Chapter 05 MONEY AND CREDIT The role of the financial system is to intermediate between lenders and borrowers, providing a menu of saving vehicles with differing risk and return characteristics. Financial intermediaries help the investors find the financing they need, taking into account the returns and risks on the project they wish to undertake. In carrying out their functions, financial intermediaries reduce transaction costs for savers and investors and help reduce problems of asymmetric information that are inherent in the relationships between investors and entrepreneurs. For a given level of saving, more efficient intermediation increases the productivity of investment. It seems obvious that the more efficient the financial system is, the stronger would be the economic growth. The global economy for some time has enjoyed good economic growth and increasing depth in financial markets, accompanied by the significant financial innovation. This growth co-existed with a combination of favorable economic indicators, with relatively benign inflation levels, low risk premia, and an easy access to finance even in the midst of continuing global imbalances. Until recently, the risk associated with such development seemed to be contained; however gains from the benign macroeconomic environment of the last few years have been dealt with a severe blow in the form of liquidity crunch triggered by the US subprime mortgage crisis. These events have brought to the forefront some global economic and financial vulnerabilities whose prolonged impact could pose certain risks given that the world is more integrated today than ever before. Pakistan has made a significant progress in improving the health and soundness of the banking and financial sector over the last two decades. During this period of transformation, the financial sector of Pakistan has evolved into a more progressive and dynamic module of the economy, both in response to the financial sector reforms and to the growing financing needs of an expanding economy. In response to the growing demands of financial globalization, Pakistan’s financial system is starting to integrate with international financial markets. Financial integration was particularly expedited in FY07 in which record high foreign portfolio investment was received in stock market as well as through the issuance of GDRs. Additionally, with the rising strength of the corporate sector and vigorous expansion plans, the central bank is in the process of initiating External Commercial Borrowing (ECB), which at the moment is approved on a transactional basis. This liberalization measure will provide an opportunity to the corporate sector to raise external loans for project finance, bond floatation, structured finance and Islamic products. In Pakistan, the composition of financial sector gives credence that the overall dependence on the banking sector has increased in the last few years. Given the scope and requirements of the private sector, growth in the banking sector is essential. Encouragingly, the outreach of the banking sector continues to improve, with diversified pattern in ownership, both foreign and local, and with the expanding network of commercial banks, microfinance institutions and Islamic banks in all parts of the country. Alongside these developments, ongoing financial sector reforms are paving the way for a more diversified financial sector, equipped to facilitate the economic growth process. Financial sector assets have recorded a remarkable growth in recent years. Strong growth of mutual fund---being managed by professional and reputable asset management firms—is largely attributed to the improved performance of the domestic financial markets, and points to the gradual but steadfast process of diversification of 81 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 the financial sector. These developments augur well for financial stability as well as meeting the goal of enhancing financial services penetration. Monetary Policy Stance The process of tightening of monetary policy began in FY05 from a broadly accommodative one to more aggressive. The moderate interest rates, together with broad-based private sector credit demand helped in raising industrial production. This has resulted in acceleration in monetary expansion. Therefore, heightened activity also fed a gradual rise in core inflation. The government’s mid December 2004 decision to lift the freeze on domestic POL prices raised inflationary expectations, forcing a more aggressive tightening of monetary policy. It was in April 2005 that the SBP raised its discount rate by 150 basis points (bps) to 9 percent, and further to 9.5 percent in July’06 with the same objective of controlling inflation. Demand pressures were still high, as reflected by high growth in credit to private sector, rising imports resulting in the widening of the current account deficit and an expansionary fiscal policy envisaged in the Federal Budget 2006-07.In FY07, inflation target of 6.5 percent was surpassed by 1.3 percentage points, primarily because of demand pressures as reflected by widening fiscal and current account deficits and double-digit food inflation. During FY08, the SBP continued with tight monetary policy stance, thrice raising the discount rate and increased the Cash Reserve Requirement (CRR) and Statutory Liquidity Requirement (SLR). During H1-FY08, the SBP raised the policy rate by 50bps to 10 percent effective from August 1st, 2007. Furthermore, the SBP zero rated the CRR for all deposits of one year and above maturity to encourage greater resource mobilization of longer tenor and 7 percent CRR for other demand and time liabilities. In H2FY08 the SBP further tightened Monetary Policy by raising discount rate by 50bps to 10.5 percent. Furthermore, the CRR was raised for deposits upto one year maturity by 100bps to 8 percent while leaving term deposits of over a year zero rated. The objective was to give incentives to commercial banks to mobilize long term deposits. In the light of continued inflationary buildup and increasing pressures in the foreign exchange market, the SBP announced a package of monetary measures on 82 May 21, 2008 that includes;(i) an increase of 150 bps in discount rate to 12 percent; (ii) an increase of 100 bps in CRR and SLR to 9 percent and 19 percent, respectively for banking institutions (iii) introduction of a margin requirement for the opening of letter of credit for imports (excluding food and oil) of 35 percent, and (iv) establishment of a floor of 5 percent on the rate of return on profit and loss sharing and saving accounts. Monetary and Credit Development In order to improve the effectiveness of monetary policy and avoid ambiguities in sending out policy signals, the SBP has abolished the Annual Credit Plan (ACP). This was a long awaited measure, following the removal of credit ceilings which made the Credit Plan redundant. Since broad money (M2) was the only intermediate target in the monetary policy framework, SBP continued to prescribe targets of NFA, NDA, government borrowings and private sector credit .It is expected that the abolishment of ACP will help remove the uncertainties emanating from multiple targets of monetary aggregates. A sharp jump in monetary aggregates during the last month of FY07 pushed the aggregate M2 growth for the year to 19.3 percent. This strikingly higher growth in M2 was caused entirely by a phenomenal rise in NFA in FY07.For 2007-08,the SBP had assumed that with real GDP growth target of 7.2 percent and inflation target of 6.5 percent, broad money(M2) supply growth should grow by 13.7 percent. The money supply growth during July- May1 of the current fiscal year slowed to 9 percent compared to 14 percent during the corresponding period of FY07 (Table-5.1). The FY 08 growth in M2 is entirely attributable to a rise in net domestic assets (NDA) of the banking system due to high government borrowings for budgetary support, as the NFA registered a contraction during the period, mainly reflecting the weaknesses in country’s external balance of payment. The monetary tightening has been successful in moderating the exceptional rise in private sector credit growth seen in recent years to levels consistent with its long term trends. However, the impact of this desirable moderation in private 1 Pertains to 10 May for FY08 and 12 May for FY07 Money and Credit sector growth on M2 was more than offset by continued strong budgetary borrowings of the government from the banking system. The NDA of the banking system registered an expansion of Rs.656 billion during Jul-May FY08 compared with an expansion of Rs.395 billion during the corresponding period of last year. (Rs. billion) Jul-May* 2007-08 423.02 362.06 60.86 0.09 414.39 369.85 44.33 -0.03 0.24 -180.69 656.72 21.32% -289.84 366.89 9.03% Source:SBP Table-5.1 Profile of Monetary Indicators Jul-May* 2006-07 185.84 212.36 -26.42 -0.09 273.98 263.43 10.40 -0.23 0.38 -64.29 395.54 14.67% 84.59 480.12 14.09% 1.Net government sector Borrowing(a+b+c) a .Borrowing for budgetary support b.Commodity operations c.Others 2.Credit to Non-government Sector (d+e+f+g) d.Credit to Private Sector e.Credit to Public Sector Enterprises (PSEs) f. PSEs Special Account-Debt repayment with SBP g.Other Financial Institutions(SBP credit to NBFIs) 3.Other Items(net) 4.Net Domestic assets (NDA) Growth 5.Net Foreign Assets (NFA) 6.Monetary Assets(M2) Growth *pertains to 10th May for F08 and 12th May for FY07 Analysis of Monetary Indicators Bank Credit to Government The net bank credit to the government for financing commodity operations and budgetary support amounted to Rs. 423 billion during JulyMay FY08 against Rs.185 billion during the same period last year. Credit to government for commodity operations expanded by Rs. 60 billion during July-May FY08 as compared to contraction of Rs.26 billion during the same period last year, while credit to government for budgetary support increased to Rs. 362 billion. Table-5.2 Monetary Indicators(Growth Rates) Indicators Net Bank Credit to Government Sector Bank Credit to Private Sector Net Domestic Assets(NDA) Net Foreign Assets (NFA) Money Supply(M2) *pertains to 10th May for F08 and 12th May for FY07 FY 05 FY 06 FY 07 13.9 34.36 22.15 9.22 19.12 11.63 23.47 16.05 11.52 15.07 11.14 17.3 14.23 38.65 19.32 In the current fiscal year, domestic and external shocks of extra-ordinary proportions caused large slippages on the fiscal side. The financing plan of the fiscal deficit also affected by these shocks. The overall fiscal deficit of Rs.398 billion was to be financed by external sources(Rs.193 billion), and domestic sources (Rs 131 billion).The remaining Rs. 75 billion was to come from privatization proceeds. Within domestic sources, Rs 81 billion financing was to come from banking sources while Jul-May* 2006-07 22.29 12.23 14.67 11.9 14.09 (Percent) Jul-May* 2007-08 45.66 14.91 21.32 -29.43 9.03 Source: SBP the remaining Rs 50 billion was to come from nonbanking sources. The domestic and external shocks not only increased the size of the fiscal deficit but they also changed the composition of financing. The borrowing requirements increased from Rs. 324 billion (the net of privatization proceeds) to Rs. 683.4 billion (with no privatization proceeds)an increase of 111 percent. External resource inflows were adversely affected by these shocks and against the budgeted level of Rs.193 billion, 83 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 during the current fiscal year, which has almost doubled the stock of MRTBs with SBP to Rs.945.9 billion. To put this in perspective, the July-May FY08 borrowings are twice the net borrowings seen during the preceding three years (Fig 5.1). The reliance on central bank borrowing is partly an outcome of scheduled banks’ reduced interest in government papers .It may be pointed out that the government had borrowed substantially from the scheduled banks during Q1-FY08. This trend however changed completely in subsequent quarters when scheduled banks showed little interest in the T-bill auctions. This probably reflects strong seasonal demand for private sector credit as well as attractive returns on such loans and tight liquidity conditions in the inter-bank market. In addition, the expectations regarding changes in discount rate in the monetary policy statement for H2-FY08 also limited the scheduled banks’ participation in the auctions of the government securities. (Fig 5.2) only Rs.119.4 billion is likely to materialize. Pakistan could not complete the transaction of GDRs of the National bank of Pakistan and could not launch sovereign and exchangeable bonds. Furthermore; some of the lending from the multilateral banks could not be materialized. These developments had adversely impacted the external resource inflows which remained below the budgeted level. Thus, the brunt of adjustments on the financing side fell on domestic sources. Against the budgeted financing of Rs 131 billion from domestic sources, it increased to Rs 564 billion. Within domestic sources, the bulk (82.2 percent) of financing came from banks while the remaining Rs 100 billion or 17.8 percent came from non-bank sources. Most importantly, the borrowings from the State Bank of Pakistan reached at an alarming level which is posing serious complications for the conduct of monetary policy. On cumulative basis, as on May 10, 2008 government has borrowed Rs.551 billion from SBP Fig 5.1Government Budgetary Borrowings Total borrowings From Scheduled banks 400 Rs.billion 551 From SBP 600 212 200 99 98 0 178 35 191 161 102 362 170 22 -59 -189 -1 -200 -400 Q1 FY 08 Jul 84 Aug Sep Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar 2008 2007 Accepted 2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 Oct Offered 2007 Target 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007 2008 2007 Rs. billion Fig 5.2 T-bill Auctions Results 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Jul-10May 08 2007 FY 07 2008 Jul-12May 07 2008 Jul-1Dec 07 Apr Money and Credit Due to phenomenal rise in government sector borrowings from the banking system, net domestic assets of the banking system registered a strong growth (21.32 percent) during July-May FY08 compared to the growth (14.67 percent) recorded during corresponding period of last year. The SBP has contributed the most to the overall NDA expansion mainly due to the strong growth in the government borrowings from the Central Bank. Credit to public sector enterprises which registered an expansion of Rs.44 billion in contrast to Rs.10 billion during the corresponding period last year also contributed to the current rise in NDA. This growth in the credit to PSEs is attributable to delays in settlement of oil price differential claims of one public sector oil marketing company (OMC), and the credit extension to the electricity distribution companies. Net Foreign Assets (NFA) NFA of the banking system registered a net contraction of Rs.289 billion during July-May FY08 compared to an expansion of Rs.84billion during the corresponding period last year. This contraction in NFA is attributable to delays in issuance of GDRs, sovereign bonds, receipts of lower-than-expected logistics support, decline in foreign investment, lower inflows from multilateral development banks, and SBP’s decision to provide foreign exchange to support a part of oil payments even when the oil prices are at their historic high levels. Fig 5.3 Net Foreign Assets 100 34.4 17.3 12.8 FY 04 FY 05 -100 -71.4 -99.9 -150 -200 -250 -300 -289.8 Jul-Dec FY07 Jul-May FY07 Jul-Jun FY07 Jul-Dec FY08 Jul-May FY 08 Credit to Private Sector Credit to private sector grew by 14.9 percent during July-May FY08 as against 12.2 percent in the same period of last year. Credit to private sector as percent of GDP is continuously rising since 2001-02 (Fig-5.5). Fig 5.5 Credit to Private Sector/GDP(mp) 23.5 FY 03 -50 FY 06 FY 07 14.9 FY 08 Net credit to private sector stood at Rs.369 billion during July-May FY08 compared with Rs. 263 billion in the same period last year. Private sector credit was growing at a slower pace till January 2008 compared to previous year, gathered momentum thereafter. The key factors contributing 31 29 27 25 23 21 19 17 15 1991-92 1992-93 1993-94 1994-95 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 1999-00 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 Percent 34.3 92.8 0 Fig 5.4 Growth of Private sector 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 84.59 50 Rs.billion Net Domestic Assets to recent acceleration in private sector credit growth include: (i) rise in working capital requirements due to higher input costs; (ii)the need for bridge financing to settle price differential claims of the OMCs and IPPs; and (iii) the higher fixed investment in the month of March 2008. 85 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 Table-5.3 Private sector credit (Flows) Sectors Overall Credit (I to V) I.Loans to Private Sector business A.Agriculture B.Mining And Quarrying C.Manufacturing Textiles D.Electricity,gas and water E.Construction F.Commerce and Trade G.Transport,storage and communications H.Services I.Other Private Business II.Trust funds and NPOs III.Personal IV.Others V.Investment in Securities and Shares A look on advances to private sector (Table 5.3) suggests that, while the increase in raw material prices did cause acceleration in credit demand in a few industries, the increase in interest rates had put significant downward pressures on credit demand especially in industries that are capable of generating cash flows internally, sufficient to meet working capital requirements. It must also be kept in mind that the credit by the banking sector is also being supplemented by other sources of financing. The private sector is using non-bank finances, thus shifting part of the credit demand away from the banking sources. In particular, besides banks, nonbank financial institutions are meeting the financing demand of the private sector through their investment in debt instruments (TFCs and Sukuk).It may be pertinent to note that most of the private sector TFC’s and Sukuk’s have been used to refinance bank credit. Availability of foreign investment and loans has also played an important role in softening the demand for bank credit particularly in telecommunication sector. It appears that demand for fixed investment loans has moderated in a number of industries. However, this does not necessarily suggests a slowdown in economic activity as (a) the moderation in fixed investment demand in cement, construction and textile is more of a reflection of the fact that these industries had already expanded their capacities in recent years; and (b) some of the industries are 86 (Rs.billion) Jul-Mar FY07 267.5 203.2 10.5 0.3 119.0 21.6 12.3 10.3 15.9 13.9 18.4 2.9 0.6 38.8 4.1 20.8 FY08 368.0 304.7 12.1 4.7 193.1 94.2 37.3 15.0 28.5 4.0 10.0 -1.2 0.5 21.2 -0.6 42.2 Source:SBP financing their expansion projects through other sources, such as foreign currency loans (e.g., telecom), foreign investments (telecom, chemical) and floatation of debt instruments (e.g., chemical, cement, real estate and ship yard) in the domestic market. Further, the demand for fixed investment is expected to grow substantially in the power and refinery sector. The commencement of financing private sector power projects will provide a boost to private sector credit growth. It is also likely that companies which met their demand from external borrowings in earlier periods would revert to domestic markets given the expected widening of spread overseas.Although the SBP kept the liquidity conditions tight in inter-bank market throughout FY08, the impact on commercial bank’s ability to lend was weaker by a number of factors such as increase in bank’s paid up capital, more than required capital adequacy of banks, increase in non-performing loans, particularly in consumer financing, SME, corporate and internal cash generation through increased profitability, the continued process of mergers and acquisitions, upgradation of the risk management systems in a few banks and a slight deterioration in credit quality have prevented a few banks from aggressive lending. Money and Credit Sectoral Analysis: Manufacturing, power, and commerce made major contributions in the growth of net advances. In contrast, contribution from services, construction, personal and others was significantly lower during Jul-Mar FY08 compared to the corresponding period of FY07. Agriculture Sector: The gross disbursement to agri-sector grew by 24.8 percent to Rs 138.6 billion) during Jul-Mar FY08 compared with 21.9 percent in the same period of last year (Table5.4).Production loans rose by 28.5 percent to Rs.125.4 billion from Rs.97.6 billion last year; while the development loans declined to Rs.13.1 billion from Rs.13.6 billion during the same period. Commercial banks gross disbursement during Jul-Mar FY07grew to Rs.95.1 billion. An encouraging factor regarding disbursement of agricultural credit was the increasing role of private domestic banks vis-à-vis traditional lender, ZTBL. The share of private domestic banks in total disbursement increased from 14.5 percent (Rs 16 billion) during Jul-Mar FY07 to 21.6 percent (Rs.29.9 billion) during Jul-Mar FY08.On the other hand, share of ZTBL declined from 36.8 percent(Rs.40.8 billion) during Jul-Mar FY07 to 28.5 percent (Rs.39.5 billion) during Jul-Mar FY08.Among the major commercial banks, National Bank of Pakistan continued its dominance, followed by Habib Bank Limited, MCB Bank, Allied Bank of Pakistan Limited, and United Bank Limited. Table-5.4 Targets and Actual Disbursement of Agriculture Loans Actual Disbursement (July-March) FY 07 FY 08 Name Of Banks Pro Dev Pro Dev Total Loans Loans Loans Loans I. Total Commercial Banks (A+B) 57.2 7.9 65 88.6 6.5 A.Major Commercial Banks 42.8 6.1 49 61.6 3.5 1.Allied Bank of Pakistan Limited 4.5 0.1 4.5 8.8 0.1 2.Habib Bank Limited 9.3 4 13.3 14.1 0.8 3.Muslim Commercial Bank Limited 5.2 0.1 5.4 13.4 0.5 4.National Bank of Pakistan 17.5 1.5 19 19.4 1.2 5.United Bank Limited 6.3 0.4 6.7 6 0.8 B Private Domestic Banks 14.3 1.7 16.1 27 3 II.Total Specialized Banks(1+2) 40.4 5.7 46.2 36.8 6.6 1.Zarai Taraqiati Bank Limited 36.9 4 40.9 33.6 6 2.P.P.C.B 3.6 1.7 5.3 3.3 0.7 Grand Total (I+II) 97.6 13.6 111 125.4 13.1 Power Sector: The demand for advances was significantly higher in power sector during Jul-Mar FY08. Indeed, the rise in working capital loans incorporated the impact of delays in payment from WAPDA to IPPs, whereas growth in fixed investment loans reflects the impact of capacity expansion in private sector power projects. Manufacturing: Credit to manufacturing sector rose to Rs.193 billion during Jul-Mar FY08 compared to Rs.119 billion in Jul-Mar FY07.This higher growth was mainly driven by higher advances to the textile sector (Rs.94.2 billion in the FY08as compared to Rs.21.6 billion in the same (Rs.billion) Total 95.1 65.1 8.8 14.9 13.9 20.6 6.9 30 43.5 39.6 3.9 138.6 Source:SBP period last year); excluding the textile industry, the growth in advances to manufacturing sector has decelerated. Construction: Advances to construction sector rose to Rs.15 billion during Jul-Mar FY08 Rs.10.3 billion in the corresponding period last year. The issuance of privately placed Sukuks for financing new projects probably explains lower demand for fixed investment loans from this sector. Besides rising housing demand, the increase in domestic raw material prices for construction mainly explains the higher demand for working capital requirement in this sector during Jul-Mar FY08. 87 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 Consumer Loans: Advances to consumer loans slowed and reached to only Rs.16.6 billion during Jul-Mar FY08 from Rs.35.2 billion in the preceding year (Table 5.5). The decline in consumer loans is evident in all categories (except mortgage finance). In particular, deceleration in the growth of auto finance was attributed to (1) lower demand for automobiles due to increase in prices of locally produced cars, and (2)risk aversions of banks following recovery issues(e.g., one of the banks has even suspended auto finance scheme). Monetary Assets The Components of monetary assets (M2) include: Currency in Circulation, Demand Deposit, Time Deposit, Other Deposits (Excluding IMF A/C, counterpart) and Resident’s Foreign Currency Deposits (RFCDs). The developments in these components during the July-May FY08 of the current fiscal year are presented below (Table-5.6) Table 5.5 Consumer Financing Consumer Financing 1.House Building 2.Transport i.e purchase of cars etc 3.Credit cards 4.Consumer Durables 5.Personal Loans 6.Others Total Table-5.6 Monetary Aggregates Items End June 2006 2007 740,390 840,181 (Rs.billion) Change During Jul-Mar FY 07 FY 08 9 10.2 7.6 3.4 7 1.8 -0.4 0.7 11.9 0.4 -0.1 0.1 35.2 16.6 Source:SBP (Rs million) July-May* 2006-07 2007-08 874,171 1,026,284 A. Currency in Circulation Deposit of which: B. Other Deposits with SBP 4,931 7,012 6,113 4,341 C.Total Demand &Time Deposits incl.RFCDs 2,661,584 3,217,962 3,006,745 3,411,470 of which RFCDs 195,501 207,312 199,955 234,882 Monetary Assets Stock (M2) A+B+C 3,406,905 4,065,155 3,887,029 4,432,041 Memorandum Items Currency/Money Ratio 21.7 20.7 22.5 23.2 Other Deposits/Money ratio 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.1 Total Deposits/Money ratio 78.1 79.2 77.4 77.0 RFCD/Money ratio 5.7 5.1 5.1 5.3 Income Velocity of Money 2.1 2 *pertains to 10th May for F08 and 12th May for FY07 Source:SBP Note: Compilation of M1 based on weekly data has been discontinued. Now M1 is being compiled on the basis of monthly returns and is given in Table 2.1 which would be published in the monthly Statistical Bulletin of SBP from April 2008 in Table 2.1. i. Excluding IMF A/c No 1 & 2 SAF Loans A/c, deposits money banks, counterpart funds, deposits of foreign central bans, foreign governments. ii. Excluding inter-bank deposits of federal and provincial governments and foreign constituents and international organizations etc. iii. Income Velocity of money is defined by the State Bank as GDP at current factor cost/quarterly average of Monetary Assets (M2) Currency in Circulation As shown in the Table 6.6, currency in circulation during July-May FY 08 increased to Rs.186 billion from Rs.133 billion during the same period of last year. The currency in circulation constituted 23.2 88 percent of the money supply (M2) as against 22.5 percent in the same period last year. Deposits During July-May FY08, demand and time deposits has declined to Rs.165 billion as compared to Money and Credit Rs.340 billion in the same period of last year. On the other hand, RFCDs has registered an increase and reached to Rs. 27 billion as compared to Rs.4 billion in the same period last year. The M2/GDP ratio, which is an indicator of financial development continued to exhibit a rising trend since 1990-00 from 36.9 percent to 46.6 percent in 2006-07.In March 2008, however, M2/ GDP ratio was 42 percent as compared to 43.4 percent in the corresponding period of last year (see Table 5.7). Table-5.7 Key Indicators of Pakistan's Financial Development Years M2/GDP DD+TD/M2 1999-00 36.9 74.6 2000-01 36.7 75.4 2001-02 40.0 75.4 2002-03 43.1 76.2 2003-04 44.9 76.8 2004-05 45.1 77.6 2005-06 45.0 72.5 2006-07 46.6 74.1 July-March 2006-07 43.4 72.3 2007-08 42.0 72.5 Source:SBP Monetary Management The Money market in Pakistan has developed substantially since the process of liberalization of the financial system began in the early 1990s.A vibrant inter-bank money market not only helps to transmit monetary policy signals but also provides stability to financial institutions through meeting short-term liquidity requirement with relative ease and at competitive rates. The focus of SBP’s monetary management in FY08 was to improve the transmission of policy rates to the retail rates by draining the excess liquidity from the money market and keeping the overnight rates close to the discount rate. The tight monetary stance adopted since April 2005, did help in containing inflationary pressures in the economy. Nevertheless, high monetary growth towards the end of FY07 and substantial increase in government borrowing from SBP during current fiscal year along with shortage in food supply, started to dilute the impact of a tight monetary policy stance. To contain the rising inflationary pressures in the economy, SBP therefore continued with a tight monetary stance during the current fiscal year, as the risk of inflation was outweighing the risk of economic growth. The SBP raised its policy rate by 250 basis points in the monetary policy statements and revised CRR for demand and time liabilities and SLR in the upward direction. Complement to the tight monetary policy stance, the SBP continued recourse to Open Market Operation (OMOs) more frequently to manage liquidity at the desired levels in the inter-bank market. (The SBP moped up Rs.766 billion during July-Mar FY07 against the injection of Rs.118 billion as compared to Rs.700billion against the injection of Rs.72 billion in corresponding period of last year.) Table-5.8 Summary of OMOs (Rs.billion) Injection Absorption FY 07 FY 08 FY 07 FY 08 Jul 133.5 141.8 Aug 21.2 105.7 228.3 Sep 87 71.3 Oct 40.9 81.3 Nov 61.9 124.7 Dec 25.8 117.2 69 Jan 27.5 60.2 52.3 Feb 11.7 70.9 Mar 25 49.55 42.1 8.1 Total 72 118 700.5 766.4 Source:SBP The impact of tight monetary stance and liquidity management began to translate into a rise in other interest rates, with varied magnitude, at different stages of the economy. For instance, 6 months T-bills cutoff witnessed an increase of 97 basis points to 9.9 percent during Jul-Apr FY08.Similarly, 6 months and 12-months KIBOR also increased by 77 basis points and 63 basis points to 10.38 percent and 10.71 percent respectively at end April 2007 in the same way, 89 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 6-months repo rates depicted an increase of 133 basis points to 9.98 percent during Jul-Apr FY08. Fig 5.6 Weighted Average Interest Rates Fig 5.7 Contribution of T-bills 100 10.5 6-Months 10 12-Months 9.5 FY 07 79.5 FY 08 8.5 8 40 20 19.1 9.1 3-Months Table-5.9 Market treasury bills Auctions Jul-Jun FY 2006-07 Offered 3-Months 6-Months 12-Months Total Accepted *W.A Rate 186,652 136,102 8.5 125,483 90,433 8.7 787,636 661,786 9.0 1,099,771 888,321 * Average of maximum and minimum rates 9.6 11.4 0 Feb-08 Oct-07 Jun-07 Feb-07 Oct-06 Jun-06 Feb-06 Oct-05 Jun-05 7.5 6-Months 12-Months (Rs million) Offered FY 07 182,802 99,320 561,683 843,805 The SBP accepted Rs.495 billion from the primary market of T-Bills during the first nine months of FY08 as compared to Rs.696 billion in FY07 (Table-5.9). Market offered a total amount of Rs. 682 billion in first nine months of FY 08 as compared to Rs.843 billion in the same period of last year. In the first nine months of FY07 heavy investment was in 12 months T-bills which constituted almost 80 percent of the total accepted amount due to the fact that 12-months T-bills provided the highest interest earnings with zero risk in the short run (Fig-5.7). In order to develop the bond market, and to reduce the cost of funds for financing the fiscal deficit in the long run, Government has started PIBs auctions since December 2000. In FY07, the supply of long term government paper started to pick up pace as the government started to hold primary auctions of 90 71.3 60 9 Percent Percent 80 FY 08 49,625 64,325 568,790 682,740 Jul-Mar Accepted FY 07 133,152 66,920 496,433 696,505 FY 08 45,225 56,395 393,605 495,225 *W.A Rate FY 07 FY 08 8.5 9.1 8.6 9.4 8.9 9.6 Source:SBP PIBs in a more regular and predictable manner. Regarding long-term interest rates, an important development in FY07 was the extension of yield curve to 30 years. Interest rates of long term government securities also registered increase due upward revision of discount rate, and yield curve moved in the upward direction in the range of 81 to 110 basis points approximately. The SBP mopped up Rs. Rs.68 billion from the primary market of PIBs during the first nine months of FY08 as compared to Rs.37 billion in the same period of FY07 (Table-5.10). Market offered a total amount of Rs.133 billion in first nine months of FY08 as compared to Rs.100 billion in the same period of last year. In the first nine months of FY07 heavy investment was in 10 years PIBs which constituted almost 33 percent of the total accepted amount. (Fig 5.9). Money and Credit Fig 5.9 Contribution of PIBs Fig 5.8 Weighted Average Interest rate of 10 Years PIB FY 07 14 2 Table-5.10 Pakistan Investment Bonds Auctions Jul-Jun PIBs FY 2006-07 Offered Accepted *W.A Rate 3 Years 36,982 10,882 9.54 5 Years 39,799 10,174 9.77 10 Years 65,986 30,211 10.31 15 Years 12,750 9,250 10.95 20 Years 20,200 11,250 11.28 30 Years 23,300 16,100 11.61 Total 199,017 87,867 * Average of maximum and minimum rates 3 Yrs Aug-07 Aug-06 Aug-05 Aug-04 Aug-03 Aug-02 0 30 Yrs 4 20 Yrs 6 15 Yrs 8 10 Yrs Percent Percent 10 FY 08 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 5 Yrs 12 (Rs.million) Offered FY 07 FY 08 21,770 11,044 17,407 21,177 26,030 58,805 9,850 14,876 13,150 9,550 12,000 17,600 100,207 133,052 Table-5.11 Lending & Deposit Rates (W.A) LR DR Spread Jun-06 9.9 2.9 7.0 Jul-06 10.2 3.1 7.2 Aug-06 10.6 3.1 7.5 Sep-06 11.0 3.2 7.8 Oct-06 11.1 3.4 7.7 Nov-06 11.0 3.6 7.4 Dec-06 11.2 3.7 7.5 Jan-07 10.7 3.7 6.9 Feb-07 10.5 3.8 6.7 Mar-07 10.6 3.9 6.6 Apr-07 10.6 3.9 6.7 May-07 10.6 4.0 6.5 Jun-07 10.3 4.0 6.3 Jul-07 10.4 4.0 6.4 Aug-07 10.5 4.1 6.4 Sep-07 10.5 4.1 6.3 Oct-07 11.0 4.1 6.8 Nov-07 10.7 4.1 6.6 Dec-07 11.0 4.1 6.8 Jan-08 10.8 4.2 6.6 Feb-08 10.8 4.2 6.6 Mar-08 10.9 4.2 6.7 Source:SBP Jul-Mar Accepted FY 07 FY 08 3,982 4,953 4,523 10,777 12,170 23,038 4,300 7,801 4,000 7,850 8,000 14,400 36,975 68,819 *W.A Rate FY 07 FY 08 9.53 10.11 9.82 10.30 10.18 10.81 11.01 11.49 11.39 11.69 11.68 11.91 Source:SBP At the second stage of monetary transmission, changes in SBP policy rate translated into an increase in financial institutions’ lending and deposit rates (Table 5.11). The spread between the lending and deposit rates has also decreased from 7 percent in June 2006 to 6.7 percent in March 2007.However, W.A. lending rate has declined by 10 basis points during December 2007 to March 2008.In the Interim Monetary Policy Measures announced by the State Bank, all banks are required to pay a minimum interest rate of 5 percent on saving deposit products; aimed at encouraging people to save more. Pakistan’s Financial Sector Performance Financial stability in Pakistan has benefited from structural transformation of the banking sector and wide-ranging policy initiatives of the State Bank. The country’s prudential regulatory regime has been crafted to promote and preserve financial sector stability. The regulatory framework encourages (i) financial sector growth, 91 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 diversification and innovation, (ii) healthy competition and risk taking to ensure a sustainable and aggressive income stream, (iii) opportunities for enhancing the franchise value of banks, (iv)prudent behavior and effective risk management and loan provisioning requirement are stringent enough to discourage infection of loan portfolio, and (v) safeguarding social obligations and consumer interests. Financial sector stability has been further fostered by strengthening of bank’s system wide capital base. Financial stability will further benefit from State Bank efforts to operationalize a Real-time Gross Settlement System (RTGS) named as PRISM (Pakistan Real Time Inter-bank settlement Mechanism) in June 2008 that will allow shift from traditional paper-based, end-of-the-day settlement system to electronic payment system for large value, low volume inter-bank funds’ transfers and settlements. Financial sector is now predominantly owned by the private sector which presents some new challenges. The State Bank of Pakistan is now working to develop an adequate policy framework for consumer protection, development of Financial Safety Nets such as Deposit Insurance ,and a welllaid out ‘Lender of last resort’ procedure. The framework would strike a balance between enhancing consumer protection and minimizing moral hazard concerns. Table 5.12 Asset Composition of the Financial Sector FY 00 FY01 FY02 Investment Banks 40,989 30,862 27,001 Modaraba 15,278 15,561 17,456 Leasing 48,384 46,948 41,141 Discount Houses 1,805 1,395 1,527 Venture Capital Companies 1,027 346 272 Mutual Funds 25,347 24,175 29,094 Total Assets 125,587 120,723 122,298 CY 00 CY 01 CY 02 DFIs 91,496 61,145 68,729 Housing Finance 22,264 23,599 22,434 Insurance n.a. 112,558 129,066 Total Assets 113,760 197,302 220,229 FY03 37,936 15,973 46,842 1,987 854 57,180 160,772 CY 03 78,803 21,562 150,330 250,695 FY04 35,568 18,026 44,806 1,341 1,005 103,080 203,826 CY 04 94,752 19,493 172,992 287,237 FY05 51,041 21,572 53,635 1,504 3,200 136,245 267,197 CY 05 107,811 18,657 201,665 328,133 FY06 54,527 23,927 63,999 1,834 4,131 177,234 325,652 CY 06 116,939 19,702 244,657 381,298 (Rs.million) FY07 41,458 25,186 63,956 1,417 4,061 313,661 449,739 CY 07 n.a. n.a. n.a. Source:SBP Commercial Banks The impressive performance of Pakistan’s banking sector has attracted considerable FDI into the industry in recent years. Commercial banks in Pakistan operate on a sound capital base with a commendable record of financial performance, particularly in the last 3 years. In Jul-Dec 2007-08, total number of branches of banks was 8233 as compared to 7890 in 2006-07; there has been an increase of 343 branches in the first six months of FY07.Assets of all banks showed a net expansion of Rs.203.1 billion in the first six months of FY08 and stood at Rs.5155 billion as compared to Rs.4351 billion in the same period of last year. An acceleration in private sector credit contributed to increase in scheduled banks’ assets. The total deposits of all banks registered an increase of Rs.168 billion in the first 92 six months of FY08 and reached at the level of Rs.3852 billion as compared to Rs. 3255 billion recorded in the same period of last year.Net investment of the banks showed an increase of Rs.95 billion in Jul-Dec FY08 mainly contributed by the private banks amounting to Rs.934 billion as compared to Rs.601 billion for the six months of last year. (Table 5.13) The banking sector of Pakistan in recent years has undergone a visible change as about 80 percent of the banking assets are now controlled by the private sector. While this has yielded significant benefits in the form of increased competition, product innovation, technological up-gradation and diversification of business activities, a host of new risks have also surfaced. This has necessitated the adoption of international best practices by the banks/DFIs in classification and provisioning Money and Credit against their loans and advances portfolio to further strengthen the soundness and stability of banking system. Table-5.13 Performance of Scheduled Banks 30-Jun-07 1.No.of Branches Nationalized Commercial Banks Private Banks Specialized Banks Foreign Banks 2.Assets (Rs.Billion) Nationalized Commercial Banks Private Banks Specialized Banks Foreign Banks 3.Net Advances (Rs.Billion) Nationalized Commercial Banks Private Banks Specialized Banks Foreign Banks 4.Deposits (Rs.Billion) Nationalized Commercial Banks Private Banks Specialized Banks Foreign Banks 5.Net Investments (Rs.Billion) Nationalized Commercial Banks Private Banks Specialized Banks Foreign Banks The NPLs are the most important indicator of determining the asset quality of any bank because the gross NPLs to gross advances and net NPLs to net advances are considered as key indicators of quality of lending. As on 30th September 2007, the gross NPLs of the banking system recorded at Rs.163 billion and gross NPLs to gross advances were at 6.5%.For the financial results of 2008, commercial banks were needed to provide Rs 24 billion excess provisioning as per SBP’s directive regarding Forced Sales Value (FSV) of collateral. On the basis of the provision provided by the commercial banks against non-performing loans, the net NPLs to net advances ratio rose to 2.4% .In December 2007, the State Bank of Pakistan withdrew the benefit of FSV against all non performing loans (NPLs) for calculating provisioning requirement which directly hampered the profits of entire banking sector. Hence, the 7890 1696 5625 534 35 4952 964 3611 123 253.8 2498.9 464.7 1838.4 71.5 124.2 3683.7 756 2745.2 13.6 168.9 1180.3 243.9 879.7 14.9 41.8 Jul-Dec 2006-07 7852 1690 5597 534 31 4351.9 836.2 3173 119 223.8 2427.7 429.7 1807.2 70.6 120.2 3255 665.6 2425.8 13.5 150.1 836.7 179.9 601.7 16.6 38.5 2007-08 8233 1715 5935 534 49 5155.1 1017.2 3845.2 119.9 172.9 2694 488.7 2044.4 72.2 88.7 3852 813.1 2907.8 13.5 117.6 1275.5 298.7 934.5 15.8 26.5 Source:SBP banks have to go for 100 percent provisioning against the NPLs. However, liquid assets are being subtracted to calculate provisioning against NPLs. Therefore, the banks will show fewer profits due to higher provisioning against their NPLs. Earlier, there was an option for the banks to shelter the actual required provisioning by showing collateral process higher than the actual value. Due to FSV, major impact would result in high recovery of NPLs. The SBP further elaborated that the classified loans and advances that have been guaranteed by the government would not require provisioning. According to an analysis; private commercial banks will face biggest impact for SBP provisioning policy while foreign banks would face the least impact. The SBP’s timely decision to eliminate the benefit of FSV of collateral will help the banks to improve their loan quality and recovery rate going forward. The measure taken by 93 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 SBP to streamline the financial sector is seen as a positive step and will help the banks to strengthen their balance sheets. considerations, by giving them the opportunity to choose between the two parallel modes of financing and investment. Islamic banks The Islamic Financial industry in Pakistan has grown substantially since the launch of SBP’s focused strategy to promote a parallel Islamic Banking system in 2001.This performance is commendable for such a short period, given that other countries have achieved similar levels of growth in their respective Islamic banking industries after several years of existence. Besides banks, IFIs in Pakistan include Islamic Mutual Funds, Shariah-compliant housing finance services, takaful companies and modarabas. Sukuk issuances have also attracted considerable attention in recent years. Initially conceived in response to a faith-based logic of conforming to the principles of Shariah in all spheres of life, the astounding growth of the Islamic Financial Industry also drew on the wealth accumulation in oil-rich countries in the ensuing years, and reflects its potential of financially viable and lucrative segment of the global financial system. Islamic Financial Institution (IFIs) have been successful in tapping the previously excluded market on faith-based considerations, as well as the already included segment on preference-based Table 5.14 Islamic Banks Assets of the Islamic banks Deposits of the Islamic Banks Share in Banks Assets Share in Bank Deposits FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 12,915 8,397 0.50% 0.40% 44,143 30,185 1.40% 1.25 71,493 49,932 2.10% 1.90% 119,294 83,740 2.90% 2.80% 205,212 146,945 4.20% 4.10% The overall deposits of IBIs at the end of February 2008 stood at Rs.141,933 million and reflected a share of 3.9 percent in banks assets as compared to 0.4 percent only in FY03, the downward trend in FY 08 as compared to last year was inline with the decreasing trend in deposits of all banks that began in January 2008. Total assets of the Islamic banks reached at Rs.200,415 million from Rs.12,915 million in FY03 and contributed 4.1 percent in banking assets till end of February 2008 (Table 5.14). The industry has over the years managed to offer a wide array of products encompassing almost the entire range of modes of Islamic financing that are able to cater to the needs of majority of the sectors of the economy. The segments covered by the industry include Corporate / Commercial, Agriculture, Consumer, Commodity financing, SME Sector, Treasury and Financial institutions and manufacturing and Services concerns through various Shariah complaint modes. Table 5.14 (a) Financing Products by Islamic banks (%age) Mode of Financing FY03 FY04 FY05 Murabaha 79.4 57.4 44.4 Ijara 16.5 24.8 29.7 Musharaka 1 0.8 Mudaraba Diminishing Muskaraka 1.2 5.9 14.8 Salam 1.6 0.7 1.9 Istisna 0.4 1.4 Qarz/Qarz-e-hasna Others 1.3 9.8 3 The highest share in financing products of Islamic banks is contributed by Murabaha, Ijara, and Diminishing Musharaka in FY08 (March).As the 94 (Rs.million) FY08 (March) 200,415 141,933 4.10% 3.90% FY06 48.4 29.7 0.8 14.8 1.9 1.4 3 FY07 38.9 25.4 0.9 0.3 25.1 1.4 0.9 7.1 FY08(March) 38.7 24.2 1.3 0.2 24.8 1.6 2.4 6.7 industry develops, SBP continues to provides an enabling environment for Islamic Banks. Work is underway on the development of Bait-ul-Maal Money and Credit certificates to provide a sovereign instrument for liquidity management, and risk management guidelines have been issued. Microfinance Institutions The operations of MFIs, including Microfinance Banks (MFBs), Non-Government Organizations (NGOs), Rural Support programs (RSPs) and Commercial Financial Institutions (CFIs) have witnessed significant improvements, which are reflected in almost all aspects of the microfinance industry. Number of new MFBs branches has grown, total assets have increased, products are being gradually diversified, outreach is being extended, branch network is being expanded and growth has been achieved in the total number of borrowers and advances. With a focus on expanding microfinance reach to 3 million borrowers by 2010, a strategy for Expanding Microfinance Outreach (EMO) has been developed by the SBP which was approved by the Government in February 2007.The EMO strategy stresses on the fact that commercialization of the sector is key to financial and social sustainability. Table 5.15 Disbursement of Loans by Microfinance Banks (Rs.million) July-March Institution 2006-07 2006-07 2007-08 Khushali Banks 3610900 2355041 2590058 Microfinance Banks ( Others) 2500968 1875405 2298604 Total 6111868 4230446 4888662 During Jul-Mar 2008, Khushali Bank, which leads the microfinance sector in Pakistan disbursed loans amounting Rs.2.6 billion as compared to Rs.2.3 billion in the same period last year. While the share of all other microfinance banks in loan disbursement increased to Rs. 2.3 billion in Jul-Mar FY08 from Rs. 1.8 billion in the Jul-Mar FY07. Small and Medium Enterprises The importance of the SME sector cannot be overemphasized in the overall industrial development of a country. SMEs constitute nearly 90% of all the enterprises in Pakistan; they employ 80% of the non-agriculture labor force; and their share in the annual GDP is nearly 40%.During FY08, credit to SME sector has decreased to Rs.18 billion from Rs.30 billion during FY07. Mining, Electricity, Commerce and other private business sector registered in crease while Manufacturing, Services, Communication, Construction sectors recorded a substantial decrease. Table-5.16 Credit to SME (Rs .million) Stocks Flows Sector Jun-06 Jun-07 FY 07 FY 08 Mining and Quarrying 822 790 172 303 153147 160791 15628 5856 Manufacturing Ship Breaking 959 539 -526 -284 Electricity and Gas 1872 2681 860 1534 Commerce and 123723 126457 1599 5447 Trade 23163 30831 4973 -1892 Services Transport and Communications 9711 11956 553 72 Construction 12976 16370 1802 -335 Other Private Business 32318 34809 5032 7360 Total 358692 385223 30091 18059 Source:SBP Non-Bank Financial institutions (NBFIs) The major objective of the introduction of the concept of NBFCs i.e. Non-Banking Finance Companies in 2002, was to enable the existing (mainly) single-product institutions serving specific market niches, to offer a whole variety and range of financial products though a one window operation akin to universal banking, subject to compliance with the prescribed progressivelytiered regulatory requirements. It was expected that consolidation of different financial services under one umbrella would lead to the emergence of stronger, well-capitalized entities, which will provide a fillip for the future development of the non-bank financial sector. The key market players in the non-bank financial sector of Pakistan are non-banking Finance Companies (NBFCs), mutual funds, modarabas and Development Finance Institutions (DFIs).The non –bank financial sector has historically played 95 Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08 an important role in the mobilization and channeling of savings in the financial system. The NBFIs have, in recent years benefited from an environment of low interest rates coupled with high economic growth but have been unable to create an impact as well-functioning, specialized financial intermediaries. The success story among NBFIs is that of mutual funds. The mutual fund sector is rapidly growing in Pakistan and accounted for the largest chunk in total assets of non-bank financial sector. Between FY00 to FY 07, net assets of mutual funds have grown by more than 12 times to reach Rs.313 billion from Rs.25 billion only in FY 00. sector entities. However, with two-thirds of the population living in the rural areas and low per capita income, the insurance sector faces various hurdles in its growth. The growth in insurance sector is reflected in the increase in premiums and profitability, as well as assets for both life and non-life insurance. Private sector companies have launched innovative products in the recent past, such as livestock and crop insurance, which will help promote the quality of bank’s lending to agriculture sector. Fig 5.11 Assets of Insurance Sector 300 Fig 5.10 Assets of Mutual Funds 313.7 300 Rs.billion 250 177.2 200 103.1 100 50 25.3 24.2 29.1 136.2 57.2 Rs.billion 350 150 244.7 250 201.7 200 150 112.6 129.1 150.3 173.0 100 50 0 CY 01 CY 02 CY 03 CY 04 CY 05 CY 06 0 FY 00 FY01 FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 Insurance Sector The role of the insurance sector is significant in promoting the stability, not just of the financial sector, but also of the overall macroeconomic environment as it provides protection against uncertainty to economic agents by an equitable transfer of risk. Life insurance companies in particular, due to the long –term nature of their premiums, are also among the large institutional investors for capital and money market instruments. The insurance sector in Pakistan consisting of life, non-life and the sole reinsurance company (PRCL), has seen considerable improvements since 2001 on account of rise in the demand for insurance by corporate, households and public 96 The low insurance penetration highlights the need for concerted efforts to bring about reforms that would increase the competitiveness and outreach of Pakistan’s insurance industry. As a step in this direction, Insurance Ordinance 2000 has laid out targets that will help the expansion of the industry in the coming years, for instance, the recent increase in capital requirements will result in the emergence of stronger players in the industry. Appointment of the Insurance Ombudsman is another measure which would also go a long way in boosting the confidence of the public by setting complaints expeditiously. Other insurance sector reforms envision the privatization of State Life Insurance Corporation (SLIC), the largest state owned operator in the life insurance sector. Moreover, Postal Life Insurance is planned to be brought under the ambit of the Insurance Ordinance 2000.Foreign investment rules in the insurance sector have also been amended in order to attract FDI in the sector. Table 5.1 COMPONENTS OF MONETARY ASSETS Stock Rs. in million 1. Currency Issued 2. Currency held by SBP 3. Currency in title of Scheduled Banks 4. Currency in ciculation (1-2-3) 5. Other deposits with SBP 1 6. Scheduled Banks Total Dposits 2 7. Resident Foreign Currency Deposits (RFCD) 8. 9. FY 08 March 07 Mar-08 (P) 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 396,548 462,095 527,557 617,508 712,480 791,834 901,401 887,301 1,048,617 1,905 1,865 2,565 2,960 3,107 3,005 3,148 3,162 2,855 19,178 26,414 30,415 36,432 43,472 48,439 58,072 49,615 63,761 375,465 433,816 494,577 578,116 665,901 740,390 840,181 834,524 982,001 11,292 13,847 3,499 2,116 3,335 4,931 7,012 5,595 3,850 1,139,287 1,304,214 1,580,399 1,905,260 2,291,408 2,661,584 3,217,962 2,948,582 3,422,237 154,154 157,456 126,138 145,694 180,295 195,501 207,312 200,484 234,882 MI 1,275,615 1,494,140 1,797,361 2,174,736 2,512,214 2,720,685 3,155,635 2,896,466 3,365,665 Monetary assets (4+5+6) 1,526,044 1,751,877 2,078,475 2,485,492 2,960,644 3,406,905 4,065,155 3,788,701 4,408,088 9.0 14.8 18.6 19.6 19.1 15.1 19.3 11.2 8.4 24.6 24.8 23.8 23.3 22.5 21.7 20.7 22.0 22.3 10. Growth rate (%) Memorandum 1. Currency / Money ratio 2. Demand Deposits / Money ratio 24.6 24.0 29.2 31.8 32.1 31.9 65.0 63.7 65.0 3. Time Deposits / Money ratio 40.0 41.5 40.7 39.0 39.2 40.5 9.0 8.9 7.3 4. Other Deposits / Money ration 0.7 0.8 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.1 0.1 5. RFCD / Money ration 5.3 5.3 6. Income Velocity of Money 3 10.1 9.0 6.1 5.9 6.1 5.7 5.1 2.6 2.5 2.5 2.4 2.4 2.1 2.0 P : Provisional 1 Excluding IMF A/c Nos 1 & 2 SAF Loans A/c deposits money banks, counterpart funds, deposits of foreign central banks and foreign governments. 2 Excluding inter banks deposits and deposits of federal and provincial governments, foreign constituents and international organization etc. 3 Income velocity of money is taken as GDP at current factor cost / quarterly average of monetary assets (A2) Explanatory Notes: a Data series on monetary aggregates other than M1 are based on weekly returns reported by scheduled banks to SBP. b Data series on M1 aggregates (as Sr. # 8) is issued on monthly returns reported by scheduled banks to SBP and published is Statistical Bulletin from Aril 2008. c The stock data of M2 has been revised since June 2002 due to treatment of privatization commission deposits with NBP as government deposits. These deposits were previously included private sector deposits which have now being included in government deposits. d Totals may not tally due to separte rounding off TABLE 5.2 CAUSATIVE FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH MONETARY ASSETS (Rs million) 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 495047 434062 47377 -12522 574023 504562 53079 -15392 630745 552580 63664 -18518 36434 37657 A. End June Stock 1 Public Sector Borrowing (net) ( i + ii + iii + iv + v + vi + vii ) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 2 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i) 3 Counterpart Funds 4 Other Items (Net) 5 Domestic Credit (1+2+3+4) 6 Foreign Assets (Net) 7 Monetary Assets (5+6) 201174 194501 18675 -12002 270165 257074 22869 -9778 345167 322772 30204 -7809 373433 345917 36786 -9270 - - - - - - - - 426520 382336 41519 -11465 - - 14130 26130 -4660 260962 9374 292381 10661 352954 14594 392820 13744 462357 16955 531064 20121 602828 29196 -5749 287 696672 28302 251588 221062 281720 251311 338360 309595 379076 352363 445402 416094 510943 478701 573632 546814 668370 632025 30526 -330 -36857 424949 -24305 400644 30409 -151 -41500 520895 -15326 505569 28765 -546 -52846 644729 -49339 595390 26713 -388 -46537 719328 -15930 703398 29308 -464 -74705 813708 11027 824735 32242 -617 -58844 966650 -27971 938679 26818 -736 -61621 1114494 -61260 1053234 36345 -650 -45290 1281477 -75157 1206320 B. Changes over the year (July-June) 8 Public Sector Borrowing (net) ( i + ii + iii + iv + v + vi + vii ) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 9 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i) 10 Counterpart Funds 11 Other Items (Net) 12 Domestic Credit Expansion (8+9+10+11) 13 Foreign Assets (Net) 14 Monetary Expansions (13+14) 27438 2 38332 2 -5315 -5579 - 68991 62573 4194 2224 - 75002 65698 7335 1969 - 28266 23145 6582 -1461 - 53087 36419 4733 -2195 - 68527 51726 5858 -1057 - 80933 72457 9 5702 (2870) 56722 48018 10585 (3126) 10304 1223 -1089 287 0 83414 * -894 * 84308 * 74781 21702 592 31419 1287 60573 3933 39866 -850 14130 69537 3211 12000 63429 3166 -4660 0 61879 4,9 -242 7 21110 25096 30132 30249 56640 58284 40716 42768 66326 63731 60263 57329 3 62121 59907 4 -3986 178 4362 -117 179 -4643 -1644 -395 -11346 -2052 158 6309 2595 -76 -28168 2934 -153 21139 3 53680 2 5712 2 95946 8979 123834 -34013 74599 33409 94380 26957 152942 -38998 147845 -33289 166983 (13897) 104925 89821 108008 121337 113944 114556 153086 (Contd.) 59392 2214 7,9 -119 5152 4,9 9527 86 26761 * TABLE 5.2 CAUSATIVE FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH MONETARY ASSETS 1999 (Rs million) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 A. Stock End June 1 Public Sector Borrowing (net) (i + ii + iii + iv + v + vi + vii) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 2 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i c. PSEs Special Account Debt Repay d. Other Financial Institutions (NBFI 3 Counterpart Funds 4 Other Items (Net 5 Domestic Credit (1+2+3+4) 6 Foreign Assets (Net) 7 Monetary Assets (5+6) 583598 505887 8 67309 (21793) 661832 545850 8 107403 (23616) 601870 4998888 8 95311 (25524) 677054 567208 100642 (22991) 598623 511186 74047 (18805) 656729 574886 65873 (16224) 37657 37657 37657 37657 37657 37657 (5749) 287 816710 41351 775359 (5749) 287 842752 68637 774115 (5749) 287 902603 75240 827363 (5749) 287 921596 60159 861437 (5749) 287 1048162 55370 992892 (5749) 287 1363669 34293 1329376 735887 43124 (3652) 0 (589) (73544) 1326175 (45629) 1280546 754190 28826 (8901) 0 (611) (59087) 1444886 (44254) 1400632 750211 37036 (12241) 52357 (562) (6202) 1497707 28338 1526046 841057 35563 (15183) 37877 (536) (67463) 1530651 230718 1761370 949030 32386 (18802) 30278 (586) (107258) 1539041 539664 2078704 1274245 53852 (22108) 23387 (628) (116405) 1903367 583190 2486556 (78361) (55952) (26595) 4186 58106 63700 (8174) 2581 B. Changes over the year (July-June) 8 Public Sector Borrowing (net) (i+ii+iii+iv+v+vi+vii) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 9 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i c. PSEs Special Account Debt Repay d. Other Financial Institutions (NBFI 10 Counterpart Funds 11 Other Items (Net) 12 Domestic Credit Expansion (8+9+10+11) 13 Foreign Assets (Net) 14 Monetary Expansions (13+14) (74824) # (75193) 8'#' 3645 (3275) 119214 13049 106165 103038 6779 (3652) 0 61 246 # 44697 29529 74226 78234 39963 8 40094 (1823) (46731) (32315) 8@ (12508) (1908) 22177 14313 5331 2533 - - - - - - - - - - 26044 3125 7 22916 18303 9862 7 (5249) 0 (22) 14457 118711 1375 120086 69194 11573 57620 48633 12327 (3340) 0 49 30863 53374 72654 126028 @ 7 @ @ 7 The difference in flow data is due to change in the composition of autonomous bodies. 8 Special Account-Debt Repayment Adjusted. # Adjusted for Rs 28.5 billion on account of Adhoc Treasury Bills created to offset the government losses due to the unification of exchange rate @' The difference in flow data is due to change in the total number of PSES 18993 (15081) 34074 52969 (1473) (2942) (14480) 26 (12040) 29156 206168 235324 148539 (4789) 153328 167723 (3177) (3619) (7599) (50) (61674) 8454 308946 317400 315407 (21077) 336484 325215 21466 (3306) (6891) (42) (9147) 364326 43526 407852 (Contd) TABLE 5.2 CAUSATIVE FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH MONETARY ASSETS (Rs million) End March 2005 2006 2007 2007 2008 P A. Stock End June 1 Public Sector Borrowing (net) (i + ii + iii + iv + v + vi + vii) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 2 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i) c. PSEs Special Account Debt Repayment d. Other Financial Institutions (NBFIs) 3 Counterpart Funds 4 Other Items (Net 5 Domestic Credit (1+2+3+4) 6 Foreign Assets (Net) 7 Monetary Assets (5+6) 752515 646682 87836 (14198) 833686 708037 107762 (14308) 926530 810053 98552 (14269) 909342 829901 61722 (14476) 1238722 1119187 101239 (13899) 37657 37651 37657 37657 37657 (5749) 287 1782368 32224 1750144 (5749) 287 2190769 36979 2153790 (5749) 287 2576474 58148 2518326 (5749) 287 2461120 39958 2421162 (5749) 287 2955791 81627 2874164 1712093 44838 (23714) 16927 (539) (204929) 2329415 636938 2966352 2113890 47237 (23225) 15889 (546) (327346) 2696564 710341 3406905 2479608 46010 (23478) 16187 (519) (422223) 3080263 984982 4065155 2385708 42756 (23446) 16144 (509) (360492) 3009461 779240 3788701 2832887 48427 (23504) 16353 (533) (507986) 3685994 722094 4408088 B. Changes over the year (July-June) 8 Public Sector Borrowing (net) (i+ii+iii+iv+v+vi+vii) i Net Budgetary Support ii Commodity Operations iii Zakat Fund etc. iv Utilization of privatization proceeds by Govt./WAPDA v Use of Privatization proceeds/ NDRP Fund for Debt Retirement vi Payment to HBL on A/C of HC&EB 9 Non-Government Sector i Autonomous Bodies1 ii Net Credit to Private Sector & PSCEs a. Private Sector b. Public Sector Corp. other than 2(i) c. PSEs Special Account Debt Repayment d. Other Financial Institutions (NBFIs) 10 Counterpart Funds 11 Other Items (Net) 12 Domestic Credit Expansion (8+9+10+11) 13 Foreign Assets (Net) 14 Monetary Expansions (13+14) 95785 71796 21963 2026 86879 67063 19926 (110) 92844 102015 (9210) 39 75656 121864 (46040) (168) - - - - - - - - - - 418699 (2069) 420768 437848 (9014) (1606) (6460) 88 (88525) 426048 53748 479796 408401 4755 403646 401797 2399 489 (1038) (7) 122416 372857 73403 446260 385705 21169 364536 365718 (1227) (253) 298 27 (94877) 383699 274551 658250 Till end June 1996 autonomous bodies consisted of WAPDA, OGDC, PTC, NFC,and PTV, thereafter 1 their composition has been changed as WAPDA, OGDC, PTC, SSGC SNGPL, KESC and Pakistan Railways. 2 Adjusted for SAF loans amounting to Rs 7371 million 3 Adjusted for Rs 5278 million to exclude the impact arising due to mark up debited to the borrowers account. 4 Adjusted for Rs 8207million being mark up debited to the borrowers account 5 Credit to NHA by commercial Banks. 6 Credit to NHA and CAA by commercial banks Note: Figures in the parentheses represent negative signs. P : Provisional 312191 309135 2687 370 270351 379317 2979 23479 267372 355838 271819 353279 (4481) 2418 (221) (25) 255 166 37 (14) (33147) (85763) 312897 605731 68899 (262798) 381796 342934 Source: State Bank of Pakistan TABLE 5.3 SCHEDULED BANKS POSITION BASED ON WEEKLY RETURNS: LIABILITIES AND ASSETS (Rs million) Outstanding Amount at end June 1993 LIABILITIES 1. Capital (paid-up) and Reserves Demand liabilities in Pakistan 36,011 2. Inter-banks Demand Liabilities 12,822 2.1 Borrowing (1,436) 2.2 Deposits (11,386) 3. Deposits (General) 217,711 4. Other Liabilities 9,112 5. Total Demand Liabilities (2+3+4) 239,645 TIME LIABILITIES IN PAKISTAN 6. Inter-banks Time Liabilities 4,937 6.1 Borrowing (3,976) 6.2 Deposits (961) 7. Time Deposits (General) 270,343 8. Other Liabilities 3,920 9. Total Time Libilities (6+7+8) 279,200 10. Total Demand and Time Liabilities 518,845 11. Borrowing From SBP 64,577 12. Borrowing from Banks Abroad 14,614 6,584 13. Money at Call and Short Notice in Pakistan 14. Other Liabilities 505,570 15. Total Liabilities 1,146,201 16. Total Statutory Reserves 26,271 16.1 On Demand Liabilities (12,311) 16.2 On Time Liabilities Assets (13,960) ASSETS 17. Cash in Pakistan 11,301 18. Balances with SBP 48,745 19. Other Balances 8,920 7,002 20. Money at Call and Short Notice in Pakistan 21. 17+18+19+20 as % of 10 14.6 FOREIGN CURRENCY 22. Foreign Currency held in Pakistan 2,194 23. Balances with Banks Abroad 6,190 24. Total Foreign Currency 8,384 BANK CREDIT ADVANCES 25. To Banks 7,830 26. To Others 308,992 27. Total Advances 316,822 28. Bills Purchased and Discounted 44,149 29. Total Bank Credit 360,971 30. 29 as % of 10 69.6 INVESTMENT IN SECURITIES AND SHARES 31. Central Government Securities 140,124 32. Provincial Government Securities 3,727 33. Treasury Bills 35,660 34. Other Investment in Securities & Sahres 31,331 35. Total Investment in Securities and Shares 210,842 36. 35 as % of 10 40.6 37. Other Assets 490,036 38 Advance Tax Paid 39 Fixed Assets 40 Total Assets 1,146,201 41 Excess Reserves (18-16) 22,474 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 43,770 14,532 (2,878) (11,654) 256,188 12,578 283,298 50,533 16,787 (5,104) (11,683) 296,739 16,500 330,026 56,255 13,281 (115) (13,166) 339,408 19,224 371,913 60,935 13,722 (407) (13,315) 358,457 21,654 393,833 91,060 10,991 (78) (10,913) 411,361 25,120 447,472 75,632 7,968 (61) (7,907) 454,072 38,491 500,531 79,648 8,580 (43) (8,537) 475,281 47,420 531,281 88,581 12,282 (34) (12,248) 527,672 42,870 582,824 7,181 (3,333) (3,848) 342,368 4,812 354,361 637,659 70,583 14,217 6,721 640,164 1,413,114 32,219 (14,501) (17,718) 9,059 (5,998) (3,061) 405,882 3,388 418,329 748,355 82,668 14,280 8,350 743,430 1,647,616 37,835 (16,919) (20,916) 5,509 (2,965) (2,544) 495,677 4,737 505,923 877,836 56,914 13,424 8,070 897,892 1,910,391 44,295 (18,999) (25,296) 5,422 (3,618) (1,804) 571,574 5,369 582,365 976,198 77,999 14,622 5,370 993,960 2,129,084 49,078 19,960 (29,118) 10,658 (7,744) (2,914) 628,076 7,141 645,875 1,093,347 113,919 16,518 7,768 264,981 1,587,593 55,056 (22,762) (32,294) 8,633 (5,845) (2,788) 661,401 8,329 678,363 1,178,894 142,147 22,089 17,528 298,019 1,734,309 59,821 (25,903) (33,918) 6,300 (5,674) (626) 652,279 10,759 669,338 1,200,619 141,016 16,657 42,469 321,224 1,801,633 59,287 (26,135) (33,152) 4,705 (3,668) (1,037) 712,978 9,494 727,177 1,310,001 139,367 15,169 30,293 400,517 1,983,928 64,651 (28,527) (36,124) 13,959 63,746 14,814 7,062 15.6 16,363 78,503 11,012 8,814 15.3 19,328 63,502 14,516 8,989 12.1 17,821 89,756 16,864 5,772 13.2 18,769 84,740 18,210 8,903 11.9 18,870 100,335 19,116 18,095 13.3 19,468 153,371 18,250 43,509 19.5 19,178 147,962 18,033 31,179 16.5 4,261 7,899 12,160 3,017 8,163 11,180 3,667 16,545 20,212 4,647 10,918 15,565 2,706 21,798 24,504 2,981 39,019 42,000 2,222 46,619 48,841 4,788 70,856 75,644 8,616 347,868 356,484 52,483 408,967 64.1 13,482 413,811 427,293 59,649 486,942 65.1 5,449 474,731 480,180 62,511 542,691 61.8 3,690 552,522 556,212 70,675 626,887 64.2 5,687 644,049 649,736 63,073 712,809 65.2 4,402 725,852 730,254 63,774 794,028 67.4 5,788 801,154 806,942 69,554 876,496 73.0 3,657 866,490 870,147 75,504 945,651 72.2 147,076 3,345 83,443 32,632 266,496 41.8 625,910 1,413,114 31,523 166,687 3,340 90,059 35,210 295,296 39.5 739,506 1,647,616 40,668 144,922 3,338 137,110 42,512 327,882 37.4 913271.0 1,910,391 19,207 134,417 2,399 167,945 39,023 343,784 35.2 1,012,645 2,129,084 40,678 123,647 2,148 235,388 40,900 402,119 36.8 254,970 49,332 13,237 1,587,593 29,684 115,671 1,969 204,160 69,069 390,869 33.2 255,378 69,564 26,054 1,734,309 40,514 115,536 1,730 103,790 65,993 287,049 23.9 252,114 72,941 29,594 1,801,633 94,048 101,161 1,836 123,889 70,048 296934 22.7 340,220 78,205 30,922 1,983,928 83,311 Contd. TABLE 5.3 SCHEDULED BANKS POSITION BASED ON WEEKLY RETURNS: LIABILITIES AND ASSETS Outstanding Amount at end June 2002 2003 2004 LIABILITIES 1. Capital (paid-up) and Reserves Demand liabilities in Pakistan 85,886 112,230 131225 2. Inter-banks Demand Liabilities 13,261 9,937 20755 2.1 Borrowing (10) (1) (15) 2.2 Deposits (13,251) (9,936) (20740) 3. Deposits (General) 609,657 785,333 1014947 4. Other Liabilities 47,333 53,352 56532 5. Total Demand Liabilities (2+3+4) 670,251 848,622 1092234 TIME LIABILITIES IN PAKISTAN 6. Inter-banks Time Liabilities 2,104 3,991 4806 6.1 Borrowing (659) (621) (1878) 6.2 Deposits (1,445) (3,370) (2928) 7. Time Deposits (General) 803,749 903,153 1026919 8. Other Liabilities 12,808 16,020 20703 9. Total Time Libilities (6+7+8) 818,661 923,164 1052428 10. Total Demand and Time Liabilities 1,488,912 1,771,786 2144662 11. Borrowing From SBP 135,556 137,882 162335 12. Borrowing from Banks Abroad 12,642 21,243 9872 31,877 28,551 27479 13. Money at Call and Short Notice in Pakistan 14. Other Liabilities 546,159 * 468,312 * 527452 15. Total Liabilities 2,301,032 2,540,004 3003025 16. Total Statutory Reserves 73,677 87,893 105955 16.1 On Demand Liabilities (32,850) (41,934) (53574) 16.2 On Time Liabilities Assets (40,828) (45,959) (52381) ASSETS 17. Cash in Pakistan 26,414 30,415 36432 18. Balances with SBP 124,883 140,077 151406 19. Other Balances 27,268 31,306 36762 32,831 28,686 30444 20. Money at Call and Short Notice in Pakistan 21. 17+18+19+20 as % of 10 14.2 13.0 12.0 FOREIGN CURRENCY 22. Foreign Currency held in Pakistan 5,003 5,435 4806 23. Balances with Banks Abroad 89,416 68,578 60976 24. Total Foreign Currency 94,419 74,013 65782 BANK CREDIT ADVANCES 25. To Banks 1,626 253 63 26. To Others 894,524 988,572 1258022 27. Total Advances 896,150 988,825 1258085 28. Bills Purchased and Discounted 75,588 80,687 99924 29. Total Bank Credit 971,738 1,069,512 1358009 30. 29 as % of 10 65.3 60.4 63.3 INVESTMENT IN SECURITIES AND SHARES 31. Central Government Securities 154,292 191,709 240842 32. Provincial Government Securities 1,728 1,234 77 33. Treasury Bills 231,507 412,449 408438 34. Other Investment in Securities & Sahres 83,493 118,234 132026 35. Total Investment in Securities and Shares 471,020 723,626 781,383 36. 35 as % of 10 31.6 40.8 36.4 353,842 * 442162 37. Other Assets 456,377 * 38. Advance Tax Paid 64,270 49,789 53879 39 Fixed Assets 31,812 38,738 46766 40. Total Assets 2,301,032 2,540,004 3003025 41. Excess Reserves (18-16) 51,206 52,184 45451 Figures in the parentheses represent negative sing, * : Contra Items, P : Provisional (Rs million) End March 2007 2008 P 2005 2006 2007 190,652 22,993 (99) (22,894) 1,211,674 70,107 1,304,774 315,414 28,608 0 (28,608) 1,350,011 97,266 1,475,885 484,296 54,796 0 54,796 2,889,589 137,089 3,081,474 430,537 45,472 0 45,472 2,631,817 128,930 2,806,219 561,557 35,910 0 35,910 3,139,258 163,956 3,339,125 10,756 (1,024) (9,732) 1,231,745 27,288 1,269,789 2,574,563 185,068 6,245 22,243 645,616 3,624,387 127,041 (64,089) (62,952) 25,759 0 (25,759) 1,490,182 34,236 1,550,177 3,026,061 198,725 2,953 172,893 168,011 3,884,057 148,585 72,364 76,221 3,861 0 3,861 512,565 69,786 586,212 3,667,686 269,109 7,015 220,941 136,119 4,785,167 229,338 211,867 17,471 8,775 0 8775 465,880 62,934 537,589 3,343,808 252,056 6,146 135,765 148,762 4,317,075 209,117 193,252 15,864 5,889 0 5,889 474,671 81,119 561,679 3,900,804 234,002 9,781 196,087 200,637 5,102,867 247,899 231,225 16,674 43,462 188,092 49,021 22,166 11.8 48,439 202,501 56,460 232,535 17.8 58,072 307,433 65,656 239,031 18.0 49,615 254,653 49,669 158,854 15.0 63,761 293,274 43,827 199,049 15.0 6,777 116,627 123,404 6,449 93,387 99,836 7,463 170,509 177,972 9,225 151,551 160,776 9,459 106,365 115,825 190 1,680,491 1,680,681 120,480 1,801,161 70.0 0 2,079,056 2,079,056 135,924 2,214,980 73.2 0 2,379,226 2,379,226 145,707 2,524,932 69.0 0 2,276,247 2,276,247 142,268 2,418,515 72.0 0 2,722,452 2,722,452 128,439 2,850,891 73.0 173,788 77 415,016 140,453 729,334 28.3 563,552 42,386 61,809 3,624,387 61,051 177,860 77 411,691 165,598 755,227 25.0 195,096 6,423 72,560 3,884,057 53,916 174,425 166,260 184,250 76 76 76 655,921 539,777 598,507 235,330 186,058 287,226 1,065,753 892,171 1,070,059 29.0 27.0 27.0 211,141 204,508 251,006 8,144 7,866 16,300 127,031 120,447 198,876 4,785,167 4,317,075 5,102,867 78,095 45,536 45,375 Source: State Bank of Pakistan Note : Effective 22 July 2006, demand & time deposits have been re-classified in accordance with BSD circular no. 9 2006 dated 18 July 2006. the time deposits of less than 6 months are included in demand deposits for for the prupose of CRR & SLR - Definition of time & demand liabilites as mentioned in BSD circular no 9 dated 18 July 2008 have been revised. As per new definition, time liabilities will included deposits with tenor of one year nad above. Accordingly, time deposits with tenor of less of than one year will become part of demand deposits. TABLE 5.4 INCOME VELOCITY OF MONEY End June Stock Naroow Money M1 Monetary Assets (M2) (Rs million) Growth Percentage (Rs billion) Income Velocity of Monetary Assets (M2) 1980-81 1981-82 1982-83 1983-84 1984-85 1985-86 1986-87 1987-88 1988-89 1989-90 1990-91 1991-92 1992-93 1993-94 1994-95 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 1999-2000 73.56 80.93 96.54 103.45 118.97 134.83 159.63 185.08 206.36 240.16 265.14 302.91 327.82 358.77 423.14 448.01 443.55 480.33 643.04 739.03 104.62 116.51 146.03 163.27 183.91 211.11 240.02 269.51 290.46 341.25 400.64 505.57 595.39 703.40 824.73 938.68 1,053.23 1,206.32 1,280.55 1,400.63 13.2 11.4 25.3 11.8 12.6 14.8 13.7 12.3 7.8 17.5 17.4 26.2 17.8 18.1 17.2 13.8 12.2 14.5 6.2 9.4 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.3 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.5 2.3 2.4 2.7 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 End March 2006-07 2007-08 P:Provisonal Explanatory Note: 1275.6 1494.14 1797.36 2174.74 2512.21 2720.68 3155.63 1,526.04 1,751.88 2,078.48 2,485.49 2,960.64 3,406.91 4,065.16 9.0 14.8 18.6 19.6 19.1 15.1 19.3 2.6 2.5 2.3 2.3 2.4 2.1 2.0 3,788.70 4,408.09 11.2 8.4 Source: State Bank of Pakistan a: It may be noted that data series of M1 from 2000-01 is not comparable as compilation of M1 based on weekly data has been discontinued by the SBP. Now M1 is being compiled on the basis of monthly returns and will be reported in the monthly statistical Bulletin of the SBP beginning from April 2008 in its table 2.1 b: The stock data of M2 has been revised since June 2002 due to treatment of privatization commission deposits with NBP as government deposits. These deposits were previously uncluded in private sector deposits which have now being included in government deposits. TABLE 5.5 LIST OF DOMESTIC, FOREIGN BANKS AND DFIs (As on 30-04-2008) Public Sector Commercial Banks 1 First Women Bank Ltd. 2 National Bank of Pakistan 3 The Bank of Khyber 4 The Bank of Punjab Specialized Scheduled Banks 1 Industrial Development Bank of Pakistan 2 The Punjab Provincial Co-operative Bank 3 SME Bank Limited 4 Zarai Taraqiati Bank Limited Private Local Banks 1 Allied Bank Limited 2 Askari Bank Limited 3 Bank Al Falah Limited 4 Bank Al Habib Limited 5 My Bank Limited 6 Creacent Commercial Bank Limited 7 NIB Bank Limited 8 Faysal Bank Limited 9 Habib Bank Limited 10 KASB Bank Limited 11 MCB Bank Limited 12 Meezan Bank Limited 13 Atlas Bank Limited 14 Saudi Pak Commercial Bank Limited 15 Soneri Bank Limited 16 United Bank Limited 17 Arif Habib Bank Limited 18 Dubai Islamic Bank Pakistan Limited 19 Bank Islami Pakistan Limited 20 21 22 23 24 25 ABN AMRO Bank Pakistan Limited Habib Metropolitan Bank Limited JS Bank Limited Standard Chartered Bank (Pakistan) Limited Emirates Global Islamic Bank Dawood Islamic Bank Limited Foreign Banks 1 Al-Baraka Islamic Bank B.S.C. (E.C.) 2 Citibank N.A. 3 Deutshe Bank A.G. 4 The Hong Kong & Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited 5 Oman International Bank S.A.O.G. 6 The Bank of Tokyo - Mitsubishi UFJ Limited\ Development Financial Institutions 1 House Building Finance Corporation 2 Investment Corporation of Pakistan 3 Pak Kuwait Investment Company of Pakistan (Pvt) Limited 4 Pak Labya Holding Company (Pvt) Limited 5 Pak Oman Investment Company (Pvt) Limited 6 Pakistan Industrial Credit & Investment Corp. Ltd. 7 Saudi Pak Industrial & Agricultural Investment company (Pvt) Limited Micro Finance Banks 1 Khushhali Bank 2 Network Micro Finance Bank Limited 3 The First Micro Finance Bank Limited 4 Rozgar Micro Finance Bank Limited 5 Tameer Micro Finance Bank Limited 6 Pak Oman Micro Finance Bank Limited Source: State Bank of Pakistan and Finance Division. TABLE 5.6 SCHEDULED BANKS IN PAKISTAN (Weighted Average Rates of Return on Advances) (Percent) As at the Precious End of Metal I. INTEREST BEARING 1999 Jun 13.39 (15.57) Dec 11.41 (16.50) 2000 Jun 11.10 (11.81) Dec 11.53 (12.73) 2001 Jun 11.75 (13.87) 2002 Jun 8.10 (8.14) 2003 Jun 12.01 (12.01) 2004 Jun 9.20 (9.20) 2005 Jun 8.51 (8.51) 2006 Jun 11.58 (11.58) 2007 Jun 10.87 (10.87) Dec 11.45 (11.45) II. ISLAMIC MODES OF FINANCING 1999 Jun 11.27 (10.01) Dec 10.91 (16.28) 2000 Jun 10.61 (11.10) Dec 11.24 (11.32) 2001 Jun 11.02 (11.28) 2002 Jun 9.30 (9.50) 2003 Jun 11.43 (11.43) 2004 Jun 10.86 (10.86) 2005 Jun 9.03 (9.03) 2006 Jun 10.66 (10.66) 2007 Jun 12.04 (12.04) Dec 9.70 (9.70) Stock Exchange Securities Merchandise Machinery Real Estate Financial Obligations Others Total Advances* 14.15 (14.16) 13.79 (13.44) 13.76 (13.45) 13.57 (12.82) 13.54 (14.06) 11.27 (11.70) 11.97 (11.82) 6.01 (6.01) 6.86 (8.29) 14.84 (14.09) 11.37 (12.11) 10.36 (10.42) 13.89 (13.91) 14.56 (14.35) 13.67 (13.83) 12.88 (13.68) 13.69 (13.59) 13.12 (13.13) 9.39 (9.67) 6.89 (7.08) 6.09 (6.01) 8.68 (8.51) 10.73 (10.68) 9.82 (9.82) 15.19 (15.18) 14.17 (14.30) 13.15 (13.15) 13.82 (13.74) 13.50 (13.55) 13.56 (13.67) 15.66 (15.68) 11.21 (11.77) 4.59 (4.07) 8.55 (8.55) 11.07 (11.06) 11.09 (11.09) 14.08 (14.49) 13.75 (14.78) 12.23 (13.73) 12.90 (13.62) 12.84 (13.86) 12.72 (12.98) 12.63 (12.86) 9.08 (9.08) 6.68 (6.68) 10.23 (10.23) 12.30 (12.30) 12.85 (12.85) 14.95 (15.13) 13.14 (13.25) 13.65 (14.03) 13.49 (13.56) 13.07 (13.00) 13.88 (13.81) 7.74 (7.66) 7.08 (7.03) 6.76 (6.70) 10.31 (10.31) 11.05 (11.05) 10.02 (10.02) 14.29 (16.11) 14.07 (16.29) 13.34 (13.98) 12.93 (13.36) 12.05 (13.87) 12.47 (13.39) 10.66 (11.49) 9.04 (9.05) 8.86 (9.02) 9.59 (9.99) 10.76 (10.81) 11.93 (11.98) 14.47 (14.88) 14.09 (14.75) 13.25 (13.77) 13.08 (13.58) 13.07 (13.64) 13.00 (13.29) 11.87 (12.35) 8.41 (8.54) 7.01 (7.01) 9.71 (9.66) 11.25 (11.30) 11.64 (11.66) 15.69 (15.39) 14.42 (14.51) 13.12 (13.48) 13.51 (13.68) 13.47 (13.57) 13.09 (13.33) 5.92 (5.77) 4.86 (5.28) 7.15 (7.17) 10.03 (10.20) 11.26 (11.34) 11.27 (11.41) 15.12 (15.03) 14.82 (14.68) 13.48 (14.07) 13.54 14.01 13.39 (13.88) 12.85 (12.73) 7.50 (7.95) 5.73 (5.96) 7.93 (7.95) 9.63 (9.66) 10.11 (10.03) 10.26 (10.23) 15.75 (15.92) 15.41 (15.45) 14.31 (14.39) 14.48 (14.53) 14.53 (14.42) 13.70 (13.81) 9.39 (9.54) 6.61 (6.81) 7.80 (7.88) 9.14 (9.20) 10.80 (10.84) 10.76 (10.82) 13.76 (14.92) 13.57 (14.84) 13.08 (14.39) 12.97 (14.24) 13.31 (14.52) 13.47 (14.05) 11.47 (12.08) 9.27 (9.68) 10.16 (10.22) 11.23 (11.26) 11.92 (11.92) 11.80 (11.79) 14.49 (14.57) 13.89 (13.86) 13.42 (13.40) 13.15 (13.09) 13.84 (13.86) 13.32 (13.22) 7.79 (8.62) 5.88 (5.82) 8.21 (8.19) 9.25 (9.25) 10.43 (10.49) 10.58 (10.62) 15.00 (15.87) 14.74 (15.82) 13.83 (14.94) 14.07 (15.09) 14.03 (14.78) 13.32 (14.00) 10.31 (10.84) 8.34 (9.01) 10.15 (10.67) 12.37 (12.90) 13.02 (13.40) 12.93 (13.26) 14.82 (15.23) 14.49 (14.96) 13.54 (14.27) 13.59 (14.24) 13.65 (14.24) 13.20 (13.52) 9.19 (9.71) 7.19 (7.60) 8.94 (9.13) 10.68 (10.83) 11.57 (11.68) 11.55 (11.65) Source: State Bank of Pakistan * Weighted average rates shown in parentheses represent Private Sector. TABLE 5.7 SALE OF GOVERNMENT SECURITIES THROUGH AUCTION (Rs Million) Fiscal Year/ Securities 1993-94 MARKET TREASURY BILLS* A. Three Months Maturity Amount Offered í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Amount Accepted í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Weighted Average Yield Accepted í) Minimum % p.a. íi) Maximum % p.a. B. Six Months Maturity Amount Offered í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Amount Accepted í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Weighted Average Yield Accepted í) Minimum % p.a. íi) Maximum % p.a. C. Twelve Months Maturity Amount Offered í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Amount Accepted í) Face Value íi) Discounted Value Weighted Average Yield Accepted í) Minimum % p.a. íi) Maximum % p.a. 2 Pakistan Investment Bonds(PIBs)** A. Amount Offered 03 Years Maturities 05 Years Maturities 10 Years Maturities B. Amount Accepted a) 3 Years Maturities i) Amount Acepted(Face Val ii) Weighted average Yield # a) Minimum % p.a. b) Maximum % p.a. b) 5 Years Maturities i) Amount Acepted(Face Val ii) Weighted average Yield # a) Minimum % p.a. b) Maximum % p.a. c) 10 Years Maturities i) Amount Acepted(Face Val ii) Weighted average Yield # a) Minimum % p.a. b) Maximum % p.a. Note *: MTBs was introduced in 1998-99 **: PIBs was introduced in 2000-01 1994-95 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 1999-2000 2000-01 - - - - 147,735 143,719 82,245 80,670 107,720 105,147 - - - - 45,985 44,893 21,085 20,725 72,720 70,984 - - - - 6.660 14.616 6.931 8.958 6.849 12.221 - - - - 343,937 322,564 205,980 197,165 115,753 109,916 - - - - 102,669 96,161 85,515 81,909 69,538 66,066 - - - - 10.599 15.740 7.092 10.355 7.138 12.876 - - - - 283,038 247,934 181,014 164,416 75,122 67,584 - - - - 78,960 69,148 51,200 46,514 54,017 48,431 - - - - 10.098 16.000 7.584 10.871 7.777 12.935 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 12.427 12.486 - - - - - - 5,317 - - - - - - 12.946 13.000 - - - - - - 36,129 - - - - - - 13.955 14.004 (Contd.) 58,814 8,534 6,674 43,606 46,123 4677 Table 5.7 SALE OF GOVERNMENT SECURITIES THROUGH AUCTION No. 1 A B C Note Securities 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 (Rs. million) July-March 2007-08 Market Treasury Bills Three Month Maturity Amount Offered i) Face value ii) Discounted value 128,358 125,693 109,106 108,332 216,637 214,315 1,011,659 1,002,708 389,173 382,026 186,652 183,039 49,625 48,596 Amount Accepted i) Face value ii) Discounted value 72,862 71,429 29,231 29,042 115,575 115,174 724,359 716,768 210,541 206,768 136,102 133,484 45,225 44,288 Weighted Average Yield i) Minimum % p.a. ii) Maximum % p.a. 5.362 12.150 1.658 5.815 0.995 1.702 2.017 7.479 7.549 8.326 8.315 8.689 8.687 9.548 Six Month Maturity Amount Offered i) Face value ii) Discounted value 287,853 276,882 747,018 731,354 328,990 326,114 470,885 460,185 182,112 173,289 125,483 120,197 64,325 61,426 Amount Accepted i) Face value ii) Discounted value 163,665 157,934 349,009 341,225 158,430 157,256 256,914 251,166 69,752 67,094 90,433 86,629 56,395 53,867 Weighted Average Yield i) Minimum % p.a. ii) Maximum % p.a. 5.645 12.555 1.639 12.404 1.212 2.076 2.523 7.945 7.968 8.487 8.485 8.902 8.902 9.822 Twelve Month Maturity Amount Offered i) Face value ii) Discounted value 202,984 187,339 695,425 665,337 476,719 466,729 136,713 128,569 555,757 509,202 787,636 717,951 568,790 516,955 Amount Accepted i) Face value ii) Discounted value 84,568 78,444 264,938 253,908 241,019 236,421 70,688 65,799 459,440 422,647 661,786 607,211 393,605 359,740 Weighted Average Yield i) Minimum % p.a. ii) Maximum % p.a. 6.383 11.984 2.356 6.941 1.396 2.187 2.691 8.401 8.456 8.791 8.786 9.160 9.159 10.124 (Contd.) *: MTBs was introduced in 1998-99 **: PIBs was introduced in 2000-01 Table 5.7 SALE OF GOVERNMENT SECURITIES THROUGH AUCTION (Rs. in million) No. Securities 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 July-March 2007-08 2 Pakistan Investment Bond A. Amount Offered 03 Years Maturity 05 Years Maturity 10 Years Maturity 15 Years Maturity 20 Years Maturity 30 Years Maturity 238,360 46,124 47,346 144,890 - 211,963 26,074 45,620 140,268 - 221,291 38,514 58,840 93,041 14,316 16,579 - 8,016 2,400 2,603 3,013 0 0 - 16,012 3,896 6,526 5,590 0 0 - 199017 36982 39799 65986 12750 20200 23300 133,052 11,044 21,177 58,805 14,876 9,550 17600 B. Amount Accepted 107,695 74,848 107,658 771 10,161 87867 68,818 24,819 9,651 14,533 100 2,846 10882 4,953 8.356 12.475 1.792 7.952 3.734 4.235 0.000 0.000 9.158 9.389 9.311 9.778 9.619 10.604 24,382 14,369 27,765 427 4,075 10174 10,777 9.392 12.994 3.119 8.887 4.867 5.270 0.000 0.000 9.420 9.646 9.528 10.002 9.796 10.800 58,194 50,828 51,606 244 3,240 30211 23,038 10.420 13.981 4.014 9.587 6.168 7.127 0.000 0.000 9.8005 9.8454 10.106 10.507 10.179 11.434 - - 6,996 0 - 9250 7,801 - - 7.683 8.994 0.000 0.000 - 10.85 11.058 11.103 11.868 (a) 03 Years Maturity. (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. (a) 05 Years Maturity. (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. (a) 10 Years Maturity. (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. (a) 15 Years Maturity. * (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. Note (a) 20 Years Maturity. * (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. - - 6,757 0 - 11250 7,850 - - 8.706 8.993 0.000 0.000 - 11.173 11.392 11.375 11.998 (a) 30 Years Maturity. (i) Amount Accepted (ii) Weighted Average Yield # (1) Minimum % p.a. (2) Maximum % p.a. 16100 14400 - - - - - 11.546 11.680 11.588 12.239 *: MTBs was introduced in 1998-99 **: PIBs was introduced in 2000-01