Arithmetic of Natural Numbers

advertisement
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
Bernd Schröder
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
2. So we need arithmetic.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
2. So we need arithmetic.
3. But arithmetic must be constructed within set theory so
that it will be part of our framework for mathematics.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
2. So we need arithmetic.
3. But arithmetic must be constructed within set theory so
that it will be part of our framework for mathematics.
4. Moreover, it turns out that the abstract properties of the
operations we consider will have far reaching
consequences.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
2. So we need arithmetic.
3. But arithmetic must be constructed within set theory so
that it will be part of our framework for mathematics.
4. Moreover, it turns out that the abstract properties of the
operations we consider will have far reaching
consequences.
5. So we also need to prove some properties for the
operations
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
The Peano Axioms Can’t Be “It”
1. The natural numbers are about counting objects, about
adding and multiplying, subtracting and dividing,
comparing numbers to each other, etc. (And the Peano
Axioms don’t directly provide for these things.)
2. So we need arithmetic.
3. But arithmetic must be constructed within set theory so
that it will be part of our framework for mathematics.
4. Moreover, it turns out that the abstract properties of the
operations we consider will have far reaching
consequences.
5. So we also need to prove some properties for the
operations and in another presentation we will consider the
consequences of these properties.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition. A (binary) operation on a set S is a function
◦ : S × S → S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition. A (binary) operation on a set S is a function
◦ : S × S → S.
Binary operations do exactly what addition and subtraction do:
They take two objects and produce a new one.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition. A (binary) operation on a set S is a function
◦ : S × S → S.
Binary operations do exactly what addition and subtraction do:
They take two objects and produce a new one.
We need simpler notation.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition. A (binary) operation on a set S is a function
◦ : S × S → S.
Binary operations do exactly what addition and subtraction do:
They take two objects and produce a new one.
We need simpler notation.
Definition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Start Abstractly
Definition. A (binary) operation on a set S is a function
◦ : S × S → S.
Binary operations do exactly what addition and subtraction do:
They take two objects and produce a new one.
We need simpler notation.
Definition. Let S be a set and let ◦ : S × S → S be a binary
operation. For all a, b ∈ S we set a ◦ b := ◦(a, b).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Or, in relation notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation
+ ⊆ (N × N) × N
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Or, in relation notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation
+ ⊆ (N × N) × N contains the pair (n, 1), n0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Or, in relation notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation
+ ⊆ (N × N) × N contains the pair (n, 1), n0 , and
for all
n, m ∈ N for which
there is a k ∈ N with (n, m), k ∈ + we have
0
0
that (n, m ), k ∈ +.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Or, in relation notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation
+ ⊆ (N × N) × N contains the pair (n, 1), n0 , and
for all
n, m ∈ N for which
there is a k ∈ N with (n, m), k ∈ + we have
0
0
that (n, m ), k ∈ +.
The relation (which turns out to be a binary operation) is called
addition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Adding Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation + : N × N → N is
defined by n + 1 := n0 and n + m0 := (n + m)0 .
Or, in relation notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation
+ ⊆ (N × N) × N contains the pair (n, 1), n0 , and
for all
n, m ∈ N for which
there is a k ∈ N with (n, m), k ∈ + we have
0
0
that (n, m ), k ∈ +.
The relation (which turns out to be a binary operation) is called
addition.
(Keep this definition handy. We’ll use it a lot.)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N : ((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
For all m ∈ S we have (n, m0 ), (n + m)0 ∈ +, so m0 ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
For all m ∈ S we have (n, m0 ), (n + m)0 ∈ +, so m0 ∈ S.
By the Principle of Induction, we conclude that S = N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
For all m ∈ S we have (n, m0 ), (n + m)0 ∈ +, so m0 ∈ S.
By the Principle of Induction, we conclude that S = N. Thus
n + m is defined for all m ∈ N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
For all m ∈ S we have (n, m0 ), (n + m)0 ∈ +, so m0 ∈ S.
By the Principle of Induction, we conclude that S = N. Thus
n + m is defined for all m ∈ N.
Because n ∈ N was arbitrary, n + m is defined for all n, m ∈ N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. The relation + is a binary operation on N.
Proof. By definition + ⊆ (N × N) × N, nothing more. So we
use relation notation in this proof. Our main tool will be the
Principle of Induction.
Step 1: The relation + is totally defined.
Let n∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∃k ∈ N :((n, m), k) ∈ +] .
By definition, (n, 1), n0 ∈ +, so 1 ∈ S.
For all m ∈ S we have (n, m0 ), (n + m)0 ∈ +, so m0 ∈ S.
By the Principle of Induction, we conclude that S = N. Thus
n + m is defined for all m ∈ N.
Because n ∈ N was arbitrary, n + m is defined for all n, m ∈ N.
Hence + is totally defined.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
of any natural number
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
of any natural number, we obtain k = n0 = l.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
of any natural number, we obtain k = n0 = l. So 1 ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
k = n0 =
of any natural number, we obtain
l. So 1 ∈ S.
0
0
Now, if m ∈ S, and (n, m ), k , (n, m ), l ∈ +
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
k = n0 =
of any natural number, we obtain
l. So 1 ∈ S.
0
0
Now, if m ∈ S, and (n, m ), k , (n, m ), l ∈ +, then
k = (n + m)0 = l and therefore m0 ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
k = n0 =
of any natural number, we obtain
l. So 1 ∈ S.
0
0
Now, if m ∈ S, and (n, m ), k , (n, m ), l ∈ +, then
k = (n + m)0 = l and therefore m0 ∈ S. By the Principle of
Induction, S = N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
k = n0 =
of any natural number, we obtain
l. So 1 ∈ S.
0
0
Now, if m ∈ S, and (n, m ), k , (n, m ), l ∈ +, then
k = (n + m)0 = l and therefore m0 ∈ S. By the Principle of
Induction, S = N. Thus n + m is unique for all n, m ∈ N. We
conclude that + is well-defined.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Step 2: The relation + is well-defined.
Let n ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Let
S := m ∈ N : [∀k, l ∈ N : ((n, m), k), ((n, m), l) ∈ + ⇒ k = l] .
If (n, 1), k), ((n, 1), l ∈ +, then, because 1 is not the successor
k = n0 =
of any natural number, we obtain
l. So 1 ∈ S.
0
0
Now, if m ∈ S, and (n, m ), k , (n, m ), l ∈ +, then
k = (n + m)0 = l and therefore m0 ∈ S. By the Principle of
Induction, S = N. Thus n + m is unique for all n, m ∈ N. We
conclude that + is well-defined.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property and then we prove that that set is N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property and then we prove that that set is N.
So, if you already know induction, this approach really is
not that different.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property and then we prove that that set is N.
So, if you already know induction, this approach really is
not that different. We’ll get back to “the usual way to do
induction” in a little while.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property and then we prove that that set is N.
So, if you already know induction, this approach really is
not that different. We’ll get back to “the usual way to do
induction” in a little while.
2. The idea that a function needs to be proved to be
well-defined takes some time getting used to.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Notes
1. To use the Principle of Induction as stated in the Peano
Axioms, we define a set that contains all the elements with
a certain property and then we prove that that set is N.
So, if you already know induction, this approach really is
not that different. We’ll get back to “the usual way to do
induction” in a little while.
2. The idea that a function needs to be proved to be
well-defined takes some time getting used to. Arithmetic
modulo m will give us a simpler and pretty natural context.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
1. Addition is associative
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
1. Addition is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have
that (n + m) + k = n + (m + k).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
1. Addition is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have
that (n + m) + k = n + (m + k).
2. Addition is commutative
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
1. Addition is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have
that (n + m) + k = n + (m + k).
2. Addition is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we have
that n + m = m + n.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proposition. Properties of the addition operation on N.
1. Addition is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have
that (n + m) + k = n + (m + k).
2. Addition is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we have
that n + m = m + n.
(We need to get used to the vocabulary.)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + k0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + k0 =
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
(n + m) + k
0
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + k0 =
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
0
0
(n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
0
0
(n + m) + k0 = (n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
= n + (m + k)0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
0
0
(n + m) + k0 = (n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
= n + (m + k)0 = n + (m + k0 ).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
0
0
(n + m) + k0 = (n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
= n + (m + k)0 = n + (m + k0 ).
By the Principle of Induction, S = N
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
0
0
(n + m) + k0 = (n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
= n + (m + k)0 = n + (m + k0 ).
By the Principle of Induction, S = N, so
(n + m) + k = n + (m + k) for all k ∈ N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof. We must prove associativity and commutativity, and we
will use the Principle of Induction.
To prove
but fixed. Let
associativity, let n, m ∈ N be arbitrary,
S := k ∈ N : (n + m) + k = n + (m + k) .
1 ∈ S, because
(n + m) + 1 = (n + m)0 = n + m0 = n + (m + 1).
Now let k ∈ S. Then k0 ∈ S, because
0
0
(n + m) + k0 = (n + m) + k = n + (m + k)
= n + (m + k)0 = n + (m + k0 ).
By the Principle of Induction, S = N, so
(n + m) + k = n + (m + k) for all k ∈ N. Because n and m were
arbitrary, + is associative.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1) = 1 + k0 ,
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1) = 1 + k0 ,
so k0 ∈ T.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1) = 1 + k0 ,
so k0 ∈ T. Hence T = N
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1) = 1 + k0 ,
so k0 ∈ T. Hence T = N, that is, k + 1 = 1 + k for all k ∈ N.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). To prove commutativity, let n ∈ N be arbitrary,
but fixed. Let S := {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
To prove that 1 ∈ S, we will perform an induction inside an
induction.
Let T := {k ∈ N : k + 1 = 1 + k}. Trivially, 1 ∈ T.
Now let k ∈ T. Then
k0 + 1 = (k + 1) + 1 = (1 + k) + 1 = 1 + (k + 1) = 1 + k0 ,
so k0 ∈ T. Hence T = N, that is, k + 1 = 1 + k for all k ∈ N.
(Back to the “main induction”.)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n = m0 + n,
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n = m0 + n,
that is, m0 ∈ S.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n = m0 + n,
that is, m0 ∈ S. Thus S = N,
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n = m0 + n,
that is, m0 ∈ S. Thus S = N, and for all m ∈ N we have that
n + m = m + n.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Proof (cont.). Using k := n we obtain n + 1 = 1 + n, and hence
1 ∈ S = {m ∈ N : n + m = m + n}.
Now let m ∈ S. Then
n + m0 = n + (m + 1) = (n + m) + 1 = (m + n) + 1 = m + (n + 1)
= m + (1 + n) = (m + 1) + n = m0 + n,
that is, m0 ∈ S. Thus S = N, and for all m ∈ N we have that
n + m = m + n.
Because n ∈ N was arbitrary, this establishes commutativity.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2 := 1 + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2 := 1 + 1
3 := 2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2 := 1 + 1
3 := 2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
4 := 3 + 1 = ((1 + 1) + 1) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2
3
4
5
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
:=
:=
:=
:=
1+1
2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
3 + 1 = ((1 + 1) + 1) + 1
4 + 1 = (((1 + 1) + 1) + 1) + 1
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2
3
4
5
:=
:=
:=
:=
1+1
2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
3 + 1 = ((1 + 1) + 1) + 1
4 + 1 = (((1 + 1) + 1) + 1) + 1
and so on, in the usual fashion.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2
3
4
5
:=
:=
:=
:=
1+1
2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
3 + 1 = ((1 + 1) + 1) + 1
4 + 1 = (((1 + 1) + 1) + 1) + 1
and so on, in the usual fashion.
Yes, numerals are merely symbols.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Back to Earth: The Usual Representation of
Natural Numbers
Definition. We define
2
3
4
5
:=
:=
:=
:=
1+1
2 + 1 = (1 + 1) + 1
3 + 1 = ((1 + 1) + 1) + 1
4 + 1 = (((1 + 1) + 1) + 1) + 1
and so on, in the usual fashion.
Yes, numerals are merely symbols. Think of roman numerals if
that feels “wrong”.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4+3
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4 + 3 = 4 + (2 + 1)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4 + 3 = 4 + (2 + 1)
= (4 + 2) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4 + 3 = 4 + (2 + 1)
= (4 + 2) + 1
= 4 + (1 + 1) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4 + 3 = 4 + (2 + 1)
= (4 + 2) + 1
= 4 + (1 + 1) + 1
= (4 + 1) + 1 + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4 + 3 = 4 + (2 + 1)
= (4 + 2) + 1
= 4 + (1 + 1) + 1
= (4 + 1) + 1 + 1
= (5 + 1) + 1
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4+3 =
=
=
=
=
=
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
4 + (2 + 1)
(4 + 2) + 1
4 + (1 + 1) + 1
(4 + 1) + 1 + 1
(5 + 1) + 1
6+1
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4+3 =
=
=
=
=
=
=
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
4 + (2 + 1)
(4 + 2) + 1
4 + (1 + 1) + 1
(4 + 1) + 1 + 1
(5 + 1) + 1
6+1
7
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4+3 =
=
=
=
=
=
=
4 + (2 + 1)
(4 + 2) + 1
4 + (1 + 1) + 1
(4 + 1) + 1 + 1
(5 + 1) + 1
6+1
7
If we do too much of this, people will believe we are nuts.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
We Can’t Prove 1 + 1 = 2, But We Can Prove
4+3 = 7
4+3 =
=
=
=
=
=
=
4 + (2 + 1)
(4 + 2) + 1
4 + (1 + 1) + 1
(4 + 1) + 1 + 1
(5 + 1) + 1
6+1
7
If we do too much of this, people will believe we are nuts. But,
this is a good exercise in mathematical reasoning nonetheless.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation · : N × N → N is
defined by n · 1 := n and n · m0 := n · m + n.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation · : N × N → N is
defined by n · 1 := n and n · m0 := n · m + n. Or, in relation
notation, for all n ∈ N, the relation · ⊆ (N × N) × N
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation · : N × N → N is
defined by n · 1 := n and n · m0 := n · m + n. Or, in relation
notation, for all n∈ N, the relation · ⊆ (N × N) × N contains
the pair (n, 1), n
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation · : N × N → N is
defined by n · 1 := n and n · m0 := n · m + n. Or, in relation
notation, for all n∈ N, the relation · ⊆ (N × N) × N contains
there
the pair (n, 1), n , and
for all n, m ∈ N for which
is a
0
k ∈ N with (n, m), k ∈ · we have that (n, m ), k + n ∈ ·.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Multiplying Natural Numbers
Definition. For all m, n ∈ N the relation · : N × N → N is
defined by n · 1 := n and n · m0 := n · m + n. Or, in relation
notation, for all n∈ N, the relation · ⊆ (N × N) × N contains
there
the pair (n, 1), n , and
for all n, m ∈ N for which
is a
0
k ∈ N with (n, m), k ∈ · we have that (n, m ), k + n ∈ ·. The
relation (which turns out to be a binary operation) is called
multiplication.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
3. Multiplication is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we
have that (n · m) · k = n · (m · k).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
3. Multiplication is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we
have that (n · m) · k = n · (m · k).
4. Multiplication is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we
have that n · m = m · n.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
3. Multiplication is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we
have that (n · m) · k = n · (m · k).
4. Multiplication is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we
have that n · m = m · n.
5. The number 1 is a neutral element or identity element
with respect to multiplication, that is, for all n ∈ N we have
that n · 1 = 1 · n = n.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
3. Multiplication is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we
have that (n · m) · k = n · (m · k).
4. Multiplication is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we
have that n · m = m · n.
5. The number 1 is a neutral element or identity element
with respect to multiplication, that is, for all n ∈ N we have
that n · 1 = 1 · n = n.
6. Multiplication is right distributive over addition. That is,
for all n, m, k ∈ N we have (n + m) · k = n · k + m · k.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Properties of Multiplication
1. Yes, it’s a binary operation.
2. Multiplication is an abbreviation for repeated addition of a
number to itself.
3. Multiplication is associative, that is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we
have that (n · m) · k = n · (m · k).
4. Multiplication is commutative, that is, for all n, m ∈ N we
have that n · m = m · n.
5. The number 1 is a neutral element or identity element
with respect to multiplication, that is, for all n ∈ N we have
that n · 1 = 1 · n = n.
6. Multiplication is right distributive over addition. That is,
for all n, m, k ∈ N we have (n + m) · k = n · k + m · k.
The proof of the last four is a bit tricky.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Then
n(m + k)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Then
n(m + k) = (m + k) · n
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Then
n(m + k) = (m + k) · n
= mn + kn
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Then
n(m + k) = (m + k) · n
= mn + kn
= nm + nk
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
Using Properties Shortens Proofs
Proposition. Multiplication is left distributive over addition.
That is, for all n, m, k ∈ N we have n · (m + k) = n · m + n · k.
Proof. Let m, n, k ∈ N be arbitrary, but fixed. Then
n(m + k) = (m + k) · n
= mn + kn
= nm + nk
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
= ac + (bc + ad) + bd
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
= ac + (bc + ad) + bd
= ac + (ad + bc) + bd
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
= ac + (bc + ad) + bd
= ac + (ad + bc) + bd
= (ac + ad) + bc + bd
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
= ac + (bc + ad) + bd
= ac + (ad + bc) + bd
= (ac + ad) + bc + bd
= (ac + ad) + (bc + bd)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Introduction
Addition
Properties of Addition
Numerals
Multiplication
FOIL
Proposition. Let a, b, c, d ∈ N. Then
(a + b)(c + d) = (ac + ad) + (bc + bd).
Proof.
(a + b)(c + d) = (a + b)c + (a + b)d
= (ac + bc) + (ad + bd)
= (ac + bc) + ad + bd
= ac + (bc + ad) + bd
= ac + (ad + bc) + bd
= (ac + ad) + bc + bd
= (ac + ad) + (bc + bd)
Bernd Schröder
Arithmetic of Natural Numbers
logo1
Louisiana Tech University, College of Engineering and Science
Download