The I Do Foundation’s Charitable Wedding Services Venture The I Do Foundation’s Charitable Wedding Services (CWS) venture develops powerful causerelated marketing programs for major wedding retailers that generate greater revenues for retailers while capturing a percentage of wedding sales for charity. Intense retailer competition, high product margins, and high couple spending in the $70 billion wedding industry create a unique and lucrative market opportunity for CWS’s cause-related marketing programs. CWS already has proven the potential for its cause-related marketing services through pilot programs with major national retailers. CWS has the opportunity to expand these successful pilots to national programs for its retail clients. Over the next three years, CWS will generate over $18 million in charitable donations for charitable organizations across the country. CWS helps major retailers develop Charitable Registry Programs through which stores offer to Retail Client donate a percentage of registry spending to charity. With each gift purchase raising donations Relationships for charity, a Charitable Registry Program creates powerful incentives for higher gift spending and provides stores with a compelling sales tool for attracting bridal customers. CWS has conducted successful online pilot Charitable Registry Programs with 9 major stores (including Target, JC Penney, and Linens ‘n Things) and 500 couples. Retail clients experienced increases of 40%-60% in spending on registries in the pilot and over half of the stores raised their donation rates. CWS is now poised to expand to develop in-store program integrations for retail clients and has set the following goals for 2004: 1. Close online pilot program contracts with 1-2 new retail clients (2 new clients already closed). 2. Begin first Regional Store Integrations of the Charitable Registry Program for 1-2 clients. 3. Extend CWS’s cause-related marketing services to national bridal boutiques and florists. CLIENT PHASE 1: Pilot Program CWS has developed online charitable wedding programs for retailers through the I Do Foundation website. CLIENT PHASE 2: CLIENT PHASE 3: Regional Store Integration National Store Integration Retail clients choose to integrate the charitable wedding programs into stores in a single market region. Retail clients expand charitable wedding programs into all of their stores across the country. Market Over 2.4 million couples get married each year spending over $70 billion at their weddings. Of couples, 91% register for gifts, generating $19 billion in gift registry spending annually. Opportunity those With almost $30,000 of spending at the average wedding, bridal customers represent one of the High per couple spending and intense competition in the wedding industry create the perfect opportunity for CWS Value Proposition Enable retailers to increase registry sales and attract new bridal customers. most coveted market segments in the retail industry. Retailers view bridal registries as the perfect opportunity to begin a life-long relationship with a couple. The once-in-a-lifetime aura of weddings lowers engaged couples’ price sensitivity, allowing vendors to garner extremely high sales margins and fueling intense competition for customers. With retailers constantly seeking compelling sales tools for their bridal services, the wedding industry presents the perfect opportunity for CWS’s cause-related marketing programs. Increased Registry Purchases: Charitable Registry Programs encourage couples to inform their guests about their registry and motivate guests to buy from the participating retailer. Compelling Marketing and Sales Tool: Charitable Registry Programs are a powerful customer acquisition mechanism for stores that are constantly seeking to differentiate their registry services. Positive Public Relations Benefits: Charitable Registry Programs create numerous opportunities for retailers to brand themselves in the media as good corporate citizens. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 1 CWS seamlessly integrates the Charitable Registry Program into retailers’ existing bridal services. CWS provides retailers with a streamlined service package that includes: 1. Program Setup Consultation 2. Technical Systems Integration 3. Customer Support 4. Associate Support and Training Materials 5. Donation Management and Disbursement The retail clients manage all ongoing program materials development, associate training, and program promotion, which enables CWS to avoid costly integration and maintenance expenses. CWS’s experienced and passionate management team has worked closely with its advisors to develop a highly specialized product for major wedding retailers. Key competitive advantages include a solid first-mover advantage, established nonprofit partnerships, a robust technical infrastructure and an existing public relations platform. The most likely competitive threat to CWS comes from the retailers developing in-house Charitable Registry programs. CWS will capitalize upon scale advantages and growing brand legitimacy to keep retailers from undercutting the venture. Management Team Peter Murray – Executive Vice-President – Founder and former President of a Philadelphia-based business development center with over 20 staff; Co-founder of the I Do Foundation; strong wedding industry knowledge/contacts and a proven sales record with major retailers. Larry Miller – Director of Technology – Former project manager for DigitalWave, CDNow, and Aquent Consulting; has lead the Foundation’s technology team for over two and a half years. In addition, the Foundation’s Executive Director, Bethany Robertson, and several board members are heavily involved in leading the CWS venture. CWS will hire five additional staff members over the next year, including a CEO and Sales Director. Financial Summary CWS’s revenue structure centers on service relationships with retail clients. In addition to the donated percentage of sales, retailers pay a 1% fee to CWS for program support and donation management. These fees are the sole revenue stream for CWS (100% of the retailers’ donations go directly to couples’ selected nonprofit organizations). As a targeted and simple cause-related marketing service, CWS maintains a streamlined cost structure – the majority of CWS’s expenses come from salaries for sales and program integration staff and an experienced CEO. To date, CWS has raised $163,000 ($93K on hand) and requires an additional $220,000 before becoming cash flow positive in the summer of 2005. Summary Projections FY 2004 FY 2005 FY 2006 Management Fee Revenue* $68,330 $1,183,200 $1,635,075 Cost of Sales $39,860 $1,041,515 $1,450,845 Operating Expenses $235,058 $761,179 $1,134,882 EBIT ($ in thousands) ($195,198) $280,336 $315,963 Operating Margin NA 24% 19% * Only includes the 1% management fee paid by stores, not the donations made to nonprofits Charitable Donations Raised by CWS FY 2003 FY 2004 FY 2005 $438,340 $7,594,050 $10,449,900 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 2 Business Description I. OVERVIEW Charitable Wedding Services (CWS) helps major wedding retailers develop cause-related marketing programs that enable retailers to increase customer spending and attract new bridal customers while generating resources for charities. Over the next three years, CWS aims to enable 3-5 major retailers to develop Charitable Gift Registry Programs in stores across the country. In addition, CWS will expand its cause-related marketing program into the floral and bridal gown markets, serving at least one bridal boutique chain and one major florist company by 2006. Over the next three years, these programs will raise over $18 million in charitable donations. CWS is a revenue-generating project of the I Do Foundation, a national nonprofit organization dedicated to encouraging charitable giving through weddings. I Do Foundation History The I Do Foundation is a Washington, DC-based nonprofit organization founded in 2001 to encourage charitable giving at weddings. Working with national media sources and wedding industry leaders, the I Do Foundation educates engaged couples about opportunities to have a sociallyconscious wedding. The Foundation has developed an online system that enables couples to select donations in place of traditional wedding gifts and provides grant management and donor services. Couples can also create charitable guest favors, where the couple makes a donation in honor of each of their guests in place of traditional wedding favors. While the Foundation’s media and online efforts have been extremely well-received, the real opportunity for social change within the wedding industry lies in capturing a share of the $70 billion spent on items ranging from wedding dresses to gift registries. In recognition of this opportunity, the I Do Foundation began developing the CWS model in 2002 in an effort to apply cause-related marketing strategies to the wedding industry. The CWS program is closely aligned with the I Do Foundation’s mission, and the income earned will contribute significantly to the long-term sustainability of the organization. In addition, the program will greatly increase traffic on the I Do Foundation website, creating opportunities to encourage couples to use the Foundation’s other charitable wedding services. The Creation of CWS CWS replicates the successful charitable wedding registry model pioneered by The Wedding List, a retailer purchased by Martha Stewart in 2002 with stores in NYC, Boston, and London. During the two years in which this program was offered, the Charitable Registry program was an enormous success for The Wedding List, increasing registry purchases by up to 50% and creating a powerful tool for attracting new couples to register with the store. After Martha Stewart bought the The Wedding List at the beginning of 2002 (The Wedding List folded soon thereafter), the I Do Foundation contacted Gregg Renfrew, The Wedding List’s former CEO, to assess the possibility of replicating the innovative model with other major retailers. Working closely with Ms. Renfrew and other wedding industry advisors, the I Do Foundation reached out to retailers across the country to develop pilot Charitable Registry Programs through the I Do Foundation’s website. After securing donation agreements with several major retailers, the I Do Foundation created the technical infrastructure and web interface to conduct online pilot Charitable Registry Programs for Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 3 each retailer. In the second half of 2003, the I Do Foundation worked with 9 retail clients to create Charitable Gift Registries for over 500 couples. These retail clients experienced increases of 40%60% in spending on registries in the pilot, and over half of these clients have already raised their donation rates. In the first three months of 2004, the I Do Foundation has added two new retail clients, Marshall Fields and REI, and has created Charitable Registries for an additional 400 couples. Building on Success: Expanding the CWS Pilot Program to Retailers’ Stores and Websites The mission of CWS is to integrate charitable giving programs into retailers’ existing in-store and online wedding services. In the pilot phase, the Charitable Registry Programs are run through the I Do Foundation’s website. CWS’s growth model is predicated upon integrating Charitable Registry Programs into retailers’ stores and websites in order to capture couples at these points of sale. CWS has conducted online pilot programs through its website (www.idofoundation.org) for major national retailers including Linens ‘n Things, Target, JC Penney, Ross-Simons, and Kitchen Etc. These online pilot programs have enabled the I Do Foundation to streamline its systems for couple services, donation management and disbursement, and store interfacing. In the fourth quarter of 2004, CWS will build on the pilot programs to begin the first in-store Charitable Registry Program integrations for 1-2 retailers on a regional basis (current pilot programs are exclusively operated through the I Do Foundation’s website). Over the next three years, CWS will develop national in-store Charitable Registry Programs for 3-5 major retailers. In addition to helping stores set up these charitable registry programs, CWS will provide ongoing back-end program support, including managing nonprofit selection by couples, customer service, and donation disbursement. Over the past nine months, CWS has begun assessing the opportunity to expand these charitable giving programs into other segments of the wedding industry. CWS’s market outreach and analysis have shown a strong demand for charitable programs in the bridal boutique and floral segments. Growth Opportunities: Adding Bridal Boutiques and Florists The I Do Foundation has received strong interest from national bridal boutiques and florists who are eager to develop charitable programs. CWS will extend its charitable wedding services to enable these retailers to offer prospective clients the option to have a percentage of their wedding purchases donated to charity. This charitable program will differentiate participating boutiques and florists from their competitors and enable them to close valuable, high-margin wedding contracts. In the second half of 2004, CWS will begin pilot charitable giving programs with bridal boutiques and florists with the goal of expanding these pilots into national programs in 2005. CWS will first focus on national clients to establish a solid operations platform. Once established, CWS will open up its services to local bridal boutiques and florists across the country. Through its streamlined donation system, CWS will enable any store to easily create “I Do” charitable giving programs. NOTE: Throughout the rest of this plan, the discussion focuses on the Charitable Registry Programs because they represent more than 90% of projected revenue in the near term. The sales and operations process for boutiques and florists is nearly identical to that of CWS’s gift registry retail clients. For an example of a program integration proposal for these retailers see Appendix F. The Role of CWS in the I Do Foundation The CWS venture is a top priority for the I Do Foundation. CWS’s cause-related marketing programs are a critical part of the I Do Foundation efforts to create lasting change in the wedding Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 4 industry. The Foundation is raising significant funding resources ($163,000 to date) and operational support in the form of office space, phones, web hosting, and Internet connectivity for CWS. In addition, several members of the Board of Directors have been heavily involved in the planning and fundraising for the venture. In 2003, CWS’s budget represented about a third of the total I Do Foundation budget and the venture will represent approximately 50% of the 2004 budget.1 Operational responsibilities are divided as follows: I Do Foundation Receives Donations Screens Nonprofits Disburses Funds to Nonprofits Manages Donor Relations CWS Directs Sales and Marketing Runs all Store Services Manages Customer Service Runs Donation Tracking As this chart indicates, CWS will be responsible for developing and maintaining retail client relationships. The I Do Foundation will then manage all stages of the grant-making process using the Foundation’s existing donation management systems. II. CHARITABLE WEDDING GIFT REGISTRY PROGRAMS DETAILS Through a Charitable Registry Program, retailers offer to donate a percentage of gift purchases to charity for couples who sign up for the program. Retailers offer the program to engaged couples through their stores and websites. Charitable registry programs create powerful incentives for attracting new bridal customers. The primary value proposition for stores, however, is the Charitable Registry Programs’ proven increase in per registry spending. With couples registering for gifts at an average of between two to three stores, Charitable Registry Programs give retailers an edge over competitors as they push to get guests to purchase from their stores. Below is an outline of CWS’s cause-related marketing model. Engaged Couples 1. Stores offer couples the opportunity to sign up for the charitable program in store or online. Retailers w/Wedding Gift Registry Registry Services Bridal Boutiques I Do Charitable Wedding Services 2. Stores pay donations and a 1% program management fee to CWS. Customer Service Nonprofit Selection Donation Tracking and Disbursement Florists 3. CWS Charitable Registry Program Management 1 CWS disburses funds to couples chosen charities. The Foundation’s total revenue in 2003 was $225,000 and is expected to be over $400,000 in 2004. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 5 How a Charitable Registry Program Works 1. Stores Offer to Donate a Percentage of Gift Purchases Through their stores, retailers offer engaged couples the opportunity to sign up for a charitable wedding registry. Under the program the retailer donates a percentage of the couple’s gift registry sales to charity. CWS consults with the retailers on the development of program information sheets and store promotional materials. The retailer chooses the donation rate for the program. In addition to the donation rate, retailers pay an additional 1% to CWS for managing the donations. 2. Couples Choose Charitable Options When a couple signs up for a charitable registry program at a participating retailer’s store or website, they automatically receive an account with the I Do Foundation that allows them to choose their charitable organization(s). Couples have the option to select a nonprofit from a list of charitable organizations in the store, or to view a broader range of charities later through the I Do Foundation’s online charitable options system. Couples can access their charitable options through the retailers’ website or directly at www.idofoundation.org. The I Do Foundation’s system enables couples in the retailers’ charitable wedding registry program to select or change a charitable recipient and manage their donation options online. 3. Couples Inform their Guests Guests will hear about the registry through the usual means: word of mouth, bridal showers, and registry enclosure cards. Couples enrolling in the charitable wedding registry program can send registry enclosure cards (see inset) with their wedding or bridal shower invitations to inform guests about their charitable gift registry. The Wedding List was able to get almost 100% of couples to send enclosure cards. Guests make purchases online or at a local store and a percentage of the total amount spent on gifts is donated to charity. Should You Wish We have registered at: MARSHALL FIELDS Marshall Fields will donate 7% of your gift registry purchase to charity. www.fields.com 4. Donation Payments Each month, CWS provides retail clients with statements containing the names and registry IDs for all couples enrolled in the charitable registry program. Each partner then returns a report of registry spending for those couples. CWS invoices the retailers for the donation percentage plus the 1% management fee and disburses donations to couples’ selected nonprofits on a quarterly basis. NOTE: Although retailers will offer the Charitable Registry Program to all couples in their stores and on their website, couples will need to sign up for the program in order to raise donations. No donations will be made on the registries of couples that have not signed up for the program in the store or online. CWS assumes that 15% of a retailer’s bridal customers will choose to sign up for the program, however, it is likely that many more couples will choose to participate.2 Charitable Wedding Programs for Florists and Bridal Boutiques CWS is extending its service offerings to enable florists and bridal boutiques to create Charitable Wedding Programs. These programs will offer retailers the same opportunity to attract customers by offering to donate a percentage of sales. A detailed program proposal for KaBloom, one of our potential 2004 floral clients, is included in Appendix F. 2 The Wedding List experienced 20%-25% adoption rates and some CWS retail clients are estimating over 50%. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 6 III. CLIENT PROGRAM INTEGRATION ROLLOUT Program Phase PHASE 1 PILOT PROGRAM CWS creates Charitable Registry Programs for retailers on the I Do Foundation website. PHASE 2 REGIONAL STORE INTEGRATION CWS helps retailers offer Charitable Registry Programs in stores in a single region. PHASE 3 NATIONAL STORE INTEGRATION CWS helps retailers offer Charitable Registry Programs in all of their stores across the country Retailer Details CWS Details Timeline Value Proposition: Low-risk opportunity to test the potential for Charitable Registry Programs to increase registry sales rates. Services Provided: Attracts couples to site, provides links to client’s registry services, manages charity selection and donation disbursement, provides customer service for all users Currently, CWS has 10 pilot clients. New Clients: 2004: 3 2005: 2-3 2006: 2-3 Fees: Retailer sets donation rate. Additional 1% fee paid to CWS. Set-up Costs: Virtually no technical or operational costs. Value Proposition: Increased registry sales will drive clients to start regional store integrations. Fees: Retailer sets donation rate. Additional 1% fee paid to CWS. Set-up Costs: Stores will develop in-store program materials, train associates, and sign couples up in their stores. Stores will also promote and market the program. Value Proposition: Continued proof of increased registry sales and a smooth regional store integration process for the Charitable Registry Program will push clients to expand nationally. Fees: Retailer sets donation rate. Additional 1% fee paid to CWS. Set-up Costs: Stores will develop in-store program materials, train associates, and sign couples up in their stores. Stores will also promote and market the program. Staff Requirements: Adding new pilot clients requires no additional staff. Currently two technical staff and one service staff member are easily able to manage the pilots. Services Provided: Consult with clients on in-store program setup, manage charity selection and donation disbursement, provide donationrelated customer service for couples and guests. Staff Requirements: Each regional integration will require 4 months of full-time work by 2 staff members (1 tech, 1 service). If the regional integration is successful, then stores will integrate nationally. Services Provided: Consult with clients on national expansion, manage charity selection and donation disbursement, provide donationrelated customer service. Staff Requirements: Expanding the program nationally will require 3 additional months of full-time work by one tech and one service staff member. Ongoing customer support costs for the program will equal approximately $2.60 per couple (compared with per couple revenue of $25.00, not including donations) Clients Moving from Pilot to Regional: 2004: 1-2 2005: 3-4 2006: 2-3 Clients Moving from Regional to National: 2004: 0 2005: 2 2006: 2 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 7 IV. CWS PRODUCT AND SERVICE OFFERING FOR RETAILERS CWS provides retailers with several key services for the development of charitable programs3: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Program Setup Consultation: CWS will consult with each client on program planning, store materials development, marketing integration, and staff training. Technical Systems Integration: CWS will link client’s store systems directly to the CWS database, so that couples can easily join the charitable program at any store. Customer Support: Once couples have joined the charitable program through the store, CWS provides each couple with online tools such as a nonprofit selection system, donation tracking, wedding website creator, and online customer support. Associate Support and Training Materials: CWS provides store associates with training materials, as well as phone and email support for their questions about the program. Donation Management: CWS tracks, manages, and disburses all donations raised through the charitable programs. The retail clients manage all ongoing program materials development, associate training, and program promotion, which enables CWS to avoid costly integration and maintenance expenses. Current Retail Clients The I Do Foundation developed pilot online charitable registry programs for nine retailers in 2003. CWS will build on this client experience to develop full-scale programs for major retailers. 3 3% donated 8% donated 5% donated 5% donated 8% donated 4% donated 4% donated 4% donated 4% donated 7% donated Additional information about each of these services is provided in the Operations Plan section. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 8 V. CWS VALUE PROPOSITION CWS is focused on providing retail clients with a powerful tool for increasing sales. Although these clients are interested promoting a positive corporate image, CWS’s increased customer purchases and new marketing opportunities will drive the retailers’ participation in the program. Who? Gift Registry Retailers Bridal Boutiques and Florists All Retail Clients Engaged Couples Benefits Increased Gift Registry Purchases (see Appendix D retailer benefit for value analysis) A Powerful Sales Tool Bridal Registry Customer Acquisitions Details -Pilot programs have created increases in average gift registry purchases of between 40% to 60% for client retailers. -Charitable Registry Programs encourage couples to inform their guests about their gift registry – a key sales hurdle for retailers. -Guests have a clear incentive to buy from the participating retailers as opposed to other stores where the couple is registered. -Bridal Boutiques are struggling to get brides to complete sales in their stores as brides move towards online wholesalers. -Florists need differentiated service offerings for couples in order to stand out in a crowded market. -Bridal customers are extremely high-margin customers for retailers, so stores are always searching for sales incentives for couples. -Unique added-value offering for engaged couples. -Improved advertising and public relations outreach to attract new couples to their stores. -A key aspect of the program is that retailers do NOT make a donation to charity for every wedding purchase. Retailers only make donations on wedding purchases by those couples who choose to sign up for the program and select a nonprofit recipient through the I Do Foundation. Targeted Sales Incentive -This ensures that retailers only make donations when a couple is interested enough in the program to select a charitable recipient. -Store associates can choose to use the Charitable Registry Program with some clients and not with others. Customer Loyalty -Charitable giving options greatly increase customer loyalty + satisfaction. Improved -CWS strives to promote its corporate clients as good corporate citizens Corporate Image and community-minded companies. Make a Purchase; -When every dollar spent raises donations for their charity, couples have Make a Difference the satisfaction of knowing their spending is making a difference -Couples sign up for the program at their local store and can select their charity there or online through the I Do Foundation. It’s Easy; It’s Free -CWS’s convenient services are provided at absolutely no cost. Flexible Charity Selection Options Convenient Wedding Planning Services -Couples can choose from the Foundation’s carefully screened nonprofit partners or select their own local organization. -CWS provides every couple with online planning tools and a personal wedding website creator. These services help simplify the wedding planning process. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 9 Market Analysis "We have observed a growing trend of couples adding a charitable focus to their weddings. It's a meaningful way to start their married life together." -- Millie Martini Bratten, Editor in Chief of BRIDE'S magazine Key Industry Statistics4 Number of Couples who Marry Each Year Total Size of Wedding Industry Average Spending/Wedding Potential Market for CWS cause marketing programs Potential Spending in CWS Market 2.4M $70B $30,000 1.2M couples/yr $35B+/yr I. WHY WEDDINGS? The I Do Foundation was created to capitalize upon the unique opportunity that weddings provide for raising charitable donations. The wedding industry has several key characteristics that make it the perfect industry in which to launch successful cause-related marketing programs. Industry Size Each year, approximately 2.4 million couples get married, feeding a steady $70 billion industry. The constant addition of new couples intent on having the wedding of their dreams has created a nearly “recession-proof” market.5 As an indicator of the industry’s strength, while most other magazine markets saw significant revenue drops in 2000 and 2001, advertising revenues for major bridal magazines actually increased by 6%-11%.6 The size and stability of the wedding industry present CWS with a lucrative target for cause-related marketing programs. Catalyzing charitable giving trends in such a large and dense consumer market has the potential to raise hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars for charity. High per Customer Spending With almost $30,000 of spending at the average wedding, bridal customers represent one of the most coveted market segments in the retail industry. Replenished on an annual basis, wielding substantial budgets and facing a firm deadline, engaged couples are hungry for information and poised to make purchases. According to Modern Bride magazine, during the six months prior to and the six months following a wedding the average couple will make more buying decisions and purchase more products and services than at any other time in their lives. High per customer spending is critical for successful cause-related marketing programs. Most causerelated marketing programs are focused on sales of a single product line or class of purchases by partner retailers. For CWS, a single customer spends $6,000 on gift registry purchases alone, with the opportunity for capturing double or triple that amount through other wedding services. These high spending rates enable CWS to more easily cover program management and marketing costs. Conde Nast Bridal Group, 2003 and The Knot, 2003 Tom Curtin, senior vice president and publisher of Bridal Guide, 2001 6 Magazine Publishers of America and the Publishers Information Bureau. 4 5 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 10 High Gross Margins The once-in-a-lifetime aura of weddings lowers engaged couples’ price sensitivity, allowing vendors to garner extremely high gross margins. Bridal boutiques enjoy extremely high sales margins – some dress manufacturers require that vendors sell their dresses with at least a 200% mark-up7. Caterers and florists usually charge “wedding fees,” which set their wedding package prices at 30%-50% higher than for other products. Even gift registry retailers, who are limited by the pricing in the rest of the store8, highly value registry customers because bridal registries represent the perfect opportunity to begin a profitable life-long relationship with a new family. High gross margins make cause-related marketing programs much more attractive for wedding retailers and service providers. Increasing sales rates and attracting new couples is incredibly valuable to wedding companies, and a 5% donation rate is relatively small in comparison to their total gross margin. Intense Competition for Customer Acquisition High gross margins and enormous per customer spending rates fuel intense competition for bridal customers. This competition is reflected by the extremely large advertising expenditures of wedding retailers and service providers. According to Advertising Age, in 1998 the top three bridal magazines generated an average of $191 in revenues per reader, compared to an average of $76 in revenues per reader in the top three travel magazines and an average of $54 in revenues per reader in the top three women's magazines. These rates reflect retailers’ constant struggle to find new avenues to attract high-spending engaged couples. Getting couples into the store is only the beginning of the challenge for wedding retailers. Couples (particularly brides) do extensive comparison shopping for nearly every aspect of their wedding— from gowns and bridesmaid dresses to flowers and caterers. In addition, most couples register for gifts at more than two stores, which leaves retailers scrambling to attract wedding guests to buy from their registry first. Wedding retailers are constantly seeking tools to close wedding contracts and increase couple and guest spending. One retail strategy is to develop gift registry incentive programs, including: registry completion programs in which couples can buy items off of their own registry at a 10% discount; gift card programs that reward couples with in-store credit certificates of varying amounts depending on total registry spending; and partner rewards programs that provide registrants with discounts at partner wedding stores. CWS is an effective and flexible variation on these incentive programs that can serve in conjunction with other programs or as a stand-alone promotion. The Culture of Weddings Weddings are highly symbolic events. Couples see weddings as reflection of their relationship, and parents often see weddings as a reflection of their family. Consequently, couples are looking for opportunities to imbue their celebration with their values. Moreover, many couples become overwhelmed by the extravagance and cost of their wedding, creating a critical opportunity for CWS’s charitable wedding programs. CWS has interviewed the I Do Foundation’s boutique advisors to obtain pricing information in the industry. Average gross margins range from 30%-45% for most retailers in the registry market (garnered from public financial statements from major stores including Target, Federated Dept. Stores, May Company, and Williams-Sonoma). 7 8 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 11 II. THE CHARITABLE WEDDING MARKET "Now, some couples in the post 9/11, post-Iraq-war era are trying to balance the day's sweetness and white-silk idealism with the realities of life beyond the chapel. Some are turning to charity to give their wedding day a deeper social context." --New York Times, June 8, 2003 As wedding spending rises, engaged couples are beginning to examine expenses more closely. Increasingly, they are considering how to bring a charitable focus to their weddings. Shifting demographics, coupled with a growing consumer preference for products associated with charitable causes, point to an emerging market for charitable wedding services. Market Size: Charitable Wedding Services MARKET SIZE: 1.2 million couples per year TOTAL SPENDING: $35 billion per year CWS estimates that the potential market for charitable giving at weddings includes 1.2 million couples each year, spending over $35 billion dollars on their weddings: - 2.4 million couples get married each year spending $70 billion Approximately 64% of these couples register for gifts and make wedding purchases from the mid and upper scale retailers targeted by CWS.9 Cause-related marketing research shows that 80% of consumers would switch brands to support a social cause.10 $70 billion X 64% X 80% = $35 billion CWS enables retailers to target socially-conscious engaged couples in this lucrative market. Sociallyfocused couples are wealthier and more educated than average. According to Cone/Roper Reports, cause-related marketing has the strongest impact on consumers who have attended college and earn $30,000-plus annually – by a two to one margin these consumers are more likely to have made a cause-related marketing purchase than consumers at large. Changing Demographics: Charitable Weddings Trend A number of key shifts in the demographics of engaged couples have helped to fuel a general rise in charitable giving at weddings: 11 Couples marrying later in life: In 1950 the average bride was 18 years old. In 1970 she was 20. Today the average bride is almost 29 years old and the average groom is over 30. Couples living together before marriage: Today, almost 60% of couples live together before getting married. Consequently, many couples have already built households and are looking for non-traditional registry options. Rising average incomes: The average combined household income of engaged couples is $55,880 and over 70% of couples pay for their own weddings and honeymoons. Couples From CWS compilation of target retailer market shares as reported by Brides Magazine, 2002 Roper Study of Today’s Bride, Greenfield Online, and Cone/Roper 2001 11 Sources: Brides Magazine, Modern Bride magazine, National Center for Health Statistics 2003, Roper Study of Today’s Bride, PRIMEDIA Research 2000, Globe Research 2001, The Knot 2004. 9 10 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 12 are more independent and wealthy than ever before, creating an opening for alternative gift options. Rising rate of second marriages: Approximately 30% of today’s marriages are second marriages. These couples are less likely to need traditional gifts as they are often combining households instead of building them from scratch. With these demographic shifts, couples are looking for alternatives to the traditional gift registry and wedding planning process. As the Philadelphia Inquirer noted in December of 2001, “More and more weddings are incorporating charitable giving – in imaginative ways.” The Philadelphia Inquirer is not the only publication to highlight the charitable wedding trend. Charitable wedding activities have received coverage in publications and websites such as: Martha Stewart Weddings, Wedding Bells magazine, and The Knot's Wedding Pages. These articles describe a variety of charitable activities that brides and grooms are already doing, such as: Making donations in place of purchasing wedding favors. Donating left-over food to local food banks. Donating flowers and decorations to retirement homes or hospitals. Donating wedding dresses and bridesmaid dresses. Doing a service project in place of a bachelor or bachelorette party. Using environmentally-friendly products, from the invitations to the napkins. The rise in socially-conscious wedding planning has helped to convince retailers of the demand for CWS’s Charitable Registry Programs. Growth in Cause-Related Marketing The growing interest in charitable weddings is underscored by the broader consumer trend in which customers prefer to do business with companies associated with a good cause. A 2001 Cone/Roper study found that over 80% of consumers are likely to switch to a brand associated with a social cause if price and quality are equivalent. In addition, over 79% of adults surveyed said companies have a responsibility to support charity. U.S. corporations have responded, increasing their spending on cause-related marketing activities by 400% from 1990 to 1998, according to IEG. This increase has been driven by consistent findings that American consumers change brands and increase spending as a result of cause-related marketing activities. According to Ed Keller, Executive Vice President of Roper Starch Worldwide, in today’s business climate, "Products will have to meet not only the price and quality demands of consumers, but their personal values as well. Given that environment, cause-related marketing is a dramatic way to build brand equity." Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 13 III. TARGET RETAIL MARKETS Wedding Gift Registry Retailers CWS’s primary targets are major retailers in the wedding gift registry market. The gift market comprises a significant portion of the wedding industry with over $19 billion in gift sales each year.12 Over 90% of couples register for wedding gifts and average gift spending is over $6,000. An average of 180 guests attend each wedding and most wedding gifts cost between $65-$125.13 Department stores have long dominated the wedding gift market with 67% of couples registering at these stores. However, 37% of couples register with mass retailers and 28% with specialty stores, giving these companies a significant market share. The Wedding Gift Registry Market Percentage of Couples that Register at Major Retailers JCPenney 30%* Marshall Fields Target 29%* Bed, Bath and Beyond Macy’s 18% Williams-Sonoma Dillards 12% Foleys Crate & Barrel 10% Filenes *Current I Do Foundation clients for pilot charitable registry program. 9%* 7% 5% 3% 3% Data from Brides Magazine, 2002 All of these stores are actively seeking additional marketing avenues to reach lucrative, new bridal customers and increase gift registry spending. Moreover, department stores view gift registries for engaged couples as an opportunity to acquire lifelong customers. Consequently, these stores pour significant resources into providing the highest quality bridal registry services. Market Segments CWS has divided potential gift registry clients into four market segments: 1. Upper-end Retailers Retailers serving middle and upper income couples provide one of the most lucrative opportunities for CWS. These stores’ gift registries are larger (couples in this demographic receive $6,000-$10,000 in gifts) and individual product margins are much higher than for other retailers. Consequently, these retailers can more easily afford to adopt a charitable registry program. 12 13 Retailer Crate & Barrel Williams-Sonoma Pottery Barn Bloomingdales Restoration Hardware # of Stores 80 200+ 150+ 34 100+ Market Share7 10% 5% 1% 3% 1% The Knot 2004 Modern Bride magazine; Brides magazine, The Knot 2004. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 14 2. Major Department Stores The country’s major department stores serving middle income customers are a solid target for CWS. Federated Department Stores (Macy’s, Burdines, and Macy’s affiliates) dominates this market segment. The large number of stores controlled by each of these retailers would make any one of these stores a major client. 3. Major Mid-Range Retailers The largest share of couples register with mid-range retailers. The major limitation of these clients is their smaller average registry size. By managing to attract middle-income clientele, Target has become the fastest growing gift registry provider in the industry. 4. Niche Retailers CWS has identified a number of smaller retailers that have carved out niche markets within the gift registry market. These retailers are particularly eager to adopt tools to better compete with major department stores in order to increase their guest spending percentage for each registry. The incentive for increased guest spending created by charitable registry programs is particularly important for these stores. Retailer Federated May Company Dillards Marshall Fields* Retailer JCPenney* Target* Bed, Bath & Beyond Linens ‘n Things* # of Stores 431 400+ 200+ 64 Market Share7 21% 9% 12% 9% # of Stores 1040 1107 500+ 390 Market Share 30% 29% 7% 2% Retailer # of Market Share Stores Pier One 1100 1% Mikasa* 170 <1% Ross-Simons* 15 <1% Kitchen Etc.* 17 <1% REI 66 <1% Fortunoff 7 <1% Michael C. Fina 100+ <1% *Current I Do Foundation clients for pilot charitable registry program. CWS is NOT currently targeting two additional gift registry market segments: 1. Discount Retailers: Retailers such as Wal-mart and Kohl’s do not have the necessary product margins to easily adopt a charitable gift registry program. 2. Luxury Retailers: This is a difficult market segment to enter because retailers such as Tiffany’s and Neiman Marcus are skeptical about whether cause-related marketing programs will help them attract their target customer. These stores rely on their prestige to attract wealthy clientele who do not necessarily fit the profile of a typical CWS couple. However, these retailers may move to join the charitable registry trend in the mid to long-term Boutique and Floral Markets Bridal boutiques seek to capitalize on all of the women’s wedding attire spending. Women spend an average of $799 on the bridal gown, $735 on bridesmaid dresses, and an additional $300-$400 on accessories (veils, garters, shoes, etc).14 High-end boutiques often sell dresses for over $5,000. 14 Conde Nast Bridal Group - 2003 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 15 Flowers remain an “essential” part of every wedding: the average spending on flowers is $967, but as wedding floral consultant Lisa Long notes, most couples that hire florists spend more: “Most couples spend an average of $1,500 on their wedding flowers… We've seen weddings for between $10,000 and $20,000. It just depends on your budget."15 Product margins in both markets are extremely high: bridal boutiques regularly begin with a baseline markup of 100% on the designer pricing. Some bridal gown designers require boutiques to start with at least a 200% markup on their dresses in order to maintain brand quality. Florists also set 200+% product markups on wedding arrangements. These high product margins provide florists and bridal boutiques with the flexibility to implement charitable wedding programs. The bridal attire and floral markets are largely filled by small local boutiques and florists. Although CWS aims to develop a turnkey solution that can be easily adapted to local boutiques and florists stores, over the next three years, CWS will focus on developing charitable programs for the national chain stores in these markets. National Bridal Boutiques David’s Bridal – 180 Boutiques – David’s is the largest boutique chain in the country and plans to keep growing with over 150 new stores planned by 2005. Owned by the May Company Department Stores, the company focuses on providing affordable gowns (all gowns cost less than $1000) and capturing auxiliary spending (bridesmaid dresses and accessories). David’s sells gowns under its own label as well as the Gloria Vanderbilt and Oleg Cassini lines. Priscilla of Boston – 10 Boutiques – For over 50 years, Priscilla of Boston has been a premier name in the bridal industry with the finest gowns available. Priscilla’s higher-end brides spend an average of $2,500 on their gowns. Priscilla of Boston was purchased by the May Company Department Stores in 2001. Jessica McClintock – 43 Boutiques – Built on the company’s prestigious brand name, Jessica McClintock’s boutiques showcase all of the designer’s clothing and fragrance lines. Saks Fifth Avenue – 15 Boutiques – Saks has teamed up with Vera Wang to develop bridal boutiques with the finest (and most expensive) gowns in the country. National Florists 1-800-Flowers.com – 125 Stores – This national flower power does much more than online and phone sales. With over a hundred 1-800-Flowers shops across the country, the company provides thousands of couples with wedding services each year. KaBloom – 66 Stores – KaBloom has quickly grown from its Boston roots to develop stores in 11 states. Often called “the Starbucks of Flowers,” KaBloom focuses on convenience with locations that are strategically located in high-traffic areas and long store hours. KaBloom is trying hard to compete more effectively in the lucrative wedding market. 15 The Arizona Republic - 2003 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 16 Competitive Analysis I Do Foundation and CWS: A Unique Service Offering The I Do Foundation is the only organization in the country that currently provides charitable gift registry services. Although a few other organizations, such as marriedforgood.com and justgive.org, provide information about having a socially-conscious wedding, the I Do Foundation is the only organization that has developed relationships with major retailers and built a platform for charitable registry management. While it is possible that a new nonprofit or for-profit organization will enter this market and create a charitable wedding registry platform and services structure, the more likely source of competition for CWS comes from the retailers themselves. As charitable wedding registry programs become more common, some retailers will begin to look for opportunities to create and operate their own platforms for the programs. Other Market Players’ Entry Potential CWS has carefully examined the potential for existing companies (and nonprofits) in the wedding industry to begin providing retailers with charitable giving program services: Online Gift Registries: Few online registry companies have survived the bursting of the Internet bubble. TheKnot.com and WeddingChannel.com are the primary survivors, and both having built a steady stream of couples using their site each year (Wedding Channel serves almost a million couples each year). Although these companies could enter this market, all of the online registry providers have shown an aversion to getting involved in offline store relationships, consulting, or management. Moreover, without any experience with charitable giving or cause-related marketing, these companies are unlikely to enter this market. Nonprofit Giving Portals: The major nonprofit online giving sites (justgive.org and networkforgood.org) have the base level of infrastructure necessary for donation management and nonprofit selection by couples. These portals, however, have consistently maintained a focus on direct, credit card donation programs. They avoided the brief “charity mall” explosion during the Internet boom and have never developed cause-related marketing programs. Without specific industry experience or store interfacing technology, these portals are unlikely to have the capacity to effectively enter the charitable wedding market. Retail Consultants: There are a variety of individual consultants providing program development support, marketing strategy, customer satisfaction evaluation, and other support for major retailers. These consultants are extremely unlikely to take on the expense and investment of developing the charitable giving systems necessary for entering this market. Barriers to Entry for New Companies Based upon CWS’s specialized product and targeted consumer market, there are a number of barriers to entry for new companies. CWS’s competitive advantages include: First Mover Advantage: CWS will capture significant scale and retailer relationship advantages due to its first mover position in the charitable wedding services market. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 17 Building on the I Do Foundation’s relationships with industry leaders, CWS will solidify the I Do Foundation’s role as THE charitable registry services provider for retailers. Established Nonprofit Partnerships: The I Do Foundation’s broad range of partnerships with national and regional nonprofit organizations will help CWS market its services to socially-conscious couples. In addition to its expertise in the nonprofit field, the I Do Foundation name brings critical credibility and integrity to CWS. Robust Technical Infrastructure: The I Do Foundation’s donation management and disbursement system, online charity selection system, and pilot program interfacing with existing retail partners provides a solid base for CWS’s development of charitable registry programs. Public Relations Platform: The I Do Foundation’s existing public relations success and established media relationships will provide additional value to CWS’s retail partners. As the first national nonprofit to enable couples to share a part of their wedding spending with charity, the I Do Foundation offers a compelling story that can be used to market CWS and its retail partners. Most Likely Competitor for CWS: The Retailers CWS believes that its most likely competitors are the targeted retailers themselves. Retailers may begin to develop their own internal systems for managing their charitable programs. In the past two years, online registry service providers have already experienced the trend of retailers shifting to internal development. Companies such as Marcole and Wedding Channel initially secured contracts with major retailers to develop online gift registry solutions. Within a few years, however, these retailers moved to in-house online registries, cutting out the service providers. CWS fully expects that some of its retail clients will do the same: start by contracting CWS to create charitable gift registry programs for their stores before moving to an in-house management system once the model is proven and the initial setup costs have been incurred. CWS has developed responses to combat this competitive pressure: Sources of CWS Advantage Over Retail In-House Systems Scale Advantages To continue to provide cost-effective services for retailers, CWS will need to capitalize upon its first-mover advantage to build scale advantages in donation management, customer service, nonprofit partnerships, and technical operations. With a single automated platform for serving couples and managing donations, CWS will be able to provide retailers with high-quality, low cost services. Service Upgrading CWS will continue to upgrade and improve its service features for both stores and couples. Improved donation tracking, customer service, and online couple wedding services will enable CWS to continue to provide added value service offering for stores. Brand Legitimacy CWS will work to establish the I Do Foundation brand as a sign of legitimacy and quality in the wedding industry. This will provide retailers with an ongoing incentive to use CWS to provide couples with a familiar, nonprofit brand association Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 18 CWS Response: Model Flexibility if Retailer Seeks to Develop In-House System Although these competitive responses may help CWS maintain its role as an active player in the charitable wedding services market, retailers will almost certainly begin to compete with CWS by establishing their own internal systems. As a result, CWS has developed an additional store services model that will enable the company to continue to serve these independent retailers’ charitable registries. Under this model, CWS will offer three complementary services to stores that want to develop in-house program management systems: CWS Service Offerings for Retailers Creating In-House Systems Program Consulting CWS will help stores design and implement their own programs. CWS will provide clients with consulting on systems setup, program structuring, marketing strategy, and training design. Technology Licensing CWS will develop its existing nonprofit selection and donation management systems into a turnkey software solution that stores can license and integrate within their own system. Brand Licensing CWS will license the I Do Foundation to stores looking for the legitimacy of the Foundation’s reputation and charitable standing. The I Do Foundation will act as a quality control agent for consumers by ensuring 100% of the donations are passed to the couple’s selected charities and that selected charities pass the Foundation’s standard financial and operational tests. Clients will be able to purchase any combination of the above services. With a flexible service model for retailers, CWS will effectively respond to the changing contours of the charitable wedding services market. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 19 SWOT Analysis The following is a summary of the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats of CWS as identified in the Business Description, Market Analysis and Competitive Analysis. This analysis was used as the basis for developing the Marketing, Management, and Operations plans. Strengths Established organization feasibility through a successful pilot program. Established relationships with almost a dozen retailers including 3 of the 6 market leaders (JC Penney, Target and Marshall Fields). First mover advantage. Only organization in the wedding industry to provide this service. Weaknesses Need for additional staff members with strong retail operations experience and additional wedding industry expertise. Need for additional cash funding to advance the organization to the next level. Parent nonprofit organization is relatively young (started in 2001) and small (6 full-time staff plus technical consultants). Established technology infrastructure. Establish non-profit partner relationships. Key advisors who are leaders in the industry and business (Gregg Renfrew, Michael Felberbaum, Lauren Sueskind, etc). Solid management team with solid business, nonprofit, and technology experience. Six full months of operating funds currently on hand. Opportunities Large market potential, 1.2 million couples spending $35B per year. Industry trend of one major retailer starting bridal programs and all others following suit. Threats The emergence of new entrants – particularly in-house Charitable Registry Program development by major retailers. Future opportunities in the high margin boutique and floral markets. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 20 Marketing Plan Over the next three years, CWS aims to provide national store integrations of charitable registry programs for 3-5 retail clients. In addition, CWS will work to develop charitable registry programs for one national bridal boutique and one major florist chain. CWS will build upon its current base of retail clients in the pilot charitable registry program to close contracts with major wedding retailers. In addition to these direct sales strategies, CWS will work to build brand recognition through public relations, industry outreach, and partnership development. I. SALES CYCLE: GRADUAL INTEGRATION CWS’s incremental sales model enables the company to gradually build a base of solid retail clients. For all of CWS charitable programs, clients are moved through the following progression: PHASE 1: PHASE 2: PHASE 3: Pilot Program Integrate retailers online through the I Do Foundation website. Draw couples from I Do Foundation network. Regional Store Integration Clients choose to integrate the charitable wedding programs into stores in a single market region. CWS provides significant setup support and consulting for each store. National Store Integration Clients expand charitable wedding programs into all of their stores across the country. CWS provides centralized associate support and donation management. CWS will begin Regional Store Integration negotiations with the first set of pilot clients after the completion of pilot analyses in the first quarter of 2004. The initiation of the first set of Regional Store Integrations is scheduled for the second half of 2004. In the first quarter of 2004, CWS has already closed new pilot contracts with Marshall Fields and REI and is in ongoing discussions with the Federated Department Stores (Macy’s and Bloomingdales). II. MARKETING STRATEGIES FOR TARGET CUSTOMER SEGMENTS Retailers Direct Sales: Build Client Base through Existing Industry Contacts The I Do Foundation already has a successful track record acquiring corporate clients. CWS’s sales team is led by Executive Vice President, Peter Murray, who has successfully closed pilot program contracts with major retailers including Target, JC Penney, Linens ‘n Things, Marshall Fields, REI, Mikasa, Amazon.com, Ross-Simons, and Kitchen Etc. Marketing materials have been developed to assist in acquiring new store partners, including documentation about the program, examples of cause-related marketing received by current partners, and a cost-benefit analysis of the program from the stores’ perspective. CWS will hire a sales director in July ‘04 and a CEO in January ‘05 who will work with the Executive Vice President to expand the current client base. CWS will leverage the experience gained managing these successful relationships to expand its program to upper-end retailers16 such as Bloomingdales, Crate & Barrel, and Williams-Sonoma, 16 Note that these are not luxury retailers (Tiffany’s, etc) – CWS is not targeting luxury retailers at this time. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 21 as well as major department stores such as Macy’s, the May Department Stores (Filene’s, Foley’s, etc., and Dillards). It is critical for CWS to target these retailers for two reasons: 1) These top retailers will increase the overall brand value of the I Do Foundation and will encourage more couples to seek and register for CWS. 2) Upper-end retailers have higher gross margins and are consequently more easily able to afford program donations and management fee payments. Intense competitive pressure among wedding industry leaders plays a key role in expanding CWS sales in the wedding market. Retailers are extremely sensitive to the moves made by competitors. CWS will capitalize on this pressure by publicizing existing partners to compel new clients to adopt CWS programs. CWS will promote sales to bridal boutique and florist shop chains through direct pitches to management. CWS has already initiated discussions with each of the major bridal boutiques and florists and has received significant interest from several stores. Relationship Development: Expand Advisory Board and Leverage Contacts The I Do Foundation pilot program and The Wedding List have demonstrated that a cause-related marketing approach to gift registries provides clear financial benefits for retailers. However, as in all business, it is relationships that ultimately close deals. The CWS team is working closely with former The Wedding List CEO Gregg Renfrew and other advisors in the industry to expand relationships with store partners. In addition, beginning in May 2004, CWS has budgeted significant funds to hire an industry expert as CEO for the program in order to increase access to key retail decision-makers. Over the next three years, CWS will work to expand its Advisory Board to include additional wedding industry experts who can help guide CWS through the first Regional and National Program Integration phases of our services for retailers. Industry Branding: Increase Media Coverage To help lay the groundwork for the CWS program, the I Do Foundation has spent the past six months targeting some of its public relations efforts towards the business media. To date, the Foundation has received coverage in outlets such as CBS Marketwatch and the MarketPlace Morning Report, as well as Fast Company Magazine, New York Times, Parade Magazine, and Boston Globe. This coverage has been important component of I Do’s strategy to build name recognition and credibility with future retail clients. The I Do Foundation has also created a monthly e-newsletter entitled Charitable Wedding News, targeted to industry experts. The email-based publication reaches over 2,000 bridal consultants, retailers, and service providers and will help CWS build brand awareness within the industry. Engaged Couples and Their Guests In-store Couple Acquisition The primary way in which couples will hear about Charitable Registry Programs will be directly from associates in CWS client retailers’ stores. As a fully integrated bridal registry services, the Charitable Registry Program will be included in retailers’ in-store wedding materials and each store will train its associates to offer the program to engaged couples. CWS will provide sample Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 22 in-store program promotion materials, registry enclosure cards, and program brochures for each store to use as templates. Marketing Integration with Retail Clients CWS will advise its retail clients on how to integrate the CWS program into their existing marketing campaigns. All of the stores CWS is targeting already conduct extensive marketing of their wedding services through bridal magazines, wedding shows, direct mail, as well as through in-store promotional activities. The CWS sales director and sales staff will work with each partner to assess current marketing efforts and suggest ways to integrate a cause-related marketing message. Retailers will be responsible for program marketing costs. Guest Purchasing Couples will use the usual means for informing their guests about their registry (registry enclosure cards, word of mouth, bridal shower, etc). Guests will be able to access their couple’s gift registry at their local store, on the store’s website, or through the couple’s personal wedding website at the I Do Foundation. Guests represent a key viral marketing opportunity for retailers with Charitable Registry Programs. There is an average of 182 guests at each wedding17 – those guests who learn about the program by making a purchase from a Charitable Registry will help to spread the word to other couples or use the service themselves in the future. III. PRICING STRATEGY Donation Rate: Clients Set Their Rates CWS enables retail clients to set their own charitable giving rate for the program. Currently, the average donation rate by pilot clients is just over 5%, and more than half of the clients have increased their giving rate since beginning with CWS.18 In store integrations may include tiered donation rates (4% for first $500 of purchases, 5% for $500-$800 in spending, etc). Management Fee: A Flat Fee for All Clients CWS adds a 1% management fee on all purchases through the charitable programs to the stores’ donation rate. To date, retailers in the pilot program have paid a 1%-2% management fee. The 1% fee level gives CWS an average of $25 of revenue per couple in the charitable program. CWS estimates that the venture can break even with per couple revenue of approximately $10-$14. Marketing Costs CWS maintains extremely low per customer acquisition costs by focusing on enabling retailers to promote the Charitable Registry Programs in their own stores. Retailers pay for all in-store materials, program advertising, and associate training. The primary marketing costs for CWS are the salaries for sales staff who are focused on closing contracts with major retailers. CWS projects that total sales and marketing costs will be $83,000 in 2004 and grow to $250,000 by 2006. At these rates, CWS’s marketing budget will be equal to 15%-18% of net revenue. CWS does some direct marketing to attract couples to its online pilot programs with retailers. Google has given a grant to provide advertising to the I Do Foundation, and CWS has had significant success with public relations outreach to acquire free media hits. 17 18 The Knot, 2004 5% is a common rate for cause-related marketing initiatives in the retail sector. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 23 IV. SALES TIMELINE Sales Timeline for Gift Registry Developed pilot Added 3 technology; initiated pilots new pilot retail with 6 retail clients. clients. Jan-June 2003 July-Dec 2003 Complete pilot analyses for 9 clients; Add 2-4 additional pilot clients. Add 2-3 additional pilots; Initiate CWS expand integration integration to for 1-2 national clients on store regional locations for basis. 1-3 clients. Initiate integrations for 2-3 additional clients on a regional basis. Add 2-3 additional pilots; expand integration for 2-3 clients to national store locations. Initiate CWS integration for 2-3 additional clients on regional basis. Jan-June 2004 July-Dec 2004 Jan-June 2005 July-Dec 2005 Jan-June 2006 July-Dec 2006 Develop pilot technology for bridal and floral clients. Initiate pilots with 1 florist and 1 bridal boutique chain. Monitor pilots; make improvements. Begin national integrations for 1 florist and 1 boutique chain. Begin technical development to enable localized charitable program development. Initiate outreach to pilot local boutiques and florists for program development. Sales Timeline for Bridal Boutiques and Florists Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 24 Management Plan The I Do Foundation is run by staff of six full-time employees, led by Executive Director Bethany Robertson. The I Do Foundation board of directors is chaired by Kelly Randall, former director of the Pilot International Foundation and Tim Sibley, CTO of StreamSage Inc. A board list is included in the attachments. The I Do Foundation has dedicated two full-time staff members to fill key management roles for CWS. Peter Murray is the Executive Vice President, and Lawrence Miller is the Director of Technology. In addition, Bethany Robertson will dedicate 30% of her time to CWS. The I Do Foundation will hire a CWS Chief Executive Officer with significant retail and bridal experience in January of 2005. CWS’ CEO will report directly to the I Do Foundation executive director. Additional technical staff, a sales director, and support staff will be hired in 2004, and CWS anticipates a total of 16 CWS staff members by the end of 2006. The CWS program will significantly increase the staff size of the I Do Foundation. The management plan has been carefully developed to ensure that there will be appropriate staffing resources to manage the CWS program while maintaining the quality of the I Do Foundation’s current programs. While the CWS staff will quickly become larger than the existing I Do Foundation team, the Foundation’s board of directors has made a strategic choice to grow in this direction. The revenue generated by CWS will enable the Foundation to strengthen its current operations and create a longterm source of programmatic support. In 2004, all CWS staff will work out of the I Do Foundation’s offices in Washington D.C. and Philadelphia. In the second half of 2005, CWS will secure additional office space for the expanded staff team. The I Do Foundation board of directors will have ultimate fiduciary responsibility for the program. I. CURRENT MANAGEMENT TEAM Peter Murray –Executive Vice President (full-time) – Murray is the founder and former President of a minority business development and entrepreneurship training organization in Philadelphia called the Empowerment Group. Murray has extensive experience with business development and corporate partnership development. In particular, he is experienced in the management of business development teams, the development of business plans and market studies, and the execution of viable business ventures. Under Murray’s leadership, the Empowerment Group grew to over 20 staff members providing business consulting and entrepreneurship training services. As a co-founder of the I Do Foundation, Peter has led the organization’s efforts to engage retailers and service providers in charitable giving at weddings. Peter has directed the planning and successful implementation of the CWS pilot program. In his role as Executive Vice-President, he designed the charitable wedding services program, led the acquisition of all of CWS’s corporate clients, conducted extensive industry and market analyses, and developed the company's wedding services suite. Peter has developed strong relationships with gift registry managers at nearly every major department store in the country. For his work with the I Do Foundation, Peter has been recognized by Fast Company magazine as one of the Fast 50 in 2002, a select group of 50 innovators from around the world making a lasting impact on their companies and industries. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 25 Larry Miller – Director of Technology (full time) – Larry contributes his considerable Internet business knowledge and programming expertise to CWS. With 8 years of experience serving as a project leader and systems administrator at DigitalWave, CDNow, and Aquent Consulting, Larry is an expert in web-based applications and technical systems maintenance. Larry has led the I Do Foundation’s technical team for the past two and a half years. Over the past six months, Larry has led the CWS technical team in the development of the pilot product version of our innovative webbased charitable giving services. For his work applying technical innovations to social issues, Larry received an Echoing Green fellowship. Bethany Robertson – I Do Foundation Executive Director (30% time) – At the I Do Foundation, Bethany focuses on developing wedding industry partnerships, shaping the organization’s charitable giving services, and raising funds for new programs. Bethany has extensive experience navigating the interface between charitable giving, technology, and business development. Most recently, Bethany provided strategic consulting for the Community Technology Foundation of California and completed a report on information technology infrastructure and nonprofits organizations. Bethany has been recognized by Fast Company magazine as one of 2002’s Fast 50, a group of 50 innovators from around the world making a lasting impact on their companies and industries. She earned a Masters Degree in Public Policy from UC Berkeley, and is also a current Echoing Green fellow. II. KEY HIRES IN 2004 The Executive Vice President will continue to lead CWS until January 2005 when a CEO is hired. Working closely with the Director of Technology, the VP will continue to focus on acquiring new high-end gift registry retail clients and new pilot deals with national florists and bridal boutiques. As clients are brought on, CWS will make the following hires: July 2004: Sales Director September: Technical Staff, Support Staff January 2005: Chief Executive Officer The I Do Foundation has already begun working with its wedding industry advisors, particularly Gregg Renfrew, to identify potential key staff members. Gregg’s previous experience running The Wedding List and her current role as a gift registry consultant to several New York-based retailers provides her with terrific industry insights and connections. We will also use our network of wedding media contacts to identify qualified applicants from the wedding industry. Chief Executive Officer – The CEO will be responsible for the management of CWS and will report directly to I Do Foundation Board of Directors. The I Do Foundation Board of Directors, Executive Director, and Executive Vice-President, will lead the CEO search process. Joining the team in January of 2005, the CEO will be positioned to prepare CWS to expand the charitable program store integrations into retail clients’ stores across the country. The CEO will bring significant retail management experience and industry connections to the team. Budgeted annual salary rate is $150,000 in 2005 moving to $200,000 by 2007 (with sales based commissions). We will be looking to hire a candidate who has the following strengths: Significant bridal industry connections. Extensive experience developing retail programs. Business relationships with gift registry retailers, florists, and boutiques. Demonstrated success in building a small business or in leading a new business unit within a larger company. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 26 A commitment to social venture enterprise and a supporter of the broader mission of the I Do Foundation. CEO responsibilities will include: Lead charitable program expansion into retail clients’ national network of stores. Develop key contacts with gift registry, florist, and bridal boutique retailers. Manage day-to-day activities of CWS, including financial management and staff oversight. Formulate and implement strategies for continued expansion of CWS programs. Sales Director – The Executive Vice President and Executive Director will recruit and hire a Sales Director in July 2004. In addition to prior B-to-B sales experience, CWS will seek candidates with recent bridal industry experience. Budgeted salary is $80,000. Key responsibilities include: Develop new accounts with gift registry retailers, florists, and bridal boutiques. Manage existing accounts and interface between clients and technical team. Accurately forecast quarterly and monthly revenue streams. Manage personnel activities of sales staff (hiring, training, coaching, motivating). Technical Staff – The Director of Technology will be responsible for recruiting technical staff to assist with the implementation of store integrations. These technical staff members will function as sales engineers. They will need to have the technical expertise to understand the I Do Foundation website and be able to communicate with clients about integrating CWS into their retail operations. Ideally, these staff members will possess skills in PERL programming and database management. One technical staff member will be hired in June 04 and another hire will be made in June 05. Budgeted salary is $40,000 in 2004. Support Staff – The support staff member will provide assistance to retail sales associates working directly with wedding customers and handle online service requests by couples in the program. In addition, he/she will provide assistance as needed to the sales director. Budgeted Salary is $30,000. III. FUTURE STAFFING GROWTH CWS envisions its staff expansion over the next 3 years as follows: This year, the CWS will hire 5 new staff members; we will hire an additional 6 staff in Year 2; and we will hire 3 more members in Year 3 for a total of 16 staff members at the end of Year 3. Staffing Chart Staffing Levels after Year 1 (Feb 2004 to Jan 2005) Chief Executive Officer Director of Technology Executive Vice President Sales Director Support Staff #1 Programmer #1 New in Year 2 (Feb 2005 to Jan 2006) New in Year 3 (Feb 2006 to Jan 2007) Sales Staff #1 (February) Director of Support (May) Technical Staff #2 (June) Support Leader (August) Chief Financial Officer (December) Human Resources Staff (January) Admin Assistant #1 (January) Website Designer (January) Support Staff #2 (February) Programmer #3 (May) Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 27 Advisory Board CWS has assembled a broad group of technical and business development advisors to augment the program's technical and business development skills. CWS’s teams taps into each advisors experience and networks through frequent one-on-one meetings. The advisory team includes: Gregg Renfrew – Wedding Industry Expert – The former CEO of The Wedding List, Martha Stewart’s multi-channel wedding registry company, brings extensive wedding industry experience to the CWS team. Furthermore, with over a year of experience implementing a donation program at The Wedding List, Renfrew provides an insider view of the benefits of CWS’s services. Michael Felberbaum – Business Expert – As the former Director of Marketing for Chelsea Paper and writer for Dessy Interactive, Felberbaum brings critical wedding industry experience to the project. Felberbaum is currently the Executive Director of the Empowerment Group. Lauren Sueskind – Wedding Public Relations Expert – Ms. Sueskind, former Director of Public Relations for the Conde Nast Bridal Group, has a clear sense of shifts and opportunities in the wedding industry. Sueskind is now Director of PR for Self, another Conde Nast publication. Tim Sibley – Technical Expert – Mr. Sibley is the Co-founder and Chief Scientist of StreamSage, Inc., which provides advanced software technology for managing audio-visual content for organizations such as NPR, NASA, Harvard, and AOL. Prior to founding StreamSage, Sibley was a business consultant at Easton Consultants and the CTO of an international scientific research organization. Philip Gordon – IT and Business Expert – Concurrently serving as Executive Director of the Fisher Center for Information Technology and Marketplace Transformation, and as a Haas School of Business lecturer at UC Berkeley, Mr. Gordon’s expertise is informed by over 20 years of IT management experience. Denise Cante – Marketing Expert – As Vice President for DeVries Public Relations, Cante contributes her experience leading major communications and marketing efforts for companies including Amazon.com and Crest. Rose Sculley – Business Expert – Currently serving as the Director of Corporate and Foundation Development for Women’s World Banking, Sculley held the position of Finance and Administration Manager for ten years, where she was responsible for financial management of a $9 million global budget, cash flow, accounting, finance, budgeting, technology and administrative support. CWS’s current staff is well positioned to move the program from its pilot stage to early implementation. With assistance from its advisors and guidance from I Do Foundation staff, CWS has developed an effective plan for steady staff growth based upon anticipated sales and program expansion. See Appendix C for staff resumes and a list of I Do Foundation Board Members. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 28 Operations Plan I. OVERVIEW Through its pilot programs, the I Do Foundation has already developed the majority of the operational infrastructure required to implement the CWS program. The I Do Foundation has designed the sales and marketing materials needed to acquire new store partners, including documentation about the program, examples of cause-related marketing received by current partners, and a cost-benefit analysis of the program from the stores’ perspective. The organization’s current contracts with 10 stores provide CWS with excellent leverage for obtaining new retail client sales. Most importantly, the I Do Foundation has already created the technical infrastructure needed to take the CWS program to scale. Through the development and implementation of the pilot charitable registry program, the I Do Foundation has completed a set of fully operational charitable registry programs complete with store services, nonprofit selection, customer service, donation receipt and disbursement, and registry tracking systems. These services complement the I Do Foundation’s other charitable wedding services for couples, including a wedding website creator, donation registry, and charitable favor service. Experience running the pilot programs has provided the I Do Foundation with a clear understanding of the costs of managing the CWS initiative. Moreover, once the CWS program is integrated into the retailers’ existing registry services, the retailers will be responsible for the majority of promotion and customer service costs. Current Status CWS is a revenue-generating project of the I Do Foundation and is based out of the I Do Foundation’s offices in Philadelphia, PA, and Washington, DC. Since launching the pilot programs at the beginning of 2003, the I Do Foundation has built a solid foundation for CWS’s growth: Activities to Date Completed a comprehensive market and competitor analysis. Allocated funds for two full-time CWS staff members and 30% of the ED’s time. Acquired almost a dozen major wedding retailers as corporate clients. Proved significant gift registry sales increase through pilot charitable gift registry programs for its first set corporate clients. Received news coverage in dozens of bridal magazines, newspapers, and business magazines regarding major retailers’ adoption of the charitable registry program. Managed charitable registry services for almost 1000 engaged couples. Raised $163,000 in support of CWS expansion. Present CWS is currently focusing on the following objectives for the 2nd and 3rd quarters of 2004: Developing final 2003 program analyses for pilot clients. Adding 1-2 new gift registry clients to the pilot program (REI and Marshall Fields were already added in the first quarter of 2004). Developing pilot charitable programs for 1 bridal boutique chain and 1 florist chain. Building relationships with potential foundation, corporate, and individual funders. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 29 Raising an additional $100,000 by the end of the 3rd Quarter. Next Steps In the fourth quarter of 2004, CWS will focus on the following objectives: Initiating in-store program integrations on a regional basis for 1-2 gift registry retailers. Hiring a CEO with extensive wedding industry executive experience. Maintaining and improving system functionality and wedding and giving services. Planning for national charitable giving program store integrations for retail clients. Preparing to raise the final $120,000 of venture funding in the first quarter of 2005. II. PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT The primary operational challenge for 2004 will be preparing and implementing the in-store integration of Charitable Registry Programs on a regional basis for 1-2 retail clients starting in the fourth quarter. CWS will use the evidence from its pilot programs demonstrating 40%-60% registry sales increases as the key to obtaining in-store contracts with current (or new) retail clients. CWS will use this evidence to convince existing and new clients of the cost-effectiveness of integrating Charitable Registry Programs into their stores and website. CWS will begin this outreach in the summer of 2004 (when final purchases/returns on registries in the pilot will be completed). To ensure that CWS can carefully monitor the success of the integration process and quality of the charitable registry services, CWS will help clients initiate Charitable Registry Programs in stores in a single region. Depending on the size and number of clients choosing to initiate in-store programs, CWS expects to create Charitable Registry Programs in 25-35 individual stores by the end of the first quarter of 2005. In 2005, CWS will expand these program integrations to a national level for 1-2 retail clients. The ongoing addition of new gift registry clients to the pilot program is primarily a marketing challenge. Once a pilot contract is closed with a new retail client, adding that store takes less than two weeks and, with CWS’s automated customer systems, management of the pilot requires minimum staff time and maintenance. Closing new pilot clients, however, will require significant direct sales outreach as outlined in the Marketing Strategies section above. CWS will repeat this cycle each year – adding new pilot clients, beginning regional in-store integrations with pilot clients from the previous year, and expanding program integrations nationally for current regional clients. CWS will provide these retailers with several services, as outlined below. CWS is also working to close contracts with major bridal boutiques and florists. Appendix F includes an outline of a charitable wedding program proposal for KaBloom, which details how the in-store implementation would occur for these kinds of retail clients. III. PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION Technical Integration Moving from its online pilot to the in-store integration model will require CWS to spend significant staff time enabling retail clients to develop the program in stores across the country. CWS’s current technical infrastructure is fully prepared to support this integration. From a technical perspective, the only difference between the online pilot and in-store integration phases is that many couples will sign up for the program in their local store. Increased traffic will require CWS to ramp up server Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 30 capacity and customer service support, but, otherwise, the current technical infrastructure is completely capable of moving into the in-store integration phase. Enabling store associates to sign up couples for the program in the store, CWS will some additional technical development. CWS’s technical staff will work to integrate the Charitable Registry Program into each store’s existing customer technology. There are three levels of technical integration possible with each store: 1. Seamless Entry: For ease of operation, the ideal scenario is full integration of the CWS program into the store’s current customer management system. In practical terms, this would mean that CWS will work with the client to add a check-box indicating whether the customer wanted to participate in the charitable program to the store’s in-store computer system. If the associate checks this box, the customer’s information will then be automatically sent to the CWS database, which would then code that customer as a registrant of that retailer. System Setup Time for CWS Tech Team: One Month per Store. 2. Web-based Entry: For those stores with systems that are antiquated or difficult to integrate, CWS will set up a web-based interface through which sales associates can enter a couple’s registration separately from their registry with the store. This will mean that the associate will most likely collect the couple’s information on paper and then enter all new registrations as a batch at the end of the day into the I Do Foundation system. System Setup Time for CWS Tech Team: One Month for first store, two weeks for each additional store. 3. Fax-based Entry: Some small retailers do not have web access in their stores. Associates in these stores will fax couples’ information to CWS, where customer service staff will enter the couples into our database. Retail clients will pay an additional fee for this option. System Setup Time for CWS Tech Team: One Week per Store. CWS will provide ongoing technical support as retailers upgrade their registry systems; CWS will also be on-call to fix any technical issues or bugs that may arise in the system. Program Setup Consulting CWS will help each retailer create an in-store charitable program that fits well with other wedding services and is easily handled by store associates. CWS will support clients in several capacities: Program Planning: CWS staff will work closely with each client’s wedding management to carefully plan the timing, structure, and implementation of in-store program integrations. Materials Development: CWS will provide sample in-store program promotion materials, registry enclosure cards, and program brochures for each store to use as templates. Each store will pay for the design and printing of all program materials. Staff Training: For each new partner, the CWS staff will develop training materials on the CWS system for use by store associates. In addition, the CWS sales team will meet with managers in the first 3-4 stores with program integrations in order to work out any initial kinks with the system. After the initial training, the CWS will work with the retailer to integrate the training materials into the retailer’s regular associate training. Marketing Integration: CWS will consult with and advise its retail clients on how to integrate the CWS program into their existing marketing campaigns. All of the stores CWS is targeting already conduct extensive marketing of their wedding services through bridal magazines, wedding shows, direct mail, as well as through in-store promotional activities. The CWS sales director and sales staff will work with each partner to assess current marketing efforts and suggest ways to integrate a cause-related marketing message. Retailers will be responsible for program marketing costs. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 31 Quality Control: CWS will use several mechanisms to ensure that retail clients provide couples with accurate Charitable Registry Program information, including: 1. Tiered Implementation: CWS will have the chance to carefully monitor each retailer’s implementation of the program during the regional store integration phase. 2. Associate Training Oversight: CWS will work with each retailer to design training materials and information to be integrated in the store’s regular associate training. 3. Audit Capabilities: CWS has the ability to confirm the accuracy of store reports and payments for registries in the program. In addition, with some couples carefully watching their donations rise, couples also serve as a natural audit of the stores. Couple Services The bulk of customer service needs will be managed by the retail clients’ store associates as they work directly with couples. CWS will be responsible for customer service solely related to the selection of charities and distributions of grants. These services will be provided primarily online using the existing I Do Foundation infrastructure. Based upon our pilot experience, we project per couple service costs at $2.60 vs. per couple revenue of $25. Nonprofit Selection: Couples can easily choose their nonprofit recipient through the I Do Foundation’s nonprofit selection system. This system enables couples to choose from a list of recommended organizations or nominate any charitable organization. The I Do Foundation manages this process and completes screening of any nominated groups. Donation Tracking: Couples can view their current donation total and any disbursements made to their selected charitable organization. Wedding Website Creator: The I Do Foundation provides each couple with an automated process to create their own wedding website with information about their celebration, selected nonprofit, gift registry, and travel information for guests. Customer Support: CWS will provide couples with email based support, online FAQs, and general program information. Associate Support In addition to providing direct support for couples using the I Do Foundation site, CWS support staff will handle service calls and emails from store associates with questions about the charitable program. This association support will add another layer of quality control, permitting CWS to respond immediately to questions arising about the program or any technical glitches. Donation Management and Disbursement Billing of clients for both program donations and the 1% management fees will occur on a monthly basis. At the end of each billing cycle, CWS will run reports for each retailer listing the customer identification numbers of couples who selected the charitable program. The retailers will run reports of spending by each couple (which is automated for all stores) and then CWS will bill the retailers based upon total couple spending. CWS has already successfully implemented this system through its pilot program. The Vice President of Corporate Partnerships will be responsible for conducting the financial analysis of sales and affiliate fees paid and reporting back to the retailers. CWS will track donations for all couples for up to a year after their wedding. Donations raised from a couple’s gift registry, bridal boutique purchases, and floral services will be aggregated with any donations raised through the I Do Foundation’s other donation services. Donations are disbursed on a quarterly basis to the nonprofit organizations in order to minimize the total number of checks the Foundation is required to process for each charity. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 32 Financials By 2007, CWS expects to generate over $300,000 in annual operating profits from annual net revenue of $1.6 million. In addition, CWS will generate over $10 million in annual donations through the charitable wedding programs. Positioned as a value-added service provider for major retailers and service providers in the recession-resistant wedding industry, CWS has a solid financial model based on program management fees from major retailers. NOTE: All of the financial projections provided below do not include any of the donations made by stores. The 1% management fee paid by stores is the only revenue included in these projections. I. REVENUE STREAMS CWS will focus on building the following three revenue streams:19 Gift Registry Client Fees (94% of Projected Revenues) Management fees from retail clients represent the largest portion of CWS’s revenue. Each month, gift registry clients will include an additional 1% payment on all purchases from registries in the program with their donation payment. CWS assumes that couples will have an average of $2,500 in gift registry spending (couples have an average of $6,000 in total gifts and 2.4 registries). Bridal Boutique Client Fees (4% of Projected Revenues) Also a 1% fee paid on a monthly basis. CWS assumes that couples will spend an average of $1,500 on bridal boutique purchases (average of $799 spent on the bridal gown plus 70% of couples selecting bridesmaid dresses at $735 average; 80% of couples purchase accessories at $350 average). Florist Shop Client Fees (2% of Projected Revenues) Also a 1% fee paid on a monthly basis. CWS assumes that couples will spend an average of $1,400 on flower purchases for their wedding (although the average floral purchase is $967, this includes couples that do their own arrangements – most florists average closer to $1,500 on weddings). II. GROWTH As CWS moves from the online pilot phase to full-fledged in-store Charitable Registry programs, revenue growth will be exponential. Although the growth rates reflected in the financial projections are extremely rapid (from less than $100K in 2004 to over $1 million in 2005), the actual retail client acquisition required for this expansion is quite reasonable. The projected revenue growth requires CWS to complete national in-store integrations with just 2 retailers in 2005 and an additional 2 retailers in 2006. Moreover, these assumptions are based upon closing contracts with smaller retailers. An in-store integration contract with just one of the largest retailers alone (Target, JC Penney, Macy’s, May Co. Department Stores) would enable CWS to garner over $2 million in annual revenue (and over $12 million in donations each year). III. COSTS Staff costs represent the primary expense for CWS (over 85%). The majority of these staff costs are the result of hiring a CEO with significant industry experience and a dedicated sales and program implementation team. Over the next three years, the primary focus of this staff will be integrating 19 The Knot, 2004, Conde Nast Bridal Group, 2002 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 33 Charitable Registry Programs into client retailers’ stores and websites. CWS estimates that the full cycle of pilot, regional, and national program integration for 1 retail client will require 7 months of full-time work by two staff members (1 tech, 1 service). Rapid growth in couple traffic will create challenges for CWS in containing costs. However, because the vast majority of the Charitable Registry Program management is automated (couple online services, donation processing, etc.), the marginal cost of adding new couples to the program is extremely low – CWS estimates a gross margin of almost 90%. In addition, with a tiered implementation of Charitable Registry Programs for clients (pilot to regional to national), CWS is able to scale integration costs in tandem with revenue growth. The 1% program management fee gives CWS an average of $25 of revenue per couple in the charitable registry program. Based on experience from the pilot program, CWS estimates that the venture can break even with per couple revenue of approximately $10-$14 (depending on the total number of customers). The services provided for couples and stores in the in-store phase are the same as for the pilot, so CWS expects that these costs will not rise significantly. II. FUNDING REQUIREMENTS To date, the I Do Foundation has spent over $70,000 in grant funds and in-kind donations for the planning, pilot development, and expansion of CWS. The I Do Foundation has also raised an additional $93,000 in funding for CWS’s expansion (this does not include in-kind office space and web hosting from the Foundation). CWS will need to raise $100,000 more by the end of the third quarter of 2004 and an additional $120,000 by the first quarter of 2005, which will carry the venture through June 2005 when CWS is expected to become cash positive. This financing will be used primarily for hiring a CEO with extensive wedding gift registry experience and to fund the first instore integrations of charitable wedding programs for retail clients. The success of CWS’s pilot program is enabling the I Do Foundation to reach out to potential social venture funders for the venture. The I Do Foundation is working to leverage its funding from existing funders such as the Echoing Green Foundation to access new foundation support to help capitalize the CWS program. Over the summer of 2005, the I Do Foundation will be submitting applications and making presentations to major social venture funders. In addition, the I Do Foundation is beginning outreach to large individual donors to garner investments for the expansion of CWS’s successful pilot. Finally, the I Do Foundation is researching potential funding from corporate foundations that are related to the wedding industry and may be interested in becoming sponsors of the Foundation. Although the I Do Foundation hopes to fund CWS through donations, the Board of Directors has discussed funding a portion of the needed $220,000 through debt instruments. With projected profitability in 2-3 years, the Foundation has the opportunity to use debt to capitalize the project. Sources and Uses of Funding Source The Empowerment Group Corporation for National Service Echoing Green Google* Additional Funding Needed Amount $20,000 $20,000 $17,000 $36,000 $220,000 Use Funding towards Dir. of Tech salary and benefits Funding towards Executive VP salary and benefits General program costs Free advertising of programs on Google Hire CEO and support first store integration costs Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 34 In addition to this direct funding, the I Do Foundation will provide office space, tech support, and website hosting for the CWS venture in 2004. *This funding is used to promote CWS’s online pilot programs. The Foundation hopes to receive annual renewal of Google funding; however, these funds are not included in funding projections. III. FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS CWS expects to generate positive operating earnings and operating cash flows in the early summer of 2005. Per couple revenue is projected to be an average of $25.00, and CWS expects to enable client retailers to serve over 100,000 couples a year in Charitable Wedding Programs by 2006. Summary Projections FY 2004 FY 2005 FY 2006 Charitable Gift Registry Couples 2,450 42,300 60,375 Bridal Boutique Couples 120 2,550 2,550 Florist Shop Couples 360 6,000 6,000 Revenue* $68,330 $1,183,200 $1,635,075 Cost of Sales $28,470 $141,685 $184,230 Operating Expenses $235,058 $761,179 $1,134,882 EBIT ($195,198) $280,336 $315,963 Gross Margin NA 88% 89% Operating Margin NA 24% 19% *Does not include funds donated to couples' chosen charities – this is only the1% management fee paid by stores. The projections above are based upon the following assumptions: Assumption #1: CWS will roll out its charitable registry program with partner retailers according to the plan laid out in the marketing section above. Assumption #2: 15% of couples offered the program will choose to have a charitable gift registry. This rate is lower than the rates of adoption by couples using The Wedding List’s charitable registry. Assumption #3: Average couple spending as outlined in the revenue section above. Assumption #4: Stores will pay an average fee of 1% of gift purchases to CWS for management of the programs donations and charitable options. The current average rate for partner stores in the pilot program is just over 1%. Funds from the operation of CWS will be used to expand the donation program and support the I Do Foundation’s operation. Although the I Do Foundation receives independent funding through foundations and individual donors, proceeds from CWS will enable the Foundation to improve its infrastructure and sustainability. Unrelated Business Income In creating its pilot program, CWS investigated the potential UBIT implications of the donations received from store partners. After reviewing current IRS rulings and studying other successful nonprofits with similar models, the I Do Foundation determined that donations from cause-related marketing programs (including any portion of the donations withheld to cover program costs) are invariably treated as charitable donations, rather than taxable income. CWS’s financial statements reflect those findings accordingly. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 35 Pro Forma Financial Statements The attached pro forma income, cash flow, and balance sheet statements outline CWS’s expected financial performance over the next three years. Key financial assumptions are also included. IV. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS A Net Present Value (NPV) calculation was used to determine the increase in value of the organization over a five year period starting in 2004. The NPV of the organization is positive at $1,689,476 at a 10% discount rate.20 Over the first five years, the major risk that CWS faces is sensitivity of the net operating cash flows. The projected figures could vary depending on three main factors: sales growth, couple program adoption, and average purchases. To assess this risk, a sensitivity analysis was performed to show what would happen to NPV if cash flows were reduced or increased due to the uncertainty of some of these factors. The graph below shows that even if cash flow was 50% less than expected, the NPV would still be highly positive at $588,380. Sensitivity Analysis of NPV to Changes in Operating Cash Flows $3,000,000 $2,500,000 NPV $2,000,000 $1,500,000 $1,000,000 $500,000 $0 -50% -40% -30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% Percentage Change in Operating Cash Flows VII. SOCIAL IMPACT CWS’s primary social impact will be made through the donations that the program generates for nonprofit organizations. CWS anticipates creating over $18 million in new nonprofit donations in the first three years of operation. The funds raised through the CWS program are directed to a nonprofit organization of the engaged couple’s choice. As a service to couples, and to increase the impact of its donations, the I Do Foundation offers a list of more than 35 “recommended partners,” such as Human Rights Watch and Doctors Without Borders. CWS’s goal to raise $18 million in the first three years is within the range of other prominent cause related marketing programs. In the first three years of a cause related marketing campaign with American Express, Share Our Strength raised $21 million to fight hunger, with an affiliate donation rate of just 3 cents per purchase. 20 This number does not include the value of charitable donations generated by the CWS venture. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 36 Summary Social Impact Projections (Pro Forma) FY 2004 FY 2005 FY 2006 $438,340 $7,594,050 $10,449,900 These social impact projections are based upon the assumptions listed above for couple traffic and spending, as well as the assumption that stores will set an average donation rate of 5% for their charitable giving programs. Current store donations rates are just above 5%, and since CWS seeks to work with higher-end retailers, 5% is likely to be a conservative estimate of the donation rate. Under these assumptions, couples will raise an average of $94 from their store and registry purchases. Couples in the CWS pilot program raised an average of $90 each. CWS expects this rate to rise significantly because online registries tend to be 40%-60% smaller than in-store registries. In addition to the donations from retail clients, couples in the CWS pilot program raised an average of $91 in donations through the I Do Foundation’s other donation services. When couples participate in the charitable registry program, they receive an I Do Foundation account which allows them to raise additional donations through the I Do Foundation’s other services such as: Donation Registry: By creating a Donation Registry, couples allow their guests to make a direct charitable donation to the couple’s chosen nonprofit organization. Couples are provided with a simple online registry management tool to create their personalized donation registry. Guests can make a donation online by check or credit card. All donations are fully tax-deductible. Charitable Guest Favors: Traditionally, couples purchase a small “favor” for each guest that attends their wedding. The I Do Foundation will allow engaged couples to make a small donation to charity in honor of their guests. Couples can choose to announce these favors through elegant favor cards provided by the I Do Foundation. Based upon our pilot program experience, CWS expects to raise additional donations from the couples that register through client stores. For purposes of this social impact analysis, we conservatively project that couples will raise $33 in donations through the I Do Foundation’s other donation tools. Average Donations Raised per Couple Store Donations: $94.00 Direct Donations: $33.00 Total: $127.00 A more detailed explanation of the social impact is included in the SROI Analysis in Attachment B. All donation disbursement will be handled by the I Do Foundation. Costs of donation disbursement will be offset by interest income generated from the donations received. In order to avoid making numerous small check payments to charities, the I Do Foundation aggregates and disburses donations to couples’ selected nonprofits at the end of the quarter after their wedding date. Consequently, there is an average of 4.5 months between donation receipt and payout. The interest revenue from this float will cover the cost of sending checks to these organizations and may provide a small revenue opportunity for the I Do Foundation. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 37 Risks and Contingencies CWS’s successful market entry relies on several intersecting market and business factors. The company has identified four primary areas of business risk: 1. Sales Growth Risks: A slow-down in sales growth represents the most significant risk to CWS’s expansion and success. Although CWS has built a solid base of retail clients, the company must continue to add new clients each year. In particular, in 2004, CWS will need to close contracts with additional major department store anchors (Macy’s, May Company, Crate & Barrel) and upper-end specialty store (Williams-Sonoma, Restoration Hardware, Pottery Barn) in order to open up these lucrative markets. Although CWS’s recent addition of Marshall Fields (which is both higher end and a major department store) will be helpful in accelerating entry in these market segments, sales growth can be unsteady and unpredictable with these retailers. In addition, CWS’s efforts to acquire bridal boutique and florist clients creates additional risks that companies in these markets will not adopt charitable programs over the next three years. Response and Contingency: CWS will use a number of strategies for mitigating this risk and responding to sales difficulties. 1. Incremental Sales Implementation: With a tiered sales strategy that moves each client through pilot, partial store integration, and national store integration phases, CWS is able to limit the investment risk on each client. As a result, CWS is able to maintain an adaptable sales growth strategy that allows for varying rates of client acquisition. 2. Broad Pilot Client Base: To take into account any potential difficulties with retailers, CWS assumes that only one in three retail clients with pilot charitable programs will actually develop in-store integrations. In addition, CWS assumes that one in four of these clients with in-store integrations will drop the program each year. Through the pilot program structure, CWS has developed a broad base of clients at a low cost. This base of pilot clients enables CWS to avoid the risks of relying on program adoption by a small set of key clients. 3. Sales Timetable Contingencies: CWS has developed several alternative sales timetables that address the risk of slow sales growth in 2004. If CWS is unable to close regional store integrations with 1-2 stores in 2004, CWS is prepared to put off store integration implementation until the beginning of 2005. An additional $50,000 in funding would be required in 2005; staff growth would be slowed; and CWS would focus on nurturing the next group of pilot clients. 4. Gift Registry Only Contingency: The pilot programs with bridal boutiques and florists will provide an opportunity for CWS to test this market opportunity. If these pilot programs do not show both strong market demand and low implementation costs, CWS will not continue to pursue these opportunities. With less than 10% of CWS’s projected revenue coming from bridal boutique and florist client sales, CWS can operate profitably without these programs. 2. Management Risk: CWS must successfully attract an experienced CEO with broad wedding industry contacts and extensive retail experience. This staff member will be critical to the company’s client development and successful program expansion. In addition, CWS must successfully manage the venture’s staff growth (16 employees by Year 3), while maintaining efficient operational procedures, tight financial controls, and attracting and retaining high-quality talent. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 38 Response and Contingency: CWS will work closely with its advisors to identify potential applicants for the CEO position. CWS will begin outreach in the fall with a target of hiring a new CEO by January 2005. If CWS has not attracted top-quality applicants by December, then CWS will renew the search process and plan to add a CEO by March. This may require the company to shift its 2005 pilot programs to start dates in the second quarter of 2005. CWS will rely on the organizational development experience of Executive Vice-President Peter Murray and the new CEO to create robust structures for expanding the venture’s staff. CWS will also continue to seek out guidance from our advisors on effective strategies for managing growth. If CWS is confronting significant difficulty attracting and managing an expanding staff team, the management may hire consultants in the retail industry on a contract basis. 3. Fundraising Risk: Although the I Do Foundation has successfully built a seed funding base for CWS, an additional $220,000 in funding must be raised to support the program’s growth. Response and Contingency: If the I Do Foundation is unable to raise these additional funds for CWS there are two primary options: 1. Slow Program Growth: CWS estimates that by scaling back of staffing leadership and building upon the current set of retail clients for CWS, the project could continue to grow with $100,000-$125,000 in additional funding. This slower growth model would require I Do to cut back on the number of gift registry store integrations each year and delay launching the bridal boutique and florist pilot programs until 2005. 2. Debt/Grant Mix: A portion of the $220,000 in funding could be raised through loans. 4. In-Store Integration Costs Risk: CWS has developed pilot charitable registry programs with some of the largest companies in the industry including J.C. Penney, Target, and Linens ‘n Things. Over the next two years, CWS must enable stores to turn these online pilot programs into in-store charitable registry programs in hundreds of locations across the country. As retailers implement these programs in their stores, the costs of staff training, materials development, and program advertising could create barriers to the expansion of the program into new stores. Although CWS has significant experience with the costs of managing the program, CWS may find that its own costs for supporting retailers’ in-store program integrations are higher than expected. Response and Contingency: In order to prepare retailers for in-store integrations, the I Do Foundation provides clients with clear outlines of the costs attendant with the creation of charitable programs. CWS will work with retailers to integrate training and materials for the charitable programs into the stores’ existing associate training programs. In case retailers find the costs of integration prohibitive, CWS has developed a lower-cost program model that limits in-store materials to I Do Foundation business cards that associates can give to couples. Couples then go online to sign up for the charitable program, reducing the cost of materials and associate training. If CWS finds that its own costs are higher than expected, the company will first look to renegotiate terms of our client agreement or change future contracts. These changes may include increasing the management fee rate and reducing CWS’s involvement in training/customer service for associates. CWS may also switch to the lower cost program model noted in the paragraph above, which reduces costs for both CWS and the retailers. Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 39 II. VENTURE RISKS FOR I DO FOUNDATION If CWS fails to become a successful and sustainable venture, there are two primary risks for the I Do Foundation’s organizational development and integrity. Although CWS offers enormous potential gains for the I Do Foundation, the venture’s failure is extremely unlikely to do irreparable harm to the overall organization. 1. Fiscal Base: The I Do Foundation must carefully consider the fiscal burden that it assumes for the CWS project. To date, the Foundation has managed to raise all funds for the project through grants and in-kind donations. However, CWS’s failure would still create rippling effects within the organization that could adversely affect the organization’s fiscal base. Nonetheless, the I Do Foundation’s other program activities are sustainable without the operation of CWS. The Foundation’s media programs, donation registry, favor service, and online charitable wedding resources are all sustainable as stand-alone projects. 2. Industry Legitimacy: CWS failure could harm the I Do Foundation’s reputation as an effective industry leader. The I Do Foundation will need to carefully manage the expectations of media and clients to ensure that CWS does not overstretch and underperform. The staged rollout of the CWS program goes a long way towards mitigating this risk by providing frequent checks of the project’s efficiency and potential. III. SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS CWS has conducted sensitivity analyses on the following key parameters in our financial statements: Sales Growth: CWS has set out a series of sales growth goals for the next three years (see above). CWS has run sensitivity analyses for sales levels that are only 30% and 50% of what is projected in this plan. The results of this analysis are summarized below: Sales Growth 30% of Assumed 50% of Assumed 100% of Assumed Break Even Date Mar. 2006 Dec. 2005 Apr. 2005 Capitalization Required $330,000 $300,000 $220,000 Couple Program Adoption: CWS assumes a 15% adoption rate by retailers bridal customers. CWS has run sensitivity analyses to assess the impact of lower adoption rates on the company’s financial stability. The results of this analysis are summarized below: Adoption Rate 7.5% of Assumed 10% of Assumed 15% of Assumed Break Even Date Feb. 2006 Nov. 2005 Apr. 2005 Capitalization Required $325,000 $290,000 $220,000 Average Purchases: CWS assumes that couples will spend approximately the national average on gift registry, boutique, and floral purchases. CWS has run sensitivity analyses to assess the impact of lower than expected spending levels by couples. (CWS has also run financial models without any bridal boutique and florist shop services. These sources represent less than 10% of total revenue and are not necessary for CWS’s success.) These analyses are summarized below: Average Purchases 60% of Assumed 80% of Assumed 100% of Assumed Break Even Date Dec. 2005 June. 2005 Apr. 2005 Capitalization Required $325,000 $260,000 $220,000 Charitable Wedding Services Business Plan 40