Department of State Treasurer Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Table of Contents Executive Summary.................................................................................................................. 1 Part I – Introduction ................................................................................................................. 3 A Purpose and Applicability ............................................................................................. 3 B. Functions of the Capital Asset Accounting System...................................................... 3 Part II – Classification and Recording ..................................................................................... 5 A Classification ................................................................................................................. 5 1. Land ......................................................................................................................... 5 2. Improvements Other Than Buildings ..................................................................... 5 3. Infrastructure .......................................................................................................... 5 4. Buildings .................................................................................................................. 5 5. Equipment ............................................................................................................... 5 6. Vehicles .................................................................................................................... 6 7. Construction in Progress ......................................................................................... 6 8. Intangible Assets ..................................................................................................... 6 9. Works of Art and Historical Treasures ................................................................... 7 B. Recording Capital Assets .............................................................................................. 7 1. Capitalization Threshold – Definition .................................................................... 7 2. Capitalization Threshold – Considerations ............................................................ 7 a. Land ................................................................................................................... 8 b. Improvements Other Than Buildings ............................................................... 8 c. Buildings ............................................................................................................ 8 d. Infrastructure .................................................................................................... 8 e. Assets Acquired with Restricted Funds ............................................................ 8 f. Small Items ........................................................................................................ 8 g. Equipment and Vehicles .................................................................................... 9 h. Construction in Progress ................................................................................... 9 i. Donated Assets .................................................................................................. 9 j. Intangible Assets ............................................................................................... 9 k. Internally Generated Intangible Assets............................................................ 9 3. Changing Capitalization Threshold ........................................................................ 9 4. Valuation of Capital Assets ................................................................................... 10 LGC Page i of iv. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Table of Contents a. Cost .................................................................................................................. 10 b. Estimated Historical Cost ............................................................................... 11 c. Capitalization of Interest Cost ........................................................................ 11 d. Self-constructed Assets .................................................................................... 12 C. Internally Generated Computer Software .................................................................. 12 D. Water Rights ............................................................................................................... 13 E. Right-of-Way Easements............................................................................................. 14 F. Annual Initial Inventory of Assets ............................................................................. 14 Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets ................................................................................ 15 A. Introduction ................................................................................................................. 15 B. Acquisition of Capital Assets ...................................................................................... 15 1. Installment Purchases .......................................................................................... 15 2. Leases .................................................................................................................... 15 a. Operating Leases ............................................................................................. 16 b. Capital Leases.................................................................................................. 16 C. Acquisition with Federal Financial Assistance .......................................................... 17 D. Disposals of Captial Assets ......................................................................................... 19 1. Competitive Sale.................................................................................................... 20 a. Advertisement for Sealed Bids (G.S. 160A -268) ............................................ 20 b. Negotiated Offer, Advertisement, and Upset Bids ......................................... 20 c. Public Auction .................................................................................................. 21 2. Private Negotiation and Sale ................................................................................ 21 3. Exchange................................................................................................................ 22 E. Impairment of Capital Assets ..................................................................................... 22 Part IV – Internal Control and Financial Reporting ............................................................. 25 A. Introduction ................................................................................................................. 25 B. Internal Control Over Capital Assets ......................................................................... 25 C. Financial Reporting Considerations ........................................................................... 26 Part V – Depreciation and Amortization................................................................................ 29 A. Introduction ................................................................................................................. 29 1. Governmental Funds ............................................................................................. 29 2. Proprietary Funds ................................................................................................. 29 LGC Page ii of iv. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Table of Contents B. Depreciation and Amortization Considerations ......................................................... 30 1. Estimated Useful Life ........................................................................................... 31 2. Expected Salvage Value ........................................................................................ 31 C. Reporting Depreciation ............................................................................................... 31 D. Amortization of Intangible Assets .............................................................................. 31 E. Selection of a Depreciation Method ............................................................................ 32 F. Straight-line Depreciation .......................................................................................... 33 1. Computation .......................................................................................................... 33 2. Illustration ............................................................................................................. 33 G. Composite Depreciation .............................................................................................. 33 Part VI – Suggested Reading ................................................................................................. 35 LGC Page iii of iv. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Table of Contents This page intentionally left blank. LGC Page iv of iv. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Executive Summary GASB Statement No. 34 defines capital assets as “land, improvements to land, easements, buildings, building improvements, vehicles, machinery, equipment, works of art and historical treasures, infrastructure, and all other tangible or intangible assets that are used in operations and that have initial useful lives extending beyond a single reporting period.” Capital assets and related depreciation expense are presented on the government-wide statements and are recorded in the accounts of proprietary funds, but are not recorded in the accounts of the governmental funds. Article V, Section 2(1) of the Constitution of the State of North Carolina requires funds generated by taxation to be spent only for public purposes. Local governments and public authorities are required by G.S. 159-26(b)(8) to maintain “a ledger in which to record the details relating to the general capital assets of the unit or public authority.” The establishment of the procedures and controls over capital assets are necessary to ensure that this constitutional provision, as well as laws and regulations, relating to the expenditure of public funds and the use of public property are being followed. A capital assets control system is important because it provides for effective property management and the safeguarding of a large public investment. The capital asset system needs to provide information not only for accounting and financial reporting but also for budgeting, for asset replacement and maintenance, and for insurance. It also can assist in making management decisions and prevent misstatements in the financial statements. To avoid recording assets for financial statement presentation with immaterial values, local governments should set minimum unit values, known as capitalization thresholds, below which an asset is not recorded in the capital assets records. The dollar amount set is a policy decision of the governing board. Each capital asset should be assigned a control number and all equipment tagged regardless of its cost. The existence, location and condition of all capital assets should be verified by taking an annual inventory. Capital assets should be accounted for at cost or estimated historical cost if actual cost is not available. Estimated costs can be calculated by using price deflator tables to discount replacement costs. Donated capital assets should be recorded at their estimated fair market value when received. Capital assets may be acquired with cash or through leases or other financing arrangements such as bonds, notes, and installment purchases. Regardless of the method of acquisition, when a local government obtains most of the benefits and risks of ownership of a property, the property must be recorded as a capital asset. GASB Statement No. 62 codifies the definition of a capital lease. A capital lease exists if at the inception of the lease it transfers ownership to the governmental unit by the end of the lease term, or it contains a bargain purchase option, or the lease term is 75% or more of the estimated economic life of the asset, or the present value of the minimum lease payments is at least 90% of the fair value of the property. With leases involving land, a lease must fulfill one of the first two above to be accounted for as a capital lease. For capital leases, a unit should record a capital asset and the related obligation. Unlike a capital lease, an operating lease does not transfer the benefits and risks of ownership to the local governmental unit. LGC Page 1 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Executive Summary Under the North Carolina Constitution, a local government is generally required to dispose of property at its fair market value. However, in certain cases a conveyance with the receiving party (usually another government or nonprofit organization) to put the property to some public use constitutes sufficient consideration for the conveyance. Subject to certain limitations, a local government may dispose of real or personal property belonging to it by: 1) competitive sale; 2) private negotiation and sale; or 3) exchange. Before a department in a governmental unit disposes of any real or personal property, notice should be circulated to other departments that the property is considered surplus. Office of Management and Budget Circular A-102 sets out the requirements for the use and disposal of capital assets acquired with federal financial assistance. Depreciation expense should be recorded in the statement of activities, the accounts of proprietary funds and some fiduciary funds. Capital assets, net of accumulated depreciation, should be recorded on the statement of net position. Depreciation expense should not be recorded in the governmental fund statements. The objective of depreciation is to charge each accounting period for the estimated loss in economic value of the depreciable assets used during the period. Theoretically, a depreciation method should be selected that achieves the most realistic reflection of the loss in economic value of the asset. The most commonly used depreciation method is straight-line depreciation which provides a uniform rate of depreciation per period. Other depreciation methods available to units of local government include accelerated depreciation methods and composite depreciation, but these are rarely used. The recording of an impairment of capital assets is required by GASB Statement No. 42 for all long-lived assets when a decline in service utility of the capital asset is substantial and the event or change in circumstances is not part of the normal life cycle of the capital asset. LGC Page 2 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part I – Introduction A. Purpose and Applicability Article V, Section 2(1) of the North Carolina State Constitution requires funds generated by taxation to be spent only for public purposes. The establishment of the procedures and controls over capital assets are necessary to ensure that this constitutional provision, as well as laws and regulations, relating to the expenditure of public funds and the use of public property are being followed. GASB Statement No. 34 at paragraph 19 defines capital assets to include “land, improvements to land, easements, buildings, building improvements, vehicles, machinery, equipment, works of art and historical treasures, infrastructure, and all other tangible or intangible assets that are used in operations and that have initial useful lives extending beyond a single reporting period.” Items of insignificant value, while they may meet the above criteria, are normally recorded as expenditures or expenses for financial reporting purposes instead of as capital assets. Local governments and public authorities are required by G.S. 159-26(b)(8) to maintain "a ledger in which to record the details relating to the general capital assets of the unit or public authority." Generally accepted accounting principles (“GAAP”) as specified in Governmental Accounting Standards Board (“GASB”) Statement 34 – “Basic Financial Statements — and Management's Discussion and Analysis — for State and Local Governments” establish the primary reporting requirements for capital assets. Adequate capital asset records are necessary for the local government's auditor to render an unmodified opinion on the unit’s financial statements. Governmental units having an unmodified opinion on their statements are viewed favorably by bond rating agencies and normally pay lower interest rates on their bonds. To meet GAAP and GASB 34 requirements, governmental units should record the capital assets at cost when historical records are available and at an estimated historical cost when no historical records exist. The LGC will not authorize the issuance of long-term debt for any units having a capital assets opinion modification. Capital assets information also is required for the unit’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report to qualify for the Government Finance Officers Association's Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting. For most local governments and public authorities in North Carolina, meeting GASB 34 requirements involves extensive year-end adjusting entries to convert governmental funds from modified accrual to full accrual basis of accounting. Recording capital asset information throughout the year and using appropriate capital asset software makes the year-end conversion process much easier and may reduce audit cost. B. Functions of the Capital Asset Accounting System Establishing and maintaining complete and accurate accounting records for capital assets is important for several reasons. First, the value of capital assets for most governmental units and public authorities is significant. Therefore, adequate accounting procedures, internal controls and asset records are essential for effective property management LGC Page 3 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets including insurance and risk management. The capital assets records should provide adequate, detailed documentation of each asset capitalized including its description, serial number, location, cost, date acquired, vendor, depreciation, and other information. This information is necessary to determine the amount of property insurance required and to adequately document a claim in the event of damage or loss from an insurable event. The stewardship responsibility involved in safeguarding such a large public investment is of the utmost importance to sound financial administration. Adequate capital assets records can assist in making management decisions. Proper use of these records may prevent unneeded assets from being acquired. When budgeting for and preparing routine preventative maintenance and replacement schedules management may use these records to determine whether maintenance costs are too high for particular assets. Capital assets records also could be used to help clarify long-term capital budgeting needs. Finally, accurate and complete capital assets records can prevent the possible misstatement of a local government's financial statements. Otherwise, assets such as those acquired under capital leases and joint ventures could be overlooked or improperly reported. LGC Page 4 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording A. Classification Capital assets owned by the governmental unit and public authority should be recorded in the accounting records using the following general account classifications. Depreciable capital assets should be recorded separately from nondepreciable capital assets. More detailed, sub-classifications may be added as needed. The level of detail necessary at the ledger level should be sufficient to provide management adequate financial information but no more complex than necessary. Detail information for the individual assets should be available from the capital asset subsystems. 1. Land The land account includes the acquisition value of land and the rights to land owned by the governmental unit. It includes all land held in fee simple and all rights to land that have no termination date. 2. Improvements Other Than Buildings Improvements other than buildings reflect the acquisition value of permanent improvements (other than buildings) that add value to the land or improve the use of the land. Examples of such improvements are fences, retaining walls, drainage systems, sidewalks, parking lots, and driveways. Note that when used with capital assets, the terms “improvement” and “betterment” have different meanings. Improvements are capital assets permanently attached to land. Betterments are additions to or changes in existing depreciable assets intended to increase their efficiency or prolong their useful lives. 3. Infrastructure Infrastructure assets are defined by GASB Statement No. 34, paragraph 19, as “longlived capital assets that normally are stationary in nature and normally can be preserved for a significantly greater number of years than most capital assets. Examples of infrastructure assets include roads, bridges, tunnels, drainage systems, water and sewer systems, dams, and lighting systems. Buildings, except those that are an ancillary part of a network of infrastructure assets, should not be considered infrastructure assets….” 4. Buildings A capital assets account that reflects the acquisition value of permanent structures owned by the governmental unit and used to house persons and property. Permanently installed fixtures to or within these structures are considered parts of the structures. The costs of major improvements to structures are included in this account. 5. Equipment A capital assets account that reflects the value of tangible property not permanently affixed to real property and used in carrying out the operations of the governmental unit. Examples of equipment are machinery, furniture, and vehicles. Most local units include their computers in this category. LGC Page 5 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording 6. Vehicles A capital assets account that records the value of motor vehicles owned by the local government. 7. Construction in Progress A capital assets account used when a government reports amounts expended on an uncompleted building or other capital asset construction project. These subclasses such as buildings, improvements, and equipment might be used. When the project is complete and placed in service, the cumulative costs are transferred to the appropriate capital assets accounts. Depreciation expense is not recorded on the assets in this category. 8. Intangible Assets Intangible assets include assets such as easements, water rights, timber rights, patents, trademarks, and computer software. Paragraph 19 of GASB Statement No. 34, Basic Financial Statements-and Management’s Discussion and Analysis-for State and Local Governments, states capital assets include intangible assets that are used in operations and have initial useful lives that extend beyond a single reporting period. Paragraph 21 of GASB Statement No. 34 explains that capital assets should be depreciated or amortized over their estimated useful lives and those inexhaustible capital assets such as land and land improvements should not be depreciated nor amortized. Paragraph 2 of GASB Statement No. 51 amends GASB Statement No. 34 and defines an intangible asset as possessing all of the following characteristics: Lack of physical substance. An asset may be contained in or on an item with physical substance, for example, a compact disc in the case of computer software. An asset also may be closely associated with another item that has physical substance, for example, the underlying land in the case of a right-of-way easement. These modes of containment and associated items should not be considered when determining whether or not an asset lacks physical substance. Nonfinancial nature. An asset with a nonfinancial nature is one that is not in a monetary form similar to cash and investment securities, and it represents neither a claim or right to assets in a monetary form similar to receivables, nor a prepayment for goods or services. Initial useful life extending beyond a single reporting period.” Intangible assets that meet at least one of the following exemptions are excluded from the provisions of GASB Statement No. 51: LGC Assets acquired or created primarily for the purpose of directly obtaining income or profit, Assets resulting from capital lease transactions reported by lessees, or Goodwill created through the combination of a government and another entity. (Paragraph 3, GASB Statement No. 51). Page 6 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording Identifiable intangible assets that meet the above characteristics and are not exempt should be classified as capital assets and recognized as such on the financial statements. As capital assets, intangibles are subject to all existing guidance regarding capital assets. It is important to remember that they are reported as expenditures in the fund statements of governmental funds and not as assets. Intangible assets are identifiable when either of the following conditions is met: The asset is capable of being separated or divided from the government and sold, transferred, licensed, rented, or exchanged, either individually or together with a related contract, asset, or liability, or The asset arises from contractual or other legal rights. 9. Works of Art and Historical Treasures Works of art, historical treasures and similar collections should be capitalized at their historical cost or estimated fair value at the date of donation. For a full discussion of accounting for and reporting works of art and historical treasures, see GASB Statement No. 34, paragraphs 27 – 29. B. Recording Capital Assets Governmental units may acquire capital assets by several methods. Possible acquisition methods include purchase, capital lease, installment purchase, construction, eminent domain, tax foreclosures, and gifts. Regardless of the method of acquisition, capital assets should be properly recorded on the unit’s books and in subsidiary records that provide detailed information on each asset. 1. Capitalization Threshold – Definition To avoid recording many assets with low values that do not, in the aggregate, amount to a material portion of the value of the capital assets, units should establish minimum asset values or a capitalization threshold below which the item is not capitalized for external financial reporting. However, adequate control must be maintained over all assets, not just high value assets. Internal control, insurance and security concerns, as well as legal compliance considerations, may require establishment of additional procedures for certain items that do not otherwise meet the capitalization threshold. Examples of such items include laptop computers and tablets, cell phones, assets acquired with restricted funds, and firearms. The internal control procedures for the capital assets not meeting the capitalization threshold should be designed to focus on the particular control issues related to these assets. The Government Finance Officers Association (“GFOA”) has issued Best Practice papers titled "Establishing Capitalization Thresholds for Capital Assets" and “Maintaining Control Over Items That Are Not Capitalized” that are available at their website, www.gfoa.org. 2. Capitalization Threshold – Considerations To determine the capitalization threshold, the unit must identify the dollar amount that identifies an asset is of significant value for financial reporting. This is a policy decision for the governing board of the local government or public authority. Assets that equal or exceed the threshold value are capitalized; assets below that amount are LGC Page 7 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording recorded as expenditures or expenses. Local governments should establish a capitalization threshold level that reflects their financial conditions and may find it useful to establish different threshold values for different classes of capital assets. Generally, smaller units of government will use a lower dollar amount as a threshold for capitalizing assets than larger units. Generally, groups of items not individually meeting the capitalization threshold would not be capitalized. However, caution must be exercised in the application of the guidance to avoid a significant class of capital assets being understated. In its Comprehensive Implementation Guide (“CIG”), GASB recommends “an appropriate balance between ensuring that all material capital assets, collectively, are capitalized and minimizing the cost of record keeping for capital assets.” Some suggested capitalization thresholds and considerations follow. These amounts are optional and units of government may establish different thresholds. a. Land All land as well as easements and other permanent rights to land should be capitalized without regard to their value. b. Improvements Other Than Buildings A capitalization of $5,000 or more may be appropriate for improvements other than buildings. c. Buildings A capitalization of $5,000 or more may be appropriate for buildings, additions and betterments. All buildings should be recorded at acquisition cost which usually is well above the threshold. If a building is below the threshold, it should be expensed in the year of acquisition. Additions and betterments costing more than the capitalization threshold should be recorded as capital assets. d. Infrastructure A capitalization of $5,000 or more may be appropriate for infrastructure. e. Assets Acquired with Restricted Funds Assets costing less than the capitalization threshold for the class of property acquired with grant funds, with funds from bonded debt issuances or installment purchases, or with funds from other restricted sources should be capitalized in compliance with the grant contract, bond indenture or other agreement. In all instances, assets acquired with these funds should be specifically identified in the asset records to assure that these assets are used in compliance with all restrictions in the grant contract, bond indenture or other agreement. If necessary the assets may be recorded at $1 or other nominal amount to maintain the asset accounting record and assure proper internal control. f. LGC Small Items Equipment costing less than $5,000 that the governmental unit desires to control may be capitalized at $1.00 for each separate asset record. (Examples: calculators, cell phones, computers and tablets, computer software, etc.) Page 8 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording g. Equipment and Vehicles Equipment and vehicles costing $5,000 or more should be recorded as capital assets. Additions costing $2,500 or more to equipment and vehicles should be recorded as capital assets. Equipment and vehicles costing less than the above should not be recorded unless they meet the criteria for small items. h. Construction in Progress Construction in progress should be recorded at acquisition cost without regard to significant value. i. Donated Assets Since there is no cost for donated assets, the determination of whether to capitalize donated assets would be based on their fair market value at the time of acquisition plus additional charges related to the asset. j. Intangible Assets All intangible assets as well as easements and other permanent rights to land should be capitalized without regard to their value. k. Internally Generated Intangible Assets Intangible assets that are created or produced by the government or an entity contracted by the government would be considered internally generated. Assets acquired from a third party, but require more than minimal incremental efforts on the part of the government to begin achieving their expected level of service capacity, also are considered internally generated. Outlays that are incurred in the generation of internally generated intangible assets should be expensed until certain criteria are met. GASB Statement No. 51 paragraph 8, states that all three of the following requirements must occur before capitalization begins. Determination of the specific objective of the project and the nature of the service capacity that is expected to be provided by the intangible asset upon the completion of the project, Demonstration of the technical or technological feasibility for completing the project so the intangible asset will provide its expected service capacity, and Demonstration of the current intention, ability, and presence of effort to complete or, in the case of multiyear project, continued development of the intangible asset. 3. Changing Capitalization Threshold When a government decides to increase its threshold for capitalization, the new threshold is applied prospectively. Assets that have been capitalized under the preceding lower capitalization threshold are not removed from the capital asset records. GASB addressed the question of whether or not a restatement of beginning net position is required for a change in the capitalization threshold in the CIG, 7.22.17 (As amended for adoption of GASB 62). It concluded that no restatement of beginning assets is required indicating “(u)se of a capitalization threshold is an application of accounting policy, and any change in capitalization threshold should appropriately LGC Page 9 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording ensure that all significant capital assets, collectively, are capitalized while considering the cost of record keeping for capital assets.” 4. Valuation of Capital Assets Capital assets should be accounted for at cost or, if the cost is not practicably determinable, at estimated historical cost. Donated capital assets should be recorded at their estimated fair market value when received. a. Cost The cost of a capital asset includes the purchase price or construction cost and ancillary charges necessary to acquire the asset or to place it in the intended location and condition for use. Ancillary charges should be directly attributable to acquisition of the specific asset and include costs such as transportation charges, site preparation, professional fees including engineering and legal fees, and certain interest costs during construction. For equipment, the costs of any testing also should be capitalized. The costs of engineering studies on the feasibility of a project are sometimes properly expensed rather than capitalized at the time they are incurred if a decision on whether assets will be constructed has not been made. If these studies eventually lead to the acquisition or construction of assets, the unit should capitalize these costs if significant as part of a project. For example, engineering costs for the expansion of a water and sewer system may be expensed if there is no definite project. If the decision is made later to go through with the project, these costs should be capitalized and the expensed amount reversed. (1) Land When land is purchased, the costs includes the purchase price; legal fees including attorney’s fees, closing cost and recording fees; filling, grading and excavation cost; and other costs directly related to the acquisition of the land and its preparation for use. Rights of way and easements are recorded at purchase cost plus legal costs. Removal cost for assets removed from the land increase the cost of the land; the net proceeds from the salvaging of any assets removed from the land reduce the cost, i.e. amounts received from the sale of the components of an existing building on the land. (2) Buildings, Improvements Other Than Buildings, and Construction in Progress If purchased or constructed, the valuation includes such costs as the purchase price, acquisition legal fees, permits, construction costs, and other professional fees related to design or construction. (3) Infrastructure If purchased or constructed, the valuation includes such costs as the purchase price, acquisition legal fees, and other professional fees related to design or construction. (4) Equipment The basis of valuation of purchased equipment includes the net contract price; transportation charges including insurance while in transit; the cost of assembly and installation of special devices or foundations; testing and calibration costs; and cost of other preparations required to ready the asset for its intended use. LGC Page 10 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording (5) Donated Assets For assets acquired by a gift, the valuation recorded should be the fair market value based on the appraised value at the time of acquisition plus ancillary charges, if any. b. Estimated Historical Cost Appropriate capital asset accounting records are essential for the fair presentation of financial statements prepared in accordance with GASB Statement 34. Prior standards and practices placed less emphasis on the capital assets as a whole, owned by the local government or public authority. Some units may find that their capital asset records are lacking in detail and completeness. In such situations, the original purchase documentation may not be available, or an inordinate expenditure of resources may be required to establish original asset costs precisely. Therefore, it may be necessary to estimate the original asset cost of such assets on the basis of documentary evidence available, including price levels at the time of acquisition, and to record these estimated costs in the appropriate capital asset accounts. In some units, the cost may not be known; but information and records may be available showing the year of acquisition. In this instance, historical appraisal cost can be used. Historical appraisal cost is defined for this purpose as the current appraised value adjusted to the year of acquisition using the appropriate construction indices, such as the Handy-Whitman Index (a subscription service available to utility companies) or The Engineering News-Record (a weekly technical magazine whose publisher issues a semiannual index upon request). If the exact date of acquisition and cost are not known, but a general time period of the acquisition and cost are known, an average year during the period and a reasonable estimated cost might be used. Information on the approximate time of asset acquisition can be obtained from such sources as building cornerstones and old newspaper clippings. The important concept is to obtain a reasonable estimated cost for use in recording the assets on the books and in establishing accountability. In order to have the auditor render an unmodified opinion, the capital assets values need to be materially correct. If the unit has documentation for assets that were recently acquired, this may represent the bulk of the dollar value of the unit's total capital assets. The depreciated carrying values for older assets should not be a large part of the total capital assets value. Using estimated costs does create some margin of error in the capital assets accounting records as compared to the proper recording at acquisition. However, such errors should be immaterial and will diminish over time as assets are retired and replaced, and estimated costs are replaced with actual costs. c. Capitalization of Interest Cost The cost of acquiring an asset in an enterprise fund includes the interest cost incurred during the period of construction as a result of outlays for the assets. GASB Statement No. 62 in paragraphs 5 – 22 discusses the capitalization of interest costs. Interest should be capitalized for “qualifying assets”, primarily assets constructed for the government’s own use and should not be capitalized for inventories, assets acquired with gifts or grants restricted to the acquisition of the assets and certain other assets. The portion of interest cost incurred during LGC Page 11 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording construction that could have been avoided if the outlays had not been made is the amount that should be capitalized. d. Self-constructed assets At times a local government or public authority may construct an asset using its own staff. In this circumstance, the unit must identify the cost of the selfconstructed asset. Since there is no external transaction to provide the exchange price, this is more difficult than for a purchased asset and requires more detailed recordkeeping. Generally, the direct costs of materials and labor are easily captured. The difficulty is determining the amount of indirect cost associated with the construction. One approach is to include only those additional costs – excluding any general or administrative expenses which are never capitalized – that are incurred because of the decision to self-construct the asset, i.e. the incremental costs. Since depreciation and supervisor’s salaries would be incurred if the asset was not selfconstructed, they are excluded when using this approach. C. Internally Generated Computer Software GASB Statement No. 51 recognizes computer software as internally generated if it is purchased or licensed by the government and modified with more than minimal incremental effort before putting into service. Websites also are considered in this group of assets, however keep in mind that there is a high hurdle here to exceed before capitalization is required. As with all other internally-generated intangible assets, computer software should be expensed until the requirements to capitalize are met. The requirements for capitalization of computer software are considered to be met when the following occur: The activities noted in the preliminary project stage are completed, and Management implicitly or explicitly authorizes and commits to funding, at least currently in the case of a multiyear project, the software project. Internally generated computer software is grouped into three stages: preliminary project, application development, and post-implementation. Only during the applicationdevelopment stage should outlays incurred be capitalized. Outlays associated with the preliminary and post implementation stages should be expensed as incurred. Preliminary-stage activities include: selecting a vendor, selecting a consultant to assist in development or installation, final selection of alternatives for development, making strategic decisions to allocated resources at a point in time, determining the performance requirements for the project, and determining the existence of needed technology. Training employees involved with the development of internally generated software, if the training does not contribute to putting the software in use, should also be expensed as incurred and not included in the application development stage. Included in the application-development stage are activities such as coding, software configuration, testing, installation to hardware, and data conversion. Tasks considered to be data conversion include purging or cleansing of existing data and reconciliation from the legacy system to the new system. Data conversion should only be included in the LGC Page 12 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording application development stage to the extent that it is necessary to make software operational. The CIG references a human resource software system as an example of when data conversion is needed for operational purposes. In a human resource system, payroll transactions are dependent on the transfer of information such as direct deposit information and tax deductions in order to pay employees. If the data conversion is deemed unnecessary for operation or more informational than essential, it should be included in the post-implementation stage. The same rule applies for data conversion activities associated with computer software that is not internally generated. Internal modification of existing software to make it able to interface with new software should be capitalized if it increases the functionality, efficiency or extends its useful life. Post-implementation stage activities include software maintenance and application training. Please note maintenance activities that do not improve efficiency, functionality or extend useful life would be considered post-implementation and should be expensed as incurred. The same rules apply for training activities when computer software is not considered internally generated. Outlays from business process reengineering activities that result during the development should not be considered a cost of development, but should be expensed. Commercially available computer software that is purchased or licensed by the government and placed into operation without modification, or requiring minimal incremental effort to modify is not considered ‘internally generated.’ However, it will still meet the description of an intangible asset in GASB Statement No. 51. For example, a unit of government that acquires computer software through a five year licensing agreement requiring annual payments for the right to use should report the software as an intangible asset and record a long-term liability for the required annual payments. The government should not consider this software as internally generated. If the licensing agreement includes several components each component should be evaluated for capitalization. Similarly, an enterprise resource planning system with multiple modules, including procurement, human resources, and financial reporting, should have each module evaluated individually as to its stage in development. Maintenance agreements result in external modifications of the software that increase its functionality or improve the efficiency of the software should be capitalized as intangibles. Otherwise, maintenance agreements should be expensed. Theoretically the unit should split its maintenance agreement outlays into these two subsets. However, materiality should be considered in this decision – the unit may as a matter of policy expense all maintenance agreements that are not specified to increase functionality or improve efficiency (CIG Z.51.23). D. Water Rights Water rights are not excluded from the provisions of GASB Statement No. 51 even if income or profit is generated through the sale of water. Question Z.51.5 in CIG states that water rights used in operations are not themselves directly generating income or profit. Income and profit are indirect results of ownership of the rights, therefore making water rights used in operations of water system an intangible asset. Water rights acquired for the purpose of trading those rights to obtain income are not intangible assets. LGC Page 13 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part II – Classification and Recording E. Right-of-Way Easements Right-of-way easements are generally considered to be recordable intangible assets. A separate asset for the right-of-way easement should be reported at fair value at the time of acquisition in accordance with GASB Statement 34, paragraph 18. Determining the fair value is a challenge for right of way easements. The fair value of any asset is the amount at which the asset could be exchanged in a current transaction between willing parties, other than in a forced or liquidation sale. In the case of right-of-way easements for roads, however, generally the only willing buyer is the government. The fair value can then be estimated to be the outlay the government would have incurred to acquire the easement in an exchange transaction. There also may be other reasonable methods for determining the fair value of a donated right-of-way easement. However, it is not appropriate to arbitrarily assign a nominal value to a donated easement. F. Annual Inventory of Assets The existence and condition of all capital assets should either be verified annually as a part of the year-end closing process or on a cycle basis during the year. If this task is challenging but manageable, then the capitalization threshold is probably appropriate for the local unit. Assets should be identified by the identification tag affixed to the asset, the asset description compared to the capital asset records, and its physical condition assessed. Any unrecorded acquisitions, additions or improvements made since the prior annual inventory should be identified and recorded. Capital asset records should be adjusted for any assets relocated since the prior inventory. Strict control must be maintained during the inventory-taking process to assure that uninventoried items are not moved to areas previously inventoried, or vice versa. LGC Page 14 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets A. Introduction Capital assets transactions arise primarily from acquisitions and disposals. These transactions appear first in the expenditure ledger as purchases or in the revenue ledger as revenues from the disposal of capital assets. The minutes of the governing board should be inspected for any transactions not recorded in the expenditure or revenue accounts, e.g., donated assets, assets received from another government entity, or assets not otherwise recorded. After the end of each month, the capital asset transactions for the month should be journalized and recorded. It is vital that capital asset subsidiary records also be maintained and kept up-to-date. It is recommended that the subsidiary records be updated on a monthly basis as well and reconciled to the general ledger. Subsidiary records should also be updated for capital assets transferred between departments at the unit. B. Acquisition of Capital Assets Local governmental units may acquire capital assets with cash or through leases or other financing arrangements such as bonds, notes, and installment purchases. The issuance of debt and the use of obligations similar to debt are allowed for counties, cities and certain other types of local governments but may require approval of the Local Government Commission to issue the debt. Regardless of the format of payment, if the local governmental unit acquires most of the benefits and risks of ownership of an asset, the asset must be recorded as a capital asset of the appropriate fund or in the statement of net position of the local governmental unit. Accordingly, the liability incurred to acquire the property also must be recorded as a liability of the appropriate fund or in the statement of net position of the local governmental unit. 1. Installment Purchases Installment contracts that create a security interest in some or all of the property purchased to secure payment of the purchase price to one advancing moneys or supplying financing for the purchase transaction are known as “installment purchases” and are authorized by G.S. 160A-20. Installment purchases that involve the construction or repair of fixtures or improvements on real property or that meet the standards set out in G.S. 159-148 require approval by the Local Government Commission. Capital assets purchased by incurring installment obligations must be capitalized. The basis of valuation of a capital asset purchased with an installment sales agreement is the lower of the market value of the capital asset or the net present value of the sales agreement plus the closing costs and the other costs of the purchase. The net present value of the installment sales agreement must be recorded as a long-term obligation in the appropriate fund or in the statement of net position. 2. Leases The standards of financial accounting and reporting for leases by lessees and lessors are set forth in paragraphs 211 – 271 of GASB Statement No. 62. The paragraphs LGC Page 15 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets define a lease “an agreement conveying the right to use capital assets (land or other depreciable assets) usually for a stated period of time.” This policy manual will only discuss the accounting by lessees, the party receiving the use and possession of the leased property. Capital assets do not always have to be constructed or purchased outright in order to be of benefit to a local government or public authority. Capital assets may be temporarily utilized through a rental agreement, known as an operating lease. In other situations, the utilization of leased capital assets may be such that the unit has in effect purchased the asset by virtue of the length of its use of the asset, or the amount of payments it has made to use the asset. This type of lease is known as a capital lease. a. Operating Leases A lease is an operating lease if it does not transfer the benefits and risks of ownership to the local governmental unit. Operating lease payments are recognized as expenses or expenditures to the local governmental unit when they become payable. The capital assets leased through operating leases are not capitalized; however, they should be inventoried and tagged for control purposes. Even if rental payments are not made on a straight-line basis, the rental expense or expenditure is recognized on a straight-line basis unless another systematic and rational basis is more representative of the pattern in which the benefits flow from the leased property. b. Capital Leases GASB Statement No. 62, paragraph 213, codifies the definition of a capital lease as follows: “If at its inception a lease meets one or more of the following four criteria, the lease should be classified as a capital lease by the lessee. Otherwise, it should be classified as an operating lease. a. The lease transfers ownership of the property to the lessee by the end of the lease term. b. The lease contains a bargain purchase option. c. The lease term is equal to 75 percent or more of the estimated economic life of the leased property. However, if the beginning of the lease term falls within the last 25 percent of the total estimated economic life of the leased property, including earlier years of use, this criterion should not be used for purposes of classifying the lease. d. The present value at the beginning of the lease term of the minimum lease payments, excluding that portion of the payments representing executory costs such as insurance and maintenance to be paid by the lessor, including any gain thereon, equals or exceeds 90 percent of the excess of the fair value of the leased property to the lessor at the inception of the lease over any related investment tax credit retained by and expected to be realized by the lessor. However, if the beginning of the lease term falls within the last 25 percent of the total estimated economic life of the leased property, including earlier years of use, this criterion should not be used for purposes of classifying the lease. A lessor should compute the present value of the LGC Page 16 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets minimum lease payments using the interest rate implicit in the lease. A lessee should compute the present value of the minimum lease payments using its incremental borrowing rate, unless (1) it is practicable to obtain the implicit rate computed by the lessor and (2) the implicit rate computed by the lessor is less than the lessee’s incremental borrowing rate. If both of those conditions are met, the lessee should use the implicit rate.” The lessee records a capital lease as a capital asset and an obligation at an amount equal to the present value of the minimum lease payments excluding that portion representing certain costs. However, the present value as determined should not exceed the fair value of the leased property. The asset acquired under a capital lease should be amortized as follows: a. When the lease transfers ownership of the property to the lessee by the end of the lease term or contains a bargain purchase option, the asset should be amortized in a manner consistent with the lessee’s normal depreciation policy for owned assets. Because ownership is expected to pass to the lessee, the portion of the asset recorded under the capital lease representing land would not be amortized. b. Otherwise, the period of amortization should be the lease term. Lease payments are allocated between a reduction of the obligation and interest expense or expenditure at a constant periodic rate of interest on the obligation. C. Acquisition with Federal Financial Assistance The federal government issued a recompilation OMB Circular A-102 (August 29, 1997), regarding uniform standards governing the utilization and disposal of property furnished by the federal government or acquired in whole or in part with federal funds by nonfederal political subdivisions. These requirements are set out in the common rule to OMB Circular A-102. Specific capital asset management information by federal department or agency may be reviewed through the following websites: www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a102 for the recompilation of Circular A-102 as amended, and www.whitehouse.gov/omb/grants/chart.html for Codification of the Government-wide Grants Requirements by Department. The capital asset management requirements may be summarized as follows. This summary is qualified by reference to the circular and relevant common rule. 1. Capital assets acquired with federal funds are restricted to the following uses: a. Real property - Unless otherwise provided by federal statutes, real property is to be used for the originally authorized purpose as long as needed for that purpose. Local governments are not to dispose of or encumber its title or other interests. LGC Page 17 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets b. Equipment – Used as follows: (1) In the grant program for which the asset is acquired as long as there is a need for the property to accomplish the purpose of the grant program, whether or not the program continues to be supported by federal funds. (2) If the property is no longer needed in this grant program, it may be used, in the following order of priority, for other grants of the same federal agency, or grants of other federal agencies. 2. When capital assets are no longer used as originally authorized, they may be disposed of as follows: a. The property may be used for the unit's official activities: (1) With fair compensation to the federal agency based on the percentage of federal participation in the original grant program times the current fair market value, or (2) Without reimbursement to the federal agency if the property cost is less than $5,000. b. The property may be disposed of under the common rule of OMB Circular A-102. (1) When real property is no longer needed for the originally authorized purpose, the unit should request disposal instructions from the federal awarding agency. The common rule provides for retaining the property, selling it, or transferring title. Whether the property is retained by the local unit or sold, the local unit must compensate the federal agency for its percentage of participation in the cost of the original purchase times the fair market value of the property. If title to the property is transferred to the awarding agency, the local unit is compensated. (2) When original or replacement equipment (nonexpendable, tangible property) acquired under a grant is no longer needed for the original project or program or for other activities currently or previously supported by a federal agency, disposal should be made as follows: (a) Items of equipment with a current per-unit fair market value of less than $5,000 may be retained, sold, or otherwise disposed of with no further obligation to the federal awarding agency. (b) Items of equipment with a current per-unit fair market more than $5,000 may be retained or sold and the federal awarding agency shall have a right to be compensated for its share of the equipment. (3) If there is a residual inventory of unused supplies exceeding $5,000 in total aggregate fair market value upon termination or completion of the award, and if the supplies are not needed for any other federally-sponsored programs or projects, the local government shall compensate the federal awarding agency for its share. LGC Page 18 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets 3. In addition, the common rule specifies that the grantee's property records shall include the following data: a. Complete description of property, including serial numbers, location, use, and the condition of the property. b. Acquisition date and cost, the purpose for which acquired, name in which title is held, and the source and amount of federal participation in the cost. c. Complete information on the disposition of the property including date of disposal and sales price of the property. d. A physical inventory at least every two years verifying the existence and current use of the property. e. A control system to prevent the loss, damage, or theft of the property. 4. Additional procedures must ensure that maintenance is adequate, usage is permissible as originally authorized or as otherwise authorized under law, and unauthorized dispositions are not made. Units must review and understand the detailed grant requirements and common rule applicable to the specific grant. Any unusual problems encountered or clarifications needed should be discussed with the federal granting agency or if the grant is a pass-through grant, through the applicable State agency. Units should review the tools related to procurement with federal grants available on the School of Government’s Local Government Purchasing and Contracting website, www.ncpurchasing.unc.edu. The documents “14 Key Steps to Federal Grant Compliance” and the “Local Government Guide to Procurement with Federal Grant Funding” are recommended. D. Disposals of Capital Assets Under the North Carolina Constitution, it is generally required that a local government must dispose of property for no less than its fair market value. The disposal of a piece of equipment that still has significant value to a local unit should be closely reviewed to ensure that such actions are accomplishing a public purpose. A gift of property or a sale at well below market value constitutes the granting of an "exclusive privilege or emolument" to the person receiving the property, which is prohibited by Article 1, Section 32, of the Constitution. Most of the procedures by which a local government is permitted to sell or otherwise dispose of property are competitive, and the North Carolina Supreme Court has indicated that the price resulting from an open and competitive procedure will normally be considered appropriate unless strong evidence indicates that it is so significantly below market value as to show an abuse of discretion. It is not always constitutionally necessary that a local government receive any monetary consideration when it conveys property. A conveyance requiring the receiving party to put the capital asset to continued public use constitutes sufficient consideration for the conveyance. The receiver in this case is usually, but not always, another government or a nonprofit organization. The following statutory references are authority for municipalities. For counties, G.S. 153A-176 refers to G.S. 160A, Article 12 giving counties the same authority to dispose LGC Page 19 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets of property as municipalities. G.S. 115C-518(a) also incorporates G.S. 160A, Article 12 as the primary disposal methods for local boards of education. Local boards of education have additional flexibility in granting easements to local utility companies, but are constitutionally prohibited from donating property. Before a department in a governmental unit disposes of any real or personal property, notice should be circulated to other departments that the property is considered surplus. A quick reference guide to the procedures for disposal of surplus property and templates for resolutions and notices required for the various property disposal methods discussed above are available on the School of Government's Local Government Purchasing and Contracting website, www.ncpurchasing.unc.edu. Article 12 of G.S. Chapter 160A governs the disposal of real and personal property. Unless otherwise authorized by statute, local governments must dispose of real and personal property by competitive sale. G.S. 160A-266(a) sets out three competitive methods of sale, each of which is appropriate in any circumstance: sealed bid; negotiated offer and upset bid; and public auction. Two other categories of disposal methods are also authorized under this statute: private negotiation and sale (meaning a non-competitive sale directly to an individual buyer), and exchange (exchanging property for other property). In all instances, the procedural requirements of the property disposal statutes must be followed exactly or the transaction risks invalidation by a court. The procedural requirements for these various methods of disposal are outlined below. 1. Competitive Sale a. Advertisement for Sealed Bids (G.S. 160A -268) (1) The same rules apply as for advertising purchase contracts in the formal bidding range (G.S. 143-129; see Purchasing Policy, Section 30, in this Policies Manual). If the property being advertised is personal property, publication of the advertisement must occur seven (7) full days prior to the bid opening. If the property being advertised is real property, the advertisement must occur 30 days prior to the bid opening. (2) An advertisement for sealed bids must be published in a newspaper that has general circulation in the local government's jurisdiction. (3) The advertisement should generally describe the property, tell where it can be examined and when and where the bids will be opened, and reserve the board's right to reject any and all bids. (4) Bids must be opened in public and be recorded in the board's minutes. (5) The award is made to the highest bidder. b. Negotiated Offer, Advertisement, and Upset Bids (1) The governing body may solicit or receive an offer to purchase property. (2) The offeror must make a deposit of 5% of the amount offered to be considered by the governing board. (3) The offer Upon accepting the offer and receipt of the 5% deposit, the local government must publish notice of the offer. The advertisement must include a description of the property, the amount and terms of the offer, and a notice that LGC Page 20 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets within 10 days any person may raise the bid by not less than ten percent (10%) of the first one thousand dollars ($1,000) and five percent (5%) of the remainder. (4) If a qualifying upset bid is received, steps b. and c. must be repeated until no further qualifying upset bids are received. (5) The governing board may then award the contract to the last qualifying upset bidder. c. Public Auction (1) The governing body must pass a resolution authorizing the sale; describing the property to be sold; and specifying the date, time, place, and terms of sale. (2) Notice of the sale of real property must be published once at least 30 days before the auction. For personal property only, the notice must be published at least 10 days before the auction. (3) High bids received at auction for real property must be reported to the governing body and accepted or rejected within 30 days. High bids received at auction for personal property may be accepted by an appropriate official or employee authorized by the governing board to dispose of the property at auction. (4) If the bids are rejected, the property may be readvertised for sale. (5) The resolution adopted by the governing board authorizing the auction may require the highest bidder to make a bid deposit in an amount specified in the resolution. 2. Private Negotiation and Sale a. Small item disposal: G.S. 160A-266(b) and (c) authorize local governments to dispose of personal property (one item or a group of similar items) valued at less than $30,000 (“small items”) by private negotiation and sale. The governing body must pass a resolution authorizing the sale and then a notice summarizing the contents of the resolution must be published once after passage. The sale cannot be consummated until ten days after publication of the resolution. The governing board may adopt a policy delegating its authority to conduct private negotiation and sale of small items to an individual official or employee. The regulations may, but need not, require published notice. b. Significant properties: G.S. 160A-266(b) authorizes the private negotiation and sale of real or personal properties with certain architectural, archaeological, artistic, cultural or historical significance to a nonprofit corporation or trust whose purposes include the preservation or conservation of real or personal property. c. Conveyance to another unit of government: G.S. 160A-274 authorizes governmental units to convey any interest in real or personal property to another governmental unit with or without consideration LGC Page 21 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets under any terms and conditions “deemed wise” by the conveying unit. The conveyance must be approved by the governing board disposing of the property. d. Conveyance to volunteer fire departments and rescue squads: G.S. 160A-277 provides that a local government may lease, sell, or convey, with or without monetary consideration, land or interest in land to a volunteer fire department or to a volunteer rescue squad for the purpose of constructing or expanding volunteer fire department or rescue squad facilities. e. Conveyance to private entity for public purpose: G.S. 160A-279(a) provides that "whenever a city or county is authorized to appropriate funds to any public or private entity which carries out a public purpose, the city or county may, in lieu of or in addition to the appropriation of funds, convey by private sale to such an entity any real or personal property which it owns...." The consideration for this type of private sale is the continued public use of the property after it has been conveyed. f. Donation of personal property: G.S. 160A-280 authorizes a city or county (but no other unit of local government) to donate personal property (but not real property) to another governmental unit within the United States, a nonprofit organization, or a sister city. It is important to note that school boards are constitutionally prohibited from conveying real or personal property without monetary consideration. g. Other private sales Other private sales are authorized in very specific instances, including for economic development (G.S. 158-7.1(d)); community development (G.S. 160A-457-this method is available only for cities); affordable housing (G.S. 153A-378 for counties and G.S. 160A-456(b)); and sale of a city-owned enterprise (G.S. 160A-321). 3. Exchange Privately negotiated exchanges of property are also permitted in any circumstance so long as equal value changes hands and Under G.S. 160A-271, a local government may exchange real or personal property for other real or personal property if it receives full and fair consideration for the property exchanged. The governing board must authorize the exchange at a regular meeting. Notice of intent to make the exchange must be published at least ten days before the exchange occurs. The notice must describe the properties involves; give the value of each, as well as the value of other consideration changing hands; and cite the date of the regular meeting at which the board proposes to approve the exchange. E. Impairment of Capital Assets GASB Statement No. 42 defines impairment as “a significant, unexpected decline in the service utility of a capital asset.” A two-step process which includes identifying potential impairments and testing for impairment is necessary to determine if an asset is impaired. LGC Page 22 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets A capital asset should be tested for impairment when any one of the following triggering events happens: Decline in market value of the capital asset; Change in the way the capital asset is used or physical change in asset; Adverse changes in legal factors or business climate; Accumulated cost in excess of amounts originally expected to construct or acquire asset; Current expectation that, more likely than not, a long lived asset will be sold or disposed of significantly before the end of its previously estimated useful life; Current period losses with history of operating or cash flow losses associated with asset. The finance officer should be alert for the existence of any of the indicators of impairment or triggering events that indicate that an asset should be subject to the impairment test. The impairment test determines if both of the following two factors are present: The magnitude of the decline in service utility is significant; and The decline in service utility is unexpected. If it is determined that a significant, unexpected decline in serve utility of an asset has occurred, the impairment – amount by which cost is to be written down – must be measured. The methods to measure the impairment include the restoration cost approach, the service units approach and the deflated depreciation replacement cost approach. The approach select depends on the reason for the impairment and whether or not the asset will continue in use. Unless evidence indicates that the impairment is temporary, the impairment loss should be reported in the statement of activities and, if appropriate, in the statement of revenues, expenses and changes net fund assets. If circumstances causing the impairment have changed, the impairment loss should not be reversed in subsequent years. The financial reporting and disclosures required for an impairment of capital assets are illustrated in the sample financial statements for the City of Dogwood. LGC Page 23 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part III – Accounting for Capital Assets This page intentionally left blank. LGC Page 24 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part IV – Internal Control and Financial Reporting A. Introduction All assets must be physically identified and tagged, their location recorded and the responsibility for their custody assigned. A control number should be assigned to each asset. It is suggested that the control number system be designed in such a manner that, at a minimum, the control numbers relate to the chart of account numbers for the asset class. Furthermore, control numbers should include identifiers that indicate the location, department or other significant information about the asset. This will facilitate controlling assets by asset classification as well as location and manager assigned responsibility for custody of the asset. Additionally, it should be noted that GASB Statement No. 34 requires that “(d)epreciation expense for capital assets that can specifically be identified with a function should be included in its direct expenses.” It will also facilitate the physical inventory of the capital assets. Control numbers should be carefully designed to meet all these purposes. For internal control, capital assets such as buildings, improvements other than to buildings, and land are assigned appropriate capital assets control numbers in the accounting records but are not physically tagged. Asset control for financial reporting purposes should not be confused with safeguarding the assets. A local government unit may purchase many different items in order to meet the needs of the citizenry. In some local units, the cost of pistols, shotguns and other weapons used by the law enforcement officers may be below the capitalization threshold. While they may not be capitalized and depreciated on the financial records, law enforcement officials must ensure that all weapons are accounted for and strictly controlled. Similarly, the public grounds department should routinely inventory all the lawn mowers and weed trimmers. By their portable nature, this equipment may easily be misappropriated. B. Internal Control Over Capital Assets It is essential that all capital assets be adequately controlled to prevent misuse. Critical internal control procedures for capital asset management include the following: LGC Adequate accounting records should be maintained that identify and classify all capital assets. OMB Circular A-102 and the common rule specify the data that the grantee's property records shall include for capital assets acquired with federal funds. Adequate guidelines should be established and followed to distinguish between expensed items and capital additions; items acquired with federal or state funds as well as other special revenue purchased items; and betterments or improvements to assets. Physical inventories of capital assets should be taken on an annual basis by independent parties. Inventory counts should be taken "from scratch" – not using the previous year's count lists. Count sheets should be initialed by the person(s) taking the inventory. The count should be reconciled to the accounting records, with written evidence of the reconciliation maintained. In small units, the inventory should be taken Page 25 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part IV – Internal Control and Financial Reporting by a board member if there is only one accounting or finance staff member. If there are two accounting or finance staff members, the finance officer may take the inventory. All capital assets should be tagged or identified in the accounting records by a control number, as applicable. Tags should be prenumbered, with all numbers accounted for, and should identify the assets as belonging to the unit. Tags should be affixed in a permanent manner. All property, buildings, titled equipment and vehicles, and other items should be held in the name of the unit. All deeds on real property should be properly recorded and stored in a secure place. All capital assets purchased, transferred, sold, scrapped, or destroyed should be recorded as such in a timely manner in the accounting system. This facilitates proper valuing of assets and helps to prevent loss or misuse. All sales of surplus property should be conducted in accordance with G.S. Chapter 160A, Article 12 (municipalities) or G.S. 153A-176 (counties). Capital assets records are often used to help determine adequate insurance coverage on all real and personal property. An independent review of insurance coverage should be conducted at least every three years. Adequate procedures should be in place to assure compliance with the uniform standards governing the utilization and disposal of property furnished by the federal government or acquired in whole or in part with federal funds by nonfederal political subdivisions set out in the common rule to OMB Circular A-102. See the Policy Manual for Local Governments, Section 80 – Internal Controls for an additional discussion of policies and procedures related to internal control. C. Financial Reporting Considerations For audited financial statement purposes, additions to capital assets and the related financial liabilities must be disclosed in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. Capital assets that are being or have been depreciated are reported net of accumulated depreciation in the statement of net position with related accumulated depreciation reported on the face of the statement or disclosed in the notes. Greater detail may be provided in reporting capital assets, such as by major class of asset, e.g. infrastructure, buildings and improvements, vehicles, machinery and equipment, etc. Governments should disclose information about their works of art and historical collections as required by GASB Statement 34, paragraph 118. The standards of financial accounting and reporting for leases by lessees are set forth in paragraphs 211 – 271 of GASB Statement No. 62. GASB Statement 34, paragraph 117 contains the following disclosure requirements for capital assets and depreciation: 1. Beginning and end of year balances, with accumulated depreciation separately presented from historical cost, 2. Capital acquisitions, 3. Sales or other dispositions, and LGC Page 26 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part IV – Internal Control and Financial Reporting 4. Current-period depreciation expense, with disclosure of the amounts charged to each of the functions in the statement of activities. Detail information should be included in the notes to the financial statements about capital assets of the primary government reported in the statement of net position. The disclosure should be divided into major classes of capital assets as well as between those associated with governmental activities and those associated with business-type activities. Furthermore, nondepreciable capital assets, such as land or infrastructure assets reported using the modified approach, should be disclosed separately from those that are being depreciated. Additionally, the notes should include disclosure regarding the policy for capitalizing assets and for estimating the useful lives of those assets. The unit's accounting policy on capitalization of interest costs incurred during construction should be disclosed and applied consistently. In a period in which some interest is capitalized, the disclosure should include both the amount of interest incurred during the period as well as the amount of interest cost that has been capitalized. Units electing the modified approach for reporting eligible infrastructure assets should describe their approach. Currently, the LGC staff is recommending against the use of the modified approach. According to paragraph 5 of GASB Statement No. 51, all intangible assets subject to this Statement should be classified as capital assets and disclosed as such. Intangible assets should be grouped with those of a similar nature and usage (i.e., right-of-way easements, water rights, and software.) The component of net position – net investment in capital assets – includes capital assets, net of accumulated depreciation and reduced by the outstanding balances of any bonds, mortgages, notes, or other borrowings that are attributable to the acquisition, construction, or improvement of those assets. Interfund borrowings are not considered to be capitalrelated for purposes of this calculation. An Excel© worksheet is provided to assist in the calculation of net investment in capital assets and is available at www.nctreasurer.com. LGC Page 27 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part IV – Internal Control and Financial Reporting This page intentionally left blank. LGC Page 28 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization A. Introduction Depreciation is the allocation of the cost of capital assets over their estimated useful lives in a rational and systematic way. The allocation of the cost over the estimated useful lives of intangible assets is known as amortization. Unless otherwise indicated, the term depreciation expense will be used to include both depreciation and amortization. Capital assets that are inexhaustible, such as land and land improvements, or are infrastructure assets reported using the modified approach should not be depreciated. Depreciation should begin when a capital asset is placed in service. Because costs reported as construction in progress represent assets that have not been placed in service, they are not depreciable until the underlying assets are placed in service. Infrastructure assets that are not required to be depreciated must meet two conditions: they are managed under a system having certain characteristics and are being preserved approximately at an established level of condition. 1. Governmental Funds Depreciation is an accrual basis of accounting concept and therefore is not an expenditure, a modified accrual basis of accounting concept. Depreciation is not recorded in the governmental funds. For governmental funds, inflows and outflows of current financial resources is the measurement focus. However, depreciation expense is recorded on the government-wide statement of activities for governmental units. Depreciation of general capital assets should be recorded in the accounts of the government-wide statement of activities. Governmental funds (the General Fund, Special Revenue Funds, Capital Projects Funds, and Debt Service Funds) measure inflows and outflows of financial resources. Since depreciation expense is neither an inflow nor an outflow of governmental fund financial resources, it is not recorded in the accounts of such funds. While depreciation is not recorded in the accounts of governmental funds, it should be calculated for cost finding purposes such as analyzing costs associated with vehicle operation, garbage collection, and data processing services. Besides these routine activities, calculating depreciation can be of benefit for determining reimbursable costs under grant provisions and for establishing fee schedules. It also can assist the governmental unit in "make or buy" or "do or contract for" decisions. Finally, accumulated depreciation related to general capital assets must be recorded in the statement of net position. When recorded, the entry for depreciation expense increases the Accumulated Depreciation account(s) and decrease the Investment in General Capital assets account(s). 2. Proprietary Funds Depreciation and amortization expense is recorded in the proprietary funds as it is an important element in the income determination process. Accordingly, depreciation of capital assets in a proprietary fund is recorded in the accounts of that fund. Proprietary funds include enterprise funds and internal service funds. Depreciation also is LGC Page 29 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization recognized in those trust funds where expenses and net income, or capital maintenance are measured, although this is rare. Proprietary funds are used to account for a governmental unit's operations and activities that should be self-supporting similar to private sector activities. The generally accepted accounting principles applicable to proprietary funds are the same as those applicable to comparable private sector enterprises. Inflows and outflows of economic resources is the measurement focus applicable to the statement of activities. The accrual basis of accounting is used. Two fund types are classified as proprietary funds: Enterprise funds which are used to account for operations or activities that are financed and operated like a private business enterprise for which the governing body intends that costs (including depreciation) of providing goods or services to the public on a continuing basis be financed or recovered primarily through user charges, or for which the governing body has decided that periodic determination of revenues earned, expenses incurred, and net income is appropriate for capital maintenance, public policy, management control, accountability, or other purposes. Water treatment and distribution, wastewater collection and processing, and electric operations are examples of activities accounted for in enterprise funds. Internal service funds are used to account for the financing of goods or services provided by one department or agency to other departments or agencies of the governmental unit, or to other governmental units, on a cost-reimbursement basis. Examples of activities frequently accounted for as Internal Service Funds are data processing centers, motor pools, and central office supply activities. Proprietary fund capital assets are capitalized in the fund accounts because the capital assets are used in the production of goods or services provided and sold. Depreciation of these capital assets must be recorded to determine total expenses, net income, and changes in fund equity. B. Depreciation and Amortization Considerations GASB Statement 34 at paragraph 22 provides that “Depreciation expense should be measured by allocating the net cost of depreciable assets (historical cost less estimated salvage value) over their estimated useful lives in a systematic and rational manner. It may be calculated for (a) a class of assets, (b) a network of assets, (c) a subsystem of a network, or (d) individual assets. (Composite methods may be used to calculate depreciation expense ….)” Depreciation is an element of expense resulting from the use of long-lived assets. It is conventionally measured by allocating the expected net cost of using the asset (original cost less estimated salvage value) over its estimated useful life in a systematic and rational manner. The objective of depreciation is to charge each accounting period for the estimated loss in economic value of the depreciable assets used during the period. Depreciation expense is a function of the cost of the asset, its expected salvage value, the estimate of the economic useful life, and the depreciation method selected. The depreciation method determines the rate at which the economic value of the asset will be consumed during its expected life. LGC Page 30 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization 1. Estimated Useful Life In estimating the economic useful life of an asset, consideration has to be given to: The physical environment in which the asset is to be used, (hot, cold, caustic, dry, moist, pressure vacuum, etc.); the physical characteristics of use (continuous, intermittent, fixed or portable, stable or alternating); and the operating conditions of weight, force, and friction to be encountered. Physical resilience or ability to sustain full utility and value with minor repetitive maintenance, as opposed to material progressive deterioration with use, irrespective of continuing maintenance. Obsolescence potential –which is defined as susceptibility to economic loss of value because of technological, fashion, or other changes that reduce an asset's relative economic suitability for its intended purposes. For additional information, see the GFOA Best Practice, “Establishing the Estimated Useful Lives of Capital Assets” 2. Expected Salvage Value The salvage or residual value is the estimated value each asset will have after it is no longer used by the government in its operations. An asset's salvage value is an estimate of the proceeds from disposal of the asset less the cost of disposal. The same factors that influence the determination of the life of a capital asset affect its salvage value. C. Reporting Depreciation GASB Statement No. 34 provides that for capital assets that can specifically be identified with a function, the depreciation expense should be included in its direct expenses. If the capital assets are used for more than one function, the depreciation expense should be allocated to the direct expenses of the various functions on a rational basis. Depreciation expense for capital assets such as a city hall or a state office building that essentially serves all functions is not required to be included in the direct expenses of the various functions. The depreciation expense for a facility that serves essentially all functions may be included as a separate line in the statement of activities or as part of the "general government". However, if unallocated depreciation expense is presented as a line item on the statement of activities, it must be disclosed that this line item excludes direct depreciation expense included in the various programs. However, for general infrastructure assets, depreciation should not be allocated to the various functions but is reported in the statement of activities as a direct expense of the function associated with capital outlays for and maintenance of infrastructure assets, or reported as a separate line item. D. Amortization of Intangible Assets Paragraph 16 of Statement No. 51 provides that “the useful life of an intangible asset that arises from contractual or other legal rights should not exceed the period to which the service capacity of the asset is limited by contractual or legal provisions.” In determining the useful life, renewal periods may be considered when there is evidence that the government will seek and be able to achieve renewal. LGC Page 31 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization Paragraph 17 of Statement No. 51 also states “an intangible asset should be considered to have an indefinite life if there are no legal, contractual, regulatory, technological or other factors that limit the useful life of an asset” (i.e., a permanent right-of-way easement). Intangible assets determined to have an indefinite life should not be amortized. However, if changes occur such that an asset no longer has an indefinite useful life, the asset should be evaluated for impairment. After any adjustment for impairment is recorded, the remaining value should be amortized over the remaining useful life of the asset. Changes in duration of use, change in term or status of contract, evidence of obsolescence, enactment or approval of laws or regulations or other changes in environmental factors, and development stoppage are indicators of impairment in addition to physical damage. Refer to paragraph 9 of GASB Statement No. 42 for more information in regards to accounting for impairments. E. Selection of a Depreciation Method Theoretically, a depreciation method should be selected that achieves the most realistic reflection of the loss in economic value of the assets being used or, for cost accounting purposes, that allocates a reasonable portion of the cost of an asset to the revenue produced (per unit of production or per unit of time). Depreciation methods available to local governmental units include the following: 1. Straight-Line Depreciation Method – This method produces a uniform rate per year over the useful life in years for the asset. This is the most common method of depreciation used by units of government. It is discussed and illustrated in the next section. 2. Units of Production Method – A uniform rate of depreciation per unit of output is determined and applied over the useful life of the asset. Unit of production might be miles driven, hours flown, etc. It is similar to the straight-line method except that the life is expressed in units of production and the periodic depreciation charge is the rate per unit times the number of units consumed. 3. Accelerated Depreciation Methods – These methods generate decreasing charges for depreciation expense over the useful life of the asset, i.e. the asset is depreciated at an accelerated rate in the early years of its life. The declining balance and the sum-of-theyears digits’ are accelerated depreciation methods. These methods may be appropriate where rapid obsolescence is expected. 4. Other Depreciation Methodologies – Group or composite depreciation methods were designed to usually simplify the clerical process of calculating depreciation expense by depreciating assets collectively, not individually. These methods create a collection of assets that are treated as a single asset for the calculation of depreciation. Group depreciation creates a collection of similar assets; composite depreciation creates a collection of dissimilar assets. The need for internal control over capital assets combined with advances in computer software has reduced the cost reduction potential of the methods. Accelerated, group and composite depreciation methods are not discussed in the manual. Information describing and illustrating the methods can be found in accounting text books. LGC Page 32 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization F. Straight-line Depreciation 1. Computation This method is simple to apply and will provide satisfactory results where the useful life and salvage value of an asset can be estimated with a reasonable degree of accuracy. Because of its simplicity, it is the most widely used method by local governments. Using the straight-line method of depreciation, the cost or other basis of the asset, less the estimated salvage value, is divided by the number of years of useful life to arrive at an annual depreciation charge. The formula for the calculation of straight-line depreciation is as follows: Annual Asset Cost – Estimated Salvage alue seful Life (in years) epreciation 2. Illustration A depreciable asset is acquired and placed is service on December 5, 20x0 costing $85,400. The asset has an expected life of 8 years and an estimated salvage value of $1,400. The annual depreciation expense would be calculated as follows: Annual epreciation $8 ,400 – $1,400 8 years $10, 00 per year The depreciation expense for this asset for the fiscal year ended June 30, 20x1 would be $6,125 for the 7 months from December through June at $875 per month the asset was in service. For the fiscal year ended June 30, 20x2 the depreciation expense would be $10,500. The depreciation expense over the life of the asset is as follows: Years Ended June 30 Depreciation Expense 20x1 20x2 20x3 20x4 20x5 20x6 20x7 20x8 20x9 $ 6,125 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,500 4,375 Accumulated Depreciation Book Value $ 6,125 16,625 27,125 37,625 48,125 58,625 69,125 79,625 84,000 $ 79,275 68,775 58,275 47,775 37,275 26,775 16,275 5,775 1,400 G. Composite Depreciation Composite depreciation can be utilized with heterogeneous assets, which may have similar characteristics or purposes. The assets are combined in one asset account and depreciated accordingly. No gain or loss is normally recognized except in extraordinary circumstances. LGC Page 33 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part V – Depreciation and Amortization For example, assume the following assets are placed in service: Asset A Cost $30,000 Salvage Value $6,000 Useful Life 10 years Annual Depreciation $2,400 B 20,000 3,600 4 years 4,100 C 10,000 --- 4 years 2,500 Total $60,000 $9,600 $9,000 Using straight-line depreciation, the composite depreciation rate is computed as follows: Depreciation Rate = Total Annual epreciation Total Cost = Depreciation is then charged at 15% of the cost of assets in service at that time until book value equals the estimated salvage value of $9,600. Additional assets may be included by adding their cost to the asset amount and determining a new composite depreciation rate. LGC Page 34 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part VI – Suggested Reading UNC School of Government Publications Kara A. Millonzi, Introduction to Local Government Finance in North Carolina, Second Edition, 2014. David M. Lawrence, Local Government Property Transactions in North Carolina, Second Edition, 2000 Jack Vogt, Justin Marlowe, William C. Rivenbark, Capital Budgeting and Finance, A Guide for Local Governments, Second Edition, 2009. David M. Lawrence, Financing Capital Projects in North Carolina, Second Edition, 1994. Frayda Bluestein, A Legal Guide to Purchasing and Contracting for North Carolina Local Governments, 2004 Edition with 2007 Supplement. Various blog posts, Coates' Canons: NC Local Government Law Blog. OMB Circular A-102, Grants and Cooperative Agreements With State and Local Governments. Revised August 29, 1997. Codification of Governmentwide Grants Requirements by Department. GFOA, Best Practices, www.gfoa.org “Capital Planning Policies” (September 2013) “Capital Asset Assessment, Maintenance and Replacement Policy” (2010) “Asset Maintenance and Replacement” (March 2010) “Role of the Finance irector in Capital Asset Management” (October 2011) “Establishing Appropriate Capitalization Thresholds for Capital Assets” (2006) “Ensuring Control over Noncapitalized Items” (200 ) “Establishing the Estimated Useful Lives of Capital Assets” (2010) Governmental and Nonprofit Accounting (Tenth Edition), Freeman, Shoulders, Allison, Patton, Smith, Prentice Hall, 2012. Governmental Accounting, Auditing, and Financial Reporting, GFOA, Stephen J. Gauthier. Accounting for Capital Assets: A Guide for State and Local Governments, GFOA, Stephen J. Gauthier, 2008. Audit & Accounting Guide: State and Local Government, AICPA, March 1, 2013, Chapter 7. LGC Page 35 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014 Department of State Treasurer – Policy Manual for Local Governments Section 20: Capital Assets Part VI – Suggested Reading This page intentionally left blank. End of Section 20: Capital Assets LGC Page 36 of 36 Pages. Revision Issued: August 2014