Annual Refresher for Whole School Staff: Safeguarding Children Duration: 1 hour Audience: All school staff – paid or voluntary. Anybody within the school community who may come into contact with children and young people. Aim: To build on the three year Safeguarding Children training and refresh knowledge of the staff role in safeguarding and promoting children’s welfare. Intended Outcomes: To be familiar with the school’s Child Protection Policy To understand their safeguarding responsibilities To be aware of the indicators of abuse Structure of the session 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Introduction (2 minutes) Quiz (5 minutes) Revisiting School’s Child Protection Policy (10 minutes) Revisiting indicators of abuse (15 minutes) Reflective practice: Case Studies (25 minutes) Reflective questions for staff (3 minutes) Appendix A: Quiz & answers Appendix B: Primary Case Studies Appendix C: Secondary Case Study Appendix D: What next? Further ideas for activities relating to practice issues. 1 1. Introduction Why am I here? Explain that everyone in the education service shares an objective to help keep children and young people safe by contributing to: providing a safe environment identifying children and young people who are suffering or likely to suffer significant harm and taking appropriate action (Safeguarding Children and Safer Recruitment in Education, DfES 2006). Explain the aims, objectives and intended outcomes of today’s session. 2. Quiz What do I know? Use the quiz in Appendix A as an opportunity for staff to reflect on previous Safeguarding Children training, draw on their own knowledge and experiences, whilst exploring issues of equality and diversity, prejudice and cultural considerations. The prevalence of myths such as these can reduce our vigilance and delay our response to children who may be at risk. For example, indicators of abuse in disabled children are often missed or misinterpreted because a presumption is made that abusers do not target disabled children. 3. Revisiting the School’s Child Protection Policy Why do I need to be familiar with it? Under the 2002 Education Act, local authorities and school governing bodies have a statutory duty to safeguard children and are legally accountable for the safeguarding arrangements they make. Safeguarding Children and Safer Recruitment in Education (DfES 2006) stipulates that every school must have a Child Protection Policy, that is reviewed annually and staff need to have accessed it. Additionally, any member of school staff could be interviewed during an Ofsted inspection and must be able to demonstrate that they are familiar with basic safeguarding arrangements in school. A key finding from local and national serious case reviews is that policies and procedures are not followed. Either established policies or procedures are not known about or are not followed by front line staff. It is therefore essential that staff are aware of internal, local and national safeguarding policies and procedures and that these are embedded in school practice. 2 Things to consider: 1. Have staff seen, read and understood the current Child Protection policy? Do they know where they can access this? 2. Are they aware of other related safeguarding policies? Do they know where they can access these? 3. Are they aware of relevant legislation, local and national guidance? 4. Do they know who the DSP and deputy DSP are in the school? 5. Are they clear about their responsibilities in the following areas?: -recognising *** -responding: including dealing with a disclosure, reporting and recording 6. Are they familiar with the indicators of abuse? *** 7. Do they know who they can seek support from? 8. Are they clear about issues of confidentiality? 9. Would they know what to do in the event of an allegation/if they were concerned about a colleagues conduct? Do they know who the Chair/Vice Chair of Governors is? 4. Revisiting indicators of abuse *** Why do I need to know? In order to fulfil your professional role, recognition and response is key. One of the main findings of local and national serious case reviews is that staff do not have knowledge, understanding and awareness of the indicators of abuse and often do not realise that what they are seeing is significant (Learning lessons, taking action: Ofsted’s evaluations of serious case reviews 1 April 2007 to 31 March 2008 ). Following on from the re-cap of the school’s Child Protection Policy, use this session as an opportunity for staff to reflect and refresh their knowledge of the various indicators of child abuse. Suggestion for an activity Get each staff member to list: a.) b.) c.) d.) 3 One sign of possible physical abuse (apart from visible injuries) One sign of possible emotional abuse One sign of possible neglect One sign of possible sexual abuse Staff to feedback (possibly record on flipchart paper?), compare their suggestions to the list of indicators in the Child Protection Policy. Remind staff that they can also find a full list of indicators in the Safeguarding Children School Staff Information Pack they received at their last 3 year refresher Safeguarding Children training session. 5. Reflective Practice: Case Studies For this section of the session, focus on the learning needs of staff at your school. Have there been any practice issues in the last academic year? Use these to structure thinking within a case study. Examples of case studies can be found in Appendices B and C. Where appropriate, please adapt these to suit your setting or use a real-life case. Examples of practice issues may include: Recognising – Knowledge of the indicators of abuse, including issues of equality and diversity, prejudice or cultural considerations? Responding: Reporting – Is my concern significant? When should I report a concern? Failure to report? Reporting in a timely manner? Clarifying information - Talking to children? Dealing with a disclosure? Issues of confidentiality? Recording Safer Working Practice You may want to choose one case study to initiate a whole group discussion or split staff into small groups to look at each different case study and then feedback. 6. Reflective questions for staff Am I clear enough about my role in school and that of other key people? Am I clear about the relevant policies and procedures in school? Am I clear about what I should do if I am concerned about a child’s welfare? Am I clear about the appropriate sources of advice and support available to me? Is there anything I need to speak to the DSP about? 4 Appendix A Quiz Myth 1) Strangers present the greatest risk to children 2) If children are really being harmed they will find someone to tell 3) Abusers can be from any class, culture and background 4) Women do not abuse children 5) Some sexual abuse is committed by children 6) Disabled children are rarely on their own and so they are less likely to become victims of abuse 5 Reality Not sure Answers: 1. Myth. The majority of child abuse is committed by someone else to the child…a family member, friend, neighbour, sports coach, childminder etc. 2. Partly true. About 50% of children do not disclose abuse at the time it is happening. Many people keep their abuse secret for most of their life. 3. True. While cases of practical neglect occur more frequently in low-income families, other types of abuse are found in all sections of society. 4. Myth. While males commit most sexual abuse, females are equally responsible for other types of abuse and neglect. 5. This is true. 25% of all cases of sexual abuse involved a perpetrator who is under the age of 18 6. Myth. Disabled children are at least three times more likely to be abused and neglected. 6 Appendix B Primary Case Studies Case study 1: Rama Rama is three years old. He lives with his mum and dad and three siblings, very close to the school. He is bright and cheerful little boy who has a slight speech impairment. He will sometimes become frustrated when people do not understand him. Like most children, Rama occasionally has bruises on his arms and legs. He is very active and particularly enjoys playing in his garden at home, and riding the bikes at high speed on the playground. Today at 2pm, you find Rama silently weeping in the corridor. At first he would not say why he was upset, but after some gentle coaxing, he tells you he is frightened to go home because he ‘has made daddy angry and will be punished’. What will you say to Rama? What are your safeguarding responsibilities? What action will you take? Case study 2: Kia Kia is a popular pupil in Year 6 and is hardworking and sensible with an infectious giggle. She lives with mum and step dad and her little sister Jody, just around the corner from the school. Her parents have been helping out with the ‘build a pond for the playground’ project and you have got to know them quite well. You have been spending some time with Kia for the past term because she needs extra help to get through her SATS. Over the last few days, Kia had been day-dreaming. She has lost her sparkle and seems preoccupied. It is nothing dramatic but, because you know her well, you can sense that something is just not right. Kia and your daughter both go to the swimming club on Fridays but Kia was not there last week or the week before. Would you do or say anything at this stage? On Thursday, you are working with Kia as usual. She is trying hard to concentrate, but she looks tense so you decide to ease off the pressure and suggest you both take a five minute break to stretch your legs. Would you do or say anything at this stage? Kia suddenly asks if she can talk to you. Without a pause she tells you that her stepdad is doing ‘horrible things’ to her. She looks really frightened and wants you to swear not to tell anyone What would you say and do at this point? 7 Case study 3: Dean Part A is what you know about Dean. Part B is what Dean would want to tell you if he could. Staff should consider part A first, then be given part B and consider whether Dean’s comments would have altered how they managed the case, if they had known Dean’s views at the outset. Part A Dean is 10. He was born in Liverpool and moved to Hertfordshire four years ago, following the break up of his parent’s marriage. He now lives with his mum, Rachel. His father Alex has remained in Liverpool and lost all contact with his son. Dean’s teacher at his special school in Liverpool had been concerned that Dean was witnessing domestic violence between his parents and then acting out the scenario in school. On several occasions he had attempted to hit or slap girls in the class, and called them ‘pig’ or ‘lazy cow’. Dean has never found life easy. He is anxious and restless boy and his behaviour can be very challenging at times. On entry to school he was thought to have learning disabilities, but was later assessed as having ADHD. Since moving to Hertfordshire he had been assessed yet again and is believed to be on the autistic continuum. His use of speech is intermittent and inconsistent and he generally communicates his needs and wishes by pointing and other gestures. He shows very little interest in using symbols, apart from ones relating to food. Dean’s current school (a day special school) has tried very hard to meet his needs, but he was temporarily excluded a month ago after he was seen fondling another boy’s genitals when they were sitting in assembly. The staff had not noticed any sexualised behaviour prior to this incident, but were deeply concerned when the other boy said that it had happened before but he was too frightened to tell anyone. Rachel refuses to believe that her son has behaved in this way and thinks that the school has over-reacted because they want him to be permanently excluded. She has decided to educate him at home. She loves Dean unconditionally and has lost faith in the education system because she feels that everyone views Dean as a ‘problem’ and forgets that he is a little boy. Rachel looks after Dean very well and has never asked for support from anyone. She works part time and has recently let out the spare room to a young man who works with her, to provide her with some money to buy Dean’s Christmas presents. The Police have just received a call from a concerned neighbour who had witnessed Dean ‘touching up younger boys’ at the local playground. What do you think might be happening in Dean’s life? What interventions could have been tried prior to Dean’s exclusion? What do you think about Rachel’s decision to home school Dean? Is Dean at risk of significant harm? When you have discussed these questions, read part B. 8 Part B This is what Dean would say, if anyone asked him and if he had the requisite language and vocabulary: ‘People think I’ve forgotten my dad, but I haven’t. I still miss him loads. I’m trying to be a good boy so he will want t o come back and live with me. My mum and dad used to argue a lot, mostly about me, so if I’m good there won’t be any need for them to argue. I liked school, but I don’t go anymore. I don’t know why. No one has told me. Mitch (mum’s lodger) is my new friend now. I suppose he is my only friend. He doesn’t talk to me (I find talking confusing)/he just strokes me and it feels nice. I’ve started stroking other boys now, because I want to be their friend’. (Case studies taken from The Child Protection & Safeguarding Handbook for SchoolsAnn Raymond, Optimus Education) 9 Appendix C Secondary Case Study Case study 1: Tom Read Part 1 and answer the following questions (add in any other relevant issues): What are you observing? What might this mean? What, if anything, should you do at this stage? Then read Part 2 and see if any of your answers to the above questions would change. Finally, read Part 3 and answer the questions at the end of the case study. Background Tom is 13 years old. He has two sisters, Megan (3) and Katie (15 months). Megan has learning disabilities and communication impairment. The three children live with their mother, Helen, who is a teacher. Helen and her husband separated shortly after Katie’s birth and Helen had to give up work for a while. Tom has only irregular contact with his father and he has said he misses his father a lot. Helen has recently returned to work part time. She teaches one day a week in a local school and on evening a week at an adult education centre. The children have always appeared happy and well cared for. The concluding paragraph of Tom’s last school report reads: ‘Tom is a likeable, studios and caring young man. I am very pleased with his progress and I am sure he will continue to do well.’ Part 1 26th April Tom says he is pleased to be back at school. He did not say too much about what he did over Easter, but he did mention that his Grandma had looked after him and his sisters for a few days when his mum went on holiday with her new boyfriend. Tom says his Grandma is really lovely and he enjoys staying with her. 7th May I have noticed that Tom seems to be having a few problems with his friends. He is usually the one who looks after everyone else and helps them out, but this week I have seen him arguing with a couple of boys and then I heard him tell one to f* off. This is not like Tom at all. I have asked him if everything is ok. He says he is fed up with everyone relying on him all the time but he agreed to apologise to the boy he swore at. 15th May Tom was involved with a fight on the playground today. He and the other boy were given detention, which is the automatic sanction for fighting. 10 19th May Another member of staff has expressed concern about Tom. He feels Tom is preoccupied and his work is not up to the usual standard. Part 2 22nd May I have had a chat with Tom, to try and find out why is arguing with everyone. He says he still misses his father and he does not get on with his mum’s boyfriend. The boyfriend is called John and is a builder. Tom says John is nothing like his dad and he does not know why his mum needs a boyfriend. It seems that John thinks boys should be tough and he playfights with Tom a lot. 3rd June Tom said he stayed with his Grandma for most of half term, and his sisters stayed at home. I said I thought that was nice (thinking he would have been pleased to have been out of John’s way for a few days). Tom then shocked me by saying ‘God, you’re so stupid. You’re all just f*ing stupid’. He walked out on me, but of course I cannot let him behave like that. I have agreed with the Head Teacher that I should ring Tom’s mother. 4th June I had a very helpful conversation with Tom’s mother. She has been concerned about Tom’s behaviour at home, but she knows he is finding it difficult to accept John being around so much. We agreed that Tom needs a lot of support at the moment, which we will readily give. I did point out that we could not ignore Tom’s swearing and fighting but said we would do all we could to help. 12th June Tom was involved in another fight today. The teacher on duty in the playground pulled the boys apart and marched them into school. The other boy calmed down quickly and was told to go back to class. The teacher said he held onto Tom’s arm and said he was not going to let him go until he apologised for his behaviour. 13th June Tom’s mother telephoned the head teacher today. It appears that Tom has several bruises on his arms. He told his mother that the teacher had grabbed him and shook him and said something to the effect of ‘I’m the teacher here and you’ll damn well do as you’re told. I don’t care what problems you’ve got, if you swear at me again, you’ll be sorry.’ Part Three 16th June It seems that half the school knows about the allegation Tom has made against the teacher. The teacher des have a bit of a ‘tough-guy’ reputation, but we also know how challenging Tom has been recently. 11 18th June The PSHE lesson today focused on relationships in the family. Later in the day Tom asked to see me. He said that the lesson was wrong because different families had different relationships. I knew, of course, about his mum and John and I was pleased that he had finally been able to approach me to talk about his feelings. Nothing could have prepared me, however, for what he told me. He said that John liked to get Megan on her own so he could ‘touch her up’. Tom cried as he told me how he had tried and failed to protect his little sister. What should you do now? Think about what you would say to Tom. Would you ask him questions? If so, how would you phrase them? Who would you speak to? What would you write down? How do you feel? (Case study taken from (The Child Protection & Safeguarding Handbook for SchoolsAnn Raymond, Optimus Education) 12 Appendix D : What next? Further ideas for activities relating to practice issues Recognition and Response Aim: To consider what influences judgements in relation to safeguarding and promoting welfare. To develop staff confidence in sharing their concerns. To reinforce their role with respect to clarifying information This exercise asks participants to express opinions and may create anxiety about “getting it right”. Reassure them that this is an opportunity to explore views and that everyone may have a different point of view. It is not about looking for right answers, but a chance to think about what influences their judgements and their role with respect to concerns about children in the school. Activity: Cause for concern? Divide participants into groups. Ask them to consider the scenario (given below) and discuss: 1. Is there a possible concern about abuse? 2. What are the issues? 3. How would they respond to the child/young person or parent? What would they say? 4. What information would you need to share and with whom? Emphasise the importance of seeking advice in worries about a child’s welfare rather than acting in isolation. Their role is to share information they have with the DSP. Check that the staff know who to contact and aware of in house procedures, including the process for recording any concerns. Remind staff of the importance that they: Reassure but do not promise confidentiality Do not ask leading questions Primary Examples 1. A three year old arrives late at nursery when he is usually on time. His mother appears distressed and says they overslept. The child becomes unusually tearful when mother leaves and wants only to sit and look out of the window. Later that morning you observe the child in the home corner with two dolls bashing them together and repeating “you dirty cow”. The child sees you watching, stops playing and bursts into tears. 13 2. A six year old has been getting into arguments and fights with other children both in the classroom and in the playground. This is out of character for this child who is unable to talk about the fight and cries when asked to explain. The child has also had an increased number of absences of late and appears to be losing weight and frequently arrives without prescribed glasses. The child is brought and collected from school by father’s new partner who has two secondary age children. Secondary Example A pupil in your class tells you that her 14 year old friend is worried that she might be pregnant. She tells you that he friend’s boyfriend said he would by her an I-pod and he has promised other presents. The pupil is asking you where her friend can get contraception. Safer Working Practice Activity Aim: To consider areas of vulnerability and ways to minimise these in the school setting. In order to create and maintain a safeguarding culture, it is important that children are safe and staff feel supported, rather than vulnerable to allegations. There will be times, because of stresses in life outside as well as the stresses of the job, when staff members will need support. Ask staff to consider whether there are there situations in which they feel children are vulnerable to abuse, by other children or adults, or they, themselves feel vulnerable? If so, how could these be minimised? Would they feel able to self report if they felt concerned about a colleagues practice? What would help them to do so? Use this to develop your code of conduct/ staff handbook as a collaborative activity. 14