SUPPORTING MATERIAL: Results: Table 1. To improve consistency in assessment and management of children with fever to the standard set by NICE, comparing the management of these patients before and after introduction of the pathway Introduction of the clinical decision pathway improved assessment of children presenting with fever (see table below). CRITERION Assessment and record of skin colour Record of activity Assessment and record of hydration state Record of heart rate Record of respiratory rate Record of capillary refill time PRE-PATHWAY 46.8% 91% 92% 92% 76.6% 90% POST-PATHWAY 96% 96% 100% 100% 96% 100% Low Risk: Urine Test Low Risk: No routine bloods Low Risk: No routine Chest X-Ray 80% 91% 22% 92% 92% 92% Intermediate Risk: Urine Test 100% 100% High Risk: Urine Test High Risk: Full Blood Count High Risk: C-Reactive Protein High Risk: Blood Culture 62.5% 81% 75% 75% 100% 67% * 67% * 33% * Safety-net advice sheet for those discharged Not Measured 100% *These results were surprising and having completed the audit and reviewed the notes a typographical error was noted on the pathway, which, if followed by staff, would have inappropriately placed older patients into the high risk group purely because of a temperature greater than 39 Degrees Celsius. There was reluctance of staff to place older children into the high risk group purely because of the height of the fever and a consequent reluctance to perform invasive investigations on these patients. We believe that removing those patients who should not have been high risk would have increased the percentage of true high risk patients who did have a Full Blood Count, CRP and Blood Culture performed, but on an “intention to treat” basis we have not adjusted the figures given that we do not have the data readily available to calculate the exact effect removing these older children from the analysis would have made on the results. The typographical error has now been corrected and the audit cycle will continue. OTHER SUPPORTING INFORMATION: 1. Implementation of a clinical decision-making pathway improved the assessment of children with fever and helped clinicians identify those patients who were at risk of serious illness. We anticipate this will have had a significant impact for patients given the diverse aetiology of fever in children 2. Whilst the pathway was very good at improving recognition of ill children, it is difficult for a pathway to ensure that the next steps (investigations and management) are consistently applied given that subjective clinician preferences can have an impact on the care of children 3. Review of the NICE guideline revealed some inconsistencies and discrepancies that we had to address and agree an interpretation of. Clinicians have difficulty differentiating between “pale” and “pallor”. Such differentiation is important within the guidance as it is one of the determinants of whether a patient is low or intermediate risk. In future more objective terms should be used 3. There was difficulty in using the NICE guideline criteria of a Capillary Refill Time of >3 seconds to place a patient into the Intermediate Risk group. This was not consistent with other guidance familiar to clinical staff which referred to a capillary refill time of less than 2 seconds as normal. The department therefore decided to use the familiar standard of 2 seconds for this section of the guidance 4. There were difficulties communicating introduction of the pathway to all clinical staff, including those who visited the Emergency Department but who did not routinely work here. This was overcome by presenting the pathway in a number of fora, and using coloured posters around the department to refresh staff memories. The presence of clinically-based senior staff within our Emergency Department for 16 hours out of every 24 helped facilitate implementation of this guidance 5. The Trust employs a dedicated clinical pathways coordinator and this key member of staff makes implementing national guidance significantly easier, and enables standardisation to take place throughout the Trust 6. Having a system to be able to collect the notes of patients where the pathway was used facilitated easier audit of implementation of the guidance. We are grateful to the medical students from the University of Liverpool who assisted us with this (John Canny, Helen Moore, Claire Sweeney). Important Information Disclaimer The Fever without a Focus Care Pathway has been produced by Dr Andrew Rowland at Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust for use internally at Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust as a fever without a focus screening tool for children aged <5 years. The information contained in the Fever without a Focus Care Pathway is provided for use by appropriately qualified professionals and the making of any decision regarding the suitability of appropriate health care support and of a particular treatment or therapy for a patient, is subject to the reader’s professional judgement. Whilst every reasonable care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of its contents, neither the author nor the publisher can accept any responsibility for any action taken, or not taken, on the basis of this information. The Fever without a Focus Care Pathway is not a substitute for the exercise of appropriate professional skill and judgement. Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust shall not be liable to any person for any loss or damage which may arise from the use of any of the information contained in this publication. The above disclaimer is not intended to restrict or exclude liability for death or personal injury caused by the negligence of Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust. Copyright © 2008 Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust. All rights reserved. Not to be reproduced in whole or in part without the permission of the copyright holder. The document may only be reproduced for non-commercial clinical internal use provided that the existing copyright statement is retained. This document must not be used, distributed or the content changed in any way other than with the express written consent of the Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust and on such terms as the Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust may specify. The document must not be sold, licensed, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or in or on any media to any person without the prior written consent of the Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust. In case of any kind of publication or presentation mentioning use of the document it shall be acknowledged that the document originated from Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust. Any intention to publish or present material mentioning the document must be authorised in writing prior to publication by Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust. Enquiries regarding copyright should be addressed to Elvina.White@Alderhey.nhs.uk FEVER WITHOUT A FOCUS Screening tool for children aged <5 years OTHERS RESPIRATORY HYDRATION ACTI VITY COLOUR Patient Name: This document is a screening tool for the risk of serious illness after a diagnosis of ‘fever without a focus’ has been made by AE Number: full history and clinical examination in a child aged under 5 years. All patients with ‘fever without a focus’ should be assessed for shock and dehydration and treated according to Emergency Department guidelines. Also consider using other departmental pathways, as appropriate eg: Limping Child Tick all boxes which apply, and follow the HIGH, MEDIUM or LOW risk management pathways overleaf as indicated. A patient with any one or more high risk sign(s) or symptom(s) should be managed as high risk. Only manage as low risk if all ticks are in low risk boxes. Pale OR Mottled OR Ashen OR Blue HIGH RISK Pallor OR Pallor reported by parent or carer M EDIUM None of the above AND Normal colour of skin, lips and tongue LOW RISK No response to social cues OR Looks unwell OR Unable to rouse or does not stay awake OR Cry is weak OR High pitched OR Continuous HIGH RISK Does not respond normally to social cues OR Wakes only with prolonged stimulation OR Decreased activity OR No smile M EDIUM Has a normal response to social cues AND Content or smiles AND Stays awake or awakens quickly AND Strong normal cry or No cry LOW RISK Reduced skin turgor OR Weak pulse Assess % dehydration & treat HIGH RISK Dry mucus membranes OR Poor feeding in infants OR Capillary Refill Time ≥ 2 seconds OR Decreased urine output Assess % dehydration & treat M EDIUM Normal skin and eyes AND Moist mucus membranes AND Capillary Refill Time <2 seconds LOW RISK Grunting OR Respiratory Rate > 60 breaths/min OR Moderate or severe chest wall recession OR Exhausted OR Abnormal respiratory pattern HIGH RISK Nasal Flaring OR Respiratory Rate >50 breaths/min (age <12 months) or >40 (age >12 months) OR Oxygen Saturations ≤ 95% in air OR Crackles heard on chest auscultation M EDIUM None of the above respiratory signs AND Normal respiratory examination LOW RISK Temperature ≥ 38oC aged < 3 months OR ≥ 39oC aged 3 to 6 months HIGH RISK Non-blanching rash OR Bulging Fontanelle OR Neck Stiffness OR Status Epilepticus OR Focal Seizures OR Focal Neurological Signs OR Bile-stained vomiting HIGH RISK Fever for > 5 days OR Swollen joint OR Swollen limb OR Child is non-weight bearing OR Child is not using an extremity OR New neck lump > 2 cm M EDIUM No HIGH OR MEDIUM symptoms or signs from any of the above sections LOW RISK FEVER WITHOUT FOCUS: Management of a child aged <5 yrs at HIGH RISK of serious illness Refer to medical on-call team for admission and proceed with investigations. If symptoms or signs of shock and/or dehydration are present, treat according to departmental guidelines. Also see departmental guidelines for lumbar puncture and NICE guidelines for UTI investigation. INVESTIGATIONS TO BE COMPLETED IN THE EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT Child aged < 3 months Time sent Time checked Comment Child aged 3 months to 5yrs FBC FBC CRP CRP Chest X-Ray Chest X-Ray Blood culture Blood Culture Lumbar puncture Urine test for UTI Urine test for UTI Time sent Time checked Comment Consider the following for a child aged 3 months - 5yrs Faeces culture (if diarrhoea present) Discuss with senior Emergency Department doctor or Medical Registrar (ST3/4) and document reason for decision in clinical notes below ALL HIGH RISK PATIENTS SHOULD HAVE: Lumbar puncture ½ hourly observations and intravenous antibiotics Blood gas Referral to Medical on call team Serum electrolytes Review within 1 hour at ____ : ____ by Medical Registrar (ST3/4) or above at ____ : ____ Faeces culture (if diarrhoea present) Please document reasoning for clinical decisions, including any deviation from the guidelines CLINICAL NOTES (time all entries) Attach urine test printout here Identification of clinician Surname: Grade: Signature: Specialty: Intravenous antibiotics given Date: ___ / ___ / _____ FEVER WITHOUT FOCUS: Management of a child aged <5 yrs at MEDIUM RISK of serious illness Upon completion of your history and examination discuss the need for further investigations with a senior Emergency Department doctor (if available) or the 1st on-call Medical Registrar (ST3/4). Document discussion and reasons for decision in clinical notes section below. As a minimum all patients should have an appropriate urine test for UTI, as per the NICE UTI Guidelines. If symptoms or signs of shock and/or dehydration are present, treat according to departmental guidelines. Also see departmental guidelines for lumbar puncture and NICE guidelines for UTI investigation. INVESTIGATIONS (if appropriate) Urine test for UTI Needed YES / NO YES Time sent Time checked Comment FBC CRP Blood culture Lumbar puncture Chest X-Ray ALL MEDIUM RISK PATIENTS SHOULD HAVE: Hourly observations Review of clinical condition & results with a senior doctor (within 2 hours of starting this pathway) DISPOSAL Discharge with Fever Management Advice leaflet (Record reasons for decision in clinical notes) at ____ : _____ Admit (Record reasons for decision in clinical notes) Please document reasoning for clinical decisions, including any deviation from the guidelines CLINICAL NOTES (time all entries) Attach urine test printout here Identification of clinician Surname: Grade: Signature: Specialty: Date: ___ / ___ / _____ FEVER WITHOUT FOCUS: Management of a child aged <5 yrs at LOW RISK of serious illness Upon completion of your history and examination all children should have an appropriate urine test for UTI, as per the NICE UTI guidelines INVESTIGATION Needed Urine test for UTI YES Time sent Time checked Comment ALL LOW RISK PATIENTS SHOULD HAVE: Re-examination for signs or symptoms of pneumonia and record details in the clinical notes below (remember that signs may be subtle) Respiratory rate and respiratory effort re-recorded on the Emergency Department observation sheet DISCHARGE CRITERIA UTI & pneumonia excluded Fever Management Advice leaflet given Please document reasoning for clinical decisions, including any deviation from the guidelines CLINICAL NOTES (time all entries) Attach urine test printout here Identification of clinician Surname: Grade: Signature: Speciality: Date: ___ / ___ / _____ DOES YOUR PATIENT HAVE A FEVER BUT NO FOCUS? USE THE FEVER PATHWAY: INVESTIGATE AND MANAGE PATIENTS APPROPRIATELY! AGE HIGH RISK (Give all patients iv antibiotics) <3 months MEDIUM RISK FBC Urine Test for CRP UTI* Blood Culture …and DISCUSS the Chest X-Ray need for other * investigations with a Urine Test for UTI doctor and Lumbar Puncture senior document this LOW RISK Urine Test for UTI* discussion clearly on the pathway >3 months FBC Urine Test for CRP UTI* Blood Culture …and DISCUSS the Chest X-Ray need for other * investigations with a Urine Test for UTI Consider Lumbar Puncture, Blood Gas, Serum Electrolytes, Faeces Culture senior doctor and document this discussion clearly on the pathway (DISCUSS with a senior doctor and document this discussion clearly on the pathway) *See NICE guidelines for the investigation of possible UTI Urine Test for UTI* Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust Shared Learning Award submission – Feverish Illness in Children Emergency Department Discharge Advice Sheet We think that your child is well enough to go home now, but please telephone the number below if: your child’s health gets worse you are worried about your child you have concerns about looking after your child at home your child has a fit your child develops a rash that does not disappear with pressure (see the ‘tumbler test’ at the end of this sheet) your child has a fever lasting longer than 5 days. Phone this number for further advice: 0845 46 47 (NHS Direct) or take your child to your GP or the nearest Accident and Emergency Department as soon as possible. What to do when your child has a fever Preventing dehydration Offer your child regular drinks (where a baby or child is breastfed the most appropriate fluid is breastmilk). Look for signs of dehydration: sunken fontanelle (soft spot on a baby’s head) dry mouth sunken eyes no tears If you find signs of dehydration encourage your child to drink more fluids and seek further advice if you are worried. Clothing Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust Shared Learning Award submission – Feverish Illness in Children Children with fever should not be under or over dressed. If your child is shivering or sweating a lot, change the amount of clothes they are wearing. Medicines to reduce temperature It is not necessary to use medicines (paracetamol or ibuprofen) to treat your child’s temperature. But if your child has a fever and is distressed or very unwell, you can help to make them feel more comfortable by giving them either paracetamol or ibuprofen (please read the instructions on the bottle first and do not exceed the maximum daily doses). Don’t give these medicines at the same time. If your child has not improved 2-3 hours later, you may want to try giving the other medicine. Please ask your local community pharmacist for more advice about medicines. Never give aspirin to a child. Sponging Do not sponge your child with water. This does not help to reduce fever. Checking on your child Check your child during the night for rashes and to see if they are getting better. If a rash appears, do the tumbler test (see below). If you are concerned that your child is not improving phone the number on the front of this sheet to seek advice. Keep your child away from nursery or school while they have a fever and notify the school or nursery of the illness. Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust Shared Learning Award submission – Feverish Illness in Children The tumbler test Do the 'tumbler test' if your child has a rash. Press a glass tumbler firmly against the rash. If you can see the spots through the glass and they do not fade this is called a ‘non-blanching rash’. If this rash is present seek medical advice immediately. The rash is harder to see on dark skin so check paler areas, such as palms of the hands, soles of the feet, tummy and inside the eyelids. (Photo courtesy of the Meningitis Research Foundation)