Title: SCOPING STUDY OF CLIMATE CHANGE ISSUES AND CHALLENGES FACING MOZAMBIQUE AND MAPUTO CITY Prepared by: Paulo Junior Email: pconceicaojr@gmail.com ; jr.conceicao.paulo@gmail.com To: United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT) C/O UNDP Country Office in Maputo Rua Francisco Barreto 322 - PO Box 4595 Phone: +258 21 481 481 Fax: +258 21 491 691 Maputo – Mozambique Project: SUD-Net Cities in Climate Change Initiative (CCCI) Country: Mozambique 1 OBJECTIVE ................................................................................................................................................. 3 1 THE VULNERABILITY OF MAPUTO TO CLIMATE CHANGE ............................................. 3 1.1 1.2 2 CLIMATE CHANGE RESPONSE POLICIES, STRATEGIES AND PLANS ............................ 9 2.1 2.2 2.3 3 BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................................. 3 WHY MAPUTO IS VULNERABLE TO CLIMATE CHANGE? ................................................................ 4 AT NATIONAL LEVEL ................................................................................................................... 9 AT SECTORAL LEVEL ..................................................................................................................12 AT LOCAL AND CITY LEVEL ........................................................................................................14 CLIMATE CHANGE RESPONSE ACTION PLAN .....................................................................16 3.1 3.2 THE ADAPTATION PROCESS ........................................................................................................16 POTENTIAL AREAS FOR MITIGATION AND ADAPTATION MEASURES ............................................18 4 EXISTING METHODS AND TOOLS FOR CLIMATE CHANGE VULNERABILITY AND IDENTIFICATION OF FUTURE BENEFITS AND RISKS ..................................................................19 4.1 UH-HABITAT METHODS, TOOLS AND EXPERIENCES IN MOZAMBIQUE ......................................19 5 LOCAL GOVERNANCE / HUMAN SETTLEMENTS POLICIES AND PRACTICES, IN PARTICULAR STATE OF DECENTRALIZATION AND HOUSING AND SHELTER POLICIES, WHICH WOULD BE RELEVANT FOR THE PROJECT. ...................................................................20 5.1 6 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FOCUS ISSUES FOR THE CCCI PROJECT ...............................................20 AN OVERVIEW OF KEY STAKEHOLDERS ..............................................................................21 6.1 BRIEF SWOT ANALYSIS OF STAKEHOLDERS THAT SEEM MOST APPROPRIATE AS COUNTERPART ORGANIZATIONS ........................................................................................................................................21 7 PROPOSED FUTURE ACTION PLAN ..........................................................................................23 8 REFERENCES AND CONSULTED DOCUMENTS.....................................................................28 2 Objective The main objective of this scoping study is to undertake a quick desk review of climate change issues and challenges facing Mozambique at national and Maputo city levels focusing on existing climate change policies, strategies, activities, tools, training facilities, and information networks. Due to the limited time frame of this scope study the National Consultant has used and compiled pre-analyzed climate change, hazard and vulnerability information where possible from the legal, scientific sources, as well as from practical points of views. 1 The Vulnerability of Maputo to climate change Vulnerability is defined by the IPCC as "the degree, to which a system is susceptible to, or unable to cope with adverse effects of climate change, including climate variability and extremes. In this respect vulnerability is seen as the function of the character, magnitude and rate of climate variation to which a system is exposed, its sensitivity and its adaptive capacity”1. From several evidences of the Maputo vulnerability, one of them is demonstrated by these remarkable words: “Our houses are built in low areas. We have no place to take shelter when the flood starts. The house owners do not help us to drain out water from our houses. People use buckets to remove water themselves. Though water has just gone, the real disaster has just begun. That is diseases.” - Residents of Mafalala in Maputo, Mozambique2 1.1 Background Mozambique is located in Southern Africa, bordering the Mozambique Channel, between South Africa and Tanzania. Given the geographic location, the country is a highly vulnerable to natural disaster – in particular those of hydro-meteorological origin. The climatic regime has two well-defined seasons: a dry season, usually from June to September; and a wet season, from October to April. Maputo City is the Capital of Mozambique. Its population is about 1.2 millions inhabitants according to Preliminary data of 2007 Census Population, INE (2008). However due to their close interconnectivity and mutual dependence, it’s recommended to take in consideration the Greater Maputo, which should include Matola city distant 20 km SW of Maputo city center. It has a population of about 0.6 millions inhabitants. In total it means up to 1.8 million inhabitants. Matola compriss basically 3 main areas: Machava with 224,606 inhabitants, Infulene with 236,695 inhabitants and Matola city center itself with 223,449 inhabitants. The same consideration was adopted by the Program Document on Sustainable Consumption and Production in Maputo and Matola cities (Programa Sustentável de Produção e Consumo para as Cidades de Maputo e Matola) prepared by Mozambique National Cleaner Production Centre (Centro Nacional de Produção Mais Limpa3 CNPML, 2007)3 with support of UNEP and of UNIDO in collaboration with the private sector through the Business Forum for Environment (FEMA) under coordination of the Ministry for Coordination of Environmental Affairs (MICOA) and the Ministry of Industry and Commerce (MIC). In the last 25 years, a sequence of droughts and floods has been registered disrupting the country’s social and economic development. Droughts were recorded in the following periods: 1981-1984, 1991-1992 and 1994-1995; and floods 1977-1978, 1985, 1988 and 1999-2000. In particular, the amounts of rainfall during the 1999-2000 wet seasons were extraordinarily high and the flood had devastating consequences. During the months of February to March 2000 a combination of torrential rains and tropical cyclones caused the most devastating floods in the history of Mozambique that caused the death of 700 people and damage assessed in 600 million dollars.4 The enormous physical consequences of climate change events in urban areas and the huge financial cost of relief efforts, compared to prevention, makes climate change adaptation measures a necessity for sustainable development. To facilitate the knowledge of all issues facing climate change in urban areas, an efficient and strategic attention is needed. 1.2 Why Maputo is vulnerable to climate change? By their nature Coastal zones are particularly affected by climate change events like sea level rise, cyclones, earthquake, and other natural hazards. Moreover Maputo is located in the coastal zone of Southern African and southeast of Mozambique. It is the major City of Mozambique with a relatively high density. According to McBean and Henstra (2003), high population density in urban areas means more people and property at risk.5 African cities are undergoing rapid population growth (more than 3.5 percent per year) accompanied by consequent rapid development pressure, namely high demand for housing and infrastructure.6 From the Table 1 below, we can see how the population of Maputo City is growing comparing data from the official population census. On other side the predicted sea-level rise related to the global warming (UNEP, 2001)7 may again result in a flooding of the lowest areas around the Coastline of Maputo, including parts heavily populated. This conclusion is supported by the Mozambique National Adaptation Action Plan to Climate Change (NAPA). According to the Holocene Evolution Study of Maputo bay the reconstruction of palaeoshorelines in the Maputo Bay, its complete picture patterns with its modern sedimentary environments including Inhaca Island may have evolved when the sea level has stood close to its present level around 7000 – 5000 years BC, after which the Maputo Bay became more or less stable.8 4 Table 1 The population of Maputo distributed by seven (7) Municipal districts Municipal District Nº 1997 Census Population 2007 Census Population Difference 1997:2007 (Preliminary Data) 1 2 3 4 5 6 (Catembe) 7 (Inhaca Island) Total 154,284 162,750 210,551 228,244 211,008 15,853 4,672 987,362 108,353 155,264 224,181 289,864 293,716 19,605 3,956 1,094,939 -45,931 -7,486 +13,630 +61,620 +82,708 +3,752 -716 +107,577 Source: Statistics National Institute, National Directorate of Census and Inquiries (INE, 2008)9 The current generation of climate models indicates that global average precipitation would increase in a warmer climate, namely by about 1-2 percent per degree of warming.10 This is due to increased evaporation which leads to increased precipitation. A warmer atmosphere as a result of global warming can hold more moisture before becoming saturated.11 Figure 1 Precipitation and Temperature data of Maputo City Source: INAM, data compiled based on normal values from 1971-2000. www.inam.gov.mz Therefore, the combination of high population density of Maputo and the season relation episode, where cool climates are associated with dry episodes and warm climates are associated with wet episodes, increase risk and vulnerability of occurring different severe impacts on people and property, in relation to each climate change event. In cities, climate change extreme events will negatively impact water, sewage, and energy distribution and transportation systems. They will damage buildings, urban trees 5 and green spaces. They will increase illness and deaths in vulnerable populations, see Table2. Table 2 Sectors and zones of Maputo vulnerable to climate change events Sector or zone Climate Impact or effect could be change event Tropical Damage to coastal infrastructure, dunes, beaches, cyclones and other natural features Increased erosion or damage to coastal Coastal zone infrastructure, dunes, beaches, and other and ecosystems natural features Sea level rise Loss of coastal wetlands and other coastal habitats and storm flow Increased costs for maintenance and expansion of coastal erosion control (natural or man-made) Saltwater intrusion into coastal aquifers Increased risk of pollution from coastal hazardous waste sites Reduced effectiveness of sea walls Transportation Variations of Increased road surface and bridges damage Temperature, Increased maintenance requirements for Heavy roadside/pavement precipitation Wetlands and Heavy Increased risk of flooding urban agriculture precipitation Heavy Dry Crop failures, water scarcity, drying of water season reservoirs and demand for water irrigation. Increased risk of loss habitat (mangroves), salt intrusion Tropical Loss of households cyclones Settlements, Heavy Loss of households Housing and precipitation, Need for new or upgraded flood control and, Infrastructure erosion control structures Landslides, road washouts, and flooding Increased demands on storm water management systems and sewer overflows Sea level rise Reduced effectiveness of sea walls Health, food Heavy Increase in vector-born diseases ( malaria, cholera) security and precipitation Waste n/a Need or demand for new collection system and Management Management 6 Figure 2 Maputo (with its 7 Municipal Districts) and Matola Cities. 7 Figure 3 The actual Maputo City Administrative Layout Source: Maputo Minicipal Urban Structure Plan – Plano de Estrutura Urbana do Municipio de Maputo (PEUMM), 2008 8 2 Climate change response policies, strategies and plans The national policies, strategies and plans constitute the main guidelines for economic development of the country. For the purpose of this scoping study of climate change issues and challenges facing Maputo City, the following documents have been reviewed taking into consideration 3 defined levels: national, sector and city local. 2.1 At National level Table 3 Brief overview of National Policies and Strategies Policy/strategy Main Objectives/Vision/Mission Transform Mozambique in an enterprising and continuously successful country by 2025 Priority Actions/strategies or activities Human Capital Social capital Economic Development Governance Correlation with Urban Climate Change in general Does not give special attention to CC in urban areas. Brings the view of how human settlement should be considered. Relevance to SUD-Net CCCI CCCI appear as an opportunity to complement and fulfill the gaps of the Agenda. Absolute Poverty Reduction Action Plan – Plano de Acção para a redução da pobreza absoluta (2006-2009) (PARPA II) (Approved by the GOM, 2006)13 Reduce the incidence of poverty from 54% in 2003 to 45% in 2009. Governance Human capital Economic Development Does not give special attention to CC in urban areas. Natural disasters and Urban zones are treated as transversal issues Does not correlate directly to CC in urban areas Poverty in urban areas at some stage its a consequence of CC, specially in Maputo CCCI appear as an opportunity to complement and fulfill the gaps of the strategy. National Adaptation Action Plan to Climate Change (NAPA) – Programa de Acção Nacional para a Adaptação Às Mudanças Climáticas (Approved by the GOM, 2007)14 To present clearly and in simple way, the country immediate and urgent necessities identified during the participative assessment process where, its implementation will increase the national capacity to deal with Reinforcement of the warming system for natural disasters prevention, Reinforcement the rural agriculture producers to deal with the effects of climate change Reduce the impacts related to climate change in the Does not give special attention to CC in urban areas. It can be used as general starting source point to design a National Urban CC strategy and Action Plan, based on Maputo case study. Agenda 2025 (Adopted in November 2003)12 9 climate change. Mozambique Environmental Strategic for Sustainable Development – Estratégia Ambiental para o Desenvolvimento Sustentável de Moçambique (Approved by the GOM, 2007)15 To Create in Mozambique a common vision for a sage environmental management, guiding to a sustainable development in order to contribute to poverty eradication based on principles of the Agenda 21 and NEPAD. To establish a direction from which all stakeholders (including NGO’s, private sector, scientific academic community, civil society and other international partners) will follow up in their development programs. Master Plan for Prevention and Mitigation of Natural Disasters – Plano Director para Prevenção e Mitigação das Complement the Absolute Poverty Reduction Action Plan (PARPA) and fill up the government sectoral strategies gaps implementing actions Coastal Zones Improvement the management of water basin resources Capacity building for implementation of strategies including establishment of goals at national and local level to achieve integrated management and protection of natural resources and ecosystems. Create institutions with technical capacity for urban planning, development of infrastructures, waste management, and water and sanitation services. Strengthen the country capacity to measure, reduce and evaluate the environmental pollution including impact on health and climate change and provide technical and financial support. Keep population growth within the limit of socioeconomic goals and sustainable development objectives. Water balance which includes the analysis of Water reserves and water uses, Reforestation Food and Nutritional Does refers to urban environment but not in particular to climate change in urban areas (point 3.2 of the strategy) Climate change issues are discussed from Atmospheric Pollution point of view. Regarding this, it addresses a range of actions to be implemented in order to fulfill the government UNFCCC compromises and terms. It can be used as general starting source point to draw up a National Urban CC Action Plan, based on Maputo case study. CCCI appear as an opportunity to complement and fulfill the gaps of the strategy. 1:1.000.000 Mapping of arid zones for planning & monitoring Inventory of existing conservations agricultural Does not give special attention to CC in urban areas. CCCI can learn, share and adopt some useful 10 Calamidades Naturais (Approved by the GOM, 2006)16 related to risk management, vulnerability reduction, prevention and mitigation of natural disasters The policy includes: the development of flood warning systems and the recognition of effective disaster management as a key component of both poverty reduction and achieving the Millennium Development Goals. Rebalance covering: Food Security and seed provision , Investigation and extension of crop species with very short growth cycle period and tolerant to drought, Domestication of non conventional crop species, Adoption and dissemination of other industrial crop species and Development of non agriculture activities with economic value Emergency management and resources related: will require the existence of promptitude, decentralized management system, rescue and aid capacity and recovering support to normal life after disaster practices and agro floristries in the country (with priority to local practices) and other arid zones of the world. Introduction of conservations agricultural practices Introduction of agricultural practices using local species tolerant to drought Adoption and implementation of the local land use planning experiences used by INGC and their partners in rural areas to apply in urban context. 11 2.2 At Sector level Table 4 Brief overview of Sector Strategies Policy/strategy Water Policy – Politica de Aguas) (Resolution nº 46/2007 of the GOM, 2007)17 National Water Resources management Strategy – Estratégia Nacional de Gestão de Recursos Hídricos (Approved by the GOM, 2007)18 National Energy Strategy – Estratégia de Energia (Resolution nº 24/2000 of the GOM, 2000)19 Main Objectives/Vision/Mission The Vision: to have available water resources in quantity and quality for the actual and future generations in order to use for sustainable development, poverty reduction and promoting peace and well being, and minimize the negatives impacts of floods and droughts . Develop an effective and integrated management of water resources that contribute to socioeconomic development Priority Actions/strategies activities or Correlation with Urban Climate Change in general It provides the need of improvement of the water drainage system and infrastructures, considering the impacts created by floods in urban areas like soil erosion. Relevance CCCI Promote the expansion of access to energy sources in the context of efficient utilization and environmental protection to SUD-Net Build capacity for water resources management Develop infrastructures for water supply and sanitation services Develop a framework for integrated management Promote the adoption of policies for sustainable use of water resources different uses. It discuss and define how should be done the management of floods in general but does not specify in urban areas. Potential for the CCCI analysis of climate change impacts in water supply and water quality to the Maputo City. Ensure low cost energy supply Increase energy availability for domestic sector Promote reforestation in order to increase biomass fuel availability Strengthen institutional capacity of relevant stakeholders Does not specify energy issues related to urban climate change Relevant for elaboration of adaptation measures with impact on energy saving in urban areas, reforestation of urban and peri-urban areas. 12 Teritoril Ordaining Policy – Politica de Ordenameto Territorial ( Resolution n.º18/2007 of GOM)20 Create a legal framework for urban development of the country. involved in energy supply in order to improve their performance Promote development and use of renewable energy (solar, wind and bio-fuels) Ensure people’s right access to land and its resources Re-qualification of urban soil degraded due to emergency occupation Identification and valorization of the socio-economic and cultural activities of rural population Protect ecological quality and fertility of forestry soils, water resources and sea Develop a legal framework that optimizes the management of natural resource and its use and access. Does not specify urban climate change issues Relevant as reference to urban issues 13 2.3 At Local and city level Table 5 Brief overview of local and city level strategies Policy/strategy Main Objectives Maputo Municipal Development Program – Programa de Desenvolvimento Municipal de Maputo (PROMAPUTO) (Aproved by CMM, 2006)21 To improve the quality of life of citizens and provide a three phase development strategy framework for the period 2007-2016. The objective for Phase I is to strengthen the CMM's institutional and financial capacity to support achievement of long-term service delivery goals, and to implement selected priority investments To implement and improve the system of Municipal Solid waste (MSW) collection and its economic component Adopt the polluter/pay Principle Develop a sustainable System Achieve based in cost/revenue Maputo City Waste Management Strategy – Estratégia de Gestão de Resíduos Sólidos Urbanos na Cidade de Maputo (September 2006)22 Maputo Minicipal Urban Structural Plan – Plano de Estrutura Urbana do Municipio de Maputo (PEUMM) (approved by CMCM, 2008)23 An instrument of City Planning or arrangement that reflect its organization philosophy through the following orientation: Define the spatial vision and strategic priorities of the city Identify priorities areas for public investment Establish the base from which Priority Actions/strategies or activities Governance: Ensure strategic, efficient and participative Municipal management Municipal finance: Improve the revenue system and promote efficient expenditure Planning and Improvement of services delivers: urban and planning services; infrastructures services and; quality and coverage of Municipal Solid Waste Management services Phase 1: Develop the institutional capacity for MSW collection in urban area Phase 2: Expansion of the services to peri-urban areas Phase 3: Achieve a sustainable system of MSW Management Re-ordaining of the informal (slums) neighborhoods Recover land for all social activities, services and public equipments Increase the occupation of city land where the conditions are preserve free land for the ecological equilibrium and Correlation with Urban Climate Change in general Climate change its not part in specific but some actions in are related to mitigation of urban climate change effects: the improvement of services provider like rehabilitation of urban infrastructures ( roads, drainage pluvial water system, coastline protection barrier) Relevance to SUDNet CCCI It clearly relevant to CCCI as guidance policy for any intervention in Maputo City. Does not correlate directly to urban climate change in general but indirectly yes, because the way you manage municipal solid and waste, you will increase or decrease the row of material (solid and waste) in the city during rain season. Essential planning instrument of Maputo City which: identify sensitive areas within Maputo Municipality vulnerable to climate change extreme events gives the direction for any urban development program intervention even related to Potential to develop sustainable CDM’s solutions for Municipal Solid and Waste Management. Strongly relevant to CCCI program 14 Sustainable Consumption and Production for Maputo and Matola Cities – Programme Document – Consumo e Produção Sustentável para as Cidades de Maputo e Matola (2007) the municipals in charge would use to solve problems based on principles and not in personal opinions. Provide clear direction to private initiative Establish a simple and systematic process of the necessary data collection and analyzes to permanent planning ensure the environmental quality Establishment of the necessary conditions for transit flow and mobility Promote the construction of social houses Promote and facilitate the development of urban agriculture promote urban diversification of activities and functions, avoiding the suburbanization and spatial segregation of the lower communities Reduce the social asymmetry and privileges during the location of land for infrastructures net, services and equipments. SCP is a follow up of the African Ten Year Framework Programme on Sustainable Consumption and Production in Africa that: Identify the key priorities that could be undertaken under the thematic areas of energy, water, urban development, and industrial development. Water and sanitation Energy efficiency and sustainable energy Urban development and infrastructure CC Does not specify issues related to urban climate change The methodologies used for assessment could be usefully to CCCI 15 3 Climate Change Response Action Plan Adaptive capacity represents the ability of a society to reduce vulnerability; thus the strengthening of adaptive capacity should be targeted at the most vulnerable groups and territories. There is a general agreement on the need to move away from top-down implementation and centralized planning towards building adaptation capacity and resilience at the ground level. To achieve this requires enhancing the capacity of local actors in a specific area to mitigate the effects of climate change extreme events and recover from their effects. According to Rosenzweig, 2003 key questions related to climate adaptation research needs are: What is response capacity and capability in urban areas to climate? What conditions make particular sites, people, and systems in urban areas more vulnerable than others? How can these sites, people, and systems be made less vulnerable?24 Before to engage on designing a climate change adaptation strategy for Maputo City it is important to start with a systematic assessment system of the impacts. Because comprehensive impact assessments examine not only how climate change is likely to affect the natural environment and physical infrastructure of an urban region, but also trace likely economic impacts on municipal operations and on the city’s economy, as well as social impacts on vulnerable populations.25 The most important steps of this process are expressed in the figure 2. 3.1 The Adaptation Process Figure 4 The adaptation process 16 Source: Clean Air Partnership, 2007. Cities Preparing for Climate Change, A Study of Six Urban Regions. (Figure 1 The Adaptation process, pp.6) Awareness and Engagement of Stakeholders (AES): for Maputo city scoping study, the result of brief consultations and interviews with key people from the Ministry of Coordination of Environments Affairs - (MICOA), Maputo City Municipality Council – CMM, National Institute for Disasters Management – INGC, Meteorology National Institute – INAM shows the evidence of strong engagement to CCCI initiative. However further comprehensive consultation process is needed to identify Climate Change Impacts and Assessment (CCIA): From the present scoping study experience, because of lack of specific data and information related to Maputo city climate change further investigation process its crucial in order to identify adaptation measures applicable and compatible with Maputo reality. It means that CCIA is needed covering the followed steps: Review and analysis of existing data on climate change and its likely impacts for Maputo City; Identification of priority impacts for further investigation and action; In-depth studies of specific vulnerable sectors (e.g. coastal zones, wetlands, water, energy, health); Assessment of the potential costs of climate impacts (may be derived from case studies of recent extreme weather events). Planning for Adaptation Action (PAA): The above overview analysis of the related policies, strategies and plans shows clearly how urban climate change issues are not well integrated at all levels: National, sectoral and city local level. Consequently it is important to bring the urban CC dimension under the table at simple and understandable for all stakeholders specially our decision-makers. Adaptive options are not well systematize despite the fact of isolated adaptation option implemented (or in on-going process of implementation) in the rural areas. 17 Tacking Adaptation Action (TAA): It means the establishment of institutional mechanisms to guide the adaptation processes: (Who and How?); the formulation of policies and/or modification of existing policies to fulfil gaps; the precise incorporation of adaptation in programs and projects. This phase require a well coordination of the key stakeholders in order to guarantee the functioning of institutional mechanisms to caring out new or modify existing policies. Implementation of demonstrative adaptation projects or programmes its essential as pilot climate change adaptation measures. 3.2 Potential areas for Mitigation and Adaptation measures The potential areas where mitigation and adaptation measures could be applicable in urban and peri-urban zones of Maputo City include: Water and sanitation Urban solid and waste management, Transportation versus air pollution, Use of renewable energy, Shelter and housing development, Coastal zones of Maputo, Biomass and urban agriculture, Management of flooded and vulnerable areas and, Development and planning of urban infrastructures. Table 6 Preliminary list of potential areas and level of priority for intervention of pilot programs or projects Potential areas Level of priority Key to intervention Type of Measures Stakeholders programs involvement Maputo Water, sanitation and Mitigation, Municipality, health High Urban solid and waste management High Urban Transportation Air pollution Low Use of renewable energy Shelter and housing development Mitigation Mitigation Medium Adaptation, Mitigation High Adaptation, Mitigation Coastal zones of Maputo Biomass and urban High Mitigation, Adaptation Medium Adaptation and Ministry of Health, Water Directorate (DNA) Maputo Municipality, MICOA Maputo Municipality, Ministry of Transport Maputo Municipality, Ministry of Energy Maputo Municipality MOPH, CMCM Maputo Municipality, MICOA Maputo 18 agriculture, Management of flooded and vulnerable areas Development and planning of urban infrastructures. Mitigation Medium to High High Adaptation and mitigation Adaptation Municipality, Ministry of Agriculture INGC, Maputo Municipality Maputo Municipality and Private sector 4 Existing methods and tools for climate change vulnerability and identification of future benefits and risks The main sectors (MICOA, CMM, INGC and INAM) involved in climate change issues and visited during the elaboration of this scoping study we find out that still, more capacity and work is needed to assess vulnerability and, more importantly, on integrated assessments to include economic and cross-sectional analysis of adaptation options at National and City local level. Table 7 Methods and tools for natural disaster prevention Methods or Tools Institution related National Disasters Management Institute Warming system for flooding events (INGC) and National Directorate of Water (DNA) Warming system for tropical cyclones Meteorology National Institute (INAM) and events National Disasters Management Institute (INGC). 4.1 UH-HABITAT methods, tools and experiences in Mozambique From a policy point of view, UN-HABITAT in Mozambique is advocating for a better urban development in Mozambique, in terms of strategy and government agenda priority. From a practical point of view, UN-HABITAT in Mozambique has already developed several activities: Training and capacity building: Manuals, game, cartoon (learning to live with floods), brochures, posters, guidelines, etc. Implementation of demonstration interventions: flood/cyclone-resistant construction, innovative architectural designs, building codes (legal), recommendations for better constructions, and actual construction Assessment tools: participatory planning manual which enhance the use of maps and geo-information tools Methodology: community involvement, work at decentralized levels UH-HABITAT in Mozambique has developed the following projects related to climate change: 19 Slum Upgrading and Vulnerability Reduction in Flood-Prone of Maputo areas, Chókwé, Tete and Quelimane. Improving Water and Sanitation Conditions in Mafala Neighbourhood, Maputo City. Regional Urban Sector Profile Study Cities without slums 5 Local governance / human settlements policies and practices, in particular state of decentralization, housing and shelter policies, which would be relevant for the project. The decentralization process is part of government strategy in order to ensure the implementation of development policies. At the Maputo City level this goal still in process of implementation. Within the Maputo Municipality as part of the Maputo Municipal Development Program – Programa de Desenvolvimento Municipal de Maputo (PROMAPUTO), governance is one of the key actions implemented in order ensure strategic, efficient and participative Municipal management. One of the outcome examples of the adoption of open and participative governance in urban development planning activity is the Maputo Municipal Urban Structure Plan – Plano de Estrutura Urbana do Municipio de Maputo (PEUMM) recently approved in 2008. Nevertheless there is still work to be done in fields like housing and shelter. In that regard Mozambique has not yet developed a Housing Policy to ensure the implementation of the principle of adequate shelter for all. In the Government of Mozambique Five year Plan 2005-2009, it is acknowledged the importance of formulating and implementing a Housing Policy that was expected to have been filed to the Parliament during the current Legislature. UN-HABITAT has been considered a relevant partner for that process. 26 While the housing policy is not adopted the City of Maputo and the country in general are confronted with an increasing demand that is expanding beyond control. 5.1 Recommendations for focus issues for the CCCI project Build on on-going UN-HABITAT activities in Mozambique, it is recommended that CCCI builds synergies for enabling strengthening of institutional capacity through pertinent advocacy, training and financing mechanisms that would target main institutional partners (MICOA, INGC, Maputo Municipality, MOPH, etc.). The interest of other entities such as HR Wallingford in taking part on the project, since CC is an area for which much more investigation is needed, should also be consider as a great demonstration of building synergies with other international organizations which shows the importance and relevance of the CCCI project. 20 6 An Overview of stakeholders Ministry for Coordination of Environmental Affairs (MICOA) o National Directorate of Planning and Territorial Ordaining (DINAPOT) o National Directorate of Environmental Management (DNGA) Maputo City Municipal Council (CMM) National Disaster Management Institute (INGC) Ministry of Energy Meteorological National Institute (INAM) Eduardo Mondlane University o Department of Physic o Department of Geology Ministry of Public Works and Housing (MOPH) o National Directorate of Water (DNA) Ministry of Transport Private Sector Civil Society (FEMA and other associations concerned with environmental issues, particularly climate change adaptation and mitigation) 6.1 Brief SWOT analysis of stakeholders that seem most appropriate as counterpart organizations Table 8 SWOT analysis of stakeholders that seem most appropriate as counterpart organizations STAKEHOLDER MICOA (Ministry of Coordination of Environmental Affairs) INGC (National Institute for Disaster Management) Maputo Municipality UN-HABITAT STAKEHOLDER MICOA (Ministry of Coordination of Environmental Affairs) STRENGTHS Government Coordination institution for environment matters Responsible institution for the coordination of the implementation of the UNFCCC Strong community partnerships/collaboration Proactive management team for Natural disasters risk reduction Decentralized organization structure New transparency governance policy is on on-going implementation OPPORTUNITIES Existence and availability of NAPA and other legal instruments Integration and cooperation of various CC projects running on WEAKNESS Lack of qualified Human Resources to face urban CC Lack of urban CC dimension discussion Lack of continuous evaluation and updating of policies and strategies Few interventions at urban level Lack of qualified Human Resources to face urban CC Lack of qualified Human Resources to face urban CC Lack of methods and tools to face urban CC TREATS Budget constraining Staffing capacity constrain Multitude of concerns to be addressed within its mandate 21 INGC (National Institute for Disaster Management) Maputo Municipality Availability of experience to coordinate disaster mitigation activities Interdisciplinarity Budget constraining Staffing capacity constrain Increased community responsibility for service delivery Bring urban CC dimension discussion to the table Draft a first Urban CC Adaptation Action Plan Budget constraining Staffing capacity constrain UN-HABITAT 22 7 Proposed Future Action Plan Table 9 Proposed and Preliminary Action Plan for CCCI in Maputo SERIAL ACTION 1 Project management (staff, missions, miscellaneous office expense, equipment) 2 To undertake Maputo City climate change awareness survey to establish the baseline level of awareness throughout the community and stakeholders. 3 Review and analysis of existing data on climate change and its likely impacts for Maputo City plus identification of vulnerable locations, populations and activities and potential opportunities arising from a changed climate. OUTPUT Project Profile document Survey 7 Review and analysis of existing data on climate change document. SWOT analysis document In-depth CC research or studies of specific vulnerable sectors of Maputo City (e.g. Specific document report coastal zones, wetlands, water, energy, health). The Assessment of the potential costs of Maputo climate change impacts (may be Assessment of the potential derived from case studies of recent extreme weather events) costs of Maputo climate change document Seminars/Trainings, coordination with government institution (INGC, MICOA, Maputo Municipality) Advocacy and dissemination of urban CC vulnerability reduction methods and tools Communication material 9 To produce a summary version of the Maputo City Adaptation Climate Change Strategy 10 To select neighborhood of Maputo City much vulnerable to one type of CC impact and implement Participatory Planning and Identification of Adaptation options Measures Implementation of a demonstration intervention (adaptation measures, etc.) 4 5 6 11 Maputo City Climate Change Adaptation Strategy summary document Participatory planning document Implemented Action 23 Table 10 Tentative Budget for CCCI in Maputo SERIAL 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ACTION UNITS National Consultant – Team Leader months National Consultant (climate change awareness months survey, establish the baseline level of awareness, reviewing and analyzing likely impacts of CC for Maputo City) National Consultant (assessing CC vulnerability in months Maputo City and its potential costs) Trainings (average 30 people each) units Advocacy (events and publications) lump sum Implementation of demonstrative interventions lump sum (adaptation measures, etc.) Miscellaneous (transportation, stationery, translations, etc.) TOTAL lump sum QUANTITY 6 3 UNIT PRICE 3000 2500 TOTAL 18,000 7,500 3 2500 7,500 2 1500 3,000 3,000 100,000 5,000 144,000 24 25 26 Figure 5 Actual Land use of Maputo CIty Source: Maputo Minicipal Urban Structural Plan – Plano de Estrutura Urbana do Municipio de Maputo (PEUMM), 2008 27 8 References and consulted documents 1 IPCC (2001), Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Cambridge,University Press, Cambridge, UK 2 Action Aid International report, (2006). Climate change, urban flooding and the rights of the urban poor in Africa. Key findings from six African cities: (Nairobi, Kenya; Kampala, Uganda; Lagos, Nigeria; Accra, Ghana; Free Town, Sierra Leone & Maputo, Mozambique) http://www.actionaid.org/docs/urban%20flooding%20africa%20report.pdf Centro Nacional de Produção Mais Limpa – CNPML (2007). Consumo e Produção Sustentável para as Cidades de Maputo e Matola - Sustainable Consumption and Production in Maputo and Matola Cities. http://www.unep.org/roa/docs/pdf/SCPProgramme-Mozambique.pdf 3 Instituto Nacional de Metereologia – INAM, (2002). MOZAMBIQUE: Post-Emergency Reconstruction Programme in the Field of Meteorology. Available online at www.inam.gov.mz 4 5 McBean, G. and D. Henstra. 2003. Climate Change, Natural Hazards and Cities. ICLR Research Paper Series – No. 31, Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction, Toronto 6 Background paper on: Impacts, vulnerability and adaptation to climate change in Africa for the African Workshop on Adaptation Implementation of Decision 1/CP.10 of the UNFCCC Convention. Accra, Ghana, 21 - 23 September, 2006 7 UNEP, GRID-Arendal 2001: Vital Climate Graphics 65 pp. web version: http://www.grida.no/climate/vital/index.htm. 8 Mussa ACHIMO, João MUGABE, Fortunato CUAMBA & Sylvi HALDORSEN2, (n/d).Late Weichselian to Holocene Evolution of the Maputo Bay, Mozambique National Statistic Institute –INE. (2008). Preliminary Data of the 2007 Population Census. Available online at: www.gov.ine.mz 9 10 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change - IPCC (2007). IPPC Fourth Assessment Reports: Working Group I Report “The Physical Science Basis”. Available online at: http://www.ipcc.ch/. 11 Andrew Thow and Mark de Blois (2008) Discussion paper Climate change and human vulnerability: Mapping emerging trends and risk hotspots for humanitarian actors. Technical annex and additional maps. 12 Agenda 2025 (Adopted in November 2003. www.agenda2025.org 28 13 Plano de Acção para a redução da pobreza absoluta (2006-2009) (PARPA II) (Approved by the GOM, 2006) Available online at: www.mpd.gov.mz 14 Programa de Acção Nacional para a Adaptação Às Mudanças Climáticas (Approved by the GOM, 2007) Available online at: www.legisambiente.gov.mz 15 Estratégia Ambiental para o Desenvolvimento Sustentável de Moçambique (Approved by the GOM, 2007) Available online at: www.legisambiente.gov.mz 16 Plano Director para Prevenção e Mitigação das Calamidades Naturais (Approved by the GOM, 2006) 17 Politica de Aguas. (Resolution nº 46/2007 of the GOM, 2007 18 Estratégia Nacional de Gestão de Recursos Hídricos (Approved by the GOM, 2007) 19 Estratégia de Energia (Resolution nº 24/2000 of the GOM, 2000) 20 Politica de Ordenameto Territorial (Resolution n.º18/2007 of GOM) Available online at: www.legisambiente.gov.mz 21 Programa de Desenvolvimento Municipal de Maputo (PROMAPUTO) (Aproved by CMM, 2006) 22 Estratégia de Gestão de Resíduos Sólidos Urbanos na Cidade de Maputo (September 2006) 23 Plano de Estrutura Urbana do Município de Maputo (PEUMM) (Approved by CMM, 2008) 24 Cynthia Rosenzweig and William D. Solecki (2003) Adaptation to Climate in Urban Areas: Identification of Research Needs. 25 Clean Air Partnership, 2007. Cities Preparing for Climate Change, A Study of Six Urban Regions. Available online at: http://www.cleanairpartnership.org 26 UN-HABITAT (Mozambique), Slum Upgrading and Vulnerability Reduction in Mozambique. Towards the Achievement of the Millennium Development Goal – Target 11. 29