Questions to Answer: Who are the closest competitors to us? What can we learn from them? local ECU – online certificate NCSU – no such program? Duke – Nursing Informatics training? nationally similar programs (see below) structural organization (host dept) standalone informatics program University of Illinois at Chicago (one of the programs)???? University of Massachusetts – Lowell University of Minnesota Columbia University of Texas – Houston LIS or Informatics School based Indiana University Northern Kentucky University Northeastern University University of North Texas public health based Emory University University of Illinois – Chicago (second program) University of Virginia New York Medical College certificate based programs without homes Excelsior College ECU University of Maryland Drexel University other College/School of Nursing (U of Arizona, U of Colorado HSC, Canyon College, U of Iowa, U of Kansas, U of Pennsylvania, Fairmont State U) School of Medicine (U of California – Davis, John Hopkins, U of Missouri, Oregon HSU, U of Washington) Allied Health (U of Alabama – Birmingham, Saint Louis, Ohio State, U of Tennessee, U of Wisconsin – Milwaukee, Medical College of Georgia) Undergraduate schools (Bellevue University, Oregon Institute of Technology) can we tell who is successful? Number of students enrolled? Applications received? how are they marketing their program? Important fields to compare prereqs number of credit hours focus areas/curriculum Competitors (Informatics) Columbia Standalone program as one of Biomedical Informatics training options. Current enrolment – 50 students in all programs (MS, PhD). Offer nice comparison of their programs for prospective students (http://www.dbmi.columbia.edu/educ/degreeprograms/index.html ) No special prerequisites, beyond usual grad school admission requirements but students can place out of required courses if they have suitable background (see curriculum below), flexible selection of 12 courses (assumed to be 36 credits) Curriculum: Computational courses (one required, can place out) Database Systems, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, Programming and Problem Solving, Advanced Software Engineering Public Health Core (4 courses, can place out of all but one) Epidemiology, Issues and approaches in health policy and management, Environmental Health Sciences, Public health informatics Mathematical (one course, can place out) Introduction to Biostatistics Specialized training in public health informatics topics- Projects (1-6 courses) Informatics Core (3 courses, cannot place out) Introduction to Computer Applications in Health Care and Biomedicine, Theory and Methods in Biomedical Informatics One research Core Course Evaluation Methods in Medical Informatics or Research design and data collection One Research Practicum Northeastern University Based in College of Computer and Information Sciences, but relies on partnership with Bouve College of Health Sciences. Non-Thesis MS Program mostly geared towards IT professionals including those actively employed - evening classes to enable part-time study options. Standard grad school admission requirements plus prerequisites: Intro to Computing Fundamentals of Statistics Health & Medicine for Non-clinicians. 40 credit program (24 core credits and 12 elective credits + capstone project and one-credit internship), GPS 3.0 or better required for matriculation. Curriculum: Health Informatics and Management Core Courses (12 credits) Introduction to Health Informatics Systems Organizational Behavior, Workflow Design & Change Management Health Information Systems Lab Project Management IT Core Courses (6 credits) Data Management in Healthcare Database Design, Access, Modeling & Security Health Core Courses (6 credits) Business of Healthcare Informatics Creation and Application of Medical Knowledge Electives (12 credits) Design for Usability Emerging Technologies in Healthcare Introduction to Genomics and Bioinformatics Key Standards in Health Informatics Legal & Social Issues in Health Informatics Management Issues in Healthcare IT Public Health Surveillance and Informatics University of Minnesota Standalone program (appears to be young, original 32 credit MS split into two distinct programs). Now offering MHI (practice oriented) and two MS (course-oriented and research oriented) and PhD degrees in Health Informatics. MHI is a limited enrollment 32 credit program (currently 10 f-time and 15 p-time) and is designed to be attractive for working professionals - designed to be completed in one calendar year for full time students and in up to three years for part-time students, offers evening and Saturday classes. Admission requirements: A Baccalaureate or post-baccalaureate degree in one of the health professions with GPA of 3.0 or better, one course in a modern computer programming language (e.g. Java, Visual Basic, C, C++) or evidence of equivalent skills. GRE or record of professional achievement for those who are more than 10 years from last degree completed MS Program Standard Grad admission requirements plus Prerequisites: equivalent of six semester credits or nine quarter credits in medical, life or biological sciences. This a a broadly defined requirement and most courses with a health or biology emphasis will be accepted including biostatistics, health services research, public health, etc as well as the more traditional biology or life science courses. one year of calculus; a course or documented work experience in a programming or application language such as C, C++, JAVA, Visual Basic, PASCAL, etc. The 42 credit program has two options (both require core courses plus 12 additional credits) For course-oriented (non-thesis) program – 6 technical electives and 6 health sciences electives, research report. For research-oriented (thesis) program – 6 “major” (concentration) electives and 6 in related field outside major. NOTE: elective courses are not provided by the program. PhD Program is an expanded version of research-oriented MS Student are expected to earn a minimum of 34 credits in their major field, 12 credits in a minor field or supporting program, and 24 thesis credits, for a minimum total of 70 credits. Core courses for MS/PhD programs Health Informatics I. (4 credits/semester) Health Informatics II. (4 credits/semester) Health Informatics Seminar (1 credit/semester) Operation Research and Quality Control in Health Care. (2 credits/semester) Information Technology in Health Care. (2 credits/semester) University of Illinois at Chicago Health Informatics Program is a 1991 addition to the Department of Biomedical and Health Information Sciences under College of Applied Health Sciences. Offers MS, Post-Baccalaureate and Post-Master certificates. All are online degrees. MS Program has just added course-only option to traditional research oriented option - reflects the industry need for health informatics field professionals. In addition, graduates can take Registered Health Information Administrator (RHIA) credential exam. MS and Post-Master admission requirements: GPA 3.0 or better, no GRE or such. Post-Bac. Certificate: GPA 2.75 or better on final semester of undergraduate work or 3.0 for any graduate work. At least two years of health care or IT work experience preferred for all programs. MS course only program is 45 credits and can be completed in 18 months. It is unclear what the certificate program requirements are. Curriculum (Note differentiated course hours) Prerequisites (may be waived in some instances) Independent Study (1 to 5 hours) Core Courses Health Care Data (3 hours) Info. Sources in Biomedical & HIS (1 hour) Communication Skills in Health Informatics (2 hours) Ethics & Legal Issues in Health Informatics (3 hours) Health Care Information Systems (4 hours) Application of Health Care Info. Sys. (2 hours) Management of Health Care Comm. Sys. (4 hours) Health Info. Sys. Analysis & Design (4 hours) Social & Org. Issues in Health Informatics (4 hours) Health Care IT Vendor Management (3 hours) Additional Core - Course Only Track Topics in Health Informatics (4 hours) Additional Core - Research Track Strategic Inquiry in BHIS (3 hours) Seminar in Biomedical and Health Information Sciences (1 hour) Research in Biomedical and Health Information Sciences (0 to 5 hours) Research in Biomedical and Health Information Sciences (0 to 16 hours) Electives - Other Courses Offered Health Care Information Security (3 hours) Consumer Health Informatics (3 hours) Topics in Health Informatics (4 hours) Health Care I.T. Administration (3 hours) Leadership Development in Health Informatics (3 hours) Practicum in Biomedical and Health Information Sciences (3 to 12 hours) Independent Study (1 to 4 hours) University of Massachusetts - Lowell On-line Health Informatics program, administered through Continuing Education. Listed as “New”. Options include 36 credit MS and 12 credit Certificate program. Liberal (no GPA, no GRE) admission requirements. Curriculum (MS): Required Core Courses - 2 courses Healthcare Finance Healthcare Management Concentration Courses - 8 courses Organizational Behavior in Healthcare Health Informatics Healthcare Information Systems Operations Analysis and Quality Improvement Law and Ethics in Healthcare Health Information Systems Planning Healthcare Database Design Healthcare Database Development Program Electives - choose 1 course Quantitative Methods in Healthcare Management Applied Health Economics Planning and Marketing in Healthcare Health Policy Leadership in Healthcare Socioeconomic Inequalities in Health Comparative Health Systems Final Project - choose 1 of the following Capstone Project OR Master’s Thesis Competitors (ILS based) Indiana Based in School of Informatics. Started as MS program in 2003, PhD added in 2005. Typical admission requirements. 36 credit program (including thesis) Curriculum: Informatics Core (18 credits) Introduction to Informatics Laboratory Information Management Systems Clinical Information Systems Informatics Research Design Health Informatics Standards & Terminology Intro to Biostatistics I One required Seminar Course (3 credits) Seminar in Health Informatics Applications Electives (9-12 credits) Social Impact of Information Technologies Informatics Project Management Scientific Data Management Data Analysis Consumer Health Informatics Natural Language Processing Business of Health Informatics Thesis/Capstone Project (3-6 credits) Northern Kentucky University Based in College of Informatics. Program started in 2007. Offers MS and Certificate options. More on program development can be found in this article: http://informatics.nku.edu/bis/mhi/docs/mhi_research.pdf Standard admission requirements. 35 credit MS program and 12 credit Certificate program. Curriculum for MS: Foundational Courses (18 credits) Introduction to Health Informatics Technical Foundations of Health Informatics Introduction to Management Information Systems Project Management Introduction to Database Management Research Method for Health Informatics One required Seminar Course (3 credits) Seminar in Health Informatics Applications Electives (11 credits) Students are required to take a minimum of 11 hours in elective courses. Students are required to take one course from each of the areas, and an additional course from one of the areas. Health Informatics Policy Electives COM 650 Health Communication PHI 510 Ethics in Information Technology CSC 670 Social Implications of Computing MGT 620 Leadership and Ethics MGT 670 Negotiation and Conflict Resolution Business Process Management Electives MBI 630 Systems Analysis and Design MBI 675 Enterprise Workflow Design and Reengineering ECO 625 Managerial Economics ACC 605 Introduction to Financial Accounting FIN 605 Fundamentals of Finance MHI 694 Selected Topics in Information Systems COM 604 Organizational Communication MGT 612 Managing People and Organizations Knowledge Management Electives MBI 660 Data Warehousing and Data Mining MBI 665 Computer Supported Collaborative Work MHI 694 Selected Topics in Information Systems MKT625 Marketing Management Capstone sequence (2 semesters) Includes real work-setting based project and weekly seminar. MHI 694 Selected Topics in Information Systems Electronic Portfolio Students will be required to maintain a portfolio during the course of the program. The portfolio will be reviewed and critiqued during a capstone seminar, where revisions and other improvements may also be required. University of North Texas Based in School of Library and Information Science; partnerships with area medical centers and medical schools. MS program started in 1988 and is an IS program with Health Informatics concentration. Advanced (Post-Master) Certificate program is for information professionals, librarians and healthcare professionals, advertized as being highly tailored to individual professional interests. Interdisciplinary PhD in IS with concentration in HI added in 1992. Two additional graduate certificate programs are under planning: Medical Digital Imaging and Consumer Health. Lower than typical grad school admission requirements for MS program (GPA 2.8, rather than usual 3.0), plus prerequisite of Entry Level Information Technology Knowledge and Skills before the first semester of enrollment: list of skills is published (like the ones obtained from Info Tools course) and there is an on-line self-assessment tool. Students scoring below 75% on any of the tool modules are encouraged to take remedial courses. MS - 36 credit program with additional internship/field experience, average grade of 3.0 or better plus successful passing of final examination. Certificate – 24 credit program (builds on MSIS curriculum) PhD – 48 credits. Curriculum (for MS): Required Core Courses (9 credits) Introduction to Information Professionals Introduction to Information Organization Introduction to Information Access and Retrieval Electives (15 credits) Not specified, should be selected with advisor Health Informatics Courses (select 12 credits) Health Sciences Information Management Medical Informatics Organization of Information of Clinical Care Community Based Health Information Medical Digital Imaging Internship/Field Experience In area healthcare organizations, flexibility of choices. University of Texas- Houston Based in School of Health Information Science, which is housed in the Texas Medical Center, but many faculty are from Biomedical Engineering. Started in 1997. Offers several programs with emphasis on flexibility of choice of courses/focus, availability of on-line and face-to-face classes: Graduate Certificate in Health Informatics or Public Health Informatics – 15 credit program MS - 42 credit program full-time (5 semesters) or part-time (typically 3 years) Concentrations in: Clinical Informatics, Computational Biomedicine, Learning & Technology or Dual Degree with SPH PhD – 93 credit program that takes 4 years to complete full-time or 6 years part-time. Typical admission requirements (Bachelor’s w/ GPA of 3.0, GRE or MAT score) Curriculum for MS: new in 2007 (adds pre-foundational & foundational courses, same 42 credit RQs) Pre-foundational Courses (as advised) Little or no CS and programming skills Information Technology for Biomedicine and Data Structures and Algorithms in Biomedicine. No biomedical background Introduction to Clinical Healthcare and Molecules to Man in Health Informatics. If not taken college calculusEssential Mathematics for Biomedicine. Verbal GRE below 640, or MAT score below 432 Technical Writing in Healthcare. Foundational Courses (min 6 credits) Foundations of Health Information Sciences I Foundations of Health Information Sciences II Foundations of Health Information Sciences III Basic Courses (3-9 credits) Introduction to Health Data and Electronic Health Records Health Information Systems in the Delivery of Health Care Special Topics: Scientific Visualization Decision Making in Healthcare Legal Ethical Issues in Health Informatics Health Information Security Systems Systems Analysis for Health Informatics Object Oriented Systems Development in Health Informatics Biomedical Signal Processing Image Processing Intro to Learning Environments in HS Cognitive Engineering I in Health Informatics Intro to Telehealth Special Topics in Health Informatics Research Informatics Courses (3-9 credits) Evaluation in Health Informatics Research and Evaluation in Health Informatics Statistical Solutions for Health Informatics Problems Data Analysis Environment Development in Health Science Methods in Computational Biomedicine Cognitive Engineering II Consumer Informatics Knowledge Modeling II Triangulation Methods in Health Informatics Advanced Informatics (3-9 credits) Advanced Database Concepts Advanced Health Information Systems Health Data Display Knowledge Modeling and Engineering I Consultation in Health Informatics Social Dynamics and Health Informatics Comparative Taxonomy Healthcare Interface Design Advanced Decision Analysis I Project Management in Healthcare Scientific Writing in Healthcare Intro to Computational Aspects of Biomedicine Applied Computational Biomedicine Advanced Topics in Computational Biomedicine Datamining in Bioinformatics Computational Cognitive Neuroscience Computational Structural Biology Biomolecular Modeling Special Topics in Health Informatics Practicum (6 credits of support courses and 6 hours of practicum) SPH Based Competitors Emory University Offers MSPH in Public Health Informatics Admission requirements: GPA 3.0 or better, GRE scores above average on all sections, strong quantitative background (calculus, linear algebra) as well as background health or biomedical sciences Program requires at least 44 semester hours of coursework plus 4 thesis hours for a total of 48, plus a 200 hour non-credit practicum. Curriculum (Note differentiated course hours) Informatics Core Courses Health Care Data (3 hours) Principles of Public Health Informatics I Principles of Public Health Informatics II Management Principles for Informatics Database Management Systems Advanced Database Management System Geographic Information Systems Health Outcomes Introduction to PH Surveillance Data Analysis Core Courses Statistical Methods I Statistical Methods II Or (For adequately prepared students) Biostatistical Methods I Applied Linear Models Public Health Core Courses Behavioral Sciences in Public Health Perspectives in Environmental Health Epidemiologic Methods I Introduction to the US Health Care System 2 2 2 3 3 2 3 3 4 4 4 4 2 2 4 2 Practicum Special Studies Project Electives (see below) 0 4 6 Electives: We envision that students will concentrate electives in a particular application area in order to add depth to their program. For instance, students will be able to take elective courses in Health Policy and Management to gain expertise in clinical information systems, patient billing systems, and their interrelationships. Similarly, students will be able to take electives in biostatistics and epidemiology to gain additional skills in analytic methods. Additional elective courses in public health informatics are also being planned. Practicum: A student must participate in a practicum experience of at least 200 hours. Practicum does not carry any academic credit, but it is included on the transcript. University of Illinois at Chicago Offers MS and a Certificate in Public Health Informatics taught on-line Admission requirements for MS program: GPA 3.0 or better, GRE scores of at least 1000 (will be waived for those with graduate or professional degree at the doctoral level, licensed physicians), just Bacherlor’s degree for Certificate. MS Program requires at least 51 credits and consists of 6 PH courses 8 informatics courses and a capstone project. Certificate program consists of 5 courses (see below) and a publication quality paper. Certificate Courses: Health Care Data Health Information and Decision Support Systems Web-Based Public Health Informatics Applications Geographic Information Systems in Public Health Data Mining in Public Health MS Curriculum Public Health Courses Biostatistics I Public Health Concepts and Practice Principles of Epidemiology Principles of Management in Public Health Principles of Environmental Health Sciences Behavioral Sciences in Public Health 4 3 3 3 3 3 Informatics Courses Health Care Data 3 Health Information and Decision Support Systems 4 Legal and Social Issues in Health Informatics 3 Survey of Health Care Information Systems 4 Management of Health Care Communication Systems 4 WEB-Based Public Health Informatics 4 Applications of Geographic Information Systems in Public Health 3 Data Mining in Public Health 3 University of Virginia Offers MS in Clinical Research – interdisciplinary degree. Admission Requirements: Bachelor’s degree (no GPA specified), GRE, MCAT, LSAT, or GMAT (those with Doctoral degrees exempt), also “strong quantitative skills and computer literacy are vital to success in our program; therefore, special scrutiny is given to evidence of these abilities in each applicant's materials.” 31 credits can be completed in 9 months of intensive study or over several years on part-time basis. Curriculum (Note: 12 courses, but 31 credits – some of Fall courses have to be lower credit): Required Core Courses (Fall) Introduction to Biostatistics Fundamentals of Epidemiology Database Design & Imp Introduction to SAS The Practice of PHS Health Care Research Informatics Electives (one of two) Health Care Economics Health Care Policy & Mgmt Required Core Courses (Spring) Health Technology & Outcomes Evaluation Introduction to Biostatistics II Applied Epidemiological Methods Specialty Electives (choose 2) Clinical Decision Support Systems Supervised Research Introduction to Clinical Trials Health Care Quality Improvement (One elective substitution allowed with permission) New York Medical College Offers MPH and Graduate Certificate in Health Informatics (15 – credit program). Emphatically “applied” program to “support of health care providers and public health organizations” – explicitly (not for research or teaching or general technical education). MPH program builds on regular MPH with some additional courses. Admission Requirements: Bachelor’s degree (no GPA specified), GRE, MCAT, LSAT, or GMAT (those with Doctoral degrees exempt), also “strong quantitative skills and computer literacy are vital to success in our program; therefore, special scrutiny is given to evidence of these abilities in each applicant's materials.” MPH program requires 45-46 credits that can be completed in 2 years of F/T or 3-4 years of P/T study. MPH Curriculum Required Core Courses Required Concentration Courses Health Care in the United States Health Economics Behavioral and Social Aspects of Public Health Environmental Influences on Human Health Health Quantitative Sciences I Health Quantitative Sciences II Thesis Practicum (1 credit) Introduction to Informatics in the Health Sciences Information systems concepts and Languages Management of Health Information Systems Systems Analysis and Design Database Management Systems Distributed Information Systems and Networks Electives (not specified – 6 credits?)