Fifth International Symposium on Process Organization Studies
Theme: The Emergence of Novelty in Organizations
20-22 June 2013
Minoa Palace Resort & Spa, Chania, Crete, Greece
Conveners:
Raghu Garud, Penn State University, USA
Barbara Simpson, University of Strathclyde, UK
Ann Langley, HEC Montreal, Canada
Haridimos Tsoukas, University of Cyprus, Cyprus & University of Warwick, UK
Hosted By
In cooperation with
1
Timetable
Wednesday, June 19th 2013
18:00-21:00: Registration & Reception Imperial Lobby, Minoa Palace
21:00-24:00: Dinner, Elia Restaurant, Minoa Palace
Thursday, June 20th 2013
Friday, June 21st 2013
08:45-09:00: Welcome by the conveners
09:00-10:00: Keynote Address:
Suzanne Guerlac, University of California (Berkeley),
The emergence of time/ the time of emergence: A Bergsonian perspective
(Room Imperial)
10:00-10:30: Coffee Break
10:30-13:00: Parallel Sessions
13:00-14:30: Lunch (Elia Restaurant)
14:30-16:00: Parallel Sessions
16:00-16:30: Coffee Break
16:30-18:00: Parallel Sessions
20:30-23:00: Dinner “Mylos tou Kerata”
Saturday,
09:00-10:00: Keynote Address:
Deborah Dougherty, Rutgers Business School
Taking Advantage of Emergence (Room Imperial)
10:00-10:30: Coffee Break
10:30-12:30: Parallel Sessions
12:30-13:30: Roundtable Discussions
13:30-14:00: Reflections on Symposium & Announcement of PROS 2014
(Room Imperial)
14:00-15:00: Lunch (Elia Restaurant)
09:00-10:00: Keynote Address:
Jaan Valsiner, Aalborg University & Clark University
Negotiating change: How novelty can be analyzed from the perspective of cultural
psychology of semiotic dynamics? (Room Imperial)
10:00-10:30: Coffee Break
10:30-13:00: Parallel Sessions
13:00-14:30: Lunch (Elia Restaurant)
14:30-16:00: Parallel Sessions
16:00-16:30: Coffee Break
16:30-18:00: Parallel Sessions
20:30-23:00: Greek night Buffet & Music, Corali seaside restaurant, Minoa Palace
June 22nd 2013
17:00* : Departure for symposium Group Excursion (Paths of Cretan
tradition) on Cretan culture with Wine tasting and evening BBQ buffet, in
the green yards of the Dourakis Countryside Winery, escorted by Creta
Brass Jazz Quintet.
* (this is an optional excursion, please contact
process.symposium@gmail.com if you want to take part in it and you have not
signed up already)
2
Thursday, June 20th – 10:30-13:00, Parallel Tracks
Room Imperial: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries
Chair:
Raghu Garud
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Natalya Sergeeva
PROS-099
Understanding novelty through the simultaneity of multiple processes
11:00-11:30
Maarten Janssen and Annemiek Stoopendaal
PROS-019
How to organize for novelty in a complex and multidisciplinary care setting
11:30-12:00
Winston Kwon and Panos Constantinides
PROS-044
Pests, winemakers and consultants: Old and New World wines and the emergence of novelty
12:00-12:30
Jeanne Mengis, Davide Nicolini, and Jacky Swan
PROS-035
Integrating Knowledge And Drawing Boundaries In The Face Of Novelty
12:30-13:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 1: Processes of Innovation
Chair:
Name
10:30-11:00
Karen L Janssen, Vera Blazevic, Kristina Lauche, and Allard
van Riel
PROS-051
Orchestrating mechanisms for sustainable innovation
11:00-11:30
Lara Pecis & Nikiforos Panourgias
PROS-067
Innovation in the making: performative dimensions of the innovation process
11:30-12:00
Philippe Lorino, Marie-Léandre Gomez, and Bernard Blanc
PROS-082
Social innovation as an abductive and dialogical process. Case study: planning a new urban area
12:00-12:30
Code
Barbara Simpson
Time
Title
Discussion
Room Imperial 2: Organizational Change and Becoming
Chair: Dvora Yanow
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Alain Guiette and Koen Vandenbempt
PROS-074
Dynamics of change recipient sensemaking during strategic change implementation. A mindful
organizing process perspective
11:00-11:30
Reut Livne-Tarandach
PROS-084
Change Resurrected: How and Why Change Initiatives Re-emerge?
11:30-12:00
Rene Wiedner, Michael Barrett, and Eivor Oborn
PROS-110
The Evolution of Inter-Organizational Practices during Periods of Organizational Transition
12:00-12:30
Kätlin Pulk
PROS-026
Social space and temporality: understanding organizational change
12:30-13:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 3: Agency and the Creation of Novelty
Chair: Hari Tsoukas
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Aris Komporozos-Athanasiou and Marianna Fotaki
Mar Pérezts, Xavier Philippe, Sébastien Picard, and Véronique
Steyer
PROS-020
Castoriadian Imagination and the theorization of Organizational Creativity
PROS-042
“Institutions abhor a vacuum”: The role of the imaginary in institutionalization processes
11:30-12:00
Tor Hernes and Majken Schultz
PROS-069
Historicizing novelty in the flow of time
12:00-12:30
Brigid Carroll and Helen Nicholson
PROS-086
Brokering Agency: Leading in-between Routine and Novelty
11:00-11:30
12:30-13:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 4: A Process Perspective on Organizations and Management
Chair: Nick Llewellyn
Time
Name
Code
10:30-11:00
Chrysavgi Sklaveniti
Alexandra Lai, Harald Tuckermann, Matthias Mitterlechner,
and Johannes Rüegg-Stürm
PROS-034
Exploring leadership as an emergent process of co-creation
PROS-059
The role of textual artifacts in the process of reorganizing a leadership constellation
11:30-12:00
Ricardo Azambuja and Gazi Islam
PROS-076
Middle Managers as Boundary Subjects: Managerial Subjectivity and Multiple Identifications
12:00-12:30
Lyndon Garrett, Peter Bacevice, and Gretchen Spreitzer
PROS-158
Working alone together: Socially constructing communities in order to thrive as independent workers
11:00-11:30
12:30-13:00
Title
Discussion
3
Thursday, June 20th – 14:30-18:00, Parallel Tracks
Room Imperial: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries
Chair: Philippe Lorino
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Marie-José Avenier, Muayyad Jabri, and Jenny Helin
PROS-033
Morin meets Bakhtin: the role of disruptions in the emergence of novelty
15:00-15:30
Iain Munro
PROS-037
Organizational Novelty as a Vector of Deterritorialization: the case of WikiLeaks
15:30-16:00
Fabio James Petani and Jeanne Mengis
PROS-136
Space as a processual test: novelty emergence (and submergence) seen through absent spaces
PROS-032
Citizen social science – A methodology to facilitate and examine the emergence of novelty in
organisations
16:00-16:30
16:30-17:00
Coffee Break
Ann Dadich
17:00-17:30
Discussion
Room Imperial 1: Processes of Innovation
Chair: Kyriakos Kyriakopoulos
Time
Name
Code
14:30-15:00
Evangelia Baralou and Georgios Vardaxoglou
PROS-104
15:00-15:30
Ann-Charlotte Teglborg
PROS-021
15:30-16:00
Michael Barrett, Eivor Oborn, Wanda Orlikowski, and Anna
Kim
PROS-116
16:00-16:30
Title
Serious Games for Serious Innovation. A process approach
Are management apparatuses the faithful servants of managerial innovations? A process perspective
to inscribe management apparatuses within a learning loop.
Reconfiguring Boundaries and Spaces in Innovation: The Development of Mobile Services in SubSaharan Africa
Coffee Break
16:30-17:00
Anne-Laure Fayard, Emmanouil Gkeredakis, and Natalia Levina
PROS-123
17:00-17:30
Tuomo Eloranta and Tea Lempiälä
PROS-150
The Dynamics of Stances on Innovation: Insights from studying innovation consultancies and emerging
forms of crowdsourcing innovation
Complex Temporalities and Competing Rhythms - Different Temporal Orientations Of Idea
Development In a Financial Service Organization
17:30-18:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 2: Routines and Novelty
Chair: Hari Tsoukas
Time
Name
Code
14:30-15:00
Robin Holt, Joep Cornelissen, and Mike Zundel
PROS-133
Developing a processual understanding of organizational routines: Bateson, flexibility and acclimation
15:00-15:30
Katharina Dittrich, Stéphane Guérard, and David Seidl
PROS-025
Embedding Routines in Repertoires: How Context influences the Persistence and Change of Routines
15:30-16:00
Luisa Errichiello, Francesco Zirpoli, and Markus Becker
PROS-168
Organizational routines, practice and the emergence of service innovation
16:00-16:30
Title
Coffee Break
16:30-17:00
Conor Horan and John Finch
PROS-107
Disentnagling Knowledge Creating Characterisitics In Organisational Routines: Guiding And
Clarification As A Source Of Emerging Novelty
17:00-17:30
Fleur Deken, Paul R. Carlile, Hans Berends, and Kristina Lauche
PROS-113
How Routines Afford And Constrain The Incorporation And Generation Of Novelty
17:30-18:00
Discussion
4
Room Imperial 3: Agency and the Creation of Novelty
Chair: Jacky Swan
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Raghu Garud, Peter Karnøe, and Rajiv Nag
PROS-052
Micro-Processes Of Agency In Emergent Situations
15:00-15:30
Duncan Pelly
PROS-106
Denial of Novelty Through Refusal of Creation ex Nihilo
15:30-16:00
Sophie Mützel
PROS-064
Newness and collaborative category construction from stories
16:00-16:30
Coffee Break
16:30-17:00
Håvard Åsvoll
PROS-004
Perspectives on reflection and intuition in management research - Towards developing a framework of
reflective-intuition knowing
17:00-17:30
Steven Cronshaw
PROS-028
Shared intuition as a source of organizational novelty
17:30-1800
Discussion
Room Imperial 4: A Process Perspective on Organizations and Management
Chair: Roger Dunbar
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Cynthia Hardy and Steve Maguire
PROS-006
Ecologies of Risk: Synergies, Antagonisms and the Social Construction of Risk
15:00-15:30
Hikari Akizawa
PROS-164
How are new business practices discovered?
15:30-16:00
Yuan Li
PROS-141
The Role of Controversy in Institutionalization: Elite, Presumption, and the Construction of China’s
Stock Market
16:00-16:30
Coffee Break
16:30-17:00
Poul Houman Andersen and Susanne Åberg
PROS-103
Sideshows and Main Attractions at CERN - A scientific organization’s endeavor to maintain legitimacy
17:00-17:30
Harald Tuckermann, Alexandra Lai, Matthias Mitterlechner,
and Johannes Rüegg-Stürm
PROS-109
"Bootstrapping" To Handle The Decision-Making Paradox In Pluralistic Organizations
17:30-18:00
Discussion
5
Friday, June 21st – 10:30-13:00, Parallel Tracks
Room Imperial: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries I
Chair: Sarah Dodd
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Isabelle Bouty and Marie-Léandre Gomez
Kyriakos Kyriakopoulos
PROS- 012
PROS- 038
Creativity At Work: Generating Useful Novelty In Organizations
11:00-11:30
11:30-12:00
Ann Charlotte Thorsted
PROS- 105
Play-community – a collective unfolding
Tamar Sagiv, Israel Drori, and Allegre Hadida
PROS- 010
From the core to the periphery: Organizational renewal processes of novelty generation in dance groups
12:00-12:30
12:30-13:00
Does improvisation foster creativity in new product development?
Discussion
Room Imperial 1: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries II
Chair: Raghu Garud
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Marja Turunen
Benoît Tricard
PROS-149
PROS- 130
The Emergence of the Collective Intelligence Fields as a Source for Novelty Processes
11:00-11:30
Robert P. Gephart, Roy Suddaby, Maxim Ganzin, and Cagri Topal
PROS- 171
Building a “bitumen bubble”: Novel discourse, temporal sensemaking and institutional legitimation
PROS- 170
Understanding the development of new corporate ventures: Liminality, struggle and emanicipation in
the emergence of a novel organisational project.
11:30-12:00
12:00-12:30
Richard Tunstall
12:30-13:00
Novelty emergence versus stable classes of meaning
Discussion
Room Imperial 2: A Process Perspective on Organizations and Management
Name
10:30-11:00
Nick Llewellyn
PROS-117
‘Two please, one oldie’: the age problem in service interactions
11:00-11:30
Berber Pas and Dirk Vriens
PROS-127
Noblesse Oblige: how systems for accountability affect trust among professionals
11:30-12:00
Laura Mitchell
PROS-126
“You won’t find dignity here!” Applying membership to highlight dignity as process
12:00-12:30
Gino Cattani, Roger Dunbar, and Zur Shapira
PROS-144
The emergence of authenticity: The case of Steinway pianos
12:30-13:00
Code
Chair: Lyndon Garrett
Time
Title
Discussion
Room Imperial 3: Process and Practice Perspectives on Strategy and the Firm
Chair: Mike Zundel
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Catherine Maritan and Margaret Peteraf
PROS-060
Studying Process to Understand Dynamic Capabilities
11:00-11:30
Hille Bruns and Jörgen Sandberg
PROS-047
Toward a practice-based theory of the firm
11:30-12:00
Paula Jarzabkowski and Carola Wolf
PROS-100
Strategy Making As Interplay Between Practical Coping And Proactive Coping
12:00-12:30
Poul Houman Andersen and Lars Esbjerg
PROS-089
Weaving a Strategy and Business Model for a Base-of-the-Pyramid Market: The Case of Grundfos
LIFELINK
12:30-13:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 4:Creative Collaboration
Chair: Martin Duffy
Time
Name
Code
10:30-11:00
Esther Maier and Oana Branzei
PROS-087
Balancing Acts: Dynamic Tensions between Creativity and Control in Large Scale Collaborative Projects
11:00-11:30
Samantha Harpley and Gary Buttriss
PROS-098
Brokering in Dynamic Front-end Innovation Collaborations: A Process Approach
11:30-12:00
Sarah Harvey and Chia-yu Kou-Barrett
PROS-081
Team Crafting: Ideas As Organizing Mechanisms For Teams
12:00-12:30
Clare Mumford
PROS-022
The Creation - and Creativity - of Silence in Project Team Working
12:30-13:00
Title
Discussion
6
Friday, June 21st – 14:30-18:00, Parallel Tracks
Room Imperial: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries I
Chair: Natalya Sergeeva
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Sarah Drakopoulou Dodd
PROS-111
The Creative Industries as a Site of Institutional Novelty. Punk Rock and Guerilla Separatism
15:00-15:30
Sally Davenport, U. Daellenbach, Shirley Leitch, and J.Motion
PROS-008
Creating Niches as Novelty and Opportunity
15:30-16:00
Thomas Paris, Gerald Lang, and David Masse
PROS-003
Challenging The Rules To Drive Emergence Of Novelty: The Case Of An Entrepreneur In The Perfume
Industry
16:30-17:00
Matthew Grimes and Elizabeth Lingo
PROS-073
The Socialization of Entrepreneurs: Toward a Theory of Entrepreneurial Identity Bandwidth
17:00-17:30
Tuomas Kuronen
PROS-115
Alchemy and bricolage
16:00-16:30
Coffee Break
17:30-18:00
Discussion
Room Imperial 1: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries II
Time
Name
Code
14:30-15:00
Pete Thomas and Judi Morgan
PROS-122
15:00-15:30
Victoria von Groddeck & Julia Feiler
PROS-181
15:30-16:00
Brian Bloomfield, Yvonne Latham, and Theo Vurdubakis
PROS-132
16:00-16:30
16:30-17:00
Chair: Tor Hernes
Title
‘Always different, always the same’ – the discursive construction of novelty and routine in
organizations
Narrating Novelty and Its Effects on Processes of Organizing – Empirical Observations from
Universities and the Field of Art
Technology as the Performance of Novelty
Coffee Break
Daniel Bartl and Simon Grand
PROS-163
Controversial Novelty: An Empirical Process Study on Managing Corporate Renewal
17:00-17:30
Discussion
Room Imperial 2: A Process Perspective on Organizations and Management
Chair: Jörgen Sandberg
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Anne Hatting and Mike Zundel
PROS-092
Seductions of the gift: An ecological investigation of standardisation in Danish hospitals
15:00-15:30
Martin Duffy and Brendan O’Rourke
PROS-148
More Sensemaking Meetings: A Systemic view towards enhanced collective mind[ing]
15:30-16:00
Sung Chul Noh
PROS-161
Making Sense of a Corporate Scandal. Empirically exploring employee’s sensemaking process of
disruptive organizational events
16:00-16:30
16:30-17:00
17:00-17:30
Coffee Break
Anthony Hussenot and Richard Baskerville
PROS-063
The becoming of organization as set of organization designs
Discussion
7
Room Imperial 3: Process and Practice Perspectives on Strategy and the Firm
Time
Name
Code
14:30-15:00
Marie Bengtsson and Lars Lindkvist
PROS-154
15:00-15:30
Bart Van Looy and Klaasjan Visscher
PROS-153
15:30-16:00
Inês Peixoto, Armi Temmes, and Raimo Lovio
PROS-131
16:00-16:30
Chair: Margaret Peteraf
Title
Connoisseurship-Based Replication Strategy
User heterogeneity as a prerequisite for regime shifts to unfold: The case of the baroque violin
technique
How the emergence of multiple paths shapes a new field: examining variety and deviation in fuel
production
Coffee Break
16:30-17:00
Irina Koprax, Christian Garaus, and Wolfgang Güttel
PROS-027
Fly on the Wings of R&D: A Dynamic Perspective on Organizational Ambidexterity
17:00-17:30
Allanah Johnston, Costas Andriopoulos, Manto Gotsi, Robert
Morgan, and Luigi De Luca
PROS-093
Novelty within Ambidextrous Organizations: Exploring the Processes and Politics in the Pursuit of
‘Balance’
17:30-1800
Discussion
Room Imperial 4: Creative Collaboration
Chair: Barbara Simpson
Time
Name
Code
Title
14:30-15:00
Karl Prince, Michael Barrett, and Eivor Oborn
PROS-029
The dynamics of collaborative innovation: the role of power in shaping networks
15:00-15:30
Ioanna Kinti
PROS-175
The emergence of novelty in teams: Collaborative Expertise as a Negotiation Struggle
15:30-16:00
Anne Rorbaek
PROS-120
Getting From A To B To C-Ollaborative, Innovative Design Utopia At The Museum?
16:30-17:00
Viviana Meschitti
PROS-072
Managing a research team: creating a space for building new practices and fostering creativity
17:00-17:30
Reijo Miettinen
PROS-176
Creative encounters and collaborative agency in product development and innovation
16:00-16:30
17:30-18:00
Coffee Break
Discussion
8
Saturday, June 22nd – 10:30-12:30, Parallel Tracks
Room Imperial: Emergence of Novelty in Organizations and Industries
Name
10:30-11:00
Chris Mowles
PROS-129
Emergence and Novelty in Organisations: the Paradox of Stability and Change
11:00-11:30
Colleen Mills, Nicolas Arnaud, and Celine Legrand
PROS-016
Explicating the discursive costs of innovation and creative practice
11:30-12:00
Nina Bauer and Miguel Pina e Cunha
PROS-048
Materiality in creative collaborations: the micro-processes of designing a fashion collection
12:00-12:30
Code
Chair: Raghu Garud
Time
Title
Discussion
Room Imperial 1: Understanding Process and the Turn to Process
Name
10:30-10:55
Zhichang Zhu
PROS-017
Needed: process thinking without process ontology
10:55-11:20
Mats Alvesson, Bernadette Loacker, and Jörgen Sandberg
PROS-023
Process here, there and everywhere: Entangle the multiple meanings of ‘process’ in identity studies
11:20-11:45
John Brocklesby
PROS-085
Why Organisation Theory’s “(Re)Turn To Process” Matters
11:45-12:10
Paula Ungureanu
PROS-054
When the Practice of Theorizing Meets the Theorizing of Practice. Building Provisional Bridges within
and in between Organization Studies Academia and Managerial
12:10-12:30
Code
Chair: Hari Tsoukas
Time
Title
Discussion
Room Imperial 2: A Process Perspective on Organization and Management
Chair: Majken Schultz
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-11:00
Fernando Fachin
PROS-007
Collective identity emergence: From sharing stories to sharing networks, spaces, practices, and
materials
11:00-11:30
Oana Branzei and Melissa Leithwood
PROS-160
Searching for a Cure: Help and Hope in Online Communities
11:30-12:00
Vanessa Strike and Claus Rerup
PROS-121
Attention Quality And The Role Of Mediated Attention Delays In Family Controlled Firms
12:00-12:30
Discussion
Room Imperial 3: Agency and the Creation of Novelty
Chair: Barbara Simpson
Time
Name
Code
Title
10:30-10:55
Bas Bosma and Ian Fouweather
PROS-040
Tales of the Unexpected
10:55-11:20
Ismaël Al-Amoudi
PROS-024
Morphogenesis and Normativity: problems the former creates for the latter
11:20-11:45
Søren Jagd
PROS-139
Criticism and the Emergence of Novelty
11:45-12:10
Marie Jose Avenier, and Laurence Gialdini
PROS-097
Problematizing Alternative Ways Of Formulating Research Questions. The Role Of
Practice In Stimulating Novelty
12:10-12:30
Discussion
9
Saturday, June 22nd 12:30-13:30, Roundtable Discussions
Room Imperial: Methodological Issues in Process Research
Time
12:30 – 13:30
Chair: Raghu Garud
Name
Title
Raghu Garud, Pennsylvania State University
Introduction: Setting the Stage for researching novelty
Deborah Dougherty, Rutgers University
Enabling Abductive Learning for Complex Innovations
Babis Mainemelis, ALBA
Backward Novelty & Progressive Tradition
Jacky Swan, University of Warwick
Contextualising and Taming Novelty in Innovation Processes
Room Imperial 1: Articulating Ontology and Epistemology: Possibilities for Process Studies
Time
12:30 – 13:30
Chair: Dvora Yanow
Name
Title
Dvora Yanow, Wageningen University
Introduction to the roundtable
John Shotter, University of New Hampshire, USA.
On ‘Relational Things’: A New Realm of Inquiry – Pre-Understandings and Performative
Understandings.
Phillipe Lorino, ESSEC, France.
Epistemology and Methodology of Dialogical Inquiry: How to make the Invisible Visible?
Caroline Ramsey, Open University, UK.
Reflexivity and the Unintended Perlocution of Research Possibilities.
13:30-14:00: Reflections on Symposium & Announcement of PROS 2014 (Room Imperial)
10