CPA Practice Aids, LLC
PERFORMING COMPILATION AND REVIEW ENGAGEMENTS,
RECENT UPDATES AND PROPOSALS
Learning Objectives
After completing this section of the course, you will be able to:
1. Understand the fundamental concepts of compilation services and the effects of recent
updates and proposals
2. Apply effective and efficient compilation engagement performance, reporting and
documentation methods
3. Understand the fundamental concepts of review services, recent updates and proposals
and other related professional standards
4. Apply effective and efficient review engagement performance, reporting and
documentation methods
Part 1—Compilation Engagements
AR Section 80, Compilation of Financial Statements
AR Section 80 establishes standards and provides guidance on compilations of financial
statements. The accountant is reminded that he or she should comply with the provisions of this
section whenever he or she:
1. Is engaged to report on compiled financial statements,
2. Submits (prepares and presents) financial statements to a client that are or reasonably
might be expected to be used by a third party, or
3. Submits (prepares and presents) financial statements to a client that are not expected
to be used by a third party.
Requirements of SSARS No. 19
SSARS No. 19 requires that the accountant establish an understanding with management
regarding the services to be performed for each engagement through a written communication
(that is, an engagement letter).
The letter should include:
1. The objective of a compilation—to assist management in preparing financial statements;
2. That the accountant utilizes management’s representation without providing any assurance;
3. That management is responsible for a fair presentation of financial statements, internal
controls, preventing and detecting fraud, complying with all laws and regulations, and
making all records available to the accountant;
4. That the accountant is responsible for complying with SSARS;
5. A description of how a compilation differs from a review or audit;
6. That the engagement can’t be relied upon to disclose errors, fraud or illegal acts, but the
accountant will notify management when any errors, fraud, or illegal acts (unless clearly
inconsequential) are discovered.
7. The effect of any independence impairments on the accountant’s report; and
1
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
8. Other matters’ such as fees and billings, limitations of accountant’s liability, additional
services, material departures, omitting substantially all disclosures or statement of cash
flows, and reference to supplementary information.
SSARS No. 19 also:
1. Establishes enhanced documentation requirements for a compilation engagement (for
significant unusual matters and fraud).
2. Allows the accountant to include a general description in the accountant’s compilation
report regarding the reason(s) for an independence impairment, and
Non-Attest Services
An accountant may also be engaged to perform a non-attest service such as bookkeeping,
payroll, or other accounting services, and in addition, certain non-attest services may also be
considered to be internal control services. SSARS does not cover the performance and reporting
requirements of a non-attest service, even if performed in conjunction with a compilation. These
are discussed in ET 101-3, Non-Attest Services.
Reporting When the Accountant Is Not Independent
The accountant may indicate his or her lack of independence by including the following as the
final paragraph of the accountant’s compilation report:
“I am (we are) not independent with respect to XYZ Company.”
The accountant is not required to provide any additional details regarding the reasons for the
independence impairment. The accountant is allowed, however, to provide a general description
regarding all the general reasons that his or her independence is impaired. If the accountant
elects to disclose a general description about the reasons his or her independence is impaired, the
accountant should ensure that all reasons are included in the general description.
Caveat: The accountant may provide a general description regarding the reason that his or her
independence is impaired. He or she is precluded from disclosing a detailed description about the
reason that his or her independence is impaired, including disclosing the specific internal control
services performed. The standard explains that to do so increases the possibility that a user of
the accountant’s compilation report may misunderstand and misinterpret the independence
impairment.
Accountant’s Communications With the Client When the Compiled Financial Statements
Are Not Expected to Be Used by a Third Party
SSARS No. 19 retains requirements in the previous SSARs regarding cases when the accountant
submits compiled financial statements to his or her client that are not expected to be used by a
third party. Preparation of management-use-only financial statements by a CPA requires an
engagement letter detailing the performance requirements for a compilation engagement and the
restrictions on the use of financial statements.
2
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Emphasis of a Matter
This section is in the previous requirements and SSARS No. 19 does not change them. The
accountant may emphasize, in any report on financial statements, a matter disclosed in the
financial statements or footnotes.
Departures from the Applicable Financial Reporting Framework
The language has been changed from “Departures from Generally Accepted Accounting
Principles” to “Departures from the Applicable Financial Reporting Framework.” An accountant
who is engaged to compile financial statements may become aware of a departure from the
applicable financial reporting framework (including inadequate disclosure) that is material to the
financial statements.
Restricting the Use of an Accountant’s Compilation Report
This section discusses restricting the use of an accountant’s compilation report and retains the
previous requirements. It describes general use and restricted use reports and says that nothing in
this section precludes the accountant from restricting the use of any report.
An Entity’s Ability to Continue as a Going Concern
This SSARS contains a discussion as to what the accountant should do if he or she encounters a
going-concern issue. The previous SSARS contains the same information as is contained in the
SSARS No. 19 standard describing what the accountant should do if, during the performance of
compilation procedures, evidence or information comes to his or her attention indicates that an
uncertainty may exist about the entity's ability to continue as a going concern for a reasonable
period of time, not to exceed one year beyond the date of the financial statements being
compiled.
In such cases, the accountant should request management to consider the possible effects of the
going concern uncertainty on the financial statements and possible need for related disclosure.
The accountant should consider the reasonableness of management's conclusions including the
adequacy of the related disclosures, if applicable. If the accountant determines that
management's conclusions are unreasonable or the disclosure of the uncertainty regarding the
entity's ability to continue as a going concern is not adequate, he or she should follow the
guidance contained in the section of SSARS No. 19, “Departures from the Applicable Financial
Reporting Framework.”
Subsequent Events
Events or transactions that sometimes occur subsequent to the balance sheet date but prior to
management's issuance of financial statements, which have a material effect on the financial
statements and require adjustment to or disclosure in the statements. Adjustments are necessary
when the entity, having knowledge of subsequent events prior to the close of the reporting
period, would have recorded those events. Footnote disclosures are necessary for other material
subsequent events. Selected footnote disclosures may be necessary for other material subsequent
events even when management elects to omit substantially all disclosures. This section is also
contained in the previous standards. The requirements remain the same in SSARS No. 19.
SFAS No. 165, Subsequent Events, (ASC Topic 855-10) retains the old rules from the auditing
literature but distinguishes between the dates financial statements are issued or are available for
3
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
issue. Management’s responsibility for adjusting or disclosing subsequent events for non-public
entities normally ends when statements are available for issue. Accountants and auditors
responsibility for subsequent events also normally ends on that date.
Supplementary Information
This section remains the same as that in the previous standards. When the basic financial
statements are accompanied by information presented for supplementary analysis purposes, the
accountant should clearly indicate the degree of responsibility, if any, he or she is taking with
respect to such information.
Communicating to Management and Others
This section is the same as that in the previous standards and concerns when evidence or
information comes to the accountant's attention during the performance of compilation
procedures that fraud or an illegal act may have occurred, communicating that matter to the
attention of the appropriate level of management. The accountant need not report matters
regarding illegal acts that are clearly inconsequential and may reach agreement in advance with
the entity on the nature of such items to be communicated.
4
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Approach to Performing Compilation Engagements
Start
OBTAIN
ENGAGEMENT
LETTER
ACQUIRE
INDUSTRY/GAA
P KNOWLEDGE
UNDERSTAND
CLIENT’S
BUSINESS AND
ENVIRONMENT
READ
FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
ANY
UNUSUAL
MATTERS?
CAN WE
OR CLIENT
REVISE?
`
REPORT
FRAMEWORK OK?
5
NO?
DISCLOSE
DEPARTURE
REPORT
DISCLOSURES OK?
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
PREPARE
STANDARD
REPORT
MODIFIED
REPORT
INDEPENDENT?
ISSUE
REPORT
DISCLOSE
LACK OF
INDEPENDENCE
Obtain an Engagement Letter
SSARS No. 19 requires a written communication with management. An illustration of a standard
engagement letter is provided in SSARS No. 19.
When management doesn’t intend to distribute the financial statements to a third party and the
accountant doesn’t plan to issue a compilation report, the engagement letter should contain an
acknowledgment of management’s representation and an agreement that the statements will not
be distributed to a third party. This, of course, assumes the accountant has no knowledge or
expectation of planned third party use.
Other matters that should be considered for inclusion in the engagement letter include:
1. Material departures from GAAP (or the applicable reporting framework) may exist and
the possible effects of such departures may not be disclosed;
2. A statement of cash flows and substantially all disclosures may not be included; and
3. The nature of any supplementary information that will be included in the financial
statements, as well as the degree of responsibility the accountant is taking for such
information.
The compilation engagement letter will normally include an understanding of non-attest and
other services performed by the accountant and it can cover services performed throughout a
6
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
year. ET 101-3 on non-attest services previously required such an understanding, which was
either communicated in a compilation engagement letter or a separate letter. To minimize
misunderstandings, descriptions of the non-attest and other services should be as specific as
possible.
Obtain Industry/Reporting Framework Knowledge
The accountant is required to have a sufficient knowledge of the accounting and reporting
principles of the industry in which the client operates. This knowledge is necessary to determine
if the financial statements are prepared in appropriate form. This knowledge is also necessary to
enable the accountant to identify and follow up on unusual matters (incorrect, incomplete, or
unsatisfactory information) common to the industry. Scrap and waste in manufacturing,
common uses of byproducts, or cost allocation methods may be unique to an industry and affect
the form and content of financial statements.
Understand Client’s Business
The accountant should obtain a general understanding of the client’s business, its organization
and operating characteristics, and the nature of its accounts. The accountant’s experience with
the client and/or its industry, reading or scanning general ledger account activity, making
inquiries of entity personnel, and completion of a practice aid, like the Small Entity Information
Form illustrated in Part 2 of this series, can provide this understanding.
An understanding of the client’s accounting principles and practices, along with the nature and
content of its accounts, is also required. Unusual matters coming to the accountant’s attention
may require additional inquiries and possible proposed journal entries to eliminate obvious
material errors from the financial statements. Financial statements should be revised to reflect
the resolution of the unusual matters. If the accountant believes the financial statements are
materially misstated and the client refuses to revise the statements, the accountant should
withdraw from the engagement.
Read Financial Statements
The purpose of the accountant’s reading of financial statements is to use the understanding of the
client’s business and industry to determine that the statements are free of “obvious material
errors.” This term is defined as clerical or mathematical mistakes in the preparation of the
financial statements and mistakes in application of accounting principles and related disclosures.
While SSARS No. 19 doesn’t use the term risk in connection with compilation engagements,
practically speaking, the accountant reads financial statements to determine any potential risks of
material misstatement.
Below is the process of “reading” financial statements used by most accountants:
1. Obtain a trial balance of general ledger accounts and trace balances to the general ledger
(or determine balances came from the entity’s accounting software);
2. Scan (read) general ledger account activity for unusual matters;
3. Perform accounting services by comparing account balances to applicable supporting
documents, records, subsidiary records, and/or account analysis as considered necessary
based on the understanding of the client’s business and industry;
7
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Propose necessary adjusting journal entries;
Perform compilation procedures if financial statements are being submitted to the client;
Draft, or assist client personnel in drafting, financial statement and footnotes;
Complete an abbreviated disclosure checklist;
Read the statements and footnotes to determine if they are presented in accordance with
the applicable reporting framework; and
9. If the statements and footnotes contain any incorrect, incomplete, or unsatisfactory
information (unusual matters), request the client to make revisions and/or make inquiries
of management personnel to facilitate additional procedures or to propose adjustments to
correct the unusual matters.
For most small annual or interim compilation engagements, the accountant will assist in the
preparation of the financial statements. Reading those statements is the culmination of the
process outlined above and the final quality control procedure performed by the accountant.
Other Compilation Procedures
In addition to reading the financial statements, other compilation procedures may be performed.
Such procedures may include:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Performing client acceptance and continuance procedures;
Evaluating independence of CPA firm personnel;
Documenting unusual matters discovered and their disposition;
Documenting communication of any fraud or illegal acts coming to the accountant’s
attention;
5. Drafting the financial statements and reading as outlined above;
6. Drafting the accountant’s report;
7. Documenting any consultations made; and
a. Making a final review of the financial statement and footnotes.
Compilation Engagement Documentation
The extent and nature of documentation will depend on firm policies and the risk of
misstatement associated with an engagement. SSARS No. 19 requires an engagement letter,
documentation of unusual matters and their resolution and documentation of the communication
of any fraud or illegal acts. A list of common documentation for compilation engagements from
Part 2 of this series follows.
Compilations (full disclosure):







Engagement letter
Client Acceptance and Continuance Form (Part 2)
Planning Document (optional)
Small Entity Information Form (Part 2)
General Ledger Analysis Worksheet
Compilation Procedures Checklist
Adjusted working trial balance
8
CPA Practice Aids, LLC




Working papers or memos documenting significant and/or unusual matters and their
disposition
Checklist and schedules supporting financial statement disclosures
or the reasons why disclosures are omitted
Schedules and account analyses for footnotes and tax return preparation.
Engagement Review Checklist (Part 2)
Compilations (disclosures omitted):









Engagement letter
Client Acceptance and Continuance Form
Small Entity Information Form
General Ledger Analysis Worksheet
Compilation Procedures Checklist (abbreviated)
Adjusted working trial balance
Working papers or memos documenting significant and/or unusual matters and their
disposition
Schedules and account analysis for tax return preparation
Engagement Review Checklist, memo or routing document
For interim compilations performed in connection with accounting services, some documentation
can be prepared annually (Engagement Letter, Client Acceptance and Continuance Form, Small
Entity Information Form) or other documentation may be combined on a spreadsheet with
multiple-period sign offs (Compilation Procedures Checklist).
Common Deficiencies in Compilation Engagements
The AICPA has compiled findings from peer reviews and issued various reports and alerts on
deficiencies noted in compilation and review engagements. Here are some of those deficiencies:
1. Management’s election to omit substantially all disclosures not mentioned in the
accountant’s compilation report,
2. Wording of compilation report not current,
3. Failure to disclose lack of independence in compilation report,
4. Failure to describe the degree of responsibility for supplementary information,
5. Statements prepared without disclosures on a basis of accounting other than GAAP that
was not readily determinable,
6. Failure to disclose omission of statement of cash flows in GAAP statements,
7. Statement of cash flows that didn’t conform to SFAS No. 95 (ASC 230-10),
8. Failure to disclose a departure from the applicable reporting framework in the
accountant’s report,
9. No disclosures of accounting policies and/or other required disclosures,
10. Improper accounting and/or classification of a material transactions,
11. Titles of financial statements and terminology not meeting industry standards or basis of
accounting,
12. Failure to refer to the accountant’s report on each page of financials,
13. Failure to include all periods presented in accountant’s report descriptions,
9
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
14. Failure to use practice aids required by firm policy,
15. Incomplete engagement letter for management-use-only engagements, and
16. Failure to disclose the effects of changes in accounting principles.
Illustrative Documentation from SSARS No. 19
(SSARS No. 19 should be consulted for detailed instructions on the use of these documents)
Compilation of Financial Statements—Illustrative Engagement Letter
(Addressed to the individual or board that engaged the CPA firm)
This letter is to confirm our understanding of the terms and objectives of our engagement and the
nature and limitations of the services we will provide. We will perform the following services:
We will compile, from information you provide, the annual balance sheet and related statements
of income, retained earnings, and cash flows of ABC Company for the year 20__.
We will compile the financial statements and issue an accountant’s report thereon in accordance
with Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services issued by the American
Institute of Certified Public Accountants. The objective of a compilation is to present in the form
of financial statements, information that is the representation of management (owners) without
undertaking to express any assurance on the financial statements.
A compilation differs significantly from a review or an audit of financial statements. A
compilation does not contemplate performing inquiry, analytical procedures, or other procedures
performed in a review. Additionally, a compilation does not contemplate obtaining an
understanding of the entity’s internal control; assessing fraud risk; tests of accounting records by
obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence through inspection, observation, confirmation, the
examination of source documents (for example, cancelled checks or bank images of checks); or
other procedures ordinarily performed in an audit. Therefore, a compilation does not provide a
basis for expressing any level of assurance on the financial statements being compiled.
Our engagement cannot be relied upon to disclose errors, fraud, or illegal acts that may exist.
However, we will inform the appropriate level of management of any material errors, and of any
evidence or information that comes to our attention during the performance of our compilation
procedures that fraud may have occurred. In addition, we will report to you any evidence or
information that comes to our attention during the performance of our compilation procedures
regarding illegal acts that may have occurred, unless they are clearly inconsequential.
As part of our engagement, we will also [list any non-attest services to be performed, if
applicable, such as income tax preparation and bookkeeping services].
You are responsible for:
a. Making all management decisions and performing all management functions;
b. Designating an individual who possesses suitable skill, knowledge, and/or experience,
preferably within senior management, to oversee the services;
10
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
c. Evaluating the adequacy and results of the services performed;
d. Accepting responsibility for the results of the services; and
e. Establishing and maintaining internal control, including monitoring ongoing activities.
If, for any reason, we are unable to complete the compilation of your financial statements, we
will not issue a report on such statements as a result of this engagement.
Our fees for these services . . . .
We will be pleased to discuss this letter with you at any time.
If the foregoing is in accordance with your understanding, please sign the copy of this letter in
the space provided and return it to us.
Sincerely yours,
________________________
[Signature of accountant]
Acknowledged:
ABC Company
_______________________
President
_______________________
Date
11
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Compilation of Financial Statements Not Intended for Third Party Use—Illustrative
Engagement Letter
(Addressed to the individual or board that engaged the CPA firm)
This letter is to confirm our understanding of the terms and objectives of our engagement and the
nature and limitations of the services we will provide.
We will perform the following services:
We will compile, from information you provide, the [monthly, quarterly, or annual] financial
statements of ABC Company for the year 20__.
We will compile the financial statements in accordance with Statements on Standards for
Accounting and Review Services issued by the American Institute of Certified Public
Accountants. The objective of a compilation engagement is to present in the form of financial
statements, information that is the representation of management (owners) without undertaking
to express any assurance on the financial statements.
A compilation differs significantly from a review or an audit of financial statements. A
compilation does not contemplate performing inquiry, analytical procedures, or other procedures
performed in a review. Additionally, a compilation does not contemplate obtaining an
understanding of the entity’s internal control; assessing fraud risk; tests of accounting records by
obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence through inspection, observation, confirmation, the
examination of source documents (for example, cancelled checks or bank images of checks); or
other procedures ordinarily performed in an audit. Therefore, a compilation does not provide a
basis for expressing any level of assurance on the financial statements being compiled.
The financial statements will not be accompanied by a report. Based upon our discussions with
you, these statements are for management's use only and are not intended for third-party use.
Material departures from generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) may exist and the
effects of those departures, if any, on the financial statements may not be disclosed. In addition
substantially all disclosures required by GAAP may be omitted. (The accountant may wish to
identify known departures.) Notwithstanding these limitations, you represent that you have
knowledge about the nature of the procedures applied and the basis of accounting and
assumptions used in the preparation of the financial statements that allows you to place the
financial information in the proper context. Further, you represent and agree that the use of the
financial statements will be limited to members of management with similar knowledge.
The financial statements are intended solely for the information and use of
_____________________ and are not intended to be and should not be used by any other party.
Our engagement cannot be relied upon to disclose errors, fraud, or illegal acts that may exist.
However, we will inform the appropriate level of management of any material errors and of any
evidence or information that comes to our attention during the performance of our compilation
12
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
procedures that fraud may have occurred. In addition, we will report to you any evidence or
information that comes to our attention during the performance of our compilation procedures,
regarding illegal acts that may have occurred unless they are clearly inconsequential.
We are not independent with respect to ABC Company [if applicable].
As part of our engagement, we will also (list any non-attest services to be provided, if applicable,
such as income tax preparation and bookkeeping services).
You are responsible for:
a. Making all management decisions and performing all management functions;
b. Designating an individual who possesses suitable skill, knowledge, and/or experience,
preferably within senior management, to oversee the services;
c. Evaluating the adequacy and results of the services performed;
d. Accepting responsibility for the results of the services; and
e. Establishing and maintaining internal control, including monitoring ongoing activities.
The other data accompanying the financial statements are presented only for supplementary
analysis purposes and will be compiled from information that is the representation of
management, without audit or review, and we do not express an opinion or any other form of
assurance on such data—[if applicable].
Our fees for these services …
Should you require financial statements for third-party use, we would be pleased to discuss with
you the requested level of service. Such engagement would be considered separate and not
deemed to be part of the services described in this engagement letter.
We will be pleased to discuss this letter with you at any time.
If the foregoing is in accordance with your understanding, please sign the copy of this letter in
the space provided and return it to us.
Sincerely yours,
_______________________
[Signature of accountant]
Accepted and agreed to:
ABC Company
_______________________
Title
_______________________
Date
13
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Illustrative Compilation Report
Detailed reporting requirements and illustrations in SSARS No. 19 should be consulted
when reporting on compilation engagements. The following illustrative compilation
report is from SSARS No. 19:
Accountant’s Compilation Report
[Appropriate Salutation]
I (we) have compiled the accompanying balance sheet of XYZ Company as of December
31, 20XX, and the related statements of income, retained earnings, and cash flows for the
year then ended. I (we) have not audited or reviewed the accompanying financial
statements and, accordingly, do not express an opinion or provide any assurance about
whether the financial statements are in accordance with accounting principles generally
accepted in the United States of America.
Management (owners) is (are) responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the
financial statements in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the
United States of America and for designing, implementing, and maintaining internal
control relevant to the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements.
My (our) responsibility is to conduct the compilation in accordance with Statements on
Standards for Accounting and Review Services issued by the American Institute of
Certified Public Accountants. The objective of a compilation is to assist management in
presenting financial information in the form of financial statements without undertaking
to obtain or provide any assurance that there are no material modifications that should be
made to the financial statements.
[Signature of accounting firm or accountant, as appropriate]
[Date]
Part 2—Review Engagements
AR Section 90, Review Of Financial Statements
Establishes standards and provides guidance on reviews of financial statements.
The accountant should comply with the provisions of this section whenever he or she has
been engaged to review financial statements, except for reviews of certaub interim
financial information.

The entity’s latest annual financial statements have been audited by the
accountant or a predecessor (SSARS No. 20 eliminated the requirement for the
accountant, or any accountant to have been engaged to audit the entity’s current
year financial statements),
14
CPA Practice Aids, LLC



The client prepares its interim financial information in accordance with the same
financial reporting framework as that used to prepare the annual financial
statements,
Accountants engaged to perform reviews of interim financial information when
the conditions above are met should perform such reviews in accordance with AU
section 722, Interim Financial Information (AICPA, Professional Standards, vol.
1), or
The accountant is precluded from performing a review engagement if the
accountant’s independence is impaired.1
Changes from Existing Standards as a Result of SSARS No. 19
Engagement Letter — SSARS No. 19 requires that the accountant establish an
understanding with management regarding the services to be performed for each
engagement through a written communication (an engagement letter). The previous AR
section 100 paragraph .05 stated that the understanding should preferably be in writing
but did not require a written engagement letter.
Expanded Guidance — provides expanded guidance on the performance of analytical
procedures in a review engagement.
Documentation of Management’s Responses To Accountant Inquiries—establishes
a requirement that the accountant document:


Management’s responses to the accountant’s inquiries regarding fluctuations or
relationships that are inconsistent with other relevant information or that differ
from expected values by a significant amount and
Management’s responses to the significant matters covered in the accountant’s
inquiry procedures. The previous AR section 100 paragraph .45 did not require
that the accountant document management’s responses.
Significant Changes from Existing Standards
Establishing an Understanding (Engagement Letter)
The accountant should:


Establish an understanding with management regarding the services to be
performed for each engagement and
Document the understanding through a written communication (emphasis added)
with management.
Review Performance Requirements
The accountant should apply professional judgment in determining the specific nature,
timing, and extent of review procedures (based on risks of material misstatements).
1
The original exposure draft contained a section that permitted the accountant to perform a review
engagement when he or she was not independent. This “non-independent review” is not part of SSARS No.
19. As a result of the comments the ARSC received on this proposal, for and against, they decided to defer
this issue in order to hold additional meetings with key stakeholders.
15
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Procedures should be tailored based on the accountant’s understanding of the industry in
which the client operates. The understanding includes accounting principles and practices
of the industry. Procedures will also be designed based the accountant’s knowledge of the
entity. This includes the client’s organization, its operating characteristics, the nature of
its accounts and its accounting principles and practices.
While there is no requirement to understand a client’s internal control system, evidence
of internal controls obtained from reading the general ledger, performing analytical
procedures and making inquiries may reduce review risk. Review evidence necessary to
restrict review risk to a moderate level can ordinarily be obtained primarily through
analytical procedures and inquiries.
Designing and Performing Review Procedures
Analytical Procedures
SSARS No. 19 provides expanded guidance with respect to the performance of analytical
procedures, which includes the following:





Understanding financial and nonfinancial relationships is essential in planning
and evaluating the results of analytical procedures;
Knowledge of the client and the industry in which the client operates is generally
required;
An understanding of the purposes of analytical procedures and the limitations of
those procedures is also important;
Analytical procedures involve comparisons of recorded amounts, or ratios
developed from recorded amounts, to expectations developed by the accountant;
and
Expectations are developed by identifying and using plausible relationships that
are reasonably expected to exist based on the accountant's understanding of the
industry in which the client operates and knowledge of the client.
Examples of sources of information for developing expectations include:





Financial information for comparable prior period(s) giving consideration to
known changes;
Anticipated results, for example, budgets or forecasts including extrapolations
from interim or annual data;
Relationships among elements of financial information within the period;
Information regarding the industry in which the client operates, for example,
gross margin information; and
Relationships of financial information with relevant nonfinancial information, for
example, payroll costs to number of employees.
Analytical procedures may be performed at the financial statement level or at the detailed
account level. The nature, timing, and extent of the analytical procedures are a matter of
professional judgment basic on the subjective level of review risk.
16
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Practical Note: For small and medium-size review engagements, comparison of absolute
dollar balances of accounts after adjustment, among a number of years, may be the most
meaningful analytical procedure. Coupled with reading the general ledger account
activity for the current year, this procedure also is the most pervasive and most efficient
analytical procedure.
Inconsistent Information
If analytical procedures performed identify fluctuations or relationships that are
inconsistent with other relevant information or that differ from expected values by a
significant amount, the accountant should investigate these differences by inquiring of
management and performing other procedures as necessary in the circumstances.
(Emphasis added)
Review evidence relevant to management’s responses may be obtained by evaluating
those responses, taking into account the accountant’s understanding of the entity and its
environment, along with other review evidence obtained during the course of the review.
The accountant is not required to corroborate management’s responses with other
evidence, however, the accountant may need to perform other procedures when, for
example, management is unable to provide an explanation or the explanation, together
with review evidence obtained relevant to management’s response, is not considered
adequate.
Inquiries and Other Review Procedures
Inquiries to members of management who have responsibility for financial and
accounting matters include the following:









Whether the financial statements have been prepared in conformity with the
applicable financial reporting framework;
The entity's accounting principles and practices and the methods followed in
applying them; procedures for recording, classifying, and summarizing
transactions; and accumulating information for disclosure in the financial
statements;
Unusual or complex situations that may have an effect on the financial statements;
Significant transactions occurring or recognized near the end of the reporting
period;
The status of uncorrected misstatements identified during the previous
engagement;
Questions that have arisen in the course of applying the review procedures;
Events subsequent to the date of the financial statements that could have a
material effect on the financial statements;
Their knowledge of any fraud or suspected fraud affecting the entity involving
management or others, where the fraud could have a material effect on the
financial statements (for example, communications received from employees,
former employees, or others);
Significant journal entries and other adjustments;
17
CPA Practice Aids, LLC




Communications from regulatory agencies;
Inquiries concerning actions taken at meetings of stockholders, the board of
directors, committees of the board of directors, or comparable meetings that may
affect the financial statements; and
Reading the financial statements to consider, on the basis of information coming
to the accountant's attention, whether the financial statements appear to conform
with the applicable financial reporting framework.
Obtaining reports from other accountants, if any, who have been engaged to audit
or review the financial statements of significant components of the reporting
entity, its subsidiaries, and other investees
Corroboration of Management’s responses—The accountant ordinarily is not required
to corroborate management's responses with other evidence; however, the accountant
should consider the reasonableness and consistency of management's responses in light of
the results of other review procedures and the accountant's knowledge of the client’s
business and the industry in which it operates. The higher the risk of material
misstatement, the more likely management’s responses should be corroborated!
Incorrect, Incomplete, or Otherwise Unsatisfactory Information (AR Section 90
paragraph .21)
This concerns situations in which the accountant may become aware that information is
incorrect, incomplete, or otherwise unsatisfactory. In this case, he or she should:


Request that management consider the effect of these matters on the financial
statements and communicate the results of its consideration to the accountant and
Consider the results communicated to the accountant by management and the
effect, if any, on the accountant’s review report.
If the accountant believes the financial statements may be materially misstated, the
accountant should perform additional procedures deemed necessary to obtain limited
assurance that there are no material modifications that should be made to the financial
statements in order for the statements to be in conformity with the applicable financial
reporting framework.
If the accountant concludes that the financial statements are materially misstated, the
accountant should follow the guidance in the section of SSARS No. 19 entitled
“Departures from the Applicable Financial Reporting Framework.”
Management Representations
Written representations are required from management for all financial statements and
periods covered by the accountant's review report. The specific written representations
obtained by the accountant will depend on the circumstances of the engagement and the
nature and basis of presentation of the financial statements. Written representations from
management ordinarily confirm representations explicitly or implicitly given to the
accountant, indicate and document the continuing appropriateness of such
18
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
representations, and reduce the possibility of misunderstanding concerning the matters
that are the subject of the representations.
The accountant should request that management provide a written representation related
to the following:








Management's acknowledgment of its responsibility for the fair presentation of
the financial statements in conformity with the applicable financial reporting
framework;
Management's belief that the financial statements are fairly presented in
conformity with the applicable financial reporting framework;
Management's acknowledgement of its responsibility to prevent and detect fraud;
Knowledge of any fraud or suspected fraud affecting the entity involving
management or others where the fraud could have a material effect on the
financial statements (including any communications received from employees,
former employees, or others);
Management's full and truthful response to all inquiries;
Completeness of information;
Information concerning subsequent events; and
Any additional information tailored to appropriate representations from
management relating to matters specific to the entity's business or industry.
Updating Representation Letter
Circumstances exist in which the accountant should consider obtaining an updating
representation letter from management, for example:



The accountant obtains a management representation letter after completion of
inquiry and analytical review procedures but does not issue the review report for a
significant period of time thereafter;
A material subsequent event occurs after the completion of inquiry and analytical
review procedures, including obtaining the original management representation
letter, but before the issuance of the report on the reviewed financial statements;
and
If a predecessor accountant is requested to reissue the report on the financial
statements of a prior period, and those financial statements are to be presented on
a comparative basis with reviewed financial statements of a subsequent period,
the predecessor accountant should obtain an updating representation letter from
the management of the former client.
The updating management representation letter should state:

Whether any information has come to management's attention that would cause
management to believe that any of the previous representations should be
modified and
19
CPA Practice Aids, LLC

Whether any events have occurred subsequent to the balance-sheet date of the
latest financial statements reported on by the accountant that would require
adjustment to or disclosure in those financial statements.
Date of Management’s Representation Letter
Management's representations set forth in the management representation letter should be
made as of the date of the accountant's review report, which should be the date the
financial statements are available for issue.
Documentation in a Review Engagement
SSARS No. 19 does not change previous SSARS requirements for the accountant to
prepare documentation in connection with each review engagement in sufficient detail to
provide a clear understanding of the work performed (including the nature, timing,
extent, and results of review procedures performed), the review evidence obtained and its
source, and the conclusions reached.
The accountant may also support the review report by other means in addition to the
review documentation, including:


Written documentation contained in other engagement files (for example
compilation or non-attest services) or quality control files (for example
consultation files) and
Oral explanations, in limited situations. Oral explanations on their own do not
represent sufficient support for the work the accountant performed or conclusions
the accountant reached, but may be used by the accountant to clarify or explain
information contained in the documentation.
The form, content, and extent of documentation depend on the circumstances of the
engagement, the methodology and tools used, and the accountant’s professional
judgment. Documentation is discussed further in other parts of this series.
SSARS No. 19 contains a list of documentation that should be included, in addition to the
customary documentation with which accountants are familiar:


Under the analytical procedures performed, management’s responses to the
accountant’s inquiries regarding fluctuations or relationships that are inconsistent
with other relevant information or that differ from expected values by a
significant amount and
Evidence from the performance of internal control services, if applicable.
The following items that should be included in the accountant’s documentation are in the
current documentation requirements (Some of the language has been modified from the
previous standard):


The signed engagement letter documenting the understanding with the client;
The analytical procedures performed including the following:
20
CPA Practice Aids, LLC








The expectations, where the expectations are not otherwise readily
determinable from the documentation of the work performed, and factors
considered in the development of the expectations;
Results of the comparison of the expectations to the recorded amounts or
ratios developed from recorded amounts; and
Any additional review procedures performed in response to significant
unexpected differences arising from analytical procedures and the results of
such additional procedures.
The significant matters covered in the accountant’s inquiry procedures and the
responses thereto. The accountant may document the matters covered by the
accountant’s inquiry procedures and the responses thereto through a spreadsheet,
memorandum, checklist, or other means;
Any findings or issues that, in the accountant's judgment, are significant, for
example, the results of review procedures that indicate the financial statements
could be materially misstated, including actions taken to address such findings,
and the basis for the final conclusions reached;
Significant unusual matters that the accountant considered during the performance
of the review procedures, including their disposition. Evidence from the
performance of internal control services, if applicable;
Communications, whether oral or written, to the appropriate level of management
regarding fraud or illegal acts that come to the accountant's attention; and
The representation letter.
Reporting on the Financial Statements
Financial statements reviewed by an accountant should be accompanied by a report. The
financial statements reviewed by the accountant should include on each page a reference,
such as "See Independent Accountant's Review Report."
Incomplete Review —When the accountant is unable to perform the inquiry and
analytical procedures he or she considers necessary to obtain limited assurance that there
are no material modifications that should be made to the financial statements in order for
the statements to be in conformity with the applicable financial reporting framework, or
the client does not provide the accountant with a representation letter, the review will be
incomplete. A review that is incomplete does not provide an adequate basis for issuing a
review report. The accountant should consider the matters discussed in the AR 90
section, “Change in Engagement from Audit to Review” in deciding whether it is
appropriate to issue a compilation report on the financial statements.
Supplementary Information
When information presented for supplementary analysis purposes, the accountant should
clearly indicate the degree of responsibility, if any, he or she is taking with respect to
such information. When the accountant has reviewed the basic financial statements, an
21
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
explanation of the accountant’s responsibility for the supplementary information should
be included in the review report, or in a separate report on the other data.
The report should state that the review has been made for the purpose of expressing a
conclusion that there are no material modifications that should be made to the financial
statements in order for them to be in conformity with the applicable financial reporting
framework, and either:


The other data accompanying the financial statements are presented only for
purposes of additional analysis and have been subjected to the inquiry and
analytical procedures applied in the review of the basic financial statements, and
the accountant did not become aware of any material modifications that should be
made to such data or
The other data accompanying the financial statements are presented only for
purposes of additional analysis and have not been subjected to the inquiry and
analytical procedures applied in the review of the basic financial statements but
were compiled from information that is the representation of management,
without audit or review, and the accountant does not express an opinion or any
other form of assurance on such data.
Approach to Performing Review Engagements
In the order of performance, here are the review engagement procedures required by the
SSARS. A discussion of each of these procedures follows.
1. Determine if the accountant lacks independence for any reason;
2. If the accountant’s independence is impaired, consider a step-down to a
compilation with disclosure of independence impairment;
3. Obtain an engagement letter;
4. Acquire industry/GAAP knowledge;
5. Understand the entity’s organization, operations and accounting;
6. Read (scan) the general ledger, make inquiries and perform other appropriate
analytical procedures;
7. Make additional inquiries or perform additional procedures to resolve “unusual
matters.”
8. Propose adjustments as necessary;
9. Prepare, or assist client personnel in preparing, financial statements and footnotes;
10. Read financial statements and footnotes to determine they are presented in
accordance with GAAP (or the applicable reporting framework);
11. Prepare a standard or modified report (disclosing omissions or departures) on
review; and
12. Obtain a representation letter.
Evaluate Independence
Because reviews are attest and assurance engagements, an accountant must be
independent to perform the services. A CPA firm’s system of quality control must have
22
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
policies in place to evaluate and document the independence of its members that are
covered by the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct.
In addition to the prohibition of certain familial relationships and financial interests in the
client, the accountant cannot perform unsupervised non-attest services without impairing
independence. Management must assign a person with suitable skill, knowledge, and
experience to oversee and approve any non-attest services performed by the accountant to
avoid impairment of the accountant’s independence.
Obtain an Engagement Letter
SSARS No. 19 requires a written communication with management. An illustration of a
standard engagement letter is provided in Appendix E of the standard.
In addition to the matters described in the illustrative letter, an understanding of the
following matters may be included:




Fees and billings;
Any limitations on the liability of the accountant, such as indemnification for
management’s misrepresentations (unless restricted or prohibited by regulators);
Conditions when others may be granted access to review documentation; and
Additional services to be provided due to regulatory requirements.
These other matters, if applicable, should be addressed in the engagement letter:


Material departures from the applicable reporting framework and
Reference to supplementary information and the degree of responsibility the
accountant is assuming for it.
The review engagement letter will normally include an understanding of the non-attest
and other services to be performed by the accountant. The client’s responsibility for
oversight and approval of those services should also be included in the letter.
Obtain Industry/Reporting Framework Knowledge
The accountant is required to have a sufficient knowledge of the accounting and reporting
principles of the industry in which the client operates. This knowledge is necessary to
determine if the financial statements are prepared in appropriate form. This knowledge is
also necessary to enable the accountant to identify and follow up on unusual matters
(incorrect, incomplete or unsatisfactory information) common to the industry. Scrap and
waste in manufacturing, common uses of byproducts or cost allocation methods may be
unique to an industry and affect the form and content of financial statements.
Understand Client’s Business
The accountant should obtain a general understanding of the client’s business, its
organization and operating characteristics, and the nature of its accounts. The
accountant’s experience with the client and/or its industry, reading the general ledger,
23
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
inquiries of its personnel, and completion of a practice aids can provide documentation of
this understanding.
For review engagements, the extent of the documentation of the accountant’s knowledge
of a client should be more extensive than for compilations. The accounting principles and
practices used by the client in measuring, recognizing, recording, and disclosing all
significant accounts and disclosures in the financial statements should be documented.
Unusual matters coming to the accountant’s attention may require additional inquiries
and possible proposed journal entries to eliminate obvious material errors from the
financial statements. Financial statements should be revised to reflect the resolution of
the unusual matters. If the accountant believes the financial statements are materially
misstated and the client refuses to revise the statements, the accountant should withdraw
from the engagement.
Performing Review Procedures
Review procedures should be designed to accumulate review evidence sufficient to
reduce review risk to provide a reasonable basis for expressing limited assurance that no
material modifications are necessary for the financial statements to be in conformity with
the applicable reporting framework. SSARS No. 19 continues by stating:
“The accountant should apply professional judgment in determining the specific
nature, timing, and extent of review procedures. Such procedures should be
tailored based on the accountant’s understanding of the industry in which the
client operates and the accountant’s knowledge of the entity. Review evidence
obtained through the performance of analytical procedures and inquiry will
ordinarily provide the accountant with a reasonable basis for obtaining limited
assurance.”
Using Professional Judgment in Selecting Analytical Procedures and Inquiries for
Review Engagements
A major change in SSARS No. 19 is the emphasis on using professional judgment to
select and perform appropriate analytical procedures and inquiries depending on each
engagement’s unique risk circumstances. Review services are attest services and require
an accountant’s professional judgment to gather sufficient review evidence to provide
limited assurance that no material modifications are necessary for the financial statements
to be presented in accordance with the applicable reporting framework.
While review engagements have always been risk-driven services and the accountant’s
judgment has been necessary to determine the amount of evidence necessary to express
limited assurance, some CPA firms have defaulted to a canned set of procedures applied
to all review engagements. While such procedures enable the accountant to satisfy the
SSARS requirements in most cases, it is possible not all risks are identified or properly
evaluated, i.e., that appropriate professional judgment is not being applied. It is almost
certain that more than the necessary review procedures are being performed!
24
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Using professional judgment to determine appropriate analytical procedures and inquiries
requires identification of unusual matters and risks of material misstatements during
planning. Reading the general ledger, tracing account balances to subsidiary records and
supporting documents, account analysis, and making inquiries of key client personnel can
reveal most unusual matters, particularly on smaller review engagements. In such cases, a
simple comparison of account balances with the prior year or with budgeted amounts
may be the only additional analytical procedures that are necessary.
SSARS 19 does require the documentation of the accountant’s expectations for analytical
procedures (if not evident from the documentation of the procedures) and of
management’s responses to inquiries about variances in analytical procedures and other
significant matters. Preparing the documentation in spreadsheet or memo form will often
be more effective and efficient than reading and using lengthy detailed checklists that
contain unnecessary procedures.
Designing and Performing Review Procedures
If we haven’t figured it out yet, review procedures are risk driven. The accountant should
focus analytical procedures and inquiries where there is indication of increased risk of
misstatements. The starting place should be scanning, or reading, the client’s general
ledger. Reading the general ledger and the documentation on a spreadsheet or memo is a
risk identification procedure that provides review evidence which, when combined with
evidence from other analytical procedures, inquiries and additional procedures, is
necessary for an accountant to provide limited assurance on the financial statements.
Here is an approach to determining which analytical procedures and inquiries should be
performed. The SSARS literature states that analytical procedures involve comparisons
of expectations developed by the accountant to recorded amounts or ratios. The first step
would be to develop a list of what is expected of a client. Here goes:
1. The client has an accounting system sufficient to prepare reliable financial data.
2. Management has designed a system of internal control, which it operates with
diligence to properly measure, record, classify and report all transactions in the
financial statements;
3. Absent unusual circumstances, the operations of the entity and the financial
reporting of results, will be consistent from year to year, or period to period; and
4. Management’s daily involvement in operations of the entity provides the control
environment that sets the standard for employees and minimizes the risk of error
or fraud.
We could make a long detailed list from the four expectations above, but this is sufficient
to identify the accountant’s expectations in performing analytical procedures. The
expectation should be that there won’t be unusual matters, errors or fraud that have
occurred and gone undetected! The beginning expectation should be that risk is low!
Once the accountant has prepared documentation for understanding the client’s business
and industry, read the detailed account activity in the general ledger, and at least
25
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
compared the current year account balances with the prior year, the areas of higher risk
should be apparent. Read this carefully. SSARS No. 19 says that the only analytical
procedures and inquiries we need are those that are necessary to determine if risks of
misstatement have a misleading affect on financial statements. While a few standard
inquiries may be appropriate, reading the general ledger and comparing the current year’s
account balances to the prior year usually represent the only analytical procedures that
should be routinely performed.
Using professional judgment to design review procedures is not a routine business.
Similar to risk assessment for audits, the analytical procedures, inquiries and additional
procedures required for reviews depends on the review risk coming to the accountant’s
attention while obtaining and documenting an understanding of the client’s business and
its operations. Here it is simply: When review risk is low, few procedures are required;
the greater the risk that comes to our attention, the more work that is required.
Inquiries and Other Review Procedures
In addition to gathering information about the client discussed above, here are some
standard inquiries the accountant may consider making:








Are there any unusual or complex situations that may affect the financial
statements?
Are there any significant transactions occurring around yearend?
What is the status of uncorrected misstatements identified during the prior period?
Are there any subsequent events that could have a material effect on the financial
statements?
Does management have knowledge of any fraud or suspected fraud?
Are there any significant journal entries during the period?
Are there any communications from regulatory agencies?
Are there any actions taken at directors’ meetings that have accounting
significance?
Preparing Financial Statements and Footnotes
For many review engagements, the accountant will assist the client in preparing the
financial statements and footnotes. Because preparing statements is the client’s
responsibility, such assistance is considered a non-attest service. The client’s oversight of
the process and approval of the finalized statements and notes is necessary to prevent the
accountant’s independence from being impaired.
Obtain a Representation Letter
Written representations are required from management for all statements and periods
reviewed. An illustrative representation letter is included in Appendix F of SSARS No.
19.
Review Engagement Documentation
Documentation is required to provide a clear understanding of the reasons for performing
procedures and their results, the source of all review evidence obtained and the
26
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
conclusions reached. A list of common documentation for review engagements from Part
2 of this series follows:













Engagement letter
Client Acceptance and Continuance Form
Planning Document
Small Entity Information Form
Inquiries and Analytical Procedures Memoranda
General Ledger Analysis Worksheet
Review Procedures Checklist
Adjusted working trial balance and analytical comparisons to prior years
Working papers documenting unusual matters and their disposition
Representation letter
Checklist and schedules supporting financial statement disclosures
Schedules and account analyses for footnote and tax return preparation
Engagement Review Checklist
Other Review Reporting Issues
Emphasis of a Matter
The accountant may wish to emphasize certain matters in an explanatory paragraph. Such
matters may include:
1. Going concern and other uncertainties,
2. Related party transactions, and
3. Significant subsequent events
Restricting the Use of a Review Report
The use of any report may be restricted to the use of one or more parties when the
information may be misunderstood or taken out of the context in which it was presented.
It may be appropriate to restrict the use of certain reports to limit the liability of the
accountant.
Going Concern Issues
When uncertainties exist about and entity’s ability to continue in existence for a year
from the date of the financial statements, management should be requested to consider
the possible impact of the uncertainties on the financial statements. If the accountant
believes management’s decisions are unreasonable or disclosures are inadequate, it may
be necessary to disclose a departure from the applicable reporting framework in the
accountant’s report. The uncertainty may be emphasized in the accountant’s report if it is
disclosed in the financial statements.
Subsequent Events
A subsequent even that has a material effect on financial statements should be considered
by management for either adjustment or disclosure. If the accountant believes such events
27
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
are not accounted for properly, a paragraph in the accountant’s report may be necessary
to disclose a departure from the applicable reporting framework.
Supplementary Information
When supplementary information has been included with the financial statements, the
review report should clearly indicate the degree of responsibility the accountant is taking.
The report should state the purpose of a review and that:


The supplementary information is presented only for additional analysis and has
been subjected to the inquiry and analytical procedures applied in the review of
the basic financial statements, and the accountant did not become aware of any
material modifications that should be made or
The supplementary information is presented only for additional analysis and has
not been subjected to the inquiry and analytical procedures applied in the review
of the basic financial statements but were compiled from information that is the
representation of management, without audit or review, and the accountant does
not express an opinion or provide any assurance on the information.
Common Deficiencies in Review Engagements
The AICPA has compiled findings from peer reviews and issued various reports and
alerts on deficiencies noted in compilation and review engagements. Here are some of
those deficiencies for reviews:














Reports dated incorrectly, without a date or with no reference to the dates of
financial statements;
Reports with financial statement titles and terminology not in accordance with
applicable financial reporting framework;
Issuance of a review report when the accountant is not independent;
Failure to disclose departures such as no income tax provision or inventory
adjustments on interim statements;
Failure to explain the accountant’s responsibility on supplementary information;
Use of inappropriate method of revenue recognition;
Failure to make required disclosures;
Failure to refer to accountant’s review report on each page of the financial
statements;
Inappropriate format for non-profit organization or other industry financial
statements;
Failure to disclose omission of statement of cash flows or misclassifications on
the statement;
Inappropriate or insufficient procedures for the level of service;
Documentation not sufficient to allow an experienced reviewer to assess
compliance with professional standards;
Failure to use a work program and disclosure checklist as required by firm policy;
Failure to perform and document inquiry and analytical procedures;
28
CPA Practice Aids, LLC



Failure to perform and document consultations and other research;
Failure to use engagement letters for accounting engagements; and
Failure to obtain representation letter for review engagements.
Illustrative Documentation from SSARS No. 19
(SSARS No. 19 should be consulted for detailed instructions on the use of these
documents)
Review of Financial Statements—Illustrative Engagement Letter
(Addressed to the individual or board that engaged the CPA firm)
This letter is to confirm our understanding of the terms and objectives of our engagement
and the nature and limitations of the services we will provide.
We will perform the following services:
We will review the financial statements of ABC Company as of December 31, 20__ and
issue an accountant’s report thereon in accordance with Statements on Standards for
Accounting and Review Services issued by the American Institute of Certified Public
Accountants. The objective of a review engagement is to express limited assurance that
there are no material modifications that should be made to the financial statements in
order for the statements to be in accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles.
A review differs significantly from an audit of financial statements, in which the auditor
provides reasonable assurance that the financial statements, taken as a whole, are free of
material misstatement. A review does not contemplate obtaining an understanding of the
entity’s internal control; assessing fraud risk; tests of accounting records by obtaining
sufficient appropriate audit evidence through inspection, observation, confirmation, or the
examination of source documents (for example, cancelled checks or bank images of
checks); and other procedures ordinarily performed in an audit. Accordingly, a review
does not provide assurance that we will become aware of all significant matters that
would be disclosed in an audit. Therefore, a review provides only limited assurance that
there are no material modifications that should be made to the financial statements in
order for the statements to be in conformity with generally accepted accounting
principles.
Our engagement cannot be relied upon to disclose errors, fraud, or illegal acts that may
exist. However, we will inform the appropriate level of management of any material
errors, and of any evidence or information that comes to our attention during the
performance of our review procedures that fraud may have occurred. In addition, we will
report to you any evidence or information that comes to our attention during the
performance of our review procedures regarding illegal acts that may have occurred,
unless they are clearly inconsequential.
29
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
As part of our engagement, we will also (list any non-attest services to be provided, if
applicable, such as income tax preparation and bookkeeping services).
You are responsible for:
a. Making all management decisions and performing all management functions;
b. Designating an individual who possesses suitable skill, knowledge, and/or
experience, preferably within senior management, to oversee the services;
c. Evaluating the adequacy and results of the services performed;
d. Accepting responsibility for the results of the services; and
e. Establishing and maintaining internal control, including monitoring ongoing
activities.
As part of our review procedures, we will require certain written representations from
management about the financial statements and matters related thereto.
If, for any reason, we are unable to complete our review of your financial statements, we
will not issue a report on such statements as a result of this engagement.
Our fees for these services. . . .
We would be pleased to discuss this letter with you at any time.
If the foregoing is in accordance with your understanding, please sign the copy of this
letter in the space provided and return it to us.
Sincerely yours,
_______________________
[Signature of accountant]
Acknowledged:
ABC Company
_______________________
President
_______________________
Date
_______________________
Chairman of the Board of Directors
_______________________
Date
30
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Review of Financial Statements—Illustrative Representation Letter
(Date)
(To the Accountant)
We are providing this letter in connection with your review of the [identification of
financial statements] of [name of entity] as of [dates] and for the [periods of review] for
the purpose of expressing limited assurance that there are no material modifications that
should be made to the statements in order for them to be in conformity with generally
accepted accounting principles. We confirm that we are responsible for the fair
presentation in the financial statements of financial position, results of operations, and
cash flows in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles.
Certain representations in this letter are described as being limited to matters that are
material. Items are considered material, regardless of size, if they involve an omission or
misstatement of accounting information that, in the light of surrounding circumstances,
makes it probable that the judgment of a reasonable person using the information would
be changed or influenced by the omission or misstatement.
We confirm, to the best of our knowledge and belief, as of [the date of the accountant's
review report], the following representations made to you during your review.
1. The financial statements referred to previously are fairly presented in conformity
with generally accepted accounting principles.
2. We have made available to you all:
a. Financial records and related data.
b. Minutes of the meetings of stockholders, directors, and committees of
directors, or summaries of actions of recent meetings for which minutes have
not yet been prepared.
3. There are no material transactions that have not been properly recorded in the
accounting records underlying the financial statements.
4. We acknowledge our responsibility to prevent and detect fraud.
5. We have no knowledge of any fraud or suspected fraud affecting the entity
involving management or others where the fraud could have a material effect on
the financial statements, including any communications received from employees,
former employees or others.
6. We have no plans or intentions that may materially affect the carrying amounts or
classification of assets and liabilities.
7. There are no material losses (such as from obsolete inventory or purchase or sales
commitments) that have not been properly accrued or disclosed in the financial
statements.
8. There are no:
a. Violations or possible violations of laws or regulations, whose effects should
be considered for disclosure in the financial statements or as a basis for
recording a loss contingency;
31
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
b. Unasserted claims or assessments that our lawyer has advised us are probable
of assertion that must be disclosed in accordance with Financial Accounting
Standards Board (FASB) Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 450,
Contingencies; or
c. Other material liabilities or gain or loss contingencies that are required to be
accrued or disclosed by FASB ASC 450.
9. The company has satisfactory title to all owned assets and there are no liens or
encumbrances on such assets, nor has any asset been pledged as collateral, except
as disclosed to you and reported in the financial statements.
10. We have complied with all aspects of contractual agreements that would have a
material effect on the financial statements in the event of noncompliance.
11. The following have been properly recorded or disclosed in the financial
statements:
a. Related party transactions, including sales, purchases, loans, transfers, leasing
arrangements, and guarantees, and amounts receivable from or payable to
related parties.
b. Guarantees, whether written or oral, under which the company is contingently
liable.
c. Significant estimates and material concentrations known to management that
are required to be disclosed in accordance with FASB ASC 275, Risks and
Uncertainties.
12. We are in agreement with the adjusting journal entries you have recommended,
and they have been posted to the company’s accounts. [if applicable]
13. To the best of our knowledge and belief, no events have occurred subsequent to
the balance-sheet date and through the date of this letter that would require
adjustment to or disclosure in the aforementioned financial statements.
14. We have responded fully and truthfully to all inquiries made to us by you during
your review.
________________________________
(Name of Owner or Chief Executive Officer and Title)
________________________________
(Name of Chief Financial Officer and Title, where applicable)
________________________________
(Name of Member of Board of Governance, preferably the Chairperson)
Representation letters ordinarily should be tailored to include additional appropriate
representations from management relating to matters specific to the entity’s business or
industry. Detailed guidance is included in the Appendices to SSARS No. 19.
32
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Review of Financial Statements—Illustrative Updating Management Representation
Letter
(Date)
(To Accountant)
In connection with your review(s) of the [identification of financial statements] of
[name of entity] as of [dates] and for the [periods of review] for the purpose of
expressing limited assurance that there are no material modifications that should be made
to the statements for them to be in conformity with generally accepted accounting
principles, you were previously provided with a representation letter under date of [date
of previous representation letter]. No information has come to our attention that would
cause us to believe that any of those previous representations should be modified.
To the best of our knowledge and belief, no events have occurred subsequent to [date of
latest balance sheet reported on by the accountant or date of previous representation
letter] and through the date of this letter that would require adjustment to or disclosure in
the aforementioned financial statements.
________________________________
[Name of Owner or Chief Executive Officer and Title]
________________________________
[Name of Chief Financial Officer and Title, where applicable]
________________________________
(Name of Member of Board of Governance, preferably the Chairperson)
33
CPA Practice Aids, LLC
Illustrative Review Report
Detailed reporting requirements and illustrations in SSARS No. 19 should be consulted
when reporting on review engagements. The following illustrative review report is from
Appendix D of SSARS No. 19.
Independent Accountant’s Review Report
[Appropriate Salutation]
I (We) have reviewed the accompanying balance sheet of XYZ Company as of December
31, 20XX, and the related statements of income, retained earnings, and cash flows for the
year then ended. A review includes primarily applying analytical procedures to
management’s (owners’) financial data and making inquiries of company management
(owners). A review is substantially less in scope than an audit, the objective of which is
the expression of an opinion regarding the financial statements as a whole. Accordingly, I
(we) do not express such an opinion.
Management (owners) is (are) responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the
financial statements in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the
United States of America and for designing, implementing, and maintaining internal
control relevant to the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements.
My (our) responsibility is to conduct the review in accordance with Statements on
Standards for Accounting and Review Services issued by the American Institute of
Certified Public Accountants. Those standards require me (us) to perform procedures to
obtain limited assurance that there are no material modifications that should be made to
the financial statements. I (We) believe that the results of my (our) procedures provide a
reasonable basis for our report.
Based on my (our) review, I am (we are) not aware of any material modifications that
should be made to the accompanying financial statements in order for them to be in
conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of
America.
[Signature of accounting firm or accountant, as appropriate]
[Date]
34