Exploring intercultural misunderstandings Topic 1: Why do cultural misunderstandings happen? 3 Topic 2: Areas of misunderstanding 7 Polite forms of language 7 Idioms 8 Questions 9 Compliments 11 Dress 11 Social customs 13 Space 14 Time 14 Topic 3: Cultural behaviours 21 Topic 4: Stereotyping and prejudice 23 Topic 5: Communicating with government organisations 25 Summary 26 Check your answers 27 Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 1 Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 2 Topic 1: Why do cultural misunderstandings happen? There may be many cultural differences between people that can cause misunderstandings Cultural misunderstandings can occur when people don’t share or understand the ‘rules’ of a particular culture. The ‘rules’ of how you behave are to do with what people expect you to do in certain situations. People can learn the rules of a new culture by watching people and through asking questions. It is cultural values that lead to expectations and ‘rules’ about how people behave. Activity 1: What is culture? Let’s remind ourselves of what we mean by culture. Read the following extract which is the first part of a lecture about intercultural communication, by Paul Kettering. Then answer the questions that follow, to make sure you’ve understood what was said. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 3 The following extract is the first part of a lecture about intercultural communication, by Paul Kettering. Good evening Ladies and Gentlemen. My name is Paul Kettering. Tonight you’re going to hear about some of the ways that cultures and, therefore, languages are different from each other. As the first speaker tonight, I’m going to give you a brief introduction to this evening’s topic. Before I do though, I’d like to clarify the link between language and culture. When we talk about culture we mean a lot of different things. We mean more than just the food we eat and the clothes we wear. These are just the obvious things. Culture also means traditions, ways of thinking, ways of looking at the world, values and many other things. These are the less obvious things. Culture is like an iceberg. The obvious things are above the surface like the food we eat and the clothes we wear. We can’t actually see the other things like traditions, ways of thinking, ways of looking at the world, and values. Language, of course, is a very important part of a culture and some people consider that every different language represents a different culture. When we speak our first language—the first language we learn as children at home from our parents—we feel comfortable. We don’t have to think about what to say or how to say something, we just do it. We know how to do it. Now, many of you have studied languages apart from your first language. It’s not the same when we learn another language. It’s not that easy. Of course, there are many stages in learning languages. At the beginning when we first start learning a language we usually learn a few words. Gradually we learn more words, some grammar and how to do things like listening and speaking. Even when we are very proficient in another language, when we can speak and understand it very well, it’s not very common to feel really comfortable with that language. Well, why is it that we feel comfortable with our own language but don’t feel as comfortable with a second language and a third language and so on. The answer to this lies in the rules of communication. There is a lot more to learning a language than just vocabulary, grammar and pronunciation. Of course, these things are very important, but, each language has it’s own rules, the conventions of communication. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 4 We feel okay speaking our first language because we know the rules of communication. We learnt the rules of our first language unconsciously from our parents when we learnt the language itself. Just like the old song: ‘It’s not what you do but the way that you do it, It’s not just what you say but the way that you say it.’ Communicating in any language is like playing a game. Every game has rules and if we want to play we have to understand the rules. If we don’t know the rules of the game we can’t play very well. Here’s one example. In English it’s very important to look at the person you’re talking to—to make eye contact with that person. Otherwise, you might be considered rude. That’s what we do. It’s the convention if we want to show the person speaking that we are listening and are interested in what they are saying. In some cultures, it’s just the opposite. People would think that you’re rude if you look the person in the eye. Many people whose first language isn’t English often have trouble communicating because they don’t know the script. They don’t know the conventions we use in English. You might ask, ‘why do we need these rules?’ The rules are very important. They are about being understood not misunderstood, about communicating not miscommunicating, and about not offending the people we’re communicating with. Questions Answer these questions based on the extract. Choose the correct answer by ticking the box next to the statement you agree with. 1 2 Culture is defined as: Just the food we eat and the clothes we wear. A combination of the obvious things like food and clothes, and the less obvious things like how we look at the world. Something that does not include language. We mostly learn our first language: From TV. At school from our teachers. At home with our parents. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 5 3 4 5 6 7 8 When we speak our first language: We feel uncomfortable. We do not have to think about what to say. We do not need to learn any rules about communicating in that language. We feel OK speaking our first language because: We know the rules of communicating in that language. Our parents taught us. We studied hard. When we learn a second language: It is not common to feel really comfortable with speaking it. We often feel very comfortable speaking it. It is easier to learn the rules of communicating in a second language. When communicating in English: If we do not make eye contact we show we are interested in what someone is saying. It is rude not to make eye contact. It is rude to make eye contact. Many people whose first language is not English: Often have trouble communicating because they know the conventions so well. Often have trouble communicating because they do not know the conventions as well as a native speaker. Are understood well because they know the right words. Aboriginal students speak English so do not have the same problems as children from a non-English speaking background. True False Please comment____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________ Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 6 Topic 2: Areas of misunderstanding Now we are going to look at nine common areas of misunderstanding across cultures: Polite forms of language Idioms Questions Compliments Dress Social customs Responding to good and bad news Space Time. Polite forms of language In English when we ask people to do something, we don’t usually use the direct imperative form (an order). For example: Close the window! If we ask someone to close a window, we might say: Would you mind closing the window? Could you please close the window? Can we close the window? Do you mind if I close the window? Close the window please. We usually soften the language or use idioms. This makes the request more indirect. How would you ask someone to close a window in your language? Do you use a more direct form of language? Sometimes people with limited English language skills may translate a request or an expression literally from their native language. This might appear as a direct or imperative form. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 7 Activity 2: Giving instructions politely Lily and Freda work together in an office. Although they are friends, Freda thinks Lily is sometimes quite rude, especially when she gives her instructions. Here are two examples of instructions. For each one, tick the version that you think is the most polite way to give the instruction. Instruction 1: Give me Mrs Jacob’s file. Could you please give me Mrs Jacob’s file? Instruction 2: Take this package up to Grace on level 4. Can you take this package up to Grace on level 4? Thanks. Check your answer at the end of the unit. Idioms Slang and colloquial language is very hard to learn and may cause misunderstandings across cultures. Colloquial language is everyday language that people speak at home or with their friends. It is informal and often includes slang. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 8 Activity 3: Australian slang Check your understanding of some common Australian slang or colloquial language. Complete the table by writing in the meaning of each of the colloquial expressions. Choose the meanings from one of these possible answers: I agree Please wait Don’t worry Correct Goodbye Made a mistake Lazy person Well done Slang Meaning Good on you mate Hang on Stuffed up Hooroo Righteo Can you think of some expressions that are used by the Aboriginal community that may not be widely understood by other Australians. _______________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________ Questions People ask different sorts of questions in different cultures. What may seem polite in one culture may be impolite in another culture. Some Australians may think it’s impolite to discuss money, age, religion, politics, their weight etc. Sometimes new immigrants may ask questions about things that local people take for granted. This might cause discomfort and may lead to misunderstanding. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 9 Activity 4: Asking questions Part A Think about the following two questions and write down your answers here. 1 Are there any topics in your culture that are impolite to discuss with people you don’t know very well? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ 2 What are some good topics to talk about when meeting someone for the first time? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ There are no right or wrong answers to these questions, but you could share your responses with a friend or peer student you may be in contact with. Part B Erica has been working at a clothing factory for about a week. Which of the following questions would be appropriate for her to ask if she was talking to her supervisor? Tick the box next to the appropriate questions. How long have you been working here? Do you enjoy your job? What do you earn? Do you have any children? Check your answer to Part B at the end of the unit. Remember that when asking questions, if you don’t understand something then ask the person to repeat the information or to explain it again. It’s okay to say that you don’t understand. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 10 Compliments We give and receive compliments differently in different cultures. In some cultures a student would deny a teacher’s compliment by looking down to show modesty. The teacher however, expects the student to be pleased and show this by smiling and saying ‘thank you’. Activity 5: A compliment gone wrong Maria teaches computer studies at TAFE. She compliments one of her students for doing well in his assignment. The student looks embarrassed, however. He looks down and says ‘Oh no. I did it very badly.’ Why do you think the student reacted like this? What do you think the teacher would think? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Check your answer at the end of the unit. Dress People have different expectations of what is appropriate (right) dress in various situations, based on their cultural experience. In some cultures, public servants (people who work in government offices) dress formally (suit and tie), whereas in Australia they might dress more informally (in jeans, for example) which can seem in some cultures as a lack of pride and taste. Activity 6: What is appropriate dress? What is appropriate dress for men and women in each of the following situations — in Australia, and (if you are a migrant to Australia) in your country? Fill in the following table. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 11 Situation Appropriate dress in Australia? Appropriate dress in your birth country? Working in an office Working in a factory At the football At the beach Visiting a bank or government department Teaching at a school, TAFE or university Attending a barbecue Around the house Visiting a friend’s house Attending a job interview Attending a wedding Attending church or other place of worship Compare your responses with those of a fellow student you may be in contact with, or a friend. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 12 Social customs Social customs (the way people behave in social situations) may seem unusual in a new country. In Australia, if someone invites you to a party and asks you to bring a plate, this means bring some food to share. If an invitation says BYO, this usually means Bring Your Own Alcohol — beer or wine. If you are at a pub (hotel) with friends and someone says, ‘It’s your shout’, this means it’s your turn to buy the drinks for everyone. Responding to good and bad news Misunderstandings sometimes happen when people respond to good or bad news by using inappropriate responses or body language. Activity 7: Responding to bad news Anne’s father has just died. When she returns to work, one of her workmates, on hearing the news, shakes her hand. Why might this cause misunderstanding? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Check your answer at the end of the unit. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 13 Space Personal space is the distance that feels comfortable between people when they meet and talk. The distance varies depending on the relationship between people, how well they know each other. It also varies from culture to culture. Activity 8: Personal space Jung is quite concerned that whenever he talks to his colleagues at work they tend to take one or two steps back. Why might they do this? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Check your answer at the end of this unit. Time How people think about and use time usually depends on how their culture values time. These differences may cause some misunderstanding. In the following table are some sayings that show different cultural attitudes to time. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 14 American/Australian Chinese/Middle Eastern French/European He who hesitates is lost Think three times before you act Patience is the virtue of asses (donkeys) Aboriginal/ TSI Time is money Saving time Better late than sorry Killing time Losing time Wasting time Activity 9: How do you value time? Thinking about time There are two main ways that people think about time: 1 Monochronic: People who think about time in a monochronic way work out an order for doing things, deal with one thing at a time, make a sort of mental list and think that it’s important to be punctual (on time). 2 Polychronic: People from some cultures think about time in a polychronic way. They do many things at once, change their plans often and think that people are more important than punctuality. Remember though that while most people in a culture might be monochronic, individuals can be different. Activity 10: Attitudes to time Do you think people of your culture have mainly a monochronic or a polychronic attitude to time? ____________________________________________________________ Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 15 Do you think Australians have mainly a monochronic or polychromic attitude to time? ____________________________________________________________ What about you, do you have mainly a monochronic or polychronic attitude? ____________________________________________________________ Activity 11: Making time Giorgio received an invitation from Anna for a dinner party. The invitation said 7.30pm and Giorgio arrived at 8.30pm. He was surprised when Anna was angry with him and accused him of ruining her dinner. Giorgio couldn’t understand her problem. Both of them got upset. Their breakdown in communication started because of their different cultural attitudes to time. What do you think Anna’s and Giorgio’s attitudes to time are? Are they monochronic or polychronic? Circle the appropriate answer for both of these people. 1 Anna, with a Swiss background, might have an attitude to time that is more: monochronic or polychronic? 2 Giorgio, with an Italian background, might have an attitude to time that is more: monochronic or polychronic? Check your answers at the end of the unit. Activity 12: Identifying some Australian cultural conventions For this activity you need to read the extract on the next page. It is the second part of the lecture about intercultural communication, by Paul Kettering. He discusses some cultural conventions in Australian society. The table below lists the different conventions or rules discussed in the extract, but they are listed here in the wrong order. Your task is to number each of the conventions to show the correct order in which they are presented in the extract. This will help you to check you have understood what you have read. For example, the convention discussed first (What topic it’s OK to talk about) is numbered ‘1’. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 16 Ideas (out of order) that are presented in the extract Place a number to show the order in which they are presented How much space should be between people speaking How we address each other How we use non-verbal behaviour What topic it’s OK to talk about 1 How we express politeness Check your answer at the end of the unit. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 17 The following extract is the second part of a lecture about intercultural communication, by Paul Kettering. As I said before, every language has a set of conventions or rules. By complying with the conventions of the language when we are speaking we are much more likely to meet the expectations of someone whose mother tongue is that language and thus communicate successfully. Here are some other examples. What we can talk about. What I mean by that is, that some topics that are okay in conversation while others are not. For example, in English, people say it’s best to avoid talking about money. Think about this. How do you feel if someone asks you how much money you earn, or how much rent you pay, or what your house costs? It’s hard for some people from other cultures to understand that it’s not okay to ask someone about these things. In some cultures it’s quite acceptable. The second convention I want to mention is how we express politeness. Sometimes when we communicate in English with someone from another culture we get the impression that they are very rude. Often it’s because politeness in their culture is expressed in different ways from the English way. In English we say ‘please’ when we are asking for something in a polite way, but in some languages, it’s not necessary. If people don’t say ‘please’ enough they are sometimes thought of as abrupt or rude. At the same time, some people would say that many speakers of English are overly polite. That we say too many ‘please’s. Another convention is the way we address each other. What we call each other. People from other cultures are often surprised at what Australians call each other. For example, it’s not uncommon for people to call their bosses or supervisors by their first names. In other cultures, this would be unheard of. In those cultures, calling a superior Mr, Mrs or Ms X is seen as a sign of respect and doing otherwise would be seen as disrespectful and impolite. Another convention is the way we use our faces and bodies to communicate. We call communication without using words, ‘Non-Verbal Communication’. Just think, for a moment, about different ways people have of greeting each other. Maybe you thought of shaking hands, or bowing, or kissing once or twice or three times, putting the hands together in a prayer position, or even rubbing noses together. These are really obvious examples of the different ways that people from different cultures communicate greetings to each other. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 18 Other forms of non-verbal communication are things like smiling and other facial expressions, as well as gestures such as waving, hugging, pushing someone in an angry way and so on. Some people say that in English, more than 50% of communication is non-verbal. That leaves less than 50% of communication that is expressed in spoken language. There are many other forms of non-verbal communication including things like our ideas about space and our expectations of how much space there should be between people speaking to each other and many more. I’d like to conclude by saying that, if we are communicating with people from different cultures and our message is not getting through, that is, our communication is not successful, we are mis-communicating. There are three skills, I think, that can help us. They are all connected to our understanding that different languages have different rules of communication. Firstly, we need to recognise when mis-communications are due to cultural differences and be aware that different rules of communication are operating. Secondly, we need to make sure we reduce miscommunications by our constant awareness of the differences. And, thirdly, we need to be able to clear up any miscommunications that occur as soon as possible. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 19 Activity 13: Recognising mis-communication The text below is the last two paragraphs of the above extract from Kettering’s lecture. There are 12 words missing. Complete the following extract using the words given below. communicating recognise message clear up cultures cultural different rules mis-communicating connected mis-communications reduce I’d like to conclude by saying that, if we are _________________ with people from different _________________ and our _________________ is not getting through, that is, our communication is not successful, we are _________________. There are three skills, I think, that can help us. They are all _________________ to our understanding that _________________ languages have different _________________ of communication. Firstly, we need to _________________ when miscommunications are due to _________________ differences and be aware that different rules of communication are operating. Secondly, we need to make sure we _________________ _________________ by our constant awareness of the differences. And, thirdly, we need to be able to _________________ any miscommunications that occur as soon as possible. Check your answers at the end of this unit. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 20 Topic 3: Cultural behaviours All the things we have been talking about so far — attitudes to time, social customs, forms of politeness, etc — are cultural behaviours. The table below shows some cultural behaviours of other cultures, the reasons for the behaviours and how Australians can misunderstand them. Activity 14: Typical Aussie behaviour Look at the table on the next page, and across each row: The first column gives you an example of a generally typical Australian behaviour. The second column gives you a reason for the behaviour. For this task you need to fill in the blanks so that the sentence is complete (and makes sense). Use the words from the list of ‘Possible answers’ given below. The third column Indicates how the behaviour may be misunderstood by other cultures. You need to fill in the missing word for each sentence in the second column of the table — to complete the reason for the behaviour. Choose the missing words from these possible answers: body know show fun normal affection friendly casual equality Strong right Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 21 When Australians behave like this … Cultural reasons for the behaviour Some people from other cultures might think this behaviour is … shrug their shoulders It’s body language which means ‘I don’t __________’. saying ‘I don’t care’ put their hands in their pockets This shows informality; it is indifferent or disrespectful confident and relaxed __________ language. write in red ink Red is the __________ colour for correcting writing. point their finger at something Use fewer words to give rude or insulting directions or to __________ who you are referring to. raise their voice to make a point Expressions of __________ feelings are valued. disrespectful touch another person’s head, especially a child’s This shows __________. rude put hats on the floor This shows they are informal and __________. rude put feet on a chair They are sitting in a relaxed and __________ way. rude because the lowest part of the body should not be put on a chair or used to point to anyone make physical contact They are often just being __________ toward each other. threatening wink They are being friendly and __________. a suggestive approach. a teacher sitting on a desk Shows feelings of __________ with students, and being relaxed. laziness take education for granted Education is a __________; everyone is entitled to it. not appreciating the privilege Exploring intercultural misunderstandings writing about dead people 22 Topic 4: Stereotyping and prejudice Cultural behaviours may lead to stereotyping and prejudice which can lead to further breakdowns in communication. Think back to Anna and Giorgio’s different attitudes to time (Activity 11). We made assumptions about Anna’s attitude because she’s Swiss and about Giorgio’s attitude because he’s Italian. What assumptions do you have about the following people? A stereotype Aussie male Activity 15: Stereotyping Try to complete the following sentences. What assumptions do you have about people, in general, who come from these cultures? Australians are: ______________________________________________ The French are: ______________________________________________ Italians are: _________________________________________________ Arabs are: __________________________________________________ Chinese are: _________________________________________________ Jews are: ___________________________________________________ Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 23 There are no right or wrong answers to this activity, but you could compare your responses with those of a friend or fellow student. See if you have made up the same stereotypes for each culture. When people generalise or believe something about a group of people and expect that all people of that group will behave that way, they are stereotyping. This often leads to judging people before you know them, which is prejudice. Some people make racist comments, tell racist jokes, write racist graffiti and call people names. These are examples of prejudice. Often prejudice results in blaming other people for your own difficulties, eg blaming migrants for unemployment. If you then treat someone unfairly because of the group they belong to, you are discriminating against them. In Australia, this kind of discrimination is inappropriate and illegal. Activity 16: Have you experienced prejudice? Have you ever experienced prejudice? What form did it take (eg name calling, labelling, body language)? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ What did you do and how did you feel? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Discuss your experiences with a fellow student you may be in contact with. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 24 Topic 5: Communicating with government organisations So far we have been talking about cultural misunderstandings that can occur between individuals. Often misunderstandings also occur when people from other cultures have to deal with government organisations like local councils, the Roads and Traffic Authority (RTA), the Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs. In this situation the person is the customer and the government organisation is the service provider. However, often there can be a communication breakdown and the person is left feeling powerless. Some causes of miscommunication are individual problems (eg poor English skills or impatience) and others are institutional problems (eg not enough staff, poor training, no clear instructions or no interpreters available). Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 25 Summary Well done. In this unit we have considered the following questions: Why do cultural misunderstandings happen? What are nine common areas of misunderstanding across cultures? What are some common cross-cultural behaviours that may be misunderstood? What are stereotyping and prejudice? Why do migrants have difficulties communicating with government organisations? If you’re not sure that you now have an understanding of any of these points, go back and read the relevant section or do the activities again. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 26 Check your answers Activity 1: What is culture? 1 Culture is defined as: A combination of the obvious things like food and clothes, and the less obvious things like how we look at he world. 2 We mostly learn our first language: at home with our parents. 3 When we speak our first language: we do not have to think about what to say. 4 We feel OK speaking our first language because: we know the rules of communicating in that language. 5 When we learn a second language: it is not common to feel really comfortable with speaking it. 6 When communicating in English: it is rude not to make eye contact. 7 Many people whose first language is not English: often have trouble communicating because they do not know the conventions as well as a native speaker. Activity 2: Giving instructions politely 1 The polite form of instruction 1 is: Could you please give me Mrs Jacob’s file? 2 The polite form of instruction 2 is: Can you take this package up to Grace on level 4? Thanks. Activity 3: Australian slang Slang Meaning Good on you mate Well done Hang on Please wait Stuffed up Made a mistake Hooroo Good bye Righteo I agree Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 27 Activity 4: Asking questions Part B: All the questions are appropriate except for question 3 — it is not polite to ask someone what they earn if you don’t know them very well. Activity 5: A compliment gone wrong The student probably reacted to Maria’s compliment in an embarrassed way because in his culture it is not appropriate to show pride when complimented, but to show modesty. Maria probably couldn’t understand why the student would say they’d done badly when they had obviously done well. Activity 7: Responding to bad news The workmate is probably from a different culture to Anne. In the workmate’s culture, it could be accepted practice to shake someone’s hand to show empathy and sorrow for someone. Activity 8: Personal space Jung’s colleagues would probably move back a few steps because he was getting too close to them. They would feel that he was invading their personal space and wouldn’t feel comfortable. Activity 11: Making time 1 Anna, with a Swiss background, might have an attitude to time that is more monochronic. 2 Giorgio, with an Italian background, might have an attitude to time that is more polychronic. Activity 12: Identifying some Australian cultural conventions Ideas (out of order) that are presented in the extract Place a number to show the order in which they are presented How much space should be between people speaking 5 How we address each other 3 How we use non-verbal behaviour 4 What topic it’s OK to talk about 1 How we express politeness 2 Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 28 Activity 13: Recognising mis-communication I’d like to conclude by saying that, if we are communicating with people from different cultures and our message is not getting through, that is, our communication is not successful, we are mis-communicating. There are three skills, I think, that can help us. They are all connected to our understanding that different languages have different rules of communication. Firstly, we need to recognise when mis-communications are due to cultural differences and be aware that different rules of communication are operating. Secondly, we need to make sure we reduce mis-communications by our constant awareness of the differences. And, thirdly, we need to be able to clear up any mis-communications that occur as soon as possible. Exploring intercultural misunderstandings 29