DESIGN JOURNAL Building Styles Note: this brief was previously written as a primer for Main Street cities, but can be applicable to any town. In order to communicate the role good design plays in Main Street cities, we must become well versed in the language of Main Street buildings and with their architectural styles. By studying styles, we develop not only a deeper physical understanding of the old buildings in our downtowns, but we also gain insight into the culture that created these buildings. Identification of building styles is not an exact science. According to the National Trust for Historic Preservation, “Improvements in communication, innovations in building, and increased affluence among Americans [during the late 19th and early 20th centuries] produced successive waves of architectural fashion. So rapidly did one follow another that the effect in many cities was the creation of interesting hybrid designs showing elements of several architectural styles. The result of this erratic evolution of architectural tastes has been to produce a rich variety of building designs. Because of this variety, it is difficult to assign dates to major periods based on styles.” Some of the most popular styles of commercial and civic architecture in Texas are explained on the next few pages. The primary features of each style are briefly discussed and should enable interested persons to pursue style research in their own towns. The Alamo, San Antonio In general terms, this type of building is considered Spanish Colonial (1700-1780). The Handbook of Texas describes this as the “frontier manifestation of the exuberant baroque style of the Spanish Counter-Reformation. This style, which dominated North American mission architecture for 200 years, was characterized by twin bell towers, curved gables, sumptuous ornament applied to plain walls, dramatic interior lighting, and elaborately carved and painted ornamental screens.” It is surprising how many Main Street towns have their own versions of the Alamo, which is itself a reconstruction of the original. 1 The Governor’s Mansion, Austin Methodist Episcopal Church Marshall Custom House, Galveston The three buildings above are representative of the Greek Revival Style (1820-1860). This style is also often referred to as Southern Colonial It is actually neither southern or colonial, since it first appeared in the East in the early 19th century. According to the Handbook, this style is defined by formal balance, geometric order and decorative details. The Greek Revival style is formal, with the building arranged symmetrically about a central axis. Its features come from the classic temple form of ancient Greece: the temple portico or porch with a roof supported by a row of columns. These columns were of three types or orders: Doric, Ionic, and Corinthian. Cotton Exchange, Houston The building above is representative of the Victorian Style (1830-1900). According to the Handbook: “In contrast to the restrained classicism of the Greek Revival Style, the Victorian style was rich in detail, exceedingly ornate, and designed to achieve a romantic and picturesque effect. The buildings were seldom symmetrical, but were characterized by the off-center tower and projecting bay. The whole was intended to be a balanced composition.” Included in the broad category of Victorian architecture is the High Victorian Gothic style and the High Victorian Italianate style. The High Victorian Gothic style was distinguished by the pointed arch. The High Victorian Italianate style was distinguished by the rounded arch. The Renaissance Revival style is yet another variation on the Victorian theme and is characterized by the two buildings below (the State Capitol and Ellis County Courthouse). Some of Texas’ Main Street towns are fortunate enough to possess an example from one of the two master proponents of this style in the state: Nicholas J. Clayton and James Riely Gordon. 2 State Capitol, Austin Ellis County Courthouse, Waxahachie Hill County Courthouse, Hillsboro The building above (Hillsboro) is representative of the Second Empire Style (1860-1885). This style was frequently used in government buildings and mansions. The steeply pitched Mansard roof with dormers and vertical emphasis are key characteristics of this style. In larger buildings, projecting pavilions and towers are common. Union Depot, Fort Worth The Union Depot may not be the best example to choose for a Richardsonian Romanesque (1880-1900) style building in Texas, but it will suffice. Common characteristics of this cousin to the Victorian family of styles include a horizontal emphasis, walls with heavy masonry features, stones of contrasting color and texture, round-arched windows and doors, and deeply set 3 windows and doors to emphasize wall thickness. This style was very popular in civic structures throughout the country. The vivid colors and classical detailing exhibited by this particular example indicate a more eclectic style. Harris County Courthouse, Houston Most major buildings from the turn of the 20th century were either Beaux-Arts Classical (18901920) or Neo-Classical Revival (1890-1920) styles. The characteristics of this style are very similar to Greek Revival, but the façades are far more elaborate and studied. Columns are often grouped in pairs, there are often monumental flights of steps, and figure sculpture is often placed in niches on the façade or along the parapet wall. This style was often used for courthouses, libraries, railroad stations, museums, and theaters. Depot, Quanah University of Texas, El Paso The early part of the 20th century witnessed a notable reaction to the industrial revolution by way of a romantic longing for the past. In addition to the popular Colonial Revival, many other regional styles took root in Texas: The Quanah Depot represents the Mission Style and the 4 University of Texas El Paso campus represents the uncommon Bhutanese Style. The name of the regional style usually provides all the description needed to explain its visual characteristics. Gulf Building, Houston Industrialization and modernization spawned the Art Deco or Moderne style. The effects of this style were far ranging from jewelry to automobiles to radios to skyscrapers. Art Deco motifs often consisted of “low relief geometrical designs, often in the form of parallel straight lines, zigzags, chevrons, and stylized floral motifs,” according to the Handbook. Concrete, smooth faced stone, and metal were used with accents of terra cotta, glass and colored mirrors. Some early gas stations used this style. Texas Fair Park in Dallas has one of the largest complexes of Art Deco architecture in the country. Conoco Station, Shamrock Fa ir Park, Dallas 5 Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth The mid 20th century is marked by the work of several leading architects from outside the state who executed important works in Texas. These works fall under the broad category of the Modern style. Much of the best work of the Modern movement is a direct offshoot of the International style, which is based on modern structural principles, materials and detailing. The style is often characterized by a strong horizontal emphasis with smooth walls devoid of ornament, flat roofs, windows running in continuous horizontal bands, and buildings regarded as objects in a landscape devoid of any established context. The example shown above, the Kimbell Art Museum, is considered one of the masterpieces of modern architecture. Bibliography: Handbook of Texas (Texas State Historical Association), What Style is it? (National Trust), American Architecture Since 1780 (Marcus Whiffen), Guiding Design on Main Street (National Trust) Please send comments or questions directly back to howard.langner@thc.state.tx.us For information on the Texas Main Street Program, contact: Debra Farst, State Coordinator debra.farst@thc.state.tx.us 512-463-5758 design journal.building.styles.6.2006 6