Authorisation to conduct litigation – guidance for applicants Do I need to be authorised to conduct litigation? 1. The new BSB Handbook allows both self-employed and employed barristers to be authorised to conduct litigation. Employed barristers who are already authorised to conduct litigation will retain their authorisation, provided that they remain in employed practice. Other barristers will be able to apply for authorisation from 22 January 2014. 2. Authorisation to conduct litigation is an additional authorisation which can be added to your rights to practise and to your practising certificate. It is optional and you will need to decide whether you need it for your practice or employment. What is the conduct of litigation? 3. The conduct of litigation is a ‘reserved legal activity’ in the terms of the Legal Services Act 2007. This means that it can only be undertaken legally by a person who is authorised to undertake that activity. The Bar Standards Board (as a relevant “approved regulator”) is entitled to authorise barristers to conduct litigation. 4. It is important to distinguish the conduct of litigation from the exercise of rights of audience, and other reserved legal activities. A barrister’s entitlement to exercise rights of audience does not entitle him or her to conduct litigation. 5. The Bar Standards Board does not itself define what is meant by conducting litigation as this is a matter of law. However, the following is intended to provide some guidance on interpretation and to illustrate the types of litigation activities. 6. The conduct of litigation has a statutory definition in Schedule 2 of the Legal Services Act: 4 (1) The ‘conduct of litigation’ means – (a) the issuing of proceedings before any court in England and Wales, (b) the commencement, prosecution and defence of such proceedings, and (c) the performance of any ancillary functions in relation to such proceedings (such as entering appearances to actions) 7. The last subheading ‘ancillary functions’ has been defined further, in relation to civil litigation, by Agassi v Robinson [2005] EWCA Civ 1507. The definition of ancillary functions is construed narrowly and is limited to the formal steps required in the conduct of litigation. 8. The remaining restrictions on activities associated with the conduct of litigation for barristers who are not authorised to conduct litigation include: • • • • • Issuing any claim or process or application notice; Signing off on a list of disclosure; Instructing expert witnesses on behalf of a lay client; Accepting liability for the payment of expert witnesses; and Any other ‘formal steps’ in the litigation of a sort that are currently required to be taken either by the client personally or by the solicitor on the record If you want to be able to carry out any of these activities for your clients, then you need to seek a litigation extension to your practising certificate. Amended 21 January 2014 1 9. O'Connor v Bar Standards Board [2012] All ER (D) 108 (Aug) (which addressed the scope of the meaning of the conduct of litigation, citing Agassi) established that signing a declaration of truth did not amount to conducting litigation, and has further underlined that litigation is narrowly defined. Criminal litigation 10. If you are authorised to conduct litigation, this authorisation extends to both civil and criminal litigation. You will, however, need to ensure that you meet the Core Duty to act within your competence in undertaking any litigation activity (see below). 11. The conduct of criminal litigation is more limited in scope than the conduct of civil litigation because of the role of the prosecuting authorities. For example, prosecution disclosure is undertaken by the police and is overseen by the CPS (who are already authorised to conduct litigation by virtue of provisions in the Prosecution of Offences Act 1985) and there are limited duties to disclose for the defence beyond drafting defence statements (a task which is already undertaken by barristers). 12. Other formal steps involved in criminal litigation may also be more limited because the prosecution process is shorter than the equivalent civil procedure and is largely the responsibility of the prosecution. Nevertheless there may be some processes for which you would need authorisation. 13. Barristers may already undertake many of the drafting tasks, such as completing Criminal Procedure Rules forms (for example the Plea and Case Management Form at the Crown Court, notices and grounds of appeal to the appellate courts). Such drafting does not constitute the conduct of litigation. Am I eligible to obtain authorisation to conduct litigation? 14. In order to be eligible to apply for authorisation to conduct litigation, you will need to hold a current practising certificate. This can be a self-employed, employed or dual capacity practising certificate. 15. There is an additional requirement which applies if you are a less experienced barrister. If you are: a self-employed barrister under 3 years’ standing; or an employed barrister under 3 years’ standing who supplies legal services to the public via an authorised body; or an employed barrister under 1 year’s standing who supplies legal services only to your employer; you will need to confirm that you have a ‘qualified person’ in your place of practice, who is readily available to provide guidance to you when conducting litigation. 16. A qualified person who can supervise you in the conduct of litigation is: an individual who has been entitled to practise and has practised as a barrister (other than as a pupil who has not completed pupillage in accordance with the Bar Training Regulations), or as a person authorised by another approved regulator (such as a solicitor) (which need not have been as a person authorised by the same approved regulator); o for at least six years in the previous eight years; Amended 21 January 2014 2 o o o o for the previous two years has made such practice his main occupation; is entitled to conduct litigation before every court in relation to all proceedings; is not acting as a qualified person in relation to more than two other people; and has not been designated by the BSB as unsuitable to be a qualified person. 17. Alternatively, if you are barrister exercising a right to conduct litigation in a Member State other than the United Kingdom pursuant to the Establishment Directive or in Scotland or Northern Ireland pursuant to the European Communities (Lawyer’s Practice) Regulations 2000, a qualified person has been designated by the BSB as having qualifications and experience in that state or country which are equivalent to the qualifications and experience (see Rule rS22.3 for further details). 18. You must ensure you have appropriate insurance in place (see below). How do I apply? 19. In order to apply for an extension to your practising certificate authorising you to conduct litigation, you will need to complete an application form. The form consists of a self-assessment questionnaire, which you should download from the following link: https://www.barristerconnect.org.uk/login/ 20. You will also need to pay the application fee, covering the administrative costs of the application to the BSB. 21. The information you provide in the form will be assessed by authorisation staff at the BSB, who will also have access to further records about you and your practice. In reviewing your application, authorisation staff will assess whether you meet the criteria for authorisation. 22. The authorisation criteria are: That you have appropriate systems in your place of practice to enable you to conduct litigation (Rule S47.3) That you have the requisite skills and knowledge of litigation procedure to enable you to provide a competent service to clients (Rule S47.4) That you have adequate insurance (Rule C76) 23. In order to satisfy itself that you meet these mandatory criteria, the BSB will need to consider a number of factors. These include: The training in and experience of litigation you have previously undertaken The policies and procedures that you have in your place of practice Insurance Knowledge and training in litigation 24. It is your responsibility to ensure that you have the appropriate level of knowledge and training in litigation. You should demonstrate on your application form that you have such knowledge and that it is up-to-date. If you intend only to provide either civil Amended 21 January 2014 3 or criminal litigation, you need to supply evidence only in relation to the relevant kind of litigation. 25. The outcome we wish to achieve is that: Barristers authorised to do litigation have adequate knowledge of civil and/or criminal litigation procedures to enable them to conduct litigation competently. You can demonstrate that you are in a position to meet this outcome by confirming or providing relevant information about the following. For your knowledge to be adequate, it must be up-to-date. When any relevant training was undertaken some time ago, you will need to show how you meet the requirement for your knowledge to be up-to-date. This might be through more recent raining or practical experience. Completion of the BPTC or equivalent 26. You should confirm whether you completed the BPTC or an equivalent qualification within the last three years. The BPTC includes component modules on civil and criminal litigation procedure which we ordinarily judge to be sufficient training, in conjunction with pupillage, in knowledge of litigation procedure. Additional training 27. Where you completed the BPTC or equivalent qualification over three years ago, it is important to demonstrate that you have taken any necessary further training to ensure that your knowledge is up-to-date. 28. You should provide details of any additional training in litigation that you have completed within the last three years. 29. We would ordinarily expect you to have undertaken the public access training course, or to have renewed your public access training. Further details are available on the public access section of the BSB website. 30. The BSB does not accredit litigation courses and it is up to you to demonstrate that the training you have undertaken is appropriate. 31. There are courses on litigation available from postgraduate law colleges and universities, such as City University, the University of Law (College of Law) and Kaplan Law School. We may publish further information about these in the litigation section of the BSB website otherwise you should contact training providers directly for further details. 32. You should also detail here whether you have undertaken any other form of relevant learning within the last three years and provide an explanation of any activities you might have undertaken. For example, this might include additional CPD, self-directed learning, or other relevant work experience. Prior experience of litigation 33. You should provide details of any prior experience of litigation. Prior experience of conducting litigation Amended 21 January 2014 4 34. If you have previously been authorised to conduct litigation, and have conducted litigation within the last three years, by virtue of authorisation by another approved regulator, for example as a practising solicitor, or by virtue of a statutory right to do so, you should set out the details of this. You should include the dates and time period of your authorisation and confirmation that your practice has included litigation within the last three years. Other experience of litigation 35. You may have other prior experience of litigation, through your involvement in preparing cases for courts or tribunals or helping to manage trials, even if you have not previously conducted litigation. For example, you may have provided advice on aspects of litigation procedure, such as providing advice on the use of evidence or instructing expert witnesses. You may also have undertaken the drafting of documents concerned with litigation, such as particulars of claim, or provided advice on the drafting of such documents. 36. You should describe your prior experience of litigation in this context. It is your responsibility to assess whether this experience has provided you with sufficient knowledge and skills to enable you to conduct litigation. Some of the areas of litigation procedure which you may wish to consider include: a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j. k. Pre-action Issue and acknowledgement of proceedings Statements of case Interim remedies Judgment without trial Track allocation and case management Disclosure Part 36 offers to settle Preparations for trial and evidence Costs Enforcement of judgments 37. We do not expect you to list all aspects of litigation procedure where you have experience, but you should provide an overview of the sort of work you have undertaken and should be able to clearly demonstrate how this experience is relevant to the litigation work you expect to take on once you are authorised. Ordinarily, we would expect this to have been a significant component of your practice. You should detail the number of years of practice in which you gained this experience. 38. You should be prepared to provide specific examples if asked to do so. Administration and management of litigation 39. You must ensure that there are appropriate administrative and management procedures in your place of practice and all persons involved in the conduct of litigation are familiar with them. 40. If your place of practice already has an individual barrister who is authorised to conduct litigation and you will be adopting the same procedures, you should state this clearly and you do not need to complete this section of the application. You should, however, confirm that you are familiar with the relevant procedures. Amended 21 January 2014 5 41. You are expected to take responsibility for ensuring that appropriate procedures are in place in your practice. It is important that you can satisfy yourself that you are personally familiar with these procedures and know how they operate. You should also ensure that anyone else who has a role in the litigation for which you are responsible has been trained in such procedures. 42. A series of outcomes relating to administration and management of your practice are listed in the checklist section of the questionnaire. Under each outcome there is a list of procedures and policies which we believe should normally form the minimum arrangements your practice should have in place. 43. You should tick off each item, confirming that your practice has relevant policies and procedures in place. Alternatively, you should add an explanation of how you believe each issue is otherwise addressed. 44. Where possible, you should add a document reference, which could be the name or number of the policy or procedure. We may ask you to provide further evidence, such as a copy of a policy and this will assist that process. 45. The outcomes we expect you to achieve are: a. b. c. d. e. f. Clients understand the service they will receive and how fees will be charged Clients receive a timely and consistent service Clients receive a service when they need it All litigation cases are managed effectively All matters relating to litigation cases are recorded fully and accurately Support staff are adequately trained and supervised The Core Duties All the Core Duties and relevant conduct rules will apply to the conduct of litigation as to the conduct of the rest of your practice. Core duties which are particularly relevant are: You must provide a competent standard of work and service to each client [CD7]: 46. Once you become authorised to conduct litigation, you will remain subject to Core Duty 7 in the Code of Conduct to provide a competent standard of work and service to each client. This obligation applies to conducting litigation as it does to any other type of legal service you provide. You must ensure that you do not take on instructions, or seek to undertake tasks, if you are not competent to do so. 47. As with all public access work, you must also consider whether it would be in the client’s interests to instruct a solicitor or other authorised person, for example because the litigation in question would benefit from more experience or resources than you have. You must take reasonable steps to manage your practice, or carry out your role within your practice, competently and in such a way as to achieve compliance with your legal and regulatory obligations [CD10]: 48. You must also comply with Core Duty 10 and take reasonable steps to manage any aspects of your practice concerned with the conduct of litigation. You must also carry out your role as an individual who is authorised to conduct litigation within your Amended 21 January 2014 6 practice competently and in such a way as to achieve compliance with any relevant legal and regulatory objectives. 49. For the purposes of this application, you will need to satisfy the BSB that you have made a thorough assessment of your skills and competencies relating to your ability to conduct litigation on behalf of each client, and to do so to a competent standard. Intended areas of practice 50. If you are granted a litigation extension to your practising certificate you will be authorised to conduct litigation in all areas of practice. For the purposes of future supervision and monitoring by the BSB, you should indicate on your application form the areas of practice in which you intend to conduct litigation. This will help allow us to assess the risks of barristers conducting litigation across different practice areas. Review of applications and sampling 51. The BSB will review all applications and may seek further information or ask to talk to you on the phone in order to discuss any aspects of your application, for example the nature of your prior experience of litigation. The BSB will also undertake random sampling of a proportion of applications for more in-depth investigation. If selected for this sample, this is likely to mean that BSB authorisation staff will contact you for further information relating to your application, such as documentary evidence of any courses you have stated that you have undertaken, or copies of policies and procedures in your place of practice. This will allow us to evaluate your application more fully. Supervision 52. The BSB’s Supervision strategy includes a focus on the conduct of litigation, because this is a new area of practice for many barristers and we wish to ensure that we identify and mitigate any risks appropriately. 53. Once you are authorised to conduct litigation, you may be subject to further supervision and the information you provide at authorisation stage may be reviewed. Further details of the BSB’s supervision arrangements are available on our website. Amended 21 January 2014 7