Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia DRAFT Report Acknowledgements Preface Executive Summary There has been important progress in addressing issues that affect the rights of children and women over the past ten years in The Gambia. National legislation and polices have been put in place that guarantee full equality for women and ensure that children have their rights realized. Programs focusing on meeting the needs and ensuring the rights of children and women are ongoing and greater attention at the national level is given to ensure that action is taken to support the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women. (CEDAW). Most recently, the Women’s Act 2010 was passed through the National Assembly. This important and holistic piece of legislation clearly specifies measures that if fully enacted would go a long way to ensuring that women in The Gambia enjoy equity of rights and benefits. Rights regarding economic empowerment, equity in employment, access to quality healthcare, equal educational opportunities and minimizing the divisions that men and women face regarding social issues are clearly laid out in this comprehensive document. Nevertheless, the Act as passed has been heavily diluted from the original intent regarding some important issues such as inheritance, divorce and traditional harmful practices. The needs and rights of children have been clearly articulated in The Children’s Act 2005. In full support of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, this document details the rights of children to enjoy a safe and healthy life, to development to their full potential, and to fully exercise their rights as citizens. Alongside these works of legislation, the government has fully committed itself to achieving the goals as set out in the Millennium Declaration. Significant advances have been made in achieving gender parity in basic education, improving access to clean water and reducing the incidence of childhood illnesses. While not all of the MDGs are on track to be fully realized by 2015, the efforts made thus far in reaching these goals, should contribute positively in addressing the needs of children and women. 1 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 While significant progress has been made as described above, there are still important issues such as the reduction of poverty, reducing infant and maternal mortality, and equalizing the disparities in earning power between men and women, which must be addressed in order to fully ensure the rights of children and women are met and safeguarded. The findings from the Situation Analysis indicate that in order to achieve full gender equity and ensure children have the rights which will enable them to reach their full potential, a stronger commitment to addressing some of the specific underlying causes of the issues raised and to close the gaps in budgetary allocations and programming is required. In summary there is much more work to be done to ensure children and women in The Gambia can fully exercise their rights. Key Findings Poverty is a major cause of, and underlies the majority of issues that negatively affect the rights of children and women. Poverty greatly increases the vulnerability of women and children to illness, poor education, abuse and exploitation. With over sixty percent of Gambians living under the National Poverty Line1, this is perhaps the most important issue which needs on-going attention. While much needed legislation regarding rights of children and women has been formalized, the systems to fully implement the directives are not functioning to optimal levels. For example, child welfare units have not been established at police stations country-wide, reporting mechanisms for abuse and exploitation outside of the Greater Banjul Area are lacking, and regulatory guidelines and monitoring mechanisms on child protection issues are nonexistent at many levels. (There are no official child protection policies or standards that are enforced in child care institutions, orphanages, NGOs, etc) Women and children are still largely left out of the decision making process at the family, community and national level. While the government has legislated specific provisions to guarantee their rights, women and children have little say over day to day decisions that affect their daily lives or larger issues that influence their future, such as education, health care or livelihood opportunities. The most vulnerable persons and thereby those who are most at risk of not having their rights realized remain a relatively neglected population. There are not enough services available to meet their needs and even fewer opportunities for their active participation at any level in the decision making process. 1 Government of The Gambia, ‘PRSP II 2007-2011’, GoTG, November 2006. 2 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Gender parity has been realized in primary education, with the percentage of girls surpassing the percentage of boys in enrolment. Yet enrolment rates in secondary and tertiary education remain significantly lower for girls than boys. Additionally, important factors such as corporal punishment and sexual harassment in schools have been identified during primary data collection exercises as some of the reasons for this lower level of enrolment and violate the fundament rights of children to a safe and conducive learning environment. Sexual exploitation and sex tourism continue to present challenges in the protection of children and women from abuse, exploitation and harm. The Gambia has regrettably gained the unfavorable status of an international hot spot for sex tourists. This unwanted notoriety places women and children, especially those in dire economic situations at risk for sexual abuse, exploitation and illness. During the primary data collection exercises, participants indicated that rural women are subjected to particularly difficult living conditions, with a long daily list of labour intensive tasks. In addition to the pressure of a heavy workload, women in rural communities do not have equal access to quality health care, opportunities for income generating activities, or input into local decision making. These factors can lead to greater vulnerability to risks, as for example in the case of pregnancy related deaths. Contraceptive use remains relatively low with few women practicing family planning2. Family size is often the decision of the man, who as head of the household makes most of the decisions affecting the family. This has direct implications on the health and economic status of women, who as the primary caregivers in the family, have little time or energy (as affected by poor health) for economically lucrative activities or are not able to pursue higher levels of education (which impacts earning power). Women make up approximately 45 percent of the Gambian labour force 3 , but the majority of women work in low paying vocations such as agriculture, domestic work and as street or market vendors. This results, in part, to the disparity of earning power. (Women only earn approximately 63 cents for every dollar a man makes in terms of purchasing power parity4.) There has been an increase in immunisation rates in The Gambia, approaching close to universal coverage. Also the rate of infant mortality (children under one year) and under Accessgambia.com, ‘Contraceptives in The Gambia’, Contraceptive Prevalence and Fertility Determinants Survey (1990) revealed that only 6.7 percent of the Gambian population uses contraceptives. www.accessgambia.com/information/ contraceptives. 3 Government of The Gambia, ‘Population and Housing Census’, GoTG, 2003. 4 United Nations Development Programme, ‘Human Development Report’, UNDP, 2009. 2 3 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 five mortality are decreasing which is a result of improved health care services for children. Nevertheless, maternal mortality rates are still high at 730/100,000 and efforts to reduce this have not been as successful as needed to meet the MGDs or other national targets. Childhood malnutrition remains a problem, with high rates of stunting and malnutrition in children under five, especially in rural areas. (According to MICS 2005/06 rural malnutrition rates are almost double the urban rates for all three measurements of malnutrition.) There are structures that have been put in place, such as the National Nutrition Surveillance, which is carried out every six months in order to identify malnourished children or soon to be malnourished children for referral to community or local recuperation services. In summary, there have been comprehensive measures developed which if successfully implemented would ensure that the rights of women and children are fully supported in Gambia society. Yet there continues to be large disparities of equity in realizing the full attainment of these rights. In order to continue to make progress on the measures which have been put in place and policies that have been developed, a stronger commitment to adequate funding, full participation of stakeholders, including target beneficiaries, and endorsing attitudal change needs to be made. This includes the full engagement of all the major stakeholders including government, donors, international and national NGOs and CBOs, private agencies and perhaps most importantly the children, women and men who are most affected. Objectives The overall objective of the Situation Analysis (SitAn) for Children and Women in the Gambia is to identify the issues and causes hindering the fulfillment of children’s and women’s rights, to analyze the capacity of duty bearers at all levels for meeting their obligations, to analyze the policy and legal frameworks for children, and make specific recommendations for future actions. In addition, the analysis identifies facilitating factors on which to build, and draws on opportunities and strategies for future action. The SitAn will also; Contribute to national research, formulating policies, legislation, and budgets. Serve as a reference for developing national plans, programmes and other processes Provide an assessment and analysis of the realization of the rights of children Identify the challenges concerning children using relevantly stratified data summaries 4 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Chapter 1. Introduction 1.1. Background and Justification for Study As part of its programming process, UNICEF in addition to the UNDAF Common Country Assessment development process, undertakes a Situation Analysis to identify the most critical issues affecting the rights of children and women in a country. In The Gambia the last Situation Analysis (SitAn) was conducted in 2001 and since that time, much of the issues and indicators on these issues regarding the rights of children and women have changed. This SitAn 2010 will assess and analyze the nature and extent to which such changes have occurred using a human rights based approach and causality analysis, which seeks to identify the immediate causes, underlying causes and the structural or basic causes of the issues and problems confronting children and women in The Gambia. Now is an appropriate time to carry out a new Situation Analysis, as UNICEF and The Government of The Gambia Country Programme of Cooperation 2007 – 2011 is in its second half of implementation and preparations for a new country programme have been initiated. An updated Situation Analysis is required to provide needed information on the changes in information and other emerging issues affecting children and women, identify the structural vulnerabilities and to contribute in the preparation of the Common Country Assessment and the United National Assistance Framework 2012-2016. It will also contribute to the new Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment for the Gambia 2012- 2015. It is envisaged that this Situation Analysis will support the articulation and strengthening – through participatory means – of policy frameworks, strategies, and interventions at different levels of society that will achieve long term beneficial results for children and women in The Gambia. 1.2 Comparative General Review of Past Situation Analysis There have been several Situation Analysis Reports conducted and produced in The Gambia. The first three reports on the Situation Analysis of Children and Women were conducted in 1992, 1997 and 20015. The most recent validated report was carried out in 2001 and recommended, among other issues that; Recommendations from ‘The Situation of Children and Women’ Report6 5 There was a SitAn developed in 2005 which was not validated. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘The Situation of Children and Women’, GoTG, UNICEF, Nov 2001, Pg 126-127. 6 5 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Arresting the HIV/AIDS pandemic in The Gambia should be of paramount concern in the provision of health services, Setting up Children and Women’s Rights Commission should be a key feature of the rights promotion and protection programme, which should be empowered to oversee the harmonisation of CRC and CEDAW and the enactment of comprehensive children’s legislation that will combine and expand on the legislation, which are already in existence. Capacity building for improved data collection, analysis and compilation at the national level. Differentiating programming based on regional variations that address specific disparities, especially for the most vulnerable. There has been progress in realizing some of the recommendations listed above. The National Women’s Commission was established and has been actively promoting the rights of women, but a joint Women and Children’s Commission or a separate Children’s Commission has not been set up. Nevertheless, in support of the UNCRC and CEDAW, The Children’s Act 2005, the Women’s Act 2010, The Trafficking Act and the Tourism Act have been legislated in order to address some of the major issues which affect the rights of children and women. While strong legislative measures have been made, implementation has not been as rigorous to ensure that children and women rights are safeguarded. (Chapter 6 provides more information on International and National Legislation and Policies.) There have also been increased efforts to collect and analyze data on issues related to women and children. A computerized Health Management Information Systems (HMIS) has been completed and the Education Management Information System (EMIS) is set up for the analysis of regularly collected data. GAMINFO has been developed in order to consolidate information from various social service sectors into one system. Nevertheless, the collection of relevant data for analysis and action is an area that needs continued strengthening and support. For example some important information on social welfare issues such as incidents of domestic violence, rape cases, and the number of street children are not readily (if at all) available. 1.3 Human Rights Based Approach A human rights-based approach is a conceptual framework for the process of human development that is normatively based on international human rights standards and operationally directed to promoting and protecting human rights. It seeks to analyze inequalities which lie at the heart of development problems and redress discriminatory 6 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 practices and unjust distributions of power that impede development progress. Under a human rights-based approach, the plans, policies and processes of development are anchored in a system of rights and corresponding obligations established by international law. This helps to promote the sustainability of development work, empowering people themselves—especially the most marginalized—to participate in policy formulation and hold accountable those who have a duty to act. As an international development organization, tasked by its mandate and mission statement to advocate for the protection of children's and women’s rights, UNICEF has worked since the 1989 adoption of the CRC to identify ways in which normative processes of international human rights law can inform and guide development work for children and women. In 1998, with the issuance of Executive Directive 1998-2004, UNICEF adopted the Human Rights-Based Approach to Programming. There are two main rationales for a human rights-based approach: (a) the intrinsic rationale, acknowledging that a human rights-based approach is the right thing to do, morally or legally; and (b) the instrumental rationale, recognizing that a human rightsbased approach leads to better and more sustainable human development outcomes. In practice, the reason for pursuing a human rights-based approach is usually a blend of these two7. 1.4 Conceptual Framework A Conceptual Framework is an analytical model developed through scientific evidence, global research, local knowledge and lessons learned from evaluations that establishes a structured way of assessing an issue. A Conceptual Framework helps: To organize or cluster the multiple causes into a pattern of relationship, and to identify immediate, underlying or basic causes; To ask the appropriate questions so that all main contributing factors are considered – for example, a low rate of vaccination may be the result of an ineffective health system To convince partners to explore specific underlying or basic causes that they may have been reluctant to consider. UNHCR, ‘Frequently Asked Questions on a Human Rights-Based Approach to Development Cooperation’, UN, 2006 7 7 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 A Conceptual Framework provides insight into the nature and structure of social services in terms of access, use, equality and quality of services. It examines information on some of the key aspects of the family and community situation, sociocultural attitudes and practices, laws, policies and institutional capacities. The situation analysis reviews the causes and effects of important issues using participatory methodologies such as problem tree analysis and responsibilities matrix. The following diagrams outline the flow of a conceptual framework. Figure 1. Diagrams of Conceptual Framework Source: Guidance for Conducting Situation Assessment and Analysis of Children’s and Women’s Rights, UNICEF, January 2008 1.5. Report Outline The report is presented in eight chapters as outlined below. Executive Summary provides a brief overview of report, highlighting some of the findings and recommendations. Chapter 1 introduces the background and justification for the study in regards to future country programs, policies and activities. It will summarize the concept of a Human Rights Based Approach and the Conceptual Framework. Chapter 2 will provide an overview of the country context in terms of geography, political structure, demography, social structures, systems and policies in Education, Health and Justice, an overview of the economy and a brief look at the National Planning Context. 8 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Chapter 3 helps to define what issues make women and children vulnerable to abuses of rights, such as poverty, food security, and emergencies. Additionally to ensure that the most marginalized are well represented in the document, issues related to the most vulnerable populations are included as sub topics in Chapters 4 and 5. Chapters 4 – 5 As the Situation Analysis is framed using a human rights based approach, the report presents issues in line with the primary international documents on children and women’s rights, the United Nations Convention of the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). The relevant UNCRC or CEDAW article is presented under the appropriate topic. Within the specific topics, an assessment and analysis of causes and existing structural support is presented. Chapter 6 takes a look at the legislative issues, policies and budget implications on the issues concerning children and women. A thorough analysis of budget expenditures and gaps in a Policy and Budget Matrix is included in the report. (Pending available data) Chapter 7 will briefly review how some of the emerging issues such as the FFF crisis, climate change, urbanization, migration, unemployment and the recent currency crisis impacts children and women in The Gambia. Chapter 8 Conclusions A general review of the identified issues and conclusions are presented. 1.6 Methodology The Situation Analysis was developed using a participatory approach. Participatory Methodology The inclusion of all stakeholders in a participatory approach was used in order to develop a holistic Situation Analysis. The Task Force and UNICEF supported the mobilization of discussions with children, youth, women and key stakeholders. Critical ongoing reviews were carried out by the Task Force members and UNICEF staff, who provided valuable input into the document. (Annex 1 is list of Task Force Members) Both primary and secondary data was used in the development of the report. Primary data was collected using Focus Group Discussions, Key Information Surveys, and Round Table Discussions with children, women, men and other stakeholders. These activities employed participatory tools such as problem tree analysis and a responsibilities matrix. (Detailed reports of the RTDs and FGD/KIIs are included as Annex 2). Primary Data Collection – Round Table Discussions and Focus Group Discussions Round Table Discussions (RTDs) 9 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Between ten to fifteen participants from four major groups of stakeholders (children, youth, women and key stakeholders) were invited for a one day workshop to discuss the importance of issues, causes and consequences of issues affecting children and women. The following table outlines the participants for each group invited. Table 1: RTD Participants Participant Group Women Children Youth Key Stakeholders Topics to be discussed Rights of Health Education Livelihoods Political Participation Social Issues Rights of: Survival Development Protection Participation Rights of: Survival Development Protection Participation Rights of: Survival Development Protection Participation Social Issues Political Participation Participant Profile 10 – 12 participants from the following groups: Govt NGO Private Organizations 10-12 participants Range of students from ages of 10 – 14 years old. Equal gender balance. 10 – 12 participants from age of 14 – 18 years old. Equal gender balance. 10 – 12 representatives from relevant line government ministries, NGOs/CBOs, media, and private charitable institutions Summary of RTDs Children’s Rights/Issues Both Children and youth groups expressed a strong desire to be involved in decision making, especially as related to family matters. All three groups indicated that there is a need for more extracurricular and recreational activities both in and out of school. Child protection issues centered around child abuse, drug use and sexual exploitation. The issue of corporal punishment was raised by key stakeholders but interestingly not in the Children or Youth groups, which may indicate that corporal punishment is not being used in the school system, or at least is not seen as a problem by students. The issue of Harmful Traditional Practices was not raised by the Children or Youth group but came out strongly as a leading issue in both the women’s and key stakeholder discussions. This issue may be too sensitive for younger participants to feel comfortable discussing in a formal setting. Even though the issue of Female Genital Mutilation was ranked one of the priority issues according to the women’s group, it was 10 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 tabled for further analysis and discussion, the overall sentiment was one of frustration and that ‘nothing would change it’. This issue had been recently removed from the Women’s Act passed by parliament in April 2010, with the explanation of long standing traditional beliefs and practices that seem to dominate attitudes concerning harmful traditional practices. Health care was the major issue raised in the Child Rights’ Survival category, as most participants thought that access to quality health care was critical for continued development but that quality services were not as accessible as needed. Additionally all three groups expressed the need for clean water and good sanitation. Children and Youth felt that in addition to free basic education, freedom of expression was important for their development. Key stakeholders stressed not only basic education as important to overall child development but also the need for Early Childhood Development (ECD) programming and traditional parental practices such as story telling. Women Rights/Issues In general the women’s group and the key stakeholder group (8 men and 1 woman) identified many of the same issues that affect women’s rights. In both groups illiteracy, low retention rate for girls (after primary school), poor maternity care, FGM, unfair inheritance laws, heavy work load for women, rural women in particular, early marriage, prostitution for ‘economic survival’ and sex tourism were listed as some of the most important issues that affect women’s rights. The Women’s group expressed disappointment and some frustration about the removal of important issues such as FGM, inheritance, divorce and marriage laws from the recently passed Women’s Act 2010. They also emphasized the issue of male dominance in family, community and national issues compared to the male dominated Key Stakeholder group. Although men did recognize that there was a male dominance in household and community issues and that women did not hold political office in equal numbers. In general and not surprisingly, it seemed that participants in the Women’s group raised issues that directly affect their daily life and that of their children. There was much discussion about the unfairness of inheritance laws, property rights and the ease of divorce in traditional laws. The Key Stakeholders group looked more broadly at some of the issues affecting the overall rights of women and children. Participants recognized inherent inequalities throughout systems and structures and expressed beliefs that these inequalities should cease. Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) and Key Informant Interviews (KIIs) 11 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In order to gather important information regarding the status of children and women, FGDs and KIIs were conducted in all six regions of the Gambia. The target groups for the community based FGDs were women, children, men and duty bearers such as MPs, Kafo Leaders, Akailos and one representative of the most vulnerable in the community. Selection of the villages/communities was stratified based on the following criteria: Village sizes between 500 and 1500: The population size of these villages was important as they had to be large enough to represent varied opinions yet manageable to mobilize participants quickly. Distance from the main road/ highway: The problem of access to basic social services is often encountered in villages far from the highway. Ethnic grouping: In order to ensure equitable distribution, the FGDs aimed to meet with some of the various ethnic groups in The Gambia. The FGDs and KIIs were carried out in the following communities. Table 2: List of Villages/communities in FGDs and KIIs Community/Village District Banjul Central Kotu A district in Banjul Serrekunda WestKMC Foni Bintang - WR Bintang Bambali Medina Sancha Kuntaur Fula Kunda Diabugu Ba Sillah Upper Badibou/NBR Kiang East/LRR Nianija/CRRN Fuladu East/URRS Population (2003 Census) 9, 094 11844 Estimated distance from highway In the capital city On the highway 632 10 – 15 km 1,144 >20km Mixed but mainly Jola Mandinka 827 986 1230 >20km 3km 10km? Wolof Fula Sarahule Main Ethnic group Wolof Mixed Summary of Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) and Key Informant Interviews (KIIs) Focus Group Discussions Children Focus Groups Education - Education was the most important issue raised by children during FGDs, specifically access to post primary education facilities as there were no secondary schools in any of the villages where the survey was conducted. (In Kotu there are only private secondary schools.) The high cost of transportation, lack of teachers in schools, shortage of learning materials and high cost of lodging( if schools were far), and distance to schools were the issues raised as deterrents to education, especially secondary education. Many students explained that they would like access to vocational or alternative training centers as an alternative to secondary schools. Girls’ 12 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 education remains an issue in predominantly Sarahule areas as traditional practices tend to include early marriage and beliefs that do not favor ‘western education’. Health Access to health care was another important raised by children’s groups. The lack of access to major medical facilities and the high cost of medication or the lack of commonly needed medication were discussed. Malaria and diarrhea were the two leading reasons gave as to why children go to medical facilities Women Focus Groups WASH The most important issue which was raised throughout all the Women Focus Groups was access to water. Specifically the lack of, or difficultly to access to clean water in terms of; distance to wells, depth of wells from which to pull water, open wells that are not clean and wells that contain only hard water that is not good to drink or easy to wash clothes. In urban areas, not all households have piped water or access to wells and must buy water from neighbors with taps, which is prohibitively expensive. Health and Nutrition Poor maternal health care was raised as the second priority issues for women, specifically relating to emergency obstetric care. The distance to health facilities and the quality of the roads were mentioned as reasons that led to maternal or infant death. Additionally, the high cost or unavailability of medications was also raised by women. A lack of vegetables, which are needed for good nutrition and health or seasonal availability to vegetables, was raised by women. This was due in part to small scale farming, a lack of water and pervasive animal grazing. Work load References to the heavy work load were brought up during the discussions with women, with the need for labor saving devices such as milling machines, plowing services and water taps or well. Additionally, women stated that there are no multipurpose centers in which to practice and apply acquired vocation skills. Credit buying of groundnuts by parastatals is an issue for both women and men as payment for production is often delayed for up to six months. This severely restricts their ability to adequately provide for their families for a significant part of the year. 13 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Key Informant Interviews Many of the issues which were raised during the FGDs were also brought up by KIs, such as access to health services, limited water supply, and issues around labour and workloads. Education in the KIIs was not listed as a priority issue, but reference to urban migration for work or educational opportunities was discussed. Health and WASH Difficulties to access health care, such as distance and poor road conditions, plus the high cost of, or lack of needed medications were also brought up during KIIs. Sanitation was raised as few households have toilet facilities. It was noted that community toilets have not proven to be effective as they are not maintained so most people must use the bush for personal hygiene activities. The KIIs agreed that the wells were often difficult to access. Additionally, a lack of electricity in areas that had once had power, but had experienced power shortages was brought up by some of the KIIs. Representatives of the most vulnerable groups who were usually members of the poorest household explained that their priority was on economic empowerment which related to agricultural production, such as access to seed, fertilizer, and draft animals. Secondary Data Collection – Desk Review A thorough Desk Review of relevant documents was essential to the development of the Situation Analysis. Some of the documents that were reviewed are listed below. (Annex 3 contains the full Document Source List.) Previous UNICEF SitAns in The Gambia Relevant policy documents related to women and children State Party report to UNCRC and CEDAW Alternative NGO reports to UNCRC and CEDAW MICS 2005/6 Statistics such as HMIS, EMIS, and CSR Poverty Reduction Strategy II CCA 2005/2006 MDG report and previous similar reports Relevant UNICEF studies or reports Sectoral or thematic reports and background documents. 14 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Chapter 2. Country Context In order to better understand the complex dynamics that directly impact the lives of children and women, a brief overview of the country profile and important contextual references are presented in this chapter, including The Gambia some of the social, political and economic Human Development Index Rankings conditions that affect the rights of Children and HDI Ranking 168 out of 182 Life Expectancy 55.7 years Women. 2.1. Geography INSERT Map of The Gambia 2.1.1. Land and land tenure issues With a total land area of only 10, 689 square kilometres, The Gambia is the smallest country on the African continent. The Gambia is made up of a narrow strip of land approximately 400 kilometers long and 30 kilometers wide, which lies on the West Coast of Africa. The country forms an enclave within Senegal with a small coast line opening onto the Atlantic Ocean on the west. The country’s low elevation put some of the areas such as the capital, Banjul, at significant risk from any rise in sea level. Men 54.1 Women 57.3 Gross enrolment rate 46.8 U5 Mortality Lowest wealth quintile 158 Highest wealth quintile 72 Urban Population 1990 38.3 % 2010 58.1 %t GDP 2007 $1, 225 GDP growth rate 0.3 % Health and Education Government Expenditure on Health as percentage of total govt expenditure 8.7 % Government Expenditure on Education as percentage of total govt expenditure 8.9 % Gender 4 women in National Assembly Ration of est. female to male income 63 (women make 63 cent for every dollar men earn.) GDI Ranking 141 Adult Literacy* Women 38 percent ** Men 49.9 percent Estimated earned income* (PPP US$) Women $951 Men $1499 *In the absence of recent data, estimates for 2005 UNESCO statistic were based on outdated census or survey information and should be interpreted with caution. ** Literacy rate from EMIS The Gambia’s main geographical feature from which it derives its name is the Gambia River, which runs through the entire country. Banjul, the capital, is situated on an island at the estuary of the river. Formally, the river was used to a large extent for the transportation of groundnuts, the main export crop of The Gambia, from the rural areas where it is grown to the port area in Banjul for export. Ownership of land in the Gambia is traditionally based on membership in a clan of common decent by inheritance, communal holding and individual inheritance8. These practices along with traditional inheritance laws, create an unequal distribution of land, with predominant ownership by men or at the community level, which result in women having access to land usage, but not ownership or control. 8 Government of The Gambia, ‘The Gambia National Gender Policy 2010- 2020’ GoTG. 15 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 2.1.2 Climate The typically Sahelian climate in the Gambia is characterized by a long uninterrupted dry season from November to May. Hot, humid weather predominates the rest of the year, with a rainy season from June – October during which temperatures may rise as high as 43 C. Rainfall in most parts of the country is about 1, 020 mm ranging from 800 mm in the East to 1, 700 mm in the west although a decrease in rainfall has been witnessed in the past few years. Persistent years of drought in the 1970’s right through to the 1980’s have exacerbated an already rapid rate of desertification, which is further intensified by the increase in population. The North Bank of the river and the eastern parts of the country are the worst affected by desertification. Population increase has led to an increase in demand for food and housing with destruction of vegetation and forest cover as natural outcomes. Drought and increased desertification has also lead to a decrease in agricultural production which has a direct impact on the income and food security of rural households. This has resulted in increased rural – urban migration, which increases the demand on basic services on an already crowded and over burdened urban population. Global Climate change also affects regional weather patterns, which has an impact on agricultural production, internal migration, poverty and food security in The Gambia. It is difficult to summarily generalize the effects of climate change which need to be measured over extended periods of time. (Climate change is addressed in more detail in Chapter 8.) 2.1.3 Coastal and Soil Erosion As a natural environmental condition and due in part to climate change, coastal and soil erosion is one of the major issues that present an ongoing challenge to The Gambia government. Coastal erosion, which directly impacts the tourist beach areas, is estimated by the National Environmental Agency to be approximately two meters annually.9 Soil erosion of arable land is another serious challenge that influences the level of poverty and food security (both access and availability) in the country. Continuous or over cropping and slash and burn agricultural techniques exacerbate the problem of soil 9 United Nations Statistics Division, ‘State of the Environment Statistics in The Gambia’, http/unstats.un.org/unsd/ENVIRONMENT/gambia 16 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 erosion and sedimentation, and result in overgrazing in, or agricultural production on marginal land areas10. 2.2. Demography 2.2.1. Ethnic groups There are five distinct major groups that have various historical and cultural backgrounds, speak different languages and co-exist with other minority groups:11. The Mandinka form the largest ethnic group (36 percent ), the Fula, the second largest (22 percent ), the Wolof, the third largest (15 percent ) and the Jola are the fourth largest (11 percent), and the smallest is the Serahule at 8 percent and the rest of the Gambian population belong to much smaller ethnic groups such as the Serer, Creole, Manjago, etc. Chart 1: Total Population distribution by Ethnicity Source: Population and Housing Census 2003 The strength of rich ethnic diversity as is demonstrated in The Gambia has contributed to a unique national identify and culture which incorporates some of the best aspects of the various ethnic groups. Nevertheless, there are a few traditional practices as supported by some ethnic groups that restrict the rights of women and children. Harmful traditional practices are further explored in Chapter Four. 2.2.2. Population size, density and age structure According to the Population and Housing Census 2003, the population of The Gambia is 1,364,507, with a growth rate of 2.77 percent from 1993 – 2003. Using this growth rate, World Bank estimates that in 2010, the Gambian population will be 1,795,242 (an 10 United Nations Statistics Division, ‘State of the Environment Statistics in The Gambia’, http/unstats.un.org/unsd/ENVIRONMENT/gambia 11 The ethnic breakdown does not include individuals of other nationalities who are currently residing in The Gambia. 17 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 almost 25 percent increase in population). This substantial increase has implications on the social service sector in regards to the equitable distribution of limited resources. The Gambia is one of the most densely populated countries in Africa (8th most densely populated), with a overall population density of 127 per square kilometer. Urban areas are much more crowded than rural areas, with Banjul and Kanifing with population densities of 2,867 and 4272 respectively. In comparison, rural areas have relatively low population density levels, such as in Mansakonko - 45 per sq kilometer and 54 per sq kilometer in Kuntaur. There is a youthful population with 53 percent of the population less than twenty years old. Women of reproductive ages (15 – 49 years old) make up 49.6 percent of the total female population and there are slightly more women (50.6 percent ) than men (49.4 percent ). Chart 2: Percentage Distribution by the Population by Age-group and Sex N/S 65+ 60 -64 55 -59 50 -54 45 -49 40 -44 Both Count 35 – 39 Female Count 30 – 34 Male Count 25-29 20 -24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4 0 50,000 100,000 150,000 200,000 250,000 Source: Population and Housing Census 2003 As noted, the Gambia has a youthful population, with nearly 42 percent of the population under the age of 15 years and 22 percent aged between 15 and 24 years (2003 population census). This large proportion has unique needs and requirements which have to be met in order to maximize their input into the development of the country and to minimize the threat of social disorder. Health, sexuality, education and 18 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 employment are but a few of the areas of particular concern to this segment of the population12. In the Gambian context, early marriage, teenage pregnancy, substance abuse and unemployment are worthy of mention as they inhibit the realization of the full potential of young people. Growth in the job market is not keeping pace with the high turn-over of school leavers and as a result there is high unemployment among the youth. This provides further evidence of the need to consider the youth population factor in economic development strategies. 2.2.3. Household size and structure Households in the Gambia average around eight (8.3) persons, with an average of 6.8 persons and 10.7 persons in urban and rural households, respectively. Basse has the highest household size (14.2) and Banjul the lowest (4.8). Larger households in rural areas can be partly attributed to the patriarchal nature of Gambia society where a preference for a male child is prevalent and the common practice of polygamy which tends to increase competition to produce children among the various wives.13 Table 3: Local Gov’t Area/Residence Household Size by LGA, 2003 Census Hhld size Banjul 5.6 Kanifing 6.3 Brikama 8.3 Mansakonko 8.3 Kerewan 9.2 Kuntaur 10.6 Janjanbureh 10.3 Basse 14.2 Urban* 6.8 Rural 10.7 Overall Average 8.3 Source: Population and Housing Census 2003 2.2.4. Population Policy In 1992, the Government of The Gambia adopted a National Population Policy in response to adverse economic conditions and rapid deforestation aggravated by high The Daily Observer Newspaper, ‘Population and Employment’, The Daily Observer, November 2009. Sagnia, ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, GoTG, August 2010, pg 37. 12 13 19 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 population growth. The policy, designed to curb the rapid rate of population growth, has the overall goal of improving the quality of life and raising the standard of living of the population. This policy was first revised in 1996 and then later in 2006 to reflect the current demographic and socio-economic realities of the country. The 2007-2015 Policy aims at addressing current population trends which are not commensurate with sustainable socio-economic and environmental development. The overall goals of the 2007-2015 National Population Policy are the same as those of the 1992 and 1996 policies, which sought to improve the quality of life by raising the standard of living of the population. An attempt has been made to harmonise the National Population Policy with other national policies, such as the National Education Policy, the Gambia Environment Action Plan, the Housing, Health and Family Planning policies. Among the targets of the National Population Policy were: Reduction of the maternal mortality rate from 1, 050 per 100, 000 live births (1990) to 800 per 100, 000 live births by 2000 and to 500 per 100, 000 live births by 2004. Reduction of the total fertility rate from 6.0 in 1993 to 5.0 by 2004 Reduction of IMR from 84 per 1, 000 in 1993 to 72 per 1, 000 by 2000 and to 56 per 1, 000 by 2004 The most recent data on the above targets indicate that although well intentioned have not been realized. The following table demonstrates that there are significant gaps in all the policy targets. Table 4: The Gambia Population Policy Target compared to Most Recent Data Indicator Maternal Mortality Rate Baseline for PP 1.050/100,000 Target of PP by 2004 500/100,000 Most recent data* 730/100,000 Total Fertility 6.0 5.0 5.4 Infant Mortality Rate 84/1,000 56/1,000 93/1,000 Gaps 230100,000 or 32 percent reduction needed to meet target 0.4 8 percent reduction needed to meet target 37/1,000 or a 66 percent reduction needed to meet target *Sources for Most Recent Data MMR 733/100,000 – Prenatal, antenatal, postnatal and contraceptive use Study 2001 Fertility rate is 5.4 – Census 2003 IMR 93/1,000 - MICS 2005/06 20 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 2.3. Political Structure and System The Gambia received independence from Britain in 1965. At that time, The Gambia had a monarchical constitution until 1970 when it became a Republic, with a President as Head of State and Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces. The executive was further enlarged by the appointment of a Vice President and Ministers selected by the President from among the members of Parliament. The Vice President and Ministers together made up the Cabinet. Parliament, to which legislative power of the Republic is vested, consists of the President and fifty-one members who have the power to create laws for peace and good governance. The Constitution went at length to create three distinct arms of Government in accordance with the doctrine of separation of powers. This parliamentary system of Government continued until July 1994 when a change of power occurred in The Gambia. After three years of rule by decree, the Second Republican Constitution came into being in 1997. This Second Republican Constitution also upholds the doctrine of the separation of powers and makes provision for the protection of fundamental human rights. The structure of Government under the 1997 Constitution is one with an Executive President and a Cabinet appointed from outside the National Assembly. The Legislature is distinct from the Executive and National Assembly members can remove from office members of the Executive, as a check on the powers. This authority also emphasises the separation of powers between the arms of Government. The Vice President is the first and longest serving female Vice President in Africa, which should set a precedence for women’s political participation, yet the number of women in the National Assembly and in local government positions is proportionately low. (Only four women members out of 53 members of parliament. Of the four members, two were elected and two were nominated by the President.) 14 The country is divided into eight administrative areas; six regions and two municipalities. The six regions are the Central North, Central South, Lower River Region, Upper River Region, North Bank Region and Western Region. Banjul and Kanifing are classified as municipalities and are governed by an elected Mayor. The regions are governed by Regional Governors who are appointed directly by the President. The six regions are divided further into 36 Districts headed by Chiefs 15 , which are appointed by the President. Prior to the constitution, Chieftaincy posts were governed by customary law. 14Women’s Bureau, ‘Key Informant Interview’, October 2010. The role of the District Chief is primarily to disseminate information and serve as head of District Tribunals. 15 21 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Traditionally, eligibility for chieftaincy centered on land ownership, and as such women were for the most part, excluded from eligibility. (There are 1873 male Akailos and only 5 women, there are no women who are currently serving as District Chiefs16.) There are currently government efforts to decentralize authority in order to help ensure that the provision of social services is more equitable, especially to rural areas. The newly drafted PAGE Policy clearly outlines the goal of decentralization as one of the major areas for intervention in order to accelerate decentralization to enhance the autonomy of the local governments and make them more responsible for the provision and financing of the basic social services.17 The 1997 Constitution, Section 33 Subsection (4), clearly prohibits all forms of discrimination based on sex. The entrenched bill of rights does not afford protection for any discrimination which stems from a person’s personal or customary law. Since the personal or customary law of a majority of Gambians is not written and therefore not easily ascertainable, this poses a serious restriction on the protection against discrimination. Broad policy changes have also been introduced which require further legislation for their implementation. The Constitution also makes provision for the modification and review of laws which are inconsistent with it. This revision is yet to be implemented. 2.4. Social Systems, Structure and Policies – focusing on specific issues related to education, protection and health that affect children and women 2.4.1.1. Social Organization and family structure The predominately patriarchal Gambia society and many cultural practices and customary laws tend to place women and children in subordinate roles, and (and girls and boys are assigned different roles. For mostly socio-cultural reasons, women and children are not accorded the same status in society as men in regards to access to control and ownership of productive assets, decision making and participation in development activities. Within the household structure, the husband is traditionally considered the head of the family and takes responsibility for most of the decisions that affect the family, such as how money is spent on education, health and the high expenditure items (bicycles, radios, etc) Women traditionally have responsibility for the family welfare and provision of daily meals, but they do not have equal access to, control and ownership of land 16 17 Women’s Bureau. Government of The Gambia, ‘National Development Strategy 2012 – 2015’, 2010 and PAGE 22 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 under communal tenure system or private ownership, except through their fathers or husbands. If this occurs, it is usually on a loan basis and must be returned18. Some of the customary practices make women and children more vulnerable to discrimination. For example, Islamic inheritance law as practiced favors males to females on a 2 to 1 ratio. Men who choose to divorce their wives, at times may place them in a precarious situation, with little or no rights to the family home or keeping her children. Girls are especially vulnerable to discriminatory practices such as early marriage and FGM/C. The Women’s Act 2010 addresses some of these issues such as inheritance, divorce and FGM/C. Yet the inclusion of the phrase ‘unless customary law applies’ tends to dilute or even negate the intent of legislation on these issues. In urban areas, the household which is smaller than in rural areas19 is structured around the nuclear family structure, usually consisting of one family unit or an extended family unit. EXPAND 2.4.1.2. Role of children and women in social organization As outlined, under Gambia’s 1997 Constitution, men and women are accorded full and equal rights. However, women do experience discrimination and inequality, which is largely due to the traditionally patriarchal social structure of The Gambia. Traditional roles of women are recognized, and have been reinforced by the patriarchal nature of the Gambian society. Gambia is based on a dual legal system: the civil law inspired by the British system and the Islamic Sharia. Provisions in Sharia related to marriage, such as divorce and inheritance apply within the legal context. In general, Gambians live in large households, which are reflective of the extended family. At the community level, the Kabilio system exists, which is a cluster of households that have biological or social links and which are usually headed by a male clan leader. Women usually have submissive roles within the Kabilio structural unit, although this is changing as there are five women Akailos 20. Children are afforded degrees of protection which stem from living in a family unit as structured within the family and Kabilio system21. ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, GoTG, August 2010. 19 Government of The Gambia, ‘PHC 2003’, approximately seven persons per household in urban areas and eleven in rural households. 20 Women’s Bureau, ‘Key Informant Interview’, October 2010. 21 International Federation of Human Rights, ‘Note on the Situation of Women in The Gambia’, FIDH, July 2005. 18Sagnia, 23 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There are also village economic structures exist as well on the community level which are comprised of both men and women and are responsible for … Decision Making Children and Youth participants in the RTDs expressed frustration at the fact that they had little influence in decision making at home, in the community or in school. While children are accorded representation on School Management Committees, the level of input they contribution is questionable due to the subordinate role children have in the company of adults. Women’s groups in the RTDs and FGDs also attributed a lack of input into the decision making process as one of the key causes for many of the problems identified such as male dominated land ownership, a disparity in political power and rights, issue regarding sex, fertility and the number and spacing of children, and inequitable decision making that affect the household spending. Marriage and Divorce There are four forms of marriage: Christian marriages, Mohammedan marriages which are governed by Sharia law, civil marriages and customary marriages 22 . The 1997 Constitution states that all marriages shall be between women and men of full capacity and based on the free and full consent of the intended parties except under customary law where the idea of child betrothal still exists. As the Gambia is predominantly Muslim (95 percent), the vast majority of Gambian women are governed by customary and Sharia law through their family relationships. Polygamy is practiced and also permissible under Sharia law, which allows Muslim men to take up to four wives. The wives have the option to divorce, and under customary law should be informed by the husband of subsequent marriage, but no legal right to approve of further marriages. During the RTDs, some participants from the women’s group expressed concern over the liberalization of divorce laws, stating that ‘it was too easy to divorce’ and that this was leading to the ‘denigration of the social structure’. Other participants during the same RTD said that the laws gave women more freedom to leave marriages that were not working well. Inheritance laws International Federation of Human Rights, ‘Note on the Situation of Women in The Gambia’, FIDH, July 2005. 22 24 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Islamic Sharia has detailed and complex calculations for inheritance shares. A woman may inherit from her father, her mother, her husband, her children, and under certain conditions, from other members of her family, but her share is generally only around half of a man’s entitlement23. Land ownership In the Gambia, most communities adhere to traditional Land Tenure System and as a result women do not have full control over the use and ownership of land, but are allowed to use the land for agricultural purpose. Men maintain ultimate control of the land and are primarily involved in cash crop production such as Groundnut, Coos and Millet. Women produce 80 percent of vegetables and 99 percent of the staple food, Rice. Both men and women are involved in fish processing and livestock rearing. Women’s access to credit has improved but still below that of men. In some situations, particularly in the rural areas, a woman may access credit, but do not control its use indicating the existence of socio –cultural barriers24. Due to primarily to traditional practices, the majority of land in The Gambia is owned by men or village structures. The implications of this disparity impact the economic status of women and their ability to access credit, which again limits their economic opportunities. According to research carried out at the University of The Gambia, The lack of appropriate technology, irrigation facilities and their low level of participation in decision making, hence there is a need to allocate land to women to expand the economic and commercial activities for them to be empowered economically25. Access to Credit Laws do not discriminate in the area of access to bank loans or credit facilities. In theory, a woman is entitled to borrow money from a financial institution once she meets the conditions set forth by the financial institution. However there are a number of obstacles faced by women. Most financial institutions will not grant credit facilities to any person unless that person has an adequate security or collateral. In most cases, they will insist on property in the form of land as security or collateral. And since access to land is International Federation of Human Rights, ‘Note on the Situation of Women in The Gambia’, FIDH, July 2005. 24 Government of The Gambia, ‘The Gambian National Gender Policy 2010-2020’. 25 University of The Gambia, Research Findings by Mrs. D’Almeida, Senior Lecturer, University of The Gambia, 2009. 23 25 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 problematic for women in the Gambia, women (especially rural women) have limited access to credit or loans. 2.4.1.2. Economic roles and institutions Women’s control over household spending Trade policies, like any other economic policy, are likely to have gender differentiated effects because of women’s and men’s different access to, and control over, resources, and because of their different roles in both the market economy and the household. Gender inequalities have various dimensions. Macro-level analysis involves examining the gender division of the labor force between the different productive market sectors and the reproductive sectors. Meso level analysis looks at the institutions that help structure the distribution of resources and activities at the micro-level. It involves examining gender inequalities in public provision as well as gender biases in the rules of operation of labor, commodity and other markets. Micro-level analysis examines in greater detail the gender division of labor, resources and decision-making, particularly within the household. It is the latter we concentrate on here. By changing employment opportunities and earnings patterns of women and men, trade liberalization is likely to influence the allocation of time and resources among household members. For example, an increase in the market value of a woman’s time that would prove profitable and add to the family income may lead her to spend more time on market-oriented activities. At the same time, this cash incentive may motivate the husband to reallocate some of his time into domestic work or other non-paid activities. Which food and non-food items are purchased, in what quantities, and how these are distributed among household members, will also be affected by who earns the income. Since women and men, younger and older people, have different needs and preferences (for example, for health care and nutrition) reallocation of both time and consumption goods will differently affect their welfare. Household spending patterns The following table indicates that both men and women spend the majority of income on food as the top priority, with farming, education and health expenditures following. While the information gathered indicates where household income is spent, it does not reveal who has made the decision as to how and on what it is spent. Unfortunately this information is not available. Chart Household Expenditure Categories in The Gambia disaggregated by Sex 26 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Total Mean 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Farming Business Health Education Food Ceremonies Travel Clothing Farming Business Health Education Food Ceremonies Travel Clothing Total Mean F F F F F F F F M M M M M M M M Source: A Socioeconomic Study on Gender Dynamics in the Household and the Communities: Gender – Related Aspects of Household and Community Resource Allocation and their Impact on Agricultural Production, Marketing and Household Food Security, CRS In the Gambia, cultural practices tend to militate against women’s control of cash income thereby contributing to household food insecurity. Women face low nutritional status at household level compared to men, despite the fact that, they are the main producers and processors of food. Some of these traditional practices also force women to deny themselves food in the right quantity and quality in favor of male adults and children. In most cases this seriously compromises their nutritional status26. 2.4.1.3. Influence of Religion The Gambia is predominantly Muslim (approximately 95 percent ). The application of both civil law (based on the British system) and the Islamic Sharia law directly impacts the rights of women and children. Provisions under Sharia law related to marriage such as divorce and inheritance, which can often favor men, are routinely applied within the legal context in The Gambia. Islam has a powerful influence particularly in uniting various peoples in the country across cultural and ethnic barriers. Islamic principles, customs, beliefs and codes of behaviour are widespread and affect almost every aspect of life in The Gambia for Muslims. 26 ‘Gender Profile’, 2008. 27 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Perhaps one of the reasons Islam has been so readily accommodated in the Senegambia region is its harmonisation with traditional African beliefs and values particularly regarding gender roles. Like traditional conceptions of gender discussed previously, Islam places significant emphasis on the responsibility of the man to protect and provide for the material upkeep of his wife and children and the responsibility of the woman to provide the necessary care and to nurture her husband and children.27 More important, Islam permits polygamy, albeit under specific conditions, which was an established custom among the various ethnic groups in the region28. Although The Gambia is mostly Muslim, there is a strong Christian influence in areas such as civil law (based on Canon Law that has it’s origins from the Bible), and the Gambia education system, which is further outlined below. 2.4.2. National Structures, Systems and Policies 2.4.2.1. Education The Gambia education system follows a 6-3-3-4 cycle as per the following table. Table 5: Gambia Education Structure Education level Years of study/age Certificate/Exam/Degree Lower Basic School 6 years/ages 7–13 Grade six Placement Exam has been phased out Upper Basic School 3 years/ages 13–16 Basic Education Certificate Exam Senior Secondary School 3 years/ages 16–19 West African Senior Secondary Certificate Examination (WASSCE) University (undergrad) 4 years Bachelor’s degree University (grad) 1+ years Master’s degree While the official language of instruction throughout the Gambian educational system is English, the majority of students, especially in rural areas do not speak English when entering primary school. This can create a particularly challenging learning environment for both teachers and students, as students must learn English while simultaneously learning basic subject matter. 27 Certain groups of Muslims do not adhere to these beliefs. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘The Situation of Children and Women in The Gambia’, GoTG, UNICEF, Nov. 2001. 28 28 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Lower Basic and Upper Basic Schools (Grades 1-9): Until 2002, primary education lasted for six years and led to the Primary School Leaving Certificate (phased out). Secondary education was divided into junior secondary schools, which offered a threeyear course leading to the Junior School Leaving Certificate, and Senior Secondary schools which offered a three-year course. Since 2002, a new unified basic education system was introduced covering 1-9 years, through an automatic transition with no examination at the end of the lower basic cycle. The cycle is divided into two cycles: lower basic (Grades I–VI) and upper basic (Grades VII–IX). There are 368 Lower basic schools and 89 Upper basic schools in the Gambia. There is another type of school system called the basic cycle schools which is a combination of the lower and upper basic school (grades 1-9). All Gambian students take the Basic Education Certificate Examination (BECE) at the end of grade 9 (ninth grade) in nine or ten subjects. Admission to Senior Secondary/High School is competitive. The vast majority of Gambian students attend government schools (75 percent ); there are a growing number of private and international private secondary schools in the country offering Cambridge IGCSE/ O Levels or the Government’s WASSCE. Table 6: Number of Schools in The Gambia Total Number of Schools Age group 574 percent of Total Total Number of Basic Cycle School (combination of the lower and upper Basic School) 7-19 62 11 percent Total Number of Lower Basic Schools 7-13 368 64 percent Total Number of Upper Basic Schools 13-19 89 16 percent Total Number of Senior Secondary School 16-19 55 10 percent Source: National Statistic Abstract, Academic year 2006/2007 Provisions for most vulnerable populations As outlined in the National Education Policy (2004-2015), the Gambian education system is premised on a non-discriminatory and all-inclusive provision of education, which emphasises gender equity and targeting of the poor and disadvantaged groups29. 29 Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’ , July 2009, pg. 34 29 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Nevertheless, the majority of secondary schools are located in urban or peri - urban areas which significantly limits the opportunity for rural children to attend post primary education institutions, which will also result in limiting future economic status and employment opportunities to higher paying jobs which require secondary or post secondary education. As shown in the chart below, there are XXX fewer secondary schools in rural areas. ADD geographical distribution Chart Education Policy 2004-2015 The aims and objectives of education in The Gambia are in line with the educationrelated Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), Education for All (EFA) goals, the New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD) education-related goals and the country's Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP). The policy priorities are identified to allow for the growth of educational opportunities and improve the effectiveness of education at all levels, from early childhood development (ECD) to higher education. While other national policies have set quantitative targets which might be easier to measure, the education policy sets general policy goals which if successful will result in a holistic education system developing the student in terms of knowledge, skills and civil responsibility. The basic aims of the Education Policy are: 1. To promote a broad-based education at the basic level for lifelong learning and training. 2. To mainstream gender in the creation of opportunities for all to acquire literacy, livelihood skills and the utilization of these skills in order to earn a living and become economically self-reliant members of the communities. 3. To develop the physical and mental skills, which will contribute to nation building - economically, socially and culturally in a sustainable environment? 4. To encourage creativity and the development of a critical and analytical mind. 5. To further an understanding and appreciation of the contribution of science and technology to development. 6. To cultivate sound moral and ethical values in the development of life skills. 7. To develop a healthy body and an appreciation of the value of a healthy mind in response to life threatening diseases like HIV/AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis. 8. To create an awareness of the importance of peace, democracy and human rights, duties and responsibilities of the individual in fostering these qualities. 9. To foster an appreciation of and respect for the cultural heritage of The Gambia. 10. To promote a sense of patriotism: service, loyalty, integrity and dedication to the nation and humanity 30 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Considering the high population growth rate, the cost of education in relation to the poor and the current share of education in the government budget, the policy has been prioritized in the following five components aimed at providing equitable access to high quality education to the population of the country: Access to Education; Quality Education; Vocational and Technical Education; Tertiary and Higher Education. There have been factors that indicate a successful implementation of the policy such as a good working relationship between the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education (MoBSE) and partners, a well defined organization structure, a focused policy framework, strong coordination mechanisms, and strong political and donor support to the education sector. For example, the education sector has received significant funding from Education for All, and Fast Track Initiative Funding, as well as World Bank, the African Development Bank, and DfID education programming funds, which are channeled through the SWAP.30 Challenges In spite of some of the successes, there are some challenges which still afflict the sector. These challenges focus on the overall goals of access, quality, resources and management. While gender parity has been realized in primary schools, there are still some disparities between boys and girls in enrolment, retention and performance at senior secondary level. The retention of qualified teachers and other important personnel remains difficult. The education sector is limited by insufficient financial resources. These challenges have not been properly addressed by the policy and the strategic plan, and result to a gap in the achievement of children’s rights in the education sector.31 The relevance of the curriculum is another challenge that needs to be addressed in order to ensure the provision of relevant skills and knowledge for the ever changing economic and employment environment. 2.4.2.2. Health The Primary Health Care (PHC) strategy was introduced in 1979 as a government response to some of the many challenges which affect the provision of quality of health care. 30 31 Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, July 2009. Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, July 2009. 31 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The PHC strategy aims to improve access and affordability of heath care throughout the Gambia. One of the key components of the PHC in improving access and affordability is to target villages and communities with populations of over 400. For each PHC village, a village health worker (VHW) and a traditional birth attendant (TBA) are trained to provide basic health services in the community. There are currently 546 PHC villages in the Gambia and five governmental hospitals located in Banjul, Bwiam, Farafenni, Basse and Bansang. The Royal Victoria Teaching Hospital (RVTH) located in Banjul is the main referral hospital with specialist consulting services. Table 7: Health Care Structure Hospitals Public Health Facilities Public Health Care Communities Within the Public Health Care Strategy Key Villages Village Clinics Reproductive Outreach Community Owned Clinics NGO Clinics Private Clinics 5 43 546 70 23 280 18 22 19 Health Research With a changing trend in disease patterns and low uptakes of effective health services and with subsequent poor health outcomes it was recognized that there was a need to use objective data and information to guide decision making within the health system. It was also recognized that challenges in the social sector for example issues around water and sanitation and inadequate nutrition also had an impact on health. Adopting this holistic approach to health the process of developing a National Research Policy began in 2005. In 2008 the National Health Research Policy was finalized the goal of which is to establish an effective, credible and sustainable health research system in The Gambia based on sound ethical principles. In October 2010 the National health research Strategic plan was presented to a wide range of national stakeholders.(National Health Research Strategic Plan 2010-2014). Health Policy The National Health Policy Framework, 2007-2020, “Health is Wealth”, seeks to address the common health desires of the population through a number of initiatives both in the area of preventive and curative health services. With a vision to improve the 32 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 health of all Gambians with a per capita income of US$ 1,500 by 2020 32, the policy has a mission to promote and protect the health of the population. It seeks to promote equity in access and affordability of quality services, maintain ethics and standards, promote health system reforms, and improve staff retention and client satisfaction. Cognizant of the multi-dimensional nature of health and the potential for health status to be influenced by a variety of factors, a number of areas have been identified in the policy that would collectively have the potential to impact on the health status. Under the current policy, areas identified for interventions relate to health care programmes and clinical care delivery, health system strengthening and capacity development, and technical support services. The policy recognizes the need for community participation and the contribution of traditional medicine to the attainment of the national health goals. Provisions for most vulnerable populations The policy provides for the accessibility and affordability of quality services at point of demand, especially for Women and Children, for the marginalised and poor, irrespective of political, national, ethnic or religious affiliations. According to the policy the population should access twenty-four hour quality essential services 33. Fee free health services are provided for all children under five including birth registration and for ante - natal services for pregnant women. The major targets of the health policy have been identified as follows: 1. To reduce infant mortality rate from 75 per 1000 to 28 per 1000 by 2015 2. To reduce under-5 mortality rate from 99 per 1000 t0 43 per 1000 by 2015 3. To reduce maternal mortality ratio from 730 per 100,000 to 150 per 100,000 by 2015 4. To increase life expectancy at the national level to from 63.4 to 69 years by 2015 5. To increase life expectancy for women from 65 years to 70 years by 2015 6. To increase life expectancy for men from 62.4 years to 68 years by 2015 7. To reduce malaria incidence by 50 percent by 2015 8. To reduce HIV/AIDS prevalence (HIV 1 from 1.1 percent to 0.5 percent and HIV 2 from 0.7 percent to 0,1 percent by 2015) 9. To reduce total fertility rate from 5.4 to 4.6 by 2015 10. To reduce tuberculosis incidence rate from 120 per 100,000 to 60 per 100,000 by 2015 11. To reduce morbidity due to non communicable diseases by 10 percent by 2015 (2007 base) 32 33 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. Chikova, ‘OVC and Social Policy’, 2010, pg. 32. 33 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 12. To reduce morbidity due to other communicable diseases by 50 percent (2007 base) Table 8: Health Policy Goals in Comparison with Most Recent Statistics Health Policy Goal Most recent Gaps data 65 pts or a To reduce infant mortality rate from 75 per 1000 93/1,000 -70 percent to 28 per 1000 by 2015 (MICS change needed 2005/06) To reduce under-5 mortality rate from 99 per 1000 t0 43 per 1000 by 2015 To reduce maternal mortality ratio from 730 per 100,000 to 150 per 100,000 by 2015 131/1,000 (MICS 2005/06) 730/100,000 (MMS) To increase life expectancy at the national level to from 63.4 to 69 years by 2015 55 (HDR 2009) To increase life expectancy for women from 65 years to 70 years by 2015 55.3 (HDR 2009) To increase life expectancy for men from 62.4 years to 68 years by 2015 54.1 (HDR 2009) To reduce malaria incidence by 50 percent by 2015 Data pending To reduce total fertility rate from 5.4 to 4.6 by 2015 5.4 (Census 2003) To reduce tuberculosis incidence rate from 120 per 100,000 to 60 per 100,000 by 2015 Data pending To reduce morbidity due to non communicable diseases by 10 percent by 2015 (2007 base) Data pending To reduce morbidity due to other communicable diseases by 50 percent (2007 base) Data pending 88 pts or a -67 percent change needed 580 pts or a -79 percent change needed 14 pts or -25 percent changed needed 12.7 pts or a -22 percent changed needed 13.9 pts or a – 26 percent changed needed 0.8 pt or a – 8 changed needed 34 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Challenges Some of these challenges, which continue to impact the health sector are a high population growth, a high attrition rate of skilled workers, inadequate financial and logistic support, and the lack of an efficient and effective referral system. There is no co-ordinated, monitoring and evaluation system to measure the performance of the policy; and planning for improvements is a challenge. There should also be in place a collaboration and co-ordination system for the sector so that programmes will not overlap. The policy should consider the issues of OVC when they visit the public health facilities34. It should be clearly mentioned that Reproductive Child Health services for OVC groups are free of charge. When abuses, like rape, happen to children the health institutions are usually the first port of call. The policy should mention services to be provided for such cases. As a sectoral policy, it should mention how programmes for children and women at the health facilities are to be strengthened, as these facilities serve as entry points for HIV screening, identification of OVC and vulnerable children, identification of children at risk of abuse and victims of violence and exploitation35. There are some general challenges in the health sector which are listed as follows. An overall weak Primary Health Care System Lack of an overarching coordinating mechanism such as SWaP, as is used in the education sector Focus on curative rather than preventive care Low retention of qualified heath workers in the provision of health care The lack of a progressive Health Education Promotion Policy to guide or direct important health education activities Under the umbrella of the Health Sector, there was a Social Welfare policy, which was drafted but has yet to be approved. This policy would help to ensure that minimum standards are established, and that directives for important child protection issues are established and monitored, with ensuing penalties for violating child rights. Nutrition 34 35 Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, July 2009. Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, July 2009. 35 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The National Nutrition Agency (NaNA) was established in 2005 by the National Assembly as a coordinating all nutrition and nutrition related activities in The Gambia. Since its inception there have been many achievements made such as developing a Food Act 2005 which led to the regulation regarding breastfeeding, food fortification and salt iodinization , promotion of child feeding practices, the design and implementation of Child Friendly Hospitals and Community Initiatives for the prevention of malnutrition. National Nutrition Policy 2010 – 2020 NaNA is responsible for the implementation of the 2010 – 2020 National Nutrition Policy. The goal of the policy is to attain optimal nutritional requirements of the Gambian population, to assure a healthy and sustainable livelihood. The policy seeks to address the following interventions. 1. Improving maternal nutrition 2. Promoting optimal infant and young child feeding 3. Food and nutrition security at national, community and household levels, 4. Preventing micronutrient malnutrition 5. Improving food standards, quality and safety 6. Nutrition and infectious diseases 7. Preventing and managing diet – related non communicable diseases 8. Caring for the socio- economically deprived and nutritionally vulnerable 9. Nutrition and HIV/AIDS 10. Nutrition in emergency situations 11. Nutrition Surveillance 12. Promoting effective nutrition education 13. Mainstreaming nutrition into development policies, strategies and programmes 14. Policy implementation framework A key factor in the strategies to attain the policy objectives is an intensive information, education and communication (IEC) programme aimed at sensitizing stakeholders to the critical roles in the successful implementation of programmes identified to meet policy objectives36. Water and Sanitation According to the MICS 2005/06, 85 percent of Gambians use improved drinking water sources and 84 percent use improved sanitation facilities. The quality and source of water and sanitation facilities vary among urban and rural, and wealthy and poor households. For example, 95 percent of the wealthiest households have access to improved sources of drinking water, yet only 82 percent of poorest households have this 36 Government of The Gambia, ‘National Nutrition Policy (DRAFT) (2010- 2020)’, 2009. 36 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 same access. In urban areas of Banjul and Kanifing, piped - in water is the most common source of drinking water, while in rural areas, only 10 percent of drinking water is piped. The most common purification method for drinking water in rural areas is straining water which has been collected from a well (protected or unprotected) through a cloth (35 percent in Janajngbureh, and only 2 percent in Banjul). Eighty – four percent of the population sampled for the MICS 2005/06 have use improved sanitation facilities. The type and use of improved sanitation facilities is strongly correlated with wealth and varies greatly between urban and rural populations. In rural areas, pit latrines37 are the most common form of improved sanitation, while in the urban areas, flush toilets are the most common. Water Policy The Water Policy in The Gambia was developed in a consultative manner and builds upon other international water declarations and policies such as the Dublin Statement 1992 and the MDGs. It was drafted and approved, with presidential endorsement in 2006. The overall objectives of the Water Policy are listed below. 1. Acknowledges that access to water is a common right, which is held in trust by the Government on behalf of the people of The Gambia 2. Involves people and places them at the centre of the process, consults widely with stakeholders to achieve the Policy objectives, and builds consensus 3. Places environmental protection and the preservation of the country’s ecological heritage at the forefront of development 4. Defines the necessary administrative structures and defines the procedures required to implement the Policy 5. Outlines the precepts, scope and time scale for a new Water Resources Strategy, which will provide the Policy’s implementation platform 6. Establishes a sound technical rational for managing water resources underpinned by verifiable information, and sound quantifiable hydrometeorological and hydrogeological data 7. Recommends a set of IWRM instruments for assessing and quantifying the available river basin yield (surface and subsurface) for a range of climatic scenarios 8. Describes a process whereby demand can be balanced against available resources, and a framework developed within which equitable and sustainable decisions can be taken on water allocation 9. Provides a long term humanitarian vision for water resources management and development maximising the use of social capital 37 Pit latrines are not considered an improved or adequately clean method of sanitation. 37 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 10. Requires transparency and accountability of those responsible for the custodianship of the country’s water resources The policy outlines the responsibilities of other Gambian agencies in the promotion and provision of water, and outlines that coordination between water and sanitation should be “accepted that no water supply scheme should be implemented without a parallel or complementary sanitation intervention”38. There are some identified gaps in the Water Policy, which include the lack of a strategic plan for the implementation of proposed strategies and specific measures. While sanitation is mentioned, the policy is relatively weak on outlining the complementary roles that exist between water and sanitation. Importantly the revised Water Bill has yet to pass through the National Assembly. National Sanitation Policy (DRAFT) The Draft National Sanitation Policy recognizes that access to basic sanitation is a human right with an overall vision of ‘Improved Sanitation Services for All’. The specific targets identified for the provision of safe water and sanitation services are as follows: 1. All people in The Gambia have access to a functioning basic quality water supply by 2015. The use of unprotected wells is avoided. Besides, the distance to the source of water should not exceed 200 metres. 2. All people in The Gambia have access to functioning basic quality sanitation facilities by 2015. 3. 70 percent of households have access to basic sanitation facility know-how to practice safe sanitation by 2015. 4. All schools have adequate/safe water supply and sanitation facilities by 2015 5. All clinics/health facilities have adequate and safe water supply and sanitation services by 2015. 6. Hygiene education and wise use of water are taught in all schools including the Madrassas by 2010. 7. Free basic water policy is implemented in all local government authorities by 2011. 8. Free basic sanitation policy is implemented in all local government authorities by 2013. 9. Sanitation Policy is adopted and implemented by 2011. 10. Sanitation coordinating structures are established and functional by 2013. GoTG, ‘National Water Policy’, Department of State for Fisheries and Water Resources, GoTG, July 2006 38 38 Sanitation & Hygiene Policy Principles National Sanitation Policy Sanitation and hygiene are essential for healthy living and for Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia sustaining a productive society. 1. Awareness and knowledge are key to behaviour change in sanitation. 2. Carrying the costs of sanitation: polluter-pays-principle should be applied. 3. Access to safe water supply and sanitation are a fundamental human right. 4. There should be a multi-sectoral approach to sanitation. 5. Achieving equity and gender sensitivity is a priority. 6. The private sector should be more involved in the provision of sanitary services. 7. Integrated socioeconomic development respectful of environmental integrity preservation of our life-support system. 8. Sanitation concepts should be developed under consideration of community participation and social intermediation. 9. Strategies should build on what exists and is in demand, including indigenous knowledge, diversity of religious and cultural practices. must be and the The National Sanitation Policy, GoTG 2010 11. Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) is implemented to eliminate open field defecation. Provisions for most vulnerable populations Affordability of sanitation facilities by households is an issue particularly in the rural areas. Fundamentally, people’s access to potable water and basic sanitation needs to be seen as a human right. In ensuring adequate supply of communities, water and sanitation infrastructure ladders should be set, which take into consideration financial capacities of councils and levels of poverty of households. Some of the gaps of the newly developed sanitation policy are that it has yet to be approved by the cabinet. Additionally, the Public Health Act which serves as the legislative framework for the implementation of the policy has not been finalised. And finally the established targets are ambitious within the current socio – economic country situation. 2.4.2.3. Judicial As previously outlined, the judicial system in The Gambia recognises customary, Sharia and common or general law. Customary law covers, for example, traditional marriage, divorce and family matters, inheritance, land tenure and tribal and clan leadership. Sharia law, which has to some extent displaced customary law, is observed primarily in Muslim marriage, family and inheritance matters. Common law, following the English model, provides the residual law. Trials are public and defendants have the right to legal representation at their own cost. The subordinate courts consist of the Cadi (or Khadi) courts (proceedings of which are in Arabic), district tribunals and magistrate’s courts. The Cadi courts have jurisdiction to apply the Shari’a in matters of marriage, divorce, child custody and inheritance where the parties or other interested parties are Muslims. A panel consisting of the Cadi and two other scholars of the Sharia preside at hearings at first instance. Appeals against decisions of Cadi courts are made to the High Court. The Cadi Court in the capital, 39 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Banjul, was constituted in 1905 and is one of only a handful of Muslim Courts established under British rule throughout the world. It is one of two such courts in The Gambia; the other is located in Kanifing some ten miles outside the capital. Situation as of December 2001 to be updated Thirty districts tribunals and magistrate’s courts have jurisdiction to hear less serious criminal and civil proceedings. District tribunals are located in the five administrative centres of the country and deal with matters under traditional laws and custom. There are eight magistrate’s courts, the largest being at Kanifing where several hundred civil and criminal cases are heard each month. Many cases heard by magistrates are noncontentious and are disposed of within a day. The superior courts consist of the High Court, the Gambia Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. The High Court (known as the Supreme Court before 1997) is normally constituted by a single High Court judge. Three judges sit in treason trials. The High Court has original jurisdiction to hear and determine all civil and criminal proceedings and to interpret and enforce the fundamental rights and freedoms provided by the Constitution. It also has jurisdiction in appeals from subordinate courts, and it has supervising jurisdiction over all lower courts and adjudicating authorities. A complex network of relationships exists between the judicial system and a range of agencies and stakeholders. These agencies and stakeholders include the Department of State (or Ministry) for Justice, the Police, the Prison Service, Parliament, the legal profession and civil society. Each agency has its own records and information needs, but the Judiciary’s records and information management systems must also meet requirements for information proved to, received from, and coordinated and shared with these other stakeholders. Juvenile Justice System The Juvenile Justice System (JJS) in The Gambia consists of a network of agencies that deal with juveniles who are in contact/ conflict with the law. These agencies include the children’s court in Kanifing, Department of Social Welfare, the Police, and Juvenile Wing at Jeshwang Prison and the child rights unit at the Ministry of Justice. The responsibility of these actors is to protect the rights of children in contact or conflict with law at every stage of the Juvenile Justice process, in line with the Children’s Act 2005 40 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 and Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) 39 . (The JJS is further detailed in Chapter Four.) 2.5. Economy 2.5.1. Macro Economic Situation Over the past two decades, the growth rate of per capita income has been subject to wide fluctuations that continue to the present day. Because of the volatility of economic growth, it is helpful to estimate a long-run growth trend in order to assess the underlying economic trajectory hidden by short-run fluctuations. The long-run trend reveals reasonably strong economic performance in the early 1970s. However, beginning in the mid-1970s, The Gambia entered a period of declining growth rates for nearly two decades40 and over the past 10 years, there is evidence of a turn-around despite the dramatic drop in economic growth in 2002, when groundnut production fell significantly due to crop failure41. Currently, long-run growth rates are among the highest in The Gambia’s post-independence history42. Estimates of gross investment in fixed capital suggest that productive investment has remained steady as a share of GDP during the past two decades43. Gross investment as a percent of GDP has hovered around 20 percent during much of this period. Interestingly, investment as a share of GDP does not show an upward trend during the past 10 years despite the noticeable improvement in the long-run per capita GDP growth rate. Therefore, improvements in GDP growth were not driven by higher rates of fixed capital investment44. Estimates of the level of domestic savings almost always fall significantly below the level of domestic investment. This indicates that, throughout its post-independence history, The Gambia has relied on foreign savings to support its domestic investment45. Although the saving gap appears to have narrowed somewhat in United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Situation of the Juvenile System in The Gambia’, UNICEF, 2010. Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. 41 Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘MRC Press Release’, Feb 24 2010. 42 Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. 43 Ford N., ‘Reforms reap strong growth: several years of painful economic reform now seem to be bearing fruit and The Gambia and its economy has been growing steadily’, African Business, Jan 2009. 39 40 44 International Journal of Education and Development using Information and Communication Technology, ‘MIS Sustainability in Sub-Saharan Africa: Three Case Studies from The Gambia’, 2008. Heintz J, Oya C, Zepeda C., ‘Towards an Employment-centred Development Strategy for Poverty Reduction in The Gambia: Macroeconomic and Labour Market Aspects’, http://www.ipcundp.org/pub/IPCCountryStudy16.pdf, 2008. 45 41 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 recent years, capital accumulation in the country continues to depend on foreign savings. The Gambian economy relies on foreign resources— foreign savings to finance domestic investment, imported capital goods, external borrowing, and official development assistance (ODA). Managing the external balance of payments is therefore central to overall economic performance. The Gambia has a pronounced current account deficit which is partially off-set by ODA transfers. The current account deficit appears to be structural—that is, it persists over time and is not caused by short-term movements in inflows and outflows46. Economic Statistics The Gambia Total GDP is $881 Million USD Per capita GNP is $440 USD Poverty Headcount is 61 .3 percent . External debt as a percentage of GNI is 65.1 percent . Annual Growth Rate 5.9 percent Source: World Bank One contributing factor is The Gambia’s reliance on imported commodities and the absence of strong export performance, creating a structural trade deficit. Both the trade deficit and the current account deficit increased significantly from 2001 to 2005. However, a large portion of this increase is most likely temporary. The Gambia received unprecedented inflows of foreign direct investment which were accompanied by large increases in imports in 2004 and 2005 (e.g., building materials for investment in new foreign owned hotels). In this case, the growth in the current account deficit was financed by FDI inflows rather than greater borrowing47. As already mentioned, there are indications that economic performance has been improving in recent times: per capita growth is higher, agricultural productivity shows signs of recovery, and foreign direct investment—not simply debt and ODA—has supplied much needed external financial resources. However, the Gambian economy is volatile and gains may disappear as quickly as they are realized. Therefore, macroeconomic policies must support sustainable development in The Gambia if longterm benefits are to be realized. 2.5.2. GDP and Growth The Gambia has a small economy with total GDP of less than a billion US dollars (881 million in 2009) and the three big components are agriculture (34 percent of GDP and over 70 percent of employment), tourism (44 percent of GDP but less than 10 percent of 46 47 Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Monitoring Policy Committee Press Release’, Feb 24 2010. 42 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 employment) and re-exporting (due to Banjul Ports Authority) which makes up just over 10 percent of GDP48. Growth has been steadily rising over the past five years averaging just over 5 percent per annum 2007-2009, up from 4 percent 2004-2007, and recently the governor of the Central Bank of The Gambia (CBG) has disclosed that the Gambia economy is projected to expand by 5.0 percent in 2010, lower than the revised estimate of 5.6 percent in 2009. The key components of the economy have all grown in the last year with agriculture estimated at 4.4 percent, industry 5.1 percent and services 4.9 percent. In addition the Gambia's fiscal balance has become less dependent on external taxes during the period; trade-related taxes fell from 40 percent of Government revenue in 2003 to 24 percent in 2009, as other indirect taxes, such as sales tax, assumed greater importance. The only area for concern for the Gambian economy in terms of potential risks is the growing trade imbalance, stemming from higher oil prices and the collapse of groundnut exports, and declines in tourist arrivals and remittances, the current account deficit rose from 5 percent of GDP in 2003 to over 17 percent in 2009. The capital and financial account remains in surplus, helped by an HIPC debt write-off in 2007. Most recent data from the monthly IMF monitoring visits indicated that GDP is at 5.6 percent, which is up for previous estimates of 5 percent, and projected to be at 5.5 percent in 2011. The IMF mission expects inflation to decline slight to 5 percent in 201149. 2.5.3. Employment in formal and non-formal sectors The incidence of poverty for households whose head is employed in the agricultural sector is the highest (76.4 per cent—includes fishing and groundnuts activities). Next are households whose head works in the construction sector (63.6 per cent). By contrast, the incidence of poverty is lower for households whose head works in social services (45.4 per cent—includes personal services), in trade, hotels (48.8 per cent— includes restaurants), and in finance and administration - private as well as public50. The population of The Gambia is 1,364,507 million, with an annual growth rate of 2.7 per cent, and with over 50 percent of the population living in the densely populated Kanifing and Brikama areas. According to estimates from the World Bank and the Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. International Monetary Fund, ‘IMF Concludes Visit to The Gambia for the Seventh Review of the Program Under the Extended Credit Facility’, IMF, Nov. 2010. 50 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. 48 49 43 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 International Labour Organization, the labour force as a percentage of the total population has remained stable in recent decades—at about 43 per cent51. Rates are higher in rural (54 per cent) than in urban areas (45 percent), and are higher for illiterate people. Adults in the age ranges of 25-49 and 50-64 have participation rates almost twice as large as those of youth in the15-24 age brackets. Participation rates for males and females are fairly similar—a pattern which can be found in other sub-Saharan African countries, but which differs from many other parts of the world where women’s participation rates are frequently much lower than men’s. Under-employment rather than unemployment in The Gambia is a source of some concern. Using the latest population census, which is usually the benchmark reference for employment indicators, the national unemployment rate is not very high at 6 per cent. But the urban rate is 10 percent (the rural rate is only 2 percent; mainly due to agriculture) and, moreover, the urban youth unemployment rate is very high, at 22 percent (in rural areas youth unemployment is 3 percent). 52 Unemployment Total Youth Rural 2 3 Urban 6 22 The most acute employment problem in the Gambia, as in many other developing countries is seldom unemployment of labor but the ‘underemployment’ of labor. This can be seen as direct i.e. part-time, seasonal and short-term or temporary employment and indirectly as low average earnings due to poor levels of productivity in informal industries such as agriculture. Gambia’s Integrated Household Survey (HIS) survey allows us to examine underemployment through the lens of number of working days per year. According to this data, most categories of workers worked around 200 days or more. In the case of wage-workers, most of them worked year round or up to 300 days per year[16]. These figures suggest that underemployment is not a particularly serious issue, at least not as serious as often assumed. However, this indicator does not provide information about other dimensions of underemployment, for example information on the number of Republic of the Gambia, ‘Gender empowerment strategy paper 2007-2011’, Round table conference, London 5th-6th February 2008. 51 Heintz J, Oya C, Zepeda C., ‘Towards an Employment-centred Development Strategy for Poverty Reduction in The Gambia: Macroeconomic and Labour Market Aspects’, http://www.ipcundp.org/pub/IPCCountryStudy16.pdf, 2008. 52 44 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 hours worked per week, or the regularity of work and the proportion of work that leads to income (much work goes unrewarded in rural – agricultural circles where inefficiency is high). Moreover, underemployment—indicating an inadequate level of labor demand—may manifest itself in forms other than average work time (be it days per year or hours per week). Consider a self-employed street vendor. Demand for her labor (providing retail services) depends on the amount she can sell in any period of time. The amount she sells will also determine her earnings. If hourly earnings are low due to inadequate demand, she may work longer hours in an effort to generate more income in total. In this case, slack demand in the economy leads to longer working hours. However, the street trader in this example can still be considered underemployed, due to low levels of productivity and insufficient demand for her labor. In a formal economy this would usually lead to substitution (movement to a different industry) but in an uneducated population with no source of welfare this is not an option. Underemployment is often seen most strongly in informal, service sectors and in agriculture and these are also the two areas that are often dominated by women. Formalization of these industries, education to improve productivity are the two necessities to shift the burden of underemployment away from overtly affecting women. The concept of “informal employment” is meant to capture forms of employment that lack regulatory, legal, and/or social protections. Informal employment is most often defined in terms of the nature of the enterprise in which the work takes place (i.e. the informal sector) and the nature of the employment relationship. In practice, enterprises are considered informal if they are unincorporated and unregistered with a government authority. When registration status is unknown, a size criterion is frequently used (e.g. informal enterprises have less than 5 employees). “Employment in the informal sector” comprises all employment that takes place in informal enterprises (including own-account workers, contributing family workers, paid employees in informal enterprises, informal employers, and members of informal cooperatives). Outside of the unregistered and/or small enterprises sector, employment may be considered to be informal if it lacks core legal or social protections, e.g. domestic workers. To be sure, de facto unregulated employment may also exist within the formal sector, i.e. in registered or large enterprises. Because of data limitations, we discuss informal employment by focusing on jobs in informal enterprises as captured by the economic census. Such employment is widespread in The Gambia. The 2004 Economic Census finds that there were 78,718 45 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 private establishments outside the crop sector where 223,610 people worked: 40 percent as paid employees, 25 percent as own account workers, 5 percent as employers, 27 percent as unpaid family workers, and the remaining 3 percent as other temporary workers. Almost three quarters of these establishments were located in the Greater Banjul, Kanifing and Brikama areas53. The majorities of these enterprises were unregistered (84 percent) and therefore can be classified as operating in the informal sector. 73 percent of all working individuals in the non-agricultural enterprises captured by the economic census were employed in informal enterprises. As mentioned above, definitions of the informal sector frequently include small-scale enterprises, not simply unregistered firms. If establishments with less than 5 workers were included in the informal sector of The Gambia, then the proportion of informal workers increases to 85 percent of employment in non-agricultural enterprises. One area of investment needs to be in the formal employment sectors, especially in agriculture and manufacturing. In The Gambia, poverty increases with household size but decreases with education54. The incidence, depth and severity of poverty are more than twice as high for households with illiterate heads compared to households whose head is literate. The likelihood of being “poor” is higher in households located in rural areas, in polygamous families (which are more common in rural areas), in households headed by widows, people of advanced age or with no work experience, and in households with sick family members. Informal establishments rely on unpaid labour (family or apprentices) but also hire a significant number of paid employees. Paid employees represent 53 percent of all workers employed in unregistered non-agricultural enterprises. Gender is a significant differentiating factor in determining types of employment and occupations in The Gambia. Male workers are employed in a wider range of occupations, partially a result of the education and training available to male workers and the customary gender roles in the Gambian labour market. There is also evidence of labour market segmentation by sex. Whereas employed men work in occupations such as vehicle driver, protection services, building, mechanic and fishery, female workers are predominantly employed in petty trading, domestic services and clerical 53 National Dept of Statistics, ‘The Gambia Economic Census’, GoTG, 2004. The Economist Intelligence Unit, ‘The Gambia: Economist Country Report’, 26 Red Lion Square, London WC1R 4HQ United Kingdom, July 2009. 54 46 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 jobs. While 45 percent of men reported that they had never received any training, the proportion of women reporting that they had no access to training was 61 percent. There is evidence of a significant gender earnings gap. Rough estimates from the scarce data on wages and earnings for a range of workers who had received training suggest that the earnings of employed men are 1.6 times larger than those of employed women. There is substantial variation in the gender earnings gap. In some cases male and female wages are nearly identical, but there are instances where the ratios of men’s earnings to women’s can be as high as 3 and even 955. It also appears from available evidence at the micro level that men dominate most forms of wage employment in rural and peri-urban areas, in agricultural and non-agricultural activities. Women’s employment is concentrated in certain informal activities, such as own account employment or “on commission” work. It should be noted that it is frequently difficult to distinguish forms of self-employment from wage employment for women in urban informal activities. There is a continuum to the degree of precariousness which different types of employment exhibit in The Gambia, and women tend to be concentrated in more precarious forms of employment. Gender is a particularly significant differentiating factor in rural areas, especially in farming, where women take on specific roles within the household. In addition, men often dominate the rural labour markets for paid employees, especially seasonal migrant labour. However, it is not unusual to find younger women working for casual wages in operations such as weeding when they are freed from household chores. The incidence of this phenomenon, however, cannot be ascertained with the limited statistical information available. Limited opportunities for well paid employment coupled with a scarcity of secondary schools in rural areas contributes to a re-occurring cycle of poverty. Children in rural areas who are not able to access post primary education may lack the necessary skills to attain a good or high paying job. This may perpetuate the cycle of poverty in that persons in these circumstances, without the skills needed to attain a good or high wage, may have children, relegated to the similar constraints. This has significant impact on women and youth who are especially vulnerable to a lack of education facilities and limited opportunities to higher paid employment. The Economist Intelligence Unit, ‘The Gambia: Economist Country Report’, 26 Red Lion Square, London WC1R 4HQ United Kingdom, July 2009. 55 47 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The impact on women on the increasing investment in sustainable development and industries that export is a reduction in shocks. Improvements in employment opportunity and a reduction in seasonal variance in employment which will mean less migration (economic) and as a result much improved use of social service provision such as health care. Agriculture Agriculture accounts for a third of GDP and employs three quarters of the workforce. Most production is devoted to the domestic market, either for subsistence consumption, sales on local markets, or sales to the hotel trade; groundnuts and fish products remain the main export crops, although cashews (partly as re-exports) and horticultural products are also traded. Gambia is still somehow able to export some food staples (ground nuts, cashew nuts particularly oil and rice). Duties on agricultural products are generally fixed at 20 percent , the highest level of duty in the ECOWAS tariff. The simple average rate on Agriculture (WTO definition) is 16.5 percent . The Gambia has drawn up ambitious plans for agricultural development with Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and International Fund for Agricultural Assistance (IFAD) assistance, including water, forestry and fisheries management, improvement of food processing chains, development of livestock and horticulture, and expansion of regional and inter-regional trade. The objective is to complete these plans by 2015. The Gambia continues to face severe difficulties in meeting export quality requirements for food-grade groundnuts. Structural problems also persist in the domestic trading mechanism. Recently, a Quality Assurance Framework for groundnuts has been proposed, which, if followed, could assist greatly in bringing the trade up to required SPS standards56. In addition rice is a staple of the Gambian diet and a major import. Improvement of domestic production and hence lower reliance on imports is a major element in Government plans. Infrastructure, including road (both main and feeder) development, will play a major role in the revitalization of agriculture. The Gambia has made great progress in improving its main road network and is working on an ambitious feeder road programme, with external assistance. Less attention has so far been paid to redevelopment of river transport, which has been identified as vital to reviving groundnut trade. 56 SPS is abbreviation for sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) measures which along with and customs and administrative procedures (CAP) are the two major non-tariff trade barriers (NTB) 48 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Fisheries are of major importance to the Gambian economy. However, the value of exports by industrial fisheries is believed to be severely underestimated, as most such fish is caught and either transshipped at sea or landed in foreign countries. A new deep-water fishing port for landing and processing industrially caught fish is due for completion by end 2010. The artisanal subsector faces different issues, in that it struggles to meet quality requirements for export markets, particularly in the EU. Recognizing this, the new Gambian fisheries policy emphasizes post-harvest quality control and the achievement of internationally acceptable standards. The advantages to improving SPS and other NTB for women in particular is the greater formalization of the employment sector - SPS and improving standards and QA tend to mean a much more formalized employment structure and a tendency for firms to have to apply to international standards of employment protection in terms of hours and working conditions not to mention termination and abridgment law. Tourism Tourism in The Gambia is one of the largest contributing imports into The Gambia economy. According to the Ministry of Tourism, revenue derived from tourism accounts for approximately 44 percent of GDP57. Despite the Global Economic Crisis, tourist numbers are increasing and providing input into the country’s revenue. The Gambian government is committed to the development of tourism and to increase its contribution to the economy. Tourism development in 2008/09 was affected by the international economic crisis, but is now believed to be recovering. Although relatively few international airlines provide long-haul flights to Banjul the service is improving, and many charter providers continue to serve the country, mainly from Europe. Efforts are being made to expand the tourist season to the European summer and to improve the offer of "eco-tourism" and "responsible tourism" facilities58. The tourist industry provides employment opportunities for women, as approximately 40 percent of hotel and restaurant industry workers are women59. Yet The Gambia also Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. Africa Region Human Development Working Paper Series, ‘Health and Poverty in the Gambia. A background report to the National Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper Copyright’, Human Development Sector, Africa Region The World Bank, November 2005. The Economist Intelligence Unit, ‘The Gambia: Economist Country Report’, 26 Red Lion Square, London WC1R 4HQ United Kingdom, July 2009. 59 Government of The Gambia, ‘The Gambia National Gender Policy 2010- 2020’. 57 58 49 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 attracts many tourists who come specifically to The Gambia to exploit women and children for sexual activities. This issue is further detailed in Chapters Four and Five. 2.6 National Planning Context 2.6.1. National Planning Context In order to address the economic development of The Gambia, strategic documents have been produced to outline clear goals, objectives and target to move The Gambia from a low income to a middle income country. A brief analysis of these documents is provided in the following section. 2.6.2. Review of Planning Process Documents The pillars of the PRSP and the principles of Vision 2020 espouse the creation of enabling the macroeconomic environment for economic growth and the enhancement of the productive capacity of the poor and the vulnerable, as central themes to achieving increased access to basic services, social protection and national empowerment through decent and productive employment 2.6.2.1.Vision 2020 The Gambia renewed its commitment to poverty reduction in 1996 through the preparation of Vision 20/20. The goal for Vision 20/20 was “to transform The Gambia into a financial centre, a tourist paradise, a trading export oriented agricultural and manufacturing nation, thriving on free market policies and a vibrant private sector, sustained by a well educated, skilled, healthy, self-reliant and enterprising population, guaranteeing a well balanced ecosystem and a descent standard of living for all, under a system of government based on the consent of the citizenry”. The Gambia planned to realize these goals through a series of five-year development plans. The Gambia’s commitments to poverty reduction notwithstanding, the Medium Term Plans (MTP) were not well linked to the Millennium Development Goals (MGDs) that are prerequisites to sustainable economic growth and reduction of poverty. 2.6.2.2. PRSP I The Gambia implemented its second strategy for Poverty Alleviation (SPA II) or PRSP I for a three year period - 2003 and 2005. The Long Term Goal of PRSP I was to eradicate poverty by significantly increasing National Income through stable economic growth and reducing income and non-income inequalities through specific poverty 50 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 reduction priority interventions. In order to achieve this, five main objectives were identified and pursued during the period. These were: 1. Create an enabling policy environment to promote economic growth and poverty reduction. 2. Enhance the productive capacity and social protection of the poor and vulnerable. 3. Improve coverage of the basic social service needs of the poor and vulnerable. 4. Build the capacity of local communities and Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) to play an active role in the process of poverty reduction. 5. Mainstream poverty-related cross-cutting issues into SPA II. At the start of the PRSP period in January 2003, macroeconomic stability was slowly returning, following the instability caused by the exchange rate depreciations in 2001-2, and more importantly, there was a realistic opportunity to introduce a single fund for donor finance of poverty reducing programmes based on budget support. However, as PRSP implementation progressed, slippages in financial governance, mainly the misreporting by the Central Bank on their operations, led to the suspension of the PRGF. Measures to check against the reoccurrence of this, including the conduct of regular independent audits of the Central Bank operations have since been instituted and are operational. However, on the side of the agreed level of budgetary financing of priority PRSP sectors, this was less than satisfactory as government revenue contracted and The Gambia’s debt burden began to seriously undermine budgetary expenditure on these sectors. This situation was exacerbated by the unsustainable domestic debt burden. It remains a huge challenge to control spending earmarked for priority PSRP sectors in the budget in the face of dwindling budget resources60. Although a number of donors made pledges at the Roundtable resource mobilization conference in 2002 in support of SPAII/PRSP I, many of the pledges were not honoured due to suspension of the IMF programme. As a result, the bulk of programmes and projects under the first PRSP could not be implemented as planned. One of the features of the PRSP I, was that employment was not explicitly considered as a priority area or key outcome of its strategies. 2.6.2.3. PRSP II The Second Poverty Reduction and Strategy Paper (PRSP II) outlined the overall policy framework for Growth and Poverty Reduction in The Gambia. It also shows key priority areas, and builds on the long – term development objectives for attaining the MDGs and 60 Government of The Gambia, ‘PRSP II 2007 -2011’ (Approved Copy), Nov. 2006. 51 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Vision 2020. The PRSP II is the main framework that defines the overall government development planning and budget process for achieving meaningful progress, prosperity, sustainable development, and poverty reduction. The priorities which are presented will be implemented through sector plans, and financed through allocations from the annual budget, complemented by donor contribution. The annual PRSP II budget also integrates the MDGs into the current planning processes. PRSP II has five pillars or areas of intervention. 1. Improving the Enabling Policy Environment to Promote Growth and Poverty Reduction. 2. Enhancing the capacity and output of productive sectors: Agriculture, Fisheries, Industry, Trade, Tourism and Infrastructure, with emphasis on productive capacities of the poor and vulnerable populations. 3. Improve coverage of the basic social services and social protection needs of the poor and vulnerable 4. Enhance governance systems and build the capacity of local communities and Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) to play an active role in economic growth and poverty reduction 5. Mainstreaming cross-cutting issues; Gender, Youths, Population, HIV/AIDS, Nutrition and Environment into the development process There are some challenges which may affect the successful implementation of PRSP II which are as follows: Reducing the rising levels of poverty continue to be a major challenge for the government and people of the Gambia; The increasingly poor public sector capacity to implement policies; The unsustainable public debt situation; Rising global oil prices; Downward trend in Aid flow due to the global crisis; and Inadequate levels of private sector investment61. Progress – pending data availability 2.6.2.4. The National Development Strategy 2012 - And The Program for Accelerated Growth and Employment (PAGE) – “Pursuing Vision 2020 and the Millennium Development Goals” 61 Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, July 2009. 52 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In support of Vision 2020 and as a means to ensure that the MDGs are successfully realized, PAGE is currently under development to specifically define policies and programs which will support government efforts. The major objectives, which are currently under development but are set to be realized by 2015, focus on the following areas; Reduce levels of income poverty Increase vocational training opportunities Improve MMR and U5MR statistics Reduce levels of diseases. The Major Areas of proposed PAGE Interventions 1. Strengthening Government institutions - enhancing effectiveness and efficiency in public service delivery. 2. .Strengthening Public Financial Management - implementation of a Medium Term Expenditure Framework 3. Development of the Human capital stock - enhancing the competitiveness of the country within the sub-region by the provision of a pool of experts that command a premium in the sub-regional market 4. Land Use Planning - having a National Spatial Development Plan to guide land use in the country (Land tenure system - processing of property, land property) 5. Agriculture as a tool for Rural Development -transforming the Gambia to a major supplier of agricultural products to the local and international market 6. Tourism upgrading and Expansion -making The Gambian tourism more attractive and competitive 7. Health System Reform and upgrading of Health Care Products -making the Gambia a major source of health care for the sub-region 8. Upgrading Energy infrastructure -energy to power the industrialization and modernization of the country 9. Upgrading the transportation infrastructure - transportation to enhance movement of goods and persons 53 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 10. Upgrading the Information and Communication Infrastructure - better and more efficient public services delivery and enhancing the country `s competitiveness 11. Business sector reform to build Gambian share of the sector - enhancing business and government relationship to guild indigenous participation and improve quality and business performance 12. Accelerating Decentralization – Local Governments as Public Corporations enhancing the autonomy of the local governments and making them responsible for the provision and financing of the basic social services 13. Enhancing social protection - ensuring a decent standard of living for one and all 2.6.2.5. Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) The eight Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) – which range from halving extreme poverty to halting the spread of HIV/AIDS and providing universal primary education, all by the target date of 2015 – form a framework agreed to by all the world’s countries and all the world’s leading development institutions. They have galvanized unprecedented efforts to meet the needs of the worlds poorest. The Gambia has made significant progress towards meeting the MDGs, especially in attaining primary school enrolment, providing for the vaccination of children, and improving the use of clean drinking water. Nevertheless, efforts to eradicate poverty and hunger, significantly reduce child mortality, improve maternal mortality, and the provision of affordable drugs are not likely to be realized by 2015. The reasons for this shortfall are complex and often challenging to address. There is a need for better statistical collection and analysis, for great investment in programs to address these challenges, and more innovative programs that address the MDGs. Emphasis on specific goals require a greater commitment to increasing the incomes of agricultural workers, of improving maternal care, especially emergency obstetric care, and in addressing issues affecting the environmental situation. According to the MGD report, if current trends continue, it is unlikely that all the MGDs will be realized by 2015. Nevertheless, successes in many indicators have been made and the work, programs and continuing efforts in achieving the MGDs should positively contribute to improving 54 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 the lives of children and women in The Gambia even if all indicators have not been fully realized 62. Summary of Progress towards the Millennium Development Goals Goal 1. Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger The country is not on track to meet the poverty targets. Poverty gap ratio has increased from 23 in 1990 to 25 in 2003, underweight children (as a indicator of hunger) has also increased from 17 percent to 20 percent in 2003. Given the current trend, intensified efforts are required in order to meet the MDG target of 10.4 by 2015 Goal 2. Achieve universal primary education The Gambia has been successful in reaching the MGD target that aims to ensure that by 2015, children everywhere boys and girls alike will be able to complete a full course of primary schooling. The Gambia has attained the MDG targets set on the proportion of pupils starting grade 1 who reach last grade of primary school and is on track for the net enrolment target for the population 15 – 24 years old. Goal 3. Promote gender equality and empower women The target to reach gender parity in primary and lower secondary schools has been achieved and the target for secondary school is on track to be realized. Goal 4. Reduce child mortality For child health, the country is currently unlikely to meet the MDG targets for infant and child mortality indicators given the current estimates. Immunization targets set for the proportion of one year olds children immunized against measles has been attained. Goal 5. Improve maternal health The country is not currently on track for reaching this MDG target. The current maternity rate is 556 deaths/100,000 live births (the MDG target is 263 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births). The target of 90 percent of births attended by skilled birth attendants is also unlikely to be realized considering a 2005/06 estimate of 56.8 per cent ‘Five Years from 2015, The Level of Achievement of the Millennium development Goals (MDGS), Synthesized Report 2010’, the Gambia, September 2010. 62 55 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Goal 6. Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria, and other diseases The Gambia is partially on track to meet this multi-dimensional goal. The country is on track to meet the MDG targets of 80 percent of under-five children sleeping under ITNs. HIV1 Has been reduced from 2.8 percent in 2005/06 HIV1 to 1.42 percent in 2007, and 0.9 percent HIV 2 to 0.5 percent (same years). In addressing childhood diseases, the goal for measles vaccination has been attained and the country is on track for TB. Goal 7. Ensure environmental sustainability According to the MDG report, the target for the population using improved drinking water is on course for attainment. Goal 8. Global Partnership The Global Partnership goal is a shared goal between The Gambia and development partners. The Gambia has shown steady progress in achieving this goal. Completion point under the enhanced HIPC Initiative has been reached and the country is eligible for debt relief under the HIPC to the tune of US$66.6 million. Recently, there has been budget support from ADB and World Bank and programmed budget support from EU, FTI and Global Fund. Five Years from 2015, The Level of Achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), Synthesized Report, 2010, The Gambia 2.7 Aid Environment in The Gambia The main multilateral donors to the Gambia are the African Development Bank, the ECOWAS Fund, the Department for International Development (DFID) of the United Kingdom, the European Commission (EC), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank (WB), the UN agencies, Arab Bank for African Development (BADEA), OPEC Fund, Islamic Development Bank, the European Community, International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), and the World Bank via the International Development Association (IDA). Some of the main social service donor profiles are summarized in the following section. World Bank (WB) The World Bank (WB) is helping to fight poverty and improve living standards for the people of The Gambia. As of June 2010, the WB, through the International Development Association (IDA) had approved a total of thirty three IDA projects for The Gambia for a total of approximately US $312 million dollars, of which the commitment 56 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 value of the four ongoing World Bank operations is approximately US$27 million dollars63. The four current active IDA operations are in the following areas: Basic education Community – Driven Development Public Resource Management through the consolidation and expansion of an Integrated Finance Management Information System (IFMIS) Agricultural Crop Protection – as a part of regional projection on the prevention of locust infestation. In addition to the IDA- funded projects, the World Bank is involved in various activities in the country which are funded by Trust Funds (for example by the Education for All – Fast Track Initiative Catalytic Funds, the Global Environment Facility, and the European Union Food Crisis rapid response trust Fund European Commission (EC) EC assistance aims to support the efforts of the Government to address the key issues that are hampering economic and social development. The two priority sectors for cooperation are infrastructure and regional interconnectivity as well as governance. In addition, €22 million have been earmarked for general budget support to sustain the Government's macroeconomic reform programme. Additional support will be provided for integrated capacity building programmes, institutional support for non state actors as well as activities addressing the issue of legal and illegal migration. EC interventions in The Gambia also take account of poverty-related cross-cutting issues, in particular gender equality, HIV/AIDS, environmental sustainability, good governance and human rights, especially children's rights as well as nutrition and health. The EC's total allocation foreseen for The Gambia under 10th EDF funding (2008-2013) amounts to €77.9 million to address these priorities64. Department for International Development (DfID) World Bank, ‘Gambia Profile’, http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/AFRICAEXT/GAMBIAEXT 63 European Commission, ‘External Cooperation Programs – The Gambia’, EC, http://ec.europa.eu/europeaid/where/acp/country-cooperation/gambia/gambia_en.htm 64 57 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 DfID is working in partnership with the Gambian Government and other donors to support the national Poverty Reduction Strategy. The UK’s bilateral development programme currently focuses on the following main areas: Basic Education – a programme (2005-2010) to enhance the capacity of the Department of Education to deliver quality education and support the development of national education policy. Legal Capacity Building (2004-2010) seeks to improve the accessibility, impartiality and efficiency of the judicial system for the rural poor majority, and includes training for professional and administrative staff in the judiciary and Department of State for Justice. Financial Governance (2006-2009) will help strengthen public financial management and ensure best use of financial resources. Training for the National Assembly’s Public Accounts Committee and capacity building in the Department of State for Finance will also be provided. Civil Society Capacity Building - including increasing civil society’s role in monitoring and tracking planned and actual budgetary expenditure against Government policies, and empowering civil society organisations through capacity building support to an NGO network organisation. Debt Management - assisting the Government with the design and implementation of a domestic debt management strategy. Foreign Private Capital Capacity Building: The Gambia was one of the beneficiary countries in the first phase of this programme (2002-04) which used a census approach to measure private capital investment. A second phase of support to consolidate this work and ensure sustainability is currently underway65 African Development Bank (ADB) The ADB provides direct and non-targeted general budget support for attainment of PRSP II's objectives with a particular focus in the social sector (health and education). Disbursement of funds will be partially linked to the levels of the achievement of agreed levels for selected performance indicators, as well as contribute to the public financial management reform, civil service reform, the revitalization of the groundnut sub-sector and improving road maintenance. Multi Donor Funding 65 UK Department for International Development, DfID web site, http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.dfid.gov.uk/countries/africa/gambia.asp 58 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Global Fund EXPAND The Global Fund supports health initiatives in The Gambia in three major disease related areas: HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria. Some of the programming initiatives include66: Provision of ITNs –over 775,705 nets distributed throughout the Gambia Provision of ARTs – 1, 306 patients receiving regular ARTs Testing for TB – 5446 new smear- positive TB cases detected and treated Education for All – Fast Track Initiative UN Agencies UNDAF report – pending availability of information There are seven UN agencies which are currently supporting programming in The Gambia. The major programming sectors for each agency are outlined below. Table 9: UN Agencies Programming Areas UN Agency UNDP UNICEF Programming Areas Support to strengthen government institutions by providing , access to its global knowledge networks and technical expertise to boost capacity development and to promote national efforts to eradicate poverty and attain the Millennium Development Goals. Support to women’s and children’s programming in health, education and protection ideas UNFPA Reproductive health programming for women UNAIDS HIV/AIDS programming that focuses on data collection, research, and support to PLWHA FAO Agricultural support to government and research institutes WHO Support to government health ministries in the areas of research, data collection and health advocacy Programming that supports initiatives to ensure food security, such as school feeding, food production surveillance, vulnerability mapping, and emergency response. Programming that supports refugees or internally displaced WFP UNHCR The Global Fund , ‘The Gambia Country Grant Portfolio’, GF, http://portfolio.theglobalfund.org/Country/Index/GMB 66 59 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia ILO UNESCO 2010 people Support programming that recognizes international human and labour rights Coordinates all education stakeholders, both formal and informal. Chapter 3. Vulnerability Context – understanding issues that make children and women vulnerable. 3.1. Poverty 3.1.1. International and National Standards There are various standards of measurement which are used to assess poverty. Three common measurement tools are explained in the following section. According to the UN Human Development Report 2009, The Gambia is ranked 168 out of 182 and also one of the twenty – three Low Human Development Index countries Gambia National Poverty Line The Government of The Gambia has established a National Poverty Line YEAR AND REFERENCE. using the upper poverty line, based on per capita consumption, the head count index (i.e. the percentage of poor people) is calculated at 61.3 percent. The poverty gap is calculated at 25.9 percent whilst the poverty severity accounts for about 14.3 percent. As the poverty level above indicates, there is a pervasive level of poverty in the Gambia, which varies along many dimensions such as households head, education levels, employment status and sector and geographical location67. Households – households with three person have only a 16 percent poverty headcount, while households with seven or larger have a 66 percent headcount Poverty rate for female headed households is 41 per cent, while male is 61 percent. This lower level of poverty for female headed households is primarily reflective of remittances received from husbands (or other family members) who travel for employment purposes and has further socio- economic implications regarding male migration. World Bank, ‘Poverty Reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, Poverty Assessment, World Bank, May 2009. 67 60 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Households with heads of households who have a secondary schooling have an estimated poverty rate of 36 percent , while those with no schooling have an almost doubling rate of a 64 percent poverty rate Nearly 60 percent of the poor are under the age of 20, which is reflective of the population pyramid due to a high birth rate and rapid population growth. There are implications for child poverty which are referenced in the following section. There are regional variations of poverty with rural areas demonstrating higher levels of poverty (76 percent as estimated by the World Bank Poverty Assessment). These regional variations are associated with variations in access to health facilities and upper basic and secondary schools, in terms of the average distance to these facilities. Interesting there were similar distances and road conditions to lower basic schools between urban and rural areas, which may indicate that access to secondary school is a leading reason for low secondary education enrolment 68 . These findings seem to indicate that further expansion of school should focus on the upper and secondary levels69. As part of the World Bank Poverty Assessment, community members identified other underlying causes of poverty during participatory assessments. . Credit buying of groundnuts – often payments are delayed which may result in the need to resort to coping mechanisms which may exhaust resources and any safety nets A strong dissatisfaction with the Primary Health Care System Large family size Girls scholarship programs discouraging boys education (enrolment rates for boys have declined in certain geographic locations)70 Efforts to address these recommendations have been taken into consideration in the development of the PAGE, with an emphasis on employment, heath care and education. International Income Poverty According to the HDI, there are approximately 34 percent of Gambians living on under $1 USD a day, and over half of all Gambians (54.7 percent) live on $2 USD a day71. The Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI)72 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’ - 40 percent male, 37 percent female World Bank, ‘Poverty Reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, WB, May 2009. 70 World Bank, ‘Poverty Reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, WB, May 2009. 71 United Nations Development Programme, ‘Human Development Report 2009’, UNDP. 68 69 61 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The MPI is an assessment approach that the measures specific indicators in deprivations in three basic dimensions; Education, Health, and Standard of Living. The MPI is calculated by multiplying the incidence of poverty by the average intensity across the poor. The following chart compares the various measures of poverty - national poverty line, international income poverty and the MPI. Chart 3: Comparative Poverty Measures Proportion 70 60 57 60 61 50 40 34 Proportion 30 20 10 0 MPI(H) U$1.25 U$2 a day National Poverty Line Source: Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) Table 10: Comparative Poverty Measures Multidimensional Poverty Index 0.324 Percentage of MPI Poor (H) 0.604 Average Intensity of Deprivation (A) 0.536 Number of MPI Poor People (in millions) 1 Percentage of Income Poor ($1.25 a day) 34 percent Percentage of Income Poor ($2.00 a day) 57 percent Percentage of Poor (National Poverty Line) 61 percent Population*(in millions) Human Development Index HDI rank (104 countries) HDI category 1.6 0.456 12 Low Source: Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI), The MPI identifies a person as poor if he or she is deprived in at least 30 percent of weighted indicators. These indicators are; schooling, children enrolment, child mortality, nutrition, electricity, drinking water, sanitation, type of floor in houses, and cooking fuel used. The table below demonstrates the level of intensity of poverty in the Gambia as measured by the ten indicators. Chart 4: Percentage of People Deprived in X Percent or more of MPI Weighted Indicators 72 Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI), ‘OPHI Country Briefing 2010’, OPHI. 62 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 SOURCE: Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) All three measurements of poverty as described above indicate that well over half of all Gambians live in poverty; a staggering statistic, which directly contributes to the overall situation of children and women (63 percent of Gambian women are classified as poor). Women and children are placed at greater risk to abuse and exploitation as they seek ways to earn needed income. Children from poor households may be kept out of school in order to contribute to family income or tend children while parents work or are engaged in farming and heath can be negatively affected if needed medications are not affordable or provided by health facilities. 3.1.2. Rural vs. Urban According to the various measurements of poverty identified above, approximately 60 percent of Gambians can be classified as poor. According to the World Bank Poverty assessment, 76 percent of the poor live in rural areas. By gender however, 48 percent of males and 63 percent of females are classified as poor, with 15.1 percent of females and 8.5 percent of males classified as extremely poor. The Integrated Household Survey indicates that while poverty is found in all parts of the country, extreme poverty can be found more in rural areas (15 percent) than in urban areas (13 percent), and that poverty affects women on a greater scale than men73. Standards of living and the impact of poverty differ greatly in the rural and urban context. Statistics on urban and rural poverty do not provide the complete picture when it comes to assessing the affect of poverty on the poor. Factor such as access to education and health services, opportunities for employment, even if only seasonal or short term and a social support system need to be factored into the assessing the overall affects of poverty. In The Gambia, many of these indicators are much more 73 Government of The Gambia, ‘The Gambia Priority Employment Program 2007-2011’, GoTG. 63 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 accessible in urban areas. At the same time, urban environments can also mean overcrowding, higher crime rates, and exposure to less traditional or ‘modern vices’ of which families may not have control. 3.1.3. Child Poverty Child poverty is the growing phenomenon of children who live in poverty as defined by national and international standards. Poverty affects more women and children on a global scale, and in The Gambia with over 60 percent of the population categorized as living in poverty, this has direct impact on women and children who make up of the largest percentage of the poor.74 According to the WB Poverty Assessment, over 60 of the poor are under twenty years old. This translates into the reality that over one third of The Gambia’s population are poor children and youth. Based on the Census 2003 and using the national poverty index rating of 61.3 % of Gambian living in poverty, there are approximately 351,000 children under 15 years of age living in poverty and over 184,000 youth between the ages of 15 – 24 living in poverty. This number is more than likely higher than this, as children are often disproportionately represented in populations living in poverty. Children are especially vulnerable to poverty due to their age and dependency. Children make up a disproportionate number of the poor and extremely poor, because of higher fertility rates in the lower income/consumption deciles of the population. Children brought up in poverty, without an adequate standard of living, are likely to suffer serious deficiencies in nutrition, shelter, clothing and other basic needs, adversely affecting their well-being and development. They are more likely to be out of school, compromising their life-time chances. They are at greater risk of exploitation, violence and abuse, including the risks of child labour and trafficking. Also HIV/AIDS is creating a growing number of orphans, whose vulnerability is increased by the loss of their parents and a sharp decline in household income75. Article 27 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) states that every child has the right to a standard of living adequate to his or her development and requires states, where necessary, to ‘provide material assistance and support programmes’ to parents to make this right a reality. Social protection systems can help to overcome these problems and Article 26 of the CRC specifically upholds the right of every child to benefit from social security. Government of Gambia, ‘The Gambia Priority Employment Program 2007-2011’, By gender however 48 percent of males and 63 percent of females are classified as poor, with 15.1 percent of females and 8.5 percent of males classified as extremely poor, GoTG. 75Chikova, ‘Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia’, GoTG, UNICEF, July 2009. 74 64 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Social Protection Social Protection as presented by the World Bank is defined as ‘interventions that assist poor individuals, households and communities to reduce their vulnerability by managing risks better’. DfID expands this by defining social protection as ‘public actions – carried out by the state or privately – that a/ enable people to deal more effectively with risk and their vulnerability to crises and changes in circumstances; and b/ help tackle extreme and chronic poverty’76. Social Protection in The Gambia While The Gambia does not have a National Social Protection Policy or Strategy there are many schemes and initiatives that work in favor of social protection. These plans listed below are under the umbrella of the Social Security and Housing Finance Cooperation, whose mission is to provide adequate social protection for workers, facilitate low cost shelter and invest funds of corporations to achieve maximum results. These plans are as follows77: Housing Finance - provision of plots of land with or without construction loans for low to middle income populations. National Provident Fund – employees from 18 – 54 contribute 15 percent of base salary to this fund Pension Fund – employees in quasi – government or private institutions contribute to this fund. Civil servants and members of armed forces have separate pension plans. Disability Pension – provides assistance to those who become incapacitated to work due to disabilities Other Social Protection Measures in The Gambia Subsided health service for all Medical Insurance for private sector employees and some of their families Cash Transfer for OVCs (GFATM and UNICEF) Elderly destitute Education Assistance Remittances from Gambians abroad ‘Osusu’ – weekly or monthly voluntary contribution UNICEF, Programme Country note for the Gambia, Social Transfer Training, Ghana, Sept – October 2010, pg 6 77 UNICEF, Programme Country note for the Gambia, Social Transfer Training, Ghana, Sept – October 2010 76 65 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Credit Unions Scholarship Schemes – most for girls Tuition Free primary education for all School feeding for 95% of lower and basic cycle school 3.2. Food Security Food security can be defined as when all members of a household have access to enough food to have an active and healthy life. Food security includes the ready availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods, an assured ability to acquire foods in socially acceptable ways (that is, without resorting to emergency food supplies, scavenging, stealing, or other coping strategies), and the adequate utilization of these foods, ensuring that daily caloric and nutritional needs are met 78 . The Gambia experiences fluctuating food security with limited access to a basic food basket due to overall low income, fluctuating availability depending on production of local food commodities and a high rate of 30 percent stunting in children under five indicating poor utilization. (WFP) Additionally, according to WFP The Gambia is a one of the countries most vulnerable to high incidences of food insecurity due in part to it is heavy reliance on rain feed agriculture and limited export trade status, with groundnuts as its main export commodity. Any variation in rainfall or climate conditions, such as drought or flooding, both common occurrence in the past five years, or fluctuations in the global market for groundnuts can result in food insecurity79. Effect on women and children When households experience food insecurity, coping mechanisms must kick in so that daily food requirements can be met. Some of these mechanisms may include reducing the amount of food consumed, and thereby an increase in childhood malnutrition, children being taken out of school to work or care for younger children while parents work, children missing school due to low levels of energy or illness related to a reduction in food, and women and children placed in situations of greater vulnerability as a means to earn money to meet household food demands. 3.3. Emergencies In recent years, the Gambia has experienced a significant number of disaster related events of natural and anthropogenic origins. The document on the hazard profile of the 78 79 United States Department of Agriculture, USDA. Women Bureau, ‘Key Informant Interview’, October 2010. 66 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Gambia and its vulnerability and capacity assessment report shows that these disasters are related to drought, floods, locust invasions, environmental degradation and epidemics. For example, between 2002 and 2006 there were 65 flood related disasters, and 45 incidents of fire in the West Coast Region alone. Recurrence of disaster events and the increasing concerns about the impacts of emergencies and disasters have attracted attention from both the Gambian Government and development partners due to the impact on vulnerable groups, impact on the environment and damage to national infrastructure80. During emergency situations, women and children are at risk of increased vulnerability, such as illness, injury, abuse, and exploitation. Children can be separated from parents or family members and exposed to increased harm, abuse or exploitation. Recent examples of alleged child trafficking during Haiti’s devastating 2010 earthquake demonstrates some of the increased vulnerability issues which are result of national disasters. Drought is one of the major ongoing emergencies which occur in The Gambia. The negative effects of drought on agricultural production and food security are evidenced by increased childhood malnutrition, increased pockets of extreme poverty and destruction to infrastructure such as homes, schools, and clinics. Flooding is another emergency that has been occurring in increasing frequency. The most recent flooding took place in the rainy season of 2010 and is addressed below. Flooding 2010 Heavy rainfalls which occurred in The Gambia from July – October 2010 resulted in flooding, with damages to infrastructure and livelihoods. Most heavily hit areas include West Coast Region, Kanifing Municipal Council and the Greater Banjul areas. A loss of lives and livelihoods was reported in areas up-country. In general, the most affected regions were concentrated in the western part of the country. The major damage which occurred resulted in damaged houses, impassable roads and bridges. Additionally a loss of food stocks, livestock and harvest crops were destroyed, affecting household food security and livelihoods, particularly for subsistence farmers. Most of the affected households have put into place coping mechanisms in the aftermath of the flooding. There was also some health and education fall out in the areas affected by the flooding in terms of infected water sources, which had been flooded and potentially 80 Government of The Gambia, ‘National Disaster Management Strategy’, GoTG, 2008. 67 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 contaminated by flood water. There was an increase in diarrhoeal diseases, malaria, skin, eye and acute respiratory infections. Some schools in affected areas were occupied by persons who had to evacuate their home or communities which affected access to school for students in these areas81. Effect on women and children In emergencies women and children often are put into vulnerable situations. They can be separated from family members, injured, and lack access to food and water. Special programming to address these needs should be put into place well before emergencies occur. Emergency prevention plans for the critical sectors of health, WASH, education and protection should be well developed in collaboration between government, CSO, and NGOs. National Disaster Management Agency The National Disaster Management Agency (NDMA) has established a national policy which seeks to minimize the effect of emergencies and disasters, by targeted planning recognizing the special needs of children and women. An overview of the background of the NDMA and the national policy is provided below. Background The Gambia Government’s interventions to avert major disasters can be dated to 1970 following the ‘Banjul Declaration’ calling for urgent measures to prevent the further degradation of the land, land cover and its disastrous consequences. The first government initiative in disaster risk reduction was the provision of emergency preparedness and contingency planning in National Environment Management Act (1994). However, this initiative lacked substantial progress due to some limitations of the Act, which failed to recognise the broader risks and laced the necessary coordinating mechanisms for successful administration. Cognisant of this deficit, the government set up the Disaster, Refugees and Relief Committee in 1996, (later renamed as National Disaster Management Committee) under the Office of the Vice-President. Since that time, government efforts to develop the national disaster management system have received significant UN and partner support. In 2006, with support from UNDP, the National Disaster Management Secretariat under the Vice President’s Office was established. Government of The Gambia/Civil Society/UN, ‘Rapid Joint Assessment of the Impact of the Heavy Rains and Floods in The Gambia’, September 2010. 81 68 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Through the UN support, a disaster management policy and a strategic action plan were developed and the National Disaster Management Act was enacted in 2008. The aim of the policy and institutional framework is to build safe and hazard resilient communities, by enhancing the use and access to knowledge and information in disaster prevention and management at all levels of the Gambian society. The Policy also establishes the strategic priorities and targets to guide, and inform, practitioners and highlights the need to institutionalise and mainstream disaster risk reduction approaches in national development planning strategies. In 2008, the Government created the National Disaster Management Agency and set up a National Disaster Fund. The mandate of the agency is to plan, coordinate the implementation and monitor all activities relating to disaster risk reduction programmes throughout the country both at national and local levels. Government’s Disaster Risk Management approach by NDMA focuses more on risk reduction and preparedness rather, than on relief and rehabilitation Chapter 4. Issues and Structural Support Context affecting the Rights of Children Information to focus on the Four Categories of Child Rights as outlined in the UNCRC – Survival, Protection, Development and Participation, and to include the most vulnerable populations 4.1. Children Survival - Child survival rights include the child’s right to life and the needs that are most basic to existence such as nutrition, shelter and adequate standard of living and access to medical services. 4.1.1. Health It is widely recognised that a healthy childhood is the foundation for a healthy adult life. Habits formed in childhood have a long term impact on health and well being. Important components that contribute to the healthy status of children are good nutrition and immunizations. A brief review of these issues follows. UNCRC Article 24 1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health and to facilities for the treatment of illness and rehabilitation of health. States Parties shall strive to ensure that no child is deprived of his or her right of access to such health care services. 4.1.1.1 Infant and Under Five Mortality The Gambia has particularly high rates of infant and under five mortality, which underscore some of the weaknesses within the health care system. The following section will review some of the causes of infant and child mortality and structures which are in place to reduce the high rates of death in infants and young children. 69 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 UNCRC Article 24 2. States Parties shall pursue full implementation of this right and, in particular, shall take appropriate measures: (a) To diminish infant and child mortality; (b) To ensure the provision of necessary medical assistance and health care to all children with emphasis on the development of primary health care…….. Up to the 1980’s, the Gambia had one of the highest rates of IMR and U5MR in Africa, but much progress has been made in reducing these rates and currently these indicators at 93/1,000 and 131 /1,000 respectively are in line with other rates in West Africa. Nevertheless there are significant variations across regions 82 . In rural areas, these rates are significantly higher (IMR 27 percent higher and U5MR is 36 percent higher) as demonstrated in the following table. Chart 5: IMR and U5MR in The Gambia as per LGAs, and Urban vs. Rural 250 200 150 IMR 100 UMR 50 Ru ra l Ur ba n Ba ss e Ku nt au r Ja nj an bu re h Ke re wa n m a an sa ko nk o Br ika M Ba nj ul an d Ka ni fi ng 0 Source: MICS 2005/06 Causes Neonatal deaths still account for the highest proportion of deaths of the under five year olds. According to the State of the World’s Children 2009, the neonatal mortality rate is 44 percent. Of this number the neonates who die, prematurity accounts for 34 percent with infection accounting for a further 28 percent and asphyxia 23 percent83. Congenital defects, tetanus, and diarrhea a further 10 percent with 4 percent covering other causes. Still birth rates are very high particularly in rural communities where access to emergency obstetric care is delayed (156 per 1,000 hospital based births). According to a study by Jammeh et al (2010) most of the rural still births were identified as fresh and therefore seen as avertable if emergency obstetric care had been available. World Bank, ‘Poverty reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, Poverty Assessment, WB, May 29, 2009. 83 INSERT 82 70 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 According to Cole et al (2010) the most common life-threatening emergencies in mothers and children are pregnancy related: massive peri-partum haemorrhage, eclampsia and sepsis. In newborn infants: failure to breathe at birth and sepsis and in children; malaria, pneumonia, malnutrition and diarrheal disease. Practices that delay the initiation of the first milk or do not support exclusive breastfeeding result in lower levels of these two vital practices that directly impact the chance of survival of children in the first year of life. Structural Support The importance of exclusive breastfeeding, duration and timely initiation of breastfeeding is well established (WHO 1995, Huffman et al. 2001; Saadeh 2003). Breastfeeding protects against a number of diseases common in developing countries (Ip et al. 2007). A review of studies conducted in developing countries found breastfeeding to be protective against a number of fatal diseases including lower respiratory tract infection and gastrointestinal infections 84 . Only 41 percent (MICS 2005/06) of women in The Gambia practice exclusive breastfeeding to up to four months, but national efforts to increase this number are implemented through Baby Friendly Initiatives and community awareness campaigns. According to the MICS 2005, the practice of initial breastfeeding within the first hour occurs in about 47 percent of women who deliver, and within one day in about 85% of women. This practice varies little among various dimensions, including mother’s education, wealth and rural vs. urban, as seen in the following chart. Chart 6: Initial Breastfeeding as per Wealth Quintile Source : MICS 2005/06 84 Rutherford, M., Dockerty, J., Jasseh, M. , Howie, C., Herbison, P., Jeffries, D., Mulholland, Adegbola, A. Hill, P., ‘Preventive measures in infancy to reduce under-five mortality:a case–control study in The Gambia’, Tropical and International Health, 2009. 71 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Additionally studies have shown that vitamin A is protective against common, serious and potentially fatal illnesses including diarrhoea, acute respiratory infection, measles and malaria (Humphrey et al. 1992; Ross et al. 1995; Thapa et al. 2005) 85. Vitamin A supplements are part of routine childhood immunizations and in child maternal health clinics which has resulted in an 80 percent vitamin A supplementation rate. 4.1.1.2 Childhood Illnesses Communicable diseases are the major cause of morbidity and mortality among children under five years, especially those living in poor conditions. Children who succumb to illness miss out on school, damaging their future prospects as well as the future economic health of their societies. Poor families are forced to spend a large proportion of their income on treating their children which damages the family’s ability to climb out of poverty. UNCRC Article 24 (2) (c) To combat disease and malnutrition, including within the framework of primary health care, through, inter alia, the application of readily available technology and through the provision of adequate nutritious foods and clean drinking-water, taking into consideration the dangers and risks of environmental pollution; (d) To ensure appropriate pre-natal and post-natal health care for mothers; (e) To ensure that all segments of society, in particular parents and children, are informed, have access to education and are supported in the use of basic knowledge of child health and nutrition, the advantages of breastfeeding, hygiene and environmental sanitation and the prevention of accidents; (f) To develop preventive health care, guidance for parents and family planning education and services. 3. States Parties shall take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children. The major childhood illnesses that result in the most deaths of children in The Gambia are malaria, diarrhea and acute respiratory infection (ARI)/pneumonia. There are specific programs which have been initiated to reduce the prevalence of these illnesses, but there is still much to be done to reduce the impact of these diseases on children. INSERT CHART with Childhood diseases – dependent on availability of data 85 Rutherford, M., Dockerty, J., Jasseh, M. , Howie, C., Herbison, P., Jeffries, D., Mulholland, Adegbola, A. Hill, P., ‘Preventive measures in infancy to reduce under-five mortality: a case–control study in The Gambia’, Tropical and International Health, 2009. 72 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Malaria In the World Malaria Report 2008, an estimated 247 million cases of malaria globally, (2006 WHO figures) led to almost 881,000 deaths, with over 75 percent of these deaths among African children under five years of age. Malaria is a leading cause of death in children under five in The Gambia. Causes Malaria is most often caused by a parasite called Plasmodium, which is transmitted through the bite of an infected female Anopheles mosquito helping herself to a blood meal to nurture her eggs. Malaria accounts for one in five childhood deaths in Africa. Anaemia, low birth weight, epilepsy and neurological problems are the common consequences of malaria in children. One of the leading causes of malaria, specifically in Africa, is the rapid spread of resistance of malaria parasites to chloroquine and the other quintiles, which are the only available drugs for treatment malaria. In the Gambia, resistance rate is XXX. Malaria and poverty Although malaria is treatable with anti-malarial drugs and preventable through immunization and sleeping under bed net, but resources to purchase these resources are often not accessible, especially to poor households. This issue receives significant attention in The Gambia with support the Global Fund, yet the MICS 2005/05 reports that household coverage is only 49 percent and there are 49 percent of under five year olds sleeping under ITNs (MICS 2005/06). There are ongoing campaigns to distribute ITNs to all areas in The Gambia. In areas of stable malaria transmission, very young children and pregnant women are at highest risk for malaria morbidity and mortality. Most children experience their first malaria infections during the first year or two of life, when they have not yet acquired adequate clinical immunity which makes these early years particularly dangerous. Adverse socioeconomic conditions leading to a reduced health budget and an inadequacy of funds for drugs, the high birth rates leading to a rapid increase in the susceptible population under 5 years of age, and the changes in the behavior of the 73 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 vectors, particularly in biting habits, from indoor to outdoor biters, all contribute to the malaria epidemic.86. There are economic costs to governments with high incidence and a stable malaria prevalence. Every year malaria is estimated to cost Africa $US 12 billion in lost Gross Domestic Product (GDP). It is estimated the disease has slowed economic growth in Africa by 1.3 percent per year as a result of lost life and lower productivity – what economists call a ‘growth penalty’. When repeated year after year it is a serious constraint to economic development87. The direct costs of malaria include high public expenditure to attempt to maintain health facilities and infrastructure, manage effective malaria control campaigns and provide public education. For countries with a high malaria burden, the disease may account for as much as 40 percent of public health expenditure, with malaria accounting for up to 50 percent of outpatient visits. In The Gambia, malaria accounts for XX of the national disease burden, and for XX percent of under-five outpatient attendance, XX of under-five hospital admissions, and XX of hospital deaths. The indirect costs of malaria are also widely felt as worker productivity lowers with increased sick leave, absenteeism and premature mortality of the workforce. For many the transmission period of malaria coincides with the planting season which further lowers agricultural productivity. For endemic countries, the presence of malaria can also deter investment, savings and turn away a potentially income generating tourism trade. Structural Support Relatively simple measures can greatly reduce the incidence of malaria. The Global Fund and Roll Back Malaria campaign strongly support the provision of ITNs. The WHO points out in fact, that “when people regularly sleep under mosquito nets treated with insecticide, serious cases of malaria decrease by 45%. Mortality among young people Ezine Articles, ‘Malaria is a Symptom of Poverty’, http://ezinearticles.com/?Malaria-is-a-Symptom-of-Poverty&id=3610504 87 The European Alliance Against Malaria, ‘Malaria and Poverty’, http://www.europeanallianceagainstmalaria.org/uploads/media/Facts_Malaria_Poverty.pdf 86 74 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 drops by 42% and the infantile mortality rate is reduced by 17% to 63%”. In the Gambia, over 775,000 ITNs have been distributed in all regions. (approximately XX households in 201088. Diarrhoea Diarrhoeal diseases cause approximately 1.7 million child deaths each year worldwide, making them the second biggest killer of children under five. In The Gambia, there is a 11 percent prevalence rate among children under five (WHO). Causes Diarrhoeal diseases are caused by ingestion of contaminated water/food or by poor hygiene and sanitation practices. They are most prevalent in areas where people struggle to find safe drinking water for drinking, cooking and sanitation. Untreated diarrhoeal episodes can cause severe dehydration and electrolyte imbalance (loss of essential minerals from the body) resulting in death. Other causes of diarrheal disease stem from a poor access to clean water and poor sanitation practices. According to the MICS 2005/06, only % of households in the poorest wealth quintile use improved sanitation. The most common source of water for the poorest households is an unprotected well. According to the Social Cultural Practices 2009, only nine percent of Gambia use soap and water during hand washing, which would be an obvious cause for the spread of diarrheal diseases. The following chart indicates that the majority of use from unimproved water sources, (unprotected wells) occurs in the poorest households. Chart 7: Water Source per Wealth Quintile 88 DestinationSante, ‘Malaria – a disease of poverty and a cause of poverty’, http://www.destinationsante.com/Malaria-a-disease-of-poverty-and-a-cause-of-poverty.html 75 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Source: MICS 2005/06 Structural Support Diarrhoeal diseases can be treated simply and effectively. Given the fact that they are mainly caused by a virus, most diarrhoeal disease do not require antibiotics. Oral rehydration salts (ORS), while do not prevent or arrest diarrheal diseases, are one of the most effective ways of ensuring diarrhoeal diseases do not result in lasting or fatal complications. In the Gambia, the use rate of Oral Rehydration Treatment (ORT) was 48.2 percent for children who had experienced diarrhea and the ‘no treatment rate’ was 51.8 per cent89. The following chart demonstrates that wealth is not a significant factor that regulates the use of ORT. Chart 8: ORT as per Wealth Quintile Source: MICS 2005/06 There also seems to be little significant difference in the use of ORT based on the Mother’s education level, as per the chart below. These results may indicate that health education campaigns about the effective use of ORT has been relatively successful. Chart 9: ORT use as per Mother’s Education 89 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, UNICEF, GoTG, WB. 76 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Source: MICS 2005/06 Pneumonia Pneumococcal pneumonia mainly causes illness in children younger than 2 years old and adults 65 years of age or older. The elderly are especially at risk of getting seriously ill and dying from this disease. In addition, people with certain medical conditions such as chronic heart, lung, or liver diseases or sickle cell anemia are also at increased risk for getting pneumococcal pneumonia. People with HIV infection, AIDS, or people are taking medicines that lower resistance to infection is also at high risk of getting pneumonia90. Causes Pneumonia can be caused by a variety of viruses, bacteria, and sometimes fungi. Pneumococcal pneumonia is an infection in the lungs caused by bacteria, which can infect the upper respiratory tracts of adults and children and can spread to the blood, lungs, middle ear, or nervous system. Health care experts have consistently identified pneumococcus as the most common cause of bacterial pneumonia in The Gambia. Acute respiratory infections are a leading cause of death, and pneumococcus is the most common cause of these infections. Structural Support In order to address these issues, a pneumococcal conjugate vaccine has been trialed in The Gambia, and has proven successful. The vaccine PCV7 was introduced into the EPI campaigns in 2009, and is currently part of the ongoing EPI activities. In order to increase the coverage rate, village health workers were trained to provide the vaccine. Data for PCV7 immunization rates are not available. 90 National Institute of Health, ‘Pneumococcal Pneumonia’, http://www.enotalone.com/article/10985.html. 77 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 According to the MICS 2005/06, sixty-nine percent of children under five with suspected pneumonia were taken to an appropriate health care provider, and 61 percent received antibiotics. Thirty- eight percent of children under five with diarrhea received oral rehydration and continued feeding. Although there is no significant difference in treatment seeking behaviors among wealth quintiles, as seen in the chart below, poor households are more likely to seek care through pharmacies and government health clinics, while the richest households seek care through private medical and also government health clinics. Chart 10: Care Seeking for Suspected Pneumonia per Wealth Quintile Source: MICS 2005/06 Immunisations In 2008 the overall immunization rate was between 91 percent and 96 percent (WHO/UNICEF). In addition to the usual infant immunizations children in The Gambia receive yellow fever and hepatitis B protection. Generally, immunization rates of children in The Gambia are making progress towards universal coverage as per the chart below. Chart 11: Immunisation Rates in The Gambia 78 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 120 100 80 60 Series1 40 20 m im Fu lly B Fe ve r He p Ye llo w d es un ise ea sl M DP T Po lio TB 0 Source: MICS 2005/06 According to MICS 200/06 data, there is little variation on vaccination coverage between ethnicity, wealth quintiles and mothers education. For example, the vaccination rate according to wealth quintile hovers between 87 percent - 95 percent , with the poorest quintile having the highest vaccination coverage (97.5%) as outlined below. Chart 12: Vaccination Rates per Wealth Quintile in The Gambia Source MICS 2005/06 4.1.2. Childhood Nutrition 4.1.2.1. Low birth weight Birth weight is one of the most sensitive – and also one of the most important – measures of the well-being of children. Weight at birth is directly influenced by the general level of health status of the mother. In developing countries, especially, maternal nutrition is one of the most important determinants of birthweight. Three aspects are of particular importance: inadequate maternal nutritional status before conception, short stature of the mother (mostly due to undernutrition and repeated infections during childhood), and poor maternal nutrition during pregnancy. According to the State of the World’s Children 2009, 20 percent of infants have been identified as having low birthweight in The Gambia. Causes 79 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In The Gambia, seasonal conditions have a significant impact on birthweight. The seasonal climate of short wet and longer dry season leads to food shortages. The hungry period is identified as the period July to September. The most vulnerable groups are women and children particularly amongst women who live in rural areas. Increased workloads on woman in these communities, as a result of the rural urban migration of young men coupled with an increased calorific demand and reduced nutrient intake impacts on their health. In pregnant women this in turn may influence the well being of the unborn child leading to low birth weight babies. 19.9 percent of babies born in The Gambia weighed less than 2.5kg at birth91. Low birth weight is a particular risk factor. Children of low (or very low) birthweight have been variously identified as at increased risk from neurosensory, developmental, physical, and psychological problems. Specific problems include increased risk of cerebral palsy, asthma, and upper and lower respiratory infections and ear infections. Low birth weight children are also likely to suffer from reduced rates of cognitive development and learning. Low birth weight also provides a powerful predictor of the future health of the child. Problems later in life include increased risks of coronary heart disease, diabetes and high blood pressure92 Anemia is another cause for low birth weight. According to NaNA, there is evidence of women not complying with the prescribed iron supplement which are provided during antenatal visits. Women do not like the side effects which they may experience when taking the iron tablets. Experiments to assess taking lower dosage iron are planned. Socio Cultural issues, such as early marriage and teenage pregnancies can also result in low birthweight. Poverty is one factor that underlies both of these issues, as early marriage can be a way to improve the economic conditions of the daughter, or the household (if the husband is able to contribute to her family) or of decreasing the economic burden on the family. This has a direct result on baby birthweight among teenage girls who may not be physically mature enough to bear children. Poverty can also lead to teenage pregnancies in cases where young girls are coerced into accepting sexual advances of older men in return for financial assistance or support (in the form of schools fees, assistance to the family, clothing or food). These liaisons may result in teen age pregnancy93. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘The State of the World’s Children 2009, Maternal and Newborn Health’, UNICEF. 92 World Health Organization, WHO, http://www.who.int/ceh/indicators/iugrnewborn.pdf. 93 The low contraceptive use in the Gambia is a contributing factor to teenage pregnancy as well. 91 80 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Structural Support Exclusive breast feeding for the first six months of life is critical for the best possible growth of the infant. NaNA in collaboration with UNICEF actively promotes exclusive breastfeeding. One of the innovative initiatives is the Baby Friendly Structures, which are small huts located close to agricultural production areas. This allows women to have their babies close by so that they can tend the fields and breastfeed throughout the work day. As a means to support child care and exclusive breastfeeding, a six month maternity leave clauses is mandated in The Women’s Act 2010. Among other intended outcomes 94 , the leave is meant to enable working women, who often do not have access to their infants during working hours to follow the best practice of six months of exclusive beast feeding. Additionally the National Nutrition Surveillance Survey, which is carried out every six months, ensures the on going monitoring for the identification of malnourished infants and children for referral to community and health nutritional recuperation programmes. (More information regarding the survey are included in the following section.) One of the major challenges which have been identified by NaNA is the need for better and more up to date nutritional data. This would help to develop programs that meet the nutritional needs of children and women and to direct limited resources for improvement of the identified needs. 4.1.2.2. Under Nutrition Under nutrition continues to be a major problem in The Gambia which is exacerbated by poverty, food deficit, rural – urban migration, environmental degradation, poor dietary habits, low literacy levels, poor sanitation, infection and a high population growth. Seasonal agriculture contributes to acute food shortages in the rainy season often referred to as the hungry season (July to September), the period of time when household food supplies are exhausted before the harvest season. Additionally the high prevalence of poverty translates into low purchasing power for both rural and urban households and has serious implications on nutrition and health95. Infants and children under-five are vulnerable to under nutrition due primarily to poor feeding practices, inadequate care and increasing exposure to infections with poor 94 There may be some negative outcomes to this mandate, as employers may less inclined to employ women of reproductive age, who will be out of work for six months after delivery. 95 Government of The Gambia, ‘National Nutrition Policy 2010 -2020’. 81 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 environmental sanitation. Exclusive breastfeeding for six months is practiced by only 41 percent of Gambian women96, even though there has been extensive awareness raising campaigns carried out on the importance of this practice. Stunting results from chronic under-nutrition, which retards linear growth, whereas wasting results from inadequate nutrition over a shorter period, and underweight encompasses both stunting and wasting. According to the MICS 2005/06, stunting was indicated in 22.4 percent of children under 5, wasting was observed in 6.4 percent and a further 20.3 percent were malnourished. Using WHO classifications The Gambia is ranked medium for stunting and high for underweight. 64 percent of children fewer than 5 were deficient in Vitamin A and 76 percent were anemic. As per the MICS 2005/06 table below, underweight and stunting are relatively high in The Gambia. These measurements are more pronounced in the poorer wealth quintiles as per the chart below. Chart 13: Nutritional Status (wasting) of Children Under Five Source: MICS 2005/06 Child malnutrition is also strongly linked with child mortality and the education level of the mother. The following chart indicates that women with little or no education have a much higher rate of children who are malnourished across all three proxy measurements. Chart 14: Child Malnutrition in Relation to Mother’s Education Level 96 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. 82 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Shading indicates moderate or severe degrees of malnutrition Weight for age - Wasting Height for age - Stunting Weight for height - Malnourished Source: MICS 2005/06. Micronutrient malnutrition Quite a few trace elements or micronutrients--vitamins and minerals--are important for health. According to the World Health Organization, one out of three people in developing countries are affected by vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Micronutrient malnutrition is highly prevalent in The Gambia with serious consequences for women and children. A national nutrition survey conducted in 2001 indicated that 64 percent of children under five are deficient in vitamin A and 76 percent are anemic. Iodine Deficiency Disorder (IDD) is a serious problem that has serious consequences for the mental development of children97. (Data is not available on the prevalence of IDD.) Causes Vitamin A Deficiency (VAD) Seasonal food availability and high cost of foods rich in vitamin A is the leading cause of VAD in children. There are many foods that are readily found in The Gambia that are rich in vitamin A such as liver, sweet potatoes, mangoes, leafy green vegetables, eggs, and milk. Yet not all households can afford these foods, especially if limited by seasonal availability and rely on diets which are heavy on carbohydrates and oil. Vitamin A deficiency is a common cause of preventable blindness and a risk factor for increased severity of infectious disease and mortality98. One of the first symptoms of marginal VAD is night blindness. If VAD worsens, additional symptoms of xerophthalmia arise, eventually resulting in blindness. Even more serious is that if a child becomes blind from VAD, only has a 50 percent chance of surviving the year. Even if children 97 98 Data for IDD is not available (Rice, West and Black 2004) 83 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 survive, blindness severely diminishes their economic potential. VAD may cause anemia in some regions, but it does not appear to impair children’s growth (Ramakrishnan and others 2004). Increased mortality is associated with VAD, most likely because of the detrimental effects on the immune system, which result in increased severity of illness (Sommer and West 1996)99. Iron Deficiency (Anemia) Iron deficiency is a principal cause of anemia. Two billion people—over 30 percent of the world’s population—are anemic, mainly due to iron deficiency, and, in developing countries, frequently exacerbated by malaria and worm infections. For children, health consequences include premature birth, low birth weight, infections, and elevated risk of death. Later, physical and cognitive development is impaired, resulting in lowered school performance. (WHO). Iron deficiency results from insufficient absorption of iron or excess loss. Iron is depleted primarily through blood loss, including from parasitic infections such as schistosomiasis and hookworm, 100 which are relatively common illnesses in The Gambia. The rate of anemia in The Gambia is 76 percent among children, as noted above. Poverty is one of the underlying causes of anemia as poor households may not always be able to afford food such as meat which are rich in iron101. Socio – cultural reasons such as family meal practices also contribute to the prevalence of anaemia in women and children as they are normally the ones in the family who are last to share from the family food pot. Iodine Deficiency Disorder (IDD) Lack of iodine is a major problem in developing countries and is considered to be the world's number one cause of preventable intellectual disability in children. Iodine is important to child growth and development. In the developing fetus, baby and young child, the effects of iodine deficiency are serious, including stunted growth, diminished intelligence and retardation. While salt is a part of the normal diet in The Gambia, the salt that is consumed, is not always enriched with iodine. In fact according to the MICS 2005/06, only 6.6 percent of households consume iodized salt. Structural Support Disease Control Priorities Program, ‘Adolescent and Childhood Diseases’, http://files.dcp2.org/pdf/expressbooks/adolsce.pdf 100 Disease Control Priorities Program, ‘Adolescent and Childhood Diseases’, http://files.dcp2.org/pdf/expressbooks/adolsce.pdf 101 There are other locally available foods which contain iron, but meat is the richest in iron. 99 84 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The National Nutrition policy 2010 seeks to protect, promote and support breastfeeding, improve national food security , improve food standards, quality and safety, prevent and manage infectious diseases, prevent and manage malnutrition as well as prevent and manage diet related disease. A National Surveillance Survey is conducted every six months in all regions in The Gambia in order to identify the prevalence and distribution of malnutrition in the population and to use this information to develop nutrition programmes which will reduce the infant and young children mortality rate. The overall objectives of the survey are to Indentify the distribution pattern and prevalence of malnutrition among under fives Identify and keep record of all malnourished children for intervention and follow up purposes Develop and employ adequate intervention strategies to prevent and mange malnutrition Evaluate the various strategies for their effect on the nutritional status of the target group. In support of this program, intervention strategies have been put in place. These are: Management of severely malnourished children at the community level utilizing Ready to Use Therapeutic Food (RUTF) Follow up on identified malnourished children by the responsible Community Health Nurses to include health education and cooking demonstrations were possible using locally available foods Intervention by the villages themselves through their village development committees.102 In order to address micro- nutrients deficiencies, NaNA in collaboration with UNICEF has included iron and vitamin A supplementation into EPI activities and in child maternal health clinics. According to the State of the World’s Children, 82 percent of children (659 months) have the full Vitamin A coverage, yet only 6.6 percent of households use iodized salt. As a means to increase this low national average, NaNA supported several measures such as; Mass sensitization campaign regarding the importance of iodine in child hood development, especially brain development National Nutrition Agency, ‘The Gambia Nutrition Surveillance Program Report’, 489th Edition, NaNA, Feb/March 2010. 102 85 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The promotion of iodine mixing into salt produced in The Gambia. UNICEF funded iodine mixing machines and mobile mixing units for salt producing communities in order to add iodine to salt Provision of iodine test kits to border security so that testing for iodine can be carried out for salt being imported for consumption. Baby Friendly Initiatives EXPAND The overall goal for Baby Friendly Initiatives is to help improve the well being of infants and mothers. Baby Friendly Communities Baby Friendly Communities have been established in XX communities in The Gambia. Under the BFCI huts have been set up near farm plots so that mothers who are engaged in agricultural activities are able to breastfeed their babies. Baby friendly communities concentrate on the overall health of the mother and child. Some of the activities include xxxx To become ‘baby-friendly’ a community must appoint eight people – a village health worker, a traditional birth attendant and six elected members, three of them men – to serve as a Village Support Group. They are trained in the BFCI Ten Steps, which they then pass along to pregnant and lactating women and their spouses. Baby Friendly Hospitals The Baby Friendly Initiatives in hospitals and health centres create a conducive environment for sick and well children as well as mothers. 4.1.3. Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) Inadequate access to safe water and sanitation services, coupled with poor hygiene practices, sickens or kills thousands of children every day throughout the world, and leads to impoverishment and diminished opportunities for thousands more. Poor sanitation, water and hygiene have many other serious repercussions. Children – and particularly girls – are denied their right to education because their schools lack private and decent sanitation facilities. Women and girls must spend large parts of their day fetching water. Poor farmers and wage earners are less productive due to illness, 86 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 health systems are overwhelmed and national economies suffer. Without WASH (water, sanitation and hygiene), sustainable development is not possible103. Eighty – five percent of Gambians use safe drinking water and 84 percent use improved sanitation facilities. 104 Yet the distance to water sources was raised as one of the priority issues that women and children raised in the FGDs. According to the MICS 2005/06, water availability varies according to rural vs. urban and wealth quintiles. Water sources are located on 55.4 percent of urban households, but only in 12 percent of rural households. The difference is more striking when analyzing wealth, none of the poorest quintile has access to water on the household premises, while 81 percent of the wealthiest households have water on the household premises. See the chart and table below. Chart 15: Use of Improved Water Sources by Wealth Quintile Source MICS 2005/06 Table 11: Use of Improved Water Sources by Wealth Quintile Poorest Second Middle Fourth Richest Piped into dwelling 0 0 0.9 6.5 24.2 Piped into yard 0 0.7 4.4 19.8 56.8 Public tap 16.4 36.4 53.4 48.9 12.6 Tubewell/borehole 51.7 31.6 14.4 8.5 0.4 Protected Well 14.4 10.7 8.1 5.4 0.8 Unprotected well 17.3 19.3 14.6 6.6 1.4 Source: MICS 2005/06 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene’, UNICEF, http://www.unicef.org/wash/ 103 104 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS, 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. 87 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In households where water is located outside of the household, the responsibility of bringing water rests with the women (76.3 percent urban, 84.7 percent rural) or girls under the age of 15 years (7.0 percent urban and 8.2 percent rural). Women in FGDs complained about the distance to the well and the depth of the well, stating that it was both time consuming and physically challenging. Even women who are heavily pregnant are required to fetch the water which can result in physical stress to the body and foetus. Sanitary disposal of excreta in rural households is 78.4 percent and 93.3 percent in urban areas, and only 55.8 percent of the poorest households use improved sanitary means to dispose of excreta compared to 97.2 percent of the richest households. This results in an inequity of resources to rural and poorer households that do not have access to, or use the necessary WASH facilities. The majority of schools in The Gambia are equipped with WASH facilities as mandated by government policy. Yet the facilities provided are in disrepair and often not used. In many schools the number of toilets are not nearly enough for the student populations. For example, in some of the large urban schools with a student body of several thousand students, there are very few toilet cubicles provided which are not nearly enough to meet the demand. Therefore children and teachers must resort to using the bush or other unsanitary practices in order to take care of personal hygiene needs. Additionally studies show that a lack of, or limited sanitation facilities often result in low enrolment or attendance of girls, especially as they reach puberty. Girls’ attendance has shown to increase in with improved sanitation facilities.105 INSERT Chart on number of facilities in schools Causes Budget constraints may limit the construction of appropriate WASH facilities in schools and health clinics. Additionally many poor households may not be able to afford to construct appropriate toilets and therefore must use bush or fields located near the community. This creates a public health problem for all members of the community. Traditional norms of not talking about personal hygiene, especially about the disposal of excreta can lead to poor hygiene practices. Sanitation and hygiene issues are seen as 105 Water AID UK, ‘Problems for children’, http://www.wateraid.org/uk/what_we_do/the_need/ 88 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 personal issues and not to be discussed. This culture of silence can result in challenges to public awareness raising on these ‘sensitive’ issues. Structural Support The National Sanitation Policy which is presented earlier in this report outlines specific measures that will help to improve the sanitation level for Gambians as a fundamental right. Some of the key focus areas are access to quality water sources and proper sanitation facilities in household, to ensure that schools and health clinics have adequate water and sanitation structures in place, and that education and awareness campaigns about benefits of clean water and proper disposal of excreta are carried out nationwide. Community Led Sanitation Initiative 4.2. Child Protection - Child Protection Rights ensure that children are safeguarded against all forms of abuse, neglect and exploitation, including special care for refugee children, safeguards for children in the criminal justice systems; protection for children in employment; protection and rehabilitation for children who have suffered exploitation or abuse of any kind106. 4.2.1 Birth Registration Birth registration is an important right which has been clearly identified in the UNCRC and other international human rights declarations. Many basic rights such as school registration, access to health care services, voter registration, national identify cards or passport application, and eligibility for political office are contingent upon birth registration documentation. This has not been a priority in The Gambia with only 55 percent of under five children registered at birth and a large number of children from 5 – 18 years old who have never been registered and have no official documentation regarding their nationality or citizenship. UNCRC Article 7 1. The child shall be registered immediately after birth and shall have the right from birth to a name, the right to acquire a nationality and. as far as possible, the right to know and be cared for by his or her parents…. As mandated in the UNCRC, all children have a right to a name and nationality and need to be registered at birth. In The Gambia, 55 percent of children under five have 106 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, ‘Child Friendly Version’, Summary of UNCRC. 89 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 been registered 107 . The goal by 2011 is to have 90 percent of children under five registered. Nevertheless there is still a large population of children between 5 – 18 years old who have not been registered, and who need to have this opportunity. Causes Prior to 2004, the majority of children in The Gambia were not officially registered. This was due primarily to the 1968 Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration (BDMR) Act, which placed the responsibility first and foremost on the father and only when the father is not on hand, or the child is born out of wedlock, does the responsibility fall to the mother. Further reasons for low birth registration rates included cost and long distance to birth registration centres, lack of awareness on the importance of birth registration, lack of knowledge on where to register their children and mothers ‘lack of information’ regarding their obligation to register children108. Structural Support The Government addressed the issue of low birth registration (approximately 32 percent in 2000) by integrating birth registration in reproductive and maternal and child health clinics, specifically into child immunization campaigns in 2004. According to the 2005/06 MICS, the registration of births increased to 55 percent for children under five as a direct result of this change of strategies which were implemented in tandem with mass awareness campaigns. The following measures were instrumental in the increase in birth registration rates109. 1. Ministry of Health’s mandate to register children The Ministry of Health (Department of State for Health and Social Welfare) is the only institution legally mandated to register births. The principal public health officer is designated to act as the registrar of births. Divisional- and district-level public health officers (PHO) stationed in all health centres and hospitals nationwide, as well as regional public health officers in each of the country’s five health regions, act as deputy registrars. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘UNICEF Good Practices in Integrating Birth Registration into Health Systems (2000-2009)’, Working Paper, Case Studies: Bangladesh, Brazil, The Gambia and Delhi, India, January 2010. 109United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘UNICEF Good Practices in Integrating Birth Registration into Health Systems (2000-2009)’, Working Paper, Case Studies: Bangladesh, Brazil, The Gambia and Delhi, India, January 2010. 107 108 90 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Gambia has also sought to integrate birth registration into health promotion activities. For example, mobile birth registration campaigns for children under age five are regularly carried out, at times in combination with mass treatment of mosquito net distribution. 2. Decentralization of birth registration The process of birth registration and certification changed in 2003, when two separate procedures were established for the issuance of birth certificates, depending on whether or not the parent possesses a clinic card for his or her child. Without a clinic card the procedures are more cumbersome. In the case of children with clinic cards, the parent(s) of a child is/are interviewed by the PHO, who enters the relevant details into the register and the birth certificate forms. The forms are then sent to the Births and Deaths Registration Unit in Banjul for verification and signature by the registrar and then returned to the public health officer for distribution. It takes approximately a month for the birth certificate to be issued in this way. For children without clinic cards, prior to taking the steps mentioned above, parents are additionally required to obtain an attestation of birth from the Alkailo (village head). A Justice of the Peace, a Member of Parliament or District Chief must then endorse this. Subsequently a six-member committee needs to scrutinize the request. 3. Integrating birth registration into maternal and child health clinics In 2004 birth registration was integrated into reproductive and maternal and child health clinics, leading to an increase of birth registration rates of children under age five from 32 percent in 2000 to 55 percent in 2005. With this strategy, birth registration ceased to be a stand-alone service, and has become integrated into highly decentralized child immunization services. As part of the integration of birth registration into maternal and child health clinics, growth monitoring cards, known in the Gambia as Under-5 Clinic Cards, are very popular with mothers throughout the country. According to the MICS 2005/06, approximately 90 percent of babies have Health Cards. Efforts to build on the popularity and wide usage of clinic cards, one strategy that is being explored in the Gambia is to integrate birth registration into clinic cards. The rationale would be that the fee for the clinic card would incorporate the fee for the issuance of birth certificates. The card records the date of birth of the child or the date first seen at the health centre. The birth 91 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 registration process then uses this as evidence of date of birth and transfers this to the birth register. This process has not been adequately achieved, and is still being refined. 4. Legal framework and enforcement In the Gambia the 1968 BDMR Act, CAP 41.01 of the Laws of the Gambia and the 2005 Children’s Act makes the registration of birth a legal entitlement of every child in the country, and the BDMR Registration Act mandates PHOs to act as deputy registrars. It also renders birth registration free of charge and makes the immediate registration of children compulsory for parents, stipulating harsh penalties in case of inaction, including imprisonment of parents. According to the Act, the father is the primary party responsible for registering the child within 14 days of birth and faces a fine or a month imprisonment in case of failure to do so. In the father’s absence, the mother will be responsible for registration, facing similar penalties. 5. Computerizing the birth registration system Efforts are underway at the Ministry of Health to computerize the birth registration system. Draft digitized birth certificates have been produced and are being analysed. Funding for this initial establishment of a computerized birth registration system and its subsequent maintenance remains a constraint. However, recent developments in 2009 include the delivery of computer software to the Ministry of Health that will facilitate the storage and retrieval of birth registration data by Gambian philanthropists. 4.2.2 Adoption and Foster Care Traditionally within the African context children who are orphaned are usually absorbed into the extended family structure. In the Gambia, among various communities this practice extends to the Kabilo structure110, which takes on responsibility for children who become orphans. Nevertheless, there are some children who may fall through this familial safety net and need be put forth for adoption. Additionally, there are some cases when parents may allow their children to be adopted so that the child will have a more economically advantageous life. It seems that within the last decade, there is greater attention given to this practice as news media covers stories about celebrities who adopt children from all corners of the globe, some who have living parents. While there are ongoing debates about the ethics of such practices, the overarching concern is that of the children who are placed in the adoption and that their rights are protected. 110 As described previously, the Kabilo structure is a community grouping of several extended families. 92 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There is also the case of foster care within the African context. The practice of sending children to live with relatives for schooling, to help family members care for younger children or carry out household tasks is a very common practice throughout Africa, including in The Gambia. Foster care is a positive aspect of a culture that embraces the tradition of the extended family. Yet children who are placed in foster care are at risk for mistreatment and abuse, both physically, sexually and emotionally. Special attention should be given to ensure that their rights are safeguarded. UNCRC Article 21 States Parties that recognize and/or permit the system of adoption shall ensure that the best interests of the child shall be the paramount consideration…….. Adoption and traditional foster care (which is not regulated by law) can leave children vulnerable to mistreatment, abuse, neglect or unfair discriminatory practices. Placing children in foster homes or in the homes of relatives is a fairly common traditional practice, which is not regulated. This issue of traditional foster care (or being placed in a family that was not their own,) was raised as an important protection issue by participants in the Children and Youth groups during the RTDs. Several of the participants explained that they themselves had been placed in this situation and did not feel that they were treated fairly or the same as the biological children in the family. In the Gambia there are fewer than fifty adoption cases a year, data related to foster care is not available but is a common practice throughout The Gambia, especially as parents send children to urban or peri - urban areas for reasons related to access to better educational opportunities. Causes Placing children in foster homes or in homes with relatives for usually education or work related reasons is a common practice in The Gambia. Poverty is one of the leading factors that lead parents to place their children with relatives who can provide better support to meet their basic needs. Also access to better or higher educational institutions is often only or more readily available for those who live in regional capitals. Therefore parents often send children to parents for access to post primary educational opportunities. Additionally, it is culturally appropriate for parents to decide to place a child with couples who are childless. Structural Support The DoSW has strict guidelines and policies for adoption, both in country and inter state adoption. Intensive background checks are carried out on prospective adoptive parents 93 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 in addition to a 36 - month period with regular monitoring reports every six months, until the adoption is finalized. Collaboration with social welfare departments in the country of placement is sought in cases of interstate adoption111. Nevertheless, The Gambia has not ratified the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Cooperation in respect to Intercountry Adoption and this has, at times led to the non-recognition by some signatory countries to the aforesaid Convention of adoption orders from The Gambia. This can put children further at risk. 4.2.3. Juvenile Justice - Children and Youth in Conflict or in Contact with the Law Globally, children who are in contact with or placed within the criminal justice system are at a high risk of mistreatment, abuse, torture and at times even death. Penal conditions vary around the world in correctional facilities with a wide range of laws and procedures governing children in these circumstances. In the Gambia this issue has been taken into high consideration and there have been efforts to ensure that measures are taken to protect the basic rights of children in contact with the law. Yet systems which have been put into place need further strengthening. UNCRC Article 37 States Parties shall ensure that: (a) No child shall be subjected to torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Neither capital punishment nor life imprisonment without possibility of release shall be imposed for offences committed by persons below eighteen years of age; (b) No child shall be deprived of his or her liberty unlawfully or arbitrarily. The arrest, detention or imprisonment of a child shall be in conformity with the law and shall be used only as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate period of time; (c) Every child deprived of liberty shall be treated with humanity and respect for the inherent dignity of the human person, and in a manner which takes into account the needs of persons of his or her age. In particular, every child deprived of liberty shall be separated from adults unless it is considered in the child's best interest not to do so and shall have the right to maintain contact with his or her family through correspondence and visits, save in exceptional circumstances; (d) Every child deprived of his or her liberty shall have the right to prompt access to legal and other appropriate assistance, as well as the right to challenge the legality of the deprivation of his or her liberty before a court or other competent, independent and impartial authority, and to a prompt decision on any such action. 111 Department on the Status of Women, ‘Key Informant Interview’, DoSW, November 2010. 94 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Children who commit criminal offences or who are accused of criminal offenses are especially vulnerable to abuse, including physical beating or torture within the justice system. Currently in the Gambia, there are fifteen children who are held at the Juvenile branch of the Jeshwang Detention Center and one girl who is held in detention at the Elderly Person’s Home due to a lack of available segregated space at the women’s facility. There are procedures and policies, such as the Children’s Act 2005 and the ‘After Arrest Procedures’, which are in place to ensure that the rights of children are upheld throughout the judicial process as outlined in this section. Criminal Responsibility The age of criminal responsibility is the age at which a child under this age is deemed incapable of committing a crime. The Beijing Rules for juvenile justice were adopted by the General Assembly of the United Nations in 1985 indicate that the age of criminal responsibility "shall not be fixed at too low an age level, bearing in mind the facts of emotional, mental and intellectual maturity" 112 . However, the age of criminal responsibility varies greatly across the world. The UNCRC and the Children’s Act specifically defines a child as someone under the age of eighteen. Yet the age of criminal responsibility for children in the Gambia is twelve years old. This is an improvement over the previous age of seven years old, yet issues of maturity and the ability to know right from wrong still comes into question with children who are only twelve years old. Causes There are a variety of reasons that result in children becoming involved in criminal activities. Many of these are related to poverty as children struggle to help their families or survive on their own. In some parts of the world, children may seek to escape an abusive family environment and income from criminal activities such as selling drugs, theft or prostitution may offer a means to support themselves. Specific data on juvenile crime is difficult to obtain, but currently there are 15 children who are held in detention. Information regarding the number of children who are currently involved in criminal proceedings is not available. Although data is lacking, anecdotal evidence suggests that at police stations across the country, there are occurrences when children get arrested and are accused of committing petty crimes. Sometimes these children are slapped by Police Officers, interviewed without the presence of their parents or Social Welfare Officer and put in the International Debate Education Association, ‘Age of Criminal Responsibility’ www.idebate.org/debatabase/ 112 95 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 same detention cells with adult criminals. All of these actions are clear violation of their rights. A major cause of this is a capacity gap at the level of the police, the parents and the children themselves. This capacity gap is in terms of awareness, understanding and recognition of children's rights on the parts of police and parents as duty-bearers and the children as right-holders. At another level it is a capacity gap in terms of lack of adequate resources being allocated by government as a state party to the UNCRC, for the police to construct separate cells for children and adults at each police station. Another capacity gap which is a structural cause is inadequate resource allocation to DoSW and the fact that DoSW is only located in Banjul and URR, which means that there is not decentralization which is needed to ensure that the DoSW officer can be present when children are arrested in all stations throughout The Gambia. While Police Child Welfare officers have been identified, trained and posted to each police station, in practice the system of Police Child Welfare is not working beyond the capital Banjul. Many of the trained Police Child Welfare officers have been moved to other police stations in the routine police transfers and have not been replaced by trained Police child welfare officers. In other instances these Police Child Welfare officers have not very active giving the impression that they see the police child welfare work as ad hoc and secondary to their main work as police officers. Children who are in this situation often do not know their rights or how they should be treated. Likewise, many of the officers who are in charge of children within the justice system may not be aware of the rights of children or receive adequate training in how children should be treated who are in conflict or contact with the law. Additionally, there are not always sufficient resources to provide separate cells for children. Structural Support Criminal Processing Under the Children’s Act 2005, children (defined as person under 18 years old) are guaranteed certain rights and treatment under the law. There are a set of processing guidelines that should be applied when children are suspected of crimes. These are outlined below. Pre arrest If a child is suspected of committing a crime and is arrested, parents of the child and the Department of Social Welfare must be informed, although this practice is at times not carried out. Arrest procedures 96 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 If children are arrested, they should be accompanied by a guardian during all processing procedures and children should not be placed in the same facilities with adults. In reality, however, parents or guardians are not always immediately informed about the arrest of their child or ward, nor is the DoSW always informed. UNICEF and CPA in collaboration with government developed ‘After Arrest’ procedures and provide training on these procedures. In cases whereby the children have committed petty crimes, the Social Welfare officer can negotiate with the police officer to release the child on bail or under custody of DoSW at the Children’s Center. However, for serious offenses and the child will have to go through the courts process. After arrest procedures – to be inserted Detention Children are to be detained in areas away from adults. Boys are held at the juvenile branch of Jeshwang Prison and girls are detained at the Elderly Person’s Home. The DoSW aims to reduce the trauma and stress related to arrest procedures by carrying regular monitoring visits during the child’s time of incarceration. Additionally academic classes or vocational training are provided. Court Proceedings Following the passage and in line with the Children’s Act 2005, the Children’s Court was established in 2005. While currently there is only one court located in Kanifing, there are plans to decentralize to the other regions. In general, The Child Court is designed to protect the child; therefore the only observers permitted are those directly connected to the case and the child’s family. Additionally, children are not ‘sentenced’ but are order to serve time in detention centres. The Child Court judges are made up of one social worker and two people from the community113. Sentencing According to the Children’s Act 2005 a child cannot be detained longer than three months for committing petty crime and no more than six months for a serious crime without going through the courts. During this time the prosecutor is required to gather evidence while at the same time the social welfare officer is also required to produce a ‘Social Enquiry Report’ which will contain information about the background of the child, United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Situation of the Juvenile Justice System in The Gambia’, UNICEF, 2010. 113 97 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 their family life and the circumstances of the crime. Then the case is presented to the judge who decides on what course of action to take. Attempts are made to make the court child friendly, with a special emphasis on reinforcing an atmosphere of the decision making over that of punishment114. The death penalty for children should not be applied to children who are convicted of crimes under, section 218 (1) (b) of the Children's Act, which indicates that a child shall not be “subjected to the death penalty or have the death penalty recorded against him or her." However, the death penalty is a constitutional provision and thus, since the constitution is more paramount than the Children's Act 2005, a child could have the death penalty imposed on him or her by the High or Supreme Court115. Probation After detention has been completed (time served is completed), children are placed on probation. There is a probation officer at the DoSW whose major responsibilities include to check up with children to ensure their reintegration back into communities. Other support The establishment of a Child Welfare Unit at the Police Headquarters and the provision of a Child Welfare Officers in all police stations, the establishment of seven Community Child Protection Committees, the creation of the Children’s Court, the creation of a Juvenile Detention Center, the provision of a Social Welfare hotline (which is to be used to report child protection violations) and the Shelter for Women and Children all help to ensure that rights of children are safeguarded within the legal system. The overall implementation of these initiatives is not completely successful due primarily to a lack of funding which limits structural and systematic support. Due to resources gaps, including human resources, these structures and systems of support are only available in the Great Banjul Area, which severely limits the rights of children in rural areas. This raises the importance issue of equity, as children regardless of their geographic location are entitled to fair treatment under the law. Budget allocations are partly responsible for this lack of funding to the DoSW. The social service budget as part of the overall Health Sector budget is allocated only minimal funding. United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Situation of the Juvenile Justice System in The Gambia’, UNICEF, 2010. 115 Child Protection Alliance, KII, 2010. 114 98 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 4.2.4. Violence against Children 4.2.4.1. Physical Violence/Abuse Child physical abuse damages children both physically and emotionally. The longer physical abuse of a child continues, the more serious the consequences. The initial effects of physical abuse are painful and emotionally traumatic for the child. The longterm consequences of physical abuse impact on the child in their adult life, on their family and on the community. In the most extreme cases, physical abuse results in the death of the child. It is important to recognize that physical abuse occurs across all socio economic strata and to understand the negative impact on the child and society as a whole. Measures need to be taken to protect children who suffer from physical violence whether it be within the family unit, in the school setting or in the wider context of other institutions in which children are placed for care. UNCRC Article 19 1. States Parties shall take all appropriate legislative, administrative, social and educational measures to protect the child from all forms of physical or mental violence, injury or abuse, neglect or negligent treatment, maltreatment or exploitation, including sexual abuse, while in the care of parent(s), legal guardian(s) or any other person who has the care of the child. Corporal Punishment in the Home Physical abuse can be demonstrated in various manifestations. According to RTDs participants, some examples of physical abuse used as discipline in The Gambia are beating, striking, burning, pinching, tugging of ears, whipping with a stick, locking up, or tying and spanking. When children are beaten, they report being beaten on various areas of the body as outlined below116. Areas where children report they are beaten All over the body - 43 percent On the back - 29 percent On the buttocks - 20 percent Head - 10 percent Face - 6 percent 116 Save the Children Sweden, ‘Beating the Misconception Not the Children’, ECPAT, UNICEF, 2006. 99 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Forty – six percent of children sampled in the corporal punishment report117 sustained injuries such as bruises (30 percent ), cuts (18 percent) and other (4 percent). Surprisingly, 24 percent received injuries resulting in internal bleeding, 12 percent had teeth knocked out and 9 percent had an arm dislocated or fractures118. As mandated in the Children’s Act 2005, any incidents of suspected child abuse should be reported to the proper authorities. Causes Corporal punishment is not always viewed to be a violent act against children and in fact many children, adults and teachers think that it is the only way that children will understand punishment. Corporal punishment in the education systems is outlined further in this chapter. Approximately 79 percent of parents believe or strongly believe that corporal punishment is accepted and normal way of disciplining children. About 68 percent of parents believe or strongly believe that children should be severely beaten in cases of gross misbehaviour, including locking up or tying up children. “…..if a child is disrespectful or rude, I give you difficult punishments. I will refuse you food or lock you in the room and would not let you go out119.” Structural Support The Children’s Act 2005 and the Criminal Code specify that physical assault is a criminal office and issues related to violence and the protection of women and children are clearly outlined. As noted previously, Community Child Protection Committees have been established in eleven communities (a total of 18 will be set up.) These communities, made up of approximately 17 community members120 serve as a front line measure for the purposes of reporting incidents of child abuse, awareness raising regarding child protection issues and data collection on child protection violations. Corporal Punishment in the School Save the Children Sweden, ‘Beating the Misconception Not the Children’, ECPAT, UNICEF, 2006. Save the Children Sweden, ‘Beating the Misconception Not the Children’, ECPAT, UNICEF, 2006. 119 Save the Children Sweden, ‘Beating the Misconception Not the Children’, ECPAT, UNICEF, 2006. 117 118 120 Committee members (the majority of whom are male) include the Alkailo, women leader, youth leaders and other members of the community who are chosen by consensus. 100 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The effects of corporal punishment on children can be long lasting. They can lead to depression, low self esteem, increased aggressive behavior in children, increased anti – social behaviors and impaired learning121. In The Gambia, ccorporal punishment is lawful in the home and schools 122 . Under English Common Law, parents can ‘reasonably chastise their children. In schools under Section 15 of the Education Regulations of the Education Act, “Firm discipline shall be maintained and enforced in all schools, but all degrading and injurious punishments are prohibited. And no child shall receive corporal punishment of any form save as in hereafter in this regulation. It goes on to state that “corporal punishment should be administered only by the head teacher or an assistant teacher in the presence of the head teacher, to female students only in exception circumstances, and logged in a designated book123. Studies conducted and discussions with children and youth indicate that corporal punishment occurs in schools. According to the Save the Children /Sweden Funded 2005 Survey of Corporal Punishment in The Gambia, children reported that in approximately 69 percent of schools in The Gambia employ corporal punishment. Only 10 percent of the students surveyed reported that they had not been beaten or subjected to other punishments by their teachers, with more boys reporting beatings than girls (22 percent, and 16 percent, respectively)124 . Chart 16: Corporal Punishment in School, according to children 50 40 30 YES count 20 No Count 10 0 Boys Girls Total Source: Combined 1, 2, 3 periodic reports on the UNCRC, Banjul Nov 2008 Causes Gershoff, E. T. ‘Corporal Punishment by Parents and Associated Child Behaviors and Experiences: A Meta-Analytic and Theoretical Review’, Psychological Bulletin, page 128(4), 539-579. 122 Tang, J., ‘Beating the Misconceptions, not the Children’, The Gambia, 2005. 123 Education Regulations of Education Act Cap. 46, Section 15 1990. 124 United Nations Convention on the Right of the Child, ‘Combined 1st, 2nd and 3rd Periodic Reports on the UNCRC to The Gambia’, November 2008. 121 101 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Corporal punishment is seen as an effective discipline measure. Attitudes that support the use of corporal punishment are common among educators, legislators, the general population and even children. Eighty percent of teachers report that they think that corporal punishment is an effective or very effective discipline strategy, although not all teachers reported that they would resort to using it (About 58 percent reported that they would not use it). Approximately 60 percent of children surveyed said that they believe or strongly believe that corporal punishment is the only thing that children understand when they disobey, and 58 percent believed or strongly believed that corporal punishment is an effective from of discipline125. Ideas based on cultural practices which view children in a secondary status as compared to adults, can perpetuate physical violence against children. As with women, who are sometimes viewed as ‘property’, children can be seen to belong to parents and as such treated as parents deem appropriate. Structural Support There are policies in The Gambia that outline that the use of corporal punishment should be abolished. The Children’s Act 2005 states that “no child shall be subjected to any social, cultural practices that affect the welfare, dignity, normal growth and development of the child….” It further states that parents have the duty to “ensure that domestic discipline is administered with humanity and in a manner consistent with the inherent dignity of the child.” Alterative discipline guidelines have been developed and distributed by the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education with the aim of diminishing or abolishing the use of corporal punishment in schools. Additionally, in 2006, UNICEF and the GoTG have produced an easy to read guide, Promoting Alternative Discipline for distribution. 4.2.4.2. Child Sexual Violence/Abuse Childhood sexual abuse can cause life long psychological and physical damage. The emotional affects of sexual abuse may not be evident immediately. Victims may discover abuse related problems as adults. Adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse may find that the abuse affects their ability to trust people and form close relationships. Adults also report feeling intense anger, low self-esteem and codependent and addictive personality traits, which can affect them through their life. United Nations Convention on the Right of the Child, ‘Combined 1st, 2nd and 3rd Periodic Report on the UNCRC to The Gambia’, November 2008, pgs 22-23. 125 102 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There is little reporting of child sexual abuse of children in households or communities in The Gambia. This may be due in part to the ‘culture of silence’ that seems to quell any discussion or revelation regarding what is perceived to be ‘personal or private matters’. Other reasons for minimum reporting may be that people in positions to report are not aware of any incidents child sexual abuse, that children don’t know their rights or that what is happening is wrong and should be reported, or that children have been told to keep the abuse ‘a secret’. Most of the research which has been conducted on child sexual abuse in The Gambia focuses on child sexual abuse and exploitation within the tourism sector. Nevertheless, according to the study on the Sexual Abuse of Children in The Gambia 2003, sexual abuse of children in homes, tourist areas and in communities as well as cross – generational sexual exploitation of children occurs in The Gambia. Causes Child sexual abuse is a sensitive and complex social issue with deep seated causes and results that can be devastating to those affected. Issues surrounding the family structure and power dynamics contribute to the incident of child sexual abuse. Cultural practices such as early marriage, where young girls are seen as eligible for marriage and sexually mature at an early age, may create an environment for child sexual abuse. The easy access that adults have to children within the Gambian context also places children in situation where child sexual abuse could occur. A ‘culture of silence’, that is pervasive in the Gambia, while not a cause of child sexual abuse, per se, tends to keep child abuse, especially child sexual abuse a closed issue with little discussion or reporting. Nevertheless, during RTDs, key stakeholders and women participants raised the issues of sexual assault and rape of young girls as an increasing problem in the country. Reasons that were given during the RTDs for the sexual assault of young girls were the prevailing ‘culture of silence’, excessive exposure to sexually explicit material in media, a lack of awareness of the issue and neglect of children. Structural Support The Children’s Act, the Women’s Act 2010, and the Criminal Code clearly outline that rape, defilement, sexual harassment, incest, indecent assault, and other sexual crimes are offenses, punishable by criminal prosecution. Reporting of such incidents are rare due to social and cultural stigma associated with the abuse. Victims may be afraid, 103 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 threatened, or made to feel ashamed or guilty. Children and adults may not know that there is a reporting structure and that it is their responsibility to report abuse Child Protection Alliance (CPA) has produced an information pamphlet on sexual abuse, outlining what it is and how to report if it is suspected. The Social Welfare Hotline offers a reporting link for children or adults who may suspect child abuse. The GoTG with support from UNICEF has set up Child Protection Committees in eleven communities throughout The Gambia. The overall function of these committees is to report and respond to issues affecting the rights of children or violations of these rights. These committees have proven successful in bringing the issue of child sexual abuse into the open for police action and public discussion and at times disclosure. Rape While rape occurs in a wide context of circumstances, there is limited information or official documentation of cases of child rape in The Gambia. The increase of the sexual assault (rape) was the number one protection issue that women participants in the RTDs identified. Antedotal evidence from media sources reveals a high incident of rape in The Gambia. Over the past year, there have been approximately 46 stories of underage rape, including the rape of infants, in two of the country’s leading newspapers126. Causes Rape is a crime of aggression and can occur to women, men and children under a variety of circumstances, and often the perpetrator is known to the victim. In The Gambia, rape cases are seldom reported in part due to the ‘culture of silence’, shame or humiliation that rape victims are often subjected to. Victims can feel that they are to blame or that they could have prevented the rape if only they had fought harder or had not been in the ‘wrong place at the wrong time’. Families may not want to subject children to further trauma that may result from criminal court proceedings and therefore not report a rape to the proper authorities. As with Child Sexual Abuse, cultural practices such as early marriage, and relatively easy access to children in the Gambian context, as well as the view that children ‘belong to parents’ can create an enabling environment for the sexual abuse of children. Structural support Gambian Newspapers, 34 stories about under-aged rape were reported in ‘The Daily Observer’, and ‘The Point’ Newspaper ran 12 stories of under-age rape, From January – November 2010. 126 104 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There are laws, such as the Children’s Act 2005, the Women’s Act 2010, and the Criminal Code that criminalize rape and set out the penalties for such an offense. The maximum penalty for rape is a life sentence and attempted rape up to seven years imprisonment. The Children’s Act seeks to protect girls from harmful practices and sexual offenses, specifically outlining the prohibition of the defilement of girls, abduction of girls under 16, indecent assault, and detention of girls against their will with intent to ‘carnally know her’. 4.2.5. Child Labour There are various definitions of child labor, which range from domestic labour within the household to slavery. The following section reviews child labor practices in the household, wage labour and some of the worst forms of child labor that take place within The Gambia. UNCRC Article 32 1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to be protected from economic exploitation and from performing any work that is likely to be hazardous or to interfere with the child's education, or to be harmful to the child's health or physical, mental, spiritual, moral or social development. 4.2.5.1. Child Labour UNICEF defines child labour as work that exceeds a minimum number of hours, depending on the age of a child and on the type of work. An estimated 158 million children aged 5-14 are engaged in child labour - one in six children in the world. Millions of children are engaged in hazardous situations or conditions, such as working in mines, working with chemicals and pesticides in agriculture or working with dangerous machinery. They are everywhere but invisible, toiling as domestic servants in homes, labouring behind the walls of workshops, hidden from view in plantations127. In Sub-Saharan Africa around one in three children are engaged in child labour, representing 69 million children. According to MICS 2005/06 and The State of the World's Children, approximately 25 percent of children in The Gambia (20 percent male and 29 percent female) in the sample size were involved in some kind of labor, with the majority of children working in the family business or on household chores. Only 3.3 of 127 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Child protection from violence, exploitation and abuse’, UNICEF. 105 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 the children sampled were performing unpaid work outside of the house and 0.6 percent were engaged in paid work128. Children living in the poorest households and in rural areas are most likely to be engaged in child labour. Those burdened with household chores are overwhelmingly girls. Millions of girls who work as domestic servants are especially vulnerable to exploitation and abuse. Additionally, labour often interferes with children’s education. Ensuring that all children go to school and that their education is of good quality are keys to preventing child labour. In addition to the MICS data, antedotal evidence which has been provided regarding street children and the work in which they are engaged indicates that there are children in The Gambia who miss out on educational opportunities to work on the family farm, tend younger children at home, or are sent out to sell small items (bananas, ground nuts, etc) as street vendors. In a recent Joint Donor Implementation Support Mission Visit, the following points were raised regarding children’s time use, indicating that many children in The Gambia are engaged in some form of child labour Children begin working at an early age, some as early as eight years old, especially in rural areas Children in urban areas are much more likely to attend school exclusive of work. Children in rural areas are more likely to mix school with work, working on average 4 hours per week. Most children in rural areas work as helpers on the family farm, almost half the the children in urban settings who are working, work in the services sector. Information regarding the transition from inactivity to school and work indicates that children tend to transition from school to full time work at the age of about 12 years129. Causes Poverty is the leading cause of child wage labour. Children work for a wage to help support the family. In these cases, when household income reaches a level that is enough to support the family, children stop working130. Yet, according to the ILO most African child labor is not wage labor but labor performed in the household. This United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘MICS 2005/06’, GoTG, UNICEF, WB. The Gambia Joint Donor Implementation Support Mission, Banjul, June 2010 , pg 10 130 18th International Conference of Labour Statisticians, ‘Report III Child labour statistics’, November– December 2008. 128 129 106 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 appears to be the case in The Gambia where 25 percent of children are working at home or in the family business. The ILO research indicates that girls who marry early are the largest group of child laborers. (The issue of Early Marriage is detailed further in this section.) Orphans carry out a large portion of farm labour, and of children who are begging or selling on the streets, a portion are doing so for religious or criminal organizations. This has implications on the level of education girls can attain and raises important protection issues for both orphans and children working on the street. 4.2.5.2. ‘Worst forms’ of Child Labor According to the International Labour Organization (ILO), Convention 182, the term "the worst forms of child labour" comprises: (a) all forms of slavery or practices similar to slavery, such as the sale and trafficking of children, debt bondage and serfdom and forced or compulsory labour, including forced or compulsory recruitment of children for use in armed conflict; (b) the use, procuring or offering of a child for prostitution, for the production of pornography or for pornographic performances; (c) the use, procuring or offering of a child for illicit activities, in particular for the production and trafficking of drugs as defined in the relevant international treaties; (d) work which, by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, is likely to harm the health, safety or morals of children. Data on all of forms of child labour as defined above is not available in The Gambia. Child Trafficking UNCRC Article 35 States Parties shall take all appropriate national, bilateral and multilateral measures to prevent the abduction of, the sale of or traffic in children for any purpose or in any form. The Gambia has become a source, transit and destination country for trafficking in children for sexual purposes. This is partly due to its unique geographical situation: its territory traces a route beginning on the west coast and through Senegal’s interior. The 107 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 number of children trafficked into the country for sexual purposes is small but a number of reports suggest that it is increasing131. Causes Poverty and lack of opportunity are two of the major causes of trafficking. Child trafficking typically begins with a private arrangement between a trafficker and a family member, driven by the family economic plight and the trafficker’s desire for profit and cheap labor. A potential trafficker may entice parents by offering jobs for children and the parents may believe them. Instead of giving the child a job, the children are put into servitude or given to someone else. Parents may think that in letting children go they are doing something good for them; but in reality the children are in extremely vulnerable and dangerous situations as they have little if any control over their lives; someone takes them and makes them domestic workers, and someone else takes all the money instead of giving them a salary. Traffickers may inform the parents that their child is doing well and getting paid, but they do not give money to the children or purchase necessary items for them. For girls, trafficking is believed to build on traditions of parents using their daughters as domestic workers rather than sending them to school. Research has highlighted that parents may prefer to send the daughter to work as domestic workers in order to contribute to the family income and help pay for school fees for other children. In 1994, Anti – Slavery International, an NGO working to prevent trafficking, suggested an evolution from the practice of child domestic labor to child trafficking: “the process of recruitment is becoming more organized, as agents and traffickers trawl rural areas offering incentives to parents,” the NGO noted. Specific data on Child Trafficking in The Gambia is not available. Structural Support The Trafficking Act Gambian legal provisions on trafficking are comprehensive: The Children’s ACT 2005 states that ‘a person shall not engage in child trafficking’ or recruit, transport, harbor or receive a child by means of threat, force, or other form of coercion, abduction, fraud, United Nations Human Rights, ‘Committee on Rights of Child Begins Consideration of Initial Report of The Gambia’, The Global Monitoring report United Nations, Accessed on 5 January 2007, from: http://www.unhchr.org. 131 108 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 deception, abuse of power or position or otherwise for the purpose of sexual exploitation or any other form of exploitation.” It goes on to state that a child’s consent may never be raised as a defence. If convicted of such an offence, the perpetrator is liable to imprisonment for life. The Gambia is a member of the Network against Human Trafficking in West Africa, GHANA-GAMBIA: Sex slave children trafficked by Ghanaian fishermen which promotes collaboration among According to the Gambian National Intelligence Agency, NGOs as well as building capacity, the girls were smuggled into the country without official papers to work as sex slaves for their Ghanaian advocacy and information sharing about masters. Ceesay confirmed this. She said the girls were national legal frameworks. A national forced to “satisfy the sexual desires of older men” and some were working full-time as prostitutes within the hotline for reporting of suspected child 5,000-strong Ghanaian community. trafficking was established by DoSW in The Gambian authorities said that the girls were also made to work long hours smoking fish and selling gari, a 2005. Additionally, CPA and Oasis popular Ghanaian staple made from cassava. Some boys smuggled into the Gambia were made to work as initiated a campaign , ‘Business Travelers fishermen. Meanwhile, their masters’ own children went against Human Trafficking’ to involve to school and had all their usual domestic chores, like washing their school uniforms and even cleaning their business travelers in reporting child shoes, done for them by the trafficked children. The trafficked children told Gambian officials they had been trafficking or sexual exploitation. CPA forbidden to contact their parents at home. has also been active in promoting a Integrated Regional Information Networks IRIN, 26 February 2004 Gambia Code of Conduct for the Protection of Children from Sexual Exploitation in Travel and Tourism and to raise the awareness of child sex tourism by conducting information workshops with tourist professionals and members of the Tourist Security Unit. Sex Tourism UNCRC Article 34 States Parties undertake to protect the child from all forms of sexual exploitation and sexual abuse. For these purposes, States Parties shall in particular take all appropriate national, bilateral and multilateral measures to prevent: (a) The inducement or coercion of a child to engage in any unlawful sexual activity; (b) The exploitative use of children in prostitution or other unlawful sexual practices; (c) The exploitative use of children in pornographic performances and materials. The Tourism Industry is one of the leading contributing factors to the Gambian economy (contributing 44 percent of GDP). During the tourist season (November – May), inexpensive packages tout the warm and sunny Gambian weather and beautiful beaches to thousands of mostly European tourists. Even in the climate of the global economic crisis, The Gambia still experiences a relatively successful tourist season. Yet 109 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 this positive contribution to The Gambian economy has a negative underbelly. The Gambia appeals to many tourists venturing to The Gambia for sex related activities, including child sex tourism. Although no up-to-date research132 has been undertaken on child sexual abuse and exploitation, anecdotal evidence indicates that the phenomenon increasingly occurs in The Gambia133. Few of the cases of sexual abuse by tourist which are brought to court, and fewer still reach a successful prosecution. Prostitution According to the Study on the Sexual Abuse and Exploitation of Children in the Gambia 2003, prostitution is an emerging issue among both boys and girls in The Gambia. Information gathered from the children interviewed indicated that there are many underaged children who are engaged in prostitution around the Senegambia Tourist Area (outside of Banjul) some as young as 12 years old. Unlike in other parts of the world such as south East Asia, third parties acted primarily as agents and not as captors of children 134 . The majority of prostitutes who were interviewed for the study articulated rational reasons for their involvement in prostitution, listing the need for money as the leading reason. One of the common themes among some of the prostitutes interviewed is that of ‘hiding income’ from family and parents, as there are some parents who are eager to receive supplementary income and would not probe their daughters for information about the sources of income. The children interviewed were from various backgrounds and age groups but a common finding was that many had been a victim of sexual abuse as young children in the family or school setting. This indicates a strong need to strengthen the awareness of, and reporting of child sexual abuse in what may be considered ‘family or personal matters’. According to this same study, a hotel proprietor estimated that 60 percent - 70 percent of tourists come to the Gambia for sun, relaxation and cheap sex. Nevertheless, the The UNICEF - GoTG, ‘Study on the Sexual Abuse and Exploitation of Children in The Gambia’ was conducted in 2003. 133 In the Tourism sector, the Child Protection Alliance (CPA) and Terre des Hommes study (2003) indicated that there is sexual exploitation of children in tourism. 134 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Study on the Sexual Abuse and Exploitation of Children in The Gambia’, GoTG, UNICEF, December 2003. 132 110 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Tourism Act was enacted after this study was conducted, which may indicate a change of statistics. More up to date research is needed on the issue of prostitution. Pornography According to the Study of the Sexual Abuse and Exploitation of Children in The Gambia, pornography does not seem to be a major problem in The Gambia, although there have been several news stories in the media which report children being used in films or tourists caught with pornographic photos or videos of Gambian Children. According to the children interviewed in the study, pornographic films are readily available and accessible by children in all parts of The Gambia. It was mainly boys who admitted to watching these types of film, and some admitted to have ‘sexual’ feelings and that it might lead them to want to be with girls in ways which ranged from sexual harassment to rape if girls were around. The study did not report any cases of children being involved in obscene exhibitions or indecent shows for pornographic purposes, but does refer to some of the dance troupes which perform in hotels as exploitative. These troupe organizers often select young girls from poor families and help to entice them to join the dance troupes with promises of meeting ‘toubabs135’ to possible travel to Europe. Causes There are many reasons why children in The Gambia are particularly vulnerable to sexually exploitation. Some of these reasons are outlined below. Poverty: The 2009 report by the Human Development Report states that over half of Gambians (56.7 percent ) live on less than US$2 a day. Families in desperately poor situations may accept contributions or gifts from tourists in return for allowing access to children. Additionally, the experience of poverty in the face of an increasingly consumerism can entice some children from poor families to see prostitution as the quickest and best option of breaking out of a cycle of poverty, or at the least of acquiring the some of the symbols of material wealth and success. Gender discrimination: The effects of poverty are particularly hard on women and girls who, due to issues of discrimination, often have less access to education, employment or land resources. This can leave them vulnerable to various forms of exploitation. However, boys are also vulnerable due to some of the same conditions of poverty and both boys and girls often work as vendors or apprentices in order to contribute to the household income. This can place them in situations that put them at risk. 135 Toubab is the local vernacular for foreigner. 111 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Wealthy adults/ tourists: Poverty increases the vulnerability of families to accepting promises of gifts and money by wealthy adults or tourists. While some tourists may make genuine offers, others donate in order to get close to the family’s children. Families may be tempted to ignore the sexual abuse of their children by the ‘donor’ in order to meet their basic needs, while others may persuade or coerce their daughters to become ‘friendly’ with ‘big men’. Additionally, families may be in denial about the source of extra income from their offspring, preferring to believe that they are working in a hotel, restaurant or bar. Early marriage: Early marriage is a common practice136 in The Gambia. While there are many problems associated with early marriage, the death of an older husband or divorce often leave the wife and her children without any means of financial support. This lack of financial resources can lead to young widows or divorcees being pushed into prostitution. Ironically, if a girl is not married early she is often viewed as a drain on her parents’ resources and may feel pressured to contribute to the household, which can make her vulnerable to sexual exploitation137. Direct interaction: Tourists can directly contact children by becoming sponsors of educational assistance or scholarships, getting mobile numbers of children, soliciting good from children on the beach or parking lots selling peanuts or fruit and by endearing themselves to families by buying food for the family and then offering educational assistance to children. Additionally, there is a broad range of actors and many ways that tourists can access children for sexual abuse or services. As outlined in the ECPAT Report, intermediaries can be hotel workers, taxi drivers, ‘bumsters’, and young men in four wheel drives driving around tourist areas who appear to provide services to tourists. Structural Support In addition to the UNCRC and the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child which have been ratified by The Gambia, The Children’s Act specifically legislates measures that protect children from sex tourism and prostitution. Under the Act, perpetrators of a sexual offence can serve up to fourteen years. It also outlines that anyone engaged or employed in the tourism industry commits an offense if s/he makes any sexual advances or offers illegal services or products to a tourist. These types of offences can lead to a fine or imprisonment of a maximum of two years and disqualification from tourism related work for ten years. 136 137 According to the MIC, 49 percent of women aged 19- 49 were married prior to their18th birthday. End Child Prostitution Pornography and Sex abuse – ECPAT/ UK. 112 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Tourism Offences Act specifically outlines illegal acts towards child and the penalties that may be imposed. The National Plan of Action against the Sexual Abuse and Exploitation of Children of The Gambia, covering the period 2004-2009, has been submitted to the Cabinet for approval and endorsement. Currently some of the work which is detailed in this plan is being carried out by implementing partners, such as the DoSW who is primarily responsible for coordinating the NPA implementation. Although the NPA was welldesigned, implementation has been somewhat fragmented due to funding constraints. Some of the activities such as dissemination of materials on prevention of sexual abuse and exploitation of children; and raising awareness about the Children’s Act, the Tourism Offences Act and the Code of Conduct of The Gambia Tourism Authority for the Protection of Children among travelers and stakeholders in the tourism industry were funded by UNICEF. UNICEF also supported the Tourism Security Unit (TSU) and purchased three vehicles for the TSU to patrol the beaches. A national database on Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children (CSEC) is being developed by the DoSW. Various trainings which have been sponsored by UNICEF, CPA and DOSW on sexual tourism have taken place including training for the police and immigration authorities in order to enhance the understanding of child sex tourism, investigation techniques and interviewing skills related to sexual offences against children. The Social Welfare Hotline is a means by which child sexual abuse, exploitation and sex tourism can be reported. International Structural Support Tourists who commit sexual offences in Gambia can be prosecuted under Gambian law, they can also be prosecuted in their country of origin for crimes committed while abroad. Many countries such as the UK, Sweden, South Africa, Togo and Germany have extra – territorial legislations to prosecute their nationals for sexual abuse and exploitation of a child in a foreign country. 4.2.6. Harmful Traditional Practices While the UNCRC protects the rights of children to participate in cultural practices and to engage in rites that are unique to their culture. yet there are some traditions that prove to be harmful to the rights of children and women. There is growing recognition that harmful traditional beliefs and practices underscore violence and discrimination against girls. This section will review two of these harmful traditional practices which take place in The Gambia; FGM/C and early marriage. 113 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 UNCRC Article 29 (c) The development of respect for the child's parents, his or her own cultural identity, language and values, for the national values of the country in which the child is living, the country from which he or she may originate, and for civilizations different from his or her own….. CEDAW Article 5 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures: (a) To modify the social and cultural patterns of conduct of men and women, with a view to achieving the elimination of prejudices and customary and all other practices which are based on the idea of the inferiority or the superiority of either of the sexes or on stereotyped roles for men and women; 4.2.6.1. Female Genital Mutilation and Cutting (FGM/C) The origin of FGM/C predates Islam and Christianity, but it continues to take its toll largely in Africa. According to studies on prevalence undertaken by organizations like WHO and Inter-African Committee on Traditional Practices at least 28 African countries are affected by the practice in varying degrees, but the total number of victims rises to over 100 million. According to the MICS 2005/06, 78% of the women sampled have some level of FGM/C. According to the WHO, there are four types of FGM/C. Type I involves partial or total removal of the clitoris Type II involves the partial removal of the clitoris with the partial or total excision of the labia minora Type III is the partial or total removal of the external genitila and stitching or narrowing of the vaginal opening. Type IV refers to any other traditional mutilation such as piercing, pricking or stretching the clitoris. Type II is the most common form which is carried out in The Gambia, although Type III is used by some ethnic groups. VERIFY In The Gambia, customary traditions and practices which include FGM/C are an integral part of society. One of the major events that take place in a young person’s life is transitioning from a child to an adult. Throughout the world, this transition from childhood into adulthood is often marked by an initiation ceremony, which is believed to help prepare young people for the responsibilities that come with being an adult. One of the main initiation ceremonies in The Gambia is that of circumcision for both males and 114 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 females. These rites symbolically represent the flow of life through the shedding of blood from the organs of reproduction. The harmful effects of this practice, both physical and psychological has received much international attention, yet is still practiced in many countries, including The Gambia. as noted, 78 percent of respondents had undergone some sort of FMG procedure. Women also support the circumcision of their daughters (72 percent said that they want their daughters to go through the initiation practice MICS 2005/06.) Therefore many young girls and women in The Gambia go through this ceremony and later face serious health related problems, including pregnancy complications. FGM is a traumatic physical experience with immediate complications including excruciating pain, shock, urine retention, ulceration of the genitals and injury to adjacent tissue. Other complications include septicaemia, infertility, obstructed labour, and even death. Yet if they do not submit to this traditional initiation ceremony, they are often stigmatized in the community and classified as ‘unmarriageable’. During the Round Table Discussions that were held for the SITAN, women respondents stated that FGM/C was a very important issue, yet expressed frustration that efforts to abolish this were futile as the traditional belief and practices were heavily ingrained within the culture. The sentiment that although there was significant work and awareness raising on this issue, ‘nothing will change’. The Key Stakeholders also listed FGM as a harmful traditional practice, yet seemed more optimistic that changes to practices and laws could be achieved. Causes The causes for FMG/C have been and can be heavily debated. Reasons can range from male dominance over women, especially women’s sexuality, the perpetuation of violence imposed upon women, religious directives that require these initiation ceremonies. Initiation into adulthood is the primary reason given in the Gambia for FMG/C. In areas where the custom is followed, everyone must undergo this practice, or the uninitiated child is to be considered a child irrelevant of age, which can become a stigma and is attached to great shame. In some cases, women can be classified as ‘unmarriageable’ if they have not undergone the procedure138. 138 Chikova, Social Policy, Social Protection and OVC Study in The Gambia, July 2009 115 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Reasons for FGM/C in The Gambia other than initiation ceremonies are briefly summarized below. Safeguarding the chastity of girls – as a means to protect the chastity or virtue of girls, FGM/C is carried out. Marriageability – as noted above, in the many communities where it is practices, virginity is seen as a requirement to marriage. The FGM/C is seen to ensure virginity and therefore ensure that she is marriageable. Sexuality – studies have suggested that FGM/C is a way of not only preventing premarital sex, but also of curbing a woman’s sexual desire. There is a concern that a man’s energies would be used up if he married an uncircumcised woman, and this is particularly so in polygamous relationships. While women may not feel that FGM/C is a way in which men control women’s sexuality, many Gambian men feel that it is an important consideration. (Daffeh et al, 1999)139. Economic Factors – money that is paid for the FGM/C provides a supplementary income to the practitioner. Studies show varying degrees of importance regarding this income, but there is usually a payment made for the procedure140. The level of education has some influence as to whether women undergo the FGM/C, with women (ages 15 – 49 years) who are uneducated with the highest incidence of FGM/C, as per the chart below. Chart 17: FGM/C as per Education Level of the Woman 139 Koroma, JM., ‘Female Genital Mutilation in The Gambia, A Desk Review’, Women’s Bureau, 2002 140 WHO, Female genital mutilation, Fact Sheet N 241, February 2010 http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/ 116 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Source: MICS 2005/06 Structural Support There are national organizations which are committed to raising awareness and helping to change the laws and traditional practices that promote and carry out FGM. For over two decades, the foundation for Research on Women’s Reproductive health Productivity and Environment (BAFROW) and the Gambia Committee on Traditional Practices (GAMCOTRAP), in collaboration with government have developed to address Harmful Traditional Practices such as FGM/C141. According to the UNCRC, the ACRWC, and the Women and Children’s Act, children and women shall be protected from harm or abuse. The CEDAW specifically outlines that cultural practices that are harmful to women can be modified or abolished. Yet efforts to include specific language prohibiting the practice into the Women’s Bill have been thwarted due to pressure from those members of parliament who uphold the traditional practice. Language regarding Early marriage, divorce and inheritance include , ‘unless customary laws apply’ allow for some of these practices that outwardly discriminate against women to continue. While FGM/C is not specifically addressed national legislation, any harmful practice that endangers children is clearly outlined in the Children’s Act 2005. In March 1997, working in collaboration with the World Health Organization, the Gambian government initiated a 20-year strategy to eradicate FGM. As a result, government ministers, health officials, and the media have discussed FGM more frequently; however, no statistics are available to determine the results of the program. 141 African Union, ‘AU Solemn Declaration on Gender Equality in Africa’ (Declaration). 117 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There have also been specific approaches tried to address the issue of FGM/C. Some of these efforts center around focusing on human rights and how FGM/C is a violation of basic human rights of women and children. According to Medical Research Council, these types of interventions are less successful and more controversial than outlining some of the medical reasons in which FGM/C is harmful. The provision of economic incentives to the practitioners has also been tried as a means to reduce the incidence of FGM/C by the Association for Promotion Girls and Women’s Advancement (APGWA). APGWA provides health care for women through a visiting midwife and also material benefits, which are distributed to communities that agree to discontinue the practice. Bafrow has provided income generation training for circumcisers and community members. The Alternative Employment Opportunities Feasibility Study which was carried out in 2001 found that all of the identified circumcisers were willing to give up the practice if assisted with an alternative source of income. 4.2.6.2. Early Marriage There are three key events that take place in most people’s lives; birth death and marriage. Only one of these is a matter of choice, marriage. Yet there are many girls who are married without a chance to make this decision. Some are forced into marriage at an early age and others may be too young to make an informed decision 142. The following section explores the relatively common practice of early marriage in The Gambia. CEDAW Article 5 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures: (a) To modify the social and cultural patterns of conduct of men and women, with a view to achieving the elimination of prejudices and customary and all other practices which are based on the idea of the inferiority or the superiority of either of the sexes or on stereotyped roles for men and women.. In The Gambia, there is no minimum legal age and child marriage is not prohibited by law. In practice, girls can be married at the age of twelve years. Early marriage in The Gambia results in young girls who are pregnant and not physiologically (or psychologically) ready for pregnancy. As reported in the MICS 2005/06, 10 percent of 142United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Early Marriage – Child Spouses’, Birth, marriage and death are the standard, UNICEF, Innocenti Research, http://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/digest7e.pdf, March 2001. 118 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 women (aged 15-49) reported being married before the age of fifteen and 49 percent before the age of eighteen. Early marriage can result in negative physical and emotional conditions. Young girls who are not physically mature may be hurt during sexual activity. Younger women face higher risks during pregnancy such as heavy bleeding, infection, anaemia and eclampsia. Psychological issues associated with isolation or some of the responsibilities of marriage can negatively affect a young girl’s mental state, creating stress or nervousness. Some of the specific negative consequences are outlined below. There is a strong correlation between the age of a mother and maternal mortality. Girls aged l0-14 are five times more likely to die in pregnancy or childbirth than women aged 20-24 and girls aged 15-19 are twice as likely to die143. Young mothers face higher risks during pregnancies including complications such as heavy bleeding, fistula, infection, anaemia, and eclampsia which contribute to higher mortality rates of both mother and child. At a young age a girl has not developed fully and her body may strain under the effort of child birth, which can result in obstructed labour and obstetric fistula. Obstetric fistula can also be caused by the early sexual relations associated with child marriage, which take place sometimes even before menarche. Good prenatal care reduces the risk of childbirth complications, but in many instances, due to the limited autonomy or freedom of movement, young wives are not able to negotiate access to health care. They may be unable to access health services because of distance, fear, expense or the need for permission from a spouse or in-laws. These barriers aggravate the risks of maternal complications and mortality for pregnant adolescents. As pointed out in FGDs, distance and poor roads limit accessibility to health facilities, especially if there are pregnancy complications and time are perhaps the most critical factors. Child brides may also suffer vulnerability to HIV/AIDS. Being young and female in Africa is a major risk factor for infection and young girls are being infected at a considerably disproportional rate to that of boys. Whilst early marriages are sometimes seen by parents as a mechanism for protecting their daughters from HIV/AIDS, future husbands may already be infected from previous sexual encounters; a risk which is particularly acute for girls with older husbands144. The age disparity between a child bride and her husband, in addition to her low economic autonomy, further increases a girl's vulnerability to HIV/AIDS. It exacerbates the abilities of girls and women to make and 143 UNFPA, 2005, Child marriage Factsheet The Forum on Marriage and the Rights of Women and Girls, Early marriage and Poverty - Exploring links for policy and programme development, 2003 144 119 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 negotiate sexual decisions, including whether or not to engage in sexual activity, issues relating to the use of contraception and condoms for protecting against HIV infection, and also their ability to demand fidelity from their husbands145. There is also a clear link between FGM/C and child and early marriages. Communities who practice FGM/C are also more likely to practice child marriages. In some societies, it it is relatively common in FGM/C practicing communities for a man to refuse to marry a girl or woman who has not undergone FGM/C, or to demand that FGM is carried out before marriage146. Causes There are many reasons for early marriage. Some of the key issues as related to poverty and cultural practices are outlined below. Poverty - In families where poverty is prevalent, a girl may be seen as an economic burden and the marriage to an older man who is economically stable may be believed to benefit the child and the family in economic gain. Also the dowry is an economic incentive to marry off girls. As per the chart below, early marriage is much more common among households in the lower wealth quintiles. Chart 18: Early Marriage in relation to Wealth Quintile in The Gambia Source: MICS 2005/06 Traditions and customs among ethnic groups Early marriage is a traditional custom among various ethnic groups in The Gambia and age for marriage differs according to ethnic groups 147 . For example, for Fulas and FORWARD UK, ‘Developmental consequences’, http://www.forwarduk.org.uk/key-issues/childmarriage 146 FORWARD UK, ‘Developmental consequences’, http://www.forwarduk.org.uk/key-issues/childmarriage 147 UNICEF, ‘Early Marriage and Teenage Pregnancy Report, UNICEF, GoTG, June 2000, pg 15 145 120 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Jalunkas – 13 years old is the norm, for Mandinkas – 15 – 16 years old and for Sarahules – 15 years. This tradition of a young marriage age, makes early marriage more common in Fula and Mandinka ethnic groups as demonstrated in the chart below. Chart 19: Early Marriage as per Ethnicity in The Gambia Source: MICS 2005/06 As noted earlier the basic types of marriage in The Gambia are civil, religious (Christian) or customary/traditional. The most common is customary or traditional which is based on tribal practices or guided by Sharia Law. As specific ages for marriage are not clearly defined by Customary or Sharia law, there are instances where girls as young as 11 or 12 are given away by their parents to older men without the consent of the girl148. Safeguarding women’s honor by protecting her fidelity is another reason for early marriages, ‘According to traditional ideology, strict sexual control of girls prior to marriage promotes their physical, social and spiritual well being. Female sexual restrain is believed to be important in order to prevent unwanted pregnancies or children born out of wedlock, which previously was a source of great shame to families. Also a woman’s sexual fidelity within marriage was a guarantee of the paternity of children for the husband and his family.’ Premarital sex in discouraged in most ethnic groups in The Gambia149. Adolescence is traditionally not seen as a natural stage of childhood development among most ethnic groups. Once the initiation ceremony has been conducted, boys and girls go directly from childhood to adulthood. Boys may be sent to school or to work until marriage, whereas girls are seen as eligible for marriage once they become an adult. Structural Support 148 149 UNICEF, ‘Early Marriage and Teenage Pregnancy Report, UNICEF, GoTG, June 2000, pg 14 UNICEF, ‘Early Marriage and Teenage Pregnancy Report, UNICEF, GoTG, June 2000, pg 15 121 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There are some NGOs (and other agencies) such as GAMCOTRAP, FAWEGAM, and Bafrow who work to raise awareness about harmful traditional practices such as early marriage and advocate for a change of attitudes and legislation. 4.3. Child Development - Child Development Rights include the right to education, play, leisure, cultural activities, access to information, and freedom of thought, conscience and religion. 4.3.1. Education UNCRC Article 28 1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to education, and with a view to achieving this right progressively and on the basis of equal opportunity, they shall, in particular: (a) Make primary education compulsory and available free to all; (b) Encourage the development of different forms of secondary education, including general and vocational education, make them available and accessible to every child, and take appropriate measures such as the introduction of free education and offering financial assistance in case of need; (c) Make higher education accessible to all on the basis of capacity by every appropriate means; (d) Make educational and vocational information and guidance available and accessible to all children; (e) Take measures to encourage regular attendance at schools and the reduction of drop-out rates. 4.3.1.1. Formal Education Early Childhood Development UNCRC Article 29 1. States Parties agree that the education of the child shall be directed to: (a) the development of the child's personality, talents and mental and physical abilities to their fullest potential…. Early Childhood Development programming is critical to the long term development of children. Early childhood is a vital phase of life in terms of a child's intellectual, emotional and social development. The growth of mental abilities is at an astounding rate and high proportion of learning takes place during this period. The first eight years of life is when the brain develops and stimulation is needed to ensure that children can reach their full “The early years of human development establish the basic architecture and function of the brain.” (J. Fraser Mustard) 122 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 potential. There are approximately 28,000 children attending 1,244 ECD centers throughout The Gambia. While the government supports ECD centers with regulatory standards, supervision and monitoring, the majority of these centers are in the realm of private entities. A strategy to target the annexation of ECD centres to primary schools has been started, with 472 ECD centres currently under the basic primary school structure. The impetus to target remote rural regions for annexation was triggered by the need to address disparities in access to ECD provisions. Until this annexation, ECD centres benefited mainly children in the urban and semi-urban regions, which are the areas where privately owned ECD provisions abound, and which are not accessible to the poorest children150. Early Childhood Development (ECD) Key service components include ECD Centres catering for 3 - 6-year-olds and Clinics and Daycare Centres for 0-2-year-olds. The Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education (MoBSE) provides technical assistance for ECD Centres, while the Ministry of Community Development supports Daycare Centres. But the overall administrative and policy responsibility for ECD lies with the MoBSE, which oversees a national multi-sectoral working group. Currently the gross enrolment rate of ECD is approximately 51 percent, which is a great improvement over past rates which hovered around 20 percent. Causes There are several reasons which lead to a low enrolment in ECD centres, which center on availability, affordability and quality. Availability Until recently, centers were not covered under the umbrella of the MoBSE and the responsibility fell on the parents and communities to provide these services. Therefore not all communities could afford or had the expertise to establish ECD centers, which resulted in part to an unequal distribution of ECD centres, especially in rural areas. As the majority of service providers are private and located in urban or peri – urban centers, 42 percent of urban children attend ECD centers compared to only 14 percent in rural areas. This gap in rural and urban ECD enrolment clearly demonstrates the inequity in the provision of early childhood development services that are critical to the Sowe, M., Draft Report UNICEF, ‘A Case Study on Early Childhood Development School Readiness in The Gambia, July 2010 150 123 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 intellectual development of children and impact their academic success throughout their life. Affordability As noted, ECD is largely provided by the private sector, making affordability an issue and a major constraint for poorer households. This problem is more pronounced in the rural areas, where poverty is more acute and where the tradition of leaving children in the care of siblings or grandparents, or having children accompanying their mothers to the farms or other work places, still remain the dominant practice for early childhood care. ( MoBSE 2006)151. Quality And finally, the quality of learning varies greatly; private (more expensive) centers normally offer higher quality and better care and instruction, and the community centers suffer from poorer quality instruction. Parents may be reluctant to send young children to centers when there is little or no learning achieved. Structural Support In its National Education Policy for 2004-2015 the Government of Gambia announced a plan to create ECD Centres for 3-6-year olds on the premises of primary schools in the most disadvantaged areas. The plan aims to optimise the existing school infrastructure and workforce for early childhood152. To date 472 ECD centers have been put under the supervision of basic primary schools, with plans for further expansion. Primary, secondary and tertiary education School enrolment and attendance Overall Gross Enrolment Rates in the Gambia is 92 percent, which is well above the sub Saharan average of 69 percent. Nevertheless there are regional disparities between urban and rural areas, with rural areas only registering around 45 -67 percent 153 . There has been a dramatic increase in girls’ enrolment levels in basic primary schools since 2005/06, with girls’ enrolment surpassing that of boys in 2008/09 as shown in the chart below. Chart 20: NET Enrollment Rates in Basic Education Cycle Sowe, M., Draft Report UNICEF, ‘A Case Study on Early Childhood Development School Readiness in The Gambia, July 2010 152 United Nations Educational Scientific and cultural Organization, ‘ECD programming’, UNESCO http://unesdoc.unesco.org/. 153United Nations Children’s Fund, PIQSS Concept Paper, UNICEF. 151 124 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 58% 2007/2008 60% Boys Girls 62% 2005/2006 52% 56% 54% 56% 58% 60% 62% Source: While gender parity has been realized in primary education, there are still significant gaps in girls’ education in secondary schools. (Girls’ education is address in the following section). The ETA/FTI has contributed to the increases in GERs across the country, yet there are variables across regions, income groups and mother’s education level, especially for secondary schools154. The chart below demonstrates the disparity in education rates among the various LGAs in the Gambia, which shows the gap in secondary education attendance in rural areas. INSERT CHART The Net Enrolment rate for Basic Education in The Gambia was 77 percent in 2008/09155. Variance of enrolment is demonstrated among regions with Banjul at the highest, reaching Education for All targets of 100 percent, while Upper River and North Bank have the lowest rates, with 45 percent and 53 percent, respectively. Madarasa Education continues to thrive throughout The Gambia, particularly in rural areas. The Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education (MoBSE) and the General Secretariat for Islamic/Arabic Education (GSIAE) worked to synchronize the various syllabuses in order to standardize learning and improve overall quality, which has contributed to improving adult literacy rates. Growth rates The education sector has seen significant progress over the past several decades, which has resulted in gender parity at the basic level. Basic education has seen an World Bank, ‘Poverty reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, Poverty Assessment, World Bank, May 29, 2009. 155 This includes the Madrassa education structure which is recognized in the formal education structure. 154 125 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 increasing trend of enrolment, especially for girls as the chart below demonstrates. (Lower Basic 3% average annual growth since 2000: 16% for private institutions, which have the highest growth rate). Growth rates – overall growth rates of education has increased overall since 2009, especially in the private sector, as follows; As outlined in the graph above, Lower Basic 3% average annual growth since 2000: (16% for private institutions having the highest growth rate). Chart 21: Basic Lower Level Enrolment in The Gambia 2000 – 2009 Source: Since 2005 grant aided education has experienced a drop of 4 percent while public institutions have remained stable. Enrolment in Madrassa schools has also increased by 16 percent over the last 5 years. Upper Basic education: 7% increase in enrolment since 2000 and 3% since 2005 compare with respectively 43% and 24% for Madrassa. Only private enrolment has decreased. Senior Secondary: average growth rate of 10% since 2000 (3% since 2005). Nevertheless, completion and transition rates are still higher for boys and drop out rates are higher for girls especially post primary rates. Causes/ Identified Barriers to Education While The Gambia Government has prioritized quality, access and management in the education sector, and has made progress in addressing some of the issues related to access, there is still a great need to identify and address access and understand why not all children in The Gambia are attending school. According to a desk review from 126 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 recently commissioned UNICEF ‘Barriers to Education Study’ 156 , there are many reasons why children do not attend school. These reasons are outlined below. Poverty and hunger – There is a wide discrepancy in enrolment rates between children in the upper wealth quintile (80 percent) and the lowest quintile (20 percent). Children from poorer households often must help with domestic chores, child minding, or even have to forego school to work in order to contribute to the family income. Hunger prevents many children from attending school and if children are in school, can affect concentration which directly impacts school performance. The following chart demonstrates the disparities of enrolment as per the wealth quintiles. Costs – While free basic education is implemented in the Gambia, there are costs beyond the school fees, such as uniform, books, food, etc that make it difficult for lower income children to attend. Opportunity costs of having a child in school rather than at home helping with domestic chores or child care also impact the right of children to attend school. Perceptions of schooling – If parents feel that an education may corrupt or spoil their children, they are hesitant to send them. Equally if children are bored or do not feel that they are learning they may not be encouraged to attend school. Socio-cultural factors – Many traditions such as early marriage and beliefs that educated women will have more difficulty finding husbands are a deterrent to sending children, mostly girls to school. Quality and relevance of education – The government’s three main educational priorities are access, quality, including relevance, and management. Access to education has been significantly improved, as demonstrated by increased enrolment rates, yet quality remains a challenge that needs to be addressed. Additionally many parents do not view the curriculum relevant for today’s changing economic environment. Many parents view education as an investment and that children once they go through the education system should be able to find employment and support the family. All too often this is not the reality. Children can pass through either primary or secondary schools who at the end demonstrates little academic achievement or skills that could qualify them for a vocation. At the same time, the child does not want or know how to farm and is seen as a non productive or contributing member of the family. This is an issue the government is addressing as it reviews and restructures the current curriculum. 156 At time of draft report this document is in DRAFT form. 127 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Gender Based Violence (GBV) – While statistics on GBV in schools are not available, the incident of violence toward girls in school have detrimental effects on the willingness of girls to go to school. Safety is a one of the major concerns parents express about sending children, especially girls, to schools located far distance from the home or away to boarding schools for higher level education. Limited Access to children with disabilities – The national policy aims to mainstream children with special needs into schools, yet there is little teacher training or appropriate infrastructure for these children. Some of the reasons for low enrolment rates that were identified by RTD and FGD participants were access to school, especially secondary schools, a lack of qualified teachers, especially in rural areas where there are sometimes only 2 – 3 teachers in a primary school consisting of six grades, sexual harassment (especially for girls) or physical intimidation by teachers and students, and the high cost of secondary school fees or ‘hidden costs’ associated with primary school. As noted, quality and relevance Issues are some of the most important factors that may prevent parents from sending children to school. Evidence of this can be attributed to the lower scores in subject matter by students. In the National Assessment Test, only 10 percent of students in grades 3 and 5 reached the mastery level (73%) in three core subjects ; Maths, English and Science. This information is supported by a 2007 study to determine the early grade reading skills of children in grade 3 across the country. This study found that an average of zero percent passed the skills test, indicating that children at this level cannot read. Some of the reason for low performance can be attributed to poor reading skills of children due to the absence of phonetics from the teacher training program, poor parental support for children’s learning (many parents are illiterate), the low quality of teaching, an inadequate supply of teaching and learning materials, and poor supervision and monitoring of teachers157. There are some significant disparities that exist in the education sector which indicate that poverty is the most discriminating factor and that rural areas (5, 6) are at the greatest disadvantage. Additionally, limited resources are not equitably distributed as 31 percent of the public education expenditures are used for only 10 percent of the most educated. There are specific disparities that exist within regions which need to assessed and addressed, but general disparities focus on poverty, gender and area of residence - urban vs. rural. 157 Presentation for Visibility Kit, UNICEF 128 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Thirty five percent of children in the poorest quintile and 22 percent of children in the second poorest quintile are out of school. For completion rates, the greatest disparities are based on wealth quintiles: Thirty-eight percent of children in the richest quintile complete grade twelve, while only 3 percent of the poorest quintile complete grade twelve. Both gender and poverty have significant impact on completion rates for boys and girls. Boys in the poorest quintile in rural areas have only a 5 percent chance to complete Grade 12, (compare this to 43% for the wealthiest boys in urban settings). Girls in rural areas in the poorest quintile have no chance (0%) of completing secondary school. This is alarmingly and places poor girls in rural settings in extremely vulnerable conditions with no chance for post primary educational opportunities. Boys in similar rural settings fare only marginally better, with a 5 percent completion rate. This further emphasizes the need to address the issues children in rural areas face and expand access to educational opportunities, especially secondary schools in rural areas. In the most rural regions, there is an approximate average of one fourth of children who are out of school. There are no gender disparities at Lower Basic or Upper Basic Education levels, but disparities start to emerge in Senior Secondary School. For example in Grade 12 there are 32 percent boys and only 25 girls, which is 12 percentage point variation. In the urban setting, boys in the richest quintile have a 43 percent completion rate, which is a 12 percentage point better chance of completing grade 12 than girls in the richest quintile, with a 35% completion rate, These statistics indicate alarming disparities which place poor children in rural areas at a great disadvantage in regards to education, especially access and completion of secondary schools. This has direct implications on the continuing cycle of poverty, as persons in these areas, with little or no education may not be qualified for high paying jobs, and therefore remain in lower economic status. This perpetuates poverty as these same populations may not be able to afford to send their children to secondary school. Tertiary education enrolment is low due to limited funding opportunities or scholarships for poor students, poor secondary school performance and a lack of secondary schools in rural areas which greatly decreases secondary school enrolment and ensuing progression to tertiary schools. There are opportunities for vocational and technical training exist, but this sector continues to experience challenges such as access to material and financial resources. 129 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Structural support There have been effective government programs that are supported through various donors and NGOS which address some of the barriers to education. Some of these government programs are outline briefly below. The DfID funded Whole School Development Program focuses on improving quality education in schools through improved school management, increased community participation, teacher training, curriculum development, and closer monitoring. The Quality Assurance Framework, the Primary Teacher Certificate Extension Program and the development of improved monitoring tools support the WSD program. The Child Friendly Schools supported through UNICEF funding encourage the full participation of all parties involved in the education of children to improve the overall effectiveness of the learning environment, including quality, retention and infrastructure. CFSI includes initiatives such as Mother’s Clubs and School Management Committees. 4.3.1.2. Non Formal Education pending data and information from MoBSE 4.3.1.3. Girls Education UNCRC Article 2 States Parties shall respect and ensure the rights set forth in the present Convention to each child within their jurisdiction without discrimination of any kind, irrespective of the child's or his or her parent's or legal guardian's race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national, ethnic or social origin, property, disability, birth or other status. A vigorous campaign in 2002 for girl’s education resulted in the creation of the ‘Girl Friendly Schools Initiative’ and scholarship programs for girls. The percent of girls enrolled in primary school is currently 77% (gross). Secondary school enrolment rates are 47% for males and 43% female (gross). The proportion of female to male enrolment rates in primary school education now stands at 109% and the net female attendance in comparison to male attendance is 103% (EMIS 2008). Literacy among youths (15 -24) during the period from 2003 – 2008 show 63% of young males and 41% of young females are literate (EMIS 2008).Thanks to the efforts of the Adult and Non-formal Education Unit (AnFEU) of the MoBSE which initiated literacy and functional literacy programs for women in particular in collaboration with Community Skills Improvement Project (CSIP) in the rural areas. These programs have proved successful in improving the literacy skills of the rural women and at the same time helped to motivate them to send their girls to school, which increased girls’ enrolment rates. There is now concern, 130 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 however, that male enrolment rates have dropped below that of girls in some regions (Education Sector Strategic Plan, 2006 – 2015)158. This chart below shows that there have been improvements in terms of enrolment and gender parity during the last decade, but there is still more room for improvement if The Gambia is to attain the recommendations of the World Education Forum {Dakar 2000). Chart 22:Girls Education Statistics in The Gambia Indicator (Female) 2001 2004 2006 2008 Enrolment 180,276 (85,503) 204,638 (92,007) 220,423 (111,883) 238,469 (174,142) Gender Parity Index 0.82 0.90 1.03 1.03 Proportion of Girls 47% 49% 51% 51% Gross Intake Rate 98% (85%) 98% (86%) 101 % (88%) 101 % (90%) Gross Enrolment Ratio 90% (85%) 91% (85%) 91% (93%) 92% (93%) Completion Rate 58% (60%) 63% (65%) 65% (67%) 70% (73%) Repetition Rate 7% (7%) 5% (6%) 5% (5%) 5% (5%) Source: Causes The causes identified as barriers to education in the previous section apply to girls’ enrolment rates. Yet there are also reasons which are unique to girls for lower enrolment which are explored below. Some of the reasons which were raised in the RTDs for a low enrolment rate for girls for post primary education (phrased as a low retention rate of girls) were poverty, teenage pregnancy (which can be also be attributed to poverty, see chapter five) sexual harassment in schools, ignorance about the importance of girls education, a preference on male education for economic reasons, and too heavy a work load for girls, especially in rural areas. Additionally, participants raised the issue of girls not be encourages to go 158 Sowe, M., Draft Report UNICEF, ‘A Case Study on Early Childhood Development School Readiness in The Gambia, July 2010 131 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 into sciences and maths which can lead to greater opportunities for post secondary education and lead to more lucrative long term employment opportunities. Structural Support Government of The Gambia through The Department of State for Education in collaboration with UNICEF and other development partners such as the World Bank have pursued a number of strategies within the context of its current education policy to meet its objectives. These strategies are: Policy Development: ensuring a favourable policy environment for girls' education has increasingly become a top priority for the Department of State for Education and the Government of The Gambia. Recently, these include the Education for All (EFA) Assessment, Monitoring of Learning Achievement (MLA), Disability Survey and Mainstreaming of Disability in schools, the Situation Analysis of Women and Children in the country. UNICEF has provided technical and financial support to several of these policy initiatives linked to girls' education. Capacity Building: building the human and material capacities of the Girls' Education Unit of the Department of State for Education to better deliver quality educational services to all especially girls has been a priority for the Department. This included training and provision of equipment. UNICEF has supported the capacity building efforts of government by contributing to the training of education officers, teachers and Early Childhood Care facilitators at both pre-service and in-service levels and training of school guidance counsellors. It has also provided vehicles and computer equipment to various units of the Department of State for Education and to The Gambia Chapter of the Forum for African Women Educationalists (FAWE-GAM). Service delivery: The Department of State for Education is not only interested in increasing access to education but also improving the quality of education. To this end, it has consistently tried to make basic learning materials accessible to every child. With the support of a United States National Committee called Alpha Kappa Gama, UNICEF has contributed to this effort by providing 40,000 copies of core textbooks for girls in grade one, to reduce the direct cost of education and ensure access to learning materials which is a prerequisite for quality education. Advocacy and Social Mobilisation: the Government has all along been aware of the importance of advocacy, sensitisation and mobilisation of communities to ensure sustainability and change negative attitudes towards the education of girls. UNICEF has 132 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 supported sensitisation campaigns of the Department of State for Education to raise awareness and mobilise resources for girls’ education. Community Empowerment: this has been done through training of communities in management, parenting education, Participatory Learning and Action (PLA) methodology. UNICEF has also provided financial assistance to women in communities to use as seed money to support the education of their daughters. Partnership and Alliance Building: UNICEF has supported the establishment of working groups and task forces in support of girls' education. It has also enhanced the mobilisation of youth and civil society organisations in support of girls' education nationwide, as well as successfully mobilising Non Government Organisations and donors, such as the United States Peace Corps, Catholic Relief Services, Voluntary Services Overseas and FAWE-GAM in the area of girls' education159. 4.3.1.4. Sexual Harassment and Exploitation in Schools In the Gambia and many other countries across Africa, commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC) is widespread in schools, as children are often forced to engage in sexual acts with teachers in exchange for better grades, reductions in school fees or other types of in-kind compensation. In focus group discussions carried out with Gambian school children by the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) in 2003, the topic of sexual harassment of girls by male teachers (and also male students) dominated discussions, suggesting that sexual abuse and exploitation of children are commonplace and affect the majority of schoolgirls. The incidences reported ranged from unwanted comments with sexual overtones to physical touching or molestation and in some cases to full-blown sexual relations or rape. Most students equated sexual harassment with rape and maintained that it is common in schools160. In support of these findings The Early Marriage and Teenage Pregnancy Study (2000) concluded that sexual abuse and sexual harassment of children is taking place in schools by teachers and other male students. Causes United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Girls Education’, UNICEF, GoTG. Child Prostitution, Child Pornography and Trafficking of Children for sexual purposes, ‘Global Monitoring Report’, ECPAT. 159 160 End 133 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The sexual exploitation and harassment of students is due to a variety of factors such as poverty, a male hierarchal social structure where girls and women have a secondary status to men, and the power dynamics that exist in schools and other places which have a hierarchical structure such as the workplace. (Teacher – student, bosssubordinate). Traditionally in The Gambia children hold subordinate roles in comparison with adults, which start in early childhood. Children are taught to listen to and obey adults in almost every situation. This is true in most institutional structures, including the school and may result in an environment when children do what teachers tell them, regardless of the nature of the instruction. This may create an environment in which sexual harassment and exploitation are tolerated. Structural Support The Gender Education Unit at the Department of State for Education implements a Girls’ Education Programme, which aims to increase girls’ enrolment and retention in schools, as well as to improve the school environment in ways that are sensitive to their needs. Their work includes sensitisation on sexual exploitation and harassment of children in schools and a re-entry programme for students who become pregnant. A Guidance and Counselling Unit was set up at the Department of State for Education Headquarters in Banjul, and some schools were provided with guidance counsellors to assist students experiencing problems such as sexual exploitation, abuse or harassment, and unwanted pregnancy. The Sexual Harassment Policy of the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education’ was drafted in 2005, but has yet to be legislated. Child Protection Alliance (CPA) and Save the Children /Sweden in close collaboration with the government authored and distribute a Guide to ‘Understanding Sexual Harassment and the Sexual Harassment Policy of the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education’. Sensitization on the policy and distribution of the booklet has been carried out in schools in The Gambia. 4.3.1.5. Programme for Improved Quality Standards in Schools (PIQSS) In recognition of the overall education goals focusing on quality, access, and management, the GoTG has worked with education stakeholders to streamline education initiatives such as the UNICEF’s Child Friendly School initiative and the Basic Education Support for Poverty Reduction implemented with DfID support. It is envisioned that synchronizing the two approaches will be a more effective strategy labeled the Programme for Improved Quality Standards in Schools. This comprehensive approach will directly impact the well –being and rights of children to quality education. 134 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The four target areas which will be prioritized are 1. Academic Effectiveness – focusing on child centered methodologies 2. School Environment – provision of adequate sanitation, and community involvement, including Mother’s Clubs and School Management Committees. 3. Leadership and Management – strengthening operational, financial and planning systems. 4. Monitoring and Quality Assurance – improvement of monitoring tools but internal and external monitoring. The program will be phased into the education system in three phases which commenced in October 2010. 4.4. Child Participation - Child Participation Rights encompass children’s freedom to express opinions, to have a say in matters affecting their own lives, to join associations and to assemble peacefully. As their abilities develop children are to have increasing opportunities to participate in the activities of their society, in preparation for responsible adulthood. Introduction 4.4.1. Decision making within social structures Children have the right to participate in decisions that affect their live and in the society in which they live. In The Gambia, there are limited opportunities for this kind of participation. UNCRC Article 12 1. States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child. Children and youth participants in the RTDs and FGDs voiced strong opinions about the need to be involved in decision making at all levels. They feel that their opinions and concerns go unnoticed or ignored. In the community, children are rarely asked their opinion, or little value is given to their concerns. In school, avenues for including children in decision making are few. Children are rarely given an opportunity to express their ideas or opinions on the management of the school, children are provided ‘token’ representation on the School Management Committees and do not have real influence over decisions that affect school policies or procedures. Again, participants in the RTD and FGDs expressed frustration at this lack of involvement. Causes 135 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In the Gambia, primarily due to the traditional patriarchal social structure, men as the head of the household make decisions affecting the family, at the community level, village leaders, who are for the vast majority men, make decisions 161 , and at the national level, children are not represented in national politics162 nor are issues that are raised by children on the agenda of political parties. Under the traditional family structure, the husband or father is responsible for virtually all decisions, even those which directly affect women and children. While there may be times when a woman is consulted, children are hardly ever consulted and decisions are taken for them without seeking their opinion. “Culturally they remain voiceless in the decision-making process”163. An example of this exclusion was provided during the RTDs, when one of the participants explained that he was not notified or given any opportunity to voice concerns about a major decision that affected his family. The lack of input in the decision making process affected this youth so much that his grades suffered and he did poorly in the year end examinations. School In The Gambia, schools are managed by the School Management Committees (SMCs). This committee is made of parents, teachers, administrators and student representatives. Due in part to cultural traditions, children are not used to being in positions of shared power with adults and are thus are not as effective members as the adults on the SMC. Therefore while representation is granted, in general children do not have meaningful input into the overall management of the school. Traditionally in The Gambia children hold subordinate roles in comparison with adults, which start in early childhood. Children are not normally given opportunities to collaborate with adults in a formalized structure. In fact, in certain situations, child looking directly into the eyes of an adult can be interpreted as a sign of disrespect. This may diminish the decision making role of children as members of the SMC. At the community level, purely village matters are decided upon by a village meeting. The right to attend this meeting depends upon the ethnic group, the locality and the local custom. Among patrialineal societies, such as the Mandingo and the Wolof (the Sagnia, ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, August 2010. 162 The legal voting age is 18 years old. 163 Sagnia, ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, August 2010, pg. 47-48. 161 136 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 majority ethnic groups in The Gambia); only adult male elders generally speak. If the subject of the meeting concerns women or children, the elder of that group may be asked to attend. It is expected that compound or family heads (men) would have thoroughly discussed the issues with their families and one another and have reached consensus before the village meeting. Therefore it seems that women and children particularly have little voice at the family level which would impact the level of input at the community level164. Structural Support While the government recognizes the need to encourage the participation of children and youth in national decision making, there are no forums for this involvement. Child forums or the National Day of the child are not given sufficient attention and resources. Programs that focus on child and youth participation such as the Voice of the Young implemented by Child Protection Alliance (CPA) actively seek to increase the participation of youth in the Gambia. The National Youth Policy clearly articulates the rights of youth to participate in the development of the nation. National Youth Policy The National Youth Policy 2009 – 2018 seeks to address the issues and rights of youth to ensure full engage and participation in the development of the nation. This is the third ten year policy and specifically targets out of school youth, unemployed youth, youth in rural areas, young people with disabilities or HIV/AIDS and emphasizes the needs of young women in this policy. Youth as defined in the national Youth Policy 2009 -2018 are young men and women from the ages of 13 – 30 years of age. (Although persons outside of this range can still benefit from youth oriented programming.) According to the policy, youth make up 47 percent of the population and youth unemployment is estimate at approximately 22 percent, which is well above the national average. The policy aims to engage these youth for the overall development of the country. As such it seeks to empower youth by addressing the following objectives: 1. To invest in youth for national development 2. To create employment of out of school youth Sagnia, ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, August 2010. 164 137 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 3. To enable youth in the country operate within a wide variety of cultures as such a culturally sensitive approaches with regard to mainstreaming the perspectives of youth in all national an local interventions 4. To ensure that the youth policy reflect the full participation of both male and female in national development – not only to ensure youth participation, but to also increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the Youth Council. 5. To enable the NYC to coordinate the implementation of youth projects and programmes based on sound youth dimension with a view to investing in the future of Gambian Youth. 6. To put in place institutional procedures based on policy guidelines which ensure that the needs of boys, girls, men and women are all met equitably in the national youth policy. 7. To formulate a framework the measures and ensures that youth – specific issues are systematically identified and addressed 8. To ensure that data on beneficiaries is disaggregated by sex for needs assessment an programme planning and youth analysis is integrated into programme design, delivery, monitoring and evaluation 9. To design strategies for capacity building in youth and investment mainstreaming as part of Institutional development programmes with special attention to staff training on youth mainstreaming and youth analysis 10. To ensure that reporting and accountability mechanisms for activities and results in youth and investment are put in place. The policy recognizes that the goals set out in the last Youth Policy have not been realized and aims to improve progress on these strategies and to introduce issues which are relevant in the current context. Some of these strategies are structure in recognition of the traditional power structure and the limited role of youth in decision making. This came out strongly in the RTDs as well. Some of the strategies which have been included in the policy can be summarized as follows Economic empowerment of youth Government to fulfill their responsible of an enabling environment for youth to thrive and prosper Create a policy to ensure equitable distribution of skills centers throughout The Gambia Ensure that special attention in the implementation of the Policy is given to the rights and needs of disabled youth Take measures of affirmative action to ensure the participation of women Promote equal and respectful gender relations among youth 138 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Facilitate the participation of youth in all aspects of youth programming 165 One of the gaps which has been identified in the youth policy, which was passed in 2010, is a lack of an accompanying action plan that operationalizes the directives which are set out in the policy. Without this plan and accompanying budget, this policy only outlines the policies which should be implemented, without the means or plans for action. 4.4.2. Recreation and Extra Curriculum Activities Under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, children have the right to play, recreation and culture. Play is crucial for many aspects of children's development, from the acquisition of social skills, experimentation and the confrontation and resolution of emotional crises, to moral understanding, cognitive skills such as language and comprehension, and the development of physical skills. While this is recognized as important to the development of children and a fundamental right, there are limited opportunities for children in The Gambia for structured recreational activities. UNCRC Article 31 1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to rest and leisure, to engage in play and recreational activities appropriate to the age of the child and to participate freely in cultural life and the arts. The UNCRC and The Children’s Act 2005 outline the right of children to participate in leisure, sports and cultural activities. Section 16 of the Children’s Act 2005 states that “A child has the right to participate in sports, or in positive cultural and artistic activities or other leisure activities. Schools in The Gambia are required to have adequate recreational facilities for students to engage in sport and other leisure activities. Yet children and youth who participated in the RTDs and FGDs prioritized a lack of opportunities for participation in such activities. As reported by the participants, there are few organized activities to recognize and address this right. Causes According to RTD participants, daily work routines, homework and a lack of structured organizations at school limit their availability and choices to leisure activities. As children are not involved in decision making processes in any level, they often do not have a 165 Government of The Gambia, ‘National Youth Policy 2009 – 2018’, GoTG. 139 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 voice in determining community priorities. For example during a FGD, the children explained that they wanted some unused land for use as a football pitch. Although there are limited opportunities for the engagement of children in community decisions, the children were able to make their ideas known to the village leaders. Nevertheless, the village leaders thought that this was not an appropriate idea as their priorities were to use all available land for agriculture. Structural Support National Assembly members have recognized the need for the Department of State for Youth, Sport and Religious Affairs to allocate more funding in order to help provide positive activities for the country’s increasing number of young people, yet funding for these sorts of activities have not been forthcoming. 4.5. The Most Vulnerable Populations Vulnerable children are those children who are at increased risk of not being able to access or enjoy their basic rights as defined in the UNCRC. Children living without the protection of their parents are potentially vulnerable as are other children who may be vulnerable due to disabilities or adverse circumstances. According to the Situation Analysis of Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children, the working definition for an Orphan or Vulnerable Child is a child below the age of 18 whom; has lost one or both parents, is severely disabled, lives in a household where at least one adult has died in the last 12 months, live in household where at least one adult has been seriously ill in the past three months out of the past 12 months, lives in a child headed household (where the head of household is less than 18 years old), lives in a household with only elderly adults (household contains children under 18 years old and adults over 59 years old), lives outside family care (lives in an institution or on the street). In addition to the categories which are identified in the Vulnerability Study, UNICEF has identified the following groups of children as specifically vulnerable within the Gambian Context166. 166 Children living in urban slums and remote rural areas Not ranked in order of most to least vulnerable. 140 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Orphans and vulnerable children due to HIV/AIDS Children living or working on the streets -The Almudos and Talibes Children with disabilities Children living in female headed households, especially girls Children from conservative religious or ethnic groupings that force young girls into harmful traditional practices ) – FGM and early marriage Children living in poor and large households Sexually abused or exploited children and those at risk of sexual exploitation Children out of school Children in conflict/contact with the law Children without birth certificates Children living in densely populated areas (not always necessarily vulnerable) 4.5.1. Orphans There are approximately 48, 000167 of orphans living in The Gambia Causes In The Gambia it is not uncommon for children to lose one or both of their parents before adulthood. In many cases, fathers are often substantially older than their wives168, and with high maternal mortality rates, there have historically been reasons for children to lose their mother or father. Estimates of the numbers of orphans and AIDS orphans which were reported for the ‘Children on the Brink’ report indicated that there are 47,000 orphans, and 5,000 AIDS orphans in The Gambia. With the advent of HIV/AIDS, the number of children likely to lose one, or in due course, both of their parents is predicted to increase. In a traditional setting in The Gambia the extended family provides a mechanism for coping with children who lose one or other of their parents. However with increasing poverty and rural-urban migration, the extended family system is often under severe economic pressure and may not have enough resources to cope with care for additional children169. According to the Situation Analysis of Orphans and other Vulnerable Children in The Gambia, there are a variety of characteristics/factors that increase the risk to United Nations Children’s Fund, UNICEF, unicef.org According to MICS 2005/06 in approximately 60% of marriages of women aged 20 -24, are married to men who are at least ten years old than they are. 169Ford, Jallow, Paine, Saar, ‘Situation Analysis of Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children in The Gambia’, August, 2004. 167 168 141 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 vulnerabilities. The quantitative analysis which compared the conditions of orphans and non orphans over a variety of factors revealed the following findings. Orphans have fewer birth certificates and health clinic cards than non orphans, yet more orphans had received DPT3 and measles immunizations. (This may be reflective of the fee attached to health cards, whereas vaccinations are free. There are fewer orphans in school than non orphans, including drop out and never attended, although academic performance is better for orphans than non orphans. Both orphans and non orphans report sharing from the household family food pot, however more non orphans report having enough food. More orphans talk about sex and having sex than non-orphans and more knowledge about HIV/AIDS. Orphans do their own laundry, but fewer report not having soap to bathe, and do not sleep under a bed net. More orphans work outside the household for money, including domestic work and farming compared to non-orphans. While surprising, more non-orphans are selling on the street. These results indicate that orphans are at a much greater risk to the denial, restriction or abuse of child rights. Structural Support The SOS Children’s Village provides care and shelter for orphans and children living in difficult circumstances. There are also institutions that take in orphans throughout The Gambia, especially in areas located close to tourist centers, yet there is little government oversight, standards or regulations for such institutions. 4.5.2. Street children Data available on street children is somewhat limited as official recognition is not readily forthcoming. Nevertheless, the DoSW identified two categories of street children; 1. Children living on the street, including sleeping on the street, and 2. Children who work on the street from early morning to dusk or after dark, and then return to lodging for sleep. As a response to growing concerns about the safety of children living or working on the streets, UNICEF and the Child Fund International (CF) (formerly Christian Children’s Fund (CCF)) conducted a rapid assessment of Street Children located in the Greater Banjul Area in 2005. The results of this study are listed below. 142 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Most of the children who were sampled were not from the Greater Banjul Area; Thirty – eight percent were from Senegal and countries in the sub-region. The majority of children sampled live at home and commute to the streets to work. Many of those that do not sleep at home live at their place of work or Madarasa (Koranic school). Most came to Banjul in search of work and educational opportunities. Only 5% of children indicated that their parents live in Banjul Center. The largest response group is Kanifing Municipal County (KMC). The second largest group (38%) is ‘other’ which includes Senegal, Guinea, Mali, etc. The third largest group is the Western Division with 22% of the total170. Children are engaged in different work activities. Girls tend to engage in street sales. while boys tend to do odd jobs such as carrying items or sweeping. Additionally, many boys are begging, which is associated with involvement with their involvement with a Madarasa. A significant proportion are exposed to risks at work such as accidents or violence from other children or adults on the street. Reported sexual activity is not particularly high. However, for those children that are sexually active, very few are protecting themselves from sexually transmitted infections, furthermore, understanding of HIV/ AIDS and means of prevention is very low. Causes The majority of issues that push children to the street are related to poverty. Most children who end up in Banjul are there for work or school opportunities. Many of the children identified may leave home due to a lack of sufficient care. 64 percent of children, who are not sleeping at home, reported that they have come to Banjul for work. 21 percent of children sleeping away from home said that they have come to Banjul for school. Many of the children in the latter category have come to study at a Madarasa. However, they spend a large proportion of their time in the streets begging for the Marabout.171 According to the rapid assessment, children who live or work on the streets are exposed to protection risks. Many are involved in exploitative work, children work long hours with little pay and some are injured on the job. A significant proportion indicated that they are exposed to violence. 170 Child Protection Baseline Assessment for Children Living and Working in the Streets of Banjul, United Nations Children’s Fund And Christian Children’s Fund – The Gambia, February, 2006 pg 8 171 The issue of Alumudos or Talibes is a sensitive issue that raises concerns from both government authorities and private organizations 143 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Structural Support There is limited support for children who are live on the streets. Child Fund has developed a program based on the risk assessment which addresses the issue of street children by providing life skills, opportunities for training and meeting other basic needs of these children. The Child Fund report recommends that projects should be set up to improve the safety of children who are at risk on the street, to include life-skills education. Child rights sensitization targeting employers and Marabouts should take place to improve living conditions of children. Additionally, alternative work and educational opportunities should be identified for referred children, and finally a minority of children will require family tracing, reunification and follow-up. 4.5.3. Children with Disabilities – section is pending further data analysis There are approximately XXX children living with disabilities in The Gambia Causes Structural Support The 1997 Constitution (Section 31 (1) (2) and (3) guarantees the recognition and respect for the rights and dignity of people with physical disabilities, as well as their protection from exploitation and discrimination. There are three schools which are dedicated to providing services for the disabled children. Campama School for the Blind Methodist School for the Mentally Handicapped St. John’s School for the Deaf All three of these schools are located in the GBA, which highlights the issue of equity. Children in rural areas who are disabled do not have the proper facilities to meet their needs, and may miss out on education due to a lack of facilities and staff who are able to accommodate their needs. Nevertheless, there is an effort to mainstream children with disabilities into the government school system. According to the National Disability Survey 1998, 25.7 percent of disabled children in the mainstream schools are partially sighted and children with speaking disabilities account for 12.5%, 8.9% have mobility problems, and those who have difficult hearing 144 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 are 9.7%, and those who are fit problems account for 3.7% of children as illustrated by the proportional pie chart below172. Chart 23: Disabled Children Mainstreamed into Government schools. Source: EFA Proposal for the Fast Track Initiative, 2003 There is an established multi – sectoral working group on childhood development including children with disabilities. Under the HIPC, micro credit loans were provided to parents of children with disabilities to help increase the family income. Sightsavers also provides funding to the Gambia Organization for the Visually Impaired (GOVI) to provide additional micro-credit loans to families with disabled children and assistance for technical mobility assistance to facilitate their movement and learning. A training manual on Early Childhood Development has been developed with one module addressing the needs of children with disabilities, which is used at The Gambia College for training teachers. Teacher Training College. The Department of Social Welfare regularly holds workshops to sensitize village leaders, teachers, and health workers on some of the main issues regarding children with disabilities. Chapter 5. Issues and support context affecting the Rights of Women. Information focusing on the general rights as outlined in the CEDAW (Health, Education, Employment/Economic Opportunities, Socio-Cultural, and Political Participation including most vulnerable populations. 5.1. Health CEDAW Article 12 Sowe, M., Draft Report UNICEF, ‘A Case Study on Early Childhood Development School Readiness in The Gambia, July 2010 172 145 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 1. States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in the field of health care in order to ensure, on a basis of equality of men and women, access to health care services, including those related to family planning. 2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph I of this article, States Parties shall ensure to women appropriate services in connection with pregnancy, confinement and the post-natal period, granting free services where necessary, as well as adequate nutrition during pregnancy and lactation. 5.1.1. Reproductive Health The importance of reproductive rights in terms of meeting international development goals has increasingly been recognized by the international community. In the September 2005 World Summit, the goal of universal access to reproductive health was endorsed at the highest level. Reproductive rights are recognized as valuable ends in themselves, and essential to the enjoyment of other fundamental rights. Special emphasis has been given to the reproductive rights of women and adolescent girls, and to the importance of sex education and reproductive health programmes173. The government attaches great importance to Reproductive Health issues as is indicative in the Population Policy and the United Nation Population Fund 5th Country Programme. Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well being and not merely the absence of disease. (WHO definition). 5.1.1.1. Fertility rates The Gambia has one of the highest rates of fertility in the world at 5.4% (Census 2003). It is higher in rural areas, with an average of 7.0 in Lower River Division and 6.8 in North Bank and only 4.7 in Banjul and Kanifing174. The higher rates could be attributed to difference in literacy rates, socio – economic status and access to family planning facilities175. Nevertheless, this rate is a substantial decrease from 6.39 percent in 1983 to 5.35 percent in 2003. Causes – pending data analysis Structural Support 173 United Nations Population Fund, UNFPA http://www.unfpa.org/rights/rights.htm. 174 Population and Housing Census, 2003 UNICEF West and Central African Regional Social Protection Transfer Training, Programme Country Note for The Gambia, Ghana, September – October 2010 175 146 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Contraceptive use and birth spacing are two ways in which national fertility rates can be decreased. These are outlined in the following sections. 5.1.1.2. Use of contraceptives According to the RCH, approximately 17.6 percent of the Gambian population use modern contraceptives. Although agencies such as The Gambia Family Planning Association (GFPA) encourage the use of contraceptives, family planning continues to meet with resistance for a number of reasons. One major factor that affects the utilization of contraceptives is the husband’s role in determining the family size. Causes As outlined previously, in the majority of households in The Gambia, men are the primary decision makers especially concerning family issues. As such it is often the man who makes the decision regarding the number and spacing of children. Many men do not support the use of birth control because they desire to have many children. Another deterrent to family planning is the practice of polygamy. Over half of married women and over a third of married men are in a polygamous relationship. Women in polygamous relationships may wish to gain favor with the husband by having more children, especially boys. (The preference of boys leads to more children as women may keep trying to have a boy or many boys176) During the RTDs, participants explained that boys may be preferred in some households for economic reasons as the boy will grow up to support the parents, whereas the grown daughter will live with her husband’s family and support them. Additionally, many men and women may feel that family planning goes against the teaching of Islam and the Koran as the Islamic Sharia Law encourages a pro-natalist attitude. Structural Support Contraceptives are available at family planning clinics. Survey data indicate that contraceptive and condom use is low but is rising in The Gambia. The contraceptive prevalence rate for modern methods is about 17 percent (RCH, 2010). Condom use (for family planning and/or STI/HIV/AIDS prevention) accounts for less than a quarter of modern method use (UNFPA). While condoms are not a popular family planning method, there is growing evidence that condom use is increasing for STI/HIV/AIDS 176 Sagnia, ‘The Influences of Socio-Cultural Factors on Development Effectiveness in The Gambia’, August 2010. 147 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 prevention, especially among youth. A survey estimated condom use at 34 percent among 1,000 unmarried youth (NACP, 2001)177. 5.1.1.3. Birth spacing Women in The Gambia space their children between two or three years apart. There are several factors that affect the spacing of births which are outlined below. Causes (Factors) In The Gambia, there are strong cultural traditions that influence women to have children every two years. In most communities, women are expected to have children every two years and any deviation from this raises concerns or questions among family and community members. As outlined in previous sections, men as the household decision maker is usually responsible for the timing and number of children in the family. In the majority of cases throughout the world, when couples lose a child during pregnancy or in childbirth, they quickly try to have another children. Yet studies on child spacing practices in Africa indicate that women whose pregnancies end in miscarriage or stillbirths are less likely to have a next child quickly. In The Gambia women who had a miscarriage or stillbirth were more likely than other women to postpone childbearing by using contraception. Some 14 percent of women who miscarried or had stillbirths used contraception subsequently, which is more than the percentage who used contraceptives during breastfeeding or after weaning. When asked why they used contraception after a miscarriage or stillbirth, women reported that they wanted to give their bodies time to rest, recover, and have a better chance of conceiving a healthy baby in the future. Structural Support The RCH promotes and implements a variety of programs that protect the health of women and children, which include active birth spacing through carrying out sensitization campaigns and including men in advocacy and information campaigns. There are also radio advertisements that promote birth spacing and contraceptive use. 5.1.2. Unwanted pregnancies There are many factors that result in unwanted pregnancies. One of the leading causes is becoming pregnant outside of marriage, which has strong social and cultural stigmas Accessgambia.com, ‘Contraceptives and Family Planning’, http://www.accessgambia.com/information/contraceptives 177 148 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 attached. Other reasons include, economic burden of additional children, uncertainty about the paternity of the child, increased burden on the health of the mother, and increased pressure by family members to continue to produce children, which may not be wanted by the woman. 5.1.2.1. Abortion rights and practices Abortion is illegal in the Gambia unless the health of the mother or child is at risk. Statistics on abortions that may be carried out in The Gambia do not exist as according to the DoSW and RCH ‘if abortions or attempted abortions occur, they are kept ‘underground’ or are unreported to health services or practitioners’. Government clinics are required to care for women who come to health clinics or hospitals and show signs of attempted abortions, but reporting of these cases is rarely done at this level. Only in rare cases when a fatality occurs due to an attempted abortion is it brought to the attention of the police. Causes As outlined above, abortion is predominantly sought in cases of unwanted pregnancies. Some of these issues are pregnancy outside of marriage, uncertainty about the paternity of the child, desire to continue education, inability to economically support the child, and pressure to have children when they are not wanted. . Structural Support Due to the illegality of abortion and to the hidden nature of this activity, there are a limited number of structures in place which provide information about the dangerous health risks associated with illegal abortions or self induced abortions, which can result in death. The RCH and UNFPA provide information regarding this significant health risk to women, and include it in awareness raising activities, but data on abortion and the impact on women’s health in The Gambia is not available. 5.1.2.2. Baby Abandonment Baby Abandonment is a complex issue as it involves child protection issues for the baby (the UNCRC stipulates that children have the right to survival), and also impacts women’s rights. Baby abandonment is primarily a result of unwanted pregnancies. As such, some of the reasons that result in an unwanted pregnancy such as freedom of choice, economic empower, decision making and cultural taboos that surround unmarried mothers directly impact women’s rights. Therefore, reasons for baby abandonment need to be further explored to fully understand this sensitive and ‘controversial’ issue. While it may be easy to place blame on women who abandon their 149 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 children, it is also necessary to fully understand some of the underlying causes and to seek solutions that will protect the child and ensure that the rights of the woman are also safeguarded. UNCRC Article 6 1. States Parties recognize that every child has the inherent right to life. 2. States Parties shall ensure to the maximum extent possible the survival and development of the child. The abandonment of new born babies is an increasing phenomenon in The Gambia which has socio - cultural as well as health and child protection implications. As the graph below indicates, from 2000 – 2004 there has been an increase in the reporting of baby abandonment which should be recognized and addressed. This increase may be attributed to better reporting practices due to increased sensitization around the issue rather than an increase in the practice. Chart 24: Baby Abandonment Cases reported in The Gambia Source: Research Report on Baby Abandonment Phenomenon in The Gambia, Unicef, June/July 2004 Additionally, in 2010, the media reported several cases of baby abandonment as per the chart below. Chart 25: Baby Abandonment in The Gambia, 2010 Abandonment 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Daily Ob. Point Source: UNICEF Communications Department 150 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Causes The reasons for baby abandonment are complex, but have much to do with poverty, the secondary status of women in a patriarchal society with limited control over decision making, and strict laws prohibiting abortion (abortion is illegal unless the health of the mother or child is at risk). A study conducted in 2004 identified several reasons for baby abandonment which are outlined as followed178. The leading and underlying cause for baby abandonment is unwanted pregnancies. Poverty and by extension the sexual exploitation of young girls in need of money is a leading cause for pregnancies outside of marriage, which are often unwanted pregnancies. Other factors that may lead women to abandon a baby are as follows: The father of the child denies responsibility Strong social and cultural stigma associated with pregnancy outside of marriage A desire to continue education The economic burden of raising a child Psychological unpreparedness of young girls Lack of, and ignorance about, the existence of childcare service providers (such as SOS) Culture of silence regarding taboo or controversial issues Structural Support The Child Welfare Unit at the Police Headquarters and the Child Rights Focal Point at the Attorney General are tasked with monitoring this issue. The Department of Social Welfare have specific guidelines and policies to address this issue. If a child is abandoned, DoSW works closely with the police to try to identify the mother. If this is successful, they work diligently in the ‘best interest of the child’, which may mean negotiating with the police so that the mother is not taken into custody but rather is allowed to stay at the Women’s and Children’s Shelter, where she can care for the child and receive counseling and parental skills training. Efforts are also made to find the father of the child and ensure that he takes at minimum, financial responsibility for the child. As noted, there are strict laws against child abandonment in the Children’s Act which guarantees the right to survival, the right to parental care, protection and maintenance, and clearly states that parents have to ‘ensure that the best interest of the child are their basic concerns at all times’. 178 United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘Research Report on Baby Abandonment Phenomenon in The Gambia’, UNICEF, June/July 2004. 151 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Women’s Act specifically states that girls should not be not dismissed from school for pregnancy, yet there is no real support or counseling services available for girls or women who find themselves with an unwanted pregnancy. The DoSW has initiated sensitization campaigns to raise the awareness about baby abandonment, but closer collaboration with national agencies such as the SOS program, the Child Protection Alliance, and options of foster or adoptive parents is still needed. Addressing the underlying causes for baby abandonment such as unwanted pregnancies, social and culture practices and beliefs that stigmatize pregnancy outside of marriage, and limited options or resources for women who find themselves with an unwanted pregnancy should be addressed in order to appropriately respond to the issue of baby abandonment. Additionally, if women were better able to support themselves, they may feel more prepared to keep children who are a result of unwanted pregnancies. As a means to help empower women and create an environment of greater self sufficiency, opportunities for vocational training and higher education opportunities should be available for all girls and women179. 5.1.3 Maternal Health 5.1.3.1. Pregnancy Care and Complications Antenatal care The issue of poor maternity care in The Gambia was identified by all Round Table participants and by several communities targeted in the FGDs. Reasons which were identified for this included poverty, poor salary level for healthcare workers, distance to health clinics, lack of medications, and inadequate number of trained staff. Causes Antenatal care in The Gambia is available through maternal child health clinics or mobile units provided through the primary health care posts or outreach clinics throughout The Gambia. According to MICS 2005.06, 97 percent of Gambia women attend at least one antenatal check up by trained personnel. Nevertheless, there seems to be limited knowledge regarding some of the danger signs related to pregnancy or childbirth by women. For women who visit health clinics, some of the basic mandatory tests such as urine analysis or hemoglobin estimation are not done. These issues 179 Sanneh, Nyakassi, and Touray, ‘Research Report on Baby abandonment in the Gambia’, UNICEF, July 2004. 152 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 affect the overall health care received by women and contribute to the high maternal mortality rate. Postnatal care Remarkably despite the reality that the majority of maternal deaths in The Gambia occur within the first few days after delivery, there is minimal health care for the mother after the delivery, A study conducted 2002180, indicated that more than two-thirds of Gambian women are not provided with any form of postpartum care or examination. Women who deliver in health facilities spend very little time (a few hours only) after delivery at the facility. For women who birth at home (approximately 48 percent of pregnant women), there is little post delivery follow up by trained workers, rather it is the TBA who attempts to carry out post partum care. TBAs receive on going training on antenatal and post natal care. Structural Support There are regular and ongoing training on antenatal and postnatal care that is provided by the RCH to all service providers including TBAs. There are national interventions that also support maternal health initiatives such as The Child Health Policy The Safe Motherhood Program Fee Free Maternal Health Care Provision of EOC capacity in rural health clinics Presidential decree on the importance of Emergency Obstetric Care EMNCH – Emergency Maternal and New born Child Health Initiative, which includes the ‘Ambulance Flying Squad’, a rural based ambulance service that has been established to respond to obstetric emergencies in rural areas. Pregnancy Complications Fistula Each year between 50,000 to 100,000 women worldwide are affected by obstetric fistula, a hole in the birth canal. In the Gambia there are approximately XXX of cases per year. The development of obstetric fistula is directly linked to one of the major causes of maternal mortality: obstructed labour. Telfer, ML, Rowley, JT., Walraven, GE, ‘Experiences of mothers with antennal, deliver and postpartum care in rural Gambia’, African Journal for Reproductive Health, 2002. 180 153 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Women who experience obstetric fistula suffer constant incontinence, shame, and social segregation and health problems. It is estimated that more than 2 million young women live with untreated obstetric fistula in Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. Obstetric fistula is preventable; it can largely be avoided by: delaying the age of first pregnancy; the cessation of harmful traditional practices; and timely access to obstetric care. Preventing and managing obstetric fistula contribute to the Millennium Development Goal 5 of improving maternal health. (WHO) Causes Obstetric fistula exists due primarily to a lack of accessible, quality maternal health care, including family planning, skilled care at birth, basic and comprehensive emergency obstetric care, and affordable treatment of fistula, which are some of the constraints challenges to maternal health care which exist in The Gambia. Additionally, fistula occurs among women living in poverty in cultures where a woman’s status and selfesteem may depend almost entirely on her marriage and ability to bear children, which is relatively common in The Gambia. Eclampsia – pending date Causes Structural Support There is ongoing support for emergency obstetric care such as through a variety of government initiatives as outlined in the previous section. Nevertheless, there are challenges in meeting these needs as there are limited skilled staff for placement in these clinics, there are often shortages of medications, and the distance to clinics are far and over difficult roads. 5.1.3.2. Maternal Morbidity and Mortality The maternal mortality rate in The Gambia is one of the highest in the world at 730/100,000. The reasons for this high rate are complex but center on a lack of quality care (especially emergency obstetric care) and women’s control or input into decision making, even into issues that affect her own (and her children’s) health. The MMR is high and varies greatly according to geographic region, income and education of the mother. According to the World Bank, women in rural Gambia are twice or up to three 154 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 times as likely to die from pregnancy or child birth than women in urban areas181. This is directly related to inadequate access to quality health facilities in rural areas. Causes Complications of pregnancy and childbirth are the leading cause of death and disability among women of reproductive age in developing countries182. In the Gambia, 730 out of 100,000 women die due to pregnancy or childbirth related deaths. Direct obstetric complications have been indicated to causes most maternal deaths in The Gambia, with hemorrhage as one of the leading causes. Some of the other major causes of maternal mortality which have been identified in rural The Gambia include anaemia, haemorrhage, eclampsia, obstructed labour and placental abruption in cases of haemorrhage. (Cham, Sundby, Vangen) Indirect medical causes are those resulting from a pre-existing disease which aggravated by pregnancy may develop during pregnancy, such as anemia, cardio-vascular disorders, malaria, diabetes and HIV/AIDS. Malaria continues to be the leading cause of maternal morbidity and mortality 183. Although women receive ante natal care (97.8 percent antenatal care by skilled personnel (MICS 2005/06 and MICS 2010) and seek care for obstetric emergencies, often the care is delayed for a variety of reasons. The decision as to when to seek care or go to the clinic or TBA for assisted delivery, is not always the woman’s choice, as the husband is often responsible for this decision. Importantly, if the decision is prolonged and the distance to the clinic is far, this can result in delayed treatment, which could eventually lead to maternal or infant death, especially if there are complications. FGD participants in rural communities reported cases where women or babies died on donkey carts on the way to the clinic. In cases when women are able to access needed emergency obstetric services in time, often there is a lack of skilled emergency obstetric care providers, a lack of appropriate facilities, and a shortage of medications to treat complications, especially in rural areas. Improving accessibility and quality of Emergency Obstetric Care (EOC) services in the area is necessary if maternal deaths are to be prevented184. There is an increase in maternal mortality risk during peak malaria transmission in endemic countries is thought to implicate malaria in maternal deaths. During the malaria World Bank, ‘Health and Poverty in the Gambia’, A background report to the National Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper, Human Development Sector, Africa Region, WB, November 2005. 182 Cham, M., ‘Availability and Quality of Maternity Care Services in The Gambia: Its impact on Maternal and Fetal Outcomes’, University of Oslo, 2009. 183 World Bank, ‘World Bank Poverty Assessment’, WB. 184 Cham, Sundby, and Vangen, ‘Maternal mortality in the rural Gambia’, a qualitative study on access to emergency obstetric care, http://www.reproductive-health-journal.com/content/. 181 155 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 season, there was a 168 percent increase in the maternal mortality ratio (MMR), a three-fold increase in the proportion of deaths due to anemia, and an eight-fold increase in the anemia MMR. Apart from a 5.4-fold increase in eclampsia, there was no significant change in the contribution of other causes of death. It is estimated that malaria may account for up to 93 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births. 185 In pregnant women, severe malaria-related anemia continues to be a major contributing cause to maternal morbidity and mortality. It is estimated that malaria may account for up to 93 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births (Anya, 2004). The latest estimation of malaria in pregnancy is at 8 percent and mortality related to malaria in pregnancy is almost 1 percent (MIS, 2007). Anaemia, defined as haemoglobin less than 11mg/dL, is also highly prevalent, for example over 50 percent in pregnant women attending antenatal care in two clinics in the Kombos 2005 were anaemic (Morton, 2005). A high population growth combined with inadequate financial and logistical support has put increased pressure on the health sector. Health facility coverage is approximately 80 percent of the population however staff numbers in the health facilities are inadequate and there are not enough of trained staff. There are also underlying socio economic factors that lead to maternal mortality such as low social status of women, lack of education, poor nutritional status, limited access to health care and a lack of financial resources. These factors are a continuing challenge facing many women in The Gambia. Emergency Obstetric Care Services An assessment concluded that hospitals lacked adequate electrical power, regular water supplies, basic equipment, emergency drugs and medical supplies. Hospital staff was found to lack the skills needed to manage emergencies, particularly those related to obstetric complications, resuscitation at birth and life threatening problems in newborn infants, serious pediatric illnesses and major trauma Source: July 2006 a country-wide assessment of emergency services was undertaken by the Ministry Of Health, World Health Organization, Maternal and Child health Advocacy International and Advanced Life Support Group. Emergency Obstetric Care The level of EOC in the Gambia is below the internationally recommended standards both for the number of basic EOC facilities and the lack of comprehensive care provided at the major health centers. Case fatality among obstetric emergencies was high at 4.7 percent . Coverage for life- saving interventions such as cesarean sections was below minimum standards nationally and well below in rural areas. Health system inadequacies such as a lack of basic 185 Samuel Anya, ‘Seasonal Variation in the Risk and Causes of Maternal Death in The Gambia: Malaria appears to be an Important Factor’. 156 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 equipment and supplies, and a shortage of skilled professionals severely limit access and availability of EOC in The Gambia. Maternal Morbidity Maternal morbidity is illness or injury, acute or chronic, caused or aggravated by pregnancy or childbirth such as anemia, incontinence, damaged reproductive organs, chronic pain and infertility. It is estimated that for every one maternal death worldwide there are thirty women who suffer serious illness or debilitating injuries 186. The longer term effects of maternal morbidity are not only physical but also psychological, social and can result in economic losses. For example obstetric fistula which affects approximately 100,000 women each year, can result is social isolation, depression and poverty. In The Gambia, there is little attention give to maternal morbidity, thus there is little available information on maternal ill – health. However, a 2002 study which assessed reproductive–organ damage among rural women in northern Gambia, found that 70.3 percent of women with at least one reproductive disorder. The two leading disorders were anemia hemoglobin, and pelvic structure damage187. Structural Support According to the Reproductive and Children’s Health (RCH) Unit, there is ongoing training for health care service providers conducted on the major causes of maternal mortality. Additionally, a Protocol Manual on antenatal and post natal care was recently produced and will be distributed during upcoming trainings to service providers. Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs) also receive regular training through the RCH. There are some fundamental challenges within the health care system such as a lack of equipment, scarcity of needed medications, and an insufficient number of training staff which need to be addressed in order to improve services related to maternal health care. 5.1.4. HIV/AIDS and STIs The HIV epidemic in The Gambia is characterized by a low prevalence, however small pockets of higher concentrations cause concern. The most current (2008) surveillance data puts the HIV prevalence in The Gambia at 1.6 percent . In the period 1993-2007, Cham, M., ‘Availability and Quality of Maternity Care Services in The Gambia: Its impact on Maternal and Fetal Outcomes’, University of Oslo, 2009. 187 Samuel Anya, ‘Seasonal Variation in the Risk and Causes of Maternal Death in The Gambia: Malaria appears to be an Important Factor’. 186 157 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 trends in HIV prevalence were generally uneven and HIV-1 is now seen as main virus driving the epidemic (Cherno et al 2009)188. Data on the prevalence is gathered through National Sentinel Surveillance (NSS) which is conducted amongst antenatal women, aged 15-49 years. Of the estimated 7,500 PLHIV 60 percent are woman aged 15 years and over and children account for 630 (7.6 percent ) of the 8,200 country total (UNAIDS 2008)189. 5.1.4.1. Prevention In terms of service provision for women and children there has been an expansion of HIV services countrywide. Twenty- four sites are now providing services for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV - a five fold increase from 2004. Thirty – four sites provide VCT services and there are nine ART sites for access to antiretroviral treatment. Under Round 8 of the Global Fund HIV grant it is anticipated that a further 30 sites will be indentified to roll out PMTCT services. The involvement of civil society in HIV policy and strategy development has been promoted on two levels; contributing to policy formulation and coordinating and promoting civil society’s involvement, in particular the networks and organisations of people living with HIV who have been involved in the implementation of HIV programmes particularly in the areas of care and support. Voluntary counseling and testing services have been scaled up throughout the country. In addition VCT community outreach has been promoted. Between 2003 and 2008 over 500 counsellors were trained on VCT and the PMTCT services. In the period 2007 2009 the number of people tested for HIV doubled from 30,565 to 66,464. A total of 171, 374 have been through VCT and HIV testing in the ante natal setting. Prevention of Maternal to Child Transmission (PMTCT) The transmission of HIV from mother to child is the main mode of spread of the infection to children. 15 percent of new HIV infections each year are caused by MTCT. An estimated 430 000 children were newly infected with HIV in 2008, over 90 percent of them through mother-to-child transmission (MTCT). Without treatment, about half of these infected children will die before their second birthday. Without intervention, the risk of MTCT ranges from 20 percent to 45 percent. With specific interventions in nonbreastfeeding populations, the risk of MTCT can be reduced to less than 2 percent, and to 5 percent or less in breastfeeding populations. 188 189 The Gambia Progress Report towards Attainment of Universal Access, 2009 UNGASS Country Progress Report, The Gambia, 2008 158 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The rate of MTCT in the Gambia with present intervention is 9.1 percent. The national strategic framework and the revised PMTCT policy guidelines have set a target of reduction of MTCT from 9.1 percent to 5 percent in 2014 and 4 percent in 2015 respectively190. The objective of the PMTCT programme is to provide access to the Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT) of HIV for 80 percent of pregnant women in The Gambia by 2014. Currently the programme provides two types of drugs, nevirapine and AZT to pregnant women who are infected with HIV depending on sero type of infection. These drugs can be a very effective tool in preventing the transmission of the HIV virus from the mother to the child. Between March 2004 and May 2006, of women attending Reproductive and Child Health clinics 62 percent of pregnant women completed the full HIV/AIDS counseling process; of those women who tested HIV positive, 24.9 percent received anti-retroviral prophylaxis, 23.3 percent of HIV positive women delivered in health facilities compared to the national average of 55 percent , 3.9 percent of infants born to infected mothers received nevirapine syrup, 6.4 percent of infected mothers were given replacement feeds191. Structural Support The National HIV AIDS Strategic Plan and framework has been reviewed, revised and validated 2009-2014. Policy guidelines for the reduction of Mother to Child Transmission of HIV in The Gambia were reviewed in 2008. The Prevention of mother to child transmission of HIV training/participants manual reviewed and updated 2010. Standard operating procedures for the PMTCT were reviewed and updated in 2010. ARV training manual reviewed and updated 2009. In view of this, measures to accelerate and improve programmes of prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission (PMTCT) should be adopted into the overall effort to control the further spread of HIV in The Gambia. These measures include increase access and uptake of PMTCT services; scale up quality PMTCT services; committed integration of PMTCT services into maternal, newborn and child health and with sexual and reproductive health programmes. Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, ‘The Gambia Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission Strategic Plan 2010 -2015 191 NAS, ‘Impact Study on the Reduction of HIV/AIDS Transmission from Parent to Child from October 2004 to December 2006, released May 2008 190 159 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 To prevent the transmission of HIV from mother to baby, the World Health Organization (WHO) promotes a comprehensive approach, which includes the following four components: Primary prevention of HIV infection among women of childbearing age; Preventing unintended pregnancies among women living with HIV; Preventing HIV transmission from a woman living with HIV to her infant; and Providing appropriate treatment, care and support to mothers living with HIV and their children and families. Health System Strengthening is the fifth component added in the Gambia to ensure effective adaptation of the components. 5.1.4.2. Treatment Causes The main mode of transmission is through unprotected heterosexual contact. Factors contributing to the epidemic in The Gambia are a lack of access to reliable information on sexually transmitted infections including HIV, the practice of unsafe sexual behavior with multiple partners by both sexes, untreated/inappropriately treated sexually transmitted infections, a lack of condoms, sex tourism, and unsafe blood transfusions (Asante and Fenny 2009)192. Impacting particularly on woman has been a paucity of services tailored to their needs and to the needs of the most at risk groups. Cultural and religious norms make it difficult for women to deny partners sexual contact. A lack of economic empowerment contributes to women’s inability to speak out and there are many reasons why women are engaging in risky behavior through sex tourism. In addition, male involvement in both VCT and PMTCT services has been low. Structural Support HIV treatment care and support services in The Gambia are free. Services available include voluntary counseling and testing. Services for the Prevention of Mother To Child Transmission and nine centres providing services for Antiretroviral Therapy. (ART) nationally. There are many challenges in confronting the battle against HIV/AIDS, which briefly outlined as follows. Asante, F., Fenny, A., ‘National AIDS Secretariat, The Joint United Nations Programme on AIDS ‘ National AIDS Spending Assessment 2007 and Level and flow of resources and expenditures 2009 – The Gambia 2010 Progress Report 192 160 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 80 percent of Gambians do not know their HIV status. Inadequate human capacity and institutional structures, and weak health systems poses a big challenge. The fear of stigma and discrimination is a barrier to access and the utilization of treatment, care and support of PLHIV and their families. Disclosure of sero-status to partners is a challenge that prevents access to ART. Fear of the consequences of disclosure may force some to remain silent with resultant ill health/ death as a consequence, and in addition denying those they may have unknowingly infected from accessing timely treatment, care and support. Supporting adherence to ART and reducing defaulters to treatment remains a challenge as is the lack of effective communication between men and women .Encouraging greater male involvement in health care /antenatal health care will require attitudinal changes. The National Spending assessment conducted for the years 2007 and 2008 indicated 96 percent of funding for HIV was sourced externally (Asante and Fenny 2009) questioning the sustainability of the response to HIV given the global economic downturn. There are currently no laws to protect people living with HIV against discrimination (including both general non-discrimination provisions and provisions that specifically mention HIV). Additionally there are no non-discrimination laws or regulations which specify protection for most-at-risk populations. Limited M&E capacity to analyze data. Generating quality data for information and knowledge to influence policy making, programme action, and research needs to be regular, and systematic. A Demographic Health Study would need to be carried out to have the correct data on prevalence rates throughout the country. Pediatric Care – pending data 5.1.4.3. Protection – HIV/AIDS Orphans – pending data 5.1.5. Nutrition, including maternal malnutrition 5.1.5.1. Under Nutrition and Micro – nutrient deficiencies There is evidence that the majority of woman who live in rural areas in The Gambia are in a constant state of energy – deficient which is caused by poor dietary intake, a heavy workload and a high infection rate. This is reflected by a high prevalence of low birth weight infants especially during the rainy season. Low birth weight is a good indicator of the nutritional status of the mother and has directly affects the newborn’s chance of 161 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 survival and long term psycho- social development. According to the MICS 2005/2006 19.9 of newborns had low birth weight. Anaemia is common among women, especially during pregnancy and is a major contributory factor to the high maternal morbidity and mortality rates. A national survey193 conducted in 2001, indicated that 73 percent of pregnant women and 56 percent of lactating women were anemic. It also found that 34 percent and 16 percent of pregnant and lactating women respectively were vitamin A deficient. An iodine deficiency study conducted in 1999 indicated a 16 percent manifestation of goiter rate, an indication of IDD, which was of a relatively mild significance. Causes Critical to the overall nutritional status of pregnant women are the seasonal availability of nutritious foods, especially vegetables, and the high cost of some of the most nutritious foods, especially for rural women. If women are not able to purchase nutritious foods high in iron, and other essential vitamins and minerals, her health and that of the feotus will suffer. Traditional practices such as food taboos are one of the factors that increase maternal malnutrition. Some of the foods that meet the increased nutritional demands of pregnant women are forbidden due to traditional food taboos194. Over the past decade, most of these taboos have diminished as women become more informed about the importance of good maternal nutrition. Structural Support NaNA provides support to women in terms vitamin supplementation during pregnancy in the maternal child health clinics. 5.1.5.2. Over nutrition A nutrition survey conducted in GBA conducted in 2009 revealed that only 49 percent of women between the ages of 14 – 49 years had a normal nutritional status. Forty two percent of the women sampled had weights above what would be considered normal for their heights. 24.6 percent were classified as overweight and 17.3 percent were obese, yet 7.5 percent show energy deficiency and 1 percent severe energy deficiency. Bah, A, Semega – Janneh, I., Prentice, A., Bates, C. ‘Nationwide survey on the prevalence of vitamin A and iron deficiency in women and children in the Gambia’, NaNA, Banjul, 2001. 194 Some of the foods that are restricted due to taboos are eggs and dairy products. 193 162 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 According to NaNA, childhood obesity is also on the increase as well due an increasing sedentary lifestyle of children in the Greater Banjul Area195. 5.2. Education Education is an essential tool for achieving the goals of equality, development and peace (Beijing Platform for Action). Education should equally benefit both girls and boys, thereby contributing to creating more equal relationships between women and men. Literacy of women is critical to improving the overall wellbeing of the family, especially regarding the health and nutrition of the family. Investing in the informal and non-formal education and training; with its exceptionally high social and economic return has proved to be one of the best means of achieving sustainable development. Taking cognizance of this, The Education Policy 2004-2015 aims to “promote broad –based education for all through quality learning, training and mainstreaming gender for girl and boys to acquire literacy, livelihood skills and utilize those skills to earn a living and become economically self–reliant. (National Gender Policy) CEDAW Article 10 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in order to ensure to them equal rights with men in the field of education and in particular to ensure, on a basis of equality of men and women… While gender parity has been reached in basic education, secondary and post secondary education is still dominated by boys. Closing this gap should be a high government priority which will help to promote gender equality in The Gambia. Girls’ enrolment at the University of The Gambia is only 21 percent of the total enrolment (although this had doubled since its opening). Efforts to lessen this disparity have been implemented such as extra classes that will help prepare young women for university education, such as ACCESS and Remedial Instruction or Female Teachers (RIFT) at The Gambia College. Causes Some of the reasons that girls drop out of school are early marriage, prioritization of boys for continuing education, lack of proper health and hygiene facilities and poor academic performance. During the RTDs, Key Stakeholders pointed out that women who had high levels of education were often ‘unmarriageable’ as men did not want to marry a woman with a higher education. (Ironically, the same theory applied if the National Nutrition Agency, ‘Food Vulnerability in the Urban Area of Banjul and Kanifing Municipality (The Gambia)’, Summary Report, GoTG, CILSS, NaNA, 2009. 195 163 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 woman did not have enough education.) Nevertheless, all RTD groups listed low retention rates for girls as a primary issue affecting the rights of children and women in the Gambia. Some of the reasons identified by the participants include teenage pregnancy, poverty, early marriage, sexual harassment in schools, ignorance of importance of Girls' education, corporal punishment, a preference on male education (boys will support the family after school, the girl moves to another family, economically more sensible) and that girls have a heavy work load at home. Other reasons are an inequitable distribution of secondary schools in rural areas. Safety and security issues which are of concern when sending children to schools away from home or walking long distances to schools are especially relevant for girls. Girls who are sent away for school are at a greater risk for vulnerabilities such as teenage pregnancy or sexual abuse or exploitation. Relevance and quality of education also directly impact the ability for girls to proceed beyond primary education. Structural Support There are community and national adult literacy programs that aim to address the high rates of illiteracy among women in The Gambia (38% EMIS). Additionally the Community Skills Improvement Program (CSIP) implements training programs for women and out of school youth, aiming to encourage entrepreneurship and self employment schemes. The project reached 81 percent of the targeted participants, with over 12,670 literacy graduates. 5.3. Employment and Economic Opportunities One of the most powerful ways to ensure that women’s rights are assured is through employment and economic empowerment. Economic equality would positively affect all dimensions of a women’s life, and also improve the standard of living for the family. CEDAW Article 11 1. States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in the field of employment in order to ensure, on a basis of equality of men and women, the same rights, in particular:… In The Gambia, there is uneven gender distribution of the labor force in public and private sector employment196. Women make up approximately forty five percent of the economically active population, yet men hold the majority of the higher paying jobs such as managers, professionals and technicians. In part due to lower education levels, 196 Government of The Gambia, ‘National Population and Housing Census of 2003’, GoTG. 164 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 women are somewhat relegated to lower paying jobs with little or no benefits such as social security or job protection. During the RTDs, women participants raised this issue as an important disparity. They explained that girls are not encouraged to study traditionally ‘male subject areas’ such as science or maths, which are often needed as prerequisites for higher education and thus higher levels of employment. There is only minimum representation of women in areas such as finance, communication and manufacturing which are normally the higher paid professions. Table 12: Women Representation in Gambia Employment Sector Fisheries Manufacturing Hotels and Restaurants Financial Services Storage and Communication Commercial, Social and Personnel Services Wholesale and retail Social Services Cabinet Parliament percent of women in the work force 16.40 22.07 41.33 2.66 6.95 39.97 43.99 25 33.33 13 Source: The Gambia National Gender Policy 2010 -2020 Causes A large proportion of self employed women in The Gambia are engaged in crop farming—two-thirds of employed women are reported as crop growers, compared to only 36 percent of men. In addition, fertility rates are relatively high, estimated at 5.4 children per woman, slightly above the 5.3 average for sub-Saharan Africa. Therefore, most women combine market work (i.e. participation in remunerative or incomegenerating employment) with non-market work (e.g. unpaid childcare and household production). The responsibility for unpaid, non-market work influences the employment options available for women. For example, paid activities that prevent women from combining market and non-market work may not be accessible to economically active women. Labour supply in The Gambia is mainly unskilled, both in rural and urban areas. According to estimates derived from the population census, 47 percent of the active and employed population has no formal schooling; only 3 percent have completed a postsecondary degree/diploma (including vocational training). As a result, average adult literacy rates remain low in The Gambia. 165 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 According to the PRSP II, the national literacy rate is 46 per cent, with a significant gap between female rates (37 percent) and male rates (60 percent). According to the NTA survey on skills and employment, almost 50 percent of the rural sample was illiterate (42 percent in urban areas). On the basis of calculations from the National Training Assessment (NTA) survey, a staggering 54 percent of the employed population had not received any training whatsoever, whether formal or informal (59 percent in rural areas and 61 percent in the case of women). For those who reported some form of training, the most common for women were the following. In rural areas: gardening, farming; tailoring, sewing, designing; soap making; in urban areas: tailoring, sewing, designing; (petty) trading. Opportunities for gainful rural employment, particularly in the farming sector, have declined due to the sluggish performance of the agriculture sector. The high poverty level of the rural areas (estimated at about 67-70 percent of the rural population) means that households have few resources to invest in improving their productive capacities and, ultimately, their earning potential. Thus, a vicious circle of poverty, low income, low productivity and scarce assets is compounded by a lack of support to crop farming from state institutions. Arguably, farming households increasingly depend on external noncrop sources of income, including remittances from family members having moved to the Greater Banjul or neighboring Senegal. The tourism sector is less labour intensive than the agricultural sector but its higher remuneration has the potential to lift workers and their families above the poverty line. Through the multiplier effect of improved household incomes on family labour, the agricultural sector would provide thousands of jobs to people living in rural areas. Higher demand for labour in these sectors may also inject greater dynamism into local labour markets and further reduce underemployment. If this happens, pressures to migrate to overcrowded and saturated labour markets in Grater Banjul may relax and a more balanced pro-poor employment pattern be achieved. The urban labour market situation can be analysed using data such as economic census and household surveys. Specific surveys designed to capture informal activities provide information about own-account and unpaid workers in urban labour markets. Although household surveys are also applied in rural areas, their capacity to adequately capture the peculiarities of rural labour markets is limited. Unless an in-depth labour force survey is administered, it will be difficult to ascertain the characteristics and dynamics of rural employment and the structural characteristics of rural labour markets. Participation in rural and peri-urban labour markets and the incidence of non-farm wage employment is not restricted to a few months during the rainy season. Household 166 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 members may engage in non-farm wage activities throughout the year. The seasonal and irregular nature of labour peaks is associated with the hiring of seasonal and casual labourers, who may come from the local area or migrate from other regions. The personalisation of employment relations and a degree of “paternalism” among employers is also a typical feature of rural labour markets. Moreover, women are traditionally employed producing specific crops, where they carry specific tasks and use particular technologies, and men are employed producing others. It is important to capture the intricacies of rural labour and agricultural production when developing policies to enhance productivity and the quality of employment in the rural areas. Like much of the labour market in Gambia, rural labour markets are not subject, at least de facto, to effective regulation. Remuneration and working conditions depend on the particular agreements between employers and workers. These agreements vary according to task, crop, and the time of the year. Employment relationships reflect “norms” and conventions, and therefore are seldom subject to a legally enforceable contract. Thus, daily wages or payments for specific tasks (like groundnut threshing or weeding) have a “conventional price” that is territorially determined and sometimes village-specific. The fact that many of these labour transactions are highly personalised contributes to the localized and segmented nature of payment and work conditions. The village or district chief may settle any disputes in the event the parties are unable to reach a settlement on their own. However, the recent introduction of the fee-based Resident Permits may have had implications on rural labour markets and production. Having been set at D7,500 per person per year for all non-Gambians, the provision has imposed restrictions on the available supply of migrant labour to the rural and agricultural areas. The new permit system not only had a dampening effect on agricultural production, productivity and output, but it also affected groundnut marketing activities that had hitherto depended largely on seasonal migrant labour for production and marketing. Therefore, efforts to improve farm output from the rural areas must address constraints to labour supply to agricultural production. Lower level of education, illiteracy and less opportunity for high paying employment are some of the constraints that place women at the bottom of the pay scale in The Gambia. General attitudes that prevail in a male dominated societal structure often allow for discrimination in the level and number of opportunities available to women. Structural Support 167 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 GAMJOBS was been created in response to the overall low employment rates in The Gambia. The overall objective of GAMJOBS is initiating the development of a “skilled, versatile, dynamic and efficient workplace”, and create opportunities for wage and selfemployment in both the formal and informal economy, within the context of Vision 2020 and the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP). The government has increased efforts to improve secondary school enrolment rates for girls as outlined in Chapter Four. Programs such as ACCESS or RIFT (Remedial Instruction for Female Teachers) provide instruction that aims to prepare girls for post secondary education. Domestic Workers The issue of domestic laborers (cleaners, maids, housekeepers), an area predominantly made up of women is a growing global concern. Conditions that women face are often exploitative and can be physically and sexually abusive. While the abysmal conditions that have made international human rights reports have not been reported in The Gambia, conditions for women who work as domestic workers often are unfair and exploitative; pay is usually low, hours can be long, and there are no benefits such as social security, paid leave or job protection. Women who work as domestic labourers lack a unified or organized voice to represent them, and therefore conditions remain extremely poor. Causes In the Gambia, employment opportunities are limited due in part to a lack of a large industrialized economy, which results in extremely limited employment opportunities. Therefore, women who must work to support their families, have little choice of jobs, and are often at the lower echelon of the employment scale. Additionally, disparities in education, responsibilities related to marriage and motherhood, and attitudes that women are not capable of performing some of the same work as men tend to relegate women to low paid employment. Structural Support There is little if any support for domestic labor. Workers in this type of work would greatly benefit from an co-hensive and organized structure to represent their interests on a local and national level. Agricultural and women’s cooperatives 168 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The youths, women and the disabled are disproportionately over-represented in the rank of the unemployed and underemployed. 70 percent of women are engaged in low productivity rural subsistence agriculture, and provide about 86 percent of household income. According to 2003 National Household Poverty Survey, income poverty has increased from 59 percent to 74 percent between 1998 and 2003. It is estimated that 78 percent of economically active women engaged in agriculture are considered extremely poor. Causes Traditionally women are responsible to provide for the basic needs of the household, In order to provide the daily meal, women grow vegetables to either sell or use the produce to contribute to the family food pot. Structural Support The National Association of Women Farmers (NAWFA) represents over 70,000 women farmers throughout the Gambia. One of their major goals is to help increase women’s income related to agricultural production and marketing. They can also serve as a strong support mechanism to engage women in grassroots political activities. 5.4. Socio - Cultural Issues 5.4.1. Violence against Women - Gender Based Violence Women world wide are subjected to violence in many forms including sexual, physical, or emotional abuse by an intimate partner; physical or sexual abuse by family members or others; sexual harassment and abuse by authority figures (such as teachers, police officers or employers); trafficking for forced labour or sex; and such traditional practices as forced or child marriages, mutilation of the body, dowry-related violence; and honour killings, when women are murdered in the name of family honour197. In the Gambia, violence against women takes on these many manifestations in the family, and at the community and national level. Yet information regarding acts of violence is not easily accessible. For example the number of rape cases or the reporting of sexual abuse and harassment in schools or the workplace were not readily available for inclusion in this report. A culture of silence somewhat shrouds the full reality of violence against women in Gambian society. An overview of some of the key issues, 197 World Health Organisation, ‘Violence Against Women’, WHO. 169 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 consequences and structures which are in place to safeguard the rights of women against violence are outlined in the following section. CEDAW Article 5 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures: (a) To modify the social and cultural patterns of conduct of men and women, with a view to achieving the elimination of prejudices and customary and all other practices which are based on the idea of the inferiority or the superiority of either of the sexes or on stereotyped roles for men and women… The United Nations defines violence against women as any act of gender-based violence that results in, or is likely to result in, physical, sexual or mental harm or suffering to women, including threats of such acts, coercion or arbitrary deprivation of liberty, whether occurring in public or in private life. (WHO) 5.4.1.1. Physical Violence – Domestic Violence In The Gambia, domestic violence is only occasionally reported, yet its occurrence is believed to be fairly common. The police tend to consider these incidents to be domestic issues outside of their ordinary jurisdiction. Wife-beating is nevertheless a criminal offence in the Gambia and constitutes grounds for divorce under civil law. Rape and assault are also crimes under the law. Any person who has carnal knowledge of a girl under the age of 16 is guilty of a felony. These laws are generally enforced. However, spousal rape is not specifically recognized even if the wife is less than 16 years of age198. Causes Domestic violence is a social problem that affects all societies with similar and somewhat universal causes. In a male dominated or patriarchal society, men may feel that they have control over women that women are not equal to men, or that women are their ‘property’. Traditional practices such as dowries or the paying of a bride price reinforce the belief that women are owned by men and that men can treat them accordingly. Some of the factors that may lead to domestic violence are low self esteem, frustration of societal inequalities, jealousy, difficulties in regulating anger and other strong emotions, or when they feel inferior to the other partner in education and socioeconomic Network on Gender based Violence (NGBV) The Gambia, ‘DESK REVIEW REPORT of Gender Based Violence in The Gambia’, NGBV Gambia, September 2010. 198 170 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 dimension. Alcohol or drug abuse can exacerbate the problem by inducing a greater loss of control over underlying emotions. Acceptance of domestic violence in a male dominated society, although not a cause of violence per se, allows for it to occur and continue 199 . Information from the MICS 2005/06 that assessed women’s attitudes concerning domestic violence, indicated that 74 percent of women believe that a man is justified to beat his wife in certain circumstances such as going out without informing the husband, if she neglects the children, if she argues with him, if she refuses to have sex with him and if she burns the food. Official statistics are difficult to obtain as there are few cases reported, yet according to key informant interviews, the practice occurs often but is not discussed or reported as it is seen as a ‘family matter’. Education level of women impacts the attitudes of women concerning domestic violence to an extent, with women who have a secondary level of education, as per the chart below. Chart 26: Attitudes towards Domestic Violence as per Education Level Source: MICS 2005/06 Wealth quintiles seem to have more of an influence on women’s attitudes about domestic violence, as households in the richest quintile seem to believe much less than others about the use of domestic violence, as demonstrated in the chart below. Chart 27: Attitudes towards Domestic Violence as per Wealth Quintile 199 Domestic violence is a cyclical pattern, when children see this in the home, they often think that violence is the only or best way to resolve family matters. 171 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Source: MICS 2005/06 Structural Support As a signatory to the CEDAW and the African Protocol on the Rights and Welfare of Women, The Gambia commits itself to prohibiting all forms of violence against women. Nevertheless, within the Gambian legal context, there are no specific laws that address GBV. The Children’s Act 2005, the Women’s Act 2010 and the Criminal Code all specify that physical assault is a criminal offence, yet there are no specific protocols, written policies or procedures on how to address cases related to specifically Gender Based Violence (GBV) currently implemented in The Gambia. Nevertheless in various laws, policies and legislation, issues related to violence and the protection of women and children are clearly outlined. Under the criminal code, wife beating is an offense with ensuing penalties, yet the lack of reporting and limited response mean that offenders are rarely reprimanded or receive penal sentences. A consortium of NGOS (Action Aid The Gambia, Worldview, TARUD, GFPA, GRCS and Mutapola) on Violence against Women was established in 2006 in order to create awareness, advocate for support and resources regarding the extent and impact of violence against women. The Female Lawyers Association (FLAG) provides legal support to women who are victims of domestic violence. Additionally, FLAG advocates and sensitizes communities as to their role and functions in representation of women, so that women will know where to go for legal assistance. 172 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 5.4.1.2 Sexual Violence – rape and other forms of sexual abuse and exploitation As outlined in Chapter 4, rape cases and other sexual abuse are seldom reported in The Gambia due to a complication of factors, such as social stigma, family pressure to avoid shame and humiliation which may be associated with sexual abuse, guilt which may be felt by the victims and unawareness about reporting mechanisms. Causes Causes for rape and other sexual abuse are multifaceted but can be attributed to aggression, attitudes that classify women as sexual objects, and in part to a machismo culture. Structural Support The Criminal Code outlines provisions against sexual violence towards women, such as rape (Section 121). Section 122 states that the penalty for rape as life imprisonment and for attempted rape as seven years (Section 124). NGOs such as AATG, work in increase awareness about gender based violence, including rape. The Women’s Bureau addresses sexual abuse and violence against women by advocating for appropriate legislation to address these issues, and implementing awareness raising activities. 5.4.1.3. Sexual Exploitation of Women The sexual exploitation of women can take on a variety of forms. In the most extreme manifestation, human trafficking is carried out wherein women are kidnapped to be bought and sold for sexual slavery. Prostitution takes place at all levels of societies when women or third parties sell women’s bodies for the sexual gratification of others, and the sexually explicit use of women’s bodies to market goods and products ranging from perfume to auto parts is a common and universal practice. Sexual exploitation is a serious human rights violation which has physical, psychological and socio-economic effects on women. Sexual exploitation denigrates the status of women from one as a complete, whole equal being to one of a secondary status with one overarching primary purpose of a sexual nature. The overall impact of the sexual exploitation of women and girls is far reaching, and overwhelming detrimental not only to women but to society as a whole. CEDAW Article 6 173 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures, including legislation, to suppress all forms of traffic in women and exploitation of prostitution of women. Trafficking Trafficking in persons is, in itself, a human rights violation, and one which can result in a series of further abuses, involving debt-bondage, forced labour and slavery-like conditions, as well as rape, torture, imprisonment and even murder. The treatment of human beings as commodities, or products to be bought and sold, is considered a violation of their most basic rights to freedom, autonomy and human dignity by the United Nations (UN) and international human rights groups (Amnesty International and Anti-Slavery International 2004; Human Rights Watch 2004; United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime 2005)200. Human trafficking has been defined as the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation. Exploitation shall include, at a minimum, the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs. The consent of a victim of trafficking in persons to the intended exploitation set forth shall be irrelevant where any of the means set forth have been used. Trafficking is a lucrative industry and is now the fastest growing criminal industry in the world. Human trafficking usually affects women and children. The total annual revenue for trafficking in persons is estimated to be somewhere between five and ten billion dollars, a massive sum by any means201. Causes Poverty which often places women in desperate situations is one of the leading cause for trafficking. Often unsuspecting women are lured by the promise of work in foreign countries, only to arrive at their destinations to be forced into prostitution or subjected to inhumane conditions. 200 Fergus, L., ‘Trafficking in women for sexual exploitation the Australian Institute of Family Studies’. The Point Newspaper, ‘The Human Trafficking Epidemic’, http://thepoint.gm/africa/gambia/article/thehuman-trafficking-epidemic, October 29, 2010. 201 174 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Structural Support The Constitution provides that women be accorded full and equal dignity of persons with men. Section 20 and 21 provide for the protection from slavery and forced labour and protection from inhumane treatment respectively. The Trafficking in Persons Act 2007 addresses the issue of trafficking of women and children and aims to prevent, suppress, and punish those responsible for trafficking and to provide counseling and reintegration for trafficking victims. The Police have adopted a zero tolerance policy towards the detection, prosecution and punishment of trafficking offenders. Additionally the stringent national adoption procedures have been enacted in order to prevent trafficking of children. Sex Tourism Prostitution As tourism increases in The Gambia, some undesirable side effects are inevitably on the rise. Many tourists view The Gambia as a sexual haven, with women and in some cases children offering relatively low cost sexual services. Official statistics on the scale of prostitution in The Gambia do not exist. Antedotal evidence indicates that prostitution is a common social phenomenon that is prevalent in both rural and urban areas. While this issue is addressed in Chapter Four under Child Protection, it is important to differentiate prostitution among women and children. While both women and children are often forced into sexually exploitative activities due to poverty, and other xx factors, women are more likely to have more control of the decision regarding their participation in prostitution. Therefore it is important to explore some of the factors that lead women to sell their bodies in return for financial gain. Causes Poverty was identified as one of the main reasons for girls and women to resort to prostitution in order to earn an income. Additionally, during the RTDs, participants identified the case of ‘sugar daddies’ who provide gifts or pay for education to girls and young women for sexual services. There are instances when men pressure girlfriends to participate in sexually exploitative activities in return for money (pimping their girlfriends). Drug abuse leading to 175 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 dependency is another factor that can push women into prostitution in return for drugs or money to buy drugs. Since statistics are not available in The Gambia regarding prostitution, it is difficult to ascertain if drugs are a reason that Gambian women resort to prostitution. 5.5 Cultural Practices 5.5.1. Polygamy The issue of polygamy has important health, education and socio- cultural implication on the rights of women in The Gambian context. In the Gambia, where approximately 95 percent of the population is Muslim, polygamy is a common practice among all ethnic groups. Under Islam men can have up to four wives. In Gambia polygamy is a widely accepted (and also widely discussed practice). Islamic tradition allows a man to marry up to four wives, if they are able to equally provide for all their financial and emotional needs. The first wife normally holds the highest status within the family.202 Health HIV/AIDS –a MRC study found that women in polygamous relationships had rates of herpes, a viral disease that is spread through sexual contact, similar to HIV/AIDS. Logically if husbands have multiple partners, the risk for health related illness increase. Socio – cultural – pending information Education Polygamy affects the education of women and children in that children from households with more children may not be able to send all the children to school. Traditionally, when parents have a choice of whom to send to school, boys have preferential status. This issue was raised in the RTDs as a reason for more boys going to school than girls. Is there data on the number of girls in polygamous households that go to school. 5.6. Political Participation Full political participation from all members of society is a necessary component of a free and democratic society and enriches the overall development of a nation. Input from all citizens including minority groups and members of the most vulnerable is critical in creating a nation that fully encompasses the rich customs and experiences from all 202 Accessgambia.com, ‘Gambian Polygamy’, http://www.accessgambia.com/information/polygamy.html 176 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 citizens. Likewise, women’s input into the political process is critical to ensuring that their rights are heard, respected and safeguarded. While women’s role in the political process is well recognized in the Gambia, as demonstrated by the longest serving woman vice president in Africa and a woman as the speaker of the National Assembly, there are other political dimensions which seem to lack the full involvement and equal representation of women. This section will provide an overview of political participation of women in The Gambia, including some of the striking disparities which currently exist. CEDAW Article 7 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in the political and public life of the country and, in particular, shall ensure to women, on equal terms with men, the right: (a) To vote in all elections and public referenda and to be eligible for election to all publicly elected bodies; (b) To participate in the formulation of government policy and the implementation thereof and to hold public office and perform all public functions at all levels of government; (c) To participate in non-governmental organizations and associations concerned with the public and political life of the country. Article 8 States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to ensure to women, on equal terms with men and without any discrimination, the opportunity to represent their Governments at the international level and to participate in the work of international organizations. The Gambia recognizes the important role that women play in private and public life. Thirty three percent of the Cabinet are women, eight out of eleven high court judges are women and The Gambia has the first and longest serving woman vice president in Africa. Yet representation of women in parliament and in leadership positions at the community level, where important decision making is carried out is dismal. Only 10 percent of parliament members are women, there are no women governors or female chiefs and not even one percent of village heads are women. Nevertheless, in the last elections twenty women contested the elections and fifteen won their seats, which demonstrates some progress203. Causes 203 Progress Report of The Gambia on the Implementation of the African and Beijing Platform for Action and Review Report for Beijing +15 177 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Some of the reasons for limited and unequal representation and participation of women in the political sphere as identified by RTD participants include inadequate of civic education, cultural barriers which limit participation, and the assumption that politics are a ‘dirty business’ which are more suited for men. Structural Support The National Policy for the Advancement of Gambian Women proposes a 30 percent quota systems for the allocation of jobs and positions in all dimensions of public life, including in decision making positions. (BPFA) The Women’s Bureau provides training in leadership skills, public speaking and public protocol for potential political candidates. 5.7. The Most Vulnerable Populations There is limited, if any data on women who are especially vulnerable. This in itself speaks loudly about the need to recognize the vulnerability imposed by their ‘invisible status.’ This group of women includes the following Single head of households Women in rural areas Disabled Single women – Widowed, divorced, or separated Poorest Quintile As data or information is not readily available the following sections outlines issues related to disabled women and women in the poorest quintile. 5.7.1. Disabled Women Disabled women in The Gambia are especially vulnerable to issues that affect their rights. Opportunities for employment are extremely limited, access to health and education are also restricted for the majority of women who have physical disabilities. Causes - pending data and analysis Structural Support The Department of Social Welfare works in partnership with the RVTH, Bansang Hospital, VSO and various Disabled Peoples Organisations (DPOs) to support activities implemented by organizations to improve and expand the services provided to their members and beneficiaries, focusing on life skills and livelihood skills training. 178 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The VSO disability programme is currently supporting research to identify issues affecting Women with Disabilities which will be used to develop a Women’s Charter to be implemented by the DPO. 5.7.2. Poorest quintile – pending data analysis of MICS 2005/06 Women who belong to the poorest quintile are at a particularly high risk to suffer from abuses or denial of basic rights. According to the MICS 2005/06 in almost all indicators women and children who fall in the poorest wealth quintile have the least access to services such good health care, employment opportunities and attain lower levels of education. Chapter 6. Legislative, Policy and Budgetary Support /Issues affecting Children and Women – conditions, policies, programs, legislation which affect, and provide support to Children and Women (success, challenges and gaps). The Gambia has ratified the UNCRC and its Optional Protocols, the CEDAW, the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa, the Africa Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child, and the ILO Conventions 182 and 138204. The ratification of these documents obligates The Gambia to honor and implement the articles and tenets therein. This also obligates the Gambia to establish laws, policies and procedures specifically applicable to children and women. Although there are extensive and detailed legislative measures that protect the rights of children and women, the implementation of these measures is often a challenge due to limited funding for specific activities such as training, child protection hotlines, increased security protocol. 6.1. Legislative and Policy Review The Government of the Gambia has ratified a number of International Declarations, and Conventions including the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women(CEDAW), AU Protocol on the Rights of Women and Girls and the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). The following section outlines some of the important international and national legal instruments for the protection of Children and Women’s rights that The Gambia has ratified, signed off on, or created. 204 Network of GBV, ‘Desk Review of Gender Based Violence’, Sept 2010. 179 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 6.1.1. International Conventions 6.1.1.1. UNCRC reports on CRC Document The UNCRC outlines basic rights pertaining to children, including those that protect children (Art 19) and specific protection for girls against ‘traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children (Art 24). Articles 34 and 35 outlines protection against all forms of sexual exploitation and abuse and from sale and trafficking and Article 37 states that ‘no child shall be subjected to torture or other cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment or punishment’. Since ratification of the UNCRC, The Gambia has made significant progress in meeting the goals of the Convention with the issues of women and children given prominence in several national development policies, strategies and programmes. In addition to creating a favourable policy environment, Government also carried out a number of legislative reforms. The 1997 Constitution was drafted to provide for the protection of fundamental human rights and the protection of personal liberty, property and protection against discrimination. It also recognises in general terms the rights of disabled persons to respect and dignity and nondiscrimination. The Criminal Code specifically provides for the protection and preservation of the Right to Life of children and the unborn foetus and ensures the child’s right to a name, nationality and for care by both parents. Despite these legislative reforms, the absence of a corporate body of laws that focuses entirely on the rights of women and children hampers the harmonisation of Gambian laws with those of the CRC and CEDAW. Existing legislations tend to focus more on the protective rights of the child rather than their developmental needs and, although the Courts may be safeguarding the human and legal rights of all individuals in the country, that may not be enough in the absence of a national surveillance mechanism to monitor the application of the different provisions of the CRC and CEDAW 205. 6.1.1.2. CEDAW The Gambia was one of the first countries to sign off on the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination of Women (CEDAW) in 1980. It was officially ratified by the Gambia in 1993. The Gambia has instituted a series of instruments to fulfill its obligations in enforcing and upholding this treaty. One of the most significant is the inclusion of discrimination on the basis of sex in the 1997 Constitution, which correspond to article 1 of the Convention, and of provisions concerning the equal United Nations Children’s Fund, ‘End – Decade Assessment Report on Follow – up to The World Summit for Children’, December 2000. 205 180 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 opportunities in political, economic and social activities. In addition to this important action, the Gambian Government has enacted the following measures in support of the CEDAW206. Government Supportive Measures of the CEDAW Structures have been put in place to empower women and to advise the Government on women’s issues, including the National Women’s Bureau and Council, and the Department of State for Women’s Affairs under the Office of the Vice-President, as well as a gender cabinet subcommittee and a gender technical committee. A gender focal point network consisting of representatives of key government departments and civil society organizations has been established. Parliament has established a select committee on women and children. A 1999 National Policy for the Advancement of Gambian Women was being implemented, and progress had been registered in particular in the areas of education, health and economic development. Girl-friendly schools and free State primary schools had been established to encourage education of girls and enhance their access to employment in the long term. The national health policy launched in 2001 aimed at reducing maternal and infant mortality, and an increased number of communities had become eligible for primary health-care services. Efforts of the Government had resulted in the decline of maternal mortality rates from 1,050 to 730 to 555 SOURCE per 100,000 live births in 1990, 2001 and 2006 respectively. Women contributed greatly to the economic life of the country, as the main producers of rice and being engaged in horticultural activities and the marine sector. Efforts in support of rural women included programmes in the areas of functional literacy, enterprise development, skills training and microfinance as a means of poverty alleviation. Rural women were increasingly becoming involved in the groundnut marketing and trade sectors, and accessed information and communication technologies through community radio stations and media telecommunication centres. Since the late 1990s, women had, for the first time, been elected as village heads (Alkailos) in the rural administrative structure, where 15 women were elected to area councils. At national level, nine women now served in the National Assembly and 28 women hold ministerial posts. Women are also represented at the highest level of the executive, with the Vice-President of the Republic being the first and longestserving female Vice-President in Africa. The Children’s Act 2005 which contained specific provisions against trafficking of children, child marriages, child betrothal and harmful traditional practices was created. Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, ‘Summary record of the 646th meeting’, CEDAW/C/SR.646, CEDAW (2004). 206 181 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Committee monitoring country progress on CEDAW has recognized the many achievements that The Gambia has put forth in upholding the CEDAW. Nevertheless, in order to ensure that discrimination on all levels is eradicated, there are several areas where the Committee recommends improvement. These recommendations are outlined in the following section. Recommendations from the CEDAW Committee207 The CEDAW and related domestic legislation are made an integral part of legal education and the training of judicial officers, including judges, lawyers and prosecutors, so as to firmly establish in the country a legal culture supportive of women’s equality and non-discrimination. Amend section 33 (5) of the 1997 Constitution, which explicitly exempts from prohibition of discrimination on grounds of gender the areas governing personal status, particularly with regards to adoption, marriage, divorce, burial and devolution of property on death. The government should view culture as a dynamic aspect of the country’s social fabric and life, and subject, therefore, to change. Measures should be introduced to modify or eliminate negative harmful cultural practices and stereotypes that discriminate against women. The government should adopt comprehensive measures to address violence against women and girls, such as enacting legislation on violence against women, collecting data on all forms of violence, providing training for law enforcement, social workers, and sensitizing the general public to all forms of violence against women and can adequately respond to it, and carry out mass awareness raising campaigns working towards a zero tolerance policy on all forms of violence against women. The adoption and implementation of legislation prohibiting female genital mutilation, and to develop a plan of action, including public awareness-raising campaigns, targeted at both women and men, with the support of civil society, to eliminate the practice of female genital mutilation. Introduce legislation on the prohibition of trafficking and effectively implement legislation on the exploitation of the prostitution of women, and to prosecute offenders. Put in place programmes to promote women’s economic independence in order to help to eliminate their vulnerability to exploitation, and measures for the rehabilitation and social reintegration of women and girls who are victims of exploitation and trafficking and to ensure the implementation of the 2003 Tourism Offence Act, and to enhance cooperation with tourists’ countries of origin aimed at preventing and combating sex tourism. Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, ‘Summary record of the 646th meeting’, CEDAW/C/SR.646, CEDAW (2004). 207 182 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Steps should be put in place to increase in the representation of women in elected and appointed bodies in all areas of public and political life and at all levels. The government should ensure equal opportunity for women and men in the labour market. Continue and re – enforce all efforts to decrease the high maternal and infant mortality rates, and increase women’s access to health services, including healthcare facilities and medical assistance by trained personnel, especially with regard to prenatal and post-natal care. Implement comprehensive policies and programmes to prevent and combat malnutrition, malaria and HIV/AIDS, including measures to guarantee effective access for women, including young women, to reproductive health-care information and services. Additionally programmes and policies should be adopted to increase knowledge about, and access to, affordable contraceptive methods and to increase the understanding that family planning is the responsibility of both partners. Family Planning Services should be easily accessible and sex education should be promoted and provided, targeting men and women, and adolescent boys and girls, including information on the prevention of HIV/AIDS. Measurements should be taken recognizing the importance women’s and girls’ right to education as a fundamental human right, including for the empowerment of women. Steps should be strengthened to create an environment that increases the enrolment and retention rates of girls in schools at all levels, including through the development of gender-sensitive educational material and to eradicate female illiteracy, particularly in rural areas, including through comprehensive education. The Children’s Act should be implemented and awareness-raising campaigns carried out on the potential negative effects of early marriage on women’s enjoyment of their human rights, especially the rights to health and education. Design and implement a gender-sensitive rural development strategy, ensuring that rural women can participate fully in the formulation and implementation of policies and programmes in rural areas ensuring that rural women and girls have full access to health-care services, education and vocational training, as well as credit facilities and income-generating opportunities. A comprehensive data collection system of measurable indicators should be established with ongoing regular collection and reporting. Encouragement of the Government of the Gambia to consider ratifying the treaties to which it is not yet a party, namely, the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, and the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families. 6.1.1.3. African Charter on the Rights of the Child The ACRWC outlines general responsibilities in the protection and promotion of the rights of the child as specified in the UNCRC and the African Charter on Human and 183 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Peoples’ Rights. Specifically it protects children from torture (Art 16), obligates States to ‘eliminate harmful social and cultural practices affecting the welfare, dignity normal growth and development of the child’, specifically outlines that the minimum age for marriage at 18 years of age (Art 21 (2)), and Art 27 and 29 address sexual exploitation and trafficking of children. 6.1.1.4. Other International Legal Instruments for the protection of Children and Women208 6.1.2. National Legislation 6.1.2.1. The 1997 Constitution The 1997 Constitution clearly outlines that men and women have equal rights under the law. Section 28 states that men and women shall be accorded full and equal dignity of person with men and shall be treated equally with men including equal opportunities in political, economic and social activities. Chapter IV outlines fundamental rights and freedoms of people, specifically providing protection to children against acts or conduct that violates their human rights, particularly the right to bodily integrity. Section 29 (2) protects children under the age of 16 from economic exploitation and hazardous work or employment. The constitution also prohibits a person from torture or inhumane, degrading punishment or other treatment. Section 27 provides for the right to marry which is given to ‘men and women of full age and capacity’ seemingly making early or forced marriage against the constitution. Section 28 identifies that ‘women shall be accorded full and equal dignity of persons with men and shall be treated equally with men, including 208 The African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights -This international Charter obligates state parties to ‘combat all forms of discrimination against women through appropriate legislation, institutional and other measures (Art 2). Other articles specifically address violence against women, harmful practices which negatively affect the human rights of women, specifically referring to FGM. Reproductive health rights should be guaranteed (Art 14). Protection for widows and elderly women against degradation, humiliation and degrading treatment are specified in Articles 20, 22 – 24. African Union Solemn Declaration on Gender Equality in Africa (Declaration) - The Gambia is a signatory to the African Union Solemn Declaration on Gender Equality in Africa (Declaration). In the Declaration, the Heads of State reaffirmed their commitment to gender equality as enshrined in Article 4 of the constitutive Act of the African Union as well as other existing commitments, principles and obligations set out in the various regional, continental and international human rights instruments, particularly those affecting women. 184 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 opportunities in political, economic, and social activities. Discrimination based on race, color, gender, language, national or social origin, birth or other status is also protected against in Section 33. 6.1.2.2. Criminal Code Act Cap 10 Vol. III Laws of the Gambia 1990 The Criminal Code makes provision to secure the protection of children from sexual abuse and exploitation. Specifically it outlines provisions against the following: The indecent assault of women and girls (Sec. 126) Defilement of children (Sec 127) Rape (Sec 121) Procurement of children for sex or prostitution (Sec 129 – 130) Indecent assault of boys (Sec. 146) Child stealing (Sec. 159) Kidnapping (Sec 232) Incest (Sec. 148 – 149) Intentional maiming, disfigurement or disabling of any person (Sec 212 a, b) Unlawfully causing grievous harm (Sec. 214) Unlawfully wounding a person (Sec. 217 a) Causing the death of another person (Sec.221 a) Unlawfully wounding a person, and assaults causing actual bodily harm (Section 227, 228) 6.1.2.3. The National Policy for the Advancement of Gambian Women The National Policy for the Advancement of Gambian Women 1999-2009 was adopted and ratified by the National Assembly in 1999. The policy aims to strengthen the capacity to adhere to the obligations as laid out in the CEDAW. The policy closely aligns itself to many of the basic tenets of the CEDAW and serves as a national recognition and support to the CEDAW. 6,1,2,4, The Children’s Act 2005 In support of the UNCRC, the Children’s Act protects children from violence and abuse, sexual exploitation, trafficking and sale, and child prostitution. It prohibits harmful traditional practices, child marriage and betrothals, and harmful publications. Additionally, there are sections of the Act have extraterritorial reach; exportation or importation of children for prostitution, kidnapping and abduction of children, trafficking children, and dealing with children as slaves, foreign travel which promotes or encourages child prostitution. 185 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 There are reporting obligations outlined in the Children’s Act, mandating that ‘any person with information on child abuse or a child in need of care and protection to report to the Department of Social Welfare or police’. It also recognizes vulnerable populations, such as orphans, street children or victims of sexual abuse and exploitation require special care and protection. 6.1.2.5. The Women’s Act, 2010 The Women’s Act 2010, which was signed in April 2010, and further reviewed and updated in October 2010209 sets forth legislation that addresses the rights of women and girls. Specifically it addresses issues related to their right to dignity, life, integrity and security of person, freedom of expression, freedom from discrimination, education and training, health and health care, reproductive rights, acquisition of property, inheritance, marriage, food security, adequate housing, positive cultural practices, healthy and sustainable environment. It address specific issues for vulnerable women; widows, elderly women, disabled women and women in distress. The Act prohibits all violence against women and girls (Sec. 6) including any form of physical, sexual, psychological, or economic harm, suffering or violence occurring in public or private. It prohibits domestic violence or wife beating. Sections 9 and 10 prohibit discrimination of women through words, acts, inactions, omissions, laws, regulations or administrative procedures by public, government or private enterprises. Abortion is protected in cases ‘where the continued pregnancy endangers the life of the mother or the life of the foetus’ contingent upon medical certification. Protection against sexually transmitted diseases, and to be educated on the health aspects of harmful traditional practices. (Sec 31 (d) and (e)) 6.1.2.6. Tourism Offences Act 2003 The Tourism Offences Act prohibits tourists or any other person from making sexual advances to a child, having sex with a child, or procuring a child for sex, child pornography, sexual exploitation of a child and child trafficking. Trafficking Person’s Act 6.1.2.7. The Trafficking Person’s Act address issues related to trafficking of persons, complaint procedures, and arrests, treatment of victims of trafficking, and rescue, 209 Revised to include a six month maternity leave clause. 186 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 rehabilitation and reintegration. It calls for the creation of a National Agency against Trafficking in Persons to ensure the effective implementation of the Act. Gender Policy 2010 – 2020 As a means to strengthen the National Policy for the Advancement of Gambian Women 1999-2009, The Gender Policy 2010 -2020 was developed. The Gender Policy is designed therefore to act as reference material and direct all levels of planning, resource allocation and implementation of development projects with a gender perspective. The priority areas for the policy are: • Gender and Education • Gender and Health • Gender and Sustainable Livelihoods Development • Gender and Governance • Gender and Human Rights • Poverty Reduction and Economic Empowerment The overall mission of the policy is to: 1. Achieve gender equity and equality at policy, programme and project levels in all institutions across all sectors of The Gambian society. 2. Achieve sustainable eradication of gendered poverty and deliver an acceptable quality of life. 3. Eliminate all forms of discrimination and gender based violence. 4. Empower women to be able to take their rightful position in national development The overall goal of this policy is to achieve gender equity and women empowerment as an integral part of the national development process through enhancing participation of women and men, girls and boys for sustainable and equitable development and poverty reduction. The policy outlines specific objectives and strategies under each of the four mission statements above. Other government measures The National Women’s Council and the Women’s Bureau strive to ensure the integration of women into the social, political and economic processes as equal partners, participants and beneficiaries. The Women’s Bureau is the executive arm of the Council and oversees its day to day administration and implementation of policy decisions made by the Council. Both organizations, established in 1980, come under the powers of the Vice President’s Office. 6.2. Policy and Budget Matrix and Analysis (To follow based on data availability] 187 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 6.2.1. Sample of Education Budget Tracking – pending available information Chapter 7. Emerging Trends– the effect of emerging trends and issues on the status of Children and Women 7.1. Financial, Fuel and Food Crisis There have been significant shifts in the order and value of various commodities throughout the world both in terms of medium terms trends abut also with a series of climate and economy related shocks in the past 12-18 months. Although some of these will have posed a short term problem to the Gambian economy in terms of the prices of staples due to widespread crop damage from fire in Russia or the recent crises in the oil industries affecting fuel prices, it is the longer term trends that should be of greater concern to Gambia. Gambia is still very much a subsistence economy whose commodity and manufacturing economies have been growing slowly. Growth rates alone show a rosy picture but they are starting from a very low baseline. Manufacturing growth means growth in re-exports; most noticeably in fisheries and agriculture, but not only do exports total less than a third of net imports, very little of these exports are manufacturing or re-exports they are primarily commodities. The immediate effects of the Global Financial Crisis on children and women in The Gambia are difficult to summarize due to the complexity of the issues, causes and outcomes. According to an Oxfam report 210 , The Gambia has been identified as a ‘fragile state’ due it’s low-income and Country Policy and Institutional Assessment score. According to the report, fragile states have been somewhat ‘shielded’ from the direct impact of the crisis due to the high level of poverty and uncertain financial environment already. The level of impact may not be readily apparent, since the incidence of poverty is high (approximately 60 percent of Gambians are deprived of basic necessities as defined in the MPI index). Nevertheless the results of the crisis can be observed in several dimensions such as reduced remittances from abroad which are sent from countries directing affected by the crisis, a decrease in the availability of donor money, inflation, and currency devaluation. Some of the evidence of the fall out from the FFF Crisis are demonstrated by a 25 percent reduction in remittances from abroad and by a decrease in tourism in 2008 (25 percent ) and 2009 (30 percent ). The Food Crisis of 2008 occurred in The Gambia at 210 Report is in draft form. 188 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 a time of severe droughts, and therefore has substantial impact on the ability of poor households to meet the basic daily food requirements. As a response to the 2008 food crisis, AATG and VSO led a campaign to increase awareness concerning the issue and engaged the government to development a response plan, with input from local communities. 7.2 Climate Change The Gambia's First National Communication to the United Nations Framework Convention for Climate Change (2003) (UNFCCC) examined the country's vulnerability to climate change and identified the main climatic hazards confronting The Gambia as the following: Increased climatic variability: Relative to baseline conditions, there have been observed changes in average, range, and variability of temperature and precipitation throughout the country; Recurring drought: The occurrences of dry spells, seasonal droughts and multi-year droughts are more frequent than in the past. The Gambia’s meteorological records indicate that there has been a general tendency towards decreasing total annual rainfall over the last three decades. Studies also show that during the second half of this century, the country experienced erratic seasonal distribution of rainfall (Hutchinson &Sam, 1984; Hutchinson, 1985; Anyadike, 1993). Statistical analysis of rainfall patterns over Banjul based on a 102-year period (1886-1987) established that, among other things, there has been a consistently late onset of rainy seasons between 1968 and 1987, and an early end to the season between 1970 and 1976 (Anyadike, 1993). Flooding: there has been a perceived increase in episodes of torrential rainfall with heavy runoff and flooding. With changing climate conditions, the frequency and intensity of floods and tides may increase and these together with drought can cause severe damage to crops, reduce fish resources and cause considerable economic losses. In order to address and mitigate some of the potentially negative impact to the environment, agriculture, and health sectors due to climate change, the Gambia Government has developed specific mitigation strategies and programs estimated at a cost of US $ 20,122,130, to address the potential impacts of climate change in the areas listed below211. 211 SOURCE on document 189 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Water resources Agriculture Forestry Health Livestock Coastal Zone Fisheries Energy Climate change is expected to translate into sea-level rise during the next century. The extent of the rise is still uncertain. According to World Bank estimates only a very small percentage of Sub-Sahara Africa’s area and agricultural land would be affected. Nevertheless, some countries would be much more severely affected. The countries with greatest land area impact would be the Gambia and, to a lesser extent, GuineaBissau. Banjul, the capital city of the Gambia, is particularly vulnerable to sea-level rise and the entire city could be lost with a 1-metre rise in sea level. A major ecological and economic consequence of sea level rise would be the destruction of wetlands and mangroves, which currently provide livelihoods to coastal populations. Women, particularly those in poor countries, will be affected differently than men. They are among the most vulnerable to climate change, partly because in many countries they make up the larger share of the agricultural work force and partly because they tend to have access to fewer income-earning opportunities. Women manage households and care for family members, which often limits their mobility and increases their vulnerability to sudden weather-related natural disasters. Drought and erratic rainfall force women to work harder to secure food, water and energy for their homes. Girls drop out of school to help their mothers with these tasks. This cycle of deprivation, poverty and inequality undermines the social capital needed to deal effectively with climate change212. One of the key challenges in climate change is technology in monitoring of current trends or changes. Additionally there is little information about community perceptions regarding climate change and local responses to changes in the environment. United Nations Population Fund, ‘Facing a changing world: women, population and climate’, State of the World’s Population 2009, UNFPA, November 18, 2009, p.4. 212 190 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 7.3. Urbanization, unemployment, and migration 7.3.1. Population Mobility It appears that in sectors where the Gambian labour force has usually dominated, like construction, fishing and tourism, the hiring of foreign workers is becoming increasingly common (up to 40 percent of hotel workers may be foreign-born). To keep things within perspective, one should not forget that although these figures are high, construction, fisheries, and tourism represent together less than ten percent of total employment. Foreign-owned establishments, which might have an inclination to hire foreign workers, employ 22 percent of wage employees The presence of foreign-owned establishments (across a number of sectors, but especially notable in trade activities) is more marked in urban areas, where they account for 25 percent of all establishments. The population Census 2003 found that 13 percent of both the economically active and employed populations were “non-Gambians”. A recent survey of the fishery sector confirms a significant proportion of units owned by foreigners, mainly of Senegalese origin, but not overwhelming. Four major reasons exist for the disproportionate presence of non-Gambian labour in various occupations. First, The Gambia is geographically surrounded by Senegal and their populations are linguistically and ethnically similar. This facilitates the movement Senegalese labour into The Gambia. Second, there is an acute scarcity of skills among Gambians in particular occupations. This relative scarcity, especially vis-à-vis Senegal, may have some historical roots. Before the founding of the technical training school in Banjul in the 1960s, skilled labour was provided through informal apprentice arrangements within technical units of organizations and government departments. The manpower made available through this system was primarily targeted at meeting short-term needs identified by government and the existing foreign owned commercial firms. No serious planning effort was ever made to develop a cadre of skilled technicians who could satisfy the needs of a growing population. As a result, unforeseen and urgently needed skilled manpower needs were often met through migration from the neighbouring regions of Senegal, where the formal apprenticeship and skill based training institutions have been in existence since the colonial period. Moreover, a shortage of skilled labour in social services has traditionally existed. So the influx of educated refugees as teachers and health staff from war-torn Sierra Leone, Liberia and other West African Anglophone countries was quite significant in the recent past. 191 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Third, the low cost of immigrant labour and the lack of enforcement of basic labour standards encourages the hiring of migrant labour. Wages offered in certain sectors may be too low to induce entry from local workers, although accurate measurements of the reservation wage among economically active Gambians are not available. Some argue that migrant workers, especially those coming for short periods of time, are more compelled to find irregular or seasonal work in order to save money before returning to their country of origin. Seasonal labour circulation between Senegal and The Gambia has the effect of driving wages down for certain occupations. Fourth, some occupations, especially in the informal sector, tend to be highly segmented and rely on social networks to function effectively. This is the case with trade in which certain migrant communities (Mauritanian, Senegalese and ArabLebanese) seem to control large niches of the sector. If such networks are essential to be competitive in cross-border trade, the barriers to entry for Gambian workers may be high. The existence of closed networks of employers and workers with a significant migrant presence runs the risk of creating niche economies and reinforcing particular forms of economic exclusion along the lines of nationality and ethnicity. This could foster a degree of resentment among the local population, especially the urban youth, if unemployment figures and the incidence of “discouraged workers” increase. 7.3.2 Urbanization Over the past twenty years, The Gambia has seen a substantial increase in the urban population. In 1990, approximately 38 percent of the population lived in urban areas, in 2010, the total percentage of Gambians living in urban areas has dramatically increased to 58 percent . According to a recent UN report on Urbanization, ‘by 2050, over 60 percent of Africans will be living in cities. Governments must invest in housing and infrastructure or face disaster’. BBC November 24, 2010. Chart 28: Urban Population in The Gambia 1990 - 2010 70.00% 60.00% 50.00% 40.00% 30.00% 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 Source: HDR 2009 192 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The move from rural areas to urban cities is happening in countries throughout the world. Some of the effects are an overcrowding and over burdening of urban centers that are not well prepared to absorb the heavy influx. 7.3.3. Migration The Gambia experiences relatively high levels of immigration, which have significantly increased approximately 900 percent since the 1960s from 31,000 migrants in 1960 to over 290,000 in 2010 (15 percent of the total population). The table below tracks immigration from 1960 – 2010. Chart 29: Immigration Trends in The Gambia Immigration Trend In The Gambia 350 300 250 200 150 Immigrant Stock (000) 100 50 0 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 Source: HDR 2009 The majority of immigrants into The Gambia come from Senegal, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Mail, Mauritania, and Sierra Leone. Women make up approximately 48.7 of immigrants and 3.1 percent of the immigrant population are refugees, Reasons for immigration in The Gambia include; Agricultural harvest Refugees from Conflict areas (Southern Senegal, the Casamance, Guinea, Liberia, Sierra Leone, Guinea Biseau) Economic incentives during tourist season (November – May ) Internal Migration Rural-urban migration is a serious concern in The Gambia, as it is in many other developing countries. The concentration of the best infrastructure, services and opportunities in the urban areas has led many rural dwellers, particularly young people, to move to towns and cities in search of a better life. The problem of rural-urban migration may have serious consequences at the family level. Migration of the male household head can affect the family and its structures, sometimes leading to increased burden and stress213. 213 The Daily Observer, ‘Population and Employment’, November 3, 2009. 193 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The 2003 census also showed a trend toward more urbanization in The Gambia which increased from 37.1 percent in 1993 to 50.4 percent in 2003. This has been fuelled by rural-urban migration. The majority of these people have been young people (63.6 percent of the population are under 25 years old). Availability of jobs is limited with a small formal sector and only employing 10 percent of the labor force. Women represent only 9.4% of the skilled labor workforce, despite making up 51 percent of the population. In contrast women represent 61.9 per cent of the unskilled labor category. (Marfo, 2007). In The Gambian context, migrants from rural areas could add to the burden of an urban relative who feels bound by tradition to provide whatever support may be necessary. This is equally true of economic migrants in search of employment and social migrants in search of employment and social migrants such as students. Emigration The emigration rate is 3.6 percent of the population with the majority of emigrants relocating in Spain, Senegal, the United States, Nigeria, UK, Germany, Sweden, France, Norway and Guinea Bissau. As in many low - middle income countries, there is significant external exodus of skilled workers in The Gambia. The emigration rate for tertiary educated is 67.7 percent or 44 percent 214. In a recent World Bank Report215, The Gambia was classified as the country with the second highest proportion of skilled emigrants. Nearly 65,000 Gambians are living outside the country in 2010. And an alarming 63 percent of the country’s tertiary-educated population is living abroad as of 2000, which makes Gambia the second nation, behind Cape Verde (68 percent ), whose university educated nationals left their country the most216. The healthcare sector seems particularly affected by ‘brain drain’ with trained health professionals immigrating as outlined below. Emigration of physicians: - 14.1 percent of physicians trained in the country Emigration of Nurses: 66.2 percent of nurses trained in the country217 Remittances 214 United Nations Development Programme, ‘Human Development Report’, UNDP, 2009. 215 World Bank, ‘Migration and Remittances Fact Book 2011’, WB, 2010. 216 World Bank, ‘Migration and Remittances Fact Book 2011’, WB, 2010. 217 Docquier and Bhargava 2006 194 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 Money sent from Gambians who migrant to other countries is important not only to the families to whom the money is sent but also to the Gambian economy. Remittances sent to individuals, families, and The Gambian economy accounts for approximately 47 million USD dollars or 6.9 percent of GDP218. Although the direct impact of the effect of the Financial Crisis on the level of remittances has yet to be assessed, and is somewhat challenging to carry out given the various means by which money is sent and received in The Gambia, the increased rate of unemployment in countries of relocation in Europe and the United States will have an impact on the amount of available resources that can be sent to recipients in the Gambia. According to the World Bank report, remittances to Africa fell by nearly 4 percent between 2008 and 2009, the first decrease since 1995. The Gambia averaged 9.6 percent of GDP in international remittances since 2003, which were among the highest in the world. However remittances have steadily declined from 14.2 percent in 2003 to 6.4 percent in 2008219. According to the WB report, the remittance flows at continental levels are expected to reach US$440 billion by end-2010, up from US$416 billion in 2009. About 75 percent of these funds, or US$325 billion, will go to developing countries. The report noted that flows to developing countries as a whole will rise further over the next two years. 7.4. Currency Crisis The current currency crisis, probably more aptly named a balance of payments crisis is due to a clash of ideologies between the two biggest economies in the world; the USA and China. Other currencies are being affected by the political posturing that is taking place, but the real problem for smaller countries, particularly countries who both import and export large amounts of commodities (i.e. those with commodities making up a significant proportion of their balance of payments deficit) is likely to be the effect on trade movement and prices. The USA, along with Europe is still the largest market by some distance of manufactured products, whereas China remains the largest single consumer of commodities, so any tension between the countries, especially in terms of trade freedom is likely to have knock on affects to all countries who have commodity dominated economies. United Nations Development Programme, ‘Human Development Report’, UNDP, 2009. World Bank, ‘Poverty reduction Challenges and Opportunities’, Poverty Assessment, World Bank, May 29, 2009. 218 219 195 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 The Gambia is a net importer of commodities; primarily rice, oil and maize, and an exporter of groundnuts and fish products. Its main source of commodity exports is India and Japan (over 50 percent) but it remains a net importer of commodities (a net negative balance of payments of in excess of $US 200 million) with China its single biggest trading partner (30 percent)220. As such the biggest risk to the Gambia is growing prices for commodities that is due to ever-expanding domestic market for consumption of commodities in China itself. The problem of imported staple foods could be a significant factor in future risks for both development of the workforce and any attempt to move away from a commodity based economy and towards a manufacturing economy, but this also acts as an opportunity to invest more heavily in agricultural technology and ‘re-export industry’ which has remained stagnant for the past two decades221. Investment in commodity agriculture both for domestic consumption and for ‘re-export’ industries should be prioritized, and in most countries this shift has generally been accompanied by a significant increase in the proportion of women in the workforce. As an aside it is also associated with significant fall in the fertility rate in rural areas, which is also likely to have positive benefits for women’s health and well-being. Chapter 8. Conclusions The rights of children and women in The Gambia are recognized and protected on various levels. The government has ratified international treaties, participated in international discussions and seminars promoting the rights of children and women, and is making strides in meeting the MDGs. National legislation has been created aimed at protecting and positively empowering children and women. There are numerous agencies that implement programs at the local level which focus on specific issues that affect the rights of children and women. Those persons who live under the National Poverty Line are extremely vulnerable to rights abuses and violations as are other vulnerable groups living in The Gambia such as persons with disabilities, single female headed households, orphans, street children, children living in rural areas, and people living or affected by HIV/AIDS. Yet the findings of this study indicated that vulnerable populations are the least represented in Gambian 220 Central Bank of the Gambia, ‘Annual Report 2007’. The Economist Intelligence Unit, ‘The Gambia: Economist Country Report’, 26 Red Lion Square, London WC1R 4HQ United Kingdom, July 2009. 221 196 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 society. In fact, one of the most striking findings of the situation analysis is that the most vulnerable populations have the least access to much needed assistance and services. Despite the achievements and progress made over the past ten years, there are still some hurdles that must be overcome. The maternal mortality rate is one of the highest in the world, women are far from achieving equal political representation on the national or local level, traditional practices that endanger the health and create economic hardships for women and children continue, and poverty affects women and children in complex ways and has far reaching and long term implications. Equity and Decentralization While strong legislation has been enacted and effective programming which safeguard the rights of children and women is ongoing, the systems that have been established to ensure that services and programs promote children’s and women’s rights are not equally implemented across geographical, ethnic and gender divisions and do not adequately address the gaps of service delivery. Currently the vast majority of programs affecting children and women are heavily concentrated in the Greater Banjul Area, with rural areas receiving minimal input and resources. The rural population, who make up over 40 percent of the population and over 70 percent of the poor, are in desperate need of, and would greatly benefit from increased access to quality services. System Strengthening Structures and systems that support the implementation of the Children’s Act 2005, the Women’s Bill 2010 and other relevant polices which protect the rights of children and women do not meet identified needs in terms of education, especially post primary, access to quality health service delivery including medications, and ensuring protection of children who are involved in the justice system. Using the DoSW as an example, legislation regarding child protection is in place, yet the appropriate facilities, staff and training are woefully insufficient in implementing the plans which have been drafted. This goes equally for the heath sector, wherein access to facilities is limited, there is an insufficient supply of basic medications and there are not enough trained staff to provided high quality care. Appropriate Funding The Women’s Act 2010 and the Children’s Act 2005 are some of the most comprehensive works of legislation protecting the rights of children and women currently in effect in Africa. Yet budgets do not reflect the required initiatives which are 197 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 necessary to implement the specific plans set out in the legislation. For example the Children’s Act calls for a Social Welfare Officer at every police station in The Gambia, yet insufficient funding makes this placement impossible. Adequate funding is needed if systems are to be decentralized and successfully functioning. Assistance to the Most Vulnerable One of the most important findings of this report is that programming, resource allocation, assistance and in some cases recognition is not properly awarded to the most vulnerable populations. Recognition of the plight of rural "A nation's greatness and vulnerable populations is the first step in meeting their needs. is measured by how it The plight of widows who are often left with minimum resources, treats its weakest the difficulties of the extremely poor (who make up over 30 members." percent of the population), and the recognition that there are Mahatma Gandhi. significant numbers of children who toil from dawn to dusk on the streets needs to be recognized and programs developed to meet their needs. Limited Participation of Women and Children in Decision Making Findings from this report indicate that women and children are not granted equal input into decision making, even in areas that directly affect personal well being such as health, marriage partner, daily work, long term vocation, or what types of food to enjoy. In The Gambia, men are often the sole decision maker when it comes to household matters. The result of this lack of input into decision making is that important needs of women and children are not met and women must confront discrimination at many levels. Women and children who are most vulnerable are especially hurt by discriminatory practices. For example, widows due to traditional practices or customary law are at times left without access to any source of income or property. One of the biggest problems facing women and children is of household investment. Decisions, which are taken by the male head of household, are often dominated by short term thinking due to necessity or an inability to frame benefits accrued in the long term. This is a widely replicated problem and is witnessed across the scope of household spending. In order to help address this issue, women and children need to be included in the decision making process, whether on the household, community or national level. Limitations of Legislation 198 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 In some of the most important, yet recognizably sensitive issues, (divorce, harmful traditional practices, early marriage and inheritance laws) the insertion of the phrase ‘unless customary law applies’ into the article in essence nullifies the original intent. The inclusion of this wording directly limits and restricts the fulfillment of the rights of children and women. Improved Data Collection and Analysis Timely data collection and analysis is essential to ensure that resources are correctly targeted, and that programs are implemented in line with objectives and any contextual changes are addressed. There are data collection systems that function well such as EMIS, which analyzes education data on a monthly basis to ensure programs such as school feeding are successfully implemented. Yet in other social service sectors, up-todate data collection and analysis is a challenge. This impedes progress in areas that affect the rights of women and children such as health care, reporting of abuse or exploitation and improving services for vulnerable populations. Limited Employment Opportunities for Women The female workforce is a highly undervalued and underutilized resource in many subSaharan African economies, and the case of the Gambian economy is no different. Women have shown themselves to be resourceful and a strategic sector of the population and are often a critical factor in the move from low to middle income countries. Evidence from South America and South East Asia have shown that the rise in the proportion of women in the workforce usually goes hand in hand with significant jumps in economic growth, particularly in manufacturing and service industries, the two key areas in which the Gambian economy needs the greatest expansion if it is to build on its already impressive growth of the last five years. Contraceptive Accessibility and Use The Gambia has shockingly low contraception usage rates, which is probably the primary reason for its still high fertility rate and its population growth rate. It is also probably one of the key factors in the relatively slow impact on health outcomes (reductions in IMR and U5MR) that it has achieved despite a considerable level of progress in health systems indicators such as immunization, ITN usage and treatment seeking behavior. Evidence has long suggested that making modern contraception alternatives available at affordable prices tends to improve choice, and it is the ‘unwanted’ children who are most likely to suffer from poor nutrition, worse health outcomes and poverty. 199 Situation Analysis of Children and Women in the Gambia 2010 A Culture of Silence A common theme that has been consistently identified as a cause for many of the issues that adversely affect the rights of children and women is the ‘culture of silence’. This refers to the cultural phenomenon in which sensitive issues that may not be exactly in line with traditional practices or not under interpretations of Shiri'a law, such as FGM, early marriage and inheritance law are not discussed or recognized. This silence can be detrimental to women and children, especially in cases such as child abuse or sexual abuse. 200