Repiinled from: ESTUAkmNE RSEXPCH. VOL. I1 G e o l o g y o n d Engineering 01975 ACADEMIC PRESS, I N C New York S-n FronrLco Londm TIDE Ah?) FAIR-WEATHER WIND EFFECTS IN A BAR-BUILT LOUISIANA ESTUARY ABSTRACT An in-depth, fair-weather, field study in July 1972 provided informtion about the response of the water level of Caminada Bay, an extremely shallow, bar-bullt Louisiana estuary. The water surface elevation was recorded at three locations il the bay along the other parameters, an equipotentid surface was established, and the time-dependent variations of a dope vector along the surface gradient were computed. It was found that the instantaneous fair-weather wind stress induced a slowly oscillating set-up around a time-averaged slope magnitude of 1 . 5 ~ 1 0 rad. - ~ This consrituted less than 50'70 of the measured time-averaged slope. The remaining tirne-averaged dope is accounted for by tidal nonlinearities. The instantaneous slope vector was found to rotate or oscillate in the horizontal plane with a diurnal period. Tidal input through two entrances governed this behavior, w h l e the wind stress and atmospheric pressure gradients served only to modify the direction of the surface slope. In general, on the diurnal scale, tidal rather than wind effects dominate the dynamics of Caminada Bay. However, the mean water level responded to the wind direction on a time-scale longer than one day. Winds p a r d e l rather than normal to the coast controlled the water elevation, indicating an Ekman eifect. INTRODUCTION A series of papers in the 1950's by Pritchard ( l 7 , 1 8 , 19,201 and by Pritcha~d 1. Coasral Studies Institute, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803. R m e n t nddrmr: Department of Geology, University of South Carolina, Columbia, South Camha BJORN K J E R F V E and Kent (21) on coastal plain estuaries lsid the dynamical framework for subsequent, intensive study efforts in various aspects of estuarine circulation and dynamics. Sinularly, the study by LicAlister et. al. (15) and other investigations pointed out the salient, dynamical features of fjord-type estuaries. However, the bar-built estuary, the third major estuarinz type, has received virtually no attention from the point of view of physical oceanography (3). The study by Dyer and Rammoorthy (6) is a noteworthy exception rhou&. Apparently, there is a need for a systematic investigation of the dynamics of bar-built estuaries. This study attempts t o illustrate the relative importance and effect of astronomical tides and fair weather winds on the water surface behavior in a representative, bar-built estuary, Caminada Bay, thus shedding light on the dynamical structure of this type of coastal ernbayment. This is of special interest, as Collier and Hedgpeth (4) and Copeland, Thompson, and Ogletree (5) indicated that the wind effects outweighed tidal effects in controlling the surface dynamics of Laguna hladre, Texas, a bar-built estuary similar to Canlinada Bay. The water surface fluctuations are, of course, intimately tied to the estuaMe velocity structure. Both coastal plain and ijord estuaries are often successfully approximated by a narrow channel, thus simplifying the analytical treatment by removing lateral variations. As bar-built estuaries are often wide, in a relative sense, with more than one opening to the ocean, the channel approximation is no longer valid. Estuarine water surface slopes can be caused and maintained by a number of different factors, t l e most obvious being atmospheric pressure gradient and wind stress. Hellstrllm (lo), Haumitz (9), Keulegan (12), Van Dorn(25), and Kivisild (13) studied wind-induced surface slopes on lakes. Van Dorn and Keulegan indicated that the wind-induced slope should be given by a linear combination of slopes produced by the surface wind shear and a wave effect. However, Saville's (22) measurement of set-up on Lalle Okeechobee during storm conltions were fully accounted for by the wind stress alone, in spite of waves 3 rn high. In view of this result, wind waves were ignored in thls study. The effect of atmospheric pressure gradients on the water surface was measured t o p e comparatively s m l l and will be treated no further. The tide is a long wave and will o f course cause a fall and rise in the water level as well as instantaneous water surface slopes. However, the tide may also maintain time-average surface slopes. Due to spatial variations in current amplitude, C m e r o n and Pritchard (3) showed that a mean surface slope may exist in the absence of wind shear stresses and density gradients. This effect arises from the noulinear terms in the momentum equation. Unoki and IsozA5 (23, 21) used nonlinear current effects to explain the observed mean sea level in Japanese ernbayments, and showed them to be similar to Longuet-Higgins' and Stewart's (14) radiation stress. Qualitatively, the mean surface is raised in regions E S T U A R I N E RESEARCH of antinodes, usually at the head of a bay, and lowered at nodal points. Density p d i e n t s (21) and f d i n g rain drops (2, 25) can both cause mean surface slopes. The Caminada warer density was almost homogeneous and the rain fnll was limited during the study period. Therefore, these effects warrant no further discussion. MEASUREMENTS AND DATA ANALYSIS Study Awa. Caminada Bay is a bar-built estuary, located along the Louisiana coast, 40 km west of the active hlississippi River delta (Fig. 1). It is a portion of the Bxataria basin, separating the ~ c t i v echannel-levee system of the Mississippi River from the abandoned Bayou Lafouiche channel-levee system. The bay, representative Figrue 1. Study sitz: Cmninadi Bay, Louisum, withinstrument locations. 49 BJORN K J E R F V E of the type of estusries found in Louisiana, m e x w e s some 14 by 6 km, and is only on the order of one-meter deep. Surrounded by vast expanses of Sparrim altemiflorn marsh, Caminada Bay is connected to ~djoinuigbays and the Gulf of Mexico via 3 series of openings. The Gulf Coast is a microtidal environment, usually experiencing low marine energy conditions. Still, the land between the Mississippi and Bayou h f o u r c h e is recedmg due to lack of an adequate sediment supply. The fresh-water runuff is largely due to rain falling over the Barataria basin, and because of dry summers, saline ocem waters encroach deep into the lower basin. The Caminada and Gulf of Mexico tide is primarily of the diurnal kind, with a weak semi-diurnal component. Furrhermore, the mean water level fluctuates on a yearly basis with a September peak and a January low. The range of this oscdlation is approximately 26 cm (16). The summer weather encountered in the Caminada Bay area is dominared by the Bermuda High pressure system with a superimposed sea-land breeze circulation and locally generated thunderstorm winds. Hurricanes have struck the area occasionally. The latest direct hr on the Baratalia basin was Hurricane Betsy in 1965. Field Experiment. The field experiment took place duiing a 20-day period in July, 1972, preliminary measurements having been m d e during six days in A u p s t , 1971. The study consisred of recordings of water surface elevation, wind speed and direction, atmospheric pressure, and temperature, along with water temperature and salinity measurements. The duration of the study was chosen to include at least one full fortnightly tidal cycle with a tropic and an equatorial tide. To facilitate presentation of the data, a time scale with ori& at 0000 on July 7, 1972, was defined. The study was concluded at 492 hrs or 1000 on July 27, 1972. All data traces were &@tized wirh a sampling rate of 20 pts/hr and smoothed with a binomial fiter. Stochastic analysis was performed.on the time series t o detect and describe major data features. Auto- and cross-spectra were computed for scalar and horizontal vector time series (81, using the Fast Fourier Transform (1). Water Level Maurements. The water level was continuously recorded at three Caminada locations, stations 1, 2, and 3 (Fig. I), using three capacitance water level gages. A ESTUARINE RESEARCH references datum was established by averaghg the water level records for each station, assunling that the means define an equipotential surface. Rather than using the over-all data traces to compute these means, it was convenient to base the reference surface on the means for a three-day period during the equatorial tide. Tidal nodineanties may then be assumed not to cause time-averaged surface slopes because of the weak currents. The computed means were further corrected for wind stress and pressure gradients. Considerations of gage response, circuit linearity, and errors in the averagng process indcated that absolute slopes greater than 1 . 0 ~ 1 0 - 6rad could accurately be assessed. Wind Measurements and Stress Calculations. The horizontal wind speed and direction were recorded continuously at station 2, 6.77 m above the mean water surface. A supporting study in 1971 established a relationship between the wind speed and the surface shear stress. A highly accurate, six-level anemometer system was then used to measure the wind proffie at station 2. The number of 15-min averaged profiles measured was 386. The extrapolated wind speed range at 6.77 m was from 0 to 10 m/sec. The profdes fo!lowed the logarithmic law closeiy; more than 90% of the protlles had a correlation coefficient in excess of 0.94. By performing linear regression of iogarithmic height above the water on wind speed, the friction velocity, U,, (von &&n2s constant &vided by the regression coefficient) and the extrapolated wind speed, U, at 6.77 m were computed for each proiile. Curvilinear regression of friction velocity on the 6.77 m wind speed yielded (Fig. 2) where U, and U are measured in cmlsec and the linear correlation coefficient is 0.96 (1 1). The surface wind shear stress, 7 ,is related to the friction velocity via where O is air density. Slope Vector Calculations. The set-up or difference in water surface elevation between any two points is a time-dependent parameter of primary importance in this study. As Caminada Bay cannot be assumed to be narrow, it is convenient to consider a two-dimensionai slope vector along the water surface gadient rxther than the scalar set-up. F r i c f i o n Velocity Figure 2. "3. Wind S p e e d Curiliinea least squares fit betvieen friction veiocity, U,, and \ ~ n dspeed at 6.77 rn, U, based on 386 wind piofilcs with a conehtion p e f l i d e n t , I = 0.96. Consider the Caminada water surface t o be a plane and choose a circle located in this plane with its origin at the water surface at station 2. The magnitude of the slope vector is the maximum slope of the water surface at any one time, i.e., a maximized, non-dimensional set-up. The direction of the slope vector is the horizontal angle, counted clockwise from true north to the lowest elevation on the circle periphery. By analyzing the slope vector magnitude and direction time records, the three-dimensional behavior of the water surface can be induced. Of course, the approximztion of the water surface by a plane is necessitated by the use of only three tide gages. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION M a n Sea Level. The smoothed water surface records indicate a greatly elevated mean water ESTUARINE R E S E A R C H level from 50 to 120 hrs and from 250 to 380 hrs at each of the three stations. The record at sration I is presented in Figure 3. The mean water level was then 8 and 24 cm, respectively, above the fdtered value for other times. As the predicted tide 3t Bayou Rigaud (Fig. 3) does not exhibit a sinular increase in the mean elevation during these periods, meteoroiopid rather than astronomical effects cause the surface rise. F i g r e 3. Cornp.uiron betivecn measured water level at station I and piedicted water level at C ~ Y U R U i p u d . A ? l - h r cqwII11y weighted running m a n filter has bcen used lo caniputo the rime-avcmged water level. Thc liltcr tiequcncy response is such t h ~ atn y osdUotion longei than 48 lus is reproduced accurately. The alongshore component of the wind stress (Fig. 4) was most intense during the periods of high mean water. The stress was then from the east, resulting in a large alongshore (55-23S0T) component from a northeasterly direction, leading at peak water level by approximately 20 111s. + 21 Figure 4. Y I H l l STRE55 ? R W 215 OZGREES TRUE Mensllicd w h d stress and direction at station 2 as n function of time. The battom g a p h shows the mess c o ~ n p o n e n t along the coastline. The time-averaged m a p i r u d e and ciirection ii a vector average, using n 24-hr equally weighted running m a n filter. The wind speed varied from 0 to Id rnlsec. According to Ekman (7), the net transport in the wind-influenced surface friction layer is in deep water 90° to the right of the down-wind direction in the northern hemisphere. This resuit is modified in the presence of a coastline and in shallow water with depth less t11m the friction layer. When the wind blows pardlel to the coast with the coast t o the right of the downwind direction, a two-layered circulation may develop perpendicuhr to the c o m , with shore-directed flow in the surface layer and an equal return transport in the bottom layer. Further, a wind regime of this kind will pile up water against the coast, causing sea surface gadients away from the land mass. In Canlinada Bay, ESTUARINE R E S E A R C H the result is an elevated mean water surhce in response t o the intense northeasterly wind stress and the coast31 surface gradients. Consider an average rise of water levels at stations 1, 2, and 3 to be 24 cm in 100 llis (250-350 hrs). Take the surface area of the Bay to be 8 . 4 ~ 1 0m2. ~ This implies that 56 m3 of water was on the average added each second, most likely through Caminada Pass, as water flowing through Barataria Pass must primarily fill Barataria Bay. Caminada Pass has a 3 x 1 0 ~m2 cross-section, implying a cross-sectionally averaged net inflow of 1.9 cm/sec during the rise fof the water surface. Similarly, the level feu 16 cm in the next 30 111s in response to the decreasing ~Vmdstreess. This corresplnds to a 4.3 crnlsec spatially averaged net outflow through Caminada Pass. Both velocities are of reasonable magnitude and compare well wit11 time-averaged current measurements made in Caminada Pass during a 1971 study (26). Water Surface Slopes. The surface slope of Caminada Bay changes both in magnigude and orientation as a function of time. The measured slope vectors are presented for a few days during one equatorial (Fig. 5) and one tropic (Fig. 6) tide. The surface slope gradient rorated anticlockviise 36O0 in 24 hrs during the equatorial tide, whereas it oscillated diurnally 60° to either side of the vectoridy, time-averaged value (180") during the tropic tide. However, both direction records show similar steplke appearances, indicating long periods of constant slope direction followed by rapid direction changes. The two magnitude records are quire similar with pronounced 12-hr oscillations (recitified wavesj, indicating a diurnal period of the slope mapitude. This was supported by diurnal peaks in the power spectra, which were computed for vector time series (1 1). At this point, it became desirable to sinwlate the obsened slope vector behavior with an appropriate analytical model. The momentum equation was integrated vertically, the coriolis and nonlinear field accderation terms were argued to be small in comparison to the retained terms. density was taken to be constant, and the bottom friction was made linear. The resulting set of linear partial differential equations was broken down into two sets of equations: one representing wind response and one governing tide effects. To facilitate the analytical treatment, Cminada Bay was approximted by a rectangular basin, 14x6 krn, with the long axis oriented from southeast to northwest, with a uniform still-water level of 1 m. The horizontal momentum component equations were balanced by an unsteady current term, a slope term, and the wind stress, which was assumed to be much greater than the portion of the bottom friction corresponding to the wind-induced current. As the wind stress was from the southeast (Fig. 4) during LW H R G N i l U O E OF S E T - U P cc ~. , h 0 0 ib8.00 *bo.OD ?;..DO ?i..OO ?...OO HOUR3 Figures. !vleasuied direction and r n a ~ i t u d eof slope vector, 1000 July 14-0113 July 17, 1972, during a n equatorid tide. Tho smooth lines we vectanally :~vernged,2 C h r equally weighted running mcnns. both the tropic and equatorial tides shown in F i s r e s 5 and 6, the stress direction was assumed t o be constant. The spectrum of the stress magnitude indicated a dominant 24-hr peak, which appears as a regular stress oscillation in the record (Fig. 4). The wind stress was therefore simulated, assuming a linear ESTUARINE RESEARCH 5.m " J 123.00 'IJS.ilD ~h5.00 ~k4.00 V63.00 Y?S.OO 185.00 ~ k . 0 0 rkao &s.ao ub5.o~ HOURS g flRGNITUOE OF SET-UP LW So3.m R g u e 6. . r k m .koo ukoo uis.co HOUR3 HW &=.on.. I m s u i e d dlreczion and mgnitude of slope vscror, 2 1 0 0 July 23-0900 July 27, 1972, d k n g r tropic tidc. The srnoorh lincs sre vecroridly averaged, 24-hr c q u d l y weighted running means. combination of a mean (synoptic) and a sinusoiddly varying (sea-land breeze)srress. The mean was 0.18 and 0.11 dyne/crnZ for the e q w t o r i d and tropic tide periods. respectively. The r.m.s. stress was chosen as the amplitude of the oscillatory term. Its value was 0.09 and 0.08 dyne/cmZ for the equatorial and tropic tides, respectively. When combining the horizontal momentum component balancce with the hydrostratic equation and an appropriate mass conservation equation, it was found that the maximum wind-induced volume transporr h g e d 6 111s behind the peak wind stress. Also, as can be expected, the wind-controilcd w ~ t e rsurface maintained a mean slope correspondmg to the m c m stress and oscillated diurnally in response to the sea-land breeze stress. The horizontal momentum component equation for the tide effect were balanced by an unsteady, a slope, and a bottom-friction term. As a first approximation, it was assumed that two two-dimensional tidal waves enter and progress through Caminada Bay at right angles along the long and short w e s of the estuary and reflect perfectly at the inside banks. Physically, the two waves may be thought of as the ridd input t h o u g h Caminada and Barataria passes, respectively. Thc theoretical tidal surface elevations at the three stations were computed by assuming reasonable values for tidal amplitudes at the passes and a phase angle between the two waves. In general, the model was insensitive ro the choice of reasonoble phase anzle. The solutions of surface elevation due to wind and tide effects were added to yield a theoretical distribution of water level in space and time. A simulnted surface slope vector time series was computed for an equatorial (Fig. 7) and a tropic (Fig. 8 ) tide in the same manner that the slopes were computed from the measured surface elevations. The qualitative agreement between the measured and simulated slope vector time series is outstanding for both equatorial (Figs. 5 and 7) and tropic (Figs. 6 and 8) conditions. "7, J, w- e U w -8 %.oa a. oo is.oo ru.m a2.m u0.m us.m HOUR3 b Figure 7. SETUP H R G N I I U O E Simulated slope dircction and magnitude for the equatorid tide, 1000 July 1 4 4 1 1 3 July 17, 1972. A compnrison between the measured and sin~uhtedinstantaneous direction series shows excellent agreement with respect to: (a) 24-hr periodicity; (b) steplke dircction changes every 12 hrs; and (c) general appearance of time series, i.e., one anticlockwise rotation of thc slope vector every 24 lus during the equatorial tide and a 14 hr oscillation in direction during the tropic tide. On the ESTUARINE RESEARCH Figure 8. Sirnuiated slope vector diiection and magmitude for the tropic tide, 2100 July 23-0900 July 27, 1972. negative side, the analytical model does not reproduce the time-averaged slope direction weil. This is probably due t o omission of n o d n e a r effects or the coriolis acceleration (1 i). The ageement between the measured and simulated instantaneous slope magnitudes is also amazing, consideling the simplicity of the model. A 24-hr and a 12-hr period are apparent (visually and in the spectrum) in measured as well as simulated records. T i e measured instantaneous rnagiitude is approximately a factor of 4 greater than the simulated slope. Also, the measured time-averaged slope, 4 x 1 0 . ~ rad, is underestimated by a factor of 4 in the model. This discrepancy may be explained in terms of slopes induced by the neglected nonlinear terms in the momentum equation (3, 11). CONCLUSIONS This study considers the response of the water elevation in a shallow bar-built Louisiana estuary t o tidal and fair-weather wind effects. d s o , water surface slopes were measured and are presented in a novel fashion as a vector time series. I t was found that: (a) Tidal effects dominate the dynamics (rise and fall of the water surface; currents) on the d u r n d time s a l e . (b) F z k v e a t h e r wind effects can cause considerable changes in mean water elevation through an Ekman mechanism on a time scale greater than the diurnal; W O R N KJERFVE winds parallel rather than normal to the coast controlled the mean water level in Caminada Bay. (c) Measured absolute water surface slopes in this microtidal bar-built estuary reached a maximum of 3 x 1 0 . ~rad with 3 mean of 4 x 1 0 . ~rad for the described fair-weather synoptic wind conditions with a superimposed sedand breeze circulation (d) Time series of water surface dopes can be simulated extremely well, using a linear three-dimensional analytical model. (e) The nonlinear field acceleration terms seem to maintain surface slopes greater than wind-induced slopes. (0To model a "wide" estuary, e.g., Caminada Bay, which h3s two major tidal entrances, it is necessary t o allow for lateral mriations; a channel approximation does not produce useful results. ACKNOWLEDGMENT Financial support for this study was provided by the Coastal Studies Insritute, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouse, under contract N00014-69-A-0211-0003, Project NR 388 002, with geography programs of the Office of Naval Research. This research was part of a doctoral dissertation in the Department of Marine Sciences at Louisiana State University. The author is thankful to Drs. S. P. Murray, C. J. Sonu, S. A. Hsu, and to the teclmicims of the Coastal Studies Institute and the Department of Marine Sciences. B e n h t , J. S. and Piersol, A. G. 1971 Random Data: Anxlysis and hleasurement Pmcedures. Wiley-Intcrscience. 390 p. Cadwell, D. R. and Eilioit, W. P. L(2): Surface rtiesses produced by rainfall. J o u . Phys. Oe-., 1971 145-148. Clrncron, W. hi. and Pritcimd, D. W. 1963 Estuaries. In nio Sea. V d . 11, p. 306-324. (ed. Hill, hl. N.) Intcislience Publishers. Collier, A. and IIedppcrh, I. W. 1950 An introduction to the lrydropaphy of ti& vaters of Texas. Publ. Inst. Marine Science., I(?). Udv. Texas: 125.194. Copciand, U. I. Thompson, , J. H., Jr., and Ogletice, W. B. n?ccffects of wind on watcr levels i n t h e Texas L:~gona Mudre. 1968 Toxu lour. Science., 20(2): 196-199. Dyer, K. R. and Ramamoorthy, R. 1969 S;iiiniry and watcr circulation in the Vcll3i estuary. Limol. Ownog., 14(1): 4-15. ESTUARINE fiESEARCH On the inilucnce of the earth's rotadon an ocean-currents. h k i v f& Maternatik, Asmmomi och Fysik., 2(11): 1-53. A rotzly component rnmhod for a d y r i n g meteorological and oceanogsphic vector time series. DeepSea Res., 19(12): 833-846. The slope of hire surfaces undcr variable wind Beach Erosion Board Tech. Mem, 25. 23 p. Wind effect on lake; and rivers. Ingeniiirwetenskap&ademins Handlinw, 158.191 p. Dynamics of the water surface in a bar-built estuary Doctoral dissertation. Department of M a k e S c i m m , Louisiana State UrUv. 9 1 p. $Find tides in m a i l dosed channels. Jour. Res. Nat. B. Stand., 46(5j: 358-381. Wind effect a n s k l l o u . bodies of ii8arer with speciil reference to Lake Okcechobee. gun& Tekn. ~ 6 ~ l ; o i a Handtingar, ns 83. 146 P. Longuet-Hil,ni, 11. S. and Stcwart, R. W. 1964 Radiation suesses in water wavcs: 3 p h y s i d discussion, with applications. Deepsea Res., 1 l ( 4 ) : 529.562. \I;AEster, W. B., Rzttray, )I., Jr., and B m m , C. A. 1959 The d y n n n i a of a ijord estuary: Silver Bxy, Alaska. Tcch. Rep. 62. Oceanogaphy. Univ. Wxhington. 70 p. Mac&, J. G. and Hopkins, S. I<. Studies on oyster mortdiliry in relariun to n a t m d eenvironmenrr 1961 and to oil f i c l b i n Louisiznrr. PubL Inst. Marine Science. 7. Univ. Tcras: 1-131. Pritchard. D. V. 1952 Salinity distribution and circulation in thc Clieiapcakc Dny estulirine system. Jour. M u . R e s , 11: 106-123. Pritchard, D. V. 1954 h study of :he salt bsllrnce in a coastal plain cstuary. Jour. Liar. Res.. 1 3 : 133-144. Pritchard, D. V. 1955 Fstuarinc circulation patterns. Proceedings o f ASCE, 81. 71711-717/11. Pritchard, D. V. 15: 3 3 4 2 . Piitchard, D. V. a n d K m t , R. E 1956 A method for detcrmirlinr mean longitudind velocities in a coasrai &plaincstuary. Jour. hlm. Res. 1 5 : 81-91. Savillc, T., 31. Wind set-up and waves in shallow water. B a c h Erosjon Board Tech. Mem., 27. 36 p. Unoki, S. and Isouki, I. Mean sea level in tays, with specid reference ro the mean slope 1965 of sw surface due to the standing o s d a t i a n of tide. 0-ogr. Mag, 17(%): 11-35. Unoki, S. and Isoraki, I. A possibility of generndon of surf beats. Proceedings of 10th 1966 Conf. Coastd Eng. (Tokyo)., 1: 207-216. Van Doin, W. G. 1953 Wind m e s s an an artifitid p o n d Jour. Mar. R e s , 12(3): 249-276. Waiters, C.D., Jr. and Hornandez-Anla, hl. 1971 Some physiwi observations in C;imimda Pars channel. 1 2 p. (Unpublished data.) 1952 23. 24. 25. 26.