The Alabama Shakespeare Festival 2013 Study Materials and Activities for To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Director Diana Van Fossen Contact ASF at: www.asf.net 1.800.841-4273 Set Design Peter Hicks Costume Design Pamela Scofield Lighting Design Phil Monat Study materials written by Susan Willis, ASF Dramaturg swillis@asf.net ASF 2013/ 1 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Characters Atticus Finch, a lawyer Jeremy (Jem) Finch, his 12year-old son "Scout" (Jean Louise) Finch, his daughter, 8 years old Dill (Charles Baker) Harris, a child, visiting relatives next door Calpurnia, the Finches' cook and housekeeper Maudie Atkinson, a neighbor and a narrative voice Stephanie Crawford, the neighborhood gossip Mrs. Dubose, the neighborhood crank Nathan Radley, a neighbor Arthur ("Boo") Radley, his reclusive brother Heck Tate, the local sheriff Judge Taylor Bob Ewell, a shiftless local Mayella Ewell, his daughter Walter Cunningham, a farmer Rev. Sykes, Calpurnia's pastor Mr. Gilmer, a public prosecutor Tom Robinson, the accused Other farmers and townspeople A Southern Classic on the Stage Harper Lee's 1960 novel To Kill a Mockingbird gives us a brilliant re-creation of a 1930s' Southern childhood and a stark look at race and class in America. The combination of these narrative forces is a great part of the novel's power. By weaving the background of her own life in Monroeville, Alabama into the fictional world of Maycomb, Lee adds to the poignancy and accuracy of her tale. The society is as clear, as stratified, as real as can be, the haves divided from the have nots, the blacks from the whites, all the while dependent on each other and living in a single town during a time of national economic depression. One decent man, a widower, a principled lawyer, raises his two children with the help of his Negro cook. This man, Atticus Finch, shapes his children's views of their neighbors and challenges his town's views of theirs. Most authors' first novels quietly disappear; this first novel by Harper Lee sold more than two million copies in its first year, and 53 years later continues to sell over a million copies annually worldwide. In dozens of translations, Scout, Atticus, and Boo Radley have come to life on the page, the novel's issues have proved universal, and along with the film they have inspired countless readers to think about their world—and in some cases to become lawyers. Adapting this novel to film or stage means making choices among the rich details of Lee's web of narrative and scene. The live enactment gives the power of being in the moment with the action and serves this much-loved story well. About Language in To Kill a Mockingbird The play is set in 1935 rural Alabama and accurately depicts the speech and views of a small town during the Great Depression. In a play that treats racial prejudice among other subjects, the use of the word "nigger" occurs at times as it did historically. In the script, it is no sooner used than its use is addressed and forbidden by Atticus Finch, though his admonition to his children does not stop others from using it. About the Study Materials These study materials assume a familiarity with the novel, since many students read it in school. Should you not be teaching the novel to students you bring to see the play at ASF, we list a number of internet sources and teacher guides for plot summaries that make discussion of the adaptation process possible, perhaps more effectively after seeing the play. There are also discussion points and activities, historical context, biography, and analysis. Setting: Maycomb, Alabama Time: the summer of 1935 Nelle Harper Lee in the court room of Monroeville's old courthouse ASF 2013/ 2 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Harper Lee in 1964 Harper Lee recently In a survey of titles frequently assigned in U.S. high schools, Harper Lee's novel ranked in the top five, along with works by William Shakespeare, Mark Twain, Nathaniel Hawthorne, and F. Scott Fitzgerald. Harper Lee: An Alabama Treasure It is not accidental that writing about author Harper Lee feels like describing Scout. Lee imaginatively accessed her own life in writing her novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, and also used the familiar setting of her hometown, Monroeville, Alabama, and the youth of her long-time friend Truman Capote, the original of Dill. As a child, Capote often visited his relatives who lived next door to the Lees in Monroeville. As so many Southern authors have, Lee took what was engrained, then crafted it into compelling fiction. At home in Monroeville where she was born April 28, 1926, the author we know as Harper Lee goes by "Nelle," her first name. Sure that anyone who read her book would mispronounce her monosyllabic first name as "Nellie," however, she used "Harper" for the novel. Her father, Amasa Coleman Lee, was a prominent Monroeville lawyer and newspaper owner who also served for a time in the Alabama legislature. Harper Lee's collegiate studies began at Huntingdon College in Montgomery and continued at the University of Alabama, where she nearly completed a law degree (her older sister Alice did become a lawyer and joined her father's practice). Instead of the law, however, Lee left the university to pursue her writing in New York City, where she worked as an airline reservations clerk by day while writing at night. Writing the Novel At Christmas, 1956, some New York friends, the Broadway composer and lyricist Michael Martin Brown and his wife Joy, encouraged Lee with the gift of a year's income so she could write full-time. She showed five of her short stories to a literary agent, who advised her to write a novel. Months of drafting and revising produced the manuscript she sent to Lippincott in 1957. The publisher thought it still seemed more like a series of short stories and asked for revision,and by working with an editor for two years, Lee turned the manuscript, then called Atticus, into To Kill a Mockingbird, which was finally published in July, 1960 and spent almost two years on the best-seller list. The novel gained Lee instant fame, a Pulitzer Prize, and the chance to see her work filmed in 1962 with a screenplay by Horton Foote and with Gregory Peck memorably playing Atticus Finch, both men winning Academy Awards for their work. As the recent film Capote portrays, Harper Lee's friendship with Truman Capote continued their entire lives, and she helped him research his famous book In Cold Blood in Kansas. Her easy openness and charm eased the locals, enabling better interviews, and her astute observations captured detail. "Writing is the hardest thing in the world," Lee says, "…but writing is the only thing that has made me completely happy." Many people find this statement tormenting since Lee, to date, has published only one novel, though there has always been talk of at least one other unpublished work. In 1963 she told the Alabama Journal she was at work on her second book, purportedly about a murder in Alexander City. For years she divided her time between New York City and Monroeville, making only selected public appearances. The Monroeville she made famous, the "Maycomb" of 1935, is long gone, now a matter of aging memories and old photo albums. The Lees' family home on South Alabama Street was demolished to make way for Mel's Dairy Dream. Nor is the home next door where Truman Capote spent his summers still standing—only part of the front stone wall remains. And down the street a gas station has taken the place of the family home at the turn in the road where a reclusive son lived. But the old county courthouse is still there, through it, too, almost disappeared in the 1970s. It is now a museum where every spring the community performs its own production of To Kill a Mockingbird with an all-white, all-male jury selected from the audience that must play its role and vote "guilty." The difficulty they face is a testimony to the changes the novel fosters and foretells. ASF 2013/ 3 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Truman Persons (Capote)—the original of Dill—as a child in Monroeville Read Truman Capote's most famous story of childhood, "A Christmas Memory," , available online at: http://www.sailthouforth.com/ 2009/12/christmas-memory. html Harper Lee and Truman Capote as Children Both Harper Lee and Truman Capote, childhood neighbors and friends, famously turned their childhoods into fiction. She imaginatively altered her own and her family's experience, but Capote's youth Lee seems to have portrayed straightforwardly. Capote often said "I had a very difficult childhood" or "I had the most insecure childhood I know of," and he may have been right. His mother sometimes locked Truman the toddler in the hotel closet so she could go out at night or left him in Monroeville with relatives. I stood in the road, watching her drive away in a black Buick, which got smaller and smaller and smaller. Imagine a dog, watching and waiting and hoping to be taken away. That is the picture of me then. Elderly cousins raised Truman in Monroeville, one of whom was a loving, fanciful playmate for the child The boy "was small for his age, to begin with," reports biographer Gerald Clarke, "and he did not enjoy fighting and rolling in the dirt, as most boys around there did." Friendship Yet like Scout, Truman benefitted from Nelle's father, Mr. Lee, whose character strongly influenced the nature of Atticus Finch. Truman had a distinctive temperament; he loved to read—having learned by "helping" Mr. Lee next door work crossword puzzles and by reading funny pages with his elderly cousin Sook—and from the age of five he loved to write. Mr. Lee gave Truman a pocket dictionary which he carried with him everywhere, along with his notebook and pencil. His vivid imagination made him an exciting playmate. The street Nelle Harper Lee grew up on; her house was near the car. In that use of imagination, Capote and Lee were a good match. As Lee observed about her own childhood, "We didn't have much money. Nobody had any money. We didn't have toys, nothing was done for us, so the result was that we lived in our imagination most of the time." In the Capote biography, Clarke also asserts a psychological link between the two children: The bond that united them was stronger than friendship—it was a common anguish.… they both were shattered by loneliness. Neither had many other real friends. Nelle was too rough for most other girls, and Truman was too soft for most other boys. While Lee wove her fiction around her own experience growing up in Monroeville, her novel is fiction, and the point Clarke makes is a good example of that fictionalization. Unlike Scout, Nelle Harper Lee lived in a largely female family; her mother was alive, not dead, although she suffered from what the family called a "nervous disorder" and was increasingly housebound (she does have an influence on the novel, however; her maiden name was Finch). Nelle Lee also had two older sisters, Alice 15 years her senior and Louise 10 years older, while her brother Edwin was six years older than Nelle. Feeding the Imagination As a child, Lee often played with Capote and his older cousin Jennings Faulk Carter. Carter recalls one of many events that partly wove itself into Lee's novel. At Truman's going away party before he moved to New York City to rejoin his remarried mother, local Klan members planned a march after hearing the rumor that Negroes were going to be at his disguise party. Instead of their supposed targets, they cornered a neighbor disguised so well as a robot in silver-painted boxes that he could not move his arms or remove his headpiece to identify himself. Mr. Lee confronted the Klan in the street and freed Sonny Boulware (who shared some personal traits with the fictional Arthur Radley). And there was also a school pageant, but one of Nelle's friends played the ham. Such remembered incidents eventually fermented and morphed into some climactic moments of To Kill a Mockingbird—Atticus's confrontation with the mob at the jail and later Scout's inability to extricate herself from her costume while being attacked. ASF 2013/ 4 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Walker Evans, Alabama, 1935. Popular Culture in the Great Depression • defining song of the Depression— "Brother, Can You Spare a Dime?" • radio was the most popular form of entertainment. Music, variety, and comedy shows prevailed, while dramas emphasized the pursuit of justice with figures such as Dick Tracy, the Lone Ranger, Perry Mason, The Shadow, Sherlock Holmes, and Superman • the era's most popular radio serial was "Amos and Andy," in which two white actors played a group of Harlem Negroes, using dialect and broad stereotypes for comic effect (now considered politically incorrect and offensive) • top three songs before Halloween, 1935: "I'm in the Mood for Love," "You're All I Need," "Cheek to Cheek" • the decade's wildest Halloween: War of the Worlds, Orson Welles' 1938 spoof broadcast of a Martian invasion that many listeners took seriously, causing a panic Sources: Time-Life Books This Fabulous Century, Vol. 4: 19301940 (1969) and Marc McCutcheon, Writer's Guide to Everyday Life from Prohibition through World War II (1995) In the Great Depression: the Novel's 1933-35 TIMELINE The 1920s: post-World War I boom, industry thriving, Wall Street profits skyrocketing with a bull market. Hemlines shorten and music swings September 3, 1929: Wall Street alltime high Sept. and Oct. 1929: stock market prices drop steeply amid panic selling that feeds the decline October 24, 1929: Black Thursday; the stock market drops six billion dollars, and more the next week November, 1929: stock market bottoms out December 1929: stock market recovers, but damage already done to American economy 1930: 4 million workers unemployed and 1,000 banks fail, taking with them families' life savings 1931: by start of year over 8 million workers unemployed; President Herbert Hoover grants farmers funds to buy livestock feed but remains staunchly against the "dole," that is, any government relief funds so people can buy food. By December more than 13.5 million workers—56% of blacks and 40% of whites—are unemployed, leaving over 30 million family members hungry and many homeless 1932: the peak/depth of the Depression; a severe drought seizes the Midwest and beyond, creating Dust Bowl conditions; people living in "Hoovervilles," large camps of cardboard shelters for the homeless with their "Hoover flags," empty pockets; veterans and their families gather in D.C. seeking help; Franklin D. Roosevelt elected President 1933: the New Deal launched during first 100 days of Roosevelt's first term: $500 million granted in relief funds for the destitute; work for the unemployed through the WPA and CCC; banks re-open. Federal Reserve Board index of industrial production almost doubles from March to June. Drought worsens, with a massive dust storm from Texas to Canada; farmers desperate. Prohibition repealed; FBI launched. Average life span is 59 years 1934: Depression begins to ease with lower unemployment and fewer business failures. Drought continues. Hilter elected in Germany and boycotts Jewish businesses 1935: Depression slowly diminishing; worst in rural, agricultural America except far West, leading to decade's "Okie" phenomenon Living in America 1932-1934 INCOME • Annual Earnings (average): coal miner $ 732.00 civil service employee $1,284.00 doctor $3,382.00 hired farm hand $ 216.00 lawyer $4,218.00 live-in maid $ 260.00 public school teacher $1,227.00 registered nurse $ 936.00 U.S. congressman $8,663.00 PRICES • Automobile new Pontiac or Dodge$ 590.00 new Chrysler $ 995.00 new Chevy pickup $ 650.00 new tire $ 6.20 gasoline (gallon) 18¢ • Appliances electric iron $ 2.00 vacuum cleaner $ 18.75 electric washer $ 47.96 • Clothing women's wool suit $ 3.98 women's leather shoes $ 1.79 men's wool suit $ 10.50 men's trousers $ 2.00 men's shoes $ 3.85 • Food and Miscellaneous sirloin steak (pound) 29¢ bacon or chicken (pound) 22¢ milk (quart) 10¢ eggs (dozen) 29¢ cheese (pound) 24¢ bread (loaf) 10¢ sugar (pound) 5¢ potatoes (pound) 2¢ cigarettes 15¢ console radio $ 49.95 • Toys doll carriage $ 4.98 two-wheeled bicycle $ 10.95 fielder's glove and ball $ 1.25 BB air rifle 79¢ ASF 2013/ 5 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Atticus: Heck, that boy might go to the chair, but he's not going till the truth's told.… And you know as well as I do what the truth is. Robert Duvall's first major film role, as Boo Radley in the 1962 film of To Kill a Mockingbird (with Mary Badham, Gregory Peck, and Frank Overton) Below: Monroeville's South Alabama Street. The house where the recluse lived is in the trees near the bottom; the Lees' former home is several doors north. Making Him Come Out: Shaping the Novel's Action Most critics of To Kill a Mockingbird divide the novel into the growing up section of the children trying to get Boo Radley to come out and later the adult section of Atticus's defense of Tom Robinson with Bob Ewell's associated vendetta and Boo's emergence. Undeniably, the novel has a child's perspective on the world, but the world that Scout, Jem, and Dill inhabit confronts them with racism, class differences, patriarchy and gender roles, economic challenges, lynch mobs, and issues of education, current events, and social complacency. In every case, Harper Lee makes an effort to get these subjects out in the open—with Boo Radley as the emblem of this effort, for what is brought out is then allowed to return to its home. In terms of the novel, however, keeping it out in the open or solving it for all time may not be the goal—the goal is that we have "finally seen them" for what they are. Boo Radley The children do get "Boo" Radley to come out long before they realize it. He leaves them trinkets in the knothole and mends Jem's pants that get hooked on the fence. That elementary effort at relationship is cemented over, forbidden, but Boo Radley nonetheless proves to be attentive and courageous—he covers the chilled Scout as she watches the winter house fire and he defends the children when Ewell attacks them. To be a pitied and demonized figure in Maycomb, Arthur Radley is one of the "seeingest" characters in the novel, as Scout realizes on his front porch. This behavior sets the novel's pattern for demonized or belittled figures or groups of people, for possibilities of relationships that are forbidden by individuals or society, and for strength in times of need. Calpurnia, Tom Robinson, and the Negroes A comparable "Boo" Radley aspect of Maycomb society is race. Its black population lives separately, with an everyday domestic life and "separate but unequal" existence largely unseen by the white society for whom they are domestics and field hands. In Maycomb, the blacks are also labelled and judged as surely as "Boo" is and with purported traits just as fictive. Being hauled into court on a false charge is not an ideal form of becoming seen, but in the courtroom there is the jury's view and the reader's view, very different degrees of seeing. Calpurnia is the maternal force in two families, Atticus's and her own. As "the help" in the Finch home, she cooks, cleans, and tends the children—telling Scout to behave and to come home when she isn't ready to come, thus helping to define the novel's basic tension between social expectations and individual insight, whether it be child's play or Miss Maudie's "handful of people" who think as Atticus thinks. Calpurnia sees and hears everything in the Finch home, exerting an influence by her integrity and presence. We meet Tom Robinson only at his trial and in the report of his death, but we know him as a good and decent man. Having already lost the use of his left hand to a cotton gin when he was a boy, his life is now imperiled by a judicial "gin" where prejudice can prevail over truth. We continue to be aware of the nearly invisible black men and women who populate Maycomb; we see them in the balcony of the courthouse as more of this society's "ghosts." Social Class and Economics in Maycomb Near the end of the novel, Jem describes the kinds of people in his world: "the ordinary kind like us and the neighbors, there's the kind like the Cunninghams out in the woods, the kind like the Ewells down at the dump, and the Negroes." That certainly categorizes the world of the novel. Scout, however, takes another view, "I think there's just one kind of folks. Folks." With a small town populace that quietly or actively survives by looking down on someone else or being looked down upon, Scout's view poses a "what if"—what if social economics were not the great demarcator; what if we're all just folks? The novel demarcates social class with Walter and Mr. Cunningham being privileged with names amid the Old Sarum mob. Only Bob Ewell and two of his children, Mayella and Burris, stand for the poor whites, the ones Maycomb considers "trash," a convenient label since they live beside the dump. With the children we see the difference most clearly at school, but school alone cannot solve these divides. And as Atticus notes, the Great Depression is a great equalizer—no one has any money. ASF 2013/ 6 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Discussing the Novel • Consider the value and significance of: --boundaries --school --the knothole --the mad dog --a hand crippled by a cotton gin --Halloween • Consider the portrayal of parents and children: --Scout/ Jem/ Atticus --Dill/ his parents --Walter Cunningham/ Mr. Cunningham --Burris/ Mayella/ Bob Ewell --Arthur (Boo) Radley/ Nathan/ Mr. Radley • Consider the image of enclosure/entrapment/ escape: --Boo Radley in his house --Dill's being left in Maycomb or his tale of being locked in a basement --Dill escaping to the movies --Jem "forced" to read to Mrs. Dubose --Mayella in impoverished life and perhaps forced into incest, yet planting geraniums and seeking a kiss --Tom Robinson in a false rape charge and later in a prison camp behind a fence --jury/society in prejudice --Ewell in vicious frustration and violent choices --Scout in ham costume Making Him Come Out: Shaping the Novel's Action/ 2 The Ladies The arbiter of Finch family rectitude and feminine propriety is Aunt Alexandra, though the neighborhood is full of opinionated women—the gossipy Miss Stephanie, the elderly Mrs. Dubose, and insightful Miss Maudie. Most of them demand that the children behave and especially that Scout instantly become more ladylike. They want her to come out of her overalls and join them in their dresses. For Scout, the question might actually be which lady to emulate. One example her father offers is Mrs. Dubose for her courage and determination to beat her addiction. The society itself is addicted to a host of views, all of which the novel makes come out for a time, whether or not it can completely solve them. For her part, Scout's choice throughout the novel is, instead, to emulate her father, her best guide to thoughtful understanding of her world and its challenges. Aunt Alexandra has no compunction about letting Calpurnia serve at her church missionary tea during Mrs. Merriweather's report on "the poor Mrunas" of Africa, an intolerant comment about a "sulky darky" after Tom Robinson's day in court, and Mrs. Farrow's belief that ladies are not safe in their beds. This scene, the satiric high point (or low point) of the novel, is the women's courtroom scene and equally as just. Where Atticus speaks the truth in the courthouse, Miss Maudie does the honors in the parlor. Because Scout has no mother, her primary female role model is missing. As a tomboy she plays with boys, and she seeks love and advice from her only remaining parent, her father. Mayella, like Scout a girl without a mother, finds only abuse at her father's hand, though she reaches out for something more with the geraniums and the kiss, a desperate recognition of her lack. She seems unlikely to become a "lady"; in fact, the community seems to ignore her plight entirely and to lump her with her father as a "Ewell," though the novel makes us see her as distinct while she's on the witness stand. Education Scout's schooling is undoubtedly a focal point of the novel in its opening chapters and near the end, because the entire novel is a form of learning—about society as a whole, other people as groups, and individuals known and less known. As Scout questions and sees, so does the reader. In first grade, Scout is told she can only learn in school, a point her father and the novel quickly compromise. Thus, rather than stifling curiosity, the novel feeds it by asking, via Scout, why things are as they are, a useful question as we look at this microcosm of America. Third grade thrusts the students into current events, as the novel has been doing all along. A report on the rise of Hitler and Nazi views of the Jews comes via Cecil, the very student who taunted Scout the year before about her father "lawyering for niggers." The teacher emphasizes how "they"—the Nazis—behave by having the students repeat "democracy," "dictatorship," and "prejudice," ideas the novel has been engaging since its beginning. In the classroom, the question arises, "why don't they like the Jews?" and Scout has made sure "why" questions about Maycomb fill the novel. The problem is not simply "over there": readers see quite clearly that it lives at our fingertips, and they are about to see violence and prejudice erupt just beyond that very schoolyard, targeting two students. Boo Radley's emergence from his house is a dramatic and essential element of To Kill a Mockingbird, but he is not the only element to emerge in the course of the narrative, nor is he the only "mockingbird" whose vulnerability we recognize. Left, Mayella "common" geraniums, and above, Mrs. Dubose's snow-on-the-mountain camellia ASF 2013/ 7 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel The cover of the 1960 first edition of To Kill a Mockingbird Adapting the Novel: Discussion Topics Harper Lee's novel is a narrative gold mine, but not all of it will fit into a two-hour dramatic experience. An adapter looks for action and major conflicts, for defining moments, dramatic climax, and character-clarifying scenes. Students who are reading or who have read the novel can benefit from thinking through the issues of adaptation and the results of various choices. Narrative Voice The novel's narrator, the older Jean Louise, is as vital a part of To Kill a Mockingbird as the young Scout's voice. Her explanations and reflections provide an essential context for the characters and action. The novel is a memory piece and gains much of its power from the interplay between adult narration and the child's perspective in a scene. What would be the effect of staging the story without the narrator, of just putting the action on the stage in scenes? Is the way the narrator stitches the events together important? What does the narrator's voice add to the novel? In a way, this adaptation actually makes both choices. It has a narrator's voice but gives it to Miss Maudie as a commentator, a physical presence who provides context for the audience amid the scenes. She, too, watches and shares the community's past with us. Her voice lends perspective that the young Jean Louise does not know or could not grasp. Yet without the voice of the grown Jean Louise, our sense of the action remains in the present, in 1935. The Monroe County Courthouse in the 1930s Incident What scenes and incidents must be in the play if it is accurately to be called To Kill a Mockingbird? The trial, surely, the confrontation the night before at the jail house, Bob Ewell's attack on the children with Boo's saving action at the end—all these are crucial. How much else from the novel must be included? Some of the children's efforts to get Boo to come out? The knothole hiding place? School? Jem's reading to Mrs. Dubose? Atticus's shooting of the mad dog? Aunt Alexandra's missionary society meeting? Not everything will fit into a play, so what is essential to set up the crucial events? The trial is the climax of the novel, a crucial event. What sets that up? What else must be in to make that clear? Is the trial the entire story? It makes the children witnesses and Atticus the active force. How much of the story belongs to the children, their relationship to Atticus, and Dill's determination to get Boo to come out? Characters Lee fills her novel with a small town's worth of characters, and all those within the children's "boundaries" are fleshed out in our minds, as are all the characters at Calpurnia's church, people at the trial, and everyone who visits or comes to call. Who is essential? The family, certainly—does that include Aunt Alexandra? Are all the neighbors vital? If not, who must be shown? Deciding who and what to include means deciding what is essential to the story, what cannot be lost. EXERCISE: Narrative Voice and Memory Especially when the protagonist is a child, a retrospective narrative voice is very useful, as Proust and Dickens have shown. Harper Lee lets the events have meaning in the present action and also in retrospect from the brief but telling comments of the narrator. • Narrate a memorable incident from your childhood involving curiosity or daring or not understanding that uses the point of view of the child you were then. (Be your own "Scout.") Then re-narrate the incident adding the perspective you now have on the incident. (Be "Jean Louise" considering and commenting on your "Scout.") What is the difference in effect between these two narrations? What is the value of each? Do you prefer the child's view, the older view, or a blended view? Why? ASF 2013/ 8 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Issues to Consider • What is the time span of the novel? What time span will best serve the needs of a play? How long would it take to show all the action of the novel on stage? • Consider the thematic effect of these juxtapositions on stage: --opening of play: Atticus "doesn't do anything (chap. 10 of novel) to the taunt "your daddy defends niggers" (chap. 9 of novel). Does the order matter? -- Dill's plan to use lemon drops to lure Boo out and Heck's news that the Old Sarum bunch may want to take Tom Robinson out of jail The children watch the Radley house in ASF's 2006 production of Mockingbird (Esther Workman, Zach Looney, and Davis Vaughn) Structuring Action for the Theatre Harper Lee divides her novel into two parts, a structure that fits the modern theatre's usual two-act structure very neatly. In Lee's novel, the break occurs after Mrs. Dubose's death and Atticus's definition of courage; Part Two opens with Jem and Scout's attending church with Calpurnia and the arrival of Aunt Alexandra in the fateful summer of 1935. Looked at from a dramatic point of view, the events that juxtapose Lee's break in the novel are not the kind of plot events that will give a strong finish to Act One of a play or a strong drive to the start of the second act, though they serve the needs of the novel well. Consider why Lee used these events in the novel and why a play might make other choices. Plays—like television shows before a commercial—need sharp, strong beginnings and endings to their component parts. In 19thcentury theatre, the "curtain" moment at the end of every act was carefully crafted for maximum effect, and that tradition still influences the structure of performance art forms today. The first decision made for a theatrical adaptation is to shorten the time span of the novel. Rather than show several summers and several years at school on the way to the climactic summer of the trial, a stage adaptation will move all the action to the climactic summer, so the action encompasses a tighter arc. That choice materially alters the sense of the story in some ways, but it does heighten dramatic tension. Thus, unlike the novel, in the stage adaptation Jem and Scout meet Dill in the summer of the trial. Their friendship is now just weeks long, not years long (and how significant a difference is that?). Moreover, they are older when they get fascinated with Boo. Despite these changes, the action of the play still falls into the novel's basic categories: 1) the children's private world, much of which involves a curiosity about Boo, 2) the children's relationship at home with Atticus and Calpurnia, and 3) the larger public world of Maycomb that holds the trial and harbors prejudices. While both acts of the play involve all three categories of action, the first act is largely the children's world and the home world, climaxing with the night at the jail and start of the trial; Act Two is largely the trial and its aftermath. While the drive of the play inevitably seems straighter and flatter than the novel's, too much change to the story of To Kill a Mockingbird would cause outcry. Consequently, the adaptation is— in spirit and central action if not in scope—very faithful to the novel. Assess the Choices the Script Makes: • the novel's time frame, summer 1933 to fall 1935, is compressed to the summer and fall of 1935, so much of the growing up story is lost. What is its role in the novel? • the novel's action does not introduce Cecil's taunt that Atticus "defends niggers" until chapter 9 (of 31 chapters), during the second autumn narrated. In the play that taunt occurs on the second page of dialogue. How well do we know Scout when she and we meet this climactic issue in the play? • the narrative voices blend effortlessly in the novel as the memory and the action meld. In the novel, Scout's voice seems to dominate and she voices her own ideas. Having Miss Maudie ofer an adult perspective follows the spirit of the novel but not its letter of having Scout's perspective young and grown dominate. • what gets omitted: all the school experiences and lessons (from learning to read to learning about Hitler); Walter coming to lunch; some knothole gifts and most efforts to get Boo out; snow and snowman; Miss Maudie's house burning; Christmas in Finch's Landing; Uncle Jack and Aunt Alexandra; going to Calpurnia's church; Dolphus Raymond; discussion of justice after trial; "our kind of people"; the missionary circle; Ewell's other vengeful acts; reading the Gray Ghost. What role do these elements play in the novel? ASF 2013/ 9 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel "To Kill a Mockingbird had a lot to do with [changing the racial climate of the South] in the same way that Uncle Tom's Cabin woke people up to injustice 100 years earlier." —Mark Childress, novelist and Monroeville native Identifying the Real Crime—Prejudice As Atticus Finch ably proves in the courtroom, in Tom Robinson's case there is no proof a crime was committed and in fact none was. But Harper Lee's novel seems to believe the equivalent of criminal acts occur in society when prejudice foments division, intolerance, and injustice. Scout runs into the brick wall of racial prejudice when Cecil taunts her about her father "lawyering for niggers." In asking Atticus about the case, she repeats the taunt she has heard, "Atticus, do you defend niggers?" Atticus first addresses the use of that term, "Don't say 'nigger,' Scout. That's common," and Scout instantly changes her speech. "That's common" is exceptionally powerful phrasing, suggesting both class and economic issues as well as the widespread judgmental use of the term. "Why does Mrs. Dubose make it sound like you're runnin' a still?" Scout asks her father. Atticus believes the promise of "freedom and justice for all," but the town sees his defending Tom as outside the boundaries of the social mores they use instead the law. So to what extent social mores shape the process of justice is a question the novel asks (twice). And these boundaries are nicely paralleled in the novel by the boundaries given the children for play, Mrs. Dubose's yard on one side and the Radley place on the other, boundaries which the children immediately try to exceed. In the play, Scout and Atticus first discuss the court case immediately before the mad dog scene, a telling juxtaposition for the drama. Atticus—"Ol' One Shot," as his children are The old Monroeville jail surprised to learn—fells the rabid dog with a single bullet. He will do the same for the blatant racism in Bob Ewell's accusation against Tom Robinson, but cannot stop the prejudicial "madness" as easily. As a result of shooting the mad dog, Miss Maudie tells the children, "If your father's anything, he's civilized in his heart." For a town in which a false charge of rape brings out savagery and the threat of lynching, the presence of one civilized man proves to be very important. Atticus clarifies the link between the mad dog and the prejudice when he explains to Scout, "Why reasonable people go stark raving mad when anything involving a Negro comes up is something I don't pretend to understand." This pattern of mad dog and prejudice may also pick up Mrs. Dubose, who seems at least angry-mad in her vitriol, but she is fighting an addiction, which adds another element to the image cluster. "Are we going to win it?" Scout asks Atticus about the court case. "No, honey.… Simply because we were licked a hundred years before we started is no reason for us not to try to win." The prejudice is deeply rooted, but, as Atticus points out in this novel from the Civil Rights era, that is no reason to accept the prejudice, no reason "not to try to win." The case is for Tom Robinson's life and more; it is for openness, honesty, and equality, as Atticus clearly sees, and he also knows that this time "we're fighting our friends." Racism is not the only prejudice the novel considers, of course—class and economic difference, religious/ethnic difference (Hitler and the Jews), and gender also figure in the novel. If prejudice is unjust and damaging, often to all concerned, what fuels it and why does it continue to foment problems in the modern world? Must there be prejudice? Researching Prejudice Research the history or prejudice against African Americans, Jews, Hispanics, Asians, Irish, and other immigrant groups in American history. When and how has the prejudice arisen? What were its consequences? How has it been addressed? The Southern Poverty Law Center's "Teaching Tolerance" program has many online materials about combating prejudice, bullying, and other issues. Get information at: http://www.splcenter.org/what-we-do/ teaching-tolerance ASF 2013/ 10 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Author Harper Lee with the Atticus of the 1962 film of To Kill a Mockingbird, Gregory Peck For more on assessments of Atticus, see Christopher Metress, "The Rise and Fall of Atticus Finch," Chattahoochee Review 24:1 (Fall 2003): 95-102; rpt. Critical Insights: To Kill a Mockingbird, ed. Don Noble (Pasadena: Salem Press, 2010), 83-93. Assessing Atticus Atticus Finch makes his view of racism, prejudice, and what's right very clear in Harper Lee's novel, and his is not a lone voice. Many readers view Atticus as a strong and heroic figure, telling the necessary truth in the face of apparently insurmountable social opposition. Increasingly over the years since the novel's publication, however, some readers have questioned Atticus's behavior. Is he active enough in confronting his society's prejudices? As a lawyer and more importantly as a state legislator, did he take action to change what needed changing? Or did he just state his own view and then passively let a racist verdict prevail, like Pilate washing his hands? Does he excuse prejudicial behavior as society just "having blind spots"? Is taking—and losing—this one case doing enough to address the wrongs he sees? Maycomb society divides on the question, many castigating Atticus and taunting his involvement, while some respect him, usually more privately, such as Miss Maudie in her comments to the children. Is this private comment enough? Should Miss Maudie barge into the parlor and confront the other ladies with their hypocrisy, or should she quietly comment to Aunt Alexandra and Scout in the kitchen? By contrast, Tom Robinson takes action; he climbs the fence to try to escape the death penalty falsely assigned him while Atticus works on an appeal. To some readers, the law seems too undramatic and inadequate a means in these circumstances—we need the cavalry to ride over the hill, guns blazing. Ironically, during the 1950s while the novel was being written, the civil rights movement actively focused on changing laws. The trial ( A S F, 2 0 0 6 with Rodney Clark and Esau Pritchett) WATCHING THE WORDS A common form of literary analysis involves triangulating what a character says, what is said about him, and what he does. Consider the value of Atticus's comments and statements made about him: Atticus • "You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view… until you climb into his skin and walk around in it." • "I'm going to defend that man.… [His case] goes to the essence of a man's conscience." • "One thing that doesn't abide by majority rule—a person's conscience." • "Heck, that boy might go to the chair, but he's not going till the truth's told." • "I wanted you to see what real courage is, instead of getting the idea that courage is a man with a gun in his hand. It's when you know you're licked before you begin but you begin anyway and you see it through no matter what." • "There is one way in this country in which all men are created equal…. That institution, gentlemen, is a court…. and in our courts all men are created equal." • "I won't live one way in town and another way in my home." About Atticus • "He's civilized in his heart." (Miss Maudie) • "A Finch … lawing for niggers! … What's this world come to with the Finches going against their raising? Your father's no better than the trash he works for!" (Mrs. Dubose) • "…there are some men in this world who were born to do our unpleasant jobs for us. Your father's one of them.… We're so rarely called on to be Christians, but when we are, we've got men like Atticus to go for us.… We're paying your father the highest tribute we can pay a man. We trust him to do right." (Miss Maudie) DISCUSSION • What constitutes heroism? How heroic is Atticus Finch in this story? Should we admire him as much as some in the story do? Does he do enough to deserve to be so admired? What is enough to be a hero when confronting prejudice and one's society? Is this a prejudice he endures, and would that make any difference? Make your case and state your reasons. ASF 2013/ 11 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Designing ASF's 2013 To Kill a Mockingbird ASF's Resident Set Designer Peter Hicks calls the design for To Kill a Mockingbird "selective realism"—the most significant elements are fully rendered and other elements less detailed. The Finch house faces the Radley home across the stage, while upstage ("up the street") a unit suggests the neighbors' homes. Director Diana Van Fossen observes that because the entire town functions as the "courtroom" for the action, the town elements adapt on stage to form the courtroom. The upstage steps pull out to become the judge's dais with a flag flown behind it, the gallery above becomes the courtroom balcony, the Radley home tracks off, and the attorneys' tables and spectators' chairs are carried in. Costume designer Pamela Scofield says that the garments will look and feel like faded, well worn clothes rather than too clean, "theme-park" costumes. Period photographs provided insight and inspiration for costumes, as some of Scofield's research photos at right demonstrate. Pamela Scofield's costume designs for Scout, Atticus and Mayella 1930s' photos from Scofield's research ASF 2013/ 12 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Pre- and Post-Show Activities LITERATURE Quotation for Discussion or Writing • from the scene in which Scout asks Atticus about taking the Tom Robinson case: Scout: Atticus, you must be wrong. Atticus: How's that? Scout: Well, most folks seem to think that they're right and you're wrong. Atticus: They're certainly entitled to think that, and they're entitled to full respect for their opinions. But before I can live with other folks I've got to live with myself. The one thing that does not abide by majority rule, honey, is a person's conscience. What is the basis for judging right and wrong? How many factors go into forming a person's conscience? What effect does society have versus the effect of conscience on one's attitude and behavior? The majority rule issue in context of conscience provides a ready comparison with the discussion of those topics in the opening of Henry David Thoreau's "Civil Disobedience" and in Martin Luther King's "Letter from Birmingham City Jail." The other side of those issues is well expressed by Socrates in Plato's Crito, the death scene dialogue. The "Scottsboro Boys" put on trial and accused of raping two white women on a train in north Alabama in the 1930s. Their trial made national headlines. Setting • Certain settings provide authors with a microcosm of society, because by looking at the few we recognize the many, the larger perspective of human activity and belief. A ship is often used as a microcosm; Chaucer used a pilgrimage to Canterbury as a microcosm; others have used a wagon train headed West or a raft headed down the Mississippi River—a particular journey can reflect life's journey. Does a small town work as such a microcosm? How universal is Maycomb? Why not set the story in L.A. or Atlanta? • Are Harper Lee and Truman Capote the only Alabama writers who come from Monroeville? Why does Monroeville sell tourists bottled water called "Inspiration"? Also see the topics on earlier pages of these study materials. HISTORY •In the story, Atticus's legal "victory" is considered to be keeping the (presumably prejudiced) jury out so long before the guilty verdict is returned. Research the historical context of racial views, Jim Crow, and civil rights in 1935, when the action occurs, and in the 1950s to 1960, when the novel was written and published. • To what extent are economics and class a factor in the action? To what extent, if any, is the lynch mob different from Mrs. Dubose's views or the schoolyard taunts? What were the legal circumstances for Negroes (the term then used) in the 1930s and in the 1950s? Is racism exclusively a Southern issue? What—and where—was the experience of the civil rights era in the U.S.? Is racism still a relevant issue in America? • Though Harper Lee is believed to have used a Monroeville court case as background for the trial, a major racial incident in Alabama close to the action of To Kill a Mockingbird is the famous Scottsboro case against nine black men accused of raping two white women in a boxcar on a train in 1931. The case made national news and was a widely observed legal battle with innuendoes and complications not unlike those in the Tom Robinson case. Several websites offer useful information and background on the Scottsboro incident. See Wikipedia or find much more at: http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/ scottsboro/scottsb.htm • How does context—such as the bombing of the World Trade Center—affect society's awareness of its minority groups? Look at racial/country of origin descriptions on census forms used in America through its history and research why specific groups are "identified" at a given time. ASF 2013/ 13 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Pre- and Post-Show Activities SOCIAL STUDIES/ SOCIOLOGY Research or Group Discussion • What effect does poverty have on people? During the Great Depression, many people became poor who had never experienced poverty before—what is the difference between the experience of chronic poverty and of sudden economic collapse? How do people cope? How does society respond? What effect on self-image and relationships, on class and status does poverty have? • With the events of the novel set in the Great Depression, times are hard—does that also heighten or harden social tolerance? Research conditions in Alabama during the Depression; look at the WPA pictures; learn more about the world in which the action occurs and how that context shapes the action and how it affected Alabama during that era. • How does prejudice against other social groups—ethnic groups or races—arise? What is its source? Is it passed down by individuals or by society as a whole? How does one recognize and address prejudice in oneself and in others? Where in the novel does there seem to be recognition and potential for progress, and where in the novel does prejudice seem deeply engrained? Why? • The novel looks at gender identity—being a man or becoming a lady. How does the novel define "man" and "lady" and do our current views agree with that definition? Divide into groups and define male and female gender roles, role models, and challenges in the novel and in society today. ART • The novel contains an abundance of powerful imagery. Design a cover for the novel or a poster for the production using imagery from the book. Write a paragraph about why you chose this imagery. • Make a collage of the imagery in the novel, choosing to focus on the point of view of: --the children --Jean Louise, the grown narrator, and her memories --Atticus --Calpurnia and Tom Robinson --the Cunninghams --the Ewells • (for younger students) Build a tree with a knothole on a bulletin board. Make friends with either Boo Radley or with one of the children in the novel by leaving him or her something simple from your life that s/he might like or be intrigued by. Put a short paragraph on the bulletin board about why you left that particular item for that character. (Make your choice of item as simple as Boo makes his choice of items for the children. He didn't buy any of the items; he had them or made them.) BIOLOGY • Research mockingbirds and check the accuracy of the novel's description of that species's behavior. Why is it called a mockingbird? How much of the U.S. has mockingbirds? How much of the world? Is this a local or a national/international image? • Feed the Cunninghams. The novel makes it clear that the Cunninghams have trouble getting enough to eat and that meat is a rarity in their diet. They must eat beans and a largely vegetarian diet supplemented by hunting. What foods would be available to the Cunninghams in south Alabama in the 1930s, and how could they design their diet to stay healthy without buying much? As a farmer, what crop(s) might Mr. Cunningham grow? What would be in his garden? Study the table on p. 4 about income and food prices during the mid-1930s. Research online to get more information about diet, gardens, or prices. ASF 2013/ 14 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel Online Resources for Teaching the Novel Teacher Resources: • Web English Teacher has a site with quizzes, projects, word guides and exercises, and many other resources at: www.webenglishteacher.com/lee.html • www.sdcoe.k12.ca.us/score/tokil/mocktg.htm This site from the San Diego schools has study units on the novel • mockingbird.chebucto.org/ This site has Harper Lee interviews and biographical information, FAQ, further reading, links to Monroeville, to other Mockingbird sites, and to historical information about the Scottsboro Boys and Emmett Till as well as Truman Capote • www.swisseduc.ch/english/readinglist/leeh/index.html This site has a synopsis of the novel, comments and questions, and context. • www.slc.k12.ut.us/webweavers/jillc/mbird.html This site provides a unit on growing up in the 1930s • rs6.loc.gov/learn/lessons/98/mock/intro.html Lessons plans for working with the novel • library.thinkquest.org/12111/ This site has two teleconferences on the book and the film, including instructional activities Basics for Students Not Reading the Novel If your students are not reading the novel, a basic synopsis and information about character, theme, and imagery are available at: www.lausd.k12.ca.us/Belmont_HS/tkm/ www.sparknotes.com/lit/mocking/ www.gradesaver.com/classicnotes/titles/killmockingbird/ www.novelguide.com/tokillamockingbird/index.html The Monroeville courthouse as seen from the judge's bench ASF 2013/ 15 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee dramatized by Christopher Sergel 2012-2013 SchoolFest Sponsors Supported generously by the Roberts and Mildred Blount Foundation. PRESENTING SPONSOR Alabama Department of Education SPONSORS Alabama Power Foundation Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Alabama Hill Crest Foundation CO-SPONSORS Alagasco, an Energen Company Robert R. Meyer Foundation PARTNERS AT&T GKN Aerospace Honda Manufacturing of Alabama, LLC International Paper Company Foundation Mike and Gillian Goodrich Foundation Publix Super Markets Charities PATRONS Central Alabama Community Foundation Elmore County Community Foundation Target Photos: Sayed Alamy