Triangle Comete 202 - bookshelf speakers
Small stars...
Product: Comete 202 Speakers
Producer: Triangle - France
Approximate price: 680 Euro/$ (pair)
Reviewer: Stefano Monteferri
Reviewed: April 2002
Once again on the pages of TNT-Audio, we get
ready to analyse a pair of loudspeakers produced
by Triangle Electroacoustique. The Comete 202
are one of the base products of the "Espace"
series, a complete line of speakers where you can
find bookshelf models (as the small Titus reviewed
a couple of weeks ago here on TNT-Audio),
floorstanders, subwoofers, centers and rear
channel models for Home Theatre applications.
The production of the house has one more
prestigious series, the "Universe Line", the main
technological expression of the French producer,
within which are present important floorstanding
Comete 202 with the grill removed
models, and all that is needed for the composition
of high quality Home Theatre systems.
But let's focus our attention on the small Comete 202 - the object of this test...
Description
The Comete are relatively small bookshelf speakers, with a pleasant aesthetic aspect
and a good level of finishing. The dimensions are 400 x 220 x 297 mm for height,
width and depth, for a weight of 7.5 Kg. each. The project has been developed as a
two-way configuration, bass-reflex, with the port on the front baffle.
The speaker drivers used are a woofer of about 16 cm diameter with a folded
surround suspension (PP72C), and a 2.5 cm. (TZ202) tweeter with Nextel-treated
dome, both made by Triangle. The tweeter in particular raises interest for its visual
appearance. It is lightly horn-loaded, with a "substantial" and striking (golden) phase
alignment guide, and a silver dome. The cross-over frequency is about 4.5 kHz, and
biwiring is allowed thanks to a double pair of good quality gold-plated binding posts.
The manufacturer claims a frequency response between 55Hz and 20KHz, and an
applicable maximum RMS power of 80W (160W peak). The impedance datum is
quite interesting being 8 ohm nominal with a minimum of 4 ohm, while the efficiency
is quite high for a small bookshelf loudspeaker, being 91dB (W/m).
This should provide an easy connection (load) for the majority of the amplifiers in the
market, even those low powered ones (SETs, for example). When all's been said and
done, let's discover they way it sounds...
The Sound
After a good period of break in, I began the critical listening of this interesting pair of
French speakers that, I should say, did show to be sensitive to the quality of the
"sparring" partners (associated equipment). They do not hide their desire for good
amplification with a sweet-humoured, warm and full sound in the medium range,
absolutely not aggressive on the high midrange, and with a good control in low and
midbass range.
A good quality source, with a balanced tonality and high detail retrieval will complete
the picture.
In such a configuration, the Comete 202 are in a position to show a good tonal
balance, with a warm and detail-rich sound. It is unrealistic to expect an extended
bass range, considering the physical limits of the speakers, but from where they are
able to start, these French bookshelves give back a tangible and vigorous bass.
At times, probably because the cabinets don't appear solid and non-resonant as they
should be, you have the feeling that the midbass is somehow more relentless than
necessary, but this characteristic is not serious enough to be considered a flaw.
Beautiful is the midrange, warm, relaxing and not tiring at all. The high midrange,
rather free from colourations, is correct and balanced, if held under control with
correct partnering equipment and there is no over-aggressiveness that could lend to
listening stress. The high and highest ranges appear to be very good, rich of details
and rather airy.
It is immediately self-evident the good efficiency and dynamic contrast, at high as
well as low listening levels. A good sense of realism is reached from the first listen,
making it pleasingly involving within the limits of the price range.
I think that these two aspects should be highlighted, because they show the
difference between a speaker that, otherwise sounding well, reveals at the end itself
to be quite difficult to drive and considerably cold, and another one that instead
succeeds to express with vitality and speed without necessarily being connected to a
real powerhouse of an amp.
Such consideration becomes more meaningful when you consider medium or lower
class speakers, which will be typically connected to amplifiers of the same price class
as those are not exactly monsters in terms of power output. Praise is therefore due to
the Comete 202...
I also found a creation of the virtual image that I sincerely did not expect (goodness
knows then why...). Precise, accurate, stable, perfectly focused and well sized in the
three dimensions, and indeed very enjoyable. The only advice I had to follow was
"toe in" the speakers towards the listening point, with the axis of the two tweeters
crossing a good meter before the tip of my nose.
There is a distinct sense of general airiness and clarity.
Conclusion
The Comete 202's are a pair of speakers which provide musicality without a high
price. Choose a balanced source and good quality amplification, even low power
(tube or solid state) with a sweet sound on the high midrange, and then you will be
able to enjoy many pleasant hours with your preferred music.
© Copyright 2002 Stefano Monteferri - http://www.tnt-audio.com
English translation: Andrea Nicolai - Supervisor: Tom Browne