Demand Forecast Work Plan Water Suppliers’ Forum Steering Committee Proposal Working Draft Version 3.4 Objective: The Water Suppliers’ Forum (Forum) will develop an updated municipal water supply demand forecast for King, Pierce, and Snohomish County. This work will result in an updated Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast for each of the three counties and is expected to meet the objectives of the King County Planning process. The Forum is committed to provide a creditable and transparent demand forecast and meaningful participation to interested stakeholders (See Stakeholder Input and Process Transparency below). The goal is to develop the best available information on future municipal water demands to assist in making more informed decisions on future water supplies. Approach: The municipal water supply Demand forecast will be based on Growth Management Act compliant data provided by the Puget Sound Regional Council (PSRC). The data includes both historic demographic data (single and multifamily households, employment, and population) at the Transportation Analysis Zone (TAZ) level as well as projected future forecasts to be used for planning by all local governments. The PSRC forecasts account for land uses as established by local land use authorities and has been “approved” by a local and state government review process. Water use factors will be based on historic water consumption of each water utility which reflects the effects of land-use, historic conservation and community values. The effects of future water efficiency and conservation programs will be discussed, and may either be embedded in water use factors, or included in conservation scenarios that may be part of the demand forecasts. To the extent that the Forum surveys water utilities for use data, the Forum will request data from utilities on any significant known non-potable water users or self-supplied uses in their service area and will include reported information in any summary report prepared. It should be noted that water utilities generally do not have information on that portion of water that they provide that is used for non-potable water uses, consequently any data reported should not be considered complete or accurate. Additional information on self-supplied users and uses will be requested from Ecology. 1 Stakeholder Input and Process Transparency: It is the intent of the Forum to provide any interested stakeholders the opportunity to participate in the development of the Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast. To achieve process transparency and opportunity for meaningful participation and input, the Water Suppliers’ Forum will establish a municipal water supply Demand Forecasting Review and Oversight Committee (Committee). The Committee will provide both technical review and oversight functions. The Committee will be made up of interested persons: selfselected, stakeholder selected, or selected by or through other planning processes, such as planning process underway in King County. The Committee will be formed before the scope of work for the demand forecast is finalized or any technical consultant is selected. The Forum is looking to the Committee to provide advice on process issues, as well as on technical and policy issues that arise throughout the development of the Municipal Water Demand Forecast. It is the intent that the Committee will seek to reach substantial agreement on elements that are important to the development of the Municipal Water Demand Forecast. Such elements may include conservation and efficiency assumptions, population expectations, including alternatives to the PSRC forecasts. It is anticipated that in some cases a variety of scenarios may be developed to provide a range of forecast. The Committee will have the opportunity to review and suggest alternatives to scenarios that are to be used. All data used and materials produced will be available to members of the Committee. Formation of the Committee will be an initial step in the work to assure input on the criteria for the work, the consultant selection process and initial direction of the work. It is anticipated that the Committee will establish a regular meeting schedule to monitor work progress and work product development and provide advice on the project to the Forum. In addition, the Committee may choose to have additional meetings and/or other means to allow an appropriate level of review and comment on the development of the Demand Forecast. The Water Suppliers’ Forum will support and facilitate the coordination and work of the Committee. The Forum may retain specialized facilitation services as necessary to complete this work. Background: A computational model similar to that used to develop the municipal water supply demand forecast in the Outlook will be used. Seattle Public Utilities has built upon the approach used to develop the original demand forecasts in the Outlook and developed a model that is available for the Forum’s project. The model uses population and household data from the Puget Sound Regional Council. The 2 data includes a detailed distribution to Transportation Analysis Zones (TAZ). Seattle’s model then assigns the TAZ data to water utility service areas using a graphic approach (with some enhanced sub-routines). Water use factors can be developed from historic data. Seattle has included a number of enhancements that may or may not be of interest in a regional forecast. As a result the demand forecast may include “adjustments” that would allow the model to develop a “suite” of demand projections. Moving Forward: A new set of regional forecasts are to be available by March 2006 from the Puget Sound Regional Council. That date would constitute an early start time for the beginning actual work on the update. If the Water Suppliers Forum agrees to undertake this effort then the process would begin with identification and convening of the Demand Forecasting Review and Oversight Committee (Committee). It is estimated that it would take a minimum of 9 months (and likely longer) to prepare the Demand Forecast with coordination and review with local utilities and with meaningful participation of Committee. Demand Forecast Features: The municipal water supply demand forecast will include the following features: Forecast periods – 6 and 20 years (or as close as possible from available data) and a long-range forecast estimate of 50 years. Forecast periods of 6 and 20 years are selected to match Department of Health Water System Planning Requirements. A discussion of seasonal variations in water use and estimates of appropriate seasonal water use factors for a regional demand forecast. A clear narrative that describes the three county municipal water supply demand forecast (Regional Demand Forecast) including its development and uses and the differences between regional forecasts and utility specific water demand forecasts that are done as part of the water system planning process. The narrative should also provide an overview of changes in regional use that occurred in the past 30 years to provide a basic understanding of the dynamic nature of water use by municipal water customers. 3 A discussion of the effects of weather and climate change on municipal water demand will be included. Historically water suppliers have experienced significant changes in year to year water use based on current weather patterns (damp spring, cool summer, hot summer, etc.). The work will include identification of any important metrics associated with weather and the associated effects on demand. A discussion of the effects of regional economic conditions and household income on municipal water demand will be included. The objective would be to develop an estimate of how water demand may change from these factors. The result could be a “range of effects” that could be used to modify base demand projections. The Municipal Demand Forecast is being prepared to assess the future water needs for municipal water suppliers and other domestic water users. It will not include agricultural water use, industrial water use or irrigation water uses not provided by municipal water suppliers. (The demand forecast will estimate future water needs of households not currently served by water suppliers, both inside and outside water service areas, but will not include extraordinary irrigation uses beyond those normally provided by public water systems.) Water utilities do not maintain information on self supplied water users inside or outside their water service areas. Consequently any identification of self supplied users is beyond the scope of a Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast, and will be separately identified. The Demand Forecast should include the following: Conservation and Effects of Future Water Efficiency and Conservation The work will include a reevaluation of how to best include the historic affects of water conservation programs and recommendations of how to include projected future water conservation effects on the municipal water demand forecast. The intent is to have the Committee play an important role in deciding how conservation and future conservation be handled in the demand forecast. Initially it seems it might be done through a series of conservation levels that result in different demand scenarios, but there are likely other useful approaches. Water Suppliers’ Forum Role: The Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast is a Water Suppliers’ Forum work effort that will be funded and managed by the Water Suppliers’ Forum. Consequently the Water Suppliers’ Forum will establish the schedule and will have final authority on approval on the scope of work, the work product and other issues to assure that the project is conducted consistently with the availability of 4 necessary data, Water Suppliers’ Forum ability to manage the work, legal constraints such as consultant selection requirements, and consultant schedules, accepted professional practice and Water Suppliers’ Forum cash flow. The Water Suppliers’ Forum will provide quarterly reports, as requested, on the progress of the Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast to interested groups, including those in the King County Planning Process. Supply Analysis: The Municipal Water Supply Demand Forecast will end with identification of a suite of future demand scenarios and will not include identification and evaluation of municipal water supply alternatives which will be a separate work element. Initial Thoughts on Demand Forecast Budget: The budget necessary to do the work will be finalized after defining the Scope of Work and selecting the Project Consultant. The Water Suppliers’ Forum Steering Committee has prepared the following as a discussion budget to assist the Forum in defining the work and the level of detail. Work done by Seattle Public Utilities developing the model, and preparing demand forecasts for the Seattle Water Supply System was used to prepare this initial discussion budget. Bruce Flory indicated that the development time to prepare the model and do the initial forecasts for Seattle required about 4 months of Bruce’s time and about one month of GIS time. The advantage that Seattle had in this process is that they did not have to depend on others (except PSRC) and it was a priority so they had access to decision makers when needed. The Forum would not have that luxury and would need to coordinate with utilities within the region and the Committee, consequently it will take longer. In considering what this effort might cost I have developed the following: Demand Forecasting Review and Oversight Committee facilitation: Labor allowance $45,000; expenses allowance $5000. Total $ 50,000 Demand Forecasting, Preparation of Alternative Scenarios, and Production of a Demand Forecasting Report: Labor allowance $175,000; expense allowance $25,000. Total $200,000 Forum Project Management: Labor allowance $35,000; expense allowance $2000. Total $37,000 Total $287,000 5