STAGE 2 MATHEMATICS PATHWAYS FOLIO TASK Queuing Topic: Mathematics and Small Business Subtopics from the Stage 2 Mathematical Applications Subject Outline: 3.2 - Queuing A completed investigation should include: an introduction that outlines the problem to be explored, including it significance, its features, and the context the method required to find a solution, in terms of the mathematical model or strategy to be used the appropriate application of the mathematical model or strategy, including - the generation or collection of relevant data and/or information, with details of the process of collection - mathematical calculations and results, and appropriate representations - the analysis and interpretation of results - reference to the limitations of the original problem a statement of the results and conclusions in the context of the original problem appendices and a bibliography, as appropriate. Learning Requirements 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Assessment Design Criteria Capabilities Demonstrate an understanding of mathematical concepts and relationships. Mathematical Knowledge and Skills and Their Application Communication Identify, collect, and organise mathematical information relevant to investigating and finding solutions to questions/problems. MKSA1 Knowledge of content and understanding of mathematical concepts and relationships. MKSA2 Use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find solutions to routine and complex questions. Recognise and apply the mathematical techniques needed when analysing and finding a solution to a question/problem in context. Make informed use of electronic technology to aid and enhance understanding. Interpret results, draw conclusions, and reflect on the reasonableness of these in the context of the question/problem. Communicate mathematical ideas and reasoning using appropriate language and representations. The specific features are as follows: Citizenship Personal Development Work Learning MKSA3 Application of knowledge and skills to answer questions in applied contexts. Mathematical Modelling and Problem-solving The specific features are as follows: MMP1 Application of mathematical models. MMP2 Development of mathematical results for problems set in applied contexts. MMP3 Interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. MMP4 Understanding of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the interpreted results, and recognition of assumptions made. Communication of Mathematical Information The specific features are as follows: Page 1 of 3 CMI1 Communication of mathematical ideas and reasoning to develop logical arguments. CMI2 Use of appropriate mathematical notation, representations, and terminology. Stage 2 Mathematics Pathways Mathematics and Small Business task Ref: A203776 (revised February 2016) © SACE Board of South Australia 2010 PERFORMANCE STANDARDS FOR STAGE 2 MATHEMATICS PATHWAYS Mathematical Knowledge and Skills and Their Application A Comprehensive knowledge of content and understanding of concepts and relationships. Appropriate selection and use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find efficient solutions to complex questions. Highly effective and accurate application of knowledge and skills to answer questions set in applied contexts. B Some depth of knowledge of content and understanding of concepts and relationships. Use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find some correct solutions to complex questions. Accurate application of knowledge and skills to answer questions set in applied contexts. C Generally competent knowledge of content and understanding of concepts and relationships. Use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find mostly correct solutions to routine questions. Generally accurate application of knowledge and skills to answer questions set in applied contexts. D Basic knowledge of content and some understanding of concepts and relationships. Some use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find some correct solutions to routine questions. Sometimes accurate application of knowledge and skills to answer questions set in applied contexts. E Mathematical Modelling and Problemsolving Development and effective application of mathematical models. Complete, concise, and accurate solutions to mathematical problems set in applied contexts. Concise interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. In-depth understanding of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the interpreted results, and recognition of assumptions made. Attempted development and appropriate application of mathematical models. Mostly accurate and complete solutions to mathematical problems set in applied contexts. Complete interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. Some depth of understanding of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the interpreted results, and recognition of assumptions made. Appropriate application of mathematical models. Some accurate and generally complete solutions to mathematical problems set in applied contexts. Generally appropriate interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. Some understanding of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the interpreted results, and some recognition of assumptions made. Application of a mathematical model, with partial effectiveness. Partly accurate and generally incomplete solutions to mathematical problems set in applied contexts. Attempted interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. Some awareness of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the interpreted results. Limited knowledge of content. Attempted application of a basic mathematical model. Attempted use of mathematical algorithms and techniques (implemented electronically where appropriate) to find limited correct solutions to routine questions. Limited accuracy in solutions to one or more mathematical problems set in applied contexts. Attempted application of knowledge and skills to answer questions set in applied contexts, with limited effectiveness. Page 2 of 3 Limited attempt at interpretation of the mathematical results in the context of the problem. Limited awareness of the reasonableness and possible limitations of the results. Communication of Mathematical Information Highly effective communication of mathematical ideas and reasoning to develop logical arguments. Proficient and accurate use of appropriate notation, representations, and terminology. Effective communication of mathematical ideas and reasoning to develop mostly logical arguments. Mostly accurate use of appropriate notation, representations, and terminology. Appropriate communication of mathematical ideas and reasoning to develop some logical arguments. Use of generally appropriate notation, representations, and terminology, with some inaccuracies. Some appropriate communication of mathematical ideas and reasoning. Some attempt to use appropriate notation, representations, and terminology, with occasional accuracy. Attempted communication of emerging mathematical ideas and reasoning. Limited attempt to use appropriate notation, representations, or terminology, and with limited accuracy. Stage 2 Mathematics Pathways Mathematics and Small Business task Ref: A203776 (revised February 2016) © SACE Board of South Australia 2010 STAGE 2 MATHEMATICS PATHWAYS FOLIO TASK Queuing Introduction Viktor and Lily are equal partners in a fruit and vegetable business and have noticed that their busiest time is between 12 noon and 1pm each day. They want to investigate the number of staff needed to serve on an additional counter that is only open for the one-hour period to cater for the overflow of customers. This counter can have 1, 2, or 3 different service points each with its own server, and customers would be served at the next available point. At 12 noon, there are already 5 customers who need to be served at this counter (5 customers are queuing). On average, a customer arrives every 2 minutes during this busy hour. The extra counter closes at 1pm, but anyone still in the queue at that time will be served. Server 1 serves continuously if there are people waiting. A new server (server 2 or 3) is added to the counter whenever the queue has 4 or more people waiting (and not yet being served). Servers 2 and 3 close unless there are 4 or more people waiting. On average, during this one hour, most customers require 3 minutes service time, but every fourth customer requires 5 minutes of service time. Read the entire task and write an informative introduction that demonstrates your understanding of the situation to be investigated. Mathematical Investigations 1. Draw a table and/or chart to display the results of the number of additional servers needed and when they are needed. 2. For each server calculate: The number of people served by each server The time when the final customer is served at one of these service points The average customer waiting time The percentage of the time that each server spends doing other tasks. 3. Repeat the process above after making changes to your choice of conditions under which the counter is staffed. At least two changes to the original conditions should be investigated. These could include variations to: the number of customers initially waiting; the arrival or service interval; the conditions of the extra servers. Use your sets of results to enable you to complete a comparison of the perceived operation and efficiency of the queue under different situations. Analysis/Discussion Using the results of your calculations as a basis for analysis, decide how many staff need to be available to serve the overflow of customers during the period from 12 noon to 1pm each day. Discuss the basis for your decision. Compare the efficiency of the models. Discuss the issue of slack time of the servers. Discuss the reasonableness of the results by considering: any methods that you could use to improve the accuracy of your answer any assumptions that you have made, or limitations of the model, in this investigation which could influence your results. Conclusion Explain how many staff Viktor and Lily need to make available during the one hour period. Your answer should consider which trial offers the most cost effective option for the business. Notes to Teacher To assist with the verification of student work each student could be given a variation of the conditions of the original scenario. For example changes to: the number of customers waiting initially, the arrival interval, the conditions for an extra server, the service time. Teachers may consider adding visual aids to the task to assist students who need support in accessing the requirements of the task. Page 3 of 3 Stage 2 Mathematics Pathways Mathematics and Small Business task Ref: A203776 (revised February 2016) © SACE Board of South Australia 2010