Presenter’s notes and handouts for phonic subject knowledge presentation See also presentation CPD materials on ‘the simple view of reading’ and materials relating to the Rose Report recommendations in the Subject leader handbook. The following materials are to support the implementation of the Primary Framework for literacy and in particular the Rose Report1 recommendations. You will need to select, tailor and adapt these materials to meet the specific needs of your children and staff and the context of your school. It is not the intention that you adopt all of these materials as they are presented here. The intention is to provide materials that could contribute to your ongoing professional development programme for over the next 12 to 24 months. Decisions on the use of these materials will depend on your school’s development priorities in literacy, the strand selected from the renewed Primary Framework and the profile of the identified focus children. Contents Introduction (slides 3 to 6) – Objective – Phonics – the priority for training – A phonics quiz – Enunciation Some definitions of phonics terminology (slides 7 to 14) – Phonemes and graphemes – Blending and segmenting – Digraphs – Trigraphs – Split digraph Phonics programmes (slides 15 to 17) – Synthetic phonics – Key message – Progression and pace Phonics subject knowledge (slides 18 to 41) – Words sometimes wrongly identified as CVC – Consonant digraphs 1 Independent review of the teaching of early reading, Final report, Jim Rose, March 2006 (DfES 02012006DOC-EN. ISBN 1-84478-684-6) © Crown copyright 2006 1 – CVC words – clarifying some misunderstandings – Links with spelling – Examples of CCVC, CVCC, CCCVC and CCVCC – A segmenting activity – Words that may be sorted incorrectly – Representing phonemes (including activity) – Spelling – High frequency words Handouts and materials It is important to note that these subject knowledge sessions may require several additional sessions to complete. Please note the notation // as in /c/ /t/ is a standard graphic device. It is important to understand that it refers to the phoneme represented by those letters, not that particular grapheme – for example /ae/ refers to a phoneme which could be represented by the letters, a, ay, ai, a-e, eigh, etc. Introduction Slides 3 to 6 – Introduction Set the context for the sessions with reference to the Rose Report recommendations. See Section E in the Headteacher booklet and information and resources from the Subject leader handbook. These sessions and activities are to support teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants with core subject knowledge about phonics. While staff need more than this – for example training on structuring and linking teaching sessions – core subject knowledge about phonics provides a critical foundation. To tailor these materials at specific individuals or groups in school you may choose to provide staff with the phonics quiz (HO1) prior to these sessions to gauge the teacher’s, practitioner’s and teaching assistant’s knowledge and confidence. Do not assume that everyone has the same critical foundation of knowledge and understanding. Slide 5 – A phonics quiz HO1 reproduces this quiz for staff to complete individually. Give plenty of time for this either in the session or prior to the session (see above). Explain that you are not going to go through the answers now, but that you will use these sessions to ensure a shared knowledge and understanding about phonics across the whole school. For your information, when this quiz has been used by literacy consultants with teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants the average scores to © Crown copyright 2006 2 date are 7/10 for literacy coordinators, 4/10 for teachers or practitioners and 2/10 for teaching assistants. Individual scores though do vary from 0 to 9. Scores have been close to the average in all groups tested, so subject knowledge is likely to be an issue in your own school. Slide 6 – Enunciation Illustrate enunciation for participants – for example demonstrate how most consonants should be pronounced in a continuous manner – e.g. ssssss mmmmmm llllllll nnnnnn shshshsh rrrrrrr zzzzzzzz vvvvvvv. However, some cannot be said like this (e.g. /c/ /t/ /p/ /b/ /d/ and /g/). Make the point that /c/ /t/ and /p/ should be enunciated without the voice. Phonemes wwwwww and yyyyyyyy are not easy but can be attempted. This is very important. Many errors spring from incorrect enunciation, for example teachers reporting that children confuse ‘ch’ and ‘tr’. If the ‘ch’ is enunciated correctly, as one phoneme, rather than ‘chur’, and ‘tr’ clearly as two phonemes, there is far less likelihood of confusion. Note any regional pronunciation issues. Many of the sounds (particularly vowel sounds) can vary slightly according to accent, but they are generally consistent within the speech of an individual and recognisable by others who may pronounce them slightly differently. Some definitions of phonics terminology Slides 7 and 8 – Phonemes and graphemes Correct terminology should be introduced from Reception Year onwards. It has been found that children do not have a problem using these words (in fact they are often very proud of their ability to do so). We wouldn’t dream of teaching 3-D shapes to children and using the word ‘ball’ instead of ‘sphere’ or ‘box’ instead of ‘cube’ or ‘cuboid’. The principle with phonic vocabulary is exactly the same – it’s just that we haven’t, as a professional body, been used to using these words with children until relatively recently. Slides 9, 10 and 11 – Blending and segmenting Mention that Rose identified blending and segmenting skills as essential features of quality phonic sessions. Slide 10 – Oral blending Evidence in our survey 2005 showed that little teaching of blending happens in schools, so this will be a shift of emphasis for many teachers or practitioners given their current practice. Having children practise this orally without reference to graphemes breaks the process down in a way that will be very helpful for many children. © Crown copyright 2006 3 Slide 12 – Digraphs Thinking back to the phonics quiz, can anyone identify two letters that teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants often incorrectly classify as digraphs? (ANSWER: Adjacent consonants, e.g. sp, st, dr, pl.) Slide 13 – Trigraphs Thinking back to the phonics quiz, can anyone identify three letters that teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants often incorrectly classify as trigraphs? (ANSWER: Adjacent consonants, e.g. spr, spl.) Slide 14 – Split digraph A digraph in which the two letters are not adjacent, e.g. in bake the a and the e are split but work together to make the /ae/ phoneme. Phonics programmes Slide 15 – Synthetic phonics Some key elements of a synthetic phonics programme are as follows. Grapheme, phoneme correspondences are taught in a clearly defined incremental sequence. Children are taught to apply the highly important skill of blending phonemes in order, all through a word to read it. Children are taught to apply the skills of segmenting words into their constituent phonemes to spell. Phonics is taught discretely. Phonics is taught as the prime approach in learning to decode (to read) and to encode (to write or spell) print. The teaching is fast-paced – ‘most of the letter-sound correspondences, including the consonant and vowel digraphs, can be taught in the space of a few months…’ Johnston and Watson, quoted approvingly in the Rose Report. Emphasise that synthetic phonics requires critical attention to a focus on phonics as the critical skill for word recognition. Quote the Rose Report: ‘…if beginner readers, for example, are encouraged to infer from pictures the word they have to decode this may lead to their not realising that they need to focus on the printed word’ Slide 16 – Key message Remind all staff that the HMI survey drawn on by the Rose Report found that ‘not all schools were clear about exactly what phonic knowledge (letter–sound correspondences) they expected their pupils to have learned at particular stages’. Emphasise that whatever scheme of phonics we as a school choose to use (and remind them of Rose’s emphasis on fidelity to a single programme or © Crown copyright 2006 4 scheme) it will be essential that teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants fully understand the progression set out in that scheme. Schemes that do not have a full and clear statement of progression (i.e. that fully describes content, progression through that content and the pace of that progression) do not provide teachers with the support a scheme should provide. Fidelity to a scheme is impossible if the scheme is so loose or imprecise that no one could know whether they were being faithful to that scheme or not. Slide 17 – Progression and pace An effective phonics programme will outline the incremental progression and the expected pace of learning. See the Subject leader handbook ‘Guidance for practitioners on progression and pace in the teaching of phonics’. Phonics subject knowledge Slide 18 – Words sometimes wrongly identified as CVC Thinking back to the phonics quiz, teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants (and some publishers) often incorrectly include words in this group. Can anyone identify an example? Answers could include words containing a digraph made up of one vowel and one consonant. At first glance these look like CVCs (see slide 18). However, these words contain vowel digraphs and therefore come at a later stage. Slide 19 – Consonant digraphs Further progression is illustrated here involving blending and segmenting CVCs containing consonant digraphs. Clarification for presenters: these words are all CVCs – the C, the V, the C refer to phonemes, not letters, so ‘duck’ is a CVC. The vowels in CVCs are always short vowels as these are the only ones the children have been taught yet. Slide 20 – CVC words – clarifying some misunderstandings This slide is designed to act as a check of understanding of which words are CVC words and which are not. Read the word ‘cat’. Write the word on a flipchart or interactive whiteboard. Get everyone to segment the phonemes on their fingers. Then add sound buttons underneath the word, i.e. draw dots under each sound. This word has three phonemes (consonant, short vowel, consonant). Repeat with ‘sir’. ‘Sir’ contains two phonemes and is therefore not a CVC word. Place a cross next to it). © Crown copyright 2006 5 Note any regional pronunciation issues. However, even where three phonemes are heard this word contains a vowel digraph and therefore cannot be a CVC word. Repeat with ‘duck’. Tip: ask participants to watch out for their lip, mouth and throat movements, which often indicate a change in phoneme. Slide 21 – Links with spelling This slide includes words just identified in the last task, plus the word ‘chick’. Say: You will see that all these words end in double letters. Can anyone explain why? (ANSWER: You get final ‘ll’, ‘ss’, ‘ff’, ‘zz’, ‘ck’ after a short vowel. These are the only consonants which double in this position.) Make links to spelling. Slide 22 – Examples of CCVC, CVCC, CCCVC and CCVCC Blend and read each example on the slide. Refer back to the earlier phonics quiz. Ask participants, reflecting on their experience, to consider what they think are the most common mistakes some teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants make with blending and segmenting these words. Answers could include: Counting consonant clusters as one sound, for example in the earlier phonics quiz when segmenting the word ‘strap’, teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants often count ‘str’ as one phoneme and if the school has been using analytical phonics, they may count ‘ap’ as a second phoneme. Synthetic phonics, unlike analytical phonics, focuses on the smallest units of sound in a word. There are usually two or three phonemes within a number of consecutive consonants. Children need to be taught to blend and segment these phonemes within CCVC and CVCC words. Teachers, practitioners and teaching assistants should not be teaching ‘sl’, ‘sm’, ‘sn’, etc. as units of sound which need to be learned individually – this takes far too long, is unnecessary and doesn’t improve children’s spelling and reading skills as quickly. The key here is applying the generic skill of blending to the phonemes in the word (using the taught knowledge of sound–spelling correspondences), from left to right in the order in which they are recorded in the word. Slides 23 to 28 – A segmenting activity In this activity participants are going to segment words into phonemes. Call out the word ‘slip’. Ask everyone to segment the phonemes on their fingers. Use the next four slides to illustrate the segmenting of the phonemes. Give out copies of HO2 (one between two participants). Participants follow the same procedure to segment the given words into the phoneme frames. © Crown copyright 2006 6 Slide 29 – Segmenting This slide shows answers to the task. Give participants a couple of minutes to check their answers. Discuss any queries. Point out that there is a single final ‘l’, ‘f’, ‘k’ after a consonant (these letters only double after a short vowel). Another common mistake is to include non-CCVCs or non-CVCCs in work on adjacent consonants. These are words that are too difficult for children to blend and segment at this stage, as they contain phoneme–grapheme correspondences children haven’t yet learned. Slide 30 – A basic principle The same phoneme can be represented in more than one way. In this case the common phoneme is /ur/. Slide 31 and 32 Ask participants what difficulties they think some may have in reading or interpreting the information on this chart and the next. Answers could include the following. Not knowing what ‘//’ means. As this is a standard graphic device it is important to understand that it refers to the phoneme represented by those letters, not that particular grapheme – for example /ae/ refers to a phoneme (which could be represented by the letters, a, ay, ai, a-e, ei). ‘oo’ is categorised under /ue/ even though it sounds slightly different. /oo/ therefore represents the sound in ‘book’ not the sound in ‘moon’. /ow/ could technically represent /oe/ as in ‘bow’ as /oe/ is used to represent this sound, /ow/ must represent the sound in ‘ground’. Slide 33 – Activity Give each pair or group of three participants copies of HO3 (this may be provided as one sheet of A3 but may come as two sheets of A4), and a bag or envelope of pre-cut words (Word pack 1). The task is to sort the words into the correct columns, according to the phonemes represented by the letters in bold type. Early finishers identify and write a list of the words which are most likely to cause a problem to teachers doing a similar task. When the task is completed distribute HO3 – Answers and give participants time to consider their answers. Slide 34 – Words that may be sorted incorrectly Nearly all these words could be incorrectly sorted according to what the grapheme looks like, as opposed to the sound it represents, and ‘grass’ could be sorted differently because of pronunciation variations. The next slide emphasises the basic principle. © Crown copyright 2006 7 Slide 35 – The basic principle Explain that this principle – the same spelling may represent more than one phoneme – shows itself as a challenge in reading (rather than writing). Children need to be able to recognise vowel diagraphs as units when they read words, instead of reading individual letters. Slide 36 – The same phoneme can be represented in more than one way This principle shows itself as a challenge in writing (rather than reading). Children need to know the range of vowel choices for spelling and that in most words these choices are limited by position in word and frequency of occurrence. Children should be taught the vowel digraphs in words in which they appear most frequently and teaching should make explicit the most probable position in the word of each vowel digraph. Slide 37 Children need opportunities to investigate these spelling patterns and generate rules. Unfortunately, this is not happening in a great many classrooms and this can cause problems for children, well into Key Stage 2. Describe the next activity: participants are going to have a go at a spelling investigation to find out which representation of /ae/ is most likely in initial, medial and final position in a word. Slides 38 and 39 – Activity Give each pair or group of three participants copies of HO4 and Word pack 2. Underline the grapheme representing the /ae/ phoneme in each word. Sort the words and formulate two simple rules for representing the /ae/ in initial or medial position and for the final position. Alternatively, generate as many words as possible with the /ae/ phoneme in that you would expect to be in the oral vocabulary of Year 1 and 2 children. For example ‘day’, ‘pain’, ‘stay’, ‘game’. Write each word on a sticky note, underline the grapheme representing the /ae/ phoneme in each word and then sort to formulate two simple rules as above. Slide 40 – Spelling HO5 summarises some key rules or patterns relating to spelling choices. Slide 41 – High frequency words Emphasise that it is only the exceptions that should be directly taught – some teachers are wasting time teaching as sight words phonically decodable words such as ‘went’, ‘am’, etc. © Crown copyright 2006 8 HO1 Phonics quiz Was MOST of your teaching experience in: (please circle) Foundation/KS1 KS2 Both 1. What is a phoneme? 2. How many phonemes are in the word ‘strap’? 3. a) What is a digraph? b) Give an example. 4. a) What is a CVC? b) Give an example. 5. Why has ‘hiss’ got ‘ss’ at the end (and not ‘s’)? 6. Why has ‘think’ got a ‘k’ at the end (and not ‘ck’ or ‘c’)? 7. a) What is a trigraph? b) Give an example. 8. How many phonemes are in the word ‘twenty’? 9. Write down at least four different ways of representing /ae/. 10. What is the best guess when you write /ae/ at the end of a word? © Crown copyright 2006 9 HO2 WORD shelf PHONEMES dress think string sprint flick © Crown copyright 2006 10 HO3 Activity – Word pack 1 /ae/ /ee/ /ie/ © Crown copyright 2006 11 /oe/ /ue/ HO3 – Answers /ae/ /ee/ /ie/ /oe/ /ue/ angel field mine road dew late me light toe moon train sweet try stole cute lay meat find post union eight misty tried grow blue these © Crown copyright 2006 12 Word pack 1 – this needs to be pre-cut, then words shuffled and placed in envelopes lay meat find post union eight misty tried grow blue these field mine road dew angel late me light toe late moon train cute stole sweet try © Crown copyright 2006 13 HO4 INITIAL AND MEDIAL FINAL © Crown copyright 2006 14 Word pack 2 /ae/ Activity tray skate may chain stray ape pay paint they wait great neigh make snail hay day ate stay way eight tray skate may chain stray ape pay paint they wait great neigh make snail hay day ate stay way eight tray skate may chain stray ape pay paint they wait great neigh make snail hay day ate stay way eight © Crown copyright 2006 15 HO5 PHONIC RULES OR PATTERNS, WHICH MAY BE USEFUL In English there are 26 letters which represent 44 phonemes. These phonemes are represented by 140 different letter combinations. After a short vowel, words end in ‘ss’ instead of ‘s’, ff instead of ‘f’, ll instead of ‘l’, zz instead of ‘z’ (e.g. hiss, whiff, hill, fizz). Note: These are the only consonants that double in this position After a short vowel, words end in ‘ck’ instead of ‘k’ (e.g. lick). At the end of a word /v/ is usually spelled ‘ve’ (e.g. have, live). CCVC words: After a short vowel, words end in ‘ss’ instead of ‘s’, ‘ff’ instead of ‘f’, ‘ck’ instead of ‘k’, ‘ll’ instead of ‘l’ (e.g. dress, sniff, block, frill). CVCC words: After a consonant, words end in ‘f’ instead of ‘ff’, ‘k’ instead of ‘ck’ (e.g., shelf, sink). /l/ doesn’t appear in the final position and /s/ only as a plural (and therefore represented by ‘s’). After a digraph, words end in ‘f’ instead of ‘ff’, ‘k’ instead of ‘ck’, ‘l’ instead of ‘ll’ (e.g. surf, park, heel), ‘ce’ or ‘se’ instead of ‘ss’. Regional pronunciation – (note: this is relevant in areas where ‘path’ is pronounced ‘parth’): /ar/ followed by /s/ (e.g. grass), /th/ (e.g. bath) or a consonant cluster (e.g. plant, ask, clasp) is written ‘a’. Where it is followed by /s/, this is written ‘ss’ (e.g. glass). © Crown copyright 2006 16 Which representation of each vowel phoneme is most likely in different positions? A) Which representation is most likely in initial, medial and final position in a monosyllabic word? Letters in brackets show less likely representations. Initial and medial position Final position ai a-e ay ea ee (e-e) ee e ea (words with 1 syllable) y (words with 2 or more syllables) i-e (igh i ie) y (ie igh) oa o-e (o ow) ow (o oe) oo u-e ew (oo ue) ar (a*) ar oi oy ou ow ow ir ur er (ear or) ir ur er aw or a (augh ough) ore aw (oor) oo u (oul) – – are (air ear) – ear eer * areas of the country in which ‘path’ is pronounced ‘p-ar-th’ The initial or medial position is the most problematic in a monosyllabic word, as a vowel phoneme can usually be represented in more than one way (e.g. ‘ai’ and ‘a-e’ are equally likely in this position). © Crown copyright 2006 17