The American Revolution The following is an overview of two units of instruction that will take a look at the American Revolution. The first unit has been developed for the fifth grade to study the lives of people who played key roles in the American Revolution. The second unit is for an eleventh grade United States history class which will explore the American Revolution and discover a deeper understanding of the attitudes and motives of the people who played key roles in it. Biographies of the American Revolution (5th Grade) Student Audience: This elementary school is located is a suburb of a large metropolitan area in the state of Indiana. It is the county seat with a population of approximately 30,000. The town is a mixture of old restored historical buildings and Victorian streets and a new growing economy that is evident in new construction in both the business sector and the residential areas. This K-5th grade building is located in an older area of the town that serves five hundred students that come from a variety of economic and social backgrounds. The administrators and teachers of this school strive for success for all students, and they do this by working together as a team to meet the school and state academic goals. This unit will be taught in a regular classroom of twenty eight students. Some, but not all, of the students have had a basic introduction to inquiry research skills at lower grade levels. There are a variety of learning levels in the classroom so it will be important to provide resources for all levels of learners. Most students in the class are enthusiastic about learning. These students will be easily motivated by an interesting, fun project. However, there are a few students who are not very motivated to learn. For these students the talk show format of the final project will get them interested in working. In addition, closer supervision by the teacher and media specialist by way of one-on-one conferencing with these students as they progress through the unit will help them. Connection to the “real world” will occur in several places throughout this project. As students research their person they will look for information that can be related to the students’ lives in the present. In the evaluation process they will be asked to think about things that are happening in today’s world that might relate to events during the revolution. The final project the students will produce will be an interview talk show as seen on television today, in which they will present their information. Information Inquiry Role and Unit Overview: The American Revolution is part of the curriculum for the 5th grade at this school. This unit will introduce the students to important figures from this time period, their roles in key events of this time period, and provide an opportunity for the students to use critical thinking skills as they as they research and present their information. The social studies teacher, language arts teacher, and media specialist will collaborate together on this unit that will include research skills, reading and writing skills, and technology skills. 1 Project Overview: As part of the study of the American Revolution students will do a unit on biographies of individuals who played key roles in the American Revolution. Each student will choose a person to research and by using a variety of resources they will gain an understanding of the life of this person and what his or her role was during this period in history. Students will get an insight to what life was like at this time, the different viewpoints of the individuals about the war, and the effect of the war on their lives. They will present this information in both written and oral formats. Students will write a one to two page paper on their person. They will create a PowerPoint presentation from the information gathered. As a final project they will be put in groups of four and produce a television interview talk show, “Dateline 1776”, where each student will have the opportunity to do an interview, be the interviewee, run the camera for taping, and be the director. Unit Objectives: Social Studies – Students will develop an understanding of the British and American leaders of the American Revolution and describe their role in key events. They will identify and evaluate the contribution of women during the American Revolution, and they will also identify individuals from other countries who assisted in the Revolution. Students will also lean to identify and interpret primary and secondary source material. Language Arts - Students will read and analyze information related to individuals during the American Revolution. They will construct their own meaning of the lives of these individuals and their part in the American Revolution. This information will be reflected in the student’s written and oral presentation of the material. Media/Technology – Students will learn strategies for using a variety of research tools, both in print and on computers. They will lean effective note taking and citation skills. Students will use a variety of technology tools to produce creative written and oral presentations. Collaborative Roles: Social Studies teacher – Introduce the American Revolution and the people the students will be researching. Assist students with research and presentations. Language Arts teacher – Read aloud of fiction book about the American Revolution and teach the reading, writing and spelling skill necessary for presentations. Assist students with research and presentations. Media Specialist – Teach note taking and citation skills. Instruct students on research strategies and resources, and technology skills needed for use of PowerPoint and video taping. Assist students with research and presentations. Time Frame: Teachers and media specialist will schedule four meetings over two weeks to set up the plan for the unit. The unit will take four weeks to complete plus one day for student evaluation. Teachers and media specialists will plan an additional meeting at the completion of the unit for evaluation. Week one – Students will choose the person they will research. The first two days will be introduction of the unit and the media specialist will teach note taking one day and citation skills the next day. She will introduce the research strategies and resources the second day. The next three days will be research. Week two - Three days of research and two days of writing paper. 2 Week three – Two days to complete writing paper. Technology instruction on the third day and students will begin putting together their PowerPoint presentations. Week four – Students will be divided into groups of four and put together their plans for their final presentation “Dateline 1776” which will be presented on the last day of the week. The day after the presentations, the students will be asked to fill out an evaluation of the unit. Activities: Social Studies – research and class discussion. Create chart for wall to post names of people the students are doing biographies on and what side of the war they were on, Patriots or Loyalists. Provide sheet with questions for students to guide them in their research. Language Arts – Read Aloud My Brother Sam is Dead and develop vocabulary unit to go with it. Have students create a journal (folder) for notes and citations as they do research. Write a one to two page paper on individual they are researching. Media Specialist – Instruct students on note taking and citation skills, research strategies and the resources available for them to use. She will introduce or review the use of PowerPoint. Media specialist will also instruct students on use of video equipment and assist with their final presentations. Common Piece of Literature: The piece of literature that was chosen for this unit is the book My Brother Sam is Dead by James and Christopher Collier. This historical fiction novel gives authentic information about the American Revolution while it tells the story of a family that is torn apart by conflicting loyalties caused by the war. It brings in many of the historical figures and their part in the war, and relates them to the lives of the characters in the book. This book offers the opportunity for students to use critical thinking skills as they hear the different points of view that are offered by the characters in the book. They can relate these points of view to the individuals they are researching, and get a better understanding of the kind of personal conflicts the people of that time were going through. This is an excellent book for students this age and can give the students a chance to feel what it was like living in this time period. Work Sheet: The following page of questions is designed to guide the students in their research. It is not the only information a student can use, but it is developed to pose challenging questions that will make the students use higher order thinking skills. 3 Biographies of the American Revolution 1. Name of person 2. When was he/she born and when did he/she die? 3. Was he/she a loyalist or Patriot? 4. Where did he/she live? 5. What was his/her occupation before, during and after the Revolutionary War? 6. In what ways was his/her life remarkable? 7. What human qualities were most influential in shaping the way this person lived and influenced his or her time? 8. What are the two or three most important lessons you might learn from the way this person lived? 9. Many people act out of a “code” or set of beliefs which dictate choices. It may be religion or politics or a personal philosophy. To what extent did your person act by a code? Were there times when the code was challenged and impossible to follow? 10.Give three other interesting facts about the person you are researching? Come up with two interesting questions of your own. 4 Names of the American Revolution John Adams Abigail Adams Samuel Adams Benedict Arnold Crispus Attucks Ann Baily John Burgoyne Margaret Cochran Corbin Charles Cornwallis Elizabeth Drinker Benjamin Franklin Elizabeth Freeman Thomas Gage Grace Galloway George III Nathan Hale Nancy Hart Alexander Hamilton Mary Ludwig Hayes John Hancock Benjamin Harrison Patrick Henry Stephen Hopkins Thomas Jefferson Miss Jenny John Paul Jones Thaddeus Kosciusko Richard Lee James Madison Francis Marion James Otis Thomas Paine John Penn Molly Pitcher William Pitt Lydia Mintern Post Paul Revere Betsy Ross Suzanne Howell Rowsen Edward Rutledge Deborah Samson Roger Sherman Fredrick von Steuben Charles Townshend Mercy Otis Warren George Washington Martha Washington Anthony Wayne Phillis Wheatley 5 Student Resources: Online Databases: Databases with access through School Website World Book Online Biography Resource Center through Inspire Websites: Liberty: The American Revolution http://www.pbs.org/ktca/liberty/ Spy Letters of the American Revolution http://www.si.umich.edu/spies/ Archiving Early America http://earlyamerica.com/series.html Amazing Women in War and Peace http://userpages.aug.com/captbarb/femvets.html Yahooligans Revolutionary War http://yahooligans.yahoo.com/around_the_world/countries/united_sta tes/history/colonial_life__1585_1783_/american_revolutionary_war/ Kids Click http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/cgibin/searchkids.pl?keywords=Revolutionary+War&searchtype=all Benjamin Franklin http://www.english.udel.edu/lemay/franklin/ Who Served Here? Baron von Steuben http://www.ushistory.org/valleyforge/served/steuben.html Colonial Hall http://www.colonialhall.com/index.php Betsy Ross Homepage http://www.ushistory.org/betsy/ Revolutionary War Biographies http://eduscapes.com/42explore/revolt3.htm Selected Portraits from the Collections of the Library of Congress http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/list/235_poc.html America’s Story From America’s Library http://www.americaslibrary.gov/cgi-bin/page.cgi American Revolution.org http://www.americanrevolution.org/home.html Books: Listed here are just a few titles. Check the media center catalog and public library for additional titles. Heroines of the American Revolution: America’s Founding Mothers By Diane Silcox-Garrett American Revolution Biographies v. 1 & 2 By Linda & Rosteck Schmittroth Those Remarkable Women of the American Revolution By Karen Zeinart The Secret Soldier By Ann McGovern Revolutionary War Leaders (Series) By various authors Journal of a Revolutionary War Woman By Judith Greenley Betsy Ross: Patriot of Philadelphia By Judith St. George 6 Assessment: Student assessment will be completed by the individual teachers and media specialist. Social studies teacher will assess students with rubric that was designed by this teacher to grade information and participation of student in social studies area. Language arts teacher will access students with rubric that was designed by this teacher to grade writing and participation of students in language arts area. Media specialist will access students with rubric that was designed by him/her to grade note taking and citation skills. The rubric will contain criteria such as accuracy, neatness and number of resources (see example below). All three together will grade the final presentations based on a rubric that was designed by all three instructors. This rubric will contain criteria such as how well students worked together in a group and helped each other out. It will also grade presentation on appropriateness of the information presented, creativity of the presentation and participation of group members. This will be done at the completion of the final projects. Student Name: ________________________________________ 4 3 2 Sources All sources are accurately documented in the desired format. All sources are accurately documented, but a few are not in the desired format. All sources are Some sources are not accurately accurately documented, but many documented. are not in the desired format. Notes Notes are recorded and organized in an extremely neat and orderly fashion. Notes are recorded legibly and are somewhat organized. Notes are recorded. Notes are recorded only with peer/teacher assistance and reminders. Number of sources Four or more sources were used. Three sources were used. Two sources were used. One source was used. CATEGORY 7 1 State Academic Standards are listed with correlating Information Literacy Standard numbers. (ILS listed below) SOCIAL STUDIES The American Revolution: 1763 to 1783 5.1.12 Identify major British and American leaders and describe their roles in key events, such as the First and Second Continental Congresses, drafting and approval of the Declaration of Independence (1776), publication of Common Sense, and major battles of the Revolutionary War. ILS 1 2 3 5.1.13 Assess the influence of other countries, such as France, Spain, Russia, Germany, Poland, and the Netherlands, in the American Revolution; identify individuals from other countries who assisted the American cause. ILS 1 2 3 5.1.14 Identify and evaluate contributions of women during the American Revolution, including Abigail Adams, Martha Washington, Mercy Otis Warren, and Molly Pitcher. ILS 1 2 3 5 6 7 Chronological Thinking and Comprehension 5.1.20 Read historical fiction and nonfiction about an event of the American Revolution and reconstruct the literal meaning of passages by identifying who was involved, what happened, where it happened, what events led to these developments, and what consequences or outcomes followed. ILS 1 2 3 5 6 Research Capabilities 5.1.22 Identify and interpret primary source and secondary source materials that pertain to a problem confronting people during the founding period of the United States. ILS 1 2 3 5 6 ENGLISH Structural Features of Informational and Technical Materials 5.2.2 Analyze text that is organized in sequential or chronological order. ILS 1 2 3 6 8 Comprehension and Analysis of Grade-Level-Appropriate Text 5.2.3 Recognize main ideas presented in texts, identifying and assessing evidence that supports those ideas. ILS 1 2 3 5 6 5.2.4 Draw inferences, conclusions, or generalizations about text and support them with textual evidence and prior knowledge. ILS 1 2 3 6 Expository (Informational) Critique 5.2.5 Distinguish among facts, supported inferences, and opinions in text. ILS 1 2 3 6 Organization and Focus 5.4.1 Discuss ideas for writing, keep a list or notebook of ideas, and use graphic organizers to plan writing. ILS 1 2 3 6 8 9 5.4.3 Write informational pieces with multiple paragraphs that present important ideas or events in sequence or in chronological order. provide details and transitions to link paragraphs. offer a concluding paragraph that summarizes important ideas and details IILS 3 6 8 9R Research and Technology 5.4.4 Use organizational features of printed text, such as citations, endnotes, and bibliographic references, to locate relevant information. ILS 1 8 5.4.5 Use note-taking skills. ILS 3 6 5.4.6 Create simple documents using a computer and employing organizational features, such as passwords, entry and pull-down menus, word searches, the thesaurus, and spell checks. ILS 4 6 8 Evaluation and Revision 5.4.8 Review, evaluate, and revise writing for meaning and clarity. ILS 3 5 6 5.4.10 Edit and revise writing to improve meaning and focus through adding, deleting, combining, clarifying, and rearranging words and sentences. ILS 3 4 5 6 8 WRITING: Applications (Different Types of Writing and Their Characteristics) 5.5.3 Write research reports about important ideas, issues, or events by using the following guidelines: " Frame questions that direct the investigation. " Establish a main idea or topic. " Develop the topic with simple facts, details, examples, and explanations. " Use a variety of information sources, including firsthand interviews, reference materials, and electronic resources, to locate information for the report. ILS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 5.5.5 Use varied word choices to make writing interesting. ILS 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Grammar 5.6.3 Identify and correctly use appropriate tense (present, past, present participle, past participle) for verbs that are often misused (lie/lay, sit/set, rise/raise). ILS 0 5.6.4 Identify and correctly use modifiers (words or phrases that describe, limit, or qualify another word) and pronouns (he/his, she/her, they/their, it/its). " Correct: On the walls there are many pictures of people who have visited the restaurant. " Incorrect: There are many pictures of people who have visited the restaurant on the walls. " Correct: Jenny and Kate finished their game. " Incorrect: Jenny and Kate finished her game. ILS 0 Punctuation 5.6.5 Use a colon to separate hours and minutes (12:20 a.m., 3:40 p.m.) and to introduce a list (Do the project in this order: cut, paste, fold.); use quotation marks around the exact words of a speaker and titles of articles, poems, songs, short stories, and chapters in books; use semi-colons and commas for transitions (Time is short; however; we will still get the job done.). ILS 0 Capitalization 5.6.6 Use correct capitalization. ILS 0 Spelling 5.6.7 Spell roots or bases of words, prefixes (understood/misunderstood, excused/unexcused), suffixes (final/finally, mean/meanness), contractions (will not/won't, it is/it's, they would/they'd), and syllable constructions (in-for-ma-tion, mol-e-cule) correctly. ILS 0 LISTENING AND SPEAKING: Skills, Strategies, and Applications Comprehension 5.7.1 Ask questions that seek information not already discussed. ILS 1 2 3 6 5.7.2 Interpret a speaker's verbal and nonverbal messages, purposes, and perspectives. ILS 2 3 6 5.7.3 Make inferences or draw conclusions based on an oral report. ILS 1 2 3 6 Organization and Delivery of Oral Communication 5.7.4 Select a focus, organizational structure, and point of view for an oral presentation. ILS 2 3 4 5 6 9 5.7.5 Clarify and support spoken ideas with evidence and examples. 2 3 4 5 6 9 5.7.6 Use volume, phrasing, timing, and gestures appropriately to enhance meaning. 9 ILS 0 Speaking Applications 5.7.10 Deliver informative presentations about an important idea, issue, or event by the following means: " frame questions to direct the investigation. " establish a controlling idea or topic. " develop the topic with simple facts, details, examples, and explanations. ILS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 2 Information Literacy Standards Met by this unit: Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently. Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively. Standard 4: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and pursues information related to personal interests. Standard 5: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and appreciates literature and other creative expressions of information. Standard 6: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and strives for excellence in information seeking and knowledge generation. Standard 7: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and recognizes the importance of information to a democratic society. Standard 8: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and practices ethical behavior in regard to information and information technology. Standard 9: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. (ALA 8-9) Information Inquiry Model and Lesson Plan: The Big6™ research model developed by Mike Eisenberg and Bob Berkowitz will be used as the students progress through their research. The Big6™ model acts as a guide to problem solving for the students. It helps students find, evaluate and use information effectively. It gives them structure that will help them in the information gathering process. It also offers students flexibility so that as they come up to roadblocks it allows them to go back and rework through any problems they encounter. The following are the six steps used in this research model. 1. Task definition: In this step the student is to identify the information problem and identify the information he will need to solve the problem. The student will use this step to identify who they want to study for their biography and identify the information they will need to find out about their person. For this project the students will be given a list of questions by the teacher to guide them in their research. 2. Information Seeking Strategies: In this step the student will determine the range of resources that are available to use and select the best resources to for their search. In this project students will use print and non-print resources. The 10 3. 4. 5. 6. teacher has supplied a list of resources for the student to choose from as a guide, but the student my find additional sources also. Location and Access: In this step students will find out how to get these resources and actually access them. They should keep records of the resources so they can come back to them. Students will want to make a list of keywords that will help them find information as they access these resources. For this project keywords would include words such as the persons name and events he/she was involved in during the Revolution. Use of Information: In this step students will read, listen or view the information they have gathered and select the relevant information from these sources by taking notes. One of the lessons the students will have with this unit is a study skills lesson on note taking taught by the media specialist. They will use the skills they learn from this lesson to extract and record information from their resources. Synthesis: Students will organize their information from all the resources they are using and present the information in a final product. For this project students will be presenting their information in three ways. They will take the information and write a one to two page paper on their person. From this they will put together a PowerPoint to share the information with the class. Then as a final step they will work in groups to present their information in interview format for a TV show “Dateline 1776”. Evaluation: As a final step the students will be asked to evaluate their product and their information process. They will be asked to compare their products – the paper, PowerPoint and interview – to the requirements for the assignment that the teachers gave them. They will also look at the problem-solving process and ask themselves questions such as what they leaned, what worked well for them and what would they do differently next time. In this project students will also be asked to reflect back on what they leaned about the person they studied and did they find any characteristics or events in the life of that person that could be relevant today. (Jansen) Media Specialist Lesson Plan Within Unit Note-taking This lesson, taught by the media specialist, will instruct students on using notetaking to extract needed information from their sources. They will learn how to take concise and pertinent notes that they will then use to develop and present in their final project. This lesson will focus on step 4 of The Big6™ inquiry model. This is the step where the students read, listen to, or view their sources and take out the relevant information using note-taking skills and citing sources. This step is similar to the “Exploring Information” step of Kuhlthau’s Information Search Process (ISP). In the ISP, students investigate information to locate relevant information and lists facts and bibliographic citations. Students will use this step to find focus in their project (Callison 29). This lesson incorporates the state standards in English: 5.2.2 Analyze text that is organized in sequential or chronological order. 5.2.3 Recognize main ideas presented in texts, identifying and assessing evidence that supports those ideas 11 5.4.4 Use organizational features of printed text, such as citations, endnotes, and bibliographic references, to locate relevant information. ILS 1 5.4.5 Use note-taking skills. ILS 3 62 It incorporates the following information literacy skills: 1. The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. 2. The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently. 3. The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively. 6. The student who is an independent learner is information literate and strives for excellence in information seeking and knowledge generation. (ALA 8-9) The media specialist, with the help of the teacher, will teach the students a research skills lesson on note-taking. In this lesson she will be helping students how to extract relevant information from their sources and take concise, pertinent notes. The students will learn how to use a graphic organizer to assist them with organizing their notes and resources. 1. The lesson will start with an enthusiastic role-playing exercise by the media specialist and the English teacher. They play the parts of a teenager who has to take a message for her parents from their friend who is on a pay phone at the mall. The script for the role-playing can be found at: http://www.big6.com/showarticle.php?id=41 . This exercise is a fun way to get the students attention. They will get an understanding of taking notes using keywords and related words. They are able to understand the lesson and connect it to the real world. This will take about 10 – 15 minutes. 2. The media specialist will then lead the students through a note-taking exercise using a short biography of Amelia Earhart. (see page 15). The media specialist will use a KWL chart written on the board or with an overhead projector (see page 14). The students will brainstorm what they know about Amelia Earhart and what they would like to find out about her. From this they will come up with a variety of questions to find the answer to. 3. The students will be divided up into pairs and each pair will receive a copy of the graphic organizer for note-taking (see page 16). The media specialist will explain how they are to fill these out. For this exercise only one resource will be used. 4. The teacher will pass out the brief biography of Amelia Earhart to each student. The students will be given time to read the biographies and work in their groups of two and take notes from the biography. The media specialist and teacher will circulate through the room to answer any questions the students might have. The process of note-taking could also be done on computers to add an element of technology if the media specialist would like. 5. After thirty minutes the class will come back together, and as a group, they will go over the notes the students extracted from the biography and complete the KWL chart. 12 6. Assessment for this lesson will be based on the completion of the graphic organizer. Students will be given full credit or partial credit depending on the number of questions from step two they were able to answer with their notes. (Sample of completed note-taking worksheet can be seen on page 17) Materials required: Chalk board or overhead projector KWL chart (either on chalk board or transparency) Biography of Amelia Earhart (28) Graphic organizer for note-taking (16 print copies – additional copies will be available for students) Or graphic organizer could be put on computers for student to use. Will need 16 computers for students to work in pairs. 13 14 Amelia Earhart Amelia Earhart was born in Atchison, Kansas, on July 24, 1897. She was the first child born to Edwin and Amy Earhart. Three years later, Amelia's sister Muriel was born. The girls’ childhood was not always easy. Their father’s drinking caused him to lose a good paying job with the railroad. Soon after that, the family split up. The girls and their mother moved to Chicago. In 1917, Amelia went to Canada to visit her sister at school. There she met some World War I soldiers who had been hurt in battle. That chance meeting led Amelia to change her mind about going to college. Instead, she took up nursing. She worked as a nurse in a soldiers’ hospital. By 1920, Amelia’s parents had gotten back together and moved to California. Amelia moved to California to be with them. It was there one day that Amelia paid $1, put on a helmet and goggles, and took a 10-minute plane ride over Los Angeles. Amelia later said, “As soon as we left the ground, I knew I myself had to fly!” Amelia worked several jobs to earn the money she needed to take flying lessons with a woman pilot, Anita Snooks. Soon, Amelia would buy her own plane. In 1927, Amelia got a phone call that changed her life. Captain Hilton Railey called and made an offer Amelia could not turn down. In 1928, Amelia became the first woman to fly across the Atlantic Ocean. Even though Amelia was not the pilot, the newspapers pretty much ignored the two men who piloted the plane; Amelia received most of the attention. Four years later, Amelia flew across the Atlantic on her own in record time -- 13 hours, 30 minutes. By that time, she was famous throughout Europe and the United States. A few years later, she became the first woman to fly from Hawaii to California. In 1929, Amelia participated in a cross-country air race for women pilots. She also founded an organization of women pilots called the "Ninety-Nines" -- named for its first 99 members. In June 1937, Amelia set out to fly around the world. She and her navigator, Fred Noonan, flew from Miami, Florida, to South America, and then across the Atlantic Ocean to Africa. They continued over the Sahara desert and on to Thailand and Australia. After taking off from New Guinea, the U.S. Coast Guard lost contact with the plane. No trace of the plane or its passengers was ever found. © 2003 by Education World®. Education World grants educators permission to reproduce this page for classroom use. 15 My Research Notes About _____________________________________________________ Name: Research Question 1 Research Question 2 Research Question 3 Date: Research Source 1 Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Research Source 2 Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Research Source 3 Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes 16 A Sample of a note-taking organizer filled out during group discussion Additional pages would be available for more research questions. My Research Notes About _Amelia Earhart______________________ Name: Sarah Smith and Lucy Davis Research Question 1 Why did she take up nursing? Research Question 2 What event made her take up flying Research Question 3 What record did she set in 1931? Research Source 1 Amelia Earhart Biography Click here to type in your notes 1917 Canada Sister World War I soldiers Click here to type in your notes 1920 LosAngeles,California $1 Parents together Click here to type in your notes Across Atlantic Alone 13 hr 30 min Research Source 2 Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Research Source 3 Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Click here to type in your notes Date: Dec. 3, 2005 17 Unit Evaluation: Students will be asked for an informal evaluation of this project in a class discussion. This will give them a chance to reflect back on the project and think about what they learned about their topic and the research skills they developed. They will be asked questions such as: What was the most interesting part of the project for them? Was there a particular source they discovered in the research process that was new to them? What did they feel they did well in this project? What can they do differently next time? Did they learn any new skills while working on this project? Is there anything they learned while working on this project that they can relate to their lives today? Project evaluation will be completed by both teachers and media specialist together at a meeting within two weeks after the conclusion of the project. The following evaluation questions will be used as guides in the evaluation. Total time required: Number of students involved: What worked will in this unit? What could be improved? How effective were the collaborative activities? In what ways did the collaborative activities enhance the unit? How could the collaborative activities be improved? To what extent were the academic standards and information literacy standards met? What were the overall results of the student assessments? What was the overall student response to the unit? From the evidence collected during this evaluation, plans can be made that would include improvements and possible extensions of this project for future use. Resources and References: There were several resources used in compiling this unit. Lesson Locator is a database of more then 1000 lessons developed by Indiana teachers and aligned to the Indianan State Standards. These lesson plans were selected by Indiana teachers under the direction of the Indiana Department of Education. This site offered ideas for lesson requirement, time frames, and resources. . Indiana’s Academic Standards lists the Academic Standards established by the state of Indiana to outline what students should know and be able to do at each grade level. By using the Social Studies and English standards the focus of the lesson was established. In addition the Information Literacy Standards were included to indicate the process in which these standards are used to help develop critical thinking skills and information-literate students. “American Revolution Webquest” is a webquest created by Laura A. Frondorf. This source offered ideas for planning a project on the American Revolution. Although this plan covered a broader area of the war then just biographies, it offered ideas for activities, resources, evaluations and general ideas for a project on the American Revolution. 18 Children’s Literature in the Elementary School is a comprehensive source about children’s literature and how to use literature in the classroom. It contains teaching features that show how literature can be used in the classroom, guidelines for evaluating books, extensive lists of children’s literature and much more. This book was used to help in the selection of a piece of literature to share with the class that would relate to the Revolutionary War and the people of that time period. Collaborating to Meet Standards: Teacher/Librarian Partnerships for K-6 is a guide to assist librarians and teachers meet the mandate, set forth by Information Power: Building Partnerships for Learning, of collaboration through planning and teaching to promote information literacy in students. It contains information on what it takes to have successful collaboration projects, overcoming roadblocks, and the benefits to students, administrators, teachers and the media specialist. There are several samples of collaboration units that correlate to Standards and link to Information Power Literacy Standards. They offer cooperative teaching plans, resources, activity ideas and evaluation tools. This source offered excellent examples of how the media specialist fits into a collaboration project. Carol Simpson’s article on The Big6™ website “Note-Taking (Grades 4-6)” is a great source for a fun activity that will engage the students right away. This attention getting activity will capture their attention and teach them about the importance of accurate note-taking in an entertaining way. Education World is a search engine for educational websites that includes lesson plans, practical information for educators, information on integrating technology into the classroom, articles written by education experts and much more. I used information from this site in putting together the lesson on note-taking. The KWL chart and the graphic organizer for note-taking are from this site. This site is a valuable tool for both teachers and administrators. 19 Voices of the American Revolution (11th Grade) Student Audience: This high school is located in the same town as that of the elementary school. It is a suburb of a large metropolitan area in the state of Indiana. It is the county seat with a population of approximately 30,000. The town is a mixture of old restored historical buildings and Victorian streets and a new growing economy that is evident in new construction in both the business sector and the residential areas. This building is ten years old and offers students many opportunities for use of technology along with a large well developed print collection in the media center. The school has 2,200 students in grades nine through twelve, and they come from a variety of economic and social backgrounds. The high school is on a block schedule so classes meet for ninety minute periods alternating two and three times a week. Students also have opportunities for research in the media center during study hall and before and after school. The administrators and teachers of this school strive for success for all students, with a curriculum developed to meet the school and state academic goals. This unit will be taught in a regular classroom of eleventh grade United States history, with thirty students. There are a variety of learning levels in the classroom. All students will have had some background in research in the ninth and tenth grade, but it will be important to provide resources for all levels of learners. There will be a brief review of research skills and a lesson on the use of primary resources that will be taught by the media specialist. One of the motivations for these students in this unit will be to achieve a good grade. However, that does not always apply to all students so in addition the unit must have something interesting for the students to work on. In this unit there will be opportunities for group work and discussion that will make the assignment more interesting for the students. Students will be able to select their own topic in the area and this should help motivate them. By allowing the students to choose their own topics for the research and final debate, they will be motivated by their own personal interest in their research. This process is illustrated in the I-Search research model described by Joyce and Tallman (Callison 45). Students will be making connections to the “real world” throughout this project. By using primary resources they will get a look at the real world documents that helped form the nation they now live in. They can see that in the days of the birth of the nation, just as in the world today, there are a variety of ideas and opinions that often clash. As they research and prepare their debate, they will learn skills that will enable them to prepare for debates and expressing their own opinions on topics that will come up in their lives in today’s world. Information Inquiry Role and Unit Overview: The American Revolution is a key part of the eleventh grade curriculum. Students will learn the major themes of United States history at this time period, and develop an understanding of the ideas of the government and rights that were part of the documents written at this time. Part of this curriculum is to find and understand both primary and secondary documents and the variety of perspectives that they represented. In this unit students will be looking beyond just the facts and use their critical thinking skills to gain a full understanding of the people and events of this time. The history teacher and the media specialist will work together to assist students with their research, 20 reading, writing and technology skills, as they research their topics and prepare their final products. Project Overview: In this unit students will look at the variety of opinions about the legitimacy of resistance and rebellion leading up to the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. Students will study the diverse perspectives and motivations of the colonists and understanding how their positions changed over the decade preceding the rebellion. In this lesson, students will be taught how to make informed analyses of primary documents illustrating the diversity of religious, political, social, and economic motives behind competing perspectives on questions of independence and rebellion. Using of a variety of primary texts will help students to "hear" some of the colonial voices that contributed to the American Revolution. Students will be introduced to a variety of individuals and viewpoints based on primary documents. They will choose the topic they are interested in and prepare for an in-class debate. They will also write an essay based on the research for their topic. Unit Objectives: United States History - Students will learn the major themes of United States history during the colonial and founding periods, and develop an understanding of the ideas of the government and rights that were part of the documents written at this time. They will also locate and analyze both primary and secondary documents and the variety of perspectives that they represented. In addition, they will receive instruction on preparing for the classroom debate. Media/Technology – Students will use a variety of research tools, both in print and on computers, to research their topics. They will receive instruction on interpreting primary documents to assist them in their research. They will also be assisted in using a variety of resources available to them beyond the high school media building, such as archival collections, museums, and historic sites. Collaborative Roles: History Teacher – Introduce the American Revolution and present the individuals and viewpoints that are to be studied. Offer a variety of the primary documents that will be used by the students to prepare for their debates. Assist students with research and present them with instructions for the preparation for class debates. Media Specialist – Teach lesson on interpreting primary documents. Assist students with research in media center with both print and online sources. Assist students with finding sources that are available to them beyond the media center setting. Time Frame: The history and media specialist will meet one or two times before the unit starts to set up the plan for the unit. They will meet one more time at the completion of the unit for an evaluation of the project. Week one – Students will receive the introduction of the unit and pick their topic. They will have the lesson on the interpretation and analysis of primary documents in the media center. They will begin their research. Week two – Students will continue to research their topics, begin writing their essays and prepare for their debates. Week three – Class will hold their debates and essays will be due. 21 Student Resources: Selected Websites from EDSITEment Africans in America from PBS [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/title.html] "Runaways" [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/2p17.html] "Free black Patriots" [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/2p53.html] "Of the Natural Rights of Colonists" [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/2h18.html] "Felix's Petition" [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/2h22.html] American Memory Collection [http://memory.loc.gov/] Documents from the Continental Congress and Constitutional Convention 1774-1789 [http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/bdsds/bdsdhome.html] Time Line, America During the Age of Revolution, 1764-1775 [http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/bdsds/timeline.html] Avalon Project of the Yale Law School [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/avalon.htm] Patrick Henry speech "Give me Liberty or Give Me Death" [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/patrick.htm] Richard Henry Lee's resolution concerning independence [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/lee.htm] Virginia Declaration of Rights [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/virginia.htm] The Constitution of Virginia [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/states/va05.htm] The Articles of Association; October 20, 1774 [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/contcong/10-20-74.htm] Declaration of Independence [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/declare.htm] The American Crisis by Thomas Paine [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/paine/p1.htm] Digital Classroom [http://www.archives.gov/digital_classroom/index.html] Declaration of Independence [http://www.archives.gov/exhibit_hall/charters_of_freedom/ declaration/declaration.html] Written Document Analysis Worksheet [http://www.archives.gov/digital_classroom/ lessons/analysis_worksheets/document.htm] Internet Public Library [http://www.ipl.org/] 22 From Revolution to Reconstruction [http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/I/pages.htm] Charles Inglis, The True Interest of America Impartially Stated [http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/D/1776-1800/libertydebate/inglis.htm] Declaration of the Causes and Necessity of taking up Arms, July 6, 1775 [http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/D/1751-1775/war/causes.htm] Loyalist, British Songs & Poetry of the American Revolution Written, Designed & Maintained by M. Christopher New Writer/Historian [http://users.erols.com/candidus/music.htm] Constitutional documents provided by the Law and Liberty Foundation [http://www.lawandliberty.org/mission.htm] Jonathan Mayhew - resistance to a tyrant was a Christian duty [http://www.lawandliberty.org/mayhew.htm] Archiving Early America [http://www.earlyamerica.com/] Plain Truth by James Chalmers [http://earlyamerica.com/review/fall96/loyalists.html] Famous Trials, Boston Massacre Trial provided by the University of Missouri at Kansas City [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/bostonmassacre/ bostonmassacre.html] Deposition of Captain Thomas Preston and witnesses for the King [http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/bostonmassacre/ prestontrialexcerpts.html] The Papers of George Washington at the University of Virginia [http://gwpapers.virginia.edu/index.html] "George Washington letter to George Mason on April 5, 1769" [http://www.virginia.edu/gwpapers/revolution/letters/mason.html] "George Washington letter George William Fairfax May 31 1775" [http://www.virginia.edu/gwpapers/revolution/letters/gwfairfax2.html] TeacherServe: From the National Humanities Center. [http://www.nhc.rtp.nc.us:8080/tserve/tserve.htm] Religion and the American Revolution [http://www.nhc.rtp.nc.us:8080/tserve/eighteen/ekeyinfo/erelrev.htm] Religion and the Founding of the American Republic. [http://lcweb.loc.gov/exhibits/religion/rel03.html] Jonathan Mayhew, "Discourse Concerning Unlimited Submission and Non-Resistance to Higher Powers" [http://www.lawandliberty.org/mayhew.htm] Joseph Galloway, "Historical and Political Reflections on the Rise and Progress of the American Rebellion" [http://lcweb.loc.gov/exhibits/religion/vc006771.jpg] Needlework: Allegory of the American Revolution [http://lcweb.loc.gov/exhibits/religion/rel03.html 23 Books: Listed here are a few titles from the media center that contain primary documents and other information helpful for students’ research. Check media center catalog and the public library for additional titles. The American Revolution By Charles W. Carey, ed. The Long Fuse: How England Lost the American Colonies, 1760- 1785 By Don Cook Founding the Republic, a Documentary History By John J. Patrick, ed. The Declaration of Independence By Kelly Barth, ed. Vindicating the Founders: Race, Sex, Class and Justice in the Origin of America By Thomas G. West The Founding of American By Leora Maltz, ed. The American Revolution: An Eyewitness History By David F. Burg Primary Sources By David M. Haugen, ed. The Spirit of “seventy-six” By Henry Steele Commager & Richard B. Morris, eds. The Revolutionary Era: Primary Documents on Events From 1776-1800 By Carol Sue Humphrey 24 Assessment: There will be three steps of assessment in this unit. The first step will be during the lesson on Analyzing Primary Documents that will be taught by the media specialist. This will be a general assessment of participation by students in group and class discussion. This assessment will be based on the completion of worksheets and observation by media specialist and teacher (see lesson description page 8). Assessment for the debate will be based on the Point/Counterpoint Rubric. Assessment for the essay will be based on the Essay Rubric. Both of these rubrics will be handed out to the students at the beginning of the unit. These rubrics will guide the students through the project and help them understand what level of work is expected of them. State Academic Standards met by this unit for United States History USH.1.1 Explain major ideas about government and key rights rooted in the colonial and founding periods, which are embedded in key documents. (Civics and Government) USH.1.2 Explain major themes in the early national history of the United States. USH.1.3 Review and summarize key events and developments in the following periods of United States history: Founding the Republic (1775–1801), Expansion and Reform (1801–1861), Civil War and Reconstruction (1850–1877). USH.9.1 Locate and analyze primary and secondary sources presenting differing perspectives on events and issues of the past. USH.9.2 Locate and use sources found at local and state libraries, archival collections, museums, historic sites and electronic sites.1 Information Literacy Standards met by this unit Standard 1: The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. Standard 2: The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently. Standard 3: The student who is information literate uses information accurately and creatively. Standard 4: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and pursues information related to personal interests. Standard 6: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and strives for excellence in information seeking and knowledge generation. Standard 7: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and recognizes the importance of information to a democratic society. Standard 8: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and practices ethical behavior in regard to information and information technology. 25 Standard 9: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. (ALA 8-9) Information Inquiry Model and Lesson Plan: As Callison describes in Key Words, Concepts and Methods of Information Age Instruction, all information inquiry models are constructed of five basic components: questioning, exploration, assimilation, inference and reflection (25). In this project, as in the fifth grade “Biographies of the American Revolution” a variety of models could be used. Kuhlthaua’s Information Search Process contains steps similar to The Big6™. It starts with selection of a topic followed by investigating information and selecting the relevant information for the project. Information is synthesized and put together in a final product and assessment of both the product and the process occurs (Callison 28-29). Unlike Eisenburg’s Big6™, Kuhlthaua also includes in her model the thoughts and feelings the students are going through at each step. This can be a very helpful tool for the teacher and media specialist to know, so they can understand the difficulties the student might be having at certain stages of research and be more able to assist them. The I-Search model could also be used for these projects. It takes the same basic components and puts them into four main steps. The first step in the I-Search model is for students to choose a topic that interests them. In each of these units the general topic of the American Revolution has been chosen by the teachers, but the students still have the option of selecting the person or area of interest to them within that main topic. In the I-Search model, the students would proceed to the next three steps: finding the information, using the information by taking notes and analyzing the materials, and then develop the final product (Lamb). Each of these models shows slight differences, but all contain the five basic components described by Callison. The high school and the elementary school described in these projects are part of a school district which encourages the use of The Big6™ as a research model for their students. This model can effectively guide students through the research process. It gives the students a structure that will help them through the information gathering process, analysis of the information, and putting together their information in the final products. 1. Task definition: In this step the students will identify the viewpoint or person they want to research and represent in their essay and debate. These choices will be based on primary documents they select to work with. 2. Information Seeking Strategies: Students will look at both print and nonprint sources on their topic. Some of these sources have been supplied to them by the teacher and media specialist. They will also be expected to search for additional resources. 3. Location and Access: Students will keep records of resources as they find them. Students will find this information by using resources supplied to them by the teacher and media specialist, and find additional resources by searching using keywords they have defined for their topic. They can use these keywords to search book indexes, table of contents, databases and authoritative websites. 4. Use of Information: Prior to beginning their research, students will have had a lesson in analyzing primary resources taught by the media specialist. 26 Using what they learned they will analyze the information and gather the information that will be relevant for their projects. 5. Synthesis: Students will gather their information and put together their final projects. For this unit students will be writing an essay that demonstrates their point of view supported by both primary and secondary resources they researched. In addition, they will prepare for and participate in a debate in class defending their point of view based on these primary resources. 6. Evaluation: In this final step, students will evaluate their products comparing them to the assessment guidelines that were given to them by the teacher and media specialist. They will also look back on the research process and ask themselves questions such as what they learned, what worked well and what would they do differently next time. Students will also be able to reflect on what they learned and how it relates to life today, looking at controversial issues with a variety of perspectives. (Jansen) Media Specialist Lesson Plan Within Unit Analyzing Primary Documents This lesson, taught by the media specialist, will instruct students on how to analyze primary documents. It will focus on step 4 of The Big6™ inquiry model which is the “use of information”. Students will engage in the resources by reading and viewing the primary documents. They will analyze the documents and pull out the relevant information, taking notes and citing sources. This lesson incorporates the state standards in United States history 9.1: Locate and analyze primary and secondary sources presenting differing perspectives on events and issues of the past. It incorporates the following information literacy standards: 1. The student who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively. 2. The student who is information literate evaluates information critically and competently. 7. The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and recognizes the importance of information to a democratic society. 9. The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to society is information literate and participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information. (ALA 8-9) The teacher and media specialist will work as a team to help students gain an understanding of primary documents and interpreting the information they represent. At the beginning of the unit, the teacher will lay the foundation to the events leading up to the Revolutionary War and the people who played key roles in this part of American history. This will be followed by the lesson on Analyzing Primary Documents taught by the media specialist. 27 1. Media specialist will explain the difference between a primary document and a secondary document using a computer with projector to display the Declaration of Independence from the National Archives, and a book about the Declaration. Primary documents – http://www.archives.gov/national-archivesexperience/charters/declaration.html Secondary documents – Give Me Liberty: The Story of the Declaration of Independence by Russell Freedman. Media specialist will explain the worksheets the students will be using. 2. Class will be divided into five groups. Each group will be given a copy of the Written Document Analysis Worksheet (see page 29) and Photo and Photo Analysis Worksheet (see page 30). Each group will also receive a copy of the primary document letter written by George Washington to George Mason April 5, 1769 (see page 32-34), and a copy of the print Valley Forge (see page 31). 3. Students will be given thirty minutes to work in their groups to analyze the letter and print, filling out the worksheets which they will use as guides for their discussion. 4. The media specialist and teacher will circulate through the room answering questions and observing the groups. 5. At the end of the thirty minutes the groups will select one person to share the results of their group with the class. As each group shares their results the entire class will discuss the results. 6. Assessment of this lesson will be based on the completion of the worksheets by each group, and observation of the students working in the groups by the teacher and media specialist. Five points will be given for completed worksheets and five points for student participation in discussion. (Sample of completed worksheet can be seen on page 35) Materials required: Computer with project tor (1) Give Me Liberty: The Story of the Declaration of Independence by Russell Freedman (1) Photo Analysis Worksheet (5 – 1 per group) Written Document Analysis Worksheet (5 – 1 per group) Letter written by George Washington to George Mason April 5, 1769 (30 – 1 per student) Print of Valley Forge (30 – 1 per student) Additional copies of the worksheets will be made available for students to use in their research. 28 Written Document Analysis Worksheet TYPE OF DOCUMENT (Check one): 1. ___ ___ ___ ___ 2. Newspaper Letter Patent Memorandum ___ ___ ___ ___ Map Telegram Press release Report ___ ___ ___ ___ Advertisement Congressional record Census report Other UNIQUE PHYSICAL QUALITIES OF THE DOCUMENT (Check one or more): ___ ___ ___ ___ Interesting letterhead Handwritten Typed Seals ___ Notations ___ "RECEIVED" stamp ___ Other 3. DATE(S) OF DOCUMENT: ___________________________________________________________________________ 4. AUTHOR (OR CREATOR) OF THE DOCUMENT: ___________________________________________________________________________ POSITION (TITLE): ___________________________________________________________________________ 5. FOR WHAT AUDIENCE WAS THE DOCUMENT WRITTEN? ___________________________________________________________________________ 6. DOCUMENT INFORMATION (There are many possible ways to answer A-E.) A. List three things the author said that you think are important: ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ B. Why do you think this document was written? ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ C. What evidence in the document helps you know why it was written? Quote from the document. ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ D. List two things the document tells you about life in the United States at the time it was written: ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ E. Write a question to the author that is left unanswered by the document: ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ Designed and developed by the Education Staff, National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC 20408. 29 Photo Analysis Worksheet Step 1. Observation A. Study the photograph for 2 minutes. Form an overall impression of the photograph and then examine individual items. Next, divide the photo into quadrants and study each section to see what new details become visible. ___________________________________________________________________________ B. Use the chart below to list people, objects, and activities in the photograph. People Objects Activities Step 2. Inference Based on what you have observed above, list three things you might infer from this photograph. ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ Step 3. Questions A. What questions does this photograph raise in your mind? ___________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________ B. Where could you find answers to them? ___________________________________________________________________________ 30 ___________________________________________________________________________ Designed and developed by the Education Staff, National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC 20408. 31 http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/revolution-images/images/valley-forge.gif 32 Letter from George Washington to George Mason April 1769 Delegate from Virginia to the Constitutional Convention Mount Vernon 5th April 1769. http://gwpapers.virginia.edu/documents/revolution/le tters/mason.html Dear sir, Herewith you will receive a letter and sundry papers which were forwarded to me a day or two ago by Doctor Ross of Bladensburg. [1] I transmit them with the greater pleasure, as my own desire of knowing your sentiments upon a matter of this importance exactly coincides with the Doctrs inclinations. At a time when our lordly Masters in Great Britain will be satisfied with nothing less than the deprivation of American freedom, it seems highly necessary that something shou'd be done to avert the stroke and maintain the liberty which we have derived from our Ancestors; but the manner of doing it to answer the purpose effectually is the point in question. That no man shou'd scruple, or hesitate a moment to use a--ms in defence of so valuable a blessing, on which all the good and evil of life depends; is clearly my opinion; Yet A--ms I wou'd beg leave to add, should be the last resource; the de[r]nier resort. Addresses to the Throne, and remonstrances to parliament, we have already, it is said, proved the inefficacy of; how far then their attention to our rights & priviledges is to be awakened or alarmed by starving their Trade & manufactures, remains to be tryed. The northern Colonies, it appears, are endeavouring to adopt this scheme--In my opinion it is a good one; & must be attended with salutary effects, provided it can be carried pretty generally into execution; but how far it is practicable to do so, I will not take upon me to determine. That there will be difficulties attending the execution of it every where, from clashing interests, & selfish designing men (ever attentive to their own gain, & watchful of every turn that can assist their lucrative views, in preference to any other consideration) cannot be denied; but in the Tobacco Colonies where the Trade is so diffused, and in a manner wholly conducted by Factors for their principals at home, these difficulties are certainly enhanced, but I think not insurmountably increased, if the Gentlemen in their several counties wou'd be at some pains to explain matters to the people, & stimulate them to a cordial agreement to purchase none but certain innumerated articles out of any of the Stores after such a period, nor import nor purchase any themselves. This, if it did not effectually withdraw the Factors from their Importations, wou'd at least make them extremely cautious in doing it, as the prohibited Goods could be vended to none but the non-associater, or those who wou'd pay no regard to their association; both of whom ought to be stigmatized, and made the objects of publick reproach. The more I consider a Scheme of this sort, the more ardently I wish success to it, because I think there are private, as well as public advantages to result from it--the former certain, however precarious the other may prove; for in respect to the latter I have always thought that by virtue of the same power (for here alone the authority derives) which assume's the right of Taxation, they may attempt at least to restrain our manufactories; especially those of a public nature; the same equity & justice prevailing in the one case as the other, it being no greater hardship to forbid my manufacturing, than it is to order me to buy Goods of them loaded with Duties, for the express purpose of raising a revenue. But as a measure of this sort will be an additional exertion of arbitrary power, we cannot be worsted I think in putting it to the Test. On the other hand, 33 that the Colonies are considerably indebted to Great Britain, is a truth universally acknowledged. That many families are reduced, almost, if not quite, to penury & want, from the low ebb of their fortunes, and Estates daily selling for the discharge of Debts, the public papers furnish but too many melancholy proofs of. And that a scheme of this sort will contribute more effectually than any other I can devise to immerge the Country from the distress it at present labours under, I do most firmly believe, if it can be generally adopted. And I can see but one set of people (the Merchants excepted) who will not, or ought not, to wish well to the Scheme; and that is those who live genteely & hospitably, on clear Estates. Such as these were they, not to consider the valuable object in view, & the good of others, might think it hard to be curtail'd in their living & enjoyments; for as to the penurious man, he saves his money, & he saves his credit; having the best plea for doing that, which before perhaps he had the most violent struggles to refrain from doing. The extravagant & expensive man has the same good plea to retrench his Expences--He is thereby furnished with a pretext to live within bounds, and embraces it--prudence dictated hconomy to him before, but his resolution was too weak to put it in practice; for how can I, says he, who have lived in such & such a manner change my method? I am ashamed to do it: and besides, such an alteration in the System of my living, will create suspicions of a decay in my fortune, & such a thought the world must not harbour; I will e'en continue my course: till at last the course discontinues the Estate, a sale of it being the consequence of his perseverance in error. This I am satisfied is the way that many who have set out in the wrong tract, have reasoned, till ruin stares them in the face. And in respect to the poor & needy man, he is only left in the same situation he was found; better I might say, because as he judges from comparison, his condition is amended in proportion as it approaches nearer to those above him. Upon the whole therefore, I think the Scheme a good one, and that it ought to be tryed here, with such alterations as the exigency of our circumstances render absolutely necessary; but how, & in what manner to begin the work, is a matter worthy of consideration; and whether it can be attempted with propriety, or efficacy (further than a communication of sentiments to one another) before May, when the Court & Assembly will meet together in Williamsburg, and a uniform plan can be concerted, and sent into the different counties to operate at the same time, & in the same manner every where, is a thing I am somewhat in doubt upon, & shou'd be glad to know your opinion of. I am Dr Sir Your most Obt humble Servant G: Washington Notes GW was not present in April 1768 when the House of Burgesses initiated Virginia's official protest to the Townshend Acts adopted by Parliament in the summer of 1767. He took a leading part, however, in forming in 1769 and 1770 the colony's nonimportation association to promote their repeal, particularly of the act laying taxes on certain colonial imports. It was in response to a circular letter from the Massachusetts legislature that the Virginia burgesses first drew up, and on 16 April 1768 adopted, addresses to the king, Lords, and Commons protesting the passage of the Townshend Acts and calling for their prompt repeal. The next year, in March 1769, the merchants of Philadelphia followed the earlier lead of their counterparts in Boston and New York and, in opposition to the acts, formed an association to ban the importation of a wide array of British goods. Shortly before writing this letter to 34 George Mason on 5 April, GW received from Dr. David Ross of Bladensburg, Md., a copy of a letter to Maryland merchants from Philadelphia merchants enclosing a copy of the nonimportation association that they had adopted for Philadelphia. Ross also sent a copy of the response of Annapolis merchants to the Philadelphians' proposal that Maryland merchants form a similar association as well as a copy of a letter to Virginia merchants from Annapolis merchants in which they forwarded to the Virginia merchants copies of their correspondence with the Philadelphia merchants and a copy of the text of the Pennsylvania nonimportation association. GW seems to have sent on to George Mason all four documents, expressing his own support for the formation of such an association in Virginia and soliciting Mason's reaction. See note 1. Mason immediately responded to GW's letter. He assured GW that he shared his views that the very desirable association could not be formed before the Virginia assembly met in May and expressed his regret that illness prevented his preparing and publishing "Something preparatory to it in our Gazettes" (5 April). As justices, GW and Mason were together in Alexandria for the meeting of the Fairfax County Court on 17 and 18 April, and Mason accompanied GW on the evening of 18 April from Alexandria to Mount Vernon for a visit that lasted until the afternoon of 21 April (see Diaries, 2:141-42). Two days later, on 23 April, Mason sent from his house at Gunston Hall changes that GW was to make in "the Association, of which I sent You a Copy." GW took the copy of Mason's proposal with him when he left Mount Vernon on 30 April to attend the meeting of the assembly in Williamsburg (see Mason to GW, 28 April, nn.1 and 2). GW was in Williamsburg for the opening of the session on 8 May. On 16 May he joined the other burgesses in adopting a series of resolutions reasserting their sole right to lay taxes on their fellow colonists and denouncing the British move to have colonists accused of treason taken to Britain for trial. When at about noon on the next day the new governor, Lord Botetourt, having "heard of your Resolves, and augur ill of their Effect," dissolved the House of Burgesses, GW and most of the other members walked down the Duke of Gloucester Street and met in the Apollo Room of Anthony Hay's Raleigh Tavern (JHB, 1766-1769, 214- 18). The moderator of the meeting, Speaker Peyton Randolph, made GW a member of a committee to present on the next day a plan for forming a nonimportation association in Virginia. GW recorded in his diary for 17 May only that he "Dined at the Treasurers and was upon a Committee at Hays till 10 oclock" (Diaries, 2:152). The plan of association that the committee submitted to the burgesses after they had assembled in the Apollo Room on the morning of 18 May, which ninety-six of the burgesses voted to adopt, was essentially the plan of George Mason given to the committee by GW (see Mason to GW, 28 April, n.1). 1. According to Stanislaus M. Hamilton (Letters to Washington, 3:346-56), GW at some point labeled a packet of his papers: "Old Papers Respecting the Nonimportation of British Goods." Of these, he sent to Mason copies of the four documents that he received from David Ross (see source note). For further reference to the plan of the Pennsylvania nonimportation association, see Mason to GW, 28 April, n.1. For the contents of the letter of the Annapolis merchants to the Philadelphia merchants, see Mason to GW, 5 April, n.3. See also source note. David Ross was a merchant in Bladensburg who served as commissary for the Maryland forces in the French and Indian War. LB, DLC:GW. From The Papers, Colonial Series, 8:177-80. 35 A sample of a worksheet filled out during group discussion Photo Analysis Worksheet Step 1. Observation A. Study the photograph for 2 minutes. Form an overall impression of the photograph and then examine individual items. Next, divide the photo into quadrants and study each section to see what new details become visible. ___________________________________________________________________________ B. Use the chart below to list people, objects, and activities in the photograph. People Objects Activities Washington and Lafayette talking Washington cannon Lafayette empty supplies soldiers around campfire soldiers campfire soldier guarding guard horse soldier walking wounded soldier tents soldier horseback riding Step 2. Inference Based on what you have observed above, list three things you might infer from this photograph. Soldiers are tired, hungry, cold and with insufficient supplies and protection from the weather.___________________________________________________________________________ Soldiers had seen battle, some are wounded. ___________________________________________________________________________ Washington and Lafayette are conferring on something. Step 3. Questions A. What questions does this photograph raise in your mind? What motivated these soldiers to stay under these conditions?__________________________________________________________________________ What were Washington and Lafayette talking about? B. Where could you find answers to them? websites such as http://www.pbs.org/wnet/historyofus/web02/ and http://www.americanrevwar.homestead.com/files/VALLEY.HTM Books from media center such as Washington’s Crossing by David Hackett Fisher ___________________________________________________________________________ Designed and developed by the Education Staff, National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC 20408. 36 Unit Evaluation: Evaluation of this unit will consist of two parts. One will be student evaluation and the other will be an evaluation by the media specialist and the teacher. The students will be asked to fill out a brief six question survey on the project. These questions will give the students an opportunity to look back on the research process and reflect on what they learned and what will be of help to them in the future. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. What was the most interesting part of the project? What information sources were most valuable to you? Where there sources that you needed but were not available? What did you do well in the project? What would you do differently next time? What skills did you acquire that you will be able to use in the future? When the project is complete and the student surveys have been filled out, the teacher and the media specialists will meet for an evaluation of the unit. They will review the student surveys to see if additional resources need to be acquired, and get an understanding of what was most valuable to the students in the research process. They will discuss the results of the students’ debates and essays to make sure the students had a good understanding of the project and the information they were to learn. They will discuss what went well with the project and what appeared to be weak points. From this discussion they will determine what changes need to be made in the project. It is from the evidence gathered during this evaluation that improvements to the project will be made for future use. Resources and References: The main resource that was used for this unit was the lesson plan “Voices of the American Revolution” from the History and Social Studies section of EDSITEment. This is a website from by the National Endowment of the Humanities. This site brings resources from museums, libraries, cultural institutions and universities right into the classrooms. It offers lesson plans in the areas or Art and Culture, Literature and Language Arts and Foreign Language in addition to History and Social Studies. The lesson plans offered on the EDSITEment site are excellent resources, especially for new teachers. They offer detailed lesson plans, resources, and links to additional valuable teaching tools. All of these are easily adaptable to fit the needs of the teacher. The lesson plan “Voices of the American Revolution” was used for this unit with a few adaptations made by the teacher and media specialist. Two of the three options for assignments were used from this lesson. The Tools for Analyzing Primary Documents was used as a guide in planning the lesson the media specialist used in this unit. In addition, the website resources on this site were also made available for the students to use. Print materials from the school media center were also available for the students to use. An initial list of titles on the American Revolution and primary documents was given to the students and they were encouraged to find additional sources by searching the online catalog. Indiana’s Academic Standards lists the Academic Standards established by the state of Indiana to outline what students should know and be able to do at each grade level. By using the United States history standards the focus of the lesson was established. 37 The primary document analysis and photo analysis worksheets are from the National Archives site for educators and students. This site offers training and activities for educators and students, and resources about primary sources. In this unit, these two worksheets were used by the students to guide them through the analysis of primary documents. Field Test: I do not work in a classroom where these units could be field tested, so I had four people review them for me. Margo is an elementary school teacher who has worked part time in a high school media center. Karen is a special education teacher in an elementary school and a recent graduate of the IUPUI SLIS program. Hella is also a recent graduated of the IUPUI SLIS program and has just finished her student teaching at the elementary and high school level. I was also interested in a student opinion. My son Michael, a senior honor student in high school, who took US history last year, looked at the high school unit and gave me his feedback. Margo: (written on paper) 5th Grade Unit 1. Like that 5th graders are given questions as an idea for what they can include in their biography. I think they really need this. Many have not written papers before. 2. Like role-playing exercise at beginning of media specialist lesson on research skills. 3. Letting students do an evaluation of the project is a great way to get some good feedback. I do think it is good to give them some specific questions you want answered – which you did. 4. Great lesson 5. Good mix of groups and individual work. th 11 grade Unit 1. I like that the Big6™is taught to students at the beginning. 2. Like the worksheets – Document Analysis and Photo Analysis. 3. Very interesting lesson. Mr. Hitchcock would be proud. Karen: (e-mail) 5th Grade Unit Jan, Another very well thought out information inquiry activity. Lots of collaboration between Media specialist,LA and SS teachers! Students should learn a lot from detailed lesson plans, 1-on-1 conferencing, pp presentions, and oral presentation with the interview talk show as the culminating activity. What fun! Since both 5th and 11th graders are working on American Revolution wouldn't it be a neat idea if they could get together - maybe the 11th graders could be present and be characters at the interview talk show??? Very detailed analysis of State Standards and coorelating ILF. I liked your idea of having students journaling their thoughts on note-taking 38 and citations. Will help give you insight into students strengths and weaknesses. Cute lesson on role play from big6 site. Nice to have students working in teams of 2 on graphic organizers. Also, very nice assessments. Very detailed lists of questions for students to answer. I liked the practicality and functionality of the informal class discussion evaluation. I also liked tying in the My Brother Sam is Dead as the common piece of literature. I thought this was a YHBA -and thought their site might offer lesson plan ideas, but after checking I was wrong. Very well done!!! Good luck and have fun implementing. May I also keep a copy of this unit for my records! Thanks for sharing - Karen 11th Grade Unit Jan, Attached is a reviewed copy of your unit. What a great lesson, may I keep a copy for my records? The inquiry project should excite your students. Your primary sources unit, specifically the photo and letter from George Washington should really motivate students. I like your thought processes on letting students choose their own person to research. Group work, discussion, and debate help make your unit exciting and mulit-dimensional. Assessments - the two rubrics seem very thorough. I also liked how you included a quick 6 question student survey in your assessment. For the media specialist and teacher to evaluate the unit for future use. What an extensive list of resources both electronic and print. Good collaborative efforts between media specialist and history teacher. I wonder if three weeks provides enough time for this unit. I defer to your judgement as I am not familiar with block schedules and HS curriculum. Thank you for sharing. Good luck Hella: (per phone conversation) 5th Grade Unit Suggested keeping note-taking forms together in a folder for organization and not to teach note-taking and citation skills on the same day. Might be too much for them. (I made adjustments in lesson plans for these ideas) th 11 Grade Unit Not much to pick on -- I really think the kids would enjoy the lesson about primary and secondary documents! 39 Wasn’t quite clear on how they pick their topics - from a list - based on their own research - guidelines? - teacher approval? (we also discussed this at time of conversation) Michael: (email) 11th Grade Unit In my professional opinion, your proposal looks like an excellent way to learn about the American Revolution. It allows the students to complete a project hands on and also teaches them the value and use of primary sources. I believe that this would be a fun and interesting way to learn about one of our country's earliest and most important events. Michael Carney Senior- Noblesville High School Noblesville IN 46060 Unit Comparison: Both of the units developed for this project were created for the study of the American Revolution, and the people and events leading up to this pivotal time in the history of the United States. This is an important part of the curriculum in both fifth grade and eleventh grade in the school district portrayed in this project. The fifth grade unit is written as an inter-disciplinary project that includes not only the media specialist and the social studies teacher, but also the language arts teacher. The fifth graders are on teams with the same core teachers throughout the year. These teachers work closely together giving them the time and structure in their program to plan these types of units. By including writing, grammar and literature into the history unit students get an understanding of the connection of what they are learning between subjects. This type of learning will eventually lead the students to connecting what they are learning to the real world. The eleventh grade unit was developed for a U.S. history class. The media specialist is the only other teacher involved in the collaboration. It would be more difficult because of schedules and curriculum demands at the high school level, however, I believe this unit could also be developed to involve the language arts teacher and bring in literature and other English components. The skills used in these units include a variety of areas such as technology, notetaking, and citing of resources. The eleventh graders technology skills will be much more advanced then the fifth graders. They will have had much more experience in using the keyboard so their typing skills will be faster. They will also be more experienced in internet research so they will be able to get through much more material in a shorter period of time then the fifth graders. The older students will be more skilled in notetaking and will be able to identify relevant facts in their resources more readily then the fifth graders, who are just learning this skill. The younger students will use a template to help guide them through the note-taking process. The eleventh graders will also be expected to use full MLA citation in their work cited page. The fifth grade students will be expected to fully cite their sources, but they will also be instructed in this using a template to guide them through the process. Their citations will not be as formal, but will 40 include all the necessary information, giving them an introduction to correct citation form. As students go from the fifth grade level to the eleventh grade level in the study of United States History their depth of knowledge and understanding greatly increases. The fifth grade standards introduce the students to the major British and American leaders and describe their roles in the key events of the times. They will also look at other countries and learn about who assisted the American cause. Students will identify the contributions of women during the revolution, and be expected to identify and interpret primary and secondary sources pertaining to that period of United States history2. As this part of American history is revisited in the eleventh grade class, their understanding of this time period will go much deeper. The standards for the eleventh grade curriculum state that students should be able to explain the major ideas and rights rooted in this time in history and which are found in the key documents. They must be able to explain the major themes and understand and summarize the main events and developments in this time in history. Students must be able to locate and analyze primary and secondary sources and understand the different perspectives on events and issues they represent. The students must be able to locate sources in libraries, museums, archival collections, historic sites and electronic sites1. Bloom’s taxonomy, a classification of children’s learning processes, explains the thinking process as progressing through various stages. It starts with the basic material or knowledge that must be obtained and progresses through stages of increasing complexity. These stages include knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation (Unger). Students working in the fifth grade unit will be working at the beginning stages of this process. They will gain the basic knowledge of the subject. They will have a comprehension of the subject where they will be able to process ideas such as, what is the main idea? who is a key character? and distinguish differences between them. The students will be able to apply their knowledge to illustrate what they have learned. They will also be able to take beginning steps into the stage of analysis where they will learn about the person they are studying, and ask questions such as what are some the their problems?, what happened when?, and what are some of the motives behind …?, as they put together their biographies. The students in the eleventh grade history class will take this thinking process to a much higher level of complexity. They will move to the synthesis stage where they will analyze their information. The students will then formulate the ideas they have researched into a presentation where they will be able to “sell” their ideas to others. They will then move up to the highest level of the thinking process which is evaluation. They will defend their viewpoint in a debate where they will have to justify their position. The various stages of this learning process indicate maturation of the students as they move from beginning learners to learners more capable of complex thinking and analysis. As fifth graders, students still need a lot of guidance as they go through the research process in this unit. In this introduction to research, students will be leaning some of the basic skills they will need to have for a strong foundation for their educational goals. As the students learn these entry skills they will require a large amount of support from their teachers and the media specialist. This support, or scaffolding, acts as reinforcement for the learning process the students are going through. Some examples of the support in this unit are instruction, research questions for the students to use as guides, templates for note-taking and citations, and assistance with technology and in putting together their final projects. As information scientist in this 41 fifth grade unit the students are just beginning to learn the skills they need for research and for putting together a research project. They will require a lot of guidance and reassurance as they go through the process. The teachers and media specialist will be very involved in all steps of the process with the students. As students build on this foundation their skill levels will become higher and they will not need as much support from the teacher. When students enter the eleventh grade history class they will have had several opportunities to use the basic skills they learned and build on them developing skills that have become much more complex and precise. The higher the skill level, the less scaffolding or reinforcement the student will need from the teacher. In this eleventh grade unit, students will receive support from the teacher in the form of instruction and some research assistance from the media specialist. It will be expected that at this level the students will be able to formulate their own questions for research, take notes, write citations and organize and present their project with very little assistance from the teacher. (Callison 279-280) At this level, the students, as information scientists, have become much more independent and will require very little assistance from the teacher. Once the unit has been introduced, the teacher and media specialist will still be present to assist and answer questions when needed, but will play a much smaller role in the guidance of the students through this process. As students progress through the learning process they grow in the ability to find and use information. This development of information literacy is evident as we look at the developing abilities of the students in the fifth grade compared to the much more advanced thinking processes of the students in the eleventh grade. Working together, teachers and media specialists can foster this learning process helping students develop the skills that will lead them to become life long learners. 42 “Amelia Earhart”. Education World. 2003. 3 Dec. 2005. < http://www.education-world.com/a_lesson/lesson/lesson322.pdf >. American Library Association. Information Power Building Partnerships for Learning. Chicago: American Library Association, 1998. “American Revolution Webquest” created by Laura A. Frondorf http://php.indiana.edu/%7Elshera/amrevwebquest.html Buzzeo, Toni. Collaborating to Meet Standards: Teacher/Librarian Partnerships for K-6. Worthington, OH: Linworth, 2002. Callison, Daniel. Key Words, Concepts and Methods for Information Age Instruction: A Guide to Teaching Information Inquiry. Baltimore: LMS Associtates, LLC, 2002. “George Washington to George Mason 5 April 1796”. The Papers of George Washington. 2005. 29 Nov. 2005. <http://gwpapers.virginia.edu/documents/revolution/letters/mason.html >. “Graphic Organizer: Research Note Taking Made Easy”. 2003. Education World. 3 Dec. 2005. < http://www.education-world.com/a_lesson/03/lp322-04.shtml > Huck, Charlotte S. et.al. Children’s Literature in the Elementary School. Boston: McGraw Hill, 2001. Jansen, Barbara A. “Big6™-A Good Way to Get Started. 2005. The Big6™. 14 Sept. 2005 <http://big6.com/showarticle.php?id=134&page=5 >. Lamb, Annette. “Information Inquiry: Wishing”. Jan. 2004. Information Inquiry for Teachers. 14 Sept. 2005 < http://www.eduscapes.com/info/isearch.html >. “Note-Taking Graphic Organizer”. Education World. 2003. 3 Dec. 2005. < http://www.education-world.com/a_lesson/lesson/images/note_taking.rtf >. Simpson, Carol. Note-Taking (Grades 4-6). 2005. The Big6™. 3 Dec 2005. < http://www.big6.com/showarticle.php?id=41 >. 1 State of Indiana. Dept. of Education. Indiana State Standards. 2001. 26 Nov. 2005. < http://ideanet.doe.state.in.us/standards/Docs-2004/English/PDF/HSSocialStudies/USHistory.pdf >. 2 State of Indiana. Dept. of Education. Indiana State Standards. 2002. August 2004. <http://www.doe.state.in.us/standards/ILS_Correlations.html >. Unger, G. Harlow. Encyclopedia of American Eduaction. New York: Facts on File, 2001. 127. “Valley Forge”. Teaching With Documents Lesson Plans: Images of the American Revolution. 29 Nov. 2005. 43 <http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/revolution-images/images/valleyforge.gif >. “Voices of the American Revolution”. EDSITEment. 28 August 2002. 26 Nov. 2005. < http://edsitement.neh.gov/view_lesson_plan.asp?id=423 >. Jan Carney L 551 Fall 2005 44