The Competencies of Public Leadership Richard A. Couto, Carlotta Amaduzzi, Hur Hyunkang, and Niklaus Welter Burns Academy of Leadership Summary In the 1990s, the U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM) set out to refine its set of Executive Core Qualifications (ECQs). These provide guidance for the selection, training, and evaluation of executives, team leaders, managers, supervisors and staff members of federal agencies. This paper describes the development of the 27 competencies of the ECQs; explains the template of each competency; relates the OPM’s competencies to other scholarship on leadership competencies; and offers observations on some of the hidden dimensions of the competencies of effective public leadership—personal mastery, global awareness, systems thinking, and the interdependence and interrelatedness of competencies. The Formation of OPM’s Leadership Competencies In 1992, OPM conducted a survey of a sample of executives and managers of federal agencies to learn their views of the necessary leadership competencies required to lead agencies successfully. The 10,000 responses helped shape MOSAIC (Multi-Purpose Occupational Analysis Inventory Closed-Ended). Further work between 1996 and 1998, compared the results of OPM with the Competency Consortium, a group of Fortune 100 companies, and with literature on leadership. In 1998, factor analysis helped group 27 competencies into metacompetencies and focus groups refined the latter into five Executive Core Qualifications: Leading Change; Leading People; Building Coalitions/Communications; Results Driven; and Business Acumen. The 27 competencies were distributed across the ECQs. Leading change, for example, included the six competencies of “creativity and innovation,” “external awareness” “resilience,” “flexibility,” “strategic thinking,” and “vision.” Expert panels, drawn from people throughout the federal government, generated examples of effective behavioral components for each of the competencies.1 This work developed concepts and operational definitions of competencies of effective public leadership. The metacompetencies that ECQs represented had operationalized definitions as well. Leading change, involves the ability to bring about strategic change, both within and outside the organization, to meet organizational goals. Inherent to this ECQ is the ability to establish an organizational vision and to implement it in a continuously changing environment. An assumption about personal growth under girds the competencies. Leadership begins with managing oneself and then moves to the management of other realms—project, people, programs, and organizations. The steps of this “leadership journey” correlate to specific competencies in one version of OPM’s work.2 1 Brigitte W. Schay. Development of a Leadership Curriculum Competency Model. Assessing Managerial Competencies. U.S. Office of Personnel Management (n.d.). http://www.napawash.org/pc_human_resources/OPM.pdf Retrieved from the worldwide web October 27, 2007. 2 Schay. Development of a Leadership Curriculum Competency Model. Assessing Managerial Competencies. The Competencies of Public Leadership--2 Table 1 OPM’s Leadership Journey* External Awareness Vision Strategic Thinking Entrepreneurship Technology Management Manager Managing Programs Financial Management Creativity and Innovation Partnering Political Savvy Human Resource Management Supervisor Managing People Leveraging Diversity Conflict Management Service Motivation Team Building Team Leader Managing Projects Customer Service Technical Credibility Accountability Decisiveness Influencing/Negotiating Integrity/Honesty Core Managing Resilience Competencies Self Flexibility Interpersonal Skills Oral Communication Problem Solving Continual Learning Written Communication *Adapted from Brigitte W. Schay. Development of a Leadership Curriculum Competency Model. Assessing Managerial Competencies. U.S. Office of Personnel Management (n.d.), p. 40. Executive Leading Organizations Competency Curriculum Dictionary Beginning in 2000, Sandra Newkirk, formerly at FIPSE and now with OPM, and Celeste Simpkins, formerly with the American Council on Education, sought to develop a curriculum that would shape training sessions to develop each specific competency and their behavioral components. To identify the curriculum elements of competency, Newkirk and Simpkins operationalized each behavioral component further into its five contributing parts—knowledge, skill, ability, outlook, and emotional intelligence. Each of the twenty-seven competencies had four to ten behavioral components and each behavioral component was associated with one or more of five pedagogical areas. They arranged the component behaviors of each competency on a scale from entry level to senior executives—tadpoles to frogs. The curriculum thus anticipates “growing” the competencies across positions—all employees, team leaders, managers, and executives; each competency has behavioral elements specific to different levels of responsibility. The detail of this work and the effort to operationalize the competencies with behavioral components explain the use of the word “dictionary” to describe it. The OPM’s Competency Curriculum Dictionary item, Public Service Motivation, is appended and illustrates the breakdown of a competency, its operational elements and their distinguishing The Competencies of Public Leadership--3 behaviors, which are associated with knowledge, skill, ability, outlook, and emotional intelligence. This one competency description provides the template for the other competencies. By 2007, the competencies had grown to 28 with the temporary addition of emotional intelligence but shortly thereafter returned to 27. Metacompetencies, ECQs, increased from five to six by separating communication competencies from building coalitions and taking other competencies and grouping them in to Core of Foundational Competencies. Figure 2 gives the current ECQs and their constitutive competencies. Figure 2 ECQs and Constitutive Competencies ECQ’s Twenty-Seven Competencies Leading People Leading Change 1. Creativity and Innovation 2. External Awareness 3. Flexibility 4. Resilience 5. Strategic Thinking 6. Vision 1. 2. 3. 4. Conflict Management Leveraging Diversity Developing Others Team Building Business Acumen 1. Financial Management 2. Human Capital M anagement 3. Technology Management Results Driven 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Accountability Customer Services Decisiveness Entrepreneurship Problem Solving Core Competencies Building Coalitions 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Interpersonal Skills Oral Communication Continual Learning Written Communication Integrity/Honesty Public Service Motivation 1. Partnering 2. Political Savvy 3. Influencing/Negotiating An Interrelated and Interdependent Network of Competencies OPM’s work stops short of making competencies into a pre-flight check list for high flying federal executives. It suggests that any competency relates to other competencies with interdependence. This relationship and interdependence safeguard reducing public leadership competences, including interpersonal skills and integrity/honesty, into techniques. Effective financial management, for example, is connected to thirteen other competencies, some of which are “softer” rather than technical: accountability, continual learning, customer service decisiveness, entrepreneurship, influencing and negotiating, integrity and honesty, interpersonal skills, oral and written communication, problem solving, service motivation, strategic thinking, and vision. Thus each competency has multiple facets entailing other competencies of other ECQs. To stay with the financial management competency for an example, it is listed within the The Competencies of Public Leadership--4 Business Acumen ECQ. Its related competencies fall within four other ECQs—Core Competencies, Leading Change, Building Coalitions and Results Driven. Just as we may portray an individual competency with many facets, we may also describe an ECQ not only as a multi-itemed competency but as a web of inter-related competencies. Figure 3 diagrams the ECQ, its component competencies, and their inter-relationship among themselves and with other competencies. It portrays the interrelations of the three competencies within the ECQ Building Coalitions. When all other competencies are related, the Building Coalition ECQ entails not only it three specific competences—political savvy, influencing and negotiating, and partnering—but 16 of the other competencies from all five other ECQs. Four of those 16 related competencies--conflict management, emotional intelligence, oral communication, and interpersonal skills—are part of all four competencies of Building Coalitions. Figure 3 The Interrelated Competencies of Building Coalitions Corroboration and Challenge of Competencies A recent analysis of empirical studies of competencies, qualitative and quantitative, public and corporate, reinforces the work of the OPM on competencies of effective leadership. Mary Ellen The Competencies of Public Leadership--5 Joyce, of the Brookings Institution, compared OPM competencies with those of 24 other studies. She found that 19 of OPM’s competencies and their distinguishing behaviors recur frequently in the other studies. Eight of them did not appear with regularity—mention in more than two-thirds of the other studies. She also identified two competencies that occur regularly in the set of 24 studies but go without mention in the OPM 27 competencies—global awareness and selfmastery. 3 These findings of her study are represented in Figure 4. Figure 4 The Competencies of OPM and Other Recent Research Compared OPM-Emphasis Only Financial Management Technology Management Emphasis in Recent Competency Research Conflict Management External Awareness Global Awareness Self-Mastery Problem Solving Technical Credibility Written Communication HR Management Common Competencies Nineteen Competencies Common to OPM and Recent Research Vision Continual Learning Creativity/Innovation Flexibility Service Motivation Resilience Strategic Thinking Team Building Leveraging Diversity Integrity/Honesty Decisiveness Entrepreneurship Accountability Customer Service Oral Communication Partnering Interpersonal Skills Influence/Negotiating Political Savvy Source: Joyce, Developing 21st Century Public Leaders: Competency Based Executive Development. While providing corroboration of the importance of the 19 common competencies and distinguishing behaviors, Joyce’s work should not be interpreted to say that eight competencies are redundant or that two other competencies—global awareness and self-mastery—are neglected. Technology management and financial management, which are listed among the eight competencies without frequent mention in other competency studies, find mention in two-thirds of the eight studies, which Joyce used, that deal specifically with public competencies. Conflict management and external awareness find mention in one- to two-thirds of the public competency studies; more than the other studies. Technical credibility and written communication find few mentions in public competency studies. Human resource management is absent from the studies of public competencies. The infrequent, less than one-third, mention of problem solving in other 3 Mary Ellen Joyce, Developing 21st Century Public Leaders: Competency Based Executive Development. Dissertation, School of Business, George Washington University. Joyce used 27 competencies omitting emotional intelligence to create comparability of sets of competencies at the time of her study. The Competencies of Public Leadership--6 competency studies seems somewhat of a puzzle. It may be a consequence of respondents conflating creativity/initiative, a frequently mentioned competency, with problem solving. Thus, we make a case for the eight competencies highlighted by OPM but not other studies. Joyce finds global awareness and personal mastery missing from OPM’s competencies although mentioned with frequency among other studies of competencies. A search of the competency dictionary reveals, however, the frequent mention of both global awareness and personal mastery. The importance of global awareness finds mention among 10 competencies most notably external awareness, strategic thinking, and leveraging diversity. The international dimensions of effective public leadership, including communication and collaboration with international organizations, find mention in an additional five OPM competencies. Personal mastery receives extensive consideration under emotional intelligence, the competency omitted from Joyce’s study, as might be expected. Self-awareness and self-mastery are discussed within the emotional intelligence competency. Self-development and self-responsibility, in a variety of terms, are two other aspects of personal mastery that find frequent mention and attention among 24 competencies in total. The central place of self-mastery in the OPM model emerges clearly upon re-examining Shay’s outline in Table 1. At one time, OPM described core competencies as managing self and envisioned it as a necessary base from which to manage projects, people, programs, and eventually leading organizations. Managing self incorporated resilience, flexibility, problem solving, interpersonal skills, integrity/honesty, oral and written communication, and continual learning. The last five of these competencies remain within the new ECQ of Foundational or Core Competencies where they are joined by public service motivation. Competencies and the Field of Leadership Studies Not surprisingly, the ECQs and competencies reflect a range of approaches to leadership within the field of leadership studies. Some of them are technical skills—the ECQ Business Acumen, for example, includes Financial Management and Technology Management. Increasingly, the research on scholarship associates these forms of competencies as expertise and managerial skills. In addition to the familiar technical skills associated and expected of responsible leadership with authoritative positions, there are competencies that portray leadership as an art of adaptive work4 for public problem solving.5 These latter forms of leadership require the use of influence rather than authority, participation rather than command-and-control, networks rather than hierarchies, and learning rather than expertise. Most of the 27 competencies are leader-centric; they suggest a style or trait of a person— creativity, flexibility, resilience, etc., and leader-centric foci. Other competencies reflect the recent emphases in leadership research on the reflexive nature of leadership—Developing Others, Team Building, Problem Solving, for example—and values-centric foci—Vision, Public Service Motivation, and Leveraging Diversity, for example. Thus the Competency Curriculum Ronald Heifetiz, Leadership Without Easy Answers. Cambridge, Mass. Belknap Press, 1994; “The Scholarly/Practical Challenge of Leadership” in Richard A. Couto ed. Reflection on Leadership. University Press of American, 2007, pp. 31-44. 5 Barbara A. Crosby and John M. Bryson. Leadership for the Common Good: Tackling Public Problems 2nd ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2005. 4 The Competencies of Public Leadership--7 Dictionary (CCD) holds a range of recent and traditional approaches to leadership including the array of leader-, relation-, and values-centric models and theories in leadership research. By its attention to all levels of employees, the CCD also reflects another current emphasis in leadership studies, distributed leadership. Eschewing traditional distinctions of superiors and subordinates this work explains the importance of people at all levels of an organization developing and using competencies.6 Conclusion What guidance can we take from the work of OPM and others about leadership competencies? Leadership is a way of being as well as doing. It entails personal competencies of leading self that provide for a foundation of leading others, programs, and organizations effectively. Openness to learning is central to effective leadership. Leadership entails myriad perspectives—leader-, relationship-, and values-centric. Competencies of effective leadership entail these perspectives as well as attention to tasks and authority. Technical skills are necessary but not sufficient for leadership which entails adaptive work. A well-developed competency extends beyond technical skills to incorporate elements of other competencies across a range of ECQs. Any one competency appears to be a network of many interrelated and interdependent competencies. The work of the OPM finds corroboration in a metanalysis of other studies of competencies. The competencies of public leadership overlap with the competencies of the corporate sector. The competencies of the OPM and the Competency Curriculum Dictionary permit us one light to shine with the black box of leadership and other to operationalize the distinguishing behaviors associated with any individual competency. 6 Unfortunately some of this work clings to misleading terms such as followership when its intent is to emphasize shared responsibility for the achievement of common goals regardless of position or authority; cf. Riggio, Ronald, Ira Chaleff, and Jean Lipman-Bluman eds. The Art of Followership: How Great Followers Create Great Leaders and Organizations, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2008. For a classic in this area see Hirschman, Albert O. Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1970. The Competencies of Public Leadership--8 Resources Sources cited in Brigitte W. Schay. Development of a Leadership Curriculum Competency Model. Assessing Managerial Competencies. U.S. Office of Personnel Management (n.d.). http://www.napawash.org/pc_human_resources/OPM.pdf Retrieved from the worldwide web October 27, 2007. Corts, Daniel B. & Gowing, M. (1992). Dimensions of effective behavior: Executives, managers, and supervisors.(PRD-92-05). Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Personnel Management. Gregory, D & Park, R.K. (1997). Occupational study of federal executives, managers, and supervisors: An application of the multi-purpose occupational systems analysis inventory – closed ended. (PRD-92-21). Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Personnel Management. Eyde, L., Gregory, D., Muldrow, T., & Mergen, P. (1999). High-performance leaders: A Competency model.(PRDC-99-02). Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Personnel Management. Sources cited in Mary Ellen Joyce, Developing 21st Century Public Leaders: Competency Based Executive Development. Dissertation, School of Business, George Washington University, 2006. PRIVATE SECTOR, QUANTITATIVE STUDIES Bikson, Tora K., Gregory F. Treverton, Joy Moini, Gustav Lindstrom. 2003. New Challenges for International Leadership: Lessons from Organizations with Global Missions.. Rand Report. http://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/2005/MR1670.pdf Buckingham, Marcus and Curt Coffman. 1999. First, Break All the Rules: What the World's Greatest Managers Do Differently. New York: Simon & Schuster. Dalton, Maxine, Chris Ernst, Jennifer Deal, and Jean Leslie. 2002. Success for the New Global Manager: How to Work Across Distances, Countries, and Cultures. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers. The Competencies of Public Leadership--9 PRIVATE SECTOR, QUALITATIVE STUDIES NOT INCLUDED PUBLIC SECTOR, QUANTITATIVE STUDIES EMPTY SET PUBLIC SECTOR, QUALITATIVE STUDIES Goldsmith and Eggers, 2004. Governing By Network: The New Shape of the Public Sector. National Academy of Public Administration. The Competencies of Public Leadership--10 Center for Leadership Capacity Services Office of Personnel Management Competency Dictionary SERVICE MOTIVATION—Definition, Importance, Significant Elements, and Behaviors with Tables SERVICE MOTIVATION (LEADING CHANGE) Definition: Creates and sustains an organizational culture which permits others to provide the quality of service essential to high performance. Enables others to acquire the tools and support they need to perform well. Shows a commitment to public service. Influences others toward a spirit of service and meaningful contributions to mission accomplishment. . SERVICE MOTIVATION—Importance: Service Motivation is at the core of the term “Public Servant” and epitomizes what the citizenry seeks from government employees. It is evidenced in unwavering integrity and honesty, outstanding customer service that is delivered to both internal and external customers, and in commitment to the mission and role of the Agency in advancing the security and welfare of the citizenry. It is of critical importance to recommit to the core values of service motivation since public trust in the government’s ability to “do the right thing” has eroded from 63% during the Kennedy administration to only 38% in 2004. Part of that erosion is due to the perception that government is controlled by special interests. Thus a vital element of service motivation is personal responsibility on the part of all civil servants to enhance trust in the government. Civil servants must provide outstanding service that is above ideological conflict, displays continuity, spurns the undue influence of special interests, and functions effectively despite the polarization of partisan politics. SERVICE MOTIVATION—Elements A. Understand, practice and exemplify a commitment to public service including personal responsibility (accountability), outstanding customer service, unwavering honesty, high ethical standards, and a commitment to the mission and role of the Agency in advancing the security and welfare of the citizenry. (E-O) (E-S) (E-A) (EI) B. Inspire and enable others to be service oriented. (EI) (E-O) (E-A) C. Demonstrate responsiveness to the needs of the citizens of the U. S., both internal and external customers of the Agency, and public and private stakeholder. (E-K) (EI) (E-A) (E-S) D. Take personal responsibility for providing friendly, cheerful, helpful service. (EI) (E-A) (E-S) E. Be responsible stewards of the nation’s welfare and resources. F. Work with internal and external stakeholders to create a shared vision of service. (EI) (E-S) SERVICE MOTIVATION—Developmental Descriptions Employees at every level must demonstrate loyalty to the Government and citizenry by fulfilling the highest obligations of service; “meet the mission” of the Agency by providing effective, responsive, and timely service to a wide variety of constituents under conditions that may be stressful and/or lacking in special recognition; and hold themselves accountable for meeting objectives, keeping commitments and following through. They must demonstrate belief in the concept of human dignity, treating all with respect and fairness; and pursue to completion all public inquiries, requests and complaints in a timely manner. All employees should understand the role of taxes and appropriations in the funding of operations and act as “good stewards” of all public resources; correct problems promptly and non-defensively; provide helpful information to others both within and outside the government; and act in a manner that welcomes questions, inviting others to seek help. Foundational: All Employees Must: A. Demonstrate B. Inspire others to C. Demonstrate D. Take personal E. Be responsible commitment to be service oriented. responsiveness to responsibility for stewards of the public service, . . the needs of the providing friendly, nation’s welfare and commitment to the citizens of the U.S., cheerful, helpful resources. security and welfare internal and external service. of the citizenry. customers, and public and private stakeholders. Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors The Competencies of Public Leadership--11 Understands, fulfills and personifies the special mandate of public service. Demonstrates loyalty to the Government and citizens of the U.S. by fulfilling, “well and faithfully,” the highest obligations of service. Embodies the integrity and ethics expected of a public servant. Serves out of concern for the wellbeing of others and the good of our nation and communities. Finds a sense of purpose in the larger mission; can sublimate personal need for recognition and to satisfaction in the intrinsic rewards of service. Understands the larger context of one’s job, its implications, and consequences. Serves as a personal model of service to others. Is trusted by others. Is a good citizen in the workplace, of the U.S. and of the global community. Demonstrates belief in the concept of human dignity; treating all others with respect and fairness, and openly, consistently challenging bias, intolerance, and incivility. Defends what’s right with courage and fortitude. Is involved in activities and groups which enhance the quality of the workplace; is involved with Agency-sponsored community projects; takes a leadership role in own community. Acts in a manner that welcomes others’ questions and invites others to seek help; takes responsibility for mentoring junior colleagues and new employees. Neither participates in nor condones offensive or discriminatory behavior. Takes on a fair share of the work. Leaves customers feeling they have been heard, understood, respected and well served. Demonstrates empathy for customers. Understands and responds appropriately and flexibly to the differing needs of diverse internal and external customer groups. Gives clear explanations; Uses plain language to clarify needs and interests with customers. Ensures that referrals of requests or issues are made to most appropriate organizational resource and that contact instructions are clear and accurate. Understands that offering the same service, or service delivery does not ensure equality of treatment or effectiveness across circumstances. Goes the extra mile to satisfy demand within the scope of own skills and authority. Provides effective, responsive and timely service. Holds self accountable for meeting objectives and keeping commitments; follows through. Takes personal responsibility for dealing with and/or correcting customer service issues and concerns; is efficient and responsive. Follows through on customers’ questions, requests, and complaints. Gains customer confidence through competence, good communications and trust. Corrects problems promptly and without becoming defensive. Uses own time and other resources prudently and appropriately to further the goals of the Agency. Understands the role of taxes and appropriations in the funding of operations and acts in general as good stewards of all public resources. Practices efficient, effective procurement, management, application, utilization and monitoring of resources (including property, people and financial) to achieve effective service. Understands accountability in terms of results, not rules. Measures work done in output, not seat time. Actively maintains high quality skills and cutting edge knowledge. Seeks out opportunities to maximize resources. The Competencies of Public Leadership--12 Service Motivation Links for all Employees: Accountability, Customer Service, External Awareness, Financial Management, Integrity and Honesty, Partnering, Political Savvy,. Strategic Thinking, Vision, Team Leaders and Supervisors must demonstrate in word and deed that public service has an ultimate responsibility to the customer, rather than the institution; practice servant leadership within the organization, helping employees to get beyond obstacles, and enabling employees to focus on and fulfill service commitments. They create a workplace culture that fosters performance, pride and purpose; maintain clear nonbureaucratic communication with customers; support training, procedures and technology that lead to competent, reliable and appropriate service and products; actively address the roots of employee burnout, disillusionment and cynicism; and address poor performance among team and group members. Team Leaders and Supervisors Must: A. Demonstrate a B. Inspire and enables others to C. Demonstrate E. Be responsible commitment to public be service oriented. responsiveness to the stewards of the nation’s service, D. Take personal responsibility needs of the citizens of the welfare and resources. …commitment to the for providing friendly, cheerful, U.S., both internal and security and welfare of helpful service. external customers of the the citizenry. Agency, and public and private stakeholders. Distinguishing Distinguishing Behaviors Distinguishing Behaviors Distinguishing Behaviors Behaviors Communicates, and acts in concert with the understanding that public service has an ultimate responsibility to the customer, rather than the institution. Assumes personal responsibility to engender trust in government. Regularly, clearly and enthusiastically communicates to employees high expectations for good customer service. Does not sacrifice trust and integrity to expediency, even under pressure. Does not make inappropriate decisions for personal gain, to include career advancements. Uses legal and ethical standards to help Practice “servant leadership” within the organization and encourage employees, and work groups to practice a similar role in their relationships with internal and external customers. Helps employees get beyond obstacles. Does not allow the shortcomings of policy or resources to halt the work of the team. Actively combats the roots of employee burn-out, disillusionment, and cynicism. Does not confuse service with workaholism. Counsels and assists others to find a balance between commitments to the Agency and to their community and family. Enables employees to focus on and fulfill service commitments by finding and allocating resources and other needed support. Ensures that rewards are allocated for outstanding service to the public. Develops effective ways of consulting with internal and external customer groups to ensure service meets needs, to poll feedback, to develop understanding of needs and changing requirements/uses. Understands and communicates how the agency interacts with the external world; relations with the community, stakeholders, etc., and uses this knowledge in achieving results. Supports personnel-, training-, procedural- and technology strategies that ensure competent, reliable and appropriate service and products to others. Maintains clear communications with customers. Gets beyond bureaucracy, jargon and red tape in service to the customer. Measures the risks of innovation and testing against the public good, and Constitutional rights. Addresses poor performance among team and group members. Ensures the integrity of accounting and performance data through good data collection and analysis systems. Ensures appropriate oversight and control over hiring practices, procurement and contracting. Practices decision making tools that are proven to help distinguish among choices in ethical dilemmas and in weighing risk. Assumes responsibilities for The Competencies of Public Leadership--13 resolve issues of fairness, equality, and appropriate scope of services and approaches. Maintains confidentiality and protect the privacy of employees, customers, and other members of the public. Sets unit goals and develops procedures and standards dedicated to serving internal and external customers. Is able to convince others of the need for change in order to fulfill the service mission. Creates a workplace culture that fosters performance, pride and purpose. Uses input and feedback from customers and team members to anticipate and make improvements in customer service. risks taken and actions embarked upon when direction is ambiguous. Suggests different approaches for customers with diverse needs. Works closely with internal and external customers and Focuses all employees on stakeholders to ensure that improving service. all perspectives and interests are understood, Helps all employees connect the and to encourage them to organization’s mission to public make their own service. contributions to policy and process. Service Motivation Links for Team Leaders and Supervisors: Accountability, Communication, Customer Service, External Awareness, Financial Management, Human Resources Management, Influencing and Negotiating, Integrity and Honesty, Partnering, Political Savvy,. Strategic Thinking, Technical Credibility, Technical Management, Vision Managers must conduct research to determine the needs of the customer; share the research findings to ensure that resources are aligned to support initiatives, and adjust approach, plans, policy, selections and resources accordingly; and align policies and programs with the true needs of the public, They must demonstrate expertise and commitment to common goals and be recognized as a trusted advisor and partner to the customer; develop and apply metrics to monitor customer satisfaction; apply lessons to improving services; and partner with internal and external customers to enable them to see long term benefits and to identify initiatives that best fulfill the agency’s mandate of service to them. Managers Must: A. Demonstrate a B. Inspire and C. Demonstrate E. Be responsible F. Works with commitment to enable others to be responsiveness to stewards of the nation’s internal and public service, . . service oriented. the needs of the welfare and resources. external .commitment to D. Take personal citizens of the U.S., stakeholders to the security and responsibility for both internal and create and welfare of the providing friendly, external customers implement a shared citizenry. cheerful, helpful of the Agency, and vision of service. service public and private stakeholders. Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Sets high Through Strives to Looks for long-term Takes full account personal and demonstrated understand at the benefits to the of appropriate organizational expertise and broadest level the customer and adjusts issues, their standards for commitment to changing issues, approach, policy and interrelationships integrity and common goals, is needs, and resources accordingly. (also across Is able to focus the service. recognized as perspectives that organizations) and Does not yield to trusted advisor and impact the welfare efforts of the their implications pressures from any partner to the organization on the of the citizenfor achieving the quarter to act in needs of the ultimate customer. customer. Agency’s mission ways counter to Cascades strategies Discovers the needs customer, rather than on to the Public. the spirit and letter to employees and of the customers issues or tasks that seem Works to establish of the laws of the teams to build shared through research urgent, but which, given and make clear U.S. or against the understanding of the and study. Goes the customer focus, are connections The Competencies of Public Leadership--14 best interests of the links between policy, beyond” handedless important, or even between and Public. programs and public down” knowledge counter-productive. common interests Implements sound, service. and assumptions. Takes a long-term among effected research-based, Rigorously monitors Looks for perspective and weighs groups and to help program policy, customer information about true value for the citizen the discussions get programs and satisfaction, and the underlying added against mere beyond positional service that applies these lessons needs of others, efficiency. understandings of support the true to improving beyond those needs and wants. needs of the services. expressed or citizens. recognized initially. Service Motivation Links for Managers: Accountability, Communication, Continual Learning, Customer Service, Decisiveness, Emotional Intelligence, External Awareness, Financial Management, Influencing and Negotiating, Integrity and Honesty, Interpersonal Skills, Partnering, Political Savvy, Strategic Thinking, Technical Credibility, Technical Management, Vision The Federal Executive has ultimate responsibility to ensure that policies and programs work toward the best interests of the citizens of the U.S. and must demonstrate service motivation with integrity, wisdom, knowledge, fortitude, tact, and persuasiveness. The Executive must engender high levels of public trust in the government by personally embodying service to the U.S. and its citizens, and employing open, transparent, and broadly participatory processes in decision making. They do not yield to pressure to act in ways counter to the spirit and letter of the laws of the U. S. or against the best interests of the Public. The Executive should use a systems approach to be fully cognizant of appropriate issues, their interrelationships and their implications for achieving the Agency’s mission; focus all employees on improving service by clearly communicating the relationship of the organization’s mission to public service; identify, develop, execute, and assess policies, programs and services that support the broad objectives of the Agency and the true needs of the customer; and champion those issues most likely to make significant contributions to public service Executives Must: A. Demonstrate a B Inspire and C. Demonstrate E. Be responsible F. Works with internal commitment to public enable others to responsiveness to the stewards of the and external service, including be service needs of the citizens of nation’s welfare stakeholders to create personal oriented. the U.S., both internal and resources. and implement a responsibility, and external customers shared vision of outstanding customer D. Take of the Agency, and service. service, unwavering personal public and private honesty, high ethical responsibility stakeholders. standards, and for providing commitment to the friendly, security and welfare cheerful, of the citizenry. helpful service Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Distinguishing Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Behaviors Works to engender high levels of public trust in the government by exemplifying civic leadership, and employing open, transparent, and broadly participatory processes in decision making. Works to ensure the citizens service that is above ideological Communicates the public service vision of the organization. Rewards service to the public, to include championing and supporting employees who volunteer in the community. Uses a systems approach to make policy and program decisions which are aligned with the needs of the public, and are made only after considering the full impact of these decisions on the public. Exposes the implications of choice to all stakeholders in an unbiased fashion. Selects to champion Shares insights and research findings in tactful, but persuasive ways to ensure that resources are aligned behind initiatives that truly benefit the citizens of the U.S. Expends resources to ensure an adequate evidence base is available Sees service from a systems perspective and works to align all stakeholders’ efforts towards integrated programs, shared knowledge, and mutual understanding of common interests. Partners with internal and external customers in a way that enables them to see long term benefits and to find The Competencies of Public Leadership--15 conflict, and undue influence of special interests. Buffers important civic goals against political polarization. Ensures that plans, resources, priorities, and human capital strategies reflect the organization’s focus on citizen-centered service. those issues most likely to make the most significant contribution to Public service. Acts on independent, but factually-based opinion, e.g. recommends approaches which are new and different from those requested by either sponsors or even by the customer, if these approaches seem to better meet the customer’s actual and long-term needs. to support plans and decisions. initiatives that best fulfill the Agency’s mandate of service to them. Promotes policy, programs and perspectives serve the best interests of the people of the U.S., rather than serving the organization. Is willing to go out on a limb personally to persuade policy makers to support the direction most likely to achieve the mission of the Agency and the greatest Public good. Service Motivation Links for Executives: Accountability, Communication, Continual Learning, Customer Service, Emotional Intelligence, External Awareness, Financial Management, Human Resources Management, Influencing and Negotiating, Integrity and Honesty, interpersonal Skills, Partnering, Political Savvy, Strategic Thinking, Technical Credibility, Technical Management, Vision