The Wave Nature of Light: Superposition, Interference and Diffraction A. Tomasch July, 2009 10.1 Introduction A wave is a traveling disturbance which transports energy from one point in space to another. Waves are among the most important phenomena in all of physics. Mechanical and acoustic (sound) waves propagate through an elastic medium, for example waves on a string. Sound waves propagate through the air (another elastic medium) and allow us to communicate via audible speech. If you have ever watched ripples interact on the surface of a pond, say from two stones thrown into the water, you have already observed that waves interact, often in complex ways. What is remarkable is that the fundamental rule governing how waves combine is simple and a wide variety of wave interactions can be readily understood and calculated from this simple principle. In this lab we will study electromagnetic waves in the form of visible light. Unlike sound waves or other elastic waves, which must propagate in an elastic medium (such as air, water, solids or strings), electromagnetic waves can propagate in the vacuum of space itself. Much of we what we know about the world around us comes to us in the form of electromagnetic radiation—visible light observed directly with our eyes—or other electromagnetic waves (radio, infrared, ultraviolet, x-rays and gamma-rays) observed with specialized instruments sensitive to the specific wavelength of the electromagnetic radiation being observed. This is particularly true of our knowledge of the universe, where virtually all information about the cosmos arrives in the form of electromagnetic radiation observed with telescopes or specialized instruments located on the Earth’s surface or aboard satellites in earth orbit. Similarly, much of what is known about atomic structure—the arrangement of electrons within atoms and their corresponding energy levels—is deduced from the study of the light emitted when electrons within atoms undergo energy level transitions, an experimental technique known as spectroscopy. By the end of this lab you should understand in detail the meaning of the terms linear superposition and interference. You should understand how to derive the condition for a dark fringe in the interference pattern of a single slit and the condition for a bright maximum in the diffraction pattern produced by a transmission diffraction grating. You should understand how to use a diffraction grating to measure the wavelength of spectral lines emitted by a glowing gas and understand the difference between this type of spectrum and that produced by a hot filament. You should also understand how to interpret the diffraction pattern produced when a LASER illuminates a slit or diffraction grating to deduce the width of the slit and the spacing of the grating. Reading and Key Concepts Before starting this lab, you should review the following concepts in Cutnell & Johnson Physics: Basics of wave phenomena: §16.1- 4 The Principle of Linear Superposition, constructive and destructive interference: §17.1- 2 Diffraction: §17.3 The Principle of Linear Superposition: §27.1- 2 Diffraction and diffraction gratings: §27.5-7 You may also find §27.8-9 interesting. Apparatus Laser slide projector and screen Incandescent lamp Single slit slide Diffraction grating slide and mount Hydrogen discharge tube DNA structure slide 10.2 Preliminaries 10.2.1 The Principle of Linear Superposition, Interference and Diffraction When two waves arrive at a single point in space the rule for combining the effects of the two waves together is remarkably simple and is called the Principle of Liner Superposition, which states that the amplitude of the resulting wave is the sum of the amplitudes of the two arriving waves at every instant of time. For electromagnetic radiation we can characterize the amplitude of a traveling electromagnetic wave as the magnitude of the wave’s electric field. The Principle of Linear Superposition arises because the differential wave equation governing all wave phenomena is linear. This means that if two waves satisfy the wave equation individually, then their sum also satisfies the wave equation. We therefore have a simple and powerful rule for combining waves arriving at the same place from different sources. When two waves combine the effect is called interference. The same rule applies when more than two waves arrive in the same place: the resulting amplitude is always the sum of the amplitudes of the arriving individual waves at each instant of time. When many waves combine in accordance with the Principle of Linear Superposition, the effect is called diffraction. This distinction is largely semantic—the physical process responsible for all of these phenomena is interference due to the linear superposition of waves from multiple sources. The terms interference and diffraction are often used interchangeably since there is no fundamental difference between them, nor any strict dividing line that separates the two effects. 2 Interference phenomena can be used to probe structures in two ways. Spectroscopic observations are made by observing the interference effects produced by a diffraction grating with a known spacing. The arrangement of atoms within matter can be deduced by studying the diffraction pattern which arises when monochromatic radiation (electromagnetic radiation of a single frequency and hence a single wavelength) interacts with matter which exhibits a regular, periodic atomic or molecular structure—typically a crystal. The accompanying photograph shows one of the most important such patterns ever observed—the diffraction pattern produced when crystalline DNA was exposed to monochromatic X-rays by Rosalind Franklin in 1953. It was the interpretation of this pattern which led Watson and Crick to propose the double helical structure of DNA. The internal arrangements of the atoms in the many “ball and stick” crystal models displayed in most chemistry departments were similarly determined by studying the diffraction patterns generated by crystals exposed to X-rays—the science of X-Ray crystallography. Figure 10-1: Early X-ray diffraction pattern from B-DNA made by Rosalind Franklin in 1952. In this lab we will learn how interference effects can be used to demonstrate the wave nature of light, to study the energy level structure of electrons in atoms (spectral lines) and to probe structures too small to see with the naked eye. 10.2.2 Monochromatic Light: The LASER To demonstrate the wave nature of light and study interference effects, we need a source of monochromatic light—light of a single wavelength. In the early 1960’s physicists developed a new and powerful way to generate monochromatic light using electron transitions between atomic energy levels as a light source. This technique was named Light Amplification through the Stimulated Emission of Radiation—the LASER. Since its invention, the LASER has become an indispensable tool for science and industry. LASERs read the digital data from CDs and DVDs, cut industrial parts with amazing 3 precision, replace metal knives in a variety of surgeries, particularly eye surgery, scan the bar codes on your groceries and serve as pointers for public speaking presentations. The first LASERs employed a high-voltage electrical discharge in gases such as Helium mixed with Neon. Subsequently, solid-state LASER diodes have been developed and are currently used for most applications. For our experiments we will use LASER diode that emits monochromatic green light at a wavelength of 530 nm (1 nm = 10-9 meters). Within the bright LASER light spot we can regard the light as plane waves with a 530 nm wavelength. This is a good approximation to true plane waves (which are infinite in spatial extent) since the laser spot size is ~10,000 wavelengths in diameter so that the wave fronts look infinite in all directions for objects ~10 wavelengths in size illuminated by the laser spot. The LASERs we are using produce a total power output 10 mW (1 mW= 10-3 Watts). While they are not dangerous, they should nonetheless be treated with respect. Never look directly into the beam of the LASER and be careful not to accidentally shine the beam into someone’s eye. Turn the LASER off when it is not in use. 10.2.3 Interference and the Wave Nature of Light Previously, we have approximated the optical behavior of light by tracing light rays, which are assumed to travel in straight lines in air or vacuum. Implicit in this view of light is that a slit in an opaque plate should cast a single shadow with precisely defined edges as shown in Figure 10.2 a. Because light is a traveling wave, what actually occurs is an interference pattern of alternating light and dark lines or “fringes” as shown in Figure 10.2 b. This effect proves conclusively that light is in fact a traveling wave. To see why this is so, let’s study the formation of the first dark fringe in the interference pattern generated by a narrow slit. Figure 10.2: Interference in the image of a narrow single slit. In Figure 10.3 an idealized “plane wave” of monochromatic light with a wavelength λ is incident on a narrow slit of width W from a source far to the left of the slit. To deduce the resulting interference pattern, each of the points along the face of the slit is considered to be source of waves which travel outward from the slit to a distant screen at an angle θ 4 to the slit axis. We have labeled five of the points along the face to aid in our analysis. This method for analyzing the propagation of waves from an extended source (the slit) is an example of Huygens’ Principle, which states that each point on a wave front serves as a source of spherical “wavelets” which travel outward at the wave speed. At any later instant of time the resulting wave front is tangent to all the wavelets. We can use Huygens’ Principle to predict the formation of the first dark fringe in the interference pattern from a single slit as shown in Figure 10.3. For a specific angle θ, the distance traveled by waves originating from point 3 is one half of a wavelength longer than for waves originating at point 1 so that the waves originating from points 1 and 3 arrive at the screen exactly out of phase and cancel by linear superposition. Figure 10.3: Formation of the first dark fringe from a single slit, in accordance with Huygens’ Principle Similarly, a wave originating just below point 1 will destructively interfere with a wave originating just below point 3 and so on across the entire slit, ending with waves originating at point 3 destructively interfering with waves originating at point 5. For each pair of points, the distances traveled by the two waves always differ by one half of a wavelength to produce destructive interference. Thus, destructive interference results in a dark fringe on the screen at the specific angle θ, set by the width of the slot W and the wavelength of the incident light λ, the hypotenuse and base respectively of the shaded right triangle shown in Figure 10.3 b. This analysis can be repeated for the case where the difference in propagation distance between waves originating at points 1 and 5 (the short base of the shaded right triangle) is two 5 wavelengths, three wavelengths, four wavelengths and so on to produce the general condition for a dark fringe from a single narrow slit: sin m W m 1,2,3... [10.1] In light of this discussion we now understand that a “narrow” slit is: one that is not very many wavelengths of light wide, say ten or fewer. Once the angle θ has been determined from the known distance to the screen and the distance on the screen to the chosen dark fringe of order m, equation 10.1 can be used to determine the width of the slit if the wavelength of the incident light is known or the wavelength of the incident light can be determined if the slit width is known. This is a general property of interference and diffraction: a known wavelength of light can be used to probe the size of a structure or the known dimensions of a diffracting object (in this case the width of the slit) can be used to deduce the wavelength of incident light. We will employ both techniques to make diffraction-based measurements. 10.2.4 The Diffraction Grating As we have seen for a narrow single slit, interference effects are due to the wave nature of light and cannot be explained with “geometric” optics (ray tracing). We will now further our study of “physical” optics (based on the wave nature of light) by applying Huygens’ Principle to deduce the properties of a transmission diffraction grating shown in Figure 10.4. The grating shown is like an almost-closed Venetian blind, with many long parallel slits perpendicular to the paper which are uniformly spaced by a distance d. A real diffraction grating would be about 10,000 times smaller than shown in the figure. Real gratings are traditionally made by inscribing closely-spaced lines on a glass or plastic plate with a diamond-tipped cutting tool. The spaces between the opaque lines (scratches) serve as the slits in the grating. Figure 10.4: Formation of a bright maximum for a transmission diffraction grating. 6 As for the single slit, consider the ideal case of monochromatic light of a single wavelength λ incident from a source far to the left of the grating. The initial wave front is a plane W1 perpendicular to the direction of the incoming light (the direction of travel for the light when viewed as a “ray”) and therefore parallel to the grating. To the right of the grating Huygens’ “wavelets” spread out from each slit in grating, in phase with the incident wave front W1. The wavelets combine to form the exiting wave front W2 in accordance with Huygens’ Principle. For an angle θ such that the successive differences in path length (the small distances l1, l2, and l3 , for example) correspond to integer numbers of wavelengths, the waves from all the slits will arrive in phase at the screen far to the right of the grating and interfere constructively, producing a bright maximum. This will occur when l1=λ, l1=2λ, l1=3λ … So the general relationship that must hold to form a bright maximum at the screen is sin m m d m 1,2,3... [10.2] where m is an integer, again referred to as the order of the maximum. Thus incoming parallel light (plane wave fronts) of a given wavelength λ will be constructively enhanced in the specific directions θm . Note that if the light is not monochromatic, but rather contains a mixture of wavelengths, each different wavelength will have a different set of θm directions, since d remains fixed but λ changes in equation [10.2]. Thus, a transmission grating will disperse the spectrum of white light, performing the same optical function as a prism. To produce diffraction angles of a few degrees requires a spacing d ≈ 10λ or about 5 x 10-4 cm (~2000 slits/cm) for visible light. 10.3 The Experiments 10.3.1 Interference from a Single Narrow Slit Procedure Without a slide mounted in the slide holder, turn on the LASER slide projector and aim the LASER so that the spot falls just above the zero mark on the centimeter scale marked on the projection screen and verify that the distance from the slide to the screen is 1.5 meters. Mount the single-slit slide in the projector with the slit oriented vertically and position it so that the LASER spot falls centered on the slit. Observe the diffraction pattern and record the distances for the first three dark fringes from the beam position. Analysis Calculate the slit width for each order fringe using [10.1] and compare for consistency. What would happen to the position of the first dark fringe if the slit width were doubled? Halved? 7 10.3.2 Characterizing the Transmission Grating Procedure Next, mount the transmission grating slide in the slide projector so that the LASER spot falls near the center of the grating. Arrange the slide so that the bright maxima fall horizontally along the centimeter scale on the screen, again with the LASER beam spot centered at zero. Measure the distance to the first bright maximum Analysis How are the slits in the grating oriented (horizontally or vertically)? Calculate the grating spacing d. How many slits per centimeter does your value of d correspond to? 10.3.3 A Continuous Spectrum Procedure A hot, glowing solid produces a continuous spectrum, which looks like a complete rainbow and can be observed through the transmission grating. The general scheme for viewing a light source through the transmission grating is shown in Figure 10.5. Figure 10.5: Scheme for viewing a light source through the transmission grating 8 Observe the light from the incandescent light bulb filament through the transmission grating. For this application, the narrow filament of the light bulb serves as the slit shown in the drawing. Measure the positions of the ends of the visible spectrum (the positions of the red end and the purple end). Analysis Calculate the corresponding wavelengths using [10.2]. You need only do this for the first-order spectrum. How do your measured wavelengths correspond to the published values for the ends of the visible spectrum displayed on the wall chart? Does the spectrum appear truly continuous (no breaks)? Does the brightness seem uniform? 10.3.4 The Spectrum of Hydrogen Procedure The viewing setup is similar to that used for the continuous spectrum. This time, the narrow hydrogen discharge tube serves as the “slit” for the apparatus and the grating is placed 50 cm from the discharge tube. In the first-order spectrum you should see a bright red line. This spectral line is called the Hα of the Balmer spectral series of Hydrogen. Astronomers map the distribution of hydrogen gas in the Galaxy by observing the intensity of this line to both determine both the presence and amount of hydrogen in ionized gas clouds. The prominent greenish-blue line is called Hβ. You should also be able to see a faint violet line (Hγ) and you may be able to see a very faint line in the far violet (Hδ). Measure and record the positions of these lines on both sides of the discharge tube. Analysis Average your two position measurements for each line (what error does this correct for?) and calculate the wavelength corresponding to each line. The wavelengths of the lines in the Balmer series are given by the Rydberg formula, a special case of the Bohr formula: 1 R(1/ 22 1/ n2 ) n 3,4,5,6... [10.3] Where n = 3 corresponds to Hα , n = 4 to Hβ and so on. The parameter R is called the Rydberg constant. Use each of your measurements separately to estimate the value of R. Do the wavelengths of your lines all predict the same value for the Rydberg constant? Are your values consistent with the published value R = 1.097 x 105 cm-1? 9 10.3.5 Probing Structure with Diffraction Procedure Tape the diffraction pattern page of your worksheet to the screen and align the LASER slide projector so that the beam spot hits the target on the page. Mount the unknown sample slide in the LASER slide projector and observe the resulting diffraction pattern on the screen. Trace the diffraction pattern on your worksheet page, measure and record the distance from the beam to one of the primary bright maxima on the page. Be sure the distance from the slide to the screen is 1.5 m. Analysis The sample you are studying consists of a regular array of identical closed shapes. What is the symmetry of the basic repeated shape? (Hint: How many primary bright maxima surround the beam spot? How many sides does the regularly repeated “cell” of the sample have?). Treating the sample as a transmission diffraction grating, use [10.2] to estimate the spacing between grating elements and hence the size of the individual elements making up the sample. Can you identify a biological sample (animal) that exhibits this regularly repeated shape? View the sample under a microscope and see if you can guess what it is. Figure 10.6: Characteristic sizes for various objects and the corresponding forms of electromagnetic radiation needed to probe them using interference and diffraction techniques. 10