REVISED Canadian and World Studies Curriculum CIVICS AND CITIZENSHIP, GRADE 10 OPEN (CHV2O) The Political Spectrum Lesson Overview (brief summary) In this 75-minute lesson students are provided with an opportunity to explore the political spectrum, gain an understanding of what it means to be on the right or left side of the spectrum, apply it to Canadian politics, and understand their personal position on it. Students gain insights into how beliefs and values are associated with democratic citizenship in Canada and to appreciate the way their own beliefs and values shape their perspectives on civic issues. Students will also make use of the following phases of the inquiry process: gathering and organization information, interpreting and analyzing information, evaluating information and communicating findings. Inquiry Process/Cycle Phases: Discipline-Specific Thinking Concepts: Formulate Questions Gather and Organize Interpret and Analyze Evaluate and Draw Conclusions Communicate Political Perspective Curriculum Document/Grade/Course Code (secondary) or Strand (elementary) Curriculum Expectations Learning Goals A1. Political Inquiry: use the political inquiry process and the concepts of political thinking when investigating issues, events, and developments of civic importance. B1: Civic Issues, Democratic Values: describe beliefs and values associated with democratic citizenship in Canada, and explain how they are related to civic action and to one’s position on civic issues. B1.2 describe fundamental beliefs and values associated with democratic citizenship in Canada. B1.4 communicate their own position on some issues of civic importance at the local, national, and /or global level. At the end of this lesson, students will understand the concept of a political spectrum is understand what it means to be on the right or left of the spectrum be able to explain various political perspectives on a variety of issues. appreciate their own positions on the political spectrum, connecting it to their personal beliefs. OHASSTA & OHHSSCA Sample Curriculum Supports 2013 Revised Canadian & World Studies Instructional Components and Context Readiness Materials There are various political perspectives. Political parties exist and what they are. Students should have at least a rudimentary understanding the platforms of the major political parties Terminology Political Spectrum Right Wing Left Wing OHASSTA-OHHSSCA Concepts of Political Thinking poster CHV2O Concept Formation handout Party platforms for cooperative group work for Canadian and Ontario political parties can be found at: o Liberal Party of Canada http://www.liberal.ca o Conservative Party of Canada http://www.conservative.ca o New Democratic Party of Canada http://www.ndp.ca o Green Party of Canada http://www.greenparty.ca o Bloc Quebecois Party http://www.blocquebecois.org o Ontario Liberal Party http://www.ontarioliberal.ca/ o Ontario Progressive Conservative Party http://www.ontariopc.com/ o Ontario New Democratic Party http://ontariondp.com o Ontario Green Party http://ontariondp.com o A list of smaller parties at the federal and provincial level can be found at: Federal: http://elections.ca/content.aspx?section=pol&dir=par &document=index&lang=e Provincial: http://www.elections.on.ca/enCA/CandidatesAndParties/PoliticalParties/ Sample political spectrum questionnaires: http://www.markville.ss.yrdsb.edu.on.ca/history/civics/polspec.html http://l-lists.com/en/lists/0isll4.html OHASSTA & OHHSSCA Sample Curriculum Supports 2013 Revised Canadian & World Studies Minds On Connections Establishing a positive learning environment Connecting to prior learning and/or experiences Setting the context for learning Small Groups / Whole Class Perspective Statement Sorting Assessment: Assessment for learning Description 1. Refer to the Concepts of Political Thinking poster and, more specifically, the criteria for Political Perspective and indicate that this lesson focuses on developing a better understanding of how to use the criteria to “think politically” 2. Divide students into small groups of 3 to 4. Distribute an envelope or paper clipped “package” of statement strips (prepared in advance of the lesson). See CHV2O Concept Formation. 3. 4. Use a concept formation strategy for this task. Invite the students to review the series of 12 “I believe” statements. Then, provide the following instructions: Your first task, as a group, is to divide them into groups or categories based on similar characteristics. Focus on whether the statements reflect shared beliefs and values or common perspectives. Your second task is to label each group of statements - give each group a name that helps to explain clearly how/why the statements in each group belong together. Students should group the perspectives into categories based on similar values and beliefs that are either explicitly/directly stated or which they can infer. Circulate among the small groups of students and, through observations and conversations, assess the students’ ability to find commonalities and their ability to identify political perspectives. Differentiated Instruction: Provide oral and written materials. Quick Tips for Teachers: Be sure to prepare the statement strips in advance of the lesson Once each group has completed its categorization of the statements, conduct a gallery walk to allow students to view the categories that other groups have created. Reconvene as a class and briefly debrief the activity. Ask students how they created the categories? What the common themes / elements / ideologies in each pile? Transition into an introduction of the concept of the “political spectrum” OHASSTA & OHHSSCA Sample Curriculum Supports 2013 Revised Canadian & World Studies Action! Connections Introducing new learning or extending/reinforcing prior learning Providing opportunities for practice and application of learning (guided > independent) Whole Class Instruction of Political Spectrum Assessment: Assessment as learning Description 1. Drawing upon the activity and using the students’ responses, explain the political spectrum and the key differences between “right-wing” and “leftwing” perspectives and positions. You may elect to provide a graphic organizer or other method to help students capture key points. Assess students’ grasp of the concepts as they complete the activities in an informal manner by listening to students as they think through the sorting/labeling activity Ensure that the following are included in the instruction: People and citizens may position themselves at different points on the political spectrum depending on their views, belief and values about specific issues. Some may find themselves more toward one side than the other or fall somewhere in the middle of the range/spectrum. The political right generally believes in the following: individual freedom over collective responsibility; smaller government with less involvement in people’s daily lifes; lower taxes. In this view voluntary charity takes the place of government assistance. The political left generally believes that society has a responsibility to protect its vulnerable or marginalized members. This puts collective rights and protections over individual rights. There is a belief in larger government and government which can do social good. Taxes have a role in sharing or redistributing wealth. Differentiated Instruction: Groups of 4 Group Discussion and Presentations Description 1. 2. 3. Divide the class into small groups of four students. Give each group a different issue. Invite students to discuss the issue and record a perspective that would reflect a right-wing position and a left-wing position on the political spectrum After about 5 minutes, have each group present their issue and left-right perspectives to the class. Probe, where/when necessary to check for and deepen understanding. Sample issues might include, but are not limited to: Capital punishment; CBC Ownership and Funding; Health Care; Immigration and Refugees; LCBO Ownership; Marijuana Legalization; Military Spending; Prison Reform; Public Housing; Public Transit; Welfare 4. To support kinesthetic learners, have groups find an appropriate place (and stand) along an imaginary “left-to-right” line in the classroom based on their party’s stand on issues. For presentations students can write their answers on paper, interactive whiteboard, or other medium in order to convey their conclusions to the class as an alternative to only an oral presentation. Quick Tips for Teachers: Next, give each group a copy of some policy platforms from one of the major political parties. Include the party’s name. Give each group 3 to 5 minutes to determine where the party might be positioned on the political spectrum based on the party’s stands on the issues. Ask students to justify their reasoning with reference to the political platform and the political spectrum. Party platforms can be retrieved from the various political party websites (see the Materials section for links). OHASSTA & OHHSSCA Sample Curriculum Supports 2013 Revised Canadian & World Studies Use visual cues to explain the concept of a spectrum. For example, consider using a spectrum with black on one end with white on the other and shades of grey in the middle. If students have sufficient background knowledge / prior learning about the names and policy platforms of the parties in Ontario/Canada, omit names from the second activity and have each group identify the name of its party. Consolidation Connections Providing opportunities for consolidation and reflection Helping students demonstrate what they have learned Individuals Self-Assessment and Reflection Assessment: Provide descriptive feedback on the answers to the question. Description 1. 2. 3. During the debriefing, highlight the fact that many variables contribute to where a person might position themselves on the political spectrum and that an individual’s position may vary over time. Distribute to each student – or provide access online to – a political spectrum self-assessment. Invite each student to individually complete the self-assessment. The self-assessment will allow each student to explore their personal political perspective. Once they have completed the self-assessment, instruct students to address the following question in paragraph form. Given the results of your self-assessment, which Canadian political party might you be most likely to support and why? Refer both to the political spectrum and to the party platforms we examined to justify your answer. Differentiated Instruction: The self-assessment can be done online or in print. The question can be answered orally at school. The question can be answered via a poster or similar visual element. Invite students to complete the paragraph as a blog Quick Tips for Teachers: OHASSTA & OHHSSCA Sample Curriculum Supports 2013 Revised Canadian & World Studies Question can assessed and/or evaluated