ITE Session: Multi-Ethnic Britain Session Leader’s Notes Introduction This two and a half hour ITE session relates to teaching about the multiethnic nature of Britain through time, and is suitable for student teachers/trainees preparing to teach History or Citizenship at KS2-4 The session aims to: Offer opportunities to work towards the standards for QTS; Work within the National Strategy frameworks; Support the recommendations of the ‘Macpherson Report’ (HMSO 1999): the inquiry into the death of Stephen Lawrence, which called upon educators to challenge racism and develop anti racist approaches to teaching and learning; Introduce subject knowledge and key issues relating to the multiethnic nature of Britain over time. Student teachers/trainees follow an activity intended for a KS3 classroom, and work with the material produced for young people. They are given the opportunity to consider the activities offered, develop and extend their own subject knowledge and can discuss the issues arising from the session. Dr. Dean Smart Faculty of Education, University of the West of England, Bristol 1 ITE Session: Multi-Ethnic Britain Session Leaders Notes Dr. Dean Smart, Faculty of Education, University of the West of England, Bristol Focus To consider the nature of multiethnic Britain over a long historical time frame To provide opportunities for trainee teachers to develop their subject knowledge, consider approaches to teaching about ethnic diversity and multicultural histories, and to consider inclusive approaches to History and Citizenship education About This Session This two and a half hour ITE session relates to the multiethnic nature of Britain through time, and is suitable for student teachers/trainees preparing to teach History or Citizenship at KS3-4 History unit. The session aims to: Introduce subject knowledge and key issues relating to the multiethnic nature of Britain over time- and therefore support teaching and learning related to ethnic diversity within Britain; Offer opportunities to work towards the standards for QTS; Work within the National Strategy frameworks; Support the recommendations of the ‘Macpherson Report,’ (HMSO 1999) the inquiry into the death of Stephen Lawrence, which called upon educators to challenge racism and develop anti-racist approaches to teaching and learning. Student teachers/trainees follow a scheme of work intended for a KS3/4 classroom, and work with the material produced for young people. They are given the opportunity to consider the activities offered, develop and extend their own subject knowledge and can discuss the issues arising from the session. Prior Learning Some students may mistakenly think that immigration into Britain is only a twentieth century phenomena, whereas there has been a constant movement into and out of Britain through time. It is also possible that negativity towards migrants and asylum seekers will have been fostered, even amongst members of the ethnic minority communities, by biased and incorrect press reportage and politicised positioning in the media. Other students, for example those that are better read, attend community Saturday or evening schools, may have a very developed awareness of the history of particular communities in Britain- or an overview of multiethnic and ‘Black’ British history. Research by the author of this material shows that current mainstream History textbooks generally represent relatively little ethnic diversity when telling the story of British History and ethnic minorities largely in connection with a limited range of historical themes at KS3 and 4, for example Empire and slave trade narratives only at KS3. Some Citizenship textbooks give a little coverage to ethnic diversity over time but more often are shallow in their coverage of this issue, and concentrate largely on diversity in modern Britain. As a result teachers and pupils are unlikely to have problematised the narratives with which they are presented. For many teachers and pupils there will be a heavy emphasis on ‘White’ British, and within that ‘White’ Southern English, History. 2 This picture of a homogeneous, mono-ethnic Britain/England is, of course not entirely true, although the twentieth century did see significant numbers of incomers from the British Empire, the New Commonwealth and elsewhere, moistly recently from the European Union. Addressing Multiethnic Histories Britain has been a multiethnic group of islands for many centuries. Archaeological evidence shows that there were African and Mediterranean, Western and Northern European traders, travellers and soldiers and their families in Britain during the Roman occupation. Other evidence demonstrates that British history has been a constant story of incomers, of immigration and emigration. This session introduces trainees to this story in overview. 3 Teaching Activities: Session Leader’s Notes Activity One: ‘Starter’ Activity This short activity is based on establishing what people know about the multiethnic nature of modern Britain. It is based on the 2001 Census figures, and people’s estimation of how the UK population is formed in terms of ethnicity. Participants should be given the Population sheet and should ‘best guess’ the percentage for each category. You should keep the answers hidden only revealing them when you have discussed with participants what their answers were- and what this might tell you about their preconceptions about the nature of the British population, and what informs their opinions. It is my experience that people wildly over-estimated the percentage of ethnic minority origin citizens in the UK, often because of the way that newspapers present issues of immigration, economic migration/guest and seasonal workers and race/ethnicity. Often key groups are over- or under-estimated in the calculations of individuals depending on where in the UK they live, and their experience of urban and rural living- for example those from some urban areas may have experienced life in multiethnic communities and others will have lived in largely mono-cultural and homogeneous groups. As with many activities the discussion is key, and should be sensitively and carefully handled. For this reason ensure that you think through the population figures carefully and anticipate the reactions of your group and the way the discussion is likely to develop. 4 Starter Activity Answer Instructions 1. Take the blank version of the starter activity and distribute them, one grid per person/group (there are two on an A4 sheet to make them more economical to copy!) 2. As individuals, or small groups, write in what you think is the ethnic mix, in terms of % of modern Britain. 3. Most respondents get their estimate wildly wrong- thinking there are a lot more people from ethnic minorities in the UK than the reality, and getting the distributions wrong also! Discuss why this is the case and any emergent issues. Answer: Ethnic Origins of the British Population: 2001 Ethnic group (ethnic groups as defined by Office of National Statistics, UK Government) % of England % of Wales White British 86.99 95.99 White Other 2.66 1.28 Asian 4.57 0.88 Mixed 1.31 0.61 White Irish 1.27 0.61 Black Caribbean 1.14 0.09 Black African 0.97 0.13 Chinese 0.45 0.22 Other 0.44 0.18 Source: 2001 Census Online Table KS06 OR….. If it helps to work in numbers of people rather than the more abstract % of population there are roughly 60 million Britons- of which 50 million are English and 3 million are Welsh: Office of National Statistics: The mid-2004 population of the constituent countries of the United Kingdom is estimated as follows: 5 Activity Material Starter Activity Task Ethnic Origins of the British Population: 2001 Ethnic Groups in the UK % of England % of Wales (ethnic groups as defined by Office of National Statistics, UK Government) White Ethnic Minority Asian Caribbean Chinese Mixed Other White Starter Activity Task Ethnic Origins of the British Population: 2001 Ethnic Groups in the UK % of England (ethnic groups as defined by Office of National Statistics, UK Government) White Ethnic Minority Asian Caribbean Chinese Mixed Other White 6 % of Wales Activity Two: Sequencing Activity Session Leaders Notes This activity is designed to challenge participants to think about how much they know about ethnicity in Britain over a long time period. Participants need to: Work in groups Be given a timeline, which runs from 0 BC to Now, and a set of sorting cards Discuss and agree any decisions about placing the cards on the timeline in the correct places The cards show different ethnic groups and each should be placed on the timeline carefully. Groups must be able to justify why they placed a particular card at the point they have chosen (some will struggle to give a coherent reason or specific date). More than one version of the timeline is provided to give you a choice- enlarging the sheet onto A3 with a photocopier is a good idea! A Note on Dates The timeline has the centuries listed in a lighter font to help pupils recognition of which centuries date fall within and to support their understanding of chronology. If you feel that you would like to remove this text- please do so! Some teachers prefer to add CE (Common Era) or BCE (Before Common Era) after year numbers so that it is clear that respect for other systems/religions is indicated rather than using the Christian 2007 AD – thus 2007 CE. This is because the numbers used for years commonly used in the Americas, Australasia, Western Europe and the UK are based on the development of the medieval Julian and more recent Gregorian calendar years – a form of the Christian calendar. BC and AD are often written after a date, representing Before Christ (BC) and Anno Domini (AD), meaning ‘In the year of our Lord’ (years since the birth of Jesus). Asian, Jewish and Islamic calendars use different year numbering systems, for example- the Islamic calendar gives a date of 1428 H or AH instead of 2007 (The letters H or AH after a date indicate the initials of the Latin Anno Hegirae: in the year of the Hijra.) - the Jewish calendar has years which begin in the Western European Autumn 3761 years ahead of the Western date (thus Autumn 2007 is the Jewish year 5768. For more information see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calendar_era http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_calendars 7 Activity Two Sorting Cards Timeline ANSWERS: (In same order as card set): Late 11th century onwards: Jewish merchants and money lenders 16th century: Dutch Protestants 5th century A.D.: Post-1066: 2nd century A.D. Norman Knights, their men and followers The African Legion of the Roman Army 1562 onwards, 1685 onwards: 1880s, 1903-6: Jewish refugees fleeing Russian/Polish pogroms 19th century: Huguenot refugees from France 17th century: Anglo-Saxons Dutch drainage and canal engineers 19th century: 1933-1939: German economic migrants 16th century onwards: Lascars (Muslim seamen) 16th century onwards: Africans: sailors, servants and the enslaved 1790s: Irish Navies digging canals and building railways 1939-1945: French refugees during ‘The Terror’ Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany Polish exiles during the Second World War Passengers on the s.s. Empire Windrush from the Caribbean 1939-1945: 8th century A.D.: 1840s onwards, 1950s &1960s: 1914-1918: Empire and Commonwealth Forces during the Second World War Vikings 16th century: 1948: Chinese settlers Empire Forces during the Great War 1972: 1990s: 1996: Romani Asians expelled by the Dictator Idi Amin in Uganda Evacuees from Montserrat 1994: 1991: Refuges and Asylum seekers from Bosnia and Kosovo 1950s and 1960s: Refuges and Asylum seekers from Rwanda Refuges and Asylum seekers from Somalia Workers from India and Pakistan Migrant workers from within the European Union Late 20th century: …..and continuously….the Scots, the Irish, the Welsh- the people the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands- and English migrants 8 Activity Two Sorting Cards Timeline ANSWERS: (Cards in chronological order) 2nd century A.D. 5th century A.D.: 8th century A.D.: Post-1066: The African Legion of the Roman Army Anglo-Saxons Vikings Late 11th century onwards: 16th century onwards: 1562 onwards, 1685 onwards: Norman Knights, their men and followers 16th century: Africans: sailors, servants and the enslaved Huguenot refugees from France 16th century onwards: 17th century: 1790s: Dutch drainage and canal engineers French refugees during ‘The Terror’ 1840s, 1950s & 1960s: 1880s, 1903-6: Jewish merchants and money lenders 16th century: Romani 19th century: Lascars (Muslim seamen) 19th century: Dutch Protestants Irish Navies digging canals and building railways 1914-1918: German economic migrants Chinese Settlers Jewish refugees fleeing Russian/Polish pogroms 1933-1939: 1939-1945: 1939-1945: Empire Forces during the Great War Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany Polish exiles during the Second World War Empire and Commonwealth Forces during World War Two 1948: 1950s and 1960s: 1972: 1990s: Asians expelled by the Dictator Idi Amin in Uganda Refuges and Asylum seekers from Bosnia and Kosovo 1996: Late 20th century: Passengers on the s.s. Empire Windrush from the Caribbean 1991: Refuges and Asylum seekers from Somalia Workers from the CommonwealthIndia, Pakistan, the Caribbean 1994: Refuges and Asylum seekers from Rwanda Evacuees from Montserrat Migrant workers from within the European Union …..and continuously….the Scots, the Irish, the Welsh- the people the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands- and English migrants 9 Activity Two Materials: Sorting Cards for Timeline Jewish merchants and money lenders Norman Knights, their men and followers The African Legion of the Roman Army Dutch Protestants Huguenot refugees from France Africans: sailors, servants and the enslaved Anglo-Saxons Dutch drainage and canal engineers Jewish refugees fleeing Russia/Polish pogroms Irish Navies digging canals and building railways German economic migrants Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany Polish exiles during the Second World War Passengers on the s.s. Windrush from the Caribbean Empire and Commonwealth Forces during World War Two Vikings Chinese Settlers Empire Forces during the Great War Romani Asians expelled by the Dictator Idi Amin in Uganda Refuges and Asylum seekers from Bosnia and Kosovo Evacuees from Montserrat Refuges and Asylum seekers from Rwanda Refuges and Asylum seekers from Somalia Workers from the CommonwealthIndia, Pakistan, the Caribbean Migrant workers from within the European Union 10 Lascars (Asian and Muslim seamen) French refugees during ‘The Terror’ Activity Two: Timeline (Version A) 0 1000 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 11 Activity Two: Timeline (Version B) 0 100 1st century CE 1000 2nd century CE 1100 11th century CE 200 3rd century CE 1200 12th century CE 300 4th century CE 1300 13th century CE 400 5th century CE 1400 14th century CE 500 6th century CE 1500 15th century CE 12 600 7th century CE 1600 16th century CE 700 8th century CE 1700 17th century CE 800 900 9th century CE 1800 18th century CE 1000 10th century CE 1900 19th century CE 2000 20th century CE Activity Two: Timeline (Version C) 0 100 1st century CE 200 2nd century CE 300 3rd century CE 400 4th century CE 500 5th century CE 600 6th century CE 700 7th century CE 800 8th century CE 900 9th century CE 1000 10th century CE Dark Ages, 5th – 10th centuries Anglo-Saxons / Anglo-Celtic Britain 5th Century - 1066 Roman Occupation 43 – 410 1000 1100 11th century CE 1200 12th century CE 1300 13th century CE 1400 14th century CE 1500 15th century CE 1600 16th century CE 1700 17th century CE 1800 18th century CE 1900 19th century CE 20th century CE Georgians 1714 - 1837 Normans / Middle Ages / Plantaganets 1066- 1485 Tudors 1485 - 1603 Stuarts 1603 - 1714 13 2000 Victorians 1837-1901 Activity Three: Research Activity Session Leaders Notes This activity is planned as a way of extending and consolidating subject knowledge and of sharing information. Participants will research one or more of the groups listed during the sorting activity and collaborate to make a large wall display showing the multiethnic nature of Britain throughout history. I recommend that participants are given ‘Success Criteria’ for this exercise and a time limit. Ideally criteria will be phrased in a positive way. See if you can think of ways to reword some of the negative statements in the example below To be successful in this activity you must… Work individually/in collaborative groups (?) Use XXXX amount of wall space Not just use things copied out from books Use no more than XXXX amount of materials/colours/media/fonts Mention no less than XXXX number of different groups of incomers Stimulate, amuse and educate your intended audience Provide a clear sense of chronology, and include a timeline, which runs from ‘0 BCE to Now’ You can decide how prescriptive you wish to be and what will encourage or stifle a creative response! Differentiating this exercise This is a very open ended display task and in a classroom there would be a risk that not all pupils would engage with the task and settle into research, extrapolation and synthesis activities. For all young people to respond to the challenges present in this activity consider: Whether having a simply worded, clear written instruction sheet might add clarity- this mightinclude the success criteria, the time limit and a very clear statement of how you will be assessing group and individual contributions. You could differentiate byHaving different versions of the task sheet, some of which have clear step by step instructions, perhaps with questions related to specific sources Providing some simple source and stimulus materials for certain pupils, whilst others are provided with more generalised reference sources, and the most able are allowed to choose whether they wish to use provided materials or seek their own and apply critical judgements about their value, utility and reliability. You could brief other adults and parents/carers about the research task to help them support the research activity and ask for guided support and encouragement. You could provide a bank of images and visual stimulus materials for learners who like to engage with such stimulus, and to support the production of an attractive and visually engaging finish ‘product’. You could create your stimulus materials using a variety of media, for example printed/photocopied sheets, text books and online materials CD ROMs of stimulus materials 14 which pupils could take away, downloadable files on the school/department website including sound/MP3 or podcast files, video files and so on. You might allow some pupils who are comfortable working in multimedia to create elements of their display in a variety of media. For example on the next two pages I have provided a sample instruction sheet at two different levels of ‘scaffolding’. You could adapt the days/deadlines to your own circumstances. 15 Materials: Activity Three, Research Task (Version 1) Multi-ethnic Britain Display: Success Criteria Target: We are going to produce an attractive, interesting and informative wall display which tells the story of Britain’s multiethnic past. This should be completed within a time limit and be ready for us to evaluate during Friday’s lesson. Success Criteria To be successful in this activity you must Take part in the whole class discussion when we discuss the overall plan for the wall display Work in pairs on the specific section of the timeline that you are given Complete your assigned task by the deadline Design interesting, attractive and informative materials to place in the wall space that you have been given Produce original text Mount your work using the two different backing colours provided Use Comic Sans Font size 14 for main text and size 20 for title Sources: You can use - the book box - the folder of sources and photocopies - reliable internet sources - materials which you track down, for example from libraries and other places Timing: TWO LESSONS AND ONE HOMEWORK You have one classroom based lesson for planning and researching, draft copy writing and editing. There will be a book box and folders of research materials available. You have one lesson in the ICT room for internet research and typing. I will be in the ICT room on Tuesday and Wednesday during the second half of lunchtime and after school to help anyone who is working on this task. The helpers in Homework Club have also been given information about this work and how they can help. The display will be put up on Thursday after school- volunteer helpers welcome! 16 Materials: Activity Three, Research Task (Version 2) Multi-ethnic Britain Display: Success Criteria What Are We Doing Today? We will do the research to produce a wall display about the people who came into Britain over the last two thousand years. The aim is to create something which looks good and is interesting and accurate. We have two lessons and one homework to get the work done: The first lesson is in our classroom The second lesson is in the ICT room What Are We Looking For? To be successful in this activity you must Join in when we talk about the overall plan for the wall display Work with a partner on your display section Make sure that your work fits in the space available Stick to the presentation rules we agreed when we planned together Finish by the end of school on Thursday and give in the work so it can be put on the wall Use your own words and be interesting and accurate Include one or more pictures if you wish Join in when we judge the quality of the work on Friday, and say what you liked about the overall display, and what you would change about your work. Where Do I Get Help? I will be in the ICT room on Tuesday and Wednesday at Lunchtime (after 1 O’clock) and from 3.40-4.30 The Homework Club helpers also know about this task and can help. I will put up the display on Thursday after schoolif you want to help please ask the people at home if you can stay so they know where you will be/what time you will get home! 17