Water Safety Plan Guide Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation Version 1, Ref P11 January 2014 Citation: Ministry of Health. 2014. Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation, Version 1, ref p11. Wellington: Ministry of Health. Published in January 2014 by the Ministry of Health PO Box 5013, Wellington, New Zealand ISBN: 978-0-478-42760-8 (print) ISBN: 978-0-478-42761-5 (online) Previously published in 2001 as Public Health Risk Management Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation, Version 1, ref p11. This publication’s title and any reference within the text to ‘public health risk management plan’ were changed in January 2014 to reflect the December 2013 legislation change of the term ‘public health risk management plan’ to ‘water safety plan’. No other changes have been made to this document. This document is available at: www.health.govt.nz This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence. In essence, you are free to: share ie, copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format; adapt ie, remix, transform and build upon the material. You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the licence and indicate if changes were made. Contents Introduction 1 Risk Summary 2 Risk Information Table 3 Contingency Plans 9 Water Safety Plan Performance Assessment Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 11 iii Introduction This Guide is concerned with the design, construction and operation of the treatment plant. Few raw waters can be safely used without treatment. To keep the risks to public health as low as possible the treatment plant must continuously provide effective, multiple barriers to contaminants. If an event occurs in the treatment plant (ie, it doesn’t work properly), the following could happen: If the plant is unable to produce water of good enough quality, sickness can come from germs or chemicals that have not been removed from the water. If the plant is unable to produce enough water, sickness may be caused by poor hygiene and by low pressure allowing germs and chemicals to enter the distribution system. Treatment plant operation can present risks to the health of treatment plant staff. These are acknowledged, but are not discussed further as such risks are the subject of health and safety in employment legislation. Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 1 Risk Summary The two events creating the greatest risks in the design and operation of a treatment plant are being unable to produce enough water (see P11.2) and being unable to produce water of good enough quality (see P11.1). The most important preventive measures are: design the treatment plant so that the failure of any one part of it cannot stop the plant from being able to produce enough water of acceptable quality (see P11.1.1, P11.2.1) make sure the plant is properly maintained (see P11.1.3, P11.2.3) make sure the plant is designed to be able to treat the expected range of raw-water qualities (see P11.1.1) develop and use quality assurance systems that will reduce the chances of something going wrong with the operation of the plant (see P11.1.4). (References in parentheses are to the Risk Information Table.) 2 Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014 Risk Information Table Reliable information about water quality is essential for the proper management of a water supply. Knowledgeable and skilled staff are also essential for minimising the public health risks associated with water supplies. Please read the staff training (Guide G1) and the monitoring guides (Guide G2). While we haven’t pointed out every detail of how these documents are linked with the present document, the links are many and are important. Abbreviations: MAV – Maximum acceptable value – see Drinking-Water Standards for New Zealand:2000 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Corrective action Signs that action is needed What to check Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE WATER OF SATISFACTORY QUALITY Possible hazards: Germs; health-significant chemical determinands. Level of risk: High1 P11.1.1 Make sure, at the design stage, that sufficient information is gathered about the water quality and its variability to allow appropriate treatment processes to be identified. Make sure that, at the design stage, the proposed treatment processes are capable of producing water of the required quality. Periodically review the performance of the existing plant to assess whether processes need to be modified or added. The plant should be designed so that the failure of no one part can result in a whole treatment process not operating. Where possible, the plant should be designed with sufficient redundancy and flexibility to allow incorrectly functioning units to be bypassed. Undertake periodic inspections of the structural integrity of the plant so that steps can be taken to carry out repairs before failure occurs. Poor plant design. P11.1.2 Structural failure of part of the plant. 1 All microbiological and chemical determinands appropriate to compliance with the DWSNZ: 2000. Visual inspection of plant. Microbiological or chemical determinands monitored fail to meet the requirements of DWSNZ:2000. Signs of the beginning of structural failure. Undertake treatment plant modifications, or consider using another source water. Bypass nonoperational units, if this can be done without the production of water of unsatisfactory quality. Repair or replace failing units, or reconsider the whole plant design. The consequences of the event, and therefore the level of risk, will be influenced by the type and concentration of hazards present in the water, and length of time they have been present. Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 3 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Corrective action Signs that action is needed What to check Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE WATER OF SATISFACTORY QUALITY cont’d P11.1.3 Inadequate maintenance resulting in mechanical failure. P11.1.4 Where practicable, backup equipment and spares should be kept on site to allow failed equipment to be rapidly replaced or repaired. Make sure there is an operator’s manual for the treatment plant, so that new staff have something to reference, and so that knowledge regarding the plant’s operation is not lost in the event of an operator leaving. Have in place a supply water safety plan (formerly known as a Public Health Risk Management Plan, PHRMP) (such as outlined in this series), and supporting systems (eg, documentation, reporting). Regularly review quality assurance systems, and make modifications where it is evident that deficiencies exist. Develop a process monitoring plan that identifies: Inadequate quality assurance systems. P11.1.6 Make sure all aspects of the plant and its operation that require maintenance have a maintenance schedule developed and followed. Inadequate monitoring. – – – – – 4 the reason for the monitoring where samples are to be taken Audit maintenance records. (Use this information to identify which determinands may need to be monitored.) All microbiological and chemical determinands appropriate for the purposes of the monitoring programme. No spare parts available. No manual available for new staff. Instigate maintenance programmes. Obtain spare parts. Prepare an operator’s manual for the treatment plant. Review quality assurance system and modify where deficient. Water leaving the plant fails to comply with the DWSNZ 2000 MAVs. Instigate a monitoring plan. Train staff in correct monitoring practices. what is being sampled the frequency of sampling and method of sampling. Make sure that all appropriate staff are aware of, understand, and follow the plan. Refer also to Guide U4. Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Corrective action Signs that action is needed What to check Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE WATER OF SATISFACTORY QUALITY cont’d P11.1.7 Inadequate security measures to prevent vandalism/ sabotage. P11.1.8 Make sure all hatches are lockable and are locked when continuous access is not required. Make sure all ladders are locked away. Install an intruder alarm or arrange for security patrols. Develop criteria for raw water quality that define when the water quality has degraded to the point at which the intake must be closed and the plant shut down. Event affecting the source with the result that the plant cannot treat the raw water. P11.1.9 Unhygienic practices (including no separation between water and waste water operations). Provide a lockable perimeter fence for the treatment plant to surround all components of the plant. If the plant is a single building, make sure it is lockable and that windows are protected against forced entry. Regular inspection by security patrols. Evidence of unauthorised entry. Review and instigate recommended, or additional, security precautions. Determinands dictated by evidence of possible intentional contamination (eg, chemical packaging left in the area). Unexplained deterioration in water quality. Appropriate raw water determinands – eg, turbidity, odour and colour. Plant unable to produce water complying with DWSNZ:2000. See Contingency Plans. Develop criteria for plan shut-down. Extra preand/or posttreatment storage capacity. Evidence of contamination being transferred from, or by staff. Train staff in hygiene practices. Staff with infectious diseases working at the plant. E. coli detected in 100 ml of water. Where raw water can be very variable, put in place an ongoing monitoring plan for raw water quality to determine how frequently such events occur, and hence what modifications to the plant/storage may be necessary. See also P11.1.1. Develop a code of practice for the treatment plant, which sets out which unhygienic practices must be avoided, including (but not limited to): – – – – Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Staff health. Staff activities. Microbiological quality of treated water. poor personal hygiene staff with infectious diseases working in the plant staff working at both water and wastewater plants use of tools in both water and wastewater plants. Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 5 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Corrective action Signs that action is needed What to check Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE WATER OF SATISFACTORY QUALITY cont’d P11.1.10 Inadequate labelling of chemical storage/no supervision of chemical delivery. P11.1.11 Destruction of part of plant by chemical fire or explosion. P11.1.12 Periodic examination of containers for correct and clear labelling. Ensure that the quality of all chemicals used in treatment is certified by the manufacturer. Make sure that plant staff are aware of delivery dates and times of chemicals, and that they are present to direct the delivery to the correct container. Make sure proper storage arrangements are made for hazardous chemicals. Make sure staff are trained in the correct procedures for handling the chemicals used at the treatment plant. Include in the treatment plant operator’s manual instructions for evaluating the need for the purchase of emergency additional chemical supplies in the event of strike action notification. Make sure an alternative power source is available. In most cases, this will be a petrol or diesel-fuelled generator. Power failure. 6 Lack of chemical supplies due to industrial action. P11.1.13 Make sure all chemical storage containers are clearly labelled with the chemicals they should contain, and their concentration, if appropriate. Audit chemical storing and handling practices. Reserve fuel level. Use of incorrect treatment chemicals because of delivery to the wrong storage container. Fire or explosion or ‘near miss’. Instigate steps to make sure containers are clearly labelled and staff aware of deliveries. Suppliers to be required to ensure that the operator is present when chemicals are delivered. Make proper storage arrangements Identify staff training needs and provide training. Low stock levels because of strike action. Instigate emergency stocking policy. Inability to operate the plant because of a power failure. Obtain a generator. Increase reserve fuel supply. Make sure there is on-site storage of sufficient fuel to maintain plant operation for several days. Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Corrective action Signs that action is needed What to check Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE ENOUGH WATER Possible hazards: Germs; health-significant chemical determinands Level of risk: High P11.2.1 Structural failure of part of the plant. P11.2.2 Visual inspection of plant. Plant construction tenders. Where possible, the plant should be designed with sufficient redundancy and flexibility to allow nonoperational units to be bypassed, so that the failure of no one part of the plant can put the whole plant out of service. Undertake periodic inspections of the structural integrity of the plant so that steps can be taken to carry out repairs before failure. In the design stages, projections for future water demand should be undertaken for the planned life of the plant to assess what the design capacity should be. The plant should be designed so that the failure of no one part can result in the whole plant being put out of service. Make sure all aspects of the plant and its operation that require maintenance have a maintenance schedule developed and followed. Inadequate plant design. P11.2.3 Make sure construction contract requires construction to appropriate building codes, and that these are followed. Inadequate maintenance resulting in mechanical failure. Design the plant to make as much use as possible of gravity flow to allow operation to continue in the event of pump failure. Where practicable, backup equipment and spares should be kept on site to allow failed equipment to be rapidly replaced or repaired. Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Water demand/ water use restrictions. Signs of the beginning of structural failure. Insufficient water produced to meet demand – limited by plant capacity. No spare parts available. Repair or replace failing units, or reconsider the whole plant design. Consider modifications to the existing plant or the construction of a new one. Instigate maintenance programmes. Obtain spare parts. Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 7 Causes Preventive measures Checking preventive measures Signs that action is needed What to check P11.2.4 Corrective action See P11.1.7. Inadequate security measures to prevent vandalism/ sabotage. Event: TREATMENT PLANT CANNOT PRODUCE ENOUGH WATER cont’d P11.2.5 See P11.1.11. Destruction of part of plant by chemical fire or explosion. P11.2.6 See P11.1.13. Power failure. P11.2.7 Natural disasters. 8 When planning the location of the plant, it should be sited at an elevation well above flood levels of nearby bodies of water. Flooding of plant. Destruction of the plant by earthquake. In regions prone to earthquakes, structural design criteria should be selected to take account of the possibility of earthquake. Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014 Contingency Plans If an event happens despite preventive and corrective actions you have taken, you may need to consult with the Medical Officer of Health to assess how serious a problem is. Event – Treated water quality too poor Indicators: Required actions: Responsibility: Microbiological and/or chemical quality of the water leaving the treatment plant does not meet the requirements of DWSNZ:2000. Outbreaks of sickness that are probably linked to water quality. Close down the treatment plant, and supply water from posttreatment storage, or provide another source of potable water until water of acceptable quality can again be supplied. (Make sure that the history of any tanker used to cart water has been investigated before it is used and that the tanker will not contaminate the water.) Notify the MOH and determine whether ‘boil-water’ notices are needed. Identify the reason for the failure and rectify. If water of poor quality has passed into the distribution system, flush and disinfect the network and notify consumers to flush their taps before drawing water for use. Record cause of system failure and steps taken to correct. Modify water safety plan if necessary. Manager designated responsible for the water supply. Event – Not enough water produced by the treatment plant Indicators: Required actions: Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 Post-treatment storage levels dropping. Drop in distribution system pressure. Notify the public of the need to conserve water. Identify the reason for the failure and rectify, if possible. If the fault cannot be rectified within a few hours, provide another source of potable water until water of acceptable quality can again be supplied. (Make sure that the history of any tanker used to cart water has been investigated before it is used and that the tanker will not contaminate the water.) Record cause of system failure and steps taken to correct. Modify water safety plan if necessary. Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 9 Responsibility: 10 Manager designated responsible for the water supply. Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014 Water Safety Plan Performance Assessment To make sure that your supply’s water safety plan is working properly, periodic checks are needed. The overview document outlines what needs to be done. The following table provides the detailed information for checking this particular supply element. What to measure or observe: E. coli (faecal indicator) and coliform bacteria. Chemical Priority 2 determinands. Turbidity. Structural failure of any part of the plant. Inoperative equipment. Post-treatment storage level. Reticulation network pressure. Plant output. Follow the protocols set out in DWSNZ:2000 (where appropriate). How often: Ref P11, Version 1 January 2014 For the monitoring frequencies for E. coli and turbidity measurements see DWSNZ:2000 Section 3.3.2. For chemical determinands see DWSNZ:2000 Table 4.1. Daily data for flows out the plant should provide an indication of water quantity problems. Major failures will become evident very quickly and should not need a monitoring programme. Water Safety Plan Guide: Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation 11 What to do with the results: Responsibility: 12 Results need to be recorded to meet legislative requirements or to allow water safety plan performance assessment. The WINZ database is good for this. The collected data need to be periodically reviewed to see whether problems with this supply element are developing. This should be done as frequently as the manager responsible considers necessary to minimise risk to public health arising from this supply element. Should this review show any unusual incidents, indicate that proper procedures are not being carried out, highlight poor laboratory results or indicate that poor water quality is reaching customers, then review the operation of the treatment plant. Evaluate the monitoring results, and any actions taken as the result of having to implement a contingency plan, to see if the water safety plan needs modification – eg, preventive measures are up to date; the contingency plan steps are still adequate; and changes to the treatment processes are recognised in the plan. Manager designated responsible for the water supply. Water Safety Plan Guide: Ref P11, Version 1 Treatment Processes – Plant Construction and Operation January 2014