Skills Tasmania North West Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile March 2008 North West Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile © Skills Tasmania, 2008. All rights reserved. This publication is copyright and further information or additional copies may be obtained from Skills Tasmania. Note that the information, views and recommendations in this document have been obtained under contract from industry sources as part of Industry Advisory Arrangements; they may include data or information which has not been otherwise verified, and they should not be interpreted as being the views, intentions or policy of Skills Tasmania or the Tasmanian Government. NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Contents Preface ...................................................................................................................................... 1 Abbreviations ............................................................................................................................. 2 1. Summary - Key Points ...................................................................................................... 3 2. Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 7 2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 3. The people ...................................................................................................................... 12 3.1. 3.2. 3.3. 3.3.1. 3.3.2. 3.3.3. 3.3.4. 3.3.5. 3.3.6. 3.4. 3.5. 3.6. 4. Vocational Education and Training provision ........................................................ 34 Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) ............................................................ 34 Number of Trainees compared to number of all students ...................................... 37 How many students complete their qualification? .................................................. 37 Where do the students come from? ....................................................................... 37 Student satisfaction with their training outcomes ................................................... 38 What do employers think of the VET system? ....................................................... 40 Conclusions: ........................................................................................................... 41 The Labour Market .......................................................................................................... 42 5.1. 5.1.1. 5.1.2. 5.2. 5.3. 5.3.1. 5.3.2. 5.3.3. 5.3.4. 5.4. 6. Population distribution and characteristics ............................................................. 12 Age structure and other selected demographic characteristics ............................. 13 Minority and disadvantaged population segments ................................................ 18 Indigenous people in the North West ..................................................................... 18 The young people in the North West...................................................................... 23 Women in the North West ...................................................................................... 25 The disabled in the North West .............................................................................. 25 The aged in the North West ................................................................................... 26 Migrants in the North West ..................................................................................... 27 Post-secondary educational participation rates ..................................................... 27 Socio-economic indexes for areas (SEIFA) ........................................................... 29 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 33 Profile of NW education and training delivery ................................................................. 34 4.1. 4.2. 4.3. 4.3.1. 4.3.2. 4.3.3. 4.3.4. 4.4. 5. Geology and soils ..................................................................................................... 7 The original owners .................................................................................................. 7 European settlement and land use history ............................................................... 8 Unemployment and labour force participation ....................................................... 42 Tasmania ................................................................................................................ 42 Mersey-Lyell ........................................................................................................... 42 Labour market dynamics ........................................................................................ 53 The impact of ageing .............................................................................................. 54 Skill and labour shortages ...................................................................................... 56 Competition in a global labour market.................................................................... 56 A need for higher education, training and skill development ................................. 57 Lifelong learning ..................................................................................................... 58 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 59 Economic Activity ............................................................................................................ 60 6.1. 6.2. 6.2.1. 6.2.2. 6.2.3. 6.2.4. 6.2.5. 6.2.6. 6.2.7. A Profile of NW Business ....................................................................................... 61 A snapshot of some important industries in the NW LGAs .................................... 68 Manufacturing ......................................................................................................... 68 Health and community services ............................................................................. 69 Retail ...................................................................................................................... 71 Agriculture forestry and fishing ............................................................................... 72 Construction ........................................................................................................... 77 Tourism .................................................................................................................. 79 Transport industry .................................................................................................. 80 Skills Tasmania i NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 6.3. 7. Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 84 Infrastructure ................................................................................................................... 85 7.1. 7.2. 7.3. 7.4. 7.5. 7.6. 7.7. 7.8. 8. Energy infrastructure .............................................................................................. 85 Telecommunications and Internet access .............................................................. 86 Roads and transport infrastructure ......................................................................... 88 Water infrastructure ................................................................................................ 91 Port infrastructure ................................................................................................... 92 Waste ..................................................................................................................... 94 Private sector investments and infrastructure projects in planning ........................ 95 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 97 The environment ............................................................................................................. 98 8.1. 8.2. 8.3. 9. Current environmental issues ................................................................................ 98 The impact of climate change and other emerging issues..................................... 98 Conclusions .......................................................................................................... 100 Key Drivers of Development ......................................................................................... 101 10. 10.1. 10.2. 11. 11.1. 11.2. 11.3. Growth projections .................................................................................................... 103 Population Growth ................................................................................................ 103 Change in the labour force ................................................................................... 104 A gap analysis of the VET provision for the North West .......................................... 106 Limitations on this analysis .................................................................................. 106 Analysis of existing public and private provision based within the region ............ 106 Conclusions .......................................................................................................... 110 Appendices ............................................................................................................................ 111 Appendix 1: Methodology for developing this report ......................................................... 112 Appendix 2: North West enrolments by state funding source and level 2002-06 ............. 113 Appendix 3: National key findings for graduates and module completers from all VET providers by state/territory, 2007 ....................................................................................... 114 Appendix 4: VET Qualifications by Level and Field of Study for NW LGAs, NW Region and Tasmania (2006) ............................................................................................................... 115 Appendix 5: Higher Education Qualifications by Level and Field of Study for NW LGAs, NW Region and Tasmania (2006) ............................................................................................ 116 12. References ............................................................................................................... 117 Skills Tasmania ii NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile List of Tables Table 1: Summary regional community socio-demographic ..................................................... 3 Table 2: Total population of NW LGAs and notional catchment populations for main urban VET delivery (2006)………………………………………………………………………………….......................12 Table 3: Estimated distances and travel times for NW communities to access major urban VET centres…………………………………………………………………………………………..13 Table 4: Resident population age by sex for NW LGAs (2006) .............................................. 14 Table 5: Gross individual weekly income by sex by NW LGA, the region & Tasmania (2006) 14 Table 6: Change & growth in residential population for NW LGAs, the region & Tasmania (1996, 2001 & 2006) ................................................................................................................ 15 Table 7: Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander population by NW Tasmanian LGAs (2006) ...... 18 Table 8: Indigenous persons by age in NW Tasmanian LGAs (2006) .................................... 20 Table 9: Age group and sex of indigenous VET students, Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania and Australia (2006) ....................................................................................................................... 20 Table 12: Census of Population and Housing, Labour force status by age by sex for indigenous persons (2006) ...................................................................................................... 23 Table 13: Comparison of labour force participation rates of NW Tasmanian Indigenous Persons and the Tasmanian population (2006) ...................................................................... 23 Table 16: Percentage of Population in older age groups in NW LGAs and Tasmania (2006) 27 Table 17: Post-compulsory education and training participation rates by sex for the NW LGAs 1996-2006 ............................................................................................................................... 28 Table 18: VET students, by age group and sex, Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania & Australia 2006 .. 29 Table 19: 2027.6 Tasmanian population census data: Burnie and Devonport suburbs – nonschool qualification by level of education (2006) ..................................................................... 32 Table 28: Employment by industry and gender for North Western LGAs ............................... 45 Table 29: Field of study by occupation for the NW region (2006) ........................................... 46 Table 30: Occupation by gender for North Western LGAs ...................................................... 47 Table 31: Field of study of non-school qualification by gender for the NW LGAs and Tasmania ................................................................................................................................................. 47 Table 33: NW regional skill priorities by field of study and occupational level (2006) ............. 49 Table 35: Industry of employment (ANZSIC06) by UAI5P usual address five years ago indicator by NW LGA ............................................................................................................... 52 Table 38: Counts of Australian businesses, including entries and exits for Tasmania (2006-07) ................................................................................................................................................. 65 Table 39: Survival of businesses by industry subdivision for Tasmania, by annual turnover size ranges: June 2003 - June 2007 ....................................................................................... 66 Table 40: Survival of entries by industry subdivision for Tasmania, by annual turnover size ranges: June 2003 - June 2007 ............................................................................................... 67 Table 41: Tasmanian food & beverage scorecard 2004 – 05 ................................................. 73 Table 42: National capital city/rural change in house prices Jan 2007 to Jan 2008 ............... 78 Table 43: Computer use at home by LGA ............................................................................... 87 Table 44: Internet use in Tasmanian NW Local Government Areas ....................................... 88 Table 45: Cargo loaded and unloaded by Tasmanian ports, 2005–06 ................................... 93 Skills Tasmania iii NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 46: Ship activity at Tasmanian ports, 2005–06 ............................................................. 93 Table 47: North West Coast Investment Projects ................................................................... 96 Table 48: North West Tasmanian regional strengths and weaknesses ................................ 101 Table 49: Employment growth by ANZSIC industry, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) ................................................................................................................................. 104 Table 50: Employment growth by ASCO occupation, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) ................................................................................................................................. 104 Table 51: Employment growth by ASCED qualification field, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) ........................................................................................................................ 105 Table 52: Employment growth by ASCED attainment level, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) ................................................................................................................................. 105 Table 53: Employment growth by ASCED attainment level, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons)……………………………………………………………………………………….107 Table 54: Output of the NW VET system (2002-06)………………………………………..…..108 List of Figures Figure 1: Satellite photo-map of North West Tasmania and King Island ................................ 10 Figure 2: Ribbon development of Penguin, Chasm Creek, Burnie and Somerset areas ........ 10 Figure 3: Comparison of Burnie/Waratah-Wynyard’s & Devonport/Latrobe's gross individual weekly incomes 2006 .............................................................................................................. 16 Figure 4: Comparison of gross weekly family incomes within the richest and poorest rural and urban NW LGAs (2006) ........................................................................................................... 17 Figure 5: SEIFA index of relative advantage/disadvantage (2001) ......................................... 30 Figure 6: SEIFA index of economic resources (2001) ............................................................. 31 Figure 7: SEIFA index of education and occupation (2001) .................................................... 31 Figure 9: Business size by turnover in NW Tasmania (2006) ................................................. 61 Figure 10: Total businesses in NW Tasmania by industry (2006) ........................................... 62 Figure 11: Size of NW Tasmanian businesses by number of employees (2006) ................... 63 Figure 12: NW Tasmania - breakdown of small businesses by industry (2006) ..................... 63 Figure 13: NW Tasmanian businesses compared with total Tasmanian and total Australian businesses by industry (2006) ................................................................................................. 64 Skills Tasmania iv NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Preface This Training Demand Profile, by necessity, provides contextual information about the sociodemographics, industry and business profiles of the region but only does so where it may provide some assistance to understanding the publicly funded vocational education and training drivers and needs. It was not intended nor purports to provide an in-depth socioeconomic analysis of the North West community and readers should refer to other more appropriate sources for that information. The Cradle Coast Authority which co-ordinates and drives economic development across the nine local government areas of North-West and Western Tasmania (http://www.cradlecoast.com/Files/01112_CradleCoastAuthorityPortal.asp) or the Infrastructure and Resource Information Service (IRIS) which has been developed by the Tasmanian Government to provide information and tools to help investors, developers and planners (http://www.iris.tas.gov.au/) or the relevant State Government Agencies are recommended starting points for further information. The content of this report has been constrained to some extent by: The nature of the statistical data gathered by government sources. In particular, in many instances data is not collected at a local government area (LGA) level that allows the compilation of a profile for specific aggregations of LGAs; The small numbers in some fields of activity may potentially result in a breach of confidentiality as determined by the Privacy Act 1988 (Cwth) if data was released to the public. To avoid this, where the statistics in any area are small, the ABS has randomly changed the number to protect privacy and so readers will note that some tables, particularly those that provide statistics for the individual LGAs, will not sum to the total shown at the foot or side of the table; Many government agencies develop policies and programs for the whole state and do not differentiate regions or industries unless there are special circumstances; ABS data, on which this report largely relies, is a self-reporting survey which at times has high levels of detail lacking and is subject, to some extent, to highly idiosyncratic interpretation of questions and therefore some bias. The exclusion of the West Coast region or the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Lyell Statistical Subdivision requires the data sets for this report to be compiled for either the EIGHT Local Government Areas (LGAs) or for the remaining TWO ABS Statistical Subdivisions, Burnie-Devonport or North Western Rural. Where it has been possible and practicable information has been compiled from data for the eight LGAs and unless otherwise stated as close as possible to the displayed data or in the cited text, ABS data for the eight individual LGAs has been used. However, any material citing “Mersey-Lyell” contains a relatively small error for the West Coast population however in these instances, the author has made a judgement that the inclusion of the West Coast population does not bias the analysis or the ultimate findings. Skills Tasmania 1 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Abbreviations ABS – Australian Bureau of Statistics AQF – Australian Qualifications Framework AQTF – Australian Quality Training Framework FOS – Field of Study LGA – Local Government Area(s) NW - North West RTO – Registered Training Organisation VET - Vocational Education and Training Skills Tasmania 2 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 1. Summary - Key Points Table 1: Summary regional community socio-demographic indicators for North West Tasmania (1996, 2001 & 2006) Area NW Rural Median age of persons Burnie-Dev NW Rural Median individual income ($/weekly) Burnie-Dev NW Rural Census year Median/Average Measure Median family income ($/weekly) Burnie-Dev 1996 2001 2006 32 35 38 34 37 40 253 308 401 231 284 365 612 734 997 574 704 944 534 638 828 The characteristics of the North West coast region of Tasmania1 are not only attributable to its rich resources, natural beauty and industrious people but also to its history and the constraints of its rugged topography. The region was first settled in the far west by the Van Dieman’s 474 559 707 Burnie-Dev Land Company grant in 1826 and NW Rural Median housing loan repayment ($/monthly)542 550 769 then gradually the rugged central Burnie-Dev 542 542 823 NW Rural Median rent ($/weekly) 70 80 100 coast was settled largely by Burnie-Dev 88 97 125 miners, timber-cutters, yeoman NW Rural Average number of persons per bedroom 1.2 1.1 1.1 farmers and some ex-convicts. Burnie-Dev 1 1 1 The original indigenous owners of NW Rural Average household size 2.8 2.7 2.6 the land, the North West and Burnie-Dev 2.5 2.4 2.4 Northern tribes, were reduced to one sixth of their original numbers by the mid-1830s and were extinct as a people by 1857. NW Rural Median household income ($/weekly) The rugged topography and distance to markets that so constrained these early settlers remain today. The difficulties associated with the steep, broken topography and deep, fastflowing rivers with thickly wooded slopes combined with impenetrable tea tree flats around the coastal estuaries has produced the ribbon development east-west along the coast and inland, north-south along the ridge lines. Today this combines with a relatively small population to produce continuing concerns about transport systems and access, particularly for the disadvantaged. The isolation and perceived lack of support from the colonial government for development as the convict labour system wound down laid the foundation for the regional parochialism that is still evident today. The NW has 21% of the state’s population, is relatively homogeneous, ageing faster than any other in the nation, has shortages of those in the child raising age groups and has the lowest labour participation rates in the country. The Kentish and Circular Head districts have been identified as the most disadvantaged by ABS modelling (SEIFA index) of a basket of socioeconomic and educational characteristics. King Island, paradoxically considering its isolation, is relatively advantaged in many aspects. The NW attracts mainly English peaking migrants and only 32, out of the 368 from nonEnglish speaking countries arriving since 2004, rate themselves as being poor in English language skills. The retail, accommodation, health care, manufacturing and agriculture have the highest proportions of people with low incomes whilst manufacturing, mining, health and education have the highest proportions of highly paid jobs. Indigenous People have high participation rates in education and training and lower employment. They are growing faster than the rest of the NW population but in other demographic respects are quite similar to the main population. Younger Indigenous women are less involved in education whilst older women are more likely to be involved. This is consistent with national statistics. Indigenous people are engaged with lower levels of education but participate at less than half the state rate for higher education. In the main urban centres several suburbs stand out as most educationally disadvantaged; East Devonport, Quoiba, Acton Shorewell, Somerset, Upper Burnie and Wivenhoe. 1 For the purposes of this report, the North West includes the local governments of Burnie, Cradle Coast, Circular Head, Devonport, Kentish, King Island, Latrobe and Waratah/Wynyard. The West Coast has been the subject of a separate analysis and report. Skills Tasmania 3 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Young people under 20 years make up 23% of the NW population. Educational participation has fallen in recent years; Tasmania has the second lowest post-compulsory education and training rates of the states, although the NW has a slightly higher rate than the state. There are 18 RTOs in the region and 40% of training occurs through the TAFE purchase agreement. The number of completed VET qualifications has increased between 2002 – 06 and 50% of VET qualifications granted are now at Certificate III or above. About 50% of students come from around Devonport (but few drive from Kentish) and over 17% drive for over half an hour to a major VET centre. NW students claimed a high degree of satisfaction with and employment success from completing their VET course. On completion students are more likely to enrol in another VET course; and less likely to enrol in a university course than the state and employers rate the overall Tasmanian VET system highly although there are some anomalies in their responses. Non-accredited training is important and highly regarded and whilst employers believed that there was no equivalent for the commercial training they sourced outside the public system they generally did not investigate to confirm that this was the case. The main VET effort is in: Business and financial services – 20.1% Tourism – 10.3% Agriculture, Aquaculture, Fishing, Food & Beverages – 8.8% IT and communications – 8.6% General education – 7.8% Building and construction – 5.9% Health and community services – 5.8% Generally, the NW workforce is lower qualified than the state as a whole, and, with the exception of King Island, the more remote rural LGAs are most disadvantaged in this respect; Unemployment is low and employment at long term highs, however there is a significant proportion of people not in the labour force and Tasmania has the highest rate in the nation (27.3%). Whilst the reasons are complex, this segment does offer an opportunity to improve labour supply in the short term; The main Field of Study employed by industry are: Engineering Management and commerce Health Society and culture (in part social welfare) Architecture and building Food, hospitality and personal services Overall there is about a 30% mobility of the workforce in/out of the region over a 5 year period – about 4 to 6% per annum. Manufacturing, retail, health care and education have the highest rates of mobility; Tasmania is ageing faster than any other jurisdiction in Australia. This will bring the following challenges: Skill and labour shortages; Competition from the global employment marketplace; A need for more education and training; A need for lifelong learning. Skills Tasmania 4 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Manufacturing is probably the major growth sector in the NW with significant investments in progress that is likely to continue for another 5 years or so with the resources boom. There is a strong commitment by some of the larger businesses to the NW and development is currently being constrained to some extent by the lack of suitable staff as well as qualified staff. There is a trend towards graduate level staff brought about by an emphasis on process work and structure of the industry but that may be offset by the ageing of existing paraprofessional and trades people; Retail is dominated by small businesses but there are also a growing number of larger chain outlets. Business failures are significant and size of turnover is a guide to resilience. There is an on-going need to increase the business skills of the sector; The health and community services industry will grow due to an ageing of the community and professionalise as the emphasis on primary (preventative) health care expands. The industry has a significant VET level workforce amongst its support and ancillary staff and due to their ageing will continue to require significant VET output; Agriculture and its related food processing sector are currently struggling due to producing commodities in a global market where competition is on price. The industry lags behind the western world in its integration and level of strategic chain-oriented business skills. The construction boom, driven by industry expansion and domestic housing is continuing although may cool due to interest rate rises. There is a significant shortage of housing stock which is the subject of a State Government intervention of $60 million that will ensure a continuing demand for trade level skills in that industry; Tourism in the NW is largely small and micro enterprise based with a low commitment or capacity for training. The industry is characterised by a high turnover of staff due to low pay, poor conditions, unattractive work and often poor management. However, the industry continues to grow in turnover and needs to also continue to grow in innovation, customer service and overall professionalism. Therefore, continued public support of all levels of training is required although some review and rationalisation to ensure effectiveness may be warranted; Transport is a major focus of the NW due to the one port policy and having the main freight and passenger entry points for the state. Freight is predicted to double by 2020. This as well the Bell Bay Pulp Mill will affect the demand for transport workers. This will be exacerbated by the ageing of the current workforce. As a major industry, their needs must be addressed; Private sector investments in large projects are very sensitive to both Tasmanian and the wider global economic environment. The high levels of business confidence and the buoyant outlook have resulted in a large number of large infrastructure projects entering the planning and commitment phase. These will continue to drive training needs in the construction and engineering fields. The State Government’s Draft Climate Change Strategy for Tasmania (2006) has a limited involvement for VET in climate change at this stage. However, it can be imputed from this brief review of the evidence that at the very least local governments require education and training support. The growth of the Tasmanian economy has brought with it a number of supply side constraints that are cost-related or are matters of resource availability. The cost of labour has been identified as the single biggest constraint standing in the way of new investment. Closely related to this have been the availability of skilled labour and the more general availability of labour. Related is the availability of appropriate training and industrial relations issues. Other issues that have been included are transport costs and freight arrangements and for some parts of the State infrastructure, including telecommunications services, water and electricity supplies. Conclusions Engineering courses are vital to the future of the NW coast development. It is the largest group of qualifications employed by industry and yet has received only 4.1% of VET effort from 2002-06. Skills Tasmania 5 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Similar comments could be made about the construction industry as were made above about engineering. It receives 5.9% of effort and yet is vital to the coast’s development. Tourism related courses receive 10.3% of VET effort and has been an emphasis for over a decade in Tasmania. However, it is an industry that is largely comprised of small and micro businesses that employ few people. It is also an industry of low pay, often unpleasant work, odd hours and sometimes poor management and is consequently characterised by high turnover of employees. Given this, an in-depth review of the tourism and hospitality training effort may be warranted with a view to re-directing funding to other higher priority industries. Health and community services receive 5.8% of VET effort. The trend towards a significantly higher proportion of older people and the current influx of older people to the coast is widely recognised. Whilst this sector employs a lower proportion of VET qualified persons than other industries, there is a significant need for VET trained support and ancillary workers. The current effort should be reviewed to ensure that regional needs are adequately met. Business, financial and IT output, combined is nearly 29% of effort. Whilst industry continue to indicate the need for these qualifications, it is unlikely that an increase is justified in the light of other needs. It is even possible that an in-depth analysis of the impact of this training in terms of direct, short term benefit to coastal businesses may indicate that the current level of effort is excessive in some areas and that efficiencies could be gained. The agriculture, aquaculture, fishing, food and beverages industry is a major employer and is economically very important to the coast and Tasmania. It is also historically a low employer of qualified persons and is currently struggling to survive. However, 8.8% of effort may be adequate for the future but some re-focusing on more appropriate skill sets and reducing non-employment related training may provide more benefit for the industry. Skills Tasmania 6 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 2. Introduction Contrary to conventional wisdom the ‘key’ factors of production are created, not inherited. Skilled labour, capital and infrastructure involve heavy, sustained investment but are more difficult to duplicate, thus creating a more sustainable competitive advantage (Porter 1992). This report aims to describe the current status and future needs of the NW Region with respect to the first of those and in doing so will provide an overview of the socio-economic context and, where possible, the developmental trends and drivers to assist Skills Tasmania in planning the continuing Tasmanian Government investment in vocational education and training (VET) for the region. Its methodology may be found in Appendix 1. However, the natural environment, resource context, culture and history also influence the nature of industrial development (Auty 1997; Malmberg & Maskell 1997; Porritt 2005; Sachs & Warner 1999; Stijns 2001); therefore it is important that this is used as the background for analysis. 2.1. Geology and soils The Tasmanian landscape is dominated by an old, erosion resistant geology that emerged about 650 - 1,000 million years ago. Tasmania has had several periods of being covered by a shallow sea which laid down sedimentary rocks that were subsequently folded several times and/or were metamorphosed by heat and temperature producing rocks rich in mica and quartzite and other minerals (e.g. large deposits of magnetite, an iron oxide mineral) that have provided the basis for the mining industry of the West and NW coasts. During the Tertiary Period, basins formed in the Tasmanian landscape as a result of crustal stresses associated with the separation of Antarctica and the New Zealand sub continent. These valleys and basins, separated by hard dolerite ridges, filled with sediments and basalt flows during the Tertiary Period. Volcanic eruptions were concentrated along the fault lines which formed the basins. The geology of the NW (and the North East) has, where the annual rainfall exceeded 750mm, produced the characteristic brown or red ferrosol soils (formerly known as krasnozems). They contain high levels of iron and are deep, well-weathered, well-drained and friable soils that originally supported heavy forest vegetation. The soils near the coast are often the reddest in colour, but with increasing elevation and rainfall they transition to brown or black and the soil pH becomes more acid. Despite their rich colouration and apparent depth due to little differentiation between the soil horizons, the ferrosols are not highly fertile but in this respect provide an ideal medium for intensive cropping of vegetables, some berry and pome fruits, and the grazing of dairy and meat livestock. The intense geological pressures during these periods have also given the region its characteristic steep ridges and gullies, particularly around the Burnie-Devonport area (Doyle & Farquhar 2007; Scanlon, Fish & Yaxley 1990). 2.2. The original owners The NW (NW) region of Tasmania was first settled by the Aboriginal people between 6,000 – 22,500 years ago and at the time of the first European assessment in the 1830s, consisted of two main tribal groups. The North Western tribe occupied a territory extending from Table Cape on the NW Coast to Macquarie Harbour on the West Coast and had a total of approximately 600-700 members in eight sub-groups. The Northern tribe consisted of four sub-groups in the central North and their population was never estimated. Skills Tasmania 7 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile The NW tribe were primarily a maritime people occupying the coastal strip with families travelling during seasonal, cultural and foraging expeditions; however they were based in, and operated from a common territory for which they possessed a developed sense of ownership. Whilst the family groups had inland routes of travel and extensively used firestick farming methods of hunting they heavily relied on the sea for their staple shell and scale-fish and as a means of travel. This made the North Western and Northern Aboriginal tribes very vulnerable to attacks from the sea by sealers and the practices of the Van Dieman’s Land (VDL) Company, a London-based investment company, which was granted extensive NW land from Cape Grim in the Far NW to Burnie in 1826. Unfortunately, by 1834 less than one sixth of the original Aboriginal inhabitants had survived to be taken into exile on Flinders Island by the Friendly Mission and by 1857 the tribe was extinct (McFarlane 2002). 2.3. European settlement and land use history Whilst Tasmania’s European history dates from Lieutenant John Bowen (1803) and Colonel David Collins (1804) in the Derwent estuary, the settlement of Tasmania’s NW was accomplished by two strategies; the previously mentioned land grant in 1826 to the VDL Company and by a myriad of small land grants to individual free settlers and ticketof-leave men (former convicts) from the 1830s. Van Diemen's Land, as Tasmania was then known, was a military settlement until becoming a colony under its own administration on 3rd December 1825. After this time the colony was administered by the Lieutenant-Governor and a Legislative Council of six members and did not become known as Tasmania or have a bicameral system of government until 1856 after a concerted political effort. By 1823 most of the good land in the eastern half of the state had been alienated (granted to settlers) and so Lt- Gov. Sorrell commissioned exploration efforts in the NW although the incoming Lieutenant-Governor, George Arthur, actively discouraged settlement to enhance the security of the Macquarie Harbour Penal Settlement. All these explorations independently concurred that the only suitable land was at Circular Head; the area from Port Sorell to Circular Head being deemed “barren” and unsuitable country. This set the scene for independent, commercially based exploration and development. Tasmania was populated by many people with aspirations to improve their socioeconomic situation from the one they were born into in Britain and was also frequented by transient exploiters such as the miners, loggers, sealers and whalers who influenced development. These began a long tradition of exploiting and taming the land rather than stewardship. All these pioneering efforts were constrained by the rugged topography with extensive areas of dense tea tree near the coast and the massive forests with an almost impenetrable under story that grew on the mountainous inland ridges and gullies cut by oft-raging torrents. The pattern of settlement started in those times remains as an influence of NW Coast development today. Early settlement occurred around the major points of sea access; the Rubicon, Mersey, Forth and Leven Rivers. Port Sorell and Latrobe were settled in the 1830s, Forth by the adventurous James Fenton in 1839, the Moriarty-Sassafras and Don areas in the 1840s, and Devonport (as Torquay and Formby), Kentish and Ulverstone in the 1850s. Concerned with the economic decline of the colony, the Tasmanian parliament in 1858 approved legislation intended to settle small yeoman farmers (few ex-convicts persisted) in the often fertile but heavily timbered western half of the island. The new act at first attracted many settlers to the forest lands, most of whom had at least some previous experience of farming, if little capital. But within a decade they were threatened with ruin Skills Tasmania 8 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile because of a disastrous fall in Australian crop prices, the effects of which were aggravated by the reluctance of a series of weak ministries to build roads in the new settlements: that most of the pioneers were able to keep their farms was a tribute to their determination and the fertility of the soil. In the 1880s Australian population and overseas markets began to outstrip food production and crop prices at last rose, encouraging another influx of settlers to the forest lands which continued, checked by the depression of the early 1890s, into the first decade of the new century. The farmer’s position was further strengthened by the introduction of industrial dairying, which reduced his dependence on the uncertain produce market, and by 1910 the North-West was a well established, quite prosperous community of small freeholders (Stokes 1969). Until the 1890s, Latrobe was the largest centre on the coast (1,500 people) with 50,000 acres under crops and its own port at present-day Bell’s Parade. Even Don, with its own port, eclipsed Devonport until the latter part of the nineteenth century. Emu Bay, today known as the City of Burnie, was the VDL Company’s second settlement, but due to the failure of their Surry Hills sheep venture the settlement barely survived until, in the midst of a livestock price recession, the Company decided to lease blocks to new settlers. It wasn’t until the discovery of the Mt Bischoff Tin Mine in 1871 that Emu Bay started to develop as a port for ore exports. Almost every significant river on the NW Coast at some time hosted a port; even the smaller Cam River (Somerset) and the Inglis River (Wynyard) between the 1860s to the 1880s had their own thriving ports. The 1870 census showed that the Table Cape district had 400 more settlers and the Inglis River was a busier port than Burnie (Fenton 1891; Pink 1990). This not only provides evidence of the difficulty of travel and the paucity of roads infrastructure but also the intensity of agricultural, timber and mining activities as well as clues to the under-lying historical roots of the community relationships in the NW today. In the 1850s, land-based travel was still largely by foot or single horse tracks through the bush. However, by this time the convict system that had supplied much of the labour for the infrastructure development for the eastern half of Tasmania was coming to an end and the settlers of the NW were developing their own roads to accommodate their own commercial needs. By and large these were later formalised by the government surveyors into the public road network seen today. This poor infrastructure lead to the establishment of ‘road trusts’ or community managed organisations seeking private or government funding to develop roads and managing the projects when they were implemented (Department of Main Roads - Historical Committee 1988). It was not until the twentieth century with Commonwealth Government funding of national roads development and the emphasis in the last thirty years on tourism that the NW Coast and its connections to the West Coast has been able to attain a first class road system. However, even that is constrained by the underlying settlement patterns and basic demographics of the region. The struggle for development has however, established a cultural precedence for the relationship of the NW with the other two Tasmanian regions. Skills Tasmania 9 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 1: Satellite photo-map of North West Tasmania and King Island Skills Tasmania 10 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 2: Ribbon development of Penguin, Chasm Creek, Burnie and Somerset areas Skills Tasmania 11 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 3. The people The characteristics of a community influence the types of training required, methods of delivery and the propensity of people to participate although there are exogenous factors that also influence decision-making and some of these will be canvassed in other sections. 3.1. Population distribution and characteristics Tasmania's population is experiencing demographic change which will have significant economic, social and fiscal impacts in future decades. This change is expected to be a more important issue for Tasmania as the population: Is ageing more rapidly than any other jurisdiction; Continues to have shortages of those in child raising age groups; and Has the lowest labour force participation rate than any jurisdiction. The estimated resident population of Tasmania at June 2006 was 476,480 people. Between June 2001 and June 2006 Tasmania's population increased by 18,100 people, at an average rate of 0.8% per year. This compares with the period between June 1996 and June 2001 when the population declined by 2,600 people, albeit at a low average annual rate of 0.1%. This has been due to significant inflows of interstate migrants between 2001-04, which has since slowed, equally significant inflows of overseas migrants and a jump in natural increase. The NW population is quite homogeneous with 86% being born in Australia, 4.3% in the UK, 1% in NZ and 0.6% in The Netherlands. Whilst 50 countries are represented in the NW, the numbers are only small fractions of one per cent. Some 25% of those born overseas are between 25 – 44 years. In the NW about 40% of households involve a registered marriage, 8% a de facto relationship and 5% are lone parent households. This is just marginally higher than Tasmania as a whole. Figure 1 (preceding) provides an overview of the region and its major towns and roads (unfortunately space will not allow the inclusion of King Island). The satellite photo is useful because it illustrates graphically just how little of the NW has been able to be cleared and densely populated (the light green areas). Figure 2 is a close up satellite photo montage of the Penguin, Chasm Creek, Burnie and Somerset urban complex. It illustrates the significant constraints of the topography common Table 2: Total population of NW LGAs to much of the NW. Note the north-south ribbon and notional catchment populations development along the tops of steep ridges and for main urban VET delivery (2006) the coastal strip. LGA/Region These two photos amply illustrate the topographical constraints of the region that made it so difficult to develop from virgin bush and to efficiently conduct business. These constraints continue today and lie behind the transport parochialism that is such a strong cultural characteristic. One need only consider the political battles that have been fought over infrastructure such as ports, airports, roads and hospitals. Table 2 illustrates in broad terms the population distribution for the NW LGAs and King Island. A simple calculation of the catchment populations for Population Catchment Population Burnie 19,701 44,145 War/Wyn 13,815 Central Coast 10,629 Circular Head Devonport Kentish Latrobe Central Coast King Is 8,188 8,188 24,880 50,362 5,965 8,888 10,629 1,703 1,703 Note: The Central Coast population has been split 50:50 to indicate that people may go either to Burnie or to Devonport for training Skills Tasmania 12 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile the main VET delivery points indicates the potential size of local markets Table 3: Estimated distances and travel times for NW communities to access major urban VET between delivery sites centres (notwithstanding that there are other Distance Travel Time minor or temporary centres used or Home Town To Main VET Centre (Km) to Major VET that people may choose to travel to Centre centres other than their closest one or even travel from elsewhere in the Burnie Devonport 50 45 min state). Wynyard Burnie Burnie This provides an insight into VET Smithton provider’s problems of achieving Ulverstone Burnie economic class sizes and the range of Ulverstone Devonport courses that the local community Devonport Burnie Devonport needs. Approximately 43% people live Latrobe Sheffield Devonport within the Devonport VET catchment and 42% (excluding Circular Head) within the Burnie catchment. 10 15 min 88 75 min 35 30 min 15 15 min 50 45 min 10 10 min 25 35 min However, this does not provide an entirely accurate indication of the actual catchment population because in the case of Burnie, many travel in from outside the region from the West Coast or from Circular Head, Central Coast and Devonport. This occurs due to community acceptance of single delivery sites due to the need for specialist equipment or facilities. Most private (as opposed to business) training participants prefer to travel no more than 30 – 60 minutes to access training. Table 3 estimates the likely travel times to the major urban delivery points. It is apparent that 85% people (Circular Head and King Island residents are excluded) live within an hour’s drive of a major urban delivery point of VET. It should be noted that because of the terrain and settlement patterns along the ridges where access is only via narrow winding roads, travel times can vary considerably. 3.2. Age structure and other selected demographic characteristics The age profile of arrivals and departures over recent years suggests that Tasmania is experiencing a net in-migration of families. If this trend is sustained it is likely to have a slight moderating impact on the rate of population ageing. Analysis of the age composition of recent net migration to Tasmania reveals that the state is becoming more attractive to younger persons and families. The optimistic economic outlook, good job opportunities and lifestyle benefits are making Tasmania a more attractive place to live. The North West region has 21% of Tasmania’s population. However, after the 1996 Census, the North West regional population fell by about 2,548 but from 2001 to 2006 the population increased by 3,089 exceeding its previous level of 103,858. Burnie, Circular Head and Waratah/Wynyard have the highest proportions of children and young people in their populations which, for Burnie and Waratah/Wynyard are to be expected as they are dormitory areas for Burnie. King Island has the smallest numbers of the younger age groups of any LGA (Table 4). However, Kentish and King Island have the highest proportion of middle aged persons, probably because of the predominance of primary industry employment in the regions. Central Coast and Waratah/Wynyard have the largest proportions of the over 60s, reflecting the fact that those LGAs host the main retirement facilities in the region. Skills Tasmania 13 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 4: Resident population age by sex for NW LGAs (2006) Burnie Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Is 0-4 years M 586 F 625 Total 1,211 M 616 F 591 Total 1,207 M 284 F 269 Total 553 M 761 F 681 Total 1,442 M 188 F 147 Total 335 M 39 F 51 5-9 years 709 678 1,387 656 655 1,311 344 289 633 857 788 1,645 229 215 444 38 10-14 years 736 703 1,439 795 710 1,505 345 317 662 848 802 1,650 221 251 472 63 15-19 years 676 675 1,351 727 684 1,411 286 234 520 855 787 1,642 228 210 438 20-24 years 544 595 1,139 419 467 886 246 244 490 613 638 1,251 105 112 25-29 years 510 566 1,076 426 470 896 209 209 418 623 702 1,325 112 30-34 years 569 592 1,161 524 588 1,112 232 254 486 694 787 1,481 35-39 years 636 659 1,295 593 704 1,297 261 288 549 768 830 40-44 years 674 707 1,381 757 783 1,540 320 297 617 726 45-49 years 634 700 1,334 816 826 1,642 322 294 616 50-54 years 597 649 1,246 734 770 1,504 276 270 55-59 years 583 609 1,192 740 738 1,478 268 60-64 years 516 492 1,008 650 661 1,311 65-69 years 438 447 885 504 536 70-74 years 319 393 712 414 75-79 years 209 308 517 80-84 years 166 252 85-89 years 60 90-94 years Latrobe War/Wyn Total 90 M 261 F 233 Total 494 49 87 288 280 50 113 328 275 39 32 71 291 217 55 46 101 99 211 64 39 140 179 319 48 1,598 215 245 460 847 1,573 253 230 776 880 1,656 248 546 815 811 1,626 248 516 736 842 224 174 398 649 1,040 137 138 275 459 873 132 109 326 374 700 75 418 226 308 534 136 196 99 163 22 63 85 43 95-99 years 5 17 22 100 years and over 3 0 3 Total 343 F 333 568 492 603 548 234 525 214 189 103 202 43 91 66 51 483 64 211 459 233 194 1,578 213 660 1,309 555 617 241 441 88 163 55 102 262 31 84 127 5 22 0 0 Tasmania Total 676 M 3,078 F 2,930 Total 6,008 M 14,803 F 13,859 Total 28,662 475 967 3,613 3,429 7,042 16,241 15,378 31,619 540 1,088 3,884 3,648 7,532 17,364 16,380 33,744 483 449 932 3,585 3,305 6,890 16,856 15,966 32,822 403 303 287 590 2,499 2,578 5,077 14,484 14,460 28,944 211 413 251 295 546 2,397 2,591 4,988 12,255 13,001 25,256 249 250 499 338 339 677 2,794 3,032 5,826 13,803 14,980 28,783 117 275 310 585 416 523 939 3,230 3,610 6,840 15,698 16,942 32,640 67 131 316 305 621 521 507 1,028 3,631 3,743 7,374 16,666 17,588 34,254 59 52 111 320 352 672 501 540 1,041 3,676 3,855 7,531 17,651 18,546 36,197 427 65 72 137 325 310 635 481 501 982 3,526 3,577 7,103 16,638 17,197 33,835 231 444 72 66 138 355 331 686 452 473 925 3,419 3,538 6,957 16,207 16,466 32,673 173 170 343 50 34 84 257 281 538 391 422 813 2,910 2,894 5,804 12,944 12,963 25,907 1,172 149 119 268 48 45 93 226 200 426 338 333 671 2,395 2,435 4,830 10,237 10,570 20,807 518 959 100 73 173 32 21 53 182 182 364 240 259 499 1,860 2,014 3,874 7,986 8,662 16,648 366 458 824 64 53 117 24 20 44 129 151 280 239 256 495 1,432 1,708 3,140 6,496 7,802 14,298 157 259 457 716 44 48 92 24 20 44 88 110 198 122 174 296 984 1,471 2,455 4,356 6,494 10,850 42 73 123 264 387 17 26 43 15 6 21 34 47 81 64 114 178 443 798 1,241 1,895 3,749 5,644 14 19 33 40 93 133 5 9 14 5 4 9 8 25 33 14 33 47 151 330 481 642 1,630 2,272 27 0 4 4 6 34 40 3 0 3 0 0 0 0 5 5 4 15 19 23 97 120 135 413 548 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 3 6 9 24 53 77 1,638 4,348 4,281 8,629 9,192 9,866 19,058 10,070 10,593 20,663 4,061 3,889 7,950 11,511 12,499 24,010 2,940 2,822 5,762 870 768 M Reg Total 6,541 6,871 13,412 49,533 51,589 101,122 233,381 243,099 476,480 Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007g) Table 5: Gross individual weekly income by sex by NW LGA, the region & Tasmania (2006) Burnie Source: Negative/Nil income $1-$149 Central Coast Circular Head Devonport M 307 F 499 Total 806 M 397 F 537 Total 934 M 157 F Total 223 380 M 401 341 744 1,085 426 Kentish King Is Latrobe War/Wyn F 535 Total 936 M 123 F Total M 184 307 34 F Total 49 83 M 141 F Total 208 349 M 239 F 372 274 Reg Total Tasmania Total 611 M 1,799 F 2,607 Total 4,406 M 9,366 F 12,496 Total 21,862 838 1,264 102 275 377 463 909 1,372 130 221 351 15 32 47 159 309 468 551 825 1,910 3,879 5,789 9,299 17,399 26,698 $150-$249 1,319 1,839 3,158 1,380 1,988 3,368 396 574 970 1,582 2,306 3,888 455 547 1,002 80 91 171 572 801 1,373 943 1,369 2,312 6,727 9,515 16,242 28,367 39,264 67,631 $250-$399 905 1,638 2,543 1,028 1,813 2,841 359 655 1,014 1,233 2,332 3,565 312 417 729 69 108 177 476 733 1,209 739 1,145 1,884 5,121 8,841 13,962 22,444 39,085 61,529 $400-$599 951 1,281 2,232 1,114 1,340 2,454 561 544 1,105 1,415 1,689 3,104 348 370 718 137 146 283 523 569 1,092 713 855 1,568 5,762 6,794 12,556 26,687 31,765 58,452 $600-$799 883 649 1,532 1,010 622 1,632 516 260 776 1,190 854 2,044 267 163 430 126 60 186 413 301 714 586 418 1,004 4,991 3,327 8,318 23,862 18,050 41,912 $800-$999 706 304 1,010 722 351 1,073 348 151 499 765 416 1,181 192 76 268 72 40 112 339 149 488 478 205 683 3,622 1,692 5,314 17,002 10,565 27,567 $1,000-$1,299 673 276 949 764 335 1,099 255 104 359 710 358 1,068 174 58 232 72 34 106 343 143 486 498 196 694 3,489 1,504 4,993 16,779 9,218 25,997 $1,300-$1,599 313 86 399 325 101 426 110 31 141 368 116 484 74 18 92 29 18 47 169 38 207 202 68 270 1,590 476 2,066 8,296 3,365 11,661 $1,600-$1,999 112 31 143 125 28 153 46 23 69 166 37 203 28 0 28 16 0 16 65 23 88 82 29 111 640 171 811 3,840 1,250 5,090 $2,000 or more 157 38 195 131 44 175 65 23 88 167 45 212 30 0 30 17 9 26 54 16 70 85 23 108 706 198 904 4,801 1,356 6,157 Individual income not stated 487 480 967 577 643 1,220 177 151 328 588 631 1,219 167 163 330 63 35 98 219 205 424 324 288 612 2,602 2,596 5,198 14,229 13,671 27,900 Total 7,154 7,865 15,019 7,999 8,640 16,639 3,092 3,014 6,106 9,048 10,228 19,276 2,300 2,217 4,517 730 622 1,352 3,473 3,495 6,968 5,163 5,519 10,682 38,959 41,600 66,507 184,972 197,484 382,456 Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics(2007d) Skills Tasmania 14 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 6: Change & growth in residential population for NW LGAs, the region & Tasmania (1996, 2001 & 2006) ERP at 30 June Change 1996-01 NW Tasmanian LGA Burnie 1996 19,977 2001 18,886 2006 19,701 % Region/Tas 19% no. -1,091 Central Coast 21,351 21,029 21,259 20% Circular Head 8,450 8,047 8,188 8% Devonport 24,935 24,257 24,880 Kentish 5,462 5,499 5,965 King Island 1,879 1,724 1,703 Change 2001-06 State Rank (2001-06) % -1.1 no. 815 % 0.8 Fastest 12 Largest 9 -322 0 230 0 23 19 -403 -1 141 0 21 22 24% -678 -1 623 1 17 11 6% 37 0 466 2 3 14 2% -155 -2 -21 0 27 Latrobe 7,801 8,241 8,888 9% 440 1 647 2 5 10 Waratah/Wynyard 14,003 13,627 13,815 13% -376 -1 188 0 21 20 Region 103,858 101,310 104,399 21% -2,548 Tasmania 474,443 471,795 489,922 -0.1 18,127 -2,648 3,089 0.8 Note: ERP = Estimated Residential Population Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics(2007d) Skills Tasmania 15 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 4.2. Age structure and other selected demographic characteristics Cont’d Table 6 (previous) indicates that all LGAs experienced small (population) increases except King Island. Across the decade 1996-06 the fastest growing LGA has been Latrobe and, along with the Kentish district have been rated the fifth and third (respectively) fastest growing LGAs in the state. Burnie, Latrobe and Devonport are ranked the ninth, tenth and eleventh largest LGAs in the state (respectively). Table 5 should be read in conjunction with Figures 3 and 4 (following). This indicates: King Island has a disproportionately large number of people with high income; High incomes are quite evenly distributed between the main urban dormitory 2areas for Burnie – Waratah/Wynyard (50.4%) and Devonport/Latrobe (49.6%); 3 Kentish, Circular Head, Waratah/Wynyard and Latrobe have disproportionately high numbers of people in low income brackets compared to the regional population; Figure 3: Comparison of Burnie/Waratah-Wynyard’s & Devonport/Latrobe's gross individual weekly incomes 2006 Ind Income NS $2,000 + $1,600-$1,999 $1,300-$1,599 Income $1,000-$1,299 Latrobe $800-$999 Devonport War/Wyn $600-$799 Burnie $400-$599 $250-$399 $150-$249 $1-$149 Nil income 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 4,000 4,500 Nos People in each Income Category Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007f) 2 Urban areas that predominantly provide domestic accommodation and their accompanying small service businesses for populations that work in a larger nearby town or city that has much larger, wealth generating industries. 3 The ABS ‘Travel to Work’ data for the 2006 Census has yet to be released, so this assumes that the Central Coast residents are evenly split between Burnie and Devonport in terms of their workplace. Skills Tasmania 16 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 4: Comparison of gross weekly family incomes within the richest and poorest rural and urban NW LGAs (2006) Individual income not stated $2,000 or more $1,600-$1,999 $1,300-$1,599 $1,000-$1,299 War/Wyn Latrobe King Is Income $800-$999 Kentish Devonport $600-$799 Circ Head Central Coast $400-$599 Burnie $250-$399 $150-$249 $1-$149 Negative/Nil income 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% No. People in each Income Category Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007f) Skills Tasmania 17 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 3.2. Age structure and other selected demographic characteristics Cont’d The Census also provides an indication of the relative wage profiles of the main industries in the North West region: The Retail trades (8.4%), Accommodation & food services (5.3%), Health care & social assistance (5.3%) Manufacturing (4.8%) and Agriculture, forestry & fishing (4%), provide the largest number of lowly paid jobs ($599 per week or less), however much of this is due to the large proportion of part time employment available, particularly for women, in industries such as Retail, Accommodation etc and Health care services. Manufacturing (7.6%), Education and training (3.9%), Health care (3.6%) and Public administration & safety (3.5%) have the highest number of middle income jobs ($600 - $1299 per week). Manufacturing (1.6%), Mining (1.1%), Health care (0.9%) and Education and training (0.8%) have the largest number of high paid jobs ($1300 +). Further analysis of the income data provides an indication of the place of residence of those with the highest paying jobs. Devonport has 1.3% of all highest paid persons, Central Coast 1.1% and Waratah/Wynyard has 0.7%. A similar pattern exists for the middle income earners. 3.3. Minority and disadvantaged population segments 4 3.3.1.Indigenous people in the North West Although the last known survivor of the North West population died in 1857, the North Western LGAs have a significant population of their descendants and other Tasmanian Aboriginals. Table 7 shows that Circular Head and King Island have the largest proportion of Aboriginal Tasmanians (7.8%) and almost all the LGAs have a larger percentage living in their municipalities (4.8%) than does Tasmania as a whole (3.5%). Table 7: Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander population by NW Tasmanian LGAs (2006) Indigenous status Proportion of Population Indigenous NonIndigenous Status unknown Total Indigenous Status unknown Waratah/Wynyard 703 12,267 442 13,412 5.2 3.3 Circular Head (M)/King Island 745 8,493 358 9,596 7.8 3.7 Burnie 888 17,398 770 19,056 4.7 4.0 Kentish 204 5,347 208 5,759 3.5 3.6 Latrobe 428 7,871 331 8,630 5.0 3.8 Central Coast 1,071 18,699 894 20,664 5.2 4.3 Devonport 1,063 21,939 1,013 24,015 4.4 4.2 Region 5,102 92,014 4,016 101,132 Tasmania 16,718 435,963 22,834 475,515 3.5 4.8 Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics (2006a) 4 It should be noted that in many instances for the data regarding minorities, small numbers have resulted in the ABS applying random variations to ensure compliance with the Commonwealth Privacy Act. In these instances, this has resulted in totals that do not balance. Skills Tasmania 18 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Tables 8, 9 and 10 (following pages) provide a snapshot of the age and educational status of Indigenous People in the North Western LGAs in Tasmania. Table 8 illustrates that the Indigenous population of NW Tasmania is growing significantly, although it is not clear whether this is due to an increasing willingness of people to declare their Aboriginality. The decline in the younger age groups that can be observed matches the rest of the Tasmanian population. However, whilst the change in the balance of age groups within the Indigenous population also matches the state, the absolute growth in the older age categories is significant. Again, this is probably due to a growth in reporting; Table 9 shows that: 480 or 9.4% of ATSI persons in the region were involved in a VET training course on the night of the census; The 30 – 39 years age group and older were less than half as likely to be involved in training than the 20-24 year old group or younger; Younger Indigenous women were less likely to be involved in VET than their male contemporaries; Older Indigenous women were more likely to be involved in VET than their male contemporaries. These observed phenomena are consistent with the state and national situation. In Table 10 we can see that: A total of 790 Indigenous People have VET qualifications and 83 have Higher education (mainly at bachelor’s degree level) in the NW LGAs. 79% of these are at Certificate IV or less and are predominantly in the under 44 year age group; Indigenous People participate in Higher Education at Bachelor’s Degree level at half the rate of the Tasmanian population (6.5%) and at even lower rates at post-graduate levels (0.5% at Grad Dip); At VET levels, 9.8% of Indigenous People have an Advanced Diploma or Diploma (Tasmania 12%) and at the lower Certificate levels have higher levels of participation than the general population – at Certificate I & II levels they actually participate at almost three times the rate of the Tasmanian population. Skills Tasmania 19 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 8: Indigenous persons by age in NW Tasmanian LGAs (2006) Indigenous 2006 Growth in Age Category 1996 2001 0-4 years 531 544 546 5-9 years 555 632 601 10-14 years 587 673 15-19 years 514 20-24 years Non-Indigenous 2006 Growth in Age Category Absolute Change in Age Relativities 1996 2001 3% -2% 6,829 5,639 5,215 8% -1% 7,117 6,614 6,130 661 13% -1% 7,488 6,628 523 621 21% 0% 6,444 314 356 387 23% 0% 25-29 years 324 277 323 0% 30-34 years 290 327 283 -2% 35-39 years 301 323 347 40-44 years 238 317 45-49 years 182 50-54 years Indigenous Status NS 2001 2006 Growth in Absolute Age Change in Category Age Relativities Absolute Change in Age Relativities 1996 -24% -2% 226 331 249 10% -14% -1% 167 211 306 83% 6,589 -12% -1% 156 219 274 5,996 6,054 -6% 0% 184 170 5,544 4,261 4,526 -18% -1% 141 -1% 6,358 4,932 4,515 -29% -2% -1% 7,033 5,935 5,362 -24% -2% 15% 0% 7,531 6,587 6,283 -17% 342 44% 1% 7,007 6,975 6,789 229 278 53% 1% 6,634 6,420 121 164 224 85% 1% 5,428 55-59 years 92 116 183 99% 1% 60-64 years 50 93 118 136% 65 years & over 84 131 188 124% Total Tasmania 2006 Growth in Age Category 1996 2001 -1% 7,586 6,514 6,010 -21% -2% 3% 7,839 7,457 7,037 -10% -1% 76% 2% 8,231 7,520 7,524 -9% -1% 221 20% 0% 7,142 6,689 6,896 -3% 0% 140 160 13% 0% 5,999 4,757 5,073 -15% -1% 121 154 155 28% 0% 6,803 5,363 4,993 -27% -2% 167 183 181 8% -1% 7,490 6,445 5,826 -22% -2% -1% 176 172 217 23% 0% 8,008 7,082 6,847 -14% -1% -3% 0% 148 210 245 66% 2% 7,393 7,502 7,376 0% 0% 7,049 6% 1% 182 168 210 15% 0% 6,998 6,817 7,537 8% 1% 6,241 6,677 23% 1% 172 169 207 20% 0% 5,721 6,574 7,108 24% 1% 4,748 5,164 6,546 38% 2% 181 166 233 29% 0% 5,021 5,446 6,962 39% 2% 1% 3,985 4,468 5,458 37% 2% 204 166 224 10% -1% 4,239 4,727 5,800 37% 2% 2% 11,741 12,407 14,819 26% 4% 1,098 1,071 1128 3% -5% 12,923 13,609 16,135 25% 3% 4,183 4,705 5,102 93,887 88,267 92,012 Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007a) 3,323 3,530 4010 Absolute Change in Age Relativities 101,393 96,502 101,124 Note: “Age Relativities” refers to the change in balance of age groups within the population between censuses 1996 & 2006 Table 9: Age group and sex of indigenous VET students, Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania and Australia (2006) Mersey-Lyell Age Group Unknown Tasmania Male Female Total Male 14 years and under 15-19 years 80 (a) 60 Unknown Total 130 870 670 11,060 9130 140 230 20 1550 20,210 20-24 years 60 40 100 25-29 years 30 20 50 170 110 280 6,490 4660 (a) 11,160 90 60 150 4,210 3070 (a) 30-39 years 30 50 7,280 80 100 110 220 6,790 6230 (a) 13,030 40-49 years 30 50-59 years 10 40 70 80 90 170 4,260 4830 (a) 9,090 20 30 30 40 70 1,640 2160 (a) 60-64 years (a) 3,800 (a) (a) (a) (a) (a) 250 370 (a) 65 years and older (a) 620 (a) (a) (a) (a) 140 280 Not known (a) (a) (a) (a) (a) (a) 390 290 (a) Total 250 680 230 480 710 560 31690 60 67,840 (a) Unknown Australia (a) 360 (a) Female Total Male 1,270 36,100 Female 420 Copyright Australian Government 2007 Due to confidentiality reasons (a) represents figures 1 to 9 inclusive. Data have been rounded to the nearest ten. Due to rounding some figures may not sum. In this table, te West Coast could not be excluded Source: NCVER Australian vocational education and training statistics: and courses. Skills Students Tasmania 20 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 10: Level of education by indigenous status by age in NW Tasmanian LGAs Graduate Level of Diploma Postgraduate Advanced & Graduate Bachelor Diploma Certificate Level: III & IV Level Level of inadequately education described not stated Total & Diploma Level, nfd 4 7 13 106 54 6 87 277 17 27 10 140 29 11 33 267 34 38 12 127 20 5 43 285 0 16 28 10 89 3 9 33 188 0 0 6 9 7 36 3 4 37 102 65 years and over 0 0 0 7 0 15 0 3 43 68 Total 0 6 77 116 52 513 109 38 276 1,187 Degree Certificate Indigenous: 15-24 years 0 0 25-34 years 0 0 35-44 years 0 6 45-54 years 0 55-64 years Non-Indigenous: 15-24 years Degree I & II Level education 0 4 300 150 129 1,268 356 64 700 2,971 25-34 years 54 64 942 568 213 2,323 235 120 399 4,918 35-44 years 95 122 985 811 251 2,933 193 217 632 6,239 45-54 years 163 170 1,175 1,015 275 2,827 161 213 729 6,728 55-64 years 124 151 694 820 160 1,753 82 181 872 4,837 65 years and over 60 61 465 697 130 1,450 35 212 2,640 5,750 Total 496 572 4,561 4,061 1,158 12,554 1,062 1,007 5,972 31,443 Indigenous status not stated: 15-24 years 3 0 4 3 0 10 6 0 261 287 25-34 years 3 0 6 3 0 14 0 0 265 291 35-44 years 0 0 9 7 6 25 3 0 330 380 45-54 years 0 0 6 3 0 20 0 3 319 351 55-64 years 0 0 3 3 3 31 0 0 314 354 65 years and over 3 0 8 10 0 25 0 0 834 880 Total 9 0 36 29 9 125 9 3 2,323 2,543 Total: 15-24 years 3 4 308 160 142 1,384 416 70 1,048 3,535 25-34 years 57 64 965 598 223 2,477 264 131 697 5,476 35-44 years 95 128 1,028 856 269 3,085 216 222 1,005 6,904 45-54 years 163 170 1,197 1,046 285 2,936 164 225 1,081 7,267 55-64 years 124 151 703 832 170 1,820 85 185 1,223 5,293 65 years and over 63 61 473 714 130 1,490 35 215 3,517 6,698 4,206 1,219 Total 505 578 4,674 13,192 1,180 1,048 8,571 35,173 Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007b) Skills Tasmania 21 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 11 provides a snapshot of those currently attending post-compulsory education and training5: Males comprise 41.8% of the total of all indigenous post-compulsory education and training attendance. Of these, about one third are at the VET level and only 3.9% are at higher education, the remainder being not sufficiently specified. Of the Indigenous female attendance, 35% are at the VET level and about 12% at higher education, the remainder being not sufficiently specified. The Indigenous male VET participation rate (2.67%)6 is five times the state Table 11: Indigenous participation rates in post-compulsory education and training in NW Tasmanian LGAs (2006) Indigenous People in NW LGAs Tasmania Males Females Persons Males Females Persons 35 40 75 341 403 8 24 32 92 234 326 Sub Total Full-time 43 64 107 433 637 1,070 VET Full-time Participation Rate % 1.35% 3.33% 2.10% 0.19% 0.26% 0.22% Aged 15-24 years 22 19 41 362 228 590 Aged 25 years and over 20 41 61 436 717 1,153 0 3 3 19 17 36 VET Institution: Full-time student: Aged 15-24 years Aged 25 years and over 744 Part-time student: FT/PT student status not stated Sub Total Part-time 42 63 105 817 962 1,779 VET Part-time Participation Rate % 1.32% 3.28% 2.06% 0.35% 0.40% 0.37% Total VET Students 85 127 212 1,250 1,599 2,849 Total VET Participation Rate % 2.67% 6.61% 4.16% 0.54% 0.66% 0.60% 3 21 24 95 250 345 269 University/Tertiary Institution: Full-time student: Aged 15-24 years Aged 25 years and over 7 13 20 92 177 Sub Total Full-time 10 34 44 187 427 614 HE Full-time Participation Rate % 0.31% 1.77% 0.86% 0.08% 0.18% 0.13% Part-time student: 0 Aged 15-24 years 0 0 0 25 65 90 Aged 25 years and over 0 9 9 170 346 516 FT/PT student status not stated 0 0 0 7 0 7 Sub Total Part-time 0 9 9 202 411 613 HE Part-time Participation Rate % 0.00% 0.47% 0.18% 0.09% 0.17% 0.13% Total Uni/Tertiary Students 10 43 53 389 838 1,227 Total HE Participation Rate % 0.31% 2.24% 1.04% 0.17% 0.34% 0.26% Other type of educational institution Type of educ institutionnot stated 11 21 32 144 288 432 153 170 323 3,367 3,527 6,894 Total 106 191 297 1,783 2,725 4,508 Total Participation Rate % 3.33% 9.95% 5.82% 0.76% 1.12% 0.95% Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007c) Note that the ABS still refers to what is now known as the VET sector as ‘Technical or Further Education’. This report uses that term in ABS tables and in the interpretive text of those tables AND all other references, uses the term VET or Vocational Education and Training. 6 Calculated by dividing the number of Indigenous persons of each gender in the NW participating at each educational level by the TOTAL number of Indigenous persons of each gender in the REGION. 5 Skills Tasmania 22 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile male participation (0.54%) and almost twice the higher education (NW Indigenous male 0.31% and state male 0.17%); The Indigenous female VET participation rate (6.61%) is ten times the state female participation (0.66%) and almost seven times (NW Indigenous female 2.24%) the state higher education (state female 0.34%). These figures must be considered in conjunction with Indigenous employment participation – Tables 12 and 13; Table 12: Census of Population and Housing, Labour force status by age by sex for indigenous persons (2006) Employed(a) Unemployed Total Labour Force Not in the Labour Force Labour force NS Total Male FemaleTotal Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total 469 54 130 268 599 228 396 7 19 503 1,014 255 214 76 331 168 12 511 361 26 63 180 424 123 161 7 14 310 599 25-34 years 207 154 37 244 38 7 289 432 35 65 272 497 122 184 4 10 398 691 35-44 years 195 237 30 225 62 6 293 316 18 29 171 345 88 150 6 9 265 504 45-54 years 163 153 11 174 62 3 239 117 3 13 44 130 80 155 14 18 138 303 55-64 years 76 41 10 86 75 4 165 9 0 0 0 9 80 161 12 17 92 187 65 years and over 9 0 0 9 81 5 95 15-24 years Total 905 799 1,704 164 136 300 1,069 935 2,004 486 721 1,207 37 50 87 1,592 1,706 3,298 (a) Includes Community Development Employment Projects (CDEP) participants. Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007h) Table 13: Comparison of labour force participation rates of NW Tasmanian Indigenous Persons and the Tasmanian population (2006) Employed Unemployed Total Labour Force Not in the Labour Force Labour force NS % Total Tasmanian % Total Tasmanian % Total Tasmanian % Total Tasmanian % Total Tasmanian Indigenous Population Indigenous Population Indigenous Population Indigenous Population Indigenous Population 15-24 years 9.2% 8.6% 2.5% 1.3% 11.7% 9.9% 7.8% 5.5% 0.4% 0.7% 25-34 years 7.1% 9.9% 1.2% 0.7% 8.3% 10.6% 3.2% 2.9% 0.3% 0.6% 35-44 years 8.5% 13.0% 1.3% 0.7% 9.7% 3.1% 3.6% 3.1% 0.2% 0.7% 45-54 years 6.2% 13.5% 0.6% 0.6% 6.8% 14.1% 2.9% 3.5% 0.2% 0.7% 55-64 years 2.3% 7.3% 0.3% 0.4% 2.5% 7.7% 3.0% 7.0% 0.4% 0.7% 65 years and over 0.2% 1.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.2% 1.3% 3.2% 15.5% 0.3% 1.8% 33.4% 53.5% 5.9% 3.8% 39.3% 57.3% 23.7% 37.4% 1.7% 5.3% Total Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007h, 2007i) These tables show that Indigenous people: Leave school to find employment earlier than the general population; Experience significantly higher unemployment levels and higher levels of nonparticipation in the labour force during the main working age groups than the general population; Education and training has therefore been used as an instrument of government policy to redress these imbalances which largely accounts for the higher rates of indigenous participation in education and training than the general population. 3.3.2.The young people in the North West The North West region has 14,678 males 20 years or under and 13,842 females, totalling 23,617 or 23% of the population; Between 15 – 20 years of age about a third of young people leave the region, often for education or training opportunities, to look for work, or to travel. The increasing prevalence of the ‘gap year’ after Year 12 may be contributing to this net loss, in that young people leave the Tasmania to travel, find work or Skills Tasmania 23 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile enrol in some form of education interstate, and do not return to Tasmania. Research has shown that regardless of the facilities provided in a region, many young people will leave simply to experience life and to make an independent life for themselves. That being said, about 5% of NW homes have a dependant child aged 15-34 years and these are twice as likely to be male as female; Only about 1.5% of young people were born overseas, most of these were not specific about their country of birth but of those who were, about 0.3% were born in English speaking countries and just over 0.2% were born in nonEnglish speaking countries; 25% of the population are children under 15 years or dependent students under 24 years and 5% are non-dependent children living at home; In 2006, 64% of all 15 to 24-year-olds in the North West who were in the labour force (i.e. working full or part-time, or looking for work), rising from 63% in the last decade.7 However, those NOT in the labour force remained relatively constant at around 36 - 38% over the census period 1996 to 2006; Overall unemployment for The North West fell by 4% during the five years from 2001 and 2006; Males aged 15 – 24 years were mainly employed in manufacturing (20%), retail trade (16%), construction (13%), accommodation and food services (9%) or agriculture, forestry and fishing (9%); Females aged 15 – 24 years were Table 14: Participation of young people mainly employed in the retail trade (15-24 years) in education 1996-2006 (30%), accommodation and food services (20%), health care and 1996 2001 2006 social assistance (9%) or TAFE 5.4% 6.0% 4.7% manufacturing (7%); Higher Education 0.9% 1.1% 1.5% Participation of young people (15-24 years) as a group in TAFE has fallen since 1996 whilst higher education has increased (Table 14); Other 1.3% 1.7% 1.5% Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007c) Factors affecting education participation rates include: o Socio-economic profile of the population; o Young people’s, families’ and communities’ valuing of education; o Curriculum and nature of available education and training; o Educational and youth employment and welfare policy settings; o Financial incentives and barriers; o Level of economic activity; o Structure of the economy in terms of industry and occupation, and o Degree of rurality of the region or state (Kilpatrick, Abbott-Chapman & Baynes 2002). The ABS definition of “unemployed persons” includes persons aged 15 years and over who were not employed during the reference week, and had actively looked for full-time or part-time work at any time in the four weeks up to the end of the reference week and were available for work in the reference week, or were waiting to start a new job within four weeks from the end of the reference week and could have started in the reference week if the job had been available then. 7 Skills Tasmania 24 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 3.3.3.Women in the North West There are 51,589 women in the NW or 51% of the population. 36% of these or 18,481 are under 30 years of age and 12% or 6,424 are over 70 years of age; Women are much more likely to be involved in sole parenting and this varies with age. At 25-34 years they are more than eight times as likely (1.7%) to be in such a family situation, but by 45-54 years this is only three times as likely (1.5%); However, women are about half as likely as men to be involved in lone person households (the maximum rate of 2.4% is reached at 35-44 years); 92% of women in the workforce are engaged in part or full time work; this has risen from 89% in 1996. Interestingly, this is 2-3% lower at the younger age categories than in 1996 and may be due to higher participation in full time study; 76% of women in the NW and only 55% of men earn less than $600 per week. Only 1% women in the NW earn more than $1,300 per week whilst 8% of men are in that category; Female participation in post-compulsory education and training in the NW LGAs matches the overall pattern for VET over the period 1996-2006 that is, peaking in 2001 and currently falling back to around the 1996 level. Full time participation in VET is highest in the 15-24 years age group (0.8%) but part time study is higher in women aged 25 years and over (1.4%). In higher education, the numbers of all women in full and part time study have increased 173% over the last 10 years. This has raised the participation rate as a percentage of the total number of women from 1% to 1.6%. This has been comprised of mainly the enrolment of 15-24year old women in full time study (the number more than doubling) and a small increase (from 0.6% to 0.7%) in the number of women over 25 years engaging in part time higher education (a 17% increase). 3.3.4.The disabled in the North West The NW has about 23.9% of those in receipt of a disability pension in the state. This is slightly higher than the share of population (21.2%) (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2006). Skills Tasmania 25 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 15: Recipients of disability support pension: NW Tasmanian LGAs (30th June 2003) No. Crude Rate No. Persons (per ,000 Persons Receiving persons) Pension Median Age Burnie 1,186 62 19,029 38 Central Coast 1,205 57 21,032 37 Circular Head 313 39 8,086 40 1,384 56 24,567 36 Kentish 293 53 5,533 49 King Island 44 26 1,677 47 Latrobe 404 47 8,518 45 835 62 Devonport Waratah/Wynyard Total 5,664 Tasmania (c) 23,702 50 13,485 39 101,927 41 477,077 40 (a) Data have been aggregated to local government areas from postcode data, consequently, some figures have been rounded and confidentialised. (b) This is a crude rate only. It has not been adjusted to take into account the population eligible to receive payment. Therefore, care should be taken when interpreting figures. (c) Totals for Tasmania include those recipients whose local government area is unknown. (Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics 2006b) Table 15 identifies the numbers of persons receiving a disability support pension and the crude rate per thousand persons by the NW LGAs. It indicates that Burnie and the Waratah/Wynyard LGAs have the highest levels of disabled persons; significantly higher than the state rate. They are also relatively young in age. Approximately 8% of Mersey-Lyell students reported a disability in 2006 (National Centre for Vocational Education Research 2007a); For the 2003-04 period 45.5% of disability service users identified their primary disability as intellectual, a further 15.5% identified their primary disability as physical. Approximately 43.7% of disability service users used services in the Greater Hobart-Southern region, followed by 42.5% in the Northern region and 16.1% in the Mersey-Lyell region. 3.3.5.The aged in the North West The NW Tasmanian LGAs have about 11, 320 people (4,896 males and 6,424 females) over the age of 70 years. The percentage in each age group by sex appears in Table 16. This shows that the proportion of males declines more quickly than females until over 85 years it is about half of the number of females. During 2004-05, the Southern region had 89.1 operational aged care places per 1,000 persons aged 70 and over, followed by the Northern region with 88.4 places and the North Western region with 82.6 places. The Southern region also had the highest ratio of places allocated, at 98.8 places per 1,000 persons aged 70 and over. Skills Tasmania 26 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 16: Percentage of Population in older age groups in NW LGAs and Tasmania (2006) Age Group North West LGAs Tasmania 70-74 years Male 3.8% Female Total 3.9% 3.8% Male 3.4% Female Total 3.6% 3.5% 75-79 years 2.9% 3.3% 3.1% 2.8% 3.2% 3.0% 80-84 years 2.0% 2.9% 2.4% 1.9% 2.7% 2.3% 85-89 years 0.9% 1.5% 1.2% 0.8% 1.5% 1.2% 90-94 years 0.3% 0.6% 0.5% 0.3% 0.7% 0.5% 95-99 years 0.0% 0.2% 0.1% 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% 100 years and over 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007g) The Community Aged Care Program supports people who are eligible for residential care but have a preference to stay at home. In 2004-05, the Northern region had 21.6 places per 1,000 persons aged 70 and over, followed by the Southern region with 18.3 places and the North Western region with 17.3 places. 3.3.6. Migrants in the North West Since 2001, 1,185 international migrants have arrived, which is 13.8% of people in the region born overseas 8. Thus, the North West of Tasmania is quite homogeneous and white, English speaking; 44% of these have come from the UK or New Zealand and a further 5.9% from South Africa. Of the remainder, 6.1% have come from the Philippines, 4.5% the Netherlands, 3.4% India, 3.4% Hong Kong, 2.4% Germany, 2.3% Korea, and 1.6% Sri Lanka and Thailand; In total, only 462 new migrants have arrived since 2004 and of these, 368 were from non-English speaking countries. However, few (32) rate themselves as not speaking English well or not at all. 3.4. Post-secondary educational participation rates Vocational education and training (VET) participation rates increased by 7.4% from 1999 to 2002, compared with 3.5% nationally. 10.1% of Tasmanian 15-64 year olds participated in VET in 2002, compared with a national average of 11.8%. With 30.2% of its population holding an advanced diploma, diploma or certificate I to IV in 2002, Tasmania is close to the national average of 30.4%. Participation in higher education by Tasmanian 15-64 year olds increased from 3.7% in 1996 to 4.6% in 2002, while the national rate rose from 4.7% to 5.3%. In some areas though, poor participation in education and training beyond Year 10 has resulted in an overall performance for Tasmania that remains below the national average: Tasmania has the second lowest proportion of all people participating in formal education and training (17.6% compared with a national average of 19.7%); The state has the lowest proportion of all people who have attained post-Year 10 qualifications (52.2% compared with a national average of 67.3%); Participation in education by 20-24 year olds remains well below the national average at 28% compared with 37.2%; 8 The ABS explanation states that this variable records the year of arrival in Australia for people born overseas who intend staying in Australia for at least one year. In 1996, data were collected in categories ranging from 'Before 1981' to '1996'. For 2001 and 2006, data were collected by single year with valid responses in 2006 being in the range 1895 to 2006. Skills Tasmania 27 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 17: Post-compulsory education and training participation rates 9 by sex for the NW LGAs 1996-2006 10 1996 Census 2001 Census 2006 Census No. Males Male Part No. Female Part Total Part Total Part No. Males Male Part No. Female Part Total Part Total Part No. Males Male Part No. Female Part Total Part Part Rate Females Rate Rate Part Rate Females Rate Rate Part Rate Females Rate Part Part Part Total Part Rate Technical or Further Educational Institution(a): Full-time student: Aged 15-24 years 408 0.8% 409 0.8% 817 0.8% 488 1.0% 509 1.0% 997 1.0% 344 0.7% 401 0.8% 745 0.7% 85 0.2% 124 0.2% 209 0.2% 134 0.3% 178 0.4% 312 0.3% 93 0.2% 232 0.4% 325 0.3% Aged 15-24 years 394 0.8% 286 0.6% 680 0.7% 319 0.7% 260 0.5% 579 0.6% 357 0.7% 233 0.5% 590 0.6% Aged 25 years and over 475 1.0% 724 1.4% 1,199 1.2% 479 1.0% 808 1.6% 1,287 1.3% 436 0.9% 717 1.4% 1,153 1.1% 14 0.0% 9 0.0% 23 0.0% 15 0.0% 10 0.0% 25 0.0% 18 0.0% 17 0.0% 35 0.0% 1,552 3.1% 2,928 2.9% 1,435 3.0% 1,765 3.6% 3,200 3.3% 1,248 2.5% 1,600 3.1% 2,848 2.8% Aged 25 years and over Part-time student: Full/Part-time student status not stated Total 1,376 University or other tertiary Institution: Full-time student: Aged 15-24 years 71 0.1% 95 0.2% 166 0.2% 69 0.1% 141 0.3% 210 0.2% 96 0.2% 246 0.5% 342 0.3% Aged 25 years and over 32 0.1% 53 0.1% 85 0.1% 84 0.2% 109 0.2% 193 0.2% 89 0.2% 179 0.3% 268 0.3% 35 0.1% 43 0.1% 78 0.1% 28 0.1% 45 0.1% 73 0.1% 25 0.1% 65 0.1% 90 0.1% 198 0.4% 293 0.6% 491 0.5% 185 0.4% 310 0.6% 495 0.5% 172 0.3% 343 0.7% 515 0.5% 7 0.0% 7 0.0% 5 0.0% 5 0.0% 10 0.0% 612 1.2% 978 1.0% 387 0.8% 838 1.6% 1,225 1.2% Part-time student: Aged 15-24 years Aged 25 years and over Full/Part-time student status not stated Total 336 484 1.0% 820 0.8% 366 0.8% Other type of Educational Institution: Full-time student 56 0.1% 52 0.1% 108 0.1% 60 0.1% 61 0.1% 121 0.1% 66 0.1% 85 0.2% 151 0.1% Part-time student 86 0.2% 156 0.3% 242 0.2% 114 0.2% 211 0.4% 325 0.3% 80 0.2% 198 0.4% 278 0.3% 3 0.0% 3 0.0% 4 0.0% 4 0.0% 6 0.0% 6 0.0% 0.4% Full/Part-time student status not stated Total 145 Type of educational institution not stated(b) Total 9 208 0.4% 353 0.4% 178 0.4% 272 0.6% 450 0.5% 146 0.3% 289 0.6% 435 2,278 4.6% 2,653 5.2% 4,931 4.9% 1,956 4.1% 2,194 4.5% 4,150 4.3% 3,370 6.8% 3,526 6.8% 6,896 6.8% 4,135 8.4% 4,897 9.7% 9,032 9.1% 3,935 8.3% 4,843 9.8% 8,778 9.1% 5,151 10.4% 6,253 12.1% 11,404 11.3% Calculated by dividing the number of persons of each gender in the NW participating at each educational level by the TOTAL number of persons of each gender in the REGION. Includes 'Technical and Further Educational Institution (including TAFE colleges) 10 Skills Tasmania 28 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Cont’d… Post-secondary educational participation rates Only 37.9% of Tasmanian 24-year-olds have obtained a skilled vocational qualification or higher, compared with a national average of 49.2% (MCEETYA, 2002). Tasmania has by far the lowest proportion of its population with a bachelor degree or higher at 11.4% compared to a national average of 17.8% (Department of Education 2007). However, Table 17 provides more detail for the North West. Please note in reading any tabular material regarding VET that the ABS term ‘Technical or Further Educational Institution’ encompasses VET providers including TAFE institutions. In the interpretive text in this report, that sector will be referred to as VET or ‘Vocational Education and Training’. Table 17 shows that in the NW LGAs in 2006 11.3% people (11,404) participated in post-compulsory education and training at a range of institutions This is 30% above the 2001 participation level. Unfortunately, over half of the respondents (6.8%) to the 2006 census were not sufficiently specific about the type of institution they attended to be able to allocate them to an institution; However, statistics published by the National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER) indicate that the NW has a slightly higher participation rate than the state as a whole (Table 18). Females were more likely to participate (12.1%) than males (10.4%); However, VET attendance is 3% down on 1996 after peaking in 2001. This is so for both males and females in the North West; Table 18 also shows more detail on the participating age groups indicating that Mersey-Lyell is ahead of the Tasmanian rate for 15-19 and 30-59 year olds; Table 18: VET students, by age group and sex, Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania & Australia 2006 Mersey-Lyell Age Group Male Female 14 years and under (a) (a) Tasmania Unknown Total Male 10 10 Female 1270 900 2170 5000 3630 (a) 20-24 years 980 610 1,580 4,410 2870 25-29 years 580 370 (a) 950 2540 1670 (a) 30-39 years 1110 930 (a) 2040 4640 3400 (a) 40-49 years 1080 1030 (a) 2110 3820 3700 50-59 years 640 560 (a) 1,200 2,320 2020 (a) 60-64 years 110 Female 5920 60 150 250 210 (a) Not known 80 50 (a) 140 330 160 10 10,560 23,740 17980 Unknown 4,920 (a) 10,840 189,430 250 427850 7,300 163240 113,740 160 277140 4,220 89860 72,160 120 162140 8040 150160 140400 240 290800 7530 115670 141290 280 257250 4,340 69,980 80,740 190 150,920 460 12130 13780 30 25940 560 17650 24,040 780 42,470 110 41,830 878,190 795,660 10 10 70 50 3.5. Socio-economic indexes for areas (SEIFA) 11 There are four SEIFA indexes produced by the ABS. They relate to socio-economic aspects of geographic areas. Each index summarises a different aspect of the socioeconomic conditions in an area. The indexes have been obtained by a technique called principal components analysis. This technique summarises the information from a variety of social and economic variables, calculating weights that will give the best summary for the underlying variables. For the SEIFA indexes, each index uses a different set of underlying variables. Please note that the SEIFA Indexes based on the 2006 Census are not available until later in 2008. Skills Tasmania 30610 2110 1,675,960 Source: National Centre for Vocational Education Research (2007e) 11 Total 8,640 238,180 690 90 4,620 Male 50 410 65 years and older 5,930 Total 30 15-19 years Total Australia Unknown 29 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile The three indexes for the NW LGAs follow. In interpreting the figures, the higher the index, the higher the relative advantage. Index of relative advantage\disadvantage - A new index, and is a continuum of advantage to disadvantage. Low values indicate areas of disadvantage; and high values indicate areas of advantage. A higher score on the Index of Relative Socio-Economic Advantage/Disadvantage indicates that an area has attributes such as a relatively high proportion of people with high incomes or a skilled workforce. It also means an area has a low proportion of people with low incomes and relatively few unskilled people in the workforce. Conversely, a low score on the index indicates that an area has a higher proportion of individuals with low incomes, more employees in unskilled occupations, etc.; and a low proportion of people with high incomes or in skilled occupations. o The Tasmanian Index is 948 and ranks lowest of all the states; the highest is the ACT with 1122. Figure 5: SEIFA index of relative advantage/disadvantage (2001) Waratah/Wynyard (M) Latrobe (M) King Island (M) Kentish (M) Devonport (C) Circular Head (M) Central Coast (M) Burnie (C) 840 860 880 900 920 940 960 Relative Advantage/Disadvantage Index o It is also apparent that the NW is disadvantaged relative to the state index, although King Island is close to the state level; o Within the NW, Kentish and Circular Head are the most disadvantaged. Index of economic resources - This index reflects the income and expenditure of families, such as income and rent. Additionally, variables which reflect wealth, such as dwelling size, are also included. The income variables are specified by family structure, since this affects disposable income. This index excludes Education and Occupation variables because they are not direct measures of economic resources. A higher score on the Index of Economic Resources indicates that the area has a higher proportion of families on high income, a lower proportion of low income families, and more households living in large houses i.e. four or more bedrooms. A low score indicates the area has a relatively high proportion of households on low incomes and living in small dwellings. o The Tasmanian Index is 935 and ranks the lowest of all the states; the highest is the ACT with 1113. o Again all the NW LGAs are relatively disadvantaged to the state as a whole with Kentish being significantly more so than the other NW LGAs. Skills Tasmania 30 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 6: SEIFA index of economic resources (2001) Waratah/Wynyard (M) Latrobe (M) King Island (M) Kentish (M) Devonport (C) Circular Head (M) Central Coast (M) Burnie (C) 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 960 980 Index of Economic Resources Index of education and occupation – This index is designed to reflect the educational and occupational structure of communities. The education variables in this index show either the level of qualification achieved or whether further education is being undertaken. The occupation variables classify the workforce into the major groups of the Australian Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) and the unemployed. This index does not include any income variables. An area with a high score on this index would have a high concentration of people with higher education qualifications or undergoing further education, with a high percentage of people employed in more skilled occupations. A low score indicates an area with concentrations of either people with low educational attainment, people employed in unskilled occupations, or the unemployed. o The Tasmanian Index is 962 and ranks the lowest of all the states; the highest is again the ACT with 1113. o Circular Head and Kentish are significantly disadvantaged whilst, interestingly, King Island is not. Figure 7: SEIFA index of education and occupation (2001) Waratah/Wynyard (M) Latrobe (M) King Island (M) Kentish (M) Devonport (C) Circular Head (M) Central Coast (M) Burnie (C) 850 860 870 880 890 900 910 920 930 940 Index of Education & Occupation The linkage between education and training, skill and socio-economic is a complex issue well beyond the scope of this report. However, the ABS analysis of level of educational attainment in some urban areas in Devonport and Burnie in Table 19 adds a further, more Skills Tasmania 31 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile detailed level of analysis of this link in some of the most disadvantaged areas of the NW LGAs (unfortunately this level of analysis is not available for rural LGAs). Table 19: 2027.6 Tasmanian population census data: Burnie and Devonport suburbs – nonschool qualification by level of education (2006) Devonport Suburb Population Grad Dip/Grad Cert Bachelor Degree Adv Dip & Dip Cert Total Quals % with HE % with VET Not Desc % Not Quals Quals Desc Ambleside 754 9 9 48 36 133 302 8.8% 22.4% 67 9% Devonport 13,945 78 84 714 656 2,074 4,995 6.3% 19.6% 1,389 10% East Devonport 4,179 8 13 88 111 548 1,263 2.6% 15.8% 495 12% Hillcrest 1,071 6 7 37 37 139 361 4.7% 16.4% 135 13% Miandetta 1,761 7 13 81 92 303 677 5.7% 22.4% 181 10% Quoiba 424 0 0 8 7 62 114 1.9% 16.3% 37 9% Spreyton 935 3 0 29 30 187 319 3.4% 23.2% 70 7% Stony Rise 323 0 3 20 13 45 106 7.1% 18.0% 25 8% 23,392 111 129 1,025 982 3,491 8,137 5.4% 19.1% 2,399 10% 7% Sub-total Acton Burnie Postgrad Degree 1,347 3 0 24 31 181 335 2.0% 15.7% 96 Brooklyn 502 3 0 12 25 93 179 3.0% 23.5% 46 9% Burnie 561 8 3 55 25 85 244 11.8% 19.6% 68 12% Cooee 576 4 0 26 22 87 201 5.2% 18.9% 62 11% Emu Heights 206 0 0 6 5 38 64 2.9% 20.9% 15 7% Havenview 714 0 0 13 25 134 232 1.8% 22.3% 60 8% 1,312 9 3 66 47 196 447 5.9% 18.5% 126 10% 12% Montello Ocean Vista 395 4 0 24 23 69 168 7.1% 23.3% 48 2,036 21 27 160 129 318 789 10.2% 22.0% 134 7% 890 14 12 99 72 134 430 14.0% 23.1% 99 11% Romaine 1,748 5 12 70 56 318 596 5.0% 21.4% 135 8% Shorewell Park 1,935 4 4 43 34 160 571 2.6% 10.0% 326 17% Somerset Park Grove Parklands 3,077 11 15 101 108 442 1,011 4.1% 17.9% 334 11% South Burnie 385 4 4 24 19 61 154 8.3% 20.8% 42 11% Upper Burnie 1,979 3 7 65 71 279 628 3.8% 17.7% 203 10% 234 5 0 5 8 33 69 4.3% 17.5% 18 8% Sub-total 17,897 98 87 793 700 2,628 6,118 5.5% 18.6% 1,812 10% Total Bur-Dev 41,289 209 216 1,818 1,682 6,119 14,255 5.4% 18.9% 4,211 10% Wivenhoe Source: Derived from Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007l) Table 19 outlines the participation rates of each suburb in Devonport and Burnie; that is, it compares those at either the HE or the VET level participating in education with the total population in that suburb. From this it appears that: In the Devonport area: East Devonport and Quoiba are relatively educationally disadvantaged at both HE and VET levels; In the Burnie area: Acton, Shorewell, Somerset, Upper Burnie and Wivenhoe are relatively disadvantaged at both HE and VET levels; Other areas are somewhat dominated by VET qualified people but that is not imputed in this report to indicate disadvantage without other indicators being available. Such areas are: in Devonport, Ambleside, Hillcrest, Miandetta and Spreyton; and in Burnie, Brooklyn, Cooee, Havenview, Ocean Vista, Park Grove, Parklands and Romaine. Skills Tasmania 32 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 3.6. Conclusions The NW has 21% of the state’s population. It is relatively homogeneous, ageing faster than any other in the nation, has shortages of those in the child raising age groups and has the lowest labour participation rates in the country; Those in Circular Head, Kentish (who have to drive more than ½ an hour for training) and King Islanders (isolated by water) are more disadvantaged in terms of VET; Waratah/Wynyard, Central Coast and Latrobe act as ‘dormitory suburbs’ for the major centres of Burnie and Devonport; King Island has a larger proportion of people on a high income compared with the other LGAs; Kentish, Waratah/Wynyard, Circular Head and Latrobe have slightly higher proportions of people on low incomes; The retail, accommodation, health care, manufacturing and agriculture industries have the highest proportions of people with low incomes; Manufacturing, mining, health and education industries have the highest proportions of highly paid jobs; Indigenous People have high participation rates in education and training and lower employment. They are growing faster than the rest of the NW population but in other demographic respects are quite similar to the main population. Younger Indigenous women are less involved in education whilst older women are more likely to be involved. This is consistent with national statistics. Indigenous people are engaged with lower levels of education but participate at less than half the state rate for higher education; Young people under 20 years make up 23% of the NW population. Educational participation has fallen in recent years; Women in the NW are more likely to be involved in sole parenting, earn less and have increasingly being participating in VET and Higher Education; The NW has a higher percentage of disabled people than the rest of the state; about 8% of students reporting a disability of some form; There are 11,320 people (11.2%) over the age of 70 years. The region has less aged care places per thousand than the north or the south; The coast attracts mainly English peaking migrants and only 32, out of the 368 from non-English speaking countries arriving since 2004, rate themselves as being poor in English language skills; Tasmania has the second lowest post-compulsory education and training participation rates of the states, although the NW has a slightly higher participation rate than the state; The Kentish LGA is the most relatively disadvantaged municipality in the NW according the ABS SEIFA index. King Island has the highest rating. In the main urban centres several suburbs stand out as most educationally disadvantaged; East Devonport, Quoiba, Acton, Shorewell, Somerset, Upper Burnie and Wivenhoe. Skills Tasmania 33 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 4. Profile of NW education and training delivery Post-compulsory education and training in the North West of Tasmania is provided by several government and non-government sources: Higher Education: o University of Tasmania o Other universities, mainly Australian-based but some international distance education occurs (e.g. University of London). There is no way of determining the size and nature of this provision; o Professional bodies accredited either independently or under the auspices of a registered Australian university (e.g. The Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists & Managers, Australia or the AMA); Vocational Education and Training: o Institute of TAFE Tasmania – training statistics from the VET Provider Collection 2002-06 form the basis for this section of the report; o Other Australian TAFE institutes - there is no way of determining the size and nature of this provision; o Other registered training organisations (RTOs), i.e. registered private training organisations that may or may not be in receipt of government funds to provide accredited training programs under the Australian Quality Training Framework (AQTF). Only the training conducted using government funding can be determined; o Commercial training or non-accredited training conducted on a contracted basis by public or private organisations. If conducted by a public organisation, the training statistics may be included in this report, however it is likely that training by private training or consulting organisations is confidential and not disclosed; o Non-accredited training of a vocational nature may be delivered into NW Tasmania by overseas private or public organisations and is not identifiable e.g. City & Guilds training. 4.1. Vocational Education and Training provision 12 TAFE Tasmania has carried out 79% of all training. VET in schools accounts for 5% and Private RTOs 16%. There were 45 state-based private RTOs included in the data. Table 20 (following page) indicates that: The proportion of TAFE funding is growing in the NW; Fee for service programs are down by about 12% on the 2004 peak; Non-User Choice funded enrolments have remained relatively constant; User Choice funded places have been increasing since 2004; The TAFE and VET in Schools proportions have been increasing since 2004 at the expense of the private RTOs. 4.2. Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) 12 Please note that RTO information is confidential and that the names of the organisation can not be released. It is also not compulsory for non-TAFE RTOs to report fee-for-service activity thus some RTOs do not report data in the VET Provider Collection, and hence the following data may be understated. Skills Tasmania 34 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile There are 131 RTOs with Tasmania as the principal place of registration and many others registered in other states/territories that have notified on the NTIS that they deliver in Tasmania; There are 18 RTOs with their Head Office in the NW Region (as defined in the TDP project), not including TAFE; The majority of RTOs, some 76 in all, cite Hobart or the southern region as the principal place of registration. Table 20: Sources of training funding for VET in North West Tasmania (2002-06) 2002 User Non-User choice Choice Fee for service VET in schools DEST funded Total % by funding TAFE 1,038 6,225 2,498 67 9,828 77 Non- TAFE 1,183 411 682 697 2,973 23 Grand Total 2,221 6,636 3,180 764 12,801 17 52 25 6 TAFE 1,142 6,313 2,674 74 10,203 77 Non- TAFE 1,106 493 676 723 2,998 23 Grand Total 2,248 6,806 3,350 797 13,201 17 52 25 6 % by Sector 2003 % by Sector 2004 TAFE 1,256 6,138 3,335 43 10,772 78 Non- TAFE 961 546 780 709 2,996 22 Grand Total 2,217 6,684 4,115 752 13,768 16 49 30 5 TAFE 1,471 6,159 3,239 62 10,931 80 Non- TAFE 1,039 408 532 691 2,670 20 Grand Total 2,510 6,567 3,771 753 13,601 18 48 28 6 TAFE 1,586 6,242 3,125 732 0 11,685 83 Non- TAFE 1,215 541 504 102 4 2,366 17 Grand Total 2,801 6,783 3,629 834 14,051 % by Sector 20 48 26 6 4 0 % by Sector 2005 % by Sector 2006 Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 Table 21 (overleaf) shows that: The majority of training is funded and delivered through the TAFE Purchase Agreement and fee for service arrangements – Competitive Bids and VET in Schools is only 14% of the total; 50% of funded places are at Certificate III level or above; Skills Tasmania 35 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 21: NW enrolments by AQF level and funding source (2002-06) Level of Training Comp Bids Advanced Diploma DEST Funded Envw. Tourism Fee for Service 41 Bridging & Enabling Courses Not Identifiable by Level Overseas Student Purchase Agrmnt User Choice VET in Schools Grand Total % 33 501 6 0% 1,314 3,399 159 1,907 7,982 12% 575 6 1% Certificate I 1,203 Certificate II 2,305 403 3,486 8,024 2,714 1,498 18,430 27% Certificate III 666 3 107 4,888 6,509 8,847 129 21,149 31% Certificate IV 466 1 49 3,372 3,665 263 18 7,834 12% Diploma Education not elsewhere classified 372 568 3,473 10 4,423 7% 21 18 Other Non-award Courses Statement of Attainment Not Identifiable by Level 160 50 3,392 37 1,035 4 962 1,239 12 89 Year 12 Grand Total % of total training 4 6,254 4 634 18,045 6 26,936 11,997 3,552 9% 0% 1% 27% 0% 40% 18% 5% 39 0% 3,639 5% 3,244 5% 101 0% 67,422 Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 Table 22: Number of trainees as a proportion of all enrolments in each industry in the North West (2002-06) Inustry Output Group (IOG) Business and Financial Services Total No. Enrolments Trainees % 13,568 2,854 21% Tourism 6,950 1,282 18% Agriculture, Aquaculture, Fishing, Food and Beverages 5,921 1,084 18% IT, Communications & Advanced Technology 5,777 94 2% General education & personal development 5,226 75 1% Building and Construction 4,003 1,080 27% Health and Community Services 3,918 517 13% Automotive 3,220 1,208 38% Engineering and Manufacturing 2,734 631 23% Mining and Mineral Processing 1,977 381 19% Retail and wholesale sales and service 1,920 1,147 60% Energy Industries 1,698 617 36% Transport distribution & storage 1,493 654 44% Arts 1,433 37 3% Forestry, Timber and Paper 1,371 144 11% Textiles, Clothing and Footwear 1,269 322 25% Generic 1,152 Government Services (include. Water supply) 1,103 88 8% Marine Manufacturing 797 674 85% Hairdressing & personal services 734 333 45% Environmental Industries 445 17 4% Sport and Recreation 303 40 13% Other manufacturing (incl. Furniture) 296 136 46% Printing 114 22 19% 67,422 13,437 20% Grand Total 0% Note: IOG is a Skills Tasmania grouping of related industries Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 Skills Tasmania 36 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 4.3. Number of Trainees compared to number of all students Traineeship details were not part of the 2002 VET Provider Collection. In 2003 25% of enrolments were trainees with the total dropping to 20% for 2004. The figure remained static at 26% for both 2005 and 2006. Table 22 (previous) shows the proportion of all enrolments from 2002-06 in each industry that were trainees. It indicates that the marine manufacturing (85%) and retail industry (60%) are the most heavily reliant on trainees, followed by other manufacturing (46%), hairdressing (45%), automotive (38%) and energy (36%). Table 24: Number of completed VET qualifications by year (2002-06) Year Enrolments 2002 12,801 Qualifications % completed Completed 3,431 Table 23: Number of qualifications awarded by AQF level (2002-06) AQF Level Number Awarded 27% Year 12 3,197 22 2003 13,201 5,677 43% Certificate I 2004 13,768 5,446 40% Certificate II 6,345 41% Certificate III 7,480 36% Certificate IV 3,931 Diploma 2,238 2005 13,601 2006 14,051 Grand Total 67,422 5,623 5,110 25,287 38% Advanced Diploma Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 424 Education not elsewhere classified 7 Other Non-award Courses Statement of Attainment Not Identifiable by Level Grand Total 633 1,010 25,287 Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 4.3.1.How many students complete their qualification? Table 23 shows the number of qualifications awarded by AQF level, 2002-06. Fifty per cent were for Advanced Diploma to Certificate III, 27% at Certificate II and 14% at Certificate I levels. In Table 24, please note that the 2006 qualifications awarded data will increase. This is due to a lag as some 2006 completions will be reported in the 2007 data, and some students are awarded their qualification in the year following completion of training. 13 Table 24 indicates that completion rates have been increasing significantly in the period 2002-06 to 38%. 4.3.2.Where do the students come from? This section relates to Section 4.1 earlier and Tables 2 and 3 that indicated the approximate travelling times and distances of students in NW locations. Table 25 indicates that NW students nominate home address postcodes centred, as might be expected from the major urban areas of Burnie and Devonport and their dormitory or feeder towns. Table 25 (overleaf) indicates that: About 50% students are focused around Devonport; 13 Many students do not complete in the year of commencement. This slower progression is frequently due to employment or personal circumstances. Such flexibility is a characteristic and imperative in the VET sector. Skills Tasmania 37 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 17.2% of western students drive for over half an hour to a major VET centre; Only small numbers of students come from the Kentish area (4.4%). Table 25: NW students by home address Student Postcode Locality Total % 7305 Kentish - Railton, Sunnyside 865 1.3 7306 Kentish - Western side 2,113 3.1 7307 Pt Sorell, W/Vale, Sassafras 4,945 7.3 17,873 26.5 8,615 12.8 7310 Devonport, Forth, Spreyton, Wilmot 7315 Ulverstone region 7316 Penguin, Sth Riana 7320 Burnie 7321 Boart Harbour, Detention R., Stowport 2,720 4 7322 Somerset 2,594 3.8 7325 Wynyard, Table Cape, Takone 5,592 8.3 7330 Smithton, Arthur R., Far North West 5,518 8.2 7331 Stanley 502 67,422 0.7 Grand Total 3,767 5.6 12,318 18.3 Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 4.3.3.Student satisfaction with their training outcomes Table 26 (overleaf) indicates that VET delivery is performing quite well against the state average: NW graduating students are: o Marginally less likely than the state average to find employment by the end of the May following graduation from their training o They are more likely than the rest of the state to find employment before training (77.4%); o More likely to enrol in another VET course than the rest of the state but are less likely to enrol in a university course; probably reflecting the limited offering of courses at the University of Tasmania’s Cradle Coast Campus in Burnie compared with the larger campuses in Hobart and Launceston; o Have similar motives for undertaking training as the rest of the state, but of these they were less likely to have undertaken training for personal development reasons. This may reflect slightly different community values placed on training; o More likely than students across the state to be satisfied with their training outcomes and its relevance to their job; o Over time (2003-07), these figures for the state have generally improved although those for the level of engagement with education after graduation has fallen significantly with regard to VET and increased slightly for higher education. Satisfaction with training outcomes and relevance to occupation has increased significantly over the period. Module Completers, on the other hand, were: Skills Tasmania 38 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o More likely to be employed after completing their training and to find a job just prior to undertaking training; o More likely to be employed or in further study than the rest of the state and so could be said to have benefited more from their single module-oriented training than their contemporaries; o More likely to be satisfied with their training outcomes but, somewhat paradoxically, to see less employment related relevance in their training. Table 26: Key findings for graduates and module completers, NW region of Tasmania, 2007 (All VET providers) North West Tasmania Graduates Module completers Graduates Module completers % % % % Employed 81.2 86.1 81.7 77.8 Not employed a 18.8 13.9 18.3 22.2 Unemployed 10.2 7.4 8.7 9.1 Not in the labour force 7.8 5.3* 9.2 12.0 Employed before training 77.4 82.9 76.4 75.5 Difference in proportion employed from before training to after 3.8 3.2 5.3 2.3 Not employed before commencing the training and employed after 10.0 8.0* 12.0 9.9 Employed in first full-time job after training b 14.1 12.0* 15.7 12.7 Employed or in further study after training b,c 89.5 87.1 89.6 78.6 Enrolled in further study after training:b 33.1 ** 30.0 3.3* Studying at university b 3.5* ** 5.3 3.3* Studying at TAFE institute b 19.6 na 15.3 na Studying at private provider or other registered provider b 9.8 na 9.2 na Employment-related outcome 81.4 71.4 81.3 73.9 Further study outcome 2.5* 0.0 1.5 ** Personal development outcome 16.1 28.6 17.2 25.7 Employment and further study outcomes After training (as at 25 May 2007): Training Reasons for undertaking the training: Training was part of an apprenticeship or traineeship b 22.1 7.1 19.8 9.1 Received some recognition for prior learning towards the training b 27.2 13.8 26.8 14.1 Satisfied with the overall quality of training 93.0 92.1 90.0 83.7 Fully or partly achieved their main reason for doing the training 89.1 80.2 88.6 79.2 Reported that the training was highly or somewhat relevant to their current job 81.7 52.5 78.3 57.9 Received at least one job-related benefit 70.1 44.0 70.9 48.2 Satisfaction outcomes Benefits of training Of those employed at May 2007: Notes a 'Not Employed' is defined as unemployed (looking for full-time or part-time work), not in the labour force, or not employed (no further information) b These questions are not asked of students from community education providers. Therefore, the percentage reported represents the proportion of graduates, or module completers, respectively, excluding those from community education providers. c 'Employed or in further study after training' for module completers is defined as employed after completing a module of VET or going onto further study at university as, by definition, the only further study captured for module completers * The estimate has a relative standard error greater than 25% and therefore should be used with caution. ** NCVER does not report on estimates based on less than five respondents because the estimates are unreliable. d This data set is based on 431 Graduates and 116 Module Completers which, when weighted, is estimated by NCVER to be equivilent to 4,135 Graduates and 1,466 Module Completers from the state total of 15,910 Graduates and 5,450 Module Completers. Thus, this represents a valid sample size. Source: National Centre for Vocational Education Research (2007b) Appendix 2 presents the national key findings for graduates and module completers from all VET providers by state/territory. This shows that: Skills Tasmania 39 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o Overall Tasmania’s VET exhibits mediocre performance on most parameters for graduates and marginally better for module completers; o However, the NW, exhibiting generally slightly better performance on student feedback, shows up well against the national performance. 4.3.4.What do employers think of the VET system? Specific data is not available for the North West however the following points have emerged at the state level. Some of the points emerging from this NCVER survey appear below: 14 Tasmania enjoys a quite high ranking for overall employer satisfaction with the VET training system when compared to the other states; Tasmanian employers generally had a high regard for the importance of the nationally recognised training system in meeting skill needs; Employers claimed less need for full qualifications for their jobs, were less likely to regard VET qualifications as being very important and were quite satisfied with the VET qualifications of their current staff. Yet they had the highest level of employment of apprentices and were more satisfied with them meeting their skill needs than all other states. This latter point may be a function of the high proportion of small businesses in Tasmania that are more reliant on the public system for training; Tasmanian employers also claimed that they had one of the lowest uses of all states of TAFE itself for the majority of their formal training and had a moderate use of external registered providers or provision of in-house accredited training; Tasmanian employers also regarded unaccredited training as very important (92.4%, Australia 93.8%) to meeting their skill needs and a high level of satisfaction with it (95.9%, Australia 92.5%). Interestingly, 58% reported that there was no equivalent accredited training and 30% did not explore that option (comparable to other states). Use of the unaccredited training system increases with organisational size, possibly because of the capacity to pay; Interest in engaging with the formal VET training system increases with organisational size (number of employees) and with its past engagement of the company and managers with the system (National Centre for Vocational Education Research 2007d). 14 When referring to the original survey results (available on the NCVER web site) readers should be aware that this is a self-rating attitudinal survey which at times produces apparently contradictory results. Skills Tasmania 40 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 4.4. Conclusions: There are 18 RTOs in the region; 40% of training occurs through the TAFE purchase agreement; The marine engineering and retail sectors are the most reliant on traineeships for their new entrants; The number of completed VET qualifications has increased between 200206; 50% of VET qualifications awarded are now at Certificate III or above; About 50% of students come from around Devonport (but few drive from Kentish) and over 17% drive for over half an hour to a major VET centre; NW students claimed a high degree of satisfaction with and employment success from completing their VET course. On completion NW students are more likely to enrol in another VET course; and less likely to enrol in a university course than the state; Employers rate the overall Tasmanian VET system highly although there are some anomalies in their responses. Non-accredited training is important and is regarded highly. Whilst they believed that there was no equivalent in the formal system, they generally did not investigate that view; The main VET effort in the NW is: o Business and financial services – 20.1% o Tourism – 10.3% o Agriculture, Aquaculture, Fishing, Food & Beverages – 8.8% o IT and communications – 8.6% o General education – 7.8% o Building and construction – 5.9% o Health and community services – 5.8% o Automotive – 4.8% o Engineering and manufacturing – 4.1% o Mining – 2.9% o Retail – 2.8% Skills Tasmania 41 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 5. The Labour Market 5.1. Unemployment and labour force participation 5.1.1.Tasmania Since April 2002, employment in Tasmania has risen by 29,900 or 15.1%, compared to 14% nationally. In January 2008, the level of employment in Tasmania increased by 0.1 per cent (in trend terms) to 230 500 persons. The number of Tasmanians employed in January 2008 is estimated to be 2.9 per cent, or 6 500 persons, above the number in January 2007. In the past five years, 64 per cent of employment growth has been in full time positions (in trend terms). Tasmania’s participation rate increased by 0.1 of a percentage point in January 2008 to 61.2 per cent (in trend terms). The current rate is one percentage point higher than the rate of one year earlier. The Tasmanian participation rate has been trending upwards since a low of 57.7 per cent in March and April 2002. Tasmania’s unemployment rate remained steady at 5.3 per cent in January 2008 (in trend terms). The current rate is the highest of all the states and territories, but is 0.4 percentage points below the rate in January 2007 and is now only one percentage point above the national rate, compared to 1.2 percentage points in January 2007. The main employment growth industries in Tasmania were: accommodation, cafes and restaurants (up 3,300 persons); government, administration and defence (up 1,800 persons); education (up 1,500 persons) and transport and storage (up 1,300 persons) (Hawkes 2008). The Tasmanian Treasury forecasts that 6000 new jobs will be created in 2007-08, with an employment growth of 2.25%. The unemployment rate for February 2008 stands at 5.3%. The year average unemployment rate in 2006-07 was 5.7%. The Treasury forecast for 2007-08 year average unemployment rate is 5.5% (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007). 5.1.2.Mersey-Lyell The latest (December, 2007) labour market snapshot for the Mersey-Lyell region appears in Table 27 below. It should be noted that in the key measures of employment and unemployment rates, the NW is marginally in a poorer position than the state as a whole. Table 27: Mersey-Lyell unemployment rate change 2006-07 Statistical Local Areas (SLAs) Unemployment Unemployed Unemployment Unemployed Rate Rate Sept. 2006 Sept. 2006 Sept. 2007 Sept. 2007 Labour Force (Not Employment) # Sept. 2007 Burnie (C) - Pt A 10.3% 865 9.6% 782 8,132 Burnie (C) - Pt B 7.1% 80 6.1% 67 1,098 Central Coast (M) - Pt A 8.1% 695 7.1% 593 8,366 Central Coast (M) - Pt B 6.8% 125 6.1% 108 1,784 Devonport (C) 9.8% 1,190 9.0% 1,056 11,764 Kentish (M) 9.4% 256 8.9% 235 2,642 Latrobe (M) - Pt A 8.3% 326 7.5% 287 3,824 Latrobe (M) - Pt B* 6.3% 29 5.8% 26 445 Source: Australian Federal Department of Education - Employment and Workplace Relations (2008) Skills Tasmania 42 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 8: Civilian population by labour force status (15+), December 2007 Persons Not in the Labour Force Unemployed Part-Time Not in the Labour Force Unemployed Part-Time Unemployed FullTime Unemployed Full-Time Employed Part-Time Employed Full-Time Employed PartTime Employed FullTime - 10 20 30 40 Source: Australian Federal Department of Education - Employment and Workplace Relations (2008) Table 27 illustrates the sharp drop in 12 months across the main urban areas in the Mersey-Lyell region.15 In the major centres unemployment has dropped 1% or more in one year and since 1996, overall those not in the labour force have dropped from 42% to 39%. The nature of regional employment The four largest industries for employment in the NW are: o Retail trades – 13% o Manufacturing – 13% o Health care and social assistance – 11% o Construction - 7% Figure 8 shows visually the civilian population labour force status in December 2007. Apart from the low level of unemployed, the outstanding feature is that those not in the labour force exceeds those that are. Whilst the explanation for this is complex and includes many people who are unable to work because of age, infirmity or personal circumstances, this segment of the existing population provides potential for engagement in the labour market. Agriculture, forestry and fishing, generally regarded as a cornerstone of the NW is ranked 8th with 5.8% and Mining has only a relatively small workforce with 1.3% of regional employment (note, that despite the West Coast being excluded from this report, many mining staff reside in the NW LGAs). However, this section is focused on employment and both these industries, as well as others listed, are significant wealth creators and so their overall importance to the NW economy is much more important when other parameters are considered. 15 Note that the rural areas have not been included because the low numbers in some LGAs may breach confidentiality. Skills Tasmania 43 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Generally, the nature of the surrounding region and/or the urban area activities determines the relative importance of the various industries to each of the LGAs. Table 28 (following) shows, for instance , that: o Manufacturing, health care and retail are the biggest employers for Burnie whilst manufacturing, retail construction and health care are the major employers in Devonport. o In the more rural LGAs such as Circular Head, Kentish and King Island, agriculture, forestry and fishing and manufacturing are the major employers; o Dormitory LGAs such as Latrobe, Waratah/Wynyard and Central Coast somewhat reflect the emphases of the major centres but also have a major provision of services such as health; o This balance of employment has both similarities and important differences to the state balance of employment, particularly at an LGA level where the overall population is small: Retail trades is the largest state employer followed by health care, manufacturing and public administration; The importance of construction to the NW; The significance of agriculture, forestry and fishing and the associated food manufacturing are critical to local economies. The top two industries for employing men are manufacturing and construction and they employ 33% of the workforce. However, for women the top two industries are retail and accommodation and they employ 50% of women. Table 29 (following) provides details of the occupations held by men and women in the NW region. It shows: o That the top two occupational groups for men are technicians/trades workers (27%) and labourers (16%) and for women clerical (22%) and professionals (17%); o The balance of men and women employed in the more skilled occupational groups, managers, professionals and technicians/trades workers is interesting; 51% of men are employed in these occupations but only 31% of women. o This balance is approximated at a state level. There are differences between the LGAs: o In the urban LGAs there are a greater number of male technicians/trades workers and labourers; and for females, professionals and community and personal service workers; o In rural LGAs there is a much more pronounced dichotomy in the occupations of men – managers or labourers and for women, labourers and managers or clerical workers o Tables 28 – 31 are important tables for educational planners because they correlate study areas and occupations thereby giving guidance as to actual industry demand and should be interpreted jointly, particularly for demand at an LGA level. However, it should be noted that the qualification profiles of regions and LGAs may well be influenced by supply rather than purely business/occupational need factors. Skills Tasmania 44 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 28: Employment by industry and gender for North Western LGAs Burnie Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Is Latrobe War/Wyn Reg Total Tasmania M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total Agriculture, forestry & fishing 201 72 273 426 182 608 650 274 924 219 101 320 210 85 295 200 78 278 503 213 716 313 123 436 2,722 1,128 3,850 8,408 3,001 11,409 Mining 139 15 154 93 3 96 53 3 56 58 0 58 24 3 27 0 0 0 285 24 309 147 7 154 799 55 854 1,485 148 1,633 Manufacturing 933 188 1,121 894 298 1,192 524 225 749 1,005 400 1,405 240 76 316 109 79 188 2,623 475 3,098 560 116 676 6,888 1,857 8,745 16,186 4,989 21,175 Electricity, gas, water & waste services 36 4 40 80 13 93 14 3 17 95 5 100 29 3 32 5 0 5 1,685 160 1,845 30 3 33 1,974 191 2,165 2,275 622 2,897 Construction 345 46 391 550 61 611 169 21 190 611 68 679 152 15 167 39 3 42 2,562 261 2,823 311 37 348 4,739 512 5,251 12,294 1,383 13,677 Wholesale trade 223 69 292 204 93 297 99 44 143 300 106 406 64 24 88 24 10 34 521 181 702 188 75 263 1,623 602 2,225 5,269 2,064 7,333 Retail trade 481 610 1,091 403 571 974 111 211 322 571 754 1,325 99 159 258 21 45 66 1,509 2,442 3,951 218 363 581 3,413 5,155 8,568 10,348 14,089 24,437 Accommodation & food services 143 340 483 156 347 503 39 158 197 229 419 648 90 143 233 8 26 34 573 989 1,562 84 198 282 1,322 2,620 3,942 5,380 8,832 14,212 Transport, postal & warehousing 352 75 427 387 110 497 92 33 125 482 165 647 100 42 142 23 15 38 682 197 879 239 55 294 2,357 692 3,049 7,131 2,246 9,377 Information media & telecommunications 34 67 101 45 39 84 6 9 15 39 40 79 0 4 4 0 0 0 155 220 375 23 28 51 302 407 709 1,764 1,557 3,321 Financial & insurance services 47 99 146 37 86 123 8 28 36 50 101 151 3 13 16 0 0 0 201 457 658 19 52 71 365 836 1,201 2,037 3,296 5,333 Rental, hiring & real estate services 38 55 93 43 53 96 12 14 26 57 74 131 7 11 18 0 9 9 139 149 288 27 32 59 323 397 720 1,407 1,472 2,879 Professional, scientific & technical services 111 119 230 129 130 259 35 33 68 165 164 329 24 21 45 0 3 3 467 442 909 66 71 137 997 983 1,980 4,868 4,043 8,911 Administrative & support services 124 203 327 115 163 278 104 74 178 134 180 314 24 25 49 10 3 13 509 374 883 81 93 174 1,101 1,115 2,216 2,557 2,912 5,469 Public administration & safety 279 251 530 265 240 505 42 59 101 266 248 514 71 63 134 28 21 49 829 1,182 2,011 133 199 332 1,913 2,263 4,176 8,538 8,693 17,231 Education & training 163 404 567 240 496 736 45 172 217 235 514 749 33 90 123 12 37 49 622 1,612 2,234 115 310 425 1,465 3,635 5,100 5,431 11,498 16,929 Health care & social assistance 210 702 912 175 730 905 21 174 195 183 796 979 32 171 203 7 49 56 556 2,637 3,193 125 494 619 1,309 5,753 7,062 4,785 18,579 23,364 Arts & recreation services 20 13 33 22 25 47 9 9 18 50 34 84 16 16 32 6 0 6 123 133 256 12 6 18 258 236 494 1,528 1,386 2,914 Other services 181 95 276 176 130 306 43 40 83 191 171 362 37 32 69 7 6 13 566 388 954 109 77 186 1,310 939 2,249 3,869 3,174 7,043 Inadequately described/Not stated 125 63 188 135 79 214 59 44 103 164 102 266 50 28 78 20 11 31 419 249 668 81 63 144 1,053 639 1,692 3,249 1,946 5,195 4,185 3,490 7,675 4,575 3,849 8,424 2,135 1,628 3,763 5,104 4,442 9,546 1,305 1,024 2,329 519 395 914 Total 15,529 12,785 28,314 2,881 2,402 5,283 36,233 30,015 66,248 108,809 95,930 204,739 (a) Industry of employment was coded to the 2006 Australian and New Zealand Standard Industrial Classification (ANZSIC) edition. This has replaced the 1993 ANZSIC edition. (b) Comprises employed persons who did not work any hours during the week prior to Census Night. Skills Tasmania 45 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 29: Field of study by occupation for the NW region (2006) Natural & Physical Sciences Managers Professionals 65 150 Technicians Community Clerical & Sales Machinery & Trade & Personal Administrative Workers Operators Workers Service Workers & Drivers Workers 42 14 17 0 11 Labourers Inadequately described/Not Stated Total 11 8 318 Information Technology 31 93 62 21 47 17 14 29 3 317 Engineering & Related Technologies 624 363 2,504 133 199 159 483 426 63 4,954 Architecture & Building Agriculture, Environmental & Related Studies 382 43 834 49 43 44 146 160 21 1,722 273 144 144 22 35 35 83 168 15 919 Health 150 1,336 45 350 106 37 7 30 0 2,061 Education 216 1,471 32 149 74 25 3 14 13 1,997 Management & Commerce 607 477 93 192 1,142 365 89 170 27 3,162 Society & Culture 141 507 66 878 152 52 18 63 13 1,890 Creative Arts 37 107 41 29 55 23 7 25 0 324 Food, Hospitality & Personal Services 156 32 552 218 95 137 65 172 13 1,440 Mixed Field Programmes 0 3 3 0 4 0 3 3 0 16 Field of study inadequately described 34 40 24 16 16 13 18 18 4 183 Field of study not stated Total 196 61 269 167 125 162 216 347 100 1,643 2,912 4,827 4,711 2,238 2,110 1,069 1,163 1,636 280 20,946 Source: Data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Skills Tasmania 46 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 30: Occupation by gender for North Western LGAs Burnie Managers Professionals Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Is Latrobe War/Wyn Reg Total Tasmania M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total M F Total 512 270 782 756 382 1,138 553 317 870 676 336 1,012 268 101 369 169 73 242 1,785 946 2,731 426 247 673 5,145 2,672 7,817 17,413 8,877 26,290 512 724 1,236 108 174 282 570 761 1,331 100 132 232 26 58 84 1,651 2,372 4,023 267 422 689 3,707 5,215 8,922 16,021 19,871 35,892 243 1,436 369 74 443 1,319 220 1,539 316 54 370 73 17 90 4,845 618 5,463 732 118 850 9,907 1,509 11,416 25,139 4,818 29,957 473 572 1,045 1,060 165 1,225 1,193 Community & personal service workers 232 549 781 197 617 814 28 195 223 268 690 958 58 196 254 3 36 39 697 1,874 2,571 140 412 552 1,623 4,569 6,192 5,946 14,519 20,465 Clerical & administrative workers 229 874 1,103 224 739 963 56 257 313 244 921 1,165 43 190 233 9 57 66 782 3,167 3,949 133 511 644 1,720 6,716 8,436 6,622 22,034 28,656 Sales workers 295 574 869 273 530 803 62 157 219 416 697 1,113 44 144 188 4 34 38 948 2,231 3,179 176 329 505 2,218 4,696 6,914 7,418 12,885 20,303 Machinery operators & drivers 673 36 709 704 65 769 352 36 388 752 124 876 208 28 236 52 0 52 2,211 136 2,347 511 23 534 5,463 448 5,911 13,292 1,288 14,580 Labourers 633 413 1,046 641 509 1,150 575 388 963 766 632 1,398 241 153 394 175 114 289 2,325 1,227 3,552 456 307 763 5,812 3,743 9,555 15,130 10,439 25,569 Inadequately described/Not stated 78 35 113 75 40 115 36 29 65 91 63 154 26 27 53 14 18 285 212 497 42 33 75 647 443 1,090 1,829 1,203 3,032 Technicians & trades workers Total 4 4,185 3,488 7,673 4,575 3,849 8,424 2,139 1,627 3,766 5,102 4,444 9,546 1,304 1,025 2,329 525 393 918 15,529 12,783 28,312 2,883 2,402 5,285 36,242 30,011 66,253 108,810 95,934 204,744 (a) Industry of employment was coded to the 2006 Australian and New Zealand Standard Industrial Classification (ANZSIC) edition. This has replaced the 1993 ANZSIC edition. (b) Comprises employed persons who did not work any hours during the week prior to Census Night. Table 31: Field of study of non-school qualification by gender for the NW LGAs and Tasmania Burnie Central Coast M 56 F 29 02 Information Technology 48 20 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 917 46 04 Architecture and Building 229 6 235 412 8 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 91 19 110 151 43 06 Health 136 293 429 87 07 Education 81 219 300 08 Management and Commerce 218 391 609 09 Society and Culture 92 256 10 Creative Arts 28 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes 01 Natural and Physical Sciences Not adequately desc or ns Total Total 85 M F Total 43 18 61 68 48 11 963 982 37 Circular Head Total 22 Devonport M 32 F 22 27 73 17 353 1,008 52 Kentish M 10 F 12 7 59 1,019 341 420 101 20 12 3 104 456 0 456 194 143 26 169 101 25 126 325 412 23 99 122 100 339 152 334 486 24 110 134 145 228 462 690 62 134 196 317 348 113 324 437 23 89 112 48 76 22 35 57 0 15 97 145 242 124 154 278 51 3 3 6 0 7 7 191 122 313 220 159 379 F 0 King Is Total 17 M 8 F 0 Latrobe Total 8 M 136 F 129 War/Wyn Total 265 M 31 F 14 Reg Total Total 54 M 17 Total 45 90 11 3 14 3 0 3 197 67 264 17 8 1,060 251 13 264 116 12 128 4,506 147 4,653 658 18 86 0 86 29 3 32 1,262 42 1,304 186 7 193 42 23 65 28 8 36 232 97 329 104 33 137 439 19 75 94 6 35 41 313 1,161 1,474 60 241 301 359 504 17 66 83 12 39 51 351 931 1,282 72 210 495 812 52 102 154 19 34 53 784 1,340 2,124 119 247 107 358 465 25 64 89 6 21 27 384 1,099 1,483 53 15 21 46 67 0 16 16 6 6 12 135 156 291 67 118 162 204 366 41 62 103 25 14 39 381 505 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 88 53 141 275 182 457 71 32 103 27 19 46 785 2,187 1,597 3,784 2,582 1,917 4,499 873 640 1,513 2,797 2,099 4,896 632 456 1,088 285 191 476 Tasmania M F Total M 2,078 333 224 557 F 1,356 Total 3,434 25 404 146 550 1,847 515 2,362 676 8,779 337 9,116 20,097 1,005 21,102 2,761 69 2,830 7,829 305 8,134 892 274 1,166 3,304 906 4,210 744 2,568 3,312 2,788 8,996 11,784 282 854 2,268 3,122 2,876 7,524 10,400 366 1,799 3,205 5,004 7,086 10,698 17,784 209 262 803 2,420 3,223 3,795 8,424 12,219 26 20 46 238 342 580 1,314 1,689 3,003 886 61 106 167 942 1,257 2,199 3,109 4,007 7,116 10 10 3 0 3 6 20 26 48 53 101 481 1,266 130 87 217 1,787 1,135 2,922 4,966 3,574 8,540 9,466 6,165 15,631 1,520 1,200 2,720 20,342 14,265 34,607 61,137 49,052 110,189 Source: Data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Skills Tasmania 47 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Tables 30 and 31 (previous) outline the field of study (FOS) of non-school qualification by occupation and FOS by gender for the NW LGAs and Tasmania. These show that: o The top two FOS for men are engineering (43%) and architecture (14%) and the top two for women are management (22%) and health (18%). Overall, Engineering (26%) ranks the highest. o Interestingly, this balance is very similar at an LGA level irrespective of the type of LGA, urban or rural. The FOS priorities are as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. Engineering & Related Technologies Management & Commerce Health Education Society & Culture Architecture & Building Food, Hospitality & Personal Services Agriculture, Environmental & Related Studies Creative Arts Natural & Physical Sciences Information Technology Similarly, Table 32 also indicates the region’s demand for occupations in terms of those currently employed. In numerical terms, the priorities are: 1. Managers 2. Professionals 3. Technicians & Trade Workers 4. Community & Personal Service Workers 5. Clerical & Administrative Workers 6. Labourers 7. Sales Workers 8. Machinery Operators & Drivers Analysis provides some insight into the FOS employed at an LGA level. This is summarised in Table 32. Table 32: Fields of study employed at a NW LGA level Engineering & Related Technologies Management & Commerce Health Burnie Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Is Latrobe War/Wyn √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ Education Society & Culture Architecture & Building Food, Hospitality & Personal Services Agriculture, Environmental & Related Studies √ √ √ √ √ Creative Arts Natural & Physical Sciences Information Technology Source: Derived from a data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Skills Tasmania 48 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile At a VET level, the detail from Table 30 indicates that the Fields of Study and Occupational Level priorities are as follows in Table 33. Labourers √ √ √ Health √ √ Machinery Operators & Drivers Clerical & Admin Workers √ √ √ √ √ Management & Commerce Sales Workers Community & Pers Service Workers Engineering & Related Technologies Professionals Managers Field of Study/Occupational Level Technicians & Trade Workers Table 33: NW regional skill priorities by field of study and occupational level (2006) √ Education √ Society & Culture Architecture & Building Food, Hospitality & Personal Services Agriculture, Environmental & Related Studies √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ Creative Arts Natural & Physical Sciences Information Technology Source: Derived from a data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Further detail to an LGA level may be found in Appendices 3 and 4. Table 34 (following) indicates the level of post-compulsory qualification by gender for the NW LGAs and shows that: Generally, the NW has a lower proportion of people than the state with Advanced Diplomas or higher and a higher proportion of those below that level; The NW has a significantly lower proportion of graduate and postgraduate qualified people than the state as a whole; At a VET level the NW has less Advanced Diploma level persons, and; Significantly MORE Certificate I – IV level qualified persons than the state as a whole. The NW has less female participation above Diploma level and more below it than the state as a whole. The NW also has less male participation above Diploma level and more below it than the state as a whole. o 13.6% women (as a percentage of all persons in the region) hold qualifications at or above Advanced Diploma level compared to men (8.8%); Skills Tasmania 49 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o 17.9% women and 32.3% of men hold a Diploma or less; The proportion of people in each LGA (as a percentage of persons in their own LGA) who possess post-secondary qualifications is as follows: o Burnie (C) 34.26% o Central Coast (M) 36.75% o Circular Head (M) 28.04% o Devonport (C) 35.23% o Kentish (M) 33.25% o King Island (M) 40.90% o Latrobe (M) 36.84% o Waratah/Wynyard (M) 34.30% This shows clearly that King Island has a relatively high proportion of postsecondary qualified people whilst Circular Head has the lowest, closely followed by Kentish. Skills Tasmania 50 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 34: Level of Non-School Qualification by Gender for the NW LGAs and Tasmania (2006) Burnie (C) Level of education N/S Male Female Persons 10 Postgraduate Degree Level, nfd Male Female Persons 11 Doctoral Degree Level Male Female Persons 12 Master Degree Level Male Female Persons 20 Graduate Diploma & Graduate Certificate nfd Male Female Persons 21 Graduate Diploma Level Male Female Persons 22 Graduate Certificate Level Male Female Persons 31 Bachelor Degree Level Male Female Persons 40 Advanced Diploma & Diploma Level, nfd Male Female Persons 41 Advanced Diploma & Assoc Degree Male Female Persons 42 Diploma Level Male Female Persons 50 Certificate Level, nfd Male Female Persons 51 Certificate III & IV Level Male Female Persons 52 Certificate I & II Level Male Female Persons Total Education Male Female Persons Central Circular Devonport Coast (M) Head (M) (C) Kentish King Latrobe (M) Island (M) (M) Waratah/ Total NW % Total Tasmania % Total Wynyard NW Tas (M) 788 1,077 1,863 898 1,158 2,061 289 295 585 1,025 1,361 2,388 261 273 536 97 80 177 383 411 798 563 666 1,228 4,298 5,320 9,624 12.2% 15.1% 27.4% 21,663 25,533 47,187 11.8% 13.9% 25.8% 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 0 3 4 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 5 3 0 3 7 8 14 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 87 85 173 0.0% 0.0% 0.1% 27 3 35 24 7 31 0 3 3 17 8 30 3 4 9 0 3 3 8 3 12 17 3 19 98 38 133 0.3% 0.1% 0.4% 1,430 698 2,129 0.8% 0.4% 1.2% 49 30 82 33 36 69 3 4 9 49 40 89 12 10 23 3 0 6 13 16 33 22 29 49 190 168 356 0.5% 0.5% 1.0% 2,097 1,943 4,039 1.1% 1.1% 2.2% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0 0 0 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 26 60 87 49 73 120 6 11 19 36 67 103 11 15 25 5 7 11 16 33 44 29 47 74 173 307 478 0.5% 0.9% 1.4% 1,345 2,199 3,545 0.7% 1.2% 1.9% 6 14 25 4 9 13 0 3 3 3 16 23 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 6 6 12 8 19 33 65 95 0.1% 0.2% 0.3% 283 483 764 0.2% 0.3% 0.4% 355 519 874 402 621 1,023 95 178 271 439 692 1,130 82 128 212 29 73 97 163 275 436 220 411 631 1,780 2,897 4,675 5.1% 8.2% 13.3% 14,535 20,327 34,867 7.9% 11.1% 19.0% 4 3 5 3 6 7 0 0 3 3 11 7 3 0 4 3 0 3 3 0 3 0 3 3 14 17 25 0.0% 0.0% 0.1% 94 118 209 0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 135 218 355 169 274 444 45 62 106 195 316 510 57 66 120 25 22 44 68 117 181 123 200 322 806 1,280 2,086 2.3% 3.6% 5.9% 4,862 6,794 11,651 2.7% 3.7% 6.4% 177 217 388 197 278 474 43 85 121 212 291 501 41 60 104 16 20 37 88 113 199 93 164 259 852 1,233 2,090 2.4% 3.5% 5.9% 4,929 5,862 10,793 2.7% 3.2% 5.9% 64 181 247 71 185 247 21 46 69 107 197 304 21 47 69 6 9 17 24 77 101 40 121 163 360 865 1,216 1.0% 2.5% 3.5% 1,835 3,888 5,725 1.0% 2.1% 3.1% 1,759 618 2,382 2,150 710 2,855 668 255 925 2,281 806 3,086 553 196 748 203 57 256 931 324 1,259 1,261 425 1,687 9,806 3,386 13,193 27.9% 9.6% 37.5% 41,811 15,357 57,170 22.8% 8.4% 31.2% 60 143 206 67 172 242 34 81 116 81 196 277 13 60 74 5 11 19 34 65 106 54 96 152 356 824 1,179 1.0% 2.3% 3.4% 1,649 3,347 4,996 0.9% 1.8% 2.7% 3,455 3,076 6,530 4,077 3,519 7,593 1,196 1,028 2,229 4,452 4,003 8,459 1,048 869 1,916 383 284 670 1,738 1,447 3,179 2,429 2,166 4,600 18,770 16,407 35,181 53.4% 46.6% 100% 96,613 86,626 183,244 52.7% 47.3% 100% Cells in this table have been randomly adjusted to avoid the release of confidential data. Created on Thursday, 10 January 2008 Australian Bureau of Statistics Web page: www.abs.gov.au Copyright © 2007 Australian Bureau of Statistics. All rights reserved. Source: Data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Table 35 (following) provides an insight into the mobility of the current population and workforce and therefore into the new entrants into the region that may require some form of education and training: Overall there is a 30% mobility over a five year census period; Manufacturing, retail, health care and education and training have the highest rates of mobility; Annual mobility rates are between 4 – 6% per annum. Skills Tasmania 51 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 35: Industry of employment (ANZSIC06) by UAI5P usual address five years ago indicator by NW LGA Total NW Not stated Not applicable A Agriculture, Forestry & Fishing B Mining C Manufacturing D Electricity, Gas, Water & Waste Services E Construction F Wholesale Trade Address % Address Address % Address Overseas 2001 same 2001 same 2001 2001 in 2001 as in 2006 as in 2006 elsewhere in elsewhere in Australia Australia % Overseas in 2001 Moved in 2005-06 % Moved in Not stated Not Overseas 2005-06 applicable visitor 2006 343 58% 159 27% 3 1% 36 6% 55 30,379 51% 16,264 27% 486 1% 2,198 4% 4,078 2,310 65% 974 28% 64 2% 150 4% 304 53% 227 39% 8 1% 34 6% 3,596 58% 2,089 34% 71 1% 307 5% Total - - 588 6,010 - 59,417 48 - - 3,539 12 - - 579 92 - - 6,155 235 65% 116 32% 3 1% 11 3% 4 - - 362 1,629 59% 902 33% 24 1% 172 6% 39 - - 2,763 954 57% 581 35% 12 1% 95 6% 28 - - 1,664 G Retail Trade 2,870 57% 1,830 36% 26 1% 246 5% 54 - - 5,020 H Accommodation & Food Services 1,378 53% 993 38% 23 1% 154 6% 45 - - 2,594 I Transport, Postal & Warehousing 1,514 62% 774 32% 6 0% 107 4% 41 - - 2,447 J Information Media & Telecommunications 195 53% 149 40% 10 3% 17 5% - - 369 K Financial & Insurance Services 307 51% 263 43% 6 1% 29 5% - - 607 L Rental, Hiring & Real Estate Services 245 52% 189 40% 5 1% 29 6% - - 468 M Professional, Scientific & Technical Services 673 57% 442 37% 12 1% 55 5% 3 - - 1,189 N Administrative & Support Services 4 - 741 53% 560 40% 7 0% 87 6% 12 - - 1,405 O Public Administration & Safety 1,293 55% 907 39% 22 1% 114 5% 18 - - 2,355 P Education & Training 1,927 62% 1,004 32% 44 1% 115 4% 19 - - 3,112 Q Health Care & Social Assistance 2,510 59% 1,416 33% 109 3% 190 4% 36 - - 4,271 R Arts & Recreation Services 144 54% 100 37% 4 1% 11 4% 5 - - 269 S Other Services 760 53% 576 41% 3 0% 72 5% 13 - - 1,421 310 58% 185 35% 9 2% 18 3% 16 - - 535 54,608 54% 30,679 30% 946 1% 4,254 4% 4,626 6,010 - 101,127 T Inadequately described Total industry Source: Data set commissioned by Strategic Alignment Associates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Skills Tasmania 52 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 5.2. Labour market dynamics16 The most significant changes in the Tasmanian labour market have been the rise in employment, fall in unemployment and the onset of a very tight recruiting environment. Total employment in Tasmania rose slightly in January, and was 2.9% higher than in January last year. Full-time employment grew by 2.4% over the year, while part-time employment increased by 3.8% over the same period. Most of the increases appear to have been in male employment, which increased by 3.8% over the year. This increase was made up of a 4.3% increase in male full-time employment and a 1.5% increase in part-time employment. Total female employment increased by 1.7% over the year, with a 4.7% increase in part - time employment and a 1.1% decline in female full-time employment. Total employment has now increased for 14 consecutive months in Tasmania. The ANZ Bank Job Advertisement series (trend) for Tasmania fell by 1.3% in January. The series is 17.7% higher than it was in January last year. Nationally, the series fell by 0.6% over the month, and was 0.5% higher than in January 2007. DEWR's Skilled Vacancy Survey Index (trend) for Tasmania decreased by 0.7% in January but was 3.5% higher than in January last year. Nationally, the series increased by 1.1% over the month and was 0.5% lower than January last year (Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations 2008). However, within this overall improvement lie both causes for concern and opportunities: Tasmania’s labour force participation rate is lower than the national average and over the past three years has shown only a modest increase, despite strong economic and employment growth during that time. One contributing factor has been Tasmania’s ageing population. However, several other important factors account for the difference. As Tasmania’s population is ageing faster than any other state or territory, this is likely to further increase Tasmania’s nonparticipation rate relative to other jurisdictions in the future. In the year to April 2007, 27.3 per cent of Tasmanians aged 15 to 64 years did not participate in the labour market. This was 3.4 percentage points above the national rate of 23.9 per cent. Males have a fairly stable rate of non-participation of around 10 per cent between the ages of 20 to 49 years. However, females, not surprisingly, have a higher rate of non-participation during the child bearing and rearing ages of 20 to 49 years. Section 2 of the full report provides further information on differences between male and female non-participation. However, a higher participation rate is an important economic measure for because: o Labour supply is critical for economic growth; o It facilitates increased output without significant upward pressure on wages; o When the labour market is tight and there are many skill shortages it provides a greater potential for overcoming mismatches between labour supply and demand; o It reduces the number of individuals who are vulnerable to financial pressures; 16 Note that this section relies heavily on the report from the Demographic Change Advisory Council 2007, Who is not participating in Tasmania’s labour force? Summary paper. Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources Hobart, Tasmania. Skills Tasmania 53 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o It increases taxation revenues and reduces reliance on government benefits and other welfare services. The ABS estimates reveal that around 31 000 or 20 per cent of Tasmanians not in the labour force in September 2006 wanted to work. The vast majority therefore of those who do not participate in the labour force do not want to work. Removing those who were neither actively looking for work nor available to start work within four weeks leaves 24 000 persons – around 16 per cent of the total number not in the labour force – who are referred to as “marginally attached”. The six main activities of those not participating in the labour force are: o Retired or voluntarily inactive; o Performing home duties or childcare; o Attending an educational institution; o Own illness, injury or disability; o Travel, holiday or leisure activity; and o Looking after an ill or disabled person. Tasmania has a higher share of those who are retired and voluntarily inactive, and have a disability or handicap, but a smaller share of those with home duties or undertaking child care, and still in education. Those who are outside the conventionally defined labour force but more readily available for employment, are known as ‘persons with marginal attachment to the labour force’. This group includes people who are willing to work, but are either not actively looking for work or are not available for work immediately. The main differences are that marginally attached people are: o More likely to be undertaking home duties or child care; o More likely to be attending an education institution; and o Less likely to be retired or voluntarily inactive. There has been a recent decline in the marginally attached which has been more pronounced for women, some of whom may have benefited from the trend towards greater flexibility in working arrangements that has helped address the family-related reasons that were keeping women out of the labour force (Reserve Bank of Australia 2007). With respect to age groups, there has been a noteworthy increase in the participation of those aged between 45 and 64 years (Demographic Change Advisory Council 2007b). 5.3. The impact of ageing Population growth has been easing since 2003-04, when net interstate in migration reached its peak. Recently, interstate in-migration and out-migration flows have been almost equal, with the result that population growth has been due to natural population increase and net overseas in-migration. For 2007-08, population growth is expected to be 0.6% for Tasmania. The age profile of arrivals and departures over recent years suggests that Tasmania is experiencing a net in-migration of families. If this trend is sustained it is likely to have a slight moderating impact on the rate of population ageing. Skills Tasmania 54 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Analysis of the age composition of recent net migration to Tasmania reveals that the state is becoming more attractive to younger persons and families. The optimistic economic outlook, good job opportunities and lifestyle benefits are making Tasmania a more attractive place to live. Tasmania's population is experiencing demographic change which will have significant economic, social and fiscal impacts in future decades. This change is expected to be a more important issue for Tasmania as the population: Is ageing more rapidly than any other jurisdiction; Continues to have shortages of those in child raising age groups; and Has the lowest labour force participation rate than any jurisdiction (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007). Most Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) population projections suggest Tasmania's total population will begin to decline between 2015 and 2025. The population is projected to peak at 504,500 people in 2023 or 2024, and then decrease to 453,000 people in 2051. This is 6% fewer people than in 2004. The ABS published a series of population projections, estimating the population up to 2051. These projections assume the components of population change e.g. births and deaths, will hold for the next 50 years. Three scenarios were published, assuming the following characteristics: Series A assumes high levels of fertility, life expectancy, overseas migration and interstate migration flows. Series B assumes medium levels of fertility, life expectancy, overseas migration and interstate migration flows. Series C assumes low levels of fertility, overseas migration and interstate migration flows and a medium level of life expectancy. According to the population projections (Table 36), Tasmania will move to a situation of natural decline by 2026 under the medium (Series B) and low (Series C) set of assumptions and by 2046 under the high (Series A) set of assumptions. The 2004 estimated resident population is used as the base population. The Series B projections are the closest to the actual 2006 population figures. Table 36: Projected Resident Population, Tasmania: 2006-2051 Projected Population Projected Population Projected Population Year 2006 (Series A - high) (Series B - medium) (Series C - low) 490,500 488,400 486,000 2011 507,600 495,400 482,900 2021 543,700 504,000 466,800 2031 576,100 500,600 436,900 2041 2051 600,400 620,100 481,400 453,000 391,000 335,400 Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics (1999a) Overall, the NW has slightly more very young people, less teenagers and young families, and more of the older age groups than the state as a whole which, in a national Skills Tasmania 55 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile comparison, means that the NW has more of a demographic ageing issue than most other regions in the country. Burnie, Circular Head and Waratah/Wynyard have the highest proportions of children and young people in their populations. King Island has the smallest numbers of the younger age groups of any LGA (Table 4). However, Kentish and King Island have the highest proportion of middle aged persons, probably because of the predominance of primary industry employment in the regions. Central Coast and Waratah/Wynyard have largest proportions of the over 60s, reflecting the fact that those LGAs host the main retirement facilities in the region. Amongst the many challenges that such ageing will bring are several relevant to education and training:17 5.3.1.Skill and labour shortages With demographic change leading to a smaller and ageing labour force, and with the increased mobility of labour, skilled labour will be in strong demand, especially when the Tasmanian and national economies are in a strong growth phase. Tasmania also faces skills shortages in several industries and occupations, particularly in the construction and metal fabrication industries. The problem becomes more acute when, for certain classes of skilled labour, a large proportion are aged 40 years or over, and there are relatively few younger persons with the necessary skills or interest in working in that occupation or industry. Current examples include aged care workers and farm managers. In the decades ahead, the average hours worked by these older employees are projected to decline and large numbers may retire over a relatively short period. This could present some major challenges to Tasmanian employers. The need to match labour supply with demand is likely to lead to increasing demand for training opportunities for mature-aged and other workers, especially while the current strong economic conditions continue. For the North West, this issue will be somewhat more significant than for the rest of the state because of the drain of younger age groups out of the region for education and work purposes, the loss of young families and the movement in of retirees. The problem is exacerbated by the regions lack of competitiveness in wages (with the exception of the mining industry). 5.3.2.Competition in a global labour market In an economic climate that involves strong demand for skilled labour, the international mobility of labour provides threats and opportunities. Currently, Tasmania only receives 0.6 per cent of migrants to Australia, which is well below Tasmania’s population share of just under 2.4 per cent. In numerical terms, this is 462 new migrants since 2004 and of these, 368 were from non-English speaking countries. International migration can play an important role in assisting to increase labour supply in Tasmania, especially for skilled labour. However, it may also make it more difficult to retain young professionals who will be highly sought after in an environment of increasing competition for skilled labour across developed countries. 17 Note, this section relies heavily on the report by the Demographic Change Advisory Council 2007, Demographic change in Tasmania: challenges and opportunities - issues paper, State of Tasmania - Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources Hobart, Tasmania. Skills Tasmania 56 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Currently, wages for skilled labour in Tasmania are generally below mainland levels, reflecting, in part, lower productivity levels in Tasmania. The capacity of Tasmanian employers to attract and retain skilled workers will be constrained without significant improvements in productivity in the years ahead. 5.3.3.A need for higher education, training and skill development The skills of the labour force influence the level of economic activity in several ways, for example: People who are more educated are more likely to participate in the labour force; People who are less educated tend to experience longer periods of unemployment; Better educated people tend to be healthier and therefore have reduced absenteeism; and Skilled people tend to be more productive and therefore can obtain higher salaries. According to one study, every additional year of education across the community increases real GSP by around eight per cent (Dowrick 2002). Over the past 40 years, skills acquisition and work patterns have changed significantly. For almost all people, formal education was only undertaken by those at the commencement of their working life. Many people intended to stay with the same organisation, or in the same profession, for their entire working life. However, it is generally agreed that there is greater movement between jobs and occupations by those currently working than in previous generations. As Tasmania’s working population ages, employers will be increasingly reliant on mature workers in the future. The challenge for many employers will be to ensure that their staff have the necessary skills to perform their jobs. Training demand is expected to increase, particularly as older workers are encouraged to remain in the workforce. This will often require re-skilling. The proportion of Tasmania’s population with a bachelor degree or higher is around 16 per cent, compared with a national average of around 20 per cent. A key challenge for the community over the next decades involves ensuring that Tasmania’s labour force has the appropriate level and type of skills required by employers. Currently, the proportion of young people participating in vocational education and training far outweighs the proportion of mature aged people. However, older people participating in training are making up a growing proportion of all students, and this trend is likely to continue. Figures from the University of Tasmania show that in 2002, seven per cent of its students were aged between 45 and 64 years; in 2007 this has grown to 8.2 per cent. In the NW, 16.4% people have a Higher Education qualification whilst the state as a whole has 24.8%. This disadvantage in higher qualifications extends to Advanced Diploma level where 5.9% people in the NW and 6.4% across the state hold that qualification level. The NW tends to have lower participation generally in the higher levels of education and training and a high proportion at lower levels (see Table 34). Many mature-aged people are reportedly enrolling in higher education and training courses to acquire new skills whilst in employment. While on-going training and reskilling is critical for all workers in a modern economy, it is particularly important for Skills Tasmania 57 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile mature-aged workers in physically demanding occupations who want to, or need to, continue in the workforce. Part of the challenge in encouraging increased participation in mature age learning involves breaking myths or incorrect perceptions about mature-aged workers. For example, some employers believe that mature-aged workers are not interested or able to learn new skills and that they are generally resistant to change. This attitude has resulted in some workplaces that have invested time and money in up-skilling only part of their workforce whilst ignoring a large proportion. Equally, it is reported that some mature age workers are reluctant to return to formal training as they are uncomfortable being in learning environments with much younger students. The design and delivery of training courses will therefore be critical for ensuring that participation by men and women of all ages is maximised in the future. 5.3.4.Lifelong learning Lifelong learning is an important concept for individuals in the modern world. By definition it emphasises the importance of learning beyond working age. Continuous learning and mental stimulation has been proven to be essential for the wellbeing of older people and for having a positive impact on people’s health. There is evidence that lifelong learning and participation in learning communities can help ward off cognitive decline, such as dementia. This form of learning will have an important role to play in keeping older Tasmanians actively engaged in lifelong learning and social opportunities. Successful interaction contributes to the reduction in social isolation and increases independence (Demographic Change Advisory Council 2007a). Skills Tasmania 58 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 5.4. Conclusions Generally, the NW workforce is lower qualified than the state as a whole, and, with the exception of King Island, the more remote rural LGAs are most disadvantaged in this respect; Unemployment is low and employment at long term highs, however there is a significant proportion of people not in the labour force and Tasmania has the lowest rate in the nation (27.3%). Whilst the reasons are complex, this segment does offer an opportunity to improve labour supply in the short term; The main Field of Study employed by industry are: o Engineering o Management and commerce o Health o Society and culture (in part social welfare) o Architecture and building o Food, hospitality and personal services There are differences between industries and LGAs regarding the types of skills apparently in demand; Overall there is about a 30% mobility of the workforce in/out of the region over a 5 year period – about 4 – 6% per annum. Manufacturing, retail, health care and education have the highest rates of mobility; Tasmania is ageing faster than any other jurisdiction in Australia. This will bring the following challenges: o Skill and labour shortages o Competition from the global employment marketplace o A need for more education and training o A need for lifelong learning The NW Region is slightly worse off than the rest of the state in this regard and, because it also has relatively lower wage structures in most industries except mining, will be out-competed in the labour market. Skills Tasmania 59 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 6. Economic Activity Tasmania's gross state product (GSP) grew by 2.1% in 2006-07, with the national growth rate at 3.2%. Consumer spending comprises over 60% of GSP and grew by 4.2% in 2006-07, compared to a national rate of 3.6%. Tasmania’s economic fundamentals continue to be strong into the first months of 2008 due to favourable external conditions and growth of high productivity industries. There are new major projects on the horizon and Tasmania’s recent investment and productivity story is encouraging. In addition, revisions to State Accounts estimates suggest that Tasmania’s economic performance relative to Australia, and Tasmania’s productivity levels, have not been as far behind Australia and the other jurisdictions as previously reported. However, despite this revision, Tasmania’s GSP per capita and productivity levels remain consistently below the national levels. Tasmania’s overseas export sales increased by 13.1 per cent in nominal terms in the twelve months to December 2007, to $3.75 billion. The volume of Tasmanian international merchandise exports increased by 3.0 per cent in the four quarters to September 2007. This growth in export value and improvements in Tasmania’s terms of trade have contributed to real income growth in Tasmania. Tasmania’s estimated resident population grew by 600 persons (or 0.12 per cent) in the June quarter 2007 to 493 341 persons. In the year to June 2007, Tasmania’s population increased by 3 271 persons (0.67 per cent) (Hawkes 2008). The continued strong economic growth in East Asia, most notably China (Tasmania's fastest growing trade partner) and India should help to drive an improved export performance in 2007-08. Tasmania's major export markets have favourable economic outlooks, as Japan experiences improved economic conditions and China's rapid economic expansion is expected to continue. The price outlook for 2007-08 for key Tasmanian commodities continues to be positive. After strong growth in mineral commodities over the past two years, the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Research Economics (ABARE) has forecast increases in world prices for Table 37: NW Tasmania - Regional industry aluminium, zinc, copper and gold. Prices are by number employed (2006) supported by high demand in China, low stocks Regional Industry by Size Employees % and a lack of spare refining capacity and Manufacturing 6,157 15% speculative activity. Retail trade 5,025 12% The long-term outlook for the Tasmanian economy is positive with the State recently recording big increases in retail trade, consumer spending, exports and building approvals: Retail trade in trend terms reached a record high of $424 million in October 2007, 6.7% above the level recorded at the same time last year; Health care & social assistance 4,272 10% Agriculture, forestry & fishing 3,540 8% Education & training 3,105 7% Construction 2,766 7% Accommodation & food services 2,597 6% Transport, postal & warehousing 2,441 6% Public administration & safety 2,360 6% Wholesale trade 1,671 4% Other services 1,412 3% Administrative & support services 1,408 3% Professional, scientific & technical services 1,192 3% Consumer spending increased by 0.8% in the quarter to its highest level on record, and rose by 4.9% in the year to September 2007; Financial & insurance services 593 1% Mining 574 1% Rental, hiring & real estate services 473 1% Information media & telecommunications 379 1% Electricity, gas, water & waste services 360 1% The value of residential approvals in the year to May 2007 was $74.6million, 13.4% higher than approvals for the previous year; and Arts & recreation services 260 1% Inadequately described/Not stated 1,119 3% Total 41,704 Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007j) Skills Tasmania 60 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile There has been a 16.4% increase in the value of engineering work and a 4.6% increase in the value of construction work in the year to March 2007. 6.1. A Profile of NW Business Table 37 (previous) shows the relative size by employment impact of NW industries. Manufacturing, retail, health care and agriculture, forestry and fishing are the biggest employers. Unfortunately, business turnover figures are unavailable for privacy reasons and this report is unable to consider the relative economic impact of industries. However, a generalised profile of the NW business environment in Figure 9 provides a visual comparison of business size by turnover in the NW. This shows the high proportion of small businesses in the NW. Only 10% have a turnover of more than $1 million. Figure 9: Business size by turnover in NW Tasmania (2006) 1800 1674 1600 No. Businesses 1400 1200 999 984 1000 912 849 822 800 642 540 600 426 400 276 200 66 51 18 12 0 0 th an 0k le $ 50 m ss 0k th to l e an $2 s $ m s t h 1m an $5 to l es m $ s th 2m $1 to l a e 0m n ss th $5m $2 t o l a 0m ess n $ th 10m $5 to 0m l e an s to s th $20 m le ss an th $50 M an m or $2 e 0 th an 0m $2 00 m k n $2 50 $1 k to s le s to $5 00 s k $2 00 k to le s s th a n th a n th a le s to $1 50 k $1 00 k 5k $1 $7 0k s le s 00 $1 $7 5k to le s s th a n $5 n th a s to le s to 0k $5 5k $2 Ze ro to le ss th a n $2 5k 0 Turnover Range Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Figure 10 also clearly indicates the numerical dominance of agriculture, forestry and fishing businesses followed by property and business services, the retail trade and construction. The need to consider the data provided in this report as a whole is apparent in this Figure 10 where the small number of manufacturing businesses (378) employ 15% of the population; clearly, that industry must be comprised of many of those businesses with a larger turnover. This obviates the importance of this industry to the NW coast’s current economy and future development. Skills Tasmania 61 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 10: Total businesses in NW Tasmania by industry (2006) 2500 2337 Number of businesses 2000 1500 1254 1158 1077 1000 500 327 315 282 48 102 27 438 378 228 246 48 6 Ac co m m od at A g i on ric Ca ul f e tu re s a n C For d R o e m st es C m ry ta ul tu un a ur ra ica nd an la tio Fi ts nd n sh Re Se i n El g C cr ec on rvic e tri at s e ci io tru s ty na c G l S tio a s er n H ea a v E n F lth in d du ice W a c an nc a a s ti d e t Co an er S on u d m m I n pp u n su l y ity ra Pe M Se nce Pr rs a nu rvi o p on fa ce er al ct s ty an ur an d i d oth M ng Bu e i n r in si ne S e g rv s s i Tr Se ces an sp Re rvi or tai ce l t s W and Tra ho d le Sto e sa ra l e ge Tr ad e 0 Industry Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Figure 11 (following) classify the number of NW businesses by the number of employees. This indicates that: 81% have less than four employees; 58% are sole operators not employing anyone; Only 45 businesses in the NW have 100 or more employees. Skills Tasmania 62 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 11: Size of NW Tasmanian businesses by number of employees (2006) 6000 No. Businesses 5000 4770 4000 3000 1941 2000 1206 1000 237 72 24 21 50-99 employees 100-199 employees 200+ employees 0 Non employing 1-4 employees 5-19 employees 20-49 employees No. Employees Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Figure 12 shows which industries are dominated by smaller businesses; it demonstrates agriculture, forestry and fishing, property and business services and construction are the main areas for owner-operators. Figure 12: NW Tasmania - breakdown of small businesses by industry (2006) 1800 Number of Businesses 1600 1400 1200 Non employing 1000 1-4 employees 800 5-19 employees 600 400 200 Ac co m m od a Ag tion ric Ca ul tu fes re a F nd Co ore Re Cu m str st a m y ltu u n an ur a ra n ica d la tio Fis ts nd hi n Re El S ng ec cr Co erv e a n ic tri ci tio str es ty na u c G l S t io as He er n a vic al F nd E th in d W uc es a n an a d ce te r atio Co an S n m d up m In ply un su ity ra n P M Se ce Pr ers a op on nu rvic er a l fa es ct ty a ur an n d in ot d B u h e Mi g n r si i ne Se ng ss rvi c Tr Se es an sp Re rvic or ta es il t W a nd Tra ho S de le t o sa r a le ge Tr ad e 0 Industry Sector Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Skills Tasmania 63 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Figure 13: NW Tasmanian businesses compared with total Tasmanian and total Australian businesses by industry (2006) 30.0% Percentage of businesses 25.0% 20.0% Total Australia 15.0% Total Tas Total NW Tas 10.0% 5.0% Ac co m m od at io n Ag Ca ric fe s ul an tu re d Re Fo st re au st Co r ra y m nt an m s d un Cu Fi ica s ltu h t in io ra g n la Se nd rv Co Re ice cr s ns ea tru El tio ct ec io na tri n ci lS ty er G vic as es Ed an uc d He W Fi at a n i o al an te n th rS ce an up an d p d Co ly In m s m un ura n it y c Se e rv M i ce an Pe s uf ac rs on Pr tu rin al op g an er ty d M ot an in he in d g rS Bu er si ne vic ss es Se rv Tr ic R e an et s sp ai lT or ra ta de nd W h o Sto ra le ge sa le Tr ad e 0.0% Industry Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Figure 13 demonstrates the industry orientation of the NW Coast. It is apparent that the NW Coast: Is dominated by large numbers of agriculture, forestry and fishing industry, property and business services, construction and retail businesses; This is particularly so for the agriculture, forestry and fishing industry in the NW than for the state and Australia; Transport, mining, manufacturing, accommodation and other public service dominated areas are also present in relatively small numbers. The entry/exit rates of business is of interest to education and training planners because when businesses change hands, particularly where there are people new to an industry who take over that business or, alternatively where businesses are struggling, then education and training may help businesses to survive. Table 38 provides data on survival rates and entry/exit rates in Tasmanian businesses: The highest exit rates occur in mining, education, accommodation, cafes and restaurants, communication services, finance and insurance, electricity, gas and water supply; Most exits of small businesses occur in agricultural industries, construction, retail, transport and property businesses; Most exits of larger businesses occur in the finance and property industries. Skills Tasmania 64 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 38: Counts of Australian businesses, including entries and exits for Tasmania (2006-07) Operating at start of financial year Industry by ANZIC Division Agriculture, Forestry & Fishing Zero to $50k $50k to less than $200k $200k to less $2m or than $2m more Entries Total Zero to $50k to less $50k than $200k Exits $200k to less $2m or than $2m more Total Zero to $50k to less $50k than $200k $200k to less $2m or than $2m more Total Operating at end of financial year Change Percentage change Entry rate Exit rate no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. no. % % % 2,340 2,442 2,064 156 7,002 279 228 222 27 756 195 315 159 6 675 6,987 -15 0% 11% 10% Mining 24 24 30 18 96 9 15 3 0 27 12 9 9 0 30 99 3 -3% 28% 31% Manufacturing 486 705 675 183 2,049 99 69 57 27 252 99 132 81 15 327 1,920 -129 6% 12% 16% 9 15 15 12 51 0 3 3 3 9 0 3 6 0 9 60 9 -18% 18% 18% 1,092 2,340 1,599 216 5,247 189 465 228 24 906 192 375 144 6 717 5,523 276 -5% 17% 14% Wholesale Trade 291 285 495 177 1,248 36 57 63 6 162 45 45 42 9 141 1,197 -51 4% 13% 11% Retail Trade 774 1,386 2,289 459 4,908 144 222 291 18 675 147 222 234 33 636 4,833 -75 2% 14% 13% Accommodation, Cafes & Rest's 246 480 741 105 1,572 57 90 165 9 321 36 90 84 6 216 1,620 48 -3% 20% 14% Transport and Storage 708 717 546 96 2,067 168 87 48 3 306 129 90 51 6 276 2,091 24 -1% 15% 13% Communication Services 96 156 45 9 306 15 36 6 3 60 18 15 6 0 39 342 36 -12% 20% 13% Finance and Insurance 525 456 540 219 1,740 126 129 63 21 339 63 30 93 69 255 1,815 75 -4% 19% 15% 3,180 3,822 3,027 621 10,650 723 693 330 63 1,809 387 492 327 165 1,371 10,965 315 -3% 17% 13% Education 96 105 45 3 249 36 18 3 0 57 15 27 9 0 51 255 6 -2% 23% 20% Health & Comm Services 447 651 771 66 1,935 102 111 105 0 318 75 72 42 6 195 2,019 84 -4% 16% 10% Cultural & Rec Services 279 267 168 9 723 57 48 18 6 129 48 42 18 0 108 774 51 -7% 18% 15% Personal & Other Services 315 501 195 9 1,020 75 87 21 0 183 69 90 18 0 177 1,026 6 -1% 18% 17% 14,352 13,245 2,358 40,863 2,115 2,358 1,626 210 6,309 1,530 2,049 1,323 321 5,223 41,526 663 -1.6% 15.4% 12.8% Electricity, Gas & Water Supply Construction Property & Bus Services Totals 10,908 Source: (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007k) Skills Tasmania 65 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 39 provides a more detailed insight into business survivals between 2003 – 2007 by industry and turnover (note that zeroes have been inserted by the ABS to protect privacy): High survival rates are experienced by businesses in metal product manufacturing, electricity and gas supply, aerospace transport, finance, machinery and vehicle wholesaling, agriculture, forestry and fishing; Low survival rates are experienced by services to mining, wood and paper manufacturing, community services, food retailing and transport; It should be noted that survival rates improve with business turnover. Table 39: Survival of businesses by industry subdivision for Tasmania, by annual turnover size ranges: June 2003 - June 2007 Operating in June 2003 Survived to June 2007 Industry ANZSIC Code $50k to $200k to Zero to less than less than $50k $200k $2m $2m or more Zero to $50k $50k to $200k to Survival less than Survival less than Survival Rate $200k Rate $2m Rate $2m or more Survival Rate no. no. no. no. no. % no. % no. % no. % 1,653 1,692 1,527 114 1,230 74.4 1,125 66.5 930 60.9 57 50.0 Services to Agriculture & Trapping 153 174 123 15 108 70.6 108 62.1 105 85.4 12 80.0 Forestry & Logging 114 231 192 24 84 73.7 120 52.0 150 78.1 27 100.0 04 Commercial Fishing 156 315 360 24 114 73.1 198 62.9 264 73.3 27 100.0 11 Coal Mining 0 0 6 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 12 Oil & Gas Extraction 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 13 Metal Ore Mining 6 3 6 0 0 0.0 3 100.0 6 100.0 0 0.0 14 Other Mining 0 6 15 3 3 0.0 15 100.0 12 80.0 0 0.0 15 Services to Mining 12 12 18 6 3 25.0 6 50.0 12 66.7 3 50.0 21 Food Beverage & Tobacco Manufacturing 27 42 87 39 18 66.7 36 85.7 63 72.4 27 69.2 22 Textile Clothing Footwear Manufacturing 45 45 42 6 21 46.7 24 53.3 45 100.0 6 100.0 23 Wood & Paper Product Manufacturing 69 66 81 18 24 34.8 51 77.3 48 59.3 15 83.3 24 Printing Publishing & Recorded Media 57 66 66 9 30 52.6 36 54.6 30 45.5 9 100.0 25 Petroleum Coal & Chemical Manufacturing 24 30 24 15 15 62.5 9 30.0 12 50.0 27 100.0 26 Non-Metallic Mineral Product Manufacturing 24 48 42 9 12 50.0 21 43.8 27 64.3 9 100.0 27 Metal Product Manufacturing 48 132 135 42 48 100.0 78 59.1 102 75.6 30 71.4 28 Machinery & Equipment Manufacturing 96 147 117 39 39 40.6 78 53.1 99 84.6 30 76.9 29 Other Manufacturing 60 126 78 15 51 85.0 72 57.1 60 76.9 18 100.0 36 Electricity & Gas Supply 3 3 3 3 9 100.0 3 100.0 3 100.0 3 100.0 37 Water Supply Sewerage & Drainage Services 3 9 9 0 0 0.0 6 66.7 3 33.3 0 0.0 41 General Construction 246 471 405 99 144 58.5 273 58.0 351 86.7 90 90.9 42 Construction Trade Services 702 1,710 891 78 432 61.5 966 56.5 639 71.7 102 100.0 45 Basic Material Wholesaling 96 75 114 45 60 62.5 51 68.0 90 79.0 39 86.7 46 Machinery & Motor Vehicle Wholesaling 39 96 138 72 33 84.6 60 62.5 84 60.9 42 58.3 47 Personal & Household Good Wholesaling 120 144 225 75 78 65.0 81 56.3 144 64.0 63 84.0 51 Food Retailing 114 309 774 81 48 42.1 120 38.8 378 48.8 72 88.9 52 Personal & Household Good Retailing 447 783 1,002 243 243 54.4 375 47.9 627 62.6 216 88.9 53 Motor Vehicle Retailing & Services 165 363 519 123 66 40.0 195 53.7 336 64.7 102 82.9 57 Accommodation Cafes & Restaurants 159 411 678 96 90 56.6 237 57.7 375 55.3 63 65.6 61 Road Transport 615 501 408 66 294 47.8 372 74.3 324 79.4 60 90.9 62 Rail Transport 3 0 0 6 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 50.0 63 Water Transport 18 39 15 6 9 50.0 18 46.2 9 60.0 3 50.0 64 Air & Space Transport 3 9 18 0 3 100.0 3 33.3 12 66.7 3 0.0 65 Other Transport 3 24 12 0 0 0.0 6 25.0 3 25.0 0 0.0 66 Services to Transport 66 90 66 21 30 45.5 57 63.3 42 63.6 27 100.0 67 Storage 0 6 21 0 3 0.0 6 100.0 3 14.3 0 0.0 71 Communication Services 78 144 51 12 33 42.3 75 52.1 42 82.4 6 50.0 73 Finance 81 90 90 99 69 85.2 60 66.7 66 73.3 33 33.3 74 Insurance 192 102 246 21 117 60.9 93 91.2 87 35.4 15 71.4 75 Services to Finance & Insurance 129 174 258 105 75 58.1 102 58.6 129 50.0 42 40.0 77 Property Services 810 1,191 717 66 525 64.8 720 60.5 504 70.3 51 77.3 78 Business Services 903 1,563 951 99 573 63.5 708 45.3 645 67.8 81 81.8 84 Education 75 108 48 0 57 76.0 39 36.1 15 31.3 3 0.0 86 Health Services 195 525 696 42 141 72.3 327 62.3 603 86.6 42 100.0 87 Community Services 123 39 57 12 48 39.0 27 69.2 42 73.7 18 100.0 91 Motion Picture Radio & Television Services 45 21 24 6 15 33.3 24 100.0 18 75.0 6 100.0 92 Libraries Museums & the Arts 168 75 30 3 69 41.1 48 64.0 15 50.0 0 0.0 93 Sport & Recreation 105 219 129 6 51 48.6 108 49.3 84 65.1 9 100.0 95 Personal Services 339 402 228 24 135 39.8 204 50.8 153 67.1 6 25.0 01 Agriculture 02 03 Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007e) Skills Tasmania 66 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 40 provides a more detailed insight into business entries and their survival by industry and turnover from 2003-07 (note that zeroes have been inserted by the ABS to protect privacy): At low turnovers, the highest rates of survival were experienced in textiles, wood and paper product manufacturing, printing, petroleum coating manufacturing, metal product manufacturing, personal goods wholesaling, services to transport, communications services, finance and services to finance, property services and health; Survival generally improved with the size of turnover with some notable exceptions of entries over $2 million in forestry logging, personal goods wholesaling, and property services. Table 40: Survival of entries by industry subdivision for Tasmania, by annual turnover size ranges: June 2003 - June 2007 Entries in 2003-04 Survived to June 2007 Industry ANZSIC Code $50k to $200k to Zero to less than less than $50k $200k $2m $2m or more Total Zero to $50k $50k to $200k to Survival less than Survival less than Survival rate $200k rate $2m rate $2m or more Survival rate Total Survival rate no. no. no. no. no. no. % no. % no. % no. % no. % 01 Agriculture 171 159 120 9 459 114 66.7 45 28.3 63 52.5 0 0.0 222 48.4 02 Services to Agriculture & Trapping 15 21 9 3 48 3 20.0 12 57.1 9 100.0 3 100.0 27 56.3 03 Forestry & Logging 30 63 21 9 123 18 60.0 24 38.1 9 42.9 3 33.3 54 43.9 04 Commercial Fishing 27 51 27 3 108 9 33.3 33 64.7 21 77.8 0 0.0 63 58.3 11 Coal Mining 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 12 Oil & Gas Extraction 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 13 Metal Ore Mining 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 6 0.0 9 0.0 14 Other Mining 0 9 0 0 9 0 0.0 3 33.3 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 33.3 15 Services to Mining 0 3 0 0 3 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 3 100.0 21 Food Beverage & Tobacco Manufacturing 6 9 9 3 27 0 0.0 6 66.7 3 33.3 3 100.0 12 44.4 22 Textile Clothing Footwear Manufacturing 9 6 0 0 15 9 100.0 3 50.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 12 80.0 23 Wood & Paper Product Manufacturing 3 15 9 0 27 3 100.0 3 20.0 3 33.3 0 0.0 9 33.3 24 Printing Publishing & Recorded Media 6 9 6 0 21 9 100.0 3 33.3 3 50.0 0 0.0 15 71.4 25 Petroleum Coal & Chemical Manufacturing 3 9 3 0 15 9 100.0 9 100.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 18 100.0 26 Non-Metallic Mineral Product Manufacturing 12 3 0 0 15 3 25.0 3 100.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 6 40.0 27 Metal Product Manufacturing 6 27 21 3 57 12 100.0 12 44.4 18 85.7 6 100.0 48 84.2 28 Machinery & Equipment Manufacturing 27 45 18 9 99 6 22.2 15 33.3 6 33.3 0 0.0 27 27.3 29 Other Manufacturing 18 24 12 0 54 3 16.7 3 12.5 9 75.0 0 0.0 15 27.8 36 Electricity & Gas Supply 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 3 0.0 37 Water Supply Sewerage & Drainage Services 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 0.0 41 General Construction 54 69 99 12 234 27 50.0 21 30.4 51 51.5 9 75.0 108 46.2 42 Construction Trade Services 117 321 84 9 531 72 61.5 153 47.7 84 100.0 18 100.0 327 61.6 45 Basic Material Wholesaling 15 9 18 6 48 9 60.0 0 0.0 12 66.7 0 0.0 21 43.8 46 Machinery & Motor Vehicle Wholesaling 12 9 24 3 48 9 75.0 3 33.3 24 100.0 3 100.0 39 81.3 47 Personal & Household Good Wholesaling 9 9 24 9 51 9 100.0 3 33.3 18 75.0 3 33.3 33 64.7 51 Food Retailing 39 75 141 6 261 3 7.7 30 40.0 69 48.9 9 100.0 111 42.5 52 Personal & Household Good Retailing 78 159 123 18 378 30 38.5 57 35.9 69 56.1 9 50.0 165 43.7 53 Motor Vehicle Retailing & Services 18 45 54 12 129 9 50.0 6 13.3 21 38.9 6 50.0 42 32.6 57 Accommodation Cafes & Restaurants 45 114 159 9 327 30 66.7 45 39.5 111 69.8 9 100.0 195 59.6 61 Road Transport 120 96 33 3 252 42 35.0 75 78.1 30 90.9 3 100.0 150 59.5 62 Rail Transport 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 63 Water Transport 0 15 3 0 18 0 0.0 9 60.0 6 100.0 3 0.0 18 100.0 64 Air & Space Transport 0 3 0 0 3 3 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3 100.0 65 Other Transport 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 66 Services to Transport 18 9 12 0 39 18 100.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 18 46.2 67 Storage 0 3 0 0 3 0 0.0 6 100.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 9 100.0 71 Communication Services 15 33 9 0 57 18 100.0 18 54.6 6 66.7 0 0.0 42 73.7 73 Finance 6 18 12 18 54 12 100.0 6 33.3 6 50.0 12 66.7 36 66.7 74 Insurance 57 18 63 3 141 42 73.7 9 50.0 6 9.5 0 0.0 57 40.4 75 Services to Finance & Insurance 18 27 30 18 93 21 100.0 12 44.4 9 30.0 0 0.0 42 45.2 77 Property Services 105 216 129 12 462 132 100.0 96 44.4 99 76.7 3 25.0 330 71.4 78 Business Services 171 306 123 9 609 117 68.4 108 35.3 78 63.4 15 100.0 318 52.2 84 Education 27 15 0 0 42 9 33.3 6 40.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 18 42.9 86 Health Services 27 84 45 3 159 24 88.9 48 57.1 45 100.0 3 100.0 120 75.5 87 Community Services 36 6 9 0 51 12 33.3 0 0.0 3 33.3 0 0.0 15 29.4 91 Motion Picture Radio & Television Services 15 0 0 0 15 6 40.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 9 60.0 92 Libraries Museums & the Arts 30 12 0 0 42 15 50.0 3 25.0 3 0.0 0 0.0 21 50.0 93 Sport & Recreation 24 18 6 0 48 3 12.5 6 33.3 0 0.0 0 0.0 9 18.8 95 Personal Services 60 90 24 3 177 9 15.0 60 66.7 12 50.0 0 0.0 81 45.8 Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics (2007e) Skills Tasmania 67 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 6.2. A snapshot of some important industries in the NW LGAs Tasmania’s economy is forecast to grow by 3.5% over 2007-08, a significant improvement from 2006-07. Whilst state level data are notoriously volatile, the economy appears to be growing strongly. This has been led by the consumer with Tasmania’s household consumption increasing 8.3% over the year to the June Quarter 2007 and consumer confidence is high. Employment is growing by 1.4% at the state level even against the backdrop of the tightening labour market. However, Tasmania is again losing population to the mainland as its growth rate has halved from 1.2% in 2004 to 0.6% in late 2007 (Rodrigues 2007). The pressure on wages is building across Tasmania to enable the state to compete in the national and increasingly globalised labour market. The Consumer Price Index for Hobart increased by 0.8% over the December quarter 2007, and by 2.9% over the year. Both these figures are slightly lower the national increase which was an average of 0.9% for the quarter and 3.0% over the year (Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations 2008). The following sub-sections will consider (in rank order) the NW coast’s seven most employment intensive industries (excluding education and training) 18; manufacturing, retail, health, agriculture, forestry and fishing, construction, accommodation, cafes and restaurants and transport. Their operating environment and developmental trends will determine the nature of labour demand and training required. Therefore, the following sections will, where possible, provide a brief situation report, list the drivers of training and review briefly the current trends or changes occurring in the industry: 19 6.2.1.Manufacturing Situation: The development of the manufacturing industry in the NW is a critical component to its future economic development and to the state’s export performance. Manufacturing businesses are concentrated in and around the major urban centres and regional towns, in particular, Burnie, Devonport, Wynyard and Smithton; Some larger businesses have a strategy of focusing their businesses in the NW and developing the local intellectual capital due to its quality and stability. Many smaller to medium businesses are struggling to compete for specialist skills; Manufacturing in the NW have 34% of their employees paid less than $599 per week, 53% paid $600-$1299 per week and 7% paid over $1300 per week; Drivers of training: The normal drivers of training demand in this industry group are: 18 The VET effort in this industry is not at a professional or paraprofessional level but at pre-entry level, largely for disadvantaged groups. Most education industry employees would be trained outside of the region. 19 It should be noted that the industry sector wages quoted in the following sub-sections are derived from the ABS Census 2006 which contains significant proportions of ‘Not Stated’ responses and thus these percentages quoted do not total 100%. Skills Tasmania 68 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o The acquiring or upgrading of trade skills clearly remains the main driver of training demand; o Specific skill or licence acquisition, for example, specialist (DNV) welding, working in confined spaces; o Quality assurance requirements; o Compliance with regulatory requirements, for example, occupational health and safety; employer duty of care; o Satisfying client requirements (contractual demand for qualified trades people); o Broadening the skill base of existing workers - particularly to deal with changing technology; o Rewarding individuals. Trends/changes: The industry is confident that the resources boom will continue for another five years at least; Several of the larger businesses have expansion plans and are facing an extremely tight labour market. In particular, there is a shortage of professional level engineers (no specific statistics are available to indicate type, but anecdotal evidence indicates that this is particularly mechanical and civil engineers). There is a trend away from an apprentice/technician base for these companies to a semi-skilled base with a narrower, task-specific set of skills. This is not cost driven but is a function of: o Change in the nature of the industry and the policy of parent companies; o Quality and supply of the skills available; o The high numbers of trades persons already in the company; o Change to a more process-based or production emphasis that comes with mature products within a business as opposed to the flexible, multi-skilling required to develop complex new products. 6.2.2.Health and community services Situation: The acute health care deliver hospital and ambulance services throughout Tasmania. Tasmania’s public hospitals and ambulance services are the front line for acute and complex health care for the Tasmanian community. Whilst the University of Tasmania provides graduate level training in the NW and provides an emphasis on rural health, the facility has a state-wide focus. Most of the professional level staff working in the region have been trained outside of the NW. The community health services deliver primary health, population health and community support services to people in community settings and includes primary health care, disability, mental health, alcohol and drug rehabilitation services and oral health services. Skills Tasmania 69 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Many of the paraprofessional and support workers in this industry have been trained in the VET sector (20% of employees have an advanced diploma or a diploma, and 35% have a certificate I-IV), in the health and social welfare fields or other areas such as business, clerical, community and personal service workers, machinery operators and labourers. However, a significant amount of specialist, commercial in-service training is occurring, both accredited and non-accredited; The NW community is ageing naturally and through an influx of older age groups as retirees or sea-changers and the rapid growth of this age cohort over the last 10 years will continue for many years. This will be a major challenge continuing over the next decade and beyond requiring services and facilities for those age groups, particularly in the health and social services field (Felmingham, Jackson & Zhang 2002; Jackson & Felmingham 2002). Other comments are: o The older age group are a homogeneous and stable group with over three quarters born in Tasmania (with only one in ten born overseas) and an average of 41 years residence in the area. Although 39.4% live alone, as a group they enjoy a high level of social support with 38.9% having at least daily face-to-face or phone contact with someone who provides support and 93.3% reporting at least one such contact a month. The group are quite mobile with 46.1% walking at least weekly and 99% having access to a car which they use at least weekly. They are low users of public transport and taxis. Although they report very modest incomes, 82.9% own their own homes and 90.2% rate their financial situation as ‘OK’ or better. They intend to stay in the region as their circumstances change (Rural Ageing Research Consortium 2005). o There are currently approximately two retirement villages, 16 nursing homes and five other types of aged care services operating in the NW. More facilities or expansions of current facilities are under way or planned in the near future; Drivers of training: Growing professionalisation of the care industry requiring professional development; Government regulation and due diligence requirements; Industrial relations; Technology and service quality changes; Ageing of the care staff themselves – many of them are older nurses who have chosen not to work in the hospital system. Trends/changes: Internationally, there have been a number of key trends that are revolutionising mental health care. Most important are: o The adoption of evidence-based practice as a paradigm in health care; o Strategic changes to system delivery and quality assurance brought about by the introduction of models of managed care (notably in the US and UK); Skills Tasmania 70 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o The emergence of the new concepts of recovery and cultural competence; and, o The empowerment and increasing activism of consumers and carers/families with a parallel increase in the need for accountability and transparency. The influence and, in some instances, the adoption of these trends in Australia and their implications for human resource capability is significant. These global changes have resulted in the development of innovative means of addressing human resource capability issues. Internet-based health support systems, such as clearinghouses of consumer information have become powerful tools overseas in consumer and carer education. Internationally, the training needs of consumers are increasingly being the subject of analysis and the focus of educational delivery as a means of promoting mental health and wellbeing and reducing the high cost of remediation of ill-health. Emerging global trends in the health, educational and management paradigms means that continuing professional development is of strategic importance to the future development of Health Services in Tasmania and in regions such as the NW (Bonney & Blackmore 2004). 6.2.3.Retail Situation: Retail premises are situated in the major urban centres however the concentration of larger businesses is in the two major regional cities, Burnie and Devonport. Retail businesses are increasingly dominated by small and micro businesses further from the major population centres; Retail quarterly turnover (chain volume measure) increased by 0.8% in Tasmania in the December quarter, and by 4.9% over the year. This compares to a national quarterly increase of 1.3% and an annual increase of 5.1% (Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations 2008); The retail industry pays relatively low wages. In the NW 71% employees earn less than $599 per week, 22% between $599-$1300 per week and 3% over $1300 per week; Drivers of training: The drivers for training in the retail sector have remained consistent. The major reasons are: o High staff turnover, particularly of junior employees; o Employment and training incentives; o Improving economic conditions in Tasmania including tourism growth. There is a widely recognised skills shortage; The target market for retail trainees continues to be school leavers although adults changing careers, women returning to work and existing employees have a huge potential to increase the numbers of people in formal training; It is expected that the drivers of training demand listed above will continue to be relevant for the foreseeable future; Skills Tasmania 71 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Trends/changes: Owner/managers and existing workers are also a target market, for higher level skills training; Flexible delivery of single modules and short courses to existing staff appears to be a need; The Reserve Bank of Australia currently undertaking a series of interest rate rises to cool consumer driven inflationary tendencies. 6.2.4.Agriculture forestry and fishing20 AGRICULTURE Situation: Agriculture, forestry and fishing outputs are fundamentally undifferentiated, commodities – that is, for example, peas from Tasmania cannot be distinguished from peas grown in South Africa, China or California and, as commodities, they are traded in bulk often being stored during overproduction to take advantage of later price rises; These commodities compete in global markets on price with other producers with lower cost structures of production; Buying power worldwide has become concentrated between a small number of very large, multinational supermarkets/wholesalers who are tending to compete on market segmentation, product differentiation, quality and customer service rather than price. They will source products from the cheapest source anywhere in the world; The value chains in these industries are generally poorly integrated and organised and suffer from dysfunctional relationships and information flows; Agriculture, forestry and fishing is a relatively lowly paid industry with 49% earning less than $599 per week, 38% earning $600 - $1300 per week and 7% more than $1300 per week. The standards of management within the industry are poor, there is a lack of career progression and the work is hard and unattractive. It is therefore being out-competed in the labour market; In the North West the major sector, production horticulture, is experiencing severe cost-price squeezes and the ageing cohort of farmers are moving to other low stress alternatives. The food processing sector, which is a major employer in Devonport and Smithton, is facing closure or a major downturn with accompanying restructuring as the major retail buyers turn to cheaper overseas sources of vegetables. Table 41 indicates on the Tasmanian Food Industry Scorecard, the value of the vegetable, dairy and fishing industries to the NW economy. 20 This ABS grouping is problematic because it is difficult to disaggregate, not the least because of small operator numbers in some areas result in privacy constraints on data analysis. Skills Tasmania 72 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 41: Tasmanian food & beverage scorecard 2004 – 05 Field Crops Food - farm gate Vale $m Livestock Dairy Fruit Vegetables Seafood Wine Food & Wine Confect'ry Total 2.6 249.7 185.2 67.9 164.3 299.0 14.8 983.6 983.6 138.0 332.8 185.2 67.9 164.3 299.0 14.8 1202.0 1202.0 Commodity Exports 0.2 6.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 7.0 Commodity Imports 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Net Interstate Commodity Exports 0.4 70.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.8 75.4 Net Interstate Commodity Imports 6.7 11.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 18.6 292.3 343.7 261.8 64.8 352.4 367.2 21.2 1703.4 400.0 2103.4 Overseas Food Exports 0.1 172.6 100.1 13.6 22.9 139.1 2.9 451.4 24.6 476.4 Overseas Food Imports 0.7 3.3 3.5 1.1 3.6 1.1 0.0 13.4 58.8 21.8 103.6 24.2 259.1 207.4 0.0 675.0 360.0 1035.0 20.0 1310.0 Total farm gate value Processed Food Value Net Interstate Food Exports Net Interstate Food Imports 7.0 58.7 58.7 75.4 18.6 15.7 29.5 52.9 2.2 43.9 0.0 24.7 65.4 218.6 Retail Sales 245.7 434.6 137.8 111.0 230.0 39.5 110.4 1308.9 279.0 Food Service Sales 213.5 75.8 2.8 25.6 70.7 87.3 97.9 573.5 Net Food Revenue 481.8 713.8 338.7 129.3 579.0 447.8 150.6 2840.5 346.0 3109.6 Gross Food Revenue 518.7 782.0 344.3 174.3 582.6 473.3 216.0 3091.1 404.6 3481.7 578.0 Source: DPIW’s Food Industry Scorecard by Griffiths (2007) Drivers of training: Essentially, farmers and horticulturalists undertake training if they see a benefit and the drivers of training demand is similar to other small businesses. The benefit may be one or combinations of the following factors: o Implementation of new technology: Where the introduction of new technology requires either generic or specific training; o New full time employee needing training: If a business decides to engage a new full time employee, the employer subsidies associated with Traineeships are a significant incentive to do so; o Problem solving: When specific problems arise, farmers and horticulturalists will frequently seek out appropriate short course training; o Exploiting opportunities: If an opportunity arises to buy an additional property, expand a contract, diversify, vertically integrate or change to producing a new product, they will frequently seek training for themselves or consider employing an additional person and seek subsidised training for that person; o Change in practices: A voluntary or forced change in business practices may also result in them seeking out training. However, it may also be more subtle such as the recognition of the growing sophistication of their industry and their need to gain new skills to remain competitive; Trends/changes: There will be far fewer Processing Vegetable farms; Corporate farming operations or large family farms will probably be at least 500 hectares or larger, professionally run with highly educated, specialised labour forces with quite a high level of reliance on specialised contracting and labour hire firms; The professional owner/managers of these larger farms will focus on managing relationships in the supply chain with suppliers and customers; They will compete as a supply chain with other supply chains around the world and share value across the chain; Skills Tasmania 73 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile The climate in Tasmania will be warmer which will bring new crop opportunities but also changes in water availability that will constrain some current commodity production and production methods; There will still be small farms, however, they will be highly specialised businesses producing high value, low volume niche products for local domestic or niche international markets; Businesses whatever their size will focus on ways to generate profit and increase margins NOT cost minimisation and develop business resilience through agility; Consumers will drive the marketplace more than ever before; Competition from imported processed vegetables will continue; Food security issues will be a major market driver; The role of farming in the economy will decline; The Tasmanian Processing Vegetable Industry will have better international relationships with similar geographic areas around the world to enhance continuity of supply to major global customers thereby improving our negotiating position; The level of government regulation will increase; The farms of 2015 will be able to identify opportunities to build value by applying new technology, seek out and evaluate alternatives and arrange to acquire it from Australia or overseas; Massive changes in technology will occur including in transport, packaging and distribution for the whole supply chain. Precision farming in 2015 will be the norm; Highly specialised labour and recognise that the skills and attitudes of the people they employ, whether as contractors or as employees, are critical to the efficiency of production and the agility of their business. FORESTRY 21 Mersey-Lyell has 463, 979 ha of state forest or 20.5% of the region. It also has 13.7% of its surface area classified as a conservation area and 22.9% as National Park (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2007). Woodchips o Situation: In recent years a downturn in hardwood woodchip exports from Tasmania has created considerable pressure on Tasmanian forest industry contractors. The Tasmanian forest contracting industry encompasses a wide range of operations but the bulk of operators are generally small family based businesses with quotas of less than 50,000 cubic metres per annum. Harvest contract volumes in Tasmania are based on pulpwood production with premiums paid for sawlogs. This is different to other states which generally set contractor volumes in terms of sawlogs. Contractor rates in Tasmania are generally negotiated annually based on performance. In many cases this has now occurred over a long period which means that base rates have not been adjusted beyond the movement in a range 21 Note that reporting generally does not distinguish regions for separate economic analysis. Further, Forestry Tasmania’s forestry districts do not match the LGAs in this report. Skills Tasmania 74 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile of cost indices. This tends to lock in current contractors. In other states and for plantation contractors it is more common to tender harvesting contracts typically for around 5 years and this could be expected to result in greater flexibility of contractors and their business operations. As would be expected, forest contractors report a range of profitability and rates of return depending on individual circumstances and business structures. The nature of forest contracting requires large investments in machinery so that fixed costs associated with interest repayments and the relative level of equity are key influences on contractor profitability and rate of return. For smaller operators with high gearing, a reduction in quota volumes means less revenue with relatively small changes in costs thereby reducing profitability and returns significantly. On the other hand a larger operator with lower gearing could be expected to have greater flexibility to park machinery and reorganise crews so that there is more chance of maintaining short term profitability and providing some protection for rates of return in the longer term o Trends/changes: Analysis of demand, supply and price trends in the hardwood woodchip market suggests that native forest hardwood woodchip exports are likely to face ongoing weakness in demand. Large increases in volumes of plantation hardwood pulpwood are a major source of competition for native hardwood woodchips. On the demand side Japanese consumption will at best remain relatively flat. Large increases in China’s consumption of pulp and paper and consequent expansion in domestic processing capacity will provide increased demand for hardwood woodchips. However, this will be moderated by imports of pulp from low cost producers, particularly in South America. Real price declines in hardwood woodchip exports are expected to continue and as plantation supplies increase it is expected that export price differentials between plantation and native hardwood woodchips will widen. While consuming country preferences for plantations may limit the ability of native hardwood woodchip exporters to maintain markets, the need to maintain the viability of plantation investments will act to moderate declines in prices for plantation woodchips. The development of a pulp mill in Tasmania would help mitigate some of the adverse market pressures for native forest woodchip exports by providing a new domestic market for Tasmanian pulpwood. However, some consolidation of the number of contractors will likely occur (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007; Paul 2007). Effect on training: The following skill shortages need to be addressed: o Machinery operators and mechanics; o Developing business management and planning skills of small contractors to assist structural adjustment and the development of more resilient businesses in the future (Paul 2007). FISHING 22 22 Situation: The State's three largest commercial fisheries are salmonids (Atlantic salmon and rainbow trout), abalone and rock lobster. While the total number employed in the industry has been steady at around 1,300 persons Note that statistics are not publicly available specifically for the North West region due to privacy concerns. Skills Tasmania 75 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile over the past four years, there has been a trend of decreasing employment in wild fisheries and increasing employment in aquaculture. Tasmania produces more farmed fish than the rest of Australia combined. The gross value of fisheries production in 2003-04 was $278.4 million, a decrease of 1.9 percent from 2002-03. The value of seafood exports from Tasmania to overseas destinations has declined significantly in recent years, precipitated by the outbreak of SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) in key Asian markets and the strength of the Australian dollar. The outbreak of SARS has instigated a sharp decline in the number of people using public places such as restaurants. This has been so severe that it has caused a large decline in the amount of abalone and crayfish consumed, with a resulting effect on price. From a fresh water perspective, short finned eels form the basis of commercial fishing. In the last financial year 6.7 tonnes of eel were caught compared to the previous annual catches of 45 tonnes. The decrease has been caused by a drop in price per kilo therefore not being viable for commercial fishermen. The product is largely exported as a frozen product to Europe and as live produce to Asia. Demand continues to expand. Green lip abalone fishery is divided into the Furneaux group, North West and King Island. Black lip fishery divided into two East and West zones with boundaries at Port Sorell and Whale Head. Tasmania produces 25% of global production of Abalone and is one of the state’s most important domestic and export industries. Tasmania is the main State in Australia where environmental conditions are suitable for Atlantic salmon with strict quarantine controls on the importation of salmonid products protecting the industry from all serious diseases. All marine farms require a licence and many leases are licensed to grow several species. There was a 31 percent increase in the number of licensed marine farming leases in Marine Farm Development Plan areas between 1997 and 2001. The Plan areas cover a total area of 466,111 ha, with 1.8 percent of this area being occupied by 185 marine farming leases. The production sector covers both hatchery operations and the on-growing of fish. There are six hatcheries in the State operated by six different companies. There are nine companies that have salmon farming operations in the State, concentrated mainly in the south-east and Macquarie Harbour. Most of the larger production companies also incorporate processing into their operations. Currently there are eight processors in the State. In the North West region: o There is a significant wild finfish industry with Petuna Seafoods being the largest producer; o The Far North West and King Island are also home to a significant catch of crayfish; o Oyster leases operate at Port Sorrell and in the far North West; o Stocks of the main fisheries are in good condition and harvest efficiency is optimal; o Only one salmonid producer is registered in the North West, Sevrup Fisheries Pty Ltd associated with the Petuna Seafoods company. Skills Tasmania 76 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile They conduct their own Ocean Trout, Atlantic Salmon and Saltwater Charr selective breeding program in a fresh water hatchery located at Cressy in Northern Tasmania but these are raised on the West Coast. Trends/changes: o Marine farming has rapidly expanded in Tasmania since the 1990s with Atlantic salmon and rainbow trout. Even though these fish are essentially freshwater fish, they are able to survive in salt water and Tasmanian conditions provide the right environment with a cold climate and minimal disease problems. Due to susceptibility of rainbow trout to stress-related diseases induced by high water temperatures, particularly in saline water, most farms are turning to Atlantic salmon with only a few rainbow trout farms remaining in Macquarie Harbour, which is brackish water. o Aquaculture production of abalone is expected to increase in Australia with Victoria and Western Australia leading the way. o In the medium term the value of production from wild fisheries will remain relatively static, restricted by the availability of the natural resource and the resultant applications of catch quotas. o Aquaculture over the past decade has grown rapidly and is forecast to continue its expansion; however this will be at a slower rate. The Tasmanian Salmonid Growers Association has forecast that salmonid production will increase by around 12 percent in 2005-06 compared to the previous year. o Marine (salt water) fishing licences vary according to the species to be caught, and at present new licences are not being issued for most commercial fisheries. Effect on training: o The industry is active in managing its own highly targeted training for deckhands and the ‘master’ series of licenses for boat owners and masters. The possible changes described above will not affect the public training system. 6.2.5.Construction Situation: The Tasmanian Building and Construction Industry Training Board estimates there are around 4,000 businesses currently operating in the industry. About 21 percent are in the North West. Building Approvals in Tasmania for December 2007 were 2.1% higher than they were in December last year. Nationally, building approvals decreased by 0.6% over the month, but were 6.9% higher than in December 2007 (Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations 2008); Skills Tasmania 77 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 42: National capital city/rural change in house prices Jan 2007 to Jan 2008 ACT Adelaide SA Country Brisbane QLD Country Darwin Northern Territory Hobart TAS Country Melbourne VIC Country Perth WA Country Sydney NSW Country Growth Rent Sales Median 10 Years Jan Rate Jan Amount Year Year to Year Value % pa Last Year Quarter 2008 Jan 2008 Change Jan 2008 Change $461,500 11.77% 14.32% 4.67% 4.69% $415 10.67% 5,535 15.48% $362,000 11.20% 20.20% 5.55% 4.25% $295 13.46% 22,473 10.98% $233,500 10.18% 12.43% 2.60% 4.47% $200 5.26% 7,260 10.28% $448,500 12.21% 23.30% 6.04% 4.07% $350 14.75% 54,280 23.42% $368,000 10.37% 11.15% 1.99% 4.54% $320 8.47% 51,183 13.77% $407,000 9.85% 16.05% 4.05% 5.13% $400 11.11% 2,077 7.56% $370,000 9.02% 14.63% 3.70% 5.36% $380 5.56% 2,836 6.14% $346,000 12.12% 8.90% 1.65% 4.52% $300 13.21% 2,615 11.85% $260,500 12.50% 16.07% 5.60% 4.41% $220 15.79% 4,805 17.00% $473,500 11.19% 21.87% 4.39% 3.86% $350 25.00% 50,755 13.75% $265,500 10.15% 10.60% 2.43% 4.71% $240 9.09% 41,316 11.33% $510,500 14.20% 4.62% 1.12% 3.37% $330 22.22% 30,891 6.04% $383,500 12.87% 13.67% 4.53% 3.60% $265 10.42% 8,675 3.43% $586,500 7.91% 8.65% 1.26% 4.01% $450 25.00% 43,042 18.22% $319,500 9.10% 3.08% 0.06% 4.29% $265 8.16% 44,857 9.07% Source: Residex Residential Property Newsletter, Edwards (2008). The construction industry in the NW has 38% employees paid less than $599 per week, 51% paid $600 - $1300 per week and 9% paid more than $1300 per week; Drivers of training: Business management training and increasing the understanding of workforce development amongst the construction business community. Other needs are similar to many small business in that it needs to include an understanding of succession planning, the re skilling and up skilling of existing workers and the role the training system can play in workforce development. The training system needs to be recognised as a part of the process of solving the skills shortage problems (Skills Tasmania 2007); Trends/changes: Recent housing prices have eased with concerns about the US sub-prime problems. Despite this median house prices in Hobart in February 2008 were $346 thousand, a rise over the previous year of 8.9%. Rural Tasmania increased a massive 16% in the last year or 5.6% in the January quarter; There is now a significant shortage of housing stock state-wide with low residential vacancy rates; The industry appears to be facing a severe shortage of not just skills but of people and a Tasmanian Building and Construction Industry Training Board survey in 2005 found that many applicants had unsuitable skills; Skills Tasmania 78 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 6.2.6.Tourism Figure 14: Percentage of NW tourism businesses in each tourism category Situation: The NW industry is Accomm characterised by the large 62% number of small to micro businesses. Such enterprises frequently only employ part time or casual staff and may even be sporadic in their operation Attraction as suits the needs of the 23% owner/operator. As such, Tour Hire they are difficult to 7% 8% coordinate and, typical of many small businesses, either have little recognition of the need for training or have little capacity to be able to afford the cost of training or the backfilling of staff who attend training; The accommodation and food services industry in the NW has 78% employees paid less than $599 per week, 17% paid $600 - $1300 per week and less than 2% paid more than $1300 per week. As indicated earlier, this is largely due to the heavy industry reliance on part time and casual employees. The industry has a high turnover of staff due to the low pay, the nature of the hours and working conditions and often poor management. Figure 15 identifies the numbers of tourism businesses by type and location. Drivers of training: The OPCET Tourism and Hospitality Training demand Profile made the point that tourism training needs to follow tourism developments. Currently in the NW the following projects are planned: o Corinna - current development is valued at $7m. Construction of a new hotel, restaurant and meeting rooms is expected to commence in late 2007; o The Hellyer’s Road Distillery is located next to the Betta Milk factory in Burnie will include a tasting and interpretive centre, a 50-seat restaurant, a retail centre, offices and a viewing and tasting area overlooking the factory; o The Hellyer’s Road Distillery opened its $8.5 million distillery and visitor centre in September 2006. The project has created 25 jobs and will generate indirect employment for another 30 people; Other important and related drivers of training include: o The increase in visitor numbers; o The need to ensure a high quality of product/service and customer service to be able to compete in an increasingly sophisticated marketplace; o Compliance with quality assurance and government regulations. Trends/changes: Skills Tasmania 79 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Total international visitors to Tasmania in 2007 increased by nine per cent to 157,000, representing a market share of three per cent (up from 2.9 per cent in 2006). Our share of international leisure visitors is now 3.2 per cent (up slightly from 3.1 per cent in 2006). The total number of nights spent in Tasmania increased by 14 per cent to 3.323 million nights with our share of all nights increasing marginally to 2.1 per cent (leisure night share remained steady at 1.6 per cent) with visitors staying an average 21.1 nights, an increase of two nights over 2006. Expenditure climbed 16 per cent to $231 million, an increase of 16 per cent over the previous year and representing a steady market share of 1.6 per cent. Note in Figure 15 that the tourism sites are organised (along the foot of the graph) in the four categories of tourism: accommodation, attractions, hire services and tour services. The figure shows largely that tourism businesses are largely located around either the major towns or significant tourism attractions or features. 6.2.7.Transport industry Situation: Tasmania is well supplied with transport infrastructure: o An extensive road and bridge network (State roads valued at $4 billion); o 867km railway network; o Four major deepwater ports; and o Four major regional airports. Road transport is the dominant response to the Tasmanian land freight task. Eighty five per cent of persons employed in the industry are in road transport and are comprised of 2 900 employees, 300 employers and 700 self employed workers; In 2002-03, 54 million tonnes were moved by road compared to a little over 3 million tonnes by rail (11% employed persons); Four sea ports, Devonport, Burnie, Bell Bay (Launceston) and Hobart carry 99% of the sea freight entering and exiting the State while Hobart and Launceston airports carry most of the air freight; Warehousing and storage employs about 4% of persons in the industry; Specifically, in 2005 31 per cent of the land transport and distribution workforce is aged between 45 and 55 and 19 per cent is aged over 55. These proportions are significantly greater than for all industries, where the proportions were 24 per cent and 15 per cent respectively; Skills Tasmania 80 0 Aberdeen Arthur River Barrington Black River Boat Harbour Burnie Corinna Cradle Mountain Crayfish Creek Currie Devonport Forth Grassy Gunns Plains Hawley Beach Latrobe Lileah Loongana Lower Barrington Marrawah Moina Mole Creek Moltema Moriarty Naracoopa Natone Nietta Penguin Port Sorell Riana Rocky Cape Roger River Shearwater Sheffield Sisters Beach Smithton Stanley Staverton Sulphur Creek Three Hummock Island Ulverstone Waratah West Kentish West Ulverstone Wilmot Wynyard Boat Harbour Burnie Chudleigh Cradle Mountain Currie Deloraine Devonport Edith Creek Gunns Plains Hawley Beach Latrobe Loorana Lower Barrington Mawbanna Mole Creek Natone Northdown Penguin Port Sorell Promised Land Railton Riana Shearwater Sheffield Smithton Spreyton Stanley Thirlstane Ulverstone Waratah West Kentish West Ridgley Wilmot Wynyard Arthur River Burnie Currie Devonport Wynyard Arthur River Boat Harbour Burnie Caveside Corinna Cradle Mountain Currie Devonport Grassy Kayena Kimberley Latrobe Marrawah Smithton Spreyton Stanley Staverton Ulverstone Wynyard Count at Each Location Figure 15: North West Tourism Businesses by Category and Location (2006) Accomm Skills Tasmania NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Attraction Hire Tour Tourism Service Category 81 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 7.2.6. Transport industry Cont’d… Conversely, 19 per cent of employed persons in ‘all industries’ are aged 2534 years, while only 12 per cent of employed persons in the land transport and distribution industry are aged 25-34. Industry consultation reveals that much training undertaken within this industry is in the form of short courses and not always through the vocational education and training system. This is due to industry need to develop particular skill areas important for job tasks and/or employer needs rather than the focus on whole qualifications. As such, training demand is linked to skill sets within qualifications rather than whole qualifications. Burnie, Launceston and Devonport were the most significant ports. Burnie and Launceston (through its Bell Bay exports) are the most internationally oriented; These tables also indicate the reason for the dominance of road transport in the industry profile as freight is shifted to the North and South population centres from the NW. Several schemes support the Tasmanian transport infrastructure and reduce cost disadvantages incurred from conducting business in Tasmania due to its isolated location. These include the Tasmanian Freight Equalisation Scheme and the Bass Strait Passenger Vehicle Equalisation Scheme. The Australian Government’s Bass Strait Passenger Vehicle Equalisation Scheme is an important boost to the state’s tourism. Econometric modelling indicates the Scheme increased motor vehicle passenger numbers on the Melbourne–Devonport service by 60 500 in 2005–06. This is an increase of 24.1 per cent on the estimated level of traffic without the Scheme—a proportion that has fallen since the introduction of the Scheme. Approximately 1.44 million adult passengers travelled by air and sea across Bass Strait in 2005–06 (Bureau of Transport and Regional Economics 2007b); Drivers of training: In 2006, skills shortages were reported for: o Bus and Coach Drivers (North West) o Heavy Freight Vehicle Drivers (State-wide) o Logistic Management for Junior and Middle Level Managers (Statewide) o Administrative, management and marketing workers (State-wide) o Truck drivers (State-wide) o Electrical tradespersons (State-wide) o Diesel mechanics (State-wide) o Track workers (State-wide) (Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2006a) Industry consultation identified the following as the most important factors driving training demand for the Tasmanian land transport and distribution industry: Skills Tasmania 82 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile o The current and continuing increase in the transport task. o Workforce attrition – due to: o Normal turnover of staff due to retirement of older workers and entry of new workers. This is a major driver due to the ageing of the workforce. The industry needs to attract new entrants who are old enough to be eligible to meet licensing requirements and over 25 years of age to meet insurance requirements. o Generally high rates of staff turnover, requiring ongoing training availability. o Increases in regulatory compliance requirements in the areas of security, occupational health and safety and fatigue management (Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2006a). Trends/changes: The increasing freight and passenger transport task, with national forecasts predicting that non bulk freight volume will almost double over the next twenty years and the total passenger task will increase by 40 per cent. The industry is considered to have an ‘image’ problem, and is not seen as an ‘attractive’ industry. Land transport and distribution industry is facing issues of how to attract and retain young workers. The ageing of the workforce and the emerging need to engage and train an increasing number of new workers as older employees exit the industry. Regulatory compliance obligations are increasing, arising from duty of care, chain of responsibility and occupational health and safety issues. As a result, organisations are struggling with meeting the operational training and upskilling requirements. The uncertainty of the long term sustainability of the rail sector. If cutbacks occur, there will be major implications for the road sector in terms of the quantity of the road freight tasks, employment and skill demands. Training and development options are flexible enough to meet the needs of a casual workforce, particularly for bus and coach drivers, taxi drivers. Administration and logistics training needs to be made accessible for junior and middle level managers. While enrolment in training package qualifications has increased since 2002, completion rates have decreased. This may be due to existing workers enrolling in qualifications with the aim of updating particular skill areas (Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2006a). Skills Tasmania 83 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 6.3. Conclusions Manufacturing is probably the major growth sector in the NW with significant investments in progress that is likely to continue for another 5 years or so with the resources boom. There is a strong commitment by some of the larger businesses to the NW and development is currently being constrained to some extent by the lack of suitable staff as well as qualified staff. There is a trend towards graduate level staff brought about by an emphasis on process work and structure of the industry but that may be offset by the ageing of existing paraprofessional and trades people; Retail is dominated by small businesses but there are also a growing number of larger chain outlets. Business failures are significant and size of turnover is a guide to resilience. There is an on-going need to increase the business skills of the sector; The health and community services industry will grow due to an ageing of the community and professionalise as the emphasis on primary (preventative) health care expands. The industry has a significant VET level workforce amongst its support and ancillary staff and due to their ageing will continue to require significant VET output; Agriculture and its related food processing sector are currently struggling due to producing commodities in a global market where competition is on price. The industry lags behind the western world in its integration and level of strategic chainoriented business skills. The industry requires training of managers as well as staff in the larger companies in new skill sets as well as training of produce suppliers and input professionals. In part this is being addressed by the current Targeting Skill Needs in Regions Program being auspiced under the Cradle Coast Authority. The current level of training effort appears adequate overall and may need review to ensure its focus; The construction boom, driven by industry expansion and domestic housing is continuing although may cool due to interest rate rises. There is a significant shortage of housing stock which is the subject of a State Government intervention of $60 million that will ensure a continuing demand for trade level skills in that industry; Tourism in the NW is largely small and micro enterprise based with a low commitment or capacity for training. The industry is characterised by a high turnover of staff due to low pay, poor conditions, unattractive work and often poor management. However, the industry continues to grow in turnover and needs to also continue to grow in innovation, customer service and overall professionalism. Therefore, continued public support of all levels of training is required although some review and rationalisation to ensure effectiveness may be warranted; Transport is a major focus of the NW due to the one port policy and having the main freight and passenger entry points for the state. Freight is predicted to double by 2020. This as well the Bell Bay Pulp Mill will affect the demand for transport workers. This will be exacerbated by the ageing of the current workforce. As a major industry, their needs must be addressed; Skills Tasmania 84 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 7. Infrastructure Infrastructure within a state or region can either constrain or facilitate business and therefore community development. New projects usually involve significant financial expenditure and, even if there are few implications for future employment involved in the maintenance of the new infrastructure, the employment generated by the projects themselves are often very significant. Therefore, both the projects as well as the infrastructure have implications for training demand. The following sections will review some of the publicly available information about both public and private infrastructure developments in the NW region and the state where those may have significant impact on regional employment and skills availability. 7.1. Energy infrastructure Situation: Electricity infrastructure in Tasmania is a significant sector for the economy and vital to all business activity. Tasmanian residential electricity consumption remains the highest in Australia due to the climate and the significance of electricity for heating. There are currently three publicly owned entities: Hydro Tasmania: Generation (Government Business Enterprise) Transend: Transmission (State-owned company) Aurora: Distribution / Retail (State-owned company) In 2005-06 the three entities employed 2,059 people state-wide and provided returns to the state of over $108 million. Most of Tasmania's electricity is generated using hydroelectric generators. Tasmania also has Australia's largest wind farm, Woolnorth in the far NW, which has a capacity of around 65MW. The electricity supply on King Island is dependent on more expensive thermal and wind sources for electricity generation. Asset ownership and responsibility for supply rests with Hydro Tasmania, which has contracted Aurora to operate the system and provide retail services. The performance level of the King Island power systems has improved on 200506 levels, although it has not reached the relatively reliable performance of 2004-05. Forecasts indicate that generation capacity will remain well above demand until the year 2017, with an adequate energy supply for the medium term. Trends/changes: From a generation perspective, the continued drought has brought challenges to Hydro Tasmania. To maintain security of supply and storages, Hydro Tasmania has been forced to import electricity via Basslink whilst also continue to invest in its ageing assets and pursue new investment opportunities. Investment in wind generation continues to be positive. Roaring 40s, Hydro Tasmania’s joint venture with China Light and Power, is active in Tasmania and Australia, in addition to undertaking major projects throughout Asia. The second stage of the Woolnorth Wind Farm on Tasmania’s North West Coast was completed in May this year, and after applying for an electricity generation licence in July this year, the Regulator determined to issue a generation licence to Musselroe Wind Farm Pty Ltd on 2 August 2007 for a wind farm on the North East coast of Tasmania (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007; Office of the Tasmanian Energy Regulator 2007). Drivers of training: Skills Tasmania 85 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Impending requirement to operate in a competitive electricity market SCADA control systems Fibre optic technology Electrical protection systems Gas retail Entry into the National Electricity Market will bring with it cultural/philosophy changes in the way that work is undertaken. Technological change Early retirement (retiring at 55), age profiles. A strong training culture prevalent within Hydro Tasmania (ranging from entry level to post graduate university training), symbolised by the organisation’s investigation into the viability of becoming an RTO Implications for training The continuing success of wind power development will have on-going implications for the demand for persons with engineering and management skills. 7.2. Telecommunications and Internet access Situation: Tasmania enjoys the same standard of advanced telecommunications infrastructure as that found elsewhere in Australia. The Tasmanian telecommunications network has digital capability at every network site. While telecommunications are primarily an Australian Government responsibility, successive governments in Tasmania have sought to provide improved access to telecommunications infrastructure and services. These developments provide opportunities, better delivery of government services and improved access for regional Tasmania. Basslink and the Tasmanian Natural Gas Project provided the opportunity for investment in telecommunications facilities in Tasmania by laying fibre optic cable. Tasmania’s infrastructure includes the following services: All Tasmanian network sites have digital capability and are interconnected by digital transmission; The state has a fibre optic cable across Bass Strait that provides high-speed voice and data links; The optic fibre cable backbone spans 420km from George Town to Hobart and across Port Latta on the North West Coast; and Reliable, high-speed data services using frame relay, ATM (Asynchronous Transfer Mode), ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) and compatible technologies are available. Accelerated growth in the information and communications technology industries in Tasmania has been enhanced by government programs such as Intelligent Island, and full service venture partners like In-tellinc. These initiatives present valuable opportunities in the State's Information and Communications Technology industries. Trends/changes: Skills Tasmania 86 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile The Information and Communications Technology industry in Tasmania includes both the ‘core’ industry, and the much broader ‘IT-user’ industry. The core ICT industry in Tasmania remains small, volatile and highly aware of the short cycle of skill redundancy. In contrast, the ‘IT-user’ industry, whose main engagement with IT is as a driver or enabler, is a growing consumer of both IT product and IT skilled workers. This group is by far the larger in terms of both need and growth potential. Tasmanian SMEs, like their mainland counterparts, are embracing IT as part of their everyday business functions, but to varying degrees of sophistication. The demand for ICT-skilled workers in these Tasmanian ‘user’ industries is difficult to quantify. However, demand from this segment appears to be strong, and growing, as enterprises in all industries discover the power of ICT as a platform for growth, and require sound advice and assistance on business application for productivity increases (Office of Postcompulsory Education and Training 2005). The National Centre for Social and Economic Modelling (NATSEM), University of Canberra found that small country town usage was well below the national average for home computers (32% compared with 42% nationally) and the Internet (25% compared with 37% nationally). In contrast, people living out of town in rural areas (the rural balance), enjoyed higher home computer usage (41%) - only marginally less that the national average. Internet usage in these areas was 32%. At a more local level, Tables 44 and 45 indicate the level of computer and internet use by NW Tasmanians: Only about a third of NW Tasmanians use a computer at home. Generally those in the major centres have the highest use although King Island is somewhat of a anomaly, possibly because of community perceptions of isolation; This pattern extends to the internet where the most isolated are amongst the highest users. However, overall usage levels are quite low. In urban areas, teenagers led the way in Internet usage (60%) and home computer usage (70%). Amongst the adult population, high income earners, those with higher education levels and those in professional occupations had the highest rates of home computer and Internet use. Table 43: Computer use at home by LGA North West No % Yes % NS % Total Burnie 62.4 34.5 3.1 18,145 Central Coast 60.5 35.6 3.9 19,938 Circular Head 64.0 33.6 2.4 7,702 Devonport 63.4 33.5 3.2 23,030 Kentish 60.4 34.6 5.0 5,407 King Island 62.9 35.0 2.1 1,687 Latrobe 63.1 34.8 2.2 7,845 Waratah/Wynyard 62.0 35.6 2.4 13,083 Total 62.5 34.3 3.1 102,352 Tasmania(c) 59.3 37.4 3.3 456,653 Source: ABS, 2001. 23 http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/2f762f95845417aeca25706c00834efa/82DC39AFCE971773CA25726 4000CAB6B?opendocument 23 The latest data available. Skills Tasmania 87 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 44: Internet use in Tasmanian NW Local Government Areas Burnie Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Island Latrobe War/Wyn Total Tasmania No % 65.9 % 65.5 % 71 % 66.9 % 66.7 % 66.7 % 68.5 % 66.9 % 67 % 62.3 At home 13.9 14.9 11.9 13.5 15.3 14.7 14.1 14.6 13.9 14.6 At work 4.7 3.6 3.3 4.2 2.2 3.4 3.8 3.4 3.9 5.5 Elsewhere 5.7 4.9 5.9 5.5 5.7 7.5 5 6 5.6 5.7 Other 5.8 6.5 4.4 6 4.7 4.5 5.6 5.7 5.7 7.9 Total 30.1 29.9 25.4 29.2 27.9 30.2 28.6 29.7 29.1 33.7 ns Total 4 4.6 3.6 3.9 5.5 3.1 3 3.3 3.9 4 18,145 19,938 7,702 23,030 5,407 1,686 7,845 13,083 102,351 456,654 Source: ABS, 2001. http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/2f762f95845417aeca25706c00834efa/FBBA8B61BECDF194CA25726 4000CAD5B?opendocument Drivers of training: New businesses New technology Industry Growth Worker Recruitment and Retention Regulatory Compliance (Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2005) Implications for training: ICT training should continue to be a priority training area both for new industry entrants as well as customised training for skills upgrading. People from Indigenous or non-English speaking backgrounds, the elderly, and those not in the labour force were more likely to be unconnected. The study highlighted the need for access to the Internet in places other than the home or at work. Australians not in the work force, Indigenous Australians, children and those in disadvantaged households often accessed the Internet in 'other' places like public libraries and schools. 7.3. Roads and transport infrastructure24 Situation: Roads are the major conduits through which rural and urban communities in the Region deliver products to market, receive goods and services and access community and commercial services. Accessibility has been a historical issue for the NW coast since the perceived discrimination in the mid-19th century against the early yeoman farmer settlers of the region by a colonial government administration more focused on the eastern half of Tasmania. The road network consists of 3 922 km of local roads (2 120 km sealed and 1 800 km unsealed) and 1 151 km of State Road network. In terms of length, the Region contains 30% of Tasmania’s local rural roads. 24 This section relies heavily on the Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources & Cradle Coast Authority 2007, Cradle coast integrated transport strategy, Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources, State of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Skills Tasmania 88 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Tasmania has a relatively extensive road infrastructure network for its population, with 15 persons per kilometre of road. The Cradle Coast Region has a higher than State average, with 21 persons/km. The Tasmanian Government funds State-classified roads from normal revenue sources. Local government funds road works via its own rates base, and through tied and untied Commonwealth and State grants. Local government receives additional funding through initiatives such as the Commonwealth funded Roads to Recovery Programme. The topographically driven ‘ribbon’ development of settlement and its secondary feeder road systems in the hinterlands around the major towns means that both the cost to local government for maintenance as well as the level of maintenance activity is high. The state strategy regarding the management of its ports and freight entry into the state combined with the passenger interstate road freight traffic entering the Tasmanian road system at Devonport mean that the NW road system has very high levels of activity compared to its population base. For example, the NW has two thirds of the state’s truck movements occurring on its roads. Key characteristics of the road network in the Region include: The Bass Highway along the North West Coast is the primary element of the network. Sections of the Bass Highway have been rerouted to bypass towns. A large number of north-south local roads, run along valley edges and connect onto the Bass Highway. The primary connections to the West Coast towns are: from Burnie – Murchison Highway and Guilford/Hampshire Main Road; and - from Hobart – Lyell Highway. The only major inland east-west connection is the Cradle Mountain Developmental Road and the Mole Creek Main Road which link Deloraine to the Murchison Highway. In the Mersey-Lyell Region, the local government areas (LGAs) of Devonport, Burnie and the Central Coast had the highest proportion of employed persons who travelled to work by car, 74.0%, 73.5% and 71.7% respectively. Thus, the region is highly dependant on road transport. Key features of the Region’s public passenger transport system are: Regular urban bus services centred on Burnie and Devonport; A dense network of student bus services (the Region has 143 school bus contracts); Regular long distance bus services linking major towns and cities; Small, specialised community transport services; and Taxis, predominantly located in major towns and cities. The Tasmanian Government operates a range of programmes to reduce transport disadvantage and facilitate mobility for individuals. The provision of core passenger bus services in urban and regional areas, subsidisation of transport costs for eligible travellers, and specific-need schemes such as the introduction of wheelchair accessible taxis and community transport funded through the Health and Community Care programme, provide key examples. Rail has played a declining role in Tasmania’s transport task since the 1950s. This decline has been matched by substantial public investment in road infrastructure, changes in transport technologies and patterns, and a lack of leadership regarding the Skills Tasmania 89 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile function of rail in meeting Tasmania’s transport task. Nevertheless, rail still plays a significant role within Tasmania’s transport system, moving approximately 25% of the total freight task based on Net Tonne Kilometres and 50% of the non-urban net tonne kilometres of freight. This is expected to increase as part of the State’s overall growth in the transport task. Some of the key areas for future rail investment include: improvements to the mainline track to reduce long-term maintenance costs; strategic infrastructure investments to facilitate competition for new cargoes; and road-to-rail facilities, which will benefit both rail and road transport providers (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources & Cradle Coast Authority 2007). Trends/changes: The construction and later the operation of the Bell Bay Pulp Mill will have initially an effect on the local supply of labour and in the medium term an increase in labour requirements involved in the transport of NW timber to the mill. The latter event will also affect impact to increase the level of maintenance on NW roads. Currently, there are some groups in the community who are disadvantaged in terms of accessibility and are of concern to regional and state planners. These are: Adults who do not have access to a car; Persons aged over 60 years; Persons on a disability pension; Adults on a low income; Adults not in the labour force; Young people below 17 years; and Persons enrolled in an educational institution. Tasmania’s aging population will increase the proportion of the population who are transport disadvantaged. While many older people will continue to drive, a proportion, particularly as they age will become reliant on public transport and assistance from family and friends. Drivers of training: The placement and scale of transport infrastructure projects; The site and scale of maintenance; Increases or changes in public transport initiatives; Employee turnover within the private industry; The effect of other business developments; for example the construction and operation of the Bell Bay Pulp Mill; The ageing of the current workforce will require new entrants to be trained for the industry. Implications for training The North West appears to be developing into a major state centre for transport and may require consideration of the re-focusing and expansion of any current training provision into the region. The impact of developments on the construction and maintenance of roads infrastructure, particularly at a local government level may well require monitoring for a potential increase in customised training and single module delivery. Skills Tasmania 90 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 7.4. Water infrastructure Situation: The supply of water industry services; including bulk water supply, reticulation and wastewater treatment and disposal; is the responsibility of the bulk water authorities and local councils. Local government is responsible for all town sewerage schemes including sewage and wastewater management. A number of industrial and commercial users pump waste directly into council sewerage systems (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007). Cradle Coast Water collects treats and supplies bulk drinking water to six councils on the North West Coast of Tasmania, the Cradle Coast Region. The six councils, Circular Head, Waratah-Wynyard, Central Coast, Devonport, Latrobe and Kentish, distribute the water to their ratepayers. The key activities are: Acquire the raw water from catchment areas; Treat the raw water; Store and deliver treated water in bulk to customers; Implement quality programs and manage the process; Maintain the asset base in an efficient and effective manner; Monitor community and industry needs to expand. Trends/changes: The major trends influencing the Tasmanian water industry in terms of industry activity, employment and training were identified as follows: High levels of staff turnover, particularly in treatment plants and laboratories; Regional councils are dealing with a number of issues associated with remoteness: Councils are struggling to recruit staff; o Difficulties are being experienced in accessing training for water industry operators, and o There is little professional support available for regional water industry operators. The forecast decline in numbers and the ageing of the workforce has direct implications for training. Existing workers will need upskilling in a broader range of areas; The planning of water infrastructure projects may have implications for training. The only project currently undergoing planning is the Forth River Irrigation Scheme which will utilise water from Hydro storages. It is currently undergoing development in 2007-08. Locally, Cradle Coast Water has identified the following trends: Social: Total consumption has increased by 16.8%. Although consumption increased water quality complaints decreased on the previous year and customer interruptions were sustained at low levels; Environmental: Although Environmental incidents moved upwards slightly on the previous year no incidents occurred that required a report under section 32 of the Environmental Management & Pollution Control Act; Skills Tasmania 91 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Economic: Generally all unit costs were reduced due to higher throughput levels. However pumping costs were high due to increased power charges experienced during the year in contrast with 2006 (MacCormick 2007). Drivers of training: Workforce attrition, due to the high staff turnover characterising the industry, requiring ongoing training for new and existing workers; Changing environmental and regulatory requirements, particularly in the areas of national drinking water guidelines, and the new Commonwealth water quality management plan requirements; Training for the water industry is primarily industry funded. Given time and financial constraints, employers are most likely to direct their staff toward training in particular areas (skill sets) to fill gaps (Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2006b). Implications for training Hobart Water is registered as an RTO to deliver some training in the area. The critical issue for the training system is the small numbers of persons needing training. There is a continuing small but important demand for: Water supply operators Water treatment plant operators Waste water treatment plant operators Water and Sewerage Labourers Plumbers 7.5. Port infrastructure Situation: The Tasmanian Ports Corporation Pty Ltd (Tasports) is a registered, private company fully owned by the Tasmanian Government. The Tasmanian Ports Corporation facilitates 99% of Tasmania’s interstate and international trade. Tasmania is very much an export state; with export freight usually twice that of import. Exports represent about 65% of Tasmania’s freight trade. All of the major sea ports facilitate the freight of goods in and out of the state, and Devonport and Hobart also accommodate significant numbers of passenger ships. Generally, each port has its specialties: Hobart - Cruise ships, Navy vessels, Antarctic supply vessels, fertilizers, metals Bell Bay (Launceston) – Minerals, fuels, timber, timber products, food Devonport – Interstate ferries, wheat grain, cement, fertilizers, fuels Burnie – bulk minerals, timber, timber products Triabunna – Woodchips, timber products Tasmanian freight statistics to December 2007 were down 2.5% for imports and up 5.5% for exports on the previous year. Burnie was up across the board whilst Devonport was down on exports by 2% (Tasports 2008). Tasports has two principal objectives: To facilitate trade for the benefit of Tasmania; and Skills Tasmania 92 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile To operate its activities in accordance with sound commercial practice. The recent amalgamation of ports and the ‘one port’ approach has resulted in improvements to coordination and better access to funding. Tasports now has adopted a collaborative strategy of facilitating solutions for larger clients and expanding the company through acquisition or merger to achieve the capabilities required to deliver that for customers. Table 45: Cargo loaded and unloaded by Tasmanian ports, 2005–06 Tasmanian Port Coastal International Exports Total Aust Loaded Unloaded Imports Ranking 496,774 1,347,253 1,844,027 36 Burnie 1,535,970 1,057,910 1,283,381 152,180 4,029,441 22 Devonport 1,833,539 1,273,105 10,200 38,662 3,155,506 27 908,708 184,520 177,331 1,270,559 38 0 71 3,325,823 26 1,000,920 2,261,702 32 Spring Bay 815,305 815,305 48 Other Ports 6,019 6,019 74 Tonnes Bell Bay Hobart King Island Launceston 9,939 Port Latta 1,260,782 Tasmania 4,630,291 3,249,662 3,093,987 221,897 6,394,332 590,070 14,864,355 Source: (Bureau of Transport and Regional Economics 2007a) Table 46: Ship activity at Tasmanian ports, 2005–06 Tasmanian Port All ships involved in All ships involved in Voyages by all ships Port calls by all ships international shipping coastal and involved in involved in coastal (no.) international shipping international shipping and international (no.) (no.) shipping (no.) Bell Bay 1 3 1 4 Burnie 20 63 25 494 Devonport 1 36 1 961 Hobart 42 91 51 196 Launceston 56 127 77 378 Port Latta 14 41 15 48 170 2,083 King Island 1 Stanley 1 1 Tasmania 134 363 1 Source: (Bureau of Transport and Regional Economics 2007a) Drivers of training: The level of ambient economic activity and access to finance in-so-far as they affect the level of company expansion; Change within the company; Staff turnover. Trends/changes: In May 2007, Tasports announced a merger with P&O and Auto & General Stevedores (POAG) that will give it mainland resources that allow the company to better facilitate total solutions for its clients. Tasports Board has also recently incorporated a ‘succession planning’ strategy into its activities that will result in a focus on training up its internal staff for roles within the Skills Tasmania 93 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile company. Part of this is also a recommitment to apprentices and trainees (more on this Mike after an interview with the HR Director). Implications for training Tasports will require trainees and apprentices as well as other training solutions over the next year. Tasports are adopting a collaborative approach with key clients and stakeholders and regard Skills Tasmania as a stakeholder. Their needs will need to be monitored by Skills Tasmania. 7.6. Waste Situation: Tasmania’s dispersed regional population historically led to growth of landfill sites which are now being decreased with a majority of waste being managed through waste transfer stations. Of the 105 landfills operative in 1990, approximately 37 of these were in the North West NRM region. The number of historic landfills is not known accurately, but there are quite a number in the Devonport area alone. However, after recent rationalisation, the existing landfills are at Lobster Creek, Port Latta, Parenna, Dulverton and Burnie. Some twelve Transfer Stations act as feeder points for these facilities. Councils are responsible for managing individual waste transfer stations and landfill sites. The Department of Tourism, Arts and Environment is responsible for: Management, transport and disposal of controlled waste through a number of statutory instruments, regulation and policy; Permitting and regulating landfills receiving more than 100t of waste pa; and Implementing the Landfill Sustainability Guide 2004. Trends/changes: Some potential issues associated with landfill sites, both during operation and after closure, include rehabilitation of the landfill site, and, pollution of surrounding soils, groundwater, and surface waters. Pollution of groundwater and surface waters by liquid or solid wastes results in elevated chemical components in these water sources, which is derived from the breakdown and leaching of the waste. Small amounts of landfill leachate can therefore pollute large amounts of water. Remediation of these water sources, especially groundwater, is a longterm project that can be quite costly. It is therefore more cost effective to ensure preventative measures are adopted during the design stage of the landfill (N.K. 2004). A Regional Waste Management Strategy has been identified as a need to coordinate policy, set strategic direction and assist in the development and management of key assets such as landfills. Burnie City Council developed a waste management strategy in 2006 as did the Cradle Coast Authority in 2007 (Blue Environment Pty Ltd 2007). Waste management issues are managed by environmental management officers in local government. Nationally persons with these qualifications are in very short supply. This produces a relatively high turnover of staff and significant difficulties in attracting suitably qualified staff to the region. Drivers of training: Short supply and high turnover of environmental managers within the region and state; Skills Tasmania 94 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Compliance with regulations; Technological change; Major infrastructure development projects. Implications for training None beyond current strategies and priorities. 7.7. Private sector investments and infrastructure projects in planning Private sector investment, increased by 1.2% in the September 2007 quarter and dwelling investment increased by 1.9% in the same period (and 7% in the year). Private sector investment has grown at an average annual rate of 15.1% since 2000-01. This has accounted for in part the employment growth since April 2002. In the year to March 2007, residential building approvals have increased by 9.4% in Tasmania compared with a decline of 2.3% nationally. Business investment in Tasmania has also been very strong, with growth higher than the national rate for a large part of the last 5 years. This growth reflects improved investment opportunities in Tasmania with an increased capacity of businesses in Tasmania to fund projects as a result of improved profitability and low interest rates over the period. Investment opportunities were high in energyrelated projects, tourism and mining and mineral processing industries. Since April 2002, employment in Tasmania has risen by 29,900 or 15.1%, compared to 14% nationally. In December 2007, 230,000 people were employed in Tasmania, the highest number on record. Regional employment figures also showed an increase of 2.5% in the southern region, and a slight easing in the north and north-west. The main employment growth industries in Tasmania were: accommodation, cafes and restaurants (up 3,300 persons); government, administration and defence (up 1,800 persons); education (up 1,500 persons) and transport and storage (up 1,300 persons). The Tasmanian Treasury forecasts that 6000 new jobs will be created in 2007-08, with an employment growth of 2.25%. The unemployment rate for December 2007 stands at 5.4%. The year average unemployment rate in 2006-07 is expected to be 6%. The Treasury forecast for 2007-08 year average unemployment rate is 5.5%. The 2007 REDI map shows that: Tasmania currently has $2.2 billion worth of projects either under construction or committed to; Of this, $1.2 billion worth of projects are under construction a net increase of around $338.6 million on the 2006 figure; There are 143 development projects across the State committed to or under construction, as opposed to 141 in 2006; and The number of developments committed to rose from 74 in 2006 to 82 in 2007 (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007). Table 46 also shows that the NW coast has $107 million worth of investment projects committed in addition to $37 million worth that are currently under way. Skills Tasmania 95 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 47: North West Coast Investment Projects NW Projects Value Projects under construction o Creative paper redevelopment $3.5 million o Devonport eastern shore development $5 million o University of Tasmania Cradle Coast Campus expansion $6.5 million o Umina Park Nursing Home expansion $9 million o Wynyard silica plant $10 million o Waterfront Gardens Residential development – Stage 1 $3 million Projects committed o Burnie waterfront development – stage 2 $2 million o Ulverstone Showground and Wharf redevelopment $6 million o Australian Technical College NW $3 million o Sassafras & Wesley Vale Irrigation Scheme $12 million o Sewerage and water infrastructure $2.8 million o Port Sorell aged care facility $11 million o Old Spencer Nursing Home retirement units $N/A o Zen Development, Penguin $6 million o Port Sorell Commercial Centre $15 million o Woolworths Burnie redevelopment $10 million o Leven River bridges and approaches $6.8 million o Ridgley Main Road $2.4 million o Sisters Hills road redevelopment $30 million o Stoney Rise Transport Depot $2 million Projects under consideration o Wynyard waterfront redevelopment $20 million o Eugene Reserve Bowls Complex $3 million o Arthur Support School relocation $3 million o Lakeside Road Retirement Village $$5 million o Camdale Industrial Site N/A o Fenton St Gated Residential Units $8 million o Old Tioxide subdivision $12 million o Penguin Outlook $10 million o Tier Views subdivision $4 million o Waterfront Gardens Residential development – Stage 2 $15 million o Motors New Showroom $4.5 million Source: REDI Map and (KPMG & EMRS 2006) Skills Tasmania 96 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 7.8. Conclusions The fortunes of the wind power industry and implications from the renewal of sections of the ageing HEC power infrastructure within the NW have the biggest potential impact on the demand for training and need to be monitored; Telecommunications infrastructure in the NW has few implications for training alone apart from the maintenance of current effort. However, the continued penetration of its use in business and homes in the region is a strategic issue. Generally, home computer and internet use is low compared to national averages. NW strategies to build awareness of the utility of the internet at home and in business as well as the skills in its use, particularly amongst the older generation, is important; Road maintenance and improvement and issues of accessibility will remain important issues on the NW coast as they have been historically. The NW coast is a major centre for transport because of the port policy. The construction of the Bell Bay Pulp Mill will affect the labour supply, the demand for transport skills as well as the maintenance of the roads that will deteriorate more quickly with the mill-based log transport. The current configuration of training delivery should be reviewed to ensure its appropriateness in the light of the size of the NW industry; Water infrastructure is a mature sector however the current emphasis of the Tasmanian Government on ‘drought-proofing’ Tasmania will have an impact on new construction and modification of the current infrastructure, particularly for local councils, water authorities and the contractors that service them and so should be monitored. In the short term, the only project to get underway will be the Forth River Irrigation Scheme; Port infrastructure is largely serviced by the training system through the construction, engineering and transport areas. Tasports has adopted a more proactive, expansionary approach to business development and this needs to be monitored for probable impacts on the training system; Waste infrastructure and its management largely impact the training system through the need for environmental managers in local government, of which there is a nation-wide shortage. There is little change in the need for lower end of training that currently services the industry, however at the paraprofessional and professional levels there is a significant need; Private sector investments in large projects are very sensitive to both Tasmanian and the wider global economic environment. The high levels of business confidence and the buoyant outlook have resulted in a large number of large infrastructure projects entering the planning and commitment phase. These will continue to drive training needs in the construction and engineering fields. Skills Tasmania 97 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 8. The environment 8.1. Current environmental issues Research on farms in north-west Tasmania shows that on steeper cropping land (i.e. over 18 degrees slope) significant reduction in yield (8-15%) occurred as a result of water erosion (Cotching et al. 2002). These were not apparent on lower slope eroded areas. Studies on river condition indicators in north-west Tasmania provide markers of the extent of erosion, and its in-stream consequences. Simms and Cotching (2000) found that erosion from intensively cropped catchments in north-west Tasmania is resulting in off-site environmental degradation such as high stream turbidity levels and suspended sediment loads. Measurements were made at both catchment and paddock scales with the highest turbidity values recorded in run-off from fallowed paddocks. Severe to extreme sheet25 and rill26 erosion occurs in the vegetable cropping areas of the northern coast (e.g. between Devonport and Wynyard). Erosion risk occurs broadly across both public and private lands in Tasmania particularly in the intensively farmed areas in the north-west are shown as areas susceptible to erosion (Resource Planning and Development Commission 2006). 8.2. The impact of climate change and other emerging issues Tasmania sits in a region where different global models tend to disagree about the sign of the change in rainfall, wind speed and pressure. The models do, however, agree that temperatures will increase, although at a rate lower than the global average. This tends to indicate that this region of the world will have somewhat reduced climate change compared to the global average. There will be some warming and some change in rainfall patterns and winds, but there is so far no reason to expect a major change of climate in Tasmania in the next 35 years. Annual rainfall in the NE of the state is projected to become drier by 70 to 140 mm (10-20%). Annual rainfall in catchments of importance to Hydro Tasmania is projected to increase by 7-11% except in the South Esk catchment, which decreases by around 8%. On a seasonal basis, there are indications of increased winter and early spring rainfall in all catchments (1-2 mm per year in each of those months, or an increase over 35 years of 35-70 mm). Insignificant trends in annual maximum temperatures (less than 0.5 degree) in all catchments except South Esk, where the projected warming by 2040 is 0.33°C. The scenario trend in annual minimum temperatures is more definite, with all areas of the state projected to warm by up to 0.5°C, with the maximum values occurring in the Derwent Valley. In the Hydro catchments, there are generally warmer minimum temperatures in winter and late spring/early summer, with a magnitude of about 1°C by 2040. Averaged over all months, all catchments exhibit an increase of minimum temperatures of about 0.3°C by 2040. 25 Relatively even erosion of a layer of soil without channel formation; generally takes place on sloping land. A pattern of erosion often occurring, with sheet erosion, in recently cultivated soils following heavy rains, identified as a series of channels or rills up to 30 cm deep. 26 Skills Tasmania 98 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Annual potential evaporation in the scenario is projected to increase in all areas except the west coast and adjacent highlands where small decreases are indicated. Scenario wind speeds are projected to increase everywhere, but by a small amount, typically less than 0.01ms-1 per year. The main projection as far as wind direction is concerned is an increase everywhere in the westerly component, with a maximum along the north coast (McIntosh, Pook & McGregor 2005). The physical (geomorphic) effects of ongoing sea-level rise and climate change on Tasmanian coasts over future decades are likely to include (but are not limited to): Increased flooding of low-lying coastal areas during storm surges; Erosion and landwards recession of soft sandy shorelines, particularly where these are backed by low-lying plains of soft unconsolidated sediments; Increased mobility of coastal sand dunes, triggered by sandy shore erosion and potentially by climate stress on dune vegetation cover; Modification of soft low-lying muddy estuarine and deltaic shores; Acceleration of existing progressive erosion of soft clayey-gravely shorelines; Increased slumping of steep landslip-prone shorelines; Accelerated rock fall, cliff-collapse and retreat of vertical or near-vertical bedrock sea cliffs; Rising coastal groundwater tables and increased penetration of salt water wedges into coastal ground waters (Sharples 2006). North West Local Governments will be amongst the first to feel the significant impacts within the region. The Local Government Association of Tasmania (LGAT) (2007) conducted a survey of Tasmanian local government has rated their views on the most relevant impacts of climate change as being: Sea level rise; Less rainfall; Reduced river flows; Coastal erosion; More extreme storm events. These impacts hold implications for coastal zone management, water storage and provision as well as broader land-use planning. Councils also have a role to play in managing emergency services and responses to storm events and risk assessment strategies will need to take account of potential climate change impacts. Surprisingly, only 14% councils had an appropriate environmental management system in place to cope with it and only 23% had done any form of risk assessment. Over 80% councils indicated they wanted assistance with these functions and rated education within their top three priorities for assistance. The report went on to state: There is a need for on-going education on climate change impacts at the council and community level. Whilst the exact role for councils in this process is unclear, greater community understanding is likely to enhance local governments’ capacity to act on climate change issues (p. 18). Skills Tasmania 99 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 8.3. Conclusions The State Government’s Draft Climate Change Strategy for Tasmania (2006) has a limited involvement for VET in climate change. The Government plans to: o “promot(e) education of young Tasmanians in sustainable and safe energy use through Aurora Energy, Transend Networks and Hydro Tasmania’s Hands On Energy Discovery Centre (p. 31)” o “Pursue further opportunities within the formal education sector and in the wider community to build understanding of greenhouse issues, and promote active engagement in greenhouse gas abatement (p. 31)” However, it can be imputed from this brief review of the evidence that at the very least local governments require education and training support. Continuing close liaison by Skills Tasmania with LGAT state-wide and with the Cradle Coast Authority in the NW will be required to monitor the specifics of this need, however it is likely to have medium term implications for training at paraprofessional to Certificate II levels and include customised training from time to time. Skills Tasmania 100 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 9. Key Drivers of Development The major influences on recent investment decisions are much the same across the regions; The level of Tasmanian demand; The economic climate; The change in competitiveness; Microeconomic influences such as a decision to take a new strategic direction or to develop a new product or service. But outside these, the influences varied quite considerably from one region to another. These included visitor numbers, changes in the Tasmanian population, technological change and the Australian demand for goods and services. In the NW population and technological change are the most often cited reasons for investment. Table 48: North West Tasmanian regional strengths and weaknesses Region Strengths Scenic beauty, Wilderness Cheaper rents and land Pro active councils Safe area Challenges Remote, inclement Extended trading hours High freight costs Cost of services Poor local roads Suggested Opportunities Tourism potential Unlock land in reserves The Tarkine Expand NW University Plant high value tree species on farms. Source: Department of Economic Development’s REDI Plan by KPMG & EMRS (2006) However, the growth of the Tasmanian economy has brought with it a number of supply side constraints that are cost-related or are matters of resource availability. Amongst these the most often mentioned constraints were the pressures that have been placed on the labour market. This was the most often cited constraint by NW businesses. These have taken a variety of forms and have been expressed by respondents in a variety of ways. The cost of labour has been identified as the single biggest constraint standing in the way of new investment. Closely related to this have been the availability of skilled labour and the more general availability of labour. Related is the availability of appropriate training and industrial relations issues. Other issues that have been included are transport costs and freight arrangements and for some parts of the State infrastructure, including telecommunications services, water and electricity supplies. For NW business: Manufacturing -, the lack of skilled workers, particularly tradespeople, was identified as a major issue; Retail - The boom in retail sector was fuelled by population and tourism growth, and the limits being reached in respect to re-borrowing of equity arising from property revaluations, has reached an end. Competition from larger national chain retailers also looms large for many smaller retailers and in turn threatens local communities. Agriculture, forestry and fishing - Many respondents recognised the potential strengths of agriculture in Tasmania, notwithstanding the challenges, having the capability of producing the highest quality produce in a clean environment; a stable population with a sound work culture and opportunities for growth, a reasonable transport infrastructure and good proximity to port facilities. Issues raised included competition between forestry and dairying for available land Skills Tasmania 101 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile (posing a threat to local communities), for vegetables there were challenges from imports but also many opportunities, threats to the honey industry from forestry and the harm the WET tax is doing to the wine industry. Construction - Despite the period’s high market demand in this industry, in the last few years, respondents still saw that there was a range of areas where reform and change could drive further investment in the future. The fairness of Government tendering processes, shortages of skilled labour, overregulation of the industry and lack of compliance were raised as issues to be addressed. Accommodation cafes and restaurants - Many respondents maintained that a key driver of tourist demand is effective government marketing of Tasmania as a tourist destination. At a regional level, many respondents considered Local Government had a greater role to play to try to attract visitors to more isolated locations, along with development of local infrastructure to support tourism such as improved quality of road systems, tourist facilities such as boat ramps/jetties and water supply. Transport and storage - Business costs loom large as a major influence on respondents in the transport and storage industry. Chief amongst these costs are rising fuel costs Other costs to be identified were; wages, insurance, accreditation expenses, commissions paid to wholesalers, payroll tax and vehicle registration fees. Government policies and processes also featured prominently, with specific issues such as public transport policy and more specifically, coach industry deregulation, compliance with regulations and too much red tape. Market demand, especially driven by visitor numbers was seen by many businesses as a key influence (KPMG & EMRS 2006). Conclusions: The growth of the Tasmanian economy has brought with it a number of supply side constraints that are cost-related or are matters of resource availability. Amongst these the most often mentioned constraints were the pressures that have been placed on the labour market. These have taken a variety of forms and have been expressed by respondents in a variety of ways. The cost of labour has been identified as the single biggest constraint standing in the way of new investment. Closely related to this have been the availability of skilled labour and the more general availability of labour. Related is the availability of appropriate training and industrial relations issues. Other issues that have been included are transport costs and freight arrangements and for some parts of the State infrastructure, including telecommunications services, water and electricity supplies. Skills Tasmania 102 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 10. Growth projections 10.1. Population Growth For 2008 and the near-term, population growth is expected to be 0.6% for Tasmania however, since the last Census the NW Region has almost half the state with 0.34% and so regional growth over the next five years can be expected to be quite low; a mere 2,729 people. While Tasmania's population has grown since 2001, an implication of the State’s declining fertility rate and ageing population is that at some time in the future Tasmania will move from its current situation of natural increase, where births exceed deaths, to natural decline, where deaths exceed births. At that time, unless net migration gains from interstate and overseas are sufficient to offset the loss from natural decrease, Tasmania will return to negative population growth (Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007). Add to this the combination of lower fertility rates and longer life spans leading to an increase in the average age of Tasmania's population. The expected result is that there will be a significant change in the structure of Tasmania's population over the next few decades (Jackson & Kippen 2001; Jackson & Thompson 2002). Most Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) population projections suggest Tasmania's total population will begin to decline between 2015 and 2025. The population is projected to peak at 504,500 people in 2023 or 2024, and then decrease to 453,000 people in 2051. This is 6% fewer people than in 2004. Earlier ABS scenarios projected a decline in the North Western population by about 4% from 2011-2021 (Australian Bureau of Statistics 1999b). The implications of this for training are: Greater competition between employers for increasingly scarce skills will result in: o Earlier engagement of young people before and during their training through the use of ‘cadetship’ style arrangements; o A greater need for part time and on-the-job modes of learning. With the increased mobility of labour, skilled labour will be in strong demand, especially when the Tasmanian and national economies are in a strong growth phase; Tasmania has been facing skills shortages in several industries and occupations, particularly in the construction and metal fabrication industries; The problem becomes more acute for certain classes of labour where ageing is more rapid than the rest of the workforce. Current examples include aged care workers and farm managers; Tasmanian employers will be challenged by the accelerating retirement of older workers and providing greater flexibility to encourage older workers to stay engaged in the workforce; The need to match labour supply with demand is likely to lead to increasing demand for training opportunities for mature-aged and other workers, especially while the current strong economic conditions continue; As the mix of age groups changes within the population, so the mix of courses and the nature of delivery strategies will also need to change to cater for the needs of older people as well as younger cohorts that provide services to older age groups. Skills Tasmania 103 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 10.2. Change in the labour force The key changes of interest to VET will be in the industry and occupational mix. Analysis from the Monash Economic Forecasts for Tasmania as a whole appears in Tables 49 and 50. They project (in rank order from highest to lowest): The highest growth in employment to 2015 will occur in education, business services, health/community, construction, personal services, retail, cultural services and hotels (sic); At the VET level, growth in associate professional and intermediate production and transport occupations will be the highest; Table 49: Employment growth by ANZSIC industry, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) ANZIC % % % % % % % % Total level 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 % Ave % Code Industry 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 2014-5 change change N00 Education 16.944 0.21 3.25 4.06 4.13 3.74 0.83 1.66 1.22 20.67 2.38 L00 Business srvcs 18.573 0.67 4.44 2.66 2 1.41 0.69 1.01 0.24 13.83 1.63 O00 Health/community 25.943 1.91 3.05 2.52 1.66 1 0.4 0.87 1.62 13.78 1.63 E00 Construction 16.538 5.93 11.04 2.5 -3.24 -0.72 1.72 -1.16 -4.09 11.68 1.39 Q00 Personal srvcs etc 9.649 1.7 2.64 1.76 1.41 1.04 0.43 0.46 0.78 10.68 1.28 G00 Retail trade 32.655 1.93 2.07 0.77 1.66 1.21 0.8 0.73 0.67 10.28 1.23 P00 Cultural/rec srvcs 6.309 0.51 1.95 0.94 1.53 0.61 0.46 0.59 0.47 7.25 0.88 H00 Hotels etc 14.38 0.3 0.9 0.26 1.41 1.07 0.93 1.07 0.96 7.12 0.86 K00 Finance/insurance 5.508 0.45 2.04 0.83 0.84 0.35 0.56 0.52 0.54 6.29 0.77 M00 Gov.admin/defence 13.985 0.84 2.97 1.93 -0.35 0.34 0.56 -0.5 0.44 6.35 0.77 F00 Wholesale trade 8.616 0.73 5.29 1.71 0.51 -0.2 -0.35 -0.2 -1.27 6.25 0.76 I00 Transport/storage 9.815 -1.35 1.58 1.09 1 0.91 0.56 0.81 0.43 5.12 0.63 A00 Agriculture etc 14.374 -6.06 1.63 2.64 2.37 0.7 2.2 1.13 -0.52 3.87 0.48 B00 Mining 2.545 1.77 -3.31 1.27 -0.48 1.19 0.99 0.38 1.33 3.07 0.38 D00 Utilities 2.934 -0.37 1.51 -0.21 0.31 -1.08 1.28 1.15 0.47 3.06 0.38 C00 Manufacturing 21.852 -5.96 0.9 1.55 0.53 0.91 2.5 1.5 -0.37 1.32 0.16 J00 Communications 2.533 -2.69 -0.47 -1.93 -0.54 -2.42 0.35 0.34 0.07 -7.12 -0.92 999 All industries 223.155 0.17 3.05 1.82 1.09 0.95 0.97 0.68 0.16 9.21 1.11 Source: Compiled from the Monash economic forecasts Giesecke, Meagher & Horridge (2007) Table 50: Employment growth by ASCO occupation, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) % level % % % % % % % 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 Total Ave % % Code Occupation 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 2014-5 change change 1 Managers and Administrators 16.015 1.37 6.14 5.11 3.82 2.43 3.2 2.76 2 30.08 3.34 2 Professionals 39.479 0.79 3.35 2.58 2 1.43 0.73 0.83 0.84 13.22 1.56 3 Associate Professionals 29.176 1.09 3.22 2.06 1.79 1.58 1.43 1.29 0.91 14.15 1.67 4 Tradespersons etc 30.721 0.13 3.96 1.2 -1.27 0.32 1.2 -0.04 -1.52 3.94 0.48 5 Advanced Clerical/Service 6.022 -0.72 2.47 0.65 -0.59 -0.08 0 -0.51 -1.37 -0.19 -0.02 6 Interm. Clerical/Sales/Srvce 37.467 0.34 2.52 1.59 1.35 0.87 0.75 0.71 0.69 9.13 1.1 7 Interm. Production/Transport 21.053 -0.95 2.68 1.67 0.78 0.87 0.8 0.58 -0.47 6.08 0.74 8 Elemen. Clerical/Sales/Srvce 22.154 -0.05 1.36 0.33 0.99 0.54 0.38 0.27 -0.07 3.79 0.47 9 Labourers etc 21.058 -1.79 1.79 0.77 0.01 -0.38 -0.12 -0.58 -1.3 -1.63 -0.21 0 All occupations 223.144 0.17 3.05 1.82 1.09 0.95 0.97 0.68 0.16 9.22 1.11 Source: Compiled from the Monash economic forecasts Giesecke, Meagher & Horridge (2007) Skills Tasmania 104 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 51: Employment growth by ASCED qualification field, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) % ASCED level % % % % % % % 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 Total Ave % % Code ASCED field 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 2014-5 change change 100 Natural sciences 4.544 1.98 5.25 4.41 3.82 3.28 2.68 2.71 2.3 29.65 3.3 200 Information technology 3.024 4.27 7.48 5.87 4.95 4.69 4.37 4.1 3.32 46.34 4.87 300 Engineering 24.884 0.02 3.84 2.37 1.08 1.4 1.8 1.41 0.37 12.92 1.53 400 Architecture, building 6.718 2.25 5.83 1.63 -2 0.98 1.88 0.13 -1.32 9.56 1.15 500 Agriculture, environment 3.525 2.3 6.22 5.16 4.17 3.32 3.51 3.1 2.33 34.31 3.76 600 Health 14.796 1.51 3.24 2.49 1.89 1.2 1.06 1.05 1.49 14.78 1.74 700 Education 7.999 1.1 3.98 3.91 3.67 3.11 1.94 2.03 2.01 23.88 2.71 800 Management and commerce 18.685 3.25 6.01 4.75 4.16 3.86 3.61 3.41 2.86 36.69 3.98 900 Society and culture 14.992 3 5.54 4.67 4.13 3.57 3.26 3.17 3.18 34.89 3.81 1000 Creative arts 4.506 2.91 5.96 4.93 4.44 4.12 3.83 3.69 3.12 38.13 4.12 1100 Hospitality, personal 7.013 1.65 3.75 2.87 3.07 2.56 2.56 2.37 2.01 22.84 2.6 1200 Mixed field programmes 112.271 -1.51 1.25 -0.05 -0.71 -0.98 -0.91 -1.3 -1.98 -6.06 -0.78 9998 No educational attainment 0.198 1.58 4.97 3.13 1.75 2.2 2.47 1.64 0.65 19.87 2.29 9999 All fields 223.155 0.17 3.05 1.82 1.09 0.95 0.97 0.68 0.16 9.21 1.11 Source: Compiled from the Monash economic forecasts Giesecke, Meagher & Horridge (2007) Table 52: Employment growth by ASCED attainment level, Tasmania 2006-7 to 2014-15 ('000 persons) % level % % % % % % % Total Ave % % 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 Code ASCED level 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-0 2010-1 2011-2 2012-3 2013-4 2014-5 change change QL1 Post-graduate degree 7.033 3.55 6.31 5.3 4.57 4.03 3.39 3.32 2.99 38.71 4.18 QL2 Graduate diploma 6.349 2.65 5.34 4.75 4.14 3.65 3.1 3.04 2.99 33.78 3.71 QL3 Bachelor degree 32.672 2.1 4.84 3.89 3.28 2.85 2.47 2.43 2.22 26.75 3.01 QL4 Diploma 19.697 2.17 4.98 3.99 3.43 3.13 3 2.82 2.47 29.11 3.25 QL5 Certificate III or IV 42.936 1.16 4.35 2.67 1.4 1.79 2.14 1.6 0.83 17.05 1.99 QL6 Certificate I or II 2.067 2.02 5.53 4.52 3.88 3.62 3.65 3.27 2.56 32.97 3.63 QL7 Year 12 and below 112.204 -1.52 1.25 -0.05 -0.71 -0.98 -0.91 -1.3 -1.99 -6.09 -0.78 QL8 No ed attainment 0.198 1.58 4.97 3.13 1.75 2.2 2.47 1.64 0.65 19.87 2.29 QL9 Dummy category 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9999 All qualification levels 223.155 0.17 3.05 1.82 1.09 0.95 0.97 0.68 0.16 9.21 1.11 Source: Compiled from the Monash economic forecasts Giesecke, Meagher & Horridge (2007) Table 51 forecasts the growth in qualification fields for the state (in rank order from highest to lowest): Information technology Creative arts Management and commerce Society and culture Agriculture, environment Natural sciences Education Hospitality, personal Table 52 indicates the likely state growth in qualification attainment levels. This supports the Skills Tasmania data and anecdotal evidence that there is and will be a continuing trends towards higher levels of attainment. Skills Tasmania 105 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 11. A gap analysis of the VET provision for the North West The effect of skill shortages on the economy is not well defined and in many sectors it means decreased output and the delay or cancellation of new projects. Skill shortages are most common at times of high economic growth and low unemployment. However, they can occur in regions of high unemployment where there is a mismatch between the skills available and the skills demanded. Skills Tasmania defines a ‘skill shortage’ to be either: The labour market condition in which there is a demand for skills but not people with those skills available locally for immediate employment at the pay and conditions on offer; The workforce condition whereby existing employees do not possess the skills required by the work processes they are employed to undertake. or The Tasmanian Government Department of Economic Development conducted a survey of Tasmanian businesses to develop an understanding of regional investment and infrastructure issues. The availability of skilled labour was identified by 34 per cent of all respondents as an important constraint, behind labour costs at 48 per cent and the economic climate at 46 per cent of respondents (Bureau of Transport and Regional Economics 2006). 11.1. Limitations on this analysis The matching of ABS data on actual employment in occupations in industries with fields of study with Skills Tasmania data on VET system output in terms of qualifications is difficult due to: Different standards are used by the ABS (ANZCO (Occupation), ASCED (Field of Study) and ANZIC (Industry)) whilst the Australian Vocational Education and Training Management Information Statistical Standard (AVETMISS) which uses (ANZCO (Occupation) and its own ‘Field of Education’ definition. This makes direct comparison of data very difficult and lacking in validity; The highly variable employment outcomes that result from completing a qualification. For example, a person completing a management or accounting qualification may become a supervisor in a function in a manufacturing plant or an aquaculture graduate may be employed in a retail store. Others may choose to travel, leave the region permanently or progress onto some marginally related or unrelated field of education. This means that analysts cannot draw direct conclusions about the industry impact of training a given number of people in a particular field of study. For these reasons, this analysis will draw only very general conclusions from the preceding data meant as a guide to further discussions by the Skills Tasmania Board. 11.2. Analysis of existing public and private provision based within the region Table 53 shows the VET output in the region 2002-06 and the priorities of the system over that period. Some 55% of the output was in the top five categories; business and finance, tourism, agriculture, aquaculture, fishing, food & beverages, IT and general education. Skills Tasmania 106 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 53: Output of the NW VET system (2002-06) IOG Description Business and Financial Services Total Enrolments IOG Share of Total Enrolments No. Trainees % Trainees per IOG 13,568 20.1% 2,854 21% Tourism 6,950 10.3% 1,282 18% Agriculture, Aquaculture, Fishing, Food and Beverages 5,921 8.8% 1,084 18% IT, Communications & Advanced Technology 5,777 8.6% 94 2% General education & personal development 5,226 7.8% 75 1% Building and Construction 4,003 5.9% 1,080 27% Health and Community Services 3,918 5.8% 517 13% Automotive 3,220 4.8% 1,208 38% Engineering and Manufacturing 2,734 4.1% 631 23% Mining and Mineral Processing 1,977 2.9% 381 19% Retail and wholesale sales and service 1,920 2.8% 1,147 60% Energy Industries 1,698 2.5% 617 36% Transport distribution & storage 1,493 2.2% 654 44% Arts 1,433 2.1% 37 3% Forestry, Timber and Paper 1,371 2.0% 144 11% Textiles, Clothing and Footwear 1,269 1.9% 322 25% Generic 1,152 1.7% Government Services (include. Water supply) 1,103 1.6% 88 8% Marine Manufacturing 797 1.2% 674 85% Hairdressing & personal services 734 1.1% 333 45% Environmental Industries 445 0.7% 17 4% Sport and Recreation 303 0.4% 40 13% Other manufacturing (incl. Furniture) 296 0.4% 136 46% Printing 114 0.2% 22 19% 13,437 20% Grand Total 67,422 0% Note: IOG - Industry Output Group Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 This needs to be compared to the ABS data appearing in Table 54 (overleaf) which shows the persons with qualifications by industry employed and their field of study; it should be noted that this includes higher education as well. However, across the industries, approximately 75% to 85% of the qualified people have VET qualifications. Unfortunately high levels of inadequate description and ‘not applicable’ in the ABS data make this appear problematic. However, the latter classification encompasses those without qualifications and some of these may also be found in the inadequately described group as well. Notwithstanding, when qualitatively correlating these two sources, the following comments can be made: Business and financial services is one of the foundational fields of education for private and public sector organisations. The VET data indicates that 20% of output is in this field whilst the ABS indicates that only 4% are qualified in this field and of these 10.6% are employed in retail, 7.5% in public administration, 7.4% in manufacturing, 6.1% in health and 6% professional/scientific services; nearly 38% of the total; Tourism broadly covers the ABS FOS that encompasses ‘food, hospitality and personal services’. Table 52 indicates that 10.3% of the output is in this field. The ABS data in Table 53 indicates that the Accommodation and food services Skills Tasmania 107 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Table 54: Industry of employment by field of study of NW Tasmanian employees (2006) Industry of Employment NAD Natural & Physical Sciences Not stated 122 0 0.0% Not applicable 6,660 158 32.7% Agriculture, Forestry & Fishing 148 25 5.2% Mining 21 17 3.5% Manufacturing 280 57 11.8% Electricity, Gas, Water & Waste Services 14 3 0.6% Construction 111 6 1.2% Wholesale Trade 69 22 4.6% Retail Trade 215 8 1.7% Accommodation & Food Services 135 3 0.6% Transport, Postal & Warehousing 123 5 1.0% Information Media & Telecommunications 10 3 0.6% Financial & Insurance Services 11 8 1.7% Rental, Hiring & Real Estate Services 20 0 0.0% Professional, Scientific & Tech Services 29 26 5.4% Administrative & Support Services 65 11 2.3% Public Administration & Safety 78 18 3.7% Education & Training 69 68 14.1% Health Care & Social Assistance 161 41 8.5% Arts & Recreation Services 6 4 0.8% Other Services 57 5 1.0% Inadequately described 56 3 0.6% Total industry 8,491 483 % Fields of Study 0% Information Engineering & Architecture & Agriculture, Health Education Technology Related Building Environmental Technologies & Related Studies 3 0.6% 30 0.4% 9 0.4% 5 0.4% 5 0.2% 8 0.3% 155 32.8% 1,903 27.8% 656 27.6% 205 18.3% 882 30.0% 978 33.0% 8 1.7% 305 4.5% 61 2.6% 357 31.8% 62 2.1% 47 1.6% 0 0.0% 178 2.6% 25 1.1% 3 0.3% 7 0.2% 0 0.0% 34 7.2% 1,530 22.3% 267 11.2% 110 9.8% 38 1.3% 16 0.5% 0 0.0% 161 2.3% 20 0.8% 4 0.4% 0 0.0% 3 0.1% 14 3.0% 487 7.1% 868 36.5% 39 3.5% 28 1.0% 9 0.3% 7 1.5% 292 4.3% 41 1.7% 63 5.6% 13 0.4% 5 0.2% 39 8.2% 275 4.0% 84 3.5% 46 4.1% 108 3.7% 45 1.5% 8 1.7% 69 1.0% 21 0.9% 9 0.8% 23 0.8% 20 0.7% 17 3.6% 354 5.2% 76 3.2% 25 2.2% 18 0.6% 10 0.3% 10 2.1% 34 0.5% 3 0.1% 4 0.4% 0 0.0% 7 0.2% 5 1.1% 13 0.2% 5 0.2% 9 0.8% 3 0.1% 5 0.2% 3 0.6% 36 0.5% 13 0.5% 3 0.3% 3 0.1% 9 0.3% 39 8.2% 139 2.0% 39 1.6% 38 3.4% 50 1.7% 22 0.7% 14 3.0% 155 2.3% 13 0.5% 36 3.2% 14 0.5% 9 0.3% 30 6.3% 203 3.0% 101 4.2% 67 6.0% 269 9.1% 59 2.0% 50 10.6% 80 1.2% 21 0.9% 36 3.2% 50 1.7% 1,619 54.6% 20 4.2% 64 0.9% 41 1.7% 19 1.7% 1,349 45.9% 67 2.3% 3 0.6% 11 0.2% 3 0.1% 26 2.3% 3 0.1% 5 0.2% 11 2.3% 440 6.4% 14 0.6% 9 0.8% 15 0.5% 19 0.6% 0 0.0% 96 1.4% 17 0.7% 6 0.5% 6 0.2% 5 0.2% 473 6,853 2,378 1,123 2,942 2,967 0% 7% 2% 1% 3% 3% Management & Commerce Society & Culture Creative Arts 7 0.2% 12 0.5% 4 0.7% 1,053 25.0% 744 28.3% 241 42.5% 138 3.3% 42 1.6% 16 2.8% 25 0.6% 3 0.1% 0 0.0% 311 7.4% 40 1.5% 29 5.1% 23 0.5% 0 0.0% 4 0.7% 92 2.2% 10 0.4% 11 1.9% 123 2.9% 14 0.5% 8 1.4% 446 10.6% 63 2.4% 36 6.3% 135 3.2% 59 2.2% 17 3.0% 196 4.7% 24 0.9% 7 1.2% 20 0.5% 46 1.7% 48 8.5% 207 4.9% 13 0.5% 3 0.5% 110 2.6% 7 0.3% 3 0.5% 252 6.0% 97 3.7% 16 2.8% 196 4.7% 45 1.7% 20 3.5% 317 7.5% 278 10.6% 19 3.4% 203 4.8% 213 8.1% 39 6.9% 258 6.1% 826 31.4% 22 3.9% 20 0.5% 19 0.7% 13 2.3% 57 1.4% 68 2.6% 6 1.1% 22 0.5% 10 0.4% 3 0.5% 4,211 2,633 567 4% 3% 1% Food, Not Total Field % Hospitality & applicable of Study Personal Services 16 0.8% 357 588 1% 581 28.7% 45,180 59,417 59% 55 2.7% 2,279 3,539 3% 7 0.3% 290 579 1% 149 7.4% 3,300 6,155 6% 0 0.0% 125 362 0% 29 1.4% 1,059 2,763 3% 36 1.8% 963 1,664 2% 204 10.1% 3,451 5,020 5% 335 16.6% 1,767 2,594 3% 76 3.8% 1,520 2,447 2% 9 0.4% 186 369 0% 10 0.5% 307 607 1% 10 0.5% 250 468 0% 13 0.6% 438 1,189 1% 43 2.1% 778 1,405 1% 43 2.1% 873 2,355 2% 35 1.7% 621 3,112 3% 93 4.6% 1,309 4,271 4% 0 0.0% 149 269 0% 251 12.4% 459 1,421 1% 19 0.9% 286 535 1% 2,023 65,949 101,127 2% 65% 100% Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics (2008) Skills Tasmania 108 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Tourism Cont’d ….industry is largest employer with 16.6%, the retail trades also employ about 10% and manufacturing employ 7%; Agriculture, aquaculture, fishing, food and beverages are a group associated with food production and processing. It is difficult to obtain an exact equivalent in the ABS data because food processing is classified into ‘manufacturing’. Nearly 9% of VET effort is in this field. The ABS data indicates that 32% are employed in the primary industries for which they were trained, nearly 10% work in manufacturing, 6% in public administration and 5.6% in the wholesale trades. IT and communications receives 8.6% of VET effort. As could be expected, in the ABS data regarding industry of employment, they are spread across the spectrum. Education takes nearly 11%, retail about 8%, manufacturing about 8% and public administration about 6%. About 66% of IT employees are VET graduates overall; General education appears to approximate the ABS category of education. However, in this instance, the VET delivery of general education is more aimed at disadvantaged and other groups and represents a basic level of education to be able to handle the world of work or other study. Therefore it does not equate at all to the ABS classification; Building and construction approximates to the ABS classification of architecture and building. Vet effort comprises 6% of the total output. The industry itself is the main destination employing nearly 37% but public administration also takes about 6%; Health and community services incorporates the ABS ‘health’ FOS and a proportion of the ‘society and culture’ FOS. The field is the focus of about 5.8% of VET effort and some 46% are employed directly in that industry with a further 9% in public administration. However, it should be noted that only 55% of people in this industry have VET level qualifications as there is a high level of higher education graduate positions in this industry. Automotive and Engineering will be considered together for the purposes of correlating with the ABS classifications. It can be seen that some 7% of persons employed across all industry have engineering or related qualifications and it is the most numerous field of study for qualified persons in industry. The VET effort is 4.8% (Auto) and 4.1% (Eng) respectively of total output and they are employed in manufacturing (22.3%), construction (7%), transport (5.2%) and agriculture (4.5%). Mining and mineral processing is 2.9% of VET effort but all that can be concluded from the ABS data is that it employs about 6% of the regions population. However, other ABS data indicates that about 76% of the qualified persons working in mining are VET graduates; Retail and wholesale sales and service is not an ABS FOS. However, it receives about 2.8% of VET effort. This may appear small however some of the relevant training occurs under the category of ‘business and financial services’. We can see from the ABS data that they employ about 7% of the regions qualified persons and that 73% are VET graduates. Skills Tasmania 109 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile 11.3. Conclusions Engineering courses are vital to the future of the NW coast development. It is the largest group of qualifications employed by industry and yet has received only 4.1% of VET effort from 2002-06. Yet the industry is indicating that its development is being constrained by the lack of qualified engineers. This comment is moderated by the industry trend towards employing more graduate engineers, although this seems to be the focus more of the larger firms on the coast. Similar comments could be made about the construction industry as were made above about engineering. It receives 5.9% of effort and yet is vital to the coast’s development. Tourism related courses receive 10.3% of VET effort and has been an emphasis for over a decade in Tasmania. There are clearly a large number of trained persons who work in related occupations and industries or who have moved out into other occupations. However, it is an industry that is largely comprised of small and micro businesses that employ few people. It is also an industry of low pay, often unpleasant work, odd hours and sometimes poor management and is consequently characterised by high turnover of employees. Given this, an indepth review of the tourism and hospitality training effort may be warranted with a view to re-directing funding to other higher priority industries. Health and community services receive 5.8% of VET effort. The trend towards a significantly higher proportion of older people and the current influx of older people to the coast is widely recognised. Whilst this sector employs a lower proportion of VET qualified persons than other industries, there is a significant need for VET trained support and ancillary workers. The current effort should be reviewed to ensure that regional needs are adequately met. Business, financial and IT output, combined is nearly 29% of VET effort. Whilst industry continue to indicate the need for these qualifications, it is unlikely that an increase is justified in the light of other needs. It is even possible that an in-depth analysis of the impact of this training in terms of direct, short term benefit to coastal businesses may indicate that the current level of effort is excessive in some areas and that efficiencies could be gained. The agriculture, aquaculture, fishing, food and beverages industry is a major employer and is economically very important to the coast and Tasmania. It is also historically a low employer of qualified persons and is currently struggling to survive. However, the 8.8% of VET effort indicated in Table 52 suggests that it may be adequate yet some re-focusing on more appropriate skill sets and reducing non-employment related training may provide more benefit for the industry. Skills Tasmania 110 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Appendices Skills Tasmania 111 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Appendix 1: Methodology for developing this report This TDP employed the following methodology: Desk research of documents in the public domain (listed in the References); Commissioned data runs by the Australian Bureau of Statistics as well as published ABS data and reports; Special data runs from the statistical databases of the Office of Post-Compulsory Education and Training (OPCET); A review of the current suite of Skills Tasmania Training Development Profiles for data relevant to the NW coast; Qualitative data was gathered by 12 semi-structured telephone or face-to-face interviews with industry personnel; This data was then subjected to content and thematic analysis. The content of this report has been constrained to some extent by: The nature of the statistical data gathered by government sources. In particular, in many instances data is not collected at a local government area (LGA) level that allows the compilation of a profile for specific aggregations of LGAs; The small numbers in some fields of activity may potentially result in a breach of confidentiality as determined by the Privacy Act 1988 (Cwth) if data was released to the public. To avoid this, where the statistics in any area are small, the ABS has randomly changed the number to protect privacy and so readers will note that some tables, particularly those that provide statistics for the individual LGAs, will not sum to the total shown at the foot or side of the table; Many government agencies develop policies and programs for the whole state and do not differentiate regions or industries unless there are special circumstances; ABS data, on which this report largely relies, is a self-reporting survey which at times has high levels of detail lacking and is subject, to some extent, to highly idiosyncratic interpretation of questions and therefore some bias. The exclusion of the West Coast region or the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Lyell Statistical Subdivision requires the data sets for this report to be compiled for either the EIGHT Local Government Areas (LGAs) or for the remaining TWO ABS Statistical Subdivisions, Burnie-Devonport or North Western Rural. Where it has been possible and practicable information has been compiled from data for the eight LGAs and unless otherwise stated as close as possible to the displayed data or in the cited text, ABS data for the eight individual LGAs has been used. However, any material citing “Mersey-Lyell” contains a relatively small error for the West Coast population however in these instances, the author has made a judgement that the inclusion of the West Coast population does not bias the analysis or the ultimate findings. Skills Tasmania 112 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Appendix 2: North West enrolments by state funding source and level 2002-06 Cert I 2002 Non-TAFE Comp Bids Cert II 122 30 99 58 17 380 264 6 11 408 719 45 TAFE - Purchase Agreement 580 1,221 1,317 774 TAFE - Comp Bids 106 931 101 43 4 TAFE - Fee for Service 371 518 567 365 68 1 2 2 1 TAFE - Overseas Student Education not elsewhere classified 21 Other Nonaward Courses State of Attain Not Id by Level 2 Y.12 Grand Total % 34 411 3% 14 682 5% 127 31 76 21 70 2 274 319 31 8 1,183 9% 4,949 39% 1,276 10% 2,492 19% 6 0% 67 1% 54 13 TAFE - User Choice 38 164 104 17 2 325 3% 5 97 592 12 7 713 6% 387 285 15 10 697 5% 1,598 3,777 3,827 1,631 938 150 25 269 16 52 8 1 15 18 VET in Schools Sub-Totals Non-TAFE Comp Bids Non-TAFE Env Tourism - 328 7 452 4% 41 0% 11 676 5% 385 192 Non-TAFE User Choice 4 375 682 45 TAFE - Purchase Agreement 588 1,122 1,278 707 831 115 3 81 TAFE - Comp Bids 562 439 87 22 61 2 102 144 88 63 2 495 606 416 93 10 3 432 12,801 1 71 333 1 39 81 1 TAFE - Fee for Service 15 513 Non-TAFE Fee for Service TAFE - Env Tourism 16 283 3 1,106 9% 4,741 37% 1,419 11% 153 1% 2,674 21% TAFE - Purchase Agreement ViS 45 29 74 1% TAFE - User Choice 21 137 136 10 1 305 2% 7 107 712 10 1 837 7% 416 264 36 7 723 6% 1,977 3,127 4,000 1,429 1,000 32 154 101 31 4 TAFE - User Choice Guaranteed VET in Schools Sub-Totals Non-TAFE Comp Bids Non-TAFE Env Tourism 99 128 3 544 522 17 104 443 3% 3 103 1% 780 6% 1 Non-TAFE Fee for Service 1 196 362 198 Non-TAFE User Choice 4 301 618 38 TAFE - Purchase Agreement 641 1,759 1,264 674 664 105 TAFE - Comp Bids 261 60 3 19 23 146 15 961 7% 5,268 40% 600 5% 66 46 33 29 28 325 690 689 442 TAFE - Purchase Agreement ViS 32 10 1 TAFE - User Choice 23 97 137 6 1 5 69 910 7 1 992 7% 366 286 56 1 709 5% 1,658 3,722 4,112 1,428 867 109 9 136 26 25 16 6 TAFE - Fee for Service TAFE - User Choice Guaranteed VET in Schools Sub-Totals Non-TAFE Comp Bids Non-TAFE Env Tourism 120 1 131 12,749 149 TAFE - Env Tourism 21 43 11 823 32 233 866 515 3 126 1 16 61 Non-TAFE Fee for Service 1 95 277 146 10 Non-TAFE User Choice 8 320 693 17 1 TAFE - Purchase Agreement 719 2,026 1,236 761 623 82 TAFE - Comp Bids 121 14 31 13 58 3 TAFE - Env Tourism 3 329 13 13 116 1 TAFE - Fee for Service 173 549 802 580 108 4 930 93 270 2% 3,335 25% 43 0% 264 2% 13,325 347 3% 61 0% 532 4% 1,039 8% 5,789 44% 369 3% 1 0% 3,239 24% TAFE - Purchase Agreement ViS 60 1 1 62 0% TAFE - User Choice 13 95 117 3 228 2% 5 89 1,145 4 1,243 9% 370 310 11 691 5% 1,470 3,560 4,313 3 1 13 140 124 93 TAFE - User Choice Guaranteed VET in Schools Sub-Totals 2006 792 Adv Diploma TAFE - Purchase Agreement ViS TAFE - User Choice Guaranteed 2005 Diploma 1 Non-TAFE User Choice 2004 Cert IV 45 Non-TAFE Fee for Service 2003 Cert III DEST Funded Non-TAFE Comp Bids Non-TAFE Env Tourism 1,525 800 89 60 2 143 240 110 Non-TAFE User Choice 300 873 42 607 1,832 1,396 747 563 72 29 34 104 55 43 3 TAFE - Comp Bids 943 541 2 97 13 4 Non-TAFE Fee for Service TAFE - Purchase Agreement - TAFE - Env Tourism 10 1 3 607 14 132 1 TAFE - Fee for Service TAFE - Purchase Agreement ViS 108 711 578 657 114 15 4 933 5 13,254 4 0% 537 4% 4 0% 504 4% 1,215 9% 5,841 43% 400 3% 1 0% 3,125 23% 1% 73 12 16 1 102 TAFE - User Choice 9 89 102 3 203 2% TAFE - User Choice Guaranteed 6 66 1,307 4 1,383 10% 732 5% VET in Schools 368 353 11 Sub-Totals 1,200 3,545 4,627 1,619 730 90 Grand Total 7,982 18,430 21,149 7,834 4,423 12% 27% 31% 12% 7% 4 936 745 14 13,510 575 39 3,639 3,244 101 67,422 1% 0% 5% 5% 0% Source: VET Provider Collections 2002 – 2006 Skills Tasmania 113 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Appendix 3: National key findings for graduates and module completers from all VET providers by state/territory, 2007 State Australia NSW Vic. Qld SA Tas. WA NT ACT Graduates Respondents Estimated population 45 863 8 275 13 705 10 228 3 457 6 354 1 658 1 212 974 478 050 144 110 139 540 96 330 27 430 41 500 15 910 6 620 6 620 % % % % % % % % % Employed after training 81.1 76.8 81.8 83.8 82.7 84.3 81.7 83.1 88.9 Not 12.8 13.7 12.3 12.8 13.2 12.9 12.0 9.8 8.9 89.2 87.6 89.8 89.3 89.9 91.1 89.6 89.5 93.5 30.8 35.1 30.1 24.8 30.3 33.0 30.0 32.1 32.3 86.7 84.7 86.6 89.2 85.7 87.6 88.6 89.4 88.7 88.8 89.0 88.9 89.3 89.0 87.1 90.0 86.6 84.2 employed before commencing the training and employed aftera Employed or in further study after trainingb Enrolled in further study after training b Fully or partly achieved main reason for doing the training Satisfied overall with the quality of training Module completers Respondents 21 342 4 351 6 696 3 478 2 550 3 113 466 323 365 Estimated population 361 170 144 100 110 050 50 650 24 050 21 020 5 450 2 910 2 940 % % % % % % % % % Employed after training Not employed before commencing 74.3 71.2 75.4 77.2 78.7 77.7 77.8 71.1 76.0 7.6 7.5 6.9 8.5 6.6 9.5 9.9 11.7 10.8 77.8 72.7 83.3 78.5 79.8 79.2 78.6 75.2 79.3 4.4 3.6 5.3 3.9 3.6 6.2 9.0 8.9 80.4 78.6 83.4 79.4 82.6 79.4 79.2 80.2 71.6 83.8 83.8 85.1 80.8 87.8 81.7 83.7 81.8 77.1 the training and employed aftera Employed or in further study after trainingb, c Enrolled in further study 3.3* after trainingb, c Fully or partly achieved main reason for doing the training Satisfied overall with the quality of training Source: National Centre for Vocational Education Research (2007c) Skills Tasmania 114 NW Tasmania Regional Training Demand Profile Appendix 4: VET Qualifications by Level and Field of Study for NW LGAs, NW Region and Tasmania (2006) Burnie Central Coast 40 Advanced Diploma and Diploma Level, nfd Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 41 Advanced Diploma and Associate Degree Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 42 Diploma Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 50 Certificate Level, nfd Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 51 Certificate III & IV Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 52 Certificate I & II Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Latrobe Waratah/ Total NW Tasmania Island Wynyard 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 4 4 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 7 4 3 3 5 0 0 0 25 16 0 4 16 7 3 34 18 37 35 21 12 0 0 209 0 12 3 39 4 10 79 90 68 29 17 8 0 0 355 5 8 16 47 3 24 87 123 70 42 11 10 0 0 444 0 0 3 4 0 24 20 25 10 10 7 0 0 0 106 3 8 10 67 4 18 77 159 100 39 21 9 0 0 510 3 0 4 16 3 4 20 30 17 14 3 7 0 0 120 0 0 3 4 0 6 11 10 6 3 0 0 0 0 44 3 0 0 13 3 18 39 55 27 10 6 7 0 0 181 9 0 3 43 3 16 74 77 54 32 15 3 0 0 322 22 28 33 234 15 126 401 569 356 181 85 44 0 0 2,086 150 200 139 1,402 168 539 2,397 2,619 2,239 851 586 358 3 0 11,651 3 3 20 59 3 13 30 30 117 86 19 4 0 0 388 5 7 13 63 4 17 32 51 131 116 26 9 0 0 474 4 3 3 3 0 18 11 11 33 32 3 4 0 0 121 6 3 40 64 4 14 31 50 124 123 30 20 0 0 501 3 3 7 11 0 3 7 9 25 22 13 5 0 0 104 0 0 0 5 0 4 4 10 11 0 0 3 0 0 37 5 8 9 27 0 10 10 22 61 38 11 5 0 0 199 3 12 6 24 0 9 22 23 56 78 18 7 0 0 259 34 36 94 255 14 90 135 198 554 490 118 61 0 0 2,090 175 222 520 1,416 148 451 664 842 3,152 2,036 794 373 3 0 10,793 4 3 10 29 4 10 11 0 122 34 11 9 0 0 247 5 3 6 24 6 15 19 6 115 41 17 4 0 0 247 0 3 0 5 0 11 4 0 33 7 6 3 0 0 69 5 3 3 29 3 15 19 4 143 43 17 17 0 0 304 6 0 0 4 0 3 3 3 29 11 3 0 0 0 69 3 3 0 5 0 0 0 0 9 3 0 0 0 0 17 3 0 0 8 0 11 13 4 43 14 3 7 0 0 101 0 7 0 24 3 3 13 5 75 22 0 9 0 0 163 23 18 24 134 19 62 75 15 565 175 52 56 3 0 1,216 109 101 89 560 119 280 370 91 2,658 864 226 239 14 0 5,725 111 3 29 1,078 311 68 44 21 254 143 27 289 3 0 2,382 130 4 21 1,168 543 136 70 17 244 152 17 345 0 0 2,855 31 10 10 362 123 90 13 6 80 52 7 137 0 0 925 172 0 41 1,194 602 69 78 17 313 167 17 413 0 0 3,086 36 0 7 306 117 39 25 4 59 33 7 120 0 0 748 10 3 3 112 37 20 3 0 10 9 4 45 0 0 256 52 3 11 533 253 47 36 14 105 55 13 148 3 0 1,259 63 5 15 774 250 85 46 23 127 88 23 187 0 0 1,687 602 22 140 5,522 2,235 552 318 98 1,191 708 119 1,673 7 0 13,193 2,869 77 660 22,391 9,782 2,152 1,432 402 5,465 3,150 684 8,100 12 0 57,170 9 0 17 29 0 11 7 3 81 19 3 28 0 0 206 5 0 15 21 3 7 10 3 108 45 3 20 0 0 242 0 0 19 14 0 11 3 0 38 13 0 14 0 0 116 9 0 16 25 0 7 8 5 126 44 5 27 0 0 277 3 0 4 3 0 5 3 4 22 18 0 6 0 0 74 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 19 3 0 3 19 0 0 4 5 50 8 4 12 0 0 106 9 0 9 13 0 10 0 14 63 13 0 20 0 0 152 32 0 84 132 10 55 39 33 482 156 22 135 0 0 1,179 152 16 277 459 36 296 167 118 2,051 736 95 566 25 0 4,996 Skills Tasmania 115 NW Tasmanian Regional Training Demand Profile Appendix 5: Higher Education Qualifications by Level and Field of Study for NW LGAs, NW Region and Tasmania (2006) 10 Postgraduate Degree Level, nfd Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 11 Doctoral Degree Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 12 Master Degree Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 21 Graduate Diploma Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 22 Graduate Certificate Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS 31 Bachelor Degree Level Field of study not stated - Field of study inadequately described 01 Natural and Physical Sciences 02 Information Technology 03 Engineering and Related Technologies 04 Architecture and Building 05 Agriculture, Environmental and Related Studies 06 Health 07 Education 08 Management and Commerce 09 Society and Culture 10 Creative Arts 11 Food, Hospitality and Personal Services 12 Mixed Field Programmes @@ Not applicable Total FOS Burnie Central Coast Circular Head Devonport Kentish King Island Latrobe Waratah/ Wynyard 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 6 3 3 3 0 0 0 0 14 3 9 0 8 5 7 42 35 20 37 9 0 0 0 173 0 3 0 0 0 6 20 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 35 0 9 0 0 0 3 5 3 3 7 0 0 0 0 31 0 4 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 8 0 0 0 3 13 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 30 0 3 0 0 0 0 4 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 4 0 0 0 3 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 0 5 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 19 0 29 0 0 0 15 51 6 3 24 0 0 0 0 133 31 827 36 87 6 120 426 102 35 433 32 0 0 0 2,129 0 5 0 5 0 4 7 25 18 16 5 0 0 0 82 4 6 0 5 0 3 6 16 17 14 0 0 0 0 69 0 3 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 9 3 9 3 8 0 3 5 34 20 8 0 0 0 0 89 0 3 0 3 0 3 3 3 10 3 0 0 0 0 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 3 3 3 0 0 3 8 5 7 0 0 0 0 33 0 4 0 4 0 4 4 14 5 20 0 0 0 0 49 8 23 3 22 0 9 36 103 70 73 3 0 0 0 356 59 311 92 233 54 161 372 919 746 891 201 0 0 0 4,039 3 3 0 4 0 3 12 40 3 16 3 0 0 0 87 3 0 0 3 3 3 17 63 10 19 3 0 0 0 120 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 19 0 3 3 3 0 0 10 68 9 9 0 0 0 0 103 0 0 3 0 0 3 0 15 0 3 0 0 0 0 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 3 4 0 0 0 0 11 0 0 3 0 0 0 16 19 7 0 0 0 0 0 44 0 0 3 3 0 0 9 44 0 3 0 0 0 0 74 3 6 9 14 6 7 77 264 28 56 4 0 0 0 478 33 82 119 61 67 109 497 1,466 374 615 110 3 0 0 3,545 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 8 3 3 0 0 0 0 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 4 4 3 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 8 4 7 3 0 0 0 0 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 0 0 5 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 4 3 3 0 0 0 0 19 0 5 0 0 0 3 34 18 29 14 0 0 0 0 95 7 8 7 9 7 11 206 99 243 154 15 0 0 0 764 14 75 21 37 0 24 291 223 68 104 18 4 0 0 874 12 53 20 36 6 30 281 364 78 127 18 3 0 0 1,023 5 11 0 11 0 6 70 110 26 23 5 0 0 0 271 22 54 16 57 3 32 290 372 113 156 28 0 0 0 1,130 0 18 5 6 3 6 52 53 33 29 6 0 0 0 212 3 6 0 3 0 11 21 25 7 12 4 0 0 0 97 6 20 5 29 3 15 140 111 27 59 10 0 0 0 436 11 37 3 26 3 20 176 197 38 88 18 0 0 0 631 70 283 67 207 29 150 1,330 1,451 395 590 103 3 0 0 4,675 859 2,791 1,057 1,824 557 966 7,626 7,729 3,821 6,007 1,561 54 7 0 34,867 Skills Tasmania Total NW Tasmania 116 NW Tasmanian Regional Training Demand Profile 12. References Australian Bureau of Statistics 1999a, Projected resident population, Tasmania: 2006-2051, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra. ---- 1999b, Projected Resident Population, Tasmania: 2006-2051, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra. ---- 2006a, 47050DO009 Population distribution, ATSI Australians - Table 1. 2006 census counts, Indigenous geographic classification - Tasmania, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2006b, Recipients of disability support pension: Tasmanian local government areas, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007a, Cat. No. 2068.0 - 2006 census of population and housing Burnie-Devonport (statistical subdivision) – Tas.- indigenous status by age by sex for time series, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007b, Cat. No. 2068.0: 2006 census of population and housing - level of education by indigenous status by age in NW Tasmanian LGAs Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007c, Cat. No. 2068.0: 2006 census of population and housing - type of educational institution attending by indigenous status by sex, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007d, Catalogue 3218.0 regional population growth, Australia: Table 6. estimated resident population, local government areas, Tasmania, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007e, Catalogue 8165.0: counts of Australian businesses, including entries and exits: Jun 2003 to Jun 2006 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007f, Catalogue No. 2001.0 2006 census community profile series - gross individual income (weekly) by age and sex based on place of usual residence, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007g, Catalogue No. 2001.0: census of population and housing - count of persons based on place of usual residence, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007h, Catalogue No. 2068.0 – 2006: Census of population and housing, labour force status by age by sex for indigenous persons, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007i, Catalogue No. 2068.0 – 2006: census of population and housing, labour force status by age by sex for Tasmania, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007j, Census of population and housing, 2006, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007k, Counts of Australian businesses, including entries and exits: Jun 2003 to Jun 2006 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2007l, Tasmanian Population Census Data: Burnie and Devonport Suburbs, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, ACT. ---- 2008, Commissioned data set, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Hobart, Tas. Australian Federal Department of Education - Employment and Workplace Relations 2008, 'Labour market information portal', viewed 29 February 2008, <http://www.workplace.gov.au/lmip/LabourForceData/Tasmania/MerseyLyell/SD/SAL M/?cid=UnemploymentBySLA|TMLY|2157|SLA|anon|Labour%20Market&view=table> . Auty, RM 1997, 'Natural resource endowment, the state and development strategy ', Journal of International Development, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 651-63. Blue Environment Pty Ltd 2007, Draft waste management strategy for Tasmania background report, Department of Tourism Arts & the Environment, Hobart, Tasmania. Bonney, LB & Blackmore, K 2004, A Tasmanian mental health and wellbeing education framework, Department of Health and Human Services, Hobart, Tasmania. Department of Transport and Regional Services 2006, Skill shortages in Australia's regions, by Bureau of Transport and Regional Economics, Commonwealth of Australia. Department of Transport and Regional Services 2007a, Australian sea freight 2005–06, by ---, Commonwealth of Australia. Department of Transport and Regional Services 2007b, Bass Strait passenger vehicle equalisation scheme, by ----, Commonwealth of Australia. Skills Tasmania 117 NW Tasmanian Regional Training Demand Profile Demographic Change Advisory Council 2007a, Demographic change in Tasmania: challenges and opportunities - issues paper, State of Tasmania - Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources Hobart, Tasmania. ---- 2007b, Who is not participating in Tasmania’s labour force? Summary paper, State of Tasmania - Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources Hobart, Tasmania. Department of Education 2007, Why Tasmania needs this strategy, Government of Tasmania, viewed 21st February 2008, <http://www.education.tas.gov.au/dept/about/visions/stateoflearning/strategy/booklet/ whyneeded >. Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations 2008, 'The Tasmanian labour market review trends', p. 6, viewed 29 February 2008, <http://www.workplace.gov.au/NR/rdonlyres/B17405A1-28BB-4C43-A4358D42E404E0A5/0/Trends_Oct_2007.pdf>. Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources 2007, Infrastructure and Resource Information Service (IRIS) Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources, State of Tasmania, viewed 26 January 2008 <http://www.iris.tas.gov.au/>. Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources & Cradle Coast Authority 2007, Cradle coast integrated transport strategy, Department of Infrastructure Energy and Resources, State of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Department of Main Roads - Historical Committee 1988, Convicts & carriageways: Tasmanian road development until 1880, Department of Main Roads, Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Department of Primary Industries and Water Tasmania 2006, Draft climate change strategy for Tasmania Department of Primary Industries and Water, Hobart, Tasmania. Dowrick, S 2002, 'The contribution of innovation and education to economic growth', paper presented to Economic and Social Outlook Conference: 'Towards Opportunity and Prosperity', Melbourne, Vic, 4-5 April 2002. Doyle, R & Farquhar, D 2007, Tasmanian viticultural soils and geology, Department of Primary Industries and Water, viewed 3 February 2008, <http://www.dpiw.tas.gov.au/inter.nsf/WebPages/CART-6F56YE?open>. Edwards, J 2008, Residex Newsletter - February 2008, Residex, viewed 26 February 2008, <http://www.residex.com.au/newsletter/source2008_02cMC.html>. Felmingham, B, Jackson, N & Zhang, Q 2002, Indicative impacts of population decline on the operations of Local Government in Tasmania, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Fenton, J 1891, Bush life in Tasmania: fifty years ago, Reprint edn, C.L. Richmond & Sons Pty Ltd, Devonport, Tasmania. Giesecke, J, Meagher, T & Horridge, M 2007, Monash economic forecasts, Monash University, Melbourne, Vic. Griffiths, HD 2007, Tasmanian food industry scorecard 2004-05, Government of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Hawkes, S 2008, February 2008 Tasmanian economic overview Department of Economic Development Hobart, Tasmania. Jackson, N & Felmingham, B 2002, 'As the population clock winds down: indicative effects of population ageing in Australia's states and territories', Journal of Population Research, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 97-117. Jackson, N & Kippen, R 2001, 'Whither Tasmania? A note on Tasmania's population problem', People and Place, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 27-37. Jackson, N & Thompson, B 2002, 'Population ageing and the A-B-C of educational demand. A focus on Tasmania and South Australia', People and Place, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 1122. Kilpatrick, S, Abbott-Chapman, J & Baynes, H 2002, 'Youth participation in education: a review of trends, targets and influencing factors'. KPMG & EMRS 2006, Regional economic development and investment plans project (REDI Plans), Department of Economic Development, Hobart, Tasmania. Local Government Association of Tasmania 2007, Local government climate change consultation - summary report, Hobart, Tasmania. MacCormick, T 2007, Annual report 2007, Cradle Coast Water, Forth, Tasmania. Malmberg, A & Maskell, P 1997, 'Towards an explanation of regional specialization and industry agglomeration', European Planning Studies, vol. 5, no. 1, p. 25. Skills Tasmania 118 NW Tasmanian Regional Training Demand Profile McFarlane, I 2002, 'Aboriginal society in North West Tasmania: dispossession and genocide', PhD thesis, University of Tasmania. McIntosh, P, Pook, M & McGregor, J 2005, Study of future and current climate: a scenario for the Tasmanian region - stages 2 and 3, CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research, Hobart, Tasmania. N.K. 2004, Regional NRM strategy development waste management - North West Tasmanian region, Cradle Coast Authority, Burnie, Tasmania. National Centre for Vocational Education Research 2007a, Australian vocational education and training statistics - students and courses: atlas of Australian public VET Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide, SA. ---- 2007b, Australian vocational education and training statistics: North West Tasmanian student outcomes 2007 – commissioned data set, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide, SA. ---- 2007c, Australian vocational education and training statistics: student outcomes 2007 – summary, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide, SA. ---- 2007d, Survey of employer use and views of the VET System, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide, SA. ---- 2007e, VET students, by age group and sex, Mersey-Lyell, Tasmania and Australia 2006, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide, SA. Office of Post-compulsory Education and Training 2005, Information technology and telecommunications (ICT) industry training demand profile, 2005, Department of Education, Hobart, Tas. ---- 2006a, Tasmanian land transport and distribution industry training demand profile, 2006, Department of Education, Hobart, Tas. ---- 2006b, Water industry training demand profile, 2006, Department of Education, Hobart, Tas. Office of the Tasmanian Energy Regulator 2007, Tasmanian energy supply industry performance report 2006-07, Government of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania. Paul, D 2007, Pressures facing harvesting contractors in the Tasmanian forest industry, Department of Agriculture Forestry and Fishing, Canberra, ACT. Pink, K 1990, And wealth for toil: a history of North-West and Western Tasmania 1825-1900, 1st edn, Advocate Printers (Burnie) Pty Ltd, Burnie, Tasmania. Porritt, J 2005, Capitalism as if the world matters, Earthscan. Porter, EM 1992, The competitive advantage of nations, The Macmillan Press Ltd. Reserve Bank of Australia 2007, 'Statement on monetary policy – May 2007: developments in labour supply', viewed May 2007, <http://www.rba.gov.au/PublicationsAndResearch/StatementsOnMonetaryPolicy/May 2007/dev_labour_supply.html>. Resource Planning and Development Commission 2006, State of the environment (SoE) Tasmania, Department of Justice, viewed 26 February 2008, <http://soer.justice.tas.gov.au/2003/index.php>. Rodrigues, M 2007, States and territories economic update, ANZ Group Ltd, Melbourne, Vic. Rural Ageing Research Consortium 2005, Rural Seniors Research – Pilot Survey North West Tasmania, University of Tasmania, Burnie, Tasmania. Sachs, JD & Warner, AM 1999, 'The big push, natural resource booms and growth', Journal of Development Economics, vol. 59, no. 1, pp. 43-76. Scanlon, AP, Fish, GJ & Yaxley, ML 1990, Behind the scenery–Tasmania's landforms and geology, Department of Education and the Arts, Tasmania. Sharples, C 2006, Indicative mapping of Tasmanian coastal vulnerability to climate change and sea-level rise: explanatory report, Department of Primary Industries & Water, Hobart, Tasmania. Skills Tasmania 2007, 'Skilling Tasmania: policy consultation', viewed 16 February 2008, <http://www.skills.tas.gov.au/documents/pdf/North-West-forum-feedback-toattendees.pdf>. Stijns, J-P 2001, Natural resource abundance and human capital accumulation, SSRN. Stokes, HJW 1969, 'North-West Tasmania 1858-1910: the establishment of an agricultural community', PhD thesis, Australian National University. Tasports 2008, Tasmanian freight statistics – 2007/08 half year (Jul to Dec), Tasports, Hobart, Tasmania. Skills Tasmania 119