Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer Electronic Supplementary

advertisement

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer

Electronic Supplementary Material

Teufelsmauer and the Subhercynian Cretaceous Basin

The SCB is one of the many sedimentary Cretaceous basins in western and central Europe filled with several hundreds of meters of clastic and carbonate sediments. Throughout its eastern extent (Fig. 1a), the surface geology is dominated by Lower (Hauterrivian to Barremian, ~130-

120 Ma) and Upper Cretaceous sandstones, where the Upper Cretaceous units can be found as an up to 3000 m thick succession from Turonian (~90 Ma) to Campanian (~83 Ma). The rocks that form the different segments of the Teufelsmauer occur within different layers of that sequence, including the Hauterrivian to Barremian Neocomian Sandstone , the Coniacian Involutus

Sandstone (~88 Ma), and the Upper Santonian Heidelberg Sandstone (~84 Ma). Despite their age difference, they show similar grain sizes (~250 µm in diameter) and porosities (~15-20 %) and are of similar texture and composition, classifying them as well sorted, well rounded, porous quartz arenites.

These sandstones were affected by folding and faulting (Fig. 1b) during the uplift of the

Harz Mountains along the Northern Harz Mountains Border Fault, herein referred to as Harz border fault. The uplift of the Harz Mountains was originally regarded to be of simple block tectonic character (e.g. Mohr, 1978). However, the complexity of the geology within the SCB and especially along the northern rim of the Harz Mountains indicated a more sophisticated structural history of the area. This motivated a number of studies to better characterize and describe the nature of the Harz border fault. Flick (1986) suggested that the Northern Harz Mountains Border

Fault was as nappe-like structure thrusting deeper units over the SCB. Other studies described the

Harz border fault as a highly segmented fault system reactivated multiple times with changing

1

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer character (Stackebrandt, 1983, 1986; Tröger, 1995) or found evidence for strike-slip motion and interpreted the Harz Mountains as push-up structure due to strike-slip tectonics (Wrede, 1988,

2008; König and Wrede, 1994).

Recently, the thrusting character of the Harz border fault as a frontal fault (Voigt et al.,

2004; Voigt and Eynatten, 2006) has been revitalized. Based on the progressively unconformable deposition of the Upper Cretaceous sequence in the SCB, the fault was found to be continuously active during Late Cretaceous time and is interpreted to have caused a fault-propagation anticline in the Mesozoic basinal units to form above the fault tip (Voigt et al., 2004). At least four unconformities in SCB occur within Santonian to Campanian units (Voigt and Eynatten, 2004;

2006; Voigt et al., 2004), constraining the timing of fault activity and pointing out the synkinematic deposition of the Santonian and Campanian units during the Harz uplift.

Due to this folding and faulting, the eastern SCB is subdivided into two sub-basins (e.g.

Stackebrandt, 1986), the Blankenburg and Halberstadt Basins (Fig. 1). The sub-basin closer to the

Harz block, the Blankenburg Syncline (Fig. 1), was affected most by the tectonic processes. The northern flank of the Blankenburg Syncline is moderately inclined, whereas the southern flank is dipping vertically and is, in places, overturned (Fig. 1b). At both flanks of the Blankenburg

Syncline, narrow ridges of highly consolidated and erosionally resistant sandstone form the prominent towers of the Teufelsmauer (Fig. 2a), whereas the horizontal parts of the same units, found in the center of the Blankenburg Synline, are largely unconsolidated.

The most prominent of all segments of the Teufelsmauer is an up to 30 m high and 3 to 4 m thick layer (Fig. 2a) that shows an extraordinarily strong cementation so that it is frequently described as a quartzite or as quartzite-like in the German literature (Schulschenk, 1930;

2

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer

Trusheim, 1941; Tiwari and Roy, 1974; Knappe and Tröger, 1988; Voigt and Eynatten, 2008).

The cementation is caused by quartz overgrowths (Tiwari and Roy, 1974; Voigt and Eynatten,

2006), resulting in a macroscopic and microscopic crystalline (Fig. 2c) rather than sedimentary texture as compared to the directly adjacent sandstones (Fig. 2b, d). The quartz overgrowths are suggested to originate from silica-enriched artesian waters, which migrated through the most permeable layers from the center of the Blankenburg Basin into both flanks (Voigt and Eynatten,

2006).

Interestingly, all segments of the Teufelsmauer contain well-organized fracture networks with systematic geometries. These fractures networks were variously described as deformed quartz dikes (Bankwitz et al., 1988); reticulated or net-like ribs, grid formations, hole-weathering and honeycomb structure (Tiwari and Roy, 1974); quartz-filled cracks (Tiwari and Roy, 1974;

Stackebrandt, 1986; Bankwitz et al., 1988; Franzke, 1990); vein-like infiltrations of quartz

(Stackebrandt and Franzke, 1989); shear plane systems (Stackebrandt, 1986; Franzke, 1990;

Patzelt, 2003) or silicified shear structures (Stackebrandt and Franzke, 1985). None of these studies, however, related the fractures of the different Teufelsmauer segments to each other nor was the origin of the fractures considered in conjunction with the deformation of the porous host rock.

Cemented sandstone or quartzite?

The most pronounced towers of the Teufelsmauer (Fig. 2a) show relatively thin deformation bands, because this compositionally pure arenitic horizon of the Heidelberg

Sandstone, in which the bands grew, was affected early on by a widespread and unusually strong

3

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer cementation. The crystalline texture (Fig. 2c) of the rocks there has them frequently referred to as a quartzite (e.g. Schulschenk, 1930; Trusheim, 1941; Tiwari and Roy, 1974; Knappe and Tröger,

1988; Voigt and Eynatten, 2008). The term quartzite, a loanword originating from the German term Quarzit , is commonly defined as metamorphosed sandstone, where the metamorphism is caused by either heat and/or pressure from tectonic processes and leads to the change of shape of the quartz grains by recrystallization (e.g. Neuendorf et al., 2005).

The term orthoquartzite was introduced for quartzose sandstones that underwent heavy cementation or recrystallization leading to interlocked grains, where cementation only occurs due to infiltration or pressure (Krynine, 1941; 1945; 1948; Ireland, 1974; Pettijohn et al., 1987) without having been subjected to the dynamic processes associated with metamorphism (Krynine,

1941). Cementation processes during structural diagenesis (Laubach et al., 2010) can lead to textures of quartz arenites and other quartzose sandstones (e.g. Lander et al., 2008; 2009; Lander and Bonnell, 2010) consistent with an orthoquartzite .

Whether one could describe these rock towers as quartzites seems a highly subjective matter, since these rocks meet both the criteria for orthoquartzites and cemented sandstones. The rocks have not lost their sedimentary texture, despite the observed heavy cementation. On the other hand, however, an origin of the heavy cementation induced by tectonic compression would classify the rocks as orthoquartzites . Cementation due to tectonic compression is likely, since the cementation is in places accompanied by grain bulging recrystallization (Fig. 8b), undulose extinction of grains (Fig. 8) and pressure solution (Fig. 5f), all evidence for increased pressure during the cementation process. The observed microstructural mechanisms, also frequently associated with low-grade metamorphism, indicate increased pressures and induce a change of

4

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer shape and size of the quartz grains. Therefore, we suggest that the term quartzite is justified and appropriate to apply to the heavily cemented rocks of the Teufelsmauer. Such a tectonically induced quartzitification of sandstones is also in agreement with mechanisms of structural diagenesis (Laubach et al., 2010) observed along other prominent fault damage zones in sandstones, such as the Moab Fault, Utah (Eichhubl et al., 2009), where, similar to the sandstones of the SCB, fault-controlled diagenesis lead to iron oxide accumulations and abundant quartz overgrowth precipitation.

References for the Electronic Supplementary Material

Bankwitz P, Bankwitz E, Benek R, Beutler G, Ellenberg J, Falk F, Frischbutter A, Franzke H-J,

Hahne K, Hoth P (1988) Klassische geologische Gebiete Mitteleuropas - Fundament und

Deckgebirge, Südteil DDR. Exkursionsführer: Zentralinstitut für Physik der Erde,

Postdam, pp 301

Eichhubl P, Davatzes NC, Becker SP (2009) Structural and Diagenetic Control of Fluid Migration and Cementation along the Moab Fault, Utah. AAPG Bull 93:653–681

Flick H (1986) The Hercynian Mountains; a postorogenic overthrusted massif?

Naturwissenschaften 73:670–671

Franzke HJ (1990) Kinematische Studien an Störungskataklasiten des Harzes und Suberherzynen

Beckens. Z Geol Wiss, 18, 390–397

Ireland HA (1974) Query; orthoquartzite???? J Sed Pet 44:264–265

5

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer

Knappe H, Tröger K-A (1988) Der Harz - Eine Landschaft stellt sich vor. Die Geschichte vonbden neun Meeren. Ursprung des nördlichen Harzvorlandes. Harzmuseum

Wernigerode pp 105 Wernigerode

König S, Wrede V (1994) Zur Tektonik der Harzränder. Z Dtsch Geol Ges 145:153–171

Krynine PD (1941) Paleogeographic and tectonic significance of sedimentary quartzites. GSA

Bull 52:915–1916

Krynine PD (1945) Physical and chemical processes in geology. GSA Bull 56:1175

Krynine PD (1948) The megascopic study and field classification of sedimentary rocks. J Geol

56:130–165

Lander RH, Bonnell LM (2010) A model for fibrous illite nucleation and growth in sandstone.

AAPG Bull 94:1161–1187

Lander RH, Larese RE, Bonnell LM (2008) Toward more accurate quartz cement models. The importance of euhedral vs. non-euhedral growth rates. AAPG Bull 92:1537–1564

Lander RH, Solano-Acosta W, Thomas AR, Reed RM, Kacewicz M, Bonnell LM, Hooker JN

(2009) Simulation of fault sealing from quartz cementation within cataclastic deformation zones. In: AAPG Hedberg Conference Basin and Petroleum Systems Modeling: New

Horizons in Research and Applications, California

Laubach SE, Eichhubl P, Hilgers C, Lander RH (2010) Structural Diagenesis. J Struct Geol

32:1866–1872

Mohr K (1978) Geologie und Minerallagerstätten des Harzes. E. Schweizerbart'sche

Verlagsbuchhandlung Stuttgart

6

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer

Neuendorf KKE, Mehl JP Jr, Jackson JA (2005) Glossary of Geology, 5th edn, American

Geological Institute, Alexandria, VA Patzelt, 2003

Pettijohn FJ, Potter PE, Siever R (1987) Sand and Sandstone. Springer-Verlag, New York, NY,

United States

Schulschenk W (1930) Die Quadersandsteine des östlichen Abschnitts der subherzynen

Kreidemulde. Leopoldina 6

Stackebrandt W (1983) Zum tektonischen Charakter der Harznordrandstoerung. The tectonic character of the northern Harz border fault system. Ver Zent Ph 77:187–193

Stackebrandt W (1986) Beiträge zur tektonischen Analyse ausgewählter Bruchzonen der

Sybherzynen Senke und angrenzender Gebiete (Aufrichtungszone, Flechtinger Scholle).

Ver Zent Ph 79 pp 81

Stackebrand W, Franzke HJ (1985) Klippen am “Großvater”. In: Bankwitz P, Schwab M (Eds)

Exkursionsführer Rupturen VI: Bruchtektonische Prozesse am Harznordrand, die

Bedeutung der Rupturen für die Strukturierung der Erdkruste, Gesellschaft Geologische

Wissenschaften DDR, Berlin, pp 41

Stackebrand W, Franzke HJ (1989) Alpidic reactivation of the Variscan consolidated lithosphere

– The activity of some fracture zones in central Europe. Z Geol Wiss 17:699–712

Tiwari RN, Roy RN (1974) Sedimentpetrologische Untersuchungen an oberkretazischen

Sandsteinen der Subherzynen Kreidemulde. Freiberg Forschungsh 301:27–135

Tröger K-A (1995) Die Subhercyne Oberkreide – Beziehungen zum Variscischen Grundgebirge und Stellung innerhalb Europas. Nova Acta Leopold 71:217–231

Trusheim F (1941) Die "Teufelsmauer" im nördlichen Harzvorland. Natur und Volk 71:29–35

7

Damage Zone Origin of Teufelsmauer

Voigt T, Eynatten Hv (2004) Das Subherzyne Kreidebecken. In: Mutterlose J, Steffahn J (Eds)

Exkursionsführer: Die Kreide des Sunherzynen und östlichen Niedersächsischen Beckens.

Bochumer Geowiss Arb 4:1–52

Voigt T, Eynatten Hv (2006) Kreidezeitliche Sedimente und Diskordanzen im Subherzynen

Becken. Jber Mitt oberrhein geol Ver 88:305–343

Voigt T, Eynatten Hv (2008) Syntectonic sedimentation in front of a late cretaceous growth fault

– the Harz Mountains and the adjacent Subhercynian Basin (Germany). In: 26th IAS

Regional Meeting/SEPM-CES Sediment 2008 Bochum, Excursion Guidebook. EDGG,

237, 59–94, Hannover

Voigt T, Eynatten Hv, Franzke HJ (2004) Late Cretaceous unconformities in the Subhercynian

Basin (Germany). Acta Geol Pol 54:673–694

Wrede V (1988) Der nördliche Harzrand – flache Abscherbahn oder wrench-fault-system? Geol

Rundsch 77:101–114

Wrede V (2008) Nördliche Harzrandstörung: Diskussionsbeiträge zu Tiefenstruktur, Zeitlichkeit und Kinematik. Z Dtsch Ges Geowiss 159:293–316

8

Download