Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) 2007 – Assessing the Impact Introduction The Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics 2009 presents for the last time data on the Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) 2003 basis. Future editions of Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics publication will be based on the new SIC 2007 basis only. The SIC 2007 came into effect on 1 January 2008 with all units on the Inter-Departmental Business Register dual coded to SIC 2003 and SIC 2007. Therefore, the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics 2009 tables provide a full time series from 2000 to 2009 on the SIC 2003 basis. However, tables for registered businesses by the new SIC 2007 for 2008 and 2009 are also available on the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics website to help users to get used to the new classification before the full move to SIC 2007 in 2010. Link to 2009 Registered Enterprise Tables (SIC 2007 basis) Background The UK Standard Industrial Classification of Economic Activities (SIC) was first introduced into the United Kingdom in 1948 for use in classifying business establishments and other statistical units by the type of economic activity in which they are engaged. The classification provides a framework for the collection, tabulation, presentation and analysis of data and its use promotes uniformity across business and economic statistics. The introduction of SIC 2007 represents the first major revision of the Standard Industrial Classification system since 1992. These revisions are motivated by the need to adapt the classifications to changes in the world economy. The revised classifications reflect the growing importance of service activities in economies over the last fifteen years, mainly due to the developments in information and communications technologies (ICT). Structure of SIC 2007 The SIC is a hierarchical five digit system. SIC 2007 is divided into 21 sections, each denoted by a single letter from A to U. The letters of the sections can be uniquely defined by the next breakdown, the divisions (denoted by two digits). The divisions are then broken down into groups (3 digits), then into classes (4 digits) and, in several cases, again into subclasses (5 digits). So for example we have: Section C – Manufacturing (comprising divisions 10 to 33) Division 13 – Manufacture of textiles Group 13.9 – Manufacture of other textiles Class 13.93 – Manufacture of carpets and rugs Subclass 13.93/1 – Manufacture of woven or tufted carpets and rugs SIC 2003 has 17 sections and 62 divisions, whereas SIC 2007 has 21 sections and 88 divisions. The detail of the classification has substantially increased (from 514 to 615 classes). For service producing activities, this increase is visible at all levels, including the highest one, while for other activities, such as agriculture, the increase in detail affected mostly the lower level of the classification. One effect of the increase in detail at class level has been a reduced need for detail at the subclass level. The total number of subclasses has decreased from 285 to 191. Comparing SIC 2003 with SIC 2007 At the highest level of SIC some sections can be easily compared with the previous versions of the classification but the introduction of some new concepts at the section level, e.g. the Information and communication, makes easy overall comparison between SIC 2007 and SIC 2003 impossible. To assist with comparison of data Table 1 below shows the broad correspondence between the sections of SIC 2003 and SIC 2007. However, please note that this table presents only the rough one-to-one correspondence between the sections: further additional details are necessary to establish the complete correspondence1. 1 Complete detailed correspondence tables between SIC 2007 and SIC 2003, and vice versa, are available at: http://www.statistics.gov.uk/statbase/Product.asp?vlnk=14012 Table 1 – SIC 2003/SIC 2007 (Section Level) A B C D E SIC(2003) Agriculture, hunting and forestry Fishing Mining and quarrying Manufacturing Electricity, gas and water supply A B C D E F G H I Construction Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles, motorcycles and personal and household goods Hotels and restaurants Transport, storage and communications J K Financial intermediation Real estate, renting and business activities L Public administration and defence; compulsory social security Education Health and social work Other community, social and personal services activities Activities of private households as employers and undifferentiated production activities of private households M N O P Q Extraterritorial organisations and bodies F G I H J K L M N O P Q R S T U SIC(2007) Agriculture, forestry and fishing Mining and quarrying Manufacturing Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning supply Water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation activities Construction Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles and motor cycles Accommodation and food service activities Transport and storage Information and communication Financial and insurance activities Real estate activities Professional, scientific and technical activities Administrative and support service activities Public administration and defence; compulsory social security Education Human health and social work activities Arts, entertainment and recreation Other service activities Activities of households as employers; undifferentiated goods and services producing activities of households for own use Activities of extraterritorial organisations and bodies Impact to the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics Series As previously stated, the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics 2009 website provides data on registered businesses based on both SIC 2003 and SIC 2007 for 2008 and 2009. We can use these tables to assess the impact of the classification change on the enterprise count, employment and turnover from the IDBR as presented in the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics Series. Table 2 below compares the results for enterprises, employment and turnover for 2009 on the SIC 2003 and SIC 2007 basis 2. Table 2 – Enterprise Count, Employment and Turnover – Private Sector Registered Enterprises - SIC 2003/SIC 2007 (Section Level) Section (SIC 2003) A,B Agriculture, forestry and fishing C Mining and quarrying D Manufacturing E Electricity, gas and water supply F Construction G Wholesale, retail and repairs I Transport, storage and communication H Hotels and restaurants J Financial Intermediation K Real estate, renting and business activities M Education N Health and social work O Other community, social and personal services Grand Total Turnover Total in £ Enterprises Employment millions Section (SIC 2007) 19,100 56,810 4,149 A Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing 265 24,710 29,209 B Mining and Quarrying 9,285 214,920 38,410 C Manufacturing D Electricity, gas, steam 95 20,600 12,875 E Water supply; Sewerage 17,100 136,970 17,075 F Construction 26,650 364,780 57,128 G Wholesale and retail trade H Transportation and storage 5,990 115,210 13,637 J Information and communication 12,870 156,730 6,347 I Accommodation and food service activities 1,630 97,540 NA K Financial and insurance activities L Real estate activities M Professional, scientific and technical activities 41,370 335,020 30,455 N Administrative and support service activities 1,580 76,090 1,910 P Education 6,035 138,810 4,960 Q Human health and social work activities R Arts, entertainment and recreation 12,395 101,190 10,703 S Other service activities 154,370 1,839,380 226,856 Grand Total Notes: 1. Excludes central and local government. 2. Turnover for SIC 2003 Section J and SIC 2007 Section K are not available. 3. Totals may not equal the sum of the constituent parts due to rounding. 2 Turnover Total in £ Enterprises Employment millions 17,750 52,570 3,900 265 24,710 29,209 8,555 203,890 37,531 80 14,040 7,165 375 11,760 6,524 19,505 144,760 19,564 25,680 361,200 56,838 5,305 94,300 9,545 6,870 58,460 6,931 12,870 156,730 6,347 1,705 97,730 NA 4,575 28,840 2,753 21,645 133,370 14,184 9,225 155,100 9,786 1,820 77,310 1,982 5,735 136,080 4,818 3,825 48,300 7,473 8,585 40,250 2,304 154,370 1,839,380 226,852 Source : Scottish Government, ONS (IDBR) Note that SIC 2007 Sections T and U (and the corresponding SIC 2003 Sections) are out of scope of the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics. There are too many differences between SIC 2003 and SIC 2007 to be listed here, but we can use Table 2 to identify the impact that the changes have on the Corporate Sector Statistics Series at the broad section level and investigate the main drivers of change: Grand Totals The grand totals for enterprises and employment are the same under SIC 2007 and SIC 2003. However, the turnover grand total has reduced from £226,856 million under SIC 2003 to £226,852 million under SIC 2007. This difference is due to the finance sector; turnover is not available for businesses in the finance sector - some businesses will have changed classification from the finance sector under SIC 2003 to other sections under SIC 2007 (and vice versa) which means that more (or less) turnover information becomes available. Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing – SIC 2003 Section A (Agriculture, hunting and forestry) and SIC 2003 Section B (Fishing) have been combined as SIC 2007 Section A (Agriculture, forestry and fishing)3. The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all reduced under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for agriculture, forestry and fishing. Employment is down by 4,240 and turnover is down by £249 million. The overall reductions are driven by landscaping services moving from SIC 2003 Section (Agriculture, hunting and forestry) to SIC 2007 Division 81 (Services to Building and Landscape Activities) within SIC 2007 Section N (Administrative and support service activities). Mining and Quarrying – Although there are changes within the Mining and Quarrying Section (e.g. new SIC 2007 Division 9 (Mining Support Service Activities)), at the broad Section level there are no differences in the number of enterprises, employment and turnover in the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics Series. 3 Note that although the SIC 2003 Sections for agriculture and fishing have been combined, the detail under the new SIC 2007 Section A (Agriculture, forestry and fishing) has been substantially increased. Manufacturing – The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all reduced under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for the Manufacturing Section. Employment is down by 11,030 and turnover is down by £879 million. The overall reductions are driven by: SIC 2003 Division 37 (Recycling) within the SIC 2003 Manufacturing Section has moved to the SIC 2007 Section E (Water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation), resulting in a reduction of 1,220 in employment and a reduction of £251 million in turnover within the SIC 2007 Manufacturing Section. The publishing part of SIC 2003 Division 22 (Publishing, printing and reproduction of recorded media) within the SIC 2003 Manufacturing Section has moved to the new SIC 2007 Section J (Information and Communication). The new SIC 2007 Division 58 (Publishing activities) within Section J has an employment level of 9,270 and a turnover level of £700 million – businesses formerly classified under the SIC 2003 Manufacturing Section make up the majority of these totals. Note that repair and installation of machinery and equipment, formerly classified under manufacturing of the corresponding type of equipment, is now identified separately in the new SIC 2007 Division 33 (Repair and installation of machinery and equipment). Electricity, Gas and Water Supply – SIC 2003 Section E (Electricity, Gas and Water Supply) has been replaced by SIC 2007 Section D (Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning supply) and SIC 2007 Section E (Water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation activities). Comparing SIC 2003 Section E with SIC 2007 Sections D and E combined, we see that the number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all increased under SIC 2007. Employment is up by 5,200 and turnover is up by £814 million. The overall increases are driven by: SIC 2003 Division 37 (Recycling) within the SIC 2003 Manufacturing Section moving to the SIC 2007 Section E (Water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation), resulting in an increase of 1,220 in employment and an increase of £251 million in turnover. The majority of SIC 2003 Division 90 (Sewage and refusal disposal) within the SIC 2003 Section O (Other Community Services) moving to SIC 2007 Section E (Water supply, sewerage, waste management and remediation). SIC 2003 Division 90 (Sewage and refusal disposal) has an employment level of 3,960 and a turnover level of £553 million – the majority of this is now included in SIC 2007 Section E. Construction The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all increased under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for construction. Employment is up by 7,790 and turnover is up by £2,489 million. The overall increases are driven by the development and selling of real estate moving from SIC 2003 Section K (Real estate, renting and business activities) to SIC 2007 Section F (Construction). Wholesale, Retail and Repairs The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all decreased under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for wholesale, retail and repairs. Employment is down by 3,580 and turnover is down by £290 million. The overall decreases are driven by the repair and maintenance of personal and household goods moving from SIC 2003 Section G (Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles, motorcycles and personal and household goods) to SIC 2007 Section S (Other service activities). However, note that the repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles – SIC 2007 Division 45 (corresponding to SIC 2003 Division 50) has been retained within the Wholesale and Retail Trade Section for comparability and continuity reasons. These changes are reflected in the name change for this section from “Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles, motorcycles and personal and household goods” under SIC 2003 to “Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles and motor cycles” under SIC 2007. Transport, Storage and Communication – Major changes have been made to this Section: SIC 2003 Section I (Transport, Storage and Communication) has been replaced by SIC 2007 Section H (Transport and Storage) and SIC 2007 Section J (Information and communication). Section J (Information and Communication) under SIC 2007 is a major new section - the main components of this section are publishing activities, including software publishing (SIC 2007 Division 58), motion picture and sound recording activities (SIC 2007 Division 59), radio and TV broadcasting and programming activities (SIC 2007 Division 60), telecommunications activities (SIC 2007 Division 61) and information technology activities (SIC 2007 Division 62) and other information service activities (SIC 2007 Division 63). These activities were included in SIC 2003 Sections D (Manufacturing), I (Transport, storage and communications), K (Real estate, renting and business activities) and O (Other community, social and personal service activities), therefore having a strong impact on comparability across the SIC versions. However, this new treatment of information and communication activities provides a more consistent approach (based on the character of the activities carried out) than the SIC 2003 version. Hotels and Restaurants – Although there are changes within the Hotels and Restaurants Section (or Accommodation and Restaurants as the section is known under SIC 2007), at the broad Section level there are no differences in terms of the number of enterprises, employment and turnover in the Scottish Corporate Sector Statistics Series. Financial Intermediation – The number of enterprises and employment has increased under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for the financial sector. Employment is marginally up by 190 under SIC 2007. The increase is a result of the activities of holding companies moving from SIC 2003 Section K (Real estate, renting and business activities) to SIC 2007 Section K (Financial and Insurance Activities). Real Estate, Renting and Business Activities – Major changes have been made to this Section: The SIC 2003 Section for K (Real estate, renting and business activities) has been replaced by three sections under SIC 2007. Real estate is now represented as a stand-alone section (SIC 2007 Section L) due to its size and importance in the System of National Accounts. However, and as outlined above, the development and selling of real estate moves to SIC 2007 Section F (Construction). The remaining activities have been separated into Section M (Professional, scientific and technical activities) and Section N (Administrative and support service activities). SIC 2007 Section M covers activities that require a high degree of training and make specialised knowledge and skills available to users. While SIC 2007 Section N (Administrative and support service activities) covers activities that support general business operations - this pulls in units from many parts of SIC 2003, for example: employment services, call centres, travel arrangements and reservation services, investigation and security services. SIC 2003 Division 72 (Computer and related activities) is no longer part of this section. Computer repair activities have been grouped with repair of household goods in SIC 2007 Section S (Other service activities), while software publishing and IT activities have been grouped in the new SIC 2007 Section J. Education The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all increased under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for education. Employment is up by 1,220 and turnover is up by £72 million. The overall increases are a result of SIC 2007 Section P (Education) being broadened to include specialised sport, cultural and other educational services and also specialised support services. Formerly these types of services would have fallen under other service Sections e.g. SIC 2003 Section O (Other community, social and personal services). Health and Social Work The number of enterprises, employment and turnover have all decreased under SIC 2007 compared to SIC 2003 for Health and Social Work. Employment is down by 2,730 and turnover is down by £142 million. The overall decreases are driven by veterinary services moving from SIC 2003 Section N (Health and social work) to SIC 2007 Section M (Professional, scientific and technical services). SIC 2007 Section Q has been renamed Human Health and Social Work Activities to reflect this change. Other Community, Social and Personal Services Major changes have been made to this Section: Substantial components of SIC 2003 Section O (Other community, social and personal service activities) have been moved to SIC 2007 Section E (Water supply; sewerage, waste management and remediation activities) and SIC 2007 Section J (Information and communication), as described above. The remaining activities have been regrouped in two new sections for Arts, entertainment and recreation (SIC 2007 Section R) and Other service activities (SIC 2007 Section S). Repair of computers and personal and household goods is now included in this new SIC 2007 Section S. More Information Details of the SIC 2007 are available on the National Statistics Classification website and in the following publications: UK Standard Industrial Classification of Economic Activities 2007 August 2008 edition of the Economic & Labour Market Review