Non-invasive methods to assess pulse wave velocity: Comparison

advertisement

Online Supplement

Non-invasive methods to assess pulse wave velocity:

Comparison with the invasive gold-standard and relationship with organ damage

Thomas WEBER (a,b), Siegfried WASSERTHEURER (c), Bernhard HAMETNER (c), Stephanie PARRAGH (c), Bernd EBER (a) a ... Cardiology Department, Klinikum Wels-Grieskirchen, Wels, Austria b ... Paracelsus Medical University, Salzburg, Austria c ... Austrian Institute of Technology, Vienna, Austria

Corresponding author:

Thomas Weber, MD, Associate Professor

Cardiology Department

Klinikum Wels-Grieskirchen

Grieskirchnerstrasse 42

4600 Wels

Austria

Email: thomas.weber3@liwest.at

Fax: 0043 7242 415 3992

1

All patients

Patient number

Age years

Men

915

61.0 (53.2-69.0)

Hypertension

Diabetes mellitus

Smoking

Coronary artery disease

752 (82.2%)

705 (77.0%)

209 (22.8 %)

188 (20.5%)

466 (50.9 %)

AngioScore

Normal systolic function

0 (0-4)

727 (79.5%)

Left ventricular enddiastolic pressure mm Hg 16 (12-20)

Body Mass Index kg/m 2 28.3 (25.6-30.9)

Waist circumference cm 100 (94-107)

Total cholesterol mg/dl

LDL-cholesterol mg/dl

200 (170-231)

114 (89-144)

HbA1c %

Creatinine clearence ml/min

Log nt-proBNP pg/ml

Left atrial diameter cm/m 2

Left ventricular mass g/m 2

E´cm/sec

E/E´

S´cm/sec

5.7 (5.4-6.2)

91 (71-114)

2.1 (1.8-2.6)

2.0 (1.8-2.2)

121 (100-149)

5.6 (4.5-7.0)

10.6 (8.6-13.7)

6.7 (5.7-7.7)

Patients with direct distance measurement

632

60.0 (53.0-69.0)

526 (83.2 %)

491(77.7%)

150 (23.7%)

122 (19.3%)

312 (49.4%)

0 (0-4)

494 (78.2%)

16 (12-20)

28.4 (25.6-31.1)

101 (94-108)

201 (169-234)

115 (88-148)

5.7 (5.5-6.2)

93 (72-116)

2.1 (1.8-2.6)

2.0 (1.8-2.2)

120 (99-148)

5.6 (4.5-7.0)

10.6 (8.7-13.6)

6.8 (1.6)

Patients with caliper measurement

336

63 (55-70)

267 (79.5%)

265 (78.9%)

96 (28.6%)

65 (19.3%)

186 (55.4%)

0 (0-4)

259 (77.1%)

17 (12-21)

28.4 (25.8-31.0)

102 (95-109)

195 (163-230)

111 (84-142)

5.7 (5.5-6.3)

89 (69-115)

2.1 (1.8-2.6)

2.0 (1.8-2.2)

119 (99-140)

5.3 (4.1-6.5) *

11.3(9.5-14.1) *

6.5 (5.6-7.4) *

Table S1: Baseline characteristics of the patients. Numbers are means (SD), medians (25.-75. Percentile), or absolute numbers (percentages).

* indicates a statistically significant difference between the three groups (Kruskal-Wallis test)

2

Age groups years

< 41 n MBP

30

41 to 50 130

51 to 60 282

61 to 70 289

71 to 80 166

80 + 18 inv mm

Hg

90

(85-94)

93

(87-102)

98

(90-109)

99

(91-109)

97

(87-108)

101

(84-112)

MBP noninv mm Hg

94.5

(86-103)

97

(91-103)

100

(92-110)

101

(92-109)

98

(90-110)

96

(83-108)

TT inv msec

88.7

(81.7-

97.5)

77.2

(69.2-

86.7)

65.8

(58.7-

75)

56.7

(49.2-

63.1)

50

(41.7-

56.7)

42.9

(35.8-

50.0)

TT noninv msec

75.6

(68.2-

84.9)

72.5

(65.5-

80.8)

65.6

(57.7-

74.1)

57.4

(49.4-

64.5)

52.9

(46.3-

62.4)

47.1

(38.8-

49.9)

TD inv cm

49.5

(47.0-

53.2)

50

(47.5-

52.2)

51

(49-

53.5)

51

(48.5-

54.0)

51

(48.5-

54.2)

49.7

(47.5-

54.0)

TD sub cm

49

(47.5-

53.0)

50

(46.0-

53.0)

50.5

(47.0-

54.5)

50.5

(47.5-

54.0)

49

(46.0-

53.0)

45.7

(44.0-

49.5)

TD bh cm

52.3

(51.3-

53.5)

51.5

(50.0-

52.5)

50.8

(49.8-

52.0)

50.3

(49.0-

51.5)

49.5

(48.5-

50.5)

47.0

(45.8-

49.3)

Height cm

180.0

(176.0-

185.0)

177.0

(171.0-

181.0)

174.0

(170.0-

179.0)

172.0

(167.0-

177.0)

169.0

(165.0-

173.0)

159.0

(154.0-

168.0) aoPWV inv m/sec

5.6

(4.9-6.2)

6.4

(5.8-7.2)

7.6

(6.8-8.7)

9.1

(8.0-10.2)

10.1

(9.0-12.2)

12.3

(10.3-

14.0) cfPWVsub m/sec

6.3

(5.6-7.1)

6.7

(6.1-7.7)

7.7

(6.8-8.8)

8.9

(7.7-10.4)

9.5

(7.9-11.1)

10.6

(9.2-11.4) aoPWVestim m/sec

5.3

(5.0-5.7)

6.2

(5.8-6.7)

7.4

(6.9-8.1)

9.2

(8.5-9.9)

10.5

(10.0-11.4)

12.2

(11.8-13.0) cfPWVbh m/sec

7

(5.9-7.7)

7.1

(6.4-7.8)

7.8

(6.8-8.7)

8.8

(7.7-10.2)

9.4

(8.0-10.9)

10.1

(9.6-12.2)

Table S2: Pulse wave velocities and their determinants in the entire study population (n=915), stratified across age groups. Numbers are medians

(25.-75. percentile). MBP ... mean blood pressure, TT ... transit time, TDinv ... invasive travel distance, TD subtr ... subtracted travel distance, TDbh ... body height based travel distance, aoPWVinv ... invasive aortic pulse wave velocity, cfPWVsubtr ... subtracted distance-based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity; aoPWVestim ... estimated aortic pulse wave velocity, cfPWVbh, body-height based formula derived carotis-femoralis pulse wave velocity

3

Age groups years

< 41 yrs

41 to 50

24

51 to 60 200

61 to 70 199

71 to 80 101

80 + n MBP inv mm

94

14

Hg

90.5

(85.0-

95.5)

92

(87-

101)

98

(88.0-

108.0)

98

(92.0-

109.0)

96

(87.0-

108.0)

99.5

(84.0-

112.0)

MBP noninv mm Hg

93.5

(85.5-101)

97.5

(91-104)

100

(92.0-

109.5)

101

(92.0-

110.0)

97

(89.0-

113.0)

96

(83.0-

110.0)

TT inv msec

89.6

57.5

(49.2-

63.1)

50

(43.3-

56.3)

43.3

(39.2-

50.0)

(81.3-

97.5)

75.4

(67.5-

85.0)

65.8

(58.3-

75.0)

TT noninv msec

76.6

56.8

(48.9-

62.5)

52.9

(46.5-

62.4)

47.1

(36.4-

49.9)

(67.4-

84.6)

72.1

(65.0-

80.0)

66.2

(58.5-

74.8)

TD inv cm

49.5

51

(48.5-

54.0)

51

(49.0-

54.2)

49.7

(47.5-

56.0)

(47.2-

53.2)

49.6

(47.5-

52.0)

51

(49.0-

54.0)

TD sub cm

49.0

50

(46.5-

54.0)

50

(47.0-

53.3)

46.2

(44.5-

50.0)

(47.2-

54.0)

50

(46.0-

52.5)

50.5

(48.0-

54.7)

TD dirx0.8 cm

54.4

53.2

(51.2-

56.0)

52.8

(49.6-

56.0)

48.4

(45.6-

52.8)

(52.8-

58.0)

53.6

(51.2-

56.8)

54.4

(51.6-

56.8)

Height cm

179.5

(176.0-

184.0)

177

(171-

180)

174

(170.5-

180)

172

(167-

177)

170

(165-

173)

160.5

(154-

170) aoPWVinv m/sec

5.6

(4.9-6.2)

6.6

(5.8-7.3)

7.7

(6.7-8.9)

8.9

(8.1-10.2)

10.2

(9.0-12.0)

11.7

(10.3-13.6) cfPWVsub m/sec

6.2

(5.7-7.1)

6.7

(6.2-7.6)

7.7

(6.8-8.6)

8.9

(7.8-10.5)

9.1

(8.1-11.1)

10.8

(9.2-12.8) cfPWVdir0.8 m/sec

7.3

(6.7-7.9)

7.3

(6.7-8.4)

8.1

(7.5-9.3)

9.3

(8.5-11.1)

9.8

(8.6-11.3)

11.2

(10.4-12.7) aoPWVest m/sec

5.2

(4.9-5.7)

6.2

(5.9-6.7)

7.4

(7.0-8.1)

9.2

(8.5-9.9)

10.6

(10.1-11.4)

12.2

(11.2-12.7)

Table S3: Pulse wave velocities and their determinants in the cohort with direct distance measurements (n=632), stratified across age groups.

Numbers are medians (25.-75. percentile). CfPWVdir0.8 ... direct distance x 0.8 based carotis-femoralis pulse wave velocity; other abbreviations see

Table S2

4

Age groups years

< 41

41 to

50

51 to

60

61 to

70 n MBP inv

8 mm

Hg

90

38

(88.0-

92.5)

94.5

(89.0-

104.0)

106 97.0

(90.0-

105.0)

112 98.5

(90.0-

MBP noninv mm Hg

100

(88.5-

108.8)

101.5

(95.0-

110.0)

103.0

(95.0-

111.0)

104.5

(96.0-

TT inv msec

86.2

(80.6-

93.1)

74.5

(67.3-

88.3)

67.1

(57.5-

76.7)

57.6

(50.0-

TT noninv msec

71.2

(64.3-

87.0)

72.5

(64.9-

80.2)

65.1

(57.3-

73.7)

55.8

(47.8-

TD inv cm

49.2

(48.5-

54.5)

50.5

(47.5-

54.0)

51.2

(49.0-

54.0)

51.0

(49.0-

TD sub cm

50.7

(46.0-

55.2)

49.0

(45.0-

52.0)

50.0

(47.0-

54.0)

48.7

(46.0-

TD caliper cm

46.2

(39.5-

51.0)

46.0

(43.0-

49.0)

46.0

(43.0-

49.0)

45.0

(42.5-

Height cm

181.5

(175.5-

185.0)

175

(168.0-

180.0)

175.0

(171.0-

180.0)

170

(166.0aoPWVinv m/sec

5.8

(5.5-6.2)

6.6

(6.1-7.4)

7.7

(6.7-8.8)

9.0

(8.0-10.4) cfPWVsub m/sec

6.4

(5.5-7.5)

6.6

(6.1-7.6)

7.6

(6.7-9.0)

8.8

(7.7-10.6) cfPWVcaliper m/sec

5.6

6.2

7.0

(5.1-6.9)

(5.8-7.2)

(6.2-8.2)

8.0

(7.1-9.6) aoPWVest m/sec

5.5

(5.1-5.8)

6.5

(5.8-6.9)

7.6

(7.1-8.4)

9.3

(8.7-10.0)

71 to

80

108.0)

64 94.5

(89.0-

108.0)

111.0)

99.0

(89.5-

112.5)

64.2)

50.4

(43.7-

56.7)

62.2)

52.0

(43.8-

59.2)

54.4)

50.5

(48.5-

54.2)

52.5)

49.0

(46.0-

52.7)

47.5)

44.5

(42.0-

48.0)

176.0)

169.5

(165.0-

173.0)

10.2

(9.1-12.2)

9.8

(7.8-11.5)

8.8

(7.3-10.5)

10.7

(10.0-11.6)

80 + 8 94.0

(84.0-

115.0)

101.5

(89.0-

111.0)

42.9

(37.5-

50.4)

40.1

(32.4-

51.0)

49.7

(47.5-

55.2)

46.2

(45.2-

48.2)

43.7

(41.2-

45.7)

160.5

(154.5-

169.0)

12.3

(9.0-14.2)

11.9

(9.8-14.0)

10.6

(8.9-13.3)

12.7

(12.4-13.2)

Table S4: Pulse wave velocities and their determinantes in the cohort with caliper measurements of travel distance (n=336), stratified across age groups. Numbers are medians (25.-75. percentile); cfPWVcalip ... caliper-based carotis-femoralis pulse wave velocity, other abbreviations see Table

S2 and S3

5

Age

Angioscore

LVMass

Ntpro-BNP

LA diameter

E´med

E / E`med

S´med aoPWVinv cfPWV sub cfPWVdir0.8

cfPWV bh aoPWVestim

0.68 0.48*§ 0.46*§ 0.47*§ 0.91#

0.25 0.12* 0.11* 0.09*§ 0.18

LV EDP 0.27

CreaClearence -0.46

0.27

0.21

0.29

-0.46

0.31

-0.28

0.22

-0.28*§

0.27

0.21

0.23§

-0.35*§

0.29§

-0.19*§

0.22

-0.28*§

0.27

0.19

0.21*§

-0.34*§

0.29§

-0.17*§

0.19*

-0.34*§

0.28

0.15

0.23§

-0.33*§

0.27§

-0.19*§

0.23

-0.61#

0.33

0.16

0.37#

-0.51

0.38#

-0.31

Table S5: Univariate correlations between PWVs and intermediate cardiovascular endpoints in 536 patients with preserved systolic function, in whom direct distance measurements were available. * indicates a statistically significant different relationship with aoPWVinv, as compared to noninvasive cfPWVs. # indicates a statistically significant different relationship with aoPWVest, as compared to aoPWVinv. § indicates a statistically significant different relationship with aoPWVest, as compared to noninvasive cfPWVs.

LVEDP ... left ventriculat enddiastolic pressure, LVM ... left ventricular mass; BSA ... body surface area, LA ... left atrium, aoPWVinv ... invasive aortic pulse wave velocity, cfPWVsubtr ... subtracted distance-based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity; cfPWVdir0.8 ... direct distance x 0.8 based carotis-femoralis pulse wave velocity; cfPWVbh, body-height based formula derived carotis-femoralis pulse wave velocity; aoPWVestim ... estimated aortic pulse wave velocity

6

Figure S1: Bland-Altman plot comparing invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) and subtracted-distance based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (cfPWVsub) in 915 patients. Mean difference was 0.1 m/sec, 1 standard deviation was 2m/sec.

7

Figure S2: Bland-Altman plot comparing invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) and body-height - distance based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (cfPWVbh) in 915 patients. Mean difference was 0.1 m/sec, 1 standard deviation was 2 m/sec.

8

Figure S3: Bland-Altman plot comparing invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) and estimated aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVestim) in

915 patients. Mean difference was 0.2 m/sec, 1 standard deviation was 1.6 m/sec.

9

Figure S4: Bland-Altman plot comparing invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) and direct distance x 0.8 – based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity (cfPWVdir0.8) in 632 patients. Mean difference was 0.5 m/sec, 1 standard deviation was 1.9 m/sec.

10

Figure S5: Bland-Altman plot comparing invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) and caliper-based carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity

(cfPWVcalip) in 336 patients. Mean difference was 0.8 m/sec, 1 standard deviation was 2.1 m/sec.

11

Figure S6: Invasive aortic pulse wave velocity (aoPWVinv) in our study vs carotid-femoral pulse wvae velocity (cfPWV) from the ACCT trial (1).

12

References:

1. McEniery CM, Yasmin, Hall IR, et al. Normal vascular aging: differential effects on wave reflection and aortic pulse wave velocity: the Anglo-

Cardiff Collaborative Trial (ACCT). Journal of the American College of Cardiology 2005;46:1753-60.

13

Download