KS3 English curriculum review Content correlation between final (September 2013) and previous NC Schoolzone September 2013 01242 262906 philip@schoolzone.co.uk KS3 English curriculum review | 2 Introduction This correlation table is based on the September 2013 final version of the curriculum. Correlations to the previous standards were carried out by a team of secondary teachers. Items in red text are new to the KS3 English curriculum while those in green are largely unchanged from the previous standards. Note that this correlation relates only to the learning objectives, not to any changes in pedagogy, assessment or emphasis. Code numbers prefixing each learning objective have been introduced by Schoolzone for referencing purposes. This document is protected by copyright and may not be shared via TES or other websites. If you wish to share it, please use the link below, where updates will also be posted CONTENTS Introduction 2 Reading 3 Writing 7 Grammar and vocabulary 10 Spoken English 12 Further support documents for the introduction of the new curriculum can be found at: http://www.schoolzone.co.uk/schools/NewCurriculum.asp Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 3 Reading Pupils should be taught to: R1: develop an appreciation and love of reading, and read increasingly challenging material independently through: R1a: reading a wide range of fiction and non-fiction, including in particular whole books, short stories, poems and plays with a wide coverage of genres, historical periods, forms and authors. The range should include high-quality works from: R1a1: English literature, both pre-1914 and contemporary, including prose, poetry and drama R1a2: Shakespeare (two plays) This was previously ‘pupils should be able to’ New mention of independence and love of reading not in original. 4.2a Curriculum opportunities, Reading – ‘develop independence in reading’. Same coverage of genres but the 2007 PoS mentioned ‘a range of nonfiction and non-literary texts’ and a suggested list of those types of text for study (3.2h). 1b Key concepts, Competence – ‘Reading and understanding a range of texts’. 3.2 Range and Content, Reading – ‘a range of non-fiction and non-literary texts’; 3.2d Range and Content, Reading – ‘The range of literature studied should include stories, poetry and drama drawn from different historical times, including contemporary writers’. 3.2a Range and content, Reading – ‘The texts chosen should be of a high quality, among the best of their type…’ The requirement to read pre- 1914 texts is more specific - previously referred to as ‘pre-twentieth century’ – 3.2e Range and content, Reading, but the list of prescribed writers form the 2007 PoS has been omitted. 3.2g Range and content, Reading – ‘at least one play by Shakespeare’. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 4 R1a3: seminal world literature R1b: choosing and reading books independently for challenge, interest and enjoyment ‘Seminal world literature written in English’ amends the 2007 reference to ‘texts that enable pupils to appreciate the qualities and distinctiveness of texts from different cultures and traditions’ (3.2f) and would appear to preclude translations, which some might be seen as a restriction on the breadth of study. 4.2a, 4.2f Curriculum Opportunities, Reading – ‘develop independence in reading’; ‘sustain individual reading for pleasure’. 3.2b Range and Content, Reading – ‘the texts chosen should be interesting and engaging…’ New reference to re-reading texts to increase familiarity. R1c: re-reading books encountered earlier to increase familiarity with them and provide a basis for making comparisons R2: understand increasingly challenging texts through: R2a: learning new vocabulary and relating it explicitly to known vocabulary and understanding it with the help of context and dictionaries R2b: making inferences and referring to evidence in the text R2c: knowing the purpose, audience for and context of the writing and drawing on this knowledge to support comprehension 3.2c Range and Content, Reading – ‘the texts chosen should be challenging…’ 2.3q Writing, Composition, Explanatory notes: ‘Drafting, editing, proofreading: on paper and on screen, using dictionaries, thesauruses and spellcheckers’. 2.2b, f, h Reading, Reading for Meaning – ‘Infer and deduce meanings, recognising writers’ intentions’; ‘recognise and discuss different interpretations of texts, justifying their own views on what they read and see and supporting them with evidence’; ‘understand how the nature and purpose of texts influences the selection of content and its meanings’. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 5 R3c: checking their understanding to make sure that what they have read makes sense. 1.4 Key Concepts, Critical Understanding No previous explicit reference to recognising and understanding a range of poetic conventions. R4: read critically through: R4a: knowing how language, including figurative language, vocabulary choice, grammar, text structure and organizational features present meaning R4b: recognising a range of poetic conventions and understanding how these have been used R4c: studying setting, plot, and characterisation, and the effects of these R4d:understanding how the work of dramatists is communicated effectively through performance and how alternative staging allows for different interpretations of a play 1.1c Key Concepts, Competence – ‘Demonstrating a secure understanding of the conventions of written language, including grammar, spelling and punctuation’. 2.2c Key Processes, Reading, Reading for Meaning – ‘understand how meaning is constructed within sentences and across texts as a whole’. 2.2j, k, l, n Key Processes, Reading, The author’s craft – ‘pupils should be able to understand and comment on: how texts are crafted to shape meaning and produce particular effects; how writers structure and organise different texts; how writers’ uses of language and rhetorical, grammatical and literary features influence the reader; how form, layout and presentation contribute to effect’. No previous explicit mention of setting, plot and characterisation in relation to reading – these were previously explored as part of the writing strand. Previously referenced under 2.1l Key Processes, Speaking and listening – ‘explore the ways that words, actions, sound and staging combine to create dramatic moments’ and 4.1g, h Curriculum opportunities, Speaking and Listening However, previously there was a focus was on ‘live’ performance and meeting drama professionals in person. New reference to ‘great dramatists’ – open to interpretation? Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 6 R4e: making critical comparisons across texts 1.4 Key Concepts, Critical Understanding. 2.2d Key Processes, Reading, Reading for Meaning – ‘select and compare information from different texts’. 2.2o Key Processes, Reading, The author’s craft – ‘Pupils should be able to understand and comment on: how themes are explored in different texts’. R4f: studying at least two authors in depth each year. The requirement to study two authors in depth each year is new. The new NC has virtually eliminated all references to cultural understanding (1.3 Key Concepts, Cultural Understanding) and to the study of texts from other cultures. In the new PoS there is less of an emphasis upon extracting and interpreting information from, and assessing the usefulness of, texts. No list of non-fiction and non-literary text purposes as previously (3.2i) No reference to multi-modal texts. No reference to ‘developing reading skills through work that makes crosscurricular links’, meeting and talking with other readers and writers or becoming involved in events and activities that inspire reading. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 7 Writing Pupils should be taught to: W1: write accurately, fluently, effectively and at length for pleasure and information through: W1a: writing for a wide range of purposes and audiences, including: W1a1: well-structured formal expository and narrative essays W1a2: stories, scripts, poetry and other imaginative writing W1a3: notes and polished scripts for talks and presentations W1a4: a range of other narrative and nonnarrative texts, including arguments, personal and formal letters 1.1a Key Concepts, Competence – ‘Being clear, coherent and accurate in spoken and written communication’. 2.3a Key Processes, Writing, Composition – ‘write clearly and coherently, including an appropriate level of detail’. 4.3b Curriculum Opportunities – ‘produce extended writing to develop their ideas in depth and detail’. 2.3t Key Processes, Writing, Technical Accuracy – ‘use the conventions of standard English effectively’. 2.3d, g Key Processes, Writing, Composition – ‘adapt style and language appropriately for a range of forms, purposes and readers; structure their writing to support the purpose of the tasks and guide the reader’. 3.3e Range and content, Writing. No requirement for ‘formal expository or narrative’ essays previously just referred to simply as ‘essays’. 3.3e Range and content, Writing. Now refers to ‘other imaginative writing’ and ‘a range of other non-narrative forms’ – the extended list of types of writing from the 2007 PoS has been omitted. No previous specific mention of writing notes or scripts for talks or presentations. The word ‘polished’ suggests rehearsed performances. Previous guidance stated ‘letters conveying opinions’ – no distinction made between personal and formal. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 8 W1b: summarising and organising material, and supporting ideas and arguments with any necessary factual detail W1c: applying their growing knowledge of vocabulary, grammar and text structure to their writing and selecting the appropriate form W1d: drawing on knowledge of literary and rhetorical devices from their reading and listening to enhance the impact of their writing 2.3m, p, r Key Processes, Writing, Composition – ‘develop logical arguments and cite evidence’; ‘present material clearly, using appropriate layout, illustrations and organisation’; ‘summarise and take notes’. 3.3b Range and content, Writing – ‘analyse and evaluate subject matter, supporting views and opinions with evidence’. 1.1a Key concepts, Competence – ‘Making informed choices about effective ways to communicate formally and informally’; 2.3 Key Processes, Writing, Technical accuracy; 3.4a Range and content, Language structure and variation In the 2007 document, this came under a section entitled ‘Language, Structure and Variation’ which had a large emphasis on standard English and the impact of technology – this is less apparent in the new PoS. 4.3f Curriculum opportunities, Writing – ‘draw on their reading and knowledge of linguistic and literary forms when composing their writing’. 2.2l Key Processes, Reading, The author’s craft –‘pupils should be able to understand and comment on how writers’ uses of language and rhetorical, grammatical and literary features influence the reader’. 2.3f, n Key Processes, Writing, Composition – ‘use imaginative vocabulary and varied linguistic and literary techniques to achieve particular effects’; ‘persuasive techniques and rhetorical devices’. 4.1c Curriculum opportunities, Listening – ‘use speaking and listening to develop their reading and writing’. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 9 W2: plan, draft, edit and proof-read through: W2a: considering how their writing reflects the audiences and purposes for which it was intended W2b: amending the vocabulary, grammar and structure of their writing to improve its coherence and overall effectiveness W2c: paying attention to accurate grammar, punctuation and spelling; applying the spelling patterns and rules set out in Appendix 1 to the Key Stage 1 and 2 programmes of study for English. 2.3q Key Processes, Writing, Composition 4.3e Curriculum opportunities, Writing – ‘evaluate and respond constructively to their own and others’ writing’. 2.3g, j Key processes, Writing, Composition – ‘structure their writing to support the purpose of the task and guide the reader’; ‘vary sentence structure for interest, effect and subtleties of meaning’. 2.3u Key Processes, Writing, Technical Accuracy – ‘use grammar accurately in a variety of sentence types…’ 3.4a Range and content, Language structure and variation – ‘the principles of sentence grammar and whole-text cohesion…’ 1.1c Key concepts, Competence – ‘demonstrating a secure understanding of the conventions of written language, including grammar, spelling and punctuation’. 2.3 Key Processes, Writing, Technical accuracy. Appendix 1 is an addition which shows the need for progression from KS2. Considerably less emphasis upon ‘creative’ writing e.g. playing with language, using imagination etc. Less emphasis upon handwriting - no mention of ‘writing legibly’ as previously. In the 2007 document there was a requirement to ‘make cross curricular links with other subjects’, ‘work in practical and sustained ways with writers’ and to ‘write for contexts and purposes beyond the classroom’. These have been omitted. Impact of technology not mentioned. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 10 Grammar and vocabulary Pupils should be taught to: consolidate and build on their knowledge of grammar and vocabulary through: G1: extending and applying the grammatical knowledge set out in Appendix 1 to the Key Stage 1 and 2 programmes of study to analyse more challenging texts G2: studying the effectiveness and impact of the grammatical features of the texts they read G3: drawing on new vocabulary and grammatical constructions from their reading and listening, and using these consciously in their writing and speech to achieve particular effects G4: knowing and understanding the differences between spoken and written language, including differences associated with formal and informal registers, and between Standard English and other varieties of English G5: using Standard English confidently in their own writing and speech This is a completely new section – was previously addressed through 2.3 key processes, Writing, Technical Accuracy and 3.4 Range and content, Language structure and Variation. There was no reference to KS1 and KS2 in the original; again highlights the need for progression from KS2 to KS3. 1.4 Key concepts, Critical understanding. 3.2c Range and Content, Reading – ‘The texts chosen should be challenging…’ 2.2l Key Processes, Reading, The author’s craft – ‘how writers uses of language and rhetorical, grammatical and literary features influence the reader’. 3.2c Range and Content, Reading – ‘The texts chosen should be, challenging, using language imaginatively to create new meanings and effects and encouraging pupils to try such writing for themselves’. 4.1c Curriculum opportunities, Listening – ‘use speaking and listening to develop their reading and writing’. This previously came under a section entitled 3.4 Language structure and variation in Range and content – 3.4b ‘The study of English should include, across speaking and listening, reading and writing…variations in written standard English and how it differs from standard and non-standard spoken language. 2.1c Key Processes, Speaking and Listening – ‘vary vocabulary, structures and grammar to convey meaning, including speaking standard English fluently’. ’1.4d Key concepts, Critical understanding – ‘Analysing and evaluating spoken and written language…’ Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 11 G6: discussing reading, writing and spoken language with precise and confident use of linguistic and literary terminology. 2.3t Key processes, Writing, Technical accuracy – ‘use the conventions of standard English effectively’. 2.2f Key processes, Reading, Reading for meaning – ‘recognise and discuss different interpretations of texts, justifying their own views on what they read and see, and supporting them with evidence’. 4.2f Curriculum opportunities, Reading – ‘discuss reading interests and preferences…’ 1.4d Key concepts, Critical understanding – ‘Analysing and evaluating spoken and written language to appreciate how meaning is shaped’. The explicit reference to ‘precise and confident use of linguistic and literary terminology’ is new, however the Explanatory Notes accompanying 3.4 Language structure and variation in the 2007 PoS did briefly mention the use of ‘appropriate grammatical terminology’ but only in relation to ‘reflecting on the meaning and clarity of individual sentences’. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 12 Spoken English Pupils should be taught to: speak confidently and effectively including through: S1: using Standard English confidently in a range of formal and informal contexts, including classroom discussion This replaces 2.1 Key processes, Speaking and Listening from the 2007 PoS. Pupils learning to communicate confidently and effectively was highlighted in the section entitled ‘The importance of English’ in the 2007 PoS. 4.1b Curriculum opportunities, Speaking and Listening – ‘engage in specific activities that develop speaking and listening skills’. 1.1d, e Key concepts, Competence – ‘being adaptable in a widening range of familiar and unfamiliar contexts within the classroom and beyond’; ‘making informed choices about effective ways to communicate formally and informally’. 2.1a, c Key processes, Speaking and listening – ‘present information and points of view clearly and appropriately in different contexts, adapting talk for a range of purposes and audiences, including the more formal’; ‘vary vocabulary, structures and grammar to convey meaning, including speaking standard English fluently.’ 3.1b Range and content, Speaking and Listening – ‘The range of speaking and listening activities should include informal group or pair discussions’. S2: giving short speeches and presentations, expressing their own ideas and keeping to the point 1.4. Key concepts, Critical understanding – ‘Exploring others’ ideas and developing their own’. 2.1d, Key processes, Speaking and listening – ‘engage an audience, using a range of techniques to explore, enrich and explain their ideas’; ‘sift, summarise and use the most important points’ 3.1a, e Range and content, Speaking and Listening – ‘The range of speaking and listening activities should include prepared, formal presentations…’; Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 13 ‘The range of purposes for speaking and listening should include…exploring shaping and expressing ideas, feeling and opinions’. No previous explicit mention of giving speeches, or ‘keeping to the point’- the 2007 PoS only mentioned ‘structuring and organising speech to support their purposes’ (2.1b) S3: participating in formal debates and structured discussions, summarising and/or building on what has been said S4: improvising, rehearsing and performing play scripts and poetry in order to discuss language use and meaning, using role, intonation, tone, volume, mood, silence, stillness and action to add impact. 2.1e, i, f Key processes, Speaking and listening – ‘listen and respond constructively to others, taking different views into account and modifying their own views in the light of what others say’; ‘make different kinds of relevant contributions in groups, responding appropriately to others, proposing ideas and asking questions; ‘sift, summarise and use the most important points’. 3.1a Range and content, Speaking and Listening – ‘The range of speaking and listening activities should include prepared, formal presentations and debates. Only informal discussions referred to previously. 3.1c, d Range and Content, Speaking and Listening – ‘The range of speaking and listening activities should include individual and group improvisation and performance; devising, scripting and performing plays’. No previous mention of rehearsing, or of performing poetry. 2.1d, k Key processes, Speaking and listening – ‘engage an audience, using a range of techniques to explore, enrich and explain their ideas’; ‘use different dramatic techniques to convey action, character, atmosphere and tension. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd KS3 English curriculum review | 14 According to the Explanatory Notes of the 2007 PoS the ‘range of techniques’ includes, for example, tone, expression, gesture and body language. ‘Different dramatic techniques’ includes, amongst others, varying volume, tone and pace, use of pause, gesture, movement and staging. The content and skills appear similar, but there are omissions in the new PoS: No mention of drama, role play or using dramatic approaches to explore ideas, texts and issues. There are no stipulations for individual, paired or group work or to taking on different roles. No reference to pupils being able to understand explicit and implicit meaning. There is no range of purposes as in the 2007 PoS (3.1e) No reference to making crosscurricular links with other subjects or to speaking and listening in contexts outside of the classroom. No mention of watching ‘live’ performances or to engaging with actors, playwrights, directors etc. Overall, there is far less emphasis upon being a listener and to responding to others. Correlations are the intellectual property of Schoolzone.co.uk Ltd Schoolzone Formal House 60 St Georges Place Cheltenham GL50 3PN 01242 262906 research@schoolzone.co.uk Further support documents for the introduction of the new curriculum can be found at: http://www.schoolzone.co.uk/schools/NewCurriculum.asp