ADDITION AND SUBTRACTION STRATEGIES Strategies are flexible. Students should not be given a prescribed sequence of steps to follow when using a particular strategy. It is likely to see each of the following strategies used in a variety of ways during a Number Talk or math lesson. The examples, models, and recording schemes given are not a comprehensive list of all ways in which the strategy can be used, rather, a small sample to provide illustrations of the strategy. Allow students to use the method that works for them. Students will eventually begin to perform these computations mentally without the need to record or model. This is the goal and should be encouraged. Note: Students should not be expected to know the strategy by name. Each strategy below is referred to by several different names. Teachers may refer to a particular strategy as “Peter’s strategy” as if Peter was the first to present that strategy. Two common components of strategies for mental addition and subtraction are decomposing one or more of the addends and compensation. Decomposing Decomposing (sometimes called splitting) is the practice of breaking numbers apart. Numbers can be decomposed in many way. Students should become flexible with decomposing in order to select appropriate combinations that make sense to the individual and are efficient for the given problem. Example: Some of the ways 78 can be decomposed 75 + 3 70 + 8 20 + 50 + 8 72 + 6 25 + 50 + 3 60 + 18 Compensation Compensation is the process of adjusting one or more of the numbers in a problem prior to performing the computation and later readjusting in order to compensate. When adding 25 + 27 a student may adjust the 27 to make the problem 25 + 25 = 50, and then compensate for the adjustment by adding 2, 50 + 2 = 52. A student may also adjust the 25 and the 27 to make the problem 22 + 30. In this case, 3 was added to the 27, making 30, and then to compensate the 3 was taken from the 25. Base ten blocks, open number lines, hundred charts, and drawing are all good models for students to use when learning strategies for mental math. A closed number line is a line with prerecorded tick marks. It is often used when students are computing smaller numbers and for learning strategies with single- and sometimes double-digit addition and subtraction. Students’ first exposure to number lines should be with closed number lines and jumps of one. An open number line is customized by creating tick marks as a problem is solved. It is used when students have a basic understanding of making jumps on closed number lines. It is primarily used when larger numbers or larger jumps need to be made. EXAMPLES OF ADDITION STRATEGIES CHUNKING (ALSO REFERED TO AS JUMPS) Early use of this strategy involves counting on one at a time and evolves into counting on in jumps that make sense to the individual. Example: 26 + 47 Students may choose to add the tens and then add the ones. Some students will add each individual ten and others may see a more efficient “jump” of 40. Students may jump the 7 one at a time or may jump to the next benchmark number and then jump the rest. Possible Models Open Number Line 26 + four jumps of ten (40) + seven jumps of one (7) 26 + one jump of forty (40) + seven jumps of one (7) + 40 + 40 +10 +10 +10 +10 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 26 36 46 56 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 26 + one jump of forty (40) + one jump of four (4) + one jump of three (3) + 40 26 (26) add the tens (26 + 40) then add the ones (66 + 7) 26 66 70 73 and compose a ten with ten of the ones Hundred Chart 2 12 3 13 4 14 5 15 21 31 22 32 23 33 24 34 25 35 41 51 42 52 43 53 44 54 45 55 61 71 62 72 63 73 64 74 65 75 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 Base Ten Blocks +4 +3 1 11 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1 6 16 26 36 7 17 8 18 9 19 10 20 27 39 28 38 29 39 30 40 46 56 66 76 47 57 48 58 49 59 50 60 67 77 68 78 69 79 70 80 Move down four (+ 40), then right 7 (+7) which requires wrapping to the next line. Students may also choose to add ones to get to the next benchmark, add tens, and then add the remaining ones. Example: 26 + 47 Add 4 to get to 30, then add 40 to get to 70, and then add the remaining 3 to get to 73. Possible Models Number Line +4 +40 +3 26 30 70 73 Possible Recording Schemes +4 +10 +10 +10 +10 +3 26 30 40 50 60 26 + 40 = 66 66 + 4 = 70 70 + 3 = 73 26 30 + 4 + 40 30 70 70 + 3 73 70 73 26 + 4 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 3 = 73 EXAMPLES OF ADDITION STRATEGIES ANCHOR TO TENS This strategy supports place value understanding and number sense. This strategy involves decomposing one of the addends to make the other addend a multiple of ten. In later grades, this strategy is expanded to “Make 100” or “Make 1000”, etc. Example 1: 28 + 7 Students can add 2 to 28 to make the next ten, or 30, and then add the remaining 5 for an answer of 35. Example 2: 46 + 38 Students can take 2 from the 46 and add to the 38 to make 44 + 40 which is 84. OR Students can take 4 from the 38 and add to the 46 to make 50 + 34 which is 84. Possible models Base Ten Blocks 28 + 7 Hundred Chart Open Number Line 28 + 7 +2 to the next “10” +5 for a total of 7 Becomes 30 + 5 28 30 35 1 11 21 31 2 12 22 32 3 13 23 33 4 14 24 34 5 15 25 35 6 16 26 36 7 17 27 39 8 18 28 38 28 + 2 + 5 30 + 5 = 35 28 + 7 = 28 + 2 + 5= 30 + 5 = 35 10 20 30 40 Begin at 28, move 2 to next “10” and the 5 more for total of 7. In Example 2, begin at 46 move 4 to next “10” then down 3 (+30) to 80 then move the remaining 4 to 84 Possible recording schemes 28 + 7 9 19 29 39 28 + 7 2 + 5 30 + 5 = 35 MAKING EASY NUMBERS Example: 50 + 78 Students may recognize 50 as an easy number to work with and decompose the 78; 50 + 50 + 28 = 100 + 28 = 128 OR Students may find it easy to add 50 + 75 and then 3 more by to decomposing 78 into 75 + 3; 50 + 75 + 3 = 125 + 3 Example: 27 + 52 Students may recognize 25 and 50 as easy number to work with and decompose 27 into 2 + 25 and 52 into 50 + 2; 2 + 25 + 50 + 2 = 2 + 75 + 2 = 79. This strategy is very flexible and can be used in many ways to solve problems. Different people will find different numbers easier to work with. Students should be encouraged to use numbers that they find make the problem simpler for them. DOUBLES This strategy is useful when adding two numbers that are close to each other. Example: 45 + 48 Students can double 45 to get 90 and then add the remaining 3 to get 93. EXAMPLES OF ADDITION STRATEGIES PARTIAL SUMS (ALSO REFERRED TO AS EXPANDED FORM) Expanding is a form of decomposing. Students can use their place value understanding to add or subtract large numbers. Example: 236 + 183 (200 + 30 + 6) + (100 + 80 + 3) = 300 +110 + 9 = 419 Possible Models Base Ten Blocks 236 + Possible Recording Schemes Right to Left Left to Right 236 236 +183 +183 9 (add ones) 300 (add hundreds) 110 (add tens) 110 (add tens) 300 (add hundreds) 9 (add ones) 419 (add the sums) 419 (add the sums) 183 Combine the hundreds, the tens, and the ones Compose a hundred with 10 of the tens 236 200 + 30 + 6 +183 +100 + 80 + 3 300 +110 +9 = 419 = 419 COMPENSTATION Compensation is the ability to add or subtract from a number and then compensate for the difference when solving. Note: Students may refer to it as “easy”, “benchmark”, “friendly” or “anchor” numbers. Example: 56 + 38 Students may change 38 to 40, add 56 + 40 to get 96 and then subtract the 2 they had added, to get 94. OR Students may add 4 to the 56 and 2 to the 38, changing the problem to 60 + 40 = 100 and then subtract the 2 and 4 (or 6); 100 - 6 = 94. OR Students may add 2 to the 38 and compensate by subtracting 2 from the 56, changing the problem to 54 + 40 = 94. Possible Models Possible Recording Schemes Base Ten Blocks Number Line +40 -2 56 94 96 56 add 40 and then compensate by moving back 2 56 + 38 + Becomes 56 + 40 by adding 2 to 38 + = Compensate by removing 2 (94) 56 + 38 +2 56 + 40 = 96 -2 94 56 + 38+2 56 + 40 96-2 94 56 + 38 + 2 = 96 96 – 2 = 40 EXAMPLES OF SUBTRACTION STRATEGIES Real-Life Context Providing students with real-life context gives meaning to the numbers and the operation. Students will more readily see the connection between addition and subtraction and understand the various meanings of subtraction, take from/add to, take apart/put together, and compare when problems are presented in context. Presenting students will all problem types prevents the common misconception that the definition of subtraction is “take away”. ADDING UP This strategy reinforces the connection between addition and subtraction. This strategy is similar to the addition strategy ADDING UP IN CHUNKS. Problems involving “How many more?” promote the use of this strategy. Students begin by counting up one at a time and progress to counting up in chunks that make sense to them. Example: “Sarah’s goal for the walkathon is to walk 82 laps. She has walked 26 laps so far. How many more does she need to walk?” 26 + ___ = 82, or 82 – 26 Students may determine the number of jumps to get to the next benchmark number, 26 + 4 = 30. This may be followed by adding up in chunks of ten, 30 +10 = 40, +10 more = 50, +10 more = 60, +10 more = 70, +10 more = 80, and then the remaining ones to get to 82; 80 + 2 = 82. The total difference is 4+10+10+10+10+10+2 = 56. Students will eventually begin to add all of the tens in one chunk, 30 + 50 = 80 OR Students may add tens to get close and then add ones. 26 + 10 +10 +10 +10 = 76, 76 + 4 = 80, 80 + 2 = 82. This evolves into adding a group of tens and then ones, 26 + 50 = 76, 76 + 4 = 80, 80 + 2 = 82; 56 is add to 26 to make 82. OR Students may overshoot by adding tens and then remove the extra ones. 26 + 60 = 86, 86 – 4 = 82, 60 – 4 = 56. Possible Models Number Line Number Line How many from 26 to 82? How many from 26 to 82? +4 +10 +10 +10 +10 +10 +2 = 56 26 30 40 50 60 70 80 82 5 15 25 35 45 55 65 75 85 6 16 26 36 46 56 66 76 86 +4 +50 2 12 22 32 42 52 62 72 82 3 13 23 33 43 53 63 73 83 4 14 24 34 44 54 64 74 84 7 17 27 39 47 57 67 77 87 How many more to make 82? 56 more makes 82 +2 = 56 26 30 80 82 Hundreds Chart 1 11 21 31 41 51 61 71 81 Base Ten Blocks Start with 26 8 18 28 38 48 58 68 78 88 9 19 29 39 49 59 69 79 89 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 How many from 26 to 82? Down 5 to 76 (+50), then right 6 to 82 which requires wrapping to the next line (+6) 56 Possible Recording Schemes 26 + 4 + 50 + 2 = 82 26 +4 +10 +10 +10 +10 +10 + 3 82 56 EXAMPLES OF SUBTRACTION STRATEGIES COUNTING BACK Students who have primarily been exposed to take away subtraction problems will be drawn to this strategy. Students may begin at the whole and find the difference between the whole and the part being subtracted or begin at the whole and count back the number being subtracted. Example: 82 - 26 Students may begin at the whole and count back tens, 82 -10 - 10 = 62, and count back the remaining ones. When counting back the ones students may count back one at a time or in chunks, 62 – 2 = 60; 60 – 4 = 56. OR Students may count back to the next benchmark, then remove the tens, then remove the remaining ones, 82 – 2 = 80; 80 – 20 = 60; 60 – 4 = 56 OR Students may overshoot when taking off tens and then compensate by adding the amount they overshot, 82 – 30 = 52; 4 too many were subtracted so add 4, 52 + 4 = 56. Number Line Number Line Number Line Count back tens, then ones -4 -2 -40 56 60 62 82 Count back ones, then tens, then ones -4 -40 -2 56 60 80 82 Overshoot and then compensate +4 -30 52 56 82 KEEPING A CONSTANT DIFFERENCE (ALSO REFERED TO AS COMPENSATION) This strategy involves adjusting both numbers in the problem by the same amount in order to make a new problem that is easier to solve. Example: 34-19 A student may recognize that subtracting 20 is easier than subtracting 19 and add one to both numbers, making the problem 35 – 20 = 15. MAKE EASY NUMBERS (ALSO REFERED TO AS COMPENSATION) This strategy is similar to KEEPING A CONSTANT DIFFERENCE, but only one of the numbers is altered and then the difference is altered to compensate. Frequently, but not always, the number being subtracted is altered to create a problem in which a multiple of ten is being subtracted. Example: 62 – 37 A student may find it easier to subtract 40 instead of subtracting 37. The extra 3 that was subtracted would then need to be added to the difference. 62 – 40 = 22, then add the 3, 22 + 3 = 25. Example: 86 – 23 A student may prefer subtracting 20 over subtracting 23 and alter this problem by subtracting 3 from 23. The new problem would be 86 – 20 = 66. In this case 3 too few were subtracted and must be subtracted from the difference. 66 - 3 = 63 EXPANDED FORM Example: 849-145 (Decompose only the subtrahend) 849 - (100 + 40 + 5) = 849 - 100 = 749 749 - 40 = 709 709 - 5 = 704