Reverse Charge under Service tax Section 68(2) of Finance Act, 1994 Read with Notification no. 30/2012 - ST Reverse Charge Mechanism Reverse Charge Mechanism Full reverse charge mechanism The entire service tax liability is on the service recipient Partial reverse charge mechanism Sharing of service tax liability by service provider and service recipient Services under Full Reverse Charge Mechanism 1. Insurance Agents Services 2. Goods Transport Agency Services 3. Sponsorship Services 4. Legal Services 5. Support Services by government or local authority 6. Director Services 7. Import of Services Services under Partial Reverse Charge Mechanism 1. Rent - a - Cab Services 2. Manpower supply services 3. Works Contract Services Full Reverse Charge Mechanism 1. Insurance Agent Services Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Insurance Agent Services Taxable services are provided by Insurance agent to any person carrying insurance business The word used is any person carrying insurance business (Not necessarily insurance company, but IRDA, accepts registration for running insurance business only for companies) Actually, Services are provided by insurance agent to insurance company but not by insurance agent to insured i.e. client Full Reverse Charge Mechanism 2. Goods Transport Agency Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services GTA means any person who provides services in relation to transportation of goods by road and issues consignment note by whatever name called. Service tax is payable by Consignor or Consignee, who is paying freight or is responsible for paying freight Generally services in relation to transportation of goods by road is specified in negative list but it excludes Goods transport agency services & accordingly GTA Services are taxable Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services But such consignor or consignee should be • Any Factory registered under Factories Act •Company established under companies Act •Corporation established by or under any law •Any Society or Cooperative society •Any dealer of excisable goods •Any body corporate •Any partnership firm (includes AOP, BOI, LLP) Therefore for the case of an individual/unregistered firm/HUF/ Governmental agency that are not covered by the above, the GTA would be liable to discharge the service tax Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services Whether following are covered? 1) A truck owner transporting goods directly without involvement of goods transporting agency Not Covered 2) A manufacturer transporting goods to there dealer through their own transportation. Not Covered 3) Transportation on bullock cart, Tonga, rickshaw, etc Not Covered 4) Farmers transporting goods fellow farmers after harvest from farm to sugar mill. Not Covered Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration DELTA Ltd. a Company, registered under the Companies Act is transporting goods to an Individual Y, on “To Pay” basis. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since the consignor is a Company (i.e. falling under the specified category), the liability is on Consignor or consignee, paying the freight i.e. “Y”, notwithstanding that he is an individual. But “Y” would request DELTA Ltd. to pay service tax. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration DELTA Ltd. a Company, registered under the Companies Act is transporting goods to an Individual Y, on payment of freight. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since the consignor is a Company (i.e. falling under specified category), the liability is on Consignor (or) Consignee, paying the freight i.e. DELTA Ltd. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration Y – an individual is transporting goods to a company, DELTA Ltd. on payment of freight. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since the consignee is a Company (i.e. falling under specified category), the liability is on Consignor (or) consignee, paying the freight i.e. “Y”, notwithstanding that he is an individual. But “Y” requests DELTA Ltd. to pay service tax Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration DELTA Ltd. an individual is transporting goods to a company, “X” on “To pay” basis. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since the consignee is a Company (i.e. falling under specified category), the liability is on the person paying the freight i.e. X Ltd. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration DELTA Ltd. a Company based in Chennai, has its consignment Agent at Delhi. The Company transports goods to him, on “To Pay” basis. The Transport Agency raises the bill in the name of DELTA Ltd., but the freight is paid by the consignment agent, directly to the GTA. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? In as much as the bills are raised against DELTA Ltd, the consignment agent is paying the freight, only on behalf of DELTA Ltd. In other words, company is paying the freight, through the consignment agent. As such, the liability for payment of Service Tax is on DELTA Ltd. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration DELTA Ltd., a Company sells the goods to “Y”. The freight for the movement of the goods has been paid by company. It collects this freight from “Y”, by showing it in the invoice, which is paid by “Y”, to company. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since this is a case of pure sale, DELTA Ltd. cannot be said to be paying the freight on behalf of “Y”. DELTA Ltd. is only getting reimbursement of the freight paid by him, initially. As such, the liability for payment of Service Tax will only be on DELTA Ltd. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Illustration “X”, an individual is transporting goods to another Individual, “Y”. Who is liable for payment of Service Tax? Since, both the consignor and the consignee are not falling under the specified categories, the liability is on the Goods Transport Agency. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Exemptions Transportation of the following goods by a goods transport agency have been exempted from service tax: 1. The following essential goods • Agriculture produce • Foodstuff including flours, tea, coffee, jaggery, sugar, milk products, salt and edible oil, excluding alcoholic beverages. • Chemical fertilizer and oil cakes • Newspapers or magazines registered with the registrar of newspapers • Relief materials meant for victims of natural or man-made disasters, calamities, accidents or mishap • Defence or military equipments Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Exemptions Transportation of the following goods by a goods transport agency have been exempted from service tax: 2. Goods where gross amount charged for the transportation of goods on a consignment transported in a single goods carriage does not exceed `1,500 (i.e. total freight charged does not exceed 1,500) 3. Goods, where gross amount charged for transportation of all such goods for a single consignee does not exceed ` 750 (i.e. there will be goods of other consignees) Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services – Exemptions (Illustration) Raj transports his goods in a goods carriage. No other goods are loaded in the goods carriage. Raj pays a freight of Rs.1300. Raj transports his goods in a goods carriage. He pays a freight of Rs.1300. Some other goods are also being transported in the same goods carriage, involving a freight of Rs.500. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services – Exemptions (Illustration) Consignor Consignee Freight Eligibility for Exemption Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Goods Transport Agency Services - Abatement Transportation of the following goods by a goods transport agency have been exempted from service tax: 1. The following essential goods • Agriculture produce • Foodstuff including flours, tea, coffee, jaggery, sugar, milk products, salt and edible oil, excluding alcoholic beverages. • Chemical fertilizer and oil cakes • Newspapers or magazines registered with the registrar of newspapers • Relief materials meant for victims of natural or man-made disasters, calamities, accidents or mishap • Defence or military equipments Full Reverse Charge Mechanism 3. Sponsorship Services Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service In case of sponsorship service provided or agreed to be provided by way of sponsorship to any body corporate or partnership firm located in taxable territory receiving the service is liable – Notification no. 30/2012 Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service - Illustration Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service - Illustration Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service – Exemption Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service – Exemption The following Services by way of sponsorship of tournaments or championships organised are exempted: (a) By a national sports federation, or its affiliated federations, where the participating teams or individuals represent any district, state or zone (b)By association of Indian universities, Inter university sports board, school games federation of India, All India sports council for the deaf, paralympic committee of India or special Olympics bharat (c) By central civil services cultural and sports board (d)As part of national games, by Indian Olympic Association (e)Under panchayat yuva kreeda aur khel abhiyaan (PYKKA) Scheme. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service – Exemption Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service What if receiver of service is not body corporate or partnership firm What if receiver of service is a body corporate or firm and is not located in taxable terriotry Advertising Services – It is not covered in reverse charge, but discussed here Negative list – Entry (g) of Sec. 66D Selling of space or time slots for advertisements other than advertisements broadcast by radio or television. ‘Advertisement’ MENAS any form of presentation for promotion of, or bringing awareness about, any event, idea, immovable property, person, service, goods or actionable claim through newspaper, television, radio or any other means but does not include any presentation made in person Advertisement is not specified in negative list but sale of space or time for advertisement is specified and hence, it is not taxable Advertising Services – What is sale of space or time for advertisement? Sale of time for advertisement in television Sale of time for advertisement in Cinema Sale of Space for advertisement – Publicity in internet Sale of Space for advertisement Hoardings Advertising Services – Question Hour? Activity Sale of space for advertisement in print media. Sale of space or time for advertisement to be broadcast on radio or television. Sale of time slot by a broadcasting organization. Sale of space for advertisement in bill boards public places, buildings, conveyances, cell phones, automated teller machines, and internet. Aerial advertising. Making or preparing advertisements (i.e. Designing) Commissions received by advertisement agencies from the broadcasting or publishing companies for facilitating business. Canvassing advertisement for publishing on a commission basis. Taxable / Not taxable Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Sponsorship Service What if Sponsorship Service is converted into advertisement service. In that case there is no reverse charge and the person receiving the amount (Service provider) can claim the amount as for sale of space for advertisement. There will be no service tax on service provider also. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism 4. Legal Services Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services - Illustration Harish salve, leading advocate Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services Legal Services provided by Advocate or Advocate firms to business entity having turnover exceeding 10 lakhs per annum, located in taxable territory is covered under reverse charge mechanism and the business entity is liable to pay entire service tax. Business entity means ANY PERSON ordinarily carrying out any activity relating to industry, commerce or any other business or profession. Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services - Exemptions The following services are exempted. Services provided by an individual as an advocate or a partnership firm of advocates by way of legal services to (i) An advocate or partnership firm of advocates providing legal services (or) (ii) A person other than business entity (iii) Business entity with a turnover upto 10 lakhs in the preceding financial year Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services - Illustration Service Provider Individual Advocate Individual Advocate Individual Advocate Service Recipient Individual Individual Advocate Business Entity (Turnover during PY ≤ 10 lakhs) Individual advocate Business Entity (Turnover during PY > 10 lakhs) Individual Advocate Firm of advocates Taxability Exempted Exempted Exempted Taxable (SR liable to pay) Exempted Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services - Illustration Service Provider Firm of advocates Firm of advocates Firm of advocates Firm of advocates Firm of advocates Service Recipient Individual Individual Advocate Business Entity (Turnover during PY ≤ 10 lakhs) Business Entity (Turnover during PY > 10 lakhs) Firm of advocates Taxability Exempted Exempted Exempted Taxable (SR liable to pay) Exempted Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Legal Services - Illustration Service Provider Advocates practicing as company Advocates practicing as company Advocates practicing as company Advocates practicing as company Advocates practicing as company Service Recipient Individual Taxability Taxable (SP liable to pay) Individual Advocate Taxable (SP liable to pay) Business Entity Taxable (SP (Turnover during PY ≤ 10 lakhs) liable to pay) Business Entity Taxable (SP (Turnover during PY > 10 lakhs) liable to pay) Firm of advocates Taxable (SP liable to pay) Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Support Services In case of support services provided by government or local authority to business entity in taxable territory, the business entity is liable to discharge the service tax liability on full taxable value. In respect of the following services, government or local authority is liable to pay service tax but not the business entity 1. Renting of immovable property 2. Speed post, express parcel post, life insurance and agency services provided by department of post 3. Service in relation to aircraft or a vessel, inside or outside the precincts of a port or airport by government 4. Transport of goods or passengers by government Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Support Services - Illustrations Infrastructural services Logistics and marketing Advertisement and promotion Construction or works contract Renting of immovable property Security Testing and analysis Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Directors Services to company Services of director to company is covered under the provisions of reverse charge by amending noti. 30/2012 w.e.f 7/8/2012 and remuneration to directors is as follows: Service Provider - Director (Service Tax liability= 0%) Service Recipient - Company (Service Tax liability = 100%) Director INCLUDES Non-executive, Nominee, Public interest and Independent directors Director DOES NOT INCLUDE Managing Director, Whole time director and Executive director, who are in full time employment of the company (Therefore no service tax as it is contract of service). Full Reverse Charge Mechanism – Directors Services to company Remuneration INCLUDES sitting fees, travelling expenses and incidental expenses for attending the meetings of Board and their committees and commission or other remuneration paid. Remuneration DOES NOT INCLUDE travelling expenses other than for board meetings and committee meetings. Service tax should be paid @12.36% on gross value of services and not by back calculations. Service tax should be computed on the amount of remuneration and TDS should be calculated on the same amount but not after including service tax. Details in Invoice under RCM Governing Rule: Rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules 1994. Invoice shall indicate the name, address and the registration number of the service provider and person receiving taxable service; the description and value of taxable service provided or agreed to be provided; and the service tax payable thereon. As per clause (iv) of sub-rule (1) of the said rule 4A "the service tax payable” thereon' has to be indicated. The service tax payable would include service tax payable by the service provider. Service tax Vs. TDS CBDT vide Cir. 1/2014 clarified that no TDS is required to be made on service tax component, if service tax is shown separately in invoice. TVS Motor Co. Ltd. V CCE (2012) (CESTAT) - Service tax is payable on amount inclusive of income tax TDS Example: Professional services by Mr. A to Mr. B is ₹1,00,000. Service tax payable @ 12.36% is ₹12,360 Invoice by Mr. A to Mr. B = ₹1,12,360 TDS @ 10% should be calculated on ₹1,00,000 but not ₹1,12,360 Payment made by Mr. B to Mr. A = ₹1,02,360 Service tax payable to Govt. is ₹ 12,360 but not on ₹ 1,02,360 (Reverse working should not be done) Service tax Vs. TDS – In case of reverse Charge In case of reverse charge the service recipient has to pay service tax and at the same time has to deduct TDS on the payment made by him to service provider. There was confusion till 2014 as to whether TDS should be calculated on the amount including service tax as service tax is paid by the service recipient. But CBDT vide its circular no. 1/2014 dated 6.1.2014 has clarified that while computing TDS, service tax element should be excluded as service tax is not the income part but is a statutory liability. Service provider under reverse charge will raise invoice only on the service portion excluding service tax and service recipient has to calculate service tax as well as TDS on the same amount and pay to the respective authorities accordingly. Even if service provider charges in his invoice only his part of service tax (in case of partial reverse charge), TDS should be computed only that service value excluding the part amount of service tax. Case 1 Where Service Tax has been charged fully in Invoice Expense A/c Dr Service Tax Input Credit A/c Dr Service Tax Deferred Input A/c Dr To Vendor A/c To TDS Payable A/c To Service Tax Payable A/c - Reverse Charge Case 2 Where Service Tax has not been charged in Invoice Expense A/c Dr Service Tax Deferred Input A/c Dr To Vendor A/c To TDS Payable A/c To Service Tax Payable A/c - Reverse Charge Debit 100.00 7.42 4.94 112.36 100.00 12.36 112.36 Credit 105.42 2.00 4.94 112.36 97.75 2.25 12.36 112.36 Case 3 In case of Abatement ( e.g. 40%) Expense A/c Dr Service Tax Input Credit A/c Dr To Vendor A/c To TDS Payable A/c To Service Tax Payable A/c - Reverse Charge Debit 100.00 4.94 104.94 Credit 98.00 2.00 4.94 104.94 Important Points relating to RCM Cenvat can not be availed for discharging the ST Liabilities on RCM ST Paid under RCM can be utilize towards the discharge ST on output services Threshold exemption of upto Rs.10 Lac is not applicable here in RCM except Legal services Allowed Refund of unutilized cenvat credit availed from input services as per Rule 5B of Central Exice Rules,2004 Partial - Reverse Charge Mechanism PARTIAL REVERSE CHARGE MECHANISM Concept Joint charge mechanism means a mechanism where the 'Service recipient’ is also made liable to pay service tax on a specified percentage of the service along with the ‘Service provider’ instead of the 'Service provider’ being liable for the entire liability payment. • The Notification 30/2012-ST Dated 20 June 2012, specifies the services on which joint charge mechanism is applicable and the proportion in which the 'Service recipient’ of services is liable to pay the service tax. • Joint charge mechanism is applicable when service provided by a non- corporate service provider to a corporate business entity. Basic Condition in Partial RCM Service Provider Individual HUF Partnership Firm AOP BOI LLP Service Receiver Business entity registered as body corporate He should be located in taxable territory PARTIAL REVERSE CHARGE MECHANISM Points to be Remembered CENVAT Credit: • Cenvat credit of the tax paid can be availed on the part of service tax paid even • • • by the service recipient. (If other rules are satisfied) However, liability under Reverse Charge cannot be paid through CENVAT Valuation: Service recipient can opt for separate method of valuation than service provider. Liability: Service recipient has to pay his liability in all circumstances and the benefit of small service provider exemption is not available. PARTIAL - REVERSE CHARGE MECHANISM List of Services Sr. No. Description of Service Percentage of service tax payable by the recipient of services Remarks 1 Rent-a-Cab service when not under abatement scheme and service receiver is not a ‘Renta-Cab’ operator. 40% The said body corporate is only liable to the extent of 40% and on balance 60% Rent-a-Cab operator will collect and pay the said liability. In case of abatement An abatement is available under Notification no. 26/2012 for renting of motor vehicle designed to carry passengers to the extent of 60% 100% However, if the service receiver and provider are both in the business of providing ‘Rent-a-Cab’ service then the reverse mechanism wouldn’t apply. PARTIAL - REVERSE CHARGE MECHANISM List of Services Sr. No. Description of Service 2 • Manpower supply service 75% provided or agreed to be provided for any purpose • Security Service 3 Percentage of service tax payable by the recipient of services 75% Service portion in Works 50% Contract Service which is provided by (a) Individual (b) HUF (c) Partnership Firm (d) AOP located in taxable territory to a business entity registered as body corporate located in taxable category Remarks Any person receiving such manpower or security service is required to pay service tax to the extent of 75% and balance 25% will be required to be paid by person providing such manpower. Any person receiving such services being a body corporate would have to pay tax @ 50% of the taxable tax. RENT-A-CAB SERVICE In Nutshell Renting of Motor Vehicle If abatement of 60% claimed S.R. is liable to pay @ 4.944% S.P. is not liable to pay any tax If abatement not claimed S.R. is liable to pay @ 4.944% S.P. is not liable to pay @ 7.416% WORKS CONTRACT SERVICE In Nutshell Original Works Works Contract of Movables Any other WC for Immovables Taxable Amount 40% = 4.944% effective rate Taxable Amount 70% = 8.652% effective rate Taxable Amount 60% = 7.416% ST = 40% x 12.36% X 50% = 2.472% ST = 70% x 12.36% X 50% = 4.326% ST = 60% x 12.36% X 50% = 3.708% REVERSE CHARGE MECHANISM Accounting Treatment Case 1: Partial Reverse Charge Debit Credit Expense A/c Dr. 100.00 - Service Tax Input Credit A/c Dr. 7.42 - Service Tax Deferred Input A/c Dr. 4.94 - To Vendor A/c - 105.42 To TDS Payable A/c - 2.00 To Service Tax Payable A/c - Reverse Charge - 4.94 112.36 112.36 Case 2: Full Reverse Charge Expense A/c Dr. 100.00 - Service Tax Deferred Input A/c Dr. 12.36 - To Vendor A/c - 97.75 To TDS Payable A/c - 2.25 To Service Tax Payable A/c - Reverse Charge - 12.36 112.36 112.36 Principle of Mutuality - Meaning, Exceptions & Exemptions: Meaning: As per this principle, there must be two parties for levy of service tax i.e. service must be provided by one person to another person. Exceptions [Explanation 3 to Sec. 65B(44)]: An establishment of a person located in taxable territory and another establishment of such person located in non-taxable territory are treated as establishments of distinct persons. An unincorporated association or body of persons and members thereof are also treated as distinct persons. Principle of Mutuality - Meaning, Exceptions & Exemptions: Exemptions [Notification no. 25/2012]: Service by an registered, unincorporated body or a non- profit entity, to its own members by way of reimbursement of charges or share of contribution– 1. As a trade union; 2. For the provision of carrying out any activity which is exempt from the levy of service tax; or 3. Up to an amount of ₹5,000 per month per member for sourcing of goods or services from a third person for the common use of its members in a housing society or a residential complex [i.e. Resident Welfare Association (RWA)] Principle of Mutuality - Meaning, Exceptions & Exemptions: Circular No. 175/1/2014 (dated: 10/1/14) If per month, per member contribution exceeds ₹ 5,000, the entire contribution would be ineligible for contribution and service tax would be leviable. Small Service Provider exemption under Notification no. 33/2012 is applicable to RWA. RWA incurring expenses viz. electricity bill, telephone bill on behalf of members is excluded as per rule 5(1) of valuation Rules, 2006 for determining the value of taxable services of RWA RWA can avail CENVAT credit in terms of CENVAT credit rules, 2004