K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools Using the EVT-2 to Differentiate Read Alouds Location: Date: Time: Overview Explicitly teaching vocabulary can be challenging. There is not enough time to teach all unfamiliar words, and it may not be clear which words are the most useful for students to learn. This team meeting asks teachers to look closely at a book they will read out loud to students and think about the vocabulary they are teaching with the story. Analyzing the EVT-2 forms of students with below-average English vocabularies will help teachers identify the types of words that students may not understand. Objective Teachers will analyze EVT-2 forms in order to adapt a read aloud book to accommodate the needs of students with smaller English vocabularies Preparation Pick a focus book for this session that will be used for read aloud very soon after the team meeting, ideally the next day Invite teachers and ask them to bring the book, their teacher’s manual, and the EVT-2 forms of one or two of their students whose English vocabularies are in the below-average range Agenda written / typed Copy materials: Adapting Vocabulary Instruction to English Language Learners Background This team meeting builds on one of the “big ideas” of literacy instruction identified by the National Reading Panel: students need direct and explicit instruction in vocabulary. Because it is not possible to teach all unfamiliar words, Beck, McKeown, and Kucan developed a framework to help educators identify which words were important and useful enough for direct instruction. The framework includes three tiers of words : Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third 1 K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools Tier One: Basic, common words that rarely require instruction in school Tier Two: Words that are common in printed text but rare in spoken language Tier Three: Rare and specialized words that are specific to a particular genre or field The recommendation is for teachers to focus direct instruction on tier two words. You can learn more about the tiers of vocabulary instruction in the book Bringing Words to Life. A framework for adapting the three tiers of vocabulary instruction for English language learners is available at Colorin Colorado, a website focused on the reading achievement of Ell’s, sponsored by the National Institute for Literacy. Important Note: By the definition of Tier One, Tier Two, and Tier Three words given by Beck, McKeown, and Kucan, nearly all words an elementary student would produce while participating in the EVT-2 are Tier One words. The EVT-2 has created their own three-tiered model to categorize the words used in the assessment, including a worksheet that assigns words into Tier One, Tier Two, and Tier Three categories. Their system, explained on page 35 of the EVT-2 Manual, does not align with the instructional model above. Resources Put Reading First Available at no cost from Ed Pubs, the U.S. Department of Education’s free educational publications website. http://edpubs.ed.gov/Product_Detail.aspx Evidence-based vocabulary instruction is the focus of pages 29 - 39 Bringing Words to Life: Robust Vocabulary Instruction by Isabel L. Beck, Margaret G. McKeown, and Linda Kucan This widely used book provides information for teachers on using evidence-based practices to build vocabulary skills through direct and indirect instruction. Colorín Colorado 2 This website was developed as a resource for educators and families of English language learners by WETA, a public radio and television station in Washington, D.C. It is funded by the American Federation of Teacher’s (AFT), the National Institute for Literacy, and the U.S. Department of Education, and partners with Reading Rockets. This page provides an overview of evidence-based vocabulary instruction for Ell’s: http://www.colorincolorado.org/educators/teaching/vocabulary Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools This page provides tips on differentiating the three tiers of vocabulary instruction for Ell’s: http://www.colorincolorado.org/educators/content/vocabulary This page provides information on teaching cognates, with a link to a pdf that lists common Spanish/English cognates: http://www.colorincolorado.org/educators/background/cognates Focusing on Special Populations: Good vocabulary instruction is also good for Ell’s and students with disabilities. While you may need additional supports for these students, they still need direct and explicit instruction in academic language. Ell’s may need additional help learning basic words that would already be familiar to other children (e.g., “baby”), that are often described as “Tier One” words. Looking more closely at the EVT-2 score form can help you identify the types of words that students need help learning. The Ell and Transition Handbook of Reading Street offers additional tips and resources for adapting instruction for Ell’s. 3 Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools Team Meeting Activities Key: = quick discussion/overview; = discussion item; = involved discussion Make sure that participants have with them a few EVT-2 forms from low-scoring students, a book that will be used for read aloud, and the accompanying teacher’s manual. 1. 2. 3. 4 Examining Materials a. Start the session by asking participants about the read alouds they are currently doing as part of the Reading Street adaptation. What has been their experience with the read aloud format? What have been the challenges? The benefits? b. Focus on the book chosen for this session. Ask participants to look through the book and identify the words that students may not know, as well as idioms and cognates. You may write these words on a piece of chart paper, or ask a team member to write them down as a scribe. c. Look at the Reading Street teacher’s manual. What words did the author’s choose as the target words? How are they taught? At what points are the words reinforced? Do these fit with the words chosen by the teacher from the read-aloud book? Digging into Student Data a. Turn the discussion to students with below-average English vocabulary, as identified by the EVT-2. Are there words in the book that would be tricky for these students? Ask teachers to identify several words that they would imagine they would need to teach a child with low vocabulary scores in order for him or her to understand the story. b. Now look through the EVT-2 forms that teachers brought for some of their lowest students. C the types of words that students missed. Did the student know more or less words than might have been expected? Are there any patterns, such as consistently missing names for animals or shapes? Differentiating and Adaptation a. Reconnect the word analysis to the book used for read aloud. Were any of the missed words connected to the big ideas or important words in the book? What types of words would be essential to understanding the book but may not be known to the student? b. Pass out copies of the “Adapting Vocabulary to English Language Learners” sheet. Help teachers plan for how they can modify the read aloud to include students with low vocabularies. Stress that not every word can be taught, the focus should be on words essential to the story or that have a high utility for understanding any written text. Common words often do not need explicit instruction, but can be pointed out during reading, perhaps Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools by pointing to an illustration of the word or demonstrating its meaning. Even students who miss very basic words still need explicit instruction in the academic language that comprise the target words of Reading Street. c. 4. Pass out small post-it notes or tags that teachers can place on pages as reminders to point out common words that may be unknown to students. Closing and reflection a. As the session ends, ask teachers to share what they learned about their students by analyzing the EVT-2 forms. Where they surprised by what the student knew or did not know? How will this inform their read alouds moving forward? 5 Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Facilitator’s Guide Boston Public Schools Furthering the Conversation The following optional activities provide ideas for looking more closely at instruction, professional development, and family engagement. Communities of Practice: To support this grade-level team meeting, teachers may invite other teaching professionals or an instructional leader to observe a read aloud session. The observer would focus on vocabulary instruction, and provide feedback in the following areas: o Introducing key vocabulary How are the words introduced? What types of words are introduced most often (Tier 1, 2, or 3?) What strategies does the teacher use during the story to emphasize the meaning of the target words? How are students engaged to use the words in a meaningful way? Are a wide range of students engaged in using words? o Making the story inclusive How are ideas crucial to the story explained to students? How are all students encouraged to actively use target vocabulary words? Connecting With Families: There is no doubt that children benefit from hearing books read aloud in their homes. There are several free resources to help parents read in an interactive, engaging manner that will ultimately build vocabulary. o Washington Learning Systems provides free videos demonstrating dialogic reading to parents in English, Spanish, Vietnamese, and Madarin available at http://www.walearning.com/language/#preview-videos o Reading Rockets provides reading tips for parents of kindergarteners in 11 different languages, free to download, print, and distribute at http://www.readingrockets.org/article/7834 6 Created by Sky Marietta | Three to Third K2 Data-Driven Literacy Instruction Teacher Handout Adapting Vocabulary Instruction to English Language Learners Margarita Calderόn, a professor and researcher at Johns Hopkins University, has adapted the three tiers of vocabulary instruction for English language learners. She points out that while Ell’s may need help understanding tier one words, they usually have a concept of the word in their native language. This means that a few quick strategies—for example, pointing to a picture or acting out a word—will help Ell’s make sense of the story and still preserve time to explicitly teach academic language. An overview of her framework is below1. 1 Find out more at http://www.colorincolorado.org/educators/content/vocabulary Created by Sky Marietta Three to Third