1 A review of impacts of climate variability and change on semi-arid agricultural systems of Ethiopia: Action steps and principles for adapting agriculture to climate variability and change 1 Habtamu Admassu, Kidane Georgis, Olani Nikus, Aklilu Mekasha, Mohammed Yesuf, Kinde Tesfaye, Emana Getu, Melesse Temsgen, Dejene Aberra, Mezgebu Getinet, Lemma Desalegn, Tolessa Debele,Solomon Assefa, Setegn Gebeyehu, Tsegaye Ketema,, Tesfaye Gissila and Henry F. Mahoo3 1 Ethiopian Institute of Agricultural Research, Melkassa Agricultural Research Center, P.o.Box: 436, Nazreth/Adama, Ethiopia, 3Sokoine University of agriculture, P.O.Box 3003, Morogoro, Tanzania ABSTRACT Agriculture is the pillar of the Ethiopian economy. However, it is affected very much by challenges of climate variability and change. Climate change has caused drying of lakes, and reduced water availability in reservoirs. It has also caused loss of the bio-diversity. Ethiopia’s GDP fluctuates with rainfall as well. Due to climate change, human food and livestock feed have been reduced, and crop diseases and pests have shifted in geographic spread. Household farm power and fuel supplies are threatened, and ecosystem has shifted in a pace difficult to cope with. Thus, climate change is not a distant worry in Ethiopia any more – it is real, it is happening and will continue to happen. The key issue now is how the agrarian community can be assisted to adapt to these changes and produce enough food on sustainable basis and reduce poverty and achieve the desired food and feed security. A synthesis based on extensive review of available literature on the historical impacts of climate variability and change on the agricultural systems of the semi-arid areas of Ethiopia revealed that the critical answer lies in implementing action steps and adopting principles aimed at: developing capacity for adapting agriculture to climate variability and change. These should include increasing public awareness about climate change impacts, and encouraging them to implement available adaptation options, enhancing rain water productivity, financing localized climate variability and change adaptation options, developing and promoting agricultural rainfall risk insurance schemes, improving institutional capacity to generate and apply climate information at local level, developing and improving human capacity in climate change science, and harmonizing policies and institutional frameworks affecting climate change adaptation. Keywords: Adaptation, Action steps and principles, Climate variability and climate change, semiarid agricultural systems 1. INTRODUCTION In Ethiopia, climate variability and change has serious direct impacts on natural resources, agricultural output, road and transport services, water intensive-industries, electric power production, and on human health. Climate driven agriculture in Ethiopia is the main economic pillar accounting for over 40% of 2 GDP and 90% of national foreign exchange earnings (USDS, 2007). The sector is sensitive and subject to climatic variations and frequent droughts which contributes to massive food shortages. The Initial National Communication of Ethiopia (NMSA, 2001) show decreasing trend in annual rainfall over the Northern parts of the country and increasing trends over the Central parts of the country. Global Circulation Model projections for the year 2030 show an increase in temperature by 1oC and a decrease of rainfall by up to 2%. According to these projections, climate change is the cause of high current climate variability and will increase the frequency of extreme events making agricultural sector more vulnerable. This will definitely culminates in poor harvests and/or complete crop failure, leading to shortages of food, pasture and animal feeds (UNFCCC, 2001). Examination of the long-term rainfall data of 92 meteorological stations in Ethiopia indicated a coefficient of variation (CV) ranging from 20-89%. Fifteen (15) of the 92 stations data examined had CV of more than 50% indicating the extreme variability of rainfall in the country (Figure 1). From Figure 1, there is a decline in the total amount of rainfall as variability increases. In semiarid areas where rainfall is already unreliable, this has severe impacts on crop production (Habtamu, et al., 2007). 2. Manifestation of climate change impacts 2.1 Flood, frost and drought extremes In Ethiopia, climate variability, and frequencies of extreme events have increased over time. For instance, flooding has become a common problem and occurs in lowlands where rivers flow over the gentle slopes with higher volume of water from the highlands. The Awash River in Afar region, Baro River in Gambela region, Wabeshebele, Genale and Dawa rivers in Somali region, Omo, Weyto and Segen Rivers in South Omo region commonly inundate large area of grazing lands and inflict heavy loss of life and damage to 3 resources. Flooding caused by heavy rainfall and river overflowing has regularly affected people and their property, especially those in the low lying areas of Somali, Afar, Gamella, Oromiya, Amhara and the Southern regional states. The devastating flood incidences in Dire Dawa city, Gode in the Somali Regional State and South Omo in the South Nations and Nationalities and Peoples Regional State (SNNPRS) in 2006 are recent examples. Flash floods affect all regions depending on the intensity of rainfall. Some floods such as those in 1996 and 2006, triggered disasters which claimed the lives of hundreds of people, displaced hundreds of thousands and destroyed physical, natural and economic assets. According to UNDHA (1995) and Osman and Sauerborn (2002), a series of flooding had inflicted environmental as well as socio-economic damage to the central highlands of Ethiopia. Extremely cold temperatures are becoming common in the highland areas of the country exacerbating the existing food insecurity. Fore example, the incidence of frost damage to field and vegetable crops as well as some ornamental plants grown in the valley bottoms and lower landscape positions particularly in the surroundings of Sinkhole lakes and the lower positions of the sub-catchments in the highlands of East Hararghe is often taken for granted with varying degrees of severity from year to year. However, unlike other years, frost incidence occurred twice at the end of 2004 cropping season in these areas. The first incidence occurred between late October and mid to late November with some deviations depending on localities, and caused severe damage on field crops (mainly sorghum and late planted beans) and some vegetable crops (Alemaya University, 2005). Through out its history, Ethiopia has encountered a number of drought crises. There is an increase in the frequency of drought from one in 100 years in the 1st century to one in six years in the 20th century and also once in 3 years around the end of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st century. In general, the intensity, frequency and the effects of droughts have increased since the mid 1970s. Besides climate variability, the dramatic increase in the frequency of drought in the past three decades is attributed to global climate change. 4 2.2 Impacts of on crop production Impacts of climate variability on crop production are manifested through its effects on planting times, growing season length, crop type or cultivars choices and over all harvest size and productivity. Therefore, crop production in the country is vulnerable to the effect of failure of rains or occurrence of successive dry spells during the growing season, which often leads to food shortage. Though food shortage resulting from adverse climatic conditions is not new in this country, it has increased in severity and there have been frequent shortages in recent years. As a result of failure of the short and long rainy seasons in 2002, lowland areas in the North, East, South and Central parts of the country faced severe food shortages (FEWS Ethiopia Food Security Warning, US Agency for International Development, 2002). Some midland areas were also badly affected due to extended dry period between mid-April and end of July. Reduction in maize and sorghum production in drought affected lowland areas is estimated between 70% and 100%. Some surplus producing parts of the country have also been adversely affected. The overall national food availability in the country was thus low. In coffee producing areas in western, southwestern and eastern parts of the country, coffee, the country's main cash crop on which almost 15 million people depend, harvest in 2002/03 declined by 30% due to drought. Preliminary production assessment results indicate that total annual crop production in 2002 decreased by 21% compared to the five previous years. According to Devereux (2006) crop yield decline and high vulnerability of food production are due to rain failure in semi-arid areas in recent years compared to the past decades. Near complete dependence on rainfall and low-input farming methods are typical features of the Ethiopian agriculture. Crop yield is strongly correlated with rainfall variability in Ethiopia (Lemi, 2005). Figure 4 on the left shows drought affected sorghum, and Figure 5 on the right side depicts considerable variation in maize yield with rainfall for typical semi-arid areas of Ethiopia during 1992 to 2002 seasons (Habtamu, Unpublished). Thus, the amount and temporal distribution of rainfall is the most important factor in determining national crop production levels. On top of climate variability, climate change is predicted to 5 present further serious challenges. 2.3 Impacts on livestock Climate variability has impacted on feed and water availability for livestock. It has reduced livestock numbers. This has already claimed lives of millions of livestock and had serious impacts on financial and capital assets. Thus it has become a major threat to the livelihoods of great majority of pastoralists (Biruk, 2003). 2.4 Impacts on water resources In Ethiopia, water availability has dramatically reduced in both rivers, streams, lakes and reservoirs. For instance, climate change in conjunction with human activities triggered by climate related disasters have killed Lake Haromaya (Tamiru et al, 2006; Furi, 2005). Lake Tana, Lake Ziway (Zeray, 2006), and River Awash water resources are also under threat (Dekiyos, 2000). There is great fear and challenge of meeting the demands of the escalating population and its demand on water needs for food production, irrigation, domestic, municipal, industrial, and energy uses (Sadoff, 2006). 2.5 Impacts on national economy, ecosystems, biodiversity, pests and diseases Ethiopian economy is also vulnerable to impacts of climate change. Grey and Saddoff (2005) demonstrated strong links between Ethiopian economy and climate performance (Figure 9). Rainfall 6 variability currently costs the country over a-third of its growth potential, and, is likely to reduce it by 38%, and to increase poverty by 25% over a 12-year period (World Bank, 2006). Besides the economic and other impacts, the other devastating impacts include emergence and proliferation of human disease such as malaria (Adugna 2002), livestock and crop diseases and pests (Emana, 2007), and vector borne and water borne diseases. In addition, ecosystem is shifting in a pace difficult to cope with. Bio-diversity losses are quite phenomenal (Amha, 2006). Furthermore, farm power and household fuel supply is jeopardised by changed climate, and this has led to desperate actions that culminated in de-vegetation, which has accelerated the pace of degradation of fertility and tilth (ICRA, 1999). Furthermore, the impact of climate change on food security in Ethiopia is also tremendous (Stephen, 2000). The above presentation makes it clear that sustainability of climatic driven Ethiopia’s agriculture is quite under risk. 3. The need for adaptation Farmers in Northern, Central and Eastern part of Ethiopia have long recognized the changes in climate. They have set out strategies to cope with variability taking different tracks. Their system based on trialand-error over long years of struggle for survival has in fact made significant contribution to the well being of their family (Fujisaka, et al., 1996; ICRA, 1999). The greatest agricultural challenge in Ethiopia is probably to feed the ever escalating population without further degrading the natural resource base. According to Olesen (2009), climate change significantly enhances these challenges by reducing crop and soil productivity, and availability of water and by increasing variability of temperature and rainfall. The increasing confidence in climate change projections and the slowness in adopting effective mitigation measures to combat climate change put increasing emphasis on effective adaptation measures in all parts of society. Changes in climate variability will be very difficult for poor-resource and information farmers to adapt to. Furthermore, adaptation strategies to cope with variability may be different from those dealing with changes in mean climate (Olesen, 2009). Therefore, newer adaptation plans must be 7 developed and employed. In addition, adaptation to climate variability and change being a social process requires us to assess and respond to past climatic impacts, to increase adaptive capacity and resilience to multiple stresses, and to formulate plans and policies in ways which reduce the risk of adverse outcomes in the future. This requires an understanding of present day risks, as well as trends in climate, and how both may change in years to come. This demands integration of climate change adaptation into national agricultural development strategy. However, there may be several restrictions to effective implementation of adaptation options, including social, institutional and technical ones. Perhaps equally challenging will be the increasing scarcity of water for irrigation and also increasing concern in society for reducing environmental impacts of agriculture and maintaining biodiversity, which will also be affected by climate change (Olesen, 2009). 4. Required action steps and principles for adapting agriculture to climate variability and change Based on extensive review, synthesis and analysis of available literature by interdisciplinary team of researchers about the impacts of climate variability and change in the agricultural systems of Ethiopia, the following action steps and principles for adapting Ethiopian agriculture to climate change has been identified. 4.1 Raise awareness of the public about climate change and its impacts Encourage NGO’s to launch aggressive public awareness campaigns about climate change impacts Mainstream climate change issues into formal and informal education curricula Invest in communication and knowledge raising products with respect to climate variability and change impacts 8 Use local-social networks to enhance the speed of co-learning and thereby increase public awareness 4.2 Rain water productivity Exploit fully the potential of rainfed agriculture Learn lessons from past experiences to guide full utilization of existing knowledge and technologies Ensure use of climate forecast products to reduce climate induced risks Take advantage of advances in Information and Communication Technologies Integrate efficient agricultural water management practices with productivity enhancing interventions Manage water to prevent flooding, water logging, erosion and nutrient leaching under increased rainfall Exploit the potential of response farming technology 4.3 Financing Invest into smallholder climate variability and change adaptation efforts Pay serious attention to use IK for adaptation to climate variability and change Encourage financial institutions to provide credit on timely and at low interest rate Promote local savings and credit Finance local initiatives for natural resource conservation and use Allocate sufficient budgets for communication, sharing, and scaling up of available climate change adaptation options 4.4 Develop and promote agricultural risk insurance Develop and promote rainfall risk insurance schemes Invest in agricultural risk insurance Encourage risk financing institutions to insure rainfall risks 9 4.5 Institutional capacity Develop capacity to generate and apply climate information at local level Make climate information products available timely in a format that that can easily be understood and utilized by target communities Enhance the operational and technical capacity of national institutions to develop and disseminate regularly updated climate knowledge, products and adaptation plans 4.6 Human capacity development Develop and improve human capacity in the science and practice of climate change and adaptation Train researchers in the science of climate change Target research to fill technological adaptation deficits Improve extension, education and partnership among stakeholders to effectively address adaptation deficits Establish village based platforms and operationalize participatory forecast production and dissemination mechanisms on sustainable basis Develop extension workers and researchers capacity in response farming techniques 4.7 Policy Harmonize policies and Institutional frameworks affecting climate change adaptation Mainstream climate change adaptation into poverty reduction and food security improvement efforts Formulate umbrella policies/strategies to reduce sectoral disconnect for climate change adaptation Adopt cross - sectoral wide programs that have strong ownership by stakeholders to effectively address climate change adaptation at different levels Invest in technologies Create additional opportunities for off-farm employment 10 Support migration Invest in research on the use of new crop varieties and livestock species that are more suited to drought conditions Encourage informal social networks Invest in irrigation Exploit IK for adaptation to climate variability and change Institutionalize climate change adaptation research 5. Summary and conclusions 5.1 Summary As indicated earlier, in Ethiopia, extreme climatic events with impacts of varying magnitude are frequent features. But, recent scientific evidence suggests that the frequency and severity of such events is increasing, making adaptation an extreme necessity. In Ethiopia, the impacts of climate variability and change are generally un-mitigated because there is little- knowledge, hydraulic infrastructure, coordination and financial resource to store and manage water. Our limited adaptive capacity makes these events beyond control. Thus, the challenge of adapting Ethiopian agriculture to climate change is not only one of ensuring crop production to maintain food security. It is also a task of maintaining our soil and water resources while at the same time protecting environment and biodiversity. This puts new challenges to research to develop and ensure that adaptation strategies are effective not only in terms of crop production, but also environmentally and economically robust. Adaptation must be addressed in a broad development context, recognizing climate change as an added challenge to reducing poverty, hunger, 11 diseases and environmental degradation. Building resilience to ongoing and future climate change calls for adaptation to start now by addressing existing problems in land and water management. Strengthening institutions for land and water management is crucial to effective adaptation and must build on principles of participation of civil society, gender equality, and decentralization. Information for local adaptation must be improved, and must be considered a public good to be shared at all levels. The cost of inaction and the economic and social benefits of adaptation actions call for increased and innovative financing. 5.2 Conclusions In conclusion, climate change is not a distant worry in Ethiopia any more – it is real, it is happening and will to continue. The critical answer to assist the agrarian community to adapt to these changes and produce enough on sustainable basis and reduce poverty and achieve the desired food and feed security lies in implementing action steps and adopting principles aimed at: developing capacity for adapting agriculture to climate variability and change. These should include: Increasing public awareness about climate change impacts, and encourage them to implement available adaptation options, enhancing rain water productivity, financing localized climate variability and change adaptation efforts, developing and promotion of agricultural rainfall risk insurance schemes, improving institutional capacity to generate and apply climate information at local level, developing and improving human capacity in climate change science, and harmonizing policies and institutional frameworks affecting climate change adaptation. 12 Figure 1 Relationship between annual total rainfall and its coefficient of variation based on date from 92 selected locations in Ethiopia (Habtamu, Unpublished). Figure 2. Farmer clear frost killed khat plantation (left) Figure 3. Floods in 2002 claimed hundreds and a frost attacked tree (right), January 2005 at of lives in Dired Dawa town in Ethiopia. Haramaya, Ethiopia, (Source, AU, 2005) 13 Figure 4. Drought affected sorghum Figure 6. Feed supply condition in range lands Figure 5. Relationship between annual total rainfall and maize yield in Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia during 1992 to 2002 (Source: Habtamu, Unpublished data Figure 7. Drought affected livestock resources in pastoral areas of the Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia 14 Figure 8. Lake Haramaya: dried up since 2005 (Source: Alemaya University, 2005). Figure 9. Relationship of overall GDP, Agricultural GDP and rainfall in Ethiopia (Source: Grey and Saddoff, 2005) Acknowledgement This publication was supported by the Climate Change Adaptation in Africa (CCAA) program, a joint initiative of Canada’s International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development (DFID). The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of DFID or IDRC. REFERENCES 15 Adugna Wayessa, Teshome Gebre-Michael, Ahmed Ali and Daniel Kebede. 2002. Malaria in Addis and its Environs: Assessements of Magnitude and Distribution: Ethiopia journal of Healt Development. 2002:16 (2): 147-155 Amha Kassahun (2006) Characterization of rangeland resources and dynamics of the pastoral production systems in the Somali region of eastern Ethiopia. Thesis Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Ph.D to the University of the Free State, South Africa. Alemaya University. 2005. Taskforce Report on Frost Damage Assessment in Eastern Hararghe. Alemaya University, Alemaya, 15 p. Alemayehu T, Kebede S, Ayenew T (2006) Hydrogeochemical and lake level changes in the Ethiopian Rift. J Hydrol 316(1–4):290–300 Coulomb CV Biruk Yemane (2003). The declining pastoral environment, vulnerability status and daptation strategy. Proceedings of the 10th annual conference of the Ethiopian Society of Animal Production (ESAP) Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Deksyos Terekegn, 2000. Vulnerability and Adaptation Assessment of Water Resource to Climate Change in the Abay Basin (unpublished), a report submitted to NMSA under the GEFIUNDP supported Climate Change Enabling Activities Project (ETH /971G31) of Ethiopia. Deverleux, S. (2006). Vulnerable livelihood in Somali Region, Ethiopia, Reseach Report 57, Brighton, Institute of development studies. Emana Getu. 2007. Comparative Studies on the Influence of Relative Humidity and Temperature on the Longevity and Fecundity of Cotesia flavipes (Cameron) (Hymenoptera: Braconidae): towards optimization of biological control of Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) in Ethiopia. Journal of Insect Science(JIS) 7:19. Fujisaka, S., Wortmann, C. and Admassu H. 1996. Resource poor farmers with complex technical knowledge in high risk system in Ethiopia: Can research help?. Journal of Farming Systems Research-Extension. Vol. 6, No.3. Gray, D., Sadoff, C. 2005. Water Resources, Growth and Development. A Working Paper for Discussion at The UN. Commission on Sustainable Development, Panel of Finance Ministers. The World Bank. Furi W (2005). Groundwater productivity and the hydrology of the dry lakes basin in the north central sector of east Hararghe zone. Unpublished MSc. thesis, Addis Ababa University Habtamu Admassu, Kidane Georgis, U.R.Pal and J Ian Stewart. 2007. Relevant Season Categories and their Rainfall Behaviour to Enhance Impacts of Improved Agronomic Recommendations on Water Productivity. In: Agricultural Water Management: A critical factor in reduction of poverty and hunger in eastern and Southern Africa. Proc of the 2nd Regional Workshop on Agricultural Water Management in Eastern and Southern Africa; Held at VIP Hotel, Maputo, Mozambique, 18 – 22 September 2006. ICRA. 1999. Livelihood and drought coping strategies of farm households in the Central Rift Valley, Ethiopia: Challenges for agricultural research. 1999. Prepared by Admassu Habtamu, Alfred Daka, Etagengnhu G., Lundall Magnuson Elize, Mulhall Abigail, and Mutsaers Arthur, Working document series 76. Netherlands NMSA. 2001. Initial National Communication of Ethiopia to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Ministry of Water Resources , National Meteorological Services Agency, Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Osman, M, Sauerborn, P. 2002. A Preliminary assessment of characteristics and long-term variability of rainfall in Ethiopia: Basis for sustainable land use and resource management. Conference on International Agricultural Research for Development, Deutscher Tropentag, October 9-11, 2002, Witzenhausen. Olesen Jørgen E. 2009. Adaptation strategies for coping with climate change. In press. European journal of agronomy. Sadoff, C. 2006. Can Water Undermine Growth? Evidence from Ethiopia. Agricultural and Rural Development, Issue 18: The World Bank. 16 Stephen Devereux. 2000. Food insecurity in Ethiopia. A discussion paper for DFID. IDS Sussex Tamiru Alemayehu, Wagari Furi and Dagnachew Legesse. 2006. Impact of water overexploitation on highland lakes of eastern Ethiopia. Ethiopia. In journal of Environ Geol (2007) 52:147–154. Springer-Verlag 2006. UNDHA (United Nations Department of Humanitarian Affairs). 1995. Ethiopia: Floods. DHA Geneva. Situation Report No. 1, Geneva. UNFCCC (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change). 2001. UNFCCC Status of Ratification. Bonn: UNFCCC. Available on-line at http://unfccc.int/resource/ conv/ratlist.pdf. USDS (Unites Sates Department of State). 2007. Background Note: Ethiopia. Bureau of African Affairs. http://state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/2859.htm, accessed on 8 August 2007. World Bank. 2006 World Bank Rural Development News Release No:2006/485/AFR WASHINGTON, June 22, 2006. www.worldbank.org/afr. Lijalem Zeray, A. 2006. Climate change impact on Lake Ziway watershed water availability in Ethiopia. MSc Thesis, University of Applied Sciences, Cologne, Germany, pp123