NATIONAL QUALIFICATIONS CURRICULUM SUPPORT Biology Unit 3: Living Together Symbiosis and Social Behaviour Student Materials Graeme Steele [HIGHER] The Scottish Qualifications Authority regularly reviews the arrangements for National Qualifications. Users of all NQ support materials, whether published by Learning and Teaching Scotland or others, are reminded that it is their responsibility to check that the support materials correspond to the requirements of the current arrangements. Acknowledgement Learning and Teaching Scotland gratefully acknowledges this contribution to the National Qualifications support programme for Biology. The publisher gratefully acknowledges permission to use the following sources: Deep Sea World resource made through a collaboration of our author Graeme Steele and Deep Sea World; image of chimpanzees from Royal Zoological Society, Edinburgh © RZSS; image of Members of our Vampire Bat Colony © The Centre for Conservation of Specialized Species; 3 images of Dr. Jane Goodall with chimpanzees © The Jane Goodall Institute / Derek Bryceson, © The Jane Goodall Institute / Fernando Turmo, © The Jane Goodall Institute / Hugo Van Lawick; image of wolves © WolfPhotography.com; image from http://www.uwphoto.net/pages/gallery_si04-666.html © photography by Jim Christensen; image from http://chemistry.csudh.edu/faculty/jim/lembehsmall/hermit.jpg © Jim Lyle; image of Fire Ant colony from http://hydrodictyon.eeb.uconn.edu/people/adams/FireAntColony.jpg.jpg; image of pea pod © 2011 Microsoft Corporation. Clipart; image of a tick, photograph by William Needham on Hiker’s Notebook website; image of an adult flea, photo courtesy CDC/Vector Ecology & Control Laboratory, Fort Collins, Colo; image of a tapeworm © dogbreedinfo.com; image of veteran oak tree covered in lichen, mosses and ferns © Lorne Gill/SNH; image of Rhizobium nodules © Courtesy J. Wynne. Reproduced by permission from Compendium of Peanut Diseases, 2nd Ed., 1997, American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, MN, USA; image of a hummingbird © Fotolia; Every effort has been made to trace all the copyright holders but if any have been inadvertently overlooked, the publishers will be pleased to make the necessary arrangements at the first opportunity. © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 This resource may be reproduced in whole or in part for educational purposes by educational establishments in Scotland provided that no profit accrues at any stage. 2 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 Contents Activity 1: Walkabout/talkabout carousel 4 Activity 2: Symbiosis card sort 5 Activity 3: Types of symbiosis 9 Activity 4: Branching keys 10 Activity 5: Symbiosis revision 11 Activity 6: The prisoners’ dilemma 12 Activity 7: Odd one out 14 Activity 8: Jane Goodall 18 Activity 9: Chimpanzee behaviour and expressions (see separate pdf file) 19 Activity 10: Chimpanzee hierarchy (see separate pdf file) 20 Activity 11: Social behaviour continuum 21 Activity 12: Symbiosis 23 Solutions to Activity 5 28 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 3 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 1: Walkabout/talkabout carousel Instructions 1. Split into 5 groups. 2. Each group must put one of the following headings onto the poster . 3. You have 3 minutes to add as much detail to this poster as you can. 4. Move to the next poster after this time and add/amend information on this poster. 5. Repeat until back at first poster. 6. Each group must take a turn to feedback to the whole group from the poster they started with. 4 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 2: Symbiosis card sort Instructions 1. Print out following pages and cut into individual cards with a matching picture. 2. Make three categories to place cards into; parasitism, mutualism, social behaviour. 3. read out statement 1. 4. place the photo of the organism into one of th e three categories. 5. Read out statement 2. 6. choose to move the photo to a new category or leave it in same place . 7. continue until all statements read and final decision made as to category. 8. repeat with all cards. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 5 STUDENT MATERIALS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6 Bacteria live in the intestines of a cow. The bacteria get a constant source of moisture and food. The bacteria get a stable habitat to live in (temperature and pH). The bacteria break down cellulose. Without the bacteria the cow would not be able to break down the grass cell walls. www.co2calculator.wordpress.com Oscar the chocolate labrador lives with his owner, Mr Fraser. Oscar recently cost Mr Fraser £90 in vet’s bills. Mr Fraser gives the dog food and water whenever it is needed. Oscar gets to sleep on the end of Mr Fraser’s bed. Oscar makes Mr Fraser very happy. Some species of shrimp live with a fish called a goby. The shrimp digs a house by moving sand around. The goby lives in the house the shrimp digs out. The shrimp is blind and uses its feelers to check the goby is nearby. If the goby notices danger and retreats into the home the shrimp does too. A hermit crab is able to carry an anemone on its back. The anemone is put there by the crab. The weight of the anemone makes it harder for the crab to move around. Food scraps from the crab can get to the anemone. The anemone will stop an octopus from eating the crab. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 www.uwphoto.net STUDENT MATERIALS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. A tick is a small invertebrate that can live on larger animals. It bites into the other organism and buries its head into the organism’s skin. Here it feeds on blood from the organism. The blood is stored in an expandable pouch on the tick. The organism loses blood and may get an infection, eg Lyme disease in humans. © Gary Alpert Ants work together. Most will never get to breed. They can get more food by working cooperatively. The colony will die if each type of ant does not do its job. Since the ants are closely related, similar genes will be passed on. http://hydrodictyon.eeb.uconn.edu/people/adams/FireAntColony.jpg.jpg 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Bodungo chimps are social animals. Chimps form close relationships with each other. By being in a group they share food and resources. A young male is unlikely to become the most dominant male in the group. By living together as a large group the troop is likely to be successful and their genes will be passed on. © RZSS Malaria kills many African children each year. It is caused by a protist. Mosquitoes carry protists for part of their lifecycle. The mosquito transfers the protist when feeding on human blood. The protist needs both vectors to complete its lifecycle. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 7 STUDENT MATERIALS 1. 2. 5. Birds frequently live in trees. They use parts of an old tree to make their nests. The bird gains an advantage of a home to live in. The tree gains little from the relationship, maybe some fertiliser. The bird does nothing to harm the tree. 8 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) 3. 4. © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 3: Types of symbiosis There are two basic types of symbiosis. Remember that symbiosis is the relationship between two organisms of different species that benefits one or both organisms: mutualism – a symbiotic relationship that benefits both organisms involved parasitism – a symbiotic relationship that benefits one organism while harming the other. Decide which type of symbiosis is described in each sentence below. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. A tick living on a dog. A tapeworm living in a sixth-year student’s intestines. A bird building its nest in a tree. The bird’s faeces fertilise the soil. A hermit crab carrying a sea anemone on its back. A bristle worm living with the hermit crab. Head lice living on a human scalp. Mistletoe putting its roots into its host tree. Ants and an acacia tree living together and both receiving benefit. Bees and a flower. Bacteria living in the intestines of a cow to help it break down cellulose. A clownfish and a sea anemone. A sixth-year student and their pet. A rhino and a tick bird. Lichen – a composite organism of a fungus and an alga that benefits both. Cleaner fish eating parasites off of a grouper fish. Bacteria, Rhizobium, that live in nodules on plants roots and fix nitrogen, using energy from the plant, which the plant is able to then use. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 9 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 4: Branching keys Make a branching key/protocol for finding out what type of sym biosis is being shown. You need to distinguish between mutualism and parasitism. Example of a branching key: Check it works with the various examples – possibly use the symbiosis worksheet. 10 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 5: Symbiosis revision 1. Explain the term ‘symbiosis’. 2. Define the term ‘parasitism’. 3. Why is it necessary for a parasite to keep its host alive? 4. Explain how parasites and their hosts interact to maintain a stable relationship. 5. Describe the three ways that parasites can be transmitted. 6. Describe, in general, the structure of most parasitic cycles. 7. Many parasites have resistant larval forms incorporated into their life cycles. Suggest a reason for this. 8. Explain, in evolutionary terms, how most parasites have become host specific. 9. Describe the phenomenon of mutualism. 10. Describe the relationships that exist between the following organisms: (a) (b) (c) fungi and algae in lichens corals and algae cleaner shrimp and fish. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 11 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 6: The prisoners’ dilemma The prisoners' dilemma game can be played online here: http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/playground/pd.html. The prisoners’ dilemma Frank and Bob have been arrested for robbing a bank and placed in separate isolation cells. Both are selfish and only care about themselves. A prosecutor makes the following offer to each. ‘You may choose to confess or remain silent. If you confess and your accomplice remains silent I will drop all charges against you and use your testimony to ensure that your accomplice does serious time (10 years). Likewise, if your accomplice confesses while you remain silent, they will go free while you do the time (10 years). If you both confess I get two convictions, but I’ll see to it that you both get early parole (after 7 years). If you both remain silent, I ’ll have to settle for token sentences on firearms possession charges (2 years each). If you wish to confess, you must tell me in the morning.’ Initially the reaction of most observers is that they should both keep quiet, however they both end up confessing and implicating the other person. This is surely the worst situation. Both get 7 years, so 14 in total!! Why is this? The solution becomes apparent when we look at the potential outcomes. If one person does not confess then they will either get 2 years or 10 years – an average of 6 years. If they do confess they will either get 0 years or 7 years – an average of 3.5 years. So they choose to confess and implicate the other on that basis. The ‘dilemma’ faced by the prisoners here is that, whatever the other does, each is better off confessing than remaining silent. But the outcome obtained when both confess is worse for each than the outcome they would have obtained had both remained silent. A common view is that the puzzle illustrates a conflict between individual and group rationality. A group whose members pursue rational self -interest may all end up worse off than a group whose members act contrary to rational 12 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS self-interest. It shows a choice between selfish behavio ur and socially desirable altruism. Further explanation and risk/rewards matrix The reason that both prisoners choose to confess is easy to explain. The following is the explanation assuming that Frank and Bob cannot communicate to each other. Frank has the following matrix (Bob has the reciprocal matrix): Frank confesses Frank is silent Bob is silent 0 2 Bob confesses 7 10 The expected payoff for the game (the average amount of benefit that a strategy will provide) is better — in this case, 3.5 years expected jail time for confessing versus 6 years for silence — if Frank confesses. Therefore, from a rational perspective, Frank should choose to confess rather than remain silent. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 13 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 7: Odd one out Instructions 1. Print and then cut out the cards on the following 3 pages 2. Pick the odd one out in each case 3. Give a reason for your choice in each case 4. Repeat for each card 5. Finally make 3 further odd ones out and give them to another group to try 14 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Parasitism Mutualism Why? Alliances Leeches Lions Why? Ticks Prisoners’ dilemma Kin selection Why? Altruism Wasps Chimpanzees Why? Termites LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 15 STUDENT MATERIALS Grooming Facial display Why? Body posture Clownfish and anemone Goby and blind shrimp Why? Rhizobium and clover A fireman saving a baby from a fire Worker ants never getting the chance to breed Why? A person risking injury to save a relative Saving a brother from harm Saving a cousin from harm Saving your wife/husband from harm 16 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 Why? STUDENT MATERIALS Co-evolution Symbiosis Why? Goby and blind shrimp (mutualism) Why? Why? Why? LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 17 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 8: Jane Goodall Find out who Jane Goodall is and why primate behaviour specialists (primatologists) were more inspired by her work compared to previous work that had solely been done in laboratories and zoos. Extension Explain why some behaviour specialists feel that Jane Goodall ’s work was tainted due to her anthropomorphism of some of the chimps. 18 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 9: Chimpanzee behaviour and expressions See separate pdf files. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 19 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 10: Chimpanzee hierarchy See separate pdf files. 20 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 11: Social behaviour continuum Agree strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Disagree strongly Students must place the following statements into the categories above (this will work best if the statements on the following pages are printed out and placed on an actual continuum): 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. Living in a group is beneficial. Competition will occur in a group. If too many people lived together there would be lots of fights . A highly successful parasite will kill its host fairly rapidly . In mutualism one organism must have evolved rapidly to take advantage of the other organism. Killing all parasites is a good idea. Zoos are good places to do research. A person is more likely to help someone they know . Humans make alliances in their lives. Humans have a similar social structure to ants . Animals will stop being altruistic if it is not reciprocated . Ritualistic display is good as it avoids ‘real’ fights. The more complex the social structure the less advanced the organism. Human behaviour in ‘Big Brother’ is similar to that in real life. If clownfish get very hungry they should just eat part of the anemone . Parasites must be careful not to harm their host too much . Plants cannot be parasites. Mutualism will increase the ability of a species to survive. I can see myself being altruistic in the future . I would be as likely to be altruistic to a stranger in a life or death situation as a relative. Social insects are ‘happy’ just to contribute to the colony . Hierarchies work best for the individual at the bottom. A chimp reared by humans could easily be released into the wild. Territories help to organise resources. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 21 STUDENT MATERIALS Cut out the cards below and place on the continuum you have been given. Living in a group is beneficial. Killing all parasites is a good idea. Competition will occur in a group. Territories help to organise resources. If too many people lived together there would be lots of fights. Zoos are good places to do research. A highly successful parasite will kill its host fairly rapidly. A person is more likely to help someone they know. In mutualism one organism must have evolved rapidly to take advantage of the other organism. Humans make alliances in their lives. Humans have a similar social structure to ants. Animals will stop being altruistic if it is not reciprocated. Ritualistic display is good as it avoids ‘real’ fights. The more complex the social structure the less advanced the organisms. Human behaviour in ‘Big Brother’ is similar to that in real life. If clownfish get very hungry they should just eat part of the anemone. Parasites must be careful not to harm their host too much. Plants cannot be parasites. Mutualism will increase the ability of a species to survive. I can see myself being altruistic in the future. I would be as likely to be altruistic to a stranger in a life or death situation as a relative. Social insects are ‘happy’ just to contribute to the colony. Hierarchies work best for the individual at the bottom A chimp reared by humans could easily be released into the wild 22 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS Activity 12: Symbiosis What is symbiosis? A symbiotic relationship is an intimate association between different species. It takes a significant time to arise and occurs through co -evolution. Symbiotic relationships can be: obligate – the association is necessary for at least one of the organisms to survive facultative – the association is beneficial for at least one of the organisms but is not essential for survival. There are two types of symbiotic association: ectosymbiosis – where one organisms lives on the other organism endosymbiosis – where one organisms lives inside the other organism. Different types of symbiosis 1. Parasitism Parasitism is an interaction between organisms of different species in which one organism (the parasite) benefits and the other (t he host) is harmed. This can happen through physical damage to the host or through stealing nutrients from the host. Question 1 ‘Parasites were collected from 107 harbour seals of f the coast of Schleswig-Holstein, Germany between 1997 and 2000. A total of 77 seals were infected with stomach worms and 4 were infected with sucking lice.’ (a) Which parasite is an ectoparasite and which is an endoparasite? LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 (2) 23 STUDENT MATERIALS (b) What percentage of the seals from this study was infected with stomach worms and what percentage was infected with sucking lice? (2) Question 2 ‘A fungal parasite of amphibians has been linked to dramatic decline in population numbers. The fungus grows best in moist environments and results in a thickening of the skin of an amphibian. ’ (a) (b) Why are almost all amphibians at risk of contracting this fungus? Why would a thickening of an amphibian’s skin result in illness and possibly death? (1) (2) ‘Some amphibians are resistant to the fungus but can still be carriers. ’ (c) 2. Why may this be an advantage and a disadvantage to conservation biologists? (3) Mutualism Mutualism is an interaction between organisms in which both organisms benefit. Question 1 ‘One of the best known examples of a mutualistic relationship is that between the clownfish and the sea anemone. Both benefit from the interaction; the clownfish is protected from predators by the stinging tentacles of the anemone, and the sea anemone is protected by the clownfish from anemone-eating butterfly fish and also receives nutrients from the clownfish waste.’ (a) (b) Is this association facultative or obligate? Do you think that this association will be short or long term? Why? (1) (3) Question 2 ‘Coral reefs are one of the most productive of all ecosystems supporting around 25% of all marine species. Reef-building coral is formed from the secretion of a calcium carbonate skeleton by the coral polyps. Within the cells of a coral polyp live microscopic algae that provide over 90% of a coral’s nutrients as reefs often form in areas of very low nutrient concentration.’ (a) 24 Why is coral reef growth limited to areas of clear, relatively shallow water? LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 (2) STUDENT MATERIALS ‘Corals provide the algae with protection and a constant supply of carbon dioxide without which the algae cannot survive. Temperature change is one of the environmental stresses that can result in the depletion of algae numbers which results in the ‘bleaching’ of coral. The coral will die unless the algae recover, leaving only the calcium carbonate skeleton.’ (b) (c) (d) 3. Is this relationship facultative or obligate? Why are conservationists concerned about climate change? Name two more environmental stresses that may affect coral reefs. (1) (1) (2) Commensalism Commensalism is an interaction between organisms in which one organism (the commensal) benefits and the other organism is unaffected. Question 1 ‘Barnacles are a member of the Crustacean subphylum closely related to crabs and lobsters. They are sedentary and will attach themselves to hard surfaces where they filter the water for food. Certain commensal species will live on crabs, turtles and even whales. ’ (a) (b) (c) What benefit do the barnacles gain by living on a host? Why may it be difficult to prove commensalism? Is this an example of ectosymbiosis or endosymbiosis? (2) (1) (1) Additional questions Question 1 ‘Coral reefs are often referred to as ‘the cleaning stations’ of the oceans. They are home to animals such as cleaner shrimps and cleaner wrasse. These organisms remove parasites from ‘clients’ visiti ng the stations and often enter the mouths of otherwise carnivorous species.’ (a) (b) What kind of symbiotic relationship if this an example of? Why do you think this? LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 (1) (2) 25 STUDENT MATERIALS Question 2 Fill in the grid using ‘benefits’, ‘negatively affected’ or ‘unaffected’ to show the effect on each organism in the relationship. Relationship Effect on organism 1 Effect on organism 2 Parasitism Mutualism Commensalism Question 3 ‘Many fish go through life with at least a low level of intestinal or stomach worm infection with no effect on their health.’ (a) (b) What symbiotic relationship is this be an example of? Do you think this relationship would remain the same if the host became ill? What would it become and why? (1) (2) Question 4 ‘Sea anemones often inhabit shells of hermit crabs. In one study predators of hermit crabs were presented with hermit crabs either with or without associated sea anemones. After 12 trials with and 12 trials without the results are shown below.’ (a) (b) Describe the trend of the results. If sea anemones are filter feeders what kind of symbiotic relationship do you think this association represents? Why? Rejection Rate of Hermit Crab by Predator 9 8 Number of Rejections 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 With anemone 26 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 Without anemone (2) (2) STUDENT MATERIALS References Lehnert, K., Raga, J.A. and Siebert, U. (2007) Parasites in harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) from the German Wadden Sea between two Phocine Distemper Virus epidemics. Helgoland Marine Research, 61, 230–245. McLean, R.B. and Mariscal, R.N. (1973) Protection of a hermit crab by its symbiotic sea anemone Calliactis tricolour. Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences, 29, 128–130. LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 27 STUDENT MATERIALS Solutions Activity 5: Symbiosis revision 1. Explain the term ‘symbiosis’. Symbiosis is the relationship between organisms of different species that show an intimate association with each other. Symbiotic relationships provide at least one of the participating species with a nutritional advantage. With symbiosis (as with predation) co -evolution occurs and the species become closely adapted to each other. 2. Define the term ‘parasitism’. Parasitism is a biotic interaction that is beneficial to one species (the parasite) and detrimental to the other (the host). The parasite lives on or in the host and obtains its nutrition from the host. 3. Why is it necessary for a parasite to keep its host alive? To secure a supply of food. 4. Explain how parasites and their hosts interact to maintain a stable relationship. There is a balance between the damage done by a parasite and the defences which the host has evolved, which creates a stable relationship. 5. Describe the three ways that parasites can be transmitted. Direct contact (fleas jump from one individual to another, the cold virus is spread by coughs and sneezes). Resistant stages (released into the environment and hatch out when eaten by the host). Secondary hosts (vectors) (transmit and devel op the infectious stage, eg the mosquito is the vector for the malaria organism Plasmodium) . 6. Describe, in general, the structure of most parasitic cycles. A parasite feeds on the primary host, grows, develops and uses the secondary host to secure widespread dispersal. Often the secondary host is required to complete the lifecycle of the parasite before it can move on to infect another (primary) host. 7. Many parasites have resistant larval forms incorporated into their lifecycles. Suggest a reason for this. Resistant larval forms allow parasites to survive unfavourable environmental conditions for periods of time until the conditions change. An example is the larvae of the liver fluke , which survive in an 28 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 STUDENT MATERIALS encysted form (inside a cyst) as long as water is ava ilable (eg in a pond). 8. Explain, in evolutionary terms, how most parasites have become host specific. This has arisen due to the co-evolution of the parasite and the host, with the relationship evolving for the best survival advantage of both, eg parasitic infection results in an immune reaction by the host to lessen the effect of the parasite; the parasite then adapts further to counter the effect of the host’s immune reaction. The host then evolves a more specific response and so on. As parasitic infection and host response become more specialised, co-evolution results in increased host specificity. 9. Describe the phenomenon of mutualism. Mutualism is the biotic interaction between two organisms of different species where both organisms benefit. Both specie s have developed adaptations to help them to coexist. 10. Describe the relationships that exist between the following organisms: (a) fungi and algae in lichens (Note: Eukaryotes are classified into four kingdoms: animals, plants, fungi and protists. Protists are unicellular organisms, eg Amoeba and Paramecium and unicellular algae (algae used to be classified as plants but now belong to the protists) . Lichen is made up of an alga and a fungus in close association. The alga photosynthesises and provides the fungus with carbohydrate. The fungus provides the alga with protection, support, nutrients (minerals) and CO 2 as the algal cells are found inside the fungal threads (hyphae). The fungus also provides water for the alga. (b) corals and algae Corals and giant clams have algae inside and between their cells. As the algae provide them with an energy source, corals can live in nutrient poor water. The algae are provided with protection, nutrients (minerals) and access to light. (c) cleaner shrimp and fish Cleaner shrimp and grouper fish have evolved a mutualistic relationship: the grouper fish allows the cleaner shrimp to remove LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011 29 STUDENT MATERIALS scraps of food trapped between its teeth – a free lunch for the cleaner shrimp and dental hygiene for the grouper fish. Shrimp also remove ectoparasites (as food) from fish such as the coral fish. 30 LIVING TOGETHER (H, BIOLOGY) © Learning and Teaching Scotland 2011