DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PREVENTION OF HARASSMENT AND DISCRIMINATION IN THE WORKPLACE GUIDELINES CONTENTS 1. Introduction 2 2. Definitions 2 3. Managing Complaints 6 4. Support Mechanisms 6 5. Outcomes 7 6. What if Behaviour is Not Deemed to be Harassment or Discrimination 7 7. What To Do If Someone Complains About You 8 8. Manager and Supervisor Responsibilities 8 9. How to Prevent Harassment And Discrimination 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines 1. INTRODUCTION Employers have a duty under the Equal Opportunity Act (WA) (as amended) to ensure the workplace is free of discrimination and harassment. The employer may be held vicariously liable for acts that are carried out by employees or persons acting under their supervision unless it can be demonstrated that all reasonable steps have and are being taken to prevent the prohibited conduct. The Department of Health aims to meet its responsibilities under the relevant legislation by providing: A policy on the prevention of harassment and discrimination; Information and guidance to employees and managers in the form of these guidelines; A grievance resolution process for dealing with complaints; Relevant awareness education and training programs for managers, supervisors and employees; and, Relevant support mechanisms including internal support networks, such as, Contact Officers, Grievance Officers or Peer Support Officers and an Employee Assistance Program that are adequately trained to deal with incidents of harassment and discrimination. These guidelines provide information promoting a work environment free from harassment and discrimination, mechanisms to resolve complaints if incidents are reported, and strategies and options to adopt if you think you have been harassed or experienced discrimination. These guidelines also address what you need to know if you are the subject of a complaint. Employees have the right to work in an environment that is free from harassment and discrimination. All employees have a responsibility to ensure their own behaviour is above reproach and they do not engage in harassing or discriminatory behaviour towards other employees, potential employees, contractors, volunteers, clients or any other person involved in providing or receiving health care or related services. Employees who become aware of harassment or discrimination are encouraged to report it to their manager as it may impact on other employees as well as productivity and working relationships. In all cases of harassment and discrimination, the grievance procedures must be complied with, confidentiality maintained and the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness applied. 2. DEFINITIONS Victimisation: Victimisation is threatening or subjecting a person to any detriment on the ground that the person has made or proposes to make an allegation or complaint, take proceedings against another person, provide information in relation to a complaint or act as a witness to a complaint. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 2 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines Victimisation includes any unfavourable treatment, such as aggression, refusing to provide information, ignoring the person (which hinders their ability to perform their duties), refusing to renew a contract of employment, or dismissal. Harassment: Harassment is defined as unwelcome, offensive, abusive, belittling or threatening behaviour or language that has the effect of intimidating, offending or humiliating a person. Harassment may be verbal, written, visual or physical in nature. Harassment will usually be repeated behaviour, but can also consist of a single act. It is often based on some real or perceived difference such as a person’s sex, sexuality, race, disability, religion or age. Harassment is based on the perceptions and feelings of the person to whom the behaviour is directed. What is acceptable to one person may not be acceptable to another. It depends on the reaction of the individual and the particular circumstances that exist. Harassment occurs if a reasonable person would anticipate that the person harassed could be offended, humiliated or intimidated by an action. Grounds for harassment can exist whether the harassment was intended or unintended. Sexual harassment can be unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favours and other verbal and physical conduct of a sexual nature. It does not arise in the context of mutual sexual attraction and flirtation, which is based on consent and is a private matter between the individuals concerned and does not constitute sexual harassment. Racial harassment is an expression of attitudes, or behaviour, based on an assumption of the superiority of one race or group of persons of colour, ethnic origin or culture over another. Racism may also consist of what is not done, as well as what is done. Examples of harassment can include: Insulting or threatening language and or gestures; Pictures, posters, graffiti, letters, e-mails, phone calls or written materials which are offensive, threatening, obscene, abusive or objectionable; Offensive jokes, suggestions or derogatory comments about another’s racial or ethnic background, gender, sexual preference, disability or physical appearance; Unwanted sexual or physical contact, such as kissing or touching; Intrusive questions or comments about a person’s sex life; Repeated sexual invitations or unwelcome love letters; Intimidation, abuse or assault; Persistent following within, to or from work (stalking); Dismissive treatment or material expressing prejudice or stereotypic assumptions about the group to which a person may belong; and, Ignoring or excluding a person or group from normal conversation, work or work related social activities. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 3 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines Harassment is not… The following are not considered to be harassment, provided they are done appropriately, with respect, courtesy and patience: Appropriate requests to work; Appropriate monitoring of a person’s work; Asking questions about progress at work; Discussions with someone about repeated lateness for work or absenteeism; Discussions about performance; or Warnings about poor performance. Discrimination: Discrimination occurs when a person is being treated, or believes they are being treated, less favourably than another because of an attribute, personal characteristic or trait. Direct discrimination occurs when a person is treated ‘less favourably’ on the basis of an “obvious” attribute, which that person may possess (such as race or sex). Indirect discrimination occurs when an apparently neutral rule, policy or practice can, in effect, have an adverse impact on a particular group, and is not reasonable in the circumstances. Under the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA) (as amended) it is unlawful to discriminate on the grounds of: Race (colour, nationality, ethnic or national origin or descent, or the race of a relative or associate); Sex (gender); Marital status (single, married, separated, divorced, widowed, de facto); Pregnancy; Impairment (physical or intellectual disability that is current, past or imputed, or of a relative or associate); Religious or political conviction; Age (or of a relative or associate in some areas); Family responsibility or family status; Sexual and racial harassment; Gender history – refers to a person who identifies as a member of the opposite sex by living, or seeking to live as a member of the “opposite sex” and who has undergone a gender reassignment procedure; and Sexual orientation – refers to a person’s actual or imputed sexuality including heterosexuality, homosexuality, lesbianism or bisexuality. Examples of Discrimination: The following are examples of possible areas of discrimination: Failure to provide physical access to a building or to different levels of a building for people with disabilities; Inadequate signage for a person with a vision impairment; Inadequate parking facilities for vehicles used by people with disabilities; Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 4 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines Requiring a person with a mobility disability to gain access through a distant side entrance; An employer’s policy of not allowing employees to work part-time indirectly discriminates against people who have family responsibilities which prevent them from working full-time; Unfair processes to determine who should be offered employment; and, Denying or limiting the employee’s access to opportunities for promotion, transfer or training based on one of the grounds above. Disability: The definition of disability adopted by the Department of Health is taken from the Disability Discrimination Act 1992. It includes physical, intellectual, psychiatric, sensory, neurological and learning disability as well as physical disfigurement and the presence in the body of organisms causing or capable of causing disease including HIV/AIDS. It also includes a disability that presently exists, existed in the past but now has ceased to exist, or may exist in the future, as well as a disability that is imputed or presumed to a person. It is important to note the broadness of this definition is not limited to someone who has a physical disability. Principles of Natural Justice: The principles of natural justice require that employees: Have the right to know all details about any allegation made against them; Have the right to be provided with the full opportunity to be heard and present their case; Will not be judged by the person making the allegation/s; Have the right to a fair and just decision- maker; Have the right to obtain the advice of a suitably qualified person; and Are to be given an opportunity to comment on the possible bias of any person involved in the grievance resolution procedure; Procedural fairness: Procedural fairness (also know as due process) is the underlying principle to be applied in all processes and procedures involved in investigating a complaint and making a decision which will affect employees. The principles of procedural fairness require that: Employees affected or at risk receive a fair and unbiased hearing; All parties to the matter have the opportunity to present their case and have their argument considered before a decision is made; All relevant submissions and other information are considered before a decision is made; Decision makers act fairly, without bias and in a timely manner; All persons are informed of the basis of a decision and any outcomes, so they can respond to the issues considered by the decision-maker; Parties have the right to obtain the advice of a suitably qualified person to assist in dealing with the complaint; and Parties have the right to review or appeal the outcome. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 5 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines 3. MANAGING COMPLAINTS Employees wishing to make a harassment or discrimination complaint will be guided by their agency/Health Service’s grievance resolution procedure. For more information about this procedure, contact your Human Resource Management Department. The responsibility for the resolution of complaints lies with line management if a complaint is lodged either formally or informally. Managers and supervisors will be guided by their agency/Health Service’s grievance resolution procedure. Important things to remember about following grievance procedures: The principles of natural justice and procedural fairness are observed throughout the grievance resolution process. It is generally preferable to attempt to resolve an issue informally as soon as possible after the incident occurs. When this is not possible, a formal process may need to be instigated. It is recommended that all parties make a detailed record of what has happened (place, date, time, persons involved, what was said or done). Ensure that your records are accurate. Complainants may withdraw their complaint at any stage if they feel they do not wish to proceed with the action. In circumstances where the employer believes that the behaviour may still exist, may impact on the work environment or other employees or, is criminal in nature, the employer may pursue the matter of their own accord. Where, at any stage of an investigation or resolution process the employer is satisfied that a complaint is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived and lacking in substance, the employer may by written notice to the complainant, dismiss the complaint. 4. SUPPORT MECHANISMS 4.1 Employee Friend At any stage of the resolution process, an employee, whether the complainant or respondent, is entitled to request the presence of a support person known as ‘The Employee Friend’ to provide support and advice during the investigative procedure, to be witness to the discussions which take place and to accompany the employee to interviews. The support person (Employee Friend) must maintain confidentiality at all stages of the process. 4.2 Internal Support Network (such as Contact Officer, Grievance Officer or Peer Support Officer) The internal support network generally provides support and information for employees who have a grievance relating to discrimination or harassment in the workplace and informs complainants of the options available to them to resolve a complaint. In some areas they may assist the employee throughout the process of resolving the complaint. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 6 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines For details of the internal support network at your health service contact your Human Resource Department. 4.3 Employee Assistance Provider An Employee Assistance Provider is a free, confidential counselling service available to all Health employees. Your Human Resource Department will be able to provide details of the Employee Assistance Provider for your health service. Counselling may assist you throughout the process of resolving the complaint. 4.4 External Agencies You may access external agencies at any time, but are encouraged to try and resolve the matter using internal processes first. External agencies you may wish to contact include: Your Union The Equal Opportunity Commission The Human Rights Commission The Ombudsman The Police if it is a criminal matter 5. OUTCOMES For most complainants a desirable outcome from making a complaint is for the unwelcome behaviour to stop. The outcome may vary according to the nature and seriousness of the incident, as well as policy and legal requirements. In situations where the employer concludes that the complaint of workplace harassment and/or discrimination is justified, disciplinary action may be taken against an employee in accordance with relevant policy and legislation. The employer may also be required to make changes in policies or practices. These changes may include counselling and appropriate training for the alleged perpetrator to enable them to recognise and take action to change their behaviour. 6. WHAT IF BEHAVIOUR IS NOT DEEMED TO BE HARASSMENT OR DISCRIMINATION? In many circumstances behaviour may not constitute harassment or discrimination, but is still unacceptable or inappropriate behaviour. It may be considered a breach of: The Public Sector Code of Ethics or Department of Health Codes of Conduct; The Public Sector Management Act (Section 9); or The Public Sector Standards in Human Resource Management (such as recruitment and selection, performance management and secondment). In these cases the employee may pursue the matter as a general employee grievance or a breach of Public Sector Standards in Human Resource Management. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 7 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines 7. WHAT TO DO IF SOMEONE COMPLAINS ABOUT YOU Employees who have a complaint made against them have rights and responsibilities in relation to the complaint resolution process. In addition to the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness, the following shall apply to respondents: 8. They will be treated as innocent until proven guilty; They shall not be victimised for being the subject of a complaint; They shall be able to nominate their own witnesses if there is an investigation into the complaint; They shall be able to have an “Employee Friend” present at any interviews or meetings as part of the investigation process; and They may have an interpreter present at an investigation interview if required. MANAGER AND SUPERVISOR RESPONSIBILITIES Managers and supervisors hold positions of responsibility in the organisation and as such, they are required to ensure that all reasonable steps have been taken to eliminate harassment and discrimination in the workplace. If managers/supervisors directly observe or are aware of harassment and/or discrimination taking place, they should not wait for a complaint to be made before intervening but should address the matter as a priority. All managers and supervisors are responsible for promoting a workplace free of harassment and discrimination, and managing grievances, misconduct and substandard performance issues involving harassment and discrimination in the workplace. In situations where the employer concludes that the complaint of harassment and discrimination is justified, disciplinary action may be taken against an employee in accordance with relevant policy and legislation. Managers who fail to act on witnessed incidents or complaints and consequently allow harassment and discrimination to continue are in effect condoning the behaviour. This is not acceptable and may lead to disciplinary action being taken against them. Under legislation an employer who does not take suitable precautions to prevent or resolve cases of harassment and discrimination may be liable for any physical or psychological injury suffered by the victim. An employer may be required to pay penalties, pay compensation to the victim or make adjustments to the workplace to prevent future occurrences. Managers and supervisors have responsibility to: Ensure their own conduct is above reproach and that they are aware of the behaviour of others for whom they have supervisory or management responsibility; Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 8 of 9 Department of Health, Prevention of Harassment & Discrimination Guidelines Ensure all staff are aware of the Department of Health Prevention of Harassment and Discrimination in the Workplace Policy and understand processes for dealing with complaints; Ensure staff have the necessary knowledge, skills and support to make or resolve complaints; Encourage and facilitate the participation of employees in educational programs designed to identify and eliminate harassment and discrimination; Monitor the workplace environment for symptoms of potential harassment and discrimination such as isolation and unexplained absences from work; Take action to prevent and stop behaviour which may be offensive or intimidating; Maintain detailed written records of the management and resolution of complaints of harassment and discrimination in confidence; Follow establish grievance procedures when dealing with any complaints of harassment and discrimination; and Ensure that persons making a complaint of harassment and discrimination are not victimised either immediately or anytime after the complaint has been resolved. In most cases the Department does not have the right to intervene in harassing or discriminatory behaviour that occurs outside of working hours. An exception to this would be interactions between work colleagues where there is sufficient connection with their employment, for example, an office party, business travel and accommodation, or use of a work related facility such as a computer or mobile phone. 9. HOW TO PREVENT HARASSMENT AND DISCRIMINATION Prevention strategies that managers may adopt include (but are not limited to) the following: Provide education and awareness programs; Ensure all employees are familiar with the requirements of Department of Health policies and guidelines, particularly the grievance resolution procedures; Encourage all employees to attend formal awareness raising sessions; Encourage managers and supervisors to attend appropriate training; Adopt open systems of communication at all levels to enable employees to voice any concerns they may have; Look for warning signs, such as negative relationships between employees, low morale, high turnover and absenteeism; Stop inappropriate behaviour, such as teasing which may develop into harassment, as soon as it occurs; Encourage employees to report any incidents of harassment or discrimination; Ensure complaints are dealt with promptly and effectively and appropriate action taken against offenders. This will demonstrate to all employees that the employer will not tolerate such behaviour; and Encourage employees to undertake exit interviews and follow up on any concerns raised by them regarding another employee/manager. Effective Date: 7 April 2004 Page 9 of 9