the heat exchanger. Furthermore, there is the significant height of the stratification tank. In conclusion, vapour condensation technology requires more space for its implementation. e) Energy losses If the brewhouse is shut down over the weekend, the water at 76-80°C and 96°C is stored in the stratification tank. Over the weekend, this water will mix and the temperature will go down, which makes the system for the first 2 brews inefficient. 3) Comparison with the MeuraStream The figure 3 shows the principle of the MeuraStream. In the formation vessel, 1% evaporation is considered and at the Ecostripper 0.5%. Total evaporation is thus 1.5%. The red lines in the picture below show the energy streams with the MeuraStream. The following table compares the MeuraStream with a brewhouse without energy recovery and one with conventional vapour condensation technology (often called the “pfaduko” system). The calculations are made are under the same conditions and recalculated to 15°P cold wort. Classic Brewhouse Pfaduko Brewhouse Meura Stream Thermal energy 26,0 MJ/hl 19,4 MJ/hl 12,6 MJ/hl Excess in hot water 37,8 l/hl 37,8 l/hl 15,6 l/hl c) Complexity of the system – maintenance costs In general , a vapour condensation assembly consists of 4 heat exchangers (two large ones for vapour condensation and pre-heating and It means that the MeuraStream reduces by 52% the thermal energy required for a brewhouse without energy recovery and by 35% for a brewhouse with pfaduko! Excess hot water is reduced by 60% thanks to the MeuraStream! These unwanted volatiles are stripped out thanks to a steam counter flow (about 0.5% w/w of steam, i.e. 5 kg of steam per ton of wort). The Ecostripper is the last unit prior to the wort cooling. It means that when the stripped wort leaves the Ecostripper it is immediately cooled down. This avoids de-novo synthesis of unwanted volatiles present in a conventional brewhouse while waiting in the trub separation step. Bruno Bonacchelli (Meura) at the EBC convention in 2007, showed a clear reduction in staling aldehydes. The Ecostripper consequently improves the flavour stability of the final beer! It is clear that the economical and ecological advantages combined with the product quality improvement makes the Ecostripper, the technology that a state-of-the-art brewery needs today. The complete Ecostripper technology from formation to wort stripping requires less than 1.5% of total evaporation rate from which almost 0.5% could be further recovered by installing a steam condenser on the outlet of the Ecostripper. We thank both breweries with the two new Ecostripper orders for their trust in our technologies. We hope that the several ongoing discussions with other breweries about the technology will add new members to the Ecostripper users club soon! FIGURE 3 What are the performances of the MeuraStream concept compared to the two most commonly used technologies? In the following paragraphs, the MeuraStream is compared with a brewhouse without any energy recovery during wort boiling and with a brewhouse with conventional vapour condensation. Two more orders for the Ecostripper! Meura is proud to announce that it started the year 2011 with two new orders for the Ecostripper technology. Star brewery in Madagascar and ATE brewery from Peru (SABMiller) decided to install a 300 hl/h and 1000 hl/h Ecostripper respectively. Wort boiling represents 20% to 30% of the total amount of thermal energy consumed in a brewery. Today, it is a major concern for each brewer to reduce their energy consumption and CO2 emissions in the brewhouse. The Ecostripper is the most efficient technology on that market and has several industrial references. Conventional wort kettles combine two main operations in one step: AB InBev, Povolzhe Brewery (Russia), 600hl/h Ecostripper. a heat treatment required for sterilization, enzyme deactivation and several chemical processes (hop isomerisation, protein denaturation, …) a n evaporation phase, required to remove unwanted volatiles and, in the case of a lauter tun, to reach the required wort density. The most state-of-the-art conventional wort kettles need at least 4% evaporation to achieve the required heat treatment and volatile removal. Meura’s Ecostripper technology separates the heat treatment from the volatile removal process. The concept consists of 3 separate steps: formation, trub separation and wort stripping. During the formation step (could be adapted from existing wort kettle), wort is kept at 100°C for 30-40 minutes with a minimum evaporation (about 0.75%). This is followed by a trub separation step. This clarification can be performed using a whirlpool or, even better, a Clarisaver. In the last step, the wort loaded with unwanted volatiles passes through the Ecostripper. It is clear that the Ecostripper provides a unique economical and ecological solution to the brewing industry. But there is more! An extended study on an industrial level of the Ecostripper, presented by Mr M EUR A n e ws | 05 SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 Meura : World leader in the malt extract industry All over the world the demand of natural colorant and the general demand of extracts originating from malt, barley, oats, rye and wheat as well as from other cereals, is continuously increasing. These extracts can be liquid (at 80°P) or solid. The malt extract’s applications are numerous in the food & beverage industry. Indeed, the malt extract is more and more often used in candies, bakery products, sauces, brewing industry… It’s also used in the pharmaceutical industry, dairies,… Malt extract coming from high diastatic malt is used as natural source of alpha and beta amylase, betaglucanase, and other enzymes mostly used in the bakery industry. The advantages are multiple for the consumer. The extract and the colorant coming from malt are natural, healthy and are not coming from genetically modifi ed raw materials. The malt extract can be produced from several cereals like oats, rye, barley, wheat, malt or roasted malt or from a cereal mix with rice, sorghum, millets, corn, etc… The malt extract production plant consists of a mash conversion vessel, a Meura 2001 mash filter and a heavy and weak wort vessel. The next step is the concentration stage. It is important to define at the beginning the kind of extract to be produced. Indeed, some modifications in the milling and brewing equipment and changes in the brewing process have to occur depending on the choice and characteristics of the final product. Nevertheless the equipment for the concentration stage can remain the same (evaporator and spray dryer). First step: The milling More than 70 % of the extracts are produced from malt or barley. To guarantee 100% extraction yield (= laboratory yield) as well as to guarantee the clearest possible wort, the malt must be milled very finely. Meura, having always been concerned about providing the best technology to its customers, developed different fine milling systems taking the specification of the different used raw material into account. Classicmill For raw material having a moisture content of 4% and more Meura proposes the Classicmill, which is a ventilated hammermill with horizontal shaft. The Classicmill affords several advantages. First of all, it can fi nely grind malt, barley, sorghum, and some cereals having a moisture content up to 15 %. Then, thanks to the ventilated hammer mill, the risk of having the mill blocked because of the accumulation of gums due to the humidity can be overcome, as well as the risk of burning or explosion. The fi neness of the grist can be regulated by changing the sieves (several sieve meshes are can be regulated by changing the sieves (several sieve meshes are available). Hydromill For the milling of some cereals rich in cellulosic fibres like oat, or for the production of extract from crumbly products as dark malt or roasted barley, or else for the production of enzymatic malt extracts from green malt, Meura proposes the Hydromill. This device has been developed to finely grind cereals under water. It offers a perfectly controlled milling process. A buffer-column is affixed vertically over the Hydromill and makes sure the malt grains and POVOLZHE Brewery Situated in south-western Russia, along the Volga river, Volzhsky is a small city founded in 1951. In 1982, the government decided to install a complete new brewery with equipment from the Czech Republic. The brewery was called the “Povolzhe Brewery”. Today the brewery is owned by Sun Interbrew, a subsidiary of the Inbev group. As is well-known, the Russian market is a fast-growing one. The original brewhouse with an installed yearly capacity of about 750,000 hl became the bottle neck of production five years ago. Povolzhe brewery decided to modernize the brewhouse and put its faith into Meura’s technology. The collaboration between Povolzhe and Meura spread over several years and the modernization occurred in two phases. Phase 1: A complete revamping of the traditional brewhouse In the year 2001 Meura received the first contract to turn the traditional brewhouse into a state-ofthe-art Meura brewhouse. In the milling section, Meura installed a Classicmill and its complement, the Mechamasher, in order to provide a non-oxidized lump-free mash obtained from fine milling. Indeed, this solution is the best one for producing the necessary thick mash (down to 1.8 l of water per kg malt grist) to obtain high gravity wort. In the mashing section, Meura replaced the double jacket system on the existing mash vessels with a direct clean steam injection system, the Aflosjet system. Some of the main reasons why the brewery chose to install this Aflosjet system are the following: Firstly, thanks to this equipment, the existing mashing vessels could remain in use. This operation led to some important cost savings. S econdly, the Aflosjet system has several major advantages compared to the double jacket system. There is no intermediary CIP required during the week. For example, since it avoids the fouling effect on the mash vessels and maintains a perfect heat exchange capacity it increases the productivity of the brewhouse. Further, it also allows very low oxygen pick up and reduces shear forces during the heating, resulting in an improved filterability of the mash. For the mash filtration, Meura supplied a Meura 2001 mash filter equipped for a 12 Ton malt equivalent throw. In its traditional brewhouse, Povolzhe provided mash filtration with lauter tuns. The project was supplied as a turnkey solution and Meura also provided for the complete automation of this brewhouse. the brewing liquor are mixed at the right temperature and in the right proportion. The inside of this equipment involves a stationary disc and a rotating disc equipped with two hammers for malt distribution over the periphery. Thanks to the flexibility of changing the gap between the two discs, adjustment in grinding can be achieved in connection with the used raw material. The Hydromill combines the process of milling and mashing – in at the same time allowing a perfect hydration even at high grist/water ratio. Second step: Brewing Process The Mashing-in During the mashing-in process, a particular attention should be paid to obtaining a wort with the highest possible density after filtration and before evaporation so as to reduce the investment cost of the evaporator as well as the costs of evaporation itself. A thick mash (between 25°P and 30°P) needs to be produced. Weak wort coming from the previous brew can be used for mashing-in and, if required, to achieve densities of about 30°P partly also during the sparging cycle of the mash filter. During the mix of the grist and the brewing liquor some problems of lumps formation can occur. To avoid this, Meura has developed the Mechamasher, an ideal complement to the Carbomill. The Mechamasher produces a lump free mix of up to 30 to 35°P. The Mechamasher achieves a ratio water/malt as low as 1,5 L/Kg. By entering the mashtun from the bottom, Meura takes care to avoid on one hand the oxygen pick up and, on the other hand, shear forces during the brewing process thanks to special agitators. This technique then enhances a better mash filtration due to the NON double its production. Because it was very satisfied with Meura’s technology, Povolzhe decided once again to give Meura the task of upgrading the brewhouse capacity. This second stage began in 2004 in order to ensure full capacity by April 2005. The project consisted of a second new brewing line, equipped with: In the milling section: Due to the fact that the Classicmill and the Mechamasher were able to provide the milling step for both lines, Meura simply connected them to the second line. In the mashing section: To provide the mashing-in, Meura installed two mash tuns and one cereal cooker. These three vessels were equipped with the Aflosjet System. To make an industrial comparison between the Aflosjets and a classic double jacket heating, the two mash tuns were also equipped with double jackets. All results were in favour of the Aflosjets system and today only this system is used. For the mash filtration: Convinced by the state-of-the-art Meura 2001 mash filter, the brewery installed a second filter. The Filtration As the aim in the malt extract production is to obtain the clearest possible wort as well as a wort with the highest density, the filtration should be assured by the Meura 2001 mash filter. The Meura 2001 mash filter is a thin bed membrane-assisted mash filter which represents a lot of advantages for the malt extract production. One of these advantages is that the precompression stage allows the recovery of more than 80% of the total extract before sparging. Related to this fact, the sparging liquor is only 2 litres per kg malt equivalent. Even weak wort can be re-used in the first step of sparging to obtain higher fi nal extract.So, in that case the Meura 2001 mash filter assures a clear and dense wort between 25 and 30°P before evaporation. The Meura 2001 mash filter advantages in the malt extract production: Productivity — Short filtration cycles with the highest efficiency due to the high filtration surface. — Perfect for high gravity brewing with first wort up to 35°Plato (with the use of a weak wort tank). — Flexible load: 80 to 110 % of the nominal capacity. — Fully-automated process. Both old lauter tuns were also turned into a buffer tank. The old whirlpools were taken off line and replaced with two Clarisavers for the separation of hot trub. Together with this second project the boiling process of both brewing lines was extended with one Meura Ecostripper. The Meura Ecostripper is a wort stripping system which provides significant energy savings and is able to control the elimination of unwanted volatiles. It is installed downstream from the two Clarisavers (hot trub elimination) and it allows the reduction of the evaporation rates in the existing wort kettles (principle - see figure 1). The Meura Ecostripper is located in-line just between the Clarisaver (or whirlpool) and the wort cooler. The function of the wort kettle then became: formation of undesirable volatiles compounds, hop isomerization, enzymatic destruction wort stabilization, sterilization and hot trub formation. Proper evaporation is not needed anymore. The second step is the stripping of these unwanted volatiles by clean steam injection crossing the wort flow in counter-current. Thanks to this collaboration with Meura, Povolzhe brewery can be proud to offer the highest quality beer to all its customers. We would like to take advantage of the opportunity to thank our colleagues at the Povolzhe brewery once again for having put their trust in us. Phase 2: A second new brewhouse After the revamping of the brewhouse was finished, the Russian market continued to grow. In order to meet this increasing demand, Povolzhe had to -Formation of large molecules responsible for a high viscosity. Meura has experience with brews up to 35°P. Further Meura has developed the Aflosjet system. The mash is heated up by injection of clean steam directly into the mash, this also avoids the burning of the double jackets and its subsequent fouling. Wort boiling kettle Wort Hot trub settling tank Efficiency — Extract yield equal to the laboratory yield resulting in savings of raw materials. — Very dry spent grains up to 30% of dry material. — Clear worts can be produced regardless of the presence or absence of husk material (from 0 to 100%) in the mash. — Easy filtration with many different kinds of raw materials (malted or not). — Acceptance of a high proportion of adjuncts (up to 100% with the use of exogenous enzymes). — No final rinsing between filtration cycles, which is limiting the amount of wasted water. Quality — Bright wort (Imhoff cone < 2 ml/l) without first wort recirculation. CONCLUSION As you can see, the malt extract, used in a lot of different Food and Beverage sectors, has the advantage of being one of the best natural products. The extract originating from dark malt or roasted barley can be used as a natural product to obtain different types of beer. It can be added in the copper or, when it is specially produced, it can also be added to the final beer. Showing interest in the development of this market, Meura decided to design and manufacture ‘tailor-made’ equipment in order to provide solutions to all the malt extract producers. Meura’s equipment, specially developed for all kind of raw materials, assures our customers of the best malt extract, whatever their requirements. Major advantages of the tandem ClarisaverEcostripper: S ignificant energy savings due to reduced energy consumption (less than 2% evaporation rate) E fficient and flexible elimination of unwanted volatile compounds in the wort (reduction of up to 96% of DMS concentration) L ess final wort coloration (<1°EBC) Fulfils the stricter and stricter environmental constraints regarding: C O 2 emissions (Kyoto Protocol, 1997) E mission of volatile organic compounds, which are considered more and more as a public nuisance. Together the two brewhouses are able to produce at least 24 brews per day with an overall brewhouse yield equal to the laboratory yield and a wort quality in accordance with Inbev’s specifications. wort stripping Wort cooler 06 | M EUR A n e ws SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 Nestlé A Квас (Kvass) concentrate plant Nigeria for Coca-Cola Created in 1866 by Mr Henri Nestlé, today the company is the largest food processing group in the world, employing more than 370,000 people worldwide. In 1988 Nestlé decided to build for the first time a factory capable of producing extract from malted sorghum. It installed this factory on its site in Agbara, Nigeria, the largest grain extract factory in Africa. The grain extract produced on the basis of malted sorghum is used as primary ingredient for the chocolaty drink called Milo that is produced by Nestlé in Africa, Australia, Indonesia and Singapore. Milo is a powder based on chocolate and grain extract which, when mixed with water or milk, yields a drink that is highly valued in many regions of the world. In 2010, in view of the growing demand in Nigeria, Nestlé decided to build a brand-new factory equipped with the best technologies. The previous factory was too small and no longer met the new standards imposed by Nestlé. For this new factory, Nestlé Nigéria PLC turned without hesitation to MEURA, by far market leader in the extraction process for the production of grain extracts. The new factory, also located in Agbara, consists of all the leading-edge technologies of Meura such as for example a Classicmill, a Mechamasher, a cereal cooker with mash cooler, mash tuns and above all a Meura 2001 Hybrid mash filter. The installation and the start-up were a real success, and Nestlé can produce its grain extract from now on with high-technology equipment for optimum quality of the finished product. Thanks to this project and the confidence of the Nestlé company in the reliability and the quality of its equipment, Meura was once again able to demonstrate that, just like its customer, our company has positioned itself as a true world leader, not only in the manufacturing of equipment for the brewing sector, but also for the grain extract industry! Nestlé’s confidence in Meura’s technologies resulted in a new order in July 2012 for 2 mills, a mash tun and a Meura 2001 Hybrid for their factory in Smithtown, Australia. Nestlé Smithtown is the plant where the famous Milo product was originally developped. With this article we are eager to thank the Nestlé group for their perfect cooperation in the success of this project, and for once again having entrusted to us the implementation of their next project in Australia. Meura’s technologies are now present in the Nestlé plants of Agbara, Smithtown and Singapore! If you have travelled to Russia, Belarus, Ukraine or the Baltic states you have certainly discovered a typical local drink called “Kvass”. Kvass is a fermented beverage traditionally made from black rye bread. With an overall alcohol content of 0.05% to 1.0%, it is classified as a non-alcoholic drink by Russian standards. In May 2008, Coca-Cola launched its own brand of kvass in Russia, “Kruzhka i Bochka”, with a unique taste and aroma of crusty rye bread. “Kruzhka i Bochka” combines the traditional taste of kvass with the high quality of the Company’s beverages. Coca-Cola was the first foreign company to make an appreciable entrance into the Russian kvass market! As a consequence of its success in Russia, in February 2009 Coca-Cola bought the famous local Kvass brand “Yarilo” and started its production on its own facility in Zaporizhzya. It was Coca-Cola’s first entrance on the Ukrainian kvass market. Besides the soft-drink “Kvass” itself, the plant at the Zaporizhzhya is making a concentrated wort, the main ingredient for kvass production. In 2006 the R&D team of Coca-Cola contacted Meura Technologies (Meura’s R&D department) to discuss the development of a state-of-the-art “Kvass” extract production line. Both companies partnered in a program of trials at the pilot facility of Meura Technologies. Rye and especially dark malted rye yield a mash with quite poor mash filterability. Starting from mashing-in, special attention has to be paid to the processing conditions in order to avoid negative impacts on the filterability. The Meura2001 Hybrid turned out to be most optimal technology due to its excellent filtration of this specific mash, producing the highest wort density in order to reduce the evaporation costs. Alexander Borisenko (Coca-Cola Technical Director RUB) Victor Behrmann (Coca-Cola Application Center Manager TCC R&D) Why did you choose Meura for the project? Why did you decide to work together with Meura to develop the final product? We knew that the company MEURA is a world leader in the production of malt extracts. Indeed, we consider MEURA on the highest level of expertise in this area. How was the collaboration with Meura during the project execution? It was, indeed, a beautiful relationship. I am satisfied and have the highest respect for the Meura company. Thanks to Meura and we wish the team all the best. It was known that MEURA2001 would give us the main target – a maximum density of a wort.. The combination of Meura’s brewhouse technology together with the expertise of the Coca-Cola R&D team in the selection of raw materials and process parameters to achieve the desired flavour, could only lead to success. Indeed, after about four years of collaboration an optimal process was developed. In 2010, Coca-Cola placed with Meura an order for an industrial plant in Zaporizhzhya (Ukraine). Meura was responsible for the entire processing line from the intake of the delivered raw materials (barley malt, rye malt, rye and barley) to the production of the concentrated Kvass wort, including the evaporation plant unit. Certain process vessels were produced locally based on Meura drawings. In addition the electrical cabinets and automation were part of Meura’s scope. The project installation of the equipment started after the winter of 2011. The first brew was made on 08/10/2012 as planned and the acceptance was already obtained by the end of November. In less than two months Coca-Cola fully accepted Meura’s installation – for a turnkey production unit which is considered an industrial prototype. Meura would like to thank the entire Coca-Cola team involved in this project for its confidence, professionalism and the fruitful collaboration. Other comments? The project was complex and unusual. As a turn key supplier, the Meura company showed their professionalism. How was the collaboration with Meura Technologies? The collaboration went very well. Most importantly, even during the tests, we became friends. Special thanks to the efforts of Laurent Marlé and Didier Hooreweghe, who were doing their utmost during start-up to achieve the desired results. Full Sail Brewing co. Full Sail Brewing Company is a craft brewery located in the Columbia River Gorge in the city of Hood River, Oregon, USA, currently recognized as the world capital for wind and kite surfing. Conclusion The brewery was launched in 1987 by Irene Firmat and James Emmerson, who immediately took the option to invest in professional equipment in order to produce top quality beers. The mash filter’s well-known abilities to produce a very bright wort with laboratory yield, using less water and with a dryer spent grain, combined with increased flexibility and productivity, all prove this to be a master choice for the future of the Full Sail Brewing Company, thereby confirming that a constant search for the best equipment is rewarded in the end result. Full Sail produces an impressive range of different brands, using a diversity of raw materials and methods. And Full Sail’s Session was named best lager at the 2010 World Beer Awards! At the beginning of 2010, in order to increase their extract yield as well as their production capacity, Full Sail Brewing Company decided to retire its old lauter tun and placed an order with Meura for a 2001 Carbo+ mash filter equipped with 29 chambers and a Classicmill CLM1 hammer mill. This technological choice required some major modifications to the brewhouse layout, a challenge that was met without problems thanks to excellent coordination from both sides. The equipment was installed in October and commissioned in November 2010 with the help of a local automation company, following Meura’s functional description and assistance. Even though the tremendous rapidity of filtration achieved for most recipes offers new prospects for capacity expansion, the main reason for implementing the mash filter technology is rather in the commitment to a sustainable and more environmentally friendly way of producing beer. As an example, “By current estimate, we’ll save nearly 1,000,000 gallons (about 40,000 hl) of water this year,” declared James Emmerson. The commissioning offered the opportunity to test the mash filter’s performance on a variety of brands, including Indian Pale Ale, Amber, Session Lager, Session Black, LTD#4, Henry’s Blonde and Hefeweize. “The mash filter yields have consistently exceeded 98% (OBY values) of fine grind as-is extract, with some brews coming in above 100%,” James Emmerson explained. “The wort quality from the mash filter is excellent, very clear and within brewery specifications.” The brewery is currently seeing an increase in brewhouse efficiency across all brands. Brand cycle time Mash pump filling speed first run gravity last run gravity OBY (%) Amber 117 min 550 rpm 21.9 °P 1.1 °P 98 Ipa 100 min 600 rpm 21.8 °P 1.5°P 98 Session 92 min 600 rpm 22.0 °P 0.5 °P 100 Ltd#4 88 min 600 rpm 21.8 °P 1.0 °P 98 Henry’s blonde 86 min 600 rpm 21.7 °P 0.5 °P 102 Hefeweize 98 min 600 rpm 22.6 °P 1.3 °P 98 “D ealing with Meura was a pleasure, and their Mash Filter is an excellent addition to our brewhouse!” James Emmerson, Full Sail’s Executive Brewmaster M EUR A n e ws | 07 SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 CIP Hot water Thanks to the recovery of a non-oxidised trub, Meura’s CLARIsaVer, a wort settling tank, is the only trub separation technology advisable for trub recycling. The trub from a wort settling tank is oxygen free during the wort cooling sequence and thus not oxidised. This is an important qualitative advantage in relation to trub recycling and compared with the trub from the whirlpool. For quality reasons (trub oxidation) having the trub recycled from a whirlpool should therefore be avoided. Moreover, while the loss of yield with a good whirlpool represents an average of 1 to 1.5%, the loss of extract with a wort settling tank when recycling the trub is almost zero. In addition, an average of about 10% of alpha acids from the hops can be recovered from the trub recycling. The water consumption of the wort settling tank is much lower compared with a whirlpool, where water is used to drain the trub cone out of the vessel. So both qualitative and quantitative advantages can be gained with this modern equipment. Thanks to the Meura 2001 mash filter working with a fine grist and the CLARIsaVer making it possible to recycle the recovered trub, the brewhouse has an outstanding extract yield. LT LE Clarisaver LE CIP LE CO2 TRUB TANK LE Turbidity Wort Wort CIP Trub CIP Possibility therefore of recycling this non-oxidised hot trub (not recommended with a whirlpool where the trub cone is intensely oxidised). This will increase the OBY (Overall Brewhouse Yield) with at least 1% compared with a whirlpool system. Limited Shear Forces due to gentle filling. Allows the control of the fatty acids content of the clarified wort. Main assets xygen free recovery of hot trub during the wort cooling sequence O and not afterwards. Low water consumption (compared with a whirlpool where water is used to drain the trub cone out of the vessel). Irish distillers Pernod-Ricard Midleton Distillery, Ireland Irish Distillers makes its new brewhouse with Meura! IDL’s core product is the famous Jameson Irish Whiskey. Indeed Jameson is the No. 1 selling Irish whiskey in the world, a consistent award winner and a truly global whiskey brand. Loved for its great smooth taste and style, Jameson is sold in over 120 countries worldwide. Irish Distillers is a subsidiary of the world’s co-leading wines and spirits company Pernod-Ricard S.A. In 2008 the distillery contacted Meura to perform some trials with raw materials. Meura, supported by its R&D Center Meura technologies, carried out a three-day trial and analysis that yielded very good results. After these tests, convinced by the Meura 2001 technology, IDL asked for a quotation for a brewhouse however the project was put on hold due to other priorities. Three years later, IDL contacted Meura for some new trials in its R&D Center Meura Technologies. The results were again excellent and IDL decided in favour of a complete Meura brewhouse as part of its €100 million expansion at Midleton. Really enthusiastic about the IDL project, Meura, thanks to its state-of-the-art technology, proposed IDL a Meurabrew concept (Meura’s continuous brewhouse), with a five-phase expansion programme. The Belgian brewing industry is known worldwide for its unique variety of beer types, and also for its important suppliers to that industry. For many years two major equipment manufacturers, the companies “Meura” and “Les Ateliers de Monsville”, have been supplying to breweries worldwide. Both companies were created during the ninetieth century; Meura in 1845 with a focus on large scale breweries and Les Ateliers de Monsville in 1888, concentrating on medium-sized and small breweries. In the 1990’s Meura and Les Ateliers de Monsville joined forces and are today working under the Meura name. Over recent years Meura has been frequently contacted by Craft brewers asking for Meura’s technologies, Very interested by this proposal, the IDL team visited Martens Brewery in Belgium, already equipped with a Meurabrew, and Heineken Den Bosch in The Netherlands, equipped with a double Meura 2001 mash filters operating 14 brews a day. During those visits, they were able to speak freely with the owners and operators about the equipment performance. And in August 2011 the order for a Meurabrew was placed. The supplied brewhouse is a unique concept ellowing to upgrade in the future with almost double of the initial installed capacity. In a first phase, two small batch brewhouses are foreseen, which will be upgraded in the final phase to a continuous brewhouse with a flow of 450hl/h. The plant (for phase 1 & 2) comprises: odifications to existing dry good screening and M transfer equipment. 2x Meura hammer mills, CLM1 & CLM4 1x Mashing in tank of 25t/h 1x Mash Preparation Vessel with AFLOSJet 2x Mash Conversion vessels with AFLOSJet 2x Meura 2001 Hybrid mash filters with Meuraclean units 2x Spent grains hoppers and expellers but adapted to their needs. This evolution led Meura to rethink their successful large scale brewhouse concept for the Craft brewing industry. This brewhouse concept has been named the “Monsville” brewhouse, referring to the long experience of Les Ateliers de Monsville in small and medium-sized brewhouses. Two types of Monsville brewhouses have been developed: the Monsville 50 and the Monsville 100, being able to produce respectively 50 and 100 hl of wort per brew. Each brewhouse can make up to 4 to 5 brews a day. Central to the Monsville brewhouse is the Meura 2001 mash filtration technology. A mash filter with reduced dimensions, the Meura 2001 Junior, has been developed, keeping all the advantages of the internationally renowned Meura 2001 filtration technology. The installation is skid mounted and pre-tested according to a “plug-and-play” concept which In 1901, Mr. Philippe Meura from Tournai, Belgium developed the first mash filter application for the brewing industry. More than 1,000 Meura filters have been installed worldwide since that date. In 1989 the Meura 2001 filter, a thin bed filter equipped with membranes, was developed. Today about 25% of the world’s beer volume is produced with a Meura 2001 filter! More than 20 years ago when the industrial introduction of the Meura 2001 filter took place, only one filter size, called the Meura 2001 Senior (from 4 to 30 metric T throw), was available, mainly sized for large lager brewers. The end of the 1990s, as a consequence of an increasing demand by medium-sized breweries, Meura introduced the Meura 2001 Junior filter (from 0.5 to 4 metric T throw). In 2012 at the Craft Brewing Convention in San Diego, supported by an increasing demand from the U.S. Craft Brewing market, Meura decided to introduce the Meura 2001 Micro. Design The Meura 2001 Micro can take a throw of up to 1000 lbs. (500 kg) of malt. Meura has sized its mash filters to fit the needs of the typical brewhouse sizes in existence. µ10 µ15 µ20 Brewsize at 12°P 10 bbl (12 hl) 15 bbl (17.5 hl) 20 bbl (23.5 hl) 1 x Spent Grains discharger unit (for existing spent grains silo) Throw in pounds of malt 450 650 1000 P rocess and service pipework, valves, pumps and instrumentation Throw in kg of malt 200 300 400 Number of chambers 18 26 36 1x Strong wort tank 1x Weak wort tank Control Software Project planning, installation supervision and commissioning. The brewhouse was installed in a new purpose-built building alongside the existing brewhouse and milling area. The building works started in October 2011, with the first Meura equipment delivered in January 2012. The commissioning started in August 2012 and full production was achieved by the beginning of September. Thanks to Meura’s innovative equipment and thinking, we were able to offer a superior technological solution to IDL that will meet their demands for increases in production well into the future. allows the project to reduce the time of on-site erection and start-up. The Monsville brewhouse is a state-of-the-art brewhouse especially developed for the Craft brewing industry and having the following unique advantages: The Meura 2001 technology enables working with all kinds of adjuncts and at high proportions, which gives craft brewers the possibility to make the recipe of their choice. Possibility to work at high densities, advantageous for high fermentation beers Exceptional yields (at least 2 to 3% above those obtained with lauter tuns) Very dry spent grains up to 30% dry material Clear worts can be produced regardless of the presence or absence of husk material. Like the other mash filters in the Meura 2001 family, the MircoMeura 2001 achieves the same unique process performances. Performances The Meura 2001 Micro offers numerous advantages, which can be summarized as follows: 01)The Meura 2001 Micro saves raw materials. The extract yield is at least equal to the E.B.C. laboratory yield (fine grist). It is common for extract losses of Craft brewhouses to be between 5 and 10%. 02)It opens up the possibility of brewing with a wide variety of raw materials in any amount. It is Belgian technology especially designed for Belgian beer styles! As a matter of interest, nearly 90% of the beer volume produced in Belgium is produced with the Meura 2001 technology. 03)It provides increased productivity thanks to a total cycle time of < 100 minutes. As a consequence, a brewhouse with a mash tun, a Meura 2001 mash filter and wort kettle can produce three brews in a 10-12 hour time period. This represents significant savings in manpower compared to lauter tun brewhouses. 04)It yields dry spent grains of 26-30% dry matter (lauter tun at 20% D.M.). This means cleaner operation with essentially dry matter handling versus liquid/matter removal of spent grains. 05)It leads to water savings. The recovery of more wort and no false bottom rinsing represents a general savings of between 0.25 and 0.50 gal/gal (l/l). 06)It enables High Gravity brewing. Thanks to a thick mash at mashing in and reduced sparging (<2,3 l/kg or 0,28 gal/lbs) of the wort before boiling and without adding sugar it will be > 16°P without extract losses. This represents a saving in energy and space and makes an ideal set-up for brewing speciality beers. 07)It creates a very high quality wort, thanks to a brighter wort (<5ml/l Imhoff solids) than with a lauter tun. A reduced sparging water ratio with less leaching out of unwanted components is also achieved with the Meura 2001 Micro mash filter. 08)A hot trub volume that is approximately 30-50% lower is achieved because of the bright wort. 09)There is lower hop consumption (ca. 5-15%) with a better yield due to the lower hot trub content. 10)The modular system allows an expansion of the system for additional capacity in the future. Intermediate plates allow almost any size brew to be produced, whether for production or low volume trials. Case example The high productivity of the Meura 2001 Micro ensures a high yearly throughput of the brewhouse compared with lauter tun brewhouses of the same size. Let us consider the following factors. The brewmaster produces wort during four days a week. He/she can use the fifth working day to contact suppliers, check fermentation etc. During a working day three brews are produced. With a brewhouse where the milling can start automatically this is not a problem. µ10 µ15 µ20 Brewsize at 12°P (no sugar) 10 bbl (12 hl) 15 bbl (17,5 hl) 20 bbl (23.5 hl) Daily production 3 brews/day 30 bbl (35 hl) 45 bbl (52,5 hl) 60 bbl (70 hl) Weekly production 4 days/week 120 bbl (140 hl) 180 bbl (210 hl) 240 bbl (280 hl) Yearly production 50 weeks/year 6,000 bbl (7,000 hl) 9,000 bbl 12,000 bbl (10,500 hl) (14,000 hl) The Meura 2001 Micro makes it possible to produce 12,000 bbl (14,000 hl) or more of beer per year. Conclusion As the result of a strong demand from the market, the Meura 2001 technology is available for Craft breweries of all sizes. Meura’s long and extensive experience since 1845 together with its Belgian brewing roots provide Craft brewers with the best technological and technical support in the development of their business. 08 | M EUR A n e ws SPecial issue — DRINK TEC 2013 Meura Technologies : More than 15 years of research Besides the development of technological innovation, the mission of Meura Technologies is also to partner with brewers that intend to make important process changes (brew diagram, changing raw materials, etc.) on their Meura industrial equipment and would first like to perform small scale trials. From the very first day, Meura Technologies has made several innovations, some of which can be considered revolutionary for the brewing industry. The recent major innovation is certainly the Meurabrew, a continuous brewhouse. In its early beginnings Meura Technologies started this development with the installation of a 4 hl/h capacity continuous brewhouse prototype. After four years of validation trials the first positive results were published at the EBC Conventions in 2001 and 2003. The process was fully approved in the year 2005 (seven years after the project started) and the first industrial Meurabrew of 200 hl/h at 20°P cold wort was ordered in 2006 by the Martens brewery (Belgium). In the meantime three Meurabrews have been ordered, and Meura Technologies regularly carries out campaigns with potential customers to demonstrate the advantages of the technology for their products. As usual in the brewing industry, it takes time before major technological changes are accepted, but Meura is confident that the Meurabrew will achieve its position in the industry. Other technologies developed and patented thanks to the R&D pilot plant are for example the Hydromill and the Aflosjet technologies. The Hydromill features a fine milling technology under water for special applications such as the milling of green malt or of roasted barley/malt. The Aflosjet is a direct steam diffusion technology for mash heating. It replaces the traditional double jacket heating. The major focus the last three to five years has been on the further improvement of the Meura 2001 technology, with as a final result the industrial introduction of the Meura 2001 Hybrid, an important modification leading to a reduced sparging water to grist ratio and thus producing a higher gravity wort, shorter cycle times and an improved wort quality. The pilot plant can also make batch brews of up to 20 hl/brew through to the final beer. Meura Technologies thus has a complete brewery except for bottling facilities. The brewhouse is equipped with a double Meura 2001 mash filter, allowing high flexibility for representative tests, up to 175 kg for batch capacity and 87 kg for filtrations in parallel in the continuous brewing process. Hot wort treatment can be performed traditionally with an internal boiler or with the three-stage concept of boiling: “Formation – clarification – stripping”. The pilot Ecostripper is often used to validate the impact of Meura’s de-intensified boiling concept on the organoleptic quality of the wort. A falling film evaporator is also part of the pilot brewhouse equipment for extract production (up to 65-70 brix) as Meura’s customers also include malt extract companies. Meura 2001 Sieve 1: > 1250 μ 20 % < 1 % Sieve 2+3: between 1250-500 μ 50 % < 9 % Sieve 4+5: between 500-125 μ 20 % > 55 % Bottom: < 125 μ 10 % < 35 % Technical feasibility trials for new recipes, products, projects. Performance improvement. Technological support to our customers. Training for customers, brewing schools. In addition to its own R&D activities, Meura Technologies offers its customers valuable tech- Top advantages of the Classicmill: The Classicmill is an air ventilated hammermill with a horizontal shaft. The Classicmill description: The classicmill consists of a hammermill equipped with hardened steel hammers fixed on a rotor, projecting the dropping malt against the breaking plates at high velocity (100m/s). As a result, malt grains are broken down into very fine particles. A feeding rotary lock equipped with steel blades and driven by a frequency converter & Since the development of the Meura 2001 mash filter, fine grist is on an industrial scale obtained mainly by the means of a Classicmill, a ventilated hammer mill with horizontal shaft. Traditionnaly, after milling the malt grist is falling by a top entry into the mash conversion vessel with the oxidation of the mash as a result. Several research (see further) indicates that mash oxidation decreases the flavour stability of the final beer. To prevent these problems, Meura developed a mechanical pre-masher, the Mechamasher, allowing a bottom entry to the conversion vessel(s). In combination with a hammer milling technology under CO2 atmosphere, the Carbomill, an oxidation free mashing-in is guaranteed. The figure shows the layout of a milling plant with the Carbomill and the Mechamasher. The Carbomill consists of a rotor made of plates with pins to carry the hammers. Grinding is During milling there is forced ventilation inside the milling chamber, which limits the temperature increase observed with other hammermills (vertical shaft type). T hanks to this ventilation, the classicmill is the ideal equipment for milling adjuncts with a moisture content up to 15% (for example barley). Thanks to its expertise and experience in brewing technologies, the R&D team is able to create solutions that keep Meura’s customers ahead of the competition. More than just an equipment supplier, Meura is a leading technical and technological partner. T he hammers and sieves are easy to replace. Symmetrical construction allows the mill to run clockwise or counter-clock wise, which increases the service life of the hammers. Low initial cost and very low maintenance costs. C an be integrated easily into an existing dry goods line. B ecause the milling chamber is ventilated, there is no explosion risk in the event of a spark produced by the shock of a small stone on the hammer. Consequently a destoner is not mandatory; a simple malt siever is sufficient. Meura currently manufactures six types of classicmill, ranging from the CLM 1 to the CLM 6. Types Motor power (kW) Rpm Capacity (tons malt/ hour) CLM 1 37 3000 4 B reaking plates in the upper part of the mill protect the sieves against early wearing, reducing maintenance costs. CLM 2 55 3000 7 CLM 3 75 3000 10 CLM 4 110 1500 14 A wide range of sieve mesh from 1.8 to 4 mm, suitable for malt and adjuncts. CLM 5 160 1500 20 CLM 6 250 1500 30 a result of impact between the hammers and the particles that are propelled on the breaking-plates. Prior to start up, CO2 (or N2) is injected into the grist bin to provide a gas blanket. During the milling, the malt grist is falling into the grist bin and pushes the CO2 back through the hammer mill and the malt feeding system. By this way, the air surrounding the malt grains is replaced by the gas protecting the malt grains from oxidation before entering the mill. The milling itself occurs also under CO2 atmosphere. The malt grist is then falling directly into the grist bin where it can be stored under CO2 between brews. During the emptying of the grist bin CO2 is injected into the bin to replace the grist. Mashing-in consists of an extremely thorough mixing of the malt grist with water at a prespecified mashing-in temperature and water to grist ratio, in order to hydrate the starch of the malt. Traditionally a hydrator, directly connected to the top of the mash conversion vessel is used for this process. This method has however two main disadvantages; a high oxidation of the mash occurs when the grist falls in the conversion vessel and lump formation is almost unavoidable especially when thick mashes (less than 2,5l water per kg malt grist) are made. O2 tC Lauter tun For the classicMill and the CarboMill, Meura uses the same grinding principle: a hammermill with horizontal shaft where the first impact of the grains is on the hammers and the second impact is on the breaking plates. The sieves are therefore protected against early wearing or early damage by the possible presence of stones. These are crushed before they can reach the sieves. This principle allows therefore economical savings. Indeed, with a CLM 3, the replacement of all wearing pieces – namely the hammers, the sieves and the breaking plate – costs less than 1,500 € for 25,000 tons, which is equivalent to a 1 year malt consumption in a 1.5 Mio hl brewery. nological assistance in total confidentiality. Prior to supplying equipment, Meura Technologies acts as a partner that helps and advises the customer: t le Grist specifications (Pfungstadt-Mebak) Although Meura has always installed and commissioned the classicMill, the manufacturing of this equipment was originally subcontracted. Since 2006, Meura has been designing and manufacturing its own hammermills so that its customers benefit from all the improvements resulting from its more than 20 years of experience in using hammermils to grind malt. From left to right: Laurent Marlé, Ariane Dewulf and David Chauvier, R&D Engineers and Frédérique Harmegnies, R&D Mana ger Ou The success was immediate and Meura started to sell its filters all over the world. But the competitors reacted with the criticism that our filter produced a wort that was too cloudy. Meura, joined by the defenders of the mash filter technology (like the Piedboeuf Brewery in Belgium), then had to deal with this weakness. Consequently research projects were launched to produce a very bright wort while guaranteeing the best extract yield as well as the highest mash filter productivity. By using an even finer grist and a thinner bed (4cm), the result was not only an excellent high filtration rate but also a very bright wort. Nevertheless, with such a thin filtration cake, it was of prime importance to avoid channelling that could reduce the sparging efficiency. Quite quickly, the inflatable membrane solution for homogenizing the cake porosity became essential. The results were very exciting: 100% of extract recovery (compared to the laboratory yield) while using less water (< 2.5 l H2O/kg grist), a high production rate (14 brews/day) This table above shows that the Meura 2001 mash filter works with fine milling. In order to obtain this kind of milling, the traditional roll mills were not suitable. Meura turned then to hammermills, which already existed in the breweries for the milling of adjuncts. Meura was the first company in the world to use the hammermill industrially in order to mill barley malt. Two types of hammermill existed, one with a vertical shaft and one with a horizontal shaft. Thanks to its experience, Meura was able to select the most efficient technology, which was the hammermill with a horizontal shaft. Today, Meura offers two dry milling technologies: the classicMill and the CarboMill. Meura Technologies is not only a R&D centre for Meura’s developments but also a real partner for the players of the Food and Beverage Industry. automatically controls the feeding of the hammermill, according to the nominal power of the motor. The mill has a symmetrically constructed milling chamber. During milling air is blown through the milling chamber in order to avoid heating of the malt grist and dust explosions. Underneath this milling chamber, a bin equipped with an automatic filter and a suction ventilator separates the air from the grist. … A Fine Milling History and a bright wort (< 5 ml/l Imhoff). In 1987, this new technology was presented for the very first time at the European Brewery Convention in Zurich and in 1989, the first Meura 2001 mash filter was installed in the Piedboeuf Brewery in Jupille (Belgium). It was the very beginning of the Meura 2001 mash filter’s adventure. Today, more than 220 Meura 2001 mash filters equipped with an ever improved technology have been sold all over the world. Meura Technologies also owns pilot equipment dedicated to trials on site in breweries. A pilot mash filter with a capacity varying between 8 kg and 80 kg malt equivalent can be rented for campaigns of tests on site with the assistance of one of the R&D engineers for the start-up. A yeast pre-oxygenation unit can also be placed in breweries for trials enabling an immediate evaluation of performances on the industrial product. Besides innovation for the brewing industry, new process or process fine tuning for the grain extract industry, distilling industry, kvas production (Russian rye-based soft drink), etc. have also been developed in the R&D centre and have led to Meura obtaining major orders for industrial applications. Rental of pilot equipment. The Meura laboratory is equipped for grist size distribution analysis (Pfungstad), lab brews (EBC or industrial recipe), and a mash filtration unit (“Bomb” filter). The “Bomb” filter is developed in-house and enables the determination of mash filterability with the industrial brewing recipe as well as extraction yield and malt The Meura Dry Milling Technologies In 1901, Philippe Meura, looking for a technology able to work with a finer grist and to guarantee a better extract yield than was possible with a lauter tun, developed the first mash filter for the brewing industry. The yield was indeed much higher and the filter technology using a thinner bed under pressure allowed an increased rate of 8 to 10 brews a day compared to the 4 to 6 brews a day produced by the competitors. It was a revolution for the brewing world. equivalent evaluation of raw materials. This equipment is very useful for testing the feasibility of new projects using unknown raw materials or for trouble shooting. For more analytical analyses samples can be taken and sent to external brewing labs of Universities in Belgium. Inlet Malt A pioneer by tradition, Meura has always promoted innovation. Fifteen years ago, in 1997, in order to offer its customers the best technological solutions, Meura decided to create Meura Technologies, its R&D division, in the heart of the university city of Louvain-La-Neuve and near its famous brewing school. Inlet CO2 Malt Grist Bin To Mash Tun