Meeting of the Board of Trustees December 4, 2014 No item in this report for release prior to 9:00 a.m. Thursday, December 4, 2014. A G E N D A BOARD OF TRUSTEES of NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY 9:00 a.m. – Thursday – December 4, 2014 Board of Trustees Room 315 Altgeld Hall 9:00 a.m. Call to Order, Roll Call, Notice Verification, Meeting Agenda Approval Special Resolution, Committee Reports, President’s Report, Chair’s Report Closed Session, Reconvene Board of Trustees Meeting for Adjournment 1. Call to Order and Roll Call 2. Verification of Quorum and Appropriate Notification of Public Meeting 3. Meeting Agenda Approval ............................................................................................. Action........ i 4. Review and Approval of Minutes: May 29, 2014 BOT Special Meeting ............................ Action....... 1 August 28, 2014 BOT Special Meeting ........................ Action....... 6 September 18, 2014 Regular Meeting ......................... Action....... 8 5. Chair's Comments/Announcements 6. Resolution Honoring Bill Nicklas…………………………………………………………………………………. Action. .... 20 7. Public Comment* 8. Reports of Board Committees and Board Liaisons a. Executive Committee b. Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee (AASAP) c. Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee (CARL) d. Finance, Facilities and Operations Committee (FFO) e. Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee (LARI) f. Ad Hoc Committee on Enrollment g. Ad Hoc Committee on Governance h. Illinois Board of Higher Education i. Universities Civil Service Merit Board NIU Board of Trustees -i- December 4, 2014 j. Northern Illinois University Foundation k. Northern Illinois University Alumni Association l. Northern Illinois Research Foundation 9. President's Report No. 95 a. University Recommendations Forwarded by the Board Committees 1) Request for a Change in Degree Designation .................................................. Action........ 21 2) Request for a New Degree Program ............................................................... Action........ 22 3) Bowl Game Participation Expenses ................................................................. Action........ 23 4) FY 16 Tuition, Fees, and Room and Board Recommendations .......................... Action........ 24 5) New Facility for Campus Distributive Antenna System ..................................... Action........ 38 6) Energy Infrastructure Improvements – Phase XI Performance Contract ............ Action........ 39 b. University Reports Forwarded by the Board Committees 1) Oversight of Academic Programs............................................................ Information........ 40 2) FY 14 Office of Sponsored Projects Annual Report................................... Information........ 43 3) Federal Relations Update ....................................................................... Information........ 52 4) Internal Audit Update ............................................................................ Information........ 55 5) Clery Act .............................................................................................. Information........ 61 6) Semi-Annual Progress Report of Active Capital Projects ........................... Information........ 72 7) Quarterly Summary Report of Transactions in Excess of $100,000 ........... Information........ 83 8) Periodic Report on Investments ............................................................. Information........ 88 9) Ad Hoc Committee on Governance Work Plan ......................................... Information........ 91 10) Ad Hoc Committee on Enrollment Update ............................................... Information........ 94 c. Items Directly from the President 1) Lipman Hearne Enrollment Management Contract ........................................... Action...... 103 10. Chair’s Report No. 68 a. Board of Trustees 2015 Meeting Dates Approval ................................................... Action...... 105 b. Ad Hoc Committee on Governance First Reading Item ........................................... Action...... 107 11. Closed Session 12. Other Matters 13. Next Meeting Date 14. Adjournment NIU Board of Trustees -ii- December 4, 2014 *The Board and its committees comply with P.A. 91-0715 through its Bylaws, Article II, Section 5.B: 1. Consistent with Public Act 91-0715 and reasonable constraints determined by these Bylaws and the Chair, at each regular or special meeting of the Board or its committees that is open to the public, members of the public may request a brief time on the approved agenda of the meeting to address the Board on relevant matters within its jurisdiction. 2. Committees of the Board review University proposals for action and make adjustments and endorsements as appropriate for further consideration by the full Board. Public comments are generally most useful at meetings of Board committees, where proposals are first considered and the time for interaction most feasible. 3. To facilitate an orderly process, appearance requests must be registered on a Board-provided form and submitted to the Board’s Parliamentarian at least 45 minutes before the meeting is scheduled to be called to order. To be recognized, the appearance request will include the name, address and position of the individual wishing to speak, the name of the organization or group represented, a concise summary of the presentation, and whether the requestor has appeared earlier on the topic before any other meeting of the Board. The Parliamentarian may confer with registered speakers to cooperatively assist the Chair of the meeting in assuring coordinated issue presentation and an efficient use of allocated time. The Parliamentarian will acquaint requestors with the generally acceptable rules of decorum for their presentations. In lieu of oral presentations, individuals may present brief written materials not to exceed five (5) pages to the Parliamentarian for distribution and consideration by the Board in advance of the meeting. 4. The Chair of the meeting will recognize duly registered individuals at the appropriate point during the meeting. Unduly repetitive comments may be discouraged and restricted by the Chair. To assure an orderly and timely meeting the Chair may limit time allotments to five minutes or less, may delay or defer appearances when appropriate, and defer or refer questions received from presenters for answers if available. Anyone needing special accommodations to participate in the NIU Board of Trustees meetings should contact Ellen Andersen, Director of Special Events, at (815)753-1999, as soon as possible, normally at least a week before the scheduled Board meeting. NIU Board of Trustees -iii- December 4, 2014 Minutes of the NIU Board of Trustees SPECIAL MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES May 29, 2014 CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL The meeting was called to order at 2:12 p.m. by Chair John Butler in the Board of Trustees Room, 315 Altgeld Hall. Recording Secretary Sharon Banks-Wilkins conducted a roll call of Trustees. Trustees Robert Boey, Anthony Iosco (phone), Robert Marshall, Cherilyn Murer, Marc Strauss, Student Trustee Elliot Echols, and Board Chair John Butler were present. Absent was Trustee Wheeler Coleman. Also present were President Douglas Baker, Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore and Board Liaison Bill Nicklas. VERIFICATION OF APPROPRIATE NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING Confirmation of Open Meetings Act notification compliance was given by Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore. MEETING AGENDA APPROVAL Chair Butler called for a motion to approve the agenda with the modification that President’s Report Item A1 be removed. Trustee Strauss made the motion to approve the agenda and Student Trustee Elliot Echols seconded. The motion was approved. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES None. CHAIR’S COMMENTS/ANNOUNCEMENTS At this time we move to the Chair’s Comments. We are very pressed for time, so I’m not going to make any comments except to say that once again I would like to point out how much the Board is aware of and cognizant of the challenges that some of the faculty and staff are going through with respect to the pension issue and the retirement issue. We know that many of you are having to make choices you did not expect to make at this time and we wish you well in that very difficult process of decision-making. I would like to then welcome the members of the University Advisory Council, who are present this morning, excuse me, this afternoon. I never expected to be speaking in the morning these are some flawed notes here. The UAC members are Alan Rosenbaum, Deborah Haliczer, Andy Small, Greg Waas, Rosita Lopez, and Dan Gebo. Mr. Rosenbaum, is there anything you or any of your colleagues would like to say to the Board? Mr. Rosenbaum had no comment and Chair Butler asked Ms. Haliczer if she had any comment to make. Deborah Haliczer: Yes. Chair Butler, thank you for reflecting the sentiments of our faculty and staff. I promised Rosita Lopez that I would give you her regards. She is one of those faculty who decided to retire under pressure and has since rescinded and appreciated the flexibility of the university in allowing her to do that since her plan was not to retire this year. And so, regards from Rosita. PUBLIC COMMENT The Chair asked Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore if any members of the public had registered a NIU Board of Trustees 1 December 4, 2014 written request to address the Board in accordance with state law and the Board of Trustees Bylaws. Mr. Blakemore noted that no timely requests had been made to address this Special Board Meeting. PRESIDENT’S REPORT NO. 91 Agenda Item 6.a. (2) – Authorization to Retain Executive Search Firm for the Appointment of a Chief Diversity Officer President Baker: We’ve discussed these issues this morning and why don’t we move through the action items. The first one regards the authorization to retain an executive search firm for the appointment of chief diversity officer. I will note that we have a diversity task force working this summer looking at best practices for structure of policies around diversity and at the end of that we will design that position and go out and search for it. This is the request to retain the search firm for that position. Trustee Strauss made the motion to approve and Trustee Murer seconded. There was no discussion and the motion was approved. Agenda Item 6.a. (3) – Authorization to Retain an Executive Search Firm for the Appointment of a Senior Associate Vice President for Human Resource Services President Baker: The second item is again for a search firm. This one is for a senior associate vice president for human resource services. Typically at a university there’s a director of human resources to oversee all of the activities and that was what this position would be. Trustee Boey made the motion to approve and Trustee Strauss seconded. There was no discussion and the motion was approved. Agenda Item 6.a. (4) – Fiscal Year 2015-2018 Fire Services Contract with the City of DeKalb President Baker: The third one is for the Fiscal Year 2015-2018 Fire Services Contract as Bill went over earlier this is a contract that needs to be redone. We haven’t been with it for 3 years and it also has the purchase of part of a used fire truck that we have gotten a very good price on. And so this is a nice partnership between the city and the community to provide this level of service and of course many of the tall buildings in town are ours. Trustee Murer made the motion to approve and Trustee Strauss seconded. There was no discussion and the motion was approved. Agenda Item 6.a. (5) – The Huskie Tram Route Phase I – Bold Initiative – Capital Project Approval President Baker: Well we had a great deal of discussion this morning on the Huskie Tram. This is just for Stage I to get the first one here and to pilot test it and see how it operates and see if it is meeting our needs and so I would ask that we approve the purchase of that first one and do the infrastructure support to get it ready. Vice President Nicklas: May I add also the other half of that that we discussed in committee was if the President determined that the beta version was successful that we would have the Board’s authority to purchase the last 3 vehicles and I also clarified in the committee meeting that we had in the long detailed take-off of the individual costs projected that we might need a storage building and some other things. We do not need that at this point. So those costs are not relevant. So it’s $270,000 for the beta version which includes the test vehicle and then $180,000 for the 3 additional vehicles. President Baker: And then the storage facility as Bill notes is at the very bottom of page 21. There’s a $170,000 storage and charging shed and we identified existing space on campus that could take care of that service for us. Trustee Murer made the motion to approve and Trustee Boey seconded. Chair Butler called for any NIU Board of Trustees 2 December 4, 2014 discussion of the item, and there was some discussion. Chair Butler: There is a motion and a second. So let me clarify. This is a $450,000 expenditure? President Baker: Well in 2 stages. If the beta doesn’t work, we’re not going to go after the next phase Chair Butler: Correct. Right. But any further expansion of this will come back to the Board provided it’s within the threshold that requires it. President Baker: Yes Chair Butler: Yes, OK. Are there any comments from the Trustees? I know we have talked about this quite bit, but this is the time for other comments. Yes, Trustee Marshall. Trustee Marshall: I’ll try to make it short. I forgot to ask earlier. Gasoline or diesel? Bill Nicklas: No. It’s all electric. Trustee Marshall: OK. No backup system? Bill Nicklas: There is a solar panel on top which will add some trickle power to it on an appropriate day which will help with the time between charging. Trustee Marshall: Thank you. Chair Butler: Trustee Echols Student Trustee Elliot Echols: Just to make sure I’m clear. When it comes to maintaining the system say it does work. Is the Student Association liable for any cost? Are they liable for purchasing anything else? What are they exactly liable for? Bill Nicklas: There is nothing in this proposal that includes the Student Association’s participation in the funding at this point. So if there’s a 3rd phase, a 4th phase, that’s a negotiation that’s not included in this proposal. Trustee Echols: OK. Thank you sir. Chair Butler: Are there other questions or comments from the Board? I would just say that I am very sensitive to the comments made earlier by Trustee Strauss. We’ve talked about this quite a bit. I’m inclined to support this because I think it’s an innovative and exciting idea and I share that sentiment with my colleague, Trustee Murer. I think she put it better than I will now, but I am very interested in the progress of it and I do look forward to hearing progress reports in the future. And I hope as we move forward that we don’t neglect the concerns of Trustee Strauss. I hope we will work to make sure that questions are answered that he has raised, even if we move forward as I believe we are about to. Yes, Bill. Bill Nicklas: I would just say that I will promise a status report at the August committee meetings and the Board meeting. Chair Butler verified there was no further discussion and called for a vote. There were five ayes and one nay by Trustee Strauss but the motion was approved. NIU Board of Trustees 3 December 4, 2014 Agenda Item 6.a. (6) – Fiscal Year 2015 Open Order for Elevator Services and Maintenance President Baker: This is the open order for 2015 for elevator services and maintenance. We have 107 elevators on campus that require repair and maintenance and this is to take care of those. Trustee Strauss made the motion to approve and Student Trustee Echols seconded. There was no discussion and the motion was approved. Agenda Item 6.a. (7) – Information Technology Services (ITS) Oracle and PeopleSoft ERP System President Baker: We’re on to 6.a.7 which the Information Technology Services Oracle and PeopleSoft ERP system. ITS requests permission to issue orders for the renewal of the ongoing maintenance contract. So this is a continuation of the master contract we recently negotiated and it has just a continuation of that and we need to do that on this annual basis. Trustee Strauss made the motion to approve and Trustee Murer seconded. There was no discussion and the motion was approved. This ended the President’s report. CHAIR’S REPORT NO. 65 Agenda Item 7.a. – Amendment to Board of Trustees Bylaws Article Vi, Section 4 – Board Committees Chair Butler: The next item on our agenda is a single item from the Chair or me. I’m very excited about this item. Unfortunately, we were not able due to time and due to Trustee Murer’s willingness to move us quickly into this meeting despite the fact that there were some things that she wanted to conclude with the ad hoc committee, but this item, I’m very happy to say, is to extend the work of the ad hoc committee and put in place a permanent place for that work. Nine months ago we created the ad hoc committee and we were to hear today from that committee a final report, but understand that that final report will be the beginning of the newly formed committee which we are talking about today. The ad hoc committee has been chaired with great skill by my colleague Trustee Cherilyn Murer and today I introduce for your consideration the Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee or LARI. LARI is a modification of the work the current Legislative and External Affairs Committee, also chaired by Trustee Murer, to include the subject areas of the ad hoc committee and overall subjects of research and innovation as those areas are conceived as functions of the Division of Research and Innovation. LARI will retain the subjects of state and federal relations and will no longer receive regular report on Marketing and Communication. This is the first reading which means the Board should make a motion to receive the proposed amendment and consider it for a second reading at the next regular meeting of the Board. So may I have a motion to that effect and then we can have any discussion? Trustee Boey made the motion to approve and Trustee Strauss seconded. Chair Butler called for any conversation and there was some. Trustee Murer: I very much appreciate this discussion today and moving this subcommittee into a standing committee and I think that the folding of the legislative is at a very appropriate time. I think we saw this morning comments under Finance when it was relative to Finance when we were addressing some of the state issues and I think that federal issues are more dominant within the research area. So I think it’s going to flow very well together. We’re going to continue with our focus of having a trilogy as I called it, the trilogy of looking at problem-solving with greater depth so what we had prepared for the last meeting which will now be in August is the final component of our initial trilogy which looked at an overview, looked at process, looked at accountability and we use the same subject matter, same case study throughout the entire process and Dr. Riggs and Dr. Freeman are incredible colleagues to work with in this regard and I do look forward to working with them to bring to the Board and to the NIU Board of Trustees 4 December 4, 2014 community greater understanding of where we are relative to research and technology and the legislation that impacts both of those. Thank you. Chair Butler: Thank you. Other comments from the Board? I want to just point out that Trustee Murer had a clean slate when I asked her to chair this ad hoc committee and she did a marvelous job of working with then Vice President Freeman and then Interim Provost Freeman and then Interim Vice President Rigg. As we learned, as a Board in the form of an ad hoc committee, much more about the research endeavor and aspect of the university and I hope that as we move forward with this action item at the next meeting. We’ll reflect on the potential of the ad hoc committee process to engage in an indepth study of an area or an issue that is raising a significant amount of concern and something that the Board should be focused on. So I would very much appreciate the Trustees support of this and what you have before you is a preliminary draft of a change in the Bylaws. I anticipate that we will going forward after the June meeting begin a process of revising the Bylaws so that the description of this standing committee will look, as the other standing committees will look, a lot more like what we see in the Bylaws with respect to the CARL committee. But this is the first step to create this merger of subject areas and to begin the work. Chair Butler called for a vote and the motion was approved. CLOSED SESSION Chair Butler asked for a motion to close the public meeting to conduct an executive session to discuss the following subjects authorized by the Illinois Open Meetings Act; personnel matters as generally described under section 2(c)(1), (2), (3) and (21) of the Open Meetings Act and Litigation and Risk Management matters as generally described under sections 2(c)(11) and (12) of the Open meetings act and property matters generally described under Sections 2c5 & 6 of the Open Meetings Act. A motion was made by Trustee Strauss and seconded by Trustee Murer, and the motion passed unanimously with a roll call vote. Chair Butler Trustee Boey Trustee Murer Student Trustee Echols Yes Yes Yes Yes Trustee Marshall Trustee Strauss Trustee Iosco Yes Yes Yes (telephone) MEETING RECONVENED AND ADJOURNMENT Chair Butler reconvened the open session of the meeting of the Board of Trustees and called for a motion to adjourn. A motion was made by Trustee Boey and seconded by Student Trustee Echols, and the motion passed. The meeting was adjourned at 4:19 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Sharon Banks-Wilkins Recording Secretary In compliance with Illinois Open Meetings Act 5 ILCS 120/1, et seq, a verbatim record of all Northern Illinois University Board of Trustees meetings is maintained by the Board Recording Secretary and is available for review upon request. The minutes contained herein represent a true and accurate summary of the Board proceedings. NIU Board of Trustees 5 December 4, 2014 Minutes of the NIU Board of Trustees SPECIAL MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES August 28, 2014 CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL The meeting was called to order by Chair John Butler in the Board of Trustees Room, 315 Altgeld Hall. Recording Secretary Cheryl Ross conducted a roll call of Trustees. Members present were Trustees Robert Boey, Anthony Iosco, Robert Marshall, Cherilyn Murer, Marc Strauss, Student Trustee Paul Julion, and Board Chair John Butler. Also present were President Douglas Baker, Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore and Board Liaison Bill Nicklas. VERIFICATION OF APPROPRIATE NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING Confirmation of Open Meetings Act notification compliance was given by Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore. MEETING AGENDA APPROVAL A motion to approve the agenda was made and seconded. The motion was approved. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES None. CHAIR’S COMMENTS/ANNOUNCEMENTS Chair Butler welcomed the members of the University Advisory Council who are present at the meeting: William Pitney, Deborah Haliczer, Jay Montero, Greg Waas, Dan Gebo, and Rebecca Shortridge. Bill Pitney commented that he appreciated President Baker’s thanks and praise to the faculty and staff for their role in welcoming students back to campus. He also noted his interest in the earlier presentations from Dr. Alden and Dr. Rigg whereby the productivity of our faculty and staff was clearly evident. I think you’ll share what we likely already know and this and that is that our faculty and staff work very hard and I was grateful for seeing that today. So thank you very much. Chair Butler formally welcomed Student Trustee Paul Julion to his first official meeting of the board. He also thanked Cheryl Ross who is serving today as the recording secretary. Cheryl is retiring after 34 years of service; and Cheryl completed her undergraduate degree at NIU while an employee during that time. For about seven years Cheryl worked on the Finance and Facilities and Operations Committee agenda book. It was primarily her responsibility and so we’ve seen her work and have worked with her for years. Overall, Cheryl spent 20 years in the Department of Psychology, 6 years in Academic Affairs, and 8 years in Finance and Facilities. She has been very important recently for us as a board helping us through a transition period. Good luck and we wish you the very best on behalf of the board. PUBLIC COMMENT The Chair asked Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore if any members of the public had registered a written request to address the Board in accordance with state law and the Board of Trustees Bylaws. Mr. Blakemore noted that no timely requests had been made to address this Special Board Meeting. NIU Board of Trustees 6 December 4, 2014 PRESIDENT’S REPORT NO. 93 Agenda Item 7.a. (1) – Open Order for Litigation Services Investigations and Litigation President Baker presented the action item finalizing an open order for fiscal year 2014 to cover the costs of work being done on the federal investigations that have been underway and to conclude the billing. He requested Board approval of $215,000 to cover the legal costs associated with that work. A motion to approve the item was made by Robert Boey and seconded by Paul Julion. The motion passed with no opposition, thus concluding the President’s Report. CLOSED SESSION Chair Butler thanked the many people who made these meetings possible; Ms. Ross, the board staff liaison Mr. Nicklas and others on his team who assist in the logistics of this meeting including the committee liaisons and the hardworking staff of media services. He also thanked the University Advisory Committee for their service, as well as the staff who are responsible for the food and refreshments. Chair Butler asked for a motion to close the public meeting to conduct an executive session to discuss the following subjects authorized by the Illinois Open Meetings Act; personnel matters as generally described under section 2(c)(1), (2), (3) and (21) of the Open Meetings Act and Litigation and Risk Management matters as generally described under sections 2(c)(11) and (12) of the Open meetings act. A motion was made and seconded, and the motion passed unanimously with a roll call vote. Chair Butler Trustee Boey Trustee Murer Student Trustee Julion Yes Yes Yes Yes Trustee Marshall Trustee Strauss Trustee Iosco Yes Yes Yes MEETING RECONVENED AND ADJOURNMENT Chairman Butler reconvened the open session of the meeting of the Board of Trustees and called for a motion to adjourn. A motion was made and seconded, and the motion passed. Respectfully submitted, Cheryl Ross Recording Secretary In compliance with Illinois Open Meetings Act 5 ILCS 120/1, et seq, a verbatim record of all Northern Illinois University Board of Trustees meetings is maintained by the Board Recording Secretary and is available for review upon request. The minutes contained herein represent a true and accurate summary of the Board proceedings. NIU Board of Trustees 7 December 4, 2014 Minutes of the BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY September 18, 2014 1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL The meeting was called to order by Chair John Butler at 9:00 a.m. in the Board of Trustees Room, 315 Altgeld Hall. Recording Secretary Sharon Banks-Wilkins conducted a roll call of Trustees. Members present were Trustees Robert Boey, Anthony Iosco, Robert Marshall, Cherilyn Murer, Marc Strauss, Student Trustee Paul Julion and Board Chair John Butler. Not present was Trustee Wheeler Coleman. Also present were President Douglas Baker, Board General Counsel Jerry Blakemore, and Board Liaison Bill Nicklas. With a quorum present, the meeting proceeded. Chair Butler asked the recording secretary to call the roll. All Trustees were present except for Trustee Wheeler Coleman. 2. VERIFICATION OF APPROPRIATE NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING Chair Butler asked Mr. Blakemore to confirm that appropriate notification of this meeting had been provided. Mr. Blakemore indicated that appropriate notification of the meeting had been provided pursuant to the Illinois Open Meetings Act. 3. MEETING AGENDA APPROVAL Chair Butler called for a motion to approve the meeting agenda. Trustee Strauss made a motion to approve the printed agenda with the following modifications: first, to remove Item 10 and all of its subparts, and second to place the following items on a consent agenda: action items 9.a 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, and information items 9.b 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11, 12 and 13. Trustee Marshall seconded the motion. Chair Butler called for any discussion and there was none. Chair Butler called for a vote with no opposition and the agenda was approved. 4. CLOSED SESSION Chair Butler stated that the Board needed to go into closed session and would reconvene in approximately 90 minutes. He called for a motion to close the public meeting to conduct an executive session to discuss the following subjects authorized by the Illinois Open Meetings Act: personnel matters as generally described under sections 2C1, 2, 3 and 21 of the Open Meetings Act, and litigation and risk management matters as generally described under sections 2c11 and 12 of the Open Meetings Act. Trustee Strauss made the motion and Trustee Iosco seconded. As there was no discussion, Chair Butler called for a roll call vote and the recording secretary called the roll. All Trustees agreed and the motion was approved. Chair Butler closed the session. MEETING RECONVENED The meeting reconvened at 12:22 p.m. by Chair Butler moving to reopen the public meeting. 5. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF JUNE 19, 2014 Chair Butler next called for a review and approval of the minutes of the June 19, 2014 regular meeting. Trustee Strauss made the initial motion and Trustee Iosco seconded. Chair Butler called for any NIU Board of Trustees 8 December 4, 2014 discussion and there was none so the minutes were approved. 6. CHAIR’S COMMENTS/ANNOUNCEMENTS Chair Butler stated that at this time we move to the chair’s comments and announcements. I would like to begin by welcoming the members of the university advisory council who are present this morning. They are William Pitney, Deborah Haliczer, Jay Montero, Greg Waas, Rebecca Shortridge, and Dan Gebo. Mr. Pitney, is there anything you or any of your colleagues would like to say at this time? UAC Representative, William Pitney, said that as a member of this advisory committee, I also act as a role as our Faculty Senate President, and recently, Monday, I was at Illinois State University attending the Council of Illinois University Senators. On that council we have the opportunity to share issues, concerns and challenges that might be common to all of us in those roles. I just wanted to simply say that I left that meeting feeling really good about where we are here at NIU with respect to shared governance. I really just wanted to articulate that I believe that my dialogs with the president have been very positive and I feel a sense of collegiality and believe that there’s a level of sensitivity with respect to the concerns of the faculty of staff and I just thought it important to articulate that. Chair Butler then continued the meeting after no further remarks were offered. Well this morning I am going to take some time to offer some extended remarks and make some official announcements. I don’t usually do this, but it’s September and the school year has begun, a new academic term. It’s an exciting time for many on campus. I found myself rather impressed when I was walking around campus the other evening with President Baker observing what I think is a remarkably different look and feel particularly in the center of campus, which seems to have opened up and become more lively. I would not have expected to feel that way based on plans that we approved in this meeting in the cold, hard chambers of the Board of Trustees, but when you walk out and actually see the banners and the library and the busses on Normal Avenue, it is a different feel. I also noted that every single student who walked by us knew President Baker and said “Good evening, President Baker” which I thought was extraordinary. Throughout the prior year and especially this summer, leaders at the university college and department level in partnership with leaders of units within the facilities and operations and the student government, have begun the complex and dynamic process of determining how to operationalize within their respective units; the need to respond to significant challenges that NIU faces, particularly regarding fiscal responsibility and the recruitment and retention of students. What it means for this board to operationalize these goals is unique in many ways. We’re a group of eight individuals, we’re tied in no particular way to any academic or operational unit. Seven of us are appointed by the Governor for six year terms, one of us is a student who’s elected by the student body. Our role is to set policy and establish strategy in partnership with the president and to hold leaders accountable for the exercise in policy and the achievement of strategy. But like most leaders in this room, our activities across the span of last year began with a first phase and that was to join the campus wide effort to focus the university in its core mission and challenges. President Baker’s keystone goal of creating a system to insure student career success has focused the university and its external committee stakeholders on the importance of recruitment and retention and the related pillars of financial and programmatic sustainability, ethic inspired leadership, and thriving communities. The board realized that these are not merely words. Endeavors within these categories were massive, multi-faceted undertakings that require the capacity to identify and describe problems in vision and invent new approaches, develop a support among stakeholders, and engage in external and internal diplomacy that addresses anxiety occasioned by transformation. We expect as a board that there will be push back. We’re in the midst of a cultural change. For the board, that culture change has had specific implications that have formed a second phase of activity for us. We’ve had to examine our structure and consider how best to facilitate and align the work of the governing board with that of the university. Aligning the work of the governing board and the university is always a complex endeavor for a board that is consciously seeking to properly function in relationship to university leadership. In my judgment, we’ve made a lot of progress in this regard. NIU Board of Trustees 9 December 4, 2014 Those of you have attended board meetings for many years know that meetings over the course of the last year have involved lively exchanges about strategic choices we have before us. Trustees have focused more than ever on the relationship between limited resources and strategic outcomes. We’ve had disagreements, we’ve had split votes. We’ve not been afraid to postpone action when we believe we need more information. We’ve also enacted rather dramatic shifts in board structure including some steps that we’ve taken that have never been taken before. When President Baker first assumed the presidency, we began the implementation of immediate changes. We created a new committee on compliance, audit, risk management and legal affairs. And we empanelled the board’s first ad hoc committee on sponsored research and technology transfer which has evolved in only the course of one year into the Legislative Affairs Research and Innovation Committee, which is now a standing committee. Structural change at this level is not easy. I’ve talked to many of you about this personally. I could have done a lot of different things with several summer weekends one year ago rather than work on all of these changes and devise all of these memorandums and descriptions of committees and charges. It’s not easy. Once we set these changes in motion we knew we would face some soul searching, moments of truth, and decisive events that occasion all serious commitments to change. So now, like so many of you, we’re operating in a midst of a third phase which I will characterize as awareness that we are pivoting from listening, learning and formulating a vision toward actions that address the critical key challenges of fiscal sustainability and declining enrollment. Our expectation is that this pivot will be accompanied by the formation of a system of control and management guided by critical imperatives, benchmarks, and indicators. It is apparent to us that the continued pursuit of an environment committed to fair treatment, transparency, and effectiveness and the development of exciting and innovative new curricular and academic offerings will prove essential to the success of these central endeavors. It is in this context I’m pleased to announce that the board is initiating and extension of our activities in two directions that are intended to increase our capacity and sharpen our focus. The first is a focus on governance; the second is a focus on enrollment. This year the board will delve deeply in these subjects in separate ad hoc committees. In terms of governance we’ll focus on our own practices and relationship with university level priorities. This improvement initiative will be collaborative, aimed at determining the means the board will employ to establish goals and measure progress, the appropriate occasions and formats for regular consultation, the constructive role of the board and committee leaders in developing agendas and the possibilities for preparation and presentation of information in advance of formal consideration action items. In short, we are seeking to establish among all relevant leaders a shared vision of and commitment to meaningful board engagement. I’ve prepared a more specific charge for this ad hoc committee on governance and enrollment which I’ll describe in a moment which I’m presenting to the board this morning and I’m pleased to provide anyone who is at this meeting. These parameters are general in nature and we may determine changes are in order as we commence our work. For most people in this room the issue of enrollment is more directly relevant to your responsibilities. The board believes this is the core challenge facing the university and should form the crux of the board’s formal strategic dialog with the university administration. The formation of an ad hoc committee on enrollment immerges out of discussions between President Baker and trustees regarding the central importance of enrollment and the prospect of several board level proposals, particularly of a capital nature that relate directly to the enrollment challenge. This committee will receive background information on the nature and extent of the enrollment challenge, produce recommendations for board level action intended to positively impact enrollment, and develop metrics for accountability purposes and building an infrastructure to receive and act on metrics related to enrollment. My memorandum which you’re welcome to read goes into more detail about what some of those subjects might look like. I’ve asked Trustee Strauss to chair the committee. President Baker has agreed to function directly in the NIU Board of Trustees 10 December 4, 2014 liaison role. So there is a strong connection between academic affairs, student affairs and personnel aboard standing committee and the ad hoc committee we’ve consulted with Trustee Marshall and he plans to serve on the committee as well. Any other trustees interested may as well. These additional committees will address matters that require extended analysis and discussion beyond our current standing committee meetings and beyond what we’re currently configured to accommodate. So I think these will result in a dramatic improvement for us structurally. I wanted to share these two developments with you and the context into which we are moving in this direction because I wanted to share with all of you that we are also engaged in an effort to operationalize goals and strategies and we hope that you are as enthusiastic as we are about that future. And so that concludes my lengthy remarks. Probably the longest you’ll ever hear from me on any subject, but it’s the beginning of the year, I thought it was important to share that with you. I’m very proud to serve on this board with these outstanding colleagues and I’m very pleased with the progress that we’re making. 7. PUBLIC COMMENT Chair Butler asked Mr. Blakemore if the board had received any timely requests to address this board, and Mr. Blakemore indicated that he had received two requests. The first was Ms. Misty Haji-Sheikh and Chair Butler recognized her and asked that she reserve her remarks to five minutes. Ms. Haji-Sheikh rose to the microphone and provided the full disclaimer that I am on the county board, but today I’m not speaking for the county, I am here to speak about something called Greenways and Trails. That is something that the county is a lead agency on, it works with the city as well, and there is grant money that is involved. I did talk to the county administrator, I am here with his approval as I am here also with the approval of some our county board members that I had the opportunity to speak with as well, and the city has been involved as well. But I am here as an individual and I’m a student too for anybody that didn’t catch this when I was here a couple of weeks ago. So back 2004 this document is the Greenways and Trails plan and the idea was that we need to have connectivity, we need to celebrate the fact that we have resources here, we need activity areas for bicycling, walking, that sort of thing, So they looked at, and I was not part of the county board at this time, but they put this together and it passed in 2004. I believe it was updated once since then. And so this is an overarching thing, it’s part of our county regulations, rules, documents, whatever you want to call it, but this is our guideline (Ms. Haji-Sheikh provided a copy to Chair Butler). I don’t expect you to read it right now and I did print it off my home computer. For any of the rest of you, you can get it off the county’s website, under Greenways and Trails. Okay. And the reason I bring that up is because in September 2013 there was an engineering study done on our lagoon here on campus. And the study was done by a firm called WBK. And they came up with some recommendations. Now the study was paid for, I have some FOIA documents, freedom of information documents and that’s where I got this information, and the FOIA documents say that they want to do things to the lagoon to dig it down three feet, change the way it looks, make it more of a detention area, and by doing that it will change the flood plain that’s over on John and Harrison back toward the lagoon. Okay, fine. My neighbors would love not to be in a flood plain. I guarantee you that. But what they came up with has a problem with Greenways and Trails. So I took the liberty of having this blown up yesterday. This is one of the maps that is there to orient you. This is Lincoln Highway. This is the Kish River here and this is Lucinda. This is Castle here. The current lagoon is approximately this area here. That’s the nice lagoon that we have now. And my understanding is that this whole are here would be the part that would be lowered three feet so that this part over here, which is John and Harrison, would be out of the flood plain. Okay, so far so good. Where this touches the Greenways and Trails are these other lines that go through here. Greenways and Trails talks about the bike trail that goes right along the river, it goes down here, and the grant money is to take it under Lincoln Highway and to carry it on south so we have connectivity with the parks and things down there by Lions Park and Prairie Park and those things. And so we have already started work underneath the bridge. We being the county and the city. I should say NIU Board of Trustees 11 December 4, 2014 they did, I didn’t do it. And there’s a bed of rocks down there, if you go and look, it’s already down there. And so they’ve been working on grant money and they are activity working on this. Gary Hanson checked with the city yesterday or the day before just to make sure that I’m on target with this. The problem with this map though as far as Greenways and Trails, is that the bike trail now no longer goes underneath the bridge. It now goes this way. And so I wanted to bring this to your attention, and it is in your packet and it is on line as well, so that you know that I’m sure the county and the city would like to speak with you about this and maybe there’s a different model that we can use, a different map we can use, a different idea we can use, that will still support the Greenways and Trails that’s been on the books since 2004. Thank you. Chair Butler called for any questions and there were none. He then recognized the second speaker, Mr. Derek Van Buer and asked that he also limit his comments to five minutes. Mr. Van Buer indicated that he was here at the May 29th Finance and Operations sub-committee meeting and during that discussion the interim CFO presented that she found 65.1 million dollars that could be used on the strategic initiatives and this money come out of the Build America bonds and bond reserve funds. During the conversation or presentation, she said that by state rules, NIU had too much money in these reserve funds. And during the conversation not once was I brought up about the official document when the bonds were issued. On Tuesday afternoon I e-mailed each of you the actual document that contains it and what’s relevant in the document that bond issue is Appendix C which are the definitions and summaries and provisions of the bond resolution. And in that appendix is the section on the flow of funds, describes how the funds come into the ancillary systems to produce incomes, how they can be spent, the establishment of all these bond reserve funds, and finally what happens when there is surplus and the end of the year. In it there are details, three of the things that you can do with the funds. Basically, pay the bonds, pay the bonds, and pay the bonds. And so I just wanted to bring it to your attention that before you spend these funds you might want to go back and review to bond issuance document because if might be the control documents. And I should also say as a disclaimer I’m not giving legal advice. I’m a graduate of the College of Law at NIU. I’m an undergrad graduate of NIU too, but I just wanted to bring it to your attention of this document that was not talked about at the May 29 th committee meeting. Thank you. Chair Butler asked for any questions, and there were none. He then thanked both speakers for coming and supplying us with that information. We take seriously what people bring to us and send to us and we’ll take seriously what you’ve said today. 8. REPORTS OF BOARD COMMITTEES AND BOARD LIAISONS Chair Butler then moved to the next agenda item, which was the reports of board committees and liaisons. a. Executive Committee Chair Butler began with the executive committee which did not meet. He then called for a report from the chair of the Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee, Trustee Robert Marshall. b. Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee Trustee Marshall reported that the Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee met on August 28, 2014. At that meeting the committee considered and endorsed the following action items: an honorary doctorate recommendation for Miss Francis Whitehead; a request to delete the emphasis in General Physical Education Grade 6-12 teacher certification within the Bachelor’s of Science education in Phys Ed. The committee also heard very informative reports on year 2013 through 2014 faculty emeritus recognition; an overview of the NIU international activities for fiscal year ’14; a report on Title IX and NIU and I would like to add that I am very impressed as a learner of all of the committee reports that contain NIU Board of Trustees 12 December 4, 2014 so much invaluable information. Thank you. That concludes my report. Chair Butler thanked Trustee Marshall and called for the report of the Finance, Facilities and Operations Committee, which is chaired by Trustee Marc Strauss. c. Finance, Facilities and Operations Committee Trustee Strauss stated that the Finance, Facilities and Operation Committee met on the same day. There are a number of items that are contained on the agenda today that came out of that committee. In order to make sense of them, simply keep track of the fiscal year. So we have three fiscal years that were before the committee and three fiscal years that are here today. We had reports for the conclusion of FY14 that appear as items B 1,2,3 & 4 on our agenda. We have several items relating to FY15 which we’re in the middle of now including the internal budget with is item 9A1 as well as the approval of some expenditures in 9A5, 6 & 7 and some reports. And we have some action on 2016 because of the state budget cycle is even in advance of our budget cycle and we had some filings that are required with the state now, those items show up under 9A2, 3 & 4. All of these items that are on our agenda today passed out with recommendation from the Finance, Facility and Operations Committee. That concludes my report. Chair Butler thanked Trustee Strauss and asked for the report of the Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee, which is chaired by Trustee Robert Boey. d. Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee Trustee Boey stated that the Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee met on Thursday, August 28th at 9:00 a.m. The committee proceedings began with the swearing in of Student Trustee Paul Julion by Board Chair John Butler. Mr. Julion was warmly welcomed by the committee and all members of the Board of Trustees. The committee then considered two agenda items. The first was an update on Title IX compliance issues and requirements presented by Karen Baker, Associate Vice President for Administration and HR Compliance and Nikita Carrington the Assistant Director for Training and Development. The second agenda item focused upon the responsibilities of the university’s Risk Management Office. This presentation was made by Sarah Cliff the Director for Risk Management and internal investigations and Emily Hochstatter, the Deputy Title IX Coordinator for Human Resource Services. Chair Butler thanked Trustee Boey and asked for the report from the Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee, which is chaired by Trustee Cherilyn Murer who was not in attendance. Dr. Lesley Rigg provided the report. e. Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee Dr. Rigg reported that the Legislative Affairs and Research and Innovation Committee met on August 28, 2014. At the meeting Trustee Murer announced the hire of Dr. Anna Quider as the NIU Federal Relations Director and that she would be formally introduced at the board meeting on November 6th. Following Trustee Murer’s announcement, I presented the federal relations update. Following the federal relations update Assistant Vice President Mann presented the committee an update on state budget and legislative issues including an update on the FY15 budget. This reduction represents, or the reduction which was .24 percent reduction, represents a much leaner amount than was originally predicted. The final item of the meeting was a presentation of the accountability portion of the drilling down on the research enterprise presentation which began with Dr. Freeman in the previous meetings, followed by a presentation by Julie Crouch in previous meetings as well. And then I briefly summarized the previous presentations and finished drilling down into the research enterprise. Chair Butler thanked Dr. Rigg and then asked President Baker for his report concerning the Illinois Board of Higher Education. NIU Board of Trustees 13 December 4, 2014 f. Illinois Board of Higher Education President Baker indicated that he didn’t think the board had met since our committee meeting so no report there. We did have the regional P20 higher education group together. It’s a regional P20 group that’s looking at how we partner in this region to align from P to 20. The Center for P20 Studies put that on and a number of board members including the executive director was there. Very supportive of our work to try and integrate the pipeline activities and we will come back together after the first of the calendar year to take the next step there, but that’s our interaction with the board. Chair Butler thanked President Baker and then called for the board’s representative to the University Civil Service Merit Board, Trustee Robert Marshall, to present his report. g. Universities Civil Service Merit Board Trustee Marshall reported that the Merit Board met on August 20, 2014 in Urbana, IL. In the one personnel action item, the board upheld an executive director’s decision to bar a job applicant from advancing past the qualifying exam. Cause, after irregularities were observed during the exam by both the exam assessor and the proctor. In other items that were action items, approval was given to the 2016 budget proposal to be forwarded to Illinois Board of Higher Education; approval for revisions of our procedure manuals; and approval of the no weapon policy for the agency office. Update reports were also given on the police series assessment center revisions, ongoing revisions of the exemption procedures manual, and a review of recent audits completed since the last merit board meeting. Regular reports included those from the Administrative Advisory Committee, the Employee Advisory Committee, the Human Resource Directors Advisory Committee, and the Executive Director and Legal Council reports from the agency. The next meeting is scheduled for 10:00 a.m. Wednesday, November 19th in Urbana. Chair Butler thanked Trustee Marshall and then recognized the Vice President of University Advancement, Michael Malone, concerning the Northern Illinois University Foundation. h. NIU Foundation i. Northern Illinois Alumni Association Mr. Malone explained that my colleague, Joe Matty, had to leave to catch a plane, but I think he e-mailed you and President Baker to note the last two pre-game receptions at our away games were some of the most successful we’ve had. More than a thousand reconnected alumni at the Northwestern and UNLV pre-game receptions. Those brave souls in Nevada came out in 100 degree heat and not an exaggeration, it was 100 degrees and yet they had a great time. They socialized and met university staff, faculty and students; and reconnected with each other. It’s a great opportunity for us collectively as the university to get university alumni from around the country reconnected to the university as it is today. I gave a preliminary estimate on our earnings on investments in the endowment pool at the last meeting that you and indicated that it appeared they’d be about 18.3 percent. The lagging alternatives are now in and the investment earned on our endowment pool for the fiscal year ending June 30 is actually going to be 20.4 percent which I think will put us in the top quartile nationally among universities and really stands pretty well given the fact that our endowment remains relatively modest and we’re competing against multi- billion dollar endowments like Harvard. We’ve beaten Harvard four out of the last five years by the way in terms of endowment return. So very proud of the volunteer committee that works on our behalf in terms of reviewing suggestions for allocation and also managers and also our group that we pay to advise us on those investments, a fund evaluation group. In the foundation and development area we’ve been really working on preparing as much infrastructure as we can for the transition in leadership. We have scrubbed the database. We’ve added another screening, a wealth capacity screening to our database called Donor Cast which is a proprietary software screen by Bentz Whaley Flessner who we’ve engaged to do some work for us. We are currently beginning a review of the prospect coordination policy. This is the policy by which all the units in the university need to agree on the rules of engagement for prospects and donors. Who will ask, who will cultivate, what they will be asked for as you know many NIU Board of Trustees 14 December 4, 2014 donors have multiple interests in the university. It may be athletics, it may be arts, but they may be a college of business grad as well. So we need a policy that we all agree to that sorts that out and the goal is to obviously ask for the gift that will result in the biggest donation to NIU in general. We’re going to be reviewing that with President Baker, senior cabinet, the deans, athletic director, etc. We have a policy in place, we’re just looking at best practices at this point. We’ve begun very preliminarily to talk with university leadership about capital projects that might be part of the next campaign. It’s not too early to begin planning and developing some program statements for those and every major gift officer is going through a portfolio review right now where we go name by name and go through the portfolio and put on and maybe put in the parking lot some that have not been very active over the past 18 months and then add some new names to each gift officers portfolio that we call the discovery pool where they need to make a contact with those individuals within the next six months. I’ve been doing personal visits to major donors to our first campaign, True North. My goal is to meet personally with every individual that made a very significant gift to True North. I’ve obviously been in the Chicago area, I’ve been in Massachusetts, Texas, next week I’m in Florida, on the west coast of Florida. I have trips planned to Missouri and to New York just basically to thank them for what they’ve done, but also to prepare the way for the new person at the helm of both the division and the foundation. One visit did result in an estate commitment of a million dollars. We’ll announce that a little bit later because we’re still discussing details with the donor. A couple I think when we finally get around to announcing it, it will be in excess of that number. We’ve had some great responses. I think their excited about the direction that the university is headed. Most of the gifts you get in your second campaign will be from donors you already know and donors who have already given. I think there is a bit of a concern that they not be forgotten, okay that just because a name changes on letterhead that they won’t be forgotten and we need to keep as many tethers attached to our major donors from the university and the community as possible. And that concludes my report. Chair Butler thanked Mr. Malone, indicating that his comments regarding the pre-game events provided some information on Northern Illinois University’s Alumni Association, and he asked if Mr. Malone had anything else to add to that on behalf of Mr. Matte. Mr. Malone stated that Joe and the Alumni Association are also involved in obviously building out the intern and mentor program with alumni and actually Joe was heading up the search for meeting and academics base in Chicago as well as sort of other duties as assigned. Chair Butler indicated that Joe did talk to me about the possibility that he wouldn’t be able to be here if our meetings went longer than expected and he’s doing good work for the university in his travels. Chair Butler then moved to the Northern Illinois Research Foundation, which was presented by Vice President for Research and Innovation, Lesley Rigg. j. Northern Illinois Research Foundation Dr. Rigg explained that the NIU Research Foundation board met last Thursday, September 11 th in the evening at Hoffman Estates. Various updates were received by the board on IP activities and other research activities here at NIU. It was also the annual meeting where all the elections of directors and appointed officers are made. At this meeting I was voted the new president of the research foundation and my term began immediately following that September 11 th meeting. Dr. Freeman, who was the outgoing president, has been retained in an administrative appointment on the board and will continue to collaborate with me in the future on many of the issues that were initiated during her time there. We very happily voted three new outside board members to the board. They are Dr. Robert Kephart who is the director of IARC at Fermi Lab. The board has maintain representation from Argon National Lab and noted that NIU has a strong collaboration with Fermi Lab and that having a representative from both ANL and Fermi Lab made a lot of sense and was also very important for the research mission of our institution. Eric Wasowicz who is an investor and entrepreneur and an NIU alum, who’s actively involved on the campus through entrepreneurship course in the College of Business and to serve us on the college board. Eric has hosted workshops on entrepreneurship for the NIU Foundation’s Venture grant process NIU Board of Trustees 15 December 4, 2014 and is currently serving on the Innovation and Entrepreneurship Committee which is being chaired by Dr. Lisa Freeman. The third member that was brought on was William F. Martewski who is an NIU alum and the owner of the law office of William F. Martewski which is currently located in Chicago. William is a successful NIU alum with a background in tax law and an interest in giving back to the NIU community through his participation on the NIRF board. It was a very good meeting and we’re looking forward to the next year. Chair Butler thanked Dr. Rigg and all those who presented reports. I appreciate everyone preparing such thoughtful observations and input. PRESIDENT’S REPORT NO. 92 UNIVERSITY RECOMMENDATIONS FORWARDED BY THE BOARD COMMITTEES Agenda Item 9.a.(1) – Fiscal Year 2015 Internal Budget Chair Butler called for a motion to approve the items in President’s report No. 94 that were approved to be considered as part of the consent agenda. Trustee Strauss moved and Trustee Boey seconded. There was no discussion and the motion passed. Chair Butler then recognized President Baker. President Baker began by saying a couple words about the semester roll out. We’re just a few weeks into it now, but I want to thank the faculty and the staff of the university for such an amazing roll out. We thought a lot about it in the spring and a lot of people took up arms so to speak and went to work and I really appreciate that hard work. There was a different buzz this year than last year and it’s because the faculty and staff took it on. They thought about it and they went out and did it and a lot of people took initiative and leadership at their local levels to make a difference and I thank all of them so very much. I got scores of letters, e-mail letters from moms and dads saying I’ve moved my kids in somewhere else and this was by far the best experience I’ve ever seen. It was effortless, we felt welcomed as parents and our students did as well. And that whole weekend, that first start up weekend was amazing from the march out to the parents and family welcome at the convocation center to the dance that we had that night that was a big deal; and even the president’s picnic down here by the lagoon was great fun and I hope nobody goes and looks at pictures of Sean Frazier and me paddling around in the lagoon, but it was great fun and I’m convinced that may have been the first time some of the students were in a canoe and then were out of a canoe and then were in a canoe and then were out of a canoe, but it was great fun to rediscover the lagoon one of the most beautiful places we have on campus. We have great assets here and it was wonderful to see that buzz. We had students performing for about four hours on stage down there and the talent was amazing and some of the freshmen that I was talking to there would say those are students. They were just amazed by the talent we had on the stage and some of the upper class students, juniors and seniors that were there, told me I’ve never been down here before, this is beautiful, I didn’t know it was here. So I think some of the efforts that we took to try and get the university to rediscover the water and the university has happened; and it is a beautiful place. And I see Ron back here. That was one of the ideas that came out of the design shred this spring. Thank you Ron for helping lead that effort, a number of those things. And to Bill and his crew for all the hard work to get the banners up and to get the posters up and clean up the MLK Mall so it’s an inviting place. A lot of good work got done in a short period of time. Thank you very much. So that does link to 9A1 and this is the internal budget and I want to extend thanks again in this case to the interim Vice President for Finance, Nancy Suttenfield, to Lisa Freeman and to their staffs who worked so hard; and also to IT. I guess Brett just left, but we had an IT staff member involved as well, that worked so hard to pull together a budget and a budget process, budget principles that were widely shared across the university. It was an enormous effort and it’s gotten us to a balanced budget in a strategic way and I want to thank them and propose to you that this budget be approved. Chair Butler called for a motion to approve the internal budget, which was moved and seconded. He asked for any discussion and went on to state that he wanted to say thank you also to the individuals NIU Board of Trustees 16 December 4, 2014 who worked on this, particularly Nancy Suttenfield for the time and the effort and your colleague in this Dr. Freeman. It was something that we discussed extensively at the committee level and I wanted to make sure that we marked the moment that we supported it as a board. This is the fiscal sustainability portion of the priorities that I spoke about earlier and I think that in supporting this budget we are demonstrating our appreciation for the hard work that’s gone into it. This is, for those of you who might be new to this and I don’t think there are anyone here who are, this is a revolutionary document. There’s a lot of information in here that we’ve never seen before, that’s never come before this board, and it’s out there for everybody to read and consider and to debate and it’s a level of transparency that I’m very proud of for this board and for this administration. Chair Butler called for a vote and there was no opposition so the internal budget was approved. ITEMS DIRECTLY FROM THE PRESIDENT Agenda Item 9.c.(1) – Permanent Easement for Prairie Professional Park LLC President Baker continued with 9.c.1 and that’s the permanent easement for Prairie Professional Park LLC. So if you’ll turn to page 147 or look at the single blown up version of this map that you’ve got in front of you at your table, you’ll not a big pink square and a yellow portion at the bottom called the Monsanto Campus. So to orient you, the Monsanto Campus is across the street from Kishwaukee Hospital and that’s where we have the Monsanto Building and there’s a picture on page two of what it physically looks like. Prairie Professional Park would like to put four parking stalls in and those are in the bottom left corner, the pink area, and right below that is a little blue slice, so those four rectangles in that pink area are parking stalls to orient you to the rough size of it. And the blue area is a little sliver of land that they would like to be able to drive across to put the cars in the parking slots. So they’re asking for an easement to allow them to drive their cars there and this is not land that we’re using or plan to use and it’s a little tiny sliver, so being good citizens, we would recommend to you the approval of the easement of this land to allow them to use those parking stalls and drive across. Chair Butler called for a motion to approve this item. The motion was made by Trustee Boey and seconded by Trustee Iosco. Chair Butler called for any discussion on this motion and there was none. A roll call vote on this motion was necessary, so Ms. Banks-Wilkins called the roll call vote. Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Trustee Boey Trustee Boey: Yes. Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Trustee Iosco Trustee Iosco: Yes Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Trustee Marshall Trustee Marshall: Yes Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Trustee Strauss Trustee Strauss: Abstain Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Student Trustee Julion Student Trustee Julion: Yes Ms. Banks-Wilkins: Chair Butler Chair Butler: Yes. Chair Butler indicated that the motion passed and called for the next item. Agenda Item 9.c.(2) – Delegation of Authority to Implement the Illinois Smoke-Free Campus Act President Baker continued to the next item, which is in response to the legislature passing and the governor signing a ban on smoking on public university campuses and so we need to comply with this by next summer and we’re required to put together a committee. And this asks you to delegate to me the authority to set up the committee to put this piece of legislation in place on our campus. So I would move that you approve the delegation of authority to me bring this policy into action and implement here NIU Board of Trustees 17 December 4, 2014 at the university. Chair Butler called for a motion to approve the delegation of authority to the President to put in motion a community task force and all that comes after that to implement this important piece of legislation, which was given by Trustee Strauss and seconded by Trustee Boey. Chair Butler asked for any discussion on the motion and there was none so the motion passed. President Baker thanked the Trustees and I noted that he was looking at this in two ways. One is the enforcement piece of course and getting the information out on that, but the other is this is an educational opportunity for us. We know smoking is harmful to health and this is an opportunity for us to use as an education tool and to help with smoking cessation programs for faculty, staff and students and so we’re going to engage the resources on campus, the people with expertise in this, to see if we can help with that activity and not just police this into submission, but see if we can improve the overall health with is the underlying intent I think of this kind of legislation. Thank you for the authority to do that and Marc if we need somebody to help we’ll know who to call. Agenda Item 9.c.(3) – Grant and Contract Awards President Baker moved to the next item, which was an information item, and these are the grants and contract that have been awarded since our last meeting and this is an information item and we’d be happy to answer any questions on the luminous grants and contracts that you have in front of you. Chair Butler asked if the Trustees had any questions on the grants and contracts items and there was none so President Baker concluded his report. Chair Butler noted that his report had been eliminated. CHAIR’S REPORT NO. 67 Chair Butler noted that these items were removed from the agenda. Agenda Item 10.a. – Benchmarking Review and Modifications to Achieve More timely and Efficient Contracting and Procurement: Resolution to Approve Modifications Agenda Item 10.a.(1) – Amendment to Board of Trustees Regulations Section V.B.2. – Financial Affairs Obligation of Financial Resources Agenda Item 10.a.(2) – Amendment to Board of Trustees Regulations Section VI.A.2. – Physical Facilities – Real Property Agenda Item 10.a.(3) – Amendment to Board of Trustees Regulations Section VII.F.1. – Legal Proceedings and Actions OTHER MATTERS Chair Butler noted before asking for any other matters that Vice-President Nicklas will have retired by the next board meeting and that a more formal statement would be made at the December meeting. He then asked if there were any further matters for discussion. NIU Board of Trustees 18 December 4, 2014 NEXT MEETING DATE Chair Butler indicated that there were no other matters and that the next meeting date of this board is December 4, 2014. He thanked all for their patience and stated that we respect very much your respect for us and the time that you give to these meetings and thank you again for coming. ADJOURNMENT Chair Butler called for a motion to adjourn the meeting. Trustee Strauss motioned and it was seconded by Trustee Iosco. There was no discussion and a call was made. All agreed and the meeting was adjourned 1:20 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Sharon Banks-Wilkins Recording Secretary In compliance with Illinois Open Meetings Act 5 ILCS 120/1, et seq, a verbatim record of all Northern Illinois University Board of Trustees meetings is maintained by the Board Recording Secretary and is available for review upon request. The minutes contained herein represent a true and accurate summary of the Board proceedings. NIU Board of Trustees 19 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 6. December 4, 2014 RESOLUTION HONORING BILL NICKLAS WHEREAS, wise stewardship is critical to the vitality and economic sustainability of institutions of higher education in the State of Illinois, and service to others within one’s community are hallmarks of strong character and excellence; and, WHEREAS, devoting one’s professional life to responsible governance, civic engagement, and positive community relations is a pursuit worthy of the highest praise; and, WHEREAS, sustaining a high standard of university governance requires intelligent and imaginative approaches to facilitate and align the work of a university with that of its governing board; and WHEREAS, Bill Nicklas, over the course of three years as a senior leader at NIU, has served the university in multiple and extended appointments, including as Associate Vice President for Institutional Planning and Sustainability, Vice President of Public Safety and Community Relations, Liaison to the Board of Trustees, and Vice President of Operations and Community Relations; and, WHEREAS, Bill Nicklas assumed the role of Board Liaison during a critical leadership transition: immediately following the selection and installation of the 12th President of NIU, Dr. Douglas Baker, in July of 2013; and, WHEREAS, Bill Nicklas’ leadership as Board Liaison was essential to ensuring that Trustees remained steadfast in their resolve to add value to institutional leadership and decision making, focus on their essential role as fiduciaries, remain committed to the covenants of shared governance, improve the Board’s capacity and functionality, and focus their time on issues of greatest consequence to the institution; and, WHEREAS, Bill Nicklas brought to his NIU responsibilities an extensive and impressive background as a trusted and respected public servant – having served 13 years as Chief Administrative Officer for the City of Sycamore and as City Manager for the City of DeKalb from 1992 to 1997 – and in all his deeds embodies the potential of an NIU education – having earned both a Master’s Degree and Ph.D. in American History from NIU; and, WHEREAS, Bill Nicklas, upon his retirement, on October 31, 2014, leaves to a the next generation of leaders a clarity of purpose and model of exceptional leadership practice; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees of Northern Illinois University in formal meeting herein assembled, extends its grateful appreciation to Bill Nicklas for his leadership and service to the administration, faculty, staff, students, and Board of Trustees of Northern Illinois University. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this RESOLUTION be presented to Bill Nicklas and a copy of this document be placed in the official files of the Board of Trustees as part of the permanent record of the university and the great State of Illinois and as a lasting tribute to the accomplishments of Bill Nicklas. NIU Board of Trustees 20 December 4, 2014 Adopted in a regular meeting assembled this 4th day of December 2014. BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY John Butler Board Chair Wheeler Coleman Board Secretary NIU Board of Trustees 20 December 4, 2014 President's Report No. 95 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(1) December 4, 2014 REQUEST FOR A CHANGE IN DEGREE DESIGNATION This change in degree designation request has received all required curricular approvals at the department, college and university levels, endorsement by the Academic Planning Council and the concurrence of the Executive Vice President and Provost. This request will be forwarded to the Illinois Board of Higher Education for approval. Ph.D. in Counselor Education and Supervision Description: The university proposes to change the degree designator for the current Ed.D. in Counselor Education and Supervision to a Ph.D. in Counselor Education and Supervision degree program in the Department of Counseling, Adult and Higher Education within the College of Education. Rationale: The Department of Counseling, Adult and Higher Education proposes to change the degree designator for the current doctoral program in Counselor Education and Supervision from an Ed.D. to a Ph.D. reflecting best practices within the discipline and better alignment with the program’s disciplinary accreditor, the Council for Accreditation in Counselor Education and Related Programs (CACREP). Data from September 2013 indicate that of the 62 programs in the U.S. accredited by CACREP, only nine (14%) continued to offer an Ed.D. in Counselor Education and Supervision. The remaining 53 (86%) either offered a Ph.D. or were in the process of transitioning to a Ph.D. The proposed change would make NIU graduates more competitive with those who graduate from other Ph.D. programs in educational counseling and supervision and increase the likelihood that prospective students interested in this field would identify NIU as their institution of first choice. The counselor education and supervision faculty have been preparing for this transition for several years and have implemented changes in course work and program requirements to move to the Ph.D. These changes were made based on a feedback from external reviewers and CACREP standards and have led to a more research-based, robust degree program. Once the Ph.D. degree is implemented, all students would be admitted to this program; the Ed.D degree will be phased out. Students currently enrolled in the program will be given the option of electing the Ed.D. degree or the Ph.D. degree if they complete the appropriate requirements. Costs: No new resources are needed to implement the proposed Ph.D. degree program in counselor education and supervision; the requirements for the doctoral degree are staffed and funded. Recommendation: The university recommends that the Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee endorse this request and ask that the president forward it by means of the President’s Report to the Board of Trustees for approval at its December 4, 2014 meeting. NIU Board of Trustees 21 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(2) December 4, 2014 REQUEST FOR A NEW DEGREE PROGRAM All new degree programs require the approval of the Board of Trustees and the approval of the Illinois Board of Higher Education. This new program request has received all of the required curricular approvals at the department, college, and university levels, has been endorsed by the Academic Planning Council, and has the concurrence of the Executive Vice President and Provost. Doctor of Nursing Practice (D.N.P.) Description: The university seeks approval for a Doctor of Nursing Practice (D.N.P.) degree program in the School of Nursing and Health Studies within the College of Health and Human Sciences. Overview and Rationale: The proposed degree program addresses expanding roles for nurses in the healthcare industry, responds to a proposed requirement for the D.N.P. as entry into advanced practice nursing, maintains the completive advantage in attracting well-qualified applicants to graduate nursing programs at NIU; and delivers the knowledge and skills for nurses to practice in increasingly complex healthcare systems with diverse clients. The D.N.P. is a practice-oriented professional degree similar to the emphasis placed on professional practice doctorates in other health professions including: medicine (M.D.), dentistry (D.D.S.), psychology (Psy.D.), physical therapy (D.P.T.), and audiology (Aud.D.). The D.N.P. program is grounded in advanced nursing knowledge, collaborative leadership, and evidence-based practices focused on addressing issues and needs of diverse client populations and healthcare systems. It is designed to accommodate both Bachelor’s (Entry-Level B.S. to D.N.P.) and Master’s prepared nurses (Post-Master’s to D.N.P.) who desire to assume the roles of leader and change agent. Implementation of the D.N.P. degree program at NIU will begin with Post-Master’s students. This degree is a logical extension of existing programs and builds upon the expertise and facilities already in place. The proposed D.N.P. reflects a much-needed expansion of education requirements from NIU’s current graduate-level programming in nursing. The year 2015 is a proposed target date for mandating the D.N.P. as entry-level educational preparation for advanced practice nursing roles by the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN). While the final deadline and mandate for converting all educational programs to the D.N.P. has not yet been announced, it is likely to occur within the next five years. If NIU’s graduate nursing programs are to remain viable, it is imperative that the proposed D.N.P. program be implemented prior to the date when D.N.P. preparation is mandated by the AACN for Nurse Practitioners and Clinical Nurse Specialists. Student enrollment for the D.N.P. is anticipated at 10 individuals enrolled part-time for the first year the program is offered (3.3 FTE) and is expected to increase to 60 individuals (20 FTE) by the fifth year of the program when it is fully implemented. Costs: Support for the program will be realized through reallocation of existing university resources. Potential also exists for differential tuition. Recommendation: The university recommends that the Academic Affairs, Student Affairs, and Personnel Committee endorse this request and asks that the president forward it by means of the President’s Report to the Board of Trustees for approval at its December 4, 2014 meeting. NIU Board of Trustees 22 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(3) December 4, 2014 BOWL GAME PARTICIPATION EXPENSES Summary: The university has requested that the Board of Trustees delegate to the President, or his designee, approval for all necessary and proper expenses related to NIU’s participation in a post-season Bowl Game competition, including (but not limited to) the following: the Bowl agreement(s), expenses relating to ticketing, tickets, travel/transportation, lodging, rentals, insurance, dining, beverages (nonalcoholic), fees, services, broadcast, apparel, commodities, equipment, and supplies. Further, such approval is requested to also authorize the President, or designee, to undertake all business transactions necessary in relation to an anticipated upcoming Bowl event. Recommendation: Board of Trustees approval is requested for expenditure authority for a post-season Bowl Game competition and delegation of approval authority to the President, or designee, to undertake all transactions necessary in relation to the Bowl, reporting actions taken where required beyond customary authorizations at a subsequent meeting of the Board. NIU Board of Trustees 23 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(4) December 4, 2014 FY16 TUITION, FEES, AND ROOM AND BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS Background and Summary: Last year, NIU modified the review and management process and related timelines for developing recommendations for the “pricing” of students’ total cost of attendance (COA) such that all tuition and fee decisions were made in February. In previous years, the Administration presented its recommendations for over a dozen separate student fees and for various room and board rates to the Finance, Facilities, and Operations Committee in February, with approval by the Board of Trustees following in March. Tuition rates (per credit hour) were adopted later in a separate action by the Board at its June meeting to permit subsequent preparation and approval of the next annual budget. This year, the Administration recommends advancing these pricing decisions to December. As noted last year, there are several compelling reasons to move these decisions up another three months: x x x x Some Illinois institutions (and others around the nation) make their pricing decisions in January. Approval later than January is an unnecessary competitive disadvantage to NIU at the very time we are implementing multi-faceted long-term strategies and short-term tactics to boost enrollment and generate the revenue essential for fiscal equilibrium. Most institutions of higher education have prepared their financial aid offers by mid-March; these offers must by law consider the total COA. Earlier pricing will allow NIU to use staff time more effectively and efficiently to focus on other aspects of our student aid practices to be more responsive to needs of students and their families. Many current NIU students begin making final decisions as early as January about whether to continue living in our residence halls. The earlier timeline for approvals of next year’s housing rates will allow NIU to maximize re-capture of students who might choose to live on campus, and thus improve our ability to maximize housing revenue, as well as foster a more vibrant residence hall and on-campus social community that is attractive and important to current and prospective students. Demand is a function of both marketplace and price, along with many other combinations of unique factors that students and parents consider. For this reason, along with continued focus on earlier pricing decisions our consolidated pricing recommendation provides for an increase in tuition and fees, with a more than offsetting reduction in room and board rates. The result is a reduction of 2.8 percent in the total COA for entering freshmen and transfers compared to fiscal year 2015. This year, there is an additional reason to advance pricing decisions to December. This decision point is the final step in accomplishing an annual timetable that permits a more effective, efficient, and transparent annual budget development process. With pricing decisions made in December, the annual budget planning and development process for the next fiscal year can begin in January, thus permitting a final budget for both the operating budget (and a new annual capital budget) in June versus September. Compared to the last internal budget cycle, which was tightly compressed and did not conclude until late August, this timetable allows more time for analysis and discussions with University leaders and other campus stakeholders. There have been clear benefits to increased transparency across the board during the past year. Further transparency and opportunity for interactive discussion during an expanded budget development phase will permit a continued focus on enrollment issues and fiscal sustainability within the new academic responsiveness/fiscal responsibility oversight model and reflecting our Guiding Principles for Financial Planning and Budgeting, and will thus allow for better informed decision making. NIU Board of Trustees 24 December 4, 2014 Moreover, assuming that decisions on appropriations are made prior to the end of June, the University will be better able to notify campus units about their approved budgets as close to the beginning of the fiscal year as possible. In order for there to be appropriate alignment of responsibility and budget authority, campus units need as much time as possible to notify their academic departments and other administrative units of the resources that will be available for the fiscal/academic year to dedicate to their student career success and other strategic goals. As noted, the Administration is recommending a reduction in its total COA for entering undergraduate students living in most residence halls. Our undergraduate pricing recommendations thus reflect a continuation of last year’s approach with some minor exceptions explained in the next section. The recommendations for graduate pricing, however, represent a number of major reforms that are related to one another and aimed at increasing enrollments and generating revenue by pricing programs instead of courses. The recommendation reflects an entirely new pricing structure that overcomes numerous current challenges and obstacles represented in the pricing of education delivered on-campus, off-campus, or online. Similar to the extended time devoted to the pricing of undergraduate education last year, the Administration welcomes the opportunity to devote significant time this year to a focus on the pricing of graduate education. Appendix I provides a comparison of NIU’s tuition and fees to other Illinois institutions for the past ten years. In the next several sections, we describe the specific Fiscal Year 2016 recommendations for each major component of pricing that drives the total cost of attendance and 50 percent of the NIU revenue budget. I. Tuition Recommendations: Undergraduate Tuition Similar to the tuition approved for FY 2015, in concert with the other pricing recommendations that comprise the total cost of attendance (COA) the undergraduate tuition recommendation for FY 2016 reflects a 2.3 percent increase for a student enrolled in 15 credit hours. Further, the recommendation reflects: x x x Pricing that is consistent with NIU’s current market and does nothing to discourage a student from enrolling, all other things being equal; Pricing that also reflects the importance of accessibility and affordability to new students that NIU wishes to attract, following an extended period prior to FY 2015 during which the COA had been increasing while numbers of new NIU students and appropriations were declining, resulting in a financial model that is clearly not sustainable if not strategically altered for current circumstances; A pricing decision early enough in the financial aid packaging cycle to have a positive impact on student/family choices for FY 2016 and in future enrollment cycles; In addition to the above rationale, the tuition recommendations also reflect Truth-in-Tuition legislation, which took effect Fall 2004 for Illinois residents seeking an undergraduate degree. Under the provisions of the law, the entering degree-seeking undergraduate class for each fiscal year, beginning in FY 2005, is guaranteed the same tuition rates for four continuous years. NIU policy adds one additional semester to this four year guarantee. NIU’s current policy is that after nine continuous semesters, the guaranteed undergraduate tuition rate adjusts to the fixed tuition rate paid by students who entered the university one fiscal year after the date of original entry for two years (in accordance with Senate Bill 3222 which was passed effective July 1, 2010). The fixed tuition rates for such students are maintained consistent with that cohort. NIU Board of Trustees 25 December 4, 2014 Other FY2016 recommendations that are reflected emanate from a new tuition task force established by the Executive Vice President and Provost and the Interim Chief Financial Officer. The task force was charged with making a comprehensive review of all instruction-related pricing to assure that it is rational and easy to understand by prospective and enrolled students, parents, and individuals inside and outside of NIU and that it is structured so as to generate sufficient revenue to sustain the institution, sustain the institution’s value proposition, and eliminate barriers to enrollment by prospective students. The task force was asked to examine alternatives that would address the following broad goals: x x x x x Modify or eliminate the current declining credit hour rate structure to eliminate unintended consequences that occur when a student drops individual courses; and to encourage students to enroll in more than the minimum number of hours required to be classified as full-time. Consider establishing an alternative tuition rate to attract more students from adjacent states. Identify options to use housing scholarships to fill residence halls in concert with alternative tuition rates for out-of-state and international students. Identify obstacles as well as opportunities to modify tuition to make NIU more competitive with major local competitors. Examine, rationalize, and simplify current program fee, on-line tuition, and other pricing and identify changes that may be in order. Accordingly, in addition to a 2.3 percent tuition increase, the Administration is recommending two changes that affect the structure of undergraduate tuition as follow: 1. Abandon the declining credit hour structure and replace it with a flattened bundled structure. The current declining credit hour structure was originally thought to be an incentive to encourage students to take additional courses and graduate on time. There is no evidence that it ever had that effect. The declining rate structure has created enormous confusion for students and parents and is highly difficult to administer due to its complexity. This strategic change from a declining scale to a bundled rate is estimated to have a time savings, simplification factor, and better service implications for the service areas interacting with students and parents addressing concerns. 2. Establish a lower out-of-state tuition for students from the Midwest (i.e., Iowa, Wisconsin, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Missouri) that covers the direct and estimated indirect instructional costs at 140 percent of in-state tuition to create a greater incentive for these students to enroll at NIU. (Students from other states, of which there are not many, would continue to be charged tuition at 200 percent of the in-state rate.) Although there is a revenue loss associated with this reduction, it is estimated that recruitment of approximately 80 additional students would make this proposal revenue neutral, which could be achieved through purchase of a student prospect list and targeted recruitment of students from these states. See Table 1 at the end of this section for a summary of the undergraduate pricing recommendation along with the graduate pricing recommendations described below. Graduate Tuition The Administration recommends a series of structural changes to graduate and law student tuition. All of the changes are recommended with the objective in mind of either easing burdens that fall on graduate and law students or of providing pathways to enrollment growth and additional revenue production. The Administration recommends establishing an alternative tuition rate for graduate assistants and fellows equal to the in-state rate. This recommendation is revenue neutral, but it will ease a tax withholding burden that falls on out-of-state graduate assistants who serve in graduate staff assistant roles. Additionally, billing graduate assistants and fellows at the in-state rate will align our tuition policies NIU Board of Trustees 26 December 4, 2014 with our grant policies, which require cost recovery for only the in-state portion of tuition, when tuition can be included in an externally-funded grant or contract. The Administration recommends combining “tuition” (currently $349.18 per credit hour) and “general fee” charges (currently $113.16 per credit hour) into one consolidated tuition rate for graduate students and law students. Charging graduate students a consolidated tuition in each semester will aid in attracting to NIU students with employer reimbursement. Generally, employer reimbursement benefits are limited to tuition charges only, making NIU, even when the institution of first choice, appear less attractive to prospective students who can attend a private institution with 100 percent reimbursement of tuition. Furthermore, consolidating the instructional charge and fees, which together constitute the cost of instruction, into a single tuition charge makes the true cost of attendance readily apparent to adult students. The Administration recommends establishing a minimum graduate program and law school differential tuition rate of $30 per credit hour and a maximum of $400 per credit hour in addition to the tuition charge described above. Currently, advanced students are charged program, excellence, and regional delivery fees, ranging from $50 per hour to $349.18 per hour. This recommendation eliminates program, excellence, and regional delivery fees and replaces them with a differential tuition charge that will be approved by the Executive Vice President and Provost and the Chief Financial Officer. Because the differential tuition will be applied to all students admitted to a program of study, regardless of the location of the program, academic leaders including deans will need to determine how best to propose a differential tuition that takes into consideration individual program costs and competitive pricing for the program in question; thus, the recommendation is for the Board to approve a minimum and maximum rate that accommodates a wide range of reasonable possibilities. Online Tuition The Administration recommends establishing a minimum tuition rate of $500 per credit hour and a maximum tuition rate of $1,000 per credit hour for one year, FY 2016, for both graduate and undergraduate online programs. Over a two year period, the undergraduate online program rate range will facilitate a demonstration project to determine the viability of large scale online programming designed particularly to appeal to adult students in our region, as well as international students. The components of the minimum online tuition rate are illustrated below in Figure 1. This recommendation relies on approval of a consolidated tuition charge and differential tuition, where the minimum differential charge will be $30 per hour and the maximum differential charge will be $530. NIU’s efforts to develop budget and pricing models to stimulate growth of online programs and enrollment has been discussed for many years. Coupled with the efforts of the Office of Online Program Development and Support, this recommendation paves the way for that growth. Figure 1 Components of Online Tuition: Rates for FY 2016 Components of Tuition Minimum Per Maximum Per Hour Charge Hour Charge Instructional Charge $357 $357 Central Services Charge $69 $69 Outreach Charge $18 $18 Career/Professional Development Charge $4 $4 Technology Charge $22 $22 Program Differential $30 $530 TOTAL Online Tuition $500 $1,000 NIU Board of Trustees 27 December 4, 2014 The recommended tuition rates for undergraduate, graduate and law students are presented in Table 1. Table 1 Fiscal Year 2016 Tuition Recommendations Undergraduate: AY 16 Part Time Per Cr. Hr. Rate 1 - 11 Cr. Hrs. $348.84 Full Time Package/Bundle Rate 12 or more Cr. Hrs. $4,732.80 PriorTruth in Tuition Year Rates (cap at 14 hrs.) AY 15 AY 14 AY 13 AY 12 AY 11 AY 10 1 - 13 Cr. Hrs $330.45 $323.95 $317.60 $303.20 $283.90 $259.25 14 or more Cr. Hrs. $4,626.30 $4,535.30 $4,446.40 $4,244.80 $3,974.60 $3,629.50 (1) Undergraduates who are entering in FY2016 or who are non-degree seeking; non-residents in the Midwest at 1.4 times and all others at 2 times the FY2016 rate. Graduate: 1 - 11 Cr. Hrs. 12 or more Cr. Hrs. AY 16 $493.63 $5,923.56 The above hourly tuition rate includes an instructional charge of $357 per credit hour and an institutional charge of $136.63 per credit hour. Law: 1 - 11 Cr. Hrs. 12 or more Cr. Hrs. AY 16 $913.27 $10,959.24 The above hourly tuition rate includes an instructional charge of $677.29 per credit hour and an institutional charge of $235.98 per credit hour. II. Room and Board Recommendations: The collection of room and board from students living in university residence halls supports Student Housing and Dining Services operations and related Revenue Bond obligations. Room rate recommendations typically address increased student wage and service contract costs, software support, indirect costs, contractual services, general operating expenses, and debt service payments related to renovations to the residence halls. At this time, in order to address student affordability concerns, the university is recommending a single room and board rate that represents a 7.08 percent reduction in rates for Fiscal Year 2016 as a modest step to entice more students to reside on campus and to reduce the total pricing package for students entering the University in the Fall of 2015. (NOTE: Rates for New Hall and Northern View, the Collegiate Housing Foundation II Project, are considered separately and are not included in this recommendation.) A summary is provided in Table 2 which details each residence hall room and board rate. NIU Board of Trustees 28 December 4, 2014 Table 2 Fiscal Year 2016 Room and Board Rate Recommendations NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY ROOM & BOARD COMPARISON FY15 and FY16 FY15 FY16 NEPTUNE Double as Single Double $ $ RATE 4,658 3,663 NEPTUNE Multiple-Occupancy RATE $4,703 GILBERT Double $ 4,206 GILBERT Multiple-Occupancy $ 5,246 GRANT TOWERS Single Double $ $ 4,828 4,206 GRANT TOWERS C/D Towers - Single-Occupancy C/D Towers - Multiple-Occupancy $5,868 $5,246 STEVENSON TOWERS Single Double Suite with bath, 2-person Suite with bath, 4-person Suite, no bath, 2-person Suite, no bath, 4-person $ $ $ $ $ $ 4,828 4,206 5,637 4,635 5,389 4,389 STEVENSON TOWERS Single-Occupancy Multiple-Occupancy $5,868 $5,246 MEAL PLANS Huskie Unlimited Huskie 65 Huskie 90 $ $ $ 1,040 1,040 1,440 Other Residential Fees Winter Break Fee Prior to deadline After deadline $42/week or $150/4 weeks $56/week or $200/4 weeks Living-Learning Communities $50/semester (Formerly Academic Residential Programs) Board Rates In an effort to best meet the dining center usage patterns for residential students and to minimize the cost of the board plan, all residents will purchase the existing Unlimited Access meal plan for FY2016 as part of their room and board package. There is an expectation that the reduced cost could result in additional nonresident student participation to help make it budget neutral through this and other dining NIU Board of Trustees 29 December 4, 2014 program initiatives. Since the required meal plan will be the same for all students, it allows NIU to create a combined room and board rate that brings us in line with what other universities are already doing in terms of showing a combined rate. It also gives students and parents a single number that they can use to determine the cost of living in the residence halls. Finally, a combined room and board rate falls in line with our desire for student bills to be streamlined and easier to read. III. Student Fee Recommendations: The university has numerous student activities, programs, services and operations that are supported to various degrees by the assessment of dedicated-use student fees. Table 3 provides a summary of fee rates for FY 2015 and recommendations for FY 2016. This year, fee committees were again asked by the President to review the continuing necessity of each fee, ensure the fee is being utilized for the intended purpose, and assume a zero percent fee increase, unless compelling documentation could be provided that would support the need for an increase. As part of the simplification of pricing, the Administration is also recommending a two-year phase in that will collapse over a dozen separate dedicated fees into four broad categories of related fees for the purpose of publicized pricing and easier to explain billing. The color coded diagram that follows depicts the current fees and the new fee to which it will be mapped beginning with next year’s fee recommendations. The uses of each of the “fees within the new replacement fee” will be explained on the University website and still be reviewed, as currently, with students each year. The accounting for the fee allocations will continue in the same manner so that fee revenue remains dedicated to the approved purpose and assure continued transparency to the students who participate in the fee review process or any student who wishes to drill down to understand where the dollars go. This change is strictly “cosmetic” and involves no change in policy. NIU Board of Trustees 30 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 31 December 4, 2014 Excluding the health insurance fee increase, the increases recommended for approval represent a 0.3 percent increase for undergraduate students. Fees for graduate and law student are incorporated into the recommended tuition rates. Following Table 3, fee descriptions are provided to describe each fee and the recommended fee rate. Table 3 FISCAL YEAR 2016 FEE RECOMMENDATIONS (Including Pre-Approved Fees)+ CURRENT FEES FY 15 Per Credit Semester (@ 12 + Cr. Hrs.) Proposed Change per Credit Hour Hour 12 + Cr. Hrs.) Per Credit Semester (@ Hour Mandatory Fees PROPOSED FEES FY 16 Percent Change ACTIVITY FEE $ 4.40 $ 52.80 $ 0.13 $ 4.53 $ 54.36 3.0% ATHLETICS $ 22.59 $ 271.08 $ - $ 22.59 $ 271.08 0.0% BOND REVENUE Bond Facilities Living/Learning+ West Campus Improvement+ $ 38.98 29.78 6.00 3.20 $ 467.76 357.36 72.00 38.40 $ (0.10) (0.10) $ 38.88 29.78 6.00 3.10 $ 466.56 357.36 72.00 37.20 -0.3% 0.0% 0.0% -3.1% + BUS $ 9.45 $ 113.40 0.33 $ 9.78 $ 117.36 3.5% HEALTH SERVICES $ 10.25 123.00 - $ 10.25 123.00 0.0% GRANTS IN AID $ 0.88 10.56 - $ 0.88 10.56 0.0% STUDENT TO STUDENT GRANT $ 0.50 6.00 - $ 0.50 6.00 0.0% 250.00 - 250.00 0.0% 75.00 - 75.00 0.0% ACAD PROGRAM ENHANCEMENT CAMPUS IMPROVEMENT NA $ 6.25 $ NA $ 6.25 $ TOTAL IF REGISTERED FOR 12 OR MORE SEMESTER CREDIT HOURS* 2014-15 per Semester $ 1,369.60 UNDERGRADUATE 2015-16 per Semester $ 1,373.92 0.32% * Totals do not include the Health Insurance Fee Refundable Fee** HEALTH INSURANCE*** NA $ 759.00 - NA TBD ** Can be waived with proof of comparable insurance. *** For full time students only. FY 16 Rates not available yet. + = BOT Pre-approved fee schedule. NIU Board of Trustees 32 December 4, 2014 Fee Descriptions Activity Fee The Student Association recommends allocations from collected Activity Fees, which are used to support student organizations, activities, and programs including concerts, films, speakers, etc. The Student Activity Fee Review Committee is recommending a $.13 increase from $4.40 to $4.53 per semester credit hour for undergraduate students. The increase, 3 percent, is requested by the students on the committee, who feel strongly that the activities supported by these fees contribute to student engagement and retention by supporting student organizations and student services areas. Athletics Fee Intercollegiate Athletics maintains sixteen sports (7 men’s and 9 women’s) at the NCAA Division 1A level. The Athletic Fee is the primary source of fiscal support for Intercollegiate Athletics. In order to support operations in the coming fiscal year, the Athletics Fee will stay at $22.59 per credit hour, with no increase. Revenue Bond Fees Revenue Bond Fees are used to support facilities and operations that have been established through the issue of revenue bonds. Included in the Revenue Bond fee is the 1996 Bond Series fee and the 2010 Bond Series Fee. One of these fees have been pre-approved by the Board based on a schedule established when the financing arrangements were created. The 1996 Bond Series (West Campus Improvements) bond fee structure was established in 1997 and initiated in FY98. The approved structure provided a specific schedule for 1996 Bond Series fees through calendar year 2022, and began decreasing in FY03; therefore, a decrease of $0.10, from $3.20 to $3.10 per credit hour, is included in the overall bond fee package for FY 2016. The 2010 Bond Series (Living & Learning) bond fee structure was established in 2010 and initiated in FY12. The recommendations for each Revenue Bond fee are as follows: Holmes Student Center – The fee will remain at $12.33 per credit hour, with no increase. Recreation Center I – The fee will remain at $4.57 per credit hour, with no increase. Recreation Center II – The fee will remain at $2.26 per credit hour, with no increase. Huskie Stadium – The fee will remain at $2.40 per credit hour, with no increase. Convocation Center – The fee will remain at $8.22 per credit hour, with no increase. 1996 Bond Series (West Campus Improvements) – This previously approved fee decreases $0.10, from $3.20 to $3.10, per credit hour. 2010 Bond Series (Living & Learning) – The fee will remain at $6.00 per credit hour. Overall, the FY 2016 recommended bond fee package reflects an decrease of $0.10, from $38.98 to $38.88, per credit hour. Student Bus Service Fee The Bus Fee supports the university’s Huskie Line bus and Freedom Mobile paratransit services. All feepaying students are eligible to utilize Huskie buses without being charged fares. The Bus Fee Review Committee is recommending a $0.33 increase from $9.45 to $9.78 per semester credit hour NIU Board of Trustees 33 December 4, 2014 per academic semester and a $0.11 increase from $3.17 to $3.28 per semester credit hour for the summer session. These increases are needed to meet obligations of the contract with the vendor that provides student bus services. Health Service Fee The Health Service Fee supports the University Health Services, Disability Resources, and Health Enhancement, which provide comprehensive ambulatory health care, disability-related accommodations, and health education for students. The Health Fee Review Committee is recommending no increase at $10.25 per semester credit hour. Grants-in-Aid Fee The Grants-in-Aid Fee supports the University Scholar and Academic Finalist Awards Program, a scholarship-based financial aid program. It is the only major academically focused scholarship program available at Northern Illinois University for outstanding incoming new freshmen and community college transfers. The Grants-in-Aid Fee Review Committee is recommending no increase at $0.88 per semester credit hour. Student-to-Student Grant Revenues collected to fund the Student-to-Student Grant program support a need-based financial aid program for economically disadvantaged students. The fee is assessed only to undergraduate students registered for twelve or more credit hours of on-campus instruction and is refundable upon request. Schools are eligible for matching funds from the state of Illinois; however, matching funds were not appropriated in fiscal year 2014, and are not expected in fiscal year 2015. The fee is presently at the ISAC statutory maximum of $6.00 per semester; therefore, no increase is recommended for next year. Academic Program Enhancement and Instructional Surcharge The Academic Program Enhancement and Instructional Surcharge is a flat fee that is assessed in order to meet the ever-emerging demands for cutting edge academic programs and services for NIU students. Critical areas for funding include library journals and books, support for courses in high demand, technology upgrades, as well as support for identified academic strategic planning initiatives designed to strengthen, direct and further improve academic programs, research, and the academic experience of students. The fee will remain the same at $250.00 per semester. Campus Improvement Fee The resources generated by this fee will be used to maintain and improve classroom physical conditions, perform renovations needed to enhance the teaching and learning environment, provide support needed for classroom buildings and campus infrastructure improvements such as mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems. These basic needs must be satisfied in order to provide students with a quality learning environment and faculty with tools and surroundings from which they can perform their mission. The fee will remain at the current rate of $6.25 per semester credit hour. Health Insurance Fee The student health insurance plan provides comprehensive medical insurance for students and their dependents. The Health Insurance fee is a flat fee, which provides coverage for all students registered for nine or more credit hours of on-campus instruction, unless proof of comparable health insurance coverage is provided. It should be noted that Spring Semester enrollment in the plan includes summer NIU Board of Trustees 34 December 4, 2014 coverage regardless of whether the student is registered for summer session instruction. This assures year-round health insurance coverage for participating students. The Student Health Insurance Fee Review Committee is currently undergoing the Request for Proposal (RFP) process to select a plan administrator and underwriter for the FY2016 student health insurance plan. This process will not finished until the March 2015 Board of Trustees meeting. Overall Pricing Recommendation for Fiscal Year 2016: The university requests approval of the recommended FY 2016 pricing package as described in this item and detailed in Figure 1, Tables 1 – 3, and summarized in Table 4. These figures reflect the average annual costs for a full-time student at the undergraduate, graduate and law school level. NIU Board of Trustees 35 December 4, 2014 TABLE 4 Fiscal Year 2016 Tuition, Fee and Room & Board Recommendations Annual Cost Summary for Full-Time Students NEW UNDERGRADUATE STUDENTS FY 2015 In-State FY 2016 In-State Change FY15-FY16 $ % TUITION $ 9,253 $ 9,466 $ 213 2.30% FEES* $ 2,739 $ 2,748 $ 9 0.33% ROOM & BOARD** $ 11,292 $ 10,492 $ (800) -7.08% TOTAL $ 23,284 $ 22,706 $ (578) -2.48% Assumptions: Full-time 15 hours for both Fall and Spring * Excludes Health Insurance Fee ** Renovated Double, Grant, Gilbert, Stevenson; w ith an Unlimited Meal Plan ($2,080 in FY 2016). NOTE: Does not include housing rates at New Hall or Northern View . Those rates are set in a separate process. NEW AND CONTINUING GRADUATE STUDENTS FY 2015 In-State FY 2016 In-State Change FY15-FY16 $ % TUITION* $ 11,096 $ 11,847 $ 751 6.77% TOTAL $ 11,096 $ 11,847 $ 751 6.77% Assumptions: Full-time 12 hours for both Fall and Spring * In FY 2015 includes $2,716 in Fees. The FY 2016 figure is all Tuition. NEW AND CONTINUING LAW SCHOOL STUDENTS FY 2015 In-State FY 2016 In-State Change FY15-FY16 $ % TUITION* $ 21,564 $ 21,918 $ 354 1.64% TOTAL $ 21,564 $ 21,918 $ 354 1.64% Assumptions: Full-time 12 hours for both Fall and Spring * In FY 2015 includes $5,628 in Fees. The FY 2016 figure is all Tuition. NIU Board of Trustees 36 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 37 December 4, 2014 7,871 7,411 7,795 5,938 9,748 7,252 6,306 7,229 6,899 6,831 5,209 8,498 5,965 Northeastern IL University Northern Illinois University Western Illinois University SIU Carbondale SIU Edwardsville U of I Chicago U of I Springfield 9,966 5,478 11,244 8,108 10,546 7,033 8,899 8,079 8,589 7,998 9,019 5,966 7,990 $ 7,730 FY 2008 12,240 9,077 11,716 7,831 9,813 8,862 9,403 8,964 9,814 7,542 8,783 $ 8,878 FY 2009 12,660 9,541 12,034 8,336 10,411 9,617 10,180 9,908 10,531 8,352 9,429 $ 9,500 FY 2010 13,658 10,374 12,864 8,401 10,467 10,149 11,144 10,698 11,417 8,746 9,987 $ 10,366 FY 2011 14,414 10,984 13,464 8,865 11,038 10,719 11,795 11,394 12,230 8,936 10,534 $ 10,724 FY 2012 *Source: IBHE. Includes student health insurance, which can be waived with proof of comparable insurance. 8,688 7,166 7,091 Illinois State University U of I Urbana-Champaign 8,040 5,050 Governors State University 7,035 6,339 Eastern Illinois University $ 7,138 FY 2007 $ 6,626 FY 2006 Chicago State University PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES ($ in 000s) TUITION & FEES* HISTORY FY 2006 - FY 2015 Entry Level, Annual, Full-Time Undergraduate Students Appendix I ILLINOIS PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES 14,960 11,413 13,938 9,251 11,528 11,182 12,472 11,435 12,726 9,116 10,930 $ 11,006 FY 2013 15,258 11,776 14,338 9,666 11,942 11,766 12,853 12,015 13,010 9,386 11,144 $ 11,126 FY 2014 15,602 12,195 14,588 9,738 12,056 12,217 13,510 12,609 13,296 9,386 11,108 $ 11,912 FY 2015 8.8% 11.6% 8.0% 9.7% 8.5% 8.6% 9.7% 11.1% 9.7% 9.5% 8.4% 8.9% Average Annual Increase APPENDIX AGENDA ITEM 9.a(4) FY 2016 TUITION, FEES, AND ROOM AND BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS This appendix includes additional information that responds to specific questions and comments that arose during the presentation and discussion of pricing recommendations with the Finance, Facilities and Operations Committee at its meeting on November 6, 2014. Below are the Administration’s responses, and the following pages include other information that provides further amplification or clarification. ï‚· Is the recommended new undergraduate tuition structure too complicated? Will it be difficult to explain it to students and parents? Response: The Administration does not believe that the new undergraduate tuition structure is too complicated or difficult to explain, given its discussions with current students prior to the November meeting and extensive past feedback from parents. The new structure greatly simplifies the way in which current undergraduate students are charged by abandoning a declining rate structure (as credit hours increase), about which many students and parents have complained for some time. They especially find the current structure counterintuitive because their tuition rate goes up, instead of down, after the student drops a course. In addition, the recommended flat tuition rate is easier for parents to understand because it is more familiar to many of them due to its widespread use by competitor institutions. The new tuition structure also makes it readily apparent to students and parents that taking more courses than the minimum required for full-time status will cost no more and lead to timely degree completion at a more predictable cost. This is very easy for students and parents to see and understand. Finally, current students are also pleased with the University’s responsiveness in addressing their current confusion, frustration, and concerns, as represented by the new structure. Future undergraduate students who apply and consider enrolling at NIU in FY 2016 will quickly recognize the recommended tuition structure as one that is consistent with and more easily compares to pricing at other universities, and we expect far fewer questions than with previous entering students. In summary, we do not anticipate any difficulties in explaining the recommended new structure in marketing, catalogue, website, billing, or other communication materials because it is so much less complicated than the current structure. For further information, attached is a two-page summary comparison of the current tuition structure and the recommended new tuition structure. ï‚· Are the FY 2016 pricing recommendations for undergraduate students presented in Table 4 of Agenda Item 9.a(4) based on assumptions that make it appear that there is a reduction in the total cost of attendance for all new and continuing undergraduate students (i.e., a “best case” scenario), when other assumptions might show that there is no reduction and some students might even be paying more? Response: The answer is no. The total cost of attendance comparison for FY 2015 and FY 2016 shown in Table 4 is based on assumptions that are as equivalent as we can make them for new undergraduate students who have entered or will enter during the current academic year (FY 2015). While tuition and fees are recommended to increase by 2.3 and 0.3 percent, respectively, in FY 2016, a new freshman must live on campus and enroll in a residential dining program. The reduction in room and board next year is therefore a real reduction for new undergraduate students in FY 2016 relative to new undergraduates who enroll in FY 2015. Continuing students, as always, are covered by Truth in Tuition, and in fact they will see a very slight reduction in their bill as the result of the abandonment of the declining tuition rate structure and replacement with a flat rate. Continuing students are not required to live and dine on campus, but if they choose to do so they will find campus housing and dining to cost $800 less than last year just as new students enrolling in FY 2016 will find these prices to be lower than those charged to new students this year. We have also attached a new Table 4.1 on the last page of this appendix. This table shows comparisons in total cost of attendance presented with last February’s pricing recommendations for FY 2015 (which reflected the Huskie 90 meal plan) and also as if the new lower priced meal plan were in effect in FY 2015. The comparison to FY 2015 is shown for both new and continuing students in FY 2016. As shown in the Table, continuing students will see their total cost of attendance decline next year by 3.4 percent if they were in the Huskie 90 plan this year; if they had been in the new plan this year, their total cost of attendance would be essentially flat. (It should be recalled that the room rates approved for FY 2015 were also reduced by $235 compared to the previous year.) ï‚· It was suggested that the Board grant approval to the Administration to set graduate tuition and on-line tuition for specific programs (versus current practice of tuition for courses) within minimum and maximum amounts for one year only. It was further suggested that the Administration provide a report on the tuitions that it will establish to permit the Board the opportunity to consider more fully whether continued delegation of authority in setting these rates is appropriate. Response: The agenda item has been revised to reflect the change to one-year approval, and the Administration will report to the Board on the tuition decisions that will be made during the coming year as requested. Proposed Change to Undergraduate Tuition Rates Current Tuition Structure: ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· Sliding per credit hour scale features three distinct credit hour rates o 1 - 11 $342.88 per credit hour o 12 - 14 $331.37 per credit hour o 15 - 16 $308.44 per credit hour Two separate per credit hour rates for full-time students Students can owe more money by dropping a class and moving from 15 to 14 hours Creates confusion, ill will among students and families Does not incentivize timely degree completion by taking more credit hours Credit hours 1 2 3 4 5 Part-time Students 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Full-Time 14 Students 15 16 Amt Charged 342.88 685.76 1,028.64 1,371.52 1,714.40 2,057.28 2,400.16 2,743.04 3,085.92 3,428.80 3,771.68 3,976.44 4,307.81 4,639.18 4,626.60 4,935.04 Having tuition rates that vary with the number of credit hours taken does not support transparency, student success or a positive customer service experience. Recommended Tuition Structure: A good way to think of the recommended structure is that it resembles an insurance deductible. Once a certain threshold is reached (14 credit hours for continuing students and 12 hours for new students), you do not pay any more. In addition, the recommended structure has the following benefits: ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· ï‚· Remains consistent with Truth-in-Tuition for continuing undergraduate students Simplified rate structure for both new and continuing students o $348.84 per credit hour for new students capped at $4,732 (12 credit hour price) o $330.45 per credit hour for continuing students capped at $4626.30 (14 credit hour price) New students gain value for any course enrollment over 12 credit hours o 16 credit hour new student will pay $4,732.80 next year vs. $4,935.04 current year Continuing students gain value for any course enrollment over 14 credit hours o 14 credit hour continuing student will pay $4,626.30 next year vs. $4,639 current year o 16 credit hour continuing student will pay $4,626.30 next year vs. $4,935.04 current year Every continuing student will receive a slight reduction in tuition Simplified bills for parents, students (no more sliding scale) Simplified administration of billing and receivables that allows increased focus on actual service to students Consistent with financial aid models based on 12 credit hour full-time student criteria New students Continuing students Part-time Students Full-Time Students Credit hours 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Amt Charged 330.45 660.90 991.35 1,321.80 1,652.25 1,982.70 2,313.15 2,643.60 2,974.05 3,304.50 3,634.95 3,965.40 4,295.85 4,626.30 Part-time Students Full-Time Students Credit hours 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Amt Charged 348.84 697.68 1,046.52 1,395.36 1,744.20 2,093.04 2,441.88 2,790.72 3,139.56 3,488.40 3,837.24 12 $4,732.80 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(5) December 4, 2014 NEW FACILITY FOR CAMPUS DISTRIBUTIVE ANTENNA SYSTEM CAPITAL PROJECT APPROVAL Summary: The Division of Information Technology in partnership with Crown Castle, one of the nation’s largest providers of shared wireless infrastructure, has proposed a new facility to house a Distributed Antenna System (DAS) hub. When completed, the proposed facility will provide a central collocation point from which Crown Castle and major wireless providers (i.e. Verizon Wireless, AT&T, Sprint, TMobile) can expand outdoor and indoor antenna systems across NIU’s campus in order to improve cellphone coverage for the entire campus. If approved, the new facility will be located on the west side of campus in an area adjacent to and north of Printing Services. It will consist of a gravel surfaced open equipment area approximately 16,000 square feet, enclosed by an 8’ high chain link fence with a privacy screen. Within the fence area there will be a 900 square foot central precast equipment shelter for the neutral host and space for between four (4) and ten (10) smaller precast concrete equipment shelters for cellphone carriers. A new fiber optic infrastructure will also be built and interconnected to the University’s main fiber optic arteries in order to provide the required transport from the DAS hub to specific outdoor/indoor DAS deployments across campus. All cost of all improvements, equipment, shelters and fiber optic infrastructure will be covered by Crown Castle, the neutral host of the proposed facility. The University is currently in discussions with Crown Castle on the terms of an equitable ten (10) year land lease agreement that may also include three (3) additional five (5) year lease renewals. Funding: Crown Castle will fund all proposed improvement costs. Recommendation: The University requests Board of Trustees authorization to establish a project for the improvements to real property including the proposed facility and fiber optic infrastructure. The University further requests approval to proceed with an equitable ten (10) year land lease agreement with Crown Castle. NIU Board of Trustees 38 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.a.(6) December 4, 2014 ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS-PHASE XI PERFORMANCE CONTRACT AMENDMENT Summary: The university requests permission to expand the Phase XI Performance Contract Project to include needed infrastructure improvements resulting in reduced energy consumption and maintenance in the future involving exterior lighting upgrades campus-wide, HVAC upgrades and air handling needs and roof replacements in various buildings on campus. As with prior Performance Contract projects the University makes no initial capital outlay or investment to fund the project. Energy and operational savings are guaranteed by the contractor to be at least at the level to fund the project, including finance charges, for up to twenty years. Original Board of Trustees approval for Energy Infrastructure Improvements-Phase XI Project was given on December 5, 2013. Recommendation: The University requests Board of Trustees approval to expand the Phase XI Performance Contract Project to include these additional items as follows: Prior amount........................................................ Amendment......................................................... not to exceed $10.8 million including financing $7.2 million New total............................................................. not to exceed $18.0 million NIU Board of Trustees 39 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(1) December 4, 2014 OVERSIGHT OF ACADEMIC PROGRAMS Northern Illinois University engages in numerous processes to monitor the quality of its academic degree programs and to inform planning and decision making about the programs. Processes internal to the university include program review and the assessment of learning outcomes, which are required of all programs by our regional accreditor the Higher Learning Commission and by the Illinois Board of Higher Education. Processes that include external constituencies or external indicators include the reviews of doctoral departments by outside evaluators, external reviews of dissertations, accreditation, licensure and certification examinations and advisory committees. Internal Processes Program Review: NIU has a long-standing history of conducting thorough reviews of its academic programs and research and public service centers through the program review process. Currently, programs are reviewed every eight years on a schedule determined by the university. Departments scheduled for review prepare in-depth self-study documents, which incorporate information from the sources cited above as well as other data collected by the program and data provided by offices from across the university. The program review documents are appraised first by the provost and the provost’s staff and then by a faculty committee, the Academic Planning Council. The council makes recommendations about the programs to the provost. The findings, recommendations and actions that result from the university’s review of programs are reported to the departments and colleges as well as the NIU Board of Trustees and the Illinois Board of Higher Education. The programs in the College of Business scheduled for review in 2013-2014 were the: B.S. in Accountancy Master of Accountancy Science Master of Science in Taxation B.S. in Finance B.S. in Business Administration B.S. in Management B.S. in Marketing B.S. in Operations and Information Management Master of Science in Management Information Systems Master of Business Administration The programs in the College of Health and Human Sciences scheduled for review in 2013-2014 were the: B.S. in Family and Child Studies Master of Science in Applied Family and Child Studies B.S. in Nutrition, Dietetics, and Hospitality Administration Master of Science in Nutrition and Dietetics B.S. in Textiles, Apparel, and Merchandising Master of Science in Family and Consumer Science The programs in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences scheduled for review in 2013-2014 were the: B.A./B.S., and M.A. in Anthropology NIU Board of Trustees 40 December 4, 2014 B.A./B.S. and M.A. in Sociology The IBHE also requires that the university review organized research and public service centers on a regular schedule. During 2013-2014, the following centers were reviewed: Business Experiential Learning Center Center for Southeast Asian Studies Child Development Laboratory Couple and Family Therapy Clinic Ellington’s and Chandelier Dining Room The information submitted to the IBHE to meet its reporting requirement for 2014 has also been forwarded to the Board of Trustees under separate cover. Assessment of Learning Outcomes: All NIU degree programs engage in the systematic assessment of student learning, and the overall assessment process is linked to program review. All degree programs have University Assessment Panel approved assessment plans that outline the methods, processes and time frames for the implementation of the plans. Each year, every program prepares an annual assessment update that provides a snapshot of the last 12 months related assessment activities, the evidence gathered from the activities and the actions taken on the evidence. These updates are submitted to the Office of Assessment Services that conducts a review of the updates using standardized rubrics, provides feedback to the individual programs and prepares a consolidated report on the extent to which the criteria for the updates were met. The assessment process also incorporates a review and/or revision of the overall plan to ensure that the plan reflects the programs’ current practices. In year four of the program-review cycle, the whole assessment plan is submitted for review and (re)approval by the University Assessment Panel. The panel uses a standardized rubric and reporting form to provide feedback to the programs. External Processes Accreditation: Accreditation is a “process of external quality review created and used by higher education to scrutinize colleges, universities and programs for quality assurance and quality improvement” (Overview of U.S. Accreditation, CHEA, 2009), and more than 25 specialized agencies accredit NIU programs across all seven academic colleges. Accreditation is earned through a comprehensive process that involves self-study, peer review, site visits and action from the accrediting agency’s commission affirming that threshold standards have been met. All of NIU’s programs that have sought accreditation are fully accredited by their specialized accrediting agency. Recently NIU’s College of Business underwent a very positive and successful accreditation site visit by the Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB) International which provided an external review of all of the College of Business programs listed above. Licensure and Certification Examinations: Graduates from NIU’s accountancy, athletic training, clinical and school psychology, counseling, law, teacher education and health sciences programs take licensure or certification examinations that permit them to practice in their discipline. The results of these examinations give programs the means to benchmark NIU graduates’ performance against state and/or national performance rates. Advisory Committees: Many programs and departments engage in periodic discussion with alumni, employers and/or professionals in the discipline who comprise their advisory committees. These individuals provide feedback related to the performance and competencies of the program’s alumni, curricular content and new trends in the discipline, which is used in numerous ways to ensure that programs are preparing students with contemporary knowledge and skills. NIU Board of Trustees 41 December 4, 2014 In combination, all of these processes provide NIU with the means to provide ongoing comprehensive and multifaceted oversight of its undergraduate, graduate and professional degree programs. NIU Board of Trustees 42 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(2) December 4, 2014 FY14 OFFICE OF SPONSORED PROJECTS ANNUAL REPORT Dr. Lesley Rigg presented the following report to the Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee on November 6, 2014. NIU Board of Trustees 43 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 44 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 45 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 46 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 47 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 48 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 49 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 50 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 51 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(3) December 4, 2014 FEDERAL RELATIONS UPDATE Prognosis for Legislative Agenda in Calendar Year 2014 Congress was in session for only twelve days during September and October and will return for a lame duck session on November 14th. Current polling indicates that the House is very likely to remain under Republican control while the Senate is somewhat likely to flip to Republican control. Under this scenario, it is expected that the House will delay acting upon legislation until the start of the 114th Congress on January 3, 2015. Congress passed a stop-gap spending measure, called a continuing resolution, to fund the federal government until December 11, 2014. The outcome of the November elections will influence whether Congress passes another continuing resolution through early calendar year (CY) 2015 or if Congress musters the political will to pass appropriations bills for FY 2015. NIU Engages Congressional Leaders NIU continues to join the national conversation on wide-ranging issues including student financing, manufacturing, and economic development through publicly dialoging with U.S. Senator Dick Durbin, U.S. Senator Mark Kirk, and Representative Cheri Bustos on these issues. x On August 18th, Executive Vice President and Provost Lisa Freeman hosted Senator Kirk x x and Chairman Fed Hochberg of the Export-Import Bank of the United States for the Exporter Forum, a half-day event at NIU-Rockford focused on regional economic development. On August 29th, President Baker hosted Senator Durbin and three NIU students/alumni for a round table on student financing and potential legislative solutions to rising student debt burdens. On September 2nd, President Baker joined Senator Durbin, Representative Bustos, and other leaders on a panel to discuss manufacturing innovation and the anticipated positive economic impact of the Digital Manufacturing and Deign Innovation Institute (DMDII) for the Rockford region and Illinois. NIU Builds Relationships and Fosters Student Career Success at the Industrial Physics Forum From September 28th to October 3rd, Dr. Anna Quider, Director of Federal Relations and a physicist, and four NIU physics and engineer student researchers represented NIU at the Brazil-hosted Industrial Physics Forum, a biennial conference uniting academic and private sector physical NIU Board of Trustees 52 December 4, 2014 scientists. With over 200 global participants, NIU was the largest international contingent thanks to a generous 6:1 cost-share from the American Institute of Physics. Outcomes from the Forum include: x Introducing NIU research students to diverse industrial applications of their academic research through presentations and hands-on field excursions x Relationship-building with notable scientists and industry leaders including a Nobel prizewinning physicist, the Science and Technology Advisor to Secretaries Hillary Clinton and John Kerry, and the Senior Manager of IBM Research-Brazil x Sparking innovation and creative venture development within NIU students through the Forum’s two-day Science Entrepreneurship Short-Course x Fostering a global perspective among the NIU community via continuous social media engagement during the Forum as well as on-campus follow-up activities Key Legislation Campus Accountability and Safety Act (CASA), S. 2692 and H.R. 5354: These bills, which have identical text, were introduced in early August by a bipartisan group of legislators in the Senate and House to address sexual assaults on campus. We expect edits to these bills and the introduction of a “CASA 2.0” bill during the lame duck session or early in the 114th Congress. Revitalize American Manufacturing and Innovation Act (RAMI), H.R.2996: This legislation passed the House on September 15th. It authorizes additional manufacturing innovation hubs--like the Digital Manufacturing Design and Innovation Institute (DMDII) of which NIU is a founding partner--with each specializing in the production of a unique technology, material, or process relevant to advanced manufacturing. Over half of the Illinois delegation, including Rep. Adam Kinzinger who represents NIU, were co-sponsors. American Super Computing Leadership Act, H.R. 2495: On September 8th, the House passed this bill to encourage the Department of Energy to invest in high-performance computing research and technologies. It includes a provision instructing the Department of Energy to partner with universities, national laboratories, and industry. Six members of the Illinois delegation supported the bill, including Rep. Randy Hultgren as the lead sponsor and Rep. Adam Kinzinger as an original co-sponsor. The Administration FY16 Budget: The Bipartisan Budget Act of 2013 provided $63 billion in sequester relief across FY 2014 and 2015. The full budget sequester returns for FY16 unless Congress acts. The Administration’s Office of Management and Budget is working on a proposed sequester fix to be included in the President’s FY16 budget (expected to be released in February 2015). NIU is working with the Association of Public and Land-grant Universities, the Science Coalition, and other organizations to shape the conversation surrounding the FY16 sequester. NIU Board of Trustees 53 December 4, 2014 Department of Education’s College Rating System: The Department of Education is developing a college rating system that evaluates institutions based on their affordability, access (e.g. demographics), and outcomes. The Department plans to release a draft of the rating system for comment in Fall 2014 with the goal of implementing the new system in Spring 2015. NIU is monitoring this situation closely. White House College Opportunity Summit: On December 4th, the White House will host its second College Opportunity Summit. It will focus on building sustainable collaborations in communities with strong K-12 and higher education partnerships to encourage college going, and supporting colleges to work together to dramatically improve persistence and increase college completion, especially for first- generation, low-income, and underrepresented students. NIU will potentially be invited to participate NIU Board of Trustees 54 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(4) December 4, 2014 INTERNAL AUDIT UPDATE Northern Illinois University’s Internal Audit Director, Danielle Schultz, will provide a brief update regarding the department and a summary of their activities for FY14. NIU Board of Trustees 55 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 56 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 57 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 58 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 59 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 60 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(5) December 4, 2014 CLERY ACT Northern Illinois University’s Police Chief, Thomas Phillips, provided a brief update regarding the Clery Act to the Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee on November 6, 2014. NIU Board of Trustees 61 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 62 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 63 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 64 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 65 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 66 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 67 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 68 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 69 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 70 December 4, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 71 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(6) December 4, 2014 SEMI-ANNUAL PROGRESS REPORT OF ACTIVE CAPITAL PROJECTS WITH A BUDGET OVER $100,000 All projects listed herein were previously approved by the Board of Trustees or the President and are currently in process. The Authorization Date is identified for all NIU-funded projects; the fiscal year is identified for all CDB-funded projects. Status reports are provided on any project, regardless of initiation date, until all work has been completed and all payments have been made. CAPITAL DEVELOPMENT BOARD PROJECTS I. Projects in the Planning Phase A. Remodeling and Rehabilitation 1. Williston Hall - ADA Fire Alarm Upgrade Total Project Budget: $150,150 (estimated) Source of Funding: FY2004 - CDB Architect/Engineer: AON Fire Protection Engineering – Glenview Status: The CDB has contracted for engineering services and 100 percent documents have been prepared for review. Advertisement and acceptance of bids awaits release of appropriated funding. 2. Campus Electrical Switch Gear Upgrade Total Project Budget: $674,500 (estimated) Source of Funding: FY2004 - CDB Architect/Engineer: Crawford, Murphy & Tilly, Inc. - Aurora Status: The CDB has contracted for engineering services and 100 percent documents have been prepared for review. Advertisement and acceptance of bids awaits release of appropriated funding. 3. William R. Monat Building Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Architect/Engineer: Replace Air Conditioning $248,864 (estimated) FY2004 - CDB KJWW Engineers - Rock Island Status: The CDB has contracted for engineering services to produce bidding documents. Advertisement and acceptance of bids awaits release of appropriated funding. 4. Founders Library – Upgrade Sunken Plaza Total Project Budget: $320,000 (estimated) Source of Funding: FY2005 - CDB Architect/Engineer: Wills Burke Kelsey Associates - St. Charles Status: The CDB has closed the original professional services agreement with Wills Burke Kelsey. Engineering and bidding awaits release of appropriated funding. NIU Board of Trustees 72 December 4, 2014 5. East Heating Plant – Repair Main Steam Tunnel Total Project Budget: $1,705,000 (estimated) Source of Funding: FY2010 - CDB Architect/Engineer: Affiliated Engineers, Inc. – Chicago Status: Affiliated Engineers has been selected as the consulting A/E for the project. CDB will not issue a contract for engineering services until appropriated funding has been released. II. Projects in the Construction Phase A. Remodeling and Rehabilitation 1. Two Buildings on Campus – Roof Repair and Replacement Total Project Budget: $845,072 (amended - estimated) Source of Funding: FY2010 - CDB Architect/Engineer: INSPEC - Chicago Status: All roofing work is complete. Final payments have been made. 2. Stevens Building – Addition & Renovation Total Project Budget: $22,517,600 (estimated) Source of Funding: FY2010 - CDB Architect/Engineer: PSA Dewberry/BCA - Elgin Status: River City Construction was awarded the general contract and received the Authorization to Proceed on April 11, 2014. Site mobilization occurred on April 8, 2014. Demolition is complete. A groundbreaking was held on September 22, 2014 with Governor Pat Quinn in attendance. Exterior walls are complete; overall construction is now 20% complete. B. Site and Utilities N/A NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY PROJECTS I. Projects in the Planning Phase A. Remodeling and Rehabilitation 1. Grant Central Core – Roof Replacement Total Project Budget: $2,685,000 Source of Funding: Bond Revenue Reserves Authorization Date: September 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Construction documents and specifications are in process. Bidding is planned for late fall 2014 with contract award during early 2015. Work will be scheduled as weather allows. 2. Montgomery & Psych/Computer Science – Animal Facilities Renovation NIU Board of Trustees 73 December 4, 2014 Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: $850,000 Institutional – Local Funds September 20114 Wold - Palatine Status: Professional Services Agreement with the A/E is in process. Construction documents and specifications are planned for early 2015. Bidding is planned for spring 2015 with contract award during early 2015. 3. NIU Naperville – Carpet Replacement for AIR Phase II Total Project Budget: $123,450 Source of Funding: Institutional - Local Funds Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Contracts for carpet and installation are in process. The work will be planned and scheduled to minimize client disruption; overnight shifts and weekends will be used. B. Site and Utilities 1. Parking Lot W – Expansion Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: $661,500 Bond Series 2010 Project June 2011 Hanson Professional Services - Rockford Status: Removal of the soil pile is complete and final payment to the contractor has been made. Construction documents are complete. However, Parking Services has re-evaluated the necessity of this project and the staff has requested that the project be cancelled. Site restoration is complete. Final payments have been made. Final payment to the consulting Architect/Engineer is in process. 2. Parking Lot P and PS- Reconstruction Total Project Budget: $1,745,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed March 2014) Architect/Engineer: TBD Status: Planning and design are in process. Construction work will be coordinated with the Lucinda Avenue Extension project. 3. Parking Structure- Reconstruct Four Exit Stairs Total Project Budget: $1,200,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed March 2014) Architect/Engineer: TBD Status: Planning and design are in process. Construction work will be scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks. 4. DeKalb Campus- Electrical Infrastructure Replacement Phase III Total Project Budget: $2,550,000 (estimated) Source of Funding: Appropriated Funds NIU Board of Trustees 74 December 4, 2014 Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: Bond Series 2010 Project March 2014 NIU A&E Services Status: Planning and design are in process. Construction work will begin in late 2014 and will be scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks. II. Projects in the Construction Phase A. Remodeling and Rehabilitation 1. Stevenson Towers – Fire Sprinkler Phase III Total Project Budget: $2,685,000 (estimated) Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project (amended) Authorization Date: September 2010 Architect/Engineer: AON Fire Protection Engineering – Glenview Status: All work has been completed. Final payments have been made. 2. Holmes Student Center – College Grind Total Project Budget: $1,100,000 (amended) Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark and Associates - Aurora Status: Construction is complete, the Grind officially opened on February 10, 2014. The contractor is completing punch list work. Change Orders and final payments are in process. 3. Gilbert Hall – Building Renovation Total Project Budget: $22,266,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark and Associates - Aurora Status: All work has been completed. Final payments have been made. 4. Grant Towers – Tower D Renovation Total Project Budget: $18,000,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: BLDD Architects - Chicago Status: All renovation and construction work has been completed. Final payments are in process. 5. Thirteen Buildings on Campus – Campus Alerting System Phase III Total Project Budget: $385,000 Source of Funding: Appropriated Funds – Administrative Support Authorization Date: December 2011 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. NIU Board of Trustees 75 December 4, 2014 6. Naperville/Hoffman Estates Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: Status: process. - New Emergency Generators $238,700 Local Funds - ITS NIUNet February 2012 NIU A&E Services Generators have been installed, hooked up and tested. Final payments are in 7. Huskie Stadium – New Score Board and Video Boards Total Project Budget: $3,300,000 Source of Funding: Local Funds & Bond Revenue Funds – Stadium Authorization Date: April 2012 Architect/Engineer: Wold - Palatine Status: All work is complete. Change orders and final payments are in process. 8. West Heating Plant – Replace Emergency Generator Total Project Budget: $142,000 Source of Funding: Revenue Bond Funds – Housing and Dining Authorization Date: May 2012 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Construction is complete. Final payments have been made. 9. Physical Plant – Drafting Room Renovation Total Project Budget: $177,910 Source of Funding: Local Funds – Physical Plant Authorization Date: March 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Work is complete. Final payments have been made. 10. DeKalb Campus – Campus Alerting System Phase IV Total Project Budget: $1,250,000 Source of Funding: Appropriated Funds Authorization Date: March 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: This project will encompass the final phases of the campus alert system. Work is approximately 10% complete. The construction work will be planned and scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks, weekends and summer schedules. 11. Residence Halls - FY14-Rotation Painting Total Project Budget: $245,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed August 2013) Architect/Engineer: NIU Physical Plant Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 12. Campus Recreation Center - FY14-Rotation Painting Total Project Budget: $123,790 NIU Board of Trustees 76 December 4, 2014 Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: Bond Series 2010 Project June 2011 (confirmed August 2013) NIU Physical Plant Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 13. Evans Field House - FY14-Rotation Painting Total Project Budget: $175,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed August 2013) Architect/Engineer: NIU Physical Plant Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 14. Campus Recreation Center - Replace Skylights Total Project Budget: $149,100 Source of Funding: Bond Revenue Funds Repair and Replace Reserves Authorization Date: August 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 15. Graham Hall - Room 237 & 241 Remodel Total Project Budget: $139,630 Source of Funding: Appropriated Funds – Academic Program Support Authorization Date: October 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Construction is complete. Final payments have been made. 16. Graham Hall- Renovate Offices 429, 431 and 431A Total Project Budget: $152,000 Source of Funding: General Revenue Funds- Provost Office- Academic Program Support Authorization Date: December 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Work is complete. Final payments have been made. 17. East Heating Plant Remodel - Renovate Room 239 Total Project Budget: $171,000 Source of Funding: Local Funds- Building Maintenance Authorization Date: March 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 18. DuSable Hall – Concrete Beam Repair at Main Entry $414,500 Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Institutional - Local Funds Authorization Date: June 2014 Architect/Engineer: AltusWorks - Chicago NIU Board of Trustees 77 December 4, 2014 Status: The work to repair the exposed concrete beams at the main entry doors is near completion. The contractor is working on punch list items. 19. DeKalb Campus – Security Improvements for Nine Academic Buildings Total Project Budget: $211,316 Source of Funding: Grant Funds- Sponsored Projects Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services/Student Affairs Status: The entry doors on nine buildings are being upgraded with new electronic security locks. The project is approximately 25% complete; work will be planned and scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks, weekends and class schedules. 20. Residence Halls - FY15-Rotation Painting Total Project Budget: $249,000 Source of Funding: Institutional – Revenue Bond Reserves Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU Physical Plant Status: Work will be scheduled when feasible and will be scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks to minimize disruptions. The majority of the work will be done in May 2015. 21. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Founders Library Clean Limestone Total Project Budget: $165,000 Source of Funding: Appropriated/Income Funds Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: The contractor has completed cleaning the limestone at Founders Library. Final payments are in process. B. Site and Utilities 1. Parking Lot 24 - Reconstruction Total Project Budget: $325,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project (amended) Authorization Date: June 2011(amended) Architect/Engineer: Wills Burke Kelsey Associates – St. Charles Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 2. West Campus - Track & Field Facility - Install Lighting Total Project Budget: $941,500 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Construction is complete. Final payments are in process. 3. DeKalb Campus – Outdoor Intramural Recreational Facility $6,200,000 (estimated) Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project NIU Board of Trustees 78 December 4, 2014 Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: June 2011 Upland Design - Plainfield Status: Work is complete. Change orders are in process and final payment is in process. 4. Parking Lot 25 - Reconstruction Total Project Budget: $155,250 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: Wills Burke Kelsey Associates - St. Charles Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 5. Parking Lot 13 – Resurface Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: $733,200 (amended) Bond Series 2010 Project June 2011 (amended July 2013) Knight E/A - Chicago Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 6. Parking Lot 2/E – Resurface Total Project Budget: $1,217,700 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: Crawford, Murphy & Tilly, Inc. - Aurora Status: Contractor work is complete. Landscape work will be completed by the University. Final payments are in process. 7. Parking Lot N1 – Reconstruction Total Project Budget: $508,950 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Architect/Engineer: Christopher B. Burke Engineering - Rosemont Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 8. Parking Lots K & L – Reconstruction Total Project Budget: $1,417,000 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 Wight and Company - Darien Architect/Engineer: Status: All work is complete. Final payments have been made. 9. Neptune North – Renovate South Courtyard Total Project Budget: $101,840 Source of Funding: Revenue Bond Funds – Campus Parking Authorization Date: July 2012 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services & Physical Plant Status: Construction work is complete. Final payments have been made. NIU Board of Trustees 79 December 4, 2014 10. DeKalb Campus – Electrical Infrastructure Replacement Phase II Total Project Budget: $2,580,000 (estimated) Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Appropriated Funds – Administrative Support Authorization Date: March 2013 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Construction started in fall 2013 and is approximately 60% complete. Work will continue to be scheduled to take advantage of semester breaks and as schedules allow. 11. Naperville- Parking Lot Replacement- Phase I Total Project Budget: $172,265 Source of Funding: Local Funds- NIU Naperville Operations Authorization Date: November 2013 Architect/Engineer: Engineering Resource Associates, Inc. - Warrenville Status: The consulting engineer is completing the engineering documents for construction. Construction work scheduled for 2014 has been delayed due to budget concerns. 12. Lucinda Avenue Extension Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: $4,500,000 (estimated) Bond Series 2010 (amended) March 2014 (amended June 2014) Knight E/A, Inc. - Chicago Status: Building environmental clean-up is complete. Building and site demolition contracts are in process with an anticipated start in late fall 2014. Road construction work will bid in early 2015. Completion is anticipated for late fall 2015. 13. Huskie Stadium – Replace Water Main for West Stadium Total Project Budget: $143,000 Source of Funding: Appropriated Funds Authorization Date: June 2014 Architect/Engineer: NIU A&E Services Status: Phase I of the project provided a new water main to the building. Construction work will resume next spring when weather permits. 14. DeKalb Campus – Huskie Tram – Phase I Total Project Budget: $450,000 Source of Funding: Institutional Local Funds Authorization Date: May 2014 Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora / NIU A&E Services Status: Four electric trams are now in service as a part of Phase I. One tram is enclosed and provides for wheelchair access, three have inclement weather shades. The sidewalk improvements and terminus area at Holmes Student Center is complete. The contractor is completing punch list work. Final payments are in process. 15. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Core Lighting Total Project Budget: $193,000 (amended) Source of Funding: Institutional Local Funds NIU Board of Trustees 80 December 4, 2014 Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: July 2014 (amended September 2014) Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed 75% of the lighting work for Founders Library, Swen Parson and Holmes Student Center. Completion is anticipated late fall 2014. 16. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – HSC Transit Plaza Total Project Budget: $222,100 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 Project Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed July 2014) Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed the transit plaza work on the east side of Holmes Student Center. Final payments are in process. 17. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Founders Library Sunken Terrace Total Project Budget: $230,100 (amended) Source of Funding: Appropriated Income Funds Authorization Date: July 2014 (amended September 2014) Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed 75% of the work on the clean-up of Founders Library Sunken Terrace. Completion is anticipated late fall 2014. 18. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Carroll Avenue Upgrade Total Project Budget: $103,500 Source of Funding: Institutional Local Funds Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed the upgrade to sidewalks and bike path at Carroll Avenue and is following up with punch list items. Final payments are in process. 19. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Lucinda Avenue Bikeway Total Project Budget: $196,800 Source of Funding: Bond Series 2010 (amended) Authorization Date: June 2011 (confirmed July 2014) Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed the upgrade to sidewalks and bike path along Lucinda Avenue and is following up with punch list items. Final payments are in process. 20. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Davis Hall Terrace Total Project Budget: $110,300 Source of Funding: Appropriated Income Funds Authorization Date: July 2014 Architect/Engineer: Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed the work and is following up with punch list items. Final payments are in process. 21. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Orientation Path NIU Board of Trustees 81 December 4, 2014 Total Project Budget: Source of Funding: Authorization Date: Architect/Engineer: $163,200 Appropriated Income Funds July 2014 Cordogan Clark - Aurora Status: The contractor has completed the work and is following up with punch list items. Final payments are in process. NIU Board of Trustees 82 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(7) December 4, 2014 QUARTERLY SUMMARY REPORT OF TRANSACTION IN EXCESS OF $100,000 FOR THE PERIOD JULY 1, 2014 TO SEPTEMBER 30, 2014 Purchase Amount No. of Transactions Appropriated Non-Appropriated Total $100,000 to $250,000 22 $779,600 $2,604,826 $3,384,426 TRANSACTIONS DETAIL: Purchases: 1. Information Technology Services – Novell License Agreement – Information Technology Services requests permission to renew maintenance and support of Novell software licenses. These licenses include Groupwise (the Enterprise email system), universitywide and departmental file servers, IDM (Identity Manager) which is used to automatically provision both staff and student computing accounts, ZenWorks which is used to manage servers and image lab desktops, Cluster Services which are used to group servers to protect against hardware failures for critical applications such as Groupwise, Vibe which is a collaboration product and Directory services which are used to authenticate/logon to enterprise applications such as Blackboard, PeopleSoft and LDAP. This purchase is exempt from posting on the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin as it is covered by an MHEC contract. (Novell Contract Management, Provo, UT ) 185,000* 2. Campus Parking Services - Parking Management System - Campus Parking Services requested permission to issue an order for a new campus parking management system to replace the custom-built system that has been utilized for the past 15 years. This purchase was the result of RFP #KMC145373 that opened December 19, 2013. The intent to award this contract was advertised in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin and has been waived by the PPB. (Electronic Data Collection Corp., Syracuse, NY) 230,000 3. Northern Public Radio - Programming and Affiliation Fees - Permission was requested to establish orders for programming and affiliation fees required for the operation of Northern Public Radio. These orders were advertised as sole sources in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin and have been waived by the PPB. (American Public Media, St. Paul, MN) 100,000 4. Northern Public Radio - Programming and Affiliation Fees- Permission is requested to establish an open order for programming and affiliation fees required for the operation of Northern Public Radio. The intent to award this contract as a sole source was advertised in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin and was waived by the PPB. (National Public Radio, Washington, DC) 249,000 NIU Board of Trustees 83 December 4, 2014 5. NIU Outreach P-20 - Services - The Department of Outreach P-20, Illinois Interactive Report Card (IIRC), requested permission to subcontract with Collaborative Communications Group Inc., for work on an Illinois State Board of Education grant titled “IIRC Design Work”. The vendor will provide services related to the IIRC web site. This order is exempt from the Illinois Procurement Code because the vendor is named in the grant. (Collaborative Communications Group Inc., Washington, DC) 129,000 6. Health Services - Radiographic System - Health Services requested permission to purchase a new radiographic system to replace an old system. The new system will be easier to navigate for patient ease, less time consuming to operate, and less expensive to maintain. Pricing is based on a bid opened August 13, 2014. The intent to award this contract was advertised in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin and has been waived by the PPB. (Central Illinois X-Ray, Bloomington, IL) 123,560 7. International Affairs - Travel Services - International Affairs requested permission to purchase air travel, lodging, land transfers, coach arrangements, sightseeing tours, meeting rooms, group dinners, optional day trips, travel insurance and cancelation insurance for a trip to Santiago, Chile, and Lima, Peru. On March 6 – 16, 2015, approximately 25 students in the Evening MBA Program will participate in this mandatory trip. Pricing is based on a sealed proposal opened on August 12, 2014. The intent to award this contract will be advertised in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin (Southbridge Access, Newark, DE) 130,000 8. International Affairs - Travel Services - International Affairs requested permission to purchase air travel, lodging, land transfers, coach arrangements, sightseeing tours, meeting rooms, group dinners, travel insurance and cancelation insurance for a trip to Beijing and Shanghai, China. On May 15-25, 2015, approximately 25 students in the Evening MBA Program will participate in this mandatory trip. Pricing is based on a sealed proposal opened on August 19, 2014. The intent to award this contract will be advertised in the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin. (Lukas Marketing, Wayne, IL) 100,000 9. Office of General Counsel – Legal Services - The Office of General Counsel requested permission to establish open orders for Fiscal Year 2015 to these vendors for outside general legal services including police discharge services and legal representation of senior staff in regards to civil complaints filed 10/16/2012. This order is exempt from advertising on the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin in accordance with Section 4.10(d)(7) of the Procurement Code. (Pugh, Jones & Johnson, PC, Chicago, IL) 220,000 10. Office of General Counsel – Legal Services - The Office of General Counsel requested permission to establish open orders for Fiscal Year 2015 to these vendors for outside general legal services including police discharge services and legal representation of senior staff in regards to civil complaints filed 10/16/2012. This order is exempt from advertising on the Illinois Public Higher Education Procurement Bulletin in accordance with Section 4.10(d)(7) of the Procurement Code. (Hinshaw & Culbertson, LLP, Chicago, IL) 249,000 NIU Board of Trustees 84 December 4, 2014 11. Office of the President - Search Services - The Office of the President requested permission to enter into a contract with this vendor in order to conduct a search for the position of Vice President of University Advancement. Services include, but are not limited to, travel expenses, advertising, committee interviews, candidate travel and miscellaneous office expenses. Approval to hire a search firm for this position was received from the Board of Trustees on June 19, 2014. This vendor is exempt from the Illinois Procurement Code because the selected vendor is an IPHEC pre-approved vendor. (Witt/Kiefer, Oak Brook, IL) 120,000 Capital Improvement Projects: 1. Residence Halls – Fiscal Year 2015 Rotation Painting – There are areas in NIU’s residence halls that require painting as part of a regular maintenance program to keep the building and facilities in good condition. Rotation painting will include those areas that are in the poorest condition. Generally, when areas are clean and aesthetically pleasing they are less likely to be vandalized and will encourage members of the university community to take pride in their surroundings. Physical Plant crafts will do the work. Existing surfaces will be cleaned and properly prepared prior to painting. Preparation will include the removal of chipping paint as well as patching and sanding. Where appropriate, masons will be brought in for the repair of wall surfaces. 249,000 2. NIU Naperville – Carpet Replacement in 2nd Floor Office Suite for American Institute for Research (AIR) - Phase II – Division of Outreach, Engagement and Information Technologies had requested carpet replacement in the second floor office suite occupied by American Institute for Research (AIR) at the NIU Naperville facility in the fall of 2013, which comprised Phase I. AIR has rented this space for 13 years and would like to recarpet the remaining office areas that were not updated during Phase I. Approximately 56% of the lease space will be updated with new carpet. The AIR has agreed to pay for this improvement. 123,450 3. DeKalb Campus – Security Improvements for Nine Academic Buildings – The University applied for and received an “Illinois School Security Grant” to improve the security at the primary entrances of nine (9) academic buildings on the main campus in DeKalb. This project will use the grant funds received to upgrade and replace existing door locks with technologically current remote locking devices. When installed, the remote locking devices will allow the building entrance to be securely locked electronically from a remote location. The new upgrade will enhance the security of the building during emergency situations and in day-to-day operations. The work will be completed by a combination of NIU Media Services, ITS, Physical Plant crafts and outside contractors under the supervision of an NIU project manager. 211,316 4. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Orientation Route – This small project was identified while working on several of the President’s initiatives. Updating of several areas that are used for the campus orientation route would be in keeping with the President’s goal of improving student retention and recruiting. This project will include concrete sidewalk replacement, new lighting, landscaping clean-up, selected shrub and hedge removal, tree trimming and removal, and planting new decorative flowering trees. Several paving brick areas will be repaired and leveled. The work will be completed by an outside contractor under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. 163,200* NIU Board of Trustees 85 December 4, 2014 5. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Davis Terrace Upgrade – This was one of several small projects that had been identified and prioritized as a part of the President’s initiative for “A Campus RE:ENVISIONED” to update campus in pursuit of improving student retention and recruiting. Davis Terrace is on the east side of Davis Hall that serves as the west terminus of the classic grass plaza framed by Faraday Hall, Davis Hall, Lowden Hall and the East Lagoon. This project will include landscaping clean-up, selected shrub removal, trimming, and new shrubs will be added. The fountains will be cleaned and repaired, the concrete paving will be repaired and new tables and chairs will be added to the terrace. The work will be completed by an outside contractor under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. 110,300* 6. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Carroll Avenue Update – This was one of several small projects that had been identified and prioritized as a part of the President’s initiative for “A Campus RE:ENVISIONED” to update campus in pursuit of improving student retention and recruiting. Carroll Avenue is the current “campus transportation hub” and turnaround for the Huskie Bus Line. The transit hub will be relocated to Normal Road on the east side of HSC allowing Carroll Ave to become a pedestrian and bicycle way that will tie Neptune courtyard into the MLK plaza. Scope of this project: x New bicycle and pedestrian path x Identify a “food truck Friday” area x Repair and update the center island landscaping The work will be completed by a combination of Physical Plant crafts and outside contractors under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. 103,500 7. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Founders Library Sunken Terrace – This was one of several small projects that had been identified and prioritized as a part of the President’s initiative for “A Campus RE:ENVISIONED” to update campus in pursuit of improving student retention and recruiting. The exterior sunken terrace on the north side of Founders Library is in disrepair and in need of cleaning, updating and restoration. This terrace will enhance and become an integral feature of MLK plaza. Scope of this project: x Improve ADA Access to the space. x Improve Drainage x Replace Paving, Trim trees, Update / Change landscape The work will be completed by an outside contractor under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. 199,100* 8. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Founders Library Clean Exterior Limestone This was one of several small projects that had been identified and prioritized as a part of the President’s initiative for “A Campus RE:ENVISIONED” to update campus in pursuit of improving student retention and recruiting. The exterior limestone wall elements of the north and east façades will be cleaned of the accumulated dirt and lichen growth and then sealed. This will enhance new façade lighting that will define MLK commons and create a great public space. The work will be completed by an outside contractor under the supervision of an NIU A/E Services project manager. 165,000* NIU Board of Trustees 86 December 4, 2014 9. DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives - Core Lighting – This is one of several small projects that have been identified and prioritized as a part of the President’s initiative for “A Campus RE:ENVISIONED” to update campus in pursuit of improving student retention and recruiting. Martin Luther King Plaza serves as a symbolic center of campus; to create a great public space at night, new lighting will be introduced to illuminate the facades of Holmes Student Center, Founders Library, and Swen Parson Hall. Scope of this project: x provide controlled / diffused lighting to illuminate existing building facades x define the MLK plaza nightǦtime boundaries x create a safe, warm, and welcoming nightǦtime environment The work will be completed by a combination of Physical Plant crafts and outside contractors under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. 180,500 10. Amendment - DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives – Founders Library Sunken Terrace – The President originally approved this project on July 25, 2014 with a budget of $199,100. Unforeseen conditions discovered during demolition work included hidden concrete slab and large amounts of unanticipated grout and mortar setting beds for the original paving bricks, increasing the cost of demolition. The project budget will need to increase to ensure that the project can be completed and meet the approved scope. The work will be completed by an outside contractor under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. Original Amount $199,100; Amendment Amount $31,000 31,000* 11. Amendment – DeKalb Campus – 2014 Campus Initiatives - Core Lighting - The President originally approved this project on July 25, 2014 with a budget of $180,500. After the initial approval, the actual pricing for the light fixtures and associated controls from outside vendors came in higher than estimated. The existing contingency will not be sufficient to cover the increase in costs. In order to continue and complete the project, the budget will need to be increased. The work will be completed by a combination of Physical Plant crafts and outside contractors under the supervision of Cordogan Clark, the consulting project manager. Original Amount $180,500; Amendment Amount $12,500 12,500 Total $3,384,426 *Appropriated Funds NIU Board of Trustees 87 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(8) December 4, 2014 PERIODIC REPORT ON INVESTMENTS FOR PERIOD JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2014 In accordance with the approved University Investment and Cash Management policy, this report on investments is submitted at the end of each calendar quarter to the Board of Trustees. The following schedules are included with this report: x x Investment Holdings as of September 30, 2014 Investment Earnings by Investment Type and Duration for the three months ending September 30, 2014 NIU Board of Trustees 88 December 4, 2014 NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY INVESTMENT HOLDINGS AS OF SEPTEMBER 30, 2014 For Fiscal Year 2015 Bond Investment Type Local Funds: Treasury Treasury Treasury Treasury Treasury Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Treasury Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Project Funds: Federal Agency Federal Agency Treasury Treasury Treasury Treasury Treasury Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Federal Agency Money Markets: IL Funds-Operations Amalgamated Bank Maturity Date 11/15/2014 05/31/2015 07/15/2015 10/15/2015 12/15/2015 01/15/2016 04/29/2016 06/27/2016 07/29/2016 09/21/2016 10/11/2016 11/15/2016 11/21/2016 11/29/2016 12/09/2016 12/19/2016 12/30/2016 01/11/2017 01/30/2017 03/06/2017 04/11/2017 05/16/2017 05/26/2017 06/13/2017 06/19/2017 07/25/2017 08/07/2017 08/21/2017 09/15/2017 10/10/2017 11/28/2017 12/11/2017 12/18/2017 01/30/2018 03/12/2018 04/24/2018 04/30/2018 05/25/2018 06/20/2018 06/26/2018 10/10/2018 11/26/2018 02/19/2019 08/15/2019 09/30/2014 09/30/2014 Purchase Date 04/16/2013 05/31/2013 05/31/2013 09/27/2013 09/25/2013 04/16/2013 04/29/2013 01/31/2014 01/30/2013 03/21/2013 10/11/2012 01/31/2014 11/21/2012 11/30/2012 12/11/2013 09/25/2013 01/09/2014 10/24/2012 02/26/2013 03/13/2013 10/24/2012 05/16/2013 09/26/2014 06/26/2013 12/11/2013 04/25/2013 02/26/2013 11/21/2012 09/15/2014 10/10/2012 05/28/2013 09/12/2014 12/18/2013 01/30/2013 03/13/2013 02/21/2014 05/31/2013 05/30/2013 06/21/2013 09/12/2014 01/10/2014 12/13/2013 02/21/2014 09/27/2013 $ 2,000,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 2,500,000 1,000,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 2,500,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 1,500,000 2,500,000 1,500,000 1,425,000 2,000,000 3,500,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 3,500,000 2,000,000 2,500,000 2,500,000 1,000,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 3,500,000 3,000,000 1,000,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 1,500,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 2,000,000 2,500,000 2,812,500 93,737,500 11/30/2012 10/05/2012 05/16/2013 10/29/2013 05/30/2013 08/22/2013 09/30/2013 09/24/2014 07/30/2014 08/13/2014 09/12/2014 09/12/2014 $ 2,000,000 1,500,000 2,500,000 1,500,000 3,000,000 3,000,000 3,000,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 1,000,000 1,500,000 24,500,000 11/19/2014 11/25/2014 12/31/2014 01/31/2015 01/31/2015 02/15/2015 03/31/2015 10/02/2015 10/15/2015 11/02/2015 11/30/2015 01/25/2016 TOTAL INVESTMENT HOLDINGS NIU Board of Trustees Maturity Value $ $ 18,980,220 14,034,131 33,014,351 $ 151,251,851 09/30/2014 09/30/2014 89 Book Value $ 2,000,477 1,999,740 1,999,303 2,497,321 998,258 1,504,626 2,001,317 1,499,729 1,000,154 2,500,000 1,999,744 2,998,928 1,500,000 2,500,000 1,500,000 1,417,416 2,000,000 3,497,727 1,998,452 1,500,000 3,497,420 1,998,688 2,499,378 2,465,918 1,000,000 2,000,000 2,997,592 2,000,000 1,497,781 3,500,000 3,000,000 999,754 2,002,011 2,998,998 1,500,000 1,506,413 1,991,258 3,000,000 1,984,169 1,997,533 2,994,910 2,000,000 2,503,845 2,736,752 93,585,612 $ 1,999,994 1,501,087 2,499,711 1,500,456 3,000,352 3,000,538 3,000,313 1,500,458 2,000,619 2,000,981 999,856 1,500,723 24,505,088 $ Market Value Equivalent Rate 0.184% 0.270% 0.294% 0.353% 0.394% 0.410% 0.460% 0.510% 0.540% 0.580% 0.626% 0.642% 0.600% 0.640% 0.679% 0.994% 0.800% 0.669% 0.733% 0.750% 0.730% 0.715% 1.010% 1.330% 1.000% 0.740% 0.878% 0.800% 1.176% 0.900% 0.800% 1.258% 1.218% 1.040% 1.030% 1.376% 1.130% 1.050% 1.470% 1.484% 1.780% 1.700% 1.713% 2.140% $ 2,003,633 2,004,280 2,003,660 2,505,636 1,001,138 1,502,238 2,000,582 1,496,348 998,207 2,485,978 1,996,076 3,004,682 1,490,935 2,489,897 1,493,753 1,419,492 2,000,525 3,477,118 1,991,832 1,491,766 3,474,889 1,979,655 2,499,481 2,474,150 994,953 1,976,093 2,965,305 1,970,458 1,499,190 3,468,308 2,950,270 994,624 1,992,193 2,962,576 1,473,320 1,502,058 1,965,869 2,952,525 1,978,874 2,002,313 3,009,015 1,995,866 2,485,504 2,738,167 93,163,432 0.273% 0.274% 0.170% 0.159% 0.215% 0.202% 0.229% 0.220% 0.200% 0.180% 0.222% 0.303% $ 2,002,560 1,505,572 2,501,290 1,486,665 3,018,380 3,003,358 3,003,021 1,500,476 2,000,851 2,001,344 1,000,116 1,501,175 24,524,808 0.010% 0.010% $ 18,980,220 14,034,131 33,014,351 $ $ 18,980,220 14,034,131 33,014,351 $ 151,105,051 $ 150,702,591 December 4, 2014 NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY INVESTMENT EARNINGS BY TYPE AND DURATION For Fiscal Year 2015 July 1, 2014 - September 30, 2014 Average Daily Investment Balance Percent of Portfolio Income Earned Annualized Rate of Return Short-Term Investments Illinois Funds $ 32,320,769 17.27% $ 1,027 0.013% Investment Accounts - Financial Institutions $ 25,007,606 13.36% $ 3,271 0.052% Investment Accounts - Project Funds $ 15,935,998 8.51% $ 456 0.011% $ 73,264,373 39.14% $ 4,754 Short-Term Total Short-Term Average Yield 0.026% Intermediate/Long-Term Investments Local Funds $ 90,991,748 48.62% $ 195,777 0.861% Project Funds $ 22,914,301 12.24% $ 15,871 0.277% $ 113,906,049 60.86% $ 211,648 Intermediate/Long-Term Total Intermediate/Long-Term Yield COMBINED TOTAL 0.743% $ 187,170,422 AVERAGE ANNUALIZED RATE OF RETURN NIU Board of Trustees 100.00% $ 216,402 0.46% 90 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(9) December 4, 2014 AD HOC ON GOVERNANCE WORK PLAN November 17, 2014 AD HOC COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE MEETING x Ad Hoc Committee on Governance selected Bylaw reform areas for immediate review (labeled Category “A” items 1-8 [see attached list]). x The Office of General Counsel, after consultation with the President and the Senior Cabinet, plans to submit for first reading, at December 4,, 2014 meeting, initial draft of recommendations for Category “A” items; full Board will review and provide direction; Ad Hoc Committee will revise on or before January 15, 2015 committee meeting; Board review and approval will be scheduled for March 12, 2015 Board Meeting. December 4, 2014 FULL BOARD MEETING x First Reading of Category “A” reform recommendations. January 15, 2015 AD HOC COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE MEETING x The Ad Hoc Committee on Governance meets to review and amend Category “A” recommendations in light of full Board discussion. x Ad Hoc Committee reviews Category B Bylaw Reform proposals. x Ad Hoc Committee provides direction for Board review for first reading of Category “B” items for the March 12, 20151 Board Meeting. x Ad Hoc Committee to determine process for addressing Category “C” items. March 12, 2015 FULL BOARD MEETING x First Reading of Category “B” items and Action on Category “A” items. June 18, 2015 FULL BOARD MEETING x Action on Category “B” items. NIU Board of Trustees 91 December 4, 2014 Board of Trustees Governance Reform Governance Bylaw Reform Recommendations A. Board of Trustees Administrative 1. Presidential Succession Policy 2. Naming Rights Policy 3. Update Record Retention Policy 4. Update University Insurance & Employment Benefits Policy 5. Update Indemnification Policy 6. Board and Senior Management Professional Development and Travel and Expense Policy (Risk Management) 7. Presidential House (mandate living or not) 8. Officer Election Policy and Procedure (clarify the number of votes necessary to continue balloting when no candidate for office obtains the minimum requirement of 5 votes) B. Board of Trustees Business Items 9. Officer Election Policy and Procedure (consider/determine legislative initiatives, minimum voting requirements and accountability, standards and expectations) 10. Update Conflict of Interest Policy 11. Establish/Clarify Administrative Leave Policy 12. Reform of all Standing Committee Charter/Charges (to include purpose, powers, duties, and the establishment of Committee benchmarks and other measures – as indicated for CARL committee) 13. Orientation and Continuing Professional Development 14. Review of Criteria and Establish/Clarify Appeal Rights for Appeals to the Board in personnel matters 15. Consider additional Bylaw provisions appropriate to implementing recommendations emerging from Board Assessment NIU Board of Trustees 92 December 4, 2014 C. NIU Constitutional Reform 16. NIU Constitutional Review and Recommendation a. Review Terms of Appointments b. Presidential Evaluation c. Revise Grievance Procedure d. Other NIU Board of Trustees 93 December 4, 2014 Information Agenda Item 9.b.(10) December 4, 2014 AD HOC ON ENROLLMENT UPDATE Report to the Board of Trustees of Northern Illinois University Enrollment Ad Hoc Committee November 14, 2014, 3:45 p.m., Holmes Student Center Skyroom Submitted by: Eric A. Weldy, Ed.D., Vice President for Student Affairs & Enrollment Management, with input from the Office of the Provost via Anne Birberick, Ph.D., Vice Provost As requested, information in this report includes the following: a) Enrollment Background/ Trends; b) Recruitment & Retention Efforts; and, c) Scholarship Information. a) Enrollment Background/Trends (Appendix A – Fall 2014 Student Profile) Northern Illinois University Total Headcount Enrollment Fall 1968 - Fall 2014 27000 25000 23000 21000 19000 17000 Notes: During the 1980s a strong interest in Business contributed to increased enrollment. But as that interest declined, so did overall enrollment. The upsurge in enrollment during the late-1990s was due to an increase in the number of students graduating from high school. There were more students in the education pipeline. Today there are fewer students in the pipeline posing many challenges for the University in its efforts to recover once again. NIU Board of Trustees 94 December 4, 2014 NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY 20-Year Enrollment History, Fall 1995 (FY 96) to Fall 2014 (FY 15) Official - Tenth day Count Headcount Enrollment Undergrad. Graduate Law FTE Total Enrollment* Fall Semester 1995 15,760 6,158 300 22,218 17,460 1996 15,387 5,928 294 21,609 17,013 1997 15,855 5,947 280 22,082 17,518 1998 16,341 5,850 282 22,473 17,962 1999 16,893 5,674 276 22,843 18,364 2000 17,151 5,800 297 23,248 18,603 2001 17,468 6,012 303 23,783 19,103 2002 18,104 6,513 331 24,948 19,958 2003 18,275 6,651 334 25,260 20,348 2004 18,031 6,463 326 24,820 20,092 2005 18,467 6,408 333 25,208 20,501 2006 18,816 6,182 315 25,313 20,758 2007 18,917 6,012 325 25,254 20,630 2008 18,431 5,669 297 24,397 19,947 2009 18,277 5,838 309 24,424 20,022 2010 17,886 5,633 331 23,850 19,592 2011 17,306 5,365 319 22,990 18,817 2012 16,552 4,984 333 21,869 18,033 2013 15,814 5,020 304 21,138 17,324 2014 15,435 4,900 276 20,611 16,940 NIU Board of Trustees 95 December 4, 2014 CHANGE Fall 06 - Fall 14 # % (3,381) -17.97% (1,282) -20.74% (39) -12.38% (4,702) -18.58% (3,818) -18.39% * FTE: Full-Time Equivalent, Undergraduate 15 Sem. Credit Hours, Graduate & Law 12 Sem. Credit Hours. SOURCE: NIU DATA BOOK TABLE A-2A Notes: Declining enrollment has occurred not just at the undergraduate level but among graduate and law students as well. NIU Retention Rates of New Freshmen Cohorts 82 80 79 80 78 78 78 79 77 77 77 77 77 78 76 76 76 76 75 78 76 74 74 74 73 74 72 72 71 72 72 70 70 68 66 66 65 65 65 65 65 66 64 64 64 64 64 64 62 62 62 61 61 61 62 60 60 60 59 63 62 60 58 58 62 61 61 61 61 58 60 56 60 60 60 55 59 58 59 58 56 56 56 57 57 56 56 54 55 52 54 53 52 50 71 66 Starting Fall Term Year Notes: Our highest retention rates occurred during the late-1990s and continued for about ten years. Since then, there has been a steady decline. NIU Board of Trustees 96 December 4, 2014 1 Year 2 Years 3 Years b) Recruitment & Retention Efforts Recruitment Recruitment occurs most broadly through the collaborative efforts of each faculty, staff, student, alumni, and community partner of NIU. Specific recruitment activities for most freshmen and transfer students are coordinated through Undergraduate Admissions. Major marketing efforts of this recruitment are conducted through a strong partnership with the Division of Marketing & Communications. Many Colleges and programs also participate in individualized recruitment activities in a variety of ways. New and/or expanding recruitment activities in which the Division of Student Affairs & Enrollment Management has been directly involved include the following: x Expand recruitment initiatives beyond the northern Illinois region. x Establish new articulation agreements (2-plus-2 and 3-plus-1) with community colleges through the new NIU Bound initiative and others. x Establish MOUs with charter schools in Chicago (e.g., KIPP Charter Schools, Perspectives Charter Schools, etc.) to attract and recruit underrepresented students. x Re-examine our current merit scholarship structure to attract more high performing students. x Enhance relationships with both the Latino and Asian American communities in Chicago, surrounding suburbs, and beyond. x Develop new initiatives that will utilize NIU alumni and friends in Illinois and across the country in recruitment efforts. Retention Student retention is a highly complex and challenging issue for many colleges and universities, including NIU. According to one model developed by NIU’s Testing Services in the Division of Academic Affairs, the following items are predictors of retention: x x x x x x x x x Good academic standing ACT score High school GPA Percentile in high school High school average ACT Application days (number of days after September 1st) Math placement exam score Credit load Problematic course units For the purposes of this report, a number of recent projects will be highlighted below. Additional information about these activities and other retention efforts led by the Academic Colleges will be shared in future meetings. Chicago Collaborative for Undergraduate Success (Appendix B – Chicago Collaborative for Undergraduate Success) NIU is participating in the Chicago Collaborative for Undergraduate Success. Initiated by the University of Illinois at Chicago, the mission states, “The Chicago Collaborative for Undergraduate Success builds connections among Chicago-area non-profit institutions of higher education, who work together with high schools and other community organizations on evidence-driven initiatives to ensure increased postsecondary student success and degree completion” (Retrieved from http://collaborative.uic.edu/documents/Chicago_Collaborative_Description.pdf). NIU Board of Trustees 97 December 4, 2014 MAP-Works (Appendix C – MAP-Works) MAP-Works is a survey-based tool that helps students start off on the right track. Incoming freshmen and new transfer students who participate in MAP-Works have shown the ability to: x Earn a higher GPA, x Successfully complete additional courses, x Reduce the risk of academic probation, and x Benefit from additional NIU support and resources. Students will receive an email in their NIU student email account inviting them to participate in the MAPWorks survey. Once the survey is completed, students will receive a personalized report summarizing their strengths and possible challenges, as well as related campus resources. Pertinent faculty and staff (success specialists, advisors, etc.) will also have access to this information so they can provide additional assistance. According to data available through Map-Works, the factors that have the strongest relationships to persistence include the following: x Commitment to the institution x Homesickness x Financial means x Satisfaction with institution x Social integration Those x x x x x factors with the strongest relationships to fall GPA include the following: Basic academic behaviors Academic integration Time management Academic self-efficacy Financial means The top five issues students are experiencing this fall according to MAP-Works include the following: x Homesick x Plan to study five hours or less x Test anxiety x Not confident about finances x Struggling in at least two courses First Year Composition Retention strategies employed by the First Year Composition program included the following: x Individual conferences with students to increase instructor and peer advocate connections with students o Peer Advocates attended class once per week on average, helped students become engaged at NIU, and researched and presented on NIU resource. Almost half of PA’s chose internship credit. x Increased instructor participation in MAP-Works to help instructors understand more about individual students’ experiences at NIU x Classroom condition upgrades to enhance the student experience during their first year x Electronic portfolio integration in order to connect the pieces of students’ learning and writing in a coherent narrative and help promote students’ academic and professional identity NIU Board of Trustees 98 December 4, 2014 High Impact Practices (HIPs) Students who participate in high-impact practices experience positive student retention and engagement outcomes. High-Impact practices include the following types of activities: First Year Seminars, Learning Communities, Writing Intensive Courses, Collaborative Learning, Common Intellectual Experiences, UG Research, Global Learning, Service/Community Based Learning, Internships, and Capstones. At NIU, some examples of HIPs which are offered through the Office of Student Engagement & Experiential Learning include the following: x Research Rookies – freshman paired with faculty, competitive, student stipend x USOAR – funded research open to all students x UG Research Assistantships x Themed Learning Communities x Huskie Service Scholars x UG Research & Artistry Day A recent study on the impact of HIPs on retention conducted by NIU’s Office of Assessment Services, the Office of Student Engagement & Experiential Learning, and Testing Services achieved the following results: x Those who participate in HIPs are less likely to drop out x The relationship between HIPs and retention remains even after controlling for other retention predictors x We can’t rule out self-selection effects x The relationship between HIPs and Retention is not simply additive x Effects of HIPs are not conditional on minority status Student Success Collaborative (Appendix D – Student Success Collaborative) The Student Success Collaborative (SSC) is a rapidly growing membership of nearly 100 colleges and universities working together to better understand the drivers of student attrition and measurably impact success. At the core of the Student Success Collaborative is an innovative predictive modeling platform that mines university data to provide NIU administrators, advisors, and academic support services professionals with actionable insights, identifying systemic and individual risk, and illuminating what steps can be taken to improve graduation likelihood across all groups. The SSC strives to enhance three things: 1) Executive Visibility: Identifying and drilling into areas of risk within individual colleges, majors, and specific populations, 2) Advisor Effectiveness: Supporting data-driven advising efforts and enabling proactive, informed interventions with students, and 3) Student Decisions: Delivering insight into majors, courses, and careers best suited to each student’s interests and abilities. Early Alert Referral System (EARS) (Appendix E – Early Alert Referral System/EARS) The Early Alert & Referral System is a collaborative effort between faculty and the Office of Student Academic Success (OSAS) that picks up where Absence Tracking leaves off. The purpose of the E.A.R.S. is to partner with select faculty at critical points during each academic semester to help identify students who may need additional support. NIU Board of Trustees 99 December 4, 2014 The Office of Student Academic Success targeted 117 different courses during the fall 2014 semester and realized a 600% increase in faculty referrals from fall 2013. Faculty put forth an unprecedented 3,000 referrals for 2,500 students. The OSAS team spoke to 1,100 students over the phone, left 1,200 voice mails, and sent numerous personalized emails to students for whom there was not accurate contact information in MyNIU. Additionally, Student Success Specialists have been meeting with students referred through E.A.R.S. nonstop during the months of October and November. Absence Tracking Pilot Program (Appendix F – Absence Tracking Pilot Program) The Divisions of Academic Affairs, Student Affairs & Enrollment Management, and Information Technology partnered together to launch a large scale student success and retention initiative during the first few weeks of the fall 2014 semester. Attendance is one of the greatest predictors of student success. A coordinating committee comprised of student services professionals and administrators developed a plan to focus on a specific retention strategy during the initial weeks of the fall semester by utilizing a centralized, systematic process. The main objectives of the pilot included centralizing fragmented student outreach efforts, developing a process to identify absent students; creating a software system to record and report student absences; designating the closest logical point of contact to reach out to particular groups of students; and, developing consistent messaging and information. Faculty and instructors from 329 sections of 100 and 200 level undergraduate courses monitored attendance and provided the name of students who were absent from each class session during the first two weeks of the semester. Persistence data for all students involved in the pilot will be measured at the end of the fall semester and again on the fall 2015 census date. Lois Hobart Retention Scholarship Program (Appendix G – Lois Hobart Retention Scholarship Program) New for the 2014-2015 academic year, The Office of the Vice Provost and the Office of Student Academic Success (OSAS) created the Lois Hobart Retention Scholarship Program in an effort to retain students nearing graduation who have exhausted all possible financial resources and are in danger of leaving NIU. Once awarded a Lois Hobart Retention Scholarship, recipients work with a Student Success Specialist to address any additional challenges or issues that could impede the students’ progress to graduation. During the fall 2014 semester 20 students were awarded $27,000. Retention Summits These campus-wide meetings first started during fall 2013. Four separate meetings, culminating in a meeting in October 2014, highlighted select retention initiatives, student experiences with NIU, and participant suggestions for how to set and achieve specific university retention targets. Initial meetings focused on communicating to the university community the current data and programs related to retention and to develop an action plan for improving retention. With each summit, the goal of creating a common retention language across campus is also being realized. Moving forward, these cross campus conversations will inform future, integrated plans focused on maximizing students’ ability to persist. NIU Board of Trustees 100 December 4, 2014 Residential Academic Coaching Program Beginning this fall, Housing & Dining Services began a new collaborative partnership with the Academic Advising Center to pilot a new program in the residence halls. The Residential Academic Coaching Program was established in an effort to encourage new freshmen students to take advantage of all of the academic support resources made available to them through the Academic Advising Center. Students living in Neptune Hall and the Health Professions Living Learning Community located in Stevenson Tower A are able to take advantage of facilitated study groups, take part in individual and group advising sessions, as well as participate in other academic success initiatives that will help students succeed in the classroom. Weekend Behavior Assessment Project (Appendix H – Weekend Behavior Survey, GPA & Retention Follow-Up) The Office of the Vice President for Student Affairs & Enrollment Management, through the Planning & Assessment unit undertook a GPA & Retention Follow-Up Study to a spring 2014 Weekend Behavior Survey. Data were collected during spring 2014 about students’ weekend behaviors, level of campus involvement, and their sense of belongingness on campus. During fall 2014, a follow-up study was conducted in order to determine if a relationship existed between the behaviors and beliefs measured by the survey and the students’ GPA and/or retention. Select recommendations from the executive summary of the study revealed the following: 1) Future programming efforts should emphasize the importance of investing in college life as a student success strategy and 2) NIU should provide resources and training to staff with high student contact about the importance of students finding their community. NIU Board of Trustees 101 December 4, 2014 c) Scholarship Information (Submitted by Anne Hardy, Director, Scholarship Office) History of Scholarship Strategy: In 2011, NIU committed to setting aside $10 million towards merit scholarships. Aligning our priorities with those outlined in the enrollment management strategic plan, several new categories of merit scholarships were established. These categories targeted students from the top 10% of their high school class. An Out-of-State Scholarship (50% tuition for students from Iowa, Indiana, and Wisconsin) scholarship was also established to help meet the strategic enrollment goal of more out-of-state students. NIU’s four-year merit scholarship was increased to accommodate more offers, and the new scholarship categories that were added were for two years or one year. This "front-loading" of recruitment scholarships was not meant to be a permanent plan. This plan continues to the current day. However, a one-year scholarship called VIP or Lead NIU was eliminated. VIP/Lead NIU was offered late in the year to bump up yield rates, and usually only went to students who were planning to attend NIU anyway. The funds are now spread out over all merit scholarship categories allowing NIU to offer all of its scholarships to incoming students as early as possible. We now have a priority deadline that is extended only as budget remains available. Attached is a document (Appendix I – Merit Scholarships for New Incoming Students) with NIU’s current merit scholarship offerings for students. There are currently strict ACT/GPA criteria that considers those two factors equally. However, the current merit scholarship model is under review. Moving forward: Over the past year, NIU has worked closely with Noel-Levitz to propose significant changes to the scholarship awarding structure, including the use of an academic index that would weight GPA at 65% and ACT at 35%. The rationale behind this is that our data proves that GPA is a higher predictor of academic success, and thus, retention, than the ACT score. There is also consideration to increase twoyear scholarships to four-years. Enrollment Management is also working closely with Academic Affairs (as well as the NIU Foundation) to holistically use all scholarship awards offered through the academic departments as well when determining other means of gift aid. Currently, Financial Aid implements a formula that was developed with Noel-Levtiz that takes into consideration need, merit, geographical location of the student, among other factors, to determine the percentage of gift aid that NIU should provide. If all departments/units are able to submit their scholarships awards sooner, the University will have a more consistent and effective use of its scholarship dollars in this calculation, and thus, NIU will be able to spread its limited resources among more students. (Note: A proposal for a software system to assist the University with its scholarship strategy is being considered.) NIU Board of Trustees 102 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 9.c.(1) December 4, 2014 LIPMAN HEARNE ENROLLMENT MANAGEMENT CONTRACT Summary: The Division of Student Affairs & Enrollment Management recently conducted a national search to fill the Associate Vice President for Enrollment Management vacancy with the assistance of a hiring firm—William Spelman & Associates. However, the search proved unsuccessful after several months of seeking out viable candidates. The University is now entering the height of the student recruitment season without someone to serve in this very strategic position. As a result, an effort has been made to seek out someone who could provide the University strategic and operational direction in enrollment management and admissions in the service of helping the University achieve its enrollment and retention goals, focusing on Spring 2015, Fall 2015, and Fall 2016. Lipman Hearne (LH), a Chicago based marketing and communications firm, has been identified as a company with the expertise to assist the University in such efforts. Lipman Hearne serves the nonprofit sector, specializing in enrollment and philanthropic solutions. Areas of expertise include branding, strategy and communications. For 45 years Lipman Hearne has worked with educational institutions of every size and scope. LH has delivered on boosting enrollment, engaging donors, and reinvigorating institutional brands. It has served many public and private institutions in higher education including SIU Carbondale, Ball State University, University of Cincinnati, University of Chicago, University of Miami, Bradley University, College of Du Page and over 700 other institutions. Lipman Hearne is able to provide the following areas of work and deliverables: a) Strategy-Focused Activities: leadership in enrollment planning and goal setting; creation of an enrollment growth Playbook (with detailed tactics, budgets, and financial projections on investment and return on investment) for Spring 2015 and Fall 2015; guidance on enrollment metrics, reporting and analysis; assessment and refinement of Fall 2015 and 2016 prospect poolbuilding strategy both in-state and out-of-state; new market cultivation strategy; enrollment influence strategy; identification of new audiences and development of audience-specific strategies; assessment and identification of retention-enhancement opportunities; guidance on event strategy; seek opportunities to refine or reframe offerings for new market segments; develop clear understanding of enrollment brand and identity; and provide leadership and troubleshooting regarding the functions and processes of the enrollment management are to streamline operations. b) Operational or Tactical Activities: assess communications flow and identify key communications— both traditional and digital—that are needed or need to be redeveloped; insure consistent and compelling brand messaging throughout communications touch points; analyze enrollment metrics and provide tactical recommendations; lead prospect pool building efforts both in-state and out-of-state; support development of new segment strategies; identify tactical approaches to reach enrollment goals; insure adherence to enrollment marketing and communications strategies; assess current communications flow elements; provide communications strategy to guide in-process print and digital communications; lead initiatives to redevelop communications (emails, print, landing pages, etc.) as needed; ensure consistent messaging across platforms; seek new media opportunities to communicate with enrollment audiences (social, video, etc.); identify opportunities to leverage paid media for enrollment objectives; and provide leadership NIU Board of Trustees 103 December 4, 2014 and troubleshooting regarding the functions and processes of the admissions area to streamline operations. The cost to the University in obtaining the services of Lipman Hearne include the following: a) Consulting fees totaling $150,000. This includes development of the Playbook, along with reasonable and customary out of pocket expenses to be preapproved in writing by the University. b) An estimated cost of $664,000 for all deliverables if performed by Lipman Hearne and based on justification of all amounts. The University may perform implementation of some or all of the deliverables, at its sole discretion, providing coordination with Lipman Hearne on any deliverables Recommendation: Board of Trustees approval is requested for the expenditure of $814,000, which includes $150,000 in consulting fees and an estimated cost of $664,000 for all deliverables for a contract with Lipman Hearne to provide strategic and operational leadership in enrollment management and admissions. This includes providing consulting services, plus the development and implementation of a marketing campaign with the goal of increasing enrollment and retention. The terms affected are Spring 2015, Fall 2015 and Fall 2016. NIU Board of Trustees 104 December 4, 2014 Chair's Report No. 68 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 10.a. December 4, 2014 BOARD OF TRUSTEES 2015 MEETING DATES Following the general pattern of meeting dates for previous years and input from Board members, the following dates and campus locations are offered for consideration by the Board. March 12th (2nd Thursday) June 18th (3rd Thursday) September 17th (3rd Thursday) December 10th (2nd Thursday) The Northern Illinois University Law and Article III of the Bylaws of the Board of Trustees of Northern Illinois University state that the Board shall convene at least once each quarter. These dates would meet those requirements. All Board meetings will convene in the Board of Trustees Room, Altgeld 315, beginning at 9:00 a.m. unless indicated differently in future meeting notifications. BOARD OF TRUSTEES COMMITTEE MEETING DATES FOR 2015 Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee Compliance, Audit, Risk Management and Legal Affairs Committee Finance, Facilities and Operations Committee Legislative Affairs, Research and Innovation Committee February 26th (4th Thursday) May 28th (4th Thursday) August 27th (4th Thursday) November 12th (2nd Thursday) All BOT Standing Committees will convene in the Board of Trustees Room, Altgeld 315, beginning at 9:00 a.m. unless indicated differently in future meeting notifications. NIU Board of Trustees 105 December 4, 2014 Ad Hoc Committee on Governance Ad Hoc Committee on Enrollment The meeting dates for these ad hoc committees will be determined on an as-needed basis by the Committee Chairs and the Committee Liaisons. The dates, times and locations will be announced in accordance with Illinois Open Meetings Act notice requirements (next meetings set as listed below). NIU Board of Trustees January 15th (1:00 p.m., AL315) Ad Hoc Committee on Governance January 16th (10:00 a.m., AL315) Ad Hoc Committee on Enrollment 106 December 4, 2014 Action Agenda Item 10.b. December 4, 2014 AD HOC COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE FIRST READING ITEM D. Board of Trustees Administrative 1. Presidential Succession Policy PROPOSED PRESIDENTIAL SUCCESSION POLICY The Board of Trustees of Northern Illinois University is responsible for the appointment and oversight of the President of Northern Illinois University and has the responsibility of assuring that the President is able to discharge the powers and duties of the office of the President. From time to time, a President may find it necessary to be absent from the position and unable to discharge the powers, duties, and/or responsibilities (hereinafter “Authority”) of the office. This Presidential Succession Policy (hereinafter “Succession Policy”) is created, and adopted by the Board of Trustees, to ensure the continued operation of the University during times when the President is unable to exercise the authority of the office and to define the circumstances under which this may occur vary. Temporary Succession Designation by the President The President has the authority to temporarily designate the Executive Vice President and Provost to carry out the duties and responsibilities of the Office of President during a temporary absence of no more than thirty (30) days. This designation shall be subject to change by a majority vote of the Board of Trustees. The President shall notify each member of the Executive Committee of the Board, in writing, of any designation under this Succession Policy that will exceed fourteen (14) days. Succession Designation by the Board of Trustees In the event that the President is unable to discharge the duties and responsibilities of the Office of President to designate the Executive Vice President and Provost for absences that last more than thirty (30) days, the Executive Vice President and Provost shall assume the role of Acting President. Circumstances under which this may occur include, but are not limited to: x x x Incapacitation1, as determined by the President or by a super-majority (2/3) vote of the Board of Trustees; Incapacitation, as certified by an appropriate medical provider or judicially declared by a court of competent jurisdiction; Abandonment of the position2, as determined by a super-majority vote (2/3) of the Board of Trustees; 1 Incapacity shall mean the President is unable to receive and evaluate, make or communicate, or understand the nature and effects of decisions to such an extent that the President lacks the ability to meet the essential elements of the agreement between the Board of Trustees and the President. A Board determination of incapacity is final and non-appealable. NIU Board of Trustees 107 December 4, 2014 x x x An extended or prolonged absence3, as determined by a super-majority vote (2/3) of the Board of Trustees; Resignation of the President; Removal from office for cause or any other relevant provision of the agreement between the Board and the President by super-majority (2/3) vote of the Board of Trustees. The Acting President, shall have the full authority of the Office of the President and shall assume the critical functions of the NIU Presidency. Nothing in this provision shall diminish or otherwise authorize the Acting President to take any actions exclusive to the Board of Trustees or not otherwise authorized to the Office of the President. The line of succession for the role of Acting President shall be: Alternate A x Executive Vice President and Provost x The most senior Vice President x The next most senior Vice President Alternate B x Executive Vice President and Provost x Vice President for _______________ x Vice President for _______________ Such succession shall occur by operation of law and does not require formal Board approval. The Board may establish protocols for the swearing in of an acting President. This line of succession and the designation of an Acting President are subject to change at any time by a majority vote of the Board of Trustees. The Acting President shall notify the full Board and the Office of General Counsel upon assuming this role under this Succession Policy. The Vice President and General Counsel shall, independent of the Acting President, notify the full Board. The Acting President will serve in such capacity until: x x x x The conditions impeding the President from exercising the responsibilities and duties of the Office of President have ceased. The determination of changes of conditions leading to the appointment of an Acting President shall be determined by a majority vote of the Board; An individual of higher order on the succession list becomes available to assume the role of Acting President; The Acting President becomes absent, in which case this Succession Policy is again applied; or The Board of Trustees appoints an Interim or new full-time President. Interim Presidents under this Succession Policy shall assume the critical functions of the Office of the President and perform such powers, duties and/or responsibilities in a manner to continue the business and operations of the University with minimal disruption until a permanent new President is appointed by the Board of Trustees. 2 Abandonment of the position shall mean the willful, continued, and unjustified abandonment of the duties and obligations of the Office of the President. A Board determination of abandonment of the position is final and nonappealable. 3 In determination of an extended or prolonged absence, the Board shall consider: the reason for and nature of the absence, the length of the absence, the effect the absence has on the President’s ability to perform the duties and obligations of the Office of the President, the impact of such inability of the President to perform the duties and obligations of the Office of the President on the University, and the best interests of the University. NIU Board of Trustees 108 December 4, 2014 The invocation of this Succession Policy, or any action taken by the Board of Trustees, in relation to a permanent succession of the President automatically terminates the former President’s employment with the University and all associated powers, duties and/or responsibilities. If a President is permanently replaced under this Succession Policy, and the conditions that led to the permanent replacement of the president cease to exist, the former President has no right to reassume the position or Authority of President of Northern Illinois University. 2. Naming Rights Policy Additional materials to follow. 3. Update Record Retention Policy Additional materials to follow. 4. Update University Insurance & Employment Benefits Policy Additional materials to follow. 5. Update Indemnification Policy ARTICLE IX. INDEMNIFICATION SECTION 1. Subject to applicable federal and state law, the availability of funds and the terms and conditions of the Board's Self-Insurance Plan, the Board of Trustees shall indemnify each present or former Trustee, officer, employee, student, and agent (“Covered Person”) of the Board, except independent contractors, against all reasonable expenses which may be incurred or paid in connection with any claim, or actual or threatened action, suit, proceeding or investigation (civil, administrative, or other non-criminal proceedings) and appeals in which the Covered Person may be involved by reason of being or having been a Trustee, officer, employee, student, or agent. In matters concerning criminal investigations or proceedings, the Board shall not be responsible for the payment of expenses where there is a criminal conviction. In the event a conviction is later successfully appealed, the Board shall be responsible for the payment of expenses up to the point of the resolution of the successful appeal. A conviction or the entry of any plea in a criminal case shall in and of itself be deemed an adjudication that the Covered Person engaged in misconduct in the performance of his or her duties to the Board. In those matters wherein there is a criminal investigation which might result in an indictment and conviction, the Vice President and General Counsel is authorized to offer indemnification where there is a good faith belief that a criminal conviction is not likely. Such indemnification shall be subject to reimbursement of expenses in the event there is a conviction. In such cases, the University shall seek reimbursement for any expenses related to the matter. SECTION 2. In cases where an action, suit or proceeding advances to final adjudication and there is a finding that the covered person acted outside of the scope of their employment, indemnification shall not be provided. NIU Board of Trustees 109 December 4, 2014 SECTION 3. For those settlement matters that are in the exclusive purview of the Board, the determination whether a settlement is reasonable and in the interest of the Board or whether the Covered Person acted in good faith for a purpose which the Covered Person reasonably believed to be in the best interests of the Board and was not aware that the conduct was unlawful may be made by a majority of the disinterested Trustees acting on the proposal. SECTION 4. As used in this Article of the Bylaws, the term "expenses" includes without limitation, attorneys' fees, costs, judgments, fines, penalties and other liabilities. SECTION 5. The rights of indemnification provided for are severable, are not exclusive of other rights to which any Trustee, officer or agent may now or hereafter be entitled, and continues in effect notwithstanding the fact that the individual ceases to be a Trustee, officer, employee or agent at the time the action is instituted, while it is pending or after the judgment is rendered. SECTION 6. The indemnification referred to above covers the conduct of the Trustee, officer, employee or agent which occurred both before and after the adoption of this Article of the Bylaws and shall inure to the benefit of their estate. SECTION 7. If any part of these Bylaws or any payment made pursuant to it is for any reason held invalid, the provisions of this Article of the Bylaws are not otherwise affected but remain in full force and effect. 6. Board and Senior Management Professional Development and Travel and Expense Policy (Risk Management) Additional materials to follow. 7. Presidential House (mandate living or not) ARTICLE VII. PRESIDENT OF THE UNIVERSITY Proposed Language: Section 4. Mandate of Presidential Housing and Full Time Commitment The Board shall determine on a case by case basis whether to require the primary place of residency for the President be provided by the University. Such determination shall be made as part of the initial term of a presidential agreement and reviewed periodically by the Board and the President, but not less than every three years. The President shall devote his full time and loyalties to the University and service on any boards and commissions unrelated to Presidential duties and responsibilities shall be approved by the Board of Trustees. 8. Officer Election Policy and Procedure (clarify the number of votes necessary to continue balloting when no candidate for office obtains the minimum requirement of 5 votes) NIU Board of Trustees 110 December 4, 2014 ARTICLE V. OFFICERS AND OTHER LEADERSHIP POSITIONS OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES SECTION 1. Elected Officers and Terms of Office The officers of the Board shall consist of a Board Chair, Board Vice-Chair and Board Secretary. All Members of the Board may be eligible for service as an officer with the exception of an undergraduate Student Member who may not serve as Chair or Vice Chair. The Board Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary shall be elected annually; however, as long as they continue to serve as a Member of the Board, they shall retain their office until a successor is elected. In addition to the officers of the Board, the Board shall also elect a Board delegate to the State Universities Civil Service Merit Board. The Chair is hereby authorized to fill by appointment vacancies that may arise in any of the elected offices (Board Vice-Chair, Secretary or State Universities Civil Service Merit Board). Such appointment shall be for the remainder of the term of the particular office. When there is a vacancy in the position of Board Chair, the Vice Chair automatically becomes the Chair for the remainder of the term and shall have all of the powers, duties and responsibilities as proscribed by these Bylaws. The positions of Board Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary may be held by the same Board Member for no more than two consecutive terms. SECTION 2. Appointed Officers, Fiduciary Roles and Terms of Office The appointed officers of the Board shall consist of Treasurer, Assistant Secretary/Assistant Treasurer, Second Assistant Secretary, and General Counsel/Parliamentarian. The appointed officers shall be University staff members appointed by the Board on the recommendation of the President to serve as ex-officio corporate officers and not as Members of the Board. These officers shall have a fiduciary duty to faithfully discharge their responsibilities to the Board of Trustees. Where the Board determines it is necessary or appropriate, the appointed officers may be directed to serve the Board of Trustees in special roles and may have occasional responsibilities or duties that relate exclusively to the Board of Trustees and be separate from their roles and reporting relationships as employees of the University. Once appointed, these officers shall hold office until removal, resignation or termination of employment with the University. SECTION 3. Removal from Office Any elected or appointed officer may be removed from office by operation of law or a vote of six of the voting Members of the Board. A motion to remove an officer can only be made at a regular or special meeting of the Board, and must be preceded by the conveyance of notice to each Board Member and to the officer ten days prior to the meeting. SECTION 4. Other Board Leadership Positions In addition to the above officers, other Board leadership positions shall be the elected delegate to the State Universities Civil Service Merit Board, appointed chairs of the Board standing committees, and appointed representatives to various public and private entities as needed. The Chair is hereby authorized to fill by appointment, after consultation with Members of the Board, the Chairs and NIU Board of Trustees 111 December 4, 2014 committee members of each of the standing committees of the Board, any Ad Hoc Committees of the Board, or the Chair of a Committee of the Whole of the Board. Such appointment shall be for the remainder of the term of the particular Committee or as proscribed by the Chair. When there is a vacancy in the position of Committee Chair or a Committee Member is absent or has vacated their committee position, the Board Chair may appoint a replacement who shall automatically assume the position with all of the powers, duties and responsibilities as proscribed by these Bylaws. SECTION 5. Election of Officers The Board shall elect Officers and other elected positions at the meeting preceding July 1 of each year. The Board may, upon an affirmative vote of a super majority of the Board and for established good reason, postpone the election to either the next regularly scheduled meeting after July 1 or a special meeting of the Board called prior to the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Board. The Board shall conduct its election of officers by secret ballot. The manner of the elections shall be the prerogative of the Board Chair. The Recording Secretary in conjunction with the General Counsel shall tally the results of each election attempt, advise the Chair and Board of the results and maintain the ballots as required by law or Board rule. Procedures for the election of officers shall be as follows: 1. The Chair shall provide an opportunity for Members to make public expressions of interest, vision or acknowledgements of willingness to serve as elected officers. The General Counsel shall provide ballots for each office consisting of all eligible members for that office. The method and manner of voting shall be determined by the Chair after consultation with the Board.. 2. Only the voting Members of the Board shall be entitled to cast votes in officer elections. A Student Member, who is an undergraduate student, shall not be eligible to serve as the Chair or Vice Chair. 3. If a majority of votes cast is not achieved by one Member for the office in the first balloting, the Member(s) with the fewest number of votes shall be dropped on the succeeding ballot. This process shall continue through three successive ballots. If at the conclusion of voting no Member shall have achieved a majority of the full Board, the Board Chair shall declare the election at an impasse. In the event of an impasse, expressions of interest, vision and willingness to serve are re-opened and the next election will be conducted at the next Regular Business Meeting or special meeting; 4. The votes of a majority of the Board shall be required to be elected, even if fewer than all eligible Board Members choose to vote; 5. Board Members shall be entitled to vote by written absentee ballot for good reason with prior notification to the Board Chair, Vice Chair or General Counsel in writing one week prior to the elections. Absentee ballots must be filed with the General Counsel in writing prior to the meeting at which the elections are to occur. SECTION 6. Duties of Officers A. Board Chair The Board Chair shall: NIU Board of Trustees 112 December 4, 2014 1. Preside at all Board meetings, with full power to discuss all matters before the Board and to vote in roll calls, secret ballots, and when necessary to break a tie if no vote has otherwise been cast by the Chair; 2. Serve as member and presiding officer of the Board Executive Committee, and at the discretion of the Chair, may serve as a voting member of all Board standing committees and be included as part of a committee's quorum if attending and serving as a voting member; 3. After consultation with Members of the board, the Chair is authorized to appoint the chairs, vice chairs and Members of the Board Standing Committees or Ad Hoc Committees. Such appointment authority shall include the appointment of members to serve for purposes of quorum as a member of any standing or ad hoc committee. Such quorum appointments shall be for the duration of that specific committee meeting. In the absence of a committee chair and vice chair, the Board Chair may appoint a Member to serve as the temporary committee chair and/or vice chair; 4. Appoint Board representatives to various public and private entities. The Chair shall determine whether to appoint Members of the Board to serve as liaisons to various entities, including, but not limited to, the NIU Foundation and the NIU Alumni Association. 5. Coordinate Board business with the President and foster communications among Board Members; 6. Assist new Board Members in becoming familiar with the operations of the Board and the University and identify and develop potential Board leadership; 7. Engage in external activities in behalf of the Board and the University, and represent the Board and the University in a ceremonial capacity at public functions. B. Board Vice-Chair The Board Vice-Chair shall: 1. Serve as presiding officer of the Board in the absence of the Board Chair with full power to vote on and discuss all matters before the Board; 2. Serve as a member of the Board Executive Committee; 3. Assist the Board Chair in facilitating communications among Board Members and in identifying and developing Board leadership; 4. Assist the Board Chair in external relations and in representing the Board and the University in a ceremonial capacity at public functions. C. Secretary The Secretary shall: 1. Serve as a member of the Board Executive Committee; 2. Sign as attesting official, with the Board Chair, any contracts and other legal documents approved by the Board, provided others delegated by the Board may sign such documents in accordance with their respective delegations. 3. Determine that the minutes and records of the proceedings of the Board are kept, published and distributed as required by law; NIU Board of Trustees 113 December 4, 2014 4. Maintain a record of the names of all Members of the Board, the dates of their appointments, and the dates of the expiration of their terms of office. The Secretary shall also maintain a record of Board officers and terms of elective office. D. Treasurer The Treasurer shall: 1. Be the chief custodian of all funds held in the name of the Board of Trustees and Northern Illinois University and be responsible for overseeing the issuance and sales of revenue bonds and other financial instruments on behalf of the Board; 2. Be responsible for complying with various financial requirements of bond resolutions, oversight of investment and banking relationships, and coordination and development of information for bondholders. Make a financial report to the Board reflecting securities held and all receipts and disbursements on an annual basis, or as required; 3. Provide for the orderly reimbursement or payment, consistent with state law, for Board Member travel and expenses, and establish necessary procedures incident thereto; 4. Exercise direct or facsimile signature authority, as authorized and appropriate on necessary certificates or contracts and other documents approved by the Board on behalf of the Board Chair or the Secretary. E. Assistant Secretary-Assistant Treasurer When the Board Chair, Secretary or Treasurer are not practically available to perform one of their ministerial duties, the Assistant Secretary-Assistant Treasurer may provide an authorized signature on necessary certificates or contracts and other documents approved by the Board on behalf of the Board Chair, the Secretary, or the Treasurer, and shall provide such other assistance to the Secretary or Treasurer as either may request and shall carry out such other functions as the Board may assign. F. Second Assistant Secretary When the Board Secretary or Assistant Secretary-Assistant Treasurer are not practically available to perform one of their ministerial duties, the Second Assistant Secretary may provide an authorized signature on necessary certificates or contracts and other documents approved by the Board on behalf of the Board Chair, or the Secretary, and shall provide such other assistance to the Secretary as may be requested and shall carry out such other functions as the Board may assign. G. General Counsel and Parliamentarian The General Counsel and Parliamentarian shall be a member of the University staff who serves as chief legal officer and advises the Board Chair, Committee Chairs and the University President on matters of law and parliamentary procedure. SECTION 7. Duties of Appointed Leadership Positions A. Standing Committee Chairs Standing Committee Chairs shall: 1. Preside over committee meetings with full power to discuss all matters before the Committee and to vote in roll calls, and when necessary to break a tie if no vote has otherwise been cast by the Chair; NIU Board of Trustees 114 December 4, 2014 2. Prepare reports of committee meetings to be presented to the Board, such reports to include notation of the committee members present, description of the agenda covered, and a summary of decisions and recommendations of the committee; 3. Keep informed of the major issues, actions and needs of the University in the areas of responsibility covered by the committee; 4. Work with the President and staff in formulating agendas and preparing for meetings; 5. Maintain communications with other members of the committee and work to keep them informed of issues and needs. B. Standing Committee Vice-Chairs Standing Committee Vice-Chairs shall: 1. In the absence of the Committee Chair, perform the duties of the Committee Chair. NIU Board of Trustees 115 December 4, 2014