CARIES, ORAL HYGIENE STATUS AND DATES CONSUMPTION AMONG SAUDI FEMALE UNIVERSITY STUDENTS* Noura A. Al Essa BDS** Manal A. Al Mutairi BDS** Hadeel M. Al Ohali BDS** Ahmed El Hejazi BDS, MSc, PhD*** Arham Chohan BDS, BSc, MSc, FPFA, FADI**** ملخص أهددف ال رف سددملرفة ددمل اددنال حس د صحة صرمل ددسمل ر ددتلو سددن طال رن ددن لعدداللعصريددص ل ر صرفددمل راددفن ص ل لرددللعصريددص ل ر صرفددمل ددتل رن ددعلفةددا للر فة ددمل صرددمل اددنال حس د صحلول ددسمل ر ددت ل ر فةنرددص ل604ع ددن ل ر نفةقملعف ص مل سمل ر تلول سن طال رن ن لقفلج فتلرللخطللل سنياصحلذ يلرخصصلردلر ل ل ر ندصج لوجدف صلأحل ل( ال سدة ال7ة,,)للوادصحلرفدفلل ر خدن لل6ة,1ل( ال سدة ال ر فادص ل10ة01رففلل ر خةلو رس نلو رخةد لادصحل ل0ة01)لول ر ننحل رس ن لع فدفلل1ة66ل(ل ال سة ال ر فاص ل0ة,0)ةل ر ننحلل ر خةن للع ففلل6ة,,ر فاص ل )لعدالل جدص لرفدفللP>0ة07() لاصحله صال خنطالرةسنظلع اننىل الرملإ صدصجامل0ة,,( ال سة ال ر فاص ل ر خددةلو رس ددنلو رخة د للرة صريددص لرددللرخنةددعلأقاددصةل رف ددة لو نا ددمللفددللذر د ل ق د ل ع د لفددف ل ر صريددص لع ادديمل )لعددالل جددص لرفددفلل ر خدةلو رس ددنلو رخة د لP>0ة001(لعصددسمل ن ددملجاددفظ لرددن ل يددصعل ددصعيلل%,7ة47 ل اددنف ةلل ر ةةددصظلرن أاددعلأس د ص ل ليصرياددمل ر صريددص لاددلل د أ لل%,,ة0و ددسمل ر ددت ليصرياددمل ر صريددص لع ادديمل )ل%1,ة0()ل نرادصلول قد ل دن ريلو دفظلردللف دةظلعصريدص ل%,,ة6()لأولثطثلردة ل%6,ة0(أس ص للرة الل )ل دكاةلل رن ددةلول ددن ريل عد لفددف ل%,1ة0(ادنف ةلل راددن الرن أاددعلأسد ص ل لأاالدةلرددللثددطثلأ عددص ل ر صريددص ل )لعددالل خددن ل حسد صحلول سددن طالP>0ة07(ل يددص لعددصرانة لرددتل أ ددةلأ لفطقددمل10-7)ل ددكاةلل%,6ة6(ر صريددص ل رن ن لخط مل رقنللأحلرففلل ايمل انال حس صحلوخ ن هلاص تلفصراملجف ل ق ل ايملقةاةملرلل ر صريص لاصحل رف لل سمل ن ملجافظلوث ص املرللاللف ةظلعصريص لالل كاةلل رن ة نراصًَ ل للللللل ABSTRACT The objectives of the present study were to determine the caries experience, oral hygiene status and consumption of dates among Saudi female University students. A total of 406 female University students were examined for dental caries and oral hygiene. The information about oral hygiene practices and consumption of dates was obtained through a selfadministered questionnaire. The mean DMFT was 10.01 (SD 4.71) with a decay (D) component of 5.87 (SD 4.28), missing (M) component of 0.83 (SD 1.44) and filled component of 3.31 (SD 3.92). There was significant (p< .05) difference observed between the mean DMFT scores of the students from various age groups. Only one-fourth (25.6%) of the students had good oral hygiene. A positive correlation (p< .0001) was exhibited between the mean DMFT scores and oral hygiene. Almost all (98.0%) students used brush to clean their teeth. A majority of the students were cleaning their teeth twice (47.0%) or thrice (22.4%) daily and only about one in ten (12.3%) students’ used miswak to clean their teeth. More than three-fourth (81.0%) students were eating dates and about one-fourth (24.4%) of the students were eating 5-10 dates per day. No significant (p> .05) correlation was observed between caries and dates consumption. It was concluded that the caries prevalence and severity was very high. Only small percentage of the students had good oral hygiene and eight in every ten students was eating dates daily. * ** *** **** Internship Research Presentation. 6th March, 2007 (16 Safar, 1428 H). Internship Program, College of Dentistry, King Saud University, Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Intern, King Saud University College of Dentistry Associate Professor, RDS Department, Operative Dentistry Division, King Saud University College of Dentistry, Riyadh. Lecturer, PDS Department, Pediatric Dentistry Division, King Saud University College of Dentistry, Riyadh hygiene status was good9. Therefore, it would be interesting to determine the oral hygiene status and practices of female university students. INTRODUCTION It is an established fact that in many countries the university students occupy a significant position in public life. They are considered as the role model for the society and opinion leaders of the future in their field. It is assumed that significance of health perception is better understood in students of health sciences than those in the other fields. Therefore, the pattern of health behaviors and beliefs of these university students are of particular importance. The date palm (Phoenix dactylifera) is one of mankind's oldest cultivated plants and important produce in many Arabian Gulf Countries. It has been used as food for 6000 years14. It could be used for the generations to come, due to its remarkable nutritional, health and economic value in addition to its aesthetic and environmental benefits15. The fruits (dates) of the date palm contain a high percentage of carbohydrate (total sugars 44-88%), fat (0.2-0.5%), 15 salts and minerals, protein (2.3-5.6%), vitamins, a high percentage of dietary fiber (6.411.5%) and common pH values for dates range from 5.3 to 6.315,16. Historically, it was found that when dates were consumed as large portion of diet, which then lead to high caries incidence and accelerated tooth loss and evidence of this was found in a skeletal series from the late Iron Age in the Sultanate of Oman17. In the literature no study has been conducted to find out the relationship between consumption of dates with caries. Dental caries is still one of the most prevalent disease in different parts of the world. Many studies conducted in Western countries have reported a general decline in caries prevalence1. Studies undertaken in countries on the Arabian Peninsula have reported a very high caries severity, commonly associated with relatively high and frequent consumption of sweets2-4. In contrast, several studies in Saudi Arabia have reported a very high caries prevalence in school children5-8. Recently a study was conducted on female dental students, which also showed high caries prevalence9. Although, there are no studies on caries prevalence in Saudi female university students, therefore, a high caries prevalence is also expected in these university students. The objectives of the present study were: It has been observed that optimal gingival and periodontal health is related to good oral hygiene. Studies done by Alexander (1970)10 and Horowitz (1980)11 have shown a positive correlation between oral hygiene and gingival/periodontal disease. Similarly, a correlation has also been reported between oral hygiene and dental caries12,13. The study conducted on female dental students showed that overall oral 2 - To determine the caries prevalence and severity in female university students. - To determine their oral hygiene status and practices. - To see if there was any difference between the students of various age groups in relation to caries and oral hygiene status. - To see if there was any correlation between dates consumption and caries severity. Oral hygiene index: The oral hygiene index described by James et al (1960)19 was utilized by the study. The index has three categories of dental cleanliness. SUBJECTS AND METHODS The subjects used for this study were Saudi female University students residing in the hostels of King Saud University and Al-Tarbyia College. The hostels which were selected for this study had the facility of dental setup where the students receive routine dental treatment for their dental problems. Prior to the commencement of the study permission was taken from the hostel administration by stating the aims and objectives of the study. In addition, students were also informed about the study and their consent was taken to carry out dental examination. The students were divided into three age groups: <20 years, 20-22 years and >= 23 years. The students were examined by two examiners (NE and HO) on a dental chair utilizing a dental mirror and explorer and the third examiner (MM) recorded the information. The examiners ware calibrated with a senior KSUCD faculty member. The data obtained during the examination were recorded on a form especially designed for the study. The following indices were used to assess the caries and oral hygiene in the sample. - - Good: The teeth are clean. There is no sign of food debris or materia alba. Poor: The teeth are very dirty. There is considerable longstanding food debris, materia alba. Fair: This class falls between the two preceding ones. There is some evidence of debris, but not of the degree recognized as poor. The information about oral hygiene practices, consumption of dates and sugary products and drinking water was obtained through a selfadministered questionnaire. The following details were covered in the questionnaire. - - - Dental caries: The WHO criteria were used for the diagnosis of dental caries18. The caries was diagnosed on visual evidence, after drying and removing the debris from the teeth with the help of explorer and mirror. No radiographs were taken. Demographic information such as age, marital status and place of residence. Oral hygiene methods used such as toothbrush, miswak and its frequency. Use of mouthwash and dental floss. Type of dates and its frequency. Consumption of sugary products. Type of drinking water used. The data were then entered into a computer using the FOXPRO software and analyzed utilizing the Statistical Program for Social Sciences (SPSS) version #10. Various frequencies were generated. The Pearson Chi-square test was used to test the difference between 3 various age groups in term of oral hygiene status, oral hygiene practices, consumption of dates and sugary products. ANOVA was utilized to test the difference between mean DMFT scores of various age groups, mean DMFT scores with oral hygiene status, Correlation between caries and dates consumption and any significance between mean DMFT and drinking water. Table 1: Caries experience of the students with age groups. Age group Mean DMFT SD Mean decay SD Mean missing SD Mean filled SD < 20 years 9.29 4.52 6.02 4.38 0.57 1.08 2.70 3.58 20-22 years 10.06 4.52 5.58 4.11 0.94 1.60 3.54 4.19 > 23 years 11.85 5.27 6.26 4.45 1.28 1.67 4.31 3.73 Total 10.01 4.71 5.87 4.28 0.83 1.44 3.31 3.92 RESULTS A total of 406 Saudi female students of King Saud University participated in the study with the mean age of 20.38 years and a range of 18-28 years. There were 210 students from arts college, 37 students from science college and 159 students from medicine and dentistry colleges. The intra-examiner and inter-examiner reliability was determined utilizing Kappa method and it was 0.91 and 0.89 respectively. P> .05 P <.05 P <.05 Only one-fourth (25.6%) of the students had good oral hygiene (Table 2). A slight decrease was observed in the percentage of students with poor oral hygiene from age group < 20 years to >= 23 years but the difference was not significant (p> 0.05) (Table 2). A statistically significant (p< 0.001) correlation was observed when the mean DMFT scores were compared with oral hygiene status (Table 3). The overall caries prevalence was 98.8% with 98.6 % in arts students, 100% in science students and 98.7% in medicine and dentistry students were having caries. Furthermore, 97.6% of age group <20 years, 99.4% of age group 20-22 years and 100% of age group >=23 years were having caries. The overall mean DMFT was 10.01 (SD 4.71) with a decay (D) component of 5.87 (SD 4.28), missing (M) component of 0.83 (SD 1.44) and filled component of 3.31 (SD 3.92). There was significant (p< 0.05) difference observed between the mean DMFT scores of the students with various age groups (Table 1). However, the missing (M) and filled (F) component of the DMFT significantly (P<.05) increased with the increase in age (Table 1). Table 2: Oral hygiene status of the students. Oral hygiene Status 4 Age group Good (%) Fair (%) Poor (%) < 20 years 46 (27.4) 101 (60.1) 21 (12.5) 20-22 years 41 (23.2) 125 (70.6) 11 (6.2) >=23 years 17 (27.9) 40 (65.6) 4 (6.6) Total 104 (25.6) 266 (65.5) 36 (8.9) P < .05 Majority of the students were cleaning their teeth twice (47.0%) or thrice (22.4%) daily and only about one in ten (8.2%) students cleaned their teeth sometimes (Table 5). In the tooth cleaning frequency no particular trend was observed in relation to different age groups (Table 5). Table 3: Correlation between mean DMFT scores and Oral hygiene status DMFT Oral Hygiene Number Mean SD P value Good 104 7.40 4.73 < 0.001 Fair 266 10.59 4.29 < 0.001 Poor 36 13.28 4.15 < 0.001 Table 5: Frequency of tooth cleaning among the students. Frequency of tooth cleaning Total 406 10.01 4.71 Age group Once (%) Twice (%) Thrice (%) Sometime (%) Total (%) < 20 years 39 (23.2) 78 (46.4) 32 (19.0) 19 (11.4) 168 (100.0) 20-22 years 40 (22.6) 87 (49.2) 39 (22.0) 11 (6.2) 177 (100.0) >=23 years 12 (19.7) 26 (42.6) 20 (32.8) 3 (4.9) 61 (100.0) Total 91 (22.4) 191 (47.0) 91 (22.4) 33 (8.2) 406 (100.0) < 0.001 A great majority (98.0%) of the students were using tooth brush to clean their teeth, whereas in contrast about one in ten students were using miswak as an oral hygiene tool (Table 4). The use of dental floss significantly (p< 0.05) increased in students from <20 years to >=23 years age group (Table 4). Almost three-fourth (76.4%) of the students were drinking bottle water (Table 6). No statistically significant (p> 0.05) correlation was observed between the mean DMFT scores and the type of water consumed (Table 6). Table 4: Various oral hygiene methods used by the students. Table 6: Correlation between mean DMFT scores and Type of drinking water consumed ORAL HYGIENE METHODS Brush only (%) Miswak (%) Floss (%) * Mouth wash (%) < 20 years 165 (98.2) 24 (14.3) 30 (17.9) 17 (10.1) 20-22 years 174 (98.3) 17 (9.6) 55 (31.3) 16 (9.0) Water Number Mean SD P value >=23 years 59 (96.7) 9 (14.8) 22 (36.1) 5 (8.2) Bottle 310 10.11 4.82 > 0.05 Total 398 (98.0) 50 (12.3) 107 (26.4) 38 (9.4) Tap 16 8.81 4.65 > 0.05 Bottle + Tap 80 9.89 4.26 > 0.05 Total 406 10.01 4.71 > 0.05 Age group DMFT * P <.05 5 Table 7 : Responses to questions about dates type and consumption. Table 8 : Responses to questions about sugary products. _______________________________________________ _______________________________________________ Question n % _______________________________________________ Question n % _______________________________________________ Which type of date you eat? 1. Barhi 2. Kalas 3. Sukary 4. Others 17 193 184 12 17.2 47.5 45.3 3.0 Frequency of eating dates per day: 1. Once daily 329 2. Twice daily. 53 3. Thrice or more than three times. 24 81.0 13.1 5.9 Do you eat / or drink sugary products? 1. Yes 386 2. No 20 95.1 4.9 What kind of sugary products do you consume? 1. Sweet (Chocolate/candies). 232 2. Soft drinks. 173 3. Sweetened milk. 246 4. Confectionary 211 57.1 42.6 60.6 52.0 How often do you consume sugary products? 1. Daily. 293 72.1 2. Every week. 35 8.6 3. Occasionally. 78 19.2 _______________________________________________ How many dates you eat per day? 1. < 5 dates per day. 282 69.4 2. 5 – 10 dates per day 99 24.4 3. > 10 dates per day 25 6.2 ______________________________________________ DISCUSSION Table 7 summarizes the responses to question about the type, frequency and consumption of dates. A great majority of the students were eating dates once (81.0%) and twice (13.1%) daily. Almost (69.4%) of the students were eating < 5 dates per day, whereas (24.4%) were eating 5-10 dates per day. On analyzing the relationship of caries with dates, no statistically significant (p> 0.05) correlation was observed. It was seen that majority (95.1%) of the students were also consuming sugary products (Table 8). Almost three-fourth (72.1%) of the students were eating/or drinking different kinds of sugary products (Table 8). The present study has provided an interesting insight into caries experience, oral hygiene status and practices, consumption of dates and sugary products among Saudi female university students. The results will be utilized in motivating the students to improve their oral health behaviors and practices in the study areas. These results will also serve as base-line data for the future comparisons because; the literature has not reported any study conducted among Saudi females in this age group. The mean DMFT of the study population was very high. However, it was not unexpected. The recent studies of Saudi schoolchildren and female dental students have reported similar levels of caries6-9 and it shows that the children continue to carry the disease with them from schools to universities. Nevertheless, such a high level of caries is alarming in any population. This situation of high caries prevalence and severity in Saudi Arabia has been identified by several authors and they have pleaded for immediate measures to ameliorate preventive efforts6-8. AlDossai et al (2001)20 and Wyne et al 6 (2002)7 have suggested to organize school based preventive programs which will impart awareness and knowledge about oral health. dental students9. Several studies have reported on the usefulness of miswak for dental health24,25. Therefore, it would be beneficial to use a combination of brush and miswak for optimum oral health. Most importantly, the use of miswak has been encouraged through the religious and cultural hygiene guidelines and traditions. The increased use of dental floss could also be attributed to increased awareness about oral health and also to increased number of restored teeth, which sometime makes it compulsory to clean the interproximal areas with dental floss. The results are in agreement with the study by Al-Zahrani et al (2004)9. There was statistically significant (p< 0.05) difference observed between the mean DMFT scores of the students from various age groups and also the mean DMFT scores continued to increase across the years. More and more students got their carious teeth restored or extracted, probably as a result of increased awareness about the disease. Similar results were reported in the study conducted in young adults10 but not in agreement with results reported in Danish20 and Saudi9 dental students. There are no such recent data available on similar age Saudi population. It was observed in our study that majority of the students had appropriate brushing habits. Moreover, three-fourth of the students were drinking bottle water which contains fluoride which is an anti cariogenic agent in preventing tooth decay but on the other hand a very high caries prevalence was unusual. Furthermore, a large number of students were eating dates and consuming sugary products but no statistical significance was observed in relation to caries severity with dates and sugary products consumption. It is a matter of serious concern that majority of the students were unaware of the harmful effects of sweets, soft drinks, sweetened milk and confectionaries. Dates contain a high concentration of sugar, which is considered the main component .This carbohydrate in dates mainly helps in reducing sugars in the form of glucose, fructose, mannose and maltose and non-reducing sugars (primarily sucrose), as well as small amounts of polysccharides such as cellulose and starch26. So because of these properties of dates it could be inferred that dates eaten in normal quantity does not directly causes tooth decay. It has been reported that women in general have cleaner teeth than men, and that the trend prevails within various age groups21. In our study population one-fourth of the students had good oral hygiene. However, overall small improvement in oral hygiene was observed with the advancement in age. This improvement in oral hygiene could be because of the awareness from different sources and as well as from peer interaction. The results were in agreement with those of Lang et al (1977)22 and Howat et al (1979)23 who reported an improvement in oral hygiene through the years in students. A significant correlation (p< .001) was observed between mean DMFT scores and oral hygiene, which mean that because of bad oral hygiene the prevalence in caries severity increased. It was worth noting that a great majority of the students were using tooth brush to clean their teeth whereas very few students were using miswak. Similar results were reported in female 7 The responses obtained through a questionnaire have to be considered with caution. There is a potential tendency towards favorable response. The possibility of a bias created by favorable response could not be ruled out. Nevertheless, it is hoped that the study has provided useful information about the caries, oral hygiene and dates consumption in the study population. - ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We wish to thank the hostel administration for giving the permission to carry out the study. We also deeply appreciate the participation and cooperation of all the students, and wish them a good health and success in their studies. We are also thankful to Dr. Nazeer Khan for helping in statistical analysis. CONCLUSION - - - - The caries prevalence and severity was very high among the Saudi female university students. REFERENCES 1. Blinkhorn AS, Davies RM. Caries prevention: a continued need world-wide. Int dent J 1996; 46:119-25. Only one-fourth of the students had good oral hygiene. A great majority of the students were using toothbrush to clean their teeth. 2. Soparkar P, Taraves M, Hussain J, Babeely K, Behbehani J , Al -Za'abi F. Nursing bottle syndrome in Kuwait . J Dent Res 1986; 65:745-. A positive correlation was observed between the mean DMFT scores and oral hygiene. 3. Al-Mughery AS, Attwood D, Blinkhorn AS. Dental health of 5 year old children in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1991; 19:308-309. Majority of the students were not aware of the harmful effects of the sugary products RECOMMENDATIONS - - Further research is needed to be carried out in larger sample size. 4. Al-Hosani E, Rugg Gunn AJ. The relationship between diet and dental caries in 2 and 4 years old children in the Emirate of Abu Dhabi . Saudi Dent J 2000; 12:149-155. The university students should be screened for dental disease at the start of their course and encouraged to seek treatment immediately. 5. Stewart BL, Al Juhani TS, Al Akeel AS, Al-Deghaishem FA , Abdulla B. Caries experience in grades 1 and 6 children attending elementary school at King Abdul-Aziz Military City , Tabuk, Saudi A follow-up mechanism and continuous reinforcement should be provided. 8 Arabia . Saudi Dent J 2000; 12:140-148. 12. Aleksejuniene J, Arneberg P, Eriksen HM. Caries prediction and oral hygiene in Lithuianian children and adolescents. Acta Odontol Scand 1996; 54:75-80. 6. Khan NB, Al-Ghannam NA, Al-Shammery AR, Wyne AH. Caries in primary school children: prevalence, severity and pattern in Al-Ahsa, Saudi Arabia. Saudi Dent J 2001; 13:66-70. 13. Wandera A, Bhakta S, Barker T. Caries prediction and indicators using a pediatric risk assessment teaching tool. ASDC J Dent Child 2000; 67:408-12. 7. Wyne AH, Al-Ghoraibi BM, Al-Asiri YA, Khan NB. Caries prevalence in Saudi primary schoolchildren of Riyadh and their teachers’ oral health knowledge, attitude and practices. Saudi Med J 2002; 23:77-81. 14. Amer WM. Taxonomic and documentary study of fod plants in Ancient Egypt. PhD Thesis. Cairo University. 1994. 15. Al-Shahib W, Marshall RJ. The fruit of the date palm: Its possible use as the best food for the future?. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition 2003; 54:247-259. 8. AlDosari AM, Wyne AH, Akpata E S, Khan N B. Caries prevalence and its relation to water fluoride levels among schoolchildren in Central Province of Saudi Arabia. International Dental Journal 2004; 54:424-428. 16. Jasim A, Hosahalli SR. Physico-Chemical properties for commercial date pastes (Phoenix dactylifera).Journal of Food Engineering 2006; 76:348-352 9. Al-Zahrani FS, Al-Qahtani HS, Chohan AN, Wyne AH. Caries, oral hygiene and smoking in female undergraduatebdental students of King Saud University, College of Dentistry, Riyadh. Internship Seminar, 2004. 17. Greg CN, Johan RL, Paul Y. Dates, Caries, and early tooth loss during the Iron Age of Oman. Am J Phys Anthropol, 1999; 108:333-343. 10. Alexander AG. Dental calculus and bacterial plaque and their relation to gingival disease in 400 individuals. Br Dent J 1970;129:116-122. 18. World Health Organization. Oral Health Surveys. Basic Methods. 3rd Ed. Geneva WHO; 1997. 11. Horowitz AM. Effects of supervised daily dental plaque removed by children after 3 years. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1980; 8:171-77. 19. James PMC, Jackson D, Slack GL, Lawton FE. Gingival health and dental cleanliness in English school children. Arch Oral Biol 1960; 3:57-60. 9 24. Almas K. The antimicrobial effects of extracts of Azadirachta (Neem) and Salvadora Persica (Arak) chewing sticks. Ind J Dent Res 1999; 10:23-26. 20. AlDosari AM, Akpata ES, Wyne A, Khan N. Correlative study of fluoride levels, dental caries and fluorosis in the central province of Saudi Arabia. Final Report. The King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology: Riyadh, 2001. 25. Almas K. The antimicrobial effects of seven different types of Asian chewing sticks. Odontostomatol Trop 2001; 24:17-20. 21. Bakdash MB, Proshek JM. Oral hygiene status of dental students as related to their personal and academic profiles. J Periodontal Res 1979; 14:438-443. 26. Shinwari MA. Date palm. In Encyclopaedia of food science. Food technology and nutrition, Vol:2, Eds Macrae, 1993. 22. Lang NP, Cumming BR, Loe HA. Oral hygiene and gingival health of Danish dental students and faculty. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1977; 5:237-242. 23. Howat A, Trabelsi I, Brandnock G. Oral hygiene levels and behavior in preclinical and final-year dental students. J Clin Periodontol 1979; 6:177-185. 10