SELF REVIEW
CIS 4327 – Senior Project 1 (Information Systems
Capstone Sequence)
Directions: Please ensure that the format you use allows all your inputs to be
aligned to those tags you are addressing.
TEAM # _________
Name: (optional) ______________________
DATE: ______________
Deliverable #: ________________
0. Your major is:
1. computer science
2. information systems
3. information technology
4. information sciences
5. other
1. How do you feel about your contribution to the project?
2. If you feel that your contribution has been unsatisfactory, how do you plan to
remedy this situation?
3. If you feel that your contribution has been too dominant or consuming, how do
you plan to remedy this situation? Remember either of these two qualities is
equally undesirable.
4. How has the time you projected compared to the time expended on the project
thus far?
5. What have you learned about working on a project with a team where all are
mutually responsible for the outcomes?
6. Do you like working in a team? Why/why not?
7. Do you feel all the members of the team should receive the same final grade
for the project? Why/Why not?
Please elaborate. These comments are held in STRICT confidence!
Peer Review
CIS 4327 and CIS 4328 – Senior Project 1 and 2 (Information
Systems Capstone Sequence)
TEAM # _______________________
_________________________
DATE:
If you had to judge the contributions of others on the team (using the scale of 1-5,
where 5 is excellent and 1 is very poor) insofar as their overall contributions to
the project are concerned, please answer the questions below: Recognize that in
a team effort, all do not normally contribute equally. But, all must contribute in a
meaningful, dependable manner, make team meetings, and support the team
goals and schedule.
List team all team member names alphabetically; associate a letter with each of
them.
A. ______________
B. ________________ C. ________________
______________
E. ________________
Team Member
A
B
C
D
(In general, 5 = excellent; 1 = very poor)
D.
E
1. Attends group meetings regularly
(to date). Is accessible.
____
____
____
____
____
2. Contributes to Tasks at hand
(does his/her agreed-to part)
(CAN YOU COUNT ON HIM/HER?)
____
____
____
____
____
3. Contributes meaningfully;
____
does his/her part; reliable. (3 to 5)
Dominates (1) or says nothing or nearly nothing (1)
(You may elaborate)
____
____
____
____
4. Would you (so far) like to work with
this team member again on a
future project? (5 = Yes!
____
____
____
____
____
3 = doesn’t matter; 1 = No Way!)
(By indicating a 2 or 1 you are saying that
you would prefer to not or definitely not
work with this individual again, given
another project.)
5. Overall, how would you judge his/her
____
____
level of collaboration?
5 – Yes! Outstanding. 4 – Excellent/Very good
3 - Fair
2 – Not really. Had to prod. Unreliable
1 – Did not contribute (terrible)
6. How do you rank the project leader?
(5 excellent; 3 acceptable;
1 terrible.)
____
____
____
____
____
____
_____
____
You may elaborate:
6. Does the team leader represent you well? ____
Please elaborate if you wish. It will help me.
COMMENTS:
____
____
____
____