Employment Equity Report 2014 As part of Laurier’s commitment to diversity and creating a culture of inclusion, the 2014 Annual Employment Equity Report provides the community with an update on Laurier’s employment equity related initiatives. Prepared by Dana Lavoie, Employment Equity Officer Diversity and Equity Office Employment Equity Report - 2014 Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 4 About this Report .......................................................................................................................................... 4 Employment Equity Policy and Procedure ................................................................................................... 5 Highlights from 2014 .................................................................................................................................... 6 University-Wide Initiatives ....................................................................................................................... 6 Representation Highlights ......................................................................................................................... 7 Women .................................................................................................................................................. 7 Aboriginal Peoples ................................................................................................................................ 7 Persons with Disabilities ....................................................................................................................... 7 Members of a Visible Minority ............................................................................................................. 8 Sexual Minorities .................................................................................................................................. 8 Recruitment, Selection and Hiring ................................................................................................................ 8 Employment Outreach Initiatives ............................................................................................................. 8 Selection and Hiring Systems ................................................................................................................... 9 Orientation Systems .................................................................................................................................. 9 Employment Equity Self-Identification Survey ..................................................................................... 9 Enhancing Laurier’s Culture of Inclusion: Equity Related Training and Educational Opportunities ........ 10 The Office of Aboriginal Initiatives & The Aboriginal Student Centre ................................................. 10 Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) .................................................................... 11 Physical Barrier Removal ................................................................................................................... 12 Diversity and Equity Office Training, Education and Support ............................................................... 12 Change Project Recommendations & Gendered Violence Task Force ................................................... 13 Employment Equity Workforce Analysis (the Data) .................................................................................. 14 Overview of requirements and methodology .......................................................................................... 14 Self-Identification Return and Response Rate ........................................................................................ 15 Understanding the Numbers ................................................................................................................... 15 Looking at the Trends: Faculty ............................................................................................................... 16 Faculty who are Women at Laurier..................................................................................................... 17 Faculty who are Visible Minorities at Laurier .................................................................................... 18 2 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty who are Aboriginal People at Laurier .................................................................................... 19 Faculty with Disabilities at Laurier ..................................................................................................... 20 Faculty who identify as Sexual Minorities at Laurier ......................................................................... 21 Looking at the Trends: Non-Academic ................................................................................................... 21 Staff who are Women at Laurier ......................................................................................................... 22 Senior Administrators and Middle Managers & Other Managers (NOC 1 & 2) who identified as Women at Laurier ............................................................................................................................... 23 Staff who are Members of a Visible Minority at Laurier.................................................................... 24 Staff who are Aboriginal Peoples at Laurier ....................................................................................... 25 Staff with Disabilities at Laurier ......................................................................................................... 26 Staff who identify as Sexual Minorities at Laurier ............................................................................. 27 Additional Data and Gap Analysis per EEOG ........................................................................................ 27 2014 Employees by Occupational Group (EEOG) ................................................................................. 28 2014 Workforce – Gap Analysis............................................................................................................. 29 Final Words................................................................................................................................................. 30 Appendix A – Employment Equity Self-Disclosure Questionnaire ........................................................... 31 Appendix B – Overall Percentage Charts ................................................................................................... 35 Overall Percentage of Women Employed at Laurier .............................................................................. 35 Overall Percentage of Visible Minorities Employed at Laurier.............................................................. 35 Overall Percentage of Aboriginal Persons Employed at Laurier ............................................................ 36 Overall Percentage of Persons with Disabilities Employed at Laurier ................................................... 36 Appendix C - Employment Equity Occupational Groups Definitions ........................................................ 38 3 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Introduction As we reflect upon this past year it is encouraging to see growing attention paid to—and subsequent momentum growing around—issues of equity in public institutions. Strong, ongoing commitment to mental health initiatives and new energy imbued in gendered violence prevention and support are just two key examples of a slowly changing campus culture. With these strides in mind we feel emboldened to meet the challenges ahead and continue working toward building a more equitable and inclusive workplace. About this Report The purpose of employment equity is to ensure that all members of our community have access to positions and opportunities for advancement and that job qualifications are assessed in relation to the requirements of the position. Employment equity is about ensuring that all qualified candidates are considered, that the best candidate is hired and that those who are hired have equitable access to opportunities for development and advancement. Employment equity is not about giving members of designate groups an advantage over others; rather, employment equity aims to level the playing field by acknowledging that systemic barriers exist and by working toward removing those barriers. In some cases, this includes initiatives to increase the pool of applicants from designate groups by sponsoring scholarships or academic opportunities for the underrepresented group (ie. scholarships with women in STEM programs). In other cases, pay equity issues are addressed head-on by reassessing job rates for positions typically performed by a particular designate group (ie. McMaster’s recent announcement that it would pay all female faculty an additional $3,515 to rectify the historical inequity of female faculty making less than their male counterparts). This report highlights various initiatives across campus designed to promote inclusivity at Laurier and provides a statistical overview of the number of Laurier staff and faculty who identify as members of the four designate groups (women, visible minorities, Aboriginal peoples and persons with disabilities) as well as those who identify as sexual minorities. Although these groups are not the only areas protected under the Ontario Human Rights Code, they are the groups considered the “designate groups” under the Federal Contractors Program which requires the collection of data outlined in this report. For the purpose of providing a full picture of initiatives related to equity and inclusion that impact Laurier staff and faculty, initiatives beyond the four designate groups have also been presented. 4 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Employment Equity Policy and Procedure Laurier has an employment equity policy and a procedure to ensure this policy is put into effect. In the policy, Laurier commits to providing equal employment opportunity to all individuals including any groups designated by federal or provincial legislation, and the University commits to providing a workplace free from discrimination. Adopting Section 5(1) of the Ontario Human Rights Code (1981) and any amendments thereto, Laurier provides that “every person has a right to equal treatment with respect to employment without discrimination because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, age, record of offenses, marital status, same sex partnership status, family status or disability.” In 2012 “gender identity” and “gender expression” were added as grounds of discrimination in the Ontario Human Rights Code1. In 2014, the Ontario Human Rights Council (OHRC) followed up with a new suggested template for the prevention of discrimination based on gender identity and gender expression. This has led Laurier to review many of its current and likely outdated policy related to equity, discrimination and accommodation. The second part of Laurier’s current Employment Equity policy (2004) states that Laurier “is committed to promote employment equity within the university community, and to eliminate any barriers that reduce or prevent employment equity.” Lastly, the policy states that provisions of the policy are subject to agreements with unions or employee associations to which the university is a party. To help enforce this policy the University has an Employment Equity and AODA Officer. The employment equity officer is responsible for: updating employee data in order to ascertain the proportion of designated group members; reviewing university policies and procedures to identify any barriers that adversely impact, reduce, or prevent employment for designated group members; promoting awareness of the university’s commitment to non-discrimination and employment equity, and providing training to employee groups on practices and processes by which employment equity may be achieved. Throughout 2015, many of Laurier’s policies related to human rights, employment equity and accommodations will be updated to better reflect current significant legal decisions and changes to the Ontario Human Rights Code. In doing so, a priority over the summer 2015 is to reestablish the Joint University/Association Employment Equity Advisory Committee and the 1 Gender identity is defined as each person’s internal and individual experience of gender. It is their sense of being a woman, a man, both, neither, or anywhere along the gender spectrum. A person’s gender identity may be the same as or different from their birth-assigned sex. Gender identity is fundamentally different from a person’s sexual orientation. Gender expression is defined as how a person publicly presents their gender. This can include behaviour and outward appearance such as dress, hair, make-up, body language and voice. A person’s chosen name and pronoun are also common ways of expressing gender. 5 Employment Equity Report - 2014 University/Association Employment Equity Committee. With the support of the Diversity and Equity Office, these committees will be tasked with reviewing the current Employment Equity Policy and its accompanying Employment Equity Plan. This will include focus groups with staff and faculty as well as other assessment criteria. By summer 2016, Laurier and its Equity Committees should have a revised policy and plan in place. Highlights from 2014 University-Wide Initiatives Laurier appointed a new Director of the Diversity and Equity Office which focuses on creating and implementing strategies related to inclusion at Laurier, conducting assessments and systems reviews of University policies and practices from an inclusion perspective and acts as a senior advisor for the University. Dr. Laura Mae Lindo was appointed into the role in July 2014. In partnership, Laurier’s Diversity and Equity Office, CPAM and ICT, supported by the Accessibility Directorate of Ontario, embarked on the “Enabling Access Through Web Renewal” project which documents Laurier’s web renewal process. The goal is to provide a template for other institutions looking to create AODA compliant websites. The Diversity and Equity Office in partnership with the Centre for Teaching Innovation and Excellence worked with students to create critical incident videos that can be used for faculty training. The videos depict real student experiences of racism, sexism, Islamophobia, ableism, and tokenism in the classroom and provide faculty with tools to engage and respond to these types of inequalities in Laurier classrooms more effectively. This project will be replicated in the 2015-2016 school year to ensure examples and tools remain current and reflective of real life concerns of students and faculty. Similarly, the Faculty of Social work in partnership with the Centre for Teaching Innovation and Excellence also created and filmed videos that address the experiences of international students with a specific look at exclusionary practices, systemic barriers to success and oppressive practices in Faculty of Social Work classrooms at Laurier. Both sets of videos will be available for use in future faculty training initiatives, as well as for use by faculty members in broader classroom settings at Laurier. Both the Diversity and Equity Office and Faculty of Social Work are working together to create handbooks to accompany the videos as an additional learning resource. A new online module related to the requirements of the Integrated Accessibility Regulation under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act was rolled out to faculty and staff. The module covers changes to the legislation, best practices in accessibility and the Ontario Human Rights Code. Over 1300 faculty and staff have participated in the training to date. The Change Project, a collaboration between the Sexual Assault Support Centre for Waterloo Region (SASC), the Social Innovation Research Group (SIRG), the Centre for Women and Trans People (CWT), the UW Women’s Centre, the Diversity and Equity 6 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Office, Laurier University and the University of Waterloo, a 3-year research project looking at preventing gendered violence on university campuses was completed in 2014. Specific attention was paid to Laurier’s Waterloo and Kitchener campuses and the official release of the project was held in March 2015. Following the recommendations therein, Laurier introduced “Bringing in the Bystander” training. The train-the-trainer model covers a community of responsibility approach that teaches bystanders how to safely intervene before, during and after an incident of sexual assault, relationship violence and/ or stalking. As part of Laurier’s ongoing strategy for increasing student, faculty and staff wellness, Laurier introduced the “Mental Health First Aid” program. This program improves the mental health literacy of faculty and staff in explaining how to recognize symptoms of mental health problems, provide initial help and refer students and colleagues to the appropriate professional services. Representation Highlights Women Women continue to make up a large part of Laurier’s workforce representing 60.1% of Laurier employees. Laurier continues to experience a higher representation of women (68%) amongst staff when compared to academics (44%). Also, it is important to note that the data collected on sex is pulled from employment data and not the self-identification survey. Therefore this is the only section of Laurier specific data not impacted by inherent issues with self-identification. Aboriginal Peoples Overall, 1.3% of Laurier’s employees identify as Aboriginal people. Laurier continues to have a slight under-representation in the area of academia and middle management; however overall does not reflect a gap. Although the gap is not present, it is important to note that there are historical and growing issues amongst Aboriginal communities’ and the Canadian government; who initiates the census data. This contextual background is important to keep in mind when accessing anytime of gap analysis. Numbers alone do not tell the personal experience story and may leave organizations feeling they have created an inclusive environment for Aboriginal People when in fact they may have done very little. Persons with Disabilities Overall, Laurier’s internal workforce closely reflects the external pool of persons with disabilities with 4% of Laurier’s population identifying as having a disability. As the definition of disability used by the province expands, stigma surrounding disability decreases, and as our workforce population ages we can expect to see more 7 Employment Equity Report - 2014 employees self-identifying as having a disability. Also, it is important to note that most employees experiencing temporary disabilities or illnesses will not be reflected in this data as the nature of the Federal Contractors Programs speaks more to permanent disabilities. Members of a Visible Minority Laurier continues to demonstrate a significant gap in its representation of visible minorities with only 8.5% of Laurier’s workforce identifying as a visible minority. This gap is not present amongst faculty, however is present in almost every staff category. Although the gap is not present amongst faculty, it is notable that the census data is referred to reflects the Canadian population in 2006, percentages of which have changed significantly with regards to its representation of visible minorities. With census changes, 2006 was the last year that this data was collected through the census, a reality that poses significant concerns regarding the accuracy of these findings. Moreover, there are inherent issues for some people disclosing their minority status on census data because of concerns about discrimination. Sexual Minorities As sexual minorities are not considered a designated group under the Federal Contractors Program and data on sexual minorities is not included in the 2006 Canadian Census, it is difficult to compare the internal and external workforces. Laurier has consistently seen an increase in the number of staff and faculty identifying as sexual minorities overtime with 3.3% of the Laurier workforce identifying as sexual minorities. Recruitment, Selection and Hiring Employment Outreach Initiatives All of Laurier’s job postings and external advertisements highlight the University’s commitment to employment equity and accessibility in the hiring process, however the data illuminates a continued gap in the successful realization of this commitment in various equity areas. 8 Employment Equity Report - 2014 All staff postings are sent to two list serves: one designed to reach persons with disabilities, persons who identify as visible minorities, new immigrants, and women and the other list serve is designed to reach local Aboriginal communities. Work continues on expanding upon and refining a recruitment plan that targets key equity areas for faculty positions. Selection and Hiring Systems Several processes are in place to decrease bias in Laurier’s selection and hiring systems. For example, hiring committees are used for both academic and staff vacancies in order to reduce biases; interview questions are drawn from a database and are consistently asked to each candidate and candidates are provided detailed descriptions of the hiring process to ensure required accommodations are put in place prior to the interview. All of Laurier’s job postings include detailed information on job responsibilities, and the corresponding required skills and knowledge; only this expertise is reviewed during the interview process. Finally, all hiring managers and many Departmental Appointments and Promotions Committee (DAPC) are provided guidance, training and coaching from HR, Faculty Relations and the Employment Equity Officer on how to maintain an equitable hiring process. Furthermore, all DAPCs are required to have an Equity rep on the committee; through 2015 training and discussions will target these reps so they are prepared to incorporate equitable hiring practices and assess the DAPC’s process related to inclusion. Orientation Systems One on one, in-person orientations are held with all staff and management hires; part time or temporary hires are encouraged to review the new employee toolkit available on the HR website. During both the in person and online orientations, employees are provided with information on employment equity initiatives, the availability of accommodations, and are encouraged to complete the self-identification survey. Furthermore, additional online training is now available for new employees that cover accessible customer service, the Integrated Accessibility Standard Regulation and the Human Rights Code. To assist in preparing new faculty, new critical incident videos have been produced through the Diversity and Equity Office as well as through the Faculty of Social Work that can now be incorporated in the New Faculty Orientation. These videos help faculty understand and practice dealing with and responding to issues related to equity in their classrooms. Employment Equity Self-Identification Survey New employees are asked to complete the self-identification survey as part of their hiring package. While it is mandatory to return the survey (tracked by “return rate”), it is voluntary to complete the survey (tracked by “response rate”). If the survey is not returned within the first 9 Employment Equity Report - 2014 year of hire, both staff and faculty are contacted and asked to complete the survey. This practice has resulted in a consistent return rate for new staff and faculty. The data collected in the survey is compared to local and national census data in order to better understand how Laurier’s internal community reflects/or does not reflect the external available labour pool. Surveys are strictly confidential and the data is only available to the Employment Equity Officer. Enhancing Laurier’s Culture of Inclusion: Equity Related Training and Educational Opportunities The Office of Aboriginal Initiatives & The Aboriginal Student Centre In January 2011, the Aboriginal Student Centre opened at the Waterloo campus, and, in September 2011, at Laurier Brantford. Beyond the primary focus of Aboriginal student support, the Aboriginal Student Centres work to raise awareness of Aboriginal people, their cultures and their issues. The Centres often organize cultural and other social events on and off campus, thus fostering sensitivity toward Aboriginal issues within and beyond the campus community. 2014-15 saw the continuation of many important events and growth of partnerships by the Office of Aboriginal Initiatives and the Aboriginal Student Centres, including the annual Aboriginal Education week, orientation week events, and other educational and social sessions. Soup and Frybread lunches continued to be successful at both campuses; these lunches provide an informal atmosphere for persons to learn about Aboriginal culture. The Centres also continue to develop and deliver a number of customized educational programs for Learning Services, the Faculty of Education, the Diversity and Equity Office, Staff Day, the Integrated and Engaged Learning Conference, as well as dozens of classrooms, including in high schools and on-reserve and offreserve Aboriginal community groups. The Aboriginal Student Centre offered a workshop for the diversity certificate program in Winter 2015, as well as workshop in conjunction with the Graduate Student Association and the Centre for Teaching and Learning Innovations on the subject of Microaggressions and Aboriginal Identity in academia. These workshops resulted from the summer of 2014 faculty reading support group hosted at the Aboriginal Student Centre, where “Colonized Classrooms” by Sheila Cote-Meek was read by 14 participants, mostly faculty. Another addition to Aboriginal content in courses was a hire of the Aboriginal Scholar in residence by the Faculty of Arts. Darren Thomas was hired to assist Faculty of Arts professors incorporate indigenous knowledge in their courses and to work with FOA students find resources for papers and presentations. Increases of Aboriginal visibility on Laurier’s multi-campuses happened through art and events, including collaboration with the University Curator on a show by Kent Monkman, a leading First Nations painter and artist. With his visit, there was a lecture, a month long art exhibit at the Robert Langdon Gallery, a campus visit with mentorship for Aboriginal students and a book 10 Employment Equity Report - 2014 created in celebration of his visit to Laurier. Additionally, both Brantford and Waterloo was treated by artist Rene Meshake, an Ojibwe author/illustrator, storyteller, visual artist, spokenword performer, musician and new media artist offered a series of 3 art workshops to Waterloo students in February 2015. In Brantford, Wilfrid Laurier University's Yellow Brick Wall present4edSongide'ewin: Ojibwe Narratives Art Exhibit featuring acrylics featuring Rene Meshake's work. It ran from March 1 to April 15, 2015 and reflected the impact of the artist's residential school experiences and is intended as a healing tool for communities and individuals. OAI is currently in talked with the library for a permanent Aboriginal art piece on campuses. Increases of Aboriginal visibility on Laurier’s multi-campuses also happened through territorial acknowledgements. In Fall 2014, the Department of English and Film Studies voluntarily led the way for several other Laurier departments by voting to provide the territorial acknowledgements in all future course outlines. 2015-2016 will further increase this campaign. In 2014 the Aboriginal Student Centre co-presented with Laurier’s Career Centre at the Cannexus Conference in a presented “ Collaborative Innovations in Career Development Outreach for Distinct Groups” , where the partnership was hailed as a unique success in engagement. A video highlighting the custom service delivery was produced. Additionally, youth engagement and community outreach has continued to be a strategy for future student recruitment. Laurier Waterloo and Laurier Brantford offered separate March Break camps reflective of community. Ilaji (I am preparing) was the Waterloo campus March Break camp offering that recruited youth ages 8-12 from Kitchener –Waterloo urban community, which focused on broad Indigenous-based learning, games and activities. Tehotikahrathè:tha (Their Eyes Sparkle) was the Brantford Campus camp, which attracted youth from Brantford, New Credit, Six Nations and as far away as Niagara Falls. Tehotikahrathè:tha (Their Eyes Sparkle), was offered in partnership with Onkwawenna Kentyokhwa Kanyen'kehaka Mohawk adult immersion program; a Six Nations community-based organization. The camp was designed to help Aboriginal youth reconnect with their ancestral language, culture and songs and provide a safe space for any and all Aboriginal youth to learn about Mohawk cultural traditions. Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) The Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) was released as law in 2005. Since this time, the Customer Service Standard and Integrated Accessibility Standard Regulation (IASR) has had various implementation dates starting as early at January 1, 2010. The 2014 requirements included provisions around recruitment language and protocol, accessible web design, and IASR and human rights training. All of these requirements have led to larger initiatives and partnerships across university departments. Standard recruitment language is now 11 Employment Equity Report - 2014 found on all staff, faculty and student postings with many administrators across the university becoming more proficient in creating accessible documents. Laurier is undergoing a long-term web renewal process which challenges Laurier departments to rethink the information they currently include on their websites. The new system will include a site for perspective students and community members, a site for current students and a site for staff and faculty. Not only is the new web platform Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.0 Level A compliant (an international standard of excellence in accessible web development), it also takes into account principles of accessibility with web content being written in simple language and information being easier to access in a logical manner. Finally, ongoing training initiatives continue with the addition of two new online modules for staff and faculty related to the IASR and human rights code. Although the AODA legislation only required training related to disability and the Ontario Human Rights Code, the training being provided covers the code in general and its various sections. A number of additional quick reference guides have also been created and rolled out which help employees better understand things like accessible documents, supports at Laurier and emergency planning preparedness. Physical Barrier Removal Although Laurier continues to make minor improvements related to accessibility, the most notable project in 2014 included the redesign and construction of a new entrance into the Library on the Waterloo campus. The previous entrance included a very narrow ramp which often became blocked because of snow and ice. The new entrance provides a universal way for all patrons to access the Library and does not segregate those who may require an accessible entrance. Diversity and Equity Office Training, Education and Support With staffing changes in the Diversity and Equity Office, including the creation and hiring of a new Director, the last year has been filled with experimenting and transition at the Diversity and Equity Office. Long running programs like the Inclusive Excellence Certificate and the Community of Practice on Inclusion were only offered through the first term of 2014 and the fall included a number of new initiatives and partnerships. For the first time, the Diversity and Equity Office started offering training modules online. The first few modules piloted concentrated on accessibility and human rights. At the end of 2014, over 1300 people had participated in at least one of the modules provided. Future online modules are in the development stage which will concentrate on a number of topics and be specifically geared towards faculty learning. 12 Employment Equity Report - 2014 The Diversity and Equity Office continued to partner with faculty members to bring interactive sessions into the classroom. Classes included but are not limited to Globalization, Culture and Society, Human Rights Education and Community Psychology. The Diversity and Equity Office’s Education & Inclusion Coordinator worked actively to provide support to faculty, teaching assistants and departments to provide pedagogical support as well as gather information about marginalization and/ or exclusion within particular departments and the larger Laurier community. Examples of the Diversity and Equity Office’s work with faculty included ongoing support to the Faculty of Social Work. The Diversity and Equity Office continued to support the Faculty of Social Work through participation on the Equity Committee. The Diversity and Equity Office was successful in receiving a small grant to assist in the creation of a “Soup and Substance” pilot program with the Faculty of Social Work that aimed to explore key social justice and equity issues that resonated with the faculty (e.g., issues of race, gender diversity, mental health etc.) Planning for these sessions began in Fall 2014 and the Diversity and Equity Office also promised to act as a panelist for upcoming sessions. The Diversity and Equity Office also began working with the Faculty of Social Work as it engaged in development of a 5-year equity and inclusion strategy and implementation plan. The plan, which addresses topics ranging from student recruitment and admissions to classroom content and conflict, should be released in Winter 2015. The Diversity and Equity Office believes that retention among diverse employees requires complementary attention to the creation of and support for an inclusive culture. To this end, the Diversity and Equity Office also worked in partnership with the Faculty of Arts to bring Alison Wearing to Laurier to perform her off-Broadway show: “Confessions of a Fairy’s Daughter.” This powerful performance discussed her own experiences growing up with a gay father in the 1980s and presented a Canadian history lesson on the human rights movement in the 1980s as understood through her father’s memories of bathhouse raids, courtroom battles and community development. The Diversity and Equity Office also began a monthly column in The Cord to discuss issues of equity and inclusion more explicitly, as well as provided articles for Human Resources’ publication, The Spot, and the Fall 2014 Teaching & Learning Newsletter at Laurier. Finally, the Diversity and Equity Office participated in the ISWEP program, hiring an International Student to work with the office for the 2014-2015 academic year and submitted an application to the Faculty of Social Work to encourage Masters of Social Work Students to conduct their placement in the Diversity and Equity Office. Interested students will begin their placements in the Winter semester. Change Project Recommendations & Gendered Violence Task Force Funded by the Status of Women Canada, the Change Project was a 3-year collaborative research project between the Sexual Assault Support Centre of Waterloo Region (SASCRW), the Social 13 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Innovation Research Group (SIRG) at Laurier’s Faculty of Social Work, Laurier’s Diversity and Equity Office with its Centre for Women and Trans People, and the University of Waterloo with its UW Women's Centre. Specifically, the project was researching ways to end gendered violence on university campuses through transforming the institutional and cultural climate of the universities and community. In following the recommendations of this project, Laurier has created the Gendered Violence Taskforce and various working groups to look at developing practical and sustainable ways to prevent gendered violence at Laurier. The work of the Taskforce will include policy development, compassionate supports for survivors, education and support for faculty, staff and students and increased relationships with community partners. David McMurray, Laurier’s VP of Student Affairs has also been asked to Chair the Council of Ontario Universities Reference Group on Sexual Violence. In this endeavor Ontario universities are sharing best practices and key learnings to create a united approach to ending sexual violence on university campuses across the province. Employment Equity Workforce Analysis (the Data) Overview of requirements and methodology Laurier’s formal commitment to employment equity began when it signed a Certificate of Commitment under the Federal Contractors program (FCP). Through this certificate, Laurier agreed to implement and maintain an employment equity program which included the following: 1. Adopt accountability mechanisms for employment equity and assign a senior official. 2. Communicate to employees regarding employment equity. 3. Consult and collaborate with bargaining agents and/or employee representatives. 4. Collect workforce information. 5. Complete a workforce analysis. 6. Complete an employment systems review. 7. Establish short-term and long-term goals. 8. Adopt measures to remove barriers. 9. Adopt special measures, positive policies and practices and reasonable accommodation measures. 10. Adopt monitoring procedures. 11. Make reasonable efforts and achieve reasonable progress. 12. Review and revise the employment equity plan. The workforce analysis is meant to determine the degree of representation of each of the designated groups (women, Aboriginal persons, visible minorities and persons with disabilities) within Laurier’s workforce as compared to the external labour market. Data for the external labour pool is taken from the most recent Canadian Census (2006) and from Statistics Canada’s Participation and Activity Limitation Survey. To provide greater comparison, the data is broken 14 Employment Equity Report - 2014 down using 14 Employment Equity Occupational Groups (EEOG) which was established by Human Resources and Skills Development Canada (HRSDC). Throughout the workforce analysis, in order to protect confidentiality, data for values less than 3 have been suppressed. EEOG 01 Upper Level Managers and EEOG 03 Professional Teaching are compared to national data, whereas all other EEOGs are compared to local Kitchener-Waterloo and Brantford Census data, unless otherwise labeled. As required by the FCP, employment equity data is collected directly from the employee. Data on gender is collected using employment data, all other data is generated from the selfidentification survey. Self-Identification Return and Response Rate Due to increased efforts during employee on-boarding, survey return rates continue to remain high with 85.2% of surveys returned. Less than 1% of those who returned the survey chose not to participate. It is important to note that the FCP requires that all internal representation rates of designated groups are calculated assuming that all non-respondents do not belong to any of the designated groups. Therefore, the actual representation at Laurier may be much higher than is represented in the workforce analysis. As such, efforts continue to encourage employees to participate in the self-identification survey. Understanding the Numbers Because of data collected through the self-identification survey, Laurier is able to determine the internal representation rate of designated group members. This internal representation rate is then compared to the expected external representation rate. The external rate is provided by Statistics Canada through regional and national census data. In conducting this comparison between internal and external representation, the representation gap is determined. As indicated by the FCP, occupational groups with a gap number of -3 or greater have been identified as having an under-representation. It is important to recognize that both Laurier’s internal data and Statistics Canada data are based on self-identification processes. There are many inherent flaws with self-identification; especially when the person providing the data does not trust the process. Because people from the designate groups have often faced discrimination and stigmatization because of their association with the designate group; there is an increased risk that the data is not telling the full story. It is more important to look at overall trends, equity initiatives and assessments of these initiatives than assuming that because we do not demonstrate a gap in representation that we are 15 Employment Equity Report - 2014 in fact reflecting the actual labour market. Therefore, the reader must be cautious when making overall assumptions about inclusion at Laurier based on the numbers alone. Also, because of the way in which the Federal Contractors Program is designed, intersectionality is not considered when assessing the 4 designate groups (i.e., when a person self-identifies with more than one designate group). The Diversity and Equity Office recognizes the importance of intersectionality and the personal experiences. Preliminary discussions have begun to re-evaluate the data so it reflects some common examples of intersectionality (for example, by examining how many of our faculty members are visible minority women and exploring how these experiences differ from those who self-identify only as “women” or “visible minorities”). A closer look at data like this will also allow for better student support, especially when attempting to connect students and faculty members seeking mentorship opportunities from others in similar designate groups, a task that has traditionally been difficult to do. Looking at the Trends: Faculty At first glance, Laurier’s faculty has consistently demonstrated strong representation from the designate groups; however the data does not demonstrate the full picture. Nevertheless, the following represents trends in employment at Laurier as compared to the national external labour pool. The straight red line identifies the Canadian external labour market based on the 2006 Canadian Census (external available pool for persons with disabilities is based on Statistics Canada’s Participation and Activity Limitation Survey). 16 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty who are Women at Laurier Laurier’s internal labour market continues to exceed that of the national labour market. 17 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty who are Visible Minorities at Laurier Because of newly hired faculty and because of an increase in the participation rate in the selfidentification survey amongst faculty, Laurier’s internal labour market is becoming more reflective of the external market. However it is important to keep in mind that the external labour market data is from 2006 and likely no longer represents the actual external labour market. Also there are issues with both sets of data because of mistrust in the self-identification process. 18 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty who are Aboriginal People at Laurier Overall, Laurier has consistently showcased similar internal representation as the available pool. However it is important to keep in mind that the external labour market data is from 2006 and likely no longer represents the actual external labour market. Also there are issues with both sets of data because of mistrust in the self-identification process. 19 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty with Disabilities at Laurier Due to increased awareness, decreased stigmatisation, and an aging workforce population both the internal and external labour pool of persons with disabilities is expected to increase. 20 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Faculty who identify as Sexual Minorities at Laurier Although Statistics Canada does not collect information on persons who identify as sexual minorities (because this group is not a designate group), Laurier has tracked data on sexual minorities since 2005. Reported representation of sexual minorities at Laurier is higher amongst faculty than staff. Looking at the Trends: Non-Academic Laurier’s non-academic employees have consistently demonstrated strong representation in the categories of women, Aboriginal Peoples and persons with disabilities; however, it has also consistently demonstrated a gap in its representation of members from visible minority groups. The following represents the employment Trends at Laurier as compared to the national external labour pool. The straight red line identifies the external available pool for each designate group based on the local Kitchener-Waterloo and Brantford areas based on the 2006 Canadian Census (external available pool for persons with disabilities is based on Statistics Canada’s Participation and Activity Limitation Survey). 21 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Staff who are Women at Laurier Laurier has consistently demonstrated a similar representation of women when compared to the external market. Women make up a larger portion of the non-academic workforce when compared to the academic workforce. Specifically, there is a very high concentration of women working in professional non-teaching positions and clerical roles at Laurier. 22 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Senior Administrators and Middle Managers & Other Managers (NOC 1 & 2) who identified as Women at Laurier Recognizing that combining all staff positions into one chart limits the ability to see what is going on at the management level; this new comparison has been added. It is important to note that because of restrictions in previous year data, NOC 1 and 2 were used to represent Senior Administration and Management; however there are some management positions also located in NOC 3 that could not be included. Also, although it would be ideal to have similar charts for all of the designate groups, because the numbers in the other categories are so small (usually under 3) the data has been compressed in previous years reports and is no longer possible to calculate. Over the last 8 years, the number of women moving or being hired into management positions at Laurier has grown fairly significantly. Because the external available pool is from 2006; it is difficult to compare with the external pool. 23 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Staff who are Members of a Visible Minority at Laurier Laurier continues to demonstrate a large gap in representation of members from visual minority groups. This gap is particularly wide amoungst the non-academic workforce, specifically in the area of professional non-teaching and service and sales employees. Furthermore, because the external labour market data is from 2006, it likely no longer represents the actual external labour market. Also there are issues with both sets of data because of mistrust in the self-identification process. With more current and accurate external data, the gap would be even wider. This is an area of priority for Laurier moving forward. After 5 years of including equity language in postings and working with hiring managers, the representation of people identifying as visible minorites has had minor changes. More agresive and creative ways of supporting current staff and hiring new staff from this designate group need to be explored. 24 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Staff who are Aboriginal Peoples at Laurier Although, the overall percentage of Laurier’s internal non-academic workforce who are Aboriginal is small; this number continues to be higher than the external available labour pool. With the creation of the Office of Aboriginal Initiatives and the Aboriginal Student Centres, Laurier continues to expand its connections with local and national Aboriginal Peoples. 25 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Staff with Disabilities at Laurier Laurier’s non-academic workforce closely reflects the external pool of persons with disabilities, however, Laurier continues to have under-representation within the middle management and service and sales employee categories. To assist in addressing current barriers, Laurier is reexamining its Employee Accommodation Policy and protocols involving requesting and updating workplace accommodations. The overall increase in 2010 was due to the increased selfidentification survey responses. 26 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Staff who identify as Sexual Minorities at Laurier Although Statistics Canada does not collect information on persons who identify as sexual minorities (because this group is not a designate group), Laurier has tracked data on sexual minorities since 2005. The representation of sexual minorities at Laurier is higher amongst faculty than the non-academic workforce. Although, there may be a real difference between representation rates, this difference may also be due to a variety of reasons including employee discomfort in identifying as a sexual minority on the self-identification survey. Additional Data and Gap Analysis per EEOG The following two charts provide a breakdown of Laurier’s internal workforce broken down per the Human Resource and Skills Development Canada’s 14 Employee by Occupational Group Codes (EEOG). The AP % for “upper level managers” and “professional teaching” are reflective of the Canadian labour market, where as all other categories are representative of the KitchenerWaterloo and Brantford areas. Note, values of three or less have been suppressed to maintain confidentiality and are represented by **. 27 Employment Equity Report - 2014 2014 Employees by Occupational Group (EEOG) Women Visible Minority Persons with Disabilities Aboriginal Peoples Sexual/Gender Minority **AP # % % OCCUPATIONAL GROUPS Total Emp. # % AP% # % AP% # % AP% # % AP% Upper Level Managers - 01 14 9 64.3 24.3 ** ** 7.5 0 0.0 2.5 ** ** 3.2 ** ** Middle Managers - 02 178 114 64.0 39.2 9 5.1 12.1 0 0.0 2.0 ** ** 3.2 ** ** Professional Non Teaching - 03 195 126 64.6 53.7 18 9.2 20.3 ** ** 1.1 9 4.6 5.0 5 2.6 Professional Teaching - 03 579 258 44.6 54.8 85 14.7 14.2 7 1.2 1.9 26 4.5 4.5 31 5.4 Professional Total - 03 774 384 49.6 53.7 103 13.3 20.3 ** ** 1.1 35 4.5 5.0 36 4.7 Semi-Prof Skill B - 04 114 60 52.6 52.6 13 11.4 10.1 0 0.0 0.8 ** ** 5.1* ** ** Supervisors CS&S - 05 32 20 62.5 64.2 ** ** 7.9 ** ** 0.7 ** ** 12.1* ** ** Supervisors Trade & Prim - 06 1 0 0.0 16.2 0 0.0 4.7 0 0.0 0.6 0 0.0 NA 0 0.0 Admin & Sr. Clerical - 07 179 158 88.3 82.7 11 6.1 6.5 4 2.2 0.9 11 6.1 NA ** ** Sales & Services B - 08 6 4 66.7 44.7 0 0.0 9.6 0 0.0 0.7 ** ** 6.8* 0 0.0 Skilled Crafts & Trades - 09 21 ** ** 5.3 ** ** 8.5 0 0.0 1.3 ** ** 5.4* 0 0.0 Clerical - 10 180 158 87.8 73.2 9 5.0 9.2 3 1.7 0.9 6 3.3 4.5* 9 5.0 Sales & Service C - 11 5 4 80.0 68.6 0 0.0 9.2 0 0.0 1.1 0 0.0 6.0* 0 0.0 Semi-Skilled C - 12 3 0 0.0 26.2 0 0.0 13.4 0 0.0 1.6 0 0.0 6.1* 0 0.0 Sales & Service D - 13 211 124 58.8 58.4 8 3.8 11.3 4 1.9 1.5 10 4.7 7.0* ** ** Manual D - 14 9 ** ** 33.3 ** ** 11.3 0 0.0 1.5 0 0.0 3.9* 0 0.0 1727 1038 158 22 70 57 60.1 9.1 1.3 4.1 3.3 University CCT University CCT % 28 Employment Equity Report - 2014 2014 Workforce – Gap Analysis Women OCCUPATIONAL GROUPS WLU CCT Aboriginal Peoples AP Gap WLU AP Persons with Disabilities Gap WLU AP Visible Minorities Gap WLU AP Gap # % #* % #* # % #* % #* # % #* % #* # % #* % #* 14 9 64.3 4 24.3 5 0 0.0 0 2.5 0 ** ** 0 3.2 ** ** ** 1 7.5 ** 2 Middle & Other Managers 178 114 64.0 74 39.2 40 0 0.0 4 2.0 -4 ** ** 6 3.2 ** 9 5.1 23 12.1 -14 3 Professional Non-Teaching 195 126 64.6 104 53.7 22 ** ** 2 1.1 ** 9 4.6 10 5.0 -1 18 9.2 39 20.3 -21 3 579 258 44.6 325 54.8 -67 7 1.2 11 1.9 -4 26 4.5 27 4.5 -1 85 14.7 84 14.2 1 4 Semi-Professionals & Tech. 114 60 52.6 64 52.6 -4 0 0.0 1 0.8 -1 ** ** 6 5.1* ** 13 11.4 12 10.0 1 5 32 20 62.5 24 64.2 -4 ** ** 0 0.7 ** ** ** 4 12.1* ** ** ** 3 7.9 0 1 0 0.0 0 16.2 0 0 0.0 0 0.6 0 0 0.0 NA NA NA 0 0.0 0 4.7 0 1 Senior Managers Professional Teaching Supervisors 6 Supervisors: Crafts& Trades 7 Admin. & Senior Clerical 179 158 88.3 154 82.7 4 4 2.2 2 0.9 2 11 6.1 NA NA NA 11 6.1 12 6.5 -1 8 Skilled Sales & Service 6 4 66.7 4 44.7 0 0 0.0 0 0.7 0 ** ** 1 6.8* ** 0 0.0 1 9.6 -1 9 Skilled Crafts & Trades 21 ** ** 1 5.3 ** 0 0.0 0 1.3 0 ** ** 1 5.4* ** ** ** 2 8.5 ** 10 Clerical Personnel 180 158 87.8 152 73.2 6 ** ** 2 0.9 1 6 3.3 9 4.5* -3 9 5.0 19 9.2 -10 11 Intermediate Sales & Service 5 4 80.0 4 68.6 0 0 0.0 0 1.1 0 0 0.0 0 6.0* 0 0 0.0 1 9.2 -1 12 Semi-Skilled Manual Workers 3 0 0.0 1 26.2 -1 0 0.0 0 1.6 0 0 0.0 0 6.1* 0 0 0.0 0 13.4 0 13 Other Sales & Service 211 124 58.8 147 58.4 -23 4 1.9 4 1.5 0 10 4.7 18 7.0* -8 8 3.8 28 11.3 -20 14 Other Manual Workers 9 ** ** 3 33.3 0 0 0.0 0 1.5 0 0 0.0 0 3.9* 0 ** ** 1 11.3 0 Grand Total 1727 1038 1059 -20 22 25 -3 70 83 -13 158 226 -78 29 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Final Words Due to the loss of the long form census, this report is based on data on external availabilities of designate groups from 2006. Also important to note is that quantitative data alone cannot measure whether employees, regardless of their personal identity, feel welcomed, included, and accepted; it cannot measure the barriers they may face in reaching their place of employment, nor can it accurately indicate whether persons of different backgrounds are thriving in their roles. This means that in some way our analysis of the numerical data can only accomplish so much. For this reason we have included more qualitative data in reports over the last few years and, going forward, we aim to continue to supplement the numerical data by developing and implementing more defined qualitative measures. With this we hope the report will continue to grow and to accurately reflect the culture of diversity and inclusion at Laurier. The upcoming year will be one that focuses on employment equity; from the review of various policies, the re-establishment of equity committees, reinvigoration of the equity plan and continued commitment to creating an inclusive environment at Laurier. Given the current and expected future economic climate in the University sector, employment equity initiatives need to shift from concentrating on recruitment efforts to concentrating on retention efforts. This includes ensuring that employees fully understand all of the resources available to them and where to go if they are experiencing a barrier to inclusion. Laurier needs to get creative working within a climate of financial constraints where diversity and inclusion remains a main priority of the institution. 30 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Appendix A – Employment Equity Self-Disclosure Questionnaire COUNT YOURSELF IN EMPLOYMENT EQUITY SURVEY All information collected is completely confidential. Employment equity is designed to ensure equality for all employees in areas of recruitment, hiring, training, promotion and retention. It is designed to remove systemic discrimination that has traditionally disadvantaged particular groups of workers. The Diversity and Equity Office at Wilfrid Laurier University strives for: • A work force that reflects the diversity of the available labour force. • Employment systems that support the workforce as a whole, ensuring all present and future employees have a fair and equitable opportunity to develop their abilities, realize their expectations and make the best contribution possible to the workplace. In addition to its responsibilities as an employment equity employer, the university intends to create and maintain an inclusive environment for all employees, including women, persons in a visible minority, persons with disabilities, Aboriginal persons and persons in a sexual and/or gender minority. Revisions to the Employment Equity Policy (8.4) approved by the Board of Governors on October 21, 2004 states that the university must collect and continually update employee data by a process of self-identification in order to identify the proportion of women, persons in a visible minority, persons with disabilities, Aboriginal persons and persons in a sexual and/or gender minority in all employee categories. Wilfrid Laurier University’s workforce information is collected through the enclosed selfidentification survey for the purpose of determining the levels of representation of each of the five designated groups and to compare these levels with the relevant external workforce (where known) using data provided by Human Resources and Skills Development Canada. 31 Employment Equity Report - 2014 This survey is given to all staff and full-time faculty members. Each person must return the survey, even though participation is voluntary and the individual may choose not to respond to the questions on the survey. Each respondent can belong to more than one of the designated groups. EMPLOYMENT EQUITY SURVEY Principles of Confidentiality The data collected in the employment equity survey is strongly protected by the following principles of confidentiality: • Surveys will be given to each staff and full-time faculty member. Confidentiality begins with each staff and faculty member placing the completed census form in the return envelope and sealing it. • The Employment Equity & AODA Officer in the Diversity and Equity Office will receive the survey and enter the information into a confidential database and produce the necessary statistical reports with suppressed data so that no one individual can be identified. • Only the Employment Equity & AODA Officer will have access to individual employee surveys. • Returned surveys are destroyed once entered into the confidential database. The timeframe for retaining completed surveys in the database will be determined after an audit by the Federal Contractors Program. • All workforce information is used to comply with the Federal Contractors Program, which includes development of employment equity programs and preparing an annual employment equity report. This report is made available at: o Diversity and Equity Office and online at www.wlu.ca/equity • The questions are in compliance with Schedule IV of the Employment Equity Regulations per the Employment Equity Act (federal statute). • No one will be given information on others. • Managers, administrators or anyone else may not determine the employee’s status without his or her knowledge and voluntary consent. • Information reported may be altered or removed from the survey only on the request of the employee who provided it. Should you require any assistance, please call Dana Lavoie, Employment Equity & AODA Officer with the Diversity and Equity Office at dlavoie@wlu.ca or at extension 4469. THANK YOU FOR COMPLETING THE SURVEY 32 Employment Equity Report - 2014 I.D. Number: Click here to enter text. EMPLOYMENT EQUITY SURVEY Please read each question and check (√) the response(s) which best applies to you. ☐I do not wish to participate in this survey 1. Do you identify yourself as (choose all that apply): ☐Male ☐Female ☐Trans* ☐I do not identify with a gender 2. For the purposes of employment equity, a person is an Aboriginal person if they are a member of the Indian (status or non status), Inuit or Metis people of North America. Based on this definition, do you consider yourself to be an Aboriginal person? ☐Yes ☐No 3(a) For the purposes of employment equity, “members of visible minorities” means persons, other than Aboriginal peoples, who are non-Caucasian in race or non-white in colour. (Members of ethnic or national groups such as Portuguese, Italian, Greek, etc., are not considered to be racially visible. If you require guidance, please consult the guide sheet found at the end of the Survey.) Based on this definition, do you consider yourself to be a member of a racial minority? ☐Yes ☐No 3(b) √ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ 4(a) If you have indicated YES in 3(a), please check (√) the visible minority group(s) that best describes your racial origin. Racial Origin: Examples: Black African, Canadian, American, South American East Asian Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Polynesian South Asian Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lankan, Bangladeshi South East Asian Burmese, Cambodian, Filipino, Laotian, Malaysian, Thai, Vietnamese West Asian Arabian, Armenian, Iranian, Israeli, Lebanese, Palestinian, Syrian, Turkish Other: For the purposes of employment equity, “persons with disabilities” means persons who have a long-term or recurring physical, mental, psychiatric, sensory or learning impairment (see 6(b) for examples) and who I. consider themselves to be disadvantaged in employment by reason of that impairment, or II. believe that an employer or potential employer is likely to consider them to be disadvantaged in employment by reason of that impairment, 33 Employment Equity Report - 2014 and includes persons whose functional limitations owing to their impairment have been accommodated in their current job or workplace. Based on this definition, do you consider yourself to be a person with a disability? ☐Yes ☐No 4(b) √ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ 5. 6. If you have indicated YES in 4(a), please place a check (√) beside the impairment(s) that best describes your disability. This will assist the equity office in addressing the unique needs of different disabilities. Any persistent degree of: Examples: Coordination/dexterity impairment Cerebral palsy Mobility/functional limitation Paraplegia Chronic illness/systemic/medical condition Hemophilia, cancer, AIDS, arthritis, diabetes Hearing Impairment Hard of hearing, deafness Vision Impairment Glaucoma, blind Inability to generate or emit verbal messages, such as Speech Impairment aphasia Developmental Disability Down’s syndrome A previous mental illness or one which is under control, Mental health issue such as schizophrenia, depression, OCD Learning disability Dyslexia, dysnomia, dysgraphia Other: For the purposes of employment equity, “persons of a minority sexual orientation” means persons who are gay, lesbian, bi-sexual, two-spirited, queer, trans* etc. Based on this definition, do you consider yourself to be a person of a minority sexual orientation? ☐Yes ☐No From time to time, the Diversity and Equity Office receives specific requests for participation of designated group members in various university initiatives, programs/services and committee work. Do you consent to having the Diversity and Equity Office contact you regarding your possible interest in participating? ☐Yes ☐No Thank you. Please return the survey to the Diversity and Equity Office using the envelope provided. 34 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Appendix B – Overall Percentage Charts Overall Percentage of Women Employed at Laurier Overall Percentage of Visible Minorities Employed at Laurier 35 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Overall Percentage of Aboriginal Persons Employed at Laurier Overall Percentage of Persons with Disabilities Employed at Laurier 36 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Overall Percentage of Sexual Minorities Employed at Laurier 37 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Appendix C - Employment Equity Occupational Groups Definitions 1. Senior Managers Employees holding the most senior positions in large firms or corporations. They are responsible for the corporation's policy and strategic planning, and for directing and controlling the functions of the organisation. Examples: President, chief executive officer, vice-presidents, chief operating officer, senior government officials, general managers and divisional heads, and directors who have several middle managers reporting to them or are responsible for the direction of a critical technical function. 2. Middle and Other Managers Middle and other managers receive instructions from senior managers and administer the organisation's policy and operations through subordinate managers or supervisors. Senior managers, middle and other managers comprise all managers. Examples: Managers of transport operations, communications, finances, human resources, sales, advertising, purchasing, production, marketing, research and development, information systems, maintenance; commissioned police officers, commissioned officers in the armed forces. 3. Professionals Professionals usually need either university graduation or prolonged formal training and often have to be members of a professional organization. Examples: Engineers (civil, mechanical, electrical, petroleum, nuclear, aerospace), chemists, biologists, architects, economists, lawyers, teachers, doctors, accountants, computer programmers, registered nurses, physiotherapists, ministers of religion. 4. Semi-Professionals and Technicians Workers in these occupations have to possess knowledge equivalent to about two years of postsecondary education, offered in many technical institutions and community colleges, and often have further specialized on-the-job training. They may have highly developed technical and/or artistic skills. Examples: Technologists and technicians (broadcast, forestry, biological, electronic, meteorological, geological, surveying, drafting and design, engineering, library, medical, dental), specialized inspectors and testers (public and environmental health, occupational health and safety, engineering, industrial instruments), dental hygienists, midwives, ambulance attendants, paralegal workers, graphic designers and illustrating artists, announcers and other broadcasters, coaches. 38 Employment Equity Report - 2014 5. Supervisors Non-management first-line coordinators of white-collar (administrative, clerical, sales, and service) workers. Supervisors may, but do not usually, perform any of the duties of the employees under their supervision. Examples: Supervisors of administrative and clerical workers such as general office clerks, secretaries, word processing operators, receptionists, and switchboard operators, computer operators, accounting clerks, letter carriers, tellers; supervisors of sales workers such as airline sales agents, service station attendants, grocery clerks and shelf stockers, cashiers; and supervisors of service workers such as food and beverage workers, canteen workers, hotel housekeeping, and cleaning workers, dry cleaning and laundry workers, janitors, grounds people, tour guides, parking lot attendants. 6. Supervisors: Crafts and Trades Non-management first-line coordinators of workers in manufacturing, processing, trades, and primary industry occupations. They supervise skilled crafts and trades workers, semi-skilled manual workers and/or other manual workers. Supervisors may, but do not usually, perform any of the duties of the employees under their supervision. Examples: Supervisors of workers in manufacturing (motor vehicle assembling, electronics, electrical, furniture, fabric, etc.), processing (mineral and metal, chemical, food & beverage, plastic and rubber, textiles, etc.), trades (carpentry, mechanical, heavy construction equipment, printing, etc.), and primary industry (forestry, logging, mining and quarrying, oil and gas, agriculture and farms, etc.). 7. Administrative and Senior Clerical Personnel Workers in these occupations carry out and coordinate administrative procedures and administrative services primarily in an office environment, or perform clerical work of a senior nature. Examples: Administrative officers; executive assistants; personnel and recruitment officers; loan officers; insurance adjusters; secretaries; legal secretaries; medical secretaries; court recorders; property administrators. 8. Skilled Sales and Service Personnel Highly skilled workers engaged wholly or primarily in selling or in providing personal service. These workers have a thorough and comprehensive knowledge of the processes involved in their work and usually have received an extensive period of training involving some post-secondary education, part or all of an apprenticeship, or the equivalent on-the-job training and work experience. Examples: Sales: insurance agents and brokers, real estate agents, retail and wholesale buyers, technical sales specialists. Service: police officers, firefighters, chefs, cooks, butchers, bakers, funeral directors and embalmers. 39 Employment Equity Report - 2014 9. Skilled Crafts and Trades Workers Manual workers of a high skill level, having a thorough and comprehensive knowledge of the processes involved in their work. They are frequently journeymen and journeywomen who have received an extensive period of training. Examples: Sheet metal workers, plumbers, electricians, tool and die makers, carpenters, glaziers, welders, telecommunications line and cable, installation and repair technicians; mechanics (heavy duty, refrigeration, aircraft, elevator, motor vehicle), tailors, jewellers, oil and gas well drillers, fishing masters and officers, paper making control operators. 10. Clerical Personnel Workers performing clerical work, other than senior clerical work. Examples: General office and other clerks (data entry, records and file, accounting, payroll, administrative, personnel, library, purchasing, storekeepers and parts, mail and postal, insurance clerks, customer service, statistics, purchasing and inventory clerks); typists and word processing operators; receptionists and switchboard operators; computer operators; typesetters; dispatchers and radio operators; couriers and messengers; letter carriers; tellers. 11. Intermediate Sales and Service Personnel Workers engaged wholly or primarily in selling or in providing personal service who perform duties that may require from a few months up to two years of on-the-job training, training courses, or specific work experience. Generally, these are workers whose skill level is less than that of skilled sales and service, but greater than that of elementary sales and service workers. Examples: Sales: airline sales agents, non-technical wholesale sales representatives, retail salespersons. Service: dental assistants, nurses aides and orderlies, tour and travel guides, hotel front desk clerks, correctional service officers, sheriffs and bailiffs, bartenders, nannies, aestheticians, pet groomers. 12. Semi-Skilled Manual Workers Manual workers who perform duties that usually require a few months of specific vocational onthe-job training. Generally, these are workers whose skill level is less than that of skilled crafts and trades workers, but greater than that of elementary manual workers. Examples: Truck drivers, railway yard workers, longshore workers, material handlers, foundry workers, machine operators (plastics processing, chemical plant, sawmill, textile, pulp mill, tobacco, welding), workers assembling, inspecting or testing products (motor vehicles, boats, electrical motors, furniture). 13. Other Sales and Service Personnel Workers in sales and service jobs which generally require only a few days or no on-the-job training. The duties are elementary, and require little or no independent judgement. 40 Employment Equity Report - 2014 Examples: Sales: service station attendants, grocery clerks and shelf stockers, cashiers. Service: security guards, janitors, kitchen and food service helpers, dry cleaning and laundry occupations, attendants in recreation and sport. 14. Other Manual Workers Workers in blue collar jobs which generally require only a few days or no on-the-job training or a short demonstration. The duties are manual, elementary, and require little or no independent judgement. Examples: Helpers and labourers in construction and other trades (plumber assistants, carpenter helpers, refrigeration mechanic helpers, surveyor helpers), garbage collectors, road maintenance workers, railway labourers, tobacco or fruit pickers, landscape labourers, fish farm helpers, roustabouts, labourers in processing industry. 41